April 11, 2013
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (62)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB2110
· 6 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…tative Malone recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 2110. Read Amendment 1, Mr.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1143
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1143”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1921
· 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Mr. Clerk read House Bill 1921”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1988
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1988”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2229
· 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…entative Rice recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 2229. Read Amendment 1. Amendment 1”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1706
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1706”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2065
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2065”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2001
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2001”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1020
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB1020”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1109
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ures from the regular session of the 89th General Assembly. House Bill 1109 is Act 1100. House Bill 1110 is Act 1101. House Bill 1164 i…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1118
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ee on joint budget, to whom is referred to House Bill 1220, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1153, House Bill 1212, House Bill 1213, House B…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1153
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…t, to whom is referred to House Bill 1220, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1153, House Bill 1212, House Bill 1213, House Bill 1219. Beg lea…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB12
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…s over House Bill 21-32. Leave it on the calendar. Passover House Bill 12-18. Leave it on the calendar.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1212
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…erred to House Bill 1220, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1153, House Bill 1212, House Bill 1213, House Bill 1219. Beg lead to report we've…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1213
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1220, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1153, House Bill 1212, House Bill 1213, House Bill 1219. Beg lead to report we've had the same amo…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1219
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1118, House Bill 1153, House Bill 1212, House Bill 1213, House Bill 1219. Beg lead to report we've had the same amount of considerat…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1220
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…we, your committee on joint budget, to whom is referred to House Bill 1220, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1153, House Bill 1212, House B…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1234
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Murdoch are you ready to Passover House Bill 1978 Passover House Bill 1234 leave it on the calendar Representative Edwards”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1256
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Representative Westman has asked that we pass over House Bill 1256. Read House Bill 1143.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1294
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…, we are your Committee on Education to whom is referred to House Bill 1294, beg your report we have the same amount of consideration h…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1499
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…use Bill 1480 is Act 1105. House Bill 1489 is Act Bill 1106 House Bill 1499 is Act 1107 House Bill 1689 is Act 1108 House Bill 1853 is…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1540
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…r Committee on Public Transportation to whom is referred to House Bill 1540, House Bill 1999, beg your report we have the same amount o…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1542
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1542”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1570
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1570”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1585
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…You concurred in the amendment. Mr. Clerk, please pass over House Bill 1585. Leave it on the calendar. Representative Armstrong has req…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1714
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ker, we're your Committee on Education, whom is referred to House Bill 1714, House Bill 2128, And Senate Bill 115, beg to lead to repor…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1715
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “House Bill 1715 is Act 1142. House Bill 1716 is Act 1143. House Bill 1717 i…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1725
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…721 is Act 1146, House Bill 1723 is Act 1147, 1724 is 1148, House Bill 1725 is 1149, House Bill 1726 is Act 1150, House Bill 1729 is Ac…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1726
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1723 is Act 1147, 1724 is 1148, House Bill 1725 is 1149, House Bill 1726 is Act 1150, House Bill 1729 is Act 1151, House Bill 1731 i…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1734
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “House Bill 1734 is Act 1155. House Bill 1581 is Act 1157. House Bill 1822 i…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1741
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1741”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1774
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Speaker, we are Committee on Education, whom is referred to House Bill 1774 and House Resolution 1045. Beg to lead to report. We've had…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB18
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…lendar. Representative Armstrong has requested to pass over House Bill 18-21. Leave it on the calendar. Representative Hammer request…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB19
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Passover House Bill 19-66. Leave it on the calendar. Passover 17-22. Leave it on t…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1931
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “House Bill 1931 is Act 1112 House Bill 1956 is Act 1113 House Bill 1973 is…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1975
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…orning hours ended. Representative We're going to pass over House Bill 1975. Representative Rice recommends we concur in Senate Amendme…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1978
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…e calendar Representative Murdoch are you ready to Passover House Bill 1978 Passover House Bill 1234 leave it on the calendar Represent…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1999
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…blic Transportation to whom is referred to House Bill 1540, House Bill 1999, beg your report we have the same amount of consideration h…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB20
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…before the House, a concurrence in Senate Amendment 1, the House Bill 20-01. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB21
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…n the calendar. Representative Hammer requests we pass over House Bill 21-32. Leave it on the calendar. Passover House Bill 12-18. Le…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2128
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ommittee on Education, whom is referred to House Bill 1714, House Bill 2128, And Senate Bill 115, beg to lead to report. We've had the…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2175
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…1116. House Bill 2034 is Act 1117. House Bill 2145 is 1118. House Bill 2175 is Act 1119. House Bill 2204 is Act 1120. House Bill 2230 i…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2252
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2252”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2296
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2296”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1045
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ittee on Education, whom is referred to House Bill 1774 and House Resolution 1045. Beg to lead to report. We've had the same under considerat…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1011
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1011”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1019
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1019”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1147
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1147”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB115
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…, whom is referred to House Bill 1714, House Bill 2128, And Senate Bill 115, beg to lead to report. We've had the same under considerat…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1184
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1184”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB251
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB251”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB26
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…, we're your Committee on Joint Budget, whom is referred to Senate Bill 26. Beg to lead the report. We've had the same amount of consi…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB361
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB361”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB585
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB585”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB590
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB590”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB719
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB719”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB755
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB755”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB784
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB784”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB817
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB817”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB874
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB874”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB914
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB914”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB996
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB996”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
Speaker 1
0:01
Lord Jesus, this afternoon we begin thinking of the words of David the psalmist who said, This is the day that the Lord has made. We'll rejoice and be glad in it. And Father, let us be glad in today that you've given us another day to live and to serve you and the great people of the state of Arkansas. Lord, for these that serve, I pray your blessing. I pray protection for them. Lord, for their families, just that you watch over them, give them guidance, give them instruction. And, Lord, for this body, as they gather and as they interact, I pray for wisdom for them.
Lord, that they would come together in unity, remembering that we don't all agree, we have differing opinions, but, Father, unity is not uniformity. Let us come together for the greater good, the greater purpose, for your kingdom, for your glory. We praise you this afternoon and just bless this time in
Speaker 3
0:57
Jesus' name. Amen. of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation for God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
Members, please indicate your presence by pushing your yellow present button. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Cast with the ballots, there are 99 members present, chair sees a quorum, Representative McGill.
Leave, Representative Holcomb. Leave granted for Representative Holcomb. Leave is granted. Representative James L. Ward moves we dispense the reading of the previous day's journal. No objection, so ordered. Are there reports from select committees? Read the reports,
Mr. Clair. Mr. Speaker, we, your committee on joint budget, to whom is referred to House Bill 1220, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1153, House Bill 1212, House Bill 1213, House Bill 1219. Beg lead to report we've had the same amount of consideration herewith, return the same recommendation. They do pass. Respectfully submitted. Representative Duncan Baird, Chair.
Mr. Speaker, we're your Committee on Joint Budget, whom is referred to Senate Bill 26. Beg to lead the report. We've had the same amount of consideration. He'll return the same recommendation. Do pass as amended. Respectfully submitted. Representative Duncan Baird, Chair. Read the reports from standing committees. Mr. Speaker, we're your Committee on Education, whom is referred to House Bill 1714, House Bill 2128, And Senate Bill 115, beg to lead to report. We've had the same under consideration. Here we have to return the same recommendation that they do pass. Respectfully submitted Representative James McLean, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are Committee on Education, whom is referred to House Bill 1774 and House Resolution 1045. Beg to lead to report. We've had the same under consideration. Here we have to return the same recommendation that they do pass as amended. Respectfully submitted Representative James McLean, Chair.
Mr. Speaker, we are your Committee on Education to whom is referred to House Bill 1294, beg your report we have the same amount of consideration here with the term and the same as the recommendation do pass, concur with the Senate amendment, respectfully submitted. Representative James McLean, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are your Committee on Public Transportation to whom is referred to House Bill 1540, House Bill 1999, beg your report we have the same amount of consideration here with the term and the same as the recommendation concur and the Senate amendments, respectfully submitted representative Jonathan Barnett chair is there any unfinished
business are there any executive communications just read the letter from
the governor April 11th 2013 to the speaker of the house dear Mr. Speaker this is the formula on April 11, 2013, I approve the following measures from the regular session of the 89th General Assembly. House Bill 1109 is Act 1100. House Bill 1110 is Act 1101. House Bill 1164 is
Act 1102. House Bill 1448 is Act 1103. House Bill 1478 is Act 1104. House Bill 1480 is Act 1105. House Bill 1489 is Act Bill 1106 House Bill 1499 is Act 1107 House Bill 1689 is Act 1108 House Bill 1853 is Act 1109 House Bill 1855 is Act 1110 House Bill 1715 is Act 1140 House Bill 1887 is Act 1111
House Bill 1931 is Act 1112 House Bill 1956 is Act 1113 House Bill 1973 is Act 1114. House Bill 1987 is Act 1115. House Bill 2022 is Act 1116. House Bill 2034 is Act 1117. House Bill 2145 is 1118. House Bill 2175 is Act 1119. House Bill 2204 is Act 1120. House Bill 2230 is Act 1121.
House Bill 1715 is Act 1142. House Bill 1716 is Act 1143. House Bill 1717 is Act 1144, House Bill 1720 is Act 1145, House Bill 1721 is Act 1146, House Bill 1723 is Act 1147, 1724 is 1148, House Bill 1725 is 1149, House Bill 1726 is Act 1150, House Bill 1729 is Act 1151, House Bill 1731 is Act 1152, House Bill 1732 is Act 1153, House Bill 1733 is Act 1154,
House Bill 1734 is Act 1155. House Bill 1581 is Act 1157. House Bill 1822 is Act 1158. House Bill 1894 is Act 1159. Sincerely, Mike B.B. Governor. Members, I'd like to take this time to
welcome our doctor of the day, Dr. Asa Wormack of Little Rock.
And our nurse of the day, Leslie Curtis. Morning hours ended. Representative We're going to pass over House Bill 1975. Representative Rice recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1, House Bill 1706. Read Amendment 1, Mr. Clerk. Amendment 1, House Bill 1706.
Representative Rice, you're recognized. Members, this is a DHS bill that we passed out of here a while ago. It had a clerical error, one word, that they corrected in the Senate. Appreciate a good vote.
Thank you. Does anyone wish to speak against the amendment for the amendment? If not, the question for the House, the concurrence is Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1706. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 84 yeas, 1 nay, and 2 present. You concur in the amendment. Representative Malone recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 2110. Read Amendment 1, Mr.
Clerk. Amendment No. 1 to House
Bill 2110. Mr. Clerk, pass over House Bill 2110. Representative Bain recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1988.
Read Amendment No. 1. Amendment No. 1 to House Bill 1988. Representative Bain, you recognize. Thank you,
Speaker. Members, this is a Senate amendment to add Senator Key and to add the Child Advocacy Centers to our task force. I appreciate a good vote. Does anyone
wish to speak against the amendment, for the amendment, not the question before the House of concurrence in Senate Amendment 1, House Bill 1988, prepared machine, Mr. Clerk?
Everyone voted. Does everyone vote to cast the ballots? 87, yea, 0, nay, and 0 present. You concur in the amendment. Representative Letting recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1, to House Bill 2001. Read Amendment 1, Mr. Clerk. Amendment 1, the House Bill 2001. Representative Ladding, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, when I presented this
bill about a week ago, I told you that we were going to amend a couple of things on the Senate end. Senator Rayburn, what we did was we changed the notification. When a company sends a certified letter to a landowner
to notify them, originally the bill said it would be presumed to have been delivered within five days. We changed that to three days, and we also took out the oil and brine operation and just made it exclusive for shale operations. Appreciate a
good vote. Does anyone wish to speak against the amendment? For the amendment? If not, the question before the House, a concurrence in Senate Amendment 1, the House Bill 20-01. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 89, yeas, 0, nay, and 0 present. You concurred
in the amendment. Representative Lee recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1 with House bill 2065 read amendment number one amendment number one the house bill 2065 president lee you're recognized to explain the amendment simple amendment by the
senate doesn't make any substantive changes from what we sent over to them thank you does anyone wish to
speak against the amendment for the amendment not the question before the house the concurrence on Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 2065.
Prepare to machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 87 yays, 88 yays, 1 nay and 0 present. You concurred in the amendment. Representative Rice recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 2229. Read Amendment 1. Amendment 1
to House Bill 2229. Senator Wright, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank
you, colleagues. All this did was add Senator Pierce as a sponsor and change some language up that satisfied the Secretary of State's office.
Appreciate a good vote. Does anyone want to speak against the amendment for the amendment? If not, the question before the House, the concurrence in Senate Amendment 1, House Bill 2229. Appear the machine, Mr. Clerk. Does everyone vote in? Cast the ballots. 89 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present. Concurring the amendment. Mr. Clerk, please go back up the calendar to House Bill 2110. Representative Malone recommends we concur and send an amendment 1 to House Bill 2110.
Read amendment number 1. Amendment number 1, House Bill 2110. Representative Malone, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, all
this does is change the code that's mentioned in that bill. Unfortunately, the wrong one was mentioned, so it makes it the right one. Thank you. Does
anyone wish to speak against the amendment? For the amendment, not the question before the House, the passage of the concurrence of Senate Amendment 1, the House Bill 2110, prepared a machine, Mr. Clerk.
Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 94, yea, 0, nay, and 0, present. You concurred in the amendment. Mr. Clerk, please pass over House Bill 1585. Leave it on the calendar. Representative Armstrong has requested to pass over House Bill 18-21. Leave it on the calendar. Representative Hammer requests we pass over House Bill 21-32. Leave it on the calendar. Passover House Bill 12-18. Leave it on the calendar.
Passover House Bill 19-66. Leave it on the calendar. Passover 17-22. Leave it on the calendar. Passover 1044 leave it on the calendar Representative Murdoch are you ready to Passover House Bill 1978 Passover House Bill 1234 leave it on the calendar Representative Edwards
Mr. Clerk read House Bill 1921
House Bill 1921, Representative Edwards, to improve transportation in Arkansas. Representative Edwards,
you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This is a fairly straightforward concept. Folks, rivers provide a great source of transportation for the citizens of Arkansas for commerce.
Many commodities are shipped on the rivers of our state. They are a vital, vital part to our future. The challenge is this. Our rivers are typically maintained by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and their funding has been cut in recent years, and it's been cut to the point where there's not enough money on a reliable basis to dredge our rivers and harbors.
