Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

March 4th, 2014

March 4, 2014
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (10)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1158 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1158”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1040 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1040”
Pre-2017 bill
SB111 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB111”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1054 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…eaker we are committee on joint budget to whom was referred house bill 1054 house bill 1071 house bill 1113 house bill 1114 and house b…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1071 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…mittee on joint budget to whom was referred house bill 1054 house bill 1071 house bill 1113 house bill 1114 and house bill 1141 but we…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1086 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…speaker we are committee on joint budget whom was referred house bill 1086 and house bill 1144 but we report we've had the same under…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1113 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…budget to whom was referred house bill 1054 house bill 1071 house bill 1113 house bill 1114 and house bill 1141 but we report we've had…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1114 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…as referred house bill 1054 house bill 1071 house bill 1113 house bill 1114 and house bill 1141 but we report we've had the same under…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1141 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1054 house bill 1071 house bill 1113 house bill 1114 and house bill 1141 but we report we've had the same under consideration here t…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1144 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ittee on joint budget whom was referred house bill 1086 and house bill 1144 but we report we've had the same under consideration here w…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
i invite the members staff press and guests in the galleries to stand to be led in prayer by representative chris ritchie and to remain standing for a pledge of allegiance to be
▶ Play
Speaker 4 0:21
led by representative deborah hobbs let's pray heavenly father we thank you for your goodness your grace and your mercy towards us. We thank you for giving us another day to serve you and to serve the people of Arkansas. Father, we thank you for the police and state police and energy crews and people who have been out working during this bad weather to keep us safe and to keep our power on. And, Lord, we thank you for the splendid job that they have done for us. Lord, we thank you for a little bit of sunshine today, for the temperatures warming up a little bit. Lord, as we meet here together, we just pray that you would give us wisdom, you would give us discernment to make the best decisions for the people that you have put us in a place to serve. And we ask these
▶ Play
Speaker 6 1:23
things in Christ's name. Amen. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
▶ Play
Members, please indicate your presence by pushing your yellow present button. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. cast up has everyone voted cast up the ballots mr. clerk 98 members present the chair sees a quorum are there any requests for leave
▶ Play
Representative Carnine Thank you, Mr. Speaker Leave for Representative Barnett Leave
▶ Play
for Representative Barnett Representative Ballinger Leave for Representative Fied Thank you Representative James L. Ward moves we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal no objection so ordered are there any reports from select committees read
▶ Play
Speaker 22 2:53
reports mr. speaker we are committee on joint budget to whom was referred house bill 1054 house bill 1071 house bill 1113 house bill 1114 and house bill 1141 but we report we've had the same under consideration here to return the same with the recommendation that they do pass mr. speaker we are committee on joint budget whom was referred house bill 1086 and house bill 1144 but we report we've had the same under consideration here with return the same with the recommendation that they do pass as amended respectfully submitted representative duncan baird chair are there any
▶ Play
reports from standing committees is there any unfishing unfinished business are there any executive communications members we have a former state representative jerry allison in the chamber today we'd like to to give him a good welcome the morning hours ended without objection the house will remain in recess until two o'clock Thank you. the house will come to order representative lee for what purpose motion let's
▶ Play
Speaker 36 5:11
hear your motion I move to reconsider the vote by which Amendment 1 to House Bill 1158 failed to pass.
▶ Play
That's a proper motion, and it is debatable. You're recognized to explain your motion. Colleagues, as
▶ Play
Speaker 36 5:31
we know, very few of us, or not a lot of us, were here yesterday. this is something that representative Nichols has been working on for five years he was not here to speak for it and so I just wanted to give him that opportunity today I'd ask that you give an affirmative vote thank you
▶ Play
representative Lee has spoken for the motion to reconsider would anyone like to speak against the motion for the motion representative Nichols raw purpose speak for the motion
▶ Play
you're recognized thank you mr. speaker and thank you representative Lee I think most of us realize today that our term in this chamber is limited this is my last last term and as she mentioned I've been working on this correctional pay issue for ever since my first term we had they had a big liability what I call it where they owed the employees millions of dollars in overtime and in the corrections world was called straight time and they even today they they owe them over ten million dollars in holiday pay where they work holidays did not get paid the holiday pay so there will be a in this this language this piece of legislation is just really clean up language to to help make sure that we don't end up with the same problem in the future so I'm speaking in favor of the of the motion to reconsider and then hopefully we'll we'll be able to have a a vote on on the bill itself as most of you or not most of most of you were here but I could not get out of my driveway yesterday and even today I had to have assistance and from the Capitol Police to get here so I appreciate a good vote
▶ Play
and thank you representative Nichols has spoken for the motion does anyone wish to speak against the motion for the motion representative Lee have you closed for representative Lee has closed the question before the house is the passage of the motion to reconsider amendment number one to house bill 1158 All in favor, say aye.
