House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (16)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1605
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1605”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB546
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB546”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1653
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “on HB 1653. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, what this amendment does,…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1750
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1750”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1961
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “sorry, House Bill 1961. And this amendment just corrects a mistake in an earlier v…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB154
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ry. I'm sorry. I'm 154. I'm looking on down the road there. Senate Bill 154. Is there an amendment on that bill? And we have an amendme…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB744
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB744”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB891
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “891 891. You are recognized to present Senate Bill 891.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1840
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1840”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1842
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1842”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB812
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB812”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB813
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB813”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB212
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB212”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB788
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB788”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB878
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB878”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB953
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB953”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
I'm going to go ahead and recognize them. What's a lady's name that, oh, in the purple, she's the one who introduced them to me. I don't know, sir.
Okay, everybody's kind of getting settled. At this time, I have some AEA members from Little Rock here. If y'all would stand, I'm not going to tell everybody's name, but if y'all would just stand, we'd like to recognize you today.
for being here with us glad you're here is mr. wood in the room tony wood
Scott, we're going to make a presentation. Sorry.
Okay, he'll join us later. Okay, Scott, go ahead. Take the end. I'm sorry. At this time, we're going to concur on a couple of amendments from the Senate. Representative Balch, you are recognized to present your concurred amendment
on HB 1653. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, what this amendment does, it puts in place what I told you on the House floor.
If we don't have the money, we're not going to fund this is basically what it
does. So, appreciate a good vote. Any questions on the amendment? Need a motion to concur. Representative Ratliff makes a motion to do pass on the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, you've passed your amendment. Thank you. And at this time, you're recognized to present the concur amendment on HB1750 for Deborah Ferguson, Representative Ferguson.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, what this does, it just changes on page 1, line 10. It deletes colleges and declares an emergency is what this does. Any questions? What's the will, committee? Have a
due pass from Representative Ratliff. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed both of those amendments. Thank you. Thank you, committee.
Still don't have it in a room. Representative Tucker, you are recognized to take the end, and I've got to get the
right bill here. I think it's House Bill 1605. Yeah,
1605. House Bill 1605, is that correct? All right. You're recognized to present House Bill 1605.
I will go ahead and tell you this, Representative Tucker, and I'm sure you know this will be the second time you've presented this. If it fails this time, it is either dead or has to be expunged to bring it back up. Thank you, Mr.
Speaker 32
3:23
Chairman. All right, thank you. You're recognized. Thank you, members of the committee. I'm here to discuss one more time with you House Bill 1605. I have amended the bill to accommodate a concern raised by Representative Bell.
This restriction was applicable to any subcontractors or third party affiliates of an entity that contract. And again, we're talking about a bill where a state takes over a local school district and the Arkansas Department of Education contracts with a private entity regarding the management of the local school district. And we're talking about making that relationship transparent for the people in the community whose school district has been taken over. And the only documents that would be subject to this provision related to the agreement between ADE and the private entity after the amendment
are documents that relate to the educational policies and procedures of the public school district under the administrative control of the state. And so I thought the bill was pretty narrowly tailored before, but I definitely think so now. One other point I want to make is I know there's been an email floating around about language that should be included in the bill to protect parties that give money to public schools or school districts or the state. That language was actually sent to me by Kathy Smith, the executive director of the Walton Foundation before I ever filed the bill, and that language
is included in the bill in subsection 6. And so if all you're doing is giving money to a public school or school district, even if those entities are under the state control, this section does not apply. So those entities are protected. I don't want to do anything to discourage private entities from giving money to school districts so those entities are protected because I incorporated the language that Ms. Smith sent me. I just also want to highlight one point It's a conversation that Representative Gossage and I had, a concern that he raised after the bill was heard the first time about the way FOI works.
I think most people think that if you have a public e-mail address and a private e-mail address, that everything that you do on your public e-mail address is foiable and everything on your private e-mail address is not foiable. But that's not the way the FOI works. The way that it works is if you send an e-mail that's related to your public duties, then it's foiable. And so if you send a private email, then it's not foiable. So you can send an email to your wife about what you're having for dinner that night on your public email, but that's not foiable. If you have a Gmail address and you send an email that relates to your public duties, then that is foiable.
Representative Gossage's concern was about having the police or a judge or somebody go into a private email account or a private company and search documents, and that's not the way the FOI works. That's never happened. We got quite a bit of
noise. I'm going to have to ask if y'all could kind of quiet down. We're having a hard time hearing everything up here. Okay, go ahead and continue.
Speaker 32
6:08
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And so if you have a public entity that has a method of capturing documents or e-mails in the administrative office,
then that's a way that documents are turned over. But if I'm just a private, I mean, I'm a public employee, and I have a private e-mail account, It's essentially up to me to turn documents over to the public entity that's been FOIA'd for those documents to be turned over. It's never happened in the history of Arkansas that I'm aware that a judge has gone in to go through a private company's records or a person's private email account to determine whether they're responsive to public documents. That's just not the way the FOI works. And so I wanted to absolve that.
Again, I'll be brief. I just wanted to say that this bill largely codifies law that's been in case law for 40 years with a couple of tweaks to it. And the intent of the bill is not to address educational policy in any way. It's not for or against charter schools. It's not for or against unions. It's not for or against pre-K or after school or summer programs. I know you all have thoughts on that, as does everyone in the room. But the intent of this bill is simply to provide a local community with the same level of transparency
as what's happening with their local school district when that school district has been taken over the state that they have when the district is under local control. That's it. It's a good intent. It's narrowly drawn to achieve that goal, and so I would appreciate a good vote. Are there questions from the committee? Seeing no
questions. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill?
All right. You're recognized. State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized to
Speaker 39
8:02
speak for the bill. Erica Ivey. Erica Ivey. I am a teacher. I'm a teacher in the Little Rock School District. When I first read this bill, I thought it was really interesting, not because it was for the Board of Education,
but everybody in this room has gone to a high school at some point in their lives. And we all know how rumors work, and as a teacher in a high school, I can say that it's pretty much the same thing, just a little bit worse probably with us because sometimes we don't know what's going on and so if if we can can work together with the board of education discuss any moves that are going to
be made in in terms of policy or what the community can do to help our kids that's the most important thing. And, you know, we have to be transparent. We like transparency all across the democratic process. And that's really all I had to say. So, thank you. Thank
you. Anyone speak against
the bill? I'm going to go one more time on four, and then we're going to go to clean up. State your
Speaker 44
9:32
name and who you're with, and you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Chris Hiller. I'm with Friday Firm in Little Rock, and I've represented a number of school districts over the years and answered a lot of FOI requests. I just want to talk about one case briefly that illustrates, I think, why this bill is needed. And I agree with Representative Tucker that there are about 40 years' worth
of Arkansas Supreme Court cases which say that when a private entity steps in and does work that would otherwise be done by a state agency, that entity is subject to the FOIA. But there's a case in the Arkansas Supreme Court, Sweeney against Tilford, where Deloitte Touche, accounting firm, was doing some audits for ADFA. And someone sued to get Deloitte's working papers. Deloitte opposed that. They said they wouldn't give them up without a subpoena.
The court ended up ruling not only that Deloitte's working papers were public documents, but that ADFA had the responsibility to get those documents and make them available to the public. So this bill would make it clear on the front end to anyone who contracts with ADE for the limited purposes Representative Tucker talked about what their responsibilities are. They wouldn't be surprised to know that they were subject to the FOIA and the State Department of Education wouldn't be surprised to know that they would be responsible for making those documents public.
So I think while the bill is right in line with case law in the FOIA, I think it could be very useful in putting the Department of Education and potential consultants on notice of the particular requirements. Thank you. Are there any questions? Thank you,
sir. All right. Would you like to close for your bill? Thank you for your time. I'd appreciate a good vote.
Representative Saban, you have a motion? I'd like to move due pass, Mr. Chair. I have a due pass motion. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed, no? I'm sorry, the ayes have it. You didn't like the way I said that, did you? Oh, I have a roll call. I'm sorry. Didn't see that. I do see two hands on a roll call. It'll take us just a second to get ready.
Speaker 53
12:08
Representative Letting. Aye. Representative Murdoch. Representative Murdoch. Representative Deffenbaugh. No. Representative Harris. Representative Harris. What is this? Representative Eubanks. No. Representative Ratliff. Yes. Representative Gillum. Representative Gillum. Representative Walker.
Yes. Representative Bell. Representative Bell. Representative Balz Representative Douglas Representative Douglas Representative Lowry Representative McElroy Representative Armstrong Representative Gossage Representative Gossage Representative Saban
Representative Hodges Representative Gray Representative Lampkin Congratulations,
Alright, at this time I am going to
since Senator English is here I'm going to go ahead and let her get hers and get out of here if you're alright with that Greg Senator English Senator English if you'll hold on the end just a minute you can go ahead and take the end if you want to I have a presentation to make from the committee and if I could get Tony Wood are you still in here come forward please I'm going to get away from the mic to do this.
Speaker 80
14:19
As you all know, today was the last night? Yesterday was the last night. You have a lot of plays. Well, you know, I don't know if it's today or this, but you need to add to what? Tony is basically is kind of retiring among us and he's going to hang on for a little while and I think it works with him. We want to give you a citation. It has my name on it, but we couldn't get everybody's name off. This is from the whole committee, I believe you. I'm not going to read it. Everybody kind of knows what they say. I'm going to hold on.