And if you can't get into a river and harbor with your barges, it's like having an interstate highway with no off-ramps. It's not really worth much to us. What this bill that is brought to you by many House co-sponsors and Senator Files, what this bill does is that it provides a mechanism to have a state program so rivers, so terminals and ports and harbors can apply for funding to help with dredging. Currently, there's a tax that's collected from the barge operators on the cargo that they carry.
The legislation says that once that tax passes over $2.5 million, that tax is already dedicated to the Public Service Commission as it stands right now, the Assessor Coordinator's Office Legislative Audit. But once we get above that amount, any excess will go into a fund that will be utilized by the Arkansas Waterways Commission to provide grants for our rivers and harbors.
This is a desperately needed bill that sets us up for the future to be able to have further prosperity and jobs for our state, and I'd appreciate a good vote. Does anyone wish to speak
against the bill, for the bill? If not, the question before the House is the passage of House Bill 1921. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 96A, 090, President, you pass the bill.
Representative Westman has asked that we pass over House Bill 1256. Read House Bill 1143.
House Bill 1143 by Representative Burris to create the Health Care Independence Act of 2013 and to declare an emergency. Representative Burris, you
recognize. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I just spent about three hours in public health
with about a third of it debating bed bugs and mattresses. And it's like everybody knew that. We passed over all the bills. I didn't have a lot of time to refresh or get my mind off bed bugs. So hopefully I won't stray during what I hope to be a short presentation. This is the bill that we all knew was coming. This is the bill we had a Committee of the Whole about on Monday. It's House Bill 1143. There's a companion bill, and that's Senate Bill 1020 that we'll also vote on later today. This is the Health Care Independence Act. I hope all of you have had a chance to read it, discuss it, ask any questions that you have.
I was thinking the one thought I did have time to have before I came down was I wanted to say that I know how high tensions are And I know how the stress that everybody's under, and that's something that I can't do. I can't do anything about that. Nobody else can. But I think all you can do is I wanted to say to at least maybe take a moment and enjoy the positive aspect of that stress. And that's that if you look around the room, there's only 100 of us in here because there's only 100 seats. We're all here because we ask people to come to Little Rock and make decisions for them, the best decisions that would impact their lives.
And we're going to disagree on what that decision is. but we ought to at least take a moment, step back, and appreciate the fact that people trusted us and sent us here and that I think everybody in this room has put a lot of time and a lot of effort into making the best decision they can. And even though we disagree, that needs to be stated and appreciated, and I appreciate all the input that all of you have had in the discussion. I don't want to spend too much time on the particulars because we did that, and I have a feeling that a lot of the particulars will discuss in the debate
because I assume there's going to be people speak against this. I wanted to touch briefly on it. I wanted to say two things. I understand all the concerns because this is a conclusion. Supporting this bill is a conclusion that it took me a little bit to arrive at. We run the easy bills in January. The tough one runs in April. There's a reason why we're running it now, and it's because it took all of us and me a long time to reach a decision, and some of you may not have arrived at one yet. But I understand the reasons for concern.
We'll talk about it in the debate, but I don't want to minimize the opposition because there's people that I agree with 9 out of 10 times that are going to disagree with me on this one. And nobody should ever portray this as black and white. But here's some of the particulars. I mean, there's a lot of concerns about the cost. All I can say are about the framework and the trust issue, frankly, with HHS. I'll say that if you read the bill, I don't think it could be written any stronger. I don't think we could provide ourselves any more protections against an ever-changing federal bureaucracy or federal government.
Because in the bill, everything is listed exactly what we've asked for, and if we don't get it, the act isn't implemented. It doesn't get any simpler than that. For those that argue wait, I would say that there's probably more harm in waiting because by passing something now, all we did was put every one of our demands into a bill and said give them to us or this act isn't implemented. That's not negotiation. That's demands. And since we get to be the ones to make the demands, I'm okay with writing the bill that way. There's protections, and the state's protected.
I would say that it's also further protected from the fear of what changes might come potentially three or four or five years down the road. And this goes to the next point, which is the cost of doing nothing. And the fact that if we choose to do nothing, we've got a Medicaid program that totals over 900,000 Arkansans in the coming years. It's proven unsustainable with hundreds of millions of dollars of deficits every year. If you're a person like me that believes that eventually the House of Cards is going to crumble, the House of Cards being the federal government or the deficit in the budget, and they're going to have to get serious about it, then we're better served by having as many people out of Medicaid and onto an exchange as possible.
Because as I quoted the other day from another writer, that exchanges are reformable in a way that Medicaid is not. And it's very important to say that these aren't just on the exchange will not just be populations of people that could be on Medicaid today or below that 100% marker. They're people that we offer services to through an Arkansas health network, through family planning, for pregnant women. They're people that we can't take those services away in Medicaid today, but by putting them on the exchange, we free the state from that obligation.
So even if there's changes from the federal government, we have a lower obligation when that happens than we do today. So if you're afraid of that anvil falling, it's better to have 500,000 people on the system, not 900,000. And again, that comes right back to the point of the cost of doing nothing. You've got a woodwork effect of potentially 40,000 to 50,000 Arkansans coming onto the Medicaid system with no reforms and no changes. That's if we do nothing. You've got a subsidy that kicks in for the over 100 percent.
All that happens if we do nothing. There are drastic costs to doing nothing, including the $1.18 billion that's pulled out of Arkansas's economy in the form of Medicare cuts and tax increases that are here no matter what we decide to do. So you add all that together, we face a great obstacle with instability in our health care system and therefore instability in our state budget. And that's what we have by doing nothing. Now, we've talked about the private option, and so I just kind of want to close.
I think I know that we're going to have the debate about a lot of the particulars during the debate, during the discussion part here. There's well-qualified people that understand the facts that I think are going to present the opportunity to debate the numbers. But I'll tell you kind of beyond the numbers, even though I think the numbers prove this is great for the state and the consumer, and I think with the opportunity for reform, it can be great for the federal government also. But that kind of leads to what I wanted to close on and really what made up my mind for me, which is a lot more beyond the tangibles and the quantifiable facts that we deal with in terms of numbers and budgets and things like that, but also the big picture.
And I can tell you that this is something that, you know, if you all know Senator Sanders very well, you know that he, I guess for lack of a better word, he probably reads and studies politics and policy more than probably most. And I think that it's important sometimes to step back and realize that we're not just dealing with the decisions that are right in front of us. We're trying to make decisions that set long-term consequences and implications. The policy that we pass today affects the policy that the person that assumes my seat in District 98 will make. It's all a building effect.
It's momentum. We rely on the precedent of those that came before us. And so when trying to make up my mind on how I felt about this debate, the philosophical aspects of it I couldn't remove from because they're perhaps the most important. And I think it kind of boils down to, I hope something that we could all agree on is that what we're doing isn't working. I just told you that doing nothing means we're going to have a Medicaid population of 900,000. We heard about a $400 million shortfall coming into this session. We face hundreds of millions of dollars in shortfall every year.
We've got people who are incentivized not to make right decisions. They're incentivized to go on SSI. They're incentivized to go on disability, driving up the costs and expenses of the federal government, but they do it to get health care. You've got people now with the system, and it's based on percentages of FPLs the way it is. You've got people that make over the limits, but they're on things like Our Kids B. Or maybe they're on Our Kids A or B, but they don't want to report their accurate income because they lose a benefit. Or maybe they just don't want to get a raise or get a better job because they lose a benefit.
And getting a dollar or more an hour costs them more than they can make up. Because the entire system promotes wrong behavior. And I think that's been a system that's been building upon itself for decades and decades. And we have a chance to, in a very unique way, reform that. We have a chance to be unique and innovative in the way we approach health care, the way we reimburse providers, the way we incentivize the right behavior on the part of the consumer to access the health care network at the appropriate point
in the most efficient way that saves the state and federal government money and makes sure that the consumer gets the better care that they need. So that's a lot more the big picture, but when trying to decide what the right thing would be from a budgetary standpoint but also others, that's why I concluded that I was comfortable moving forward because we're protecting our state from the instability of the federal government. We're protecting ourselves from the instability that will happen in our state budget because of the negative consequences of ACA.
We're protecting the consumers who are going to be paying the penalties and the fines and our businesses who are going to be paying the $38 million. We're protecting them by implementing this, all at the same time implementing reforms that I think will be unique and innovative and give other states the opportunity eventually to model the way that we're approaching health care in the state of Arkansas. And all that means the state wins, the federal government wins, and the consumer wins because they get better care. So with
Representative Kassay, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized. Mr. Burris, I appreciate you bringing this bill. So I just had a question, really an opinion question for you on what the impact of 1143 will be on rural hospitals. Well, I
mean, I think we all know it would be positive. But I also want to stress, too, and I'm going to take this a different direction than maybe you wanted, but it's the point of all this. What we don't want to do and why I think Arkansas can do this while no other state really should or can is because we're not just taking the money and running.
We're not just saying it's free money. Give it to us. We're not just saying expand Medicaid. What we're saying is maybe wait. We've got a chance to take a unique approach to the entire system. So to answer your question, I will tell you my own personal opinion. There needs to be a restructuring of our health care system in the state. And I may get a bunch of chemo. There are some rural hospitals that need to close, or at least they need to restructure the way they're offering care.
And this will, the passage of this act, I think will help ensure that the appropriate transitions happen to where we turn our health care system into the model that I described, which is getting people access to care at the right point. What that means, that will mean a little bit of a realignment. You always need to get the urgent care and the trauma treatment and all that type of stuff that you need to get. but maybe in a rural hospital they don't need to be able to do a knee replacement. Maybe they need to go to the bigger city for that.
I don't want to give too many examples because you can chase a lot of rabbits, but the point is there needs to be some changes, and this bill really outlines the fact that we're not just saying give us the check, don't just expand coverage, which is a laudable goal, but doing it in a way as a metaphor that was used with me was there's a lot of – we've created because of our health care system a lot of buckets It's catching all the water coming in from the ceiling, be it provider taxes, be it funding uncompensated care, being upcoding and all these other things that providers can do to generate revenue, to make up for revenue they're losing over here.
As we patch the holes in the roof, we need to pull up the buckets of water and make sure that they're not still there because they're not needed anymore. And that's where you get to the conservative aspect of this bill because I think it would be completely irresponsible to just pass a bill that says it's free money, we're going to take advantage. And that's not what we're doing. We're saying, well, here's one, two, three bad things that are happening that we can't avoid. Can we do four, five, six, seven, eight, nine things that are good, avoid the bad effects of one, two, and three, and actually take advantage of the bad situation created by others
and create a system that works for Arkansas? No other questions? I'll sit back and watch the debate. All right. Thank you. Does anyone
wish to speak against the bill? Representative Meeks, you're recognized to speak against
Speaker 67
28:52
the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I really appreciate the time and effort that my colleagues have put together in this whole private option plan.
And conceptually, I like it. I really do. There's a lot of good things that are in it, and I wish that today I could be down here actually speaking for it. But my constituents set me up here to make sure that I get all the answers or to get as much answers as I possibly can before voting on something. And Washington, D.C., you know, it's been famously said that we've got to pass it to find out what's in it. Members, we don't want to do that today. We want to make sure that we know what's in it. So some of my concerns and some of the answers that I would like to see, some of the questions that I would like to see answered that I haven't seen yet, is what are these plans going to look like?
Everybody just assumes, well, they're going to be like you with private insurance, but yet the HHS secretary has said for all intensive purposes, these are still Medicaid folks and you still have to provide all the benefits and everything that you would with Medicaid. And so that leads me to believe, okay, well, are we going to actually be able to do co-pays to have folks actually have the skin in the game? We don't know the answer to the question. We don't know how much those co-pays are actually going to be. We don't know when we're talking about the premium assistance.
There's still some questions surrounding how all that is going to actually work as well. Another concern that I have is the doctor reimbursements. reimbursements. Again, we're making an assumption because we're going through private insurance that doctors are automatically going to get paid more. But that may not necessarily be the case because we haven't seen the plans and we haven't seen anything actually in writing set in stone to say, yes, their providers will get paid. And again, that I have seen, and I'm sure whoever
wants to can correct me if I'm wrong on that. Providers also in the bill, it says, shall have to go through the payment improvement initiative. And I have talked to several doctors early on, and again, they may have changed their mind lately, but I've had several that have concerned about the payment improvement initiative. Again, how that's going to be reimbursed with the episodic care. They were very concerned about how all that process was going to work. And I could go on and on and on, but I'm sure that there are other folks who will probably
bring up other things as well. But there are concerns out there. To me, we need to fill in the blank. We need some more details about how things are going to work. Maybe even get the waivers from the federal government to actually have things set in stone before I can be comfortable in even wanting to vote for this bill. Thank you. Does anyone wish
to speak for the bill? Charlie Collins, your Reverend, I speak for the bill.
I could vote on this bill, the bill to stop Obamacare. In order to do that, the bill would have to say the calendar will not turn, and I don't know how to bring that bill to life. And so that's my problem. I'm now stuck in a nasty, horrible, sickening place. And I'm going to a grieving process. And I'm going to a grieving process with many, many other people. And the grieving process has many steps to it.
The first one is denial. Denial. The second step is anger. The third step is bargaining. And that's where I am. I'm at the bargaining step. I've given up on D.C. They're not going to fix Obamacare. I had high hopes in 2010 we could elect a two-thirds majority in the Senate and a two-thirds majority in the House so we could overturn Obamacare
and then overturn the veto. I had high hopes at the Supreme Court that Obamacare would be overturned. And I had high hopes in 2012 that we could elect a president who would overturn Obamacare. But none of those things happened. So now where am I? I'm bargaining. The founding fathers said that the states will be the laboratories of the solutions for the country.
Obamacare is coming. Whether you're in denial, whether you're in anger, or whether you're in the bargaining stage like me, Obamacare's coming. This plan has a stunning level of waivers from those strictures and regulations that are coming to our state and every other state in the land. I've been stunned by the Fed's willingness to give us the flexibility that's been given to us in this plan.
