House Education Committtee
Video
Transcript
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
thank you welcome everybody looks like we've got a pretty full house today
I'm going to recognize Mr. Broadway to make an announcement. If you would go to the end, go to
Speaker 13
0:55
the end. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I wanted to come to you today to introduce you to the new director, beginning Monday,
the Arkansas Department of Higher Education, as well as, beginning last Monday, our new Senior Associate Director for Academic Affairs. You probably recognize her, those at the table. Former Representative Ann Clemmer is our new Senior Associate Director of Academic Affairs, and our new incoming director of the Arkansas Department of Higher Education, Dr. Brett Powell. So please welcome them, and I know they look forward to working with each of you. Ann has already began last week.
Cynthia Moten, who was with our agency for 35 years, retired, and so she spent last week with her going over our processes and procedures, and Dr. Powell is going to spend some time with me this week, and then I'll be there on Mondays and Fridays for a little while during the transition to assist the department in any way. But I'll turn it over. Dr. Powell has anything he wants
Speaker 18
2:02
to say by way of introduction? Nothing really. Just looking forward to the opportunity. This is exciting.
I'm looking forward to working with all of you, and I know that there will be many good things to come. So I appreciate the opportunity to do this. Anyone
Speaker 22
2:20
say anything? I'm learning that there aren't very many seats at the back of the room. But I look forward to visiting with you all as you wish. Feel free to contact me. Most of you should still
have my cell number. Thank you. We're excited to see you all coming in, and we're looking forward to working with you,
and especially Ann. I tell you what, it's like you never left. I will. At this time, I'd like to recognize for the Arkansas's for Gifted and Talented Education, Davis Hendrickson. Hendrickson, I'm sorry. I'll get it right. He's got a little bit of some information he'd like to share with us. You're recognized if you would state your name and who you're with for the record, please.
Speaker 31
3:16
Davis Hendrickson with Arkansas for Gifted and Talented Education. Thank you. I have a few just prepared remarks I'd like to share with you, and I think you're getting a handout right now that's got a folder. It has some information about gifted education in Arkansas. I hope that it'll be helpful to you. A number of different little pieces in there that we put together that we thought might be helpful. Certainly, I'm always available. I'm up here almost two or three days a week available. You have my card there. Also, don't hesitate to email me, call me.
anytime if there's questions or concerns about gifted education or education in general because we're not just about gifted kids. We're about rigor in schools. We're about quality education, appropriate education for all kinds of students. I have a few prepared remarks I want to share with you, and then I'll take any questions you have and let you get on with your business this morning. My name is Davis Hendricks. I'm a legislative advocate for AGAT, and I've officially served in that role for the past eight years.
although I've been engaged in the legislative process on behalf of gifted education for the past 25 years. I'd also like to introduce several members of our legislative committee who are with us today. We have Charlotte Green, if you'll stay in Charlotte, who's a GT director in the Conway Public Schools. I have Lynn Harrison Bullard, who's program manager for the Arkansas Advanced Initiative for Math and Science, who's also on our legislative committee, and Aaron Randolph, the GT director for the Cabot School District. These are three of about eight people in Agate who serve on the legislative committee and help me do the work.
As most of you know, there's too much work for one person to do. So these folks are very engaged in the legislative process, believe in it, and we're able to be here this morning to meet you. Our Kansas for Gifted and Talented Education is a nonprofit organization that was created over 30 years ago simultaneously with the state legislative mandate that all public school districts in our state would provide programs specifically designed to meet the needs of gifted and talented students in grades kindergarten through grade 12. In 1979, several visionary legislators with the guidance
of Martha Ann Jones, a parent of a gifted child, passed legislation that would guarantee that academically and creatively advanced students would not be lost in the educational process. Since that time, Arkansas has grown into a leader in the field of gifted and talented education. We are one of only 31 states who have a mandate to provide programs and 21 states who actually fund those programs at some level. Some states it's an unfunded mandate, not in Arkansas. According to last year's data, of the 474,995 students in Arkansas's public schools,
45,759 are identified gifted and talented, or almost 10% of the total population of students. Since funding in Arkansas is based on 5% of each school's student population, you can see that we're serving almost twice the number of students for which we are funded, making gifted education programs a bargain in Arkansas. Over the past year and a half, our committee has researched the statutory history of gifted education and have created a trifold that you'll find in the folder that we provided you, along with a GT at a glance fact sheet, an agate brochure, and agate position statements
that clarify a number of educational terms, strategies, philosophies, and our perspective on some key issues in education. We learned that there are over 29 pieces of legislation over the past 35 years that are related to gifted education in Arkansas and provide the foundation for those programs. We appreciate the support we've received over the years from visionary legislators like Gloria Cabe, Jody Mahoney, Mike Beebe, and the governors from previous administrations who understood that gifted and talented students are special needs students
who deserve appropriate educational services that help them actualize their potential. When we consult the numerous studies that have been done in the past 10 years on dropouts, and the few that attempt to identify the number of dropouts who could be identified as gifted and talented, the spread is between 11 and 20 percent of dropouts that could be identified as precocious or gifted learners. If we use that lower number and apply 11% to the 45,759 gifted students in Arkansas who would not be receiving services if we didn't
have GT programs, we could see as many as 5,033 of them drop out of school. And remember, that's the lower end of that spread. It could be as many as 9,000 students. It is no wonder that your predecessor saw the need for gifted programs and continued to support legislation that would guarantee that Arkansas would never abdicate her responsibility to her gifted students. I must also acknowledge the role that Gifted Ed has played in the establishment of a rigorous standard for all students in Arkansas, along with legislators like Jody Mahoney and Joyce
Elliott and GT educators like the late Tommy Sue Anthony and our own Dr. Ann Robinson have co-authored advanced placement legislation over the last few years that has resulted in Arkansas also being honored recently by college board as a leader in AP programs, both in numbers of minority, numbers of students taking tests and being successful on those tests, as well as numbers of minority students taking and scoring successfully on those tests. The numbers continue to grow each year thanks to the insight of legislators like yourselves and programs
like the Arkansas Advanced Initiative for Math and Science, which some of you helped to sustain through legislation and funding during the last session when the Exxon grant money was exhausted after six years. I wish I could tell you that GT education was continuing to grow and expand in our services to students, but I would be abdicating my responsibility as an advocate if I did not also clarify that the trend in recent years has been to reduce funding for gifted education. In addition to Governor's School, Arkansas used to provide summer programs for motivated students called EGIS programs, stands for academic enrichment for gifted in
summer. For almost 10 years, the state funded two- and three-week residential and day programs for middle and high school students in a variety of content areas, including computer technology, arts and music, ecological camps, math, science, and history institutes, and much more until funding was cut, even though the programs had an exemplary track record and identified Arkansas nationally as a leader in summer educational opportunities for students. Four years ago, the funding for our co-op GT specialist was cut virtually in half and within the past six months
one of only three positions in the department's office of gifted and talented which is responsible for monitoring all 274 GT programs in the state every three years was not renewed when our colleague Bob Nichols retired. In spite of these losses GT programs continue to provide services to our gifted students as our co-op specialists our teachers and administrators do what is necessary to ensure that our students continue to have appropriate educational opportunities in their schools. I'll close by thanking you again for this opportunity and extending an invitation to you to join us at the Agate State Conference on February 26th
at the Marriott Hotel for our luncheon, where we'll honor your own Mark Hudson with Agate Presidential Award for Service to Education in Arkansas. Mark was instrumental in supporting our research into our statutory history and has long been an essential behind-the-scenes resource in the legislative process, and NAGID appreciates his many years of service to the General Assembly. An invitation to that lunch is included in your folder. We will also be co-sponsoring a legislative breakfast with the Arkansas Association of Gifted Education Administrators on Wednesday, February 25th at 7 a.m. in the Capitol Cafeteria.
So you have two opportunities to join us and meet some other members of our organization. I appreciate the time you've afforded us this morning and be glad to entertain
any questions you have. Are there any questions from the
committee? representative douglas you're recognized thank you very much if you could give me a definition of what a gifted and talented program is in a school is does it have to be a pull out where those kids you know if they are mixed in all the grades then you pull those out by grade and have
a special curriculum or can you consider it gifted and talented if they are ability grouped and you have them all in one class. Okay. There's
Speaker 31
11:32
a variety of ways, and within our state guidelines, there's different program models that you can adopt in your school district. The pull-out model is one that's prevalent across the country and certainly has been one that's utilized a lot in Arkansas. But in addition to that, there's a K-2 program that's kind of a standard for the state
in which kindergarten through second grade students receive enrichment from the GT specialist in the school for those three years, and from that grouping, their smaller groups are pulled together to help kids who are disadvantaged or maybe have started school behind to get to a point to where they catch up and actually exceed and are then able to be identified. So there's different models, different ways that it can be done, and certainly there are schools that are using very creative ways to serve kids. The ability grouping approach, you know, there's a difference in ability grouping and tracking,
and that's something we've dealt with in gifted education for a long time. Ability grouping is grouping kids with similar ability for specific educational strategies and opportunities, but it's not meant to be locked in to where they're tracked into those groups for their whole career in education. There should be flexibility between those groups, and, of course, there's some misconceptions about that. So there's a lot of ways to serve kids, a lot of different ways to approach it. Thanks for the question.
Thank you. Two things. Is there an objective definition for determining who's gifted other than allowing a person or someone to indicate that he or she is gifted? I mean, is there an objective definition that's operative in the state? And the reason I ask this is because the standards seem to vary throughout the state,
and there is no uniform definition. Some districts say that anybody who wants to be in a gifted class can. Those persons necessarily do not meet or fit any uniform definition. And that's my first question. The second question is that while it's a feel-good program, do you have any objective reports, evaluations,
which show that gifted students do any better in life or otherwise than ordinary students. Anything based on empirical research over our 30 years here in Arkansas, other than by segregating the students and sending them to the math school, where you know they're going to be successful because you have the plethora of support and you have them carefully culled on the basis of AP scores and on the basis of IQ.