The President, we appreciate all you have done, and we thank you so much. Thank you. Tell
us what you're going to do after this, anyway.
Speaker 80
15:32
so many of you that I see in the room I am very pleased in regard to what I've had the opportunity to be with him since 2004 and it's always been up here as a man of the day and without question, it's hard to the kids and that's been exemplified time after time in regard to his leadership on Sunday so I really look forward to what he will bring to the table you have a lot going down
so we'll make some progress thank you I'll make sure I've
got the right bills you have it which one do you want
891 891. You are recognized to present Senate Bill 891.
Thank you. Jane English. There is an amendment to
that bill. Is that correct? No, there's no amendment. Oh, is there? There is. We do have an amendment to that bill. We're going to pass that out. It's the sponsor's amendment. That's all this does. Oh, okay. And I will recognize the motion for the amendment at any time. Representative Eubanks makes a motion to do pass on the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay. The amendment has passed. You are
recognized to present the bill as amended. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. This is a part of the governor's package
workforce package and what it does is it establishes a fund inside of the Department of Higher Education for planning grants, for regional planning grants encouraging folks to work with their business and industry in their areas and to determine what those needs are and what their future looks like and put together a plan. So that's pretty much exactly what this bill does.
Walker you are recognized. Thank you Mr. Chair. What is the goal of this Act? The The goal of this act is to provide planning grants for regional areas, economic development areas, workforce investment areas to come together and identify the industry needs in their area. Could be any kind of industry needs.
Could be agriculture, could be high tech, could be anything. But the governor's idea is to have regional boards and this is exactly what it will do. Follow up, Mr. Chair. You are recognized for follow-up. What is the amount
of money that is being devoted to this particular bill? There would be planning
grants up to $100,000. $2 million all told. So that would be 20 regions?
Ten. Ten regions. Could be ten regions, could be 20. What would happen
to the other million dollars? You're recognized for that third follow-up. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ten regions and $100,000 apiece is a million. That leaves a million. What
happens to the other million? It could be 20 regions. The amount of money that's coming out of the governor's fund is $2 million, and the grants could be anywhere up to $100,000. It might be $25,000 for an area to apply for a planning grant.
They're all competitive. Mr. Chair, if nobody else has a question, I'd like to know what the regions are, but I'll defer it to
someone else. Which regions they are, that's your question. Well,
if it's regions, I mean, there has to be some predetermination of geography. I don't think those regions have been
determined. I don't think those have been set. No. Yeah. It'll be up to the folks throughout the state to decide what those regions are. Representative Walker, I don't believe those regions have been set yet. Thank
you. So we just have a batch of money that people can apply for,
and if they apply, they can get grants of up to $100,000. Well, and I'll just state this from
the chair. A lot of those things, when we do these bills, a lot of things have to go through and have everything set up to fix this, and this just hasn't got there yet, so it will. Right now,
there are no rules and regulations. There are no rules and regulations. It's just setting
the framework. That's correct. Any other questions? Does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill, for the bill?
You're recognized to close for your bill? I'm closed. Thank you. Mr. McIlroy, you're a recognized rep. Move, do pass. I have a motion, do pass as amended. Thank you. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? You have passed your bill.
Thank you very much. I have one more. What's your other one? The
546, Senate Bill 546. And what this does is it goes through its cleanup language and it takes out for the Arkansas Code, takes out general economic, I mean, GED, and puts in high school equivalency.
Are there any questions? Yeah. Representative Walker, you're
recognized for a question. What is the purpose of this? I mean, if it's high school equivalency and GED, what's the purpose?
There could be other exams as we go along. GED may not be the only high school equivalency program. Do you know of any, Mr. Chair, may I
follow up? You may. Thank you. Do you know of any other equivalency exams in the state of Arkansas now?
I don't at this point in time. Is there anybody in this? I'm sorry, Mr. Chair. You recognize one more. Is there anybody in the State Department of Education with whom you have consulted who could tell you about other equivalency exams? I'd like
to know more about what they are before I say yes to it. This is really coming out of the Department of Career Education and the Adult Education Program, and they have determined that it limits the ability. instead of saying just a GED is the only high school
equivalency, that there could be other possibilities. And we've passed some things already in this legislative session. Thank you, Senator. Are there any other questions on this
committee? Does anyone in the audience like to speak against it? For it? Are you closed? Are you closed for your bill? I'm closed. I'm sorry. Representative Armstrong, you recognize for a motion? Move, do pass. I have a motion to do pass from Representative Armstrong.
All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your other bill. Hold on. Representative Letting is recognized. I need a motion to suspend the rules. I need a motion to suspend the rules to hear his bill. I have a motion from Representative Letting to suspend the rules to hear this. The impact is not laid on the desk for three days.
It's the only problem, and we're running out of time. So I have a motion. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion carries. You are recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr.
Chair and Madam Vice Chair, members of the committee. I'll be very brief. We've seen a number of bills filed to protect privacy at certain levels in this session. and I myself have filed a number of them. This is a bill that would protect student privacy here in Arkansas. Actually, we have an amendment that's
also being. Yeah, there's an amendment. That is 1961 is that bill number. Yes,
sorry, House Bill 1961. And this amendment just corrects a mistake in an earlier version of the bill.
A motion on the amendment. I have a motion from Representative Eubanks on the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? You can present
your bill as amended. Okay, thank you. Like I said, this bill would protect student data here in Arkansas. The bill is based off of model legislation used elsewhere in the country. It started in California. The bill would prevent outside contractors that sometimes work with our K-12 public schools who collect student data to help create an app, an educational app of some sort.
The bill would prohibit those service contractors from using that data to provide targeted advertising on any of these apps or services and would also prevent them from selling the student data to other individuals, companies or organizations. It would also require the state to provide reasonable security measures to protect that data from being destroyed, from having unauthorized access or being modified or used in any other inappropriate way.
And I'll leave it at that in the interest of
on the committee? All right. Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the bill? We have a motion. Any one of you are closed? I'm closed. I have a motion. I have a motion to pass from Representative Walker. As amended, sir. As amended? As amended. All right. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no?
Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative Lowry, you are recognized to present Senate Bill 744. Is that correct? Oh, wait a minute. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm 154. I'm looking on down the road there. Senate Bill 154. Is there an amendment on that bill? And we have an amendment on that one also. Has it been signed? Do you
want to explain what your amendment is real quick?
there was a drafting error that's been corrected. The original language said that the number of students in this adult charter school would be capped at 150. The amendment raises that to 350. Okay. You all have heard the amendment. Do I have a motion
on the amendment? I have a motion to do pass from Representative Letting on the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Opposed, no. Okay, amendment has passed.
You may present your bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, committee. This, I would just characterize this as a real feel-good bill, not just for the sake of feeling good, but for the sake of really being able to help a lot of individuals. We have a number, obviously a lot of folks out there that for one reason or another were not able to complete their high school education or perhaps went the route of the GED. This legislation enables the development of what would be called an adult charter school,
adult education charter school. Now, I know that that, using the word charter school, gives some, Representative Walker has already told me it gives him a little bit of heartburn, But I hope that he's going to be able to be comfortable with it because of what this is going to accomplish. Nothing I say is certainly intended to malign GED or getting a GED. But significant studies, a number of them point out, high school diploma holders earn approximately $4,700 in mean monthly earnings
compared with GED certificate holders who earn $3,100. That's $1,600 a month net gain for someone who would have a high school diploma. These adult charter schools, which would be developed by or enabled to be developed by nonprofit entities spending their own money, they would have to put in at least a million dollars towards the funding of this. This would enable folks who are out there with the GED to be able to come back,
not only earn a high school diploma, but to also earn certification in other areas concurrently. There is no funding. There's no general revenue spent. There's no funding from the state. What you do see in the bill, and let me see if I can find the exact reference. on page on page four funding for an adult education charter school shall not be provided through the public school fund so that is specifically guaranteed funding for an adult education
charter school may come from public or private sources including from the eligible entity that operates an adult education charter school in this case you we actually have an entity that is stepping forward and wanting to implement this and it would be goodwill industries they have done successfully in the states of Texas and Tennessee and Indiana. They are wanting to bring this concept to the state of Arkansas. It is not part of Senator English's workforce training package, but it certainly dovetails extremely well
with what we are wanting to do of making sure that folks that are out there, Arkansans are out there, that they are career ready. And this is going to be, as Representative Collins would say, a great tool in the toolbox. I am open for for any
questions. MR. Representative Harris, you recognize for a
question? MR. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Representative Lowry, just to, I mean, I think it's a good idea and I think nothing wrong with it, but why is this needed, I mean, as far as, I guess, let me preface the question.
Could someone just not do this? Is this something, if a non-profit's doing it, Senator English is setting up workforce, why is this needed just something extra? Well,
one of the things that's enabled by this, and I also want you to know that this is co-sponsored by Senator English, Senator Hendren, and Senator David Johnson. The charter guidelines allow some flexibility in being able to save money, save costs. So, for instance, you'd have some waivers to be able to do this at a lower cost.
That would be significant if we were talking about expending of public dollars, but it's even more significant when you're talking about a private entity that's putting the money up and wanting to maximize those resources so that
they can aid more Arkansans. Okay. Thank you. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you. Thank you for that comment about my comment.