I'm actually in awe of the work that's been done by a handful of young policymakers here in little old Arkansas. Since I moved to this state in 1996, I've heard the expression, thank God for Mississippi, so many times it makes me sick. Because I'm tired of being 49th. Absolutely tired of it. I'm done with thank God for Mississippi. It's about time Arkansas stood up and said,
we can come up with a path forward. A path forward not just for us and our people, but a path forward that we can expand to the entire country. Collins, you crazy. Maybe. Maybe I am. But maybe I'm not. Do you know if just two or three of the reforms that we're putting in place can reduce the Arkansas Medicaid health care curve by a half billion dollars a year? And do you know if bringing in four or five more insurance companies can reduce the cost curve on private exchanges by just a half billion dollars a year?
that if we were to expand that nationally, that could literally save the country $1 trillion per decade in health care costs. I mean, can you imagine that? If Arkansas led the path to reducing the U.S. debt by $1 trillion a decade, I think we can do it. I believe in each one of us, and I believe in all the people in Arkansas, and I believe that this plan opens the door to do all those things. Now, what if I'm wrong? What if I'm wrong? People are telling me, Charlie, you don't know those feds. They are really, really untrustworthy. You can't believe a word they say. I understand that. So let's go. What happens?
What happens if they lie to us on everything or anything? If they lie, we fall right back into Obamacare do-nothing. We get the Obamacare do-nothing plan if they lied. So the risk of the feds lying to me is mitigated by the fact that our only alternative is what we get if in fact they do lie. because the bill is very, very tightly written to make sure that's what happens.
I want to cover one other thing, and that's this notion of incentives to work. One of the things that I and many of my fellow right-wing friends cannot stand about the broken Medicaid program today is the fact that if you're on it, you'll never get a job. That's what we think. Because if you do get a job making a relatively low amount of money, you then have to give up a tremendous benefit. And people are smart. Arkansans are smart. And why would somebody go get a low-paying job
when you sacrifice more than that in benefits for you or your family or others? It's a disincentive. The beauty of private exchanges and a subsidy approach, which is what we're doing here, is like the difference between a light switch and a rheostat. if you're in a room with a light switch you either have one choice or the other either the light is on or the light is off but if you're in a room with a rheostat you can adjust the amount of light
if you're forced to for some reason we do that here every session and we all have the political courage to do it every session we just did it a couple weeks ago we have a scholarship lottery in Arkansas and we've been disappointed that it hasn't raised as much money as we wish it did or as we hoped it did. And what happens is we adjust the scholarship values every two years. We don't like it. It's painful, but we do it because we have to.
And we reduce those values much like turning down a rheostat. Do we have the courage to throw 900,000 people off of Medicaid five years from now, three years from now, when the Feds go bust? I think that would be a lot harder decision and a lot tougher place to be than to be in a place with an exchange where when the money stops flowing to some degree, we can reduce the subsidies by percentages. We can say to people, all of us need to cut back because the Feds just don't have the money.
The last thing I want to say is, from an Arkansas budget standpoint, the Obamacare do-nothing option is devastating. By my calculation, it's $300 million per year in additional direct and indirect hit to the budget. I'd love to talk through anyone that's got questions about that. And in the private option, the budget goes the other way by $150 million a year. By my math, it's $450 million a year swing.
you recognize to speak against the bill? Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, ladies and gentlemen in the gallery, my fellow Arkansans watching online, The people of Arkansas have sent us here to this chamber to be their representatives as part of our Republican form of government.
We are charged with the task of setting the public policy of our state and responsibly spending the money government, both state and federal, collects from hardworking Arkansas taxpayers. I am proud to serve along with you, my fellow members, who took it upon yourselves to sacrifice and be the voice of nearly 30,000 citizens in our respective districts. We did so knowing the pay wasn't very good, we'd be spending time away from our families and friends, and that our real-life professions would suffer.
We did so because we chose to serve our fellow Arkansans, to speak on their behalf because they are too busy raising their families, putting a roof over their head, clothes on their backs, and food on their table. We were sent here to make choices for them as part of a covenant between our constituents and ourselves. As the majority leader of this House, I have an additional covenant with my fellow Republicans. As the majority leader, I also maintain a covenant with all of my colleagues to maintain comedy in this chamber, where we all sit, thanks to the permission granted to us by the people.
Of those covenants, the one that I maintain with my constituents is the one I hold most sacred. Therefore, I do not stand before you as the majority leader. I do not stand before you as a Republican. I simply stand before you as a representative of the hardworking Arkansas taxpayers who have given me their permission to speak and act on their behalf. I rise today in opposition to this particular legislation, but I do not rise to simply say no.
I rise today to say yes to real permanent reform of our state's Medicaid system, because that is the real goal we need to achieve in our state. Lasting Medicaid reforms is what our state needs to move forward, and I will say yes to any plan that reforms the inefficiencies in our system on a permanent, not temporary basis. And I will also say yes to any plan that promotes moving people towards self-sufficiency, not a plan that takes them off of one entitlement and moves them on to another that has a more palatable name.
the expansion plan we are considering today is the fruit of labors by members and senators that i respect and consider to be dear friends as you know i personally invested time to put this bill together i joined the effort to write this bill in order to try and work through the challenges it faces and be able to deliver to you and the people of arkansas a plan that will be a palatable solution to the Federal Affordable Care Act that has left so many people in our state and nation
with a sour taste in their mouths. Regrettably, I could not get to that point in the time frame that has been laid out for us in this House. Therefore, I removed my name from the list of those who support it. It is not that I believe that my colleagues remaining on this bill are on the wrong path. Rather, I believe this approach does not allow us to arrive at the goal that I and they have for the public policy of our state. The expansion plan being put forward is the work of people that I respect tremendously.
It is a piece of work that is in the best traditions of the House, and the work that went into it honors the covenant that we as legislators have with our constituents. However, as we continue to rush towards the arbitrary deadline before us, we no longer had the luxury of time to try to get rid of the sour taste of the Affordable Care Act. As we kept coming closer to a certain date on the calendar, I was forced to start looking at the work and make a decision. Based upon my examination, and in no small part to the limited amount of communication from Washington, D.C.,
which is a couple of paragraphs addressed to us and a nondescript memo to the rest of the nation, I came to the conclusion that this plan is not in the best interest of our state at this time. The current legislation before us is but a mere few weeks old. In addition to the scant guidance coming from Washington, there has only been one third-party analysis of this plan. The supplemental materials, the pie charts and handouts presented to you and the press are coming from state agencies and outside firms who have a vested interest in this decision.
Our covenant is not with the state agencies or the firms looking to spend the free money we have been promised. No, our covenant remains with the hard-working Arkansas taxpayers who know that every dollar government takes out of their pockets is not free. The Affordable Care Act is an uncertain law with an uncertain future. It is a flawed law where new flaws are discovered regularly, and HHS is seemingly throwing its policies and rules together on an ad hoc basis. Every number that we are talking about is subject to the whim of Congress,
and we are one sequester agreement, debt ceiling agreement, continuing resolution, or budget deal away from having this expansion proposal become untenable. There are many triggers and circuit breakers in this bill designed to protect our state. I have proposed some of those. This chamber should be proud of our colleagues in the many ways they have attempted to protect the interests of our state. However, there still remains over $400 million in projected savings that can be taken away by Congress in a snap.
And we have no way to protect ourselves based on the language in this bill. Many of us in this chamber today scoffed at the remark made by then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi that Congress needed to pass what we called Obamacare in order to find out what was in it. It would be easy for me to make a similar comparison to what is happening here today, but that would be unfair to my colleagues. Rather, I submit to you that this is instead a situation where we are being asked to sign the biggest contract in the history of our state,
then begin executing that contract before the other party in our contract has agreed to sign it. For my colleagues who deal with contracts and their real lives back home, would that be a prudent way for you to conduct your business? I will leave it to you to answer that question. Finally, a new talking point has been interjected into this debate The do-nothing talking point and its negative implication of those who are withholding their support of this legislation I ask you, is it do-nothing to have serious concerns about our nation adding to its debt?
I remind my colleagues that we are in a unique position as members of this House While it may be Congress's call to continue its runaway spending and send billions of dollars in borrowed money to Arkansas, it is our call as to whether or not we enable its spending. I will acknowledge that our state receives federal dollars for other programs and that we as a House approve those expenditures, but I reject the false notion that if we do not agree to this based on a certain principle, then we should therefore send all the federal money back.
It's a good tweet, a good bumper sticker, a good rhetorical quip, but we must rise above that level of debate, for this plan is different than a road or school or other established program. This plan is new, its rules are still being determined, and its first check is yet to be written. We have the opportunity to get this right, and if that means stopping here in order to create a permanent reform, then I say yes. That is not doing nothing. And is it really doing nothing to choose to wait until the federal government agrees to its half of the largest contract in the history of our state?
Is it really doing nothing to demand the opportunity to explain this expansion plan for more than a couple of hours to the people who elected us? Is it really doing nothing to listen to the voices of thousands of Arkansans who either do not want this plan or wish us to wait? I will leave it to you to answer those questions. As for me, I choose to fight for permanent reforms of our state's Medicaid system. I choose to oppose this bill for the reasons I have described.
I choose to honor my covenant with my constituents. That's not nothing. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for allowing me the opportunity to address the House, and thank you, members, for your attention and your consideration, and I encourage you to vote no on this legislation. Does anyone wish
to speak for the bill? Representative Edwards, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I don't know about you all, but I'm ready to get this vote behind me.
And for me personally, for nothing more is every time I go to dinner at my parents' house, they always ask about how that nice John Burris is doing. So I'm ready to talk about something else. But there have been some really excellent points made here today, and I just want to make two. I think that this state has a very unique set of circumstances in that we've had the right governor, the right speaker, the right sponsors of this legislation all come together at the right time.
I think that's important. I think that's how things like this can occur. The other point, and the point that gives me so much comfort about what we're doing here today, because, yes, there are unknowns, but this bill has probably my favorite circuit breaker in it on page 8, lines 12 to 14, that we can shut this thing down on June 30, 2017. It has to be extended.
If it doesn't get extended at that time, it's shut down. I think that's the best circuit breaker we can have for something that's been thought of a lot. And, Mr. Speaker, I appreciate a positive
vote. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill? Representative Mayberry, do you recognize to speak
against the bill? Members, this is probably going to be one of the worst against speeches you've ever heard because, in fact, I'm actually for the bill, but I'm going to be voting against it today.
And here are my reasons for both sides, as you'll hear. First of all, I want to thank Representative Burris and all the others who have put in a lot of time, Representative Westerman as well, who have put in so much time and effort on this. I have kind of an analogy that I like to use. I feel kind of like I'm in a burning building. on the second story of it and that if i i stand there and i i don't do anything um that you know
obviously i know what the end result is going to be there's a window in the room but it's locked it's got bars on it and there's no way to get out that window but but macgyver and friends back here have used some duct tape and uh and a clothes hanger and they found a way to jimmy it open So I can choose to dive out that window and take my chances and possibly turn out in pretty good shape, just maybe a cut, scratch, something like that.
I think this private option is an extremely innovative solution or potential solution to a very bad situation that we are facing in this state come January 1, 2014. I believe this is the route we need to take. My concern with passing this right now is that I have been contacted by untold numbers of my own constituents who have said, Vote no. Vote no. Scream no.
Well, screaming no really doesn't do me any good. I can scream no with that fire, and I'm still going to get burnt up. However, a lot of the reasons that they cite, that my constituents cite, that they want me to vote no, are actually reasons to be in favor of this bill. And I understand more and more that many of these constituents do not understand fully what this bill is, what the implications are with the different options that are out there.
And that is because I think that we as a legislative body have been so very consumed in this legislative session with the policy making that we haven't had a good opportunity to go back and visit with those folks who we represent and give them the information that they need. Because unless they are the most politically engaged who sit at home watching this stuff on the Internet all day long, which most of them, they've got jobs, they can't afford to do that. Unless they are the most politically engaged, they're not privy to the same information that you and I are.
And so I think that it is incumbent upon us to be able to let them know what we're doing and what those things are and what those details are, and then come back here. And I'm not talking about coming back here in terms of months down the road. I'm talking weeks, not months. We do need to act. We can't draw this thing out. That fire is coming. But I don't think that we have to do this right now today. I think that we owe it to our constituents to provide them that information.
That's why I'm going to be voting against this today, though I think it is the best option available. And I am very proud of my colleagues for all of the work that they've done to pull this together. Thank you. Does anyone wish to
speak for the bill? Representative, Dr. McGee, you're recognized to speak for the bill. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker and colleagues.
I come from this whole issue of health care expansion from a unique perspective. And I want to present you a perspective of this that hasn't been really fleshed out and hasn't really been talked about. First of all, I'd like to thank all that worked on this. I think Representative Burris indeed has a true grasp of the problems and the situations that face this, and I commend Representative Burris
and all that did all that they do to try to help develop this issue of the private option. we've all looked at all the issues. We've looked at the current environment. There's been a lot of information. There's been good information. There's been bad information. You've had charts up here. You've had graphs. You've had numbers. I'm not a numbers person. Representative Collins would understand numbers a lot better than I do, and I think he gave an excellent presentation on his support. So I'm coming from this from the aspect of a physician,
And I'm here today to speak for the patients, the patients in this state that need this. I see this as a practicing physician, and you can talk to any physician in the state. We see this every day in our practices. We see people who don't have coverage, and Arkansans are proud. And a lot of times, because of their pride and their lack of access to the finances of health care,
their lack of access to insurance, they wait. And they'll put off their health care decisions. And I can't tell you the number of people I see. I treat patients with diabetes and diabetic retinopathy, and it's one of the most preventable causes of blindness that we have. But it's also one of the leading causes of blindness. And the primary cause is because some patients, because of their lack of ability to access care or their pride, they don't have a means of paying for their care. They just don't come to the office.
So you take someone that works, and it's a very insidious disease that until they really begin to lose vision, they don't show up for their routine care. They don't come in and have early laser treatment or early care with their primary care doctors to help control their diabetes and prevent all the problems. And so by the time I see them, these are the patients that we walk out of the room and you just have this sincere thought of, you know, just how in the hell are we going to help this patient?
You know, they've waited too long. It's too late. Now the next place they're going to be is they're unable to go back to work. They end up on their disability. And we're taking someone that potentially was a very productive individual that if only they had come in six months or a year earlier, they still would be out there working and still be producing and still be providing for their families. So I look at this from the patience aspect. I've seen patients that through no fault of their own
Well, it really isn't their fault Their spouse dies Or they divorce And then they become ill Then they can't work And when you can't go back to work You lose your job Then you lose your health care And then you end up back on a state system that if only we had the ability for that person to access health care. We had a young lady here that testified, oh, I don't remember, three or four weeks ago outside
that was 52 or 54 years old and had breast cancer. She lost her job. She was divorced. Lost everything that she worked for in her life. And all because of a system that could not help provide her care. You know, families, we have families in this state that because of uncertainties in their employment, they're forced now to choose between putting groceries on the table and buying health care insurance. This issue is about all those Arkansans, and it's really about many others.