I'd just like to know just what it is that requires this other than that some people like it and want to have their children so labeled. Good questions, and
Speaker 31
14:59
thanks for asking those questions. First off, there is within the standards which were created almost 30 years ago when we established Gifted Ed and the mandate in Arkansas, there is a standard definition. It's kind of based on the Renzulli three-ring approach of an interaction of three things. Task commitment, which is usually measured by how kids do in the classroom on an extended basis
and how well they do on the things they're interested in, and task commitment about those things that they care about. Above-average creativity and above-average ability is measured by a test. Those are three things. In Arkansas, we don't have a cutoff score, whereas in some states, if you score 129, then you're not in the gifted program. If you score 130 on an IQ test, you are. Arkansas, we use a case study approach, which is multiple criteria, which a committee of teachers who are trained in the school by the GT facilitator in that school
with information about Arkansas's definition of gifted or what you're looking for. They take applications from all the kids. Any kid can recommend even himself for a gifted program, as you said. If you want to be, you can, but that screening committee has to approve and place the student based on the resources that that school has to offer. And the reason it's a case study approach is because in a school that doesn't have the resources to provide, say, a quality dance reinforcement for a creatively gifted dancer,
it would be pointless to get identified for a gifted program for which there's no resources to enhance that area of giftedness. So in Arkansas, yes, sir, we do have a standard definition that served us for a long time. It's recognized across the country as being one that's more inclusive because of the fact that it's a case study approach. Now, honestly, that identification process is only as good as the training of the people on that committee, how well they understand the different ways that gift news manifests itself in different populations and different groups,
as well as different socioeconomic groups. So there's a lot of education that goes into that, and we're learning more about that every day and certainly apply it. But our standard has held for a long time. Now, your second part of your question is as far as a longitudinal study, there's not been one done, and there needs to be one done. I heartily agree with you that it's hard to really quantify some of the benefits that kids receive from being in the program. Some of the benefits kids receive from being in a gifted program are affective needs being met,
and some people have questioned me and said, well, isn't that where you just tell gifted kids they're better than everybody else? Absolutely not. What we try to get gifted kids to understand affectively is that, number one, there's nothing wrong with being different. You do learn differently from other people, and that's okay. We also try to help them understand their gift is a gift and that they should be aware of that and they should be thankful for it and they should understand that everybody has gifts of some kind, different kinds. And that's kind of a generally accepted affective approach in Arkansas.
So some of the benefits of gifted programs I think are hard to quantify, but I will agree with you that some of the aspects of it certainly can be quantified and we need longitudinal studies done in the state. Unfortunately, I'll be very frank with you, sometimes gifted education in some states just fight to defend their right to exist and that leaves very little energy left to be proactive about doing the kind of studies that you're talking about. But I agree with you. We should do more of that and I would welcome that in the state of Arkansas.
Representative Letting, you are recognized Thank you,
Mr. Chair, and I will be very brief You referenced the Aegis program in your opening remarks I did not participate in that program, but a number of my close friends did and they loved it, they talk about it fondly Can you explain briefly why funding was cut and is that something we might be able to get started again
Speaker 31
18:57
in the future? Nothing would thrill me more Yes, that was during a series of cuts the Department of Education were making cuts I think it was during Ray Simon's term, I'm pretty sure.
I look at some of my other colleagues that have been here as long as I have. And it was necessitated by cuts, and certainly that happens sometimes. We think about what do we cut. Well, let's look at things that don't serve as many kids. Unfortunately, you know, those kids that were used to those programs missed them and certainly put Arkansas on the map in the field. And here's another thing about the Aegis programs. I ran 18 of those programs. I ran two some summers in a row, one at the National Center for Toxicological Research in Jefferson
where we brought 15 high school science students in and let them work for three weeks with some of the Ph.D. level scientists in that program and learn about that field and understand more and more about bacteriology and toxicology and chemistry and et cetera. Another one was an arts program that we ran, both in four different areas of arts, music, art, creative writing, and theater. And those programs, we were not real strict about it.
If kids had a real high degree of aptitude in those areas and a lot of interest in those areas, they didn't have to have already been identified as gifted and talented in their school programs. We were a little more loose about it. So those programs served a lot of kids. They certainly served a lot of gifted kids, but I know our program served kids who just had high aptitude in those areas but may have not been actually identified as gifted and talented. Great programs. Love to see them come back. Would certainly entertain any support we could get for that.
Well, I know they made a huge difference in a lot of people's lives, so I'd like to visit with you sometime soon.
Thank you. I look forward to that. Thank you. Any other questions? Thank you committee and thank you Mr. Hendricks for coming and sharing that with us today Thank you so much for the time. Appreciate it. We look forward to seeing some of you at the Agate conference At this time I'd like to recognize my co-chair Representative Lampkin for anything she'd like to say today No comments today she said
Alright at this time we are going to get started If you haven't signed in on to speak for or against a bill and you want to, I'm going to open that for just a little bit. You'll just have to come up here and sign in to see Mark. And at this time, we are going to start with SB94. Representative Collins, you are recognized to present SB94.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and good morning, committee. A couple months ago, a friend of mine called me. Her name is Andrea Fournay. She's known as the yoga lady in Fayetteville. She actually did a yoga show on public broadcasting for many years. And she shared with me that the State Board of Private Education that summer had made a move to include yoga teacher training instruction as a regulated activity under their career instructor mandate.
And the state was looking to impose fees on the order of $2,000 a year on yoga training instructors as well as setting other standards and things for this activity. Andrea herself, over the last 14 years, has trained over 100 yoga instructors. There's a private group known as the Yoga Alliance. It's a national organization. It is the organization that has set standards for teacher training, credentials, things of that nature, and yoga trainers pay fees to that group, and frankly, it's a system that's been working very well.
Since the state board is focused on vocational training, that's their mandate. Yoga instructors don't make a living teaching yoga. This is an avocational, a recreational, a spiritual, a health and exercise-oriented activity. And the way that they make sure that the training happens properly follows the guidelines of the private national organization.
So in a nutshell, we don't need to have the state board expanding their purview to cover this type of training. It doesn't fit with their vocational mandate, and these kinds of fees and things of this nature would be putting all of these training schools out of business. The teachers that learn yoga are not making money doing it. It's for those recreational and avocational reasons, and that's what SB94 does,
and it also identifies a couple other activities that are very similar, dance, music, horseback riding, sewing, knitting, and other needle crafts as fitting in the same category, so we don't need to come again and again with each one of these. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'm happy to answer any questions.
Representative Letting, you are recognized. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Collins, for running this bill. I also had some conversations with Andrea.
I know it'll mean a lot to the yoga teachers. I do think the state, trying to impose itself on yoga teachers is a bit of a stretch.
Would you not agree? Yes. Motion at the proper time. I will remind the committee that we do one question and you have to ask for a follow-up, please. I'm just going to put that back out there to remind you.
Representative Douglas, you'll recognize. Yes. Odd that you would remind, you know, that before my question.
So the statement in your bill where you specify this subchapter does not apply to a school or training program that offers only a vocational or recreational instruction, could that be stand-alone? And then you've gone on to specify a few. my question is if you wanted to teach riflery or if you wanted to teach whatever it is
roping that would fit under your avocational you're making
a wonderful point Representative Douglas my belief is that if we do this the way we've got it we'll be okay but you and I will team up if this board thinks what What that does is overly limit as opposed to actually allow an expansive interpretation. So I agree with you, and if what we're finding is the State Board is abusing this language, then I'll make it.
They can't do squat. Thank you very much. Are there any other questions? Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are we dealing with public school students eligible to be in public
schools with this bill? I'm not an expert in yoga teacher training, but usually these are private yoga studios.
Normally, teachers come from the ranks, people that go and learn yoga, enjoy yoga, enjoy the culture, enjoy the exercise. They then want to learn more about it and become better and then get this teacher training. So it's really more like a hobby is the way I would describe it for a lot of folks for spiritual exercise and other reasons. This is not in schools, as I understand it, public schools. Follow it, Mr. Chair. You're recognized.
Thank you. And so the teachers of these students will not be providing grades to them which will be capable of being converted to grade point averages that will help qualify them for state benefits? Correct.
The credentials come from the Yoga Alliance organization, and they're about doing yoga correctly, not injuring yourself,
getting the benefits from it and so on.
Thank you. Do we have any other questions from the committee? At this time, we have testimony from the audience, and we have for and against testimony, and I'm going to start with Chris Comer from the State Board of Private Career Ed and against the bill. please state your name and who you're with
Speaker 89
28:10
for the record please yes sir mr. chair i appreciate you let me have come here my name is christopher comer and i'm the chairman of the state board of private career education you're recognized thank you sir i also have here with me uh brenda german who is our director of the state agency. The first point that I want to make as we come to this committee hearing is I want to point out that the purpose of our agency is for the student protection,
to protect the students who are going to private schools within the state of Arkansas who are not covered by another licensing agency or licensing board to ensure that they get a proper education, that they have proper rights and that those rights are properly executed when these students do have problems, which do often arise. Secondly, we also protect the schools who are operating in an ethical, responsible manner, the schools who come out here and who are following the rules,
the schools who are not like many of the massage areas that we see here in Little Rock right now, the ones who are out there actually following the law, following what needs to be done, and working in an ethical manner. We protect them from students who come and bring frivolous accusations against some things of that nature. And I appreciate the comment earlier that this may be a stretch to talk about yoga here. And I'll assure you, I have no intent and no desire to attempt to regulate yoga instructors themselves.