And of course my concern is that charters are really profit centers seeking to take advantage of state operations and convert the money into private purposes even though it may be in the form of a nonprofit. I'd like to know, since you have a million dollars' worth of primary money, where the supplemental funds are going to come from, and you know what I mean by primary money, don't you?
Right. You're priming it with these private funds in order to get public funds later on.
Well, I don't know that that's necessarily the case on page two. If you
say that's not the case and you're going to continue to get private funds,
then I'll be supportive of your bill. Can you say that? Can I say that there will never be any public funds? The motive of this is not to obtain public funds for private. There is an individual here from Goodwill Industries that would be more than happy to answer that question.
That's fine. If the chairman would
allow. That's fine. You may bring him forward. State your name and
Speaker 164
32:16
the questions. Brian Marsh, Chief Operating Officer, Goodwill Industries of Arkansas. You're recognized. We are prepared to fund this, fully fund this. We are operating, Goodwill of Industries of Indiana is operating nine charter schools in Indianapolis. They do receive public funding, but that is set up in the Indiana state laws and state budget.
We are prepared, we understand the cost. The cost to operate the school is going to be between 1.8 and $2.2 million, and We are prepared to fund that with private and or foundation money that we are prepared to seek. You're right, Mass. Thank you.
Are you prepared to fund it for a number of years or is it to just get it started? We
Speaker 164
33:06
are prepared to fund this as we do other programs in the state of Arkansas.
We fund our programs through the sale of donated goods. and through foundations that we work with for grants. Thank you. Are there any other questions? Seeing
none, is there anyone in the audience would like to speak against the bill for the bill? Hold on a second, Representative Walker.
OK. I'm OK with that. I'm just making sure. Nobody for or against. I didn't know if he wanted to make another statement since he's at the
Speaker 164
33:52
end, because I'm sure you're for the bill. I would. I would like to speak on the impact of these schools in Indianapolis. They have 3,000 students. I had the opportunity to go up and meet with the teachers, the directors, and with the students. Got to actually sit down with five students. One of the students has an eight-year-old son who was having issues in school.
His father has now been in the program for three sessions. It's an eight-week session. His son is no longer having problems, is getting his homework done, and they sit at the dinner table every night and do homework together. The impact of this is amazing. It's needed. We have 300,000 Arkansans without a high school diploma over the age of 19. Thank you. Would you like to close
for you, Bill? Yes, I would just briefly say that I believe that this legislation and certainly the offer of goodwill to fund this, it's transformative.
It's going to have a significant impact on the state of Arkansas, economically for individuals but also for the state, and I do appreciate the impending motion from Representative Walker, and I appreciate the due pass vote. Representative Walker has a motion
of do pass. Is that correct? As amended? Oh, Mr. Lowry's bill. All right. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed your bill.
I don't see Senator Elliott in the room at this time, and I don't see Senator Clark in the room at this time. Senator Rayford has a bill. I will present that for him. and I
Representative, you're recognized to present your bill. Senate Bill 878. Thank
you, Madam Chair. Committee, this is a bill from the Senate. Quite a few senators on there. And this requires a student to pass a United States Citizenship Civics Test provided by the United States Citizenship and Immigrant Services before he or she receives a diploma from the public school or general education diploma.
Now, this is a very short bill. It's very simple. They can take this test, and it will be required before they can graduate, and they can take this test as many times as they have to. They have to get a correct answer of at least 60 of the 100 questions on that test to pass. And like I said, they can retake it as many times as they want. It will not keep them from graduating. It's just eventually they've got to get 60. Now, I'm going to give you my input on this. I don't watch late night show a lot
but every once in a while I'll stay up and watch used to be the Jay Leno show now it's Fallon and tonight show but if you ever watch them when they get out on the streets with a microphone and they'll walk up to people and just ask them a general question who's the president of the United States they don't know who was the first president of the United States half of them don't know this is something I think that will kind of let our kids possibly pick up a little bit of information on some questions that they would need to know in life. It is funny if you ever watch those shows. I'm
sure some of y'all are in here and they ask them those questions and they're just as, and I'm going to plainly speak, just dumb as a rock when they get on the street sometimes and don't know anything. Senator Raper asked me if I'd run this bill for him. He didn't have a House sponsor, so I'm glad to do it.
committee? Representative McElroy, you're recognized. Thank you. Do you think the sponsor would maybe amend that bill to include legislators?
Chair. My question, Representative Cozart, has nothing to do with the intention of the bill. Because of course, I agree with it. we need to do this. As you may know, myself, also Representative Deffenbaugh introduced bills, trying to get a little bit of personal finance education into the school curriculum as well, thinking that our high school students need to graduate knowing how to balance a checkbook
and understand debt and all of that kind of stuff. And I introduced a bill two years ago to do the same thing, and I keep hitting my head up against a wall every time I try to do something pretty simple and straightforward. And so when I look at this bill, again, makes perfect sense I'm just wondering what will the schools have to do to prepare these young people to pass this test if anything and I mean are the there's a subject matter of the test covered in the school curriculum like in social studies classes things like that and that I'm just trying to because
we're creating a requirement for graduation that um you know I'm just wondering what kind of preparation are we actually going to make provision for in our
school curriculum. Representative Saban, I believe the curriculum is there. It's just that they have to actually apply it to their lives and put that in their minds. I believe everything that's taught in the schools would be something that would be on this test. Now, did they remember it all from school? Possibly not. And it's hard for a student to remember everything,
and, you know, that's why they go to college. They get more and more. But I think it's something that will be a refresher to them. And like I said, if they take it the first time and they don't fail it, they'll
And I think that's something that will stick with them in life. Okay. Representative Diffenbaugh, you're recognized. Thank you, ma'am. I do like this idea, Representative Cozart. Now, my only question is, or if I understood what you said, the test can be taken numerous times.
There's no limit on it. Okay. Occasionally I ran into situations where, you know, actually teaching a course and I'd have somebody that had immigrated in here and honestly didn't know the English language. So I'm just curious. You think they'd be willing to keep a youngster in high school that long, you know, if it took him five times to pass that test or six?
and I'm not being funny or anything like that. I've seen that where a youngster couldn't, in my case, couldn't understand the Algebra II book, and so we could kind of coax him through, but they can't be coaxed through on a test. So you got any ideas on that? I'm not sure how
this test is given. It could be given in Spanish. I don't know that. It's a citizenship test, so I've never taken it because I was born here, So I didn't have to take it, and I didn't have to take this.
I took civics years ago. Don't ask me who some of those presidents are because I'm not going to remember who they are. But anyway, I think it's a good deal, and they can take it. I'm sure that they could be coached a little bit, but not during the test, but before or after they've maybe failed it once. They could probably be coached on that. I think it's a good deal, and I agree with Representative Saban and Representative Deffenbaugh that those were good bills, but I don't know what happened. It just didn't happen. And as we know, we have good bills that don't happen.
We have bad bills that happen. So things happen here. I would appreciate a
I've got a question I'd like to ask our new education director. That's right.
i think i heard that bill
uh is civics a required course taught in in the 38 credits right now civics is taught and it's
grade or 11th grade ninth i think i had an eighth grade sorry okay anyway yeah that's so let's go back but the the problem i have with this is what about our special need children are we going to not let them graduate
because i can't take this test and i thought that'd be a good
Speaker 197
43:03
question for you well that's a good question i don't know how that's in the in the law that's presented if there are any exceptions made available for that obviously a special needs student with an iep is going to have some uh some provisions made right right but
some of these folks that are in self-contained and things like that to me you're penalizing those kids
Speaker 197
43:27
well if if it's an iep and again
i don't know if the provisions are made in here for that but we make provisions for those students We certainly don't want to create a roadblock for them to not be able to graduate. I mean, y'all have done a lot of work here with Representative Broadway's bill previously in this session for these students. So we would not want to see anything like that create an additional hurdle. Can I have an additional question? Yes, sir. One more.
Representative Kozak, would you consider talking to them about amending this thing? For the special needs, John? I mean, I just thought we sure don't want to
Speaker 197
44:26
create more non-graduates. I'll ask Mr. Hernandez to. Okay. He might be able to clarify that for you, Representative.
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Okay. Okay. Good morning. Mike Hernandez, Department of Education. Representative Ratliff, the way that bill reads is that the test is required to be identical to the civics portion of the naturalization test. It also requires that rules be established by the State Board. Okay. And because that's a test, it would now be a required assessment. You know, one of the questions, I guess, and something we will have to get worked out is,
is that something that we'll probably have to standardize and put out there? And any time we put out a standardized test like that, you know, there will have to be thoughts in place about how do we address students with special needs. And it really will become a new assessment piece that will be required for graduation. So all of those things, as far as accommodations, will have to be addressed
during that rulemaking process. Okay. Mr. Chairman, can I still represent Walker's questions? Let's put you back in the queue.
Mr. Handez, do you think that we need more testing or less testing in our kids out here today? that is a as far as a you
know we we do we test um in schools quite a bit and then that's something that we're always need to be mindful of and analyzing to see you know what is it that we're we require from a state perspective and what could be put on the schools as their responsibility to
assess you know the standards and curriculum um so as far as is is too much or or not enough i I think that's always the question that's always raised. So it's something that definitely needs to be considered and looked
you, Madam Chairman. Okay, Mr. Walker, you're recognized for your question. Thank you, Madam Chair. You indicated that you wouldn't be taking this test, Chairman Cozart, because you were born in America.