▶ Play
Speaker 44 8:08
Aye. Opposed, nay. The ayes have it. The question before
▶ Play
the House is the passage of Amendment 1 to House Bill 1158. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, nay. The ayes have it. Aye. Send the bill to engrossing.
▶ Play
Representative Link, for what purpose? There we go. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to ask for reconsideration to Amendment 1 to House Bill 1040. Let's hear your motion. I'm sorry. My motion is for reconsideration, Amendment 1 to House
▶ Play
Bill 1040. Is it amendment two? Excuse me. Yes, sir. Amendment two. That's proper motion. It is debatable. You're recognized to speak for the motion.
▶ Play
members this is a an amendment to the appropriation for the ADEQ appropriation then represent Branscom came down here and spoke yesterday and he spoke on behalf of his counties, which is pretty well Newton County and Service County, that's affected by how this would, how this would work. So I think I need to go into a deeper explanation as to what this amendment does to this appropriation. There's a neighbor's landfill in our, in Baxter County, and there's six counties in, that's part of an agreement and part of an association with this landfill, and they have gone broke. Now, Regulation 22, which controls a trust fund for landfill cleanups does not allow that trust fund to be used for an open landfill because this landfill went bankrupt they can't close the landfill therefore the trust can't be used there's no money to close off the landfill so they can't use the trust for the cleanup this amendment what our language would allow that money from that trust fund to go in and close this landfill and and to put it to rest and put it to rest safely however we go about this right I mean right now the course this landfill is bonded and so these bond daddies are being sued which are then going to sue the counties that are all involved and so this process will go through a legal process would take a long time before we'd ever be able to actually close these these landfills off using this process of the special language we'd be able to get use the trust fund money now finish off this landfill close it off clean it up and then come back with the lawsuits to get the money to put the money back into the trust for that reason I think we should take another look at this and reconsideration it looks like I may
▶ Play
have questions representative rise for our purpose question
▶ Play
go ahead with your question representative link and I've just got this the language that was concerning to other counties outside of these six counties that's the only one that affected is that correct six counties this just the six counties this would affect now the other counties that had concern because of language in the amendment that they might be found liable in that language do you have anything you could put those concerns to rest that's why this
▶ Play
is that's why there's a second amendment to this it cleans it up to where only this these six counties would be liable this totally got everything else out that's
▶ Play
right okay that's what I need you
▶ Play
clarify thank you thank mr. representative Hutchison
▶ Play
you're recognized mr. thank you mr. Baker representative is this same trust fund that is collected by dumping fees by the waste
▶ Play
people it is a solid waste trust fund yes is this is this the
▶ Play
same fund that like gets to a certain point and it's supposed to stop yes sir is everybody aware that it that money sometimes is that is this the same one that the one that that money is shifted and keeps on going as a tax you know anything about that I don't know the history of it well if that be the case and everything maybe we ought to help these people out get these things cleaned up in huh I think it'd be wiser to clean it
▶ Play
up now than later either way it's going to get cleaned up it's got to be there will be lawsuits it will be cleaned this would make it happen sooner than later yes sir thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 67 13:12
represent war lawful purpose thank you question you recognize thank you representative link is there anything in the statute that guarantees a repayment of these funds back to the trust fund there's nothing
▶ Play
guarantees there's no sir okay there's I don't know that the statute says it but it's accepted knowledge that these counties will be sued and that they will be expected to pay it back yes sir represent house what purpose you recognize if the landfill
▶ Play
is bonded I understand bonding construction bonds road bonds and road building bonds if the contractor fails to perform its obligations one of which is to properly close a landfill then the bonding company must step in and provide the money to meet that contractors obligation yes sir we are talking about a contractor not a county owned operation am I correct and that's
▶ Play
That's right. It's considered as a neighbor's landfill is what it's called. Yes,
▶ Play
sir. All right. So if, and I am asking a question. So if the bonding company is liable for the cost of closing, why would the counties face any liability for something that the private contractor failed to do? and and you're going
▶ Play