I don't want to come into your gym. We have no desire to license the instructor in your gym. In fact, if you want me looking at your yoga stuff, I'm about as good as the Aflac duck is on its commercial. But what we do want to do is we want to clear up the misinformation that's been provided, apparently, to some members of our General Assembly, some misinformation that's being provided to the media, and ensure that this is cleared up so that you understand what the actual issues are. My time as a military officer in the United States Air Force, we had three parts of our core values,
integrity, service before self, and excellence in all that we do. I don't have time to provide what this agency does to provide all three of those, but I do want to talk about integrity. We have been given many different scare tactics from an outside lobbying group, a special interest group that is coming in and trying to indicate that we are concerned about horseback riding, that we are concerned about needle craft, that we are concerned about dance studios, and even brought up in one of our committee hearings or one of our hearings that we were concerned about Sunday schools. I can assure you
none of these have come across my desk or across Ms. Garman's desk is something we're concerned about. What we are specifically discussing are schools who are advertising themselves as a higher education to enhance or create a career for people to go and open yoga studios. That is a business activity. It is an activity that is not avocational in nature when you stop and you look at these. We also have a provision in our law currently to exempt any school that believes
that it's avocational in nature. When presented with this information, when we had our hearing ourselves in December, the alliance that came before us asked us to do your job. They asked us to write law. They said, we want you to change the law to say we are exempt. We did not overstep our bounds in any way. We simply said we do not have the power of the legislature. We execute the laws that are given to us. We inform them we do have a manner for you to come forward and say
that you're avocational in nature. It's two pages, two pages, not $2,000 for a license. It's two pages. If in fact your particular school has come here and is actually doing advocational in nature just to make somebody a, I don't know what you call the highest level of yoga, but a black belt in yoga, you fill out a two-page form. And we routinely examine those forms and we do approve those forms throughout the industry. The question becomes the ones that are actually out here so
that people can have a vocation, so that people can earn extra money. Why do I talk about student protection so much? Because while I've been on this board, I have seen people come forward, students who have come forward, they were required to make $1,500 additional purchases for equipment that they could buy online for $300, the exact same equipment, brand new. The student handbook that this school had said, you don't have to do this.
But yet when it came time for this person to graduate, you had asked about graduation earlier and grade point averages. When it came time for them to graduate from the school, they were denied graduation because they still owed $1,400 or $1,500. Our board helped refund some of those funds to this student so that they could transfer to another school. They could complete their education. and we protected them from that. We've had case after case where these things happen. We also would like to point out one of the things that we like to do as a board is we also look at
the people who come in to these schools and own these schools. We do background checks. It's part of the requirement is to do a background check if you come in and you apply for a license. We want to make sure that we don't have sex predators out there opening different schools and bringing people in under the guise of you're going to get an education, and we have caught numerous felonious crimes that have been committed by different instructors. Now, I'm not specifically talking of yoga, but I am talking of different schools. So the purpose here, or my purpose here,
is number one, we don't need to add anything to the law. The law already allows exemption from the majority of these and allows exemption for the yoga schools if they'll simply fill out a two-page form. Secondly, I want to point out that multiple schools in the state have already agreed with us and have contacted us and told us they would like to be licensed. They would like to have the protection that we do offer to the schools and they have formally applied for it
and we, I believe, will have a hearing ourselves here in a couple of weeks or a few weeks and we'll probably be looking at these particular licenses. So even within their own organization, there's not agreement. Um As we go forward, I would like to ask that we that I would love to see that we not pass this through committee. We don't need to have this change here, but at the very least give give opportunity to speak on behalf of the students here to speak on
behalf of the of the ethical of the ethical school and stop being pushed by an outside group who has openly threatened our agency and has gone so far as to request that our budgets be stopped and held up for the for those of you probably lean more in my direction on this I like small government and I like less spending I would like you to know that we do not get general revenue from the legislature. Our revenue is generated through the license and fees that we have,
so we are not a drain on your resources. And at the same point, the last point I want to make is we've also specifically asked these yoga schools and we've asked some of these instructors if the fee amount was a burden to them. One of the schools said, yes, I charge $2,000 per student, which sounds a little less like a hobby to me, but we charge $2,000 per student, but we only do a handful of students per year. So guess what? If they come in with a $10,000 revenue for the year
and we're charging $2,000 for a fee, absolutely. We agree. That is too much. And we have also begun the process of discussion of how we can better be representative without being overly burdensome. So to say that this board is attempting to go outside of its bounds, to say that we have any ideas of grandeur with it. I would just assume you all have never heard of the State Board of Private Career Education because we're quietly doing our jobs as we have for several years. But I think that this matter is important enough that somebody needs to take a stand
and somebody needs to stop this and somebody needs to stand for the state of Arkansas and for Arkansans and not for the outside interests. I appreciate your time, Mr. Chairman. Are there
any questions, committee? Representative Harris, you're recognized. Thank
But this is the time. You do have time to tell us what you do as a state board, because you are a state board.
I just want to make that clear, but I don't want you to go into that right now. and welcome to the club of threats and different thing. We get it all the time in hearing from people. But in this case, maybe we're on the side of protecting the people and not necessarily you. But I want to ask the question for this particular yoga instructor. I think the question is concerning the definition of a private residence or a school.
Is that the question this show, so I can be clear in voting on this, is she running a school inside a
Speaker 89
38:19
private residence or can you answer that? Yes, sir, I can absolutely answer that. We have absolutely no idea because they have not approached us as anyone individually. We have only been approached to change the entire law on that. We have not been spoken to. they provided some limited testimony in front of us.
Follow-up. Thank you. So we're going to impose something that we haven't even known about, a $2,000 licensing fee that we're not sure. We
Speaker 89
38:55
haven't attempted to impose. We haven't made a decision to impose. We have never been asked the question about imposition of any license. the question that was asked to us was a school that has tuition of this amount about how much
would a license cost. So I believe the original one was $2,000 per student. I think it was actually $1,500 if I recall. I was actually just mimicking there, but no, we have not looked at the case of one single school at this time. We do have a few that have request licensure, however, and we will be reviewing those. That's why I believe it's a little premature to change an entire law.
I think this is just making an exception for this one or for the yoga.
Any other questions? Representative Bell, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I heard something that got my attention when you started talking to us about, well, this doesn't take any of your money. We don't have money. State general revenue belongs to the people. There are two ways to spell tax, TAX and FEE, and they have the same end result and same impact on the people of this state.
It's the state taking money away from the private system. So I'm troubled by your perspective that somehow a fee is not a burden on the public or on private enterprise. So I just want to start with, preface my comments with that, because it goes a little further into your philosophy. and you've indicated somehow that it's perfectly okay for the state to demand that someone file a two-page form to engage in their occupation without the heavy hand of the state interfering in their ability to do business.
I have a problem with that. If they're not trampling on someone else's right, why should the state demand that they file a form to engage in private enterprise? You touched on background checks and the fact that they're required for people in private that run a lot of these private schools. I'm familiar with one that I personally have to work with in one of my professional occupations.
And there are many things in the background of one of the people who runs that that are unsavory at best. and yet they continue to be licensed so I guess the the whole background check thing rings a little hollow with me could you elaborate a little bit on the level of protection that's there and what you do with those background checks well if I may if I could address the
Speaker 89
41:50
first couple of points there and then I'll get Ms. Gurman to talk more to the background checks if that's okay
first and foremost I think you and I probably agree on a lot more than you would ever imagine as far as coming to taxes and fees. My point of making that earlier was we were threatened with our budget, as in we're just going to shut you down by withholding your budget. So my point was, well, we are not trying to go out and grab general funds. It was being withheld. I do agree that fees are taxes, and I do agree I would love to see fees lowered. I'm excited about
what's going on in the state of Arkansas. You and I agree on those, and I apologize if that didn't come through in what I'd said earlier. When it comes to coming in and filling out a two-page form or not, the question that I begin to see here, or the question that I have, is at what point do we say we will no longer offer any student protection to any student anywhere? We can use the same argument for any fee.
I sell insurance. I have a life insurance license. Well, I'm paying a fee in order to have a license. There's a board that oversees my licensure and ensures that I stay within the bounds of the law on licensure. So would I like to have that fee go away? Absolutely. Would I like not to have to fill out the forms to get that? I absolutely would, but it's required. Some of these schools, however, blur the line on whether or not they're providing any vocation. There are yoga studios out there.
There are people who go out and open yoga studios and run it as a business, which would, in fact, be a career. So we're looking at education for those. There are possibly some out there. And like I said, we're just asking to hear it. And we're asking for any of the schools to explain to us what they're doing. And by all means, if they're doing an advocational act here, we will exempt them. We have no problem with that. So we're not, you know, I guess that's how I look at it.
We want to lower the fees to make sure that they're not egregious. We certainly do. But we don't, but at the same point, we don't want to go out there and just start guessing, well, who doesn't have to pay, who does have to pay from the standpoint of blanket statements out there? And we certainly don't have that ability. You know, I can't rewrite the law. The law says if it's vocational or if it's advocational. All I'm asking is to have the ability to speak to the schools
and see if they're going to do this in a vocational manner or an advocational. Honestly, from many of the questions I've heard asked, it sounds like most of them would probably be advocational. but in order to say that you know we would just need to see some documentation just to know hey you're advocational we're done but what about the school that's out there not doing it applicationally that is doing it vocationally who's watching the students there and I will say the one point that was made in a previous conversation someone said we'll just let them
go sue well many of these people are working multiple jobs they have kids at home that they don't have an attorney. They don't have the money to hire an attorney, don't know how to go to court in order to do that. So they have no other recourse, but to, you know, to correspond with us and we've helped them. So, you know, I hope that clarifies that I don't want to come across that. I don't think fees are taxes and that, uh, that I think this is trite and what we're doing. I agree with y'all on that or those that do agree and a hundred percent agree. And I
want to see lowering, but at the same time, I want to make sure we have some protections out there And I believe Ms. Gurman can probably answer better on
Speaker 119
45:48
the backgrounds. I'm familiar with your background and what fields you're licensed in. Could you state your name for the record, please? I'm Brenda Gurman, the director of the State Board of Private Career Education. The person that you're talking about does not own the school, and owners are who we check. We do have an investigation going on right now in the situation you're talking about.
and as soon as all this legislative stuff's over, I'll get back to doing that investigation. So that's what the answer is to that one. They don't coincide. The definition of a school is someone that offers training that leads to or enhances occupational qualifications. We don't go into whether it's full-time and part-time. My question would be if we're going to put yoga, then the next time we send out a letter to someone are y'all going to say well no you're
overstepping your bounds and yoga doesn't fall under this group doesn't fall under it either so you know that makes it very difficult for us we had two meetings with the yoga instructors of these 12 schools they were going great until yoga alliance got contacted yoga alliance is making a move to go to every state in the United States that's trying to make yoga be licensed or request that they be licensed because they meet this definition in all the states.
So that's where it's come from. Our fees are based on a sliding scale. It's based on what you charge one person to attend school. We have worked with them on things. We want tuition and registration fees. We're not interested any lab fees or anything like that. We've worked with them on how they can lower their fee to our board. But there aren't very many boards that do that kind of thing. So that's where our concern is. It's what's going to be the next step and who's going to be next that we don't need to be
licensed. There's never been a school that got licensed that planned on closing. But they do close. And when they close, you've got students left out here without their education. That's also a big part of what we do. We can take them, put them in another school because bottom line we want them to get educated. That's what they went to school for. So we can take them and put them in another school. We can use our student protection fund to pay that school to complete their training. No additional expense to the student or if we can't find a school in their area that will
take them, we can refund the money that the school has not earned up to this point. So I think, like Chris said, there are a lot of things that this leads to, and we're just talking about yoga and the stretching and all that. This is a very important thing. I've done it almost 30 years, and I can tell you lots of stories. All
these sort of things, you know, everything we do here requires balance.
whenever we place a burden on private enterprise there should always be a compelling public interest i'll just be honest with you as i consider this bill i don't see the the compelling public interest in licensing yoga trainers at all that's the whole philosophical discussion but where is the compelling public interest in you forcing them to fill out this form help me understand that I just don't I don't see a compelling public interest yes sir I think the
Speaker 89
49:20
the first part there is we're not asking yoga instructors individual yoga instructors to be licensed it's not them at all it is these schools the public I'm sorry I misstated that I do understand that yes sir well it has been one of the probably the most confusing parts of this conversation because we get a lot of phone calls the other direction on that so we're looking specifically at these schools only and the compelling public interest here is the protection of the student the bottom line is we're we're taking people in who trust in these schools to be there to trust in these schools to do what they're supposed to do and to educate them and
provide prepare them for some type of vocation or an enhancement to the vocation that they're in and you believe there's
a significant problem in arkansas with that being misused we have seen a problem with
Speaker 89
50:05
other schools who have misused that in the past yes in these subject areas in the subject area of yoga we have not had a yoga school come before us before so we have not had one in yoga however if we look at the avocational sides of it it's still avocational it the parts that
are avocational would not come before us anyway we'd only be
talking about these schools thank you mr. chair are there any other questions thank you for your presentation and now i have one that would like to speak for, that would be John Emmons. John's off. He doesn't want to speak for it. I have one more, I believe, that is against Trey Campbell. You are recognized to speak against this.
If you would, recognize yourself when you sit down and you
may proceed. Hello. This is my first time doing this, so I'm kind of nervous my name is william robert campbell the third but that's a mouthful so i just go by tray um i am 21 years old i turned 22 in a couple of weeks um i'm just a concerned citizen i'm not trying to cause any problems i just wanted to voice my concerns whenever i found out about this
law i wanted to make the two and a half drive up here this morning so i could voice those concerns I am at the age where I am trying to further my education, and my brother, who's my roommate that lives with me, is also at that age where he's trying to further his education, as are the many teenagers that I work with in my youth group. We have two seniors that are going to graduate this year. They are fixing to start furthering their education, and the way this is worded, no, I don't think any of you would think that I'm trying to further my education in yoga based on my size,
but it's not just yoga that's involved in this. There are many other topics and areas that are trying to be affected by this law, and I'm just worried about student protection because if something happens, if there's a dispute with me or my brother or these teenagers or our families, we can't afford to hire attorneys or lawyers. I don't even know how to fill out a lawsuit. I would have no idea how to go about that. It's just I'm worried about our teenagers and our kids in Arkansas having student protection.
Again, it's not just yoga that's involved in this. There's dance and music and all these other different areas that if I were to decide that I wanted to go into a school and take classes and something happens and I can't finish for various reasons and they refuse to refund me my money, then I won't have any sort of protection. And I just want to say three more things that make sense to me as just a citizen, not as a lawyer or a politician or anything. Number one is that if I'm going to go to a school, no one that I know of that is going to go to a school my age
would ever want to go to one that's not licensed because there's very little chance of getting a job from an unlicensed school in the first place. Number two is that, I'm sorry, give me one second. Again, I'm very nervous. There's a lot of people in this room. number two is that if this gets passed it's not just the yoga alliance
that people are going to get outraged with it's also going to be the people in this room that decide to pass this again just from what I see there's not a whole lot of headaches that they're going to get I think all the headaches that are going to come up is you thank you so much and I can't remember my third one but I promised it was going to be good thank you are there any questions on the committee I would love them
seeing no questions thank you for your testimony thank you I do not have anybody else on the list for for or against Charlie would you like to close for that bill
thank you Mr. Chair sorry Representative Collins thank you very much You know, when I got that call from the yoga instructor about the over-regulation that she was looking at dealing with,
I kind of chuckled to myself a little bit. And when she told me that Senator Lindsey was picking up this mantle because of how surprised and disappointed he was at the situation, I kind of chuckled a little, frankly. The meetings that the earlier speakers mentioned were going so well were anything but. They were completely one-sided.
The people that talked to me felt their voice was completely dismissed, disregarded. And so what I'm going to call the technicality that we're discussing here of the difference between avocational and vocational is whether or not you receive money. So if you receive $1, you are vocational if somebody wants to get technical, and it's a job.
The example that I believe his name was Mr. Campbell used, somebody has $10,000 of revenue coming in per year, and a 20% regulatory fee on that perhaps was egregious and could be reduced. when for the past umpteen years yoga instructors in arkansas were just doing their thing and doing it fine with no problems anywhere and they had self-organized under a national group like many
other private groups self-organized and it was a clear situation of it ain't broke we don't need to fix it. But, as he pointed out, technically, they receive over $1, over $1 in revenue. Therefore, it is a business, it's not a hobby, with $1 in revenue. So that's why we're here. Because that was about as much give and take and about as much cooperation as could be had with
this board from the people that came to me. Afterwards, the yoga alliance got involved after that. So this bill passed overwhelmingly in the Senate. It makes a lot of sense. If we start having massive problems with yoga instructors being incompetent, losing their money, with students not able to get proper yoga instruction, with yoga instructor schools abusing their students with all kinds of other problems i'm very happy to revisit this and look
at it again but that's not the situation here this is something that these people have been doing for many years and it's working just fine it ain't thick it ain't broken we don't need to fix it and i would appreciate a good vote mr chair what are the wishes of the committee representative harris I make a motion
for do pass. I have a motion to do pass.
Any discussion on that? If not, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, no. The ayes have it. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. All right. At this time, we will call on. Senator Hester, Representative Dodson and Senator Hester are going to present SB 76.
And there is an amendment to that bill, so they will be presenting an amendment first. And we will pass that out. If you all would just hold your presentation and we get this amendment passed out, then we will let you begin at that time. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is a... Here we go, sir.
Rep. Dotson, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have with me Senator Hester today, Senate Bill 76. This bill is a – we've got a little amendment we would like to put on here, If we could start with that, the change is the last line of the bill, line number 35,
takes out the 10% that's on the last line and substitutes two students per day. That's all the amendment does. Are there any questions on
the amendment? I need a motion to adopt the amendment. I have a motion from Representative Bell. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed? Motion
carries. You may discuss your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senate Bill 76, as amended, basically what this does fairly simplistically is allows flexibility at the local district level
for classroom sizes that are at the maximum level at or below the beginning of a semester to increase that by no more than two students per day through the remainder of that semester. So if they do exceed that by more than one or two students over the course of that semester, they can't. They're still limited by that. They can't do that more than once per school year.
So at the end of the semester, they would still have to go back and no teacher would be affected, no classroom would be affected, by more than one semester for that particular school year. I'm not sure if Senator Hester has anything to add
to that. If I could, I think the important part of every time a bill is presented is hopefully we're trying to correct a problem or prevent a problem. Anyone that's worked in the school system from administration down to teachers
understand that classroom size is a very pivotal part of education. The problem that we are attempting to correct here is when you have your classroom sizes are made up, say we take a very rural school district that only has one third-grade class, and they're at 25 students' capacity, and I don't know if it's 25 or 23, but they're at capacity. They only have one class in the school district. If they have one child show up extra, then according to the current law, immediately they have to become compliant so they have to go hire a teacher in the middle of the
semester find another classroom size maybe they get another or find another classroom location say they get another classroom location hire another teacher and then a child moves out and so all this is doing is saying we understand that there is a real problem that schools on a large large school district like Bentonville that I that me and representative Dotson represent that are growing or very small districts that face on a regular basis. I think the real question here is what do you think schools do currently that face this problem?
I think the answer is they enroll the children. They probably get a reprimand from the state. They don't deny children being able to come to school. This is something that I would say a vast majority of schools already do, if not all of them. This is very important to Bentonville because our school district, he doesn't want to be noncompliant to the law. So he just asked for a little bit of flexibility just until semester and to be able to correct that at semester.
Representative Armstrong, you're recognized. Could not you ask for
a waiver? I think that's a great question. You can ask for a waiver. The problem is you have a student shows up on Tuesday to enroll into class. Testimony from the Senate end could be that it could be four or five weeks until you can get a waiver. Do you not allow that child to attend school for four or five weeks until you get your waiver in? The reality is the child needs to be in school immediately when they enroll. We have to try to find a way to have some flexibility
to make sure that child's in
class. Thank you. Representative
Douglas, you're recognized. I am very much in favor of giving schools flexibility and having local autonomy to make these decisions. My fear is that this is a fiscal problem that schools face in hiring a teacher.
we're addressing this in a fiscal way instead of an academic way the academics caring for the kids and caring for what happens in the classroom I think teachers if they're consulted they would solve this in a much different way putting two more students into a classroom that has an autistic child,
has two or three kids with a 504 that you're having to accommodate, it's kids that are pulled out, and then you say, take on two more kids just for a month or two. I fear what we're going to do is we're going to substitute our desire to have the best academic delivery for those children in lieu of the school district not wanting to hire
or put an aide in that classroom or have a traditional or a transitional class that they could, you know, if your school district is trending up and you're growing, you should have smaller class sizes to accommodate those students. So my question is, is this going to become the go-to solution instead of other things that could be a better academic fit
for kids that are in classrooms that have too many kids in them? I
think that's a great point and I think your question is should we not look at adding an aid or creating another class with the children's best interest at mind and I think the other thing you brought up was physical impact and the reality is education is you guys will fight this fight far more than I will the reality is we are under physical restraints in education they get a majority of our budget but they're simply not enough
So this just allows the school district a little bit of flexibility in that district, but point made is very well taken. Thank you.
I recognize my vice chair for a question.
Speaker 173
1:06:57
My question is, you mentioned before that in a case like some cases they can get a waiver, and then you said, but four weeks is too long. So what are schools doing now? You know I think that's the
That's the question at hand And that's the purpose for this bill The reality is I believe school districts Are just being non-compliant with law And if this doesn't pass They can continue to be non-compliant I don't think it's a realistic expectation That they're going to hire a school teacher Seven weeks into school The availability of an appropriate school teacher Is a lot of times not an option Would
Speaker 173
1:07:35
you not think that being Non-compliant with a law might not be setting a very good example for our kids i understand where you're coming from but i i agree
with with representative douglas i'm concerned that this is beginning of just taking adding every time we have an extra problem add another one to some teacher and i think you really another student some teacher's class and i think you really have maybe to be in that classroom to understand what you're doing schools are very very experienced in shifting funds here and there? Maybe they should try whatever they're doing now that might be within the law, like shifting some funds.
You know, we have a constant problem with adequacy with being a funding formula and a spending formula. So maybe my question would be, why are we advocating maybe, well, if we don't do this, they can just break the law? Why can't we advocate they find a way, you know, for one or two students? And if it's more than that, maybe we need to hire another teacher. Representative Douglas is right. If you get one maybe autistic child or one special need child and then you add two more to it,
it's really a burden for them. And we want to incentivize and keep our good teachers too. I think that's part of our mission. We talk about losing good teachers or not being able to get good teachers. These are why we overburden them with special needs children, and no one minds having them. But still, if you keep adding a couple more and a couple more every year because it's convenient for somebody's budget, maybe they need to shift their budget there a little bit. Would you not agree? Representative
Lampkin, I certainly agree, and I think your point is well taken.
You go back to the point of we understand that we have a problem. I'm presenting a solution that I think is appropriate. You may have another solution
that would be appropriate as well. Representative Duffenbaum, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Well, I've got two questions. Number one, have y'all – all right, let's just say before you solicited any advice or any input, had you seen or heard this situation much?
I mean, did it come up – I mean, what brought this to the table? I mean, did y'all, have you talked to, was it a lot of problem in several school districts? That's what I'm getting at. I think it's a problem in my
school district. And to be very frank with you, I don't vote with my superintendents very often. And I was trying to work with them on something that I felt like I could help them with. And, you know, my father is a public school superintendent. And, like I said, I'm trying to find a way to work with my superintendents more
because, like I said, I don't vote with them as
often as I should. Thank you. One more. You're recognized. All right. Well, what about have you heard of any situations where school districts have had to add a teacher? I mean, say, for instance, your dad. I never have seen that, but maybe, you know, I was talking to Representative Gossage. In a smaller school, it might happen. I never saw it happen over, you know, a student coming to school in mid-semester. So I'm just curious if you've seen that or heard of that situation.
Right. I think it goes back to the root of this problem. The law says they should do that, but the reality is we don't do that because of the logistics and the ability to start a new class in the middle of the semester. All right, thank
you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Mr. Chair, thank you. May I inquire of Mr. Tony Woods for my question? Mr. Hernandez is here,
but Mr. Woods is not. Is that going to be all right? Take what I can get.
Commissioner, Department of Education Thank you, may I begin?
You all have at your disposal the tool of giving warnings and other advisories to school districts which exceed class size.
Is there any data that we can see which represents the number of school districts which have been sanctioned for having exceeded class size in the last several years? I believe that's something we can produce, yes, sir. You can produce. Has that been something that's been presented to the State Department of Education in a report that's available to the public, as far as you know?
On a yearly, maybe it might be more beneficial to the committee if I kind of described the process about
how it would come about that this would become a problem for a school district. Well, before you do, Senator, here's my observation, if I may, Mr. Chairman, is that only a few districts get advisories for having exceeded class sizes. And the other concern that I have is that in large districts like the one which Senator Hester,
to which he refers, it's seldom that where you have multiple classes at a particular grade level, Each one of them is at the optimum level. I mean, you may have 28 in one, 29 in another, if there's a 30 maximum, but seldom do you do that. And school districts all the time go over or above for a short while, and the State Department does not get involved in that. Is it fair to say that you all don't get involved in that situation on a routine basis? On a routine basis, no, sir.
There is a, again, if I was able to describe the process, that might make a
lot of clarity. Well, I understand you, but I mean, my point is that it hasn't been a problem for the State Department, sufficient to suggest that the department would take it up in a board meeting or suggest or initiate litigation, legislation. So it has to be sort of like private litigation. And I want to apologize to Senator Hester because I told him I had a doctor's appointment and I wouldn't be here to ask these questions.
It turned out that I was a day early for my appointment, and I apologize. But now I've looked at this, and I see that you have four levels you can do of advisories. One is advisory, and another is warning. Am I wrong about that? There are different ways that you address a problem if it becomes a problem. Representative, you're on your last question right there. Thank you, and that was the last one, but I'd like an answer.
With regards to that, whenever there's something that violates the standards of accreditation, which this clearly would as far as class size, there's a citation or there is a probationary violation. As far as the probationary violations, those are the ones that all are reported to the State Board, but the ones that are most serious in nature that have a lot of effects for school districts are the probationary violations. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Gossage, you're recognized.
I think I'll have a question by the time I finish, but I've done this type of work specifically in dealing with schedules for about 20 years. I was a school counselor and made schedules for 13 years, and I was a high school principal in the central office. I'm very familiar with the tasks that schools are faced with, and what you typically have at the beginning of the school year you have all your kids on your roll who were there the last year you have new kids who come and enroll over the summer who show
up the first week of school but you'll have any number of students that don't show up and you don't know if they're coming or not they're on your roll you haven't records have not been requested they're just they're not there but you're left in a situation for the first couple of weeks of school where you don't really know how many you've got on the rolls you have too many but in fact after later on you find out you didn't so you're you're placed in a situation
of not knowing what you ought to do because you you cannot know your true numbers that's one situation that that happens you also can find yourself having started school just fine and in four or five weeks into school, you have, and I don't know, it seems to happen all at once. You'll have several families move in, especially in small communities, and it'll put you over right in the middle of the semester. Well, again, the point is three weeks later, you may have that many move out.
You're in a transitional situation. It's not static. It is constantly evolving and changing, and you can't be sure what you want to do. If you add an instructor, the day you go over or very soon thereafter, which you should do according to the law currently, it's going to be about $50,000 out of the teacher's salary fund. It also means that if you're going to add an instructor, you're not just going to affect that one student. You're going to affect, if you have five second grade classes,
I would assume what most schools are going to do is they're going to pull two, three, four kids out of each classroom and move them into this new teacher's classroom a brand new teacher who's not prepared necessarily to teach second grade do you agree that this could present some sort of problem that does need a solution to it whether it's yours or something else I absolutely agree
Representative Gossage and I think what you're bringing up would be is worst case scenario if we school districts like Bentonville who is saying hey I understand I'm just going to be put on probation but I don't want to be a bad actor I want to do things right and by doing it right you start a new class and you pull many other kids out of their comfort zone with the teacher they're used to with rules they're used to and a style they're used to into a brand new teacher mid semester that's certainly not doing justice to our students to make school districts become compliant in the middle of the semester.
Chair. What I'd like to do is follow up on a point Representative Lampkin was making about adequacy. And I want to go back just for starters. You said in your testimony for this bill that school districts are currently noncompliant with the law, even when, as Representative Armstrong pointed out, that there are waivers available. And I think that's remarkable in and of itself because, obviously, what we do here every day at the legislature is we pass laws,
and I don't think any of us would probably like to know that any law is being violated or not complied with. And so, if we were to pass this law and turn this kind of practice into something that's legally justified, I wonder, and this is leading into my question, whether that would be constitutional. I mean, just because we make a law doesn't necessarily mean we're following the state constitution. Right now, the State Department of Education creates the maximum class size standards
in order to comply with the adequacy formula that's been dictated based on our constitution. And so my question is, what would be the effect of adopting a law like this on the adequacy formula, on its constitutionality, because it seems to me it just opens up the opportunity for someone to challenge law and current practice based on violating our constitutional guarantee of an adequate education for all the citizens of Arkansas? Representative
Saban, I think that's a very fair question.
I think by definition any law that we pass is constitutional until it's challenged. Therefore, I would think this would be constitutional, and if someone chooses to challenge it at that point, you said it's not right that people don't follow the law, And I think I totally agree with that. I think we need to give them a better solution and ability to follow the law. Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Yes.
I think I could support something like this if we could go back and maybe put some safeguards in place for classes with high needs that we're going to direct some aides because there is mobility for aides within a school district to be moved from place to place. And then also I would think that just for teacher morale, that that teacher that's going to have to teach over the limit
should be given a stipend for that time period if they are willing to take on extra kids, high needs. You know, they're going to have to have more supplies, you know. So these things to just say that we do appreciate the teachers. We do know that they're going to have to have extra work. We're willing to give them some compensation for that. And we're going to try to put an aid in there if you've got a certain percentage of high-needs kids.
Those would be two things I would think would be more palatable for me. I
think that's a very fair I'm not sure if I'm in a position to be able to ask a question but Mr. Handis to reach the maximum classroom there should
already be an aid is that correct in reference to the kindergarten classrooms there are 20 kids and you can have up to 22 with a part time aid only in kindergarten I believe so I'd have to check Representative Bale
you're recognized Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think my question is for Mr. Hernandez, if that's okay with the chair. The whole subject of finding these teachers on short notice to come in and create these new classrooms is one that concerns me. And the typical time when faculty move between schools or are hired is generally year-end or on occasion semester.
Is the labor pool that's available mid-semester the same quality that's available year-end or end-semester? or are we simply creating a situation where children who get dropped into one of these classrooms with a hastily hired teacher have a higher probability of getting a substandard education? Representative Bell, I think that,
you know, the question about whether or not the poll is different,
I think the answer would be yes. You know, just from a practical standpoint, teachers sign year-long contracts to be employed with the district It usually typically starts around July 1, ends June 30. So as far as the amount that are available during the year, there's probably a lot less. And then the pool that's maybe a little bit more available during a semester time. Now, as far as the quality, you know, I can't really speak to what the quality is. But there would, I would imagine, be a lesser pool that is available during the year as opposed to being semester
or at the end of the year when there would most
likely be a higher pool of applicants. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? would would you agree that that pool consists of people who for whatever reason were not hired or weren't available during the normal hiring time and so that would lend some credence to the idea that maybe they weren't at least in a generalization on the same par with the other folks who were employed you know as as far as
being on on the same same par i don't know that
i could give a general explanation for that i can just speak from my my own personal experience as being a superintendent and and sometimes when what for whatever reason we lost staff during during that time usually we would find people that were were not on current contract and so for whatever reason you know there could be a myriad of reasons just moved to town to to you know many reasons why they're not employed but i mean that is typically the case that they don't have a current contract are there any other questions from the committee
all right this time we have some signed up to speak against and for the bill we're going to go with brenda robinson and rich nagel from the aea to speak against the bill first i guess you guys would like to go together. And I would ask, if you please, we have quite a bit left of testimony that if you do speak, please try not to be repetitious about this if it's already been brought up. I mean, I don't mind the next one to bring up something,
but try not to keep bringing up the same thing if we've already heard it. We are going to run a little short on time today. We still have quite a few bills to present. You
Speaker 224
1:25:50
you're with. Brenda Robinson, president of the Arkansas Education Association. Rich Nagel, Interim Executive Director of the Arkansas
Speaker 225
1:25:57
Education Association Thank you, Chairman Cozart and the committee I am Brenda Robinson, again, the President of the Arkansas Education Association
and I represent educators across the state of Arkansas Research tells us that smaller class sizes, especially those in the earlier grades is highly beneficial for students This bill seeks to increase class size, which is in the wrong direction. In addition to my role as an AEA president, I'm testifying today as a teacher myself. I've taught an array of classes, a one-two split, second grade, third grade, fifth grade, a literacy coach, an interventionist coach.
In my last teaching assignment, I was a sixth grade teacher teaching math and English. Any attempt to increase the number of children in classrooms is detrimental to the students because it limits the amount of one-on-one instruction for each student. This bill would affect the current class size limit set forth in the Arkansas Standards of Accreditation of Arkansas Public Schools. For instance, the early childhood program, it says there shall not be no more than 10 students
to every teacher in the classroom, no more than 20 students to one teacher and a qualified aide. So this bill would change the class size to 12 students in a class of 22 for each teacher with an aide. For grades 1 through 3, the State Board of Education says that there should be no more than 25 students per teacher in the classroom. This bill would increase the number to 27. For grades four through six, the number is 28, and this bill would
increase it to 30. For grades seven through 12, the class size should not exceed 30 students, and this bill would increase the number to 32. These standards are there for a reason, to ensure that students get the support, the guidance, and attention they need and deserve. Additionally, there is currently a process by which a school district can get a waiver if it is needed. I know that you've chose to be on the education committee because you know how critically important it is that we
educate all of our students regardless of their zip code. We need schools that prepare students to compete for the 21st century. This bill will undermine our ability to do so as it limits the amount of time each student will receive from their teacher. In fact, smaller class sizes offer a range of measurable benefits. Smaller class size can help close the racial achievement gap by 38%. Smaller class sizes allow for early identification of learning disabilities
and result in fewer special education placements. Smaller class sizes results in an increased college entrance test taking rates. Smaller classes also have a proven result in improving behavior including reduction in discipline referrals. This bill is offered by legislators from the Bentonville school district. Bentonville is a growing district. Under their funding matrix, growing districts receive additional funds in the year in which additional students are enrolled. For the
purpose of that money is to hire additional teachers. This bill seeks to exceed the class size for a semester but the growth funds would be in place for the entire school year. We seek to maintain high standards while working to break down barriers to the opportunities for our students. Adding more students per classroom adds a significant barrier to the shared goal. Our students deserve better. Please vote no on this bill.
Speaker 224
1:29:49
Dear Rick Ness. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I just wanted to make a comment about two things. First of all, the amendment that was placed on the bill this morning actually increases the number of students for early childhood education programs. Under the bill before it was amended, the class size limit would go from 10 to 11. With the amendment, the class size now for early childhood would go from 10 to 12.
And at that level, this amendment is worse than the original bill. Second, in response to Representative Gossage issues about students coming in and out throughout the year, we would recognize that what he's saying in his experience, I'm sure it bears that out for anyone who's made a lot of class schedules. But if there's ever a student that needs to be ensured that their needs are met,
it's the students who are moving around a lot during a school year, fundamentally through no fault of their own. But smaller class sizes for those students are more important, I would argue, than in many other situations. Thank you. Representative Harris, you are recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is the first we've heard about the amendment, including early childhood education.
And where did, is Tanya Russell in the room? Anywhere? I think she's out in the hallway. We'll see if. I can respond, Mr. Chairman. Well, I'd like to hear from, since they made the claim. Well, it's right here.
Speaker 224
1:31:57
Pass that down. The amendment's right here. No. The standards are right here.
We'll give her a second to get here. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay. Not available. Okay. I don't know if this is possible, but if Mark could work on getting her here, because that changes the state, may change state law with minimum licensing requirement.
So, okay, thank you. But can I ask a follow-up question? You're recognized. To that. Now, we are aware of, because, you know, you mentioned Bentonville schools, I think this is more than just a Bentonville bill because I live so about 20 minutes, my driving, to get to Bentonville. But West Fork, we have students that can't afford to live in Bentonville, so they may lose a job at Walmart or head offices.
They come to West Fork to be able to live. So we do have students that come mid-semesters because we've lost students. Now they're coming back. And so this kind of affects us, and this will help us in our area. And then we can't afford to hire teachers mid-semester. And so in that area, do you think this bill will help my school district to just help us for one semester until we can maybe hire a teacher for the new school year?
Speaker 224
1:33:52
it may help your district it won't help the students and if you'd permit me I can read the standards on early childhood well I mean I
don't mind you doing that Richard or Mr. Nagel I just would like to hear from Tanya or Miss Russell I understand Miss Williams if you don't mind because this is the first the sponsor has heard of it and it's the first I've heard of it Senator I respect your request I'm not a senator yet, but thank you.
I don't think I ever will be at this point, but thank you. Well, maybe. I appreciate it. I don't think I'm going to run, you know, but I appreciate it. I don't want to be, so thank you very
much. All right. Are there any other questions from the committee for them? If not, thank you. At this time, we have Richard Abernathy that would like to speak for. if you would state your name and who you're with and
you're recognized thank you mr. chair richard abernathy executive director of aea and just for the record we
certainly agree with us senator hester he does not vote with superintendents near as much as he should but we think his dad's working on him so we do believe that this is a good bill and it provides flexibility to the local district in order to allow those maximum class size reduction just for a temporary time period and I have in fact been in a district where we've had to hire teachers they're in the middle of the semester and I tell you to me it comes back to kids parents
and quality of applicants that you have. When you're talking about kids, kids get used to their teacher. They get used to their schedules. They get used to the curriculum, who they're setting by in class. When you have someone move in and eventually you have to hire a teacher, then you're going to, just like Mr. Goss has said, you're going to be splitting those classrooms, and you're going to be pulling two or three kids from this class, two or three kids from that type, to even out the load amongst the teachers. Well, that's not good for kids. And let me tell you, if you think the kid's upset, that the parents also get upset.
When their child's been in a classroom with a teacher that they like, they enjoy, they trust, and all of a sudden they're moved in the middle of the semester, it's not good for them. Also, it was mentioned about the quality of applicants. And let me just tell you, when I've hired in the middle of the semester, I've hired some really good teachers. But I've also hired some that I would not have hired during the middle of the summer. So it kind of works both ways. But we're asking just a little flexibility until that next semester. give us a little more time to prepare kids, prepare our parents,
and also be able to hire a good teacher to
put in that classroom before we split it. Are there any questions? Yes. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you. Doesn't the State Department of Education have that authority now, if provided with that situation? It does not have to give an advisory nor a warning. those things are deferred for habitual, regular, consistent problems
rather than just the occasional situation such as the one to which the Hester bill refers. Would you not agree with that?
I would like to agree with
that, but no. Well, can you tell me, as I look at it, the State Department does not have a record of really passing out very many advisories to large school districts I mean I've studied this and I haven't seen more than two in a whole year
I mean you're a superintendent, head of the superintendents association, wouldn't you agree with that?
lot of citations. Well if there are no citations that means the problem is being handled now as it could be You have the flexibility, and instead of trying to have a legislative resolution, it would seem that this would be something which is already working, and it does not cry out for new legislation. I'm not opposed to it. I'm just simply saying if it were something that were a problem, then we try to fix it.
But it does not present itself other than as a theory. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Slavin, you are recognized. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. My question kind of follows a little bit from Representative Walker's, but goes back to what you opened with in terms of the problem of, you know, splitting classes. You know, the way this bill's been amended, it's only affecting two students per day. So it seems to me that it would neither mitigate the problem of splitting classes if you really had more than two students show up.
And as Representative Walker pointed out, it also is kind of addressing a problem it seems like can already be addressed in multiple other ways without changing the law. So if you could help me understand, how does this bill, as amended, address the problem that you started out talking about? Currently, if you have one student move in and all
your classes in that particular grade level were full at the maximum, you had one student moved in, then you would be bound to hire an additional teacher. This would allow you at least to have two teachers moved in, or two teachers,
two kids move in to that same grade level and not have to
until semester. If I could follow up, Mr. Chair, I guess where I'm confused is we've had testimony from the sponsor of the bill saying that the law is not being complied with right now. We're also of the understanding that there's a waiver process, and another process in place to basically prevent that very situation that you just described from happening. So it seems to me that there really isn't a situation where we've got one kid that moves in
and you all are creating new classes. I mean, it's either not happening, even if it's supposed to, and even if you all wanted to comply with it, you could just get a waiver and you wouldn't have to do it. So why are we changing the law? Two things about that. For
those not complying with it, I can't answer that. For those of us who have had to hire teachers in the middle of the semester for one kid, I can't answer that. It is not something you want to take to your school board as superintendent and say that I have voluntarily chosen to not follow the standard of accreditation
and place our district on a citation or probation. That's just not something that's good business practice. So the waiver process could be a way to resolve this particular issue. Typically, waivers are asked for on the back end. And so by the time you go through the waiver to the State Board of Education, if they don't grant it, you're on probation or cited, whatever the standards require for. If they do grant it, then, in fact, there would be no sanction. So that could be a solution.