So that implies to me that it is intended to apply to
people who are not born in America. Would you agree? Well, the original citizenship test is what I'm talking about. I'm not talking about the one now. I never took a citizenship test because I was born here. This is to be an immigrant type test. This is kind of what they're looking at for the immigration services. That's the type of test they're looking at giving them. So if you were born in America, you did not have to take an immigration
test. Am I correct? Well, I mean, we're citizens.
to take a citizenship test. Well, my question, of course, is why is it that we are creating a test that applies to immigrants and does not apply
we presenting this now is what you're saying? Well, I'm saying now, basically, this test is intended to apply, let's say what it is, to persons of Hispanic origin who perhaps are here in the eyes of some illegally.
And my question is, why do we have to have this test? I mean, what is its purpose other than to offend a race of
people? It's not about a race of people. This is everyone. This is any student that graduates. We're not – this is general. This is – there's
– if I may, your honor. It's everyone. There's no race. This is any student that graduates from a high school or is going to graduate to take a simple civics test that is in the immigration service type test.
Have you ever seen that test? No, sir. I didn't have to take it.
have not, sir. You have not. Representative Saban says he has. You've seen it. Don't you agree that this is something that is absolutely unnecessary, represents another burden on students and on teachers in terms of grading?
It offers the lack of uniformity. There are no standard answers, and it's something that's also prepared by the United States government. There are no standard answers on
this test? Do you know of any? Can I call on Representative Sabin to make a statement on that? I don't know
if Representative Sabin can answer, but if he can, I'd like to know if there's a set
of standards. Madam Chair, I'd like to call on
Representative Sabin to help me out here. Representative Sabin, you're recognized. I certainly don't want to
portray myself as some expert on the subject, but I have seen the test,
and it's a very difficult test, actually. I mean, I would venture to guess that out of this room, there are probably only 50% of us that could probably pass it. It's very difficult, and it's serious, and it's often embarrassing that people who are naturalized into this country know more about our civic form of government than those of us who were born here. So I think it would be great if all of our high school graduates could pass this test, and I hope that they can. And I just hope they're prepared to do so through the education that we're offering them in our schools.
Thank you, Representative Saban. That's exactly what I was trying to say, Madam Chair, is that if you really, I'm serious, I've watched the late night show, and there's been quite a few of those show hosts that will pick up those people on the streets, on the beach, different places. They know nothing about our country. And this is something I think if
Your Honor. Okay. One more question, Mr. Walker. Now, I had a bill that I haven't run yet to require school superintendents to score at least 16 on the ACT.
Now, we have superintendents who don't score 16 on an ACT. We have them who don't score 19. We have legislators who don't score 19. Maybe myself. Why is it that we are so test conscious when we haven't had to have qualifying tests ourselves and when there is no correlation between the test and any expected outcome and serves no purpose other than to possibly embarrass somebody
and deny them an opportunity to complete an education for which they have been taught? Why do you need it? Are you
sure? Well, I think our kids need to be brought to another level, and we were already trying to teach our kids better to be more competitive. And like I said, I'm embarrassed at what some kids know and what some of us know about our country. I think it's not taught the way it should be, but I think this is another step in the direction to getting them to know more about our country
and what we stand for and what we're about. As you referenced the legislators, no, we're not tested. We come from all walks of life. We come from all educational levels. I don't know what everybody's educational level is in here. That doesn't matter. We represent. This has nothing to do with our level of education as being a legislator. And a school, if you're going to move on and go to jobs and go to teaching and things like that, that does have a difference in your level.
Okay. Representative Harris, you're recognized for a question. Oh, I'm sorry. Go ahead. Then we'll get Mr.
Armstrong. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think you just answered my question, but if I'm not mistaken, the purpose and intent of this bill is, especially when, you know, we just took a trip to Washington, D.C., the purpose of this is for the students to have more knowledge about the Republic and not to
embarrass, but to make sure that they have the common knowledge about a constitution, about what we, because I have taken this test. It's online. We were helping someone get their citizenship, and so we, it was a test on the, and so we were helping them go through the answers so they could study it. And so you can do this test. And that's the whole purpose of this bill. Is that not correct? That is correct. All right. Thank you. I may do have to do that. Okay.
I'm going to recognize Representative Armstrong and then Representative Eubanks. Mr. Cozart,
Representative Cozart, the intent of this test is to acquaint students and make sure that they are familiar with all forms of that government and everything and I think I think it's good because people ask I'm like you they ask some questions just you you just don't expect and I come from a small school and I know that they taught civics and government classes and
history and we're not getting enough of that you know we the schools strayed away from that and they went to just literacy and math and I think it should be inserted back into the schools. Thank
you, Representative Armstrong. I agree with that. Representative Eubanks, you're recognized. I believe Representative Armstrong touched on what my question was. And Representative Cozart, is the purpose of this is to, with the participation rates that we have in elections and the knowledge of our,
maybe the general public about our government and the process is the purpose of this is to try to make people aware better educated about the process and hopefully improve the participation rate in elections yes sir it is all forms of our government like i said most of
the people you ask them any question about our government they know very little very little about it and this will get them better informed on it. Thank you. One
By that answer and by that question, it suggests that you could, as a condition for voting, you could require a person to pass this test. Would you agree? No, sir. This has nothing to do with voting. Thank you.
It would probably well inform them a little better, but it doesn't it doesn't do anything to that any more questions from the committee okay
is there anyone in the audience who'd like to speak for the bill against the bill represent you all right i'm closed okay i think we had one person but i
can't come on bring them down representative former representative climber did you want to speak for the bill huh i couldn't find
Speaker 250
55:57
you Madam Chair, thank you. Thank you, Representative Cozart. I'm here not really as a representative of anyone except a member of the Arkansas Political Science Association, and for years we have had a recommendation that civics, an additional American government class be taught in high school
or moving the civics test forward to the senior year. because of the lack of knowledge that we see of freshmen coming in. And so even though this bill does not address that, I think it is in the spirit that I want to acknowledge that students, our association has acknowledged the lack of preparation for basic college government to take an American government class. So our students are not really remembering much from ninth grade.
And I think that this bill, and I'm not speaking for the association, only as a member of the association, but I think this bill speaks to
that. All right. Thank you. Against the bill? You're recognized. You're recognized. State your name for the record,
Speaker 257
57:17
please. My name is Barbara Hall. I'm a teacher here in Little Rock, and I'm very concerned that people don't know the basics of our democracy.
But what concerns me is that because of testing, I'm an elementary school teacher, and because of testing, social studies kind of has gotten drummed out of the curriculum because we're worried about math and we're worried about writing, and we're not spending time at a young level teaching these things. So it concerns me that I think this is an issue that needs to be discussed. us, but when you think that testing is going to make that sort of knowledge happen, I think that that's not really the correct way to address a problem. I think we need to look at across the curriculum from when our children are in elementary school, that that's where
we should start learning these things so that perhaps then we would be prepared and not wait until we're in middle school and have a class and then think that I have to graduate high school with that sort of bare minimum of social studies
education. All right. Any other questions? Any other one else to speak for or against the bill? Yes, ma'am. You're recognized.
Hello, my name is Candress Jones, and I'm a teacher in the Little Rock School District as well.
And I just want to reiterate what the two young ladies before me stated. As far as adding on a test, we have so many things to consider. First of all, how are we going to accommodate those kids with special needs, the IEPs, the 504s, the ELL, and the ESLs? Also, with all due respect, and I know you were saying this as a joke, you were speaking of the late show as an example of the –
Yes, I'm serious. Okay. Well, and I watched the late show as well, and I've also watched those segments. But we have to remember that's something that's staged. We have to think about research and what research tells us. And from what I can see right now, we don't have or I don't know what research is available that has proven that a test needs to be given. I would like to reiterate that a class be given later on in high school years
rather than thinking about what students know at ninth grade and testing them in, well, a grade has not been stated in the bill. But thinking about what they know in ninth grade and testing them based on something that they learned in ninth grade may not be fair to the kids, and that's all I have to say. and also how and when would the test be done because right now at the school where I teach, testing last week was a fiasco.
Yes. We didn't have the time or resources really to successfully pull it off, and problems were presented because of that. So that's all I have to say. Thank you. Thank you.
Are there any other questions by the committee? Would you like to close? Oh, Representative Armstrong, I'm sorry I didn't see you.
We've heard enough against, I believe, but Madam Chair, I don't care. You can go ahead and hear whatever you want against.
I have a motion for immediate consideration, ma'am. Okay. Mr. Armstrong will hear your motion. I move for immediate consideration. Okay. Proper motion, not debatable. Would you like to – what are the wishes of the committee? All those in favor say aye. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Okay, now we need a motion on the bill. Representative Lowry? Do pass. All those in favor say aye.
Aye. Opposed? No. No. No. Okay. Congratulations. You've passed your bill according to what I heard. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you, committee. Roll call. Doesn't matter. Roll call. I believe you're too late,
Chair, in all due respect. Do what? If no other bill has been called, in all due respect. One hand. I see one hand.
Speaker 53
1:02:03
Okay. Regible. Okay. Roll call. Representative Letting. Representative Letting. Representative Murdoch. No. Representative Deffenbaugh, Representative Harris, Representative Eubanks, Representative Ratliff, Representative Gillum, Representative Gillum, Representative Walker, Representative Bell, Representative Baltz, Representative Douglas, Representative Douglas, Representative Lowry,
Yes. Representative McElroy? No. Representative Armstrong? Yes. Representative Gossage? Representative Gossage. Representative Sabin? Representative Sabin. Representative Hodges? Yes. Representative Gray? Representative Gray. Okay. Thank you.
