House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (18)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1442
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ime, Representative Mayberry, you are recognized to present House Bill 1442.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1443
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ulations you have passed 1442 you are recognized to present house bill 1443. thank you one of the things that we”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1444
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1444”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1552
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1552”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1586
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1586”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1605
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1605”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1623
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1623”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1650
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1650”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1651
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1651”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1652
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1652”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1895
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1895”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1913
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1913”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2007
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2007”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB226
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB226”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB366
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB366”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB789
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB789”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB894
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB894”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB999
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB999”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
I'm just pleased to see a corner. Stretching my eyes around the corner. Good morning, everyone. At the end of the table, we have Representative Mayberry. She has three bills she will be presenting today. She has three minutes on one, two on the other, and one on the last one.
I'm just kidding. I'm going to tell everybody in here today, if you speak for or against the bill, please try to be as brief and get your message across. We are very limited. We have a lot of bills to run. We have a long schedule we've got to make between now and next week, so I would appreciate anything you can do to not linger the process. At this time, Representative Mayberry, you are recognized to present House Bill 1442.
Thank you, Chair. I'm here today because of two very special people in my life. And you can see on one sheet of paper, and I'm probably, don't worry, I'm not going to bring you through everything on this piece of paper. But there's a picture of two people who are important to me in my life. On this front page, that's my Aunt Dottie. My Aunt Dottie was born in 1932. I only knew her for about a month. She died a month after I was born.
My Aunt Dottie had what was determined as a mental disability, mentally retarded. My grandmother tried twice to put her into first grade, and she was denied an education. she was told that she's unteachable she's a distraction in the class and she has too many medical concerns and so my aunt dotty never got an education i am very thankful that there have
been people along the way who spoke up for people like my aunt and many others who now are in our school system getting an education because today i have a daughter the other picture there my daughter Katie, who has spina bifida. Katie sees the school nurse twice a day, every day. Without that school nurse there, I would fear sending her to school. My daughter is a straight-A student and is doing
well in school. I want her in public education, and she deserves to be there. Three years ago, I came to the awareness that my daughter is privileged my daughter shouldn't be privileged every body should have access to a school nurse if they need it let me introduce the other person I have sitting with me Lakeisha Shavers who can tell you her story thank you
hi my name is Lakeisha Shavers last year January of the 21st My son, Gabriel, he was given the wrong medication at school. Okay, he was given the wrong medication at school. He is ADD, ADHD. He takes Focalin 5 at home and Focalin 5 at school. Well, the nurse, well, it wasn't a nurse. It was a substitute secretary that gave him the wrong medication.
My son stated to the secretary that it was a wrong medication. Well, she told him to hush and take it anyway. Gabe came home just out of it. He was just completely out of it. He was telling me that he had a headache. I didn't know, gave him a Tylenol. He was saying that his heart was hurting. I panicked. I called 911. The ambulance came and got Gabe. He told me that he was given the wrong
medication. Children Hospital did. They ran IVs in both of his arms, did a blood test. Come to find out he had focal in 30 milligrams in his system. As a parent, that hurts. And the nurse was supposed to be there. She was not there for my son. Like I said, as a parent, it is
disturbing to know that a substitute secretary, thank you, a substitute secretary can give a child some medication when the nurse is supposed to give a child a medication. Since that day, I go every day and give my son his medication due to the fear of him getting the wrong medication again. I feel that nurses, she should have been there to administrate my son his medicine.
Gabe, he's a very smart little child he's a straight-a student always every nine weeks he's always on principal honor roll like I said it it just hurts for for me to be in the hospital with my son and he has IVs and everything running from his vein due to the lack of nurses at school do you mind
just sharing real quickly the nurse is not there because she shares three other schools she's at
Three schools. Three schools. Representative Mayberry, which bill are
you presenting? I'm presenting 1442. But you're on
Can we try to just stay on 1442 because we've got everybody confused here where we're at. Okay. We're
on 1442, but this is setting up why we have 1442 and why this is important. All right. Thank you. Okay. um because of stories like that that we knew ahead of time last session you all as legislators
those that were here you helped us put together a group of people an advisory committee to look into this situation to see because there wasn't data on this so you put together a committee that spent a year and a half gathering information for the first time we were able to in june get information from all school nurses around the state, just about all of them, so that we have data to work with. If we collect data, we need to use that data. And this is the thick piece of
book that contains all this information. If you want to look at it, I'm not going to go through it. But it very much shows how many kids we have on our school campuses that need nurses. 1442 what it is going to do is allow us to keep this committee together to continue to develop some possible solutions to these problems because what i'm presenting today is the smallest step that we can take it's not going to solve the problems it's not going to put a nurse on every
campus unfortunately so 1442 will allow us to continue to work together the other thing that it's going to do is it is going to ask the school nurses to prepare information to give to the school board each year because we found out that's a missing link. I think any school board and school superintendents, once they hear what really is going on in that school nurse's clinic and that office and how many kids really need this help, they're going to hear that and they're going to
want to do more. They right now don't get the information to know what's going on and how dangerous the situation is in their school. And so that's what 1442 is, and I would appreciate a
questions, committee? Not seeing any? Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill?
For the bill? I have some listed to speak for all three bills on here. Four. Do you want to do that now? If you do, I have Deborah Jones to speak for the bill. I'm Debra Jones I'm
Speaker 39
9:08
with the Arkansas State Board of Nursing and I'll be very
brief in that we have read this bill we have I served as the person from the Board of Nursing on this advisory committee for the last year and a half and we are very supportive of the bill we think it is the right direction to be heading to looking at the
needs of all of our children in the schools are there any questions from the committee thank you
speak against the bill do I have is it Shannon or Shannon sequest speak for
the bill right is that correct there you go i'm sorry sharon okay we sorry ma'am you're you're recognized take your
Speaker 46
9:58
name and who you're with i'm sharon segrest and my child is zoe mashburn she has been diagnosed with her springs disease she attends daisy bates elementary school and i just want to tell you all a few things about her and why we need a nurse My child eats through a feeding tube, and sometimes this is not easy, as the nurse needs to assess her sometimes.
And without her advice, we would be constantly running back and forth to the doctor. And Zoe has had difficulty learning because she wouldn't be in the classroom. She would be at the doctor's office. My child has been hospitalized twice this year, and both times without the school nurse, we wouldn't have picked up on the fact of what was going on with her. The nurse took the time to speak with us and our doctors and the medical team that we have for her
to help them understand what was happening with her and without her advice, the medical team wouldn't, we would have waited too late to have her seen. I don't know how we would survive without our nurse. We have 510 children at our elementary, which 400 of them have some kind of medical issue. She takes time, our nurse takes individualized time to talk to the parents
and to care for each one of the children in there. In closing, I'm not only a parent, but I work in our special needs classroom. I'm a paraeducator. And just last week, we had a situation that involved one of our students that has a trach. And the machine, she was needing to be suctioned. And the machine didn't, we couldn't get the machine to work, and she was choking. Our nurse got down there, fixed the machine, and got the child suctioned, and everything went real well.
So if we hadn't had our nurse there, it could have turned really bad
very quickly. Are there any questions? Thank you, ma'am. Would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill? Would you like to close for 1442?
vote. What's the will of the committee? Representative McElroy? Have a due pass for Representative McElroy.
all those in favor say aye all those opposed no congratulations you have passed 1442 you are recognized to present house bill 1443. thank you one of the things that we
discovered in in all of this and i'm going to pull paula smith up here with me and let her introduce herself
Speaker 58
12:55
good morning good morning I'm Paula Smith state school nurse consultant with the Department of
Health you're recognized thank you one of the things that we discovered we knew we were gonna discover that there's not enough nurses but the thing that really kind of took me off guard is discovering how bad our facilities are for our school nurses and how many of our school nurses don't have a room to work out of and and surprisingly don't have a sink to wash their hands. That's medical 101. They don't have a sharps container to throw away dirty needles.
And I kind of sit here and go, well, where do those dirty needles go? We have a problem with our facilities and all of our data is there to support that. And so we were trying to figure out how do we solve that problem? And that's what this bill addresses. Again, it doesn't solve the problem, but it takes a step. And if you look at what we're asking, we know about the academic facilities partnership program, and there is a $150,000 cap on applying for that. Some of these
schools might have a school nursing facility that needs some updating, but won't ever make it to that $150,000 cap. We want to use existing funding that's already there to help facilitate some better facilities for our nurses, and that's what this bill is trying to do. There is another section in here that if there is no funding for it, it won't happen, but I needed to put it in there because I need to show that there is a need here. If there is some extra money, whether that's $25,000
or a million dollars, whatever it is, some of these schools do need some equipment, basic equipment, a refrigerator to keep your medication cold, a file cabinet. It's a shame that we are asking for the simplest of things, but some of these school districts need that help, and that's what that extra fund would do. At this time, there is no money for it, so I tried in revenue and tax to find some more money,
and it got shot down, but that's okay. We will take little steps, but that's the other part of this bill again this isn't going to cost districts anything this is going to help them apply for some funding so that they can meet the needs of their nursing facilities and that's what this bill is questions
Speaker 58
15:35
any other comments you're recognized me yes okay um just so that you will um know that some of the items the
double lock cabinets are for medications, scheduled two medications. All of the ADHD medications, Ritalin, Adderall, Focalin, all of those are scheduled two medications. That means they are on the same schedule as morphine, Demerol, and Dilaudid. And so it's necessary for the safety of everybody at school that these medications be kept in double lock cabinets, just like the refrigerator for certain medications that have to be refrigerated
to keep them until the kid takes them, like amoxicillin, those kinds of things. So just so you'll know the need for these pieces of equipment, sinks and running water. Okay. Are there any questions on
committee? Representative Ratliff, you're recognized for a question. Representative, you
said that, I think you said if funds were available, are you saying they only do this if the funds become available?
No. If you look on page 2, starting at section 2, line 23, that's what I'm referring to is that if there was extra money, there could be money that ADE has set aside for a grant program. Again, I don't know where that money is going to come from. If there is, by some miracle in the next two weeks, some money to put in there, we have the formula to help with that. Okay. And, again, whether it's $25,000 or a million dollars, it will definitely go a long way towards helping some of these schools meet some of those needs.
You know, the only problem I have is these unfunded mandates for these schools. And, you know, I'm
not against nurses, but. Well, that part's not an unfunded mandate. Okay. All right. And the other part in here is just allowing them to make use of funding that is already there. They have to go through the entire process of applying for that facilities partnership program. And it's just saying that the nursing facility should be a part of when we're considering if the school needs new facilities,
that the nursing facility should
Thank you. Representative Walker, you are recognizing the question. Thank you, Chairman Cozart. I like your suggestion about data-driven decisions and also the purpose of this. I see an opportunity for you to, if you were not a public school, for the services that you want to have provided to these children,
they would be indemnified by Medicare, and the monies would go into the public school treasury. But if they were not in a public school, they would not, would
they? Well, I think that might be addressing a little bit more of our next bill. Well, I
guess the real question that I'm, Mr. Cozart, if I may, I guess the question that I'm saying is that when we authorize it for the publics, it'll necessarily have to be authorized for the charters.
and that provides a profit opportunity by use of these nurses. Of course, I still favor them, but I just want us to be mindful of what the possible fallout of this is. Are there any other questions from the committee?
Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience would like to speak against the bill? for the bill would you all like to speak again
or are you good against the bill for the bill would you like to close for your bill I'd appreciate a good vote alright what's the will of the committee Mr. Lowry have a due pass from Representative Lowry all those in favor say aye those opposed no the ayes have it congratulations you have passed 1443 you are now recognized to present house bill
1444 evidently this is the main one this is the main one thank you
sure i also would like to recognize a former rep a colleague of mine representative mayberry number one representative mayberry in the room with us and this is the husband of the representative Mayberry's presenting these bills. Andy, good to have you with us today. Well, you were the first one. You were recognized. Go ahead and present.
Okay. Members, I appreciate your time here to listen. I could take hours and hours and hours of explanation to you because we have truly, this committee has spent an untold number of hours collecting information. Here is an opportunity for you when we ask for research and we ask for data to turn around and make something happen with it. If we don't make something happen with it,
then why do we ever ask for the research and data to begin with? And here is that opportunity. In a nutshell, what this bill will do and where you will hear the greatest argument is that we are taking the law as it stands right now is a 1 in 750 ratio. You have to have on our schools, in our schools, one nurse for every 750 students. However, the law as it stands right now is not
part of our standards of accreditation. And it has a line at the bottom that basically says if there's no funding, you don't have to follow it. In a nutshell, that's what it says. So you know when you have put together the adequacy, which is talked about over and over and over again, you are funding those schools based on that 1 in 750 ratio. And I have Nell Smith here today from the Bureau. If you want to ask any questions specifically about how that funding is,
and she can answer questions. She's done a tremendous amount of research on this. But the funding is there. They're getting the funding to meet that 1 in 750 ratio. and what we're asking is to move it into the standards for accreditation. In our standards for accreditation, which I've got the whole big list here, several pages, it will outline that you need one teacher for every 20 kindergarten students.
It gives specifics on how many counselors you need. It gives specifics on how many principals you need for however many students. But nowhere in the standards for accreditation does it say that you need 1 in 750 ratio for school nurses, which to begin with, think about that. 750 students and one nurse. Our nurses are overwhelmed. I want to point out that when we presented information to our school nurses in June
and we asked them about their comments on all of this one nurse stood up and she said I know you've mentioned something about our salaries here and I want to make it clear that if we as a school nurse have a choice of having an increased salary or more nurses we definitely would choose more nurses these nurses recognize that their kids are not being taken care of they go home at night and they're concerned about those kids they want to help those kids they're
not looking for more money I can't speak for every single one of them I'm sure they'd be happy to have a raise
Speaker 58
23:57
but they are saying they want more nurses I'm here to provide information and answer questions about the conditions that the school nurses take care of in our schools, the number of students on our campuses with chronic diseases, the number of students with procedures that
have to be provided every day in order for them to be able to attend class. So I'll entertain questions if you have some. Reverend Ratliff you're recognized for a question
okay if we've got a school that's below 750 but have two different schools are they going to have to hire a second nurse the
ratio that is in here is one in 750 so they wouldn't one could travel that's all we're saying is moving into the standards for accreditation now if you look
further if there was more money which again I tried hard in revenue and tax to come up with some more money for this, and if there was some more money, then there was going to be a separate fund, which we could still find some more money, and the session's not completely over with. I do recognize that they're not being funded at a ratio greater than 1 in 750. The majority of the school districts are following that, and many are going above and beyond that because they recognize that need. So all we're saying with this is that we move it into the
standards for accreditation and make them follow what what we as legislators have said meets adequacy. Thank you.
Are there any other questions? Representative Mayberry, I have a question and you may have covered this. I've been kind of busy taking care of some business. Registered nurse, does this require just one registered nurse per school or does this require every one of them to be a registered
nurse um if if you look at it let's see um on page two is where we we talk
specifically it says a school nurse supervisor newly employed by a school district shall have at least a bachelor of science in nursing degree beginning july one each school district shall ensure that each school and the school district has at least one school nurse that is a registered nurse. So we are saying that you do need a registered nurse. And what we discovered in our research is that there are a lot of LPNs, and I'll let my nurses kind of explain this a little bit more, but a lot of LPNs are performing things that are outside of their scope of
practice. And we do need to make sure that we have an RN that's overseeing what the LPN
is doing. My second question, are you saying district or school building? the the school district okay the district so one one district that's pretty broad on some
districts but it is very complicated as you know representative
Cozart I know it can be real complicated lately so um but anyway so per school district I understand more all right I
would love to say that there is a school nurse on every single campus and that's what the additional
part of this is if there is more funding and and Nell Smith did an incredible amount of research to find out what is that magic number how many do we need and we know that it's going to cost about five million dollars more to get a school nurse on every campus and to meet these acuity levels that's what we have estimated would would solve the problem but we don't have that extra five million dollars so in the meantime this is a small step until we can come up with some more money all
right are there any other questions committee representative def of all you are
recognized for question thank you mr. chair um representing maybe i might have missed this but what about um schools like for instance my wife was lpn and she was a school nurse what would happen to those people uh that uh are already on staff as an lpn i mean
we we're clear in saying newly hired we don't want a good LPN to lose his or her job and so we we say in here newly hired
that's that's the intention and we hope that our LPNs will go back to school I would hope our education committee would be in support of people being encouraged to to go further their career by getting more education you can do that online is that correct okay thank you
thank you Mr. Chair Representative Ratliff, you're recognized for a
question. I think I read in this bill here also that we can't use NSLA money for this. You can.
It's very clear. It says that. Oh, it says it? Yes. Let me find it. Because we want to make sure, I think it's page two, top of it. It says, to ensure the school districts are able to maintain the appropriate school nurse-to-student ratio, a school district may use the National School Lunch categorical funds provided to meet or exceed the current standards required. We know, based on allocation reports from this summer, that there was $38 million intended to be used for school nurses.
Only $19 million of foundation funding actually went to the school nurses. many of the school districts did tap into their nsla money and did tap into medicaid money so there are other sources besides just the foundation funding to meet these needs that the school districts can make use of mr chairman i'd like if someone's here from ade
i'd like to ask that question make sure that's i mean i'm not doubting their word but i you know i don't
want to get into some of these schools doing this and then
getting written up for it we have someone coming. Sir, if you would
recognize yourself and who you're with, you are recognized to speak. Mike Hernandez, Department of Education. Representative Ratliff,
I'm sorry, could you repeat that question? She said I asked if we could use NSLA funding for paying
nurse. I think within the bill, that's one of the things that's an allowable expenditure if this bill passes. Was that allowable through the ADE, though?
um through the through everything else we got to do right and
some of that i don't have the answer if we've allowed that um in the past i don't know if that's one that's actually specifically written in law right now but there are some things that are allowable based on circumstances as approved by the ad okay so if if this passes and a school calls you and asks you
to do that you're going to say okay we do our best to follow the law okay thank you thank you Representative Bell, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you. Representative Mayberry, if you go to page 2 of your bill, line 10, you referenced this earlier, I believe, in your presentation, but beginning on July 1, 2017, each school district shall ensure that each school in the school district has at least one school nurse that is a registered nurse. I believe I heard you say that those school nurses who currently are serving who are LPNs would need to go back to school to continue employment.
Did I understand you correctly? No. If you look here, it says a licensed practical nurse may be hired to assist a registered nurse. So it only would be newly hired would have to come in with that RN. And so the LPN can continue to stay there and can work. Follow-up,
Mr. Chair. You're recognized. well i think in the unlimited budget world that would be true but um if the school district simply can't afford to have both a registered nurse and an lpn on staff um they're going to have to make
a difficult choice uh as i read your
bill well first of all i'll tell you that the uh school nurses are funded um again blr can back me up on this with the the allocation um information that they passed out in the summer, they're funded at a $60,000 a year salary. So there's money there to hire the RN if they need to hire the RN. Put me back
in the queue, Mr. Chair. I'll come back. Representative Walker, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I wanted to ask Mr. Hernandez, Dr. Hernandez, a question.
You're recognized. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Hernandez, Representative Mayberry has indicated that about half of the apportioned money for nurses is unused or at least unspent on nursing programs.
Do you all have, as a department, any concern to make sure that more of the money or most of the money is used for the allocated purposes, and if so, how do you implement or enforce that? Representative
Walker, my understanding of the matrix is it is currently written as a funding model. The way that the actual schools spend that money is that it's unrestricted revenue and
they have the freedom, as long as they're compliant with existing statutes and rules, that they can spend that money how they choose to do so. So as far as ensuring that they spend it as allocated within the matrix,
we do not do that. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized. So that if they choose not to put any of it into nursing or for this kind of care, the The ADE has no say in that. It doesn't matter to the ADE.
Is that fair to say? I don't know that as far as the word matter to ADE, I think I have trouble with that. But as far as making sure that they're compliant, that's what we do, is to make sure that they're compliant with the existing rule and statute. So you all don't enforce this provision? I think we enforce what's written in statute or rule. Thank you. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dale, you recognize. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Representative Mayberry, I want to take you back to the original scenario I posed
where we have a school that has an LPN who is currently their school nurse. You indicated that there's $60,000 in the matrix for hiring a nurse. And I believe I heard you say that that should be plenty to hire an RN. I think the question that I have is we have an LPN who is there who is currently employed. Are you suggesting that that $60,000 is adequate to hire both a new RN and to continue employment for the LPN?
Or are you saying that they're going to have to get rid of the
LPN and hire an RN? I would encourage the LPN, and there's plenty of time because this wouldn't go into effect until 2017, to take an online course and become an RN so that there's no concerns or problems. I think as an education committee that we should encourage education. You are asking an LPN to, and I would love if I could ask our State Board of Nursing to get up and kind of address the issue when we have LPNs that are working without an RN supervisor,
that you're actually creating a huge problem, and I would. Representative Bell, would you like to ask that question to her? That kind of gets into nursing. Well,
I think my question is not so much a nursing question as it is a practicality question on the finance side, Mr. Chairman. We're off to a for and against questioning,
and then, okay. Are there any other questions?
Anyone would like to speak against the bill? Dr. Abernathy, you are recognized to speak against the bill. So, recognize yourself and
who you're with, please. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA. And we want to thank Representative Mayberry for bringing this issue forward.
And I'll be quite honest, she has worked with us diligently trying to get to an area that that we could all agree to. We're not there at this time and if I could just real quickly point out a few things in the bill that I think is problematic. If you look on page one starting on line 21 we talk about the evaluation of a nurse. It's a little confusing about who is going to evaluate the nurse. I think it's clear that on the nursing components the nurse supervisor would take care of that but that at the end of the day someone has to conduct the final summative
evaluation on employment decisions so the nurse may be dispensing medication extremely well but irritating parents and doing other things and and that has to be addressed by the supervisor which ultimately is going to make the employment recommendation if you look over on page two starting on line 10 i think several of you've already picked up on this and that's requiring an RN not at the district level but at each school that is a huge issue and we certainly
support school nurses but represent Bell I think you have it exactly right it's going to become a budget issue and LPMs will in fact lose their jobs in order to take care of this this criteria right here if you look on down starting on page line 24 we have the 750 is not a new number but you see the strikeout 0405 and that turns into 1516 let me show you another one that goes along with that and that's on page three down at the bottom line 35 has a provision this section
shall be effective only upon available funding that is stricken 750 is not the current standard that has not been funded now there's a lot of question on that from blr from others what's funded what's not funded so if you indulge me just a minute let's take a little time and look at that currently in the matrix if you take what's in the matrix and in in funded and hire those nurses it would fund 617 school nurses currently superintendents and school boards has seen a need in their districts and there are 798 nurses employed at this time now school districts are
hiring more nurses than provided through the matrix now as superintendent when you look at budget issues obviously you try to spend the restricted funds first before you go to the unrestricted funds restricted funds include categorical funds but more importantly includes federal dollars we have nurses hired with federal money out there that if this is implemented it very likely may eliminate our use of some federal dollars in those categories so we have more nurses hired than this bill would demand and but we're doing that at the local level through their
decision through their budgeting criteria and so we would like to uh like to keep it that way if you look on page four starting on line five said the state board of education shall include the nurse requirements and standards for accreditation i'd just like to point out that The matrix in Lakeview is developed based on meeting the requirements of the current standard for accreditation. So if those standards for accreditation are changed or modified, then it may be an issue in that particular area.