You know, that's not particularly what this is trying to do, is to allow the waiver process to kick in automatically until semester, at which point the kids will move off or you're going to hire a teacher to be back in compliance. Representative Gossage,
you're recognized. Representative Sabin was on the same line of questioning, and he elicited the response from Mr. Abernathy that I was wanting to hear. Are there any other questions? Thank you, Dr. Abernathy.
recognized. Do you think from the superintendent's point of view that this could fall under extra duties for a teacher and that they would be able to be eligible for a stipend for that semester of extra work? I certainly think that would be
a local district decision. I've had teachers come to me when we've run over those class sizes instead of breaking up their classroom and pulling kids away from them,
I said, just let me have them for a couple weeks until we get to the semester where you can do that. So I think that's
a local decision that can be made at that level. You're citing the problem of splitting those kids into two classes, but you could possibly
have to do that at semester anyway. Yes, if those numbers did
not change, you would have to be in compliance. So your fears about the kids' transition to another class and the parents, Would that transition not be better accepted in October than it would be in January
after they've had that teacher for another couple of
months? I wouldn't think so, no. Quite honestly, when you change a semester, the kids and everyone is changing, typically come back after Christmas, whatever, and you kind of start anew. I would think there would be a better time to split those classes than October. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you, Dr.
Abernathy. Dr. Michelle Lynch to speak against the bill.
State your name and who you're with,
Speaker 263
1:43:13
and then you're recognized. Michelle Lynch, Executive Director of the Arkansas State Teachers Association. it's been a little difficult to get everything wrapped up into a neat package about what our members are saying about this we serve thousands of educators across the state we strive to be an authentic voice for them and put out a quick response survey with over 700 responses in basically a little over a day
The issue that we're finding is that many believe that this is a permanent class size increase across the board, and next year everyone's going to have more children in their classes permanently, and that's just not true. So part of this process of trying to get a grasp on what the actual feeling is about the merits of the bill has been a little bit difficult. So when we polled them, definitely 70% were opposed to this legislation.
But when we asked them about the merits of the bill, that's when they more than half agreed that there was some merit to the bill. Where they're concerned really has, from what I can tell in my research background and qualitative research, pulling themes and that sort of thing, is that there are so many class size issues already in existence that 85% of them said that they're just fearful that this will exacerbate existing issues.
So we ask a little bit about that, and honestly, most, 65% said that there weren't class size. Their districts did not exceed class size, or if they did, they were resolved immediately. But we have this 13% who said, my district regularly does exceed class size and it's not dealt with properly. And just a few anecdotals, a fifth grade teacher with 31 students
who has on paper a special ed teacher as a teacher, a second teacher of record who's never in the classroom. So there are some loopholes in existing policy that some districts seem to be working around. We have an issue at the 5th and 6th grade level. We have some 5th and 6th grade teachers who teach history and science, and they have over 170 students that they see. And that is because, unlike the 7th through 12th grade policy
that says no teacher can have more than 150 total, there is not that cap for these upper elementary schools or middle schools who do have students going from class to class. So a lot of the issues that we're seeing in terms of negativity toward this piece of legislation have to do with a lot of underlying issues that exist. They want parental notices. When we ask, only 8% of the districts were letting parents know that there was an overage in their child's classroom.
As a parent, that would be very important to me, especially if my child who receives special services was in that classroom. For me, it would be a red flag to offer more support or to go to the principal and ask about that. And 56% weren't sure if their parents were notified or not. Just some transparency. They're concerned that ADE will be left out of the loop now if this becomes automated. and how will that accountability be made known at the Department of Ed
and perhaps a monthly report to the Board of Education, much like done with licensure and teachers who are teaching out of licensure each month. So that's kind of in a nutshell what we're hearing from our members, and I'll be happy to answer any questions. Are there any questions? Looks like I
have no questions. Thank you. Thank you.
Do I have anybody that would like to speak for the bill that is not on the list? If not, I have one more that would like to speak against the bill, Karen Sykes. You are recognized to speak against the bill. If you would, state
your name and you are recognized. you. My name is Karen Sykes, and I'm a citizen here in Little Rock, Arkansas. I will graduate
with my master's in public administration from Mueller in May. Full disclosure, I am a legislative coordinator for the Arkansas Democratic Party, but I'm here speaking as a mother. I have a 10-year-old son in the school district here. I'm not here to spout out a bunch of statistics to you. I think you've heard them, and I think you understand, but I'm here to talk about the reality of the classroom size. Before we got settled into my son's current school, which is Pulaski Heights
Elementary and serves the Hillcrest Capitol View Stiff Station area, we went to Jefferson, which is in Kamek, and Booker, which is there at I-30, and I'm here to tell you that these classrooms are full. These kids go to classrooms that are smaller than this room that are full of six to twelve tables, a couple of computers, a teacher desk, bookshelves, a project-based
curriculum, which is obviously bigger than just a worksheet, and then perhaps a pet guinea pig or something like that. And then, of course, the classroom is full of children. And these children are definitely full of energy, whether they're 5 or whether they're 18. These children come with a wide range of intellectualism and emotional maturity.
And along that whole spectrum is also, as mentioned earlier, the spectrum of learning disabilities such as autism. And because that's such a wide range of a wide range on that spectrum, many are allowed and should go to public school. Right off the bat I thought of some of the kids in my child's classroom and there are at least four I could think of who are on that spectrum. And in this classroom that is
already small and full of things. So what I'm saying is that there is no more room. That there is usually more than one child in there with special needs along with children who have disciplinary issues and we just don't need to compound the problem. If you want to be known for quality education, then we need to individualize education as much as we possibly can by decreasing the size of the classroom and not increasing the size
of the classroom. Thank you for letting
me speak. Are there any questions? Thank you for coming. I have, anybody would like to speak for? If not, I have one more that I overlooked against and that would be Amy Townley. Amy, you're recognized. Just state your name and who you're with, please.
Speaker 274
1:51:26
Hi, I'm Amy Townley. I am the current president of the Forest Heights PTSA. I have two children in the Little Rock School District. I am also a parent who started the Change.org petition to petition the committee members to vote against this bill. It was brought to my attention Saturday. I honestly am like a fish out of water here. I don't really have never done this. So it started on Saturday, and by Sunday we had over 200 parents
who said that they would like to see our representatives vote against this. Some of the things you've heard what parents or what teachers have said, Some of the things I wrote down that I wanted to point out, if we're taking an average class of 25 kids and two more kids come in because they might have started, all classes started at 25, and two more come in, even if it's for a semester, what happens when somebody spoke that kids are coming into West Fork constantly?
what happens when another kid comes in and then it's all kids all classrooms are full at 27 and another kid comes in and makes it 28 and then another kid comes in you keep getting waivers or what do you do when all those are full you still have to get a waiver which is what you're already doing currently I think if you're abiding by the law that is out there anyway so you're back at the current problem um representative douglas uh talked about having a stipend for
teachers this may make a teacher happier to be paid more money but from a parent's perspective i'm not any happier that there's two more children in my kid's classroom and the teacher's getting paid more but my kid gets less attention um so the teacher might be happy but i can tell you i'm not And as far as Mr. Abernathy saying that pulling kids from a teacher to a new teacher disrupts kids' lives, I'm sorry, but it doesn't.
We ask kids to transition from a classroom to a PE room to a pullout for GT to some kids go to speech, OT, PT. They make it throughout their day, and so they meet new friends and they're sitting by new people, and I would rather my child go to a new classroom with a new teacher in October and have that new teacher for the entire year than, say, have less time with the teacher that they're used to.
Kids have to learn how to transition through life, and getting a new teacher shouldn't be that difficult of a transition, and I have a special needs child who I task on transitioning. So if I'm asking my special needs child to do this, a child without special needs should be able to do this in October just as well as they can do it in December. So I just wanted to give my two cents. I think most of the points have been made.
I don't see how adding kids to a classroom, even for a semester, benefits anybody especially my kid if it becomes 27 kids in that classroom thank you are there any questions from the committee thank you for
coming what's the will of the committee oh well we better let y'all close for that then I'm sorry you're you're uh you can close for your bill I guess I was just trying to hurry things up
I agree I think what we've heard here is what I've reiterated a few times there's certainly a problem that needs to be addressed with deference to everyone involved I feel like I've provided a very viable solution to this problem and I hope the committee will agree with me and should they not maybe someone will have a better solution to this problem I'd appreciate a
good vote What are the wishes of the committee? Reckon to Eubanks, you're recognized.
Motion do pass. As amended. Motion do pass as amended. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Those opposed? No. Bill fails. I need two hands for a roll call. I have two hands. Would you call the roll, please? Representative Letting?
Speaker 278
1:56:24
No. Representative Murdoch? No. Representative Deffenbaugh? No. Representative Harris? Yes. Representative Eubanks? Yes. Representative Ratliff? Representative Ratliff Yes Representative Gillum Representative Gillum Representative Walker
No Representative Bell Yes Representative Balts No Representative Douglas No Representative Lowry, Representative Lowry, Representative McElroy, Representative Armstrong, Representative Gossage, Representative Saban, Representative Hodges, Representative Gray,
Speaker 288
1:57:38
Representative Lampkin? No. You want to vote, Mr. Chairman? You only got six affirmative votes or it
failed? The bill fails. No, sir. It failed. You can give it six votes. We will now hear Senate Bill 30.
Senator Johnson, you are recognized, and I do appreciate your patience for setting through all of that. You
are recognized. Thank you, Chair, and members of the committee. Senate Bill 30 is about a simple bill as I have seen presented in this session thus far. It simply strikes the 10 hours of professional development days
and inserts no less than 6 days of professional development hours. This gives flexibility to the districts on those four days in the 190-day contract, and it lifts a state mandate on the schools that is not being funded currently. We are funding 36 hours, and there's four days of service that the school districts are required but not funded for.
And whenever it states no less than six days, that complies with the certification for the teachers, and it also would leave flexibility in the future if funding was available and the certification would still be there. So I guess that's the nuts and bolts of it. Are
Representative Baltz, you're recognized Motion at the
proper time Mr. Deffenbaum, Representative Deffenbaum, you're recognized Thank you, Mr. Chair My mind is
somewhere else It changes from what to what? Currently, it is 10 days Or 60 hours And this bill changes that to 6 days no less than six days so it gives us flexibility to the district if they need seven or eight days
and they want to fund those other two days they can and the pay is still on a 190 day contract so it would also give those school districts flexibility to pay those teachers for things that they are doing voluntarily now like setting up their classrooms and other things. Thanks.
Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions? Yeah. Representative Walker, you're recognized.
Does that mean that you are authorizing the districts to give too fewer days per year
to teaching the students
in class? No. It has absolutely no change on the days of class time. is strictly just the professional development requirement. Thank you. Any
other questions committee? I have one signed up to speak for the bill. Dr. Abernathy you are recognized to speak for the bill.
Thank You Mr. Chair. Richard Abernathy, executive director of AAEA and we do appreciate Senator Johnson running this and and believe it allows those decisions be made at the local level where it needs so we we certainly support the
bill would anyone like to speak against the bill you are welcome
to close for your bill thank you chair and in committee I apologize this wasn't nearly
as controversial as the ones that went before me but uh uh you know whenever you do things that that help everybody involved and gives flexibility district i think that's what what we all need and and i would appreciate a good vote what is the wishes of
the committee Representative Bell. Motion do pass. Actually, I'm going to take yours away, and I'm going to recognize
because he had already asked for a due pass. Motion do pass. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? Hey, I've got to make a mistake every once in a while. You have passed your bill. congratulations we have one more bill to run today house bill 1183 represent Gossage you are recognized to present your bill
Thank you, Mr. Chair. House Bill 1183 is the fulfillment of the campaign promise of Governor Hutchinson to see to it that computer science course was available in every Arkansas high school.
In K-12 education right now, primarily our students are consumers of technology. The goal of this legislation, and I believe Governor Hutchinson's vision, is that our students become more than consumers but become producers of technology. I think one area that is definitely underserved in K-12 education is computer science. We do a great job of so many core subjects, but one of the areas where we're probably a little bit deficient is in computer science and computer technology.
In the next five years, by 2020, there'll be 1.4 million computing jobs in America. There'll only be 400,000 graduates with a computer science degree. Governor Hutchinson's goal again is to not just the first point is to add this computer science course but it's a much broader vision than that he wants Arkansas to be a state that leads the way
when it comes to coding and the use of computer science just a few statistics real quickly to give you an indication of where we are as a nation and as a state in AP courses in America today 862,000 students take English AP courses, 387,000 take calculus, 154,000 take Spanish, 140,000 take chemistry, 110,000 take European history, 31,000 students take the AP course
in computer science. Four times as many students take AP geography as take computer science. We also see that in the last several years There's been a decline in the number of women Or girls who are taking computer science courses It's actually dropped by greater than 25% Over the last few years Minority students as well In computer science careers today 29% of the people with jobs in computer science field are Asian
5% Hispanic and only 4% are African American We've got a long way to go, and this is a start in Arkansas to move forward with computer science skills. I want to thank Mike Hernandez and Debbie Jones for their great work, as well as Tony Woods. I don't think Tony's here today, but they've been working with me from ADE for several weeks, Sarah Moore from the governor's office. What this bill does, it's a fairly simple bill. The bill itself, the part that's codified, is only 14 sentences long.
we wanted to make it as simple as possible the non-statutory language which creates the task force is is the bulk of the bill what we're going to do is in beginning with the next school year is there will be one course that will be offered through virtual arkansas that any school district can take free of charge any student can take free of charge and i'm probably going to let mike talk a little bit more about the process that ADE used in coming to that to help meet the requirements of this bill.
Yes, it's after lunch now, so good afternoon again, committee. My name is Mike Hernandez, Deputy Commissioner of the Department of Education. And as far as the steps that went in to develop this course, we have a two-pronged approach. There's actually two courses developed, one that was heavy mathematics. In addition to this, some coding aspects and computer science aspects put into that course we've also worked over the last week or so or a few weeks convening another group to develop the frameworks for an additional course that
we're are titling essential essentials of computer programming computer coding that will be a new course and both of those will be offered as as represent gossage stated through virtual arkansas it's a online delivery system through the arch forward co-op um that will be free available to every uh every school district next year again we
want to be clear this first year a district only has to offer
this computer science course uh it's not going to be one it's not an additional course that's required and make it a 39th course currently there's 38 courses that are required under the standards. This does not add a course. They just have to offer it. The task force job, however, if you'll look at that, their job over the next couple of years is develop a multi-pronged approach to meeting these computer science standards. You can expect to probably see a career education set of courses. You can probably expect to see that they'll adopt this AP computer course.
it's computer science principles I think is the name of it that's currently being developed the curriculum for that's being developed by code.org you'll probably see some concurrent courses with colleges and universities that will count in meeting this requirement anyway there'll be a number of things coming forth from the task force, again it won't be just a single stand-alone course but we hope there's a whole array of courses that will be offered a menu of opportunities for our students to take
at the proper time. Representative McElroy, you're recognized for a question. Okay. And I have other questions. Representative Deffenbaum, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gosha, I want to make sure I heard that right. But this is not going to raise the number of credits it takes to graduate, right?
No. Okay, so the second question being they're not going to remove anything to make a place for this, right? No. Okay. I like it. I just want to make sure. Thank you. Thank you.
Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Yes, I do too see a need for this and appreciate you bringing this to us. The only question I've had is on any expense to the school districts going forward. Is there going to be some funding for
materials or computers that they may need? Some help with that. To meet this first course requirement, the
one that we're going to be offering next year. The two are going to be offered next year being delivered through virtual Arkansas. The reason that we did that is we did not want there to be an unfunded mandate on schools. Normally there's a $2,500 charge for school districts to be part of the virtual school and then they pay, I believe, a per student charge on top of that. That
fee is being waived. The $2,500 is waived for this course to be delivered to your school district. So if this is the only thing your school decided to do, the only potential cost of the local school district could be if they're going to have to place a teacher in that classroom, if they're going to have it during a particular class period of the day, they would have somebody overseeing the course. But even that
would not be necessary. Representative Walker, your recommendation. Thank you. Have you or your committee, in conjunction
with the Department of Education, done a budget computation of what it would take in order to do this in every school in the state of Arkansas and for every student who would otherwise be qualified. Just assume that it doesn't happen this year, but next year. The $2,500 and an amount per student. Do you have any idea of how much that is likely to be and how it would otherwise impact the school district's budget?
I'm sorry, Representative Walker. I don't know that I understand
the question. But as I understand it, this involves, if you're going to offer something, you have to make it realistically available to everybody. And that means it's going to have a cost if it's going to involve computers. And if it's going to be in association with an existing network, I guess broadband will be involved, where you don't have all school districts connected to broadband now, all students.
I'm just trying to understand how this will look in terms of the dollars the first year or the second year that it's to be in operation. It may be a worthy idea, but I'd like to know what its cost relationship is to the preexisting cost of education. As far as the first year, I think
I'm going to address that. because we don't know what the task force will go as far as how much this will grow in the future. So it's hard to say on that. But in the first year, you know, going back to the session of 2013,
when we had the Digital Learning Act, I don't know the exact terminology of it, where we required that a digital course be offered in every school, that kind of set the table for this type of course being already mandated that be available in courses. This was just an effort to possibly make a school be able to be compliant with both of these at the same time. As far as any computer costs, you know, we do have the online assessments that are going on in most schools. Every school should have some kind of computer and do have broadband, or they have Internet access currently.
Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes. I'm aware that there are a number of school districts in the state that offer a range of AP courses. But it's just an offer because only a few people take them, and if less than a certain number take them, then it is not actually offered. How do you plan to address that kind of situation?
I mean, do you make it just an offer and then nobody accepts and therefore we go about our business so that the schools that are either low performing or in generally poverty areas can be treated in a way where you say, well, we offered it to them. The fact that they didn't take it is their
fault. Yes, sir. As far as the current language of the law basically says that it's an offer. So schools will be required to offer in a similar manner that they are required to offer the AP courses.
Now, if there is not a student in the district that doesn't sign up or choose to take this class, it will not have to be offered and attended, meaning that they'll have a kid actually enrolled in the
course. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Are there any other questions, committee? Would you like to close for your bill? Hold on a sec. I don't have anybody signed up to vote for or against, but is there anyone in the audience elect to speak for or against the bill, either one?
I have no one. You're welcome to close for your bill now. Committee, I would appreciate a good vote on this. This is, again, one of the governor's key initiatives that he campaigned on this year. I think this is great for kids. It's not the kids that I'm worried about. They're going to love this. It's converting all the adults who grew up in a different world than the ones our kids are growing up in. In China, 100% of their students in school take computer coding, 100%.
In the United States, 5% of students are exposed to computer coding. This initiative, again, we've talked to, there's been some talk about cursive writing, whether we're going to offer cursive writing or not. this is critical skill for the kids growing up in Arkansas right now. This gives us an opportunity to move forward and be a state which is a leader in computer science and computer coding, and I would appreciate a good vote.
Rep. Armstrong, you are recognized for a motion.
Motion do pass. I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor, say A. Any against? Motion. And congratulations, you have passed your bill. Representative Ratliff, you are recognized for an announcement. We've
Speaker 317
2:16:50
been forgetting this for the last two or three weeks, but we're wanting to form an education caucus, and anybody interested in forming one, get with me and Bruce Cozart.
And I think Mr. Cook over there has volunteered to help us some. And anybody that's interested in education, we just thought we might do an education caucus. Thank you. Thank you,
Representative. Is there any other business before the committee? If not, I'll entertain a motion. So move. All those in favor, aye. Aye. You are dismissed. You are dismissed.
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Speaker 13
Speaker 18
Speaker 22
Speaker 31
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Speaker 45
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Speaker 89
Speaker 94
Representative Justin T. Harris
Unverified
Representative Nate Bell
Unverified
Speaker 119
Speaker 68
William Robert
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Speaker 173
Chair
Unverified
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh
Unverified
Mike Hernandez
Unverified
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Speaker 225
Speaker 224
Speaker 257
Speaker 263
Karen Sykes
Unverified
Speaker 274
Speaker 278
Speaker 288
Senator David Johnson
Unverified
Speaker 291
Speaker 134
Speaker 317