Speaker 277
1:03:10
Hold on. I need a vote. We've only got nine votes. Thank you. Motion failed. Senator Elliott is here. Give me
Okay, due to time, we have one hour left, and we're going to try to move these on. We will hear no more than 15 minutes of testimony from each bill, no more than, and that's going to be limiting that. As much as possible. I would like to hear from if you have a group in the audience that has people from the same group that want to speak for or against one person representative only from that without objection from the committee.
I hear no objection. So that's the way it's going to be. We'll present. We will hear one for from each group. Now, that doesn't mean we can't hear more than one from our forwards are against, but I want to limit it to 15 minutes. We have to move these bills off this calendar today, or we will not get these bills through. Senator Elliott, are you in the room? I'm here. You have three bills? Yes. Tell us which one you want to start with, and we will start.
The first one, Mr. Chair, is the one that's on innovation. And I left my iPad. I don't have the number in front of me.
953. It's a one-liner. Are you ready for me?
No. Oh, wait, okay. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, last year we passed this bill called the District of Innovation. And as people were considering implementing it, there was some confusion, I understand, that some folks thought perhaps they didn't have to still meet the needs of the students who are classified, gifted, and talented. And all this bill does, it just clarifies, yes, you still have to do that. You don't get to just skirt by that and leave them unaccommodated for.
And that's all this bill does, the one line that you see. Any questions from the
committee? Seeing no questions, does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. I have a do-pass motion from Representative Ratliff. All those in favor, say aye. Any against? No. Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. The next one is for Senate Bill 212.
Senate Bill 212? Yes, please. All right, you're recognized for
presenting. Mr. Chair, there are some people here who wanted to speak, but if I ask whoever wants to come to the table, come on to the table. If they're both from the same organization, I'm going to ask them to just choose one person or two or whatever you tell us to do, and I can make note of the folks who are supporting. It really doesn't matter. You've got
15 minutes to present. Okay. I think it won't take us that long. you're recognized and if they if they would like to uh state their name and who they're with then
Speaker 305
1:07:53
Thank you. Morning, sir. Lieutenant Colonel Miriam Cardall with the Arkansas National Guard.
Tom Simmons with El Dorado Public Schools. Okay. You're recognized at any time. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, last year during the interim, some folks from El Dorado and the National Guard came to us with this idea of a way that we can, in my words, recapture some of our kids that we have lost. This bill applies to students who are between the ages of 16 and 21.
And we referenced them in the bill of students who are disengaged and they are dropping out of school, maybe not even getting a GED in most cases. And so what they brought to us was the notion of let's figure out a differentiated pathway for them to get a diploma. They could choose to go the GED route, but some students would prefer to get a diploma. and the notion is a group of folks could work together at the local level and we had everybody who has worked on this idea come to speak to us
that included El Dorado School District and the National Guard and in the process of working on this bill we worked with two-year folks and included the two-year colleges and we also include the four-year colleges and technical schools may work with this as well. So it would work like this. Right now, even though they want to do this, they don't have enabling legislation to do so. So what would happen is everybody at that local level who wanted to come up with a differentiated pathway to recapture these students 16 through 21,
they, under the auspices of a contract that's put together by the Department of Education, They could work out a plan at that local level to work with all the entities that I mentioned, to work with businesses to try to get internships for these kids, still meet the standards, but work out an individualized plan for them to work through what they need to and get a diploma. That would either lead directly to work or it may lead to academic endeavors in a further way.
But the notion is that it does not lead to a dead end and that they have an opportunity, even though we have lost them somewhere in the system, to get them back and they can graduate with a diploma. And I will allow them to say two or three words if they want to, and then we'll take questions if that works
Speaker 307
1:10:23
with you, Mr. Chair. That is fine. Go ahead. Okay. Okay, thank you again. And just to expand just a little bit on Senator Elliott's comments, These are the students that are basically mathematically eliminated of graduating on time or at all.
They have less than half the credits needed based on their age. We find that when we lose the students out of the schools and they enroll in a GED program, we lose track of them. What we propose is to have the high school guidance counselor, before a student chooses to drop out, take a look along with the building level principal and their designee, to develop a program of study that would be the same, would give the student the same type of diploma that students get, whether they're in smart core or the core curriculums.
This would basically be just a third type of diploma. The reason being, and Colonel Carlisle can expound on this a little bit more, a GED just won't do much for you anymore. There's a lot of career paths that that blocks their progress towards. What we propose is to these students actually receive a high school diploma, and I'll be available
Speaker 310
1:11:38
for questions. Sir, just on National Guard, what we offer, the Youth Challenge Program,
they basically take these at-risk children that are looking to gain a little or their parents are looking for them to gain a little discipline and try to get them back on track to complete their schooling. When they go to Youth Challenge, currently we offer the GED, the potential to take the GED. But as I have spoken to before, in the Army, they are no longer enlisting people with the GED. And I just state that just to show the level of, I don't know, respect given to a GED these days.
It's no longer considered enough to get in the Army. So what this bill will allow us to do out there at the Youth Challenge Program is to try to keep these youth on track to get back with their high school or go through this pathway to continue their education toward a high school diploma, therefore enabling them to be a better product for society. And if you have any questions.
I'll take any questions, Mr. Chair. Are there any questions, committee? Representative Deffenbaugh, you have
a question. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can I have two questions? May I have two? Yes, sir, you may. All right, anybody that's – this program is just for people that are still technically enrolled in high school.
Is that right? Am I understanding that right? Have they been in high school? Have they kind of halfway
dropped out? Yes. Is that right? Now, you might be 21 and then just have totally disengaged, and you have a chance to come back to connect to the school where you
would have gotten a diploma, and they would have that opportunity as well. Okay. So what about one or two cases here? One is they're on a GED track. They're working toward that.
Is it possible for them, since they recognize the GED is not as powerful as a high school diploma, is there a way to get back into this from the GED program, you know, before they get to GED? Yeah,
well, that would be possible. But I want to be sure that I don't misrepresent the GED because there are many, many people who are doing just great getting a GED, and I don't want that to be, you know, the notion that's given here. it's just that there are some pathways that have been cut off so if a student
is in a maybe you are 17 and you've dropped out and this program becomes available in your district you could indeed because remember it's going to be individualized so if the work that you've done moving toward a GED we could verify that and that it would meet the standards and that could be a part of the plan that that student had toward moving toward a diploma that could absolutely be the case I'm going to ask
one more. Is there a lot of interest in this today?
I know there is from the folks in El Dorado, and I've had several. When I filed the bill, I immediately started hearing from people about the possibility, wanting to know more about it. But that's just, you know, I don't have anything empirical to tell you. But I know the two- and four-year schools are very interested in being a part of it, and so are the technical schools. because I think everybody sees this as an opportunity for us to work across paths to make sure we respond to these kids that we're losing. And, Representative, that's an interesting question as well just from the standpoint of
I think more and more people have begun to realize what a small state we are and that we don't have any people to lose. And so we need to do more and more to recapture folks that we are acting as if we have the luxury, you know, of not reengaging them, and that's what we propose to do. I'm all for
anybody who wants to come back and get their education. Yes, thank you. Thank you. I don't
know if we're going to meet this afternoon. Any other questions? Seeing no other questions.
Anybody in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the
bill? Would you like to close? I'm closed, Mr. Chair. I
think I've said everything I need to say. All right. Do I have a motion? Do pass. I have a do pass motion from Representative Ratliff. All those in favor say aye.
The last bill she has for Senate Bill 788. Senate
Bill 788 will be the last one. Yes. Members, back in 2011, I guess it was,
for those of you who don't know the history of the dyslexia bill, Senator DeKee and I set out to try to get a bill passed to address students who are dyslexic. Because as a teacher for 30 years, I recognized there were issues that were going on. I didn't know what was happening, and I didn't know very much at all about dyslexia. But the bottom line is, after about three years of work, we brought forth the bill to the session last year. And when we passed that bill, I mean, it was after a lot of work and a lot of different groups working with us.
One of the things I said to the committee is that we are at a point now where we are doing something new and bold and different. I don't think there's much doubt that as we begin to implement, we're going to find things we need to try to work out. And indeed, we have found that to be the case. So that's why we have these amendments today. As we have worked through the year of trying to make sure we get everything implemented, here are the things that we have found that we need to work on.
And one of them is something that's not addressed directly in the bill. We have some school districts who've done a fantastic, what I call, bang-up job. And we have some school districts who have been absolutely resistant and very inappropriately and inexplicably and indefensibly rude and disrespectful, I think, and not responsive to parents. And that's part of something that is bothering people very much out there who are now suspicious that we are trying to pass a bill to go back on what was in the original bill.
No matter what kind of bill we pass, no matter what kind of amendments we make, it is going to be an incumbent upon us that some folks change their minds about the way they are reacting toward making sure kids who have dyslexia get the services that they need. For example, one of the largest school districts in our state, when asked how many students they have serviced last year who had dyslexia said 10. That just doesn't even stand to reason. So when parents contact you and they are very upset about what has been done and has not been done,
I want to say to you very directly, they are not making that up. I happened to be in an airport a few months ago and a teacher that I didn't even know started talking to me about the dyslexia bill and all of the roadblocks they had faced in that district. I don't even know who the teacher is. And she started telling me about how they're not even allowed to use that word. So the changes that we make today to this bill, if this bill is to pass, I want you to please understand that back in our districts, we still have work to do with attitudes and making sure kids get what they need.