to step over my my somewhat limited knowledge I've just kind of started studying this more recently but these six counties are in this agreement with this organization so it's all a large partnership the counties are also as liable as this corporation as I understand it represent house so yes the bonding company should do it and that's why they're being sued and then those lawsuits will continue our concern now is there's an ongoing cost because of the leachate in other words these these cells have liners in the bottom of them that keep the moisture keep the rain from going down through all the roughage if you will and then going on to the ground and so we have to come in I say we do these companies have to come in and pump this water out this leachate and haul it off so there's ongoing costs until we can get this closed and by going through all the legal processes with the bonding companies and back to the counties it's causing a lot of time to go by without this being closed off and so these counties are going through the cost of hauling off this leach ache and we're also taking more and more risks as far as environmental damage if there's leaks or whatever so what we really want to do is put this whole situation to bed and then let the lawsuits and the financial obligations work themselves out instead of waiting for that to happen first it'll be cheaper to get it done now and it'll be more environmentally safe to get it
▶ Play
done now then we'll go back and settle everything rip some house you're breaking us if we use the trust fund monies to do this can the trust fund through the adq recover those monies from the bonding
▶ Play
company back into the trust fund who and how they sue will be up to adq this is I don't believe it's laid out in this language as to how they can go about getting back their money. So I would assume they could, Representative House, but it's beyond my feeble legal mind. Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, for what purpose? Two questions. Can the counties, which have some responsibility here, be sued civilly in your understanding regarding this matter? Representative Walker you're over my head sir my understanding that they have some degree of immunity cannot be I would hope I would think so means that if we have to rely upon them we won't be able to
▶ Play
Speaker 82 17:10
get any money the second question is
▶ Play
can you tell me the position of a DEQ with respect to this amendment a DEQ will do as we instruct we are the legislature I understand that but did they take a position in favor of or
▶ Play
against this position this motion I think a DEQ would like to see it cleaned up sooner than later and take less risk of more problems I understand
▶ Play
that too the question is still the same did they take
▶ Play
a position in favor of this amendment or against it I've not seen them work against
▶ Play
this amendment are you do you feel
▶ Play
Speaker 89 17:54
at home well I guess that's the best
▶ Play
Speaker 90 17:58
answer I'm going to get representative Murdoch for purpose question recognize okay so the contractor neighbors they're the contractor they have a surety that have bonded this project so if we do what your what this amendment is asking us to do will we violate our rights our fiscal rights because the surety should step in when there's a performance issue by the contractor to finish that as represent house related to so are we going to violate anything by stepping in and taking our place at this time or we will we be properly reimbursed i don't know and the reason what makes that very important because we don't want to get out of line sometimes you can do things to avoid the warranty if you will yes sir i can tell you my assumptions i can't tell you
▶ Play
for a fact so i'm not going to stand here and try to tell you for a fact my assumptions is that we could take we could go with the bonding companies but again the bonding comes through they're going to sue the counties anyway so eventually it's going to come back to the counties having to pay for this one way or the other would be that's my assumption of the facts but as far as I'm going with that sure my
▶ Play
Speaker 90 19:12
last statement is if there's a contract involved the county becoming the as part of is the owner then the county should be protected what that contractor does yes sir and that surety bond it protects the agency the municipality so So the county should not be liable if I understand the relationship properly. Well, part of this, Representative Murdoch, is part of the reason that the
▶ Play
bankruptcies of the counties have all pulled out kind of one by one as they've watched this thing kind of fail. It's never, there's never been as much trash hauled there as what was projected in order for it to financially work. They needed up to one, they needed about 100 tons a year for this to fiscally work right. The most that was ever hauled, there was, I'm sorry, 100 tons, 100 million tons. It's never been that much. It's fallen short of that every time. So it's never fiscally worked right for them. So they found it, the other counties were finding it cheaper to haul it to other places, even out of state. So one by one, they've pulled out of their contracts that they were in in this agreement, and that's why this thing has gone to the point it is. Okay. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Rice, for what purpose? Question. You recognize. I appreciate you taking a follow-up question. My concerns were, and I hadn't talked to you about this, that was related to me, was the all of the entities was concerned from some other things that people thought might come out of this. And it says, uh, of composing the region of solid waste management, are there any elected officials, uh, or anybody that would be on these type entities that were on there from not from their own volition, such as an elected official put on a solid waste just by the fact that they're elected?
