House Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (8)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1555
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1555”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1409
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1409”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2029
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2029”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2054
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2054”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB5
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…our bill, Representative Hester. Senator Hester, thank you. Senate Bill 5-2. Senate Bill”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB52
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB52”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB766
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB766”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB778
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB778”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 17, 2026
Okay, give us one second, and it will be on the screen here in just a second. If you've
got an amendment, Representative Pickerson, you'll recognize, present the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, this basically just changes the word committed all throughout the bill and substitutes detained or involuntarily admitted. And we felt like that word had bothered us a little bit off and on. And we felt like that best describes the situation here and what it needs to say.
Okay. Any questions on the amendment? Seeing none, do I have a motion on the amendment? Got a motion for Representative McElroy to adopt the amendment. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed, looks like the ayes have it.
Congratulations. The amendment's been adopted. You recognize, present your bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I have Brett Hopkins, who's chief counsel with the DHS, and he's going to be available after the presentation to help answer questions. Also, Dwight Sperry is signed in, and he is the director of the Southwest Arkansas Mental Health Center,
and he can also answer some questions as to the situation that this bill addresses. Thank you. You recognize the present bill. Okay. House Bill 1555 provides a mechanism for transferring back into Arkansas for purposes of commitment for mental health treatment, an Arkansas resident who's in a private hospital in a city that borders the Arkansas state line. The bill adds a definition of residency to the Civil Commitment Statute and authorizes the Department of Human Services to enter into a reciprocal agreement
with an adjoining state to facilitate the return of Arkansas residents to our state for treatment. This legislation is needed to address a situation with southwest Arkansas residents who present in the emergency rooms of the Texarkana, Texas hospitals with severe mental health issues. They need to be committed to a mental health facility for treatment. An Arkansas resident presenting to these hospitals in mental health crises is evaluated by mental health professionals.
And if the person's deemed a threat to himself or herself or to others, an involuntary commitment is needed, there is currently no legal authority to transfer the patient back into Arkansas for commitment to a facility for treatment. Mental health inpatient treatment is not available at either hospital. There are no private or state health inpatient facilities in northeast Texas. The hospitals will keep a patient until he or she is deemed stable, but they cannot offer treatment.
And ultimately, they're stable. It's been about 72 hours. If they want to go home, they have to release them. To me, this is just a serious concern. These individuals who are our Arkansas residents, our Arkansas citizens, don't receive the treatment necessary for their illness. there's a possibility that they could do harm to themselves or to others. I don't have the numbers for one of the hospitals, but in 2010, Christa St. Michael had two such cases in their emergency room.
In 2011, they had six cases in their emergency room, and in 2012, they had eight. So while the numbers are small, they're growing, And I feel like that even one Arkansas resident who has a mental health emergency and is released without the proper treatment is just one too many. And this bill is the culmination of many months of research and work by the BLR staff, DHS Deputy Director Janie Huddleston, and most notably Chief Counsel Brett Hopkins,
who ultimately provided the solution that's the basis for the bill's language that will allow, under a reciprocal agreement with Texas, Arkansas law enforcement to pick up Arkansas residents and bring them back to an Arkansas mental health facility for commitment and treatment. Texas State Representative George Lavender has filed a companion bill that will authorize the Texas Department of Human Services to enter into this reciprocal agreement with Arkansas DHS. Now, as you can see from the fiscal impact statement, there would be little cost to the state.
Local law enforcement will undoubtedly bear some additional cost of transport, should be minimal. I do want to point out that under additional comments on the impact statement, it states that there are fewer than 10 patients who would be affected by this legislation each year. But, you know, in reality, that's impossible to predict, so we don't really know. The legislation has the support of the Arkansas Department of Human Services, the Mental Health Council of Arkansas,
the Southwest Arkansas Counseling and Mental Health Center, the Miller County Prosecuting Attorney Carlton Jones, and Circuit Judge Brent Haltom, who helped me work on this the past few months, Southwest Arkansas Law Enforcement, and Christa St. Michael Hospital. So, colleagues, I respectfully ask for your support for this bill, and I'll thank you for a good vote and be glad to take some questions and I know you probably have some. Any questions
from committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It does sound like a good bill but I'm curious to know if this is like local legislation for Texarkana or does it apply in situations like West Memphis and Fort Smith. It would seem as if there should be some experience elsewhere in the state or it should be made clear if there is no experience elsewhere in the state that it's not local legislation just for Texarkana. Thank
you, Mr. Walker. That's a really good question, and we've addressed that.
And I'll let Chief Counsel Breck Hopkins answer that if it's okay with the
chairman. Absolutely. You'll just recognize. I'd now say
you are. You're recognized. Thank you. My name is Breck Hopkins. I'm with DHS. The answer to your question is it's drafted to attach to any border city. You specifically mentioned West Memphis. Yes, it does also apply to West Memphis. And as a matter of fact, the language defining residency for the purpose of the involuntary admission statute is not new.
It's the same language that's already in the code for the adoption provisions. Any other questions
from committee? Seeing none, nobody signed to speak for or against the bill. Representative McElroy, did you have a question? Representative Hickerson, do you recognize a close for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Chairman and
committee members. I just appreciate a good vote. Thank you, committee. It looks
like we have a motion due passed from Representative McElroy. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed. It looks like the ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill.
Just a brief announcement real quick, everybody. Just want to let everybody know that today is Behavioral Health Day in the Rotunda. From 9 o'clock to 1 o'clock, I encourage everybody to stop by, except us, because we'll probably be in committee. Senator Hester, you're recognized. Without objection, we're going to go out of order. You're recognized to present your bill, Representative Hester. Senator Hester, thank you. Senate Bill 5-2. Senate Bill
5-2. Thank you, Chairman. What this bill is, it's appropriately named victims' rights,
and what it does is if you or an immediate family member are involved in a capital punishment case as a victim's side, that the immediate family would have the right to view the execution from the execution viewing room. I'll tell you a little bit about the current law that we have. Currently, we have an execution room to view the executions from a one-way looking glass, and right now we have three media. You have the attorney that condemned, you have the spiritual advisor that condemned, and then from 6 to 12 independent viewers that are chosen by the warden.
