House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (12)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1515
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1515”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB205
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB205”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1381
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1381”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1516
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1516”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1074
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1074”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1272
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1272”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1495
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1495”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HCR1008
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HCR1008”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1029
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1029”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1032
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1032”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB211
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB211”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB342
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB342”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Dragging them in. Thank everybody for being here today on such a treacherous day of travel. I don't think we'll feel quite so pressured out there. The room's a little cleaner
mean that because they were dirty people. I just mean that it's not as crowded. Yeah, probably.
Representative Richman, I'm going to recognize you to run SB 205. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
and this is an important bill to several people.
That's why I walked a half a mile this morning to get to my car because I couldn't get to the apartment last night and then walked another half a mile this morning to be able to get to the vehicle and come on in this morning. What SB205 does is that it allows school districts to take property that is no longer in use, schools that have been shut down, facilities and things. and gives them the option to donate that property
to institutions of higher education, non-profit organizations, or other, basically allows them to use those facilities and have a chance for those facilities to do something besides sit in a spot and deteriorate. We have a perfect example of the Fish Valley Schools where that is in my district and is also in my community. There is a gymnasium and also a tech facility where it was about four years old and now almost 10 years later
it is just sitting and deteriorating. We'd like to be able to see those kind of facilities used. And with that said, I think if you read the bill and take a quick look at it, it's a simple bill and it's a good bill. Thank you. Representative Bell, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Richmond, I just had a question about that walk this morning. Was that uphill both ways and were you barefooted in the snow?
It was uphill, but that wasn't as bad as the downhill part of it. That was the same question we had
recognized for a question. There are statutes that already allow school districts to make those donations. Are you aware of them? I'm aware
of that, but this particular bill would help assist in those donations so that the school districts could go ahead and do
it. May I follow up, Mr. Cozart?
Mr. Chair? You're recognized for follow-up. Well, what does this bill do that they don't do? I mean let me finish my question what does this bill do that they don't do in that this bill does not have any criteria that a donating district under your bill would require as a condition of a gift what are the criteria? Well I would
not be able to answer that at this time because I'm not familiar with the actual laws and things in the bill that you're referring to
Representative Ratliff, do you have a question? Yes. Has this bill got an emergency clause on it
where it goes in effect immediately? Not that I know of, no. Thanks, sir.
Are there any other questions on this committee? Representative Letting, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I apologize, Representative Richmond. There's no constitutional issue at all with this particular bill, right?
No, nothing that I am aware of that could be questionable. That's any type of constitutional issue about this.
Thank you. Representative Bell, you recognize for a question. This
one won't be about Snow, Representative Richmond. As I read the bill, it just simply adds an incorporated town or their sub-entities to the list that's already in the statute, and that's the only change that's making. Am I reading it correctly? You are reading it correctly,
So we're not changing anything about who can give, that type of thing. All we're doing is just adding a different classification of cities and our village, that type of thing, to it. That is correct. Are there any
other questions, committee? Is there anyone in the audience who likes to speak against the bill? For the bill. Would you like to close for the bill? Yes, I'm closed. What is the will of the committee? Mr. McElroy has a motion?
Motion to do pass. We have a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. You want to do it from here? Or do you want to go there? I'm going to recognize my vice chair, Representative
Lampkin, for a resolution. All right. Thank you, Chairman. Colleagues, this is just a little old bill that really doesn't do a lot, but it would mean a lot to someone. I'm sorry, that's H.R. 1029.
I forgot to mention that. Yes, H.R. 1029 is a resolution. A resolution? Whoa. No, a resolution. You see why I'm not much of a public speaker. But anyway, this bill, this resolution actually just honors Dr. Jack Lasseter, who retired May the 31st from UAM, which is University of Arkansas at Monticello, upon his retirement and we want to honor him because he's been there this time 10 years but
in all he spent 28 years in Monticello and he's done more he's done a wonderful job of leading the university but he's done even more in uniting and leading that community he is a stabilizing force and has been for a long time we wanted him back we got him he's been here 10 years but But it's time for him to retire, he feels like. And so we want to arm him with this resolution upon his retirement. And I'd appreciate a good vote if there aren't any questions.
Are there any questions, committee? Does anyone in the audience like to speak for or against the resolution? Mr. McElroy, have a motion to do pass? Motion to do pass. All
Speaker 47
7:14
those in favor say aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, you passed your resolution. Thank you. Representative Letting, I recognize
him to run, are you going to run both of those?
Yes, sir. Okay. First one would be HB 1515. You're recognized. And
thank you, Mr. Chair, Madam Chair, members of the committee. These are two very short bills that have been out there for a while, have received zero input. They're pretty straightforward. House Bill 1515 does exactly what it says it does. when they are performing on-campus standards for accreditations of Arkansas.
It simply requires that they do at least one open forum to give the public a chance to provide some input.
Are there any questions? No questions, committee? Does anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. What's the will of the committee? I have a due pass motion. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? No.
Well, that's a tight one. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. House Bill 1516, you're recognized to present that. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. That is also a very simple and straightforward bill just to promote. actually I think the word promote is a little misleading just to require transparency in the charter school lotteries to be absolutely clear it's my opinion that all the charter schools are operating in good faith when it comes to their lotteries I have had some concerns from a couple of parents but it
is my opinion that they're all acting above board this bill just simply provides I guess a little assurance to parents by requiring that the lottery be transparent. I wish Representative Charlotte Douglas were here. She is supportive of this bill. We really see it as being a pro-charter school bill to help ease any concerns that are or might be out there. Are there any questions of the
committee? Seeing none. Is there anyone in the audience who'd like to speak against the bill?
For the bill? Are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. What's the motion? We have a do pass motion from Representative Gillum. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you. It just
Representative Bell, you're recognized to present House Bill 1381. Is that correct? Thank you, Mr. Chair,
members of the committee. Let me give you a second to get a tablet caught up here so that I have the bill in front of me. This is a bill that I've done my best to talk to everybody concerned. I believe at this point there is no opposition to the bill.
I've visited with a number of people. We've tried to amend it to accommodate to ADE, everyone involved. What you have here sounds like it's doing something really big to alter accountability, and in many ways I wish that there was a little more accountability, but currently we test homeschool students at a cost of about $250,000 a year and then do absolutely nothing with the data. So literally every year we just throw away $250,000.
I've visited with a number of people around this. There are a lot of us that have things we would like to see done around it, but nobody has ever attempted to do anything with this data that I can find in the history. So we're, like I say, we're just spending $250,000 to accomplish nothing. With that, I think there are a lot of better goals and better things that we can accomplish other than just testing to say we tested. So with that, I'll take committee questions.
Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bell, what was the reason for starting this test
at first? Well, Representative Armstrong, I was not here at the time. I think there at some point was an intent to ensure some accountability that homeschooling students were actually being educated. Those who register should be testing. It's my understanding there's only about 40% who do. But behind that, again, once they're tested and we spend this money,
Nothing's done with the tests. I got a lot of calls. That's the reason why that question came to
you. I was trying to get an answer. I don't know the answer to that. It predates me, and
I've been unable to run that trap. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Saban, you're recognized. I'm sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bell, I'm actually, just for clarification, not remotely opposed to this legislation, But I've had some conversations with Mr. Cox and just wanted to clarify a couple things so everybody understands them.
Number one, is it true that our public schools still will be required to keep a record of everyone who has obviously taken the option to be homeschooled so that there's still that kind of accountability and record-keeping going on? This does not address registration
in any way, shape, or form. Right. Can I have a follow-up,
Mr. Chair? You may. And the only other concern that kind of came up was, you know,
it's brought to my attention that sometimes these exams are the only opportunity for people to put eyes on these children who are being homeschooled, and therefore sometimes it's an opportunity to see if any abuse might be taking place. And so I just was wondering if you could address that concern as
well. I could, and as a parent who at one point we homeschooled our children, what I know from that personal experience, you remember that 40% compliance rate I mentioned to you? The people who are testing currently aren't the problem, and there's no question in my mind,
there are people who use homeschooling for a variety of unsavory reasons. I'm certainly not here to make any case other than that. Your people who are the problem are not going to bring their children to a school to test. Those are the parents who actually care and who are paying attention and who want to monitor educational progress. And, frankly, they're going to continue to do that whether there's a mandate or not. Representative
Gossage, you're recognized. I'm sorry, Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Is there anybody from the Department of Education here who can address this? i'd like to know whether the factual basis on which your bill proceeds is accurate and if it is it raises other questions i mean representative walker i i will tell you two
things first of all if there's opposition to this bill in this committee today i don't have i don't think i have enough votes here absent yours to even pass the bill so
I'll be glad to wait if that's the case because I don't think ADE was able to make it today but I will give you my word on video that I vetted this with the Department of Education and they assured me that what
I've told you is the case I'm not questioning your veracity representative if I may continue representative
and I would be glad to back up that question I talked with Tony about this bill representative Walker and this does nothing they get no information from the homeschoolers on this.
There's nothing that comes back to them. As far as Tony said, it's just $250,000
out the window. That's specifically the reason I'm carrying this bill. We're
literally wasting the money. Well, I would still like to have that on the record from Tony. If you don't mind pulling it down, I'd appreciate it. You can bring it back up. But I'd like to find out about not only the – I don't need confirmation since you both, The Honorable Gentleman, but I'd like to know what use they have made of this data, where it is, and what use is available.
I mean, whether it can be used by researchers to determine whether it served the public, the intended purpose. Representative Walker,
we're to the point in the session
where literally if I don't get this bill to the Senate, it has a very strong likelihood it will not proceed. I would appreciate personally your indulgence in moving the bill forward, and I will make certain personally to get you that information. Well, I
mean, since you put it that way and
it's not typical for you to be humble,
I will defer. I guess I'll absorb the insult seeing as
I need your assistance today, sir. Representative Gossage, you're recognized to follow
Speaker 99
16:57
that. Representative Bell, you know, we've talked a little bit about this bill,
Speaker 100
17:03
and I've talked to some of the folks who are supportive of it, and I certainly don't want to get in the way of passing this. You know, my only question all along has been is whether we have any constitutional obligation.
You know, in Arkansas, it's the state's responsibility constitutionally to provide an adequate and equitable education for every child. And all I wanted to make sure of is that this, whether this was part of that or not part of it. And Representative
Gossage, I have done my best to run that trap every way that I can personally find. I've been assured by everybody that I can get an answer from that that is not the case because the state's responsibility only applies to public schools.
So that's all I can tell you. I am not a legal expert, and I'm certainly not a Lakeview legal expert. And I don't want to, despite Representative Walker's assertion, I do not know enough about that to be able to respond other than what I've been advised. And I've been advised that it has no effect. Thank
you, Representative Bell. Representative McElroy, you recognize for a question?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, when this bill first came out, Representative Bell, I thought to myself, I said,
man, if my mama homeschooled me and they didn't give a test, I'd be Dr. McElroy by now. You know, magna cum laude, that's what I'm talking about. But I thought about it more, and as I investigated it, they're not doing anything with the test. And am I correct that nobody sees the test? They don't ask you that when you go to apply for ACT and all that. So it's just a waste of money. There's
literally nothing being done with it. We're literally just throwing the money away.
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just to Representative Gossage's point and also to Representative McElroy's, I mean, there's still examinations that need to be taken by the homeschool students in order to move through the system, correct? I mean, these exams haven't been used, but those final sort of benchmark exams are still required. Isn't that correct? Well, Representative Sabin, as my understanding,
and I'll be glad to bring someone that knows more about that than myself to the table,
but it's my understanding that these are unrelated to graduation requirements and all the other things. Homeschoolers, basically, as Representative McElroy indicated, your homeschooling diploma is only worth what it's worth. I mean, which has minimal value until you prove that you actually received an education in some other venue. So it's really, it has the value of the paper it's written on until it's validated elsewhere.
So whether that's through another test or, you know, SAT, ACT, you know, college academic record following that, it really has no value other than that as it is. I mean I can bring someone up here who can maybe answer the question more specifically but the end result is homeschooling is outside the traditional education system and they're just not related Question I have
Representative Gray next you're recognized Thank you Mr. Chair and Representative Bell thank you I apologize
I've asked you about a number of bills and this one hasn't come up. I've learned a little bit around here that once we get rid of something, sometimes it's hard to bring it back. And I will absolutely not get in the way of this thing passing day, but I have an opportunity to ask a question. Did you explore alternatives to doing away with the test?
If they're collecting this data and not doing anything with it, are there better alternatives? My concern would be to kids that weren't college-bound. There's no assessment if they're not headed to college. Did you look into any
of that at all? I did not. And I'll tell you just bluntly the reason that I didn't is having observed this body, both as a homeschooling parent for a number of years and a number of other things, there's been a great reluctance by the Arkansas legislature, regardless of its political makeup,
to place additional constraints on homeschoolers in general. and I think the likelihood of any additional use being made of that data is somewhere between slim and none based on my knowledge of the political history and I think what would continue is every four years we'd be throwing away a
million dollars. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Yes, I'd like to follow up. You're recognized for a question and a follow-up. Thank you. I am still concerned about the accountability of the Department of Education because it
was required to utilize the data to determine whether or not the Homeschool Act as it was passed had utility and was serving the intended purpose so as not to harm the children. That is the first thing. The second thing I'm concerned about is what I have seen many times is that children in the Pulaski County area who are homeschooled will wait until the 10th or 11th, perhaps even 12th grade and bring their almost straight A's into one of the underachieving schools
like McClellan Affair. And then they take top honors in the class because they've got grade point averages of 4.0. I mean, and I'm concerned about the ability of homeschoolers to manipulate and utilize the system so as to give greater advantage to them than to the students who stay in a public school system. How do you address that?
Well, Representative Walker, I share your concern there. This test would have nothing whatsoever to do with that.
Grade inflation is a problem in public schools. It's a problem in private schools. It's a problem in a variety of schooling environments, and I believe they're just simply unrelated. But I do share your concern. I don't think I got
it on. Does anyone else have a question in the committee? Okay. Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for the bill, against the bill?
Paul Calvert would like to speak for it. Okay. Mr. Calvert. Okay. State your name and your affiliation, please,
for the record. I'm Paul Calvert. I'm from Faulkner County. I'm just here on my own behalf. I was a homeschooler back years ago
back when it wasn't very popular or not as popular as it is today and I think we just need to respect the rights of parents to raise their children and without this intrusive measure and To me, it's a Fourth Amendment issue. I think we need to respect parents rights If there's an indication that parents are neglecting their children, then you can have probable cause to be more intrusive in a manner like this. But otherwise, I think we need to leave parents alone to do a good job with raising their children.
And I ask that you please pass this. Thank
you. Are there any questions from the committee? Does anyone like to speak against the bill?
For the bill? would you like close for the bill Mr. Chair I would like to say that I disagree with Mr. Calvert I don't believe this is an intrusive measure it's simply not being used so while I respect
his position I do believe that this is not intrusion because we're just not doing it we're just taking the few folks who do choose to test because there's no enforcement on whether they test or not so we're taking the few folks who do choose to test testing them and then doing nothing with it so with that I would appreciate the support of the committee to move this forward and again allow our state over the course of years to save a few million dollars here and there what's
the will of the committee mr. mackerel you recognize motion
do pass. I have a motion do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye.
Speaker 129
26:10
Opposed? No. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Appreciate it. Senators,
I will defer to which one of you want to go first.
she is coming before we can do that amendment.
So I guess we'll have to let Senator Irvin, you are recognized to
run your bill first. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank
you, members of the committee. This is Senate Bill 342. an act to amend the Arkansas School Recognition and Reward Program.
Many of you are familiar with the Arkansas School Recognition and Reward Program, and I would invite you to go onto YouTube, actually, under Arkansas Learns and YouTube, and look at the different presentations. First, we need to adopt the amendment. Sorry. Before I present the bill, the amendment On page 2, line 1, this was requested by the governor's office as well as members of the Senate committee.
On page 2, line 1, we are including if funds are available back into the bill. and the reason for that is currently it is funded at 7 million there's a request to increase that to 10 million however that's if the appropriation passes and if the appropriation is funded but if it's not then we want to make sure that there's not something that the department
would have to fund if that's not passed, if that makes sense. So it's important to make sure that if funds are available, that language is back into the bill. That's important. So I would appreciate a good vote on adoption of the amendment. Any questions on the amendment? Need a motion to adopt
amendment? I have a motion to adopt. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Amendment is adopted. You're recognized to run your bill. Thank you. So running the bill as amended,
And, again, this is the School Recognition and Reward Program. Many of you are familiar with this. Lots of your schools and your districts probably received these grants, and it's based on the academic achievement and growth in academic performance and progress as measured by assessments and other criteria required by rule of the State Board of Education. I can tell you just as a personal experience in presenting these checks to the different schools, quite often we recognize and we award and we applaud athletic achievements through assemblies.
And I'm all in favor of that. I'm a volunteer soccer coach for my public school for two, three years, and very actively involved with my school. So I love athletics, and I think that we do need to support them. But I also think we need to have assemblies for academic achievements. And that's what this program does. It allows for those students to really be applauded and celebrated for their academic achievement in a meaningful way.
When you take a large check to that school and you tell those kids, this is your money and it's $20,000, that's a big deal for an elementary school kid or even for a high school kid. and then they understand that their hard work and academic achievement really translate into real-time dollars, that really encourages those kids to continue down that path of academic achievement and academic success
and how that will translate to their future. And most of the, there is a board that comes together that decides how that money is then spent and most of them purchased technology and Chromebooks for their students to use. I would say probably 99% of them did. So I think it's a phenomenal program. It's something that the former Governor Beebe embraced and supported,
and I'm just glad that we have a consistency with the previous administration and now with this administration, and I think that that's a mark for a very good program when you have that type of tremendous support. So I would entertain any questions. Are there
any – Representative Walker? Yes, I have two. Oh, okay. Hold on, Representative Walker. I had
Representative Armstrong first. You recognize Representative Armstrong. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator, this program is probably good.
If you bring it up, do you bring it before the students at the first of the school year so they'll have a challenge to reach? You know, I've seen this program work in schools, especially charters and private schools, where they've rewarded the students for so many, bringing their grades up to a certain level. And this is the same type program that you're referring to, right? Yes, it
is. It sure is. And I have the liberty to go a little further. I'm a product of private schools.
I'm a private school-educated person. However, my husband and I chose to move to Mountain View, Arkansas and put our children into the public school system. And I am passionate and committed to making sure that our public school system is just as good as any private school system out there. And this program helps achieve that, just like what you were saying. Well, I'm proud to see this and you giving
them rewards and giving them goals. They can set a goal. I'm going to reach this because I'm going to win this money. Absolutely.
And I would encourage you as representatives of your district to be integrally involved in this. And if you'll go on YouTube and you'll look up all the different schools, Rosebud, Salem, Viola, and the Guy Perkins that I went to do these presentations at, and they're on YouTube with Arkansas Learns, and look at the excitement and the administration had, the teachers, parents, and the students. It's tremendous, and you're a part of that because you made that happen if you support this program.
So get involved. It makes a big difference when they see your face
there. Thank you, Senator. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess I'm the fly in the ointment. The bill doesn't make it possible for all children in the state to get this reward, does it? It only allows those who are in the highest 5% of achieving schools, according to Section C1A1A.
The public school or charter school is in the top. It was before 10%, now 5% of all public schools in Arkansas. So in order to get this reward, you have to be in
an achieving school already. Is that correct? No. No, we actually have changed the bill to where you now have schools that can demonstrate improvement and growth, as well as we've separated that, and there's also to where actually more schools will probably be included as the bill is written now.
And that was one of the things that we worked with, because there are schools that have achieved, but may be left out because they can't demonstrate that they can grow in that achievement because they're already there. But there are other schools that can demonstrate an improvement in where they have been and then where they end up. So that's why we've reduced this and transformed the program so actually more schools could be involved with the program. Mr. Chair, would
you be kind enough without holding against me
to ask the Senator to show where in the bill the criteria for eligibility in a particular school or in all schools is set forth in this so as to afford the opportunity for every student in the state to have an opportunity to get this $100. You may. Representative Walker, every student in the
state of Arkansas. I'm saying in the bill. Just tell me in the bill where it is. Every student in the state of Arkansas has the opportunity to succeed in our public school system.
And if they are taught and if they put in the hard work and they earn the grades and they do well on their test, they have that opportunity. There is no person in this General Assembly or in the public out there that would deny a child an opportunity to succeed if they are well taught in our public school system. so this bill does not discriminate against any child in the public school system it rewards those that work hard all due respect to the
senator i'm just asking if she could just direct
my attention since i see in the in the writing something contrary is there something in this writing that reflects the argument that is being set forth for the bill if you could
just draw my attention to it but when it says public school that means the public that's not discriminating against any person or child that's inside the school system. Public, to me, does not discriminate. We provide a public school education constitutionally, and when the word public appears in this bill,
which it does over and over and over again, it gives any child within that public school system that
may. Here's the problem I have, Mr. Irvin. And it says the language of the law is limited to the public school or public charter school being in the top 10% of all public schools in Arkansas. And I am aware that the University of Arkansas group that deals with public policy has compiled a list of all the schools in the state.
And in that, it's for every region of the state, and I'll be happy to share that with the other members of the Education Committee. But in that, we can now tell which schools would be and the students would be able to qualify for that because they have ranked the schools that are within the top 5 percent and the top 10 percent. And in my understanding, there is only one school in southeast Arkansas that meets the standard, and that's KIPP. And all the others in southeast Arkansas, there may be two or three out of about 100 that are in the top 5 percent.
So all of the schools are the ones where you have higher achieving students right now. So this seems to reward the schools that are already, have students that are already higher achieving. So I'd like to know how a student, let's assume that there's one in Mr. McElroy's district, Dumas. And Dumas is not on the University of Arkansas's list. How a student there would fit in there since it doesn't come within one of the 5% or 10%
or even for that matter in Representative Bell's district where you don't have any students who are within the top 5% or 10% of the schools in the state. How do those students, according to this bill, yet include it for the $100 gift? I guess there's no
answer on that question. Well, I mean, you
know, I would say that the KIPP school, we need to look and see why the KIPP school is there
and why it's doing well, and we should translate that into all those schools in South Arkansas. Every school has the opportunity to make it into that top 5%. There is nothing that we do to prevent them from achieving that. And so I understand your argument. I would just disagree with it, and I appreciate your perspective. However, mine is just very different. I think you reward hard work. I think you reward work ethic.
I think that you reward people and students to work hard to achieve something, and that's what this program does. I'll give you an example. My public school system in Mountain View, Arkansas, has over 65% on free and reduced lunches. There are poor kids that can achieve, and this bill does not discriminate against any of them. So I would appreciate us looking at that and understanding that hard work and success
and hard work ethic for students should be recognized and should be rewarded.
Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. What I love about this bill is that it has in this section where I'm reading it, we're not just, you know, awarding this money to, you know, a top academic school, but we're basing this on student performance growth.
and that opens it up to you know to put those levels out there that you know let's start wherever we are and let's move those students upward and you know we see at the end of that we're going to be able to you know reap some rewards from those efforts too many times we're just worried about who's not meeting the standard and we were not we didn't have a mechanism for rewarding you know and putting those you know those carrots out there for those you know for
just growth so I've seen some benefits of that in schools you know in my area that have you know how you know how reduced you know and free lunch and so my my question is having the qualifier in there for it you know being able to go to growth schools you know and how does that change the the equation for who is getting the rewards right and and
i agree and i think that
was a good change to the program and one that was needed and actually um in the testimony with with in the Senate, that will actually translate probably into more schools that will be recognized through the program. Thank you. Representative Bell, you're recognized for a question.
Point of information, Mr. Chair. Representative Walker indicated that the students in my area weren't able to qualify for this, and I just wanted to point out that I personally delivered
three checks in the last cycle, and I just wanted to Since my lack of humility was noted, I wanted to say how proud I was of the people in those schools. There was one school. There are
occasional schools here and there that are in the area. But by and large, they are limited to a particular area within particular zip codes, within socioeconomic. Representative Walker, you need to be recognized. But if you want to turn your mic on, I will let
you say that. I don't want to just go and speak against the bill,
but it is not a good bill in terms of equity. All right. Thank you. Is there any other questions from the committee?
Representative Hodges, you're recognized for a question Senator Irvin, you mentioned that
a board once the funds are awarded, makes the decision as to where the funds will go and what they're used for. Could you just clarify that a little bit? Who at these schools is making the decision on where the funds go and a little bit more on where the
funds typically go? I believe it's a teacher, a parent, and perhaps an administrator or perhaps even a student.
I have to look at the makeup of that, and I don't see those folks here. But parents are involved in this decision-making, which I believe is necessary and appropriate. And all of the ones that I am familiar with decided to purchase technology for their schools and Chromebooks for the students to use. If you look at Grovesbury Westside, They have now transitioned to where every student at Greersbury Westside has the ability to have a Chromebook that they can even take home with them.
And on their bus rides to their athletic events, they download their homework and make sure the kids do their homework on the buses. And then when they come pull back in, they turn in those Chromebooks and they've got their homework already done. I just appreciate that level of discipline and use of technology. and that's at Greer's Ferry Westside, and they're in my district, and I'm super proud of them. I will comment that I live in a very, very poor county. Stone County, Arkansas, is one of the poorest counties in the state of Arkansas.
It is always compared to the Delta when it comes to those children that qualify for free and reduced lunches. and the population there, if you look at their salary, the annual salary of the folks that live in Stone County, it's very low. It's a very poor area. It's always included on the Minority Health Commission's reports. Stone County and Fulton County are both included on those reports.
And there are these two counties that I represent kind of in the pocket of north central Arkansas And then you'll see South Arkansas and, unfortunately, the Delta when you look at those statistics on the Minority Health Commission report that my former senator really championed. And it's because of just the poor economic conditions of those counties. And I've lived there for 17 years, and I know it very well. and so but my checks that I have delivered to Salem which is in Fulton County to Viola which
is in Fulton County to Rural Special which is in Fox Arkansas Stone County Timbo which is in Stone County Mountain View which is in Stone County these are all really poor kids that have achieved unbelievably well in their assessments and in their grades so I just wanted to add that to the conversation. I appreciate your question. It's very important that you have parents engaged and involved in those decisions. Thank you.
Seeing no other questions, Committee, Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a question. Could you
take this and put it in your lower performing schools and this would be a great incentive for the students to pick up and you wouldn't have, some of your schools would pick up all for this. And so I think it would be a great effort if this was handed down to the schools, not all your top performing, because you've got students, they can't help it because of the school they're in. They can't change that condition. So I think it should be spreaded.
And the studies that's been done nationwide shows that you can go into a low-performing school and give them good incentives and the grades and stuff will pick up and make them be a top school and tell you you'll have top students coming out. Yes, ma'am.
Wouldn't you say this is true? Yes, I would say that's true, and I think that's part of the reason why we revised the program for the growth factor that Representative Douglas mentioned. And, again, I would encourage you as a representative to go into your schools and bring this program to them and challenge them
and make them aware of what they can achieve and how that translates into real money and to technology for their schools. You have the ability to do that. You have the freedom to do that, and you have the position to do that. And they respect you, and those children look up to you, and they want to be you one day. And it gives them hope if they can come in and see that maybe I could grow up and be a state representative or a state senator one day. And so I appreciate that question, and I appreciate anybody that wants to get involved with this.
You know, this is great, but some schools won't allow you in there to talk to their students like that. You tell them that you have the appropriation for their school.
Well, I served on the school board, and I know some of the problems
there. Yeah, I know. Thank you, Senator. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any other questions on the
committee? I'm seeing none. Is there anybody in the audience that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Would you like to close for your bill?
I think I've said a lot. Thank you. I would appreciate a
good vote. How's that? Rep. Douglas? Motion to pass. As amended. We have a representative as amended. As amended. I have a motion to do pass as amended. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, no. No. You have
passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. And I appreciate all the perspectives shared today. Thank you.
Senator Clark, you are recognized to present SB 211, and I believe you have an amendment to present on that bill first. Good advice. Sorry, I didn't get his message.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I am, this is my first time to run a bill in house education in my either session that I have been here. So y'all please be kind. Remember how kind I've been on the other end. and all the kindness that was extended was because I talked to the other members and told them to be kind.
That was all directly from me. I've got a bill here I think you'll like. You will direct me on how we proceed. We need to run the amendment first. And so what it's representative of finance amendment. Does everybody
have the amendment in front of them? Yes. Is there any discussion on the amendment or any questions on the amendment? I have a do-pass motion from Representative Douglas on that amendment. All those in favor say aye.
Aye. Any opposed, no? Amendment is passed. You are welcome to explain your bill as amended. Ignore the amendment.
I hate to run amendment in committee because it's so hard to read the two. It just cleans up some language. The bill itself really says very well what we're doing. Does everyone have the handout? I guess Mark, okay.
The handout includes both a color chart, two-page handout, front and back, that we are proposing to be handed out in public school in 7th through 12th grade, and also to entering freshmen, at least the backside to entering freshmen. I'm sorry. Excuse my manners. Where did Sarah go?
Right there. If I could ask Sarah to come sit with me, please. Sarah, if you'll go
ahead and state your name and who you're with, then
Sarah Argue with the Arkansas Research Center. Thank you. And you can recognize it any time. They have compiled this report. My compliments to Arkansas and the Division of Workforce Services
and to the organization that Sarah works with, we are one of the few states that have this information already compiled. We didn't have to spend extra money to get these numbers. It's already there. And they have both a book, if you allow us to hand these out, from the Arkansas Research Center, Arkansas Education to Employment Report, that I think you will find quite interesting that they do.
What this bill does is it requires, beginning this coming year, if we look on the second page, line 18, that every two-year school will present this report to their incoming freshman. On line 28, that every four-year school will present this report to their incoming freshman. And the report that they will give is this one on the back that shows the top 15 paying degrees and the lowest 10.
I very much wish my daughter may have got the same degree, just graduated from UCA a couple years ago. But I certainly, as a parent in counseling her, wish I had thought of this and would have liked to look at it because it may have changed what she did. Then on page three, the last page of the bill, line three, annually beginning August 1, 2016, a public school student, grades 7 through 12,
or the student's parents shall receive a two-page summary. That is, this is a prototype. this report can be changed, that shows the difference in varying degrees of education and the difference in degrees. They also get the backside, and this is important as they're preparing to go into high school and decide what courses to take and what direction they want to go. Certainly a great thing to do at a very low cost, almost nothing, one piece of paper.
and one other thing you have my talking points which is an email from someone else but the 45% of the graduates McKenzie and Company did a survey of recent four year college graduates, 45% of the graduates were working in positions that did not require a four year degree, 45% 48% of the graduates were not working in their chosen field of study 48% did not look at the graduation rate of their school or program, 38% did not look
at employment of their school or program, 37% did not look at starting salaries of their school or program, and a whopping 53% of the survey graduates would choose a different field or college if they could. We think that this report will be most helpful in directing both young people in 7 through 12 that they need an education and entering college freshmen on what education that they might want. I'll be glad to accept questions at this time.
Representative Douglas, you recognize for a question. I really appreciate you bringing this because I think it is the piece that's missing in helping kids make that decision about what they want to be when they grow up. We're doing maybe an okay job in K-12 to get some of this information out in some of our career classes, but pushing that to the college level, I think, is just phenomenal, so I just would, you know, how do you perceive this
being pushed to the freshman, what kind of delivery vehicle, or have you thought about
that? Representative Vining-Douglas, I don't think that far ahead. Okay. I would hope that, and talking to higher ed, they have embraced this and I trust that they will do a good job of presenting it. Thank you. Good bill. Are there any other
done a great job presenting that. Is there anyone in the audience Oh, you have another question? Okay. Does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill?
Speaker 192
56:42
like Do you have anything to say? I think I would just point out that the handout you've received is pulled from the 2013 AEER and that all of this data can be reconfigured in however the committee best sees the presentation to meet its goals.
Seeing no questions, Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Motion to
pass as amended. I have a motion to do pass as amended.
All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, Chair. Passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, members of the committee. Representative Clark, while you're here, would you want to present 179 or you want me to go ahead and do that? If you would
that. But I will stay here, and if there's any questions, I want something to know. I would appreciate that. Representative Harris, you're recognized to
present your bill. House Bill 1272. Merry Christmas, Representative Harris. Thank you.
Jingle bells. I'd sing Jingle Bells, but I don't think that would be very pretty. Thank you, committee members. Thank you, Chair and Madam Vice Chair. Today I bring you what is also known as the Merry Christmas Bill, but I think we all can remember back in school when we celebrated Christmas and kind of the good memories we had when we would make ornaments at school or do different types of fun activities at school And just this year, my wife and I went and did an activity at my son's fourth grade class
and made ornaments and put it on their Christmas tree. But this bill just simply allows the school to continue to do those type of activities. And it was sparked by a grandmother who told me a story of where their grandchild could not say the word Merry Christmas in the school or in that particular classroom. And so this just protects the child to say it and the teachers to have the freedom to say it.
But it's really just to have a good time in the classroom and just to continue to do it. And just to remember the committee members that this is a federal holiday that was recognized in October of 1870. So this is something that we're just allowing to continue to go on. And in the bill, we did amend it. I worked with the Attorney General's Office to make it a better bill.
The state representative that passed this in Texas in 2013 called me. They've not had issues up to this point in Texas. Indiana is passing it this year. Ohio is looking at it. And there's a couple other states that are doing it. And so this is just something that I thought was a good idea. And you guys had some issues on the other House Bill 1273, which we are amending to make it better
and to have some of the ideas that you put in it. And to kind of make sure that you understand what we put in the bill was that it says may. None of this is must or shall. It says may, and we also made sure on the putting up the symbols, it cannot adhere to one religion. And it also says that as far as the display, it's up to the school to put up the display.
And so that keeps you from having displays that you don't want. And so that's why
we added that to the bill. Okay. Are there any questions by committee members? Representative Walker,
you're recognized. I'll defer first to Representative Lowry, if you
Thank you, Madam Chairman, and thank you, Mr. Walker. I am extremely sympathetic to the concern about political correctness run amok in our schools
where kids are being told that they can't say Merry Christmas. But I am really, I mean, I want to try and put this in preface it as a question. we have been Republicans have been cornered or accused of being all over the map on local control how is this not the most egregious example of taking away local control
on a decision that really in the whole scope of things is minor as far as education of our kids is concerned I'm going to shoot it
right back to you, Representative Lowry. Please do. This puts local control at its finest point because it says the school may, which means the school board chooses if they're going to display. The school board chooses the curriculum. The school board chooses what they're going to do. This is not what the state's doing.
This is allowing the school board, the local school, to choose what they're going to do. So they may do it. This is allowing them to do it. That's all this is saying. This is not
that flexibility? I was standing when a representative, I was standing with him, and he called somebody, because I don't want to, you know,
And they said they do still call their Christmas, they use the word Christmas, but it was passed down to them by the Department of Education not to use the word Christmas. And in my local school district, it is now called the winter break. They don't use the Christmas break. And in their handbook, the only recognized holiday they have now is Halloween. and they celebrate it for five days.
It's in their handbook. That's what this bill is not only just because of that, but it's so they can continue to use the word Christmas. It's not a politically correct word. And so that's all it's doing is allowing them to use it. And so this is about local control. And this is about them being able to make that decision. And so this is local control at its
finest. Well, thank you for that clarification. Thank you,
Thank you. I'm concerned also about the emphasis to do what already districts can do, but when they do it, they have some possible exposure, recognizing that not many people have filed lawsuits regarding it. But my question is, how can we condone the state, in effect, saying, as I was taught, that Christ was killed by the Jews, and therefore we ought not to like Jews, recognizing, of course, that the Bible says that Christ was a Jew.
Why should we have that dialogue in public schools at a particular Christmas time when there are other alternatives that are less intrusive and are less inclining to promote racial bigotry, religious bigotry? Representative Walker, I don't
want to be flippant with your question, but I'll be honest with you.
We're talking about a time of celebration, being with your family, traditions of Christmas. That's what
we're talking about. And how putting requiring districts, you know, I'll do deference to what Representative Lowry asked, we are effectively requiring districts to disregard what the State Department has found fairly workable. And that is to allow people an opportunity to worship as they please or to provide recognition
of the holidays as they please. And I'm trying to understand what public interest that promotes, what religious public interest that promotes that is not otherwise divisive or perhaps may be divisive.
What does that promote? What we're promoting about the Christmas holiday is time held tradition in the United States
of America from the very beginning of a country that came together to celebrate something as one body. And that's what we celebrate at Christmas, where we can come together at one time on December 25th as a nation to celebrate us together. And that is what it's about, the Christmas holiday. Thank you. Representative
Yes, thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. And Representative Harris, I appreciate your clarification to me of the language of May. I, like you, am extremely troubled that schoolchildren are not able to reference Merry Christmas. uh my office did a an art contest with the uh elementary schools that are in my district we had kindergarten students provide to us their artwork of the holiday season
and um and i'm sure in an attempt to not offend anybody you know one school the all the artwork we got was they were told to draw a snowman there's a whole lot more to the christmas season or the holiday season than snowmen and i after hearing your answers to my questions and also to representative walkers i you know i do concede that there is a significant problem with schools
school districts feeling compelled uh to not do what might be their conscience which would be to allow celebration of various sorts. I just wonder if you have looked at any other options. For instance, I think this is a perfect example of why issue one is going to be so important. The ability of a legislative council to be able to review rules and regulations promulgated by departments. Because if it's true that the State Department of
Education sent down a policy that you should not celebrate Christmas or however they worded, then that kind of oversight is necessary. But have you looked at any other vehicles to
be able to promote this? There's always unspoken rules to Representative Lowry. That's what I've always gotten into with the line of work that we do. always unspoken rules that you wish
you had a tape recorder at all times. Do you have this documented or do you have this recorded? Well, no, I didn't have it recorded to know that it was said. That courts have repeatedly ruled that Christmas is also a secular celebration. they've also ruled Hanukkah as a secular celebration just like that's why the menorah was on the White House lawn
two years ago along with the Christmas tree when I was there in Washington D.C. in 2013 and I was surprised to see it, I mean it was life size, I mean that's why I was so surprised to see it because it was as big as the White House and took pictures of it. And so it's the interpretation that comes down because we're hypersensitive. And that's
my point, Representative Lowry. And that's why I wrote this piece of legislation.
Follow-up, Madam Chairman. Yes, sir. One follow-up. I would like to just suggest, because I've run into something similar, well, not really even similar, a bill in another committee where it directs a commission to do something, and I have found out that the commission is already in the process of doing that. So I've scrapped the bill and instead made it a resolution to express legislative intent.
Would you consider, because I think that there's a lot of us that are very sensitive to what you're talking about and also sensitive to the fact that the legislature needs to speak on this, but not to the extent of any kind of, and again, I understand you've got the word may in there, but it still is in part a mandate. It is, as Representative Walker said, it's kind of a free pass for them to violate a rule that the department's laid down.
Would you consider running this as a resolution so that we could make a loud statement that we do believe that there should be recognition of all traditions? No, I will
not. And I will tell you this, though, because I'm making a stand, and I'm tired of legislators not taking a stand. When you have people dying and taking a stand,
and yet we cannot take a stand, and I'm sick and tired of it when the Constitution covers us. I'm pulling down the bill today, and I will work it to where it appeases people, and I'm good with that. But no, I will not make it a resolution because it does nothing.
Are you pulling your bill down then, Representative Harris? Yes, Madam Co-Chair. Okay.
Speaker 53
1:12:48
Okay, thank you. Representative Douglas. Dan Douglas. He's been here for a while.
HB 1495, is that correct? I believe so, Mr. Chair. Do you have it in front of you? I don't in front of me, so I'll take your word for it. We can get you
one if you need it. That's all right. You don't need it. It, uh, yes, it's 14. It's, uh, the bill allow us district to option of advertising on school bus. Yes, sir. Okay, you're recognized for $14.95.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, we all know that all of our school districts' transportation budgets are stretched thin. Lots of times we hear different groups and school organizations wanting to go on field trips. They go to a band trip, go to FFA competition, go to different competitions, and they can't go because they don't have the transportation dollars available. What this bill does is it allows the option, nothing is mandated,
but it allows the option of local school districts to decide if they want to sell advertisement space on their school buses. Every time you go to a football game or a basketball game, you see local businesses advertising signs out there in support of their school districts. This advertising money would go into the transportation of the school districts, and they could use it however they see fit, but hopefully they would be able to gain extra money for extracurricular activity transportation.
Other states do this. I'll be honest, this idea was brought to me by a local superintendent in my district, and he came from a state where it was allowed the rules and regulations on the type of signage. Of course, we don't want any, just open up the advertisement to anything. We don't want beer or cigarette advertisements or scotch advertisements. We don't want seductions or, you know, other stores that might not be appropriate advertising.
But local businesses could certainly advertise. You said on taxi cabs, on other buses, and that's basically the bill. Pretty simple. I'd entertain any questions.
who can advertise. Representative Bell is recognized for the question person. Thank you,
Mr. Chair, and I will have a follow-up. Representative Douglas, I guess I have two concerns. Do these rules that are referenced here exist currently,
or is the subsection C, the commission shall adopt rules as necessary, mean that these rules will all be created in the future? They
would all be created in the future, and I believe they would come under review. Back
to, and I'm very glad that we do now have that review, and it gives us a little more confidence in situations like this. I guess my question goes to the whole world of free speech and just how far we actually would be able to go in restricting what that advertising is
without then getting lawsuits of denial of access. I'll give you an example. Several things were mentioned here earlier, but one that came to my mind immediately was political advertising. I think there are a number of candidates who would really like to have their face on every school bus in their district can we, based on Citizens United ruling and some of the others that are out there would we be able to restrict
that? Representative Bell I'll be honest, I can't tell you for sure, but I have never
seen a political advertisement sign at a football field or a basketball court. I believe there are already restrictions on that. I feel like there should be. If not, there should be. Also, you don't see bear or Victoria's Secret advertisements at a school facility. So I feel like there is probably ample latitude in the law and regulations to allow this without discrimination suits being able to
Speaker 129
1:17:32
be brought forth. Thank you, Mr. Chair. That's my two. Representative Douglas, you
recognized yes after the after the beating you just gave me in transportation I'm my attitude is but
on cuz bring it on that my my question follows representative Bell's I would think that you would really need to set up some regulations on defining, you know, could we put Merry Christmas if a church wanted to do that
and put that on the bus? I mean, we're just discussing those things right here. Could a church say, you know, we're going to have a lock-in, you know, everybody come to church? So I'm seeing some gray areas here that are going to put a lot of pressure on school boards to make those decisions and wonder if we need to lay out
something in the bill to help that. Representative, on line 30, section C, it states the commission shall adopt rules necessary to implement this.
Okay. That way, those rules and regulations on what type of advertisement would be allowed would come back before this legislative body to be approved. Okay. The commission is? State Education Commission. Okay. By the way, the visiting with Commissioner Wood, he had no problems with this. He said he wouldn't support it or fight it, but he had no problems.
He was neutral on this. Representative
recognized, Representative Walker. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess when you have a lame duck commissioner, he won't comment on anything either way. But I'm concerned about two things. One is, of course, what Representative Bill mentioned, and I guess one of the other representatives, and that's the free speech thing.
Let's just assume that the Ku Klux Klan wanted to advertise on a school bus, and they put it there, or some really pro-ISIS-type group wanted to advertise. That would apparently be possible because of the district's need to obtain revenue to allow that, but there would be no restrictions against it, it would seem. And the second one is that if you're dealing with public schools, public schools, do you not agree, have to provide equal education to all so that you cannot let some schools get revenue while others in the same school system don't share that same revenue and therefore allow for means tests to be the basis for the quality of education within a school system one child gets.
Do you understand my question? Yes, sir. I certainly do, and I think this has no relationship at all to that because currently I have never been to a football game, but what you see advertisement out around the football field, Nunley Chevrolet, B&B Heating and Air, Al's Plumbing, whatever it may be, schools already sell advertisement to local businesses. This is absolutely no different, and each school district can decide if they want to sell that advertising or not.
So, therefore, the equality issue, they all have the option. This is all optional. It is local control at its best, with the exception of the State Commission determining and giving the rules and regulations on what type of signage, the size it could
be, and the location it would be placed on the school buses. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. I think that was an excellent response to my question. However, the question of inflammatory advertising has not been addressed.
And the First Amendment may allow for inflammatory advertising, but I wonder how this can be done in such a way as to limit the speech of prospective advertising to those persons whose businesses may not be inflammatory to somebody. I understand your concern, Representative Walker, and
we would not want that in any shape, form, or fashion. But I believe there are already probably regulations in place
because I have yet to see the Ku Klux Klan advertising at a local basketball game. I think we already have those rules
recognized for a question. I guess my question is about the unfair competition advantage that public schools would have.
For instance, Central Arkansas Transit already has difficulty in being able to fund their operations. And if I were an advertiser and I had a choice between having my ad on the side of a school bus that's traveling all over the county or putting it on Central Arkansas, and probably at a cheaper rate, I would imagine the school district would be more competitive. I would choose the buses. How would you answer the criticism that this may be an unfair competitive edge
to other types of advertising medium? Well,
you would agree that this enterprise is supported by public dollars, so that gives an unfair advantage in the marketplace? No,
Representative Lowry, I wouldn't. I think this is just a common-sense idea to allow school districts to try to help fund their transportation dollars. It's no competition towards anybody else.
These other transit buses, they don't have to answer to the regulations here. They can advertise cigarettes. They can advertise lingerie or whatever else they want to on it. The school buses would not be allowed to do that, so they would be restricted. I haven't seen many transit buses going up and down the road with Al's Plumbing on it. It's usually national brands there. This would, in all likelihood, from what I've seen of other advertisement at school districts,
would be more local business support there. Okay. Thank you. Point well taken.
And thank you for your allowing me to do my follow-up without asking for it. You can punish me however you want. And thank you for the question. I'll give
the next one to Representative Walker. He'll get an extra one for you. Representative Saban, you recognize. I'll just give it to Representative Saban. You have three if you want them. I'll take all three. No, probably not.
Actually, Representative Douglas, I think this is an outstanding idea, and I just wanted to have an indulgence for a second. When I was the student body president at the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville, about 15 or 16 years ago, Razorback Transit, which for decades had been free of charge for all of the students, anybody who wanted to use it on campus, the administration was going to charge or begin, had proposed charging anybody a fee to start using the buses.
And I actually brought a proposal to them and said, well, instead of charging the students, why don't you just sell advertising on the buses and keep the system free? And ultimately, that's what they ended up doing, and to this day, Razorback Transit at the University of Arkansas continues to be free of charge if anybody wants to use it. I think this makes sense because obviously those schools who obviously have their buses circulating more often will have a source of revenue to support them.
So my question, it's kind of a two-fold question, so I'm glad the Chair gave me an opportunity here. Number one, do you know if there are already regulations in place in terms of what public school buses need to look like in terms of the fact that they need to be yellow, that kind of thing, and would those regulations be affected by putting advertising on the outside or on the
inside of a bus? Yes, there are regulations, and there are a lot of federal regulations on that, standards that have to be met,
But the standards do not prohibit this type of advertisement. As I said, other states are doing it currently, so there should be no issue with that. Okay. And just the
second follow-up was, have you looked at the University of Arkansas to see what their policies are? Because as you've sort of indicated in response to a number of the questions, there probably are models for this in terms of ensuring that constitutionally protected free speech is maintained
while at the same time regulating for things like political speech and other things that may not be appropriate in a public venue or with students under a certain
age. I'll be honest. I have not looked at the University of Arkansas. They haven't been a big supporter of highways, so I haven't looked at them and taken them into consideration.
I have two more on the list. Representative
Bell, you're recognized. Mr. Chair, my question has mostly been answered.
I think just very narrowly, my concerns are centered around the whole issue of how far can we go to restrict constitutional rights to free speech in this aspect. that there are people clearly who are doing it so obviously there's some sort of policy that works so i guess uh is that basically what you're asserting representative douglas is look we'll stay consistent with what other folks are doing now yes
sir thanks mr chair representative mackerel you're recognized thank you mr chair representative
douglas i many many moons ago i was on the annual staff at school and we would take out out of school, which I really loved more than anything, and so I had to pay for the annuals. I suppose they're still doing that today. So wouldn't this be effectively doing the same
thing? Effectively it would be, Representative, except I think these would be machine printed and not in quill.
I didn't say that far back. Motion at proper time. Representative
Gray, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Douglas, I tend to agree with you on the ability to regulate this and the free speech issues and also the financial ramifications of it.
My question is, have you given any thought or addressing concern that maybe the smaller areas or the rural schools would be at a little disadvantage, even more so than they are now? They have a smaller tax base, smaller business population, are already struggling, and the larger school districts in the more populated areas where they're already at advantage because of that will be put at even more of an advantage? and also have you thought about the small businesses in these communities
that open up their checkbook as many times as they can for these schools and were creating maybe potentially creating another obligation upon them to more visibly support their local school? And that
but nobody's holding a gun to their head and saying you must advertise that this is all free and willing advertisement. And let's face it, bigger school districts have more buses.
They'll bring in more revenue. But this just opens up an option for some funds that none of them have at the present time. Even a school district in a rural area, if they just get four or five businesses that advertise, or they don't want to have the trouble. They could survey the business community, see who wanted to advertise, to see if it was even a viable option. It just opens up an opportunity to try to help some of these school districts with their transportation funding issues.
Thank you, Representative Lewis. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any other questions from the committee? Is there anyone in the audience who'd like to speak
against this bill for the bill? would you like to close for your bill I am closed Mr. Chair thank you committee I'd
appreciate a good vote Representative McElroy you're recognized for a motion motion do pass I have a motion to do passed all those in favor say aye any opposed no congratulations you passed your bill thank you Mr. Chair thank you committee
I appreciate you Representative Wallace you are recognized to present your resolution House Resolution 1036 I'm sorry 1032 I'll get it
members This is a resolution, simple resolution that congratulates the Manila High School team, the Manila Lions
as a Class 3A Boys District and Regional Basketball Champion these are a good bunch of kids it's a good school they're not a basketball powerhouse the last time they did this was back in 1962 and there's not a lot of talent that was on this team but there was a lot of a lot of hustle and a lot of heart
and the whole town's proud of them we're proud of them district and I would ask you all to
give me a good vote on this. Are there any questions committee? Reps. McElroy, you're recognized. Representative Wallace, is it
true that when you were a child that you played maneuver and they actually beat the jeans off of you? Am I allowed to
take the fifth on this Mr. Chairman? Yes you are.
are there any other questions anyone like speak against
the bill our resolution for the resolution you recognize close for that thank you mr chairman and i
have nothing to say except i i enjoyed sitting here and listening to you all day and listen to the more senior legislators it was a learning experience for me so thank you for what you're doing here
representative bell you recognized for a
motion mr. chair indifference to my senior neighbor to my
left motion do pass I have a motion to do pass all those in favor say aye any opposed no congratulations you have passed your resolution thank you mr. chairman thank you committee representative Charlotte Douglas you're I recognize to present your House Concurrent Resolution 1008.
Representative Charlotte Douglas. Thank you, Mr. Chair. this was a collaborative effort between teacher of the year Jonathan Crossley and I while he was still here we got together and thought you know how can we improve you know just information and communication between legislators and what's happening in their districts and what's happening at their schools and just in general with late education And we decided to go forward with this resolution.
It's not a binding bill, but we want to designate the month of September as bring your legislator to school month. and would like the schools in collaboration with their school boards or the AEA to try to plan some activities around the legislators coming to school, tours of the buildings, some forums, speak in a civics class,
just generally start those conversations and get us back into the district to looking at what is going on in our districts. It gives the schools a great opportunity to tell us what their successes are and what their challenges are before we come back into the session. So this is just a resolution to encourage us to do that, and we'll try to work with the education community to push this and make it a really fun and meaningful activity.
I'd be glad to take any
questions. Are there any questions? Representative Walker, you're recognized. Your
resolution, of course, is good, and I support it, but is there a presumption that people in the public are welcome in our public schools and that legislators are welcome in the public schools?
Is there that presumption? We all know what happens when you assume. Thank you. But having said that, you know, if there is not a good public perception,
I think this is an opportunity for us to put a good step
forward and to... No, my question went to welcome. I mean, there are districts that refuse public access, not only to public information under the FOIA, but even to presence in the schools just to be there. I'm not aware of
that, but, you know... Thank you. I think it's a shame that that is the truth. Are there any
other questions? Does anyone in the audience like to speak against the resolution, for the resolution?
Do I have a motion? I have a motion. Representative McElroy, do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you have passed your resolution. Appreciate it. Representative Hendron, we are finally there. you are recognized to present house bill 1074 thank
you mr chairman i thought for a while i was at our regular monthly nursing home
service at the bella vista nursing home because when i start playing my accordion i'm not going to play my accordion out there the crowd starts leaving one by one and i'm afraid i've got a problem here because if this is a problem bill I don't think we've got 10 or 11 members here but we'll try anyway this I'm glad this is not the cursive writing bill by the way this is a better bill than that perhaps house bill 1074 I was not aware until recently that in fact our school districts weren't aware that one school
district can do business in another school district and they're doing it frequently up in our neck of the woods and and some of it's okay but it goes further than that perhaps you know we found out through an attorney general's opinion that was released here not too far ago far along back that let me just be specific because i think we make better laws when i really know who's doing what to whom and why they're doing it so let me tell you what's going on here is that the bentonville school district was looking for some additional space for schools because that as you know is a
growing school district. They looked over to my hometown, over towards Gravitt, and they looked up towards Pea Ridge, which is the north, which is another contiguous school district, and that contiguous word is something that as you get questions about some other legislation that's passed down here recently, you need to read that bill and look what that means. But anyway, so the question we found out is actually if one school district decides to build a school over in somebody else's district, they can do it, according to the Attorney General opinion in the current law. If you read this bill that you've got here with the amendments we make to it, we say, yeah, you can still do that,
but you're only going to do it if it's mutually agreed between the two school districts that are going to do it. That's all this thing says. You can read both sides of it. For instance, I learned that currently the Bentonville School District, as I understand, is leasing a cooler space or freezer space in Springdale to serve their students, which makes sense and which works well. So all this does says you can still do this stuff if you want to, but you need to get the agreement of the school district with whom you're working. So that's what that thing does.
committee? Representative Rattler, if you're recognized for a question. I know over around Jonesboro, Representative, we've got some school districts that just packed in around each other, like Nettleton and Jonesboro. They went outside of the district and bought, like, a little farm, and they've got FFA projects out there, steers and hogs. No, carol hogs, but, you know, this wouldn't affect those folks.
No, sir, and that's why we changed the bill. That's what this thing's all about down here. Whenever we get these bills drafted, I'd say to all of us, especially we senior members like Walker over there and me, is that you learn that just because the Bureau drafts a bill that you've suggested It doesn't mean it's what you really want to do or what this group needs to do. So what we found was exactly what you raised is that sometimes somebody may leave an estate or something to another school district. And you start to open that can of worms, there's no way to fix it. So what we did is just, oh, common Arkansas, your horse sense, common sense is that if you want to agree to do that, then have at it.
That's what this does. Thank you, sir. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you to my junior. Watch it now. to a to my junior representative former senator elder statesman that's enough john uh i was under the impression that we already allowed that as reflected by the jockson city school districts with with louisiana and arkansas having uh schools together even in pulaski county
where you have scott schools in conjunction with pulaski county the concern that i thought you you were going to address is the one that expansion usually results in, and that is absorption of those adjacent districts which you were trying to hold on to, because it's just a matter of time before gravity is no longer. Yes, sir, and that's one of the things that he's
talking about, a bill we discussed here the other day. I might say that this is one of the things that happens, I think, down here when you
have debate about these bills. You learn things that perhaps you didn't know that occasionally even changes your vote. And it has mine in the past. But what this does, Representative Walker, is it just says with a mutual agreement. And I, as you did, I thought they couldn't do that already. But they're doing it, and they do it successfully in some places. And what we termed up was an attorney general's opinion, going back to this law, if you read it here, that it says what it says. They have the right to own property now, but it does not restrict it into your own district. All this does is if the district you're working with agrees, fine.
If not, then if you can't agree, then perhaps you need to come back with some more legislation if you choose to do that. But this
just says mutually agreeable. Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Hendren, along Representative Ratliff's point, I'm concerned that this doesn't end the bill. Well, I'm going to sign that it's not really covered. If someone was to leave a farm to a small school district that lay in a district outside that school district,
and for some reason, unforeseen to us sitting here, the school boards couldn't get along or the districts were competing or at odds, would this bill defeat the purpose of the person that left the property to that school district? That's a good question. and that's one of
the things we talked about here. We tried to, we thought about massaging this bill around where it would address the specific thing you just mentioned. Let me just say on a light matter here that, again, I think that we need to, as Paul Harper used to say, shuck down to the cob. When this was going on up in my district, I said,
let me tell you something, Bentonville, if one of the person who ever owns the Walmart headquarters there in Bentonville choose to give that to the Pea Ridge School District and then lease it back to Walmart to run the outfit there, then Bentonville, because of the loss of that real estate and value of that real estate property, would be playing football on the same size field Peabridge did. So what my specific answer to that would be is that if that occurs, then first of all we're going to head to the courts with it, which probably you would now, and then at that time there needs to be new legislation.
But I think the basic concept that we have here is, again, we talk about local control, and sometimes that's plus or minus. But what I'm doing, Mr. Chairman, is filibustering because I know it's almost lunchtime. But that's still a problem at this point. And I would just hope and assume that whenever that happens, the two school districts can mutually agree for the advantage of the kids. And that's what this boils down to. It just puts it on the burden to work together.
And I almost pull this down because that problem up in our area has been solved because they said we'd do it. Then others came back to me, well, it may have been solved this time, but it may happen somewhere else. So, again, if they mutually agree, they can do it according to this addition into the current legislation
or current law. You're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Representative Hendren. Just while I agree, we all would hope that the districts and the school boards would always have the children's best interests in mind.
And unfortunately, most of the time that gets lost in the shuffle of things. More to my specific concern is that, yes, we could go back to the courts or maybe to more legislation. But in the more rural areas, I really could foresee not really an unreasonable situation where some property was left to a school district and a school board member or more than one school board member would see that as property they might or would like to acquire. and if it weren't for the school in the other district having that option they could go and
they would be the first potential buyer of that property and so once again i just wonder if this doesn't take some rights away from from property owners and their disposition of their property probably every
time we pass a law we take the rights away from somebody and you understand that and as you were asking that question one thing i'd suggest if that's a concern that perhaps that you and I perhaps, and we talked about this thing, maybe there needs to be legislation that on a specific gift or endowment or bequeathment of somebody to a district,
and we talked about putting that in the bill, but when you get into that, you get into some real problems on how to do it. So what we did was just to try to simplify it and say, if you mutually agree, you can do it. If they get down and can't do that, then we're going to have to have
other legislation. Thank you. Thank you. Are there any other questions, committee? Does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for your bill?
What's the will of the committee? I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? No. Congratulations, you passed your bill. That was close.
I told this senator a while ago. I said, now, don't make him mad before I get up there, but I think he almost
done it. Is there any other bills that anybody would like to run in the committee today? If not, without objection, we are adjourned.
Agenda
SB205
HR1029
HB1515
HB1516
HB1381
SB342
SB211
HB1272
HB1495
HR1032
HCR1008
HB1074
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Speaker 3
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative Nate Bell
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Speaker 47
Speaker 4
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Speaker 99
Speaker 100
Representative Mark D. McElroy
Unverified
Speaker 109
Speaker 124
Paul Calvert
Unverified
Speaker 129
Speaker 12
Speaker 133
Speaker 137
Senator Missy Irvin
Unverified
Speaker 162
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Senator Alan Clark
Unverified
Speaker 192
Speaker 42
Speaker 199
Speaker 201
Representative Justin T. Harris
Unverified
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Speaker 53
Speaker 229
Speaker 233
Speaker 234
Speaker 257
Representative Kim Hendren
Unverified
Speaker 48