But really it's about improving access to high-quality health care, which will improve the lives of all Arkansans. Health care is important to our population as a quality education is. If we have a healthy, educated workforce, we'll continue to grow. My dad's a physician. He's 84 years old. Still practices part-time in Marlton, Arkansas. He taught me years ago, along with all my mentors over here at the university,
that my job as a physician is to always do what's in the best interest of the patient. Ladies and gentlemen, this is in the best interest of the patients in Arkansas. It's in the best interest of you, each of you in this chamber, each of you here, everyone in this room, you're going to have a diagnosis, and you're going to access the health care system at some point in your life. 40% of us in here are going to end up in nursing homes, in long care facilities.
You may be diagnosed with cancer next week, or you may have a heart attack next week, or you may develop Parkinsonism, or you may develop Alzheimer's. All of us have a diagnosis, and the fact is, is regardless of our station in life, regardless of whether or not we're rich, or whether or not we're poor, or whether or not we're black or white, whether we're young or old, each of us, each of us here and each Arkansan deserves to have their health care needs addressed.
They deserve access to high-quality health care. We have the chance with this Medicaid bill to provide that for Arkansans. This is a chance for Arkansas, for our little state of about 3 million people, to lead this nation in a program that if it falls apart in three years, we stop it. But if it works, this could transform the delivery of health care across this entire country.
They didn't pick Arkansas and let Arkansas do this. They looked at our, this is a, we are a mycosm, we're a pilot project for something that I really commend our leadership, our governor, our colleagues on both sides of the aisle for putting this together. I think this is a tremendous opportunity for us to show Arkansas and show the rest of the country that we can provide our citizens with the health care that they need and deserve.
Let me just leave you with this. And I apologize to any of the ministers or anyone in the assembly. Just let me leave you with this from Matthew 25, 40. And I say to you, whatever you did for the least of my brothers, you did for me. Thank you. Representative Miller,
I hope so. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. folks I will be brief and then I will get my tail out of the well I'm nervous I'm not going to lie about it it's a big decision and I'm a businessman in real life and I look at this maybe from a little
bit of a business angle So, we are possibly entering into a deal with a partner, our financing agent, who is trillions of dollars in debt. We all know that. That scares me. It scares me a lot. Now, I want to do the very best thing that I can for my constituents.
I did not run, nor do I believe any of you all ran, on the principle of coming down here and kicking the can down the road. I have a fear that that is what this legislation does. It kicks the can down the road. But folks, I don't know everything. I'm not nearly as smart as Representative Burris, Representative Westman, Representative Collins, and many of you others. These guys are sharp, and I applaud them.
I wanted to use an analogy that my dad taught me when I was young. And that is, you can put old spice on a skunk, and it still stinks. But I don't actually know that to be true in this case. The more I've thought about it and the more I've studied it. But on the flip side of that, I don't know that it's not. I guess what I'm saying is, I don't know.
Nor do my constituents. And I told my constituents for over a year as I campaigned through a primary and through a general election. that I would not do them the way Washington, D.C. has done us. And I feel like if we vote on this right now, we put this in order right now, that is what we're doing. Thank you all.
Does anyone wish to speak for the bill? Against the bill, Representative Hammer, you recognize.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The one thing I will say that I think makes us different than what goes on in Washington is that everything that we say and everything that we do and the manner in which we go after it is striving to get to the best result, the best product. And Representative Burson will look you in the eye because I respect you for all the effort that you've put in. And it's difficult for me to stand up here and to speak against this bill, but it's not necessarily your fault that I'm doing that.
And I'll be honest with you, the folks, like all of us, we've been asked, especially the last two weeks, well, where do you stand? You can't get up the steps, can't even go to the bathroom hardly without somebody asking you where you stand on this, you know. And I guess that's what makes this chamber hollow and sacred is at least we can come in here and it be among ourselves. and I am honest when I tell you that I was reserving the final decision until we got in the chamber here today and listened to the debate that is going on on the floor
and be open-minded right up to the very end because sometimes I think we commit before we get to that point and we wish we hadn't committed and it would be better to wait until our finger hits the button but a word was used a while ago and the word was trust And I'll be honest with you, and I'm pitching this to you so when you make your closing comments, you can help convince me. But in the last four hours, I can see the practicality of the private option. I genuinely can. And if I had to pick it over Washington, I'd say keep it here in the state any given day of the week.
Because if it goes to Washington, it's probably going to get screwed up. We've got to clean up their mess, which is what we're having to do now. But what happened in the last four hours was, and as vested as you are in this bill, I was vested in another bill, both health care related, both trying to help the citizens of Arkansas. What I felt was a very practical solution, without compromising, of which I was never convinced it wasn't, did not make it out of committee. and the second thing was
and I think this is fair to you to speak and that we need to know one of the private option providers we are having to pass a law to get them to do the right thing and I got to tell you in the last four hours a lot of my trust went out the window because the agency said at the end of the table that we're supposed to be trusting and because a private provider that we're supposed to be trusting we are having to pass a law in order to get to the table to do the right thing. And unfortunately, I think we're going in the right direction.
But for me as a legislator, what happened in the last four hours spoke volumes. And I think this is a product going in the right direction. But like I was told in a committee meeting the other day too, its time has not yet arrived, and we need to keep working on it. So I'll be voting against it today, not to kill it, but to keep working on it, try to get some trust back in some
areas. Thank you. Does anyone wish to speak for the bill, against the bill?
Representative Harris, you recognize I speak against the bill? Representative Harris, I apologize. Let me, I've got to go and let me take a for the bill. Representative McGill, you recognize the speaker for the bill. Representative Harris will come back to you next. You recognize. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
to this debate about people that need us. I've heard about circuit breakers and rheostats and burning buildings, sour taste, untold numbers. What if, right now, we have 250,000 Arkansans standing on these steps?
would we be having this debate? What would you do? Again, if there was 250,000 Arkansans standing on these Capitol steps begging you to give them help. I understand.
Arkansans standing on these capital steps I told Representative Burris and I told Representative Letty that I was proud of them that Arkansas is in good hands with their leadership I'm the gray-haired guy in a bunch. And I applaud them. They listened to me. I saw them one day, and they had their guns, hands on their guns, in political debate.
And I said, fellas, I'm counting on you to make the 89th General Assembly one of the best ever. About 30 minutes later, I ran up on them sitting down talking to each other. And that's what they've done here. we have the greatest opportunity to do the greatest good for the people who need us yes I like a cake with icing on it I didn't get it this time but I got the cake if you help me we'll have a cake and we can share that with the 250,000
people that need us what we do matters what we do today matters Doing nothing should not be an option. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I encourage you to stand up and vote for the people who need us. Let the 89th General Assembly be recognized as one of the greatest that ever served. Thank you. Representative Harris, you're recognized.
Speak against the bill. thank you mr speaker thank you colleagues if you set out to be liked you will accomplish nothing lady margaret thatcher and i understand this is a very emotional issue um i too was raised in a well I was raised in a single home by a mom who had no health insurance where it was often
times hard to get food but also hard to get medical care so I that we had no benefits from the government to get health care so I understand that and this is an emotional issue but I also remember standing just like these people up here in the gallery on December 9th, 2009, in the U.S. Senate gallery, looking down as, and I hate to say it, but on TV, Harry Reid looks pretty strong,
but as he walked across the U.S. Senate gallery, he looked pretty feeble that day. And I was the guest of U.S. Senator Mitch McConnell up in the gallery, looking at them debate the numbers on the, what we call now Obamacare, because now it's popular to call it Obamacare, where it wasn't during the election in 2012. But they were talking about all these large numbers, because sometimes they think the American people aren't smart enough
to understand if we talk in large numbers, it gets a little confusing. And sometimes when we talk about this private option, that if we talk in large numbers, that the Arkansas people won't understand it. And I think sometimes we've talked, and as I've heard people talk with me, we talk about large numbers, but I think the Arkansas people do understand this a little bit. That this is an expansion of Medicaid.
And so I just want to read the definition of what Medicaid is. And Medicaid is designed for those who are unable to afford regular medical services and that's what this is doing and I want people to understand that if we don't vote on this today if we are a no vote that this is not going to stop services for people from zero to 17 percent they will continue to get services and it was alluded to earlier by my dear friends who I have fought with in the last session and they have worked
hard on this bill and i understand it that we may be a leader in this option but we were told in the two-hour testimony that was given the other day that they're not going to allow other people to do the arkansas model so even though they may be looking at arkansas no one else is going to be able to do that and so i want to be careful and what we do today it impacts everybody but in my opinion, this private option is a short fix to a long-term problem. And we keep on saying there's
triggers. This bill has triggers in it. Yes, it does. But if we keep taking the triggers and we put everyone from our kids be these children onto this, and then all of a sudden we say, oh, we're sorry, we're not going to do this anymore. What are you going to do in three years when us that are term limited and they come back what are you going to do with those children and there's going to be a whole bunch of issues here and then i also have an issue when tomorrow if we vote on this appropriation when you have to put in a bill and spell it out that this is not an entitlement
program that lets me know that it probably is an entitlement program and i also want to just state this yesterday i was told and i don't mean any offense to this person that told me that but they told me you know if you're part of the problem you need to just get out of the way and i'll tell you just like i told my 10 year old son who now is 11 i said sometime you have to stand and sometimes you have to stand alone and that's what i'm doing
today, but I know I'm not alone. So I ask today that you vote no on this
private option. Thank you. Does anyone wish to speak for the bill? Rivers of the House, you recognize
to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This will be very brief. Quotation from John Adams. Facts are stubborn things, and whatever may be our wishes, our inclinations, or the dictates of our passions, they cannot alter the state of facts and evidence.
A number of you have made similar trips that I have made to the chief financial officers, the chief executive officers, visit with the boards of directors of many hospitals, Saline County, Baptist Medical Systems, St. Vincent's, UAMS, Conway, Searcy, Jacksonville North Little Rock does anybody know that there were 55,000 uncompensated emergency room visits to North Little Rock Spring Hill last year that the Baptist system
has taken a 68 million dollar loss in cost not billings cost that were uncompensated last year in the previous two years 2010 2011 Conway Memorial Regional Hospital made $10 million and $7 million in profit, but this year they're projected to lose $4 million. Here's the facts. We've got a ton, thousands, tens of thousands of people that are banging on the emergency room doors,
demanding for medical care. They cannot be turned away, and there is no way that our smaller hospitals can sustain those kinds of losses. That is the problem. That's the real problem. Now, if you know these facts, how do you approach the problem? The most important thing to my constituency, and indeed I believe all of our constituencies, is to keep our hospitals open. Because if those hospitals close, there's not going to be a steel mill in Osceola, a new one.
There's not going to be colleges in Conway, Arkansas. There's not going to be any kind of thing. A town will dry up and blow away when it loses its hospital just as quick as it'll dry up and blow away when it loses its school. So we're here to exercise leadership. Now, I've got a lot of people that want me to wait, too. But I didn't get elected to come down here and wait for somebody else to make the decision for me in Washington, D.C.
I am now the government. And that's an unusual position to be in. I have worked for some amazing leaders. I've never been a great leader, but I've worked for General Petraeus. I've been chewed out by Colin Powell himself. I have worked for Bill Clinton. I have worked for Mike Huckabee. I have fought against and with Mike Beebe. I've been around some great military leaders and civilian leaders in my career. And one thing that I finally understood about leadership is there's nobody out there ahead of you telling you which way to go.
We're the ones out front. We're the ones that have to have the answers. If you wait on Washington, you're going to be disappointed. Let me tell you all a little secret. I've been up there 150, 200 times for visits in the Pentagon, in the halls of Congress, talk about appropriations and laws and changes. And let me tell you something, folks. I have never been around a smarter bunch of people than I am in this room right now. You know just as much as they do.
Oh, yeah, they know a few things that you may not. But as far as wisdom and knowledge and understanding, nobody holds a candle to y'all. We're leaders. It's time to make a decision. That's why I don't want you to put it off. And Josh knows I love him very, very much. And I really appreciate what he said. But this is the last thing I want to talk about. I've talked about facts. We've got a problem. Two, be leaders. But the third thing I want you to remember is courage.
Jesus said it best. Do not be afraid. Thank you. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill? Representative Meeks, you recognize to speak against the bill. Members, I think
at this point most of us know which way we're going to vote on this monumental piece of legislation.
So I'm just going to be brief and make just a few remarks, a few concerns that I have. I agree with Representative Collins' statement earlier that, you know, we've been handed a box that we're stuck in. We may not like the box. We may not like the way the box has been constructed. But we've still been handed this box. My concern is that if we go forward with this, we're going to end up building our own box, trying to fix the box that we were given. And what do I mean by that? If we go forward with this private option, we are going to set a certain amount of expectations among the citizens of our state that this private insurance is always going to be there.
And sure, there is a clause in three years we can decide to come out, but I think it was Ronald Reagan that said it best. There's nothing more permanent than a temporary government solution, something along those lines. And I fear we may end up doing that even though we've got good intentions here. The other concern that I'm going to raise is in this piece of legislation, I fear in the end, even though this is a good debate to be having, I fear in the end it may all be for naught because there are several good triggers put in this piece of legislation.
We are once again dependent on Washington to agree to our terms as if we're in a position of authority here, but I believe that position is simply an illusion. You know, if I was a betting man on this, and I don't know how many of you in this chamber are involved in betting, but how many of you in this chamber would be willing to bet your hard-earned money that Washington is going to agree to all those expectations that we've laid out? I don't hold high hopes for it.
So what's the answer? Well, I believe the answer is some of the things that we've kind of looked at. The answer is not creating bigger government, more programs. The answer is trying to empower our local communities to be able to help their citizens. During this last session during the interim, we had the opportunity to visit one of the community health centers out in Helena, West Helena, a local program where they're going out proactively, door to door, seeking out citizens who need help. They are holding classes to teach citizens how to be better stewards, how to have better health.
I believe that is the proper direction we need to take our health care. Instead of trying to grow, we get more and more government trying to dictate from the top. The answer is not dictating from the top. It's trying to support the local-level initiatives. And with that, I would appreciate
an upvote. Mr. McElroy, you recognize I speak for the bill. Mr. Barris, I'll get
you next. You know, we've talked about numbers.
