House Agriculture, Forestry & Economic Development Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (6)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1832
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…l order of business today from Representative Williams from House Bill 1832. Before we could, I fail to recognize the members today. We…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1145
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1145”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1580
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1580”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1653
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1653”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1703
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1703”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2088
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2088”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 17, 2026
Room A, Big Mac, Monday, March 25th on Big River Steel. Also, if there are any members that have bills on the deferred list and you want to move to the regular agenda, please let Chairman Shepard or Tammy know, preferably by today or tomorrow, so that they can move those over to the active agenda. Ms. Martin's going to pass out a couple of handouts for the upcoming bill.
We've got a special order of business today from Representative Williams from House Bill 1832. Before we could, I fail to recognize the members today. We have with us the state FFA officers seated over here in the committee room. If we could give them a warm welcome, please. With that, Representative Williams, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have an amendment first that I'd like to explain and then ask for adoption. Please explain the amendment. Members, this
first thing the amendment does, it adds three additional House sponsors and one Senate sponsor. And let me say that I appreciate the members of the House and the Senate who signed on as co-sponsors
and the 14 members of this committee who signed on as co-sponsors. I take that as a very positive sign and look forward to having hopefully a good time in front of you all today. So the amendments quickly, really the substantive amendments try to provide greater transparency, more oversight by AEDC, and greater protection of taxpayers' tax credits. The very first portion of the amendment, the largest section on page one, really tries, or what it does is it prevents a business from really double dipping on state tax incentives.
There are certain tax incentives that are statutory, meaning they apply if you comply with a statute, you automatically get them. Those three are Invest Arkansas, Advantage Arkansas, and Arkansas Plus. This amendment says if you participate in this new market tax credit program, you are not eligible to also participate in those other tax incentives. There may be discretionary tax incentives that AEDC can provide for you, but you're not going to be able to participate in this statutory program as well as one of those three statutory programs.
You'll have to decide. That's the first section of the amendment. The second section, really the first half of page two, deals with AEDC is required to report annually to the state about its activities. This section basically says that the community development entities that participate in this program will have to provide AEDC based with any economic information necessary for AEDC to produce that report. And then the third section, which is labeled Revenue Impact Assessment, it's very important.
This is more transparency than any other state new market tax credit program in the country. This provision, what it says is prior to an investment in each individual deal or each individual investment, a third-party independent study assessment has to be made to guarantee or to ensure that the investment being made will be revenue neutral or revenue positive, I'm sorry, for the state. meaning if we're going to give our state tax incentives to a business,
we want to make sure that business is doing what they say they're going to do. That means that we want to make sure they're going to create jobs. And so this is to ensure that we are properly protecting the taxpayers' tax credits and to make sure we're doing a good job in creating jobs, which is the priority for this legislation. These amendments were adopted pursuant to several discussions with the governor's office. We appreciate the governor's input. We believe these are positive amendments. They make this a better bill, and I would appreciate you all adopting these amendments.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any questions on the amendments? Representative Letting, you're recognized. Motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? The bill has been amended. Please
discuss the bill, Representative Williams. Thank you again, Mr. Chairman. And because I have so much support in this committee, I'm going to be very brief. Let me again start by thanking the chair today, our co-chair, Chairman Steele, for participating in our press conference yesterday
and talking about how positive this bill would be for his district. You have a letter in front of you from EPI, Mr. Edward Ryan, who is the owner of Environmental Products Industries, which is located in the Cherish District. And if you notice in that letter, he unfortunately could be with us today, but he says that he's participated in the state New Markets Tax Credit Program in Missouri, and if this program passed in Arkansas, he would definitely participate, and he could even see how such a program here would allow him to expand
and possibly create an additional 100 new jobs in his Nashville plant in the Cherish District. So I appreciate the chairman for participating, And I think this letter is evidence of how important this legislation is. We all campaigned on going to create jobs. And I'd like to say that this House Bill 1832, the New Market Jobs Act, is the bipartisan jobs bill for 2013. I hope that each one of you all will be able to take this back to your districts and show that you have fulfilled your campaign promise of creating jobs.
Let me just briefly describe the legislation, and then I'll be happy to take questions. I have several folks here who may be able to answer the really complex questions if you go beyond my knowledge of the bill. But first, the goal, really, the primary goal of this legislation is obviously to create jobs. We're seeking to drive private investments into qualifying businesses in qualifying communities, in low-income, distressed communities throughout the state. And because those are described based on census tracts or delineated based on census tracts,
those communities basically are throughout the entire state of Arkansas. Just briefly how this bill works, this is just one more tool that the state has to provide incentives. Under this bill, a community development entity is created. That entity receives an allocation of tax credits, sells those credits, and raises additional capital and makes investments into qualifying businesses. We say that this legislation, not that we say it, this legislation actually creates $250 million in investment in small businesses in Arkansas.
The bill requires the CDEs to invest 100% of their allocation or their money, their fund, in the first 12 months of operation. That's important because the tax incentives that are sold here, the tax credits, don't apply until the third year. Therefore, again, this legislation creates a situation where you have revenue-positive impact day one because the tax credits can't be taken until the third year.
However, the money has to be invested completely in the first year. What's also important is a CDE has to invest 150 percent of its money. So for every dollar they receive, they have to invest really a dollar and a half. So this is going to be a positive development for the state. And because of the amendment you just added, the assessment of the front end makes sure there's revenue positive based on the first 100 percent of their money. The additional 50 percent that they invest really is, for lack of a better term, gravy.
it ensures or guarantees we're going to have a very positive return. What's important about the jobs that will be created under this bill is that this legislation requires that the wages that are paid for these jobs be at 115% of the state wage average. So we're creating good jobs, not low-wage jobs, not giving tax incentives to create low-wage jobs, but to create good jobs. Also, this program will require very little regulatory oversight from the state level, Because we're piggybacking off the federal new market tax credit program,
if a CDE qualifies to receive and has received a federal allocation, they will also qualify for a state allocation. However, the state will have, again, significant controls through AEDC to make sure they're complying and make sure investments are proper and all the things that I've talked about in the amendment. Let me talk also about, I believe it's page 11 of the bill, which is the recapture provision of the bill. And this is important because this is also maybe the strongest recapture provision of a state New Markets Tax Credit program in the country.
This basically says if for some reason the CDE fails to do what it says it's going to do, fails to or invest in a business that does not qualify for some reason throughout the life of its fund, that the state can go back and recapture its incentives. This is a very, very strong provision and an important provision. The provision also says that if for some reason that CDE has a clawback or the federal government decides to claw back their tax credits if they're both federal and state tax credits involved,
then if the feds go back after these CDEs, then that means the state also can get their tax incentives back. So that's a very important provision to make sure that we have safeguards and controls over the legislation. This model that we're using is not typical for AEDC. AEDC, typically credits are sold or given to the actual person who's creating the jobs, and so they've got different clawbacks than we usually see here.
Here, the credits are given to a CDE. The CDE raises the money and then invests, so you can't really go after the business because the business didn't get the credit. The credit was sold to raise money to invest in the business. What AEDC is most used to seeing is where you can actually go back and claw back that money from the actual person who received the money. We've strengthened this provision. We think we've made it as strong as we can, even though it's not exactly like AEDCs in the past. We've done all we can, I think, to try to satisfy as much as we can in their provisions
and maintain the structure of the program where we let private money and private businesses drive these investments. Who will benefit from this legislation? We believe and know that small businesses in Arkansas will invest, as you can see from what Mr. Ryan said in his letter. We also know that Arkansas lenders will invest because many of these deals are done as gap financing, so you may have traditional lending as well as lending through these investments through the CDEs. So we think we'll also strengthen the financial markets in Arkansas.
Also, obviously, our constituents will benefit because we're going to create jobs, and because of the assessment that's required on the front end, we have to show that we're going to create jobs. It has to be revenue positive day one, so we believe we will create jobs, and I'm proud to say that many people support this bill, including the chamber. For brevity's sake, I've asked them not to testify unless you want to hear from them, but I have permission from Mr. Zook to say that the chamber also supports this legislation.
With that, I'll be happy to try to take
any questions. We've got a couple of, Representative Williams, but first from the chair, if I could. I'm looking at this letter, and I think this was mentioned yesterday. Not only are these 100 jobs that Mr. Ryan says would be added if this bill passed or could be a result of this legislation, but the 200 jobs he's already created at that Nashville plant came from Missouri, this Simabula, Missouri. Is that correct? That
is correct, and for brevity's sake, I didn't go over this, but you have – or the other handout that I gave you talks about what other states have done.
For example, in Florida, they've had a state new market tax credit program for a while. They've created over 4,000 jobs. Those jobs pay an average wage of $47,000. In Missouri, as the chairman said, they've created, I think it was about 3,000 jobs for every $1 of tax incentive invested. It produced revenue of $1.53, so it's clearly revenue positive. We believe we'll see very similar results in Arkansas. Eleven states have adopted a state new markets tax credit program.
This makes us competitive and able to help existing business. New business can use it as well. This is important because this really helps existing business find that growth capital they need to expand and grow jobs. I want to thank you
for bringing this letter because that particular business in my district, DPI has been an outstanding corporate citizen. They've sponsored a lot of things for charity, and they've brought a lot of good jobs to the district. So thank you for the letter. We're going to go to questions. Representative Gene, who is recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 24
13:37
Representative Williams, I appreciate you bringing this bill up, and it's truly where we need to get started in this state in attracting businesses. And I had a few questions from people that were kind of wanting to know a little bit more detail about this bill, and I couldn't answer them. Sure. Yeah, and I knew you were going to be down there, and I knew you could. I will have somebody in the can. The tax credits can never be sold like some
tax credits can. Is that correct? Well, when you say never be sold, again, the CDE, it's akin to more like a venture capital fund.
The CDE receives the tax, an allocation of tax credits, and these are insurance premium tax credits. Every insurance policy sold instead of Arkansas has an insurance premium tax. insurance companies know their profitability, they know they're going to have to pay this tax regularly. So these tax credits will be sold to insurance companies to offset their insurance premium tax. So they are going to be sold, unlike traditional tax credits, they're going to be sold to fund this CDE that then will take the money to invest into businesses.
Speaker 24
14:42
And, of course, if these corporations have stockholders and shareholders, the credit will be distributed among them into a percentage of ownership to benefit those shareholders. No, the credit actually will be taken
against their insurance premium tax. Every insurance company has to pay a percentage to the state. So it will be used to offset their insurance premium tax. And that's why it's important that the assessment we're talking about is done on the front end because the insurance premium tax, the portion that goes to general revenue, the portion that goes two-thirds to general revenue, one-third.
I think to police and fire, we want to make sure that the investments that are made are revenue positive day one so we're not having an unnecessary hit on the state tax roll. We've got several things to try to prevent that. One, we phase in these tax credits. I said they don't start until year three, so we've got two years' worth of investment. They're phased in over a seven-year period. So from year three to year seven, they're phased in.
And the maximum amount in any year, if this was full-blown, would be $20 million. So the credits are, I think they go 12 percent, and then they're up and down between 12 and 11 percent. They can be taken each year. But the maximum impact that will be felt by the state from a tax credit would be $20 million. Now, you have to weigh that against the fact that we're requiring an assessment on the front end. And we're acquiring these businesses to create jobs and to show that it's going to be revenue positive day one. So we're going to get off the first $166 million allocations.
We're going to for sure get at least $166 million in money back. Then they're going to have to invest 150% of the fund. That's how we get the $250 million in investments. So we're going to have a situation where we're at least talking about something like Florida, Missouri, I'm sorry, where they had $153
Speaker 24
16:36
for every $1 in Texas. And one other question, Mayor, Mr. Chairman. Where these businesses are located, or are they based on census track, federal census tracks? It's based on federal
census tracks, and there are, I think, 73,000 census tracks across the country that qualify.
Maybe, I think that's right. I think I looked at that. You know, the federal new market tax credit program was started by Congress in 2000, and every year they look at, every 10 years when they do the census, they look at, And if a census tract is 20% or greater the poverty rate than it qualifies, or if it's 80% or the, I think, employment rate, 80% of the jobs rate or income rate, I think it qualifies. So let me say there are several, many, many, many census tracts throughout the state of Arkansas
in both urban and definitely in rural areas that qualify. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Representative Meeks is recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I
have a couple questions. First off, I just want to make sure I'm understanding exactly what's going on here from a layman's perspective. So when I walk out and, you know, someone from the media asks me what we did, I don't just say, you know, hey, we passed this great tax thing. It's going to make jobs. I really want to understand what we're doing here. First off, can you – first question is, can you tell me what an insurance premium tax is?
So I've got that background. Sure. Every insurance policy that's sold in the state of Arkansas, they're required to collect an insurance premium tax, a tax on that policy. So that's what the credit's going against, against that insurance premium tax.
Okay. So to make sure I understand, if I'm a business and I'm paying my tax bill, what we're doing is we're going to say we're going to give you a tax credit towards part of that tax bill to then reinvest in businesses. Would that be a very broad, would that be correct, or am I not?
you. The insurance premium tax credit only applies to insurance companies, companies that sell property, life, casual insurance. Okay, so we're talking about State Farm Progressive. Exactly, exactly. Those are the businesses that would be purchasing these tax credits. The funds, the proceeds from those purchases would seed or capitalize the CDE. The CDE then, in turn, will make investments in qualifying businesses in qualifying areas. Okay, so I'm insurance company A.
I'm going to be taking this tax credit money, and I'm going to take that, give it to this investment entity, and then that investment entity will then dole the money out to businesses. Am I getting closer there? That's a crude way of
saying it, Mr. Mixon, but that's close. I just want to make sure I've got a broad understanding. I know the devil's in the details. Yes, sir. Okay. I want to make sure you want to say that the insurance company, they are purchasing the credit to later use in year three through seven to offset their taxes.
So the insurance company has profits, they have revenue. They've got to pay taxes based on the revenue. So they're going to purchase a tax credit at less than a dollar for a dollar. It could be 70, 80 cents on a dollar. So they're saving a little bit by doing that. And in return, the community development entity that receives that money then takes those funds, raises additional funds, and make investments into qualifying business and qualifying areas. Okay, so
the community development group is going to sell these tax credits to the insurance company to raise money
and then use that money to invest in businesses and the communities that qualify. That's a very good way of saying it. Okay, good. I just want to make sure I understand what we're doing here. The next question I have, this is kind of getting into the devils in the details here. I'm looking at the financial impact from DF&A. I don't know if you've got a copy of that or can pull that up. But I'm looking at the legal analysis, and just let me know when you get there. It says the bill erroneously requires DF&A to issue letter rulings regarding the tax credit program,
and DFA does not administer the premium tax credit or is not the proper agency to issue letters. Do you have a response to that? I do,
and I appreciate DF&A. We just talked right before we came in here. It's the first time we saw it. It's not their fault. We're just we've been working with the governor's office quite a bit on this. And this is a point that I appreciate you bringing this to my attention. The letter ruling that we're talking about here, we believe, may be more appropriately done by AEDC or possibly the insurance department.
I will commit to fixing that as we move forward with this legislation. But we just found this out today, five minutes before I came in here. They've explained it to me, but we can fix that. That's a very simple fix. Yeah, I'm fine with that. I've had that happen on
bills myself, so I know I'm good with that. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Ballinger, recognized for a question.
Speaker 55
21:42
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is just, I mean, first of all, I want to say I appreciate you bringing this bill. It
does seem like it's, you know, my hope is it will be as effective as I think it probably will be. But there are a couple businesses that are specifically excluded, and I'm sure that there is real good reason for it. And I just was wondering what it was on, you know, page three where it talks about, one, retail businesses, retail sales, and real
estate businesses. And what was the motivation behind that? Well, really, particularly the real estate, our purpose here for this legislation is really to create jobs.
And so we have a 15% cap on real estate revenue because we're not necessarily trying to build buildings. A lot of the federal new market tax credit programs are used to build buildings. We're actually – we want to make sure that this is revenue positive for the state. And the way to do that, since we're having – since we'll use these credits to have a hit, We need to create jobs so those folks who have those jobs can actually pay taxes and reinvest back into the community. And so that's the reason why we've tried to do that. We're really trying to be very, very responsible to make sure that any hit on the state tax rolls
will more than be made up for by the jobs that are created, and that's why we're also delaying implementation of the tax credit being effective until
year three. I have a follow-up, if that's all right. But so it seems like what you're looking at is trying to avoid creating a potential real estate boom or bubble that would bust in construction. But are you also talking about, you know, a company that wants to open up a real estate office? Would that fall in that category or a title company? No.
As long as they're not deriving more than 15 percent of their revenues from the actual real estate, then if you open a title company and employ five or six people, then you can use this. as long as the revenue you're deriving is from your doing title work, not from owning property. Okay, so a real estate, if the revenue is from commissions are from some
real estate, they wouldn't be exempted from this, or would they? I don't think they would be exempted from this. I want to make sure. Let me look to my experts. Okay. Under the
next code, that would be a title company would be a service business and would be LN.
There. There. There. That's great to me on the record of ABC. Answer that question. Very good
for me. uh... so so this was specifically exclude somebody
who was when we were starting a
you know it in a in one of these areas that qualify starting a real estate firm that that's going to they're going to be that the realtors list and sell real estate but they're not actually make
the money off from yet that service industry that various codes service service industry is allowed to use this
if you don't mind me asking them would you be willing to just clarify that here if you've got to make an amendment anyway and i'd hate to ask you to do that but in the way it's it's it's right now i don't know if the when talks about some
real estate most i think most realtors would assume that they make a lot more than fifteen percent of their income off of the seller real estate
even though it's not their real state so well i think one thing is that rejection does gives the gives a dc rulemaking authority i think you're gonna see after that rulemaking authority going to see actual civic codes that will be uh... included i'm looking toward a dc that that that will provide for to the rulemaking process to provide for that uh... uh... clarity that you're asking for it
represent charlotte douglas you're recognized for
Speaker 72
25:45
question yes thank you very much first of all this is designed more for growth of present businesses instead of startup for new business
or? Well, both can utilize it, but given today's economy, given the restrictions on lending, oftentimes existing businesses have trouble finding that growth capital necessary. So it's not a prohibition from startups using it, but you're probably going to see existing businesses
Speaker 72
26:14
use it more. Okay. And then this is a better way for businesses to grow than using traditional money from a bank because... Well, this actually may be part
of a larger package that may include some traditional money from a bank. But because of today's economy, because of certain restrictions on lending, banks may not want to lend all of money necessary. This oftentimes is a gap financing between what a traditional lender may lend and what
an investor may need to grow
Speaker 72
26:48
its business. And these entities will set their own percentage of return and their own deadlines for repayment or? It will
be all a part of the transaction. That's correct, yes. And, of course, now, like any investor, they're going to present their deal, and the CED is going to present its terms, and those will be negotiated.
Speaker 72
27:10
Okay, those are negotiable. Okay. Okay. And then the insurance companies are the only ones that can buy the tax credits?
Is that legislated or is that just part of this whole program federally and statewide? Well, the way we set
it up, only an insurance company would want to have this tax exemption because everyone's paying an insurance premium tax. And really, we're trying to be responsible. We could have done this really on any tax, but we're trying to be responsible and make sure that we don't unnecessarily impact the state treasurer. I see. Thank you very much.
Representative McCrary, you're recognized for a question. Representative Williams, a couple of questions. The first one, I
guess Arkansas Economic Development Commission seems like this may limit their flexibility or bog them down. What's your response to that? Well, I think they'll
probably be here to testify, and we have tried to amend the bill in a way that I think we have come a long way
and making this a much better bill, and I appreciate their assistance. This tax incentive program is different from other incentives they're used to dealing with, where they're able to go and claw back from the actual business owner when they don't do or live up to what they're supposed to, because this is creating a CDE or kind of a venture capital fund who has a tremendous amount of incentives to make sure that they actually do what they're supposed to, because if they don't do what they're supposed to, So then the recapture provisions that are the strongest in the country will kick in toward them.
So understand they sold these credits to some insurance company, and they'll have to go back to the companies that you can't use those credits. And so that means they're going to want their money back. So it is a strong way. We've got a strong recapture provision. It's a strong way to provide incentives, but it's not traditionally where AEDC has the type of control. But, again, on the amendment that I presented at the beginning, because we have an economic assessment by a third party, and AEDC is a part of this, that looks at these deals to make sure that they are revenue positive,
I think that plus the recapture provision will be strong provisions to make sure that we're not just being irresponsible in giving the state
revenue positive side of it. How much of, through all this process, how much of this money actually gets to the project? I've heard various things from 40 cents on the dollar to what's your response to that?
Well, obviously, that's part of the negotiated transaction. I can't give you a figure. But I will say in the – this bill allows for two models, and largely because that's what the governor's office really wanted us – ADC wanted us to do. And I truly believe under this funds model that I really talked about, you're going to see more dollars going to – or less dollars going into administrative costs than under the traditional model of the federal new markets tax program, where there is a significant amount of money that goes to but needed goes toward legal expenses and various other things
under the model that we've talked about mostly I believe you'll see much more money going to the deal and I believe, I've been dealing this so long now I believe there may be a prohibition on someone out there can help me is there a limit on how much can be can go in administrative expenses somewhere in the deal I'm sorry, I'm looking to all my
counsel that's right so there's a requirement
of 150% of the capital to be reinvested so all of the credit money will be put to use 150% will be put to use one and a half times basically
thank you Mr. Chairman seeing no other questions we'll go
to the list of those who signed up. Representative Williams, did you have anybody in particular that you wanted to call to the table with you at this time? Let's hear what the people
who may be in the opposition, and then we'll pick and choose who we need from there. I've got a lot of support out here. I just don't know which one
to shoot right now, you know? Is it Will Kittle or Kendall? Okay. And I'm not sure, originally signed up against the bill, but then that was scratched out.
Yeah, right. If you would, introduce yourselves to the committee, and then you can make your comments on the bill.
MR. I'm Grant Tennille. I'm Executive Director of the Arkansas Economic Development
for the Department of Finance and Administration. MR. First and foremost, I want to thank Representative Williams. As he has indicated, we have spent quite a few hours over the last week or so working
on this bill. I think the bill that you've got in front of you is a much better bill from our perspective than the one we started with. I think Representative Williams' explanation of the bill is accurate. And he talked about where our sticking point is. We think we've done a lot to try and ensure that the impact to the economy and to the
state treasury is going to be a net positive, or at the very least, revenue neutral. I still have a concern about the callback provisions, but I understand very well why why we can't get to what I feel is optimal. As Representative Williams explained, insurance
companies are providing the money into this deal. Money is then flowing down to a company. I'll give you the worst-case scenario for what could happen even with all of the safeguards we've put in place. So we run the model that says company is going to hire this many people and pay them this much, and therefore the impact on the Treasury is, you know, a positive. For every dollar we're putting out, we're going to get $1.53 back or $2 back or whatever
it is. If the company then doesn't live up to what it said it was going to do, if it doesn't hire the people it said it was going to hire or pay them what they said they were going to pay them. I don't have any ability, and the state doesn't have any ability, to go to the company and say, guys, you didn't live up to your end of the bargain.
Give me my money back. The reason is that the guys trying to raise this fund And if they had to go to the insurance companies and say, guys, put your money in, but if everything doesn't go just exactly perfect, the state's going to come take your money back. Well, the insurance companies have no control over the businesses that they're investing
in, and these guys wouldn't raise a dollar into a fund that had that provision in it. I mean, they'd have a really hard time going out and raising the capital if the insurance companies putting the money up were at risk of DF&A or AEDC showing up at their door and saying, give me my money back. That's a concern because, again, these are tax dollars.
And at least for the first hundred million of this, the state is going to be a 58 percent investor in every business that gets invested in. And without the ability to go get the money back, if the company doesn't live up to its promises, then we're at risk. Now, is that good risk? Yeah, I think it probably is.
I mean, again, that's why when Representative Shepard asked if we were for it or against it, I'm sort of like this. I like the tool a lot, and I think it's going to get used. But there's some risk here. The thing could go badly, and the thing could go badly for the state and well for the investors. Let me give you an example. A company tells us they're going to hire 100 people and pay them $10,000 a month,
and they figure out after a while that they can do it with 50 people paying them $7,000 a month. And it's going to make them more efficient and maybe even more profitable. Good for the investors, good for the company, not so good for the state. So the only point that I'm trying to make here is that I like the tool.
I think the bill's stronger than it was. It's not absolutely risk-free. There's significant risk here. And I just think everybody needs to know that when they vote. I've spoken with my friends at DF&A who said, you know, correctly that there was revenue impact. We think we've done our best to limit that potential revenue impact by saying you've
got to run it through this model and show us that it's going to be revenue positive before you can even take your project forward, but again, if the company doesn't live up to its end of the bargain, it'll end up being a revenue impact that we've got no ability
Speaker 111
38:47
to mitigate. Do you have anything to add? Thank you. Really not to that point. I think Grant has very accurately stated what
our concerns are. The things that we know concretely are of course the potential loss even if it's three or four years in the future could be 58% of the 166 million and this particular scheme is not the type of thing we're used to seeing in terms of being able to budget and see things that are certain. It's not like say a specific appropriation that deals with a grant to a particular entity.
To us, we have not yet seen, and maybe some of the changes that are being made that I think you were informed that we weren't quite aware of might mitigate some of this issue, but at this point, based on what we've seen, you know, whether this is revenue neutral or revenue positive, we can't confirm. The second part of the issue, of course, was with regard to the letter rulings, and I think Representative Williams has satisfied us that our concern that we aren't the agency who
administers this tax or any of the other provisions, probably that duty would be left better to AEDC or
Insurance Department. MR. Mr. Chairman, if I may, one more point, and then I'll hush. We have talked throughout this process, and we haven't done it yet, but I still think and this gets somewhat to Representative Meek's line of questioning. We have discussed making these credits only applicable to the non-health side of the premium tax.
A lot of the reason for that is that many legislators have different plans for what we're going to do with the health side of the premium tax, tax, depending on what you all decide to do with Medicaid. And so I'm not saying that we've got to make this change now, but I think Representative Williams is aware, depending on what decisions are made with what happens with the health side of the premium tax, we may have to limit the applicability of this to property casualty
life and because there may be other plans to spend health premium tax dollars that we need to protect. So I think we're ready to make that change on the Senate side if that's what's necessary. Fair statement, sir. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. A couple of questions
based on your statements. First off, if we were to implement this, the amount of risk to the insurance companies,
the way it's written, would be zero. Would that
be a fair statement? Well, no, it's certainly not zero because technically they could make a bunch. Well, they're going to get their tax credits if they put the money back up. The risk to them is that the reinvestment doesn't happen and we end up in a recapture situation and the CDE has to go back to the insurance companies and say, give us our money back or give us our credits back if you haven't used them yet.
So there is risk, certainly. Okay, and that
risk is both borne by the state and by the insurance companies. That's correct. And obviously the insurance companies are voluntarily taking that risk. Absolutely. Okay. The next question I have is kind of a follow-up. When, if we implement this and we do get a business that goes south on us here, currently by this there's the clawbacks. You said there wasn't opportunity there maybe to get. Is there legal action that can be taken?
Obviously there's cost involved there, but is there legal action that could be taken to try to recoup that or are we just
pretty much out of luck? I'm not an attorney, and I'll look to Representative Williams, but if there's nothing in the contract, there'd be nothing to enforce in legal action to try and get
the money back. Okay. Two more questions, and I'll be done. You kind of mentioned some things that would make you feel more comfortable with this. Have you stated everything that you believe would make you more comfortable with this?
Well, and I'm comfortable with the fact that the thing that would make me the most comfortable won't let the fund work. Right, right. I just want everybody to know on the front end that here's some risk. Sure.
And then the final question, and I'm kind of looking at this. It looks like every state that's implemented, it's been a positive forum. Sure. The $166 million, and this may be a better question for Mr. Williams or Representative Williams, But the $166 million that we're looking at, is there something in the bill or is there something in the way this program is set up that says the state's going to invest a certain amount of money?
Is this something that can be phased in maybe more slowly instead of going directly to a $100 million potential risk? Or kind of talk to that
a little bit. And we've discussed that a lot over the last couple of days. And part of the issue is there's attractiveness, as you've recognized, in mitigating our risk on the front end. The flip side of that attractiveness is if you get the pool too small, you can't.
I mean, it's the difference between specific risk and aggregate risk. You know, with a big enough fund, we'll make enough investments that, on the aggregate, I can tell you with a whole lot of confidence that I think we're going to end up cash flow positive. If I start cutting the size of that fund down and making a smaller number of these investments, you know, let's say I could make 20 and you cut it down and I can only make seven.
If two or three of seven go bad, my aggregate just goes. Sure, sure. So would I like to step out there a little less? Yeah. But at the same time, you know, I think they're going to have an easier time raising the fund if it's that size. And I think that, you know, on the aggregate, the large size actually mitigates our risk a little bit. Okay, so if you were
Yeah, no, because, I mean, I know. Yeah or no? I know, at least here in Arkansas, and the guys that we've worked with from out of state who are interested in this, I think they're good at their jobs. I think they're going to make good investments.
All right, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Link, you're recognized for a question. Grant, you pretty well danced
all around this, and you've not known a purpose. I know, but you said earlier you think this will be used. Oh, it will be. And you think we'll probably max out that 166 and just kind of float there?
I think that if I have another concern, it's how quickly we've got to get the thing in place. You know, we need to make that $100 million of investments in one year. We talk a lot about the fact that access to capital has been a problem in Arkansas. And in some cases, it has. We don't have the deal flow historically that we've needed.
And a program like this or any of our incentives don't make a bad deal good. They've got to be good deals. I think there's going to be a whole lot of pressure on the CDEs to get this money out the door in that first year. Now, the flip side of that is I think we're all very hopeful that we've got some people in businesses all across the state sitting out there saying, well, I think there's market opportunity for me, and, you know, I'm willing to take some risk here.
give this a shot and and we're hoping that with a tool like that available out there that people will step up to that risk a little bit better okay thank
you thank you mr. chair representative Linderman you're recognized for a question thank you
mr. chair grant this has apparently been successful in other states how does Arkansas's model compared to the other states I mean and you're trying to lay it all out here for us.
I think, as Representative Williams said, we've created, with a lot of work together, a model that is stronger than the other states, stronger from the state's perspective than a lot of what the other states have done. um i wouldn't be sitting here saying mostly good things if i didn't think we'd done that
um you know again everybody has got to figure out what level of risk they're willing to to accept and you know our tolerance for risk is maybe less than florida's um but We've got a good model here. You alluded to this, Mr. Chair, if you will,
that we have a better model than these other states have, this recapture provisions.
Did the other states have recapture provisions that were better or worse than
what is in this model? No, a lot of those recapture provisions, as Representative Williams said, are based on the recapture provisions in the federal new market tax credit. And so a lot of the recapture provisions are the same across all of the states. I'd like a stronger one, but I understand why I can't
get to a stronger one. We are working on a huge project, Big River Steel.
How does this compare to what we're working on with Big River Steel? Is it going to be a
companion? Is it added risk? Is it? Well, I'll tell you that Big River right now is looking at employing up to $100 million in federal new market tax credits. Would they, if given the opportunity, would they layer some of this on top of it, maybe?
But that's also a lot of the reason why we limited the access to some of our statutory incentives to make sure, I mean, as I explained to Representative Williams when we first started this conversation, we feel like our job is to pay not one dollar more than it takes to land a project. And so what we try and limit is people's ability to step up to the menu
and say I'll take one from column A and two from column B and stack all this stuff on top of it and end up costing the state a whole lot of money. This tool isn't designed for a big river size project. Could I see a day when it could be applied in a big stack with a bunch of different other things to a larger project? Sure. But this, well, it's really
aimed at small business. Now, remember, the statutory definition of small business, you can employ up to 500 people so most of the businesses in arkansas are small businesses okay thank you thank you mr chair i believe we
have one one final question representative gillum thank you mr chair uh representative linderman i got one
of mine uh answered there but just for clarity's sake director if you wouldn't mind going back if i understood you correctly earlier
You might have alluded to it or maybe even specifically said it, but in relation to our other tax credit programs, kind of where does this one stack up? I mean, is it your understanding or maybe your belief that the other tax credit programs we have are maybe more foolproof than this one, or would it be fair to say maybe even that none
of them are foolproof? Well, none of them are foolproof. And let me tell you, we can put the clawbacks in place,
and we can back the clawbacks up with personal guarantees. But if we end up in a situation where somebody has truly gone kablooey and there is nothing to claw back, I mean, we can take them to court, but you can't get blood from a stone. So none of them are perfectly foolproof. I will say that you compare this to the other tax credits, and there's a reason for this,
and it's the way the thing is structured. It's going to be on a percentage basis the largest tax credit that we give out, at least across that first $100 million. When they load the full thing at 150% over time and revolve it a couple of times, the percentage starts to go down. But right now, everything we're doing is in the 30% range, and this is 58 to start.
Okay. But this one actually has tighter controls than a lot of our other tax
credit programs. No, it's got about the same controls with the exception of the clawbacks. Okay. I mean, we're running, part of what we've worked on is we're running these deals now with this amendment through the exact same process we run all of our other deals
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Link, you're recognized. Mr. Chair, I have a motion.
What's your motion? We've nearly had an hour of testimony, great testimony, but I'd like to limit debate to seven
minutes per side. It's a proper motion. All those in favor of limiting debate, seven minutes aside, indicate by saying aye. Any opposed? Okay, seven minutes aside, and the four-side, Representative Williams closing is part of that seven minutes. Representative Eubanks, I believe you had a question.
Mr. Tennille, Representative Jean asked Representative Williams about the salability of these credits,
and the bill doesn't allow that, but it does allow the allocation or the pass-through of these credits, Does that make it more difficult for the recapture, or does that part of that allocation make it more
attractive? No, the recapture, the terms for the recapture are rock solid, and, you know, we're going to the CDE for the recapture. We're going to know where those guys are. I mean, if they want to fight with the insurance company, they're going to have to do that, but that's not going to be left on the state.
the CDEs. But does the pass-through or the allocation ability of the credits make it more attractive for the investors? Well, it's only getting
passed through once from the CDE to the insurance company. The insurance company can't then move it to somebody else or sell it to another insurance company. They're going to get their credits for the money they put in.
Well, I was reading on the – well, help me understand this section on the bottom of page 5, line 34. It says a tax credit earned by a corporation, et cetera, et cetera, may be allocated
to the partners, members, or shareholders. Oh, well, yeah, you're right. Okay. It ultimately flows all the way upstream to the equity holders in that insurance company. So, you know, but I don't really know why that would be.
I almost think that's normal language taken out of the federal bill where most of the time we're dealing with income tax credits, and that's the way those things flow. I can't think of a, and I'm looking at the guys who really know, I can't think of a reason why you'd flow a premium tax credit up to the shareholder of an insurance company. But, yeah, I guess it depends on how the insurance company is structured. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. See no other questions.
Thank you. And for purposes of clarification, there have been a number of questions. The Chair is going to rule that Mr. Thiel was speaking against the bill, so that counts against the against time. Next up, we have the final person signed up to speak on this is Randy Zook, who has signed up to speak in favor of the bill. He's waving me off. All right, so that's all that we have signed up. Representative Williams, would you like to close for your bill? I'd like to close for the bill. I don't think I need seven minutes, though.
Let me make sure that I repeat a couple of points that Grant made. One, you heard a lot of things, and I appreciate his testimony. I appreciate them working with us. A couple of things he said that I think are important. One, he says we've got a good model. He also said that this is aimed at small business, and that's correct. Somebody asked a question about Big River Steel. Also, he said that no deal is foolproof. Every one of their incentives has certain risks. Every business has some risk, and this one does, but we think those risks have been significantly modified.
Let me say a few other things. This model, this bill, this state new market tax credit program is more transparent than any state new market tax credit program in the country. It has more safeguards than anyone in the country. You asked about the size of the fund. He had a great answer. Economies of scale would suggest that we need a larger fund. This is really not a large fund. You look at some of the sizes of those funds on your sheet, you see this is not really large. I think we're at an optimal size.
Some states have been successful with this. They're in their second round of funding, so they've gone to round two of funding. Let me speak just for a little bit about the CDE. If you want to know where the rubber meets the road and who's got the real responsibility here, it's the CDEs. Because it's a CDE that will be looked at. Those guys have to run this program correctly. If they don't run the program correctly, they won't get investors. There are probably 200 CDEs around the country that could qualify for this program because they qualify federally.
They've received an allocation that would include Arkansas. And usually when this is passed, less than 10 come into the state. So I anticipate seeing some of them coming into the state. It's important to recognize that in the legislation, the CDE itself cannot decertify or basically receive money from this until the seventh year of operation when the fund is decertified. They have to comply with every provision before they can get money out. So you're talking about they're willing to put their neck on the line
and not get paid for seven years before this happens. They have all the incentives in the world to make sure that they make wise, sound, and good investments. And I'll close with this is yet one more tool that Arkansas needs to attract jobs. We all know our problem with this economy, and it's all about creating jobs. I would challenge you that outside of Big River Steel, I'm not sure that we're doing a whole lot as a legislature to create jobs. As I said to begin with, this is the bipartisan jobs bill of 2013.
I suspect years down the road, future legislatures will be reauthorizing a second round of state new market tax credit programs, and I suspect that your communities will see jobs created from this bill, and I would appreciate a good vote. Thank you,
Representative Williams. Representative Thompson, you're recognized for a motion. Thank you,
We have a motion do pass as amended. Is there any discussion? All those in favor, indicate by saying aye.
Those opposed, the motion passes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members. All right, members, we're going to go to our regular agenda, House Bill 2088. Representative Gilliam, are you ready to run your bill? Okay, you're recognized to run House Bill 2088. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank
you, committee. What I have before you is a new and improved version of a bill that I ran a couple of weeks ago.
And as you know, those of you that know me, I'll start by saying that, I always try to find the win-win scenario in most anything that I get involved in. And what I believe I have before you is a new and more improved version of that previous bill. So targets the same, the goals are the same, however, we're going about it a different way in one in which I believe that now the NRC has the flexibility that they need to conduct the business the way they need and the way they see fit in regard to the compacts and things that were addressed previously.
It also gives the protection moving forward in these emergency situations that agriculture needs. And so I believe we have found the win-win scenario that we were all looking for in this. And with that, I know we've got a full calendar, so I'll keep it brief, and we'll answer any questions if anybody has any. Vice Chairman Steele, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'll try to be brief,
too. I appreciate your willingness to do that. I'm looking at the bill. Well, it looks like this is a different part of the section than the previous bill was
under. Is that correct? Yes or no. I mean, a different section of the code? Yes or no. We are dealing with primarily a different section of the code, but also we are addressing some concerns with the section of code that we had dealt with before in the previous bill. So I may
muddy the water a little bit for you, and I apologize. That previous bill had, I guess, the water uses and it had them not prioritized, had
them listed out without priority, correct? Well, actually, upon review of that, it was kind of determined that the priorities were in that.
I think there's some other different confusing sections of code that do not prioritize, and so the feeling was is that that particular portion did actually prioritize. However, not to get into all that today, but we cleaned that up to make sure that agriculture was not in that particular area because that was the concern on those compacts and stuff. So we made sure that we did not cause any more confusion with that particular section of code. Gotcha. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I see no other questions. We have no one signed up against the bill, but we do have Bo Bishop has signed up to speak for the bill. You'll pass. Okay. Representative Gillum, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. I'm closed. What's the pleasure of the committee? Okay. Representative Linderman has a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? Representative Meeks, for what
purpose? Just clarification. This 2088 amendment, do we need to adopt the amendment before we do a full pass?
just to make sure we're doing it correct. It's my
understanding that the amendment was put on it. It was a member's own amendment previously. It's been engrossed, so it
is part of the bill at this point. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for checking, though. All right. Any other discussion? All those in favor, indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Moving on down the agenda, House Bill 1145, Representative Nichols, are you ready to present your bill?
Representative Nichols, you're recognized to present House Bill 1145. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman and committee. Obviously, if you look on the co-sponsors of this bill, you'll find that we have a wide range in the political spectrum who are supporting this bill.
And what brought this about, you know, was that looking at my opponent's campaign report showed that he had a contribution from the Greater Little Rock Chamber of Commerce. I also knew that the Little Rock Chamber of Commerce received public funds from the city of Little Rock. So my first bill would have just wiped out completely that provision of Arkansas law
that allowed a local chamber to contract with a city for economic development purposes. And I spoke with my local chamber when I explained where I was coming from on it, that they're responsible. We don't give political contributions. We don't do that. And I told them at the time, well, I'm going to amend it, where they can continue contracting
with the local government, but there has to be some accountability there, and there has to be some restrictions on their funds. And so I said, so what my bill does is it prohibits the giving of political contributions. It prohibits using those funds for issue advocacy, and like if there's something on the ballot, we don't need public funds being used to sway us on how to vote.
And so that's where I came up with those ideas. And then also said, because I think there are some issues where when the economic development entities, they don't necessarily report back to the local government how the funds were spent. So basically what this bill does, it prohibits political contributions, it prohibits political advocacy, and it requires reporting.
Now I will go back to my first premise that kind of got my attention, but now I think we are in an accountability way to deal with these funds. I did meet with the Little Rock Chamber of Commerce, and they said, we did not give your opponent any money. And I said, well, and I showed him the report that showed that they had given my opponent $200.
And he brought me their checkbook for their PAC fund showing that they had actually given him $300 out of their PAC fund and not the $200. I said, well, it sounds to me like somebody needs to file something to straighten that out. I don't know if it's been done yet or not. But it was from a PAC fund. And I understand that, that's fine. But with the impression that it left that they were using public dollars to be involved
in a political campaign really concerned me. And also using public dollars to be involved in a sales tax campaign where not everybody is for a sales tax, and so their tax dollars should not be used against their position. So I think I have a good bill that requires transparency, requires accountability, and we have passed a number of bills in this session to limit the use of public funds in issue
campaigns. And those have been supported by, they've been bipartisan, and my bill, as you can see, also bipartisan so I'll I'll be happy to entertain any questions that the committee might have representative Gilliam you're recognized for a question thank
you mr. chair thank you representative Nichols you had shared this bill with me previously and I
do appreciate the chance to take a look at
it back a couple weeks ago and a question that didn't come up until just now or I would have already asked it because you know I like to get all this stuff out you said you wouldn't blindside me I remember that and and so I don't think this is a blindside question it's more of a clarifying question so I can kind of understand how this would fit into the framework and part of this is loc is coming from a local standpoint too because our Chamber of Commerce back home has been really inundated by our hospital to get involved in trying to persuade all of us down here at the legislature to back from White County to get involved in the
Medicaid expansion debate, and they've been really putting a lot of pressure on the chamber to run all these ads and really try to influence our vote on what will happen with Medicaid expansion. Does this bill, is that kind of what you're trying to target
here? Well, what I'm saying is if that local chamber has funds from the government, they cannot use those funds to run advocacy ads. And that's what that would be.
And I just don't think that's appropriate. If the hospital wants ads to run, then let them pay for it. Don't have the taxpayers paying for the issue advocacy. Okay. And I agree
with that. That's why I'm just trying to ask a clarifying question on that there. And like I said, I promised I wouldn't blindside you. And hopefully that one didn't
stumble you. So I appreciate it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Nichols, I've got a question or two. Number one, why are you targeting economic development entities when there are a number of other agencies and groups that contract with various municipalities and receive money?
Is it just based on your personal situation, or is there any particular reason why we should be focused only on these groups as opposed to the various other groups
that contract with state, local, and city government? MR. Well, I would say that what started me was what I noticed in my campaign. But there's also been a lawsuit filed because the Arkansas Constitution prohibits cities and counties from giving money to a private entity.
So now we call it a service contract to try to keep from falling under the restrictions of our state constitution. I consider that most entities that contract with the state or with the city, they're not using those contract funds to make issue advocacy or political contributions, and that's my
issue, so if any, and I would assume that a lot of contracts would prohibit the recipients from being involved in political campaigns with those funds. So I think the economic development activity that goes on is worthwhile. We need it, but I think they cross the line when they get involved in the political process with those public funds.
And as I understand it, your bill would prohibit any contribution.
It wouldn't just be that any kind of tracing of public money. It would actually prohibit any contribution from an economic development organization that receives money. Is that correct?
I think that could be an interpretation, but I just didn't know how we could split the hairs to say, well, it's okay to use these funds for this type of activity and not political activity but not this other type of activity. If the head of the chamber is paid 60 percent by their dues income and 40 percent by the
public funds, then that raises some issues. And I've heard from former chamber executives who sometimes feel pressure from the local government saying, you need to be behind this because we're funding your organization. And so they're also put in a squeeze. So it works, you know, that way
also. And then a final question, and I haven't had an opportunity to check the code section that this refers over to.
Would this prohibit, for example, a local chamber from supporting, let's say, a local vote for an economic development tax? I think it would prohibit
you using the public funds to advocate for the passage of a local tax. But I thought you
just said that you can't distinguish those
monies. And I don't know how we as policymakers can say this type of political activity is permissive or okay and others are not.
I just don't know how we would do that. Do you have any concern that if we implement this legislation that it might have a chilling effect on our chamber's ability to operate and do business and attract businesses? In other words, if a chamber has an opportunity or sees a need to pass a local tax and we're not allowing them just by the basis of receiving some money, is that not going to encourage these chambers just not to take any money?
And in essence, are they going to continue to do the business that right now
cities are contracting with them for? Well, if the city was proposing a sales tax increase, I don't think they can use public funds to advocate the passage or defeat of that proposal. So what makes the difference when a check is written to an economic development activity that now they can use those funds for that purpose that the city could not use it for?
MR. But again, for clarification, you're not talking about tracing funds. You're talking about an outright prohibition. If they receive $1 from a governmental entity, then they can't spend any money on any of these issues. I just want to
make sure we're all clear on this. I'd say that could be a fair interpretation, that if they're receiving public dollars, they don't need to be out advocating on political positions or candidates.
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Chair, but you actually asked my question. Vice Chairman
Steele, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Nichols, are you aware of the bill? I think there was a bill passed out of the House recently by Representative Bell that would prohibit any public entity from advertising for political gain. Are you familiar with that, and would that not cover this
as well? No, because the city or the school board, they're not the ones doing it.
It's the other entities out there that are doing it. So that bill did not prohibit public money, it just prohibited public
entities, is that? Yes, I believe so. So this is in line with that legislation of Representative Bell and other legislation that he has run. Before I mention that, I mentioned that before
I saw that Representative Bell was in the audience, so I guess I could have just walked over there and asked him. Thank you. Thank you for
your answer. Any other questions? If not, we'll go to the list.
We have several people that have signed up, and I will recognize Michael Lindsey, who has signed up to speak against the bill. Michael Lindsey Thank you,
Mr. Chair and members of the committee. My name is Michael Lindsey. I work for the Rogers-Lowell Chamber of Commerce. We have over 2,000 members that employ more than 20,000 people in northwest Arkansas. And I appreciate the time to come here today and explain our opposition to this bill.
Let me first say that we do a contract with the city of Rogers to do economic development. We provide those services every year. That contract comes up every year. And we would, under no circumstances, use those public funds to advocate, to lobby, or to do any sort of political activity, especially contributing to candidates or to issue campaigns. Those funds are separate. They're used for economic development services only because that's what we're contracted for. That's what it says in our contract. And that's a contract that's negotiated and approved by the city council every year. And so we definitely do not use those funds for the type of activities that Representative Nichols has mentioned.
But because of our interpretation of the bill, we are then not allowed to use our private funds to do activities that we do believe are important to represent our member businesses. And we have primarily three issues with this bill. Number one, we disagree with the principle of singling out one private entity from participating in the political process. I think that you've already discussed a little bit, but I think that you're setting a precedent that the state can then stop anyone with a city contract from engaging in the political process. Number two, we think this undermines local control.
We've heard several times throughout this legislative session that local control is important. It's something that this legislature believes in and that should be supported. And so by limiting what cities can do, who they can contract with, we feel it's micromanaging what cities do. Like I mentioned, our contract is reviewed every year, and the services that we provide are included in that contract. And I can assure you that those services that we provide are not or does not include supporting candidates or issue campaigns. And our final point in opposition to this bill is really our most major point,
our most major stance that we're against this is that it prevents us and other chambers from representing business in local elections or statewide elections. You know, businesses often look to us to be the voice and to represent them for issues that either are good or bad for the region or for economic development. And we feel that contributions also in the definition, it's a very broad definition. It's not just monetary. It's anything of value. And so from our perspective, anything of value could be a staff time. So if we have a staff member that needs to go out and talk about an issue.
We're not allowed to do that. It's a flyer in our newsletter. We're not allowed to do that. So I think the contribution is not just us writing a check to a candidate or us writing a check to a ballot initiative. This is also our staff time as well. We feel that this bill would prevent us from taking a stance on that, whether it's in for or against a local or statewide issue. So those are primary reasons for opposing this bill. I'd be happy to take any questions if you have them.
Seeing no questions, thank you, Mr. Lindsey. Thank you, Chairman. Going back to the list, we do not have anybody signed up to speak in favor of the bill. The next person up to speak against the bill is Randy Zook. Okay. And Mr. Jay Cheshire signed up to speak against the bill. So have a seat, introduce yourself, and you may make your comments. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 205
1:21:00
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Jay Cheshire with the Little Rock Regional Chamber of Commerce here in Little Rock. I appreciate the opportunity to come and discuss this with you folks today. I've had a conversation with Representative Nichols, who I actually happen to like. So this is not an issue of an us versus him, but it is an issue that we believe prohibits, per this bill, our ability to, first of all, be the voice of business while, secondly, doing the work that many of you in your local chambers of commerce do in your community.
So to add to what Michael said, we have a contract for services for economic development with the city of Little Rock. We also have agreements with other public entities. And per this legislation, it would prohibit us from actually being able to do the work that our members ask us to do, and that is to help grow this economy, not only in Little Rock and central Arkansas. There's been made mention of PAC funds, and I can tell you that Representative Nichols and I have discussed what really started this,
and it was a political opponent of his had filed a financial disclosure stating that the Little Rock Regional Chamber had contributed to his campaign, which in fact was not true. The filing, I believe, Representative Nichols has since been amended. I did speak to that political candidate, and he understood that he had filed that in error and was going to amend that to show that it came from a political action committee that's not even a political action committee of the Chamber of Commerce. It's a political action committee of the business community in central Arkansas, and it has
been around for many, many years. And so that's how all of this started. I happen to agree with Representative Nichols from the standpoint of if you're taking political dollars or, excuse me, if you're taking public dollars to do a service, whether it's economic development or whether it's phone service, for that matter, taking those dollars and using them for the political process certainly wouldn't be applicable. and we believe, as Representative Steele has stated earlier, is taken care of with other existing legislation currently on the books today.
So first of all, I want to say that I agree with that. Secondly, when we run an economic development program, we segregate those dollars from our chamber operations budget so that there could be no question about where those dollars are being spent. In fact, we offer and provide to our public entities an audit of those funds each and every year, not only of the public dollars coming into the Economic Development Fund for the contract for service, but also of our private dollars.
So we are trying to be as transparent as we possibly can in providing the service for the city of Little Rock and our other public entities that we're being asked to do. So what does this do if, in fact, this bill passes? I don't know about your communities, but when the local library needs to talk about expansion and needs to talk about going to the people to provide an opportunity for that expansion through a millage election or what have you, who do they typically come to for help? It's the business community, and it's normally the Chamber of Commerce.
The same thing with your local school board when you're looking at trying to expand education within that community. The same thing from the city's perspective or the county's perspective if they're looking at trying to add infrastructure. And so what we're doing is taking an entity, in this case a chamber of commerce, out of the political process that we believe would be unfair, number one, and number two is a slippery slope because if we're a private corporation contracting for economic development services with the local community
and now all of a sudden we're taken out of the political process, then what's to say the next time we have a legislative session Somebody gets mad at the phone company and decides, well, they have a contract for service with the local community. We're going to add them to this legislation and take them out of the political process, too. Or the local company that picks up the trash, are they now no longer going to be able to be part of the political process? We believe that this legislation, while we understand the intent, goes way beyond any intent that was originally part of why this legislation coming forward itself,
Number one, and then number two, that the issue is already resolved in terms of existing law. I'll be happy
to answer any questions you may have. Any questions from the committee? Seeing none, thank you for your comments. I believe that's all that we have signed up for against
the bill. Representative Nichols, you're recognized to close for your bill. Thank you, committee. I appreciate your indulgence in hearing this bill.
Again, I feel like there are more positives here than negatives. We need to get a handle on how public funds end up being funneled into political issues, campaigns, and this is a step in that direction. So I appreciate a good vote. MR. What's the pleasure of the committee? We
have a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All those in favor indicate by saying aye.
Those opposed? No. Motion fails. House Bill 1539 has been deferred. We're going down to House Bill 1653. Representative Lee. 1653 motion to pass you're out of order you're out of
Speaker 211
1:27:00
order I usually am if I may have I invite mr. Cox from the Lane Commissioner's office up here we're on
House Bill 1653 if you would introduce yourselves to the committee and then representably you can present your bill
hi members I'm Cory Cox I'm an attorney Attorney and Government Affairs Liaison for the
Speaker 211
1:27:24
Land Commissioner's Office. MS. First, I'd like to say this is not an anti-duck hunting bill, as has been – we've waited to run this bill for the purpose of making sure we've assaged everyone's concerns.
This bill basically says it's codifying what is really already known, and that is the land commissioner is responsible for all public land – well, I'm not – submerged public lands. One of the other concerns that – and therefore is responsible to make sure of the sale, the use, et cetera, and regulate it. One of the other concerns that was expressed to me about this bill had to do with islands. There are people that are concerned their islands are going to be taken over or the
land commissioner is going to move in on them. The Lane Commissioner's Office has assured me that every island in the state of Arkansas has a deed on it, and they're aware of every single deed of who owns what islands and whether the Lane Commissioner owns them or not. So that's another piece of information that was out there that I want to calm everyone down on. Are there any questions? Representative Linderman, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, Representative Lee. This question may be for Corey. Corey and I have had some rather extensive conversations about this, and one thing that I would like for you to clarify in testimony, right now up in my area we've got St. Francis, Cache River is part of Cricket County over there, and they're doing some dredging and things right now. Now, if a river channel cuts a new channel due to some type of a log jam or anything like this
and does, in effect, create an island that was not in the original channel, how is that going to be handled by the Land Commission? Well, thank you, Representative
Linderman. We acquired title when the state became a state in 1836. So what we own is what was conveyed to us by the federal government in 1836. So if there are any changes, we can always give away what we have,
but we can't gain anything unless the federal government comes back and gives it to us. So there's no way that just because we lose something because it changes, is because there's farmland that now is submerged, we don't gain that farmland that's submerged. We can only claim what was navigable at the time that Arkansas became a state.
And so in your instance, as we discussed before, that wouldn't be something that we would be laying claim to. That's simply because we couldn't say that we got title from the federal government at that point. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Vice Chairman
Steele, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. I think you just touched on this. I took a water law course in law school a long time ago, and I don't remember much from it. But I do remember there are some major distinctions between navigable and non-navigable waterways.
My understanding is it's only navigable if it were navigable when the state entered into the union. Is that correct? Yes, sir. Okay, so I guess my question is along the same lines Representative Lenderman was asking. This doesn't affect anything on those non-navigable waterways, even though
now they may be presumed to be navigable. No, sir. And it wouldn't affect, like if you're talking about, well, Lake Maumelle, for instance. It's a man-made lake. Now, the Maumelle River, we could claim the channel because at that point it was navigable,
but we can't claim all of that surrounding it. If you go down here to Hot Springs to some of the man-made lakes that were made, I think, energy, built a couple of lakes, we can't claim those. Those are private lakes that they have to go through their processes. That's not our bailiwick. This only affects those that you already have claimed. Yes, sir.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Letting, you're recognized for a question. Motion at the proper
time. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My first question, I may be being a little obnoxious here or splitting hairs, but submerged lands, don't we usually, those are lakes, river streams. Give me a definition of a submerged land. How do you differentiate between that and, okay, there's a river? You know, there's obviously submerged land there, so I'm just
wondering if you could. Yes, sir. The Arkansas Supreme Court has said that it's anything underneath the ordinary high water mark. Now, that would include lakes and rivers. So the bottom of the Arkansas River, we would say that the state owns that, and we hold it in trust for the state.
That's why my boss goes out there and talks about this 12-foot channel issue. We own the bottom of it. What we're hoping to do with this is let folks understand that a little more. As Representative Lee noted, this is already law, but we run into issues where folks don't understand that somebody does own that, and it's the state that owns it. And so one reason we think is because how the law is currently written. It just gives us a broad brush to say that any rule or regulation that we promulgate will be equal to law.
Well, we don't think that's the best way to do it. We think that if we make it clear that we can work with folks and we can help you achieve whatever it is you're wanting to do, but just come to us and talk to us, yeah, we own the bottom of the river, but, you know, we'll be reasonable about it. It's like any other state-owned property. We work all the time with different agencies to sell timber or mineral rights, And that's the same kind of thing that we're trying to do here is just help.
You answered one of my questions about what kind of precipitated this, but I guess more of a practical question. If the Corps of Engineers comes and they dredge the Arkansas River, since we, quote, unquote, own that, are we now going to become responsible for paying for those operations? Will we get any benefit from the sale of that sand? No, sir.
What's the practical aspect there? We will not become responsible for the cost. Now, we do already permit sand and gravel. The land commissioner's office does. So if you want to come out and dredge and take that sand or that gravel and sell it,
you have to come to our office and apply for a permit. So that's one of the reasons why we're clarifying this. We have the authority to do all these other things, but it's just really sort of vague in this statute what all we can do with it. And the courts have been clear, and they've said several times, the land commissioner owns this. You've built a fence across this river, and you need to pull it down. And the last question I have is I notice you're
adding language in here that says that any antiquities that are found or abandoned for more than 25 years become the property of the state.
Have you all found some hidden treasure that you're trying to
make sure? No comment. We actually have. We have some very nice cultural artifacts that come up from time to time. One of them on the Mississippi River is a flatboat, which is the only one of its existence known. It was exactly like the one that Abraham Lincoln took down the Mississippi to New Orleans. And it's already in common law, the property of the state.
It is sheets to the state. What we want to do is try to clarify that this is – so folks won't go out there and just start taking things. Gotcha.
All right. Appreciate it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Link,
you're recognized for a question. If property tax has been paid on the land for all these
years, then who owns the land? If the property tax? Well, if it's deeded out from our office, it would be the individual we deeded it to.
But if we vote yes on this, then has it become the property of the
state? Oh, no. No, sir. No, this won't change anything that we've already – we will either already own it or we won't. When you vote, it's not going to change it. Is that – Well, I don't understand what we're doing then. Okay. Well, we're clarifying. We're just trying to clarify. The federal government gave us
the land. I'm talking specifically about Crooked Creek here.
There's been a lot of debate over Crooked Creek. And, of course, land and gravel and who owns that property on the bottom of the creek. Yes, sir. And there's been a lot of debate about that, and this doesn't have anything to do with it. No, sir.
No, I would guess that Crooked Creek isn't navigable. It's claimed,
yeah. I'm telling you, it's a big fight, and I won't be voting yes on this because I have concerns once we start getting into Crooked Creek. Thanks, sir.
Seeing no other questions, Representative Lee, would you like to close for
Speaker 211
1:37:01
your bill? I can't say do pass, but basically, and I understand your concerns, and I understand I've heard from others about the issues up there on the creek. Basically, this is common law that we're putting into code. So I would appreciate a
good vote. Representative Letting, you're recognized for a motion. Do pass. We have a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, aye.
Aye. Any opposed? No. Motion passes. Moving on. House Bill 1580. Representative Talley, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. If
I'd like to call Mr. Preston Scroggins with me as well.
This is a bill we looked at the other day and vetted. What we've done is gone and added just an amendment to add another level of protection to keep the rate from being increased. We've set the cap at $2 and have added that the fund must drop below half a million dollars before the fee can be adjusted
at all. Any questions? Representative Ballinger, you
recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. And, Representative Talley, we have visited about this, and I still have a little bit of a hard time with raising that
because you explained to me what would prohibit this fund from being depleted down below $500,000. I mean, basically the agency has control over that. And so if they pay out the expenses for a variety of different things and it goes below $500,000, then they would just have the ability to increase that cap to $2. Is that correct? Well, we are not increasing the fee. First of all, let me
clarify by saying we are not increasing the fee at all. We discussed this at length the other day.
Right now, it's our understanding, and we've gotten an opinion through Preston Scroggins and his legal team, that the commission has the ability to raise that fee to any amount right now. And so what we're trying to do is, as we broaden the scope of this to do bovine health, we wanted to put a cap to where that fee could not be increased beyond $2. It's at $1. It's been at $1 since 1990, with the commission having the authority to raise it to $25. And they have not done that. They've kept it at $1 and moving forward. But as we broaden the scope of this, we felt it was just good policy to put a cap on that at $2
and give the agency, long down the line, some ability to adjust if they need to. If you have an outbreak of disease, we want to make sure they've got the ability to service that and get their people out there in the field and take care of that disease. And so that's the reason why there is a cap. And, I mean, they do have resources to those funds, ability to get to those funds. Right now there is some proceeds in that, 900. Preston, I'm going to speak more about what the balance is in there. And there's only been a very small dip in those funds over the past few years.
So we don't see that's not a – they're not going to utilize all those resources in one year and be at us next year, you
know, trying to increase that fee. I have a follow-up. Last time we visited about where the authority comes from for that dollar, because on the bill itself it says that they can charge it until July 1st of 1990. And in visiting, at that time we thought that there was another bill that may have needed to be edited to show that that authority was still there.
And I read the opinion, which was four sentences, and if somebody here could explain it a little clearer to me, that would be great. But in what I saw, the explanation didn't jive, I guess would be the best way to put it. And so the way I look at it now is I don't know that the agencies had the authority since 1990 to charge the dollar. And so I hate to increase that to $2 when, you know, I think that we're just running a risk here of not doing the right thing for,
I mean, I think of the folks in my district who have been selling cattle for years being charged a dollar. And I know it goes to good things, but I sure hate to increase basically a tax on them to $2 over, especially when we're talking about the issue that I really have a concern about is, you know, we're charging this increased tax on cattle that are going to go to all these other things, and I just don't know that it really benefits, goes directly back to the cattle people now. I mean, could you explain that? Sure, and again,
I want to clarify, we are not increasing, we are not pushing to increase the fee at all.
The fee is at $1. All we're doing is put a cap on it in this legislation. All we're doing is saying they cannot at any point vote and raise it above $2. We are not increasing the fee to $2 at this point. I just want to make sure we clarify that because, again, in your comments there, in your question language, you're saying that we are trying to increase. I just want to clarify for the committee that we are not increasing the fee. We're simply putting a cap at $2 on that, and you're exactly right. It's very important to have these people where they can be out in the field. So, Preston, you had a great question last time we were before this committee and you got this passed.
That's why we've gotten some opinion on that. Preston, you might want to speak on that as well
as far as opinion. Well, you know, the opinion from my legal counsel and from my years of being here, I do believe the commission and a lot of commissions have the ability represented to, you know, raise fees and everything as they see fit. They have to go through the administrative process to do that, which, you know, allows input from the legislature even during interim. So, you know, that's
my take on it. Would you all mind then explaining where the authority – so the agency has the authority to raise the fee,
but then it has to be approved by the legislature, either in interim or whenever. When did that happen, that the approval for this fee after 1990 was made? So that would be my first question. And then, also, if you can explain to me the idea of this not being an increase to $2, what protections would be put in there to keep it from, I understand that the fee goes below $500,000, so what protections are put in there to keep it from going below $500,000,
or is that just at the discretion of
the agency? Well, the protections, as far as, get those questions right in my mind. First of all, we're not increasing the fee. We're putting a cap at $2. And then what we're trying to do is there's not even the protections to keep them from raising that fee is the fact that, you know, they have to spend down below the $500,000 in that reserve. And, you know, Preston, as we testified last time, is new at this job. We have some new commissioners on this job, and what they want to do is look at this.
We understand, I think we all can agree, the importance of having those men out there in the field and the job they're doing for the state in case we have some kind of an outbreak and the need to broaden this from just brucellosis to bovine health. And as we broaden that, we want to make sure that we've got the ability to look at those and address any kind of concerns that come up. So what they're now doing is going back, and they've asked us to give them the ability to go back, cut some dollars in the way they do business. They have had to dip into the reserve over the five of the past six years.
They've had to dip into that fund. some dollars to keep things going and so they've asked us to you know give them the ability to to cap that for you know we want to cap that where they can't just raise it above something that farmers cannot handle i'm a cow producer myself i have to pay this fee when i sell my my cattle at the barn um so that you know we want to put a cap on there a good common sense policy to where they can't go above two dollars and then give them ability to come in cut some costs within their within their agency and then um and then serve the communities and and that's another thing
I think has got lost in this is a little bit, it's a fee, in my mind, is a separate issue. You've also changed in the name of this program. It's going to allow us to make changes in what we do at the barns and what we do overall, and that will result in some savings. We've found some savings already since I've been there, and we're going to continue. And going forward, I'm going to bring you all some stuff near an interim. I've been working with the Cattlemen's Poultry Federation. We're going to look at some stuff near an interim as well.
I guess one more question, just to clarify, because I don't think it was answered, but I'm not sure if it wasn't the way I asked the question that was a problem. What prevents this from just being a granting the authority to the agency to raise it to $2? I understand that if it dips below $500,000 that there's a kick in, but what prevents this from being just a new revenue source to continue spending funds below $500,000
and then just kick the fee up to $2? Where is the protection there? I mean, why is this not just an increase of the fee? There is
a requirement that they have to go through the Administrative Procedure Act. We have to bring that, you know, take it out to public policy, get public input from that. I mean, the truth of the matter is right now the way the law is written, I mean, they can vote and raise that fee to any amount they want. There's no safety net. So what we're trying to do is add some extra precautions in there to protect producers, protect the beef cattle industry, put that cap in there, put this other trigger where they have to dip those funds down, you know, beyond half a million.
So we're trying to put as many safety mechanisms in there that are not existent right now in current law. Does that
mean? I guess I understand what we're trying to say. Now, we're a little bit of disagreement because I don't know that the authority is there to charge any fee, much less raise it to whatever we want. I just have not, that's not necessarily been explained or demonstrated to me yet. But, you know, I still don't, well, I appreciate the work you're trying to do. I just, you know, I'm still having a hard time not seeing this as a fee increase, but I appreciate it.
Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The first question I have is directed toward Director Scroggins. The fee, and this may be one of the best safeguards against a fee increase. You're a cattleman, from what I understand, so you'd be increasing this fee on yourself if you were to do it. Yes, sir. Okay, I think that's a good safeguard. The next question I have is it's kind of maybe, and this may be helped Representative Ballinger. You've got a bottom limit that says if we go below this, we're going to increase the fee.
Would you be opposed to working out some number, and I don't know what that is, a million, two million, whatever, that you all deem appropriate and says if the fund balance goes above two million, that the fee will automatically decrease? Yes. Would that be something you all would be willing to work out that maybe alleviates some of the concerns here? Yeah. Okay. So that may be something that you all can work
with, Mr. Ballinger. You know, and Representative, I'm going to tell you long term, like I said, I've been on the job about seven weeks and I'm still trying to feel my way through it. and there are changes that need to be made, and we're going to make them,
and we get through with the session where I can catch a breath. We'll work on some of that, and I'll come back to you then or some other stuff. I mean, we're not automatically going to go out here and raise a fee. Right, right. That would be suicidal on my part to begin with.
Right, and I don't have that in front of you. Thank you. I appreciate what you're trying to accomplish here.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Ratliff, you're recognized for
a question. Representative Talley, where's the livestock market folks on this?
Livestock market, guys, we've been working, and that's why we're back with the amendment, trying to get this as close as possible. It's not exactly where they want it. They want it capped at $1. But we feel like we need to give them some lead way to the agency, act of good faith, and that we're not increasing it, but we're capping it. Right now there's not a cap. Yes, sir. So we felt it was kind of a slap in the face to take it down to just, you know, to $1. Right. But we've capped it at $2. Added these other triggers in there as well to make it as hard as possible to increase this fee if they ever do decide to out in the future. Yes, sir.
the support of Farm Bureau and Arkansas Cattlemen's with this.
Okay. Thanks, sir. Representative Linderman, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First thing, how many
cattle are sold in Arkansas each year? I want to know how much this fund is generating. Around
600,000 would be a good figure. 600,000, okay. This kind of reminds me of a biblical application. I think we're swallowing a camel and choking on a gnat here.
We're putting a cap on a fee that has no cap at this
point. Why the name change? The name change will allow us, right now we see some cost savings that we can acquire by changing our techniques of testing at the barn. Our field men, we will no longer have to test at the barn with this if we get this change in the program name. You know, it allows us to look at other diseases as well, you know, tuberculosis, you know, anaplasmosis,
any type of diseases, anthrax, it may come up. We're limited because of that brucellosis title in that legislation. Okay. Two questions.
One of them is, what's the new services, and you hit on a few of those right there, is trick one of them that y'all are going to start testing for at the barn. Yes, sir. The other thing was, and you just stated that you would no longer be required to test at the barn. Are all cattle tested at the barn, even those that are calfhood vaccinated now?
All the cattle that are being tested right now is all the bulls and cows that are coming in, regardless if they're going back to herds for breeding stock or going to slaughter. Most of the cattle that are going to slaughter, well, all the cattle that are going to slaughter are being tested at the slaughter plants. They're pulling the blood samples there. We will continue. We've got a new regulation that came down from the USDA that kicked in, I believe, March 11th, where we're having to do mandatory I.D. now on anything that is going back to a farm,
a bull or a cow that's breeding stock or any dairy animals that will also have to be tagged. So we're kind of evolving into that as well. That's a new program that just came into effect March 11th. Is this premise I.D.? Premise
I.D., yes, sir. Okay. Do you all supply premise I.D. to producers? Do you all have the
tags or do they have the federal government? Yes, sir. We are, like I said, it's very new. We just got into it since March 11th. You know, the rules came out in January, and we've had to work with several sale barns this week already on some hiccups on getting that started.
But, yes, sir. Thank you. Thank you, Mr.
Speaker 24
1:52:21
Chair. Representative Gene, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Director Scroggins, we sell somewhere between 600,000 and 700,000 cattle and sale barns every year, and this dollar program goes for bovine inspections and other inspections, how many hogs do we sell in our
sale barns every year? Well, you know, that number was great in the 90s, and it started going down. I think the last number, Fred, was about under 300, I think.
Under $300,000 last year? Well, no, under $300, I do believe. $300,000, period. Yes, sir. How many goats? Off the top of my head, I'm going to say probably 5,000, 6,000 goats. 5,000, 6,000. That's down from about 10,000, I remember. Horse market is dead. Yes, sir. And I'm just taking
Speaker 24
1:53:15
that your thoughts are in the interim that you're going to try to get more of this livestock that we're selling,
part of this program, to help fund this? Yes, sir. Right now, they're not charged anything, are they? Correct. Yes, sir. I'm going
to look at several things. Like I said, I'm going to sit down with leaders from the industry, and I'm going to come back to you during the interim with some proposals that I think you're going to like. Well, and the reason we're passing this bill today
Speaker 24
1:53:46
is to change the name and to cap the fee. Yes, sir. And this fee will not go up this next year. Is that correct? Yes, sir. I have your word on it.
Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. Representative Dan Douglas, you're recognized for a question? I'll have. All right. No other questions? Representative Jett? Mr. Chairman, I'll make a motion at the proper time,
Nobody has signed up to speak for against the bill. Representative Talley, you closed for your bill? I'm closed for your bill.
Thank you. All right, and Representative Gillum, I think you had a motion. I move. Do pass, Mr. Chairman. Okay. Any discussion? All in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? Aye. Ayes have it. Motion passes. Thank you, committee. Thank you, sir. All right, moving on, House Bill 1703, Representative Barnett, you're recognized to present your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members
of the committee. I don't think this will be near as serious as some discussion you all have had today. I'll just consider this to be a freedom of movement bill for your kids and your grandkids. and this is to allow the Department of Tourism to authorize the use of motorized scooters within the state parks
and to define what a motorized scooter is. Presently, the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department has jurisdiction over the roads inside state parks and presently, there's a lot of kids riding around on scooters. Something could look just like this if you all see a picture down here that I'm displaying, be it a typical scooter that kids are running around the parks. And I know none of you all here have ever done that on city streets or county roads legally or illegally when you were young.
But anyhow, I think that what the highway department would like to do is just give jurisdiction for the purposes of motor scooters to the Department of Tourism and let them handle the restrictions or lack of whatever they want to do to allow these kids to run around in the parks on these type of motorized scooters. I do have with me Richard Davies with Parks and Tourism,
and I do have Scott Bennett, director of the highway department as well.
Speaker 265
1:56:55
Do either of you have any comments? Yes, Mr. Chair. My name is Scott Bennett. I'm the Director of the Arkansas State Highway and Transportation Department. This has been an ongoing issue over the last two or three years with some of the park superintendents because really this vehicle is not excluded from the definition of a motor vehicle,
and because it's not excluded, it is a motor vehicle. And the roads into and around state parks are highways. And because this little scooter is not excluded from the definition of a motor vehicle and because these roads are highways, the people that ride them have to follow all the rules and regulations of driving a motor vehicle on a highway, registration, license, all of those things. And we don't really think that's the intent of some of these, you know, children being able to ride their scooters into and around the parks.
And we think really because the overall jurisdiction of the park is under parks and tourism that we just think they need to have the ability to regulate the use of these types of vehicles within the state parks. Mr. Chairman,
Speaker 266
1:58:14
I'm Richard Davies, Director of Parks and Tourism. Not to be redundant, we requested this because technically under the law, these kids couldn't ride the scooters,
and we had a lot of grandparents getting upset with us. And Sid, we went to Scott and said, can we fix this somehow? They got the lawyers involved, and
here we are. Representative Meeks, you're recognized
for a question. A question and a motion. Just a clarification, there's no conflicts of federal rules on this because it's a, how, okay, I have a motion. No, sir, it
right, and if everyone's got a motion at the proper time, then.
Vice Chairman Steele, you're recognized for a question. Mr. Bennett,
are there any signs on these highways, and can they drive in any lane, these scooters? Are we going to designate them over to the right lane? Not if they're
Speaker 265
1:59:11
passing. Okay. Not unless they're passing. They can only pass on the left. I see they're
defined as only having a top speed of 20 miles per hour, and that's like a lot of the vehicles I see in the left lane. I
Speaker 265
1:59:25
Thank you. You're exactly right. We can put up signs to make them drive in the left lane only when they're passing.
Any other questions? Representative Meeks you're recognized for a motion any discussion all in favor say aye any opposed motion passes thank you Mr. Chair members of the committee same here thank you I think we're getting down to the area where I don't know does anybody else have a bill that they want to run today If not, a couple of announcements, and I think Vice Chairman Steele covered some of these things.
We're going to have a joint meeting of House and Senate Agriculture Monday at 2.30, and it will be in one of the Big Mac conference rooms. This will be on the Big River Steele project, so Monday at 2.30. Our next meeting will be this Friday, and then we will have a special order on Representative Letting's bill, House Bill 2001. That will be set for special order a week from today on Wednesday.
Without objection, we will be adjourned. Thank you.
Agenda
HB1832
HB2088
HB1145
HB1653
HB1580
HB1703
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Nate Steel Chair
Unverified
Representative Darrin Williams
Unverified
Speaker 15
Speaker 24
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Speaker 44
Speaker 55
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair
Unverified
Speaker 72
Representative Walls McCrary
Unverified
Speaker 87
Speaker 111
Representative Kelley Linck
Unverified
Representative Homer Lenderman
Unverified
Representative Jeremy Gillam
Unverified
Speaker 156
Representative Jon S. Eubanks
Unverified
Speaker 151
Representative Jim Nickels
Unverified
Michael Lindsey
Unverified
Speaker 205
Speaker 211
Corey Cox
Unverified
Representative Brent Talley
Unverified
Speaker 247
Scott Bennett
Unverified
Representative Jonathan Barnett
Unverified
Speaker 265
Speaker 266
Speaker 66