But the major things that we have changed in this bill, We have defined the word interventionists because school districts were having issues with, we said that students had to be delivered dyslexia therapy. And so many school districts want to know, well, what is dyslexia therapy? What does that mean? Who can deliver it? And so we defined it in the bill what that means and who can deliver it. And I've had lots of emails from people about now a paraprofessional might be delivering the interventionist services.
services. But what the bill says is that a dyslexia therapist, a dyslexia specialist, a certified teacher, a reading teacher, a tutor or a paraprofessional under the guidance of a certified teacher may deliver the services. And these people, any of them who deliver the services, have to be trained. And how do they have to be trained? They are trained through something that we defined in here because this is one of the things the school districts kept saying, I don't know how to move with this because I don't know what you mean
by training. So we defined dyslexia program and everybody who delivers any services will do so through a dyslexia program. The other thing that we added to the bill, there is something called the dyslexia resource handbook that's really important to implementation of the bill. And one of the problems we had last year was the dyslexia handbook, I think, cause some issues for people because there were misunderstandings or misrights or whatever you might want to call it. But we lay out in
this case who shall serve on that committee to make sure the dyslexia handbook reflects what needs to be done. And that book is a living document and we put much of how we implement in that book because sometimes things need to change on a dime and we are not in session and we don't need to be tied to the session for everything we implement and change. And Mr. Chair, those are the basic things that are changed in the bill. I will take any questions. I can just feel you're saying, move it along. Representative Harris, you reckon
asked for questions. Thank you, Mr. Chair, for taking my question. And remember, I voted for your bill, so. With no luck. Senator Elliott, thank you, and you know I supported this bill last time. but I'm having a lot of I'm running through my emails so don't think I'm ignoring you but they're very concerned about these amendments watering down what you did last time and what I'm hearing though
I can do two things at once listening to you and looking at these concerns do you it doesn't sound like you're watering it down No, and I
know I've had lots of questions and discussions with people like this. For example, one of the main things I've gotten is watered down because you don't specifically use the term Orton-Gillingham. That's one of the things I've got over and over. No, the words Orton-Gillingham are not in these amendments
but those words are also not in the original bill. But what is in the original bill and is in this amended version as well. We know that Orton-Gillingham is an approach to dyslexia therapy. It's an approach. It is the most well-known. It's not the only one. It's the most well-known, the one that is used most, and the ones when I work with all the people who were specialists in the area, this is what they recommended. So we don't use the words in it, but everything that it takes to be
an Orton-Gillingham approach is directly in the bill, which is common for bill writing protocol, that we might not list that particular thing. And one of the reasons that the watering down bit of it just doesn't work is because anybody who is trained has to be trained by a dyslexia program that has all of the Orton-Gillingham requirements. So I'm very, very careful about that. And one of the things that folks who would like to have, and we would
too, is for every school to have a certified therapist. That would be great. I could put it in the bill, but the fact is they don't exist for every school. And we are working with colleges and universities, and part of what's in the bill is for us to begin to move that way. I could put it in the bill, but we wouldn't get anywhere. But in the meantime, we are trying to figure out what to do to be helpful to kids. It's not perfect, I grant you that, and as we train more people, everybody is going to be better off, because I do prefer that it's a specialist or that it's a therapist, but we don't have one for every school,
and what's required is that the co-ops must have, every co-op must have a specialist that can work with the school districts, and I expect that we'll be here again next year as we're able to do more things with this bill. All right, I agree with that. So thank you very much. You're
welcome. Are there any other questions, committee? All right, seeing none, I have one that would like to speak against the bill, Dixie Evans.
You're recognized to state your name and who you're with, and
Speaker 330
1:24:50
you'll be recognized to speak against the bill. Hi, my name's Dixie Evans. I am a parent of a dyslexic student. I am a certified interventionist and a dyslexia advocate. Some of my concerns with SB 788 are because in the original Act 1294, it makes allowances. It wants people to be trained in these dyslexia programs, yes, but it also says they're to be working towards certification.
If we don't certify these people offering this intervention, we have no way of knowing that they're using these programs with fidelity. when I went for my certification there were three out of ten people in our own state these are Arkansas teachers who had already been tutoring children that failed their certification which means they were not using this program as it was designed to meet the best interests of these children and another one of my major major concerns is in SB 788 it says these interventionists that
are just trained, not certified, or supervised by a certified teacher. This does not say a teacher certified in an intervention program that they are using. They could pick any certified teacher to supervise these people, even one that is not knowledgeable on dyslexia. That terrifies me. um one uh sorry i'm losing my notes um they don't specify how much training is necessary
and that wasn't in the original 1294 and it doesn't mention og and i don't have a problem with it not mentioning orton gillihan because the what is lined out for the specific training you draw the conclusion what is acceptable is an orton gillihan program i organized an event in october and through for an awareness event to meet the requirements of teachers needing to receive awareness and dyslexia through what it specifies here not requiring certification now of these teachers it's going to open the door for because we did go over all the processes
of an orton gillihan approach and what those meant and what they look like schools can now say that that five-hour day could potentially qualify their teachers to be interventionists. I'm so concerned about taking away the certification requirements. It's just not a good idea because they need to be certified. And in Act 1294, it says they need the certification. We need to do what is best for these dyslexic children. Making amendments now is going to send to the schools the idea
that they can continue to push for things that suit their interest, not the students' interest. And I feel like that SB 788 is looking out for the interest of the schools that don't want to implement Act 1294, not the students. If you don't mind, I'm going to turn it over
to Ms. Aldi. Unless somebody has questions, I'm happy to answer any. Any questions from the committee? Okay. Seeing none, thank you. I have Richard Abernathy from AAEA to speak against the bill. For the bill. I'm just kidding. For the bill.
Speaker 334
1:28:10
Well, don't do that, Mr. Chair. Senator Elliott's going to shoot me down here. I'm Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA, and we have literally spent days and hours and hours on this legislation and trying to get it to where it would be beneficial for students and that we could continue serving kids in a particular way. Many of you served on the adequacy committee when you had a presentation from Flippin' Arkansas and the program that they did up there. This will allow them to continue working with those kids
and achieving some of the results that they did this past summer. And we expect other schools to follow that same suit. Without this legislation, they're not going to be able to use that program to serve these kids. So we would certainly appreciate a strong, positive vote on this, and we absolutely support it. Are there any questions? Anyone like
to speak against the bill? I would, sir. All right. State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized to speak against the bill.
I'm Audie Allenbaugh. I'm a certified teacher in the state of Arkansas, and I have failed children. I have failed children that have had dyslexia for over 10 years. The reason I have is I have a master's in special ed, but I am still not trained to teach students with dyslexia. It requires a set skill that you can have only through certain programs. This law, how many certified therapists did we have in the state two years ago?
This law was passed two years ago. It was a good law then. It's a good law now. We don't have very many more than we did two years ago because school districts have knowingly and willingly drugged their feet to pass this law. 20% of the students in the state, if we tend to the nationwide trend, 20% of the students in the state have dyslexia, 20%. We would need Senate Bill 212 that Ms. Elliott spoke about prior to me speaking about students not being engaged if we would fix it on the front end.
These students aren't engaged because they're not learning to read. It's a financial burden. 20% of students not learning to read, that's a financial burden. In educational research, there are three indicators for student success. They are assessment, engagement, and knowledge. This is a three-legged stool. This amendment takes away two of those legs. It takes away knowledge as to who's going to be teaching these students,
and it takes away the assessment. with those two you won't have student engagement Orton-Gillingham was in place in 1930 we are in the year 2015 the certification for screening that is listed in the amendment on page 2 and the top of page 3 in the amendment there is no certification for screening page 6, line 21 through 24 the interventionist can determine a school's interventionist
Now, interventionists will be paraprofessionals, according to this amendment, not certified teachers. The people that are actually where the rubber meets the road teaching with children, they will be interventionists, paraprofessionals. Okay? I want to ask you, committee members, if you were having a heart attack, would you want a heart surgeon working on you? Or would you want an LPN? These kids are going to get an LPN. I hope you get a heart surgeon.
But these kids will get an LPN. I have failed the kids out of ignorance. Pass this, and you're going to fail the students out of willful neglect. I'd like to know when these students aren't being served like they haven't been in the past, who can we call at ADE? We've asked this in the Senate. We asked, and the spokesperson for the ADE shrugged. Didn't know who they were going to call. I don't want to say. Parents call ADE. That's a big place. It's like searching the web. I'd like a name.
I'd like somebody that's going to be held accountable for these parents because there are thousands out there that are not getting served. Who are we going to contact? I would urge you to vote against this. Let the original law stand. It is time that we hold these school districts accountable and we educate these kids. I have
a question for you. Representative Harris, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
First of all, I agree with you 100%. And I think if Senator Elliott hadn't introduced the bill last session, I think none of this would have even been brought to light. And I think the school systems still would have shrugged off the system. I had a constituent that they shrugged off, made the parent go to Smeeding Center, pay for their own evaluation, which was a low-income family that they couldn't even afford. the assessment. Now they're in collections for it. It's just a big nightmare for them,
but finally. But in going back with these amendments because of the cost, do you feel though in some way that because of the co-ops taking on it, because of the rural district that I represent, that at least that the students still will be served in some fashion? Like the bigger schools can afford it, but maybe the rural schools where they can't afford it, that they still will be served?