We've talked about problems. We've talked about Washington, D.C., but I won't put a face on this. My son's 28 years old, and he works every day that he can. He lost his job and lost his insurance back this summer. And he got too hot working on a farm. He's working on a farm part-time, and he got overheated. And his wife called me and said, you need to come over here. Nick's sick.
He said he's got cramps and he's shaking and he can't keep any liquids down. So I went over there. Of course, he didn't have any insurance. This is on Saturday. We'd have to carry him to the emergency room. I'm not the wealthiest man in the world. and there he is in a bath with cold water on him and he's shaking and all kinds of convulsions.
And I'm trying to make the decision, do I take him to the hospital and incur a $2,000 bill? Or will he make it if I just leave him here? No parent should make that decision. What if he died? He didn't. We didn't carry him to the hospital. He didn't die. He's not a deadbeat. He works and pays taxes. This is not about Washington, D.C. and how bad you hate Obamacare.
This is about doing something right for somebody that's hardworking. Give them a chance to afford some insurance. And if we carried them to that hospital and it was $2,000, You know why it was so high? Because just what someone said a while ago, they wouldn't let him die outside that hospital door, but they've got overhead costs to cover, and the four or five people that went in before them couldn't pay, and it still costs the same amount. When we pay this in federal taxes, it's our money that's coming back from Washington, D.C.
And if we don't take it, somebody else will. But don't make parents make those kind of decisions over their health care. I'd appreciate a vote. Representative Burris, you recognize the close for your bill. Thank
you, Mr. Speaker. and colleagues, I think we can all agree and appreciate the debate we just had. I think everybody had valid points and expressed them very well.
I might go through and rebut very quickly, speech by speech, some of the things that were said. I laughed at Representative Edwards, and if there's one thing we can all agree on today, despite all of our other disagreements, it's that his parents have never met me, because they still say I'm nice. But tell them I appreciate it. I want to go through quickly. Representative Meeks talks about how the cost sharing wasn't structured, wasn't dictated, wasn't mandated in the bill. I just very respectfully say that's kind of the whole point.
By putting the over 100% and above into the private option, into the exchange, they're obligated under a different set of rules of cost sharing. If we do nothing, over 100 is going to the exchange, and their cap, their maximum cost sharing can be at 6% of the price of the plan. Those are the exchange rules. Under the Medicaid rules, their cost sharing can be 5% of their income. 5% of income happens to be more than 6% of the cost of the plan. So the cost sharing will actually be higher for those people under the private option.
And not only that, in terms of how the co-pays are structured, again, the entire point is for the legislature and the government not to have to mandate to a private carrier how they structure their plans. I think the carriers will have the incentive to structure the plans and the co-payments under the allowable cost-sharing mechanisms in a way that encourages the right behavior and disincentivizes the wrong. We don't have to do that. They will. That's the point. We don't have to get involved. That's the market. I would say, I keep going down, it was mentioned about the waivers, the waivers required for implementation.
What if we don't get them? It's very simple. The act isn't implemented. We barely talked about the employer penalty that Arkansas employers are going to be spared. We're talking about $38 million a year, at minimum, that's going to come out of the pockets of businesses because they don't have an affordable option, but yet they're paying the federal taxes that are required with ACA. Representative Westerman and Representative Miller talked about contracts, and I think that a lot of those were fair points. Representative Westerman talked about would you enter into a contract, and he talked about signing it, mail it.
But I would simply say that what we're really doing is mailing our contract with our terms and saying agree or disagree, to Representative Stephen Meeks' point. We're saying agree or disagree, and if they don't agree, ladies and gentlemen, we did our job. but the terms of the contract are strong and so you either like the terms or you don't but there's no way out and they either say yes or no to Representative Miller's point about signing a contract with the federal government that's $16 trillion in debt we're not signing a new one
folks, we're in a contract we're here if we don't vote for this bill and then approve the appropriation we're in a contract that covers 900,000 people in a Medicaid program we're not starting from scratch we're not doing something We're in a contract with a government that can't afford what it's doing. We have a chance to minimize our risk if our financial goes bad. So to your point, Representative Miller, this accomplishes exactly what you're concerned about. Arkansas is less exposed when the federal government eventually faces the consequences of what it's doing.
Representative Harris mentioned the need to sign a form stating that this wasn't an entitlement. That wasn't a talking point. It wasn't something we put in there to feel good. It was an additional protection. Because by requiring an enrollee to sign an entitlement or a form stating that this wasn't a guaranteed entitlement that could be canceled at any time, it protects the state if it ever is. If the feds ever do reject the terms of the contract or change the terms, Arkansas backs out. That person doesn't have standing or they have less standing, certainly, in a court if they try to sue and say they're entitled to something.
The form actually serves a legal purpose. It's not just mean-spirited or to drive a political point. And the last point I would make is to Representative Hammer. I voted for your bill, so, yeah, twice. But to your point, you said that you were discouraged because we've seen twice where we had to pass a law to require somebody to do the right thing. I'd say two things. One, a major aspect of this, by adding 500,000 people total into an insurance market, you're going to see changes.
I think we certainly should see some competition in the carrier market, and that's really the biggest problem that you're facing right now. But two, I think your story actually makes the point that I'm trying to make. Sometimes you have to vote and do something to force a change in the status quo and the way it is. By entering in and making the votes that we made earlier in public health, you didn't become involved with the people you're frustrated with. You were trying to pass a law to change it.
And sometimes as legislators, we have to act or the status quo stays the same and all the problems that we don't like still exist and nothing changes. It's our job to act. It can be discouraging. It can make you frustrated. It can make us all emotional and not understand why it is the way it is. But it is the way it is until a majority of this body, a majority of the Senate, and upon the signature of the governor, decide it's going to be a different way. And that's what we have an opportunity to do here today.
We have a chance to take away the most harmful effects of ACA. We have a chance to turn it into something that's good for the state, good for the consumer, and I think sets the model for long-term health care reform in the country. And you know what? At the end of the day, Representative McGill, Dr. McGee made good points. It's not my job to sell this to Democrat members, but I will say the one point is coverage. Coverage is achieved.
And if that's your goal, it's achieved through this bill. But it's achieved in a way that produced, not in the way that was mandated in ACA, not with all the harmful things that come along with it, but in a way that can still accomplish a goal that's important to all of us, not just one political party. But it's not just the coverage on the scale. We're adding all these other things. And when you add it, it balances out. And I think it's a win for the state. It's a win for the federal government. And it's going to be a win for the people of Arkansas that we all represent. I hope I've addressed the concerns that were listed out.
I think we've done all we can, and I think this is the best vote for
the people we represent, and I would appreciate a good vote. Representative Burris is closed for the bill. Members, we have a pair on the desk. Representative Mike Holcomb votes yes. Representative Denny Altus votes no. This was witnessed by Representative Scott Baltz. Representative Altus is the present member. Are there any procedural objections to the pair?
Please do not vote either of these two voting machines. The question for the House is the passage of House Bill 1143. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots with 62 yeas, 37 nays, and one present.
The bill passes. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine for the emergency
everyone voting? cast the ballots 61 yeas, 35 nays and 1 present.
The emergency clause fails. Mr. Clerk, read House Bill
2252. House House Bill 2252, We're representative letting to amend certain laws concerning water quality standards to improve the process for refining and revising water quality standards and to create cost-effective attainment strategies.
Representative Link, you're recognized. All right, lighten up, everybody. This bill is not near as neat, near as important or offending as its title. What we did is we used a shell bill that Representative Bledding had, so that's why you see he's the main sponsor. And then Representative Sabin and myself got involved as well. Up in my area, most of you probably heard, there's a new hog farm, C&H Hog Farm,
which is a CAFO, a grow-out facility, if you will, a large farm operation, concentrated animal farming operation. And it scared the heck out of a lot of people that noticed this went in near the Buffalo River. And really, I don't know that the farm operation is a problem. But, again, it scared a lot of people that didn't know it was coming. So this bill, all it does is it puts in place for the future, for the immediate future, because there is an emergency clause on it,
a better way of local notification if a CAFO has an application to go in. Of course, a concentrated animal farmer operation has to go through numerous procedures to get permits. Right now, there's not a single CAFO application and process. It normally takes about a year to get one of these processes through. And currently, the notification process is the Arkansas Democrat Gazette only. And those of you who live up in north-central Arkansas, maybe some, maybe south, know that we don't give that paper a lot. We don't see it a lot, and those that do probably aren't going to read notifications of CAFOs.
So this bill requires local notification of an application process because, again, what scares us most are things we don't know. And I think that a lot of times if we saw these operations and if the people that are scared of them saw they were coming in and had the chance to review them and go through the review process, they'd probably realize they're not going to be a harmful or bad thing. But, again, it scared the heck out of a lot of people up there. So this process will give local notification and better local notification,
let everybody know what's going in so people can kind of be involved as it goes through. I'd be glad to answer questions. Representative Ward-Law, for what purpose?
You recognize? Representative Lee, can you tell us approximately how far from the river this CAFO is, hog farm? Yeah, I can go by testimony
from the committee. I don't know that that's important to this bill because this bill doesn't address that hog farm. All right. Thank you. Representative Payton, for what purpose? You recognize. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Speaker 165
1:38:06
I have a technical question about the bill. It calls for notification twice a week in a newspaper in the county where it's going to be located. Do all 75 counties have newspapers published in them? All 75 counties do have newspapers published in them. And we
got that information, I believe, from the Press Association. There is an opportunity, and those papers
Speaker 165
1:38:23
are published twice a week. I just want to make sure there's an opportunity. And some of them may only be weekly
papers, and obviously you wouldn't be able to advertise twice a week in those. So if it is a weekly paper, then obviously you couldn't do it twice.
Okay. Representative Davis, for what purpose? You recognize us. Representative Lincoln, testimony committee. Did anyone speak to whether or not a public notice is already required when an application is made for this general permit? Yeah,
public notice is required, and that was spoke to, but it's required only in the statewide newspaper, which I named by name earlier and I probably shouldn't have, but it's only required in a statewide newspaper. And, again, a lot of these rural areas don't necessarily get the statewide papers, so we thought it's important that it be in the local papers.
Follow up, Mr. Speaker. So the requirement, the current requirement for public notice, would that be addressed in a
separate statute? I'm sorry, and let me follow up and go a little bit deeper into this, and this will answer your question. I'm going to circle around to it. Further in the bill, it also puts together a small temporary committee. We're not setting up another board or another committee. But it put together a temporary committee that will report with a recommendation of a rule change for ADEQ by the end of this year of what they could do for better notification and process.
And then at that point, that rule will become part of ADEQ rules, and this statute will expire. So this is not permanent statute. It's part-time statute until rules can be put in place with ADEQ.
it? Yes, it does. I believe one year from enactment, which it does have an emergency clause on it, but the recommendation for a new rule will be made
by the end of December. Would that rule be specific to this type of general permit? It is specific to CAFOs.
Or would it apply to all? No, it's specific to CAFOs, which I think there's only been two under Regulation 6 that it's ever been applied for in the state. It's not a frequent application. I
understand, and I'm not opposed to this, but I do think that you're going to have one rule for public notice and advertising for this application, and we're going to have a different set of rules for other public notices and applications. And I would just like to see in all regulation, but especially environmental regulation,
do we keep those rules consistent regardless of the
type of application? I wouldn't have thought
it was possible to complicate ADEQ, but we may be
doing that. Representative Hutchinson, for what purpose? Your recommends. Representative Link, I got on this just a
little late here, but how will this affect my area in northeast Arkansas? If you have a concentrated animal farming operation application coming to your area in northeast Arkansas, then that person would be required to let the people know of your community
by your local newspaper. Animal operation. Concentrate on Animal Farming Operations, CAFO. There's only, I think, two ever been applied
for. Thank you. Does anyone speak against the bill, for the bill? If not, the question for the House, passage of House Bill 2252. Prepare a machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted?
Cast the ballots with 62, 64 yeas, 9 nays, and 0 present. You pass the bill. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine for the emergency clause. Voting on the emergency clause. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? cast the ballots with 60A, 16A, and 0 present.
Emergency clause fails. Read House Bill 1542.
House Bill 1542 for Representative Kazay to clarify the procedure for certain annexation matters. Representative Kazay, you recognize. Thank you,
Mr. Speaker. Friends, I bring an annexation bill to you today. As I begin, I would like to give special thanks to Representative Eubanks, who has been a mentor through my entire process of working this bill through.
And I would also like to thank Representatives House and Lowry, who are responsible chiefly for the present form that you've seen it in. What this statute basically does is this is an existing statute in Arkansas Code which empowers the landowners to decide how to obtain municipal services from neighboring cities, so if you have one city next to another. What it does is it's a pro-landowner bill. It allows the landowners to make decisions about where they need to be to obtain services to maximize the value of their property.
It's good for the individual property owner. What it does principally is codifies several Supreme Court decisions that make it even more pro-landowner and gives one additional tool which encourages cities to act right and provide resources to their people who have property within their borders. With that, I'm open to any questions. Seeing none, I'd ask for a good vote. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill, for the bill?
If not, the question for the House, the passage of House Bill 1542. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Which everyone voted? Which everyone voted? Cast the ballots for 78 yeas, 0, 9, and 1 present. You
pass the bill. Read House Bill 1741. House Bill 1741, Representative Westerman, to allow for reduction of regulation by cities in unincorporated areas of counties.
Representative Westerman, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This bill has to do with county road standards. It gives the quorum court the ability to establish their own road standards that would supersede city standards in non-incorporated areas. This bill is supported by Farm Bureau, the Association of Counties. It was supported by the Municipal League, but now I understand it's not. But I'll take any questions and appreciate a good vote.
recognized. You kind of addressed what I just started to ask there, and I'm getting some mixed signals here. My mayor in my largest town in my area sent me an e-mail that said this will absolutely destroy orderly and public growth, and yet I got an e-mail from the Association of Counties and the Municipal League that says they're supporting of this. Would you please
clarify their stances for me, please? I've been preoccupied with another issue. My understanding yesterday was that everybody had agreed on it.
I got some e-mails that said the Municipal League had backed out of it, but I know the Farm Bureau and the Association of Counties are still in support of this bill. It was amended in committee to make it applicable only to roads, not to setbacks and subdivisions, but it's only applicable to road standards. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Love, for what purpose do
I just wanted to know, why did the Municipal League choose to back out?