But I guess the important thing is that we think whoever makes employment decisions needs to be one conducting the final evaluation. If you require an RN in each building in the school district, that's going to be an issue. LPN would in fact lose their positions very likely again that'd be a local decision you'd be limiting the use of federal dollars to employ school nurses and we currently have more school nurses hired in the state of Arkansas than required under the matrix are there any questions
from the committee thank you sir anyone like speak for the
Speaker 39
41:01
bill you're recognized again I'm Debra Jones with the Arkansas State Board of Nursing and the Board of Nursing has reviewed and does support this bill we do feel like that all of our children deserve to have a nurse in every school whether that's an RN or an LPN
you know that that can be negotiated somewhat the LPN scope of practice does not include assessment diagnosis or care planning those components of the nursing process are required for nurses to develop the health care plan so the school district has to have an RN somewhere in the process to even be able to develop the health care plan. Now the LPN can certainly assist in carrying out the health care plan and helping the RN
with the task, nursing task, but the law requires that the LPN work under the supervision of an RN, a physician, or an APN, or a dentist if it was appropriate for a dentist to be supervising. So the law requires the RN to be the supervisor of an LPN. The Nurse Practice Act also limits the LPN scope of practice to things that they just cannot provide that are needed in the schools.
And that's the reason for the push to have a registered nurse available to do those assessments and to ensure the care of our children. we think that this is a good this is a good first step it may not be the final step but it's certainly the first baby step in meeting some of the recommendations of the advisory committee that you put together two years ago are there any questions from
the committee seeing no questions thank you ma'am anyone like to speak against the bill
take the end of the table recognize who you are and who you're with and
Speaker 166
43:18
you're recognized to speak against the bill thank you i'm jerry newton superintendent of poen school grant county uh and i again want to tell represent your maybe i appreciate all she's done to bring this forth but i want to just tell a little bit about what this will do to my particular school district i have about 570 students in the polling school district k-12 we have a full-time lpn and a part-time rn the way
i read this bill i would have to have a full-time rn and i disagree with the interpretation on page 2 line 10 i believe that it would be a full-time rn for each school within my school district learned a long time ago in legislative process it's not what somebody says that they intend it to be is the way it's read and the way it's written, and I believe this is written to require a full-time RN for each school in my school district. My issue is with my LPN. I've got
an LPN that's been with me for 20 years. I've got a part-time RN. For the amount of funding that I'm going to be able to put forth, I will have to lay off that LPN in order to hire a full-time RN, so it is going to affect employment in there. I do feel like it's an unfunded mandate. I heard someone say that before the standards and the the laws right now do not require that we have a full-time rn on our campus this will require that so it will be a mandate to my school district that is
not required right now and i'll answer any questions
are there any questions seeing none thank you sir thank you is there anyone like to speak for the bill you're a little quick against the bill you're recognized take your place at the end of the table and state who you're with and your name please or however you want to state that
Speaker 169
45:08
thank you, Ronnie Cazare, Superintendent of Washtenaw School, don't want to take a lot of
time but I'm in the same boat that Mr. Newton is, a little over 500 students, we have our LPN, we have two district two buildings so in the same aspect we would be required to have two full-time rns under this bill that's going to take a hit on us and i'm also concerned about you know this being the first step because when you look at the rest of the steps there's some considerable funding issues i think when you're looking at the levels one through five you know you get a level five student
in or you get two level five students in then we're going to have some serious funding issues so i think we need to go back to the table with this and actually do the research with the first bill we talked about gathering more research from the districts and i think that needs to be seen we've not had the you know rn on site for 10 years while i've been there and it's not
been an issue are there any questions seeing none anybody like to speak for the bill
against the bill would you like to close for your bill yes I would I will tell you that I have worked very closely with Mike Mertens from AAEA I'm sure he would be willing to say that I have made changes made okay let's work this out let's work this out from the very beginning. At some point, you just have to say, okay, I can't anymore. We sat down Wednesday, yesterday, the day before, and there were a few other minor tweaks that I would be
willing to go ahead and do, but I knew that we needed to present this bill. You all know the time deadline on this, and I need to get it through here, and I need to get it through the Senate, and I said, look, I need to get this going. There are two small changes I'm willing to make on here. I still believe that it needs to be in standards of accreditation or it will never be followed. The reason why they follow one in 20 kindergarten students, you know,
one teacher is because it's in the standards for accreditation. There's no way, just finding out how many school nurses we have has been the most difficult process to know how many nurses do we have and how many more do we need. No one's tracking it. so I would be willing to on page one where it says to to clarify because that was never our intention we found out that nurses are only being evaluated by school principals who don't know
anything about checking for diabetes and and all these other things so we wanted to make sure that a nurse is is doing some evaluation here it was never our intention to completely move a principal out of evaluating a nurse, and that's not what was intended there, and they did give me some other language that they would prefer in there, and I'd be willing to make that amendment when it gets over to the Senate side. I have no problem with that. That's very easy to do, and we want to make sure that a principal does have a say if a nurse is not showing up on time
or what have you. The other would be to clarify in page two on line 11, scratching out the words that each school, I would be willing to do that to make it very clear that there is at least an RN in that school district overseeing the LPNs. So I would be willing to make those changes to proceed with this bill and not let it die. I also did want to point out that, yes, $19 million of foundation funding
was used for school nurses in 2012 and 2013. NSLA money, nearly $10 million, $9.5 million of NSLA money was used to provide those nurses. And other state unrestricted funds, nearly $2.5 million was used there. This bill will allow those school districts to continue to use the NSLA money to meet those needs to meet or exceed those needs so I guess I'm closed I just have
to say I think sometimes we forget who we're trying to serve here are we trying to serve the school district and making a superintendent happy because they don't have to go back and look at their books and figure out where the needs should be and where the money should be spent, this might inconvenience some superintendents. And I'm sorry if it does.
But I care about those kids. I care about Lakeisha's little boy that was sent to the ER. are. I care about my child who does have a school nurse. There are school districts that are doing this right now and if a school district can do it then another school district can do it too and that's all I'm asking for you to do. If I'm a school superintendent and my school district is meeting this ratio, I'm mad that other school districts are not meeting that ratio. and now i'm closed thank you let me get it
straight now you're willing to put two i am
willing to put those two amendments on there to clarify and to make sure i can't do it here if i do it here you know it's going to sit for
three days you're going to do it on the senate end i will do it on the senate end is everybody clear with what she says on the amendments okay all All right, she is closed. What is the will of the committee? Representative Letting has a motion of due pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, no. No. All the ayes have it.
Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Have a roll call.
Speaker 186
51:43
Call the roll, Mr. Clerk. Representative Letting. Aye. Representative Murdoch. Representative Murdoch. Representative Deffenbaugh. No. Representative Harris. No. Representative Eubanks. No. Representative Radliff. No.
Representative Gillum. Representative Gillum. Representative Walker. Aye. Representative Bell. No. Representative Balts. Representative Douglas Representative Douglas Representative Lowry Representative Lowry Representative McIlroy Representative Armstrong
Representative Gossage Representative Saban Representative Hodges Representative Gray Representative Lampkin
sorry your bill fails
Would you like to present your other bill that you have on the second page if it's a quick
if that's a quick one. House Bill 1895. House Bill 1895. Sonia. Sonia Wright-McMurray here. Oh, there she is. And I'm pretty much going to let her present this bill, if that's okay, because this comes from their department. Just
state who you're with and your name, and you're recognized.
Speaker 198
53:34
Sonia Wright-McMurray, Associate Director for Arkansas Works Department of Career Education. And this is basically a cleanup bill. We ran this bill back in the session of 2011. There's some language in there we wanted to provide some clarity on and to give us a little bit more of an understanding of what we're trying to do. So it's just cleanup language at this point. Are there any questions? No questions from the committee?
Anybody in the audience like to speak against the bill? for the bill. Would you like closed for that bill? Are you closed? I have a do pass motion from Representative McElroy. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed?
Senator Irwin, you are recognized to present your bill and
Then I will hear Senator Files and then Senator Clark. Senator Clark, I thought you were going to be next, but Senator Files beat you here. Sorry. The bill's 226. The Senate Bill 226, and you are recognized to present. Can I ask for a copy
of it? I don't have – the screen's not working.
thank you sorry thank you thank you this is senate bill 226 and what this bill does it is permissive we've worked with the department of education on this and it talks about administering the explore and that part is already in the code but it talks about allowing for schools to administer the plan or PSAT, but to also allow for the Aspire
assessment system to be used. And also we have included the ACT in grade 10, grade 11, or grade 12, and it doesn't designate when, or they could give that test any other, they could give it every year, or they could give it one time. The reason I brought this bill is because I've worked with many of my high school counselors and the folks, teachers in my school, and I have four children that went through the public school system. And as a parent, you all know the ACT has kind of
become the standard test. That is the test that colleges look to for entrance, admissions, and all the different colleges. So if you're looking to try to get into a specific college, the ACT is the test that they use. Also, the ACT is kind of the benchmark on scholarships and how much money you earn really relates to how your score is. And if your score goes up, that opens up more opportunities for more money for you to go to college. So what this bill does is use the
system, the ASPIRE system, which is part of the ACT, and use that as our assessments. And also, So instead of us studying and starting to study for the ACT at the grade 9 or grade 10, start it all throughout the assessment series, which starts in third grade. And that way you can accumulate the knowledge base, and we're testing to make sure you're accumulating the knowledge base to do well on that ACT test.
Right now, the only opportunity for a public school student, well, not the only. There are some schools that do pay for this, and there are some schools that do ACT courses, but the funding was not able to be there, and I'm not sure they can tell you when that was cut. But you have parents like me that we make sure our kids take ACT courses. I've purchased lots of CDs and material for success on that test.
We make our kids study 20 minutes a night for that test. And we also start them taking the test in grade 9 so that they can increase that score. And hopefully by the end of graduation, they've got a really good score and they can get into the college that they want and get the scholarships they want. And I'll remind you, we also made this the standard for the lottery scholarship. um so uh this does not um this is permissive for the department of ed to to look at this testing and hopefully my my goal is to try to kill two birds with one stone so you're assessing
our standards but you're also gaining that knowledge base for the ultimate test which is the act so i can answer any questions i know one of the questions that came up in the senate committee is is um how this might deal with common core standards and this test uh would it it doesn't hurt that in any way um it actually so the decisions that are made by the common core advisory council will be can be taken consideration with this as well um but it is linked to act
college readiness benchmarks and it can be aligned to assess common core state standards if that's the right the path that we decide to go in or not it can be used either way and it's just a very articulated standards-based system of assessments and so I would answer any questions representative douglas you are recognized for
Speaker 212
59:28
idea i've looked at it for a couple of years and i'm hearing good responses
from from teachers that they like this and i've always liked the plan and the explore i thought it was a great indicator for for kids i'm also hearing that it's cheaper yes and so I just wondered if you had the found the cost on that or don't have to have a specific cost but I was hearing that it was cheaper and wondered if
you had yeah you know I'm always I'm always wanting to go for quality but if prices can be competitive that's great too my ultimate goal though is just
it makes sense to me this just makes sense and there's a lot of kids out there in our public school system that don't have the parents that are able to pay $54 every time you take the ACT test or to pay hundreds of dollars for a course to improve your score on ACT or to pay for CDs and discs and study material for the ACT course. So it just makes sense to me and I appreciate those comments. And my teachers feel the exact same way, particularly my guidance counselor who
requested this bill because her job is to help those kids get the lottery scholarship her job is to help them get as many scholarships as they can and also to help them get admitted into college so i i appreciate those questions i've heard about
the motion motion representative walker you're recognized for question thank you represent
deffenbaum uh thank you mr chair uh senator
uh you know i now it seems like uh the farther in in in time we go i hear more and more that um the best um indication of a student's ability to succeed in college or vocational school whatever uh is their is their grade point average and that kind of have you heard do you hear that or did you consider that uh um i you
know i it's not really involved with the bill as far as grade
point average i mean this is dealing with assessments and this this act test um i don't know i'm not an expert and cannot really say you know what indicates success i mean i just i just can't. I do know that there are a lot of kids that are C students and D students that are extremely successful in life. I mean, my brother is a great example. He's a professional artist and he played football for the Arkansas Razorbacks, but he's dyslexic and he was a C student in school, but he's tremendously successful. So it's difficult to assess that. I just know that what we have
decided to make a priority is this ACT test. And we have done that through public policy on the lottery scholarship. So it makes sense to me that we should give our public school systems the best opportunity to succeed on that test. Okay. Thank you. Representative Lauer, are
you recognized for a question? Yes, thank
Speaker 225
1:02:49
you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Irvin, I just wanted for you to clarify for us that the language within this bill is completely permissive. It is. Correct. And this will also, I assume in your
viewpoint, also you've talked about lottery scholarships or preparing students for admission, but do you believe that it also would be a major component in being able to lessen our remediation rate at the higher education
level? Absolutely, because the score of 19 on the ACT is kind of the magic number um if you below if you score below a 19 then that requires remediation at the college level so yes excellent question so if we can achieve scores above 19 in our
public school system on that test it will make a tremendous impact i think in college years great point thank you thank you thank
Speaker 229
1:03:40
you mr chairman are there any other questions committee no okay i already have
a motion but anybody on the audience like speak against the bill for the bill would you like to close for your bill i've closed thank you representative douglas you're recognized for a motion motion do pass have a motion do pass all those in favor say
aye any opposed no congratulations you have passed your bill thank you committee
files you are recognized to take the end of the table and represent pitch if you want to join him you're welcome okay and this will be Senate bill 894 is that correct yes sir you're recognized and you have an amendment to put it with that yes sir all
right we will hear the amendment I believe they're passing that out or the Thank You mr. chairman members of the
committee. Senate Bill 894, the amendment, I'll explain it, dealt with residency requirements that the AAA asked me to add on to hedge off any unintended consequences. It'll make a little more sense when I present the bill with it, but that's all it does. It just addresses their concerns.
Have you already explained your amendment? Yes, sir. Okay. Any questions on the amendment? Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. I do. Is this amendment
intended to deal with the situation in North Little Rock? No, sir. Thank you. Sorry, I don't mean to cut you
off. That's fine. Yes, sir. It does not have anything to do with North Little Rock.
any other questions on the amendment I have a do pass motion from representative McElroy all those in favor say aye any opposed congratulations amendment has passed you are welcome to present the bill
as amended thank you mr. chairman members this what we're trying to do is is a address an issue that came up a couple years ago and I'll be brief with it but we have a junior high triple-a school in Fort Smith that's a private school Trinity Junior High. One of the students' parents was a volunteer soccer coach at Northside, a public
AAA high school in Fort Smith. He was a volunteer coach. The ninth grade kids all go to play for him and his daughter could not play because she attended Trinity, the junior high private school. All of her friends could play because they were at public school and turns out that a homeschooler could go play as well but her she couldn't so I called the AAA and I said obviously this is this is just a mistake and he said no our rules don't allow that because it's a AAA member school I said well so are the other junior high schools they're AAA member schools as well and then he
went into you know well it really doesn't need it just kind of became a he said it needs a rule change so I said no problem so fast forward to November of 2014 the issue comes up again we've got a couple of kids that want to play and this doesn't affect very many very many kids at all but for those kids it's their it's their life and so I've talked to the AAA they they helped me with the amendment basically it says that their if their school does not does not offer a spring sport so it's baseball and soccer that only is applies to then they're eligible to
participate in the in the public school on the senior high team and so it doesn't say they have to play it doesn't say they make the team it just gives them the option to play they're still covered by the triple a insurance and the other thing is the other thing they were concerned about was well what what if they go to one school in the ninth grade want to transfer to another school in the 10th grade and so we put that they would be ineligible for a year if they did that the amendment just says if they have a bona fide move if somebody moves from fort smith to little rock and wants to attend another school it doesn't affect their eligibility i'd be happy to take
a school choice act and students may choose to move from one district to another. Those students required if they move from one district to another, if they have played or participated in athletics or other extracurricular activities to sit out for one year upon exercise by them of the choice act and Mr. Bill a representative bill is
telling me all right so pert so he's he's let me restate my question so a student who exercises a transfer option under the school choice act is not afforded the opportunity to participate in extracurricular activities if he or she chooses to transfer from one district or another under the choice that unless there's a bona
you are there any other questions from committee seeing none is anyone the audience like speak against the bill for the bill like closed for your bill I'm closed I have a motion of do pass from representative Douglas is that correct I should do pass. Thank you. As amended. As amended. All right. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, members. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Clark. I think he's here somewhere. If you can find him, I'll hold for just a sec. Since I've made time for him today.
He'll be presenting Senate Bill 366, I believe. Senator, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 366. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I
would like to ask permission for Superintendent Sean Cook to join me at the table.
He may. Superintendent, if you go ahead and recognize yourself and who you're with, you're recognized to talk
at any time then. Hello, I'm Sean Cook, Superintendent of the Lakeside
School District. You will be recognized. Thank you, members of the committee. the almost all of you were here when I ran this bill before oh and by the way
Representative Walker I just got an urgent message that you're needed down on the other end of the building laughter is that what
can present to you the same thing I did before and will be glad to.
I know that y'all are busy. So I'm going to let Superintendent Cook talk to you from his point of view if that's okay with you
yes you recognize i'm sorry thank you representative cozart i approached senator clark a while back about something that i believe will benefit students greatly our legislators are constantly
asking us to bring something to the table to help and not just be fighting against a bill but to try to bring a bill that would help the school system so i met with my administration and we looked at different things and this is one of them what this will do many times we'll start the school year and we'll be maybe in October and we go over in numbers our student our teachers are only allowed to teach 150 students a day even though they're allowed to teach 30 students per period so like we're on a seven period
day so you know it was six periods that they teach they could teach up to 180 students but they're not allowed to do so because of the 150 per day limit so what I end up having to do in October is I have to start advertising for another teacher when we go over and we end up getting I guess you would say what's left over from the hiring season from the prime hiring season and I would like to be able to keep my kids with the very best teachers we have and at the same
time not go over the per class limit that we have if it was my kid that's what i would want i'd want my kid to stay with our very best teachers and i want to fairly compensate the teachers if they have to teach over the 150 students a day and i want it to be completely voluntary on the teacher's part i put all of that in the bill with senator clark no teacher would have to do this more than a semester at a time so if they got into it and decided hey this is too hard or i don't like it it or whatever then after that semester they would be off the hook and wouldn't have to do it again
so first of all I think it's very good for for kids secondly I have teachers in my district that drive school buses that work ball games that teach college after class after school and doing different things just to try to to raise their kids and bring a good income home for their family this would give them an opportunity to do that for example if a teachers making $40,000 a year and instead of teaching 150 students in those six periods they
teach 180 they would make 48,000 so you know that's an $8,000 increase that could help them maybe put their kids through college or whatever and you know teachers didn't get into this for money and I know that but I also know they need to be able to make a good wage so I think this is just another opportunity to give them a chance to make some extra income without having to go and find another job after hours like they're doing right now, many of them.
Like questions? I'm starting to get a list here. Ripson Murdoch, you're recognized.
Speaker 273
1:14:37
Thank you, Chairman, and thank you. I came in a little late. You may have said this already, but your teachers, you're superintendent, correct? Yes, sir. Okay. Your teachers, they are okay with this? Are you getting much pushback from your staff? I've not gotten any pushback
from my staff. I'm sure across the state there's probably some that like it, some that don't like it, and that's why I wanted it to be completely their choice,
where if they want to do what they can, if
Speaker 273
1:15:06
they don't want to, they don't have to. Okay. Some of the communication I had gotten, it seemed as though their interpretation was that it was an automatic versus an election. So I did want to come and make sure that that was clear, Senator Clark, that it was not something that was mandated. It was an election.
Yes, sir. If you look on line 12 and also on line 22, it's completely voluntary on the part of
Speaker 273
1:15:31
the teacher. And we don't anticipate any pressure from administration to make this a practice.
But sometimes, you know, sometimes choices become mandates. That has happened in labor-type situations, and I think that becomes a concern as well. And, you know, we have grievance policies
for anything like that that goes on. It would be the same thing if a principal tried to put pressure on a teacher to drive a school bus and get their bus line. I mean, you know, if they're getting that kind of pressure they have in a process where they can come to the superintendent, we can deal with
Speaker 273
1:16:04
four is okay. I do apologize. One other concern that I have is let's just say that a teacher who we know
a lot of teachers don't make a lot of money, and this teacher teaches two courses for you, teaches biology and chemistry, and because they're not paid well enough and they choose to exercise this option for financial reasons, is there a chance that an unintended consequence can be that they need to be preparing, getting ready for the biology class, but they're trying to help with the mortgage and the light bill at the
same time? Good intention, but are we concerned about that as well have you did you consider that i did and i see
it much the same as i do again for a teacher driving a school bus after hours coaching being in the band working at dillard's or wherever they work to make that extra income i just wanted to give them an opportunity to do what they do best and teach our kids if they want to thank you so much and thank you chairman
for a question sir wouldn't would Would you agree that this would also help on retirement and help pay that extra cost
of insurance? Yes, sir. I mean, you get to count your
top three years for retirement. Thank you. Representative Walker, your recognition. Well, thank you, Mr. Chair. I can't believe that I'm hearing what I hear. Let me ask these questions. This isn't a teacher pay bill is it, well it isn't, but you don't suggest that teaching
students is comparable to chaperoning students at a game or driving a bus to get them to school for extra pay, do you? I consider it the same as like my
teachers that teach college classes after hours or tutor our kids after hours. I think that would be more comparable, and they're allowed to do both of those right now. Well,
I don't think we pay bus drivers anywhere close to what we pay teachers, and nor do we pay people who have other duties as assigned as parts of their contract
extra pay for doing the things that they are assigned pursuant to that contract. The second thing, if I may, you may have, isn't it true that you may have by giving a teacher, taking a teacher, at least giving the teacher the option to eliminate his or her class period for preparation, You may have some teachers in the Representative Murdoch example Who may not teach more than 100 students
In the day because of the subject matter that they have Or they may be special ed teachers who may only teach a few But by giving them another period to teach you are giving them an opportunity to earn more money just by giving them an opportunity to work an extra period without any tangible, measured, data-driven information.
Isn't that correct? There's no data to support what you do other than a choice to just try to favor some people in the event that they volunteer and you want
to favor them. Across Arkansas, you talked to superintendents, We've been paying teachers for their conference period for years. We're just not allowed to go over the 150 students. And I've seen great success with it, you know, because we keep our best teachers with our kids, that the principals have to go to the teacher and ask them. And we go to our teachers that we know are doing a good job and say, would you be interested in working an extra period?
Follow-up, Mr. Chair? So you're going to continue to pay them for the conference
period and then give them more pay? Yes, sir. If they go over the $150,000, they would get additional pay. So
a teacher could possibly make up to an extra $20,000 a year. Mr. Chair, please. I'd like to know how a teacher whose minimum salary is $35,000, whose maximum is about $75,000,
can make almost a third or half of the pay that he or she earns by teaching one additional course i don't understand
i'll be glad to explain that the example that i'm giving is a forty thousand dollar if you make forty thousand dollars for teaching 150 students and you divide the forty thousand dollars by 150 and then you multiply it by 210 you get an extra fifty seven hundred dollars for teaching that extra conference period and you get an extra two hundred and sixty six dollars for every student you teach over
150 students that equals around $61,000 so that's an extra $21,000 representative Douglas you
are recognized for a question in schools I've taught in
Speaker 212
1:21:21
we we have had zero hours where teachers would be paid for the seven to eight time slot and i think in the afternoon it's called something else from 3 30 to 4 30 slots
so this is not a new concept that we're bringing it in we're just moving that possibility into the regular school day instead of the before after would would that be am i on target by saying that i think you are on target and like
i was just talking to a small school superintendent and he said you know if this was not allowed that he would not be able to offer some concurrent courses that he's wanted to offer before and after school because his teachers are maxed out at 150 already
but if this is allowed he would be able to do that so it would give more opportunities there also and many more schools are offering concurrent courses now and their teachers have master's degrees and I think you'll see more and more approaching teachers to
Speaker 212
1:22:23
see if they would like do that. I want to just follow up. Did you think about figuring the rate of pay just by dividing the salary into days taught and then divide by seven, which would give you what they
make per period, instead of doing it on a per pupil basis, you would be paid for that class period because you're I mean whether you've got 10 students in there or 30 you would be compensated for one hour that's how we presently do it we
give them one seventh on the same period day however I thought it would be very fair to teachers that if they're going to teach over the 150 students in a day they'll be grading more papers and things like that at night to compensate them to do
Speaker 212
1:23:11
so i i just think that might bear a closer look as to how those the payment compares
on those so so in this bill i have both i have the seventh and the extra per
right no it's both like if you teach during your conference period you get a seventh and if that makes you go over 150 students in a day you also get paid per student for every student you go over 150 so that could cost a district if the teacher was completely maxed out for the seven period about twenty-one thousand that's still a lot more reasonable for the school district
than going out and trying to find whatever's left in the pool of teachers and paying them the starting salary. Thank You Mr. Chair. Representative
Ratliff you're recognized for a question. And one thing I want to stress, too. These folks have got to be certified in that
field. They're teaching. They can't be. Yes, sir. They have to meet all
Arkansas Department of Education requirements. So if they're teaching seven periods of English a day and you add one more, just
another period of English. Yes, sir. Okay. Thank
you, sir. Seeing no more questions, I have one that is ready to speak against the bill. If you would recognize yourself and
Speaker 298
1:24:36
who you're with, you'll recognize. Speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Rich Nagel, Interim Executive Director with the Arkansas Education Association. We testified against this bill in here last time. None of our arguments that we gave for it being against the bill have changed. I just want to reemphasize that while some individuals here will make some additional
salary, please keep in mind the funding level that these districts are getting under the matrix. This leaves even more money on the table for school districts to use for other purposes. Giving someone $20,000 more is still cheaper than hiring an additional teacher. And as we said last time, on the average, school districts are spending on teacher salaries
thousand dollars less per teacher than the actual average salary that exists in the state and for 33,000 teachers you're talking 33 million dollars so I'll close with that any questions seeing none
thank you sir anyone like speak for the bill? You're recognized. Take your name and who you're with, please. Again.
Speaker 169
1:26:09
Veronica Zire, Superintendent of Washtenaw. I have to disagree with that. You know, what we're trying to do with a bill like this is offer above the standards. And so, you know, that's additional money that the district's paying out that we don't have to do. when you start saying you know what he's talking about with your teachers you know we we have minimum amounts of teachers that the matrix is paying for but what we're trying to do is go beyond the requirements to help our students out and that's the key another thing we do as far as
this goes we had some questions about forcing you know are we forcing teachers to do this well we have our district policy and as Mr. Cook mentioned that'll go back to the grievance procedure but we also ask teachers to do summer school to do after school tutoring things of that nature that's voluntary and we're not forcing them to do that at this time so to say that all of a sudden we're going to force on this issue it doesn't make a whole lot of sense i mean i see the potential in a district my size with this you know right now this is 712 bill you know it may be
looked at in the future to say hey we could offer some of our tutoring some of our after school stuff during the school day if these teachers are interested in it
are there any questions thank you sir anyone i speak against the bill for the bill
you're recognized thank you mr chair richard ebernath executive director of aaa we spoke
for the bill the other day our position still remains the same that again this is an option for school districts and teachers to consider and we think that it may help some teachers in that position when they have to take on the second job so we support the legislation
anybody against the bill for the bill would you like close oh okay we got one more for it You're recognized Tony
Speaker 304
1:28:17
Prothrow, Executive Director of the Arkansas School Boards Association
We spoke for this bill on the Senate side And feel it necessary now to go ahead and lend our support to this bill For the
reasons that have been previously stated Anyone against the bill? For the bill? Would you like a close
for your bill? I would, Mr. Chair Thank you and members of the committee Make no mistake teachers need time to prepare I have never known a teacher that did not work at home at night preparing they teach an extra class during the day that's going
to be another hour at home at night they're not going to that's why there's an agreement to pay more the only negative that I can see is that if this law were wildly successful it could severely hurt her bus driver pull the The two hours that my dad spent in the morning and the two hours that he spent in the evening severely hurt his preparation time, four hours a day.
And I think if he had been allowed to teach an extra class a day, rather than driving a bus, as he was driving the bus, which, as you said, doesn't pay nearly as well, doesn't require the education, he began to consider whether teaching was really, if he's got to do something else to make a living, where teaching was really what he needed to do. And so I think this is also a teacher retention bill. We talk about that a lot in retirement committee. I think he might have still been teaching instead of leaving to form his very
own is a very successful business and we we lost another asset and we're I think we're losing a lot more let's let teachers teach and I'd appreciate a good vote what's the will of the committee
representative Lowry I have a do pass have a do pass from representative Lowry all those in favor say aye all those opposed no no the ayes have it Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Roll call. Reverend Walker, you're real good at that roll call.
I am. I see two hands. And Representative Armstrong is your second
Speaker 186
1:30:38
man. Go for it. Roll call. Representative Letting. Representative Murdoch. Was that Iser? Okay. Representative Deffenbaugh. No. Representative Harris Representative Eubanks Representative Radliff
Representative Gillum Representative Gillum Representative Walker Representative Bell Representative Balz Representative Douglas Representative Lowry Representative McElroy Representative Armstrong Representative Gossage Representative Sabin Representative Hodges
Representative Gray Representative Gray Representative Lampkin Representative Lampkin congratulations you have passed your bill thank you
i need to present so i'm going to turn it over to
madam chair last year it's
Thank you, Madam Chair. This is House Bill 1623. Hopefully this will be fairly simple. This is the minimum teacher salary increase, and it's pretty self-explanatory. It raises the teacher salary the first year, $878, and the second year, another $878. So that's basically it. I'd be glad to take any questions. Are there any questions by the committee?
Speaker 319
1:33:11
questions? Okay, Representative Murdoch, you're recognized for a question. Representative Cozart, is this
another one, these adequacy bills? This is a recommendation from the
Speaker 273
1:33:29
to voice it every time we do this. I understand it comes from a committee, But at some point, I really wish that we as a committee, adequacy committee,
a legislature, would come to really address the true needs that have been given to us outside of the adequacy committee. I know we're funding at some level, but when we come to know our needs are 10 and we continue to fund at less than that 5, 6, or 7, those are real children that are not being addressed in those numbers. It's not against your bill. I understand what you're doing. It's not my bill. This blocks the adequacy. Right, certainly. I understand what we must do because we must approve something.
But I think that the court said that we have to stop taking dollars into consideration and we must do what it says do. And so many children are suffering because of this. And, again, this is not against your bill. It's a statement that I need to continue to make. Well, and I will. You could agree with me.
I'm not going to say I don't agree with you. I'm just going to say, you know, as money is available, you know, that's the problem. You know, we have a certain money in the state that comes in.
Are we going to put it all in education and not
it comes to this. And we're trying to do that. But, I mean, I'm going to have some people that are going to speak probably against this that they don't have the money to do what we're wanting to do right here. Right. So, I mean, and you start putting more
Speaker 273
1:35:01
pressure on your schools that don't have the money available? No, no, it's not a school. No, no, this is not a mandate on districts. This is a mandate on us as a legislature to approve this money. So I think it stops, and again, it stops with us because the courts spoke very clearly, and they gave a definitive reason why.
But I think what we continue to do is subject ourselves to litigation, further litigation because of the way we fund it. And I understand the justification, but the justification has not been accepted. by the courts, and I think
Thank you. Representative Diffenbaugh, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Kosar, what did you
say the two speakers were? The increase is $878 each
year for one school year, then the next school year, and that will bring them up to this salary schedule. It'll go from $29,244 to $30,000 122 on the first year this is this is zero years experience this first one i'm not going to go through all those levels and then the next year on the zero year it would be 31 000 would be the starting salary okay thank you
physical impact how much is this going to cost the state this increase i'm all
for increase in teacher salary because they they're the main people that we need to increase because if we don't educate the children, they are of the future. I agree. We need
to realize that. The first year is $18 million. The second
year is $16.6 million. Thank you, Representative. Thank you, Madam
Yes. Thank you, Madam Chair. I hate to always be the fly in the ointment, but isn't it true that this amount is not adequate?
and it's not equitable, as Lakeview discussed it. And the court sort of, especially in view of our last conversation where you give superintendents the opportunity to just double pay, at least increase pay about 30 or 40 percent to volunteers. How do you come up with these figures when you know that the equity issue is interrelated with the adequacy issue,
i.e., the districts that don't pay very much money as starting salaries are the ones that have the lowest achievement. And they are in the poorest areas that have the hardest time getting good teachers. I'm trying to understand how doing this and making it across the board, including the places which already pay much more than the average. How does this contribute to adequacy? How does it contribute to adequacy?
It seems that the gap is being maintained between the haves and the have-nots. Representative, I
don't know what the haves and the have-nots have to do with this, but this is a bill that we all worked on during the interim, and Senator Joyce Elliott was our leader on the adequacy committee and she fought hard, and we all did, to get what we got and as much as we could. But this is what the adequacy committee recommended that would meet adequacy.
Follow up. Yes, sir. While I'm impressed that Senator Elliott was on the committee, I'm not impressed with the outcome. The concern is to make sure that the teachers for those people, those students like those in Mr. Murdoch's district and some of the others like Representative Lampkin's district or even Representative McElroy's district, those teachers at $30,000 a year are not going to be teachers of retention. and they'll leave as soon as they can because it's hard to get them in the first place.
And it is important, according to Lakeview, to have good teachers in the areas of great need. And you have to have a salary scale that, while it should be somewhat uniform, that takes into account those things in order to provide adequate education. There's no way in the world that a $30,000 beginning teacher can be as attracted to Mariana as a $40,000 beginning teacher can be extracted to Springdale
or, for that matter, Little Rock or Pulaski County. So I don't see where the adequacy is being dealt with. I understand this is a compromise, but at some point, don't you think you have to try to really live up to Lakeview? This does not do it. Well, and also it
matters to what kind of degree they have is what that starting salary is. that's a BA degree if you have an MA degree you're going to have a you get your masters you got a $34,000 so I mean that does change Representative I think we worked hard
to do what we could there'll be another adequacy study going on this interim so we'll work again and try to come up as best as we can to help the teachers the kids are our main and most focused but our teachers are who teaches them and we try to do the
Speaker 319
1:40:31
best we can with what we have Are there any other questions from the committee?
Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? On the bill? Okay. okay
okay please recognize yourself thank you madam chair Richard Abernathy executive director of AAEA and we applaud the work of the adequacy committee and trying to address the salaries raising minimum salaries schedule we absolutely support that quality teachers you really can't pay
them enough by the same token we just need to be on record that there is the funding concern I think represent Murdoch hit that on the head that the funds are not adequate in those schools that are meeting the minimum salary schedule to cover this new mandate so I just need to be on record thank you
Speaker 346
1:41:41
sir my name is Greg crabtree and i'm superintendent of the hillcrest district and i'm not here for the bill or against
the bill but only about how it affects our school district and let me start by saying i am for our teachers and i am on the salary schedule we have the best teachers anywhere in the state i would argue just to tell you how this bill would impact us year one the cost would be eight hundred and 44 dollars total salary and benefits year two the cost would be fifty three thousand five hundred and eighty nine dollars salary and benefits year one with the point eight percent increase from
the adequacy committee we would net twenty six thousand forty dollars year two the point eight percent increase twenty six thousand four hundred and sixty dollars that is a total cost of fifty two thousand five hundred and would leave us with a negative balance of nineteen hundred and twenty seven dollars and no money left to do anything else for our classified employees I want to state again I'm not here for or against just telling you how it will impact Hillcrest
do that to you. Okay. Representative Walker, you had a question? Yes,
Speaker 346
1:43:14
I'm not familiar with Hillcrest. Is that a small district located where? Small, rural, and isolated located in northeast Arkansas consists of parts of five former school districts put together. Is it a poor county? Yes, Lawrence, Randolph, Sharp Counties, 300 square miles. Thank you.
Speaker 319
1:43:31
Okay. Any other questions? Okay. Thank you, sir. You're welcome. Okay. Mr. Nagel,
Speaker 298
1:43:51
you're here to speak for the bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Rich Nagel with the Arkansas Education Association. We're supportive of this newly proposed minimum salary schedule that comes to you from,
as a recommendation from the House and Senate Education Committees. I guess I'd just make two points to be brief. One is, it's important to recognize that the average teacher salary in Arkansas saw, has not grown by even one full percent for the last four years. Not one percent in four years.
Now I understand arguments that it should be more, and I couldn't agree more with that. But more money is not what this bill is going to, this bill won't provide more money for that argument. should have been dealt with earlier. Second, as I testified on the other bill, the actual average teacher salary within the state is $1,000 less than what is actually funded through
the matrix so we've done quite a few bills this session to free up some other money people teaching another period other sorts of things you know there's probably going to be enough money with all this said and done you could do seven hundred and fifty more nurses within the state there'll be so much that will be left at the discretion of the district so the average teacher
salary and this new minimum salary schedule it's really long overdue and I would encourage you to do everything you can to support this measure even though it's not sufficient thank you thank you is there anyone
Speaker 319
1:46:00
else in an audience who like to speak for against the bill any more questions from the committee would you like to close for your bill appreciate a good vote what are the wishes of the committee representative Eubanks gives a motion of do pass all
right we have a motion of do pass all those in favor say aye opposed say nay All right. The ayes have it. Congratulations. You've
Senate Bill 789. Senator Hendren, you're recognized as to present Senate Bill 789.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. It's good to be back before you again. I've got Senate Bill 789. This bill is a bill that makes a process available to get some funds to facilities of charter schools. It's got a lot of protections in there to make sure that those dollars go to schools that are performing and that the state's interests are protected. So let me just kind of go through those.
it cannot go to a charter school that utilizes primarily virtual technology. So it has to be a real charter school with real bricks and mortar. It has to be a facility that meets the applicable health, fire, and safety codes. So it has to be a facility that we don't worry about the kids learning in. It also has to go to a charter school that's performing well. And by that, I mean it can't be in academic distress. It can't be a priority school district or one that's going to be rated with an F once they change that scale. can't be one that's placed in probationary status. The charter school would have to sign
over security interest when they take some of this money, and that's specified in the bottom of page two and the back of page three, so that in the event that they stopped using the facility for educational purposes, the state would be able to recoup its investment. So what this bill does is basically say that there will be some dollars made available if the dollars are found outside of the traditional funding methods that could flow to charter schools to meet some of their needs with facilities. This is not going to take dollars from the public schools traditional funding formula.
This is dollars that will either be found through general improvement or through dollars that have been previously allocated towards charter schools. So it is an attempt to try to put in place a process that we've got, I think nearly 10 to 12,000 kids that are receiving tax dollars through foundation funding to make sure that those ones that are doing well are able to have facilities that they can afford. Charter schools have not had available any facilities funding at all from the taxpayers.
They haven't had available local millage funding as local school districts do. So this is, I think, an attempt to try to recognize those districts that are doing a good job to give them tools to do it. In my business, I try to focus dollars where I see things performing, but I also don't neglect the rest of the business. So let me just also say that in no way is this an effort to try to take dollars or to stifle the ability of our traditional public education to achieve. I'm a big believer in public education, 15 years on a public school board, graduated from
public school, and my kids are all going to graduate. I hope my last one in May. But I also know that when you've got 10 to 12,000 kids that are in buildings that are in need of repair and we've got right now five million dollars in a fund that was allocated for charter school revolving loans that has not been able to be accessed we need to get those dollars out to where they can help the education of these kids so I think it again with the framework and the limitations that are put on this legislation so that the dollars are required to go where
they're needed I think it's a needed piece of legislation we passed the appropriation bills out this morning of budget that would allow some funding to to be made available for this perhaps through general improvement or again through some of the funds that were approved previously for the revolving loan fund account so that's what the bill does and I'd be happy to answer any questions. Representative Ratliff you're recognized for a question. Senator
could you tell me why they didn't none of them apply for that money when
we put it in that loan I mean you know I think part of the issue that charter schools have had and there may be some folks who can speak more to that than I can but I will tell you as a former school board member I knew that as we tried to build facilities we had we had the ability to do that because we had an ongoing revenue stream generated by the millage it's difficult to do that with without some sort of funding
stream and they don't get to use bonds and things like the Other school districts do. Could I have one follow-up, please? You're recognized.
Do you know how many of the charter schools actually transport their kids?
they get $300 a child transportation money. So, you know, if they don't use that, I guess they could use that for something. Well, you know,
there's, again, those of us who served on school boards know that a lot of times dollars that are allocated for transportation get used for maintenance and operation. and dump mills that have been passed for construction get used for maintenance and operation. So there's no question that some of that goes on in both forms of education.
We have one charter school in my district, and they run two buses. So I
sir. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Am I hearing you right? You're proposing that the public schools, that the public school system finance the construction of the facilities operated by the private charter schools, which are not subject to government regulation, which are not subject to regulation by local boards of education or other elected people.
No. but tell me what you're really trying to do with this bill because you're saying that you only give some money to help them with construction that's the way I see it so
so what are you really doing well this is not dollars again that's coming from the local school district the charter school governor's doesn't change under this legislation that's that's operating under legislation that's been approved previously the only thing this does is allow just as we allow foundation funding to flow to those kids this would allow some under rules and regulations that are adopted and approved by Department of Ed and the facilities division to find some way to make sure that the kids that are in a
school that we as a legislative body have approved and are supporting with tax dollars to make sure that there are also some dollars to support that those facilities are safe
and warm and dry. So what you're doing is trying to make sure that you have some money go to each charter school each charter student
to be used any way you want to? No. There's very tight stipulations on where the dollars could be used in the legislation with regard to maintenance, construction, restoration,
alteration, modification, and there will also be additional rules and regulations as approved. There's also stipulations and regulations in the bill about which charter schools, so it's not every student in every school, so it is far more tightly constrained than you described. How much would it cost? Well, this bill has no fiscal impact because the fiscal impact is going to depend on what the legislature decides to appropriate or what is appropriated through general improvement. Thank you.
Are there any other questions, committee? Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience who likes to speak against the bill?
Speaker 380
1:54:39
My name is Mike Mertens with the Arkansas Association of Educational Administrators. Last year, during adequate testimony, our association recommended that charter schools be allowed to participate in the partnership facilities program. program. Students that attend charter schools or public school students just like those that
attend traditional schools and those students deserve adequate facilities just like all students do. So I just wanted to mention that because I'm not saying that our association supports adequate facilities for charter schools in response to this bill, but we have said that previously. Our concern regarding this bill is, and with all due respect to Senator Hendren,
we do not think that this is a facilities bill at all. For one thing, the bill amends the part of Arkansas Code that deals with charter schools. it does not amend the law that pertains to the facilities partnership program or anything to do with facilities. This means that this new funding stream is not subject to the same requirement of traditional schools for facility planning, for application, and approval. There is nothing in this bill that requires any of this additional appropriation
to be spent on facilities. In fact, the bill specifically says that these funds can be spent on maintenance and operation. So general maintenance, custodial services, custodial supplies, utilities, and classified salaries would be allowable expenditures for any or all of these funds. Nothing in the bill requires that these funds be spent on academic facilities. This means that these funds could be spent on athletic facilities, which have not been funded by the Facilities Partnership since its inception.
If these funds are spent on facilities, charter schools will not be required to submit any documentation showing that the project is needed or that it meets suitability guidelines. And one of the key components of the Facility Partnership Program is the district must show that the facility that they are requesting funding for, that it is needed and that it meets suitability guidelines,
which means districts can't ask for more facilities than they actually need. Now, Senator Hendren mentioned the appropriation bills. there is one of them that is a transfer of five million dollars from the open enrollment public charter school loan program into this program and there's also another appropriation bill for 15 million so so we don't know how much
money will be appropriated for this but it could be as much as 20 million or it could be some amount below that but just using the amount 15 million which since we have an appropriation bill out there for 15 million it seems to me that that would be an intent of this program to have at least 15 million dollars in it that means an approximately 1700 extra per student that would flow to charter school with no guidelines at all that any of it has to be spent
on academic facilities so if this bill passes charter schools will receive the six to three dollars per student that all schools are getting and they also could receive another amount which is based on 15 million could be an additional $1,700 now our position on this and again it's been our position before today is that if there are funds available for school facilities they should be placed in the partnership program and all public schools, traditional and charter,
follow the same requirements for application and approval. Facility needs need to be funded by priority. We heard testimony during adequacy that after the 15-17 cycle, the seed money that was put into the facility partnership program a decade ago will basically be gone and that any money available there will be based on appropriations from this group or from this legislature
now some opposition to that will say the well charter schools don't have the ability to raise millages they can be given the ability to go to their communities and ask for a millage increase There are, according to an OEP report of earlier this year, there are four states in the nation that actually do allow charters to ask for millage increases. And if this body didn't consider that to be an alternative,
they could be assigned a wealth index that would allow them to receive partnership funds equal to some of our poorest districts in the state in regard to property assessments. districts are assigned a wealth index some districts receive little or no money if they have a facility project they need and some districts receive as much as 82 percent of their project funded and for those districts that are that receive 80 or or around 80 percent those are
very poor districts when it comes to property assessments uh either it's difficult for them the path of millage and if they can pass the millage it would be so high to raise the amount of money they need that it would almost be impossible to fund to pass. So what they do is they save their money when they get enough money in reserve to meet their match then they apply for a facilities grant. Regarding all school facilities in this state since that pot of money
is not an unlimited funding source. I think it's crucial that we identify the needs that we have and we fund those most in need first. And if everyone goes through the process, whether they're a charter school or a traditional public school, then whatever projects are at the top, those are the ones that need to be funded as long as we have the funds to do so. So with that, I'll conclude my testimony and be glad to answer any questions.
Thank you. Representative Ratliff, you are recognized for, I'm sorry, Representative Letting was first. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just one quick
question. I heard a lot of talk about appropriations and funding. Would this do anything to jeopardize or otherwise limit funding that could go to
go around. Representative Ratliff, you're recognized. Okay, I've got a question that's kind of just sitting here and hitting me and thinking about.
House Bill 1377 passed Representative Murdoch put some waivers for the public school to have the same waivers as the charter schools. Will this also make this money available for
Speaker 380
2:02:47
those schools? well as far as i know no charter school has a ask a waiver for facility requirement because they're not covered under the facility requirement under the facility law
okay i just wonder that i kind of you know something that just that waiver bill was something in there that we probably don't know what that may do in the future so that's
Speaker 225
2:03:17
thank you president lower you recognize your question yes thank you mr. chairman since representative Ratliff did mention representative Murdoch's bill one of the main discussions about it was having a level playing field for public schools in districts where charter schools are
pulling from them level playing field works both ways though doesn't it Charter schools right now are not on a level playing field as far as facilities
Speaker 380
2:03:43
funding. Is that correct? Yes, sir. That's absolutely correct. And our testimony today and during the adequacy testimony is we think they should be allowed to access that money under the same rules and regulations that traditional schools have. You know, that project, that process involves several things. It involves an application.
It involves a suitability study where the division is going to say whether or not they actually need that facility. Now, there are public schools that are disappointed every year, traditional public schools that are disappointed every year because the division says we're not going to approve that project. We're not going to recommend that project for approval. So when it comes to facilities, to get our best bang for our buck, whether they're traditional or charter schools, It's our position that all facility projects could run through the same procedure.
The division of facilities has become very good at reviewing a project and determining if it is truly a priority need for this state. Thank you for the
have spoken against the bill, right? Yes, sir. Does anybody want to speak for the bill? You're a recognized speaker for the bill.
Speaker 387
2:05:17
State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized. Scott Shirey, Executive Director, KIPP Delta Public Schools. Thank you, Chairman, and thank you, Representatives. I've had the privilege of speaking to some of you before in the past, And I do want to take a quick second to just acknowledge some of our accomplishments and who we are, for those of you who are less familiar with our work. First of all, we serve nearly 1,400 students in Helena and in Blytheville, opening in Forest City next year.
Ninety percent of our students qualify for free or reduced lunch. This year, 11 percent of our students receive special education services. We run about 1,200 miles a day in transportation, taking up about 8% or 9% of our budget. We have a track record of academic success over the last 13 years since opening in 2002, where we've outperformed the local school district in 90% of tested areas. And for the past four years, our high school has been ranked in the top five of high schools in the state by U.S. News and World Report, most recently number two.
despite the low-income averages where only 10% of low-income students actually graduate from college our initial classes are persisting through college at an 80% rate and we're quite proud of that and our vision is simply to eliminate the achievement gap that exists in our communities and across our state for students of high need. Despite all that, we're at a critical juncture and we do need your
support. KIPP Delta, like all charter schools, receives state funding on a per-pupil basis for every enrolled student. However, we have no access to local tax dollars or millage for facilities and we've had no access over the last 13 years to the facility partnership program. One of the was asked was why didn't we apply well we weren't able to apply so that leaves us in a quandary where we've been given permission to serve students yet we have no support in getting infrastructure to actually house them OEP study recently
put out that charter schools on average receive two thousand dollars less per pupil than traditional districts and depending on that community the gap can be even wider therefore again where we're taking money out of operating dollars which should be designated to serve our our schools and serve our students we're taking money out of operating and applying it toward facility which again should go towards educating our children despite being
number two in the in the state we have no access to none of our schools have a library none of our schools have a dedicated cafeteria we don't meet meet those basic needs for our kids often we most of our students are housed in trailers we only have one athletic space for all 1400 students and often students are eating lunch on their laps because there's there's no space and I do want to say that the division would have control here so there's no intent
for the money to be used on anything but educational classrooms and again many of our students are in trailers crammed in we're in churches creative spaces just trying to find room to teach they are poorly insulated just recently with all the storms we've had major leaks in our trailers creating problems and it is not warm safe or dry I urge you to pass this legislation it would provide charters
with some some access to facility dollars and again not taking anything away from traditional schools that is not the that is not the intent so thank Thank you for having me here today, and I'm happy to answer any questions. Representative Walker for a short question. Sir, well, are you limiting
me? No, sir, I'm just making a little fun. Oh, that's fine. We need a little fun today.
It's been a long day. I think that's right. Mr. Sarri.
before you all set up the so-called KIPP schools, that those KIPP procedures were in place in Little Rock, Arkansas, in the form of incentive schools, and they were approved by the United States Court of Appeals and were in place for a number of years
until Little Rock decided that, well, they were too successful by dealing with the smaller classes and the very things that you all have now taken and used in your schools and they chose to discontinue them. Are you aware of that? I'm less familiar
you are aware that KIPP did not come into being until after 1990? Yes, the first KIPP school opened in 1994. That's right. And they were all modeled after our incentive schools, which Little Rock chose to discard.
Now tell me this. Why should you be allowed in a context where the schools in your district for all of the black children have never been made equal? And Lakeview did not cover equality of schools. They only dealt with safe, warm, and dry. Why is it that you all should tap into this fund before the schools that are public are made equal? You go around and you will see they all have vestiges of discrimination.
Forest City, Helena, Marvell, all the way down the delta. So why should you all be able to get this money before the schools are made equal and before those students have adequate facilities either. In Little Rock, we know that in the southeast quadrant, those schools are leaking. All the things that you mentioned about your schools are there and even worse. So why should the state now take money and prioritize the charters when the public schools,
especially for the poor and minority children, have
Speaker 387
2:11:56
not been addressed? Well, this is not to prioritize charters over traditional schools over the last decade.
No, no, it is to compete with them. It is to take money away from them when the first priority of the state is to provide adequate, free and equal education to all the students of the state, especially for the public schools. There is no state obligation to do that for charters or for private, not under the Constitution.
Speaker 387
2:12:24
Let me try to answer your first question, which was around the allocation of dollars Over the last decade, there's been literally a billion dollars which has gone toward the traditional facility partnership program. We've been in existence that whole time. We've had no access to those dollars. Most recently, Helena West Helena, through that partnership program, received $6 million. And again, over the last 13 years, we've received zero dollars.
Bentonville recently received $15 million on the other side. But again, just in a local comparison, Helena and West Helena had access to $6 million. And we're not asking for near that much. And again, the money would come from non-traditional public funding sources. So I don't see this as competition. And I'm not here to compete. I'm here to serve children. And we know there are a lot of children in the state, and particularly in the Delta,
who need support and need help and who need adequate facilities. Is that a question, sir?
Yes, sir. Do you agree, since you are trying to locate there, do you agree that they need public facilities in each one of those places
Speaker 387
2:13:50
that I've mentioned? I haven't done an assessment of all of those facilities, but I do believe there's need. And, again, the question is one of mechanism.
There's no mechanism right now for charters to even have an opportunity to get any funding, and that's what we're here trying to
Speaker 273
2:14:14
address today. Thank you. President Murdoch, you're ready to ask for a question. Thank you, Chairman. How you doing, Scott? I'm good, sir. How are you? Good to see you. we've had many conversations about the situations of KIPP Delta and the job
that's done. You all do a great job with the children that you receive, and I commend you on that publicly without any reservations at all. You do understand the sensitivity, and I think we've had a long conversation about how we as a, and some of this is not to you but you are the product you are the one there that it the appearance sometime of a or an unintended consequence let me say that
of what has happened has caused such division that sometimes it's tough to get to the purity of the moment you know just the purity of what we need to do because we all agree that children need to be educated, facilities need to be utilized for that purpose, and we all need to be walking that way. So many times what happened is how leadership has governed
in some cases and put institutions and positions have caused some of what you're going through right now. We have to become greater and larger as leaders to somehow overcome this. I think we have to be leaders in our communities to make this more acceptable and deal with this. You know where we come from. It's very emotional, very, very emotional, because some people, intended or unintended, have been harmed.
School districts, communities have been decimated. And I just want to make sure that as we move forward and as the political landscape has changed, that people still understand that there are human beings that have been affected by these changes. And there are human beings on both sides of this conversation that have suffered in some way. So as we move forward, and we move forward explicitly, and we just define it as just for the children,
which ultimately it should be, but there are a lot of people in between that that have worked very hard, have, you know, did a lot of things to make Helena, West Helena, and other school districts in the Delta viable, and the perceptions of what they are and the realities of what they are. So hopefully that as you present and as you continue to flourish, because I do think it's going to continue. Point of
Speaker 225
2:17:01
order, Mr. Chairman. We're supposed to be limited to asking questions, correct?
I believe we have got to a statement. Do you have a question for
way, if that's okay. I think you were kind of dwelling on a big statement. Let's go ahead and get a question. We are running out of time
Speaker 273
2:17:29
part of what I just said, what you've just seen happen is where we are. And so when something is so, as you know where we come from, so dramatic and sensitive, but because of the day
then I get cut off like that and we need to move on so I'll just deal with it as it is and we'll just hopefully everyone
understand the sensitivity of where we are thank you for being here Representative Bell
you're recognized for a question or whatever I have a motion
Mr. Chair I move immediate consideration I have a
motion of uh consideration all those in favor say aye any opposed all right what's the will of the committee
i have a due pass all those in favor say aye all those opposed no no eyes have it congratulations you have passed your bill thank you you all right committee here's here's the deal it's it's 20 after i have five people that are still waiting to present today i'm at your mercy do you want to hear i have here's what i have i
have represent douglas has two quick bills i have represent ratless has three they're all pretty good short bills, and then I have Representative Broadway, Representative Tucker, and Representative Scott. Those are the ones waiting in order. You give me a time, we'll go till we run out of time. Anyone want to make a motion on time? Suggestion on a time? 1240. I have a suggestion of 1240. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed?
No. No. Ayes have it. We're going to 1240. Charlotte. Representative Douglas, you are recognized. We
are, without objection, we are going to limit debate from one side to the other,
four against, to three minutes. I heard no objection. You're recognized
Speaker 212
2:19:57
to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is House Bill 1913. It is on facilities. It is going back in the law 10 years where we had made some provisions for some reports to be made, and so we've cleaned up the language and ask that those reports be made on some funds that were
were going to be studied and we'd like for that study to go forward and then we've also asked for some ability to go in and have a conference before your facilities plan is either, you know, turned down or accepted in order to have some you know, some help from the facilities on anything that you may be lacking.
It's a good bill. We don't have opposition from the facilities at all on this and would like a good vote. Are there any questions, committee? I have Superintendent Hester with me to answer questions as well. We'll see if we have any questions.
So far I have none. I have no questions from the committee. Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? You are recognized closed for your bill. I'm closed.
Thank you. Representative Armstrong? Move, do pass. Do pass from Representative Armstrong. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations. You have
Speaker 212
2:21:36
passed your bill. Thank you. You may present your other bill. What number is it? This is 1586. All right. 1586. What I'm asking for in this bill is to consider moving the timeline on consolidation of the schools that meet the 350 breakpoint from two years to three years.
And I'm asking that the Department of Ed work with the school when they meet that first under 350 mark to give the indication to the community that they're going to work with that school to try to reverse that negative, that decline in enrollment. And I think this will send a message to the communities that the school is not going to just be abandoned by the ADE
and allowed to, you know, just die. that it is a way to develop a plan, use best practices, and see if we can't help the schools to reverse those declining enrollments. And I'd ask for a good vote from the committee on it. Any questions on it?
question. Mr. Chair had a motion to the proper time. All right. Any other questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill?
For the bill? Are you closed for your bill? I am closed, thank you. Representative Bill, you're recognized for a due pass? Move, due pass. Have a due pass motion for Representative Bill. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any
Speaker 212
2:23:21
opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed both of those bills. Thank you. Do you want me to present Representative House's? I'll do your amendment for Representative House. Representative House has an amendment to be filed on his bill 1913 concerning public school. No, no, I'm sorry. Forget it. Wrong paper. It's on 1552.
on scholarship on his scholarship program for students with disabilities okay we just need to adopt that yes sir anybody have questions have a motion to
adopt all those in favor say aye any opposed no motion is adopted thank you mr. chair thank you thank you represent ratliff you're recognized for three bills Tell you what, we'll just batch them We'll pass all three of them at
once I've already asked, I said I couldn't do it
It's worth a try House Bill 1650 is an act to Clean up some license background checks On license personnel And it's just a cleanup bill from Arkansas Department of Education And got any questions? How many questions, committee? Seeing no questions, anyone in the audience like to
speak against the bill, for the bill? Are you closed for your bill? I'm closed and do pass, please. I have a do pass from Representative Ratliff for his bill.
All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The ayes have it. You have passed your bill. You are recognized to present House Bill
1651. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This bill is another AD cleanup bill, and it deals with the code of teacher licensure. And it's just a cleanup bill, and it's been vented, and everybody's talked
about it, and it looks good. Any questions, committee? Seeing none. Audience, against? For? You closed for your bill? Closed and due pass, please.
I have another due pass from Representative Ratliff on his bill. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you've passed your bill.
Okay. That's a bill of 1652, your record. 1652 is a test, excellent support system. It's an ADE bill. It's for cleanup and to improve the system for them. And if you've got any questions, I'll sure
answer them. Any questions? Anyone in the audience against?
For? Closed? Closed and do pass, please. I have another do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, you've passed on three-year bills. Representative Broadway, you are recognized for Senate Bill 999. Another quick one, I
least it's not 666. That's exactly right. You're recognized, and you have people joining you.
If they want to speak, just recognize who you
are and who you're with. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I bring to you today Senate Bill number 999. What this bill is, is that this was brought to me by the University of Arkansas, but it has to do with audit procedures. It's to create an exemption from the Freedom of Information Act concerning working papers related to audit reports for institutions of higher learning. There are just a few institutions, frankly, that this would apply to
in that they have internal audit procedures. There is already a law in place, general, with regard to legislative audit when they, in fact, perform these audits. This is not in any way to try to circumvent FOI procedures, but it's a timing issue. And then often when these investigations are going on, FOI requests become frequent. They interfere in the staff's time and preparation, preparing the reports.
And thus, we believe that when it's much, the public is better served, the taxpayers are better served, that if a FOI request is sent, that that is done after the investigation has been completed. Upon completion, then the FOI is complied with and the working papers and everything else are provided.
Mr. Chair, I have procedurally messed up, and I apologize. We have actually an amendment to this bill. I believe that Representative Bell had a request for an amendment on this bill, and we, in fact, have done that. We have removed, if we want to look at the bill.
Do you have that amendment with you? Yes, she does. Okay. Okay. You'll hold on just a second.
That was your question, I'm sure. It would be page one, I believe, line 34 through
page two, line one. We're still good since we haven't taken
action on the bill. We'll let you present your amendment if you want to. Go ahead. Okay. Thank you. What our amendment does is it removes section A, B, the unsubstantiated allegations obtained in complying with the American Institute of Certified public accountants, U.S. auditing standards,
clarified, and other professional guidelines regarding detection of fraud as they exist on January 1, 2005. That language is completely eliminated. All right. She has presented the amendment. Do I have a motion on
the amendment? I have a motion from Representative Eubanks on the motion. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? All right. You can present your bill as
amended now. Thank you so much. basically you already heard the spiel about the purpose of the bill um and and so with that um i
would um turn it any questions over to someone a little bit more knowledgeable than me uh mr fleuroy is that correct yes my name is jacob fleuroy i'm
Speaker 416
2:29:33
an internal director university architecture system i'm available to answer any questions you have about the bill any questions
committee seeing no questions anyone in the audience would like to
speak against this bill for this bill i'll let you close for your bill i'm close
i'm going to give that motion to representative bell since he found that amendment move do pass mr do pass as amended okay we have a do pass as amended all those in favor say i any opposed no congratulations you passed your bill thank you mr chair representative tucker You are recognized for – You want to do Ms. Scott first, sir, because his may take a while. Representative Tucker, would you possibly yield to Ms. Scott? Representative Scott, she has a real short one. Sure. In case you are – if you get started, we won't quit until you get going.
So, Representative Scott, you are – For anyone other than Representative Scott, I'd say no. I would say the senior member, but she would get me for that. Rep. Scott, you are recognized to present. Oh, I lost that number. Yeah, House Bill 2007. Yes,
Mr. Chair, and thank you, and thank you, committee.
I presented a bill earlier today in the Senate, and it sure is nice to see happy, smiling faces here. So I appreciate you guys. And my bill did pass, by the way. I have with me today Jim Hall from NWAC, which is a wonderful community college in Northwest Arkansas in my hometown of Rogers. And I'd like to just turn this bill over to him, please. Thank you, Representative
Scott. Tell you who you're with and be recognized.
My name is Jim Hall. I'm the Director of Community and Government Relations at Northwest Arkansas Community College.
We are one of four. Our Board of Trustees is one of four community colleges in Arkansas that are elected. it's a non-member board uh up through 2010 our board was elected at large within uh a service or a district a taxing district of around 150 000 people in 2000 with the 2010 census we zoned our board uh to comply with federal voting rights act and we zoned it to nine areas of 17
thousand citizens each. When we did that, that made this number of signatures required to get your name on a petition to get on the ballot, it made it somewhat cumbersome. And our board started talking about possibly reducing the number of signatures required to get on the ballot from 50 signatures down to a little more manageable number. We looked at different numbers. We looked at the number of signatures needed to get on to the ballot on a first class city of
30 signatures and then a school board of 20. So we split the difference and we're asking for 25. Representative Saban, you're recognized for a question. Motion at
other questions committee? Is there anyone in the audience would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? are you closed
closed and thank you committee uh what's the will of the committee move to pass from representative saban all those in favor say aye any opposed no
congratulations you passed your bill thank you thank you okay President Tucker you are recognized to present your bill thank you very much
mr. chairman and members of the committee that is house bill 1605 is
that correct yes sir all right all right this bill addresses transparency
of the state government when the state government has taken over local school district and I just want to take a second to just identify the fact that I think everyone recognizes that the state to take over local school district is not a first choice because you have a situation where you have a community that pays local tax dollars they have a locally elected school board and the community should make the decisions for their schools unless there's some
extenuating circumstances and that's when the state takes over local school districts and a couple of the reasons why I think everyone prefers for local school districts to have control it's because number one you have much more opportunity for local input and number two you have much greater opportunity for local transparency all the work of the public school district is subject to public disclosure under the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act and so the general purpose of the bill is just to make sure that when the state takes over a local school district the local community who's still paying tax dollars
to fund that local school district has just as much transparency about what's happening with their school district when it's managed at the state level as they do when it's managed on the local level so just a couple of words real quick on what current Arkansas FOI law apply and so well just one other thing first I think everyone recognizes that the work of the ADE of the Arkansas Department of Education is subject to disclosure so anything ADE does the public can find out about under current law and I don't think there's any dispute about that so what the bill seeks to address is and the circumstances when
ADE contracts or enters into some sort of legal arrangement with a third-party entity to help manage the operations of the local school district. And it's not a circumstance that's completely unique in the law. For example, I'm just going to read real quick from a Supreme Court of Arkansas decision from 1990. It says the intent of the FOI establishes the right of the public to be fully apprised of the conduct of public business.
And again, the purpose of this bill is just to make sure that when public business is being conducted, and if there's any business that's public, it's the local administration and management of a school district in any way. In this case, you have a city who, well, there's a city attorney on staff, but the city hired a private attorney to conduct some work, and there was a FOI request to obtain the documents of the private attorney, and that was challenged, and it went all the way to the Supreme Court. And the Supreme Court ruled that the specially retained attorneys were the functional equivalent
of the regular city attorney. The city cannot avoid the FOIA requirements by substituting a private attorney for the city attorney. To condone such logic would arguably enable public officials to shield from disclosure sensitive or controversial material by hiring an outside attorney instead of using its regular city attorney. The FOIA requirements cannot be circumvented by delegation of regular duties to one specially retained to perform the same task as the regular employee or official. This would be contrary to the requirements and intent of the FOIA.
The second case I'll just mention real briefly is a case from 2007 where you have the same circumstance but the FOIA request was submitted to the third party private entity rather than to the local government. In that case the Supreme Court said you can only submit a FOIA request to the public entity not to the private entity even if the private entity is doing public work and they have public documents that should be subject to public disclosure. And so really the first thing that my bill does is it clarifies and codifies that law. And there are some circumstances where I think
codifying case law is positive. And this is one of those circumstances for a couple of reasons. Number one, as an attorney, and I wish this weren't on the record, but sometimes judges change their minds. And so that's kind of the first reason. But the second reason is this law deals with the public's right to know and it's superior in my opinion for the public to be aware of their right to know through statutory law rather than through case law because that's just more readily accessible by the public rather than rooting through cases that go back over a 40-year
period and so that's the first thing the bill does is it just clarifies and confirms the law that if ADE hires a third-party entity to help in the administration operation of a local school District, the documents related to that, even within the private entity, are subject to public disclosure. And then it really departs from current FOIA law in two ways. In my opinion, relatively minor ways, but I may not have the only opinion on that. The two ways are, first, a private entity's documents are only subject to disclosure if
they are supported wholly or partially by public funds. And this bill removes that requirement, but again, only in the narrow circumstance of when the Department of Education takes over a local school district. That does not change the FOIA law for all public contracts with any governments across the state. Only in this narrow circumstance. And the rationale for that change is the same rationale that the Supreme Court applied in the language that I read. And basically, if you have the Department of Education, they have the responsibility
manage the the local school district if they're delegating that responsibility to a third party entity that third party entity is engaging in public work and the local community has a right to know about what's happening with their local school district and so that's the rationale for that change the second change basically is and this is sort of a preemptive measure because i think in some communities when their local school district has taken over if they're concerned about this issue then they're just going to be submitting foi request after foi request to learn whether
ade has entered into one of these sort of arrangements and so what this does is it says if ade enters into some sort of arrangement along these lines at that point the department has to notify the chair of the house committee on education and the senate committee on education as well as all members of the general assembly who represent the territory that includes the affected school district about the relationship and basically the terms of the relationship and so forth and what has to be turned over at that time would be equivalent to what the ADE and the
entity would have to turn over if an FOI request were submitted and so that's it so there's an affirmative obligation put on ADE within 10 days of the initial time they put on the they enter into the contract but that's the only affirmative obligation they have there's no ongoing affirmative obligation other than to comply with four-year requests which they're already subject to and so that's basically what the bill does a couple changes i made to the bill through the process i've had conversations with a lot of people including commissioner tony wood also senator
johnny key three members of the state board of education and with other members of the education community one who i spoke with is kathy smith who's executive director of the walton foundation One concern that she raised is if you give a grant to a school in academic distress or a school district in academic or facilities distress or whatever, would that subject those documents to the Freedom of Information Act? And so in recognition of that concern, I added a provision in the bill that basically says if all you're doing is providing a grant or other unilateral funding to a school or school district in any sort of distress, that does not subject you to the terms of this provision unless you enter into a contract with ADE to manage the local school district.
So if you enter into a contract with ADE to manage the operations and administration of the local school district, then you're subject to this. But if all you're doing is giving a grant or other unilateral funding, then this section does not apply. In a conversation with Representative Bell, he raised another concern because there's a portion in the bill that says the third party that enters into the contract with ADE, all of their subcontractors and affiliates are subject to the same disclosure requirements. but there's a limitation on that that it those documents have to relate to the
educational policies and procedures of the local school district under state control and so that's another change that I made to the bill just a couple concerns that have been brought to me and I just like to clarify those on the front end with the indulgence of the committee is whether this will apply to other contracts between school districts and ADE and the for example a teacher of the year contract and the answer to that is it will not apply to first of all it doesn't apply to any contracts whatsoever with local schools or local school districts it only applies to contracts with the Arkansas Department
of Education and only with regard to contracts that have to do with the administration or operation of a local school district and then another concern that's been raised is if a private entity enters into a contract with ADE are all their documents going to be subject to public disclosure and the The answer to that is absolutely not. Only the documents that relate to their contract regarding the operation and administration of the local school district are subject to disclosure.
And that's the same way it is with current FOIA law. As I mentioned, all the time public entities enter into contracts with private entities. In those cases, if the documents are supported by public funds, then even the documents within the private control of the entity, the control of the private entity, are subject to public disclosure but only those documents not all of the documents of the entity and so basically that's the gist of the bill I have Chris Heller with me today he's he's the attorney for Little Rock School District and he's been on the receiving
end of FOIA requests in that capacity for the last few decades and so I don't I'll leave it up to the chairman how he wants
to proceed since time's going short I would probably like to go to questions right now if you're good with Are you ready for questions? Yes, sir. Representative
Speaker 225
2:43:51
Lauer, you're recognized for a question. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Tucker, you know you and I originally spoke about this bill, and I'm all for transparency and understand the intent of what you're doing and do appreciate the language that you put in that clarifies about grants.
My concern may be just a drafting issue, but you grant this exemption when it refers to grants. the exemption to section F I guess the definition of documents yet the bottom of page 2 section C refers to that documents memorandums of understanding all these other documents
would be FOIable whether the services are supported wholly or partially with public funds including those supported without public funds. So it appears to me that your caveat that you put in there or your exemption does not apply to this section. Would I be correct? No, sir. That's not the way
you look in subsection F at the bottom of page 3,
it says nothing in subsection including F2C. That would include F2C. applies to a third-party person or entity or to their documents or contracts or so forth if they provide a grant or other unilateral funding to a public school or school district. And so I don't think that it's unclear at all that even in those situations, those documents are not subject to public disclosure.
Speaker 225
2:45:37
Follow-up. You recognize for follow-up. Okay, follow-up, Mr. Chair. I'm sorry, I'm looking at the section