I'm not sure, because I don't know where the teeth are in this amendment. I'm not sure that any kids are going to get served under this amendment. The law has been in place for 28 months. 28 months! The guidelines in this law were replaced with words, and I don't know you, but I know of you, Representative Harris, so I know you're a Christian man. The Ten Commandments don't say may. They say
shall. Shall was taken out of this amendment, and may was replaced. May is a suggestion. Shall is a commandment. Shall is something that we honor, and we do. That's gone in this. This is weakened. The people that helped, one of the people that helped write this amendment, actually has commented that she is absolutely comfortable with coming back in two years and strengthening the law. To indicate that you need to strengthen the law, it's by definition that you've weakened it.
Okay. Thank you. Any other questions in the
Speaker 342
1:35:21
name and who you're with please I'm Jerry Dorlikowski with Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families and I understand the frustrations of the
group that worked so hard to get the legislation last time and that Senator Elliott spent three or four years working with and I know anything that in their view weakens the bill is a concern and I really understand that I have frustrations with the way things are getting done in some of our schools too and I would put forward in SLA and how that money gets used is one of my frustrations but I honestly feel that this bill is I don't think we have enough of the kind of people in place right now to do what we need to
do for all the kids that have dyslexia and I think that this bill will help make sure we get some kind of services for all the children that need some kind of services. And I, too, would like to urge our superintendents to do a better job of making sure that they treat their parents and they address the needs and concerns in a way that helps parents understand what they're doing and how they are best served for dyslexia in their district.
So with that, I would say I speak for the
bill. Any more questions? I really closed already, but I will let you do it. Okay, go ahead. I have one more against. This will be the last against. I will give one more for, and that will be equal, and then we are going to vote on this bill. We have run about 25 minutes already.
Speaker 343
1:37:03
Sorry about that, and I appreciate you, Mr. Chairman.
Dusty Maxwell, and I'm a special education advocate. that I have been in special education for 40 years. Last session, Senator Elliott passed the bill that you're trying to amend, and it was a great bill, and it's moving forward. We don't need to move backwards. These are the kids that go on to fail if they don't get what they need. This is obviously the education folks not wanting to follow through because they're throwing their hands up and saying, we can't find them. Find them.
make the people go get their certification let's not go backwards let's wait again every one of these members that I know personally on this committee are for improving education in Arkansas this does not improve it thank you I'll take any questions but I doubt you need it thank you anyone
would like to speak for the bill Seeing none
Would you like to close for your bill Yes I would Mr. Chair Thank you very much It is really a rather interesting thing That before I even approached Introducing this bill And did all the work years ago For anybody to assume I did all that just so I could come forward Years later and make the bill worse that just does not stand to reason and you hear people say things like paraprofessionals
are going to be doing the work of the interventionist and that in the original law the only people who could do the work were the therapists and specialists. That's just not true because from the original law let me read to you directly. Dyslexia interventionist means a school district or a public school employee trained in dyslexia programs, and it lists the folks out who can do this. These are the folks that are listed in the original law. Dyslexia therapist, dyslexia
specialist, reading interventionist, certified teacher, or tutor or paraprofessional or tutor, and what we've got listed now along with the tutor is along with the tutor listed now is a paraprofessional. It is possible for a tutor and a paraprofessional to do the work as one. Because I'm a paraprofessional doesn't mean I can't be a tutor. But what you need to recognize in the original law where it just said a tutor can be highly trained,
this is the thing that was causing people trouble. What does it mean to be highly trained? And folks were asking that question, what does that mean? And what we do in this bill is lay out what it means to be highly trained. And I am at a loss as to know how in the world that's watering down this bill. There is an enforcement problem here. Everybody you heard come up here talked about whether or not the school districts were going to do what they're supposed to do. That's an enforcement problem.
I don't care what bill we pass. If people are not out there implementing it, that's not the issue here. What I am attempting to do here is put something in place so that nobody has an excuse for not delivering to kids what they need to have delivered. I have put nothing in this bill that's in here without working with what's become now very polarized sides of this issue, very polarized. And to get to these amendments, there was not a single day, not a single moment,
I sat down and said, here's what I'm going to do. I work with people on both sides just as I did when we worked with the original bill. Everybody does not have in here what everybody wants. And for anybody to suggest that George Eliot, the one who started the whole thing, is now I'm here because I would just really like to not serve kids. It is absolutely illogical to sit here and say that, and it's absolutely not true.
So if we're going to make sure kids get what they need, we can say all we want to. Everybody has to have a therapist, but if they don't exist for kids out there now, we can't just do nothing. You want us to do nothing? Everybody is on the page of moving toward making sure we get people who are certified to do this work. So I ask you for a good vote, and thank you, Mr. Chair of the committee. What's the will of the committee?
I have a motion to do pass from Representative Burdock. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. No. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. Senator Johnson is over
Speaker 285
1:42:06
there, sir. He's been waiting for a while. Senator Johnson. He passed three
I guess 744 you are recognized to present senate bill 744 do you have any amendments on that bill that we are presenting at committee or is
it already ready I think it's already amended you are recognized to present it thank you this bill adds an additional non-traditional licensure possibility for the state of Arkansas and if it be okay with the chair and the committee I have
the Frank Atkinson from American Boards here and also Mike Hernandez who I've got together to make sure the department is good with this if it be okay Mike. They are welcome to join you at
the end of the table. If at any point, if they want to go ahead and recognize themselves, then they are welcome to speak at any
time when a question arises. It's my feeling that this bill will add people with practical experience
who have bachelor's degree into our educational facilities. And unlike some of the other nontraditional licensure programs, These are people in rural areas a distance away from our post-secondary institutions that can go through this facility and give them the possibility to come into our districts and make a difference. If it be okay, Frank, if you want to elaborate on it.
Speaker 360
1:44:04
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Frank Adkisson. I'm the chairman of the American Board Certification for Teachers of Excellence, and we do. We were founded over 10 years ago with a grant from the federal government, set up as a non-profit. We're approved in about a dozen states right now, and it's real simple. There are a lot of people that have not come out of college, but a lot of people that have gone back home, they're looking for second and third careers, and they would like to teach. They'd like to take their craft back, and especially some of the STEM needs that we have all across America.
And we actually go in and we test for competency, and that's what this is all about. They can now present themselves to the principal, to that school board, saying, I don't need to go for third-party training to become certified. I have shown the initiative, and I want to teach children in this district, and I've shown my initiative to do that. And so it's a very good program. I'd be more than happy to answer any questions. Are there any questions?
Anybody else want to speak on the end? Reps. Armstrong,
you recognize for question. Will this test exam be open to everyone that want
Speaker 360
1:45:22
we do a, and we're working with the department as we do in all states. They have to come to us and show, the applicant has to show that they have graduated with a bachelor's degree from an accredited university. and we work with the department to verify various accredited universities around the state,
around the country as well. So, yes, it's open to anybody with a bachelor's degree. And then we will not approve them. Again, we work with the department. We also work on the background checks. So you can come in, but you're going to be able to be a safe individual going into the classrooms. We're going to concur and confer with the department on that, and then you're going to have a bachelor's degree in some field of expertise.
May I follow up, Mr. Chair? You may. Will you offer any kind of guidance or continuing educational courses
in order to get them involved in how to set up dual curriculum and scheduling and all that's required of a teacher? Because some of it you missed just with
Speaker 362
1:46:32
a bachelor's degree. Go ahead. Thank you. Ivy, if ever, Department of Ed. I think I can answer that question. The bill, as it's amended, would allow these candidates who have completed the certification program to come to the state and be granted a provisional license, and during the time that they have that three-year provisional license,
they would receive mentoring and support at the school district level. we would set up a memorandum of understanding that would outline the requirements, and at the end of that provisional time, those candidates then could be eligible for a standard license. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You're welcome. Anyone else like
to have a question on committee? Okay. Is there anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill for the bill?
you, Chair and members. I'd appreciate a good vote. Representative Balts, you're recognized for a motion. Motion to pass. I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations,
you passed that bill. Let's go to the next one. Thank you, sir. I think Representative Murdoch's going to do 812 and 813.
813 does have an amendment. Okay. You want to start with 812 then?
Speaker 366
1:47:56
and we'll get the amendment out on the other one thank you chairman thank you committee 813 this bill just simply amends various provisions of the Arkansas code relating to the state mandated assessments so that's pretty much all we're doing everywhere in the code where you see reference the words augmented criterion referenced and norm reference assessments we're just going to excuse me are
you presenting amendment I'm on the wrong one.
Okay, if you're going to do 12 first. If
Speaker 366
1:48:30
you'll do 12, then we'll get the amendment out. I'm sorry. Okay, this 12, it amends various provisions in the Arkansas Code relating to the Arkansas College and Career Readiness Program as follows. And everywhere in the act where you see explore and plan, the department proposes that they propose that the Arkansas State Board of Education designate the college readiness assessments that may be used to satisfy the requirements of existing law.
So they're going to eliminate, explore, and plan everywhere you see it in the act, and they're going to enter a shall. So they're going to be, it's not an explore and plan, it's going to be an actual doing it. It won't just be an exploration. It'll be an actual action. That's the only difference that it's making in the plan. If you have any questions, Mr. Hernandez,
is that correct? Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Representative Roddick is correct. And what we're doing here is in the 16-17. You'll go ahead and introduce yourself. Mike Hernandez, Department of Education. Thank you.