I can't answer that. You'll have to ask them. I don't know. I just got a note that said they are no longer in
what purpose? Question, please. You recognize. Two questions. The first one is if a county has no standards, would the city standards still apply, or are we just saying all city standards
out in that potentially annexed areas go away? Sorry, Representative Meeks, did you say if the county had road standards or no standards?
No standards, or if the standards are lower than what the city is. If the county has no standards, then the city's standards would take precedence. But if the county has adopted standards, the county's standards would override the city's standards and where the county's jurisdiction was in the non-incorporated areas. Which leads to my second question.
We've just passed a bill that gives the county or the city's, you know, annex coding area out, you know, one mile, two miles, three miles, depending on the city's size.
How would that influence this bill? Or would that, you know, if we say that the city can, you know, they've got a jurisdiction out a mile beyond their boundary for further annexation, how
would that affect this? Depending on the size of the city on the territorial jurisdiction bill, the city would have extra territorial jurisdiction for that amount of distance. But in that area of the non-incorporated part of the county, if the county had road standards, they would supersede the city's road standards.
Even within that buffer zone we've established? Right. Okay. All the way up to the city lines. Right up to the city lines, then. And it's just basically saying the county has jurisdiction outside the city limits. The city has jurisdiction inside the city limits. The city has been granted permission through other laws to regulate in this one-mile radius now or up to three-mile radius depending on the size of the city. But where the county has their own standards, their standards supersede those of the cities in their jurisdiction.
So if the city line dissects a road, does the city get to set the standard for one side of the road in the county
for the other side. I'm being suspicious. Parallel dissection or a perpendicular dissection. Exactly. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, I
would appreciate a good vote. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill, for the bill? If not, the question for the House, the passage of... Oh, I'm sorry. Representative Broadway, you reckon I speak against the bill. you recognize
thank you mr speaker i've been up in the well several times but i've never
had the occasion to speak against a bill and i do not do this lightly because i know that representative westerman does not put bad bills before this assembly however i have had the emails like many of you in the conflicting information and so I called my mayor and as of 15 minutes ago the Municipal League is opposed to this bill. I just want to point out a couple of things for you about the practicalities of this. I've been a city attorney and I know the importance
of the ability of a city to plan and this dramatically affects that ability of a city to plan for the future further this can affect the quality of roads in counties which is going to be devastating to emergency responders and finally it's going to affect and diminish the property values and real estate values in our cities on the borders and potentially in our counties i think the taxpayers would be subsidizing substandard development and for these reasons i
purpose. Ripson Cozart, you reckon I speak for the bill? Colleagues, I'm here to speak for this bill for Representative Westerman. He's done a great job on this bill, and he pretty well covered it, pretty much so. But the deal is, when your counties are having to maintain these areas, they would rather maintain the areas the way they maintain their roads.
City roads and county roads are different standards, usually. It's not that either one of them is at a bad standard. It's just a different type of standard. So if you're trying to repair something that somebody else has put standards on, it's kind of hard for you to do. You have to usually either go get a different type of material or fix it in a different way. So this makes it easier for counties to take care of the areas because they maintain everything in that jurisdiction, in that planning area. Whatever that city does, it doesn't matter if they plan it or not. The county still is going to take care of it.
So this will be a good bill and it will help the counties to be able to maintain the areas that
they need to maintain. And I appreciate a good vote. Representative Meeks, for what purpose? You
recognize us. I'll take it. Thank you, Mr. Cozart. And I hope you can answer this, and if not, maybe Mr. Westerman can when he does his closing remarks. I'm still kind of wavering on which way to go on this bill. My question is, does not the counties already have authority over the unincorporated area?
So if that is the case, what necessitates a law to say you've got authority over the unincorporated area that you already have
authority over? Well, the city has planning rights to their ETJ area, which could be one mile, two mile, or three mile, and they set those specifications up for that planning area. The county does have authority over that if they have a planning commission. If they do not have a planning commission, then they do not have that authority because the city would do the planning for that area. When they set up their own planning commission, then they have that authority.
Okay, so we're basically making in law what the counties already have the right to do anyways. Would that be a fair assessment? Well,
the county pretty well has authority in there, everything except for planning, unless they set up their own deal. I believe what this bill does, it allows that quorum court to either be the planning or set up a planning deal for that, and then that gives them pretty well authority of that area. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thank you. Does
anyone wish to speak against the bill, for the bill?
So, Representative Gillum, you reckon I
speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, Representative Westerman, it's been a great deal of time on this bill. Came into the chamber today, I mean, had an agreed-upon deal, everybody was on board. Nothing changed from the time that the meetings he had with the Municipal League and everybody. No substantive things changed or anything at all. I think this is yet another example of the municipal league.
They've done this multiple times during the session. I don't think that that should be a factor than pulling out anybody's decision on this. Read the bill. Look at the bill. The bill's a good bill. And everybody's had a chance to be a part of this process up until the very end. I encourage you to please vote for this bill. Representative Bell, for a purpose. Question, Mr. Speaker. You reckon it. Representative Gillum,
is this bill supported by Farm Bureau? Yes, it is, and the Association of Counties. Thank you. Thank you.
Do you recognize the close for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Broadway, I'm glad I gave you an opportunity to speak against the bill before the session closes. members for some reason I can't get a I should have filed a license plate bill as a shell bill well I guess that would have been controversial too but I think this is a good bill again it's
supported by the association of counties the county judges association and the farm bureau I live in the county I own property in the county I don't mind the government that has jurisdiction over my property, making regulations on the roads, but I do have a problem with the government that I have no representation in and the city making rules that would affect my property out in the county. I would ask you to vote yes on this bill.
Thank you. The question before the House is the passage of House Bill 1741. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? As everyone voted, cast up the ballots for 50 a's, 24 nays, and one present, the bill fails. Mr. Clerk, read House Bill 1570.
House Bill 1570 by Representative Neal to establish a web page to provide a menu of links to employer-related web applications for required reporting. Representative Neal, you recognize.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. House Bill 1570 is actually the idea of one of our former colleagues, State Representative Eric Harris. It has DF&As set up a site where an employer can go make multiple reports from tax submissions, employment reports, child support submissions,
and other data submissions. This is a business-friendly bill that makes interaction with our agencies easier. I appreciate DF&A's help and support to make Arkansas State Government more business-friendly. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill, for the bill? If not,
the question before the House, passage of House Bill 1570. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted?
Cast the ballots. ADA 0, nay, and 0 present. You pass the bill. Representative Bragg, I have a letter here from the Senate asking for the return of House Bill 1712. Is that okay? That's your bill. Okay. Mr. Clerk, will you please read
the letter from the Senate? April 11, 2013. The Honorable Sherry Stacks, Chief Clerk of the State Capitol. Dear Ms. Stacks, the Senate respectfully requests the return to the Senate of House Bill 1712,
respectfully submitted, and Cornwell, Secretary of the Senate. Leave granted to return the bill to the
Senate. Leave granted. Please send the bill to the Senate, Mr. Clerk. Representative Douglas, for what purpose? What's your
motion? I move to re-refer Senate Bill 719 back to state agencies and governmental affairs committee. That's a
proper motion. It's debatable. You're recognized. Come to the well and explain your motion.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This just adds a provision for an FOI, and it's a way to make a good bill better. I appreciate a good vote on this. Thank you. does anyone wish to speak
against the motion for the motion not the question before the house a re-referral of senate bill 719 back to state agencies community all in favor say aye all opposed nay the ayes have it motion carries the bill of the committee Mr. Clerk Representative Steele for what purpose motion let me hear your motion
move we re-refer house bill 2296 back to the house committee on judiciary proper motion is debatable we
recognize it's come to will and explain your motion thank you mr speaker
in my haste i uh send a bad bill i'll just share if y'all send it back i'll improve it bring it
back to you thank you does anyone wish to speak against the motion for the motion if not the question before the house is a re-referral the house bill 2296 back to the committee all in favor say aye
All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Ayes have it. Senate bill back to the committee, Mr. Clerk. Mr. Clerk, read Senate bill, no, Passover Senate bill 5, read
House bill 1019. Senate bill 1019 by Senator Dispeng to create the Medicaid eligibility verification system.
Representative Barris, you're recognized. Thank you, members. This is a bill by Senator Rismang that is part of the Medicaid reform package. It requires the state government to track using systems they already have.
income reported to people enrolling in Medicaid and compare it with the equivalent in the federal government. It is a way that requires no additional burden on the recipient. It's a way for the federal government to track with the state government and compare the income eligibility of people enrolled in Medicaid programs. This is one of the reform packages. There's no opposition. The department is supportive. So I'll be happy to answer any questions. Okay. I'd appreciate a good vote. Does anyone want
to speak against the bill, for the bill?
If not, the question before the House passes to Senate Bill 1019. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast with the ballots. 75 yeas, 1 nay, and 0 present.
You pass the bill. Read Senate Bill 590. Senate Bill 590 by Senator Fowles. concerning venue and cases involving public school districts and to declare an emergency.
Representative Douglas, you recognize. Thank you, colleagues. This is an addition to current law, and it has to do with school districts. This will say that actions described against a public school district shall be brought in the county or in the judicial district of the county in which the public school district is situated or has its principal office.
We also added an amendment. We brought this back to committee with an amendment that said that in the case of personal injury, where the plaintiff lived at the time of the injury, then we can bring the case in the county or the district court where that injury occurred. So we made an exception to it. I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Does anyone
Before the bill, if not, the question before the House passes to Senate Bill 590. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Reporting on the bill and the emergency clause, has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 84, yea, 0, nay, and 0. Present, you pass the bill
and the emergency clause. Read Senate Bill 1147. Senate Bill 1147 by Senator Chesterfield to evaluate the impact of school discipline on student achievement.
Representative Love, you recognize. Good afternoon, colleagues. City Bill 1147 is an
act to evaluate the impact of school discipline on student achievement. Basically, this is going to be a study commissioned to the Department of Education. They will do a report. They will study the impact of student discipline on achievement, and then the report will be given to the Board of Education.
The report will help schools become aware of the disparity and proposes a positive discipline model to be shared with school personnel to help them deal fairly with their students and allow them to be better able to teach the students. And with that, Mr. Speaker, I will close and I will take any questions. Does anyone wish to
speak against the bill, for the bill?
I'd appreciate a good vote. Not the question before the House. This is a passage of Senate Bill 1147. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 64, 8, 5, nay, and 2 present. You pass
the bill. I'll read Senate Bill 1011. Senate Bill 1011 by Senator Irvin to protect public school students from child maltreatment to establish a specific violation of the Code of Ethics for Educators concerning the educator's
inappropriate relationship with the student. Representative Klemmer, you're recognized. Members this
is, thank you Mr. Speaker. This is Senator Irvin's bill, as you heard, and I am running it for her on this end. This bill directs an educator in a supervisory role to file an ethics complaint if he or she observes or has reasonable cause to suspect that an educator has violated the standard
of ethics that has been defined that involves the sexual abuse of a student. The professional licensure board will follow due process, then investigating the complaint only if they take affirmative action on the complaint will they then post those affirmative findings on a website that a school must check before they hire an individual with a teaching license. This information is already available for the public. The website will streamline the communication between the school districts and the department
to avoid phone calls. I believe that if someone in authority solicits sex in conversation through text messages, emails, notes, or engages in sexual relationships with students, then at the very least it should be considered an ethics violation that would appear on their license. It's a simple bill, but one that's needed. Senator Irvin worked with the Department of Ed, with Dr. Cushman, Kristen Gould with the School Board Administration Association,
Rich Nagel with the AEA, with a number of people on this bill. It protects students, protects administrators, protects school districts, and protects teachers in their profession. Thank you very much. I'd appreciate a good vote. Representative Lee, for
what purpose? Does anyone wish to speak against the bill, for the bill? If not, the question before the House, the passage of Senate Bill 10-11. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 83, yeas, 0, and 81 present. You pass the bill. Read Senate Bill 10-20.
Senate Bill 10-20 by Senator Dismang to create the Health Care Independence Act of 2013. and to declare an emergency. Ripson Burris, you recognize.
Members, this is just the companion bill to the one we voted on earlier. We're going to track them similarly back in between the chambers, so I'd appreciate a good vote. Does anyone wish to speak
against the bill, for the bill? If not, the question before the House. We have a pair on the desk. Representative Mike Holcomb votes yes. Representative Denny Altus votes no. Witnessed by Representative Scott Baltz. Representative Altus is a present member. Are there any procedural objections to the pair? If not, the question, please do not vote either of these two voting machines.
The question before the House passes to Senate Bill 1020. Prepare a machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots with 63 ayes, 35 nays, and one present. You pass the bill. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine for the emergency clause.
Has everyone voted? As everyone voted, cast out the ballots for 68, 33 nays, and one present. The emergency clause fails. Mr. Clerk, read
Senate Bill 996. Senate Bill 996, Senator Key, to amend provisions of the Arkansas
Code concerning public school student excess absences from school. Representative Klemmer, you're recognized.
I walk up here, thank you, Mr. Speaker, with nothing in my hands. This bill really doesn't do very much. It really puts the law back the way it was prior to 2011, and it changes the word excessive back to excused. So we're now back to differentiating between excused and unexcused absences. We found there were some unintended consequences.
Kids who maybe had an extended illness and they were missing school but were keeping up from home were being turned in as truant. And because of this, their families were getting notified as families in need of services because they might have an ill child. It also will allow kids to have excused absences to come be pages for us at the legislature, which currently they could not because it was simply measured as excessive or unexcessive.
recognize? I had a constituent whose son had missed five days of school, and part of that was because of the death of a grandparent and got a letter saying we're turning this over to the prosecuting attorney. Will your bill stop that shenanigans? Yes. Okay, thank you. Representative
Hammer, for what purpose do you recognize? This actually returns more control
to the school board and the local school
who has the better knowledge of the situation personally to where they can manage that and work with the local court system when in the event there is excessive absentee. Is that correct? Yes. Thank you. Representative House, what
purpose do you recognize? This bill, does it have an emergency clause because Monday I'm going to court with somebody that just got turned in because they have some troubled children with excessive absences?