Some people that specifically can't be chosen by the warden would be victims' family members. There's two states that are adjacent to us, Oklahoma and Texas, that give victims' families the first right to view these executions. For me, there's some local constituents of mine that this is a very close story to. It's very important to them. I can't say that any of us would know how we would feel in this situation, but if it's going to help them deal with the closure or deal with this,
I think we as a state have an obligation to allow victims the right to do what they feel like is best for them and their family. We've worked closely with the Department of Corrections. They've been very cordial. We've worked closely together on this. We haven't seemed to quite come to terms. There's a couple of concerns by the Department of Corrections, and they'll certainly speak on them. But the main concern is the states that allow this have a separate viewing room for the families from other people. So we would have two choices when this law passes, hopefully it will,
that we either allow them into the same room with the media. If the family chooses to go into the same room with the media, if that's the case, the family would certainly understand what they're walking into, that they would be sitting next to someone that's going to write the story in the next day's paper. If there's a potential emotional situation there, I think Cummins Prison is certainly capable of handling emotional situations. The second solution we have is to build a victim's viewing room like Oklahoma and Texas would have.
The estimated cost on that victim's viewing room is $100,000. You can look up, I have filed a general GIF bill, and I've committed the first, should this pass, the first $100,000, should I be fortunate enough to get any GIF money would go, I've committed to funding this room. It's very important for me, and the more I look into this almost injustice to these families that I feel like I'm willing to commit, put my money where my mouth is, to build this room for them. And that's my bill.
Senator, a question from the Chair briefly. Wasn't it the last time we – I appreciate what you're doing, and I appreciate where you're coming from. It's been a while since we've unfortunately put anybody to death in the state of Arkansas, I believe 2005. So is there, I mean, a huge need for this?
I don't think that's a very good point. You know, it has been since 2005, and this certainly isn't an execution debate.
This is, if that is the law of the land, should we give family members the right to view? What you're going to see is the family members that speak today or should it be any of your constituents. It doesn't matter if it's once every 10 years or once every 20 years or when this happens. If it's important to their family, this is a brief moment to help them deal with this crime. Thank
you. Any questions from committee? Representative Williams, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman, and thank you, Senator, for bringing this bill and for talking to me about it before you got here.
A couple of questions that I ask you, I think it would be instructive for the membership to hear, and I apologize if I miss you saying this. Right now, a victim's family member can watch execution at the prison by closed-circuit TV. Is that not correct? That is correct. So they do have a means for viewing, just not in the room with everyone else, or not a separate room, but a separate room would be a closed-circuit TV. MR. That's right.
And I think as a victim, and they can speak on this, they're feeling like that's putting them as a second-class citizen in this situation. They're saying, well, you can move the reporters and the spiritual advisors that are condemned out to the TV and let us
come view if that's a problem. They just want equal treatment. MR. Okay. And do you think if we give the victim's family the right to view that we're going to be in danger of any equal protection problems if we don't also provide the same type of protection for the criminal defendant's family to come and view the execution.
Let's say they want to and we have made provisions for them, are we subject to probably some equal protection problems because we've not provided the same type of facilities
for them? You know, that's a good question. That's certainly something that's possible and something that we've worked through. The other states that allow this do not allow the condemned family involved. And the argument for me is the condemned made a choice to be there. The victims did not make a choice to be
there. Right. And finally, I think my last question, at least for now,
the $100,000 GIF appropriation that you are going to commit to this, this bill, as I read it, doesn't make the construction of that prison contingent upon your funding. So if you're not able to get GIF funding or if for some reason other things are more important to you, the construction of this separate room would be the responsibility of the Department of Corrections. Is that not
correct? MR. That would be correct.
If there's no GIF money and I'm not able to fund it, I have committed that it would be the first project that I do fund. MR.
Well, I know you senators get a whole lot more money than we do. I only got $45,000 last year. I could only do half the room, but I
appreciate that. Thank you. Representative Williams, will the chairman? Well, it's going to be quiet because you all got more than us last year, but I'm
not going to say anything about that now. Representative Nichols, you recognize your question. Yes, this may be for the chair. Normally when bills impact the Department of Corrections,
we have a fiscal impact study done by Department of Corrections or by bureau staff, and all we have right now is an estimate from the presenter of the bill that would cost $100,000 and he's willing to fund it out of his GIF. Do our rules require a physical impact study on this particular bill? And if they do, then it's not properly before us. No, it doesn't affect the
inmate population, so it's not required.
Okay, thank you. Any other questions from committee? Representative Bain,
you recognize your question. I just want to make sure I think we're all clear that if there were family members in the room that's already set up, they would not be, even if there was an emotional outburst by the family member, which is possible, they could not actually disrupt the actual procedure itself. Can you give us a little bit of an outlay of the room and the configuration and where they are relative to where the condemned is?
Okay, and I have recently toured this room. It's two very small rooms, okay, and the separation between the two rooms is a one-way looking glass. So regardless of what's going on in the room and the unlikelihood of emotional outbursts, and I certainly know the Department of Corrections has to plan for everything, but if there was an outburst in that room, it would not affect the execution itself going on on the other side of the glass. Thank you. Any other questions from committee?
Representative Slinkard. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator, I'm just concerned about the number of people. It says here that the maximum number could be 30 people in this room. does, again, does that not have to I mean, I don't know, I thought it was limited
to five or six or something, but at the discretion of the director, they can have as many as 30? Is that what this says? Well, that is current law
that there could be as many as 30. The room certainly would not hold 30 people as it sits today. I think, and I've thought about this question in case it came up, and the way I would like to describe it to you is if you look through the bill, even if this involved the Duggars, it wouldn't involve more than about eight or nine people that could come.