You're recognized. In the 16-17 school year, ACT will eliminate the explore and plan assessments. And so since those are required in the law, this is just a cleanup bill to strike those specific terms out and just replace it with state-mandated tests. And those will be things that still meet the guidelines of being college and career-ready assessments. All
Speaker 336
1:49:53
right, what he said. Are there any questions? Good response. Any questions, committee?
I have no questions, committee. is there anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill for the bill would you like to close for that bill representative Murdoch I'm close what's the will of the committee representative Letting has a has a do pass motion all those in favor say aye any opposed no congratulations you passed your bill we need a motion on the amendment I move to adopt the amendment.
We have a motion to adopt the amendment on 813. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed, no. Your motion has, your adoption has been taken. You're welcome to present 813 as amended. Okay,
lot better. Yes, sir. Again, Mike Hernandez, Department of Education. This is another one of our cleanup bills, And what we're doing on this one is striking anywhere that's referencing augmented criterion reference
or norm reference exams in addition to benchmark testing and change that to state-mandated assessments. And that's so we have all tests that are as required under ESEA flexibility. Our waiver will still be in place. It just cleans up that language where we don't have those specific items listed there. Ready for questions? I'm closed.
Any questions, committee? Anybody in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the bill? And he's closed for the bill. What's the will of the committee? I have a due pass from Representative Baltz as amended. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. I need to keep running my other two while I'm down here. He's got two. He can run, sir. No, sir. I'm not going to let you. No, I'm just kidding. Stay there a minute. Hold on.
What do you have? 1842 and 1840. House Bill 1840. Sir,
Speaker 281
1:52:11
1842, you're going to have to suspend the rules. Take it up, sir. I'll have to suspend the rules
and take which one up? One of them? Well, 1840,
Yes, sir. I'm trying to find it. Front page. Right there, sir. I thought you popped over all those the other day. I'm sorry. I thought you told me we weren't going to run that one.
it off. Too late. Okay. No, you're recognized to run House Bill 1840. Okay, I'm going to
Speaker 366
1:52:47
recognize attorney James Valley who will explain the bill. Okay. State your
Speaker 380
1:52:55
you'll be recognized. I'm James Valley. I'm an attorney out of eastern Arkansas. I'm having a small school, District Hughes, and doing some other work over here. Bill 1840 is an attempt by us to define fiscal distress. As it stands right now, Arkansas Code does not define fiscal distress per se.
It defines fiscal distress status, which is a different phrase. Of course, under Arkansas law, as the Supreme Court interprets the law, is that if you don't have a definition of a word, and then you use the plain and ordinary meaning. And so this is an attempt to define fiscal distress, and it's defined to mean a district that's in state takeover status.
All right. Any other testimony on that? Y'all ready for questions?
Yes, sir. Any questions, committee? Representative Walker has been very
I've been occupied. Thank you. We should have started that at the first of
the year. Well, when you're inclusive, you have
recognized. Thank you. Who, I don't even understand, who is going to define the physical distress?
Who will be in charge of defining fiscal distress in this bill? This body is in
Speaker 380
1:54:28
charge of defining fiscal distress. And then you may delegate that or sub-delegate that to the Department of Education if you so choose. But at this point, it has not been defined. Okay. All right. Thank you. Yes, sir. Any other questions, committee? Seeing
bill. Mr. Hernandez, you are recognized to speak on the bill.
I'm sorry, okay, whoever. State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized
Speaker 387
1:55:06
to speak. Eric Saunders, Department of Ed. On 1840, the definition, as the law is currently written, just changing this definition would create lots of problems throughout code. There's various sections of code that reference either fiscal distress or fiscal distress status. They've been used interchangeably. And so to make the distinction between the two, which there would be two different definitions within this code,
by this law passing by itself would be very problematic. Question. Representative
Walker, you're recognized for a question. Do you have
any problem with the legislature defining the term? I have no problem.
Speaker 387
1:55:48
defining whatever. It's just trying to apply it once it's been defined. Just a follow-up.
Has the department sought in all these years to define the term? You're opposing it in a way. So have you all ever sought to define the term and
given it to the legislature for implementation? I think that's yes or no. Have you all ever sought to do that in a writing that I can see? I assume the answer
you any other questions thank you sir anybody like to speak before the bill against the bill
would you like to close for your bill I'm close I need a motion. What's the motion? Will's committee. Do a pass. I have a do pass from Representative Murdoch. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Well, I didn't have a no in a bunch. I guess you passed your bill. Was that hard? I mean, two yeses and no no, so I mean.
We are a little after 12. I'm going to allow you to go ahead and do your other bill, and that's going to be it for this. Right now, we'll try to come back after noon sometime. Can't
present your bill. Okay, 1842. I need a motion to suspend the rules to hear this one. I have a motion from Representative Gray. All those in favor, say aye. All right. You are recognized to present House Bill 1842.
Speaker 380
1:57:42
Is that right? Again, I'm James Valley, and I'm helped with this bill as well. This is, I guess, the companion to 1840 where we go through the code pretty particularly and define fiscal distress or fiscal distress status such that it can be applied using the two various categories. We did not go into the co-ops, so this is limited to school districts as it is.
And I believe it goes through all of the code sections that are affected. But it basically distinguishes fiscal distress from fiscal distress status. And fiscal distress status gives the department the full power that it has now to do what it's been doing ever since we've started fiscal distress status in the state of Arkansas. It just makes this singular change to whether fiscal distress itself means that the district has been taken over on the daily management and control of the Arkansas Department of Education at the direction of the commissioner or the State Board of Education.
Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing no questions from the committee, anybody would like
right, I think Mr. Saunders will speak on the bill. You're recognized. Eric
Speaker 387
1:59:22
Saunders, Department of Ed, and just expressing, I think,
some of the possible concerns with the bill, specifically with undetended consequences. Looking at various sections of code and just highlighting a few of those, one section of code, 613, 1020, 1027, and various codes with that concerning education service cooperatives where the terms are used interchangeably with fiscal distress and fiscal distress status would mean that when some of those education service cooperatives would have been placed on fiscal distress,
would put them under state control under this new definition, since this would be the definition of fiscal distress within the law. Additionally, under 615-2202, districts would no longer be required to post on their website what district is doing to be removed from fiscal distress status would no longer be a requirement. Capital outlay expenditures for academic facilities from school district balances could now be used to place a district on fiscal distress. This would eliminate a local school board's authority to remove a superintendent for cause
as it would only apply to fiscal distress and not fiscal distress status. And there's various other sections, but there's, I think, many sections of code where fiscal distress or fiscal distress status have been used interchangeably, and those are some of the concerns. Are there any questions? Representative Walker, you recognize? Thank you. Are you speaking
for the Department of Education or are you
speaking personally? Just some of the concerns that we come with. My question is direct.
Are you speaking for the Department of Education? Yes, sir. Has the Department of Education staff considered? Recognized. Yes, thank you. Has the Department of Education staff had a discussion regarding this and come to this or is this your personal conclusion?
internally. Follow-up. Did the commission direct us for your third follow-up. Thank you. Did you all come to a consensus in a meeting that is capable
of having minutes to look at and subject to FOIA? I do not think so, sir. Thank
you. No question. Are there any other questions? Thank you, sir. Anyone like to speak? Are we on the floor? For the bill? Against the bill, sir. Against the bill?
Speaker 380
2:02:04
Would you like to close for your bill? Yes, sir, we'd like to close. Mr. Bell. Mr. Chairman and members of the committee, we certainly appreciate your consideration. this bill has either or all the way through it and it would be up to the Department of Education to make those choices so those unintended consequences will only come to be if the Department of Education makes that unintended choice so this is a good bill we ask that you give us a good vote please You close? Yes sir
What's the will of the committee? Do pass I have a do pass motion with Representative Murdoch All those in favor say aye Aye. All those against, no. Okay, you have passed your bill. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Committee. Thank you. Without objection, we are adjourned, and we will be at the call of the chair on this afternoon.
Agenda
HB1653
HB1750
HB1605
SB891
SB546
SB546
HB1961
SB154
SB878
SB953
SB212
SB788
SB744
HB812
HB813
HB1840
HB1842
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Speaker 3
Speaker 8
Representative Scott Baltz
Unverified
Representative Clarke Tucker
Unverified
Speaker 32
Speaker 39
Speaker 44
Speaker 53
Speaker 62
Speaker 80
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Speaker 45
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Speaker 141
Representative Justin T. Harris
Unverified
Speaker 162
Speaker 164
Speaker 170
Chair
Unverified
Representative Mark D. McElroy
Unverified
Speaker 6
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Chair
Unverified
Speaker 48
Speaker 197
Mike Hernandez
Unverified
Speaker 220
Speaker 65
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Speaker 250
Speaker 257
Candress Jones
Unverified
Speaker 269
Speaker 277
Speaker 281
Senator Joyce Elliott
Unverified
Speaker 290
Speaker 310
Speaker 305
Speaker 307
Speaker 171
Speaker 330
Speaker 334
Speaker 124
Speaker 342
Speaker 343
Speaker 285
Speaker 226
Speaker 360
Speaker 359
Speaker 362
Speaker 366
Speaker 336
Speaker 380
Speaker 382
Speaker 383
Speaker 9
Speaker 387
Speaker 397