I don't believe it does because that would be dealing with retrograde. with this past year so this is for next year thank you it was senator keys bill blame him thank you mr speaker thank you members appreciate a good vote sounds like
the continuance is due mr house and usually does anyone wish to speak against the bill for the bill not the question before the house to pass to senate bill 996 prepare the machine mr clerk Everyone voted
Everyone voted Cast the ballots With 98, 0, 9, and 0 present You pass the bill Read Senate Bill This is for Passover Senate Bill 883
Read Senate Bill 784 Senate Bill 784 By Senator Files Authorize the issuance to the Arkansas Tennis Association Special License Plate.
You know what it's about. It's a great cause, and I also bring this on behalf of Senator Fowles and a good friend of mine, Ms. Cindy Bagley, who was a strong proponent of youth health and youth fitness who passed away just recently. I'd appreciate a good vote. Does anyone wish
to speak against the bill, for the bill?
Not the question, but for the House. Passed to Senate Bill 784. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. It was 63 a's, 8 and 8, from 5 present. He passed the bill. reach
Senate Bill 1184. Senate Bill 1184 by Senator Fowles to establish reporting requirements
to provide information for considering amendments to the eligibility requirements for the Arkansas Academic Challenge Scholarship that include income limitations. Representative McGill, you recognize. Again, thanks, Mr. Speaker. This
is a bill by Senator Fowles, and basically what it does, it provides additional data so our lottery commission people can get a better handle on who's receiving the scholarships and the good it's doing. And higher ed says there's no problem with them collecting this data.
I'd appreciate a good vote. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill, for the bill? If not, the question before the House passes to Senate Bill 1184. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 62 yea, 7 nay, and 0. Present, you have passed the bill. Reach Senate.
Mr. Clerk, pass over Senate Bill 361. Reach Senate Bill 817. Senate
Bill 817, Senator Malik, to require that producing mineral interest be reappraised annually. Representative Gill will be recognized. Friends, I have a very straightforward bill for
you here. The system doesn't change as far as how everything is conducted. The only thing is now that it moves the time frame up to an annual
and will actually make things mirror what the values really are instead of the cycle that they're on now. and the disparities financially. This has been vetted very thoroughly and comes to you with no opposition. Thank you. Does anyone
wish to speak against the bill, for the bill? Drop the question before the House. Passes the Senate Bill 817. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Is everyone voting? Is everyone voting? Cast the ballots for the 8790 ayes.
One nay and zero present. You have passed the bill. Read Senate
Bill 585. Senate Bill 585, Senator Fowles, to amend the law concerning annexation of
surrounded lands. Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, colleagues. This is just a little amendment to a current law. It is going to say that whenever the incorporated limits of a municipality have completely surrounded an unincorporated area,
the governing body of the municipality may propose an ordinance calling for the annexation of the land. And this is saying that this can be done in three additional cases. Presently, this can be done when your municipality has a pocket of land and that fourth side is a state boundary. We're going to add to this that it can be done if there's a military base, a state park, or a national forest.
I'd appreciate a good vote, and I'll
for your question? So essentially, if you have a U-shape municipality and that one side is a park, a state park, a military base, something, it allows it.
But that municipality, I mean, you're really making it easier for them to annex in the U then. You still have
to go through the processes that are in place to come before the city council. And you, you know, if there's someone within that boundary that does not want to be annexed, there's a process for them to make an appeal. But it does make it easy when this situation has occurred and you have a small pocket of land that is, you know, needing to be annexed.
All right. Thank you very much. Thank you. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill, for the bill? The question before the House, the passage of Senate Bill 585. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 59 yeas, 12 nays, and 0 present. You have passed the bill. Mr. Clerk, read Senate Bill 914.
Senate Bill 914, by Senator Sanders to establish the Office of Medicaid Inspector General and to declare an emergency. Representative Westerman, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Members, this is a simple little 21-page bill that was introduced by my good
friend, Senator Sanders. He actually came down and presented it in the House State Agencies Committee. And if you know him, I was sitting at the table with him, but I didn't talk a whole lot because he had plenty to say about it.
But what this bill does, it creates the Office of Medicaid Inspector General. If you get the NCSL magazine, you'll notice that there was an article about how successful states have been with an Office of Medicaid Inspector General in fighting waste, fraud, and abuse. We were able to talk to the inspector generals of the states of New York and Texas when we were putting this bill together. We believe this is a significant change that will allow us to shine transparency into the Department of Human Services.
It will allow us to help cut out the waste, fraud, and abuse in the system. As you know, DHS has a $5.8 billion budget right now, and $5 billion of that are in grants that go out for Medicaid. So this is a part of our reform legislation for Medicaid, and I'll be glad to take any questions that you have. Representative Wilkins,
we talked about in committee, this does create two new $150,000 a year jobs for the state.
It does, and it also moves 35 people out of the program integrity unit that's in DHS into the office of Inspector General. The inspector general would report directly to the governor, would have reporting to the director of DHS, and also would report to the legislature. But it would create two new positions, an inspector general and the deputy inspector general. And there is an appropriation made for this office in the, I think it's House Bill 1216, actually.
Representative Williams, for what purpose? Question. You recognize? Mr. Westerman, in my previous government service, I had the pleasure of serving as Chief Deputy Attorney General for the state of Arkansas. And the AG's office has an outstanding Medicaid fraud control unit that each year returns millions and millions of dollars. In fact, we just had a record-breaking settlement in that division of over a billion dollars. How does this OIG differ from what the
AG's office does? and are we duplicating services?
That's a great question, and no, it's not at all a duplication of services. You've got the, under the Attorney General's Office, you've got the Medicaid Fraud Control Unit that actually prosecutes Medicaid fraud. In DHS right now, you've got the Program Integrity Unit that investigates and audits fraud. The Program Integrity Unit makes recommendations to the Medicaid Fraud Control Unit for prosecution. They also recommend to the FBI and other agencies that prosecute Medicaid fraud.
The program integrity unit right now, their budget's about $1.9 million, and they recovered, or through their investigation, they saved about $7 million last year. We think by enhancing this program integrity unit, we can cut out even more waste, fraud, and abuse, and I believe that the The money that they save will greatly outweigh the additional cost of the director and the deputy director. A follow-up
question. Are you aware that the AG's office also hires a significant number of investigators?
As a matter of fact, currently I believe there are several members who are former state troopers, former law enforcement officials that work there. So the AG's office also investigates fraud as well in addition to just prosecuting fraud. They employ both attorneys as well as actually more investigators than attorneys in their Medicaid fraud control
division. Yeah, and I appreciate you pointing that out, Representative Williams, with your past experience in the Attorney General's office. It's the Medicaid fraud control unit's an excellent unit that's doing a good job, and I think this will – and they both have a hotline that they share information on,
and I think this will even enhance the ability for the Medicaid fraud control unit to recover even more funds.
Well, they do outstanding work. I appreciate you, Bill. I'm just concerned about its growing government,
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Westman, where is
this money coming from? It's in the Medicaid appropriation. Okay, so it's coming out of general revenue. I believe we'll have matching funds, Medicaid matching funds with it.
It's funded the same way as the program integrity unit is currently funded. Okay, so if we've got matching funds, then that means we're going to take some of the federal money and match it with state money to hire these two new people? Is that right? That's correct. And, you know, I believe an ounce of prevention is worth a pound to cure these two positions. Sometimes you have to spend money to make money, and I believe that's what we're doing here. Okay,
so let me get this right. We're going to take federal funds with a $16 trillion deficit,
and we're going to hire two more people and grow government in Arkansas. Am I hearing that right? You're right. And we've got a $5 billion budget. There's estimates from 10% to 20% of waste, fraud, and abuse. For every 1% of waste, fraud, and abuse, we stop. We save $50 million in the state right now. If we expand our Medicaid budget, it's going to be $7 billion. So for every 1% of waste, fraud, and abuse, we save $70 million. And $300,000 to save just 1% would be $50 to $70 million per year.
I think that's a pretty wise investment, and that actually saves the federal government money and reduces the budget. So that's why I'm in support
you recognize? Well, you actually just hit on one of my questions, was we're using some of the federal government's money to help them save money. The question that I had was, in these other states that have set up these inspector generals, did they give you any idea of how much money they saved by doing so?
I don't recall those numbers, but you can imagine in New York and Texas, and I believe it's in that NCSL article, I just don't recall the numbers, and I've got an idea, but I don't want to say because I'm not sure
what they are. All right, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative
Hammer, for what purpose? You recognize. In other states where this has been, how many other states have this type office? I believe there's 11 right now. Do all the other states have complementary, for example, do they have somebody in the attorney general's office that also has the division?
Are we patterning this after any other states as far as the potential duplicating services? We patterned this bill off of
legislation out of New York, and I'm not sure exactly how they do the prosecuting side of it, but I know that their inspector general's office is set up very similar to this
one. Okay, and in light of the fact that we just passed the health care bill that we did, How do you see this office helping enhance that bill to make sure that the fraud and waste is detected?
And will they also have liberty to go after the private sector as well as those that are maybe the users of the private insurance plans? Well, CMS
mandates that you have to have a program integrity unit, which that's what we have right now. It's just embedded deep within DHS under several layers of management. The head of the program integrity unit doesn't even report directly to the director of DHS. Since the expansion will be using Medicaid funds, the auditing of those Medicaid funds,
even though it will be for buying private insurance, my understanding is that since it's still Medicaid funds, that the Office of the Medicaid Inspector General would have
purview over the auditing of those funds as well. So is this actually going to pull that office out of DHS, or is it going to make it easier, more transparent, or what is it going to achieve?
Yeah, it transfers the program integrity unit out of DHS and moves it into the Office of Medicaid Inspector General.
So it's not the hen garden or the fox garden or hen house anymore. or it's outside with transparency with different reporting to the governor and to the legislature and back to the director of DHS. All right, then to
the specific question, by this bill being enacted, if we pass it, what it's going to do is put a brighter spotlight on DHS in order for us as legislators to be able to identify areas within DHS that may be problematic. Would that enhance that and make it a greater potential for that to happen?
Absolutely, and it would also have the ability to recommend policy changes back to DHS. And right now that can't be done? Right. Well, theoretically, it can be done. The
question is, is it being done? That can't be done through any of the offices, Attorney General's Office
or any of the other offices? We looked at several places and ways to set this up, and this Office of Medicaid Inspector General, I believe, is the best way
to do that. Thank you. Representative Wilkins, for a purpose. Question. You recognize?
Mr. Westman, you said we are currently recovering $7 million a year in Medicaid fraud? That's correct. With the creation of these jobs, how can you tell us or how do you know that we'll recover more money? As I told you in committee, my biggest problem with this is I go home and I talk to my people people at coffee shops and one of the first questions they asked is why do y'all keep creating hundred thousand dollar plus jobs and so how do i explain this to them and what guarantees
that we have that we're going to
recover more money i think you can look at the evidence from other states that have put these in place that have recovered significant amounts of money i think you can look at the potential of of fraud that's out there based on numbers from the government accountability office if we're recovering seven million dollars out of a five billion dollar budget that's not a very high percentage when we know that that percentage could be 10 to 20 percent the number could be upwards of 500 million dollars that's available
to be recovered so i think it's got great upside potential um to more than pay for two positions to run this agent or this group.
Representative Thompson, what purpose do you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Westerman, if we put our people under the private option and move $250,000 off of Medicaid, are we still going to need 35 people looking for fraud
and $300,000 a year more money spent when we have that many less people on the program? That's a
good question and a good point to bring out is that the purpose of the program integrity unit, and I'm going to stop and say how good a job those people do, how much pride they take in their job in the program integrity unit, but they see over expenditures of Medicaid funds. Even though if we do the private option, the funds would be used to purchase private insurance plans and you could theoretically move people off of the existing Medicaid program, the $7 billion of money would still be Medicaid funds that would be funding the private option.
So the Medicaid inspector general's office would still be the ones that look for the fraud, waste, and abuse and how those $7 billion of Medicaid funds were spent. Representative Ballinger, for what purpose? Thank
the package of the reforms that we were looking for that was packaged with the private option? From what I understand is when this was presented to a lot of my colleagues, and we've talked about it a bunch, is one of the reasons why so many individuals would be willing to vote for the private option
is reforms just like this one in particular. Isn't that right?
Yeah, this has been identified as one of our key reforms for fixing the existing Medicaid system. Okay. To put transparency in the system and to have this oversight. And to go back to Representative Thompson's question, I mean, you could make the case that if we're going to be managing $2 billion more money with a private option, you might even need more people. If I remember the numbers correctly, in Texas, this office has like 300 or 400 people in it, and we would do it with 35 here in Arkansas.
Representative Hammer, for what purpose do you recognize?
Do you like ping pong, Representative Westerman? I've played before. Okay. Okay. Whether this is private option or whether this is Medicaid dollars, my question is, if we create this department, are they going to have unrestricted ability to go after people who are committing fraud under a private insurance plan?
or by us going into the private insurance mode, is that going to prevent this inspector general's office from being able to pursue conviction of those individuals if they themselves have committed fraud? Not at all, because
the private insurance premiums would be paid with Medicaid dollars, so they would still be investigating the way those dollars are expended, and if there's fraud, they'll be able to go after it. So fraud is fraud? Fraud is fraud, waste is waste, and abuse is abuse.
recognize? Mr. Westerman, I want to piggyback on a question that Mr. Ballinger just asked because I guess I was not a part of the grand bargain. It sounded like that there was a package of reforms out there that we've got to vote on to pass the Medicaid options. Was your answer that this is part of one of those packages that we need
to pass in order to get Medicaid option, the exchange bill? This is a package of reforms we've discussed to reform the existing system. My position has been all along that we need to reform the existing system.
The Medicaid expansion is another question. So they're in no way tied together? I believe that if we fail to reform the existing system, it will certainly cast doubt on people's ability to vote to expand the existing system. So that's for each member to determine whether they're tied together or not. Well, maybe you can share with me at a later date all the reforms necessary to pass the Medicaid expansion because I bet
there are a lot of folks in here who would be willing to maybe go for some of those reforms
if we knew what that package reforms look like. Yep. I
can tell you the ones in my mind, but others may have different ones in their
mind. All right. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill, for the bill, or if it's embarrassed? You recognize I
speak for the bill? Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Westerman is a much more patient man than me.
This is going to be one of those things that I probably decide later on I overreacted to. I can sit down here and take questions all day long about policy. My blood pressure doesn't go up. My face won't turn red. I'll take it all day long. When we start acting like this is some junior high student council, I get really mad. So I know it's fun to ask cute questions, but I don't know if anybody's noticed the stakes are pretty high.
