House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (13)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB821
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “you identify yourself for the record you're here for Senate bill 821 and I have”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1551
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1551”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1552
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1552”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1787
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…I bring for your consideration today a Senate amendment on House Bill 1787. This bill was passed out of committee and off the floor of…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1805
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1805”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1809
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1809”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1875
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Senate amendment for HB 1875 until mr. Wilkins didn't quite tell me which one it was yes…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2100
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2100”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2186
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2186”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1787
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1787”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1875
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1875”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB719
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB719”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB992
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB992”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
Speaker 1
0:00
71787. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. I bring for your consideration today a Senate amendment on House Bill 1787. This bill was passed out of committee and off the floor of the House permitting the Arkansas Game and Fish to enter the interstate wildlife compact. It was passed off the House floor with the promise that I would have it amended on the Senate end and today I'm bringing you that amendment for concurrence. we can get this thing on the House floor and on the governor's desk committee any
questions we have a movement for the option of the move for the adoption of the amendment all in favor say
Speaker 4
0:48
aye opposed Thank You mr. Gauzee you pass your amendment Thank You mr. chair Thank You members
the committee we have anyone else here to present a bill this morning any of the members
represent the bail while you're looking I'm gonna run a Senate concurrent amendment for representative flanker real quick
Speaker 20
2:51
down to the Senate and actually do something. They took up my time. Where are we? Who's presenting? Go ahead. Representative Richey. Thank you,
Speaker 27
3:04
Madam Chair. I think I'm here to run a concurrence on amendment.
Senate amendment for HB 1875 until mr. Wilkins didn't quite tell me which one it was yes 1875
turn all in favor sure I pose congratulations Richard you pass your
Speaker 42
4:11
you identify yourself for the record you're here for Senate bill 821 and I have
an amendment I am John Vines state representative
amendment okay thank you madam chair and committee appreciate the opportunity to be back with you I was sincere we've amended this bill since we're with you last time and points you through a couple of the amendments and I may need to come get a paper copy because I'm not sure this one's showing down here yeah I can get can I borrow thank you
what this what this does is in the amendment that you we just handed out uploaded we changed the registration and training process we amended that rather than having the individual canvassers register with the Secretary of State or travel a little rock the responsibility of collecting that information about the canvassers and training canvassers has now been placed on the sponsor of initiative before paid canvasser can collect signatures a sponsor must of the
initiative must have the paid canvasser execute an affidavit that he she has not been convicted or of a crime or entered into no contest plea B provided the canvasser with the Secretary of State's initiative and referendum handbook and explain the process and loss of the canvasser and C file a list with the pay with the paid canvassers names and current residents with the secretary of state the provision that prohibited payment of canvassers based on the
number of signatures collected has been removed this bill offers continued reform it'll make the fight it'll provide the following statutory guidance to the secretary of states and county clerks require the secretary of state county clerks to report suspected forgeries to the proper authorities for investigation it will hold sponsors accountable for collection process of their canvassers from the beginning of the process and will discourage forgeries and other fraudulent activities as it will reduce the waste of public resources used to verify fraudulent petitions and restore the public's face
in this process and that's in essence what the amendment does we've tried to work with with a bulk of the concerns that we're out there to make this a better bill and we feel better being in front
of you today with the with the current package it appears those there's some
significant changes representative Overby you had a question put no question just since we went over this bill the other day and mr. Vines has gone over everything and mr. Bell I
think did what mr. Bell wanted him to do I think in essence
of time at the proper time you're such a southern lady that was so polite
by understand this bill it just puts a it's just puts a burden of responsibility on those who are gathering signatures yes particularly the pay campers I was lost involved not you know in a statewide campaign
petition driving it's very difficult but but there's nothing wrong with having that responsibility to to lessen the burden over on the Secretary of State of verifying each name is certain no and I think if you go back to
the original bill there were some some statements in the original bill that talked about that they're darn going to be codified that talked about the problems we've had in recent years with the collection of signatures and the amount of time and effort that's been kind of transpired taking care of the short mass shortfalls
in the collection of those signatures that it's resulting in an immense amount of work for the state secretary of state and also ultimately state resources
representative overbead let's go ahead and take your motion of adopting the amendment how about we start with that motion all those in favor I hollow suppose okay but we can get into the bill now whoops you have two people that can't are you having a hard time getting the amendment up is that okay let's we're
gonna get you a hard copy here representative Walker you have a question several thank you
Representative Lee I understand that we want to try to agree on things toward the end but don't you think this is a bad bill first of all are you you're requiring people in the political process before they undertake to collect signatures not only to identify themselves but to get information from
the Secretary of State's office that is not readily available and which must be obtained in a burdensome way such as the booklet and everything that they are required to provide why is it that we want to burden the process of petitioning I don't know
that we're burdening the process of petitioning is so much as we're protecting it because before you know what we're doing is we're with these referendums initiatives is putting stuff in state law and in our Constitution and we should not take that haphazardly no I don't think this is a
bad bill or I would do well I wouldn't have let my name to it
I understand that thank you I'm not suggesting that
I apologize no no no no I was always enjoy your perspective and you bring a unique perspective to all committees and about joy I enjoy your questioning but but this is a what when we when we initiate no pun intended these initiatives and referendums we need to take all due care and responsibility because we are not just affecting the next election
cycle or the next legislative session these will be on the books for 10 20 15 hundred years to come and we should take every precaution to make sure that that process is adhered to is transparent is he's conducted properly and you know with the with the I don't want to allege I don't want to name called and alleged fraud or misconduct but in recent years it's become to the point where you get a few not a few but several
pieces of paper lots of paper reams of paper you go around you get names whether they're good bad indifferent and you throw them at the state government Secretary of State's office in particular and say here you figure it out we went and got these signatures and we see names copied directly out of phone books we see alphabetize where we just start filling in names we start seeing signatures all with the same in the same handwriting so I don't think it's too much to ask that this process be streamlined and protected when it's
going to affect so many for so many years
concern the First Amendment protects the right to petition the government for redress of grievances canvassing is a petition right I mean people solicited to not necessarily vote on the matter but in a particular way but they have they're being solicited to be able to have it submitted to the electorate for consideration so it's not the same as
participating in the direct election but the other thing is that when you when you put when you say that people have to meet all these conditions that seem to be here are you are you're imposing financial obligations upon them in order to participate in the petitioning process and as I understand the First Amendment you cannot burden the First Amendment with a financial obligation I mean tell me if I'm wrong though you can't in order to have speech you got to pay to
that make that there's no financial obligation on the canvass or what we're dealing with here are these paid canvassers if if you mr. Walker representative Walker decide to start a petition you're gonna go around collecting you're not paying you're not doing you know doing anything out of the ordinary you'll have no problem with your First Amendment rights are not being affected at all and even the paid canvassers aren't because they're not facing
any financial burden Well, now, I understand what you're trying to do, and you're really trying to purify
the process, but I don't know if you can purify the assertion of speech. I mean, how do you do that? I mean, basically, people have a right to petition their government one way or another for the redress of grievances, and it can't be encumbered. And in that respect, I understand you don't let felons participate in the process. They are still citizens. I don't see how you can limit their right of free speech either in participating in the petitioning process. I don't see how you can say, well, felons cannot assert their speech,
and they cannot participate in encouraging other people to sign a petition. Well, let's talk about the felons and how I
this subject, but in a lot of instances they don't have that right to vote, do they? well the right to vote is different
so how are we offending their free speech if they can't vote already well here's the point they don't lose our right to free speech simply because they're felons they don't lose their right to equal protection of the laws or their right to bear guns I mean I guess they
do it because that's been specifically taken away
but we're getting a we're getting away away from this
bill on this one well I understand but I don't think that the intent I don't think the well I have such respect for you and the sponsor as do I I'm in and I'm reluctant to mention these things but I think it's more burdensome than beneficial
representative Vines if I wanted to start a petition drive today as an individual I can do that and not have to I'm not worried about this right if I'm paid canvassure how much how hard how available is a list of registered voters to
to check last I'm always my my witness to address that
yourself for the record and go ahead and pull
that mic a little closer. Thank
Speaker 102
15:56
you. I'm Elizabeth Murray from the Friday Firm. Representative Wilkins, I can tell you that you can buy a CD disk from the Secretary of State, and I believe in the last election cycle last summer, it cost $6.50 for anyone can get that, and it's updated periodically, and you'd have to spend another $6.50 to get an updated one throughout the cycle and they are readily available if I can follow up
madam chair this is it's just by precinct by county or how are they they're not just listed in alphabetical order I hope I believe you
representative bill thank you madam chair representing vines following the
amendment on this bill essentially what we have now is a bill that deals with the employment contract between someone hiring canvassers in the canvasser in the terms of that contract rather than the individual right to petition would you not
agree that that is the scope of the bill incessance yes
thank you representative Nichols thank you madam chairman your amendment requires the
identification of the paid canvassers by name and mr. mr. Walker may be able to tell me the actual name of the case but I know there have been laws passed that memberships of various organizations were required or had to be disclosed and And since the petition route is an Arkansas constitutionally protected route, that gives
me a little bit of a pause, even though that whoever solicits signatures has to sign on the form that they got those signatures and they're valid and all that, but just a list to all the people who were paid and in those petitions may not have been submitted that may be chilling their First Amendment rights also but I have
Speaker 102
18:55
have any response to that representative Nichols if I could speak to that the requirement that the sponsor file a list of paid canvassers with their names and their current addresses is is tied to if problems arising with the canvassers the secretary of state and county clerks as you know under this bill are required to prevent to report to authorities instances of fraud and forgery
immediately as I believe one of the witnesses last time pointed out many of these people are transient and will not have permanent addresses in Arkansas this way the secretary of state and or any authority of a problem does arise we'll be able to locate those people immediately here their permanent address will be kept by the sponsor in their business records that the current address while they are in Arkansas will be available to the secretary of state
and that is so that if problems do arise they can be located and as you pointed out on the petitions they turn in their name and address appear on those but that is after the fact that's in July when petitions are delivered to the Secretary of State that is not between now and July of 2014 if problems arise with the collection of signatures that's why that requirement is in
there so the the paid canvassers have to be identified before the petitions are
Speaker 102
20:25
submitted yes before they are circulated a paid canvasser their name and current address needs to be with the Secretary of State before they solicit signatures and the sponsor is responsible for that not the canvasser doesn't have to make a trip to Little Rock or anything the sponsor will file that list and update as necessary and the Secretary of State will not be issuing any type of photo ID or anything like that it will just be an informational list if a problem arises
so if the Family Council or the NAACP is using their members and and pay on them a modest sum to for their signatures they would have to turn over that information how much how much time or as soon as they start or when is the deadline for that they would have
Speaker 102
21:17
to turn over the names and current addresses of those who are being paid and only those who are being paid before those canvassers begin circulating a petition
okay thank you very similar to a lobbyist almost all we're wanting is an identify them representative Hickerson representative Walker we have let's see three people from the audience to speak for against this
now being paid is also significant because being paid implies that it's for fee it does not take into account that it may be for mileage or
for other things like that and so being paid is makes it ambiguous and incapable of being attacked but the two cases that mr. Nichols referred to our NAACP the button and Shelton versus state and I remind you that in in 1958 59 this same situation rose where the state of Arkansas wouldn't governor FAUBUS WAS THE GOVERNOR, WANTED TO IDENTIFY THE PEOPLE WHO WERE MEMBERS OF THE NAACP WHO
WERE PETITIONING FOR VARIOUS ACTS UNDER THE LAW. AND MR. SHELTON WAS FIRED AS A SCHOOLTEACHER IN THE SUPREME COURT OF ORGANIZATION SAID YOU CANNOT PUNISH THE PERSON FOR MAKING THESE KINDS OF ASSERTIONS OR FOR REFUSING TO DISCLOSE THE IDENTITY OF THOSE IN ASSOCIATION WITH YOU. It's freedom of association, not only freedom of speech, freedom of association, those in association of youth who are banding together in order to try to protect and project a common
interest. How do you address that? I mean, that's well-established law. It's law of this particular site, this particular forum 60 years ago involving Governor Faulkner. do you deal with that go back to the
paid canvassers if you're out if John John Walker individual and forgive me for not using
your title wants to go out and change whatever an issue whatever initiative referendum you know whatever issue is this has little or no effect on you but but I was moved to bring help bring this legislation with something that happened to me last election cycle I was at a meeting and lady that I considered somewhat friendly came up to me with a clipboard and had one of the many whatever they were the initiatives or this was before the light this was
back I guess probably may have been in the spring summer last year I may be time to stay in the time and asked me to sign something one of the one of the initiatives they
kind of politely declined she literally takes it rolls the paper back and goes well okay what about this one well no I'm not interested and finally comes to a third one it goes hey what about this one and so we finally keep going keep going and finally I get out of her that she's getting paid X number of dollars
per signature now she had little or no interest I mean I say that she may have they may have all been near and dear to her heart but she wasn't motivated by changing the world changing the state changing law changing government she was motivated by the financial gain that she was going to have about turning in ten a hundred a thousand signatures and that's what this is intended to do the Shelton case you're dealing with I don't have with me I know it briefly I can't quote it you know you have a long distinguished history and are more
well-versed in that area but I don't think that that case would be on point here because again we're dealing with paid cancer I don't think anybody's concerned with who they are just the just the matter that one they're doing the process they're handling it the right way and doing the right thing because what we've got out there right now is you go out and you get get your initiative you you you get everything lined up and then you go pay out of state in-state someone to come gather these signatures just like that was approached with me and we're going you know they want my signature so they can
make financial gain off of it and I just don't think if we're worried about the the the purity of our state law and our Constitution that's that's the way these processes should be conducted and that's the rationale for this bill it's not to out some secret group it's not to put the spotlight on on some activity it's to purify and keep keep the sanctimity of the process and I think we've gotten
away from that in recent years with some of our processes and this is just trying to keep the keep the keep it as it was and should be because again we're not dealing with willy-nilly subjects like whether we go to this restaurant or that I mean these are laws that are going to affect you and I our children our grandchildren for the rest of our days on this planet and I think we can whatever we can do steps we can take to again I keep using the word pure to keep the process pure and clean I don't think we can take too many steps
representative Hickerson thank you madam chair is it is it a proper motion to move to limit debate
those opposed that was loud because it was right in my ear but I've got a rule for the eyes there representative Wilkins okay then here's let me lay it out then we have
three people signed up Elizabeth Murray you're at the end of the table already and and so I'm assuming you've already spoken for it okay then we're going to the people need to recognize and this will give okay will we can let there's There's only three people signed up then against, and that will give Representative Vines a five-minute closing, if that works out. Or, Representative Bell, did you have a question that you want?
Okay, before we start the clock then, go. Yeah, that's proper. Yeah, because we haven't started the clock until we go four against. We're still asking questions of the Representative at the end
of the table. Representative Vines, it appears that the purpose of this bill is to limit the influence of money on the initiative and referendum process and to actually improve the standing of the individual citizen on that. As I look at it, I don't see anything in this following the amendment that in any way restricts
a citizen. This is, as I understand it, purely aimed at those folks who want to purchase signatures is that your intent here I'm sorry excuse me that
isn't indeed the essence is I try to to explain or express during during our discussion it just it's somewhat sickens you to see the process one and whenever your signature becomes a commodity out there and it's in recent cycles that's that's what it's become
it's become a money game so to speak and in this process we all we all know we We've all chosen to be in this room. We've all taken the necessary steps to be in this room, this capital, in this role of government. But when you're dealing with these initiatives and referendums, it should not be about the money gaming result, I don't think. And that's why I brought this
bill. All of us, I think, have taken a stand against the buying and selling of votes in various forms. And this certainly would appear to me to get very close to that, this process of buying signatures. Would you agree? I agree.
Okay, thank you. Here we go. So there is a Mr., I think it says Couch. Okay. I recognize you. Come to the end of the table and identify yourself, and we'll start the clock. Remember, you have five minutes, and there are two other people to speak. I'll be real brief since I – Oh, you have signed up against the bill. Is that correct? Correct. Okay, hit it. David
Speaker 147
30:01
Couch. I appreciate the changes that have been made.
I wish I'd have seen them before right this minute. First of all, I think that the distinction between paid and unpaid is unnecessary because paid or whether or not you're passionate about a subject, either of those things could cause someone to misrepresent something or to obtain signatures fraudulently. One of the biggest concerns that I have that's constitutionally about this particular thing is that Amendment 7 requires that only the signature be on the petition.
One of the provisions of this amendment says that not only does the signature have to be on the petition, but all of the data signing, your name, your address, and it has to be in the handwriting of the person who actually signed the petition. As the current law stands, that has to be on there, but it's by statute, but it's merely an aid to the verification
Speaker 147
31:00
the problem that I have with that is that it shouldn't be on there and if
you've been through the petitioning process that's a big impediment on getting signatures on the ballot I think it's unconstitutional and it causes concerns with the canvassers as well because it allows a canvasser to fill that in if the person signing it is disabled but there's no definition of disabled so the canvasser is going to have to make a determination on the spot of whether or not an individual is disabled and if he makes the wrong
determination it's a crime under this provision so I have a real problem with that one particular session section about requiring the information on there as part of the statute and making it a crime y'all heard me before I will pass to someone else let them have some time
Speaker 152
32:08
and there's three minutes go ahead and introduce yourself for the record I'm I'm Melissa Fultz, and thank y'all for letting me come today. I'll be really, really quick. One of the biggest problems that I see is saying there's a difference between volunteers and paid canvassers. I ran the medical marijuana campaign, the petition drive, and I don't know if any of y'all have had to run a petition drive or not,
but there is a whole lot to do with it. And I know that most of the forgeries and most of the illegal things were done by one particular woman. And the law that's on the books now works. The problem is we begged for her to be prosecuted, and the people that did the forgeries to be prosecuted, nothing was done. If they had been prosecuted, the system would work. We turned in our first turn-in, and we had a 56% validity rate.
Most of that was done by volunteers. When we had the paid canvassers, the actual professional paid canvassers, our validity rate shot straight up. As a matter of fact, they stopped counting our petitions and still had several counties, including Pulaski County, to even count. So to say that the paid petitioners are the problem is not the problem. And I think having a difference between the paid and the volunteers is a definite problem.
The volunteers need more training than the paid canvassers. The paid canvassers are doing it everywhere, and they know what they're doing. They know how to get a proper signature. They know how to talk to people. They know how to ask the questions. And the woman a moment ago said that you can get a disc. You can't take that disc out in the field with you. So when somebody says that they're a registered voter, you can't check it.
You cannot check it out in the field. So you have to just depend on what they say is true. And also another one of the problems. There's one minute left. It was not so much that they weren't registered voters. They were just in the wrong county. But the original bill
Speaker 154
34:45
seconds first madam chair thank you this is the first power I'm
right the Constitution amendment 7 the first power reserved for the people is the initiative which makes me very upset they only have 43 seconds so I would actually respectfully request a little more time it also says an amendment 7 that in the legislature shall not no law shall be passed in any manner interfering with the freedom of the people in procuring petitions. Then it says it's self-executing, and all its provisions shall be treated as mandatory. No legislation shall be enacted to restrict, hamper, or impair the exercise of the rights herein reserved to the people.
And let me point out clearly, Madam Chair, the words sponsor and canvasser do not appear in Amendment 7 anywhere. This is something that's been added to restrict, hamper, or impair the rights of the people that they have reserved under Amendment 7. So I respectfully request the committee to vote down this terrible piece of
legislation. Thank you, Mr. Johnson. There's no one else signed up to speak, and we're out of time.
So Representative Vines, you're recognized to close for your bill, and you can't go over five minutes. In
the interest of time, we've kicked this around, and we need to call to a close. A couple of things to address on those comments just briefly. The signature, and I believe if I can get Ms. Murray to come back, I believe that there are some provisions.
again I having a little trouble pulling up the the original bill but I believe there are provisions that we have in there for the disabled signature and helping those those folks out I think there's some provisions in there again I don't have the billing from me and I'm going to
Speaker 102
36:52
addressed there is a process and the definition is not disabled is not there but if someone is unable to complete their birth date and address and the date they are signing in their own hand yes the canvasser can do so
and note in the edge of the petition that the person was disabled and they assisted but most voters if they're wanting to change the law of the state they have the time to fill out their own name print the name their birth date their address and the date they're signing it that's what when a canvasser does it all that's known as transcription and it's illegal in many states with the initiative process because it gives rise to fraud you can have one that one person sign the signatures and another fill out all of
the addresses and we found a lot of that in 2012 in a lot of the initiatives that
were submitted represent Nichols yes what are the criminal sanctions involved in this
Speaker 102
37:57
bill all of the if a cancer signs a false affidavit actually this will lessen it to a misdemeanor it currently on the books is a felony and it has been of course criminal convictions come after the process if they don't discourage
people at the beginning to do it right also forgeries are a sponsor who knowingly all of these criminal offenses are couched in terms of knowingly turning in or knowingly signing the affidavit that it is false it's not aimed at people who accidentally don't know his signature is genuine what's the penalty what level of felony are we talking about there is no felony it's a class a misdemeanor okay thank you representative vines two minutes and
counting with that we will be close to the bill I'm sure I appreciate the discussion and
everything that well I'm sorry representative Hutchison I didn't see your hand down there I'm sorry thank you madam chair I'll raise
a little higher next time okay I was leaning towards this representative vines because the way I was saying it was is that basically it just put somebody in charge I'm a rat I mean just implying simple English just put somebody in
charge to hand the signatures over to rat but
if you're dealing with paid canvassers and that's that's it what the essence of this is dealing with is this paid canvassers
okay mr. Murray then but you said something about like it's illegal for somebody to what did you say on
Speaker 102
39:44
any of the petitions if the process is there's a line for the signature next to that the voter is to print their name then the voter is to
put their date of birth their current address or where they are registered to vote and the date they sign that petition and they are to do that
all in their own hand okay but ma'am we all know now that like I'm sure probably on absentee votes and things and like nursing home people you think they do it all like that honestly speaking this is absolutely nothing to do with absentee voting well I mean when she said signing the names though and all that you know I
mean you reckon everybody we're gonna stick we're gonna stick to this This initiative referendum process, we don't want to, no disrespect,
but we don't want to, without a doubt, but this has nothing to do with the absentee process. Okay, I'm refereeing this. Thank
you, thank you. Okay, you got it. We're calling time. Representative Overby, I'm going to take your motion. Do pass. As amended. As amended. The motion is do pass as amended. All those in favor, aye.
Aye. All those opposed. Aye. The ayes have it. two hands for
Speaker 338
41:20
roll call roll call representative Baird represent Baird representative Hobbs representative Hopper, Representative Hopper, Representative Clemmer, Representative Clemmer, Representative
Nichols, Representative Kerr, Representative Kerr, Representative Altus, Representative Catlett, Representative Westerman, Representative Westerman, Representative Hickerson, Representative Overby, Rep. Walker, Rep. Bell, Rep. Bell, Rep. Ritchie, Rep. Dotson, Rep. Miller, Rep.
Miller representative Hutchinson representative Wagner representative Wilkins with nine votes it failed to pass thank you
madam chair appreciate the opportunity to present it
represent a bill you're recognized madam chair should be an engrossed amendment on House bill 2186 that previously passed out of this committee and we referred it back this this is a bill that originally was designed to be a companion to Senate bill 587 that failed on the House floor one of the provisions what we've done is we've
amended out the provisions that were germane to assisting 587 there was also technical correction language in the bill currently some of our school districts around the state are actually operating outside the bounds of the law with regard to the locations of the early voting locations some of the early voting locations are not in the school districts and the current law requires that this simply will allow the current practice of locations of early voting to to continue and with that I'll take any questions or be glad to make a motion to
do this thing along see no questions I'm assuming you move do pass of do pass as amended it was engrossed so it doesn't need to be as amended move do pass madam chair duly corrected motion is do pass all those in favor aye all those opposed bill passes thank you thank you committee senator Burnett nine nine two
Senate bill nine nine two thank
engrossed? No. The amendment should be out there, committee members. You're recognized.
Speaker 194
44:47
All right. Thank you, Madam Chair. This is a pretty simple good government bill, as I'm sure you've heard before.
This bill would prohibit a person appointed to a constitutional committee, a constitutional body from seeking other public office while their term of office exists. To be similar to a senator or representative, you can't run for another office during your term of office. My amendment makes this bill really simple. makes it proactive and not retroactive so it does not apply to any current
board member or commissioner now serving the effective date of this bill would be January 1 of 2014 any person after that date appointed to a board or commission would be required to serve out their term of office before seeking other constitutional office and the the boards and the commissions that are identified in the bill it would apply only to game and fish highway and lottery so those
three boards if you're appointed to those boards you would have to accept the fact that that you could not seek other constitutional office governor lieutenant governor land commissioner secretary of state or but member of the legislature that's all it does it's pretty simple be happy to take any questions
and we'll have some I'm sure you and I'm glad you're happy to take him representative Kerr
thank you madam chair got one that works senator with this bill prevent someone serving currently in office for say running for US
Speaker 194
46:52
Congress would not would not affect the only only state offices no and it would not affect any current board member or commissioner now serving okay it'd be only those appointed after January 1 of 2014 but after that say a
state senator could not retain their seat and run for
Speaker 194
47:11
US Congress no it would doesn't apply to state senators okay all right and it wouldn't apply to US either any federal office it wouldn't apply to those whatsoever all right thank you representative
Wilkins one of my favorite people sitting down there and I've known him since I was just a pup but I do that I was too but it's really history of this I've been associated with the Arkansas
Game Fish Commission been a commission watcher all my life I never recall this occurring at all, but it may have, I mean, in the Highway Commission or something, but do we have
Speaker 194
48:00
a history at all that you know of? No, but back in the Clinton era, there was similar legislation passed that affected other positions in state government. No, I just felt like it was a good ethical measure to prevent someone that assumes one
of those high-level commissions that are constitutional commissions from using that position as a stepping stone to a higher office. In addition to that, there's really nothing wrong with using that as credentials to run for another office. The problem with it is when someone is appointed to a commission of that nature, that their decisions might be affected by their intent to run for further public office
and that's what I'm trying to avoid the decision should be based upon what's good for the citizens and of this state and not for their personal gain now you need to understand I don't find anything wrong at all if they serve out their term properly is using that to show their ability to handle office as a a basis for running for other office but during the time that they're on that Commission they shouldn't use that as a stepping stone
representative Walker thank you madam chair what do we do in the legislature don't we use election to the house as a stepping stone to seeking the Senate seat no there's nothing
Speaker 194
49:41
wrong with that whatsoever I just said if you complete your term of office in the house and want to seek further office and that's appropriate well you don't you don't
have to complete your term before well
yes you do not before you seek office before you assume office you do but not before you seek it so some of us will be as legislators soon will be seeking to run for Senate and will still be representatives now that's a step that's a stepping stone argument I don't know how we can secure that for ourselves and deny it to others who happen simply to be performing as appointees of the state how do you explain the difference one is an appointee and one is elected well I
Speaker 194
50:28
understand your question representative Walker the most of those commissions are long term seven to ten years and there's a difference in a two-year term is representative and then running for a higher office so your your term would expire before you could take office senators on the other hand with a four year term are prohibited from seeking other constitutional office during their term of office it's the same thing the only difference is is an elected
representative your term is so short that you it probably wouldn't you know it and again I'm not I'm not saying that you shouldn't use your honestly earned credentials as a stepping stone to further office it's just when you have a long term that you might be positioning yourself to run for other office in the decisions you make I guess you could analyze that to say a representative could do that perhaps they do. Well, isn't that basically
what people do when they go into government? They
position themselves for further government service, and that's really regarded as a positive rather than a negative. Well, some may. I don't. Well, is the real, I understand that there is at least one person who's rumored to be a candidate for
Speaker 194
51:51
governor. Doesn't apply to anyone currently holding a commission well why wouldn't I mean because of because it has a initial date of January 1 of 2014 so anyone currently in a border Commission that
this bill applies to would not be affected so that
so there is such a person that person has the advantage once and for all and nobody else will ever have it I didn't quite follow that if you have a person now so positioned and that person anticipates running, say, for governor, that person gets a free ride, and nobody else will ever be able to take advantage of the same
Speaker 194
52:32
opportunity. Well, yes, I suppose you're absolutely correct. That's what my bill is trying to address in the future.
basically unpaid positions. They're paid expenses in them. So are we not discouraging qualified people, people that we may want in them positions from seeking them if they know they are prohibited? And I've never known of it happening, but if they're prohibited for running from office from the time they enter that position to the time their term expires,
I see that maybe as a negative as far as getting good people, the people that we want to serve in
Speaker 194
53:24
that position. I understand your question, and that's probably a valid question. On the other hand, these positions are sought after. They're political plums, if you will. They're patronage jobs that people seek and want. And I think if you eliminate the ones that are purely political in their motivation, you're going to get people that want to serve the people of the state in that capacity.
And that's – but I do understand your question. Representative
Catlett. Yes, thank you, Madam Chair. Senator, these positions, these commissioners that you've named on these, the highway lottery game and fish and highway yeah it was three right lottery highway gaming fishes at all
Speaker 194
54:16
yes that's correct there there are two others one would be the apportionment committee of course that obviously you couldn't it
wouldn't apply to that couldn't yeah well there's a federal law that was passed in the 30s and the name of it is left to me but basically states that any anytime you receive or you're over any federal monies any grants any federal monies that you're not you can't run in a partisan election period now I mean there's a federal law out there not in the Hatch Act that's it that's thank you do you do you not feel that this this covers these put this covers that I
okay and you know we we we we have our we try to recruit the best and the brightest in the political process I feel like and do you do not think this will hinder some of the best and brightest that we
Speaker 194
55:17
have from running for office well I hope not I think maybe it might encourage some that aren't politically motivated that want to do the job for the benefit of the people that are not planning on
seeking other office to to aspire to those commissions those jobs are sought after and people beg for them and this they would they would be on notice that after January 1 that that they would not be able to seek office during their term of office I think it make him more dedicated to complete the job I'm not it It does not apply to anybody currently on the board.
Okay. Thank you, Jay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Pickerson. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator, this, you know, what, is this after, like, they would have to resign before they announced, before they filed? I mean, you know, you could, could they keep their position and just let it be out there that they're going to run for an office and you see what I'm saying? Or was it, when is it triggered that they would need to resign this appointed position?
Speaker 194
56:36
Well, they can't run for other constitutional office during their term of office. I would suppose that if one wanted to do that and you were in your last year or last period of time you could let it be known that you wanted to run but you couldn't officially file until your term expired or announce or well you know there's a lot of ways to announce okay thank you represent Dotson thank you
madam chair been flipping back and forth between this amendment and
this bill looks like you've made several changes to it help me understand just as an example if let's say for instance a highway commissioner has a ten-year term or ten-year appointment in your appointment yes so they're two years into their ten-year appointment and they make the decision that they want to run for some other office state representative whatever it happens to be they would be
prohibited from actually running filing until after the ten years so they couldn't do that for eight more years in this is correct that's
okay okay now if they resign that position and resign and run either that's in the bill okay so so we're effectively once you've accepted this disappointment you're locked in you can't change there's no way you can do anything else for the full term regardless if you've resigned or you haven't resigned until that term is completed the way the bill is written
Speaker 194
58:16
that's correct okay thank you that might be a something that could be addressed but that's the way it's written at our
time and if I'm understanding it correctly follow up on that they could not actually hold they obviously couldn't take office but they couldn't even announce for or start to run for the office until after the expiration of their
Speaker 194
58:46
term I think but you know announcing the office letting the
newspaper know at the end of my term I plan to seek that the office of governor I think they could do that yeah you you couldn't hold office during your term of off on the board but you could you could announce and you hold
office now I mean you can't hold an office you'd have to resign the position to actually take office but running and taking office are two separate things right right okay thank you I appreciate it
represent Nichols senator I ran your amendment for you the day but there have been some questions raised and kind of I'm still going to support you but I don't think it's going to get out of this committee without some
Speaker 225
59:43
you ain't even got a quorum I will know there's a quorum here there's 12 there's 12 I will table just looks big and I need 11 votes I don't think I'm going to get it I'll
withdraw it okay thank
you thank you all right I appreciate a man who can count senator King are you still in the room senator King five four three we're We're moving this baby along. Two, one. Representative Ward, you're up.
Speaker 259
1:00:31
Thank you, Madam Chair. My bill is very simple. It's a very common sense piece of legislation. This is House Bill 1805.
1805, okay. Give the members a second to bring it up. this looks a little similar to the one anyway go you're
Speaker 259
1:00:58
recognized sent your bill thank you madam chair members this particular bill just simply prevent a
person to appear on the same ballot for two separate positions at any given time what is going on in a lot of the areas in which that it happened in Jefferson County this past general election is that a person had filed early and he went unopposed and also dutely he was already elected to that position that he currently was holding and just as the filing period ended he did went and filed
for another position the problem that that creates is that the Attorney General opinion at this particular time is that it is legal for a person to actually file for two positions and appear on the ballot at the same time but what happens is that it creates a financial burden for the municipalities that have to hold a special election in the event that this particular person is elected to the position that he is not currently
holding but he held file for a different position the person that I have reference to the county was very fortunate not to have elected him but it would have called a financial burden on the county if this would occur this particular legislation here just simply will keep an individual from actually filing for two position two of more position and appearing on the ballot two or more time in any one election and it just it's just that simple it's just
simple piece of legislation that we really know that and we want people to you know seek public office and we want them to you know participate in the process but actually we want them also to make up their mind on which office he or she wants to hold before they actually go file nine times out of ten there are but whenever you have a person that filed for two or more of the position at any given time there are no filing fee so normally it doesn't cost
them anything to actually to file because they are more or less collecting petition and signatures to do so but it caused a really financial burden on the areas that actually have to hold a special election in the event that this person is elected to a position that he is not currently holding as an incumbent And that's all this bill does. This is one of those
bills where you go, what? We've been able to do that? That's interesting. Representative Kerr?
Thank you, Madam Chair. I kind of feel like I've been missing out, you know. I hadn't thought about doing that. I have a motion to do pass, Madam Chair.
Seeing no other questions from committee members, I'll accept that motion. The motion is do pass. All those in favor, aye. All those opposed, congratulations. Representative Ward, you finally made it to the committee and passed your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, committee. Okay. Senator King, are you in the room now? All right. You're recognized.
Senate Bill 719, is that the first one you're running? Okay. Senate Bill 719, there's an amendment that should be showing up. You're not in the House any longer, Senator. You're running Senate bills. all right
you're recognized well first we need to adopt the amendment
those in favor all those opposed okay the amendments adopted you're recognized thank you madam chair this
amendment this is the bill in the voter integrity unit that was passed out this committee the other day there was some mr. Larimer with the press association on page three we had the fact-finding part of this pull the mic a little closer
please okay we had the fact-finding part of this that had FOI exemptions we've now deleted that the miss like I said mr. Lerner with the Press Association contacted me and I thought he had a valid point since this is a more designed to be fact-finding that we just delete the FOI exemption out that's it any
questions from committee members we adopted the amendment yeah
all right and if no questions are from committee members I have one person speak signed up to speak on the
bill whoops representative Walker on this matter of voter fraud I still want to know why it should be magnified at this point everybody talks about Crittenden County but nobody does anything about it and the only people who've done anything about it are the federal government people there's not been one state prosecution I mean the prosecutor's had it for at least a year and a half there's no there's no expenditure of
funds and no the only thing we do is just talk about it so why we want to talk about fraud one of the things that the law is that fraud is a crime and we cannot eliminate all fraud in advance so if fraud is a crime we should punish the crime rather than try to prevent the fraud in the first place I mean you're gonna you can't prevent fraud it doesn't matter what it is people who would deceitful find a way to circumvent pre-existing law or our expectation so in this case and since we're using Hudson Helen again I don't see how this
helps anything the state doesn't have any real interest in prosecuting him this the federal government prosecuted him and yet took a modest plea I mean he doesn't have to go to jail I mean so what's the deal I don't understand
it well I mean that's a little and I've got some other bills that hopefully address some of that in your your ride in the fact that there's several parts to this and the intent of this bill is that when you have irregularities people see things that are wrong that it initiates a fact finding to find out what happened in the election
if there was something wrong or something stolen so that's what that initiates so that corrects the problem of you know actually investigating or looking into voter fraud or irregularities to find out if it wasn't mistakes was it criminal intent and the reality is that you know mr. Hallam is the one that gets all the talk about right now, but voter fraud's been going on here in Arkansas for years, and the reason it has, a big part of it, is that no one goes and investigates.
No one looks into the fact-finding. I mean, you can go to things, Senator Crumbly's case over there in that election, you can go to things that can't be explained. Well, if things can't be explained or there's irregularities, either there's mistakes or there's fraud, and so that's what this bill's intent is, is that when people make complaints, there's somebody going to go look into it and make a determination. And then it goes to the prosecutor, the state police, they investigate it, but the prosecutor won't prosecute it, which is a problem here in Arkansas.
And that's why I filed the constitutional amendment to make, you know, voter, this is off on another matter, but to try and address your point, that make it where independent judges and prosecutors look into voter fraud. Because a lot of prosecutors and judges have election consequences if they happen to look into those things but on the amendment madam chair this this is about strike we've already debated the the original bill but this is
about striking the FOI exemption to this correct we did debate the bill in its entirety any other questions representative
Hickerson you had a question thank you madam chair and this is just about the bill and I'm just real quick any fiscal impacts is it any no I know this is within an
agency state or office the fiscal impact would be if there's actually you know a substantial amount of work has to and they find something which we hope doesn't happen we hope that this unit doesn't find voter fraud and doesn't have to actively aggressively you know look into it but
The Secretary of State is trying to coordinate their own positions on their own budget for the initial part That they feel like and I think mr. Boyd's testified to that with the Secretary of State's offices Testified to this committee in
the Senate committee as well about that Representative Walker here's my concern We have an attorney general we have elected prosecuting attorneys I don't see the value of having the Secretary of State become an investigator into things like fraud. I mean, the Secretary of State is generally a ministerial
function. That's the way the Secretary of State is throughout the United States in all 50 states. And to create this kind of unit, obviously, it's going to cost some money, but it just denigrates the position of Attorney General and the position of District Attorney, I mean, I understand what you want to do, but creating more levels of bureaucracy is
what this does, and I understand that there are some who sit here who are opposed to more levels of bureaucracy, and while I'm not necessarily opposed to it, I think that that's hypocritical in a sense. We need to just deal with what we have, and if it's not working, fix it. So I would, I don't think we have a quorum, but I'd ask you to consider taking it down and trying to reconsider it.
We do have a quorum, just for the record. Okay, are there any other people with questions? Otherwise, I have someone from the audience who wants to speak on the bill. Representative Altus. Thank you, Madam Chair. are we discussing
the bill or the amendment when a bill is re-referred to
committee it it's a whole bill again oh so it's been re-referred it's been referred back to committee for at the purpose of amendment we adopted the
amendment but it opens the bill up to discussion that's part of the process no problem okay there's one person signed up for this Susan Inman if you'd like to take the end of the table you're here to speak against the bill
Speaker 277
1:12:42
thank you madam chair I'm Susan Inman and I am here in two respects I have a seat on the State Board of Election Commissioners and I'm also president of
the Arkansas County Election Commission's Association this is the first bill in a package that seeks to overhaul elections in our state before this first bill passes, the House, the legislature needs to be fully aware of what the current state election administration is and how it got there. In 1993, in the wake of Bill McEwen's tenure as Secretary of State, the legislature created a bifurcated state election structure.
Under that structure, the independent, bipartisan State Board of Election Commissioners has duties that include training election officials making rules and regulations of the election process assisting county election commissions and perhaps most importantly investigating election law violations the secretary of state maintains statewide voter registration system selects voting machines provides voter education files candidate petitions among other duties the
bifurcated system provides important checks and balances necessary for secure and fair of even handle handed election processes SB 719 is the first in an effort to eliminate those checks and balances in our elections it transfers the power to investigate to a partisan election of elected official giving that That person's unfettered authority to decide who, when, and how to investigate individuals
accused, often by their political rivals of violating election laws. The power to investigate used wrongly is the power to intimidate voters, influence the outcome of elections. That power now rests in the hands of a bipartisan board. Each political party has the ability under this structure to influence the policy, to avoid abuse and wash over the shoulder of the other party when important policy decisions
are being made. Under SB 719, the Secretary of State, whoever that might be at a given time, acting alone without any oversight whatsoever would have the sole power to set these policies. The consequences of this bill are too far-reaching to address in the rush of the waning days of this legislative session. For these reasons, the members of the State Board of Election Commissioners, of which
I have a seat, voted unanimously, with Secretary Martin absent, not to support these bills. furthermore the membership of the County Elections Commission's Association also opposes this wholesale change I'd be happy to answer any questions thank you miss Inman members what is the will of the
oh did you have a question please excuse me representative Hobbs has a question thank you
madam chair can you tell me
I'm according what I read in the paper you know I think there were some complaints made and it appears that there were no or was no investigation conducted can you comment on that for me I don't what what are you speaking well I just know there were a couple of times that we you know we had instances and it seems like it was you know the election took place and then it would be months later before the investigation was conducted
Speaker 277
1:16:26
well if a complaint is filed with the State Board of Election Commissioners it is investigated and a
finding is reached and presented to the board this would actually make that same process happen there would be two investigative agencies one the Secretary of State that would ultimately come back to the board for a decision anyway so you've got a an extra process an extra layer that you're trying to Senator King is trying to include but but the investigations do occur you may not read about the end result but they do occur and in the instances of Crittenden
County which seems to be talked about a lot these days there was an investigation by the State Board there were monitors sent to Crittenden County there was an involvement by the Secretary of State in Crittenden County to assist them but the issues that occurred which by the way were under investigation by the state police in such a manner that the state board hardly would want to become involved because we don't have those investigative powers so I thought I
understood you say that you do have the authority
Speaker 277
1:17:45
to investigate do absolutely but but we don't have the things in place to do wiretaps and real genuine investigation of a criminal act okay thank you thank you madam chair thank you
madam chair cannot at least yes my bill or cannot take questions during this correct correct
your hand yes I would like to ask senator King a question senator King I mean, the Secretary of State's a partisan position, correct?
No, it's not a partisan position. He runs a – that's totally inaccurate. A partisan position, if we want to talk about a partisan position, that's the appointees to the state board under the parties. Elected officials are not partisan. I mean, we do bipartisan things all the time and vote on different bills. I mean, Mark Martin was elected by the people.
He wasn't elected by the Republican Party. I mean, he's not a partisan appointee. He's an elected official by the people the state of Arkansas just like Secretary of State Charlie Daniels was I'm not elected by the Republican Party I'm elected by the people in my district I Understand that Thank you. Thank you. There is more accountability under an elected official than partisan appointees I'd like to close close for your bill, please
Well, one thing I want to address here is the need that is the attitude that we don't need to overhaul anything. Well, you know, we've had voter fraud going on for years. If you remember several years ago, Governor Huckabee on the IMAS show made a comment that in some places, basically in elections, it was a banana republic the way they conducted elections. Let me quote Hudson Hallam since that's the big case. He said, this is his quote, this is just the way we've been doing elections over here for years. We've known voter fraud's been going on for years. And this attitude that we don't need to overhaul the elections is mind-boggling to me.
We've had voter fraud going on here for years, and the reason is no one watches it. No one actively, aggressively pursues. She says that she admits that they don't have the powers. Well, this gives the powers to this bill to an elected official that actually can report through our budget and accountable, and he's actually accountable to the people of Arkansas. all so there's more accountability let me talk about the some of the past stuff in this bill one of the people that made a motion to deny election monitors in the Hudson Hallam general
election was Jason Willett the Democratic Party nominee do you know who was hired for $15,000 as a political consultant when when elected when Hudson Hallam was running for office and no opponent, Jason Willett. Now, he may not have been a part of the state board then, but if you want to tell me something doesn't stink about that, that the person that makes the motion to deny election monitors in Hudson Hallam's general election was later hired as a
political consultant when Hudson Hallam didn't have an opponent for $15,000. I mean, folks, if we don't, this just proves not in Carroll County we fought election fraud and fought election irregularities that can't be explained in voter manipulation and suppression in Arkansas in different places the we say this will be a bit not a perfect system a better system than what we've had this will actually initiate some type of response
to actually go and look into it if you make complaints to the state board the staff may look into it they then recommend it to this partisan appointee board and then they may deny Senate election monitors they may deny and shut off everything as they've done quite clearly passed in the years so folks I just say and I want to say the Democrats on the committee you know when I first got elected there was 75 Democrats and 25 Republicans in the House and I made a comment to Democrats that maybe we're gonna have a Republican majority where they and they said that will never happen what we see in today's
world that may actually happen and this these bills will actually help the minority party whoever that is when you're out there fighting for elections and having something going on that some people are going to come look into the facts of the allegations that were made in that so I
would appreciate a good vote Thank You Senator King what are the wishes of the committee representative Altus makes motion do pass as amended all those in favor aye all those opposed
the nose habit senator King do you want to present Senate bill 720 member thank you madam chair
but with the members of committee that are not here present I want to try and make sure we have a full committee before I present the rest of them they might be out in the hallway all right
you'll have a meeting Tuesday next week either Monday or Tuesday correct we haven't decided yet thank you representative love house bill one five
five one is that what you're
up on your tablets you're recognized representative love Thank You madam chair and committee
I have two easy bills 1551 deals with the number of election monitors currently we have two election monitors to serve the whole the entire state and what this bill would do is propose that we we up that
to one election monitor pro congressional district the reason being is that sometimes we have some voting irregularities or different things and these election these election monitors cannot get to the spots of these communities and so therefore what we want to do is just increase the number of election monitors so that these voting irregularities or mishaps can be taken care of immediately so the monitors would
go from two to four yes ma'am okay any questions from committee members representative Kerr
represented love yeah there's a financial impact on it and it says it's minimal and it's no there's no
impact on the state Treasury all right thank you thank you madam chair motion do pass the
proper time any other questions from committee members no one has signed up
to speak for or against the bill so I'll accept that motion the motion is do pass all those
in favor all those opposed congratulations you're on a roll you want to hit your next one one you five five two
yes ma'am thank you madam sure and thank you committee house bill 1552 it's just to is in regards to election monitors training actually I want to try to pull it up right now so I can this well I'm gonna go ahead and speak to it this bill just deals with the
training currently election poll workers only have to get trained once every once every five years and so out of the three out of the three poll workers only one One has to be trained, and the training only occurs once every five years. What this bill would do is move to have all three poll workers trained. And I do believe that's it, Madam Chair.
And here's also with that there will be a fiscal impact of about $45,000 to get the training done. The training, I have no issue with the training. The training is good. I actually talked to my election executive director in Palacic County, and they already do training for all poll workers, but there are some counties that don't. And what we're trying to do is with the new election laws is just make sure that everyone gets the ample training that they need. The training, like I said, the training is not bad.
It's just that everybody needs to be trained. And so that's what Bill 1552 moves, just to make sure that all
poll workers get trained. thank you representative Kerr thank you madam
chair represent love this the $45,000 is that statewide that there would be statewide as I understand mr. Kerr as of right now it would probably come from from from general revenue I'm not I'm not quite sure I asked that mr. Wilson I
I wish Mr. Wilson was here to explain it, but how it occurs, and I think Susan Inman might be able to speak to this. I'm not sure, but how it occurs is it's a split. The financial impact is split between counties and state, I do believe, as I understand. And the training is already currently happening, but what we want to do is just expand the training so they're all three poll workers get trained instead of just one did you want
Speaker 277
1:27:26
to speak to that I was just going to say thank you it's just a reimbursement expense coming from
Speaker 262
1:27:33
the state to the counties okay all right thank you motion proper time manager
represent Dotson thank you madam chair did I hear you say it's a reimbursement from the state to the counties so how's there no financial impact on
the state Treasury no no no no this did you must be looking at I have two financial impacts are you looking at 15 1552 okay well this is
this is what mr. Wilson is prepared so I mean I cannot explain the fiscal impact but I asked him to run a fiscal impact he said it was gonna be minimal on revenue the revenue impact is gonna be minimal and then it was gonna be an additional of
forty five thousand dollars so we're not passing any unfunded mandates on to the counties for for this at all the state's paying
for the whole thing sir okay here's here it is mr. Dotson what it is is we're already providing funding to
do training anyway this is just gonna you know the forty five thousand dollars is additional funding to make sure that the poll workers all part of poll And I think we cannot underscore the fact that having trained poll workers is very important on election days, number one. But number two, with the laws changing, we need to make sure that our poll workers are trained. And so, I mean, $45,000 for the entire state, that's, I would say that's mental to ensure that our poll workers are trained and trained properly.
thank you thank you representative Kerr well that was interesting representative curse motion is do pass all those in favor aye all those opposed congratulations two for two thank you madam chair and thank you members and
for those members that have any questions please get with me and we'll give Richard Wilson and we'll get it straightened out
thank you okay everyone that's getting up to take a break remember to come back in please so we can keep working thank you representative Lowry you're recognized for house bill one eight zero nine There's an amendment out on your machines, tablets.
Thank you, Madam Chairman and committee. This is a bill that you had passed out previously. once it got to the house floor it was noted that there was some opposition to this and so that's what this amendment takes care of the amendment before you exempts law enforcement in the course of their duties on all the provisions of being licensed and the oversight on the use of voice stress and so before we
We're going to proceed. I hope that you would
vote this amendment up. Representative Kerr. Motion to accept the amendment. Adopt the amendment. So all those in favor? Aye.
All those opposed? Thank you. Go ahead. Okay. Thank you. House Bill 1809 now is an intact bill, one that all parties are agreeable to. The Arkansas Board of Private Investigators and Private Security Agencies have signed off on this change.
The chiefs of police and the various law enforcement entities are also in agreement. And so you can feel extremely confident with reaffirming your due pass vote of previous. It's always brave to bring a
bill back to committee that passed out and amended. Any questions from committee members? If not, Representative Kerr. I have a motion. Do pass as amended. Representative Kerr has a motion. Do pass as amended. All those in favor, aye.
Aye. All those opposed? Congratulations. You got it out of here twice. Okay. Thank you very much, committee. Feel free to go out into the hallway and tell anyone who wants to run a bill to get in here. The time's short. Representative Wilkins okay committee members I'm everyone can get up and get a drink for just a second we have another bill coming
committee members don't go too far though okay all right everyone can just kind of mull close by
Rips of Hutchinson you're recognized you have an amendment thank you for your patience committee members this is House bill 2100 thank you madam chair there should hang on just second if everyone can bring it up on their tablets there should be an amendment out there just a little housekeeping the we will probably have a couple Senate bills come down and so I think we're going to meet
again probably Tuesday I know it all depends so so kind of hang loose and please check the calendar for the house it might be Monday after session or Tuesday early it's just getting everyone here and getting the last of the work done we just went through the agenda as it stands now and we've pretty much worked through it but there are a couple
Senate bills coming our way so I want to give them a fair hearing as well representative Hutchison you're recognized I'm assuming you want to move to as amended there we go we're I'm gonna take your motion to adopt the amendment all those of all those in favor aye all those opposed all right your amendments adopted go ahead and present thank you ma'am all
I'm going to do here is in the Freedom of Information Act I'm wanting to say that all public
records that are given out by our state agencies is we're able to maybe do an FOI on it from like nonprofit for nonprofits just to keep up with the record of their performance or their lack of performance that's all I'm want to do and representative Kerr okay represent Hutchinson
to help you out here run it
past me again you're wanting to for everyone for nonprofits this only affects nonprofits correct yes sir okay and you're wanting the information on nonprofits to be a while
it if necessary if necessary the anything is given from our fit from our state budget from a Bureau Commission or state a any state agency you know anything anything that any any agency or as such that receives
50% of its money funded from it if I could already be yes sir representative Overby I'm sorry I came in
late so I may have missed some stuff but this doesn't affect the state police does it are they non-private Oh okay okay thank you
you representative Walker I kind of think I see where you're going with this this this would apply to a nonprofit organization that gets more than half of their funding from the state is that your intent here that's correct could I guess as I'm sitting here racking my brain for examples of who might be affected by this I'm generally coming up blank would you give me a couple examples of who
might follow within that sector well off
my head I mean whoever that might be nonprofit you know I just figured this would be a good transparency bill you know I generally agree with that I
guess as I look at it I'm just sitting here because because I think it's a great idea I'm just curious as I sit here and look at it obviously there are people that fall into that sector but for for
the life of me I'm not sure who that is well should I name some
names that's I guess specifically what I'm asking you to do okay well any anybody you know and And I'm not just putting me on the spot here, aren't you? But anyway, you're on the spot, sir. I am on the spot, you're correct. Well, anybody such that is such as your Blue Cross Blue Shield, any of those are the facts.
I would think Blue Cross Blue Shield doesn't receive 50% of their operating budget.
No, I cannot say that. No, I'm not saying that. I see you put me on the spot there, Representative Bell, but I couldn't tell you who. I hadn't looked into it that much. I just thought that might be a good bill. You know, I hate
to. I concur because, as you know, I'm all for transparency. I have just I'm struggling because I'm just coming up trying to find in my mind a list of people who might be affected
And off the top of my head, I can't you know I'd be in a freshman, you know, I hadn't been on a full budget
representative Walker Representative Hutchinson I don't know if I can help that that's the question though you remember some years ago there was head start operated by the
organization then known as the Little Rock Urban League Arkansas Gazette Democrat Gazette I guess I don't know which one was who it was at the time they wanted some access to the the records of the agency because they received most of their, more than half of their funds from the public, not a particular agent in the public, but in public. And I was on the, I represented the Urban League, and we resisted that, and the courts
of Arkansas Hill that the funds were so infused and subjects to state domination until they were subject to freedom of information yes sir so the Urban League would be one and I would guess any other organization that receives a substantial amount of public funds that calls itself nonprofit and that may include
sure if I may that's why you might see in the B section there it talks about it would exclude federal monies you know I if it's my understanding and you know I know I know like the head start in our in my hometown it was my assumption that it's basically through federal money I might be wrong I don't know
if I may follow up I think that if you put the limitation of federal money you may you
may defeat what you're trying to do the question is public funds whether they are whether if they are if they come through the state of Arkansas most there are most federal funds come to the state of Arkansas and in the state of Arkansas parcels them out and is the regulatory agency and and the other agency for looking after and ensuring their wise use yes sir and I
and you know I don't know if the law I don't know if our laws would allow that on the
federal you know I mean I'd love for it to be that way too but I don't know if our laws allow
that maybe y'all can help me out there I have to defend the build on the floor and at this
you can't defend it you're a good manager representative bill representative walk I've got Ripsy Walker on the mind.
As I was sitting here thinking, I actually came up with an organization that I think would fall under this that meets that scrutiny, or that probably does need that scrutiny, and they're now out of business because they didn't have adequate oversight, but there was a child care organization, I believe based out of Russellville, that had a lot of commingled funds that went bankrupt and I had about 30 constituents who were very negatively affected plus the families who no longer had access to childcare for a while so I
think I've answered my own question but it may mainly a point
of information you know kind of way I look at this is is I'm all about right and right are right wrong and right right wrong wrong and if there's any way that this could could help keep things in order I may not know that when I ran for this office you know they like keep me in tune you know and there's nothing wrong with it and that's good that's all good and I'm just trying to my team here just for the
right thing and I and with that I
guess I'm closed okay see no further questions from the committee members I'm assuming
pass as amended as amended the motion is do pass as amended all those in favor aye all is opposed it passes well
Speaker 27
1:44:11
thank you very much right I'm sure mr. chair all right we've got a
roll call okay y'all
Speaker 338
1:44:29
tough on me Representative Baird, Representative Baird, Representative Hobbs, Representative Hopper, Representative Hopper, Representative Klimmer, Representative Nichols, Representative Kerr,
Kerr representative Altus representative Altus representative Catlett representative Catlett represent our westerman represent Westerman representative Hickerson represent Overby representative Overby represent Walker represent a bell represent Richie represent Richie represent Dodson
represent Miller represent Miller represent of Hutchinson yes represent Wagner represent Wilkins receive nine votes so it fails thank you
for your time thank you is there anyone else in the room to run a bill all right we've texted everyone we can to tell them
to come they haven't come so I'll entertain a motion to adjourn I'm assuming everyone's in favor thank you very much keep keep a please look at your agenda pardon me the calendar
Agenda
SB1787
SB1875
SB821
HB2186
SB992
HB1805
SB719
HB1551
HB1552
HB1809
HB2100
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 1
Representative Butch Wilkins
Unverified
Speaker 4
Speaker 8
Speaker 13
Speaker 19
Speaker 20
Speaker 27
Speaker 29
Speaker 32
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 42
Representative John T. Vines
Unverified
Representative Betty Overbey
Unverified
Speaker 64
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 83
Speaker 77
Speaker 92
Speaker 99
Speaker 102
Speaker 105
Representative Nate Bell
Unverified
Representative Jim Nickels
Unverified
Speaker 117
Speaker 129
Speaker 131
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Speaker 136
Speaker 108
Speaker 147
Speaker 150
Speaker 152
Speaker 154
Speaker 53
Representative John K. Hutchison
Unverified
Speaker 168
Speaker 338
Speaker 194
Representative Allen Kerr
Unverified
Representative John Catlett
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 195
Speaker 252
Speaker 225
Speaker 259
Speaker 192
Senator Bryan King
Unverified
Representative Denny Altes
Unverified
Speaker 277
Representative Debra M. Hobbs
Unverified
Frederick Love
Unverified
Speaker 262
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Speaker 85
Speaker 217
Speaker 238