▶ Play
Are you familiar with it? I'm not sure that I'm following you exactly. The county judges were, you're talking about this board? okay the county judges were all on this board they're automatically
▶ Play
on there when they get elected whether they want to be or not correct I would assume so yes sir and one thing that we've I was familiar with the reason I'm asking this question is there was a default in something totally different from this and county judges had to had to pay for liability coverage out of their own pocket as far as legal and that's the question in here when it says all other entities because you're on there when you run for office whether you know about when you ran for office or not so there are concerns and i just want
▶ Play
to go back and address that so thank you okay thank you y'all would appreciate
▶ Play
Speaker 100 21:49
reconsider represent payton for a purpose you recognize representative link i appreciate you standing up there and taking questions i just is it your understanding that some of the counties in this pact uh did not fulfill their obligations under the contract and that ultimately they would be found liable for a breach of contract and so therefore those surety companies would have sued against them I think it's very good possibility thank you very much
▶ Play
representative link has spoken for the motion does anyone wish to speak against the motion for the motion representative Branscom you recognize speak for the motion thank you mr. speaker I'm
▶ Play
not really for it but now I'm not really against it yesterday was pretty clear to me I thought I knew what I was doing and then when I've visited with ADEQ and the department associated county governments they explained more to me and I've tried to get the explanations before the vote ever come up yesterday well I continued to get more information and And Representative Link did an adequate job, did a very good job trying to explain it. I'm even more confused now than I was. But to put it simple, it seems like they're going to clean it up. The sooner we get started on cleaning it up, the cheaper it's going to be. We're going to get sued anyway because we signed the contracts. And the only thing I can understand is they have the fund. Why couldn't they go ahead, ADQ, and use the fund? Well, because we were told, ADQ told Kelly and I, it's got to be a certified closed landfill, be certified before you can use the funds. Well, it seems like we need to fix that sometime. But anyway, you know, I appreciate your vote yesterday, so I think it's the best thing to do. I'm not real sure, to be honest with you, but I think it's the best thing to do.
▶ Play
Does anyone wish to speak for the motion, against the motion? All right, the question before the House, is the motion to reconsider the vote by which Amendment 2 to House Bill 1040 failed. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed no. The ayes have it. Alright, the question before the House is the adoption of Amendment 2 to House Bill 1040. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed no. The ayes have it. Amendment's adopted. Send the bill to engrossing.
▶ Play
Representative Baird, you're recognized. All right. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. members we're going to move directly to the second bill on the calendar this is senate bill 111 it's an act for the department of human services division of medical services as you'll remember several weeks ago this bill was amended with two section of two sections of special language one dealing with advertising the other dealing with health savings accounts deductibles co-pays and non-emergency transportation and with that i'd appreciate a good vote does Does anyone wish to
▶ Play
speak against the bill? Representative Farrar, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm not going to stand up here and plow old ground. I hope you all got the letter that I
▶ Play
Speaker 118 25:32
sent out to everybody yesterday. It shows that we are already over budget on this private option. so I'm gonna end in this three years from now how are we gonna pay for it five years from now how are we gonna pay for it ten years from now how are we gonna pay for it if you can't answer those questions why would you vote for this
▶ Play
thank you does anyone wish to speak for the bill or some hammer you recognize speak for the bill you recognize
▶ Play
today we will make one of the as far as myself will make one of the most difficult decisions I feel have had made since being down here and I'm not really voting necessarily for this bill because I agree with everything that's in it but I will tell you when the day is said and done I will not trash talk anybody that votes one way or the other because for the most part I think everybody here has studied this thing to the depth of their soul and we are all going to make decisions that we have to go home and live with at the end of the day I have to live with the decision that I'm about to make and that will be to vote for this bill not because I agree with everything and I would only have respect and ask this that the vote that I'm about to make that each of you about to make that you would understand that we need to have the highest respect and integrity for this house chamber and that is displayed in the way in which we treat each other when we pass our vote and when we walk away from here because if we don't do anything if if we if we talk bad about each other when we leave here it just discredits the whole intent with that being said here's a couple reasons why I'm going to go ahead and vote for this bill at this time up to this point I've been very adamant against this bill and I'm still going to be against this bill with regards or previous my votes previously and even on this bill I have been against it and I will continue to fight to change the things in it that I do not like I'm afraid that there are people who have honorable needs that have been mixed into the package and there are those who are probably just trying to build their welfare portfolio but for me to point and to say which ones they are and which ones they aren't I can't do that but I do know this there are people that will be hurt if I don't vote for this and I don't want to see those innocent people get hurt because of that number two it's also because while it is that I fear that we will expand our Medicaid numbers if you want to talk in that terminology I have reached the personal conclusion that if we're going to see it fail at 125,000. We'll see it fail at 250,000. We'll be able to come back in the general session next year and take care of it at that time. And to that, I would also say, yes, I'm going to vote for it today. But I promise you this, and I give you this, my promise, that if it doesn't show the measurable results that we have been promised, as much as I'm standing here today, say I'm going to vote it and let it go through, because it's either going to be a great success or it's going to be a miserable failure one of the two and when we come back here in January if it's not a great success I will be voting against it whether there's 125 on the floor or 250 and to those of you who I know you feel like maybe I've betrayed or I've stepped away from the battle I haven't stepped away from it I plan on coming back in January and it better be successful otherwise it will be voted down on my boat if nothing else thank you very much does anyone wish to
▶ Play
speak against the bill representative alexander you're recognized to speak against the
▶ Play
bill thank you mr speaker you know we've been overwhelmed with details on this issue for months now and i've thought a lot lately about the fact that all the primary supporters of this bill have publicly stated they hate Obamacare they would end it if they could and I believe them I think the majority of the people in this house from both parties would agree with that I also don't believe that any member of this house from either party has any desire whatsoever to hurt any of our citizens we would all like everyone to have the health care that they would need. So why is it that we've had so much trouble coming to an agreement on this? I think to answer that, we have to stop and get out of the details a minute and consider a larger question. Because these issues are going to come up again. And I don't think we've given enough thought to this question. some of you may think this question is a joke but I assure you I'm completely serious and I think we need to consider this now and for the future are we still a free people do we still enjoy the liberty to address the challenges that we face and the way that we deem best these very intelligent people, and I mean this sincerely, that created the private option. If they had been able to create what they truly believed to be the best approach to health care in our state, does anyone here think it would look anything like the private option? If this body had the liberty to start with a blank slate, Could we create a health care system for the people of Arkansas that was better at a lower cost? Of course we could. I recently attended several doctor panels sponsored by Conduit for Action, and I've learned a lot more about the crushing challenges of Obamacare placed on these doctors. I've also heard some amazingly creative ideas from doctors who have already dramatically lowered the cost and improved the care of their patients. And I'm now absolutely convinced there is no way the Affordable Care Act is going to improve health care in this country. It's impossible, even if we could afford it. It will destroy quality health care in this country, and in the end, the poor will suffer most of all. they always do and that's just one reason i will never vote for this bill the affordable care act does stupid things it tells people who already had health insurance that they chose and liked you did not choose well you can't keep it you've got to do something else it drives people away from doctors they've trusted for years. It's made it significantly more difficult to have access to some of the best hospitals in the country. It dictates to women who are elderly, infertile, or have taken a vow of celibacy that they, along with men, single men, must have pregnancy coverage. It demands the little sister of the poor except a policy that includes abortion services in violation of their conscience and their First Amendment rights. So I ask you again, are we still a free people? The most famous words in the history of our nation are probably these. We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. We all know these words. We can all recite them by heart. But we seem to have forgotten the words that immediately follow those in our Declaration of Independence. That to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed. That whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the people to alter or to abolish it. Those sound like the words of a free people, a people who are determined to remain a free people. Are we determined to remain a free people? We don't have to abolish our government, but we do have to alter our thinking and reclaim our constitutional rights. The people created the states who created the federal government and not the other way around. Our Constitution clearly enumerates limited power for the federal government, and the Tenth Amendment says all of their powers are reserved to the states and to the people. That sounds to me like the Constitution of a free people. It doesn't sound much like what we have today. So I ask you again, are we still a free people, or are these now just words on old parchment? Is it our job as legislators to serve our people or serve the federal government? Friends, we will never be able to create a truly efficient, effective health care system for our people unless we understand this. Only a free people who have the ability to choose the best course of action can create a system like that. We will never be able to do this by remaining servants of a central government that allows only poor choices that meet nobody's needs but theirs. So we can begin by saying something like this, Mr. President, with all due respect, the Affordable Care Act legally passed by Congress no longer exists. You have changed that law, Mr. President, 28 times through executive fiat. But, Mr. President, you have no constitutional authority to amend our laws. According to our