There's a lot of people that have invested a lot of time to see if maybe we can make something work. And I hope that we all take it pretty seriously for the next day or two. This is a good bill. It's been well debated. It's agreed to by DHS and the governor's office. And anybody that wanted any information could read the paper or ask any of the sponsors, because it's been out there for a really long time. Like I said, I'll probably decide later that I shouldn't be as mad as I am.
But it's really aggravating to be out there doing what I'm doing, doing what other people are doing, and then to treat some of this so flippantly with the stakes being
pretty darn high. So I'd appreciate a good vote. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Hammer, you recognize
to speak for the bill. As I understand it, through the option that was passed a while ago, the potential for us to be able to eventually see a reduction in government because things are going to be shifted to the private sector is great.
And I'll tell you for the record, if you want to use it against me later, that's fine. I'm not about growing government, but I'm bigger against growing waste and growing fraud. And sometimes you've got to spend the money in order to get to the issue. And part of the reason I think this is a good bill is because we need to remove out from underneath the umbrella and to place into independent hands and to place into hands people who can do the job that this office is being created to do. And we shouldn't have a fear of that. And if it creates a savings, it will create a savings.
If it doesn't, we can come back and do away with it just like we can in any given session that we do something. So if this thing falls on its face, and if it proves not to be true, that's great. But it sure is hard to argue against success, isn't it? And what other states have done it and have become successful at it, it makes you wonder, if we're going to do it in other areas, why wouldn't we do it in this area as well? Appreciate a good vote.
Does anyone wish to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Alexander, you recognize to speak for the bill?
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I have two quick comments. First of all, I want to address Representative Williams' question. Yes, it's tied for me. As a person who currently believes that the private option is probably the best direction but will not vote for it unless we have time to go back and speak with our constituents, this is a deal breaker for me if we don't have this. The second point I want to make is the money that we're going to spend creating this office, I bet you we will get that money back tenfold within the first 90 days.
Thank you. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Nichols, you're
recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. it's difficult for me to speak for it in the sense that there are so many folks that have problems with it from a conceptual standpoint but I think we're at the reality stage and in order to have the grand bargain
if this is part of the grand bargain I think we need to also vote for this I mean, most of you know my preference would not be for the private option but for a public option. But, of course, we didn't go that way. We went the private option route, and I voted for that, and we also need to fund it. Now, is this the best way to take care of waste, fraud, and abuse?
My concern in committee was, well, if it's going to private insurance, the insurance department also has an operation that deals with waste, fraud, and abuse. The attorney general deals with waste, fraud, and abuse. And some of this, I think, could have possibly been taken care of if your representative Westman was talking about it's down in the bowels of DHS. Well, the governor has the power to reorganize that department and take it on up to the top level.
But that's not where we are. This is part of the overall health care debate that we've got. This is a part of that. And based upon what I've been told, that this is part of what we need to do in order to have a consensus on all our health care issues. and I believe people of integrity have told me that, then I'm in favor of this and I'm going to vote for it. Thank you. Does anyone
wish to speak against the bill?
For the bill, Mr. Westbrook, are you closed for the bill? The question before the House, the passage of Senate Bill 914. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? As everyone voted, voting on the bill and the emergency clause, cast with the ballots, 69 yeas, 7 nays, and 0 present, you pass the bill on the emergency clause. Representative Wilkins, please, we expunge the vote by which Senate Bill 755 fails.
Proper motion. Representative Wilkins, you come and
explain your motion. Members, I wish to expunge your vote on Senate Bill 755 that we debated the other day. It will be a motion shortly to send it back to the committee for amendment. So I'd appreciate a positive vote on the expungement motion. Thank you.
Does anyone wish to speak against the motion, for the motion? If not, the question before the House, The motion to expunge the vote by which Senate Bill 755 failed. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 84, yea, 0, nay, 0, present. The motion passes. Representative Malone moves we place Senate Bill 755 back on second reading for the purpose of amendments.
Proper motion. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. The ayes have it. I'll read Amendment No. 2, Mr. Clerk. Amendment No. 2 to Senate Bill 755. I'll make
a motion to send it back to committee so we can amend it so Representative Burr won't kill it again. To adopt
All right. Does anyone wish to speak against the motion, for the motion? The question for the House is the adoption of Amendment No. 2 to Senate Bill 755. All in favor say aye. All opposed nay. The ayes have it. Mr. Clerk, please send the bill to a grossing. Read
Senate Bill 874. Senate Bill 874 by Senator Rafer to amend the offense of negligent homicide.
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized. thank you mr speaker i'm going to keep this short and let's have a bunch of questions but yesterday we honored um the family of officer mccrary he was killed in the line of duty but how he was killed is a individual who had fallen asleep at the wheel crossed over the center line and hit him and killed him and currently there's really nothing that a person can do um to prosecute now this is going to be a difficult thing to prove that a person's driving driving while basically impaired, you know, the level of impairment actually is several times higher
than what is the minimum for driving while intoxicated. But it's a difficult thing to prove, but occasionally, like in the facts of another case, a person posted on Facebook that they just pulled up and been up all night partying and then was out on the road. So anyway, this is just an opportunity to provide prosecutors with a chance to try to make things right if at all possible, and I appreciate a good vote. Does anyone
wish to speak against the bill? For the bill, Mr. Thompson, you recognize to speak for the bill.
Colleagues, the incident they're talking about happened in Conway County. In fact, it happened in Moralton, within just a few miles of my home. And it was devastating to this family, and I, too,
would appreciate a good vote. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill? before the bill. Now I have to question before the House. It's a passage of Senate Bill 874. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 72 yea, 4 nay, 72 yea, 6 nay, and 0 present. You pass the bill. Read Senate Bill 251. Senate
Bill 251 by Senator Stubblefield to clarify the procedures for remitting funds associated with Uniform Commercial Code activity and to declare an emergency. Representative DeBell, you recognize.
I was asked to present this bill today by Secretary of State and Senator Stubblefield. So the bill basically makes technical corrections to address some of the funding streamlined that was behind or ties UCC filings to the county voting systems grants. As far as I know, there's been no opposition to the bill expressed. This bill will make sure that our county voting systems have adequate funding going down the line. It corrects a couple mistakes that were made in the original legislation.
So anybody have any questions? I'd appreciate a good vote.
Does anyone wish to speak against the bill? For the bill. If not, the question before the House is a passage of Senate Bill 251. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? We're voting on the bill and the emergency clause. Cast the ballots. 85 yea, 0, 9, 0. President, he passed the bill on the emergency clause. Representative Bell moves to expunge the vote
by which Senate Bill 587 failed it's a proper motion Representative Bell, he recognized the explainer motion Mr. Clerk, we're going to pass over the motion on Senate Bill 587 Representative Wardlaw would you like to go up the calendar Senate Bill 361 Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 361 Senate Bill 361
by Senator Key to allow school volunteers to administer glucogen to students for any type of diabetes and to declare an internal reference. Representative Ward, law you recognize. Thank you Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, this just
changes the current law from type 1 to any type diabetes. Appreciate a good vote. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill? Representative
House, to speak against the bill. I have no personal knowledge. I have
had many concerns expressed to me by school nurses that the primary rule is do no harm. And they asked me to express their serious opposition to doing this because you can kill a kid by injecting glucagen as well as you could by injecting insulin as well. I have no personal knowledge about the subject, but I said I would express their concerns. Representative Lee, for what purpose?
Representative House left the well. Does anyone wish to speak
for the bill, against the bill. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized to close for your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative House, this is not the same bill that you're talking about. You're talking about the insulin bill. Glucon is actually a pill. It's not insulin. You do not inject it. You take it by swallowing. Appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Question before
the House. There's a passage of Senate Bill 361. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 69 yeas, 3 nays, and 1 present. You have passed the bill. Representative Baird, you recognize.
Representative Baird, can you come up here with just a real quick minute? Give me one minute. Thank you.
Okay, we are not going to take up the yellow budget calendar today. Representative Baird, you recognize for the
adjournment motion. After the announcements, reading of the bills, placing the calendars on the desk, amending members on bills with their own amendments, members withdrawing their own bills, finalizing resolutions, reading communications, and any remaining committee reports. I move we adjourn until
1 p.m. tomorrow. Proper motion. All in favor, say aye. All opposed, nay. The eyes have it. Motion carries. Representative Davis, you're recognized for an announcement. House Rules Committee will meet tomorrow. Big Mac be upon adjournment. Representative Lee, you're recognized. Tomorrow
morning, 9 a.m., 9 instead of 10, House State Agencies is meeting. The time is short. Get there and run your bills, folks. Representative Fielding, you're
recognized. City and County Local will be tomorrow at 9 a.m. in the Big Mac B. After that day,
we will only meet at the call
Speaker 67
2:50:48
of the chair. Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Due to the great work of my committee, Aging and Youth will not meet tomorrow. Representative
Wren, you're recognized. Mr. Speaker, House Insurance and Commerce will meet 15 minutes after adjournment, and we will meet tomorrow at 10
a.m. as well. Any other announcements? Read the committee
reports, Mr. Clerk. Mr. Speaker, we, your Committee on Judiciary, to whom is referred, House Bill 1727, House Bill 1990, House Bill 2296,
Senate Bill 185, Senate Bill 653, Senate Bill 896, Senate Bill 1111, begs the leader to report we had the same amount of consideration herewith, return the same recommendation that they do pass. Respectfully submitted, Representative Marshall Wright, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are your Committee on Judiciary to whom was referred. House Bill 2297, House Bill 1719, House Bill 1713, House Bill 1638, House Bill 1470, House Bill 1391, House Bill 1350, House Bill 1284, and Senate Bill 860.
Beg the leader to report if we have the same under consideration here with the term. The same is the recommendation that do pass as amended. Respectfully submitted, Representative Marshall Wright, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we're your Committee on Judiciary. To whom was referred, House Bill 2108, House Bill 1735, and House Bill 1971. We beg the lead to report we had the same under consideration here. We have to return the same recommendation. We do concur in Senate amendments. Respectfully submitted, Representative Marshall Wright, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we're your Committee on Public Health. To whom was referred, House Bill 1183, House Bill 1871, House Bill 442, House Bill 888,
Senate Bill 916, Senate Bill 1010. Senate Bill 1039 and Senate Bill 1171. Beg to lead to report if I had the same amount of consideration. Here we have to turn the same with the recommendation. They do pass. Respectfully, if it's submitted, Representative John Burris, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we're your Committee on Public Health, whom is referred House Bill 1482. Beg to lead to report if I had the same amount of consideration. Here we have to turn the same with the recommendation. Do pass. As amended, respectfully submitted, represented to John Burris, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are in the Committee on Public Health. Tumors referred to House Bill 1384, House Bill 1968, and House Bill 2210.
Begley to report. We've had the same amount of consideration here. We've determined the same as the recommendation that they do pass, do concur, and Senate amendments. Respectfully submitted, represented to John Burris, Chair. Read
Speaker 271
2:53:23
the bills, Mr. Clerk. Senate Bill 48. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 48. Calendar. Did you hear that?
Calendar. Calendar, okay. Senate Bill 76. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 76. Calendar. Senate Bill 86. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 86. Calendar. Senate Bill 87. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 87. Calendar Senate Bill 157 Without objection, read the bill a second time Senate Bill 157 Calendar Senate Bill 213 Without objection, read the bill a second time
Senate Bill 213 Calendar Senate Bill 233 Without objection, read the bill a second time Senate Bill 233 Calendar Senate Bill 234 Without objection, read the bill a second time Senate Bill 234 Calendar Senate Bill 720 Without objection, read the bill a second time Senate Bill 720 State agencies Senate Bill 794 Without objection, read the bill a second time Senate Bill 794 Education Senate Bill 941
Without objection, read the bill a second time Senate Bill 941 Revenue and tax Senate Bill 999 Without objection, read the bill a second time Senate Bill 999 Judiciary Senate Bill 1047 Without objection, read the bill a second time Senate Bill 1047 City, county, and local Senate Bill 1052 Without objection, read the bill a second time Senate Bill 1052 Education Senate Bill 1086
Without objection, read the bill a second time Senate Bill 1086 Judiciary Senate Bill 1097 Without objection, read the bill a second time Senate Bill 1097 City, county, and local Senate Bill 1100. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 1100. Hold up, Mr. Clerk. 1100? Next one's 1108.
Senate Bill 1108. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 1108. Transportation. Thank you.
Read the bill, Mr. Clerk. Senate Bill 1100. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 1100. Education. Upon completion
of the items named in the adjourned resolution, the House will be adjourned until 1 p.m. tomorrow.
Agenda
Call To Order
Prayer & Pledge
Committee Reports
HB1706
HB1988
HB2001
HB2065
HB2229
HB2110
HB1921
HB1143
HB2252
HB1542
HB1741
HB1570
SB719
HB2296
SB1019
SB590
SB1147
SB1011
SB1020
SB996
SB784
SB1184
SB817
SB585
SB914
SB755
SB874
SB251
SB361
Announcements
Reading of the Bills
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 1
Speaker 3
Chair
Unverified
Representative Terry Rice
Unverified
Representative John Baine
Unverified
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Representative Andy Davis
Unverified
Representative Marshall Wright
Unverified
Representative Stephanie Malone
Unverified
Representative John Charles Edwards
Unverified
Representative John Burris
Unverified
Representative Bruce Westerman
Unverified
Speaker 67
Speaker 70
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Representative Andy Mayberry
Unverified
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 109
Representative George B. McGill
Unverified
Speaker 113
Representative Justin T. Harris
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Representative Mark D. McElroy
Unverified
Speaker 150
Representative Kelley Linck
Unverified
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Speaker 165
Representative John K. Hutchison
Unverified
Representative Homer Lenderman
Unverified
Speaker 90
Representative Mary Broadaway
Unverified
Representative Bruce Cozart
Unverified
Representative Gill
Unverified
Representative Nate Bell
Unverified
Representative Micah S. Neal
Unverified
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Representative Nate Steel
Unverified
Speaker 210
Representative Fredrick J. Love
Unverified
Representative Ann V. Clemmer
Unverified
Representative Jim Nickels
Unverified
Speaker 232
Representative Butch Wilkins
Unverified
Representative Darrin Williams
Unverified
Speaker 50
Representative Tommy Wren
Unverified
Representative Tommy Thompson Chair
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger Chair
Unverified
Representative Randy Alexander
Unverified
Speaker 22
Representative Duncan Baird
Unverified
Representative David Fielding
Unverified
Speaker 271
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified