Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

January 29, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (6)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1110 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…We're going to start. Is Representative Womack here? Okay. House Bill 1110. Representative Womack, you're recognized to present your b…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1164 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1164”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1012 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1012”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1114 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Is Representative Lowry here? We're going to pass over House Bill 1114. We're going to pass over House Bill 1117. Representative F…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1117 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…oing to pass over House Bill 1114. We're going to pass over House Bill 1117. Representative Feit, you're recognized to present House Bi…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1180 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1180”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
I believe, isn't that correct? Representative Petty, are you okay with us taking a couple out of order today? We're going to start. Is Representative Womack here? Okay. House Bill 1110. Representative Womack, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and
▶ Play
committee. This is a very, very simple bill. I'm not going to spend a lot of time on it. What it does is it allows, it strikes the age of 18 to sell scrap metal and brings it down to 16, and the entire reasoning behind that is I feel like if a kid is old enough to drive and work, we ought to have the opportunity to work. It does not loosen restriction at all. They still show their driver's license. They still do the fingerprint. They still say where the stuff came from and who the original owner was. It doesn't loosen restrictions at all. It just lets a kid that's old enough to drive and work work. and i'll add uh since the arkansas crime information center gave me these numbers since not january 1st of 1995 there have been uh nine people between 16 and 17 year olds that have been charged with scrap metal threat theft so it's it's basically a non-issue it as far as maybe opening up a new avenue for for teens to go still and so they just don't they just don't do it in that age group literally nine people since January 1st of 1995 and I'll be happy to answer any questions representative house you
▶ Play
recognize for question representative Womack would you relate the
▶ Play
personal experience about your kids that you related to me and a job you gave
▶ Play
them to do sure I remodel and paint for a living so we often have scrap metal and on more than one occasion we've either bought an old abandoned property or stuff that we've just torn out of places that pile up in my my yard and I have a high school kid or my oldest son now is 16 and you try and send them to the scrapyard and you you end up having to leave work during business hours to go sign a piece of paper so a 16 year old kid that did all the work all day can can get paid for his work by see to me it just we I think everybody around this table would like kids to be productive and work, it just gives them an opportunity to
▶ Play
do that. Any other questions from the committee? Okay, we've got one individual who's signed up to speak for the bill. Mr. Calvert, Paul Calvert. If you'll take a seat at the end of the table and state your name.
▶ Play
and then make your statement. My name is Paul Calvert. I'm from Faulkner County. I'm here on behalf of Liberty and Justice. I don't have a whole lot to say about this. I just think it's reasonable to let younger people work and make a living. It shouldn't be illegal to make a living.
▶ Play
Thank you, and please pass it. Thank you, Mr. Calvert. Representative Womack, do you want to close for your bill? Yes, sir. I'm closed. Thank you. All right, he's closed for his bill. Any discussion? Is there a motion? Representative House, what's your motion? Okay, we have a motion do pass. All in favor indicate by saying aye. Any opposed? Ayes have it. Bill's passed. Thank you. Is Representative Lowry here? We're going to pass over House Bill 1114. We're going to pass over House Bill 1117. Representative Feit, you're recognized to present House Bill
▶ Play
1164. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members. I'm here today to present to you House Bill 1164. Currently, our law says that Level 3 and Level 4 sex offenders may not reside within 2,000 feet of a school, daycare center, youth center, elementary or secondary school, public or private. To this list, I would like to add churches. I want to read to you the definition of a Level 4 sex offender. And please keep in mind that the bill I present to you affects only Level 4 sex offenders. Level 4 sex offender, and this is from the Arkansas State Sex Offender Protocol Manual, a sexually violent predator adjudicated guilty of sex offense or acquitted on grounds of mental disease or defect, judged likely to engage in predatory sexual offenses. This is the group I'm referring to. And I would like to invite Crawford County Sheriff Ron Brown to join me at the table with the chair's permission. I would like for Sheriff Brown to share an incident that happened in my home county, Crawford.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 5:31
You can pull the chair around. Thank you for having me this morning. Representative Fiedt asked me to come and testify on the behalf of this bill. Arkansas sheriffs do support this, and we ask that you pass this. In Crawford County alone, we had two Level 4 sex offenders that are under the authority of the state hospital who are being cared for privately. first moved into Crawford County in the incorporated city of Van Buren and they later moved. Part of their therapy was to raise chickens and rabbits and they had to move outside the incorporated city and the area they moved into is a small community. They're living in a rent house adjacent to a church and also within probably 3,500 feet of another church. As she explained to you, the definition of a level four and then them being in the custody of the state hospital and being privately cared for. One of them assaulted his caretaker and left the residence and went to the church property and then, of course, it was after hours of church, but went to the house adjacent, knocked on the door. Lady opened it. She had her small children there, and he was carrying a pair of channel lock pliers. Her husband, being a vampire and police officer, she immediately dialed 911 and he was taken into custody, and therefore charges were filed against him for assault on his caretaker. Our job is as representatives and as sheriffs and, you know, it's public safety, and I believe that adding this to the bill would just hold those that choose to commit these crimes accountable for their actions. So I ask for your support
▶ Play
of this. Any questions for the sheriff? Representative Farrar, you recognize for
▶ Play
a question. Thanks, Mr. Chair. Could you read the definition of the level four sex offender to me
▶ Play
one more time? Yes. Sexually violent predator, adjudicated guilty of sex offense, are acquitted on grounds of mental disease or defect, likely to engage in predatory sex offenses. Thank you. Do you think that the distance of 2,000 feet will
▶ Play
prevent this person from doing exactly what you said? Do you want to take that? I don't think
▶ Play
Speaker 24 7:59
we can prevent anything in this country. I think we can only just put a roadblock in front of it. Okay. Okay. Do you think we're
▶ Play
over-regulating? And I hate these people, too, just like you do. I don't hate them. No, I do. I don't want them in Crofton County or Arkansas. We should do a lot more stuff and keep them away. I'm not going to say it. I'm just thinking we're writing a law of 2,000 feet when these people can go 2,500 feet and do
▶ Play
Speaker 24 8:25
the exact same thing. Exactly. Are we over-regulating this whole thing? I think if we were saying convenience stores and other things like that where kids congregate, I do. But a church is a facility where every church has juveniles, okay? And I believe that we just need that adding this is just another roadblock to hold them for their accountability and protect the public. Okay. I understand. But is 2,500 feet, it's legal? Yes, sir, it is. 2,000 foot is legal.
▶ Play
Right. Is that going to prevent them from going to that church and molesting children and doing what you're trying to prevent? Well, it's 2,000 feet
▶ Play
Speaker 38 9:02
further away that they have to walk. Okay, thank you, Mr. Chair. I have a
▶ Play
question, and maybe the representative fight or the sheriff could answer it. With regard to this bill, is there anything that – well, let me back up. This is only focused on residency. this would not prohibit, or there may be something already in the law, prohibit a level 4 sex offender from, say, attending church. You are correct. This only
▶ Play
says reside. And there is a grandfather clause in here that if a level 4 sex offender owns property now that is adjacent to church property, they would not be affected by this law. This law is going from now, henceforward, and saying that you cannot reside within 2,000 feet of church property.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Broadway? Okay. Do we have any other questions? Representative Howell, she'll recognize for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. When I read your bill, I had no problem with keeping folks away from schools, including schools on church property. Just outside of my district, Paul, what's the name of the ranch up there around Greenbrier where we have offenders? There's a ranch in Faulkner County, and there's a church on the ground, and that's what they do is take in felons and rehabilitation programs. That kind of gives me a problem now. We, I've also talked to one of our other representatives who pastors a church who they take in, they have living facilities and take in felons. I seriously doubt they're level four. I don't know, but I know at this rehabilitation ranch.
▶ Play
Let me call, I have with me today Brad Kosort from the ACIC. May I call him forward with the chair's permission? He may be able to answer this question for us.
▶ Play
You may. Thank you, Ron. You recognize, if you would, introduce yourself and where you work and make your statement, please.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Brad Cazort with the Arkansas Crime Information Center, and one of our tasks is obviously maintaining the sex offender registry, so any questions you may have, we'd
▶ Play
be happy to try and answer. I don't think I have a question about the registry. I have a question about this bill where churches actually are engaged in trying to bring in the faith-based community to rehabilitate parolees. And we're asking the churches and the faith-based community to take an active part in that, and that may include establishing residence for them. So I'm wondering, are we working against cross-purposes now by telling them just to stay away from the churches, can't reside on church property, which I know in one case they do
▶ Play
take felons? I do have a definition of church written within here, Representative House, that might help with that. May I read that definition? Sure. Church or other place of worship means a physical location that has a primary purpose of facilitating the meeting of persons in order to practice a religion. And again, I think most of the groups to which you are referring would not be working with level four sex offenders. Okay,
▶ Play
my last question. I looked at your bill, and I went on Google Maps this morning and just Googled churches. City of Cabot, City of Little Rock, City of North Little Rock, just all the towns in Pulaski County and a few outside Faulkner County and that sort of thing, no level four sex offender. I couldn't find a place that was not within a half mile of a church. that's where the jobs are and these folks are going to be back out on the streets so we're effectively and I think it's probably a reasonable statement to say we're effectively telling level 4 offenders they can't live in an incorporated town because that's where the churches are do you get a different impression I know what the Google Maps showed and that's what it showed so what do we do now?
▶ Play
I mean, you all are talking about a policy question. If you have to decide, I can give you some numbers that will make, you know, I would just tell you that as of this morning, we have 14,322 people registered on the Arkansas Sex Offender Registry, and only 366 of those are
▶ Play
a Level 4. Representative House, I think when you're thinking of sex offenders, you're thinking of 1, 2, and 3. Level 4 are the worst of the worst. They are typically not going to be going back into the community. They are typically not going to be rehabilitated and getting jobs. We have to keep in mind the people we're speaking of in this case.
▶ Play
Representative Talley, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. My question was the definition of place of worship, and it says here the physical location and the primary purpose. Does it have to be established? What I'm concerned about is can you come in where three or more gather, you're singing, you're playing and singing and worshiping. Is all of a sudden that established as a, you know, if you've got it in a community, I mean, under a pavilion, you can gather up and that would be your
▶ Play
primary place you're meeting and worshiping every week. That would not meet the definition of the law. That's why I put in here what current code says. It meets the definition of a church. It has to be a building established primarily for the purpose of worship. So saying I have a Thursday night Bible study in my home would not meet the law.
▶ Play
Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Representative Fite, if I understand the spirit of your bill and being a pastor, we work a lot with level one, twos, and threes, seeing a few fours in our local congregation. and we've had to really struggle with how to show love and compassion and yet protect our children. And would you say the spirit of this bill is for someone like us, we want to work with everybody we can. And I'm very familiar with Level 4, and that's a whole different sphere, as you said. And while I want to work with them and help them, as some of these others have mentioned, I do not want them living within eyesight or even in close proximity to our church playground where our kids go to play after Sunday school, and I would love to have that 2,000-foot buffer. Thank you for that,
▶ Play
and one thing that has been said to me is that often level four sex offenders say to mental health care professionals and to law enforcement as they are leaving to live in a community, please help me. Please help me stay away from children. Please help me stay away from the group to which I am attracted. I cannot help myself. I need your help. This would add another level of safety. Any
▶ Play
other questions from the committee? Representative Tosh you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you Mr. Chair. Just make sure I understand the language so there's no misinterpretation as far as law enforcement if they had to enforce this law when it says resides are we talking about the individuals normal place of abode or we talking about they can be there by the invite of a friend exactly if law enforcement had to deal with this what would they have to support them as far as the language in this law as to whether they could remove them or not level 4
▶ Play
sex offenders would not typically be going out on their own to visit a friend?
▶ Play
Would you say that is correct? No, I don't know if I, I can't comment or have any knowledge other than anecdotal about their activities. I can tell you that reside is fairly much a term of art in the law and there are legal cases that talk about what constitutes residency and I assume any prosecutor or law enforcement officer would fall back to those definitions in trying to enforce this law.
▶ Play
Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a follow-up.
▶ Play
I understand that, but also the language in one paragraph, and I'm trying to find it now, it says that the sex offender cannot reside there if they own or reside at that property. It actually defines it. So, if they don't own the property, I just don't want there to be any confusion as far as someone trying to enforce this law, especially when we're dealing with class 4 sex offenders. I just want to make sure the language is correct. Are
▶ Play
you comfortable with that? Yes, what it says is if they owned the home prior to the enactment of this bill, prior to this bill becoming an act, that they can continue to live there. However, if they did not own the property within 2,000 feet of a church prior to this bill becoming an act, they may not reside there. Representative
▶ Play
Armstrong, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So, Representative, if they own the residents prior to this law, they remain, correct? That's
▶ Play
correct, because in that case, residents in their neighborhood would have been notified. Okay. And
▶ Play
so after this law is enacted with those individuals that own and law enforcement that is now, that knows that they live in these communities, whose responsibility? Would it be law enforcement or, I don't know, POA to notify any resident that may own a home that they may have to move or relocate if this law is enacted? But they, or you're saying they get
▶ Play
to remain? Representative, under the current law, all notifications are handled by local law enforcement agencies. And
▶ Play
local law enforcement would note, so, okay, next follow-up, if you don't mind, Mr. Chair. If they, when we, or if this law is enacted, law enforcement would notify these residents or homeowners that we now have a new law on the books. How would they be informed that, I mean, they're informed when they get out and they have to register as a sex offender if they're moving to a neighborhood. But who informs them now that there's a law enacted that
▶ Play
it can't be? Actually, that would be a combination of law enforcement and ACIC. You know, offenders have to report, level one, two, and three offenders have to report every six months to verify their address. Level four is every quarter. When they report to local law enforcement to verify their address, they are provided with a statement that they signed that lists all of the obligations that they have. this bill passes, this obligation would be added into that statement. So every time they go into verify, they would be getting notice of this requirement in addition to all the others that
▶ Play
already exist. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank
▶ Play
you. Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Fiedt, I understand your intentions with this, and I think they're very well served. My question would be, I live in a very rural area, and we have churches come and go quite a bit. We had one not too recently in an old restaurant building in the center of town. Well, then we have one that it moved out of town. Every time a church moves or puts in, does that mean that if there is a level 4 sex offender already there, that
▶ Play
they will be notified that they have to move? If it meets the definition of a church as written in this law, I would assume that would
▶ Play
Speaker 85 21:45
be correct. Thank you. Representative Broadway, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I'd really like to go back to Representative Tosh's issue with regard to Term of Art Reside. Clearly, these individuals are dangerous people. They aren't going to go and visit friends, probably, but they do have families, and they become released. And you may even have this issue with regard to other levels of sex offenders when they're transitioning. You know, if someone goes to stay with their mother upon release for three days, are they in violation of this law? I mean, where is the line?
▶ Play
This would meet exactly the same criteria as if they went to visit their mother who lived next door to an elementary school.
▶ Play
So my question, I guess, is a timing question. Is it three days? Is it a week? Is it a month? When are you residing, and when is it a visit, I guess? And I'm really
▶ Play
not trying to trip you up. I'm just trying to understand what reside means. Well, it would follow the same as the law currently is, Representative Broadway. Right now we say that they cannot be within 2,000 feet of an elementary school, a daycare center. And the way that we look at that in the law and say if they're visiting someone, and it would be exactly the same as if they were within 2,000 feet of a church. This is just adding to that list that's already currently in law. So then what is the status of the law right now?
▶ Play
Representative, again, I don't think there's a strong definition. There's a number of factors that courts look at to determine whether or not somebody is residing, such as where do you get your mail, do you have your name on a utility bill, is it your usual place of abode, where are you registered to vote? I mean, there's a whole number of factors that they would look at to determine,
▶ Play
is this a residency or are you visiting? Okay.
▶ Play
That helps me. Thank you. I would point out one thing, I think, to Representative Gray's question. On 514-128-B2, it states, It's not a violation of this section if the property on which the sex offender resides is owned and occupied by the sex offender and was purchased prior to the date on which the public or private elementary or secondary school, public park, youth center, daycare facility, or church or other place of worship was established. So that kind of answers part of it, but it references ownership, I believe, as opposed to occupancy or residency with regard to that exception to it. So I'm just wanting to point that out as a point of clarification. Representative Ballinger, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm hesitant about adding on anything else onto new people, and especially if you blankly cover just registered sex offenders in general. But what I think may need to be reiterated, and I know you've tried to say this several times, but just, you know, we are just talking about, what, 300 people? Is that what you had said? As of this morning, 366, level four. All right, so 366 people, and these are some of the worst offenders. I actually started looking it up, some of the things that they've done. This is not the minor stuff or else they would be a three, two, or one. These are the worst of the worst. These are the 360 worst offenders, and frankly, of all the criminals, I'd say that the 360 worst criminals in our in our state frankly be my my opinion and so we're not talking about a large number of people are we I mean it's a fairly small number of people 2,000 feet that's you know not a not a real broad distance so I you know to me it doesn't seem like this is nearly as intrusive a lot of the things that we do apparently
▶ Play
wouldn't you agree I would agree and thank you for that clarification. Some crimes are so heinous that the effects of those live on forever and repercussions from those live on forever. This may be one of those that you may not go within 2,000 feet of certain places. This is adding churches to that list because I believe that the rights of people to have their children play in a church playground, the rights of women to come to a sowing circle on a weekday supersede.
▶ Play
I'd agree. Okay, I've got two more questions on here, and then I think Representative Farrar has a motion for me, so I'm going to go ahead and take these two questions, and then we're going to take a motion.
▶ Play
Representative Scott, you're recognized for a question. Mr. Chair, I was
▶ Play
just going to say motion at the proper time. Okay, thank
▶ Play
you. Representative Brushing, you're recognized. The question I have is we're talking about if they say they own the property prior to this effective date, that this does not apply, but if this person is in a rental agreement or lease agreement, we don't address that. So will we be putting that person in the risk of violating their lease and not being able to fulfill their lease and putting them in a situation where they will
▶ Play
have to move at that point? Most of these facilities where people would be living are operated by outside groups. Am I correct in that?
▶ Play
Again, I don't have a statistical analysis of where level fours live. If they're owning or renting, I would think that as I read this bill, it does talk about ownership, not
▶ Play
necessarily residency. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Before I move to the motion, I see no other questions from the committee. We do have Representative Bennett,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Would you have an objection to including or rents or contractually leases in this provision?
▶ Play
I think the best course right now is to leave
▶ Play
the bill as it is written. All right. I see no further questions from the committee. We do have a few who are signed up. Let's see, first Robert Combs signed up to speak against the bill. Mr. Combs, if you would come to the end of the table and state your name and what organization you represent and please let's try and keep our statements as brief as possible. MR. Good
▶ Play
morning, ladies and gentlemen, Mr. Chairman, ladies and gentlemen of the committee. My name is Robert Combs. I'm with the Central Arkansas Reentry Coalition, the CARE Coalition. And we feel that any legislation that establishes systemic barriers to reentry makes it more difficult for people to become successful once they reenter society. And this is another enhancement that is making it more difficult for people to reenter and become successful citizens. I've been contacted by Level 4 sex offenders this week. Most of the ones that contacted me own their own homes and were concerned about how this would affect them. And I said, right now, the way the law reads, if you own your own home, you're safe. But one rents, and this may affect him. Also, people who leave the rent market and eventually buy their own home, if a church is established in their neighborhood after they've owned their own home since this bill has passed, then they will be forced to leave their home that they own. That's the way I understand it. And one of the things that I need to stress is that the CARE Coalition is a coalition of constituent memberships all involved in reentry. And we feel that family reunification and community integration is important for people to live a healthy, safe life. And most of the people that I've encountered who are level fours have jobs, have families, many have wives and kids. It's a different perspective than what I hear debated around the table. Thank you. Representative Petty, you're recognized for a question. What
▶ Play
is the recidivism rate for a level four sex offender? I don't
▶ Play
have the breakdown of recidivism for level four sex offenders. But for sex offenders in general, the recidivism rate according to the Department of Justice study is about 5% but that's
▶ Play
not the level 4 which is the worst of
▶ Play
the best that's that's correct that's the general recidivism rate for all sex offenders I can't speak to level 1 2 3 or 4 separately
▶ Play
Speaker 115 30:46
which is what representative fight is presenting that's right it
▶ Play
would only affect level force but one thing I do understand is that recent legislation has created the state default for sex offenders as level 3 it has altered that so now the state default can be level 3 or 4. So you can be defaulted as level 4 without a full assessment. Representative Bennett you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Okay so now
▶ Play
that I'm going back and rereading this ownership issue one I would feel more comfortable if it had that they'd rented it before but this term the effective date of this act means that if a level four sex offender moves into my community I can declare my house a church if it's a principal place of worship you have to meet the definition of the law as
▶ Play
to what a church is and declaring your house a church would not meet the definition physical location that has a
▶ Play
primary purpose of facilitating meetings in order to protect us of religion. I mean, it's not real hard to rent a place at the corner and declare it a church, and now people that may have purchased property are forced to leave. So essentially, we could manipulate the system in order to force these people to leave. Well, that would be very hard
▶ Play
to do and meet the criteria of church that's already been established under the law.
▶ Play
Representative Beck, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Yes, you mentioned that you'd been contacted by some level for offenders and that they own properties and possibly might be affected. Are you saying that these people that contacted you were in this boundary? One of them that owns a home is within this boundary,
▶ Play
but he would be safe because he would be grandfathered in. The other two have not checked to see if they're grandfathered in I mean if they're within that boundary but since they are homeowners at this time they would be grandfathered in the one that rents checked and found that right now there is no church within 2,000 feet and so at this point he's safe but a church could come in at any time another thing to bear in mind that daycare centers schools parks and youth centers are already covered and many churches do have daycare centers or schools incorporated within the church property so many churches are already covered by the
▶ Play
existing legislation Okay. Is there a follow-up question? So to help me understand, what you're saying is all the level four sex offenders that contact you, none of them would be affected by this law?
▶ Play
None of them would be affected by this law at this time. If a church were built by the renter, he would be affected by the
▶ Play
law. But at this point, he's not. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Combs. Now, next on the list is Carla Swanson, who has signed up to speak against the bill. Ms. Swanson, if you'll take a seat at the end of the table, state your name and what organization you represent, and then you're recognized to make a brief
▶ Play
statement. Good morning. Good morning. Good morning. My name is Carla Swanson. I'm with the advocacy group called Arkansas Time After Time. All I can say is just read this book. This is studies, research on resident restrictions. They do not work. What you do is you push a sex offender further and further out into no man's land where it makes it harder for them to get a job, to even be around family. And, you know, talking about level fours, The definition of a level four is just basically for resident notification. The definition that's in the book really doesn't mean anything. I know personally three level four sex offenders. One of them is mentally disabled. His father died a few years ago, and now he is the sole take care of his mother. He's in his 60s. She's in her 80s. If they have to move, I'm not sure what in the world would happen to them. He's a level four. What did he do? Touched a lady on her boob. He's a level four. Why? Because he went like this. Because his hearing aid battery was dying. He showed aggression during the assessment. I have a level four who is deaf. He couldn't hardly understand some of the question. They made him a level four. so even though they're classified as a level four are they truly a level four so that's something you need to ask and yes a lot of these people have families they have homes they rent so again you're going to make it to where they have to move find another place to live and it's already a burden trying to find a place to live uh senator or representative house you looked on google map Little Rock alone, there is like a tiny little half of a block where a level three or four can live just in the Little Rock area. So you push these people further and further away from their families, their jobs. A lot of them can't even afford a car, so now they can't use busing. They can't use the cabs because they're in a small community. There's no cab service in local towns. So resident restrictions, like I said, I have got a book. If anybody wants studies or research, email me. I'll be glad to send you all the research that I have that shows resident restrictions do not work. It does not stop a crime from happening. The church incident that y'all talked about, that could have easily had been a school that he walked into. That could have easily had been a daycare center. It just so happened to be a church. it would not have stopped him from walking into any place even if this law was in
▶ Play
place Representative Ballinger you're recognized for a question
▶ Play
thank you Mr. Chair one of the things that I guess we need to make sure that we're on point on this bill what this bill says is level 4 sex offenders the only change that it does means that they can't live within 2,000 feet of a church I know you're making the argument that maybe some people shouldn't be level 4 sex offenders And from my standpoint, that ought to be another bill. So if you have somebody who inadvertently made a mistake and is not likely to reoffend and didn't commit some of the really heinous facts. And so you may have a couple of people who didn't do very much. And I am, like, embarrassed to even mention some of the things that most of these level four sex offenders have done. And they've also been deemed likely to reoffend. So if your problem is three or four people, they need to get good attorneys. maybe we need to change the law to make sure that they aren't labeled level four if they do something on accident. But from my standpoint, what I'm looking at here are these are people who are likely to hurt kids again or rape a woman again or do a bunch of other nasty, horrible things to people again. And all we're doing is saying you can't live within 2,000 feet of a church. And, you know, your organization, I appreciate your effort in trying to make it where people can get back out into society and be productive, that to me seems really important. But I guess my question to you, don't you think that this kind of belittles your efforts if you're willing to fight something as minimal as 2,000 feet from a church for level four sex offenders? I
▶ Play
do believe everybody deserves a second chance. And if they were that bad, then they shouldn't have made parole to begin with.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Broadway, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. You have a lot of information about sex offenders. To follow up with Representative Petty's question, do you have any specific information about their recidivism rate for level four sex offenders? Arkansas
▶ Play
does not keep that type of record, because I have looked into that before. I do have some numbers about Arkansas, but they don't break it down into what levels re-offend or don't re-offend. OK. Thank you. I'm sorry, Broadway, I will send you what I do have. Okay.
▶ Play
Seeing no further questions, thank you for your statement. Next on our list is Jeff Rosenzweig. If you'd take a seat at the end of the table and state your name, who you represent, and then make your statement. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 140 39:46
Jeff Rosenzweig, Arkansas Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. I want to just point out a couple of things that people have sort of hit on but may not be aware of. There's an interplay between Title V, where this is, and Title 12, which is where the sex offender registration laws are. And the definition of residence in Title 12 includes place of employment. And so what you're going to have here is more unintended consequences. If you tell the level four that he can neither live nor work within 2,000 feet of a church, essentially what you're going to do is drive these people into unemployment and homelessness and you will have the exact opposite of what you're intending, which is to know where these people are. If you drive them into homelessness, you will have the exact opposite. You won't know where they are. And I think you need to consider this very carefully. I guess this isn't the time or place to debate residence restrictions in general. But if these people are the worst of the worst, as several people have said, you really need to know where they are and not just leave them out foraging under a bridge.
▶ Play
Thank you. Okay, that's the last person on the list. Representative Fite, you're recognized to close for your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you. According to the ACIC, there are places for level four sex offenders to live. They're not going to be foraging under a bridge. They will have homes. They are typically not going to be employed, and in fact, this bill does not say that they cannot work near a church. This is saying only they cannot reside within 2,000 feet of a church. Again, this bill is only adding churches to the list that currently exist in the law of places where level 4 sex offenders cannot reside. And again, I would read to you the list, the definition of a level 4 sex offender. This is from the Arkansas State Sex Offenders Protocol Manual. The sex offenders go before a committee at the Department of Corrections. This is composed of mental health professionals as well as law enforcement. The level four sex offenders go through an interview as well as just looking at their conviction before they are given the level four status. Sexually violent predator. adjudicated guilty of sex offense or acquitted on grounds of mental disease or defect. And just because someone is acquitted on grounds of mental disease or defect does not mean that they cannot hurt people. Likely to engage in predatory sex offenses. So with that being said, I would appreciate a good vote. Thank you, Representative Fite. Representative Farrar, are you
▶ Play
recognized for a motion? Motion do pass. Okay, we have a motion to do pass. Okay. And any discussion? All those in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Those opposed? Ayes have it. You've moved your bill out of committee with a do pass
▶ Play
recommendation. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you,
▶ Play
committee members. Okay, we're going to go back to the top of the regular agenda. To House Bill 1012, Representative Petty. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee members. Representative Petty, you're
▶ Play
recognized to present House Bill 1012. Thank you very much. This bill is really special to my heart, and I've talked to a lot of you about it. And this is an act concerning victims' rights in a capital punishment case, also to be known as Andy's Law. And I just want to tell quickly my story and why I'm fighting for victims on this complete issue. Fifteen years ago, in May, my 12-year-old daughter was abducted and murdered. And just to make a long story short, we have been through lots of appeal process and everything. And in 2004, this came down the line and the man who murdered her was facing execution. So my family goes down to the Department of Corrections to view this execution. And to mentally prepare for that, I can't even begin to relay that to all of you. It is something that just you have to prepare yourself mentally and physically for. So when we get down to the prison, we're there. We're ready to witness this execution. And I'll just preface that by saying that the execution did not happen that night. So my family's there. We're ready to go and view this thing. And we get there, and they tell us, you're not allowed to view. However, the prosecutor and all of the players that were in the case, they're allowed to go behind the glass and view the execution. Your family and the people that are with you, they have to go into the warden's office to view this live via feed. So we end up in a stuffy warden's office, and it was just a bad, bad deal. So what I have drafted here for, I couldn't even talk about this for many, many, many years. It was so traumatic to me and my family. So this legislation puts the rights back to the crime victims and lets them choose whether they want to view or not. So I want to just lay that baseline out, and I have some closing, but there's also some people that want to speak on behalf who could do a really, really good job, and if that's okay. All right. Are they signed up, or is this – who
▶ Play
are the individuals you're wanting to call up? Christy Fricker. Okay. All right. Ms. Fricker, if you would move to the end of the table and then state your name,
▶ Play
and you can make a statement. Thank you for the honor to speak with you all today. My name is Christy Fricker, and this is the first time that I have publicly spoken about the things that has happened to our family, anything to do with Andrea, so I will get through this the best I can. Like Rebecca said, in 1999, my 12-year-old niece, Andrea Brewer, was abducted from her rural southwestern Arkansas home. She was brutally raped and strangled. Her small, naked body was left in the woods for three days before her murderer confessed and led the authorities to her broken body. today I am tasked to try to help you see as through the hearts of the families the victims families but as a as a family member I know that there is no way that I can help you understand there's no words that I can say that will help you understand even begin to understand the path that we walk on a daily basis but we do that it's simply a place that no human being should have to walk and we do it every day so all I can attempt to do right now is to paint you a story our story just one family story an Arkansas family's story when the murderer was arrested he was given the right to be tried by his peers and we understood because that's the law. When our family is marched through metal detectors and patted down and searched before every court hearing, we try to understand and we know that it's for protection and so we have to understand. When the murderer is led into the courtroom surrounded by police officers and protected by a bulletproof vest, we are forced to understand. When the hours tick by in the courtroom while the doctors and psychiatrists attempt to give rationality and reason behind such unspeakable actions, we don't like it but we try to understand. When Andy's photos of her murdered body are displayed for hundreds of strangers in in an open courtroom. We're disgusted and we're sickened, but we had to try to understand that it's a part of the judicial process. When the state of Arkansas sentenced the murderer to death, regardless of our beliefs for or against the death penalty, the decision was out of our hands as a family, and we understood. We were told that only a small number of family members would be allowed to be present at the execution, to view the execution, and that we would have to write letters to the warden pleading, pick me, pick me. And we were vying against other family members who were just as devastated and deserving to be there to view that process. But it was a part of the process, and we had to understand. But then when the rifts formed within the family, because some were chosen and some were not chosen to be present, we had no choice but to try to work out understanding within our core family. So when we were bused to the prison, and Rebecca spoke a little bit about this earlier, When we were bused to the prison on the execution day, we saw the many protesters at the gates protesting against the death penalty. And we understood that that was their right to be there to protest. When the unchosen family members, including the elderly family members, were directed to a tent outside of the prison gates, a tent in sub-freezing weather, And all the while, they are feet away from protesters with nothing but a tent separating them. We tried to understand. Those people in that tent, our family members in that tent, cold, they tried to understand. When the few chosen family members reached the prison, all of our personal identification and belongings had been taken away from us. We were led through the metal detectors and patted down and searched once again. We understood why, and we complied. When we were led into the warden's office, and it was explained to us that we would have to view the execution via closed circuit television on an ancient turn knob, black and white, 19-inch television screen. We were devastated. We were shocked, but we understood. Quietly, we understood. After waiting hours, we are finally told, just like in the movies, that he had been granted a stay of execution. We were devastated again, but yet we still understood. We were understanding. When hearing that a family member, an elderly family member that had been in a tent, had chest pains and had to be rushed to the emergency room, we understood because our hearts were breaking too. When a decade has come and long gone and the appeal process continues, when the victim traveling funds are discontinued because the case has gone on so long that the victim funding has run out, when the state of Arkansas has spent hundreds of thousands of dollars to house and feed and care for the murderer, when the murderer has been on death row now longer than Andrea was even alive. We keep trying with every bit that we have left in us to understand. And I will close with this. We're not monsters. We're God-fearing, good, loving, compassionate, strong, law-abiding, law-making citizens of the state of Arkansas. We're normal people who experienced and continue to daily cope with a devastating blow to the very core of our family. We do not joy in the death of another human being, but we do rejoice in justice, and we believe that victims' families should be treated with more respect and dignity than that of the offenders. We believe that we have the right to see justice carried out with our own eyes if that's what we choose to do and if that's what will bring us closure. We should have the right to choose who goes into the execution chamber instead of leaving it up to someone sitting in an office reading our letters and choosing for us. We should not be stuck in tents, feet away from protesters. We should not be left alone in a warden's office with small TVs while strangers are in the execution chamber viewing the justice that is for our loved ones. I realize that there's nothing, again, that I can do or say today to make you understand the years of pain and emptiness and even the confusion that the families of violent crimes have to endure on a daily basis. But I will only ask you one thing, that you take this vote to heart and to realize that it is now your turn to understand. It's our choice to tend to the last business that our loved ones have left on this earth and to ensure that that justice is carried out for them in their behalf with our own eyes if that's what we choose to do. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you. I see no questions from the committee. Moving to the list for those who signed up against, Wendy Kelly. She's already left the table, so, Ms. Kelly, if you would take a seat at the end of the table, state your name, who you're with, and then you may
▶ Play
Speaker 158 56:20
make a statement. Hi. My name is Wendy Kelly. I'm the director for the Arkansas Department of Correction. and I am here not to in any way belittle what this family has suffered and what other families have suffered. At the Department of Correction, I've had a role in trying to bring about a solution to the execution stays that we face, and I take that very seriously and have taken that very seriously. I have met with Representative Petty several times. We have toured the Cummins facility, and we at the department do want to accommodate victims' families. We simply can't accommodate an unlimited number, and we suggested a number of six in the viewing room. They would be in there along with the citizen witnesses, with the condemns attorney, with the condemns spiritual advisor, and with our staff that are necessary. We have another area where we could have additional family members that would be on the prison property but not inside the gate. It is within viewing distance of the execution chamber. And so we would like some time to continue to work with Representative Petty to see if we could come to what we consider a workable solution. but we do not want to create an unsafe environment on the prison property or in the execution chamber.
▶ Play
I'll be happy to answer any questions. Any questions from the
▶ Play
committee? Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Answer me this if you can. Are your objections to what Representative Petty's bill would do based on your feeling that it would be impossible to implement or simply expensive and inconvenient?
▶ Play
Speaker 158 58:24
It would be impossible to implement under the current facility that we have because there's no limits on who would be in the viewing room. And the viewing room does have walls. There's no way to change that currently. I also would not be comfortable with the fact that any family member that is listed in that list could be present regardless of what their background is. You know, unfortunately, in some instances, crimes tend to run in families. You know, we may have an inmate that's got seven brothers that are also in prison. Not that that has anything to do with Don't misunderstand me and I don't mean this to come across But what if the family member is also an inmate A family member to the victim is an inmate There's nothing in here that lets me say that person can't be present And I do think that's another flaw in the bill There needs to be a way for us to screen people We wouldn't do that lightly We wouldn't, you know, exclude Representative Petty in any form, but there are family members that unfortunately have violated the law, and those people would be a security threat to us and to others in that room. If I
▶ Play
may follow up, Would you be willing to work with a bill that specifically stated who, say, violent offenders, current residents of the Department of Correction, et cetera, would be specifically disallowed this privilege? I'm willing to work on any kind of amendment possible.
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:00:16
I just can't accept the draft as currently drafted, not that it's my choice, it's y'all's choice, and I understand that. But, yes, sir, I'd be willing to work on some amendments. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Rushing, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Yesterday evening you sent out an email to the members of this committee stating that, you know, making a point that no one on this committee attended, I guess, a tour of your facility on Monday with Representative Petty, and I think that was because there was other obligations here at the House of why we could not attend with her while some of us did want to attend that tour. But also in there, you stated that each family member that would be allowed to come into the viewing, you felt like should have a full background check and that it should be at the sole discretion of the warden and able to go in and have this viewing for the family. And is that something that you're just stuck on, that this is going to have to happen before you're going to be ever in agreement with any kind of this law that she's trying to get passed?
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:01:39
Currently, no one goes into the viewing room that has not had a background check. Family members under the current law, there were up to five of them that were allowed to watch it by closed circuit television, and so they're not in the adjacent room to the execution. People that are in the adjacent room should have a
▶ Play
background check. Yes, ma'am. Representative
▶ Play
Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank you for this. Would your, if you do background checks, would it require any additional new procedures or you would just be following your current procedures?
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:02:22
We currently do background checks on anybody that visits the prison absent state officials and legislators. If I
▶ Play
follow up. So assuming there was no objection to the typical background check in this bill, then that issue would be removed. Is that right? Yes, as long as we could
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:02:42
make decisions based on that background check. Yes, ma'am. Representative
▶ Play
Tosh, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Your current policy is to how many people can actually view the execution. Is that your policy or is it state law? And if so, if it's state law, is it your policy or state law? State law. That's state law. And tell me the numbers. I'm not familiar with that law, but exactly who's allowed what? How many? What does each one get? The victims, how many do they have?
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:03:25
The victims have up to five family members currently who view by closed circuit television. There are six to 12 citizen witnesses. There's the attorney for the condemned. There's the spiritual advisor for the condemned, and then there are staff that are present that are named in the law. So
▶ Play
how many does the condemned get? How many are they allowed? He does
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:03:47
not get any, and they are not allowed on
▶ Play
state property. Okay. So that's a state law that regulates how many can be in, and this law then will change that. Is that correct? Yes, sir. Okay. I have worked those executions. I've been there, and it always amazed me that the victims, that their rights just didn't seem to carry the same weight as those of the ones that we were fixing to execute. And we need to look.
▶ Play
Yes, no further questions. Representative Brown, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. First of all, I want to say your arguments to me are falling on deaf ears. I've worked in far less secure facilities on a global scale than this, and I can say when you why do you give an excuse that one of the family members may have an inmate that is currently in the facility? Just on the levels of security that you have in your facility, how is that even an issue? Because that family member, you move the inmate to the other end if that's what you need to do. Why is that one of the reasons that you say a family member cannot come in and view an execution of someone who has committed a crime
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:05:27
like this? I'm sorry, I don't understand the question.
▶ Play
The question is, you had referenced that one of the reasons, why are you, one of the excuses you're using as to, well, a family member might be, because this goes with what Representative Tosh had said, these family members are being treated like victims, or the victims are being treated like criminals, excuse me, or the family members, and one of the references you use is, well, one of the family members may have, we have to do these background checks because they may have, even though they do not have a criminal background, the family member may have, or one of the family members, there may be a family member currently incarcerated in your facility. So that is reasoned, one of your concerns. And I don't understand how that is a concern because of the different levels of security you have. So why is it that if there is a family member that is associated with this case, Why is that an issue with allowing someone into the
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:06:29
prison to view the execution? The execution room is, the witness room is fairly small. There are 18 chairs currently in three rows in that room. It's fairly cramped and by current law, there are a number of people that have to be present in that room. And putting a felon in the room would be a security concern. I'm sorry if I misunderstood, and I apologize if the email was offensive. It was not meant to be. I assure you that was not the intent, but please accept my apology. No, I
▶ Play
may have misunderstood your reasoning behind. And my understanding was that there was concern that if one of the family members of the victim, that they would not be allowed to view where there was a potential security risk if a family member connected with the victim's family was currently incarcerated in the prison. Now, maybe I misunderstood what she had said.
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:07:37
My concern was simply on who would be
▶ Play
in that room. Ms. Kelly, just so we're clear your concern was if a victim's family member was incarcerated, then they would have the right to view the execution and that's what you were stating, is
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:07:56
that correct? Yes, I'm sorry, if I was a victim's family member and I am not, but if I was and my brother was incarcerated in the Arkansas Department of Correction the way it's currently drafted, he would get to be there in the room. He might be in shackles, but he would get to be there, and he would be there along with the citizen witnesses and the other people. I just
▶ Play
wanted to make sure, for the benefit of the committee, I wanted to make sure we were all understanding what the concern that you had raised. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a question. Thanks, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
When's the last time we've actually had an execution in the state of Arkansas? 2005.
▶ Play
okay thank you representative Scott
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question I hope I can get through this I cannot imagine the pain this family has gone through and continues to go through we talk about a lot up here about mental health let's do something about mental health I believe this would help a whole lot of find folks who really need closure and I too thought Mrs. Kelly or Miss Kelly's email was inappropriate. I also thought it was cold and I'm sorry maybe my heart's just a little bit too big to have coldness or coolness when we're talking about something like this. I've had the privilege of getting to know Hello, Mrs. Petty, and I've had also had her open up to tell me what happened to her little girl. Last night I was talking to my husband, John, and I was talking to him about where and what our little girls were doing at age 12, and I cannot imagine what they've gone through. and I don't care if you have to add on to those rooms. I don't care what it costs. You do whatever needs to be done to help families like this and if not, you need to get somebody in your position with a bigger heart to help out these folks. Don't
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:10:18
you agree? I agree that I offended you And I am very sorry that I did that. I was trying to be factual and not be emotional. I have been touched by what Representative Petty and her family endured. I was a couple of years ago when this issue came up. We also emailed Ms. Petty last night, Representative Petty last night. It wasn't an attempt to blindside anybody. There wasn't anything in that email that we hadn't discussed with her.
▶ Play
And, again, I'm sorry. Representative Bain, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. And this question is for both Representative Perry as well as for ADC. I'm trying to understand the mechanics of one part of this law. When it says on page 3, lines 23-24, the number of viewers shall not exceed 18 per execution, my only question or concern is once you have the list of all those, you may actually exceed 18. So I guess my question is, who would come off that list if you exceeded 18 people to view the execution? If you had between the citizens, you know, the minimum number of citizens, the priest, the legal counsel, the family, and all that number, when you add that number up, it was 19 or more. How do you pick and choose who are the
▶ Play
18 that are going to be there? If I may, the 18 is capped for the victims. And I went back and made sure because there was some confusion when the bill was written. So the 18 is the cap for victim families, if that makes sense.
▶ Play
Okay, so, but there's only, I think it's been testimony, please correct me if I'm wrong, there's only 18 seats in the
▶ Play
chamber. So how do you? The way that we had discussed it, six family members would actually go into the chamber and it would be however they want a background check, all 18 people, the rest would go to a victim support room that's not even behind the prison gate. So six behind the execution, actually into the prison, and then the remaining folks would be outside in a room. Thanks, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Representative Rushing, you're recognized for a question Well
▶ Play
I think I might have just got my question answered but I just wanted to clarify of the 18 seats now that are there how many are for the victim's family to be able to go
▶ Play
in? The way it is written six of us in the chamber inside the chamber the outer room that we had discussed when we toured would be for the rest of the family. And it's a facility on the prison grounds, but not behind the gate. Does that make sense? The limit of six wasn't in the
▶ Play
Speaker 199 1:13:24
limit. It's a cap of 18. Did you see the amended?
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:13:30
That just listed the viewers with the caps at 18? Yes, I amended the cap.
▶ Play
Right. Right now, without this bill, how many of the victim families are allowed in for the viewing? Five viewing. Okay. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question
▶ Play
is for ADC. Were you here two years ago when this bill was ran before? Yes, sir, I was. Okay. What I remember two years ago is us trying to do a lot of work with ADC to try to work with you to make it, you know, get something together that could get passed. And what I felt like is we were blocked every, I mean, just basically, you know, it didn't seem like you did much to work with us then. So I feel a little bit, I mean, less sympathetic to having much need to work with ADC considering two years ago, you know, you did everything you could to stop this from happening. And your assessment may be different, but, I mean, that was from my standpoint when we were trying to get this done two years ago. I was not the director.
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:14:42
I've been the director about two weeks. Right. But I was around, and at the time, I believe, and I heard Representative Petty say the other day, the reason it failed was because of the appropriation that would be required
▶ Play
Speaker 194 1:14:59
to enlarge the room. Is that correct? I'm not sure why it
▶ Play
was. I mean, there were three votes that it didn't pass. Yeah, it didn't pass because of the fact that there was another money that was tied to it. But honestly, it was because of the fact that ADC was lobbying everybody to kill it and wouldn't work with us even though we tried. I'm sorry that
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:15:23
you feel that way, and I don't remember it that way. but I am and continue to stand ready to work with Representative Petty in this legislature. And I just heard Representative Petty say that it would be six in the viewing room, but I didn't see that in the amendment. I didn't see any limit to who would be in the viewing room in the amendment. So if we could go back and get that clarified, then I would be happy
▶ Play
to do that. Representative Gray, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I may be beating a dead horse with this question, but going back to the background check, what is the current criteria that disallows entry into the
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:16:12
facility currently? Currently, for visitors or for witnesses to the execution? I haven't been in this role where I was the one making that decision. I do know they do a background check, and they determine who was going to be in the viewing room. I don't believe they did a background check on the family because the family wasn't going to the viewing room. But I wasn't in this position, and I couldn't
▶ Play
say for all certainty that that's what happened. Okay. Follow-up question, please, Mr. Chair. Thank you. So my next question is, does this law, what the proposed bill is, change your current policy for background checks? and if it does not, then that background check would prevent a victim's family member who has a record that meets that criteria from entering that room. Is that correct? No, ma'am,
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:17:05
because as I recall, the current law says that the citizen witnesses are chosen by the director, and we do the background check in order to make that choice. this draft doesn't say that we choose who any of the victim family members are
▶ Play
that will be in that room. Follow-up question? Thank you. If this bill were to pass, would you do a background check on every person that entered that room under your current policy? Under current law, yes, ma'am, we do.
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:17:42
Thank you. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
You would, if under current policy you would do a background check, as I'm reading this bill, and I don't know that this was the intent of the bill, it excludes the ability to then exclude someone because of that background check. Is that correct? If they're a family member that fit that definition, yes, ma'am. And if I could follow up, because this place is the choosing on the victim's family, and once they've chosen who's going to attend, it does not give you the ability to exclude those people. Is that correct? That's the way I read it. Yes, ma'am. And if I might, one more. So if we had a gang member who was being executed, I mean, it's a different situation when we're looking at a very sympathetic family and a victim, But if we had some sort of dangerous family, you would still be required to let all of those people in, and you would have no ability to exclude them. Is that correct? The way I read the
▶ Play
draft, yes, ma'am. Representative Broadway, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I don't want to get out in the field too much. But do you know the rationale behind having six citizen witnesses? And if so, could you explain that? because it seems to me that if we could eliminate some of the citizen witnesses in favor of allowing more family members in, that we might be able to resolve some of this issue with regard to the crowding and those types of issues.
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:19:28
The law currently says 6 to 12 citizen witnesses, and they are allowed to view to ensure that the Department of Corrections carries out the execution in accordance with state law. I
▶ Play
understand that, but I'm wondering if you know historically the rationale for that number why is it necessary that six unrelated citizen witnesses you know watch the execution do you know i'm sorry i don't know i would assume it had something to do
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:19:54
with the size of the room but i don't know that thank you representative ballinger you recognize for
▶ Play
question thank you mr chair my question would actually be for for both the adc and and representative Petty, if Representative Petty would agree to put the language in there to say six family members to amend that and make it real clear that it's capped, and that if anyone doesn't pass a background check, and someone may have to talk about that, if there were a situation where there was somebody who had felonies in their background, they would be excluded. If she was willing to amend the bills, would ADC support this bill? Yes, sir. Would, I mean, the nature of what we have here, we have a lot of people who travel a long way for this bill. If Rebecca Petty, I'm sorry, Representative Petty, was willing to say that she will amend this bill, would you let it pass and allow her to amend it before we run it on the floor? I'm not sure I
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:20:59
understand the question, but I don't think I have the authority to stop you from doing that, if I
▶ Play
understood correctly. Well, but to me, it seems like it's great if you are willing to work with us, especially if it's something Representative Petty is already basically agreeing to in her bill. If she would go back and you could work with her on getting those amendments done before we vote on the floor, you know, those are some things that, you know, I think Representative Petty kind of assumes her bill does. If it clarifies it for you, then I think everybody else would be supportive of it, or most of us would.
▶ Play
I'll stay here as long as it takes, sir. I'm good with cleaning it up if that's what kind of you're asking I would be open to that I have a motion at
▶ Play
a proper time Representative Broadway I mean I think that's a great solution my concern is that procedurally that works I would think that before we pass this bill out that we would need her to make the amendments that Representative Ballinger is talking about or it's still going to have to come back before the committee.
▶ Play
I think, well, the other alternative is to take care of it on the Senate end, which that's actually Representative Petty and I have previously talked about some of those concerns. So it's just, I mean, that's one possibility, but ultimately we've got a procedure here. So it would just be a matter of agreement, and so that's where we're at at this point. But to be amended on the House end, it's either going to be – it'd either have to be amended before we vote here, or it would have to – I guess the amendment would likely come back to our committee. Any other questions? Representative Whitaker? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Clarify this for
▶ Play
me. Regardless of background checks, everyone coming into that facility, particularly into the viewing room, is thoroughly searched and goes through metal detectors, et cetera? Yes, sir. They're currently searched
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:23:05
in Pine Bluff, and then they're placed on a van and brought down to the facility.
▶ Play
So I'm trying to reconcile that with his background check and why we'd exclude people, unless I guess you're afraid they might burst through the window of the death chamber and choke the condemned man to death with their bare hands. Well, sir, I
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:23:27
don't know that they wouldn't hurt someone else in the room with them. It's not about protecting the condemned. And I guess
▶ Play
you would say you don't have the security just to make sure that people act right in your
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:23:43
room? If there is an unlimited number of witnesses, then there are only so many security officers that could be present.
▶ Play
Well, I think we've established that Ms. Petty is restricting the viewing room to six, right? So we're not talking unlimited, are we? If
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:24:01
the amendments are made, no, sir. Okay, thank you.
▶ Play
Representative House, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. Ms. Petty, thank you for a few days ago sharing your bill with me and answering all of my questions a few days ago. I still have my concern about somebody desiring to be present and that they have a right to be there, but for some unforeseen circumstance, they can't make it and the execution getting postponed. So if you're going to make some amendments, you might – that they are, in fact, present. So if they get held up on the road, car wreck, state police gives them a ticket, whatever, that the executions aren't held up because of the way the language reads. But thank you. My last question is, all of your bill presupposes that the form of execution will be by lethal injection. have you given much thought about what if this legislature decides the method of execution is not going to be by lethal injection
▶ Play
Speaker 52 1:25:07
okay go ahead as I recall
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:25:11
her bill refers to the method of execution act it recites the code section so if you change that code section that would apply thank you that's what I wanted
▶ Play
to know representative Bennett you're recognized for a question Representative Petty, would you be willing to make those two amendments before we recommend do pass? I am certainly supportive with those two amendments, but as it's written now, I don't know that I can vote do pass.
▶ Play
Would you be okay if we did it on the Senate end? I mean, we had, the chairman and I, we had discussed that beforehand. And I'm not here to try to ramrod anybody, and that is something that I would give my word to take care of. And I believe that the Senate and the folks that I'm working with would do that.
▶ Play
I guess, you know, my concern is you can't guarantee what the Senate end will or won't pass, and my responsibility is to do what's best, you know. I mean, the top priority of the Department of Corrections is to keep their facilities secure. We should do everything we can do to accommodate and respect victims' families, but their first priority is to be sure that the bad people stay in, you know? Right. And I just, I guess, if you're not willing to amend it, I can't vote on it at this time.
▶ Play
So, okay. Okay. Okay, we've come to the end of questions. One point, if there's an amendment put on the Senate and it comes back down here, but, again, what's voted on out of here, so everybody's clear, if the Senate didn't amend it or whatever, then it is what it is, but just as a point of information. I believe we have all the questions for this witness. We've got a couple more signed up to speak on this. We're going to recognize Representative Nate Bell, who has signed up to speak for the bill. Representative Bell, you can take a seat. No need to introduce yourself. Go ahead and make your statement. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members
▶ Play
of the committee. I'm here today not as a representative, but as a citizen of Polk County. a friend of many of the members of this family, and a citizen of the state of Arkansas. I live just a few miles from where Andy Brewer was brutally murdered, raped, and left in the woods to rot by an evil man. I know most of the family members I know Greg Brewer in some of my capacities professionally I've had interaction with some of the family members and I've seen the pain that comes from this situation and the ongoing saga that they've had to deal with now all that's not the responsibility Department of Corrections and I'm not here to say that it is what I am here to ask you all to do is to to carefully consider that this has been going on before this body for a long time. ADC, Department of Corrections, has repeatedly blocked this family from getting what they seek. They've used every trick under the sun to do that. Yesterday, and why I'm sitting here, You all received an email that as a human being, I find so offensive, I can't even find the words to describe it. You see, the person that was mentioned as this out-of-control person is Greg Brewer, this child's father, who sat in a courtroom a few weeks ago and had the murder of his child taunt him continuously until he lost his cool. charge the rail how many of you would have done the same thing I'm a dad of two daughters I ask you to look inside yourself and think about that you've heard arguments today about how ADC can't control people who have a bad incident in their background if they can't they're in the wrong business when you screen someone you know they don't have weapons if you can't control a weaponless human being then you need to get people in your agency who can I've heard the argument today that you that ADC is incapable of controlling an inmate that they can bring in in shackles if they can't do that folks we need different people involved in the process I've heard some arguments today that frankly I just find personally offensive I find the email offensive I can't imagine how these family members feel at this point but as a citizen of the state of Arkansas, the fact that one of our own members in this body, that ADC chose to use a personal family incident, for whatever reason, to try to argue against this case, this bill, is beyond reprehensible, I implore you to pass this bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the
▶ Play
committee. moving back to the list Dr. Mary Parker pass over next on the list Kathy Fry if you would make your way to the end of the table state your name who you're speaking on behalf of
▶ Play
and then you may make your statement my name is Kathy Fry and as of a few weeks ago I am the public information officer for the Department of Correction And I am basically, oh, quivery voice. I simply wanted to say I'm the one who drafted that email. I appreciate the director's ability to sit up here and listen to the criticism. I would like to note that up until two weeks ago, I was a newspaper reporter for 20 years, actually more than 20 years. I deal in facts. if it sounded cold I apologize I was trying to keep the emotion out of it it's what I was trained to do and I did consider myself always to be a compassionate reporter and I feel a great deal of compassion in this case because as a reporter I covered the trial of Miss Petty's daughter's killer. I was there and I heard it all and I saw it all and my attempt at the email I guess was making sure I removed myself from that and if I overachieved on that ground in that way I apologize but it's kind of difficult for me you know I have a background there but I also do represent the department and as a reporter i covered executions i have witnessed them and i understand it is a highly highly charged environment i have sat in there and uh what i would like to make clear is adc if we come across as unsympathetic it is not a lack of sympathy it is the fear of anything happening on our watch on our property we are responsible for the safety of anyone who comes on to the prison grounds and the primary concern in this case is ensuring that we don't have something escalating in an environment that is already so incredibly the inmates are restless. An execution affects everybody who is on the grounds. The security is higher, and it probably seems like a very cold process. Yes, we bus people in. They're searched. They have a state police escort. Everybody is kept separate, and it's not because we're unfeeling and think that nobody should be allowed to move freely. We're just responsible for everyone who is there and I sat in there as a reporter and you are touching I mean you can't not touch someone in that room so I would welcome anyone who wants to come down and look at it I'd be happy to show you be happy to meet with you just so you can kind of see what we have in terms of space we can show you the facilities that we show to representative petty and I'm more than happy to do that at your convenience. Anyway, thank
▶ Play
you very much. Thank you for your statement. We have one final individual who's signed up. Paul Calvert
▶ Play
signed up to speak for the bill. My name is Paul Calvert. Again, I'm from Faulkner County. Ms. Petty came in for the radio show with Dave Ellswick back, what was it, a couple weeks ago now? She told us her story, and it's, I think this is just a kind of a very minimal thing to ask. I mean, it's, we're not even, they're not even asking for full public viewing, which isn't even unreasonable, but this is a very minimal thing to ask for the family to be able to view it. Only six people, that's, that's seemed like a pretty small thing to ask for, for something that should be public as much as a government operation like that. I think it's a good thing to pass, and to me it's not a big deal. Why are people arguing about this? And I find it rather absurd that our public servants are coming down here on our tax money to lobby against decent legislation like this. I come down here, I have to pay for it myself, and they do it with my money. I despise that. Thank you.
▶ Play
Please do pass. Okay, that concludes the list that we had signed up. Representative Petty, do
▶ Play
you want to close for your bill? My intent for this, as you all know, is crime victims. Bottom line, they should have the right to choose how they deal with the last bit of business that their loved one has on this planet. And I sure would appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Scott, you're recognized for a motion. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Do pass, please. Okay, we have a motion. Do pass. And a second. Any discussion? All those in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? The motion passes. It comes out of the committee with a recommendation of do pass. Thank you, Representative Petty. Going back to the regular agenda, House Bill 1180. Representative Vines,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:37:31
you're recognized to present House Bill
▶ Play
1180. Is this going to include jet skis?
▶ Play
Speaker 201 1:37:50
Snowmobiles, jet skis. And while Representative Vines is
▶ Play
making his way to the other end of the table, a couple items of housekeeping. Just a reminder, in House committees, there's no need for a second, so that's why I was initially hesitant to call on that, but hey, why not? I feel better. The other item is, particularly for new members, my trustee assistant here, Rebecca, is paying attention to who's raising their hand for questions. she's making a list here and so just make eye contact with her get her attention and and even though I may not be looking at you she's she's always watching so she'll she'll make sure to get you on the list and I'm trying to work through the list as we talked about the other day one question a follow-up then if you raise your hand again I'm trying to get others who haven't asked to allow their questions and then come back to those who have asked questions And so I think we've done a good job so far. I just wanted y'all to know so that people wouldn't think I was passing over them or not trying to recognize them. Not that I would ever do that. Representative Vines, you're recognized to present House Bill 1180.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee, and I second that. This is a very – I'm happy to bring you House Bill 1180, very basic bill. What this does is includes the term motorboat and adds a definition to the offensive battery in the second degree. I do have a representative from the prosecutors, Mr. John Snyder, that I'm going to let visit and speak with you. And this came about as a request from our prosecutor down in Garland County, as you well know. If you haven't visited lately, I encourage you to do so. But we have lots of lakes and recreational activities. And one of the problems we had with any boating under the influence or any offenses on the lake is there's really nothing on the books to charge when you get into those offenses. So it became a necessity. It might affect you in your districts if you have any lakes, rivers, other waterways, wherever motorboats are utilized. And at this time, I'm going to yield the microphone and floor to my friend, Mr. Snyder, to testify
▶ Play
further. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. members of the committee. My name is John Snyder. I'm a staff attorney with the Office of the Prosecutor Coordinator, and I researched this issue for the prosecutor in Garland County approximately a year ago regarding an issue they had. 5-13-202, the battery in the second degree statute was amended last session two years ago to include a DWI element, and that did not include motorboats at the time. And the purpose for that amendment was to clear up some confusion as to whether a motor vehicle was a deadly weapon in the state of Arkansas. There are a handful of cases which hold that a motor vehicle is a deadly weapon, but there was some confusion in between courts and juries from district to district. And so it was amended to clear that up. In researching this issue, I found that motorboat, as you may not be surprised, is not a motor vehicle by definition. I found zero cases in Arkansas or in the Eighth Circuit holding that a motorboat is or is not a deadly weapon, and I found no Arkansas Attorney General opinions. I found one case in the 11th Circuit, I believe, in Florida. Yes, one 11th Circuit case holding that a motorboat was a deadly weapon, and that was a racing boat. So, currently, if someone causes serious physical injury while operating a boat while intoxicated, it would be up to the fact finder to find that that boat is a deadly weapon, and that could vary from district to district, as I mentioned, and this would create some uniformity. Also, I'd like to add that we polled the prosecutors, and they were unanimously in favor. I'd be glad to answer
▶ Play
Speaker 246 1:42:01
any questions. Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Vines, I think you've got a good bill. I question one term of art, which is motorboat. If I hit you with my jet ski, is this going to apply? Would watercraft perhaps be some kind of wide-open term better suit your purpose? Wonderful question. I'm
▶ Play
going to direct you to line 34 where we reference how we define motorboat, and I'm going to let, I believe, Mr. Schneider read that definition for
▶ Play
us if he has it with him here. Thank you. Motorboat is defined and would be defined under this bill in Arkansas Code Annotated 576-101. It states motorboat means any vessel operated upon water and that is propelled by machinery, whether or not the machinery is the principal source of propulsion, and goes on to state motorboat includes personal watercraft as defined in 27-101-103-10.
▶ Play
Perfect. Representative Bain, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Actually, Representative Broadway's question was my same question. Representative House, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
I was really disappointed that snowmobiles are not included, but motion at the proper time for immediate consideration. Okay We have
▶ Play
nobody else to sign up Representative Vines do you want to close for your bill I just appreciate a Good vote Okay we have a motion do pass from Representative House all those in favor say aye Any opposed Ayes have it Representative Vines you've moved your bill out of committee Successfully With that We have concluded our regular agenda. We still have one bill on the deferred list. I guess as is right now just watch the website and the calendar with regard to future meetings next week. I'm sure we'll have some more bills coming our way. And with that, without objection, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1110

0:21 - 4:28 12 segments 5 speakers

HB1164

4:28 - 43:50 155 segments 24 speakers

HB1012

43:50 - 1:37:53 176 segments 25 speakers

HB1180

1:37:53 - 1:44:18 19 segments 6 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
70 segments
Representative Richard Womack Unverified
5 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
11 segments
Paul Calvert Unverified
4 segments
Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
32 segments
Speaker 24
7 segments
Representative Joe Farrer Chair Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 38
1 segment
Representative Bob Ballinger Chair Unverified
27 segments
Representative Brent Talley Unverified
2 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
2 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
8 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
6 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 85
1 segment
Representative Mary Broadaway Unverified
9 segments
Representative Sue Scott Unverified
5 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Chair Unverified
6 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
12 segments
Robert Combs Unverified
11 segments
Representative Rebecca Petty Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 115
1 segment
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
3 segments
Carla Swanson Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 140
3 segments
Christy Fricker Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 158
38 segments
Representative David Whitaker Unverified
8 segments
Representative Karilyn Brown Unverified
5 segments
Representative John Baine Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 199
1 segment
Speaker 194
1 segment
Speaker 52
1 segment
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
8 segments
Kathy Fry Unverified
6 segments
Chair Unverified
1 segment
Representative John T. Vines Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 201
1 segment
John Snyder Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 246
1 segment