Constitution, the power to amend laws is granted solely to our Congress. the people's representatives by ignoring that law mr president you have violated your oath to preserve protect and defend the constitution mr president you're not the only one who's taken an oath to defend our constitution we who serve the people of arkansas and this legislature have taken that same oath to that same constitution and we take our oath seriously so mr president We hereby announce our intention to develop a new health care system for the people of Arkansas, using the best ideas of our doctors, our hospitals, and our people. And we will not allow our hands to be unconstitutionally bound in that process. Now that sounds like the voice of a free people. If we have the courage to reject the ridiculous limited choices the Federal Care Act forks has on us, we can devise a plan that will pass in this house with an overwhelming majority because truth although difficult simplifies just as it was for our nation's founders the fundamental questions are always the same are we still a free people are we going to remain a free people as it's been for every generation of americans the answer to that question lies entirely with us. Representative Hutchison, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Does anyone wish to speak for the bill, against the bill? Representative Hutchison, you recognize to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm going to be up here short and to the point shortest y'all ever heard me say anything about running my mouth but here's my deal that flag back there and that flag back there it's an honor for me to be here today and to represent both of them I just would like to ask y'all to think about when you vote yes for this you're going to give the authority to a non-governmental not-for-profit private entity that is exempt from state and local taxes that is exempt from all state laws that is that only the FOI Freedom Information Act and I and trust me that's not easy one to do and let me I'll
▶ Play
Speaker 126 38:43
leave you with this if you don't stand for something you'll fall for anything thank you mr. Baker does anyone wish
▶ Play
speak for the bill against the bill represent Peyton erectile speak against the bill Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
Speaker 100 39:12
Members, I've spent a few sleepless nights wondering what I'd say. I wanted to come down here or not, so I don't know if it'll be long or short. Just going to speak from my heart for a minute. I really appreciate what Representative Alexander was saying, because one of the things I've been debating with myself over for the last few weeks or months is we were not made free by a declaration of freedom. We were made free by a declaration of independence. Only an independent person can be free. Only an independent state can be free. The more dependence that we promote amongst the citizens of our state and our country, the less freedom we'll have. I think it's extremely evident in our school system when the changes and the reforms that need to be made are limited by the money and the control that comes from Washington, D.C. over our options of what we can do in our school system. And the more taxpayer money that is passed down through the system to our health care, the less freedom we'll see in our health care. I'm fundamentally opposed to the Affordable Care Act. I'm fundamentally opposed to the private option for reasons I don't expect many of you to agree with me on. I question whether or not government should be involved in health care, especially on the personal level. I do believe that government should help with the infrastructure. And for decades, we've helped hospitals exist. We've helped build buildings and provide equipment to hospitals. Personally, in Cleveland County, I've put personal money into structure to help Baptist Health build a facility there. And the more government gets involved in these things, the less private industry and private people feel compelled to do so. When somebody comes to you on a private level and they ask for help, a lot of times you think, well, there's a government program for that. The problem is our society has become too dependent. We're cannibalizing each other when we take from one taxpayer to bestow favor on another taxpayer. When we confiscate wealth from one part of society in order to provide for the other, we can justify it by saying there's a need there. But I see that as a personal duty to help the needy. I see it through charitable institutions nationwide, more numerous than I think they've ever been in our history, that those things should be done. But I don't see it as something that government should do. And the reason is right over that door. Our country was founded on In God We Trust. It's on our currency, In God We Trust. But what we've done is we've created a society that's trusting in government to meet their needs. I think this is unhealthy. I think it's unsustainable. And as Representative Alexander just alluded to, I think it tramples on people's freedom. We can only live in a free society as long as that society remains independent. Because with the dependence will come control. A little today, a little more tomorrow, lot down the road we've all felt that control sitting right here in this chamber we felt that control over the last 12 months we've struggled against what Washington would allow us to do under the Affordable Care Act we've struggled with what local government and laws would allow us to do you fight it and what's in the back of your mind is yeah but we can't afford to cut off that money stream we can't afford to oppose this we'll lose our funding for this other area over here the more dependents we foster in our society the less freedom will have no matter how you weigh it when we add a hundred thousand names to the role of dependents we had two hundred thousand names to the role of dependents we've limited our flexibility in the future the private option is unique it doesn't just pay for people who need care it actually provides insurance to healthy people who have no medical needs at all to the tune of nearly $6,000 per individual per year we are insuring against a possible future health problem that that person is going to have I have a lot of things I could say about insurance but just think about it like this when you buy insurance you're laying a bet against yourself you're hedging a bet against your success and so if you have something to protect and you have wealth I could understand neither the need for insurance but the bottom line is, we don't need to be betting against ourself. We don't need to be betting against the citizens of Arkansas by hedging a bet with private insurance. If government is to be involved in health care, if government is going to provide it, we don't need the insurance. We have a diverse population, and we can cover it within the realm of government, which I'm fundamentally opposed to but if you're going to do it there's nothing private about the private option we hire people we hire companies and corporations to build roads but we don't try to convince people that that's a private undertaking everybody knows it's government building the road I challenge you to search deep and think about what representative Alexander said how much of your freedom do you want to give up how much independence do you want to foster in our society I'd appreciate
▶ Play
a no vote does anyone we speak for the bill represent Collins you reckon
▶ Play
I speak for the bill I share many of the principles, thoughts, and beliefs of the folks that were up here speaking over the last few minutes. In fact, I believe that the founders knew that we lose control and that control gets lost little by little when the federal government confiscates our property, confiscates the property of the people, and confiscates the property of the states. And one of the things that concerns me a little bit is a president who has policies that I disagree with very strongly, I think, maybe a little bit smarter sometimes than my friends and I give him credit for. And when it comes to the Affordable Care Act, a law that I think is horrible and terrible and should never have been passed, has as one of its fundamental bad elements the confiscation of arkansas property and not just arkansas property but property across the country it comes in two major forms the first is the confiscation of 600 billion from the country over 10 years as a reduction to the medicare program that's the program that serves seniors in arkansas and across the country and what the aca does is confiscate 600 million dollars per year that's been pouring into our state and puts it in a bucket in washington dc the next thing the aca does is raise over a dozen taxes federally to the tune of 500 billion dollars per year nationally over 10 years our share of that is 500 million dollars per year now people talked about changes to obamacare and some of the changes delay some of the taxes so the actual tax increase bill is on the order of 460 million instead of 500 million that's a progress but i'm still thinking about the other $460 million per year. All told, the ACA confiscates out of Arkansans' pockets over $1 billion per year. Now, I agree that if we could start from scratch, and if we had that as an option, we could do better. I know that the 100 people in this chamber and the 35 in the Senate and other people in Arkansas have outstanding ideas on what the best health care system would be for the people of Arkansas. I would submit to you, we could also do that by starting over with our tax code, but I'll save that for another day. But that's not reality. We live in a real world, and in the real world, there are parameters on the things that we can do. 49 states took Obama's options and chose one. One state, this one, said, Mr. President, we refuse to accept your federal government shove-it-down-your-throats, take-it-or-leave-it approach. We refuse to accept that. This state is going to stand up and design something that is better than the alternatives you're giving us. And that's what was done. And I believe that that approach, the privatization of broken government programs like Medicaid, will lead us on a path to actually give our country a test market of solutions that rely on private markets instead of public ones and in the process we will be having returned to us a significant portion of the billion dollars per year that's being confiscated as we sit here and debate this bill and of that billion dollars that's being confiscated much of what returns comes back to the Arkansas state government in the form of the budget hole of 89 million the form of uncompensated care in our hospitals and increase of 200 million if we don't do this and I believe another hundred million and Medicaid woodwork effect 400 million to the people of Arkansas I don't know where the folks that are not in favor of this intend to get the 400 million dollars that we will lose as a state from a public and government institution standpoint so i'm voting for this and i would encourage everyone to do so representative hobbs what purpose question recognized thank
▶ Play
you mr speaker representative collins do you
▶ Play
trust our federal government to honor their commitments to us as a state? I
▶ Play
believe that the federal government can only be trusted to do what they've committed to in writing, which is why in the private option approach we've created triggers and many other mechanisms so that if they do not deliver on the key promises that are associated with the private option, it will go away. And regardless of whether or not they commit on every single promise perfectly it will still go away in 2017 I did
▶ Play
you happen to see the Washington Times article today that stated that the President Obama's new budget proposal does not take into account some cuts which was an agreement agreement made just a few months ago I did not see the Washington
▶ Play
Times today I and one last
▶ Play
question please as someone who is opposed to taxes tax increases when the federal government tells us we have to pick up more of this bill your children will be paying it mine will be paying it which taxes do you propose to increase to cover those costs the private option goes away
▶ Play
if that happens and I would submit to you which taxes do you propose to increase now to make up the 400 million dollar gap that i just mentioned thank you mr speaker thank you does anyone
▶ Play
wish to speak against the bill before the bill all right we've got a couple of pairs on the desk representative hank wilkins votes yes representative joe farrar votes no witness by representative mark lowry representative farrar is a present member are there any procedural objections to the pair please do not vote either of these two machines representative prissy hickerson votes yes representative jonathan barnett votes no report witnessed by representative less coronet representative hickerson is the president member are there any procedural objections to the pair please do not vote either of these machines the question before the house is a passage of house of senate bill 111 prepare the machine mr clerk has everyone voted has everyone voted cast up the ballots 76 yays, 22 nays 0 present, you pass the bill and the emergency clause Senator Barrett, you recognize
▶ Play
all right thank you Mr. Speaker members we'll go ahead and start with the next bill House Bill 1038 we'll consider that bill and below onto the second page go ahead and take a look at doing those as a batch so we're going to pass over House Bill 1150 and start with House Bill 1038 so as usual if there's a bill that you'd like to pull out pass over for a day or pull out and vote over separately now would be the time to speak up so members represent Ballinger what purpose I'd like to pull out on Passover 1127 so we'll pull out House Bill 1127 Department of Human Services Division of County Operations and we'll put that on the calendar for tomorrow representative Lowry for purpose I'd
▶ Play
Speaker 96 55:05
like to put a hold on Senate bill 57 for
▶ Play
one day we'll take Senate bill 57 University of Central Arkansas will pass over it put it on the calendar for tomorrow representative house for a purpose mr. Speaker House bill 1101 pull down from this vote okay and that's the Arkansas State Police House Bill 1101. Okay. Representative House, do you want that
▶ Play
pulled out for a separate vote or passed over until tomorrow? So we'll pass over House Bill 1101
▶ Play
until tomorrow. So we've got those bills that'll be pulled out of the batch. So members, your one vote will be recorded on each bill and each emergency clause after they've been read for the third time. So Mr. Speaker, I invite you to direct the
▶ Play
clerk to read the bills for the third
▶ Play
time represent a word that you need to be recognized house bill 1124 for tomorrow house bill 1124 is the division of aging and adult services we'll pull
▶ Play
Speaker 14 56:17
that one out okay Good to go. Read
▶ Play
Speaker 22 56:33
the bill for the third time, Mr. Clerk. House Bill 1138. I'm sorry. House Bill 1038. House Bill 1066. House Bill 1088. House Bill 1097. House Bill 1103. House Bill 1119. House Bill 1126. House Bill 1137. House Bill 1147, Senate Bill 3, Senate Bill 24, Senate Bill 53, Senate Bill 60, Senate Bill 73, Senate Bill 80, Senate Bill 86, Senate Bill 87, Senate Bill 104, Senate Bill 110, Senate Bill 113, Senate Bill 114, Senate Bill 135, and Senate Bill 140. Prepare the machine. Voting on the bills and the emergency clauses. Has
▶ Play
everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast with the ballots. 93 a, 0 nays and 0 present. You pass the bills and the emergency clauses.
▶ Play
Representative Barrett, you recognize. After the announcements, reading of the bills, placing the calendars on the desk, and amending members on bills with their own amendments, members withdrawing their own bills, finalizing resolutions, reading communications, and any remaining committee reports. I move we adjourn until 1.30 tomorrow. All in favor say aye. All opposed, no. Ayes have it. Motion carries any announcements. Representative Baird, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Joint budget will meet 9 a.m. tomorrow morning. Any other announcements?
▶ Play
Upon completion of the items, name the adjourn. The desk will remain open for the reading of the bills until 3.30 p.m. And upon completion of the items and the adjourned resolution, the House will be adjourned
▶ Play
Speaker 40 58:48
until 1.30 p.m. tomorrow. In action from the viewing gallery high above the House floor. After all, it's your House. You elect its members, and they meet to represent you. If you can't observe the sessions in person, you can follow news coverage gathered here in the Media Gallery. And every session is broadcast live on television and on the House's website for your viewing. We invite you to learn more at WWW.
▶ Play

Agenda

CALL TO ORDER

0:00 - 5:43 15 segments 6 speakers

HB1158

5:43 - 8:56 8 segments 4 speakers

HB1040

8:56 - 24:50 58 segments 15 speakers

SB111

24:50 - 55:57 74 segments 12 speakers

BUDGET BATCH

55:57 - 59:13 11 segments 5 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative John Charles Edwards Chair Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 4
3 segments
Speaker 6
1 segment
Representative Les "Skip" Carnine Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 22
4 segments
Speaker 36
2 segments
Representative Jim Nickels Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 44
1 segment
Representative Kelley Linck Chair Unverified
22 segments
Representative Terry Rice Unverified
6 segments
Representative John K. Hutchison Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 67
1 segment
Representative Douglas House Unverified
3 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 82
1 segment
Representative Reginald Murdock Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 89
1 segment
Speaker 90
4 segments
Chair Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 100
14 segments
Representative David L. Branscum Unverified
3 segments
Representative Duncan Baird Unverified
8 segments
Representative Joe Farrer Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 118
1 segment
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
6 segments
Representative Randy Alexander Chair Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 126
1 segment
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
15 segments
Representative Debra M. Hobbs Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 96
1 segment
Speaker 14
1 segment
Speaker 40
2 segments