Representative Nichols, you recognize your question? Oh, good. Any other questions from committee? Seeing none, it looks like we have some people to speak. I'm sorry, Representative Walker, you recognize? Well, there are
some families that according to what I see in a lot of funerals, they have 50 or 60 family members that are all close why not just put it in the public square of the penitentiary and let everybody see it
do y'all want to respond to that no Okay. Representative Steele, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
And, Senator, I appreciate what you're trying to do. And I've talked to you about this bill personally several times. So I apologize for springing this on you right now because I'm just now reading the text of the bill. Otherwise, I would have brought it up in our multiple conversations. And I want to say I appreciate your willingness to put your GIF money towards this project
because I think that, in my mind, that's putting your money where your mouth is and that ought to be enough to get the bill passed. One concern I've got, though, is I was looking at the bill. On page 2, line 15, it describes, it says the following persons shall be present. And then under that we put any of the following persons related to the victim, and you list them out, spouse, parent, step-parent. My concern is if we say they shall be present in the statute,
then it would be a defense to execution should they not be present. In other words, wouldn't there be a concern that if I'm the condemned and the victim's family does not want to be present or is not present, couldn't I petition the court and say under the statute they shall be present, they're not there, so you can't execute me? Have you discussed that
with anyone? I have not discussed that, and that seems like a reasonable question to me.
And it's something I think is worthy of some consideration. I would like to proceed with our – we've got everybody here today. I'd like to proceed with that. But if that's something we need to address here at the end, I'm happy to look at a possible amendment. What we didn't want to have is to have it say maybe present, because if it says may, then someone could exclude a victim's family. So maybe we should say shall have the right to be present.
Well, again, I apologize for springing it on you because I didn't read the text of the bill until just now, but I appreciate your willingness to look at that, and I agree we should proceed while everyone's here. So thank you for considering it, and maybe sometime before this
hearing's over we can make a decision on that. Actually, you know what, I'm looking here further down on line 29 through 31 of page 2. It says any of the persons related to the victim of the crime which the person is being
executed, if he or she chooses to be present. Okay. It would still be a little bit of a concern for me because I've seen some of the petitions that there are some really, really good lawyers that rightfully so represent these defendants, and I would think that that might give them an argument.
And as I know you know well, because you drafted the legislation that helped reinstate capital punishment this session, you know how complicated that can be. So I would be concerned about giving an argument like that to a defense attorney of the kind of caliber that we're dealing with in these kind of cases. But I understand that. It won't sway my vote, and I appreciate you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Shepard, you were
out. Okay. Thank you. Representative Bottewee. Okay, any other questions from committee?
Any other questions from committee? Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Chair. Senator Hester, if that were to become a problem, would you be amicable to us amending that here to actually have the language that says shall have the right to be present? I absolutely would be open to that. I think the reason for these
vetting processes is to make it right, and that's what we want to do. I think that's the right thing to do. I would support that. All right, no further questions from the
committee. There have been some people signed up to speak for and against the bill.
We start off with against Dinah Tyler with the Arkansas Department of Corrections. Dinah, you are recognized. If you'll go just down, well,
Speaker 80
21:35
you know the drill. Mr. Chairman, if it's okay with you and the rest of the committee, I brought Benny Magnus with me, the chairman of the Board of Corrections. Before he speaks, I do want to clarify a couple of things.
As current law exists, there is a cap on how many people can see an execution. The cap is at 30 right now. That includes ADC staff, the citizen witnesses, the media, and the up to five members of the victim's family who view in a separate part of the institution. When the victim viewers were included, the cap was raised from 25 to 30.
We did that in 1997 and put them in a separate area for a few reasons. One, because of the fact that our execution chamber is so very small. And if we expand it, which is possible, it would cost money. Because we did not want to put them inside the execution chamber where the other witnesses are, where there are three members of the media and six to twelve members of the public
chosen not by the warden but by the director. Because that to us put too many unknowns and too many possible sparks all very close together. There are times when an execution is delayed for a little bit, maybe while they're polling the U.S. Supreme Court. And we have to move those witnesses out of the execution chamber and into another room for a little while.
And that would put the family in there with them. I want to bring Mr. Magnus in, and I'll talk some more later, but I know Mr. Magnus has
some thoughts on this. Mr. Magnus, you're recognized. I'm Benny Magnus, member of the Board of Corrections, and when this first came up, we have worked with Senator Hester and Mr. Merrill very much and went to Cummins and viewed the death house with her, death chamber, and she has an excellent advocate for her case.
He's listened to us very well. But from the standpoint of the Board of Corrections, there's many of us that own the Board of Corrections that have been there that night doing a condemned man's execution or a female. And it's very sober. It's very sober and sterile. We try to keep it as sterile as possible and try to make as little news as possible other than the fact of the execution itself. And we just feel like putting them all in the, first of all, for me from the Board of Corrections,
putting them all in the same room just wouldn't work. You know, we could, first of all, we wouldn't have, couldn't put that many family members. And so we would have to look at building another facility, and we've looked at that. We're the ones that came up with the price of the $100,000, somewhere between $100,000 to $125,000, depending on which model we chose. But even doing that, we still believe that then we'll be faced with, And we get a request almost constantly or almost every execution for members of the condemned man
or condemned prisoner to be a part of that viewing as well. And so I know what Senator Hester said, that one chose to be there and one didn't, but us as a Board of Correction has to make some of those tough decisions. And I want to go back to something Mr. Merrill said to me, are we against her? We're not against her. We just try to make the best decisions we can for the state of Arkansas, the Department of Corrections, and not one entity, not one person.
And that's what we're faced with here. I can give you a scenario that it just didn't work when we had either a victim's family as the same as a condemned family. So which way do you draw the line? How many people do you draw the line? And it's obvious that at some point we would have to say in a large family no to somebody because there could be more than 30 in that list, even if we build another chamber.
There's no question that we're liable to be challenged in the courts by not giving the condemned man a right to be in the chambers. You know, everyone knows that this happens, that people that are opposed to the death penalty, they will look for any reason to stall, delay, or quit the death penalty. So with that said, I'll turn it back to you.
Speaker 80
26:38
If I may say one thing to follow up. Yes, ma'am. This session, y'all worked very diligently as a General Assembly to pass a new execution procedures law because the one that used to be on the books was struck down as unconstitutional. That is now an act. The ink wasn't even dry on the paper, really, before we were served with our first lawsuit over that. It came this past week.
So to think that we won't be sued over allowing the victim's family inside the execution is a little simplistic. I think that it will definitely happen. If you break it down, the state will have its witnesses present. The media will have its witnesses present. The victim will have his or her witnesses present. The only one who won't is the condemned inmate.
Sure, law allows for them to have their attorney of record and or their spiritual advisor there. But let's face it, that's not the same as mama. It's not. And I think knowing the climate that we have existed in for years now regarding the barrage of lawsuits, that it would be very simplistic to think that we wouldn't be sued over this. That's not to say that we don't appreciate the efforts of Senator Hester or understand
Mrs. DeMauro. This is very, very difficult all the way around. Sure, we don't know exactly what she's feeling, and I thank God that I don't, but we appreciate the depths of her feeling. But what we have to do as an agency, what we're charged with doing on that night is is setting aside all emotions and dealing with the difficult task at hand after having prepared for every possible what-if that we can think of.
Representative Shepard, you recognize your question? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just, I guess, for the benefit of me, if maybe nobody else, go through again with me who presently would be present for an execution if it were conducted
Speaker 80
29:09
today? MS. There could be up to 30 people present. That includes ADC staff. There would be 6 to 12 members of the public, the citizen witnesses.
There would be three media witnesses, one representing print, one representing broadcast, and one representing the Associated Press. There would be up to five members of the victim's family present in another part of the institution. Do they count against the 30? Yes, they do. Okay. The cap was raised from 25 to 30 to include them back in 1997. Ms. Tyler, let me interrupt you. Are you
including everybody that's watching by closed circuit TV? Yes, I am.
Speaker 80
29:50
Those are what we call the victim viewers. Okay. Thank you. Okay. So that's got to include staff. I mean, and we have to have staff in there. Obviously, the director is in there. There is a recorder in there. There's a mental health staff person in there. There is a medical person for us in there, and I may be missing some, but it's everybody, everybody with the Department of Correction, everybody who is a witness. The law says that it can only be seen by 30 people.
Somebody from the AG's office? They are, no,
no, they're in a separate part of the institution. Okay, thank you. And so, with regard to the condemned, the only person, I guess, the condemned can have his or her spiritual advisor there. No members of the condemned's family are presently there. And his attorney. And his attorney. And his attorney and his spiritual advisor are in the live
Speaker 80
30:50
viewing area behind the glass. Is that correct? Right. The attorney comes and sits down with the other witnesses.
The spiritual advisor can escort the inmate on the short walk from the quiet cell to the door of the chamber. And that's as far as the spiritual advisor can go. And then he comes around and sits with the witnesses. But those are the only two that the inmate can have present. Not one of his family members can be there. As a matter of fact, they don't even come on property, and we have had them show up. If they show up, they're held at the roadblock.
Mr. Chairman, if you'll allow me some leeway to follow up on this. I have, Mr. Shepard. So now there's been some question raised about how would you determine which members of the victim's family could attend. That's already an issue because right now they're allowed essentially five members of the
Speaker 80
31:48
victim's family. Normally what they do is we tell them, you know, you can have five members there and they choose among themselves who goes. And this would go a step farther about, you know, outlining.
If we have a case where the condemned inmate is related to both, the victim, I mean, in other words, was a relative of the victim, then the lines get kind of blurred on are they a relative of the condemned or are they
a relative of the victim. Okay. But that would already, I mean, conceivably that's already an issue. Yes, sir. Yes, yes. Now, Senator Hester has offered up some of his GIF funding
for purposes of constructing a separate room. And I think you all have already addressed this to some degree, but I just would like to hear specifically what, if he's willing to put up the money for this, if the funding's there and a separate room's constructed, what issues still remain in the Department of Corrections' mind with regard to proceeding down this
Speaker 80
33:02
road? I think the very real possibility of facing a lawsuit or more over the fact that the inmate's family won't be present,
And then there's the logistics we would have to work out. Plus, in this bill, it actually does two things with the victim's family. One, it allows some to come inside the chamber. Then it also says that others will come to the unit that night and watch via the video and audio feed. So there'd be two groups of them. And I think it's up to 30 or so. I forget if it has a number in there. But there could be, in other words, what it does is take the cap, right now set at 30,
and says this will all fit within the cap unless the family is big enough to go over the cap, and then they can all watch in a separate part of the institution. Well, what if they have a big family? And it is the Duggars, as Senator Hester said. And all of a sudden we've got close family members, and there's 40 of them that are watching and five of them in the execution chamber. because that makes it a sliding cap that slides
according to the size of the family. And I'm sympathetic to the difficult job that the department has.
I guess with regard to the issue being raised of litigation, I mean, y'all would agree, when you're dealing with the death penalty, litigation, that comes with the territory. I mean, there is always going to be litigation, and, I mean, even to the standpoint now, we already allow the victim's family to watch. So, I mean, to me, I'm just not sure if we're carrying out the death penalty. I think the litigation component, that just comes with the territory. But I appreciate your testimony, and thank you for clarifying that for me.
Thank you. Thank you. And, all right, committee, we've got a lot of stuff on the agenda. Representative Ballinger, you're next, but let's keep it brief. We need to move
on. Thank you, Chairman. How are the citizens selected now currently? People write in to ask
the people. I'm sorry. I'm sorry, Representative Ballinger. Director, we're going to move on. We've got to deal with the bill, not with how the other people are selected. We want to talk about the condemned family, so we need to move on. Representative Ballinger, do you want to have another question? Well, and that's fine.
My thinking is that we're talking about six citizens, so how would they be selected and what would be the reasoning why we would have these individuals who are citizens and other individuals who are citizens who would be kept out. I apologize. I'm back with
you. Go ahead with the question. I think it's
a proper question. Okay. Well, the six citizens, people that view the execution are selected. They write in to the director, and the director picks which six.
We're looking for people that doesn't have any axe to grind or anything for or against the death penalty, just want to come and view the execution. We want six citizens' witnesses there that can view the execution and, let's say, a lack of better words, a neutral party to see that it was carried out in a humane, sterile way. I go back to the room of the building of the room. We don't have it. My opinion is, as a board, and I'm only one member,
that we would have to build another room to make this happen. We cannot make this happen without another room. There's just too much room for error. And so that's our position on it. Thank you. Representative Bain, you recognize for a
Chairman. I'm trying to understand the history. Since 1997 or 1999, we've had this separate viewing room with up to five. Have we had any kind of outbursts or any kind of issues from any of those family members since we started having that separate viewing room?
Has there been any history that would give us calls or pause for a concern of having them actually in the viewing room itself?
Speaker 80
37:03
I don't think that we – that I'm aware of any. I know that, you know, it's emotional and they're tense, but I am unaware of any outburst. Thank
you. Any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, thank you very much. We've got somebody to speak for the bill. It looks like Belinda Ritter. Ms. Ritter, if you'll make your way to the end of the table, please, ma'am.
If you'll introduce yourself to everybody, you're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Belinda Harris Ritter. I'm an attorney. I'm an adjunct professor of Crime Victim Rights at UALR in the Undergraduate Criminal Justice Department. I'm a member of the Board of Directors of the National Organization for Victim Assistance. I previously served on the California Parole Board, appointed
by Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger. And my parents were murdered in Stone County, Arkansas, In 1981, the man who murdered them was charged with capital murder. Several months after a number of continuances, he pled guilty to avoid the death penalty, so I did not have to go through dealing with whether I wanted to be there or not. But I have, as an attorney and in my role with other victims' organizations, worked
with a number of people who have had to deal with this issue. I will keep this brief. I know that there's a limited amount of time, but I think there are some points that are important. First of all, the victim's family has given up more than anybody in the entire state when it comes to the murder of someone in their family. And only murderers get the death penalty.
So we're dealing with a pretty horrible murder for it to have been charged as capital murder to have that person convicted and to go through years of appeals and then still be winding up at the death chamber. To say that there can be 30 people but we don't need the victims in there because they might cause a fuss is offensive to me. The victims are years away from the death of their loved one. They have scar tissue over
their hearts by that time. Of course it's possible there might be an emotional outburst, but there also might be an emotional outburst from the spiritual advisor or the attorney for the defendant who has worked closely with them. And I want to address Representative Williams' question about equal protection. There is no equal protection problem here because murderers' families are not a protected class. I think to say we have room for everyone
except the victims is horrible. Of all the people affected, the victims' families are affected the most, and they should be the first people, if they choose to be there, You should be allowed to see that it really happens and how it's carried out. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions from the committee?
Seeing none, thank you very much. It looks like we have nobody else to speak against the bill, so we got somebody to speak for. It looks like Rebecca DeMauro. DeMauro.
I'm sorry if I didn't get that right. If you'll just make your way to the end of the table, please,
ma'am, introduce yourself to everybody. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and everyone for having me here. My name is Rebecca DeMauro, and if I can just give a little background on my story, my 12-year-old daughter, Andy Brewer, was kidnapped, raped, and murdered in Polk County in 1999, and her
Her murderer decided to appeal not to appeal, if that makes any sense at all. So we've kind of been through some ugly things, and they went ahead and decided to let him not appeal. So in 2004, Governor Huckabee signed the death warrant, and my family was rushed over to the prison to view this execution, which did not happen in what I sort of call a non-execution.
What happened that night to my family was pretty much beyond horrible. We got there. We did not know that we were not going to be able to be behind that glass to view. And to me, at that time, and even more so now, I feel like that as Andy's mother, that I have the right to see to the last business of her life. She was a little girl. She was 12 years old, but only by one month and five days.
So she was a little girl who was preyed upon and murdered, and it is my job as her mother to see to the last business of her life. And when I got to the prison and I was escorted while the prosecutor and the FBI and all these people who never knew her were escorted into the execution viewing room and myself and four other family members were taken into the warden's office to view on a TV that wasn't any bigger than anything.
and the TV was grainy, it was kind of green, you could make out the execution place, but I felt so robbed that I was not able to see to her last business on this planet. So, I mean, this was in 2004, so this just went around in my head for years and years and years. And in 2011, I started writing letters, and I got no response until finally Senator Hester.
I sat down with him and said, this is not good. Can we do something to make this right? And it's just right. He's been on death row now for longer than she was even alive. And I feel that I should have the right to choose. I should have the right to choose, to see. I mean, if I may, I mean, she was a little bitty girl. She was my daughter. And I just want what's right.
And I feel like that if I'm able to see that execution, then I should have the right to choose, as should any victim, then that should be our choice, not to be escorted off into a side room and people that never even met or knew her have that right. It's not fair. It's not fair. I loved her. I taught her to walk and talk. She's my baby girl, and I'll never, ever see her again. And it's my job as her mom to see to the last business of her life on this planet.
And that's what I'm asking today. And I'm open to questions as well. I'm going to leave this, but we're going
to do something different here. I'm going to leave this up to you. If you want to take questions, I'll allow them. If you don't, I
anybody have any questions? Seeing none from the committee. I'm sorry for
Okay. There has been nobody else to sign to speak for or against the bill. Any other questions from committee? Seeing none. Senator Hester, you're recognized to close for your
bill. Thank you. I want to address three points. The first point is the amendment that we possibly talked about. While I was waiting, I sent it to Brent Gasper and BLR, and it said, hey, could you shoot this amendment over to me quickly? And his response to me was that he thinks that that is not a good amendment because he says what it's speaking to is the person shall be present.
If you follow down, it's the director or assistant director and the Department of Correction officials in charge of medical services. He's saying those people shall be present, and they need to be present. He said when you go farther down, when it talks about the victims' families, that's when it talks about it gives them, it says chooses specifically for them. So in his recommendation, he does not think we should amend that, but we certainly could. But the second thing I would like to mention, this is a little bit I think we've heard from a few people today
that this is something potentially that could give people stays or hold off in execution. So I think if you are not for the death penalty, maybe this is something good to vote for. It gives somebody a little hope. And if you're for the death penalty, I think you should be for the victim's rights. And then in closing, I think we just have to look at this and say we understand this is not a great situation for either side. It's very difficult for the Department of Corrections and the charge that we give them in seeing these out, and this is not a good situation for the victims' families. I just ask that you side with the victims' families and a good vote.
Thank you, Senator. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Scott, you have a motion due pass. Representative Scott has a motion due pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Opposed. The ayes have it. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Is there anybody else in the audience ready to present their bill?
Is there anybody from committee? Representative Neal, you're recognized. Representative Neal, if you'll just let everybody know which bill you're going to run. Representative Neal, are you running the concurrence for House Bill 1409? Are you recognized? Present House Bill 1409
in the concurrence. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. There she is right there. I have Dinah Tyler with me from the Department of Corrections, and she's going to speak to this. Mr.
Speaker 80
48:07
Chairman, members of the committee, this bill was amended on the Senate
sent it in to correct an oversight on our part, all it does is take those offenders already given the classification of sexually violent predator and roll them in to the new classification outlined in this bill, which is sexually dangerous person. We just wanted to make sure that we didn't have a situation where someone under the old designation could say oh this doesn't apply to me because I'm not that I'm
this and that's all we're doing is correcting the oversight
any questions from a committee on the concurrence any questions from a committee seen none from the audience anybody what's the pleasure of the committee got a motion to adopt the accept the concurrence all those in favor say aye all those Those opposed? Looks like the ayes have it. Congratulations. We concurred in your bill. My good friend Senator Thompson is down there. Senator Thompson, are you ready? I'm not ready.
Okay. Is there anybody else? Representative Edwards. Vice Chair Vines, you're recognized. Mr. Vice Chair, if you'll just let everybody know which bills you're running we appreciate it and you're recognized Thank you Mr. Chair,
good to be back in House Judiciary House Bill 2029 is the bill I bring forth today
This is a simple cleanup bill brought to clean up the definition of custodian in dependent and neglect proceedings. What this bill does is, for purposes of foster care cases and parental counsel representation, it eliminates the distinction between guardian and custodian. It will further ensure that the statutes comport with juvenile judges' current practice and will not increase cases or expand programs. Essentially, this will make more efficient use of state funds.
Simple bill, two pages. The biggest change is right there in the middle of page one where it defines who's entitled to custody under that definition of custodian, who's entitled to write to counsel, excuse me. And that is the essence of the bill. I'll
Any questions from the committee? Seeing none, and seeing none for or against from the audience. What's the pleasure of Representative Byrnes? Do you want to close your bill? Absolutely.
I'm closed for the bill. All right. Looks like Representative Bain, did you have a motion? Got a motion to be passed. Representative Bain, all those in favor say aye. All those opposed, looks like the ayes have it. Congratulations. You've passed your bill. Thank you, committee, Mr. Chair. Representative Steele, you're recognized. If you'll just let everybody know, Representative Steele, which bill you're running, you'll recognize.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have two bills here that are very similar in nature. One is Senate Bill 1766. Members, this bill deals with enhancements for multiple offenses of delivery of a controlled substance. Many of you know during Act 570 we changed some of the delivery of controlled substances to misdemeanors. Those involved in Act 570, Representative Williams and the governor's office and others, that had a lot of input on that act, mentioned at the time that if there was any major kinks we needed to work out
after the act went into place, we could come back and address those. This is one of the ones that was a consensus that the prosecutors and other law enforcement officers came back, asked for some compromise on this, and that's what both of these bills are. But the first one, Senate Bill 766, simply says that if you have multiple deliveries, if you have four prior convictions, the fifth could be charged as a Class D felony, which is the lowest felony in the criminal code, zero to six years. So I'll be happy to take any questions on that, but previously we just made them misdemeanors.
This just says if you have five, just keep people from going through the revolving door where sheriffs arrest them, bring them in, take up jail space, release them, arrest them, bring them in, take up jail space over and over. So this just says if you get caught on the
fifth time, you can be charged with a Class D felony. I'd be happy
to take any questions. Any questions from committee? Representative Williams, you're recognized. Only because he called my name. I want to say that I am fine with this amendment. While I think it's unnecessary, I don't oppose it. Thank you, Representative Williams.
I have a huge amount of respect for Representative Williams. Representative Steele, isn't this basically fixing what you and I talked about, a fix of somebody taking that misdemeanor amount, going home, coming back out, selling it, going back, coming back. And after the fifth time, I mean, that's a lot of times correct? As I mentioned, it's been a
problem for county sheriffs. They want to make sure that they don't have the same inmates in their jail every week, which after a while does happen. And as we all know, we end up not being able to collect those fines
and that's part of why the Administration of Justice fund is in the shape it's in. So this just gives a little bit extra tool for law enforcement
after multiple offenses. Representative Williams, you're recognized. Mr. Steele, don't you agree that we have some of the most outstanding prosecutors in the country and they are quite able to find ways to make sure that these folks are convicted of felonies even without this. While I support this, they would do a good job even without it.
Isn't that right? That's correct and you were kind enough
to accommodate that during Act 570. We do appreciate it.
Any other questions from committee? Seeing none, nobody signed to speak for or against the bill. Looks like Representative Sid, do you want to close for your bill? I
will just close for my bill by saying I appreciate a good vote, and I'll go ahead and have a
motion if the Chair wants to recognize one. I'll recognize the motion. I'm assuming it's due pass. Due pass. Got a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed, the
ayes have it. Congratulations, you've passed your bill. Thank you, committee. Mr. Chairman, the next bill I have is Senate Bill 778. Again, same statute, same enhancement, just deals with different controlled substances.
As you all know, our controlled substances are divided out into schedules. This covers the schedules that the other bill did not.
Any questions from committee? Seeing none, none from the audience. Representative Steele, are you closed for your bill? I'm closed. Representative Williams had a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, look like the ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, committee, and particularly Representative Williams. Representative Scott, are you ready? If you'll just let everybody know which bill you're running.
Representative Scott, you're recognized. Is that 2064, Representative? 2054. Representative, you're recognized to present House Bill 2054. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Finally, I have an easy bill. Isn't that wonderful? Well, this bill is to prohibit a registered sex offender from residing within 2,000 feet of a private park.
And I'm ready for questions if you have any.
Representative Steele, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Scott, what is a private park? I thought
all parks were basically public. Could you tell us what a private park is? A private park would be in a subdivision, like where there were probably 20 or more homes. And in northwest Arkansas, we have lots of subdivisions that qualify and do have private parks.
I know I've heard from people in Conway, Maumelle, and Pulaski County also. So that seems to be a real popular thing now that the subdivisions offer to entice younger families to move into those subdivisions, a place for the children to play. Are there any markings or anything
that a sex offender would know he or she was in a private
park? Yes, usually the parks or any of the ones that I have seen have signs up that say private park, and it's usually put there by the homeowners association.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Any other questions from committee? Representative Bain,
you're recognized. Well, I'm kind of following up on Representative Steele. That was really my only concern with this. How do you differentiate between a private park and just open a vacant lot and some of these subdivisions? I mean, what is the – do we have a test to say – I mean, does it have to have something set up for an activity, or can it just really just be an open
field? Well, I guess it could really just be an open field there that they hadn't even built anything in yet, and they could designate that that is a private park
until they did get it built and ready for the children or the
families. Thank you. Representative Nichols, you're recognized. You mentioned subdivisions and property owners, and sometimes they have property owners associations. Sometimes the covenants talk about common facilities like a swimming pool or a park area, and when they bought that lot, whoever they are, they're entitled to
those things, are they not? So are you interfering with their contract rights, the covenants that run with that land that will be a park for the benefit of the lot owners there? How do you deal with that aspect of it? I think you're interfering with the covenants on that land if you're saying, but even though you own this and you bought this, you cannot get that benefit from your ownership because of this particular law.
How do you respond to that? I respond to that with this. I think anyone who is paying dues into a homeowners association would be happy to have this sign or a sign in their part to hopefully prevent anything from happening to their children. And this lot is owned, this property is owned by all of the homeowners. That's why they're paying dues. That's part of it. But
if I can follow up, what I'm saying is the people you're focusing on here,
they also may be property owners in that subdivision. I'm not talking about somebody from outside coming in. I understand. I'm talking about the contract rights of the people who
live in that subdivision. And in this bill, if you had read, you would have found that it states very clearly that those people who are offenders, who are already living in a subdivision, it does not affect them. They are grandfathered in. This prevents anyone new who has been convicted of a sex crime who might move in,
and this would include Level 3 and Level 4 sex offenders. And if you know anything about what a Level 3 and a Level 4 sex offender does, those are terribly heinous crimes. And for someone, some young family, to work for 10, 15 years to get their family in a nice neighborhood and have to put up with something like that, I think this is not anything but fair. This should have been enacted
years ago. But I'm still, from a legal standpoint, those promises run with that land,
and I question whether or not we can take that away from them by state law or city ordinance or whatever. I'm just speaking it from looking at potential problems that you might have. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Representative Walker,
you're recognized. Yes. I don't know how you define nice neighborhood. Would
you tell me how you define that? I define a nice neighborhood as a neighborhood where children can play safely,
where families can entertain friends, where families can teach their children about church, and where a mother can sit at a park on a park bench and watch
her two- and five-year-old play. So according to your definition, children who come from families where there is one parent who live in a housing project or who may live in a residence where they are transient,
those persons are by definition not in a nice neighborhood would you not agree? I
it's my turn Scott, we're moving on I appreciate what you want to do but we're kind of getting off so everybody will stay on
point Ms. Walker, if you've got a question the point is this seems to be a nice neighborhood bill uh did you did you ever think about the fact that private park uh is not defined in this bill
i mean it's it's whatever you want it to be it could be a vacant lot next to somebody's house let's assume i live in one of these bad neighborhoods and i have and i have a vacant lot and i let kids come and play on that that's my private park why is this not the same as a park that someone designates in a gated community or in one of these nice neighborhoods that you mentioned, why is it not entitled, why are those people to be treated differently?
They are not. A private park could be anywhere for any race, any color. It does not matter. Well, doesn't that make it void
for vagueness and also otherwise unconstitutional? No, sir. Okay, any other
questions from the committee? Seeing none, we've got a couple to speak for and against. It looks like Carla Swanson. Ms. Swanson, if you'll just go to the end of the table, introduce yourself to anybody, please.
Tell them who you're with. You'll be recognized.
Speaker 148
1:03:07
It's true. Hello, Mr. Chair. I'm Carla Swanson. I'm with Arkansas time after time. I represent sex offenders. Ms. Scott, you were talking about level threes and fours. I would like to give a short little definition of a level four. I have two men who are, one of them is in his 60s. He's mentally challenged. He has a hearing aid. When he went for his assessment, he was a level one because all he had done was touch a lady on the breast.
When he went in for assessment, he put his hand up into his ear because his hearing aid was going low. That showed aggressiveness, and he is now a level four. Another young man that I know, his crime was child pornography. He is 100% deaf. He was not allowed to bring an interpreter with him when he got his assessment done. He was classified as being difficult. He's a level four.
Now, when you say that these bills are against level threes and fours, you're putting it against some of these people that were mislabeled when they went down to Pine Bluff. You've got men who are actually successful and may be able to live in these neighborhoods and have worked extremely hard to get where they're at, who have families. They would love to live in these neighborhoods with a private park, and this is going to hurt them. So, you know, as much as I, you know, I do know that we have some bad people out there,
but when we have Pine Bluff who is misinterpreting some of our assessments down there, and even though Level 4 is deemed one of the worst ones, you do have some Level 4s that are not bad people. And these laws are hurting some innocent people. So that's one of the things I wanted to point out.
Thank you, Ms. Fonson. Are there any questions from committee? Seeing no questions from committee, Ms. Swanson, thank you very much. Looks like we have somebody else to speak against the bill. Jeff, Mr. Rosenzweig, you're recognized.
If you'll just introduce yourself to the table, remind
everybody who you are, you're recognized. Jeff Rosenzweig, Arkansas Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, and we as an organization spoken against these bills every time another classification is added of where you can't live. The problem that you have is that the more places, particularly in urban areas where
someone can't live, you are driving people underground. And this is the presumably unintended consequence. They've had the same problem in other states. And if the purpose is to figure out where these people are, the more places you say you can't live, you lose track of them, you don't know where they are, and you've defeated the purpose that you're trying to do. Thank you, Mr. Rosenzweig.
I've got a question. Representative Williams, you'll
recognize for a question. Mr. Rosenzweig, you make a good point. Let me ask you a couple of questions. Most of our criminal policy usually is based on some evidence-based principle that it actually works. knowledge, any research indicating
that these residential restrictions are actually effective? MR. I don't see where they are. Again, the ones we have have forced people away from their homes. You have to own the home, for instance. And, for instance, let's say
you have someone who is not the owner but was the caretaker of an elderly parent. Parent own the home, and he or she has to leave and can't be there to take care of the parent. You run into that all the time. It's hard to count alleged offenses that were never committed because you don't know whether they would have been committed. And also adding to what Ms. Swanson said, essentially, as far as I can tell, Level 3
It's sort of the default assessment level at the sex offender assessment people. And so you have a lot of people who are level threes who you don't see where they got there. The appellate process is basically nonexistent because the way the law is written, you appeal to one person on the board and then any appeal from theirs to the circuit court which only
has to find whether there's basically a rational basis for
finding where they are. These restrictions on sex offender law seem to be based on a couple of myths, one that sex offenders are likely to reoffend or treatment doesn't work or what we call stranger danger. Are you familiar with any reason or any rationale
why such restrictions would be successful? Well, you know, it's, you know, it's, I don't see, you know, what your, let me rephrase it this way.
When the U.S. Supreme Court got these cases, all the Supreme Court said was, we are upholding the laws that require people to register and tell us where they are. We are not saying you can't live here, you can't work there. All these have been added on subsequently, and the U.S. Supreme Court has never said one way or the other, we are approving these restrictions, and the more restrictions you
place on them, the more it is going to be deemed a punishment and thus subject to all sorts of ex post facto issues, things like that, too. MR. Any other questions
from committee? Seeing none, I don't see anybody else signed up to speak for or against. Thank you, Mr. Rosenzweig. Any other questions from committee? Just seeing none, Mrs. Scott, Representative Scott, would you like to close for your bill?
Yes, I would. Currently, this law says that registered offenders may not live. Let me see. I'm sorry. Okay. Registered offenders living near schools, public parks, youth centers, or daycare centers. Those are the people who are affected currently. All this does is add two words, private park. I don't know about you all, but there are not enough laws for me to make or suggest to protect my grandchildren or my children.
I think if this, adding two little words, private park, keeps even one precious child from being taken or one precious child from going through what the young mother talked about earlier that we heard her testimony, then I think it's a good bill. I think for you all today in this committee, this would be a good vote, and I'd certainly appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you, Representative Scott.
What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Fite, you have a motion.
We got a motion due pass from Representative Fite. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? No's have it. Sorry, the bill has failed. All right, is there anybody else that has? I got two for a roll call. Representative Scott, you've asked for a roll call. And Representative Fite, are
Speaker 155
1:11:22
you asking for a roll call? Representative Hodges, Representative Hodges, Representative Broadway, Representative
Broadway. Representative Neal. Yes. Representative Wagner. Yes. Representative Bain. Yes. Representative Balinger. Yes. Representative Fite. Yes. Representative McGee. No. Representative
Kazay. Yes. Representative Malkeroy. Yes. Representative Scott. Yes. Representative Walker? No. Representative Gillum? Representative Shepard? Yes. Representative Steele? No. Representative
Representative Slinkard. Representative Nichols. Representative Nichols. Representative
The bill fails. All right, is there anybody else here to run a bill? Anybody on committee that wants to run a bill? Last chance. Anybody else in the audience? Seeing none, do I have a motion? Got a motion to adjourn? All those in favor say aye.
Agenda
HB1555
SB52
HB1409
HB2029
SB766
SB778
HB2054
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Marshall Wright Chair
Unverified
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Breck Hopkins
Unverified
Senator Bart Hester
Unverified
Representative Darrin Williams Chair
Unverified
Representative Jim Nickels
Unverified
Representative John Baine
Unverified
Representative Mary L. Slinkard
Unverified
Representative Nate Steel
Unverified
Speaker 70
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Speaker 80
Chair
Unverified
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd
Unverified
Belinda Harris
Unverified
Rebecca Demauro
Unverified
Speaker 87
Representative Micah S. Neal
Unverified
Representative John Charles Edwards
Unverified
Speaker 10
Representative Sue Scott
Unverified
Speaker 144
Speaker 148
Speaker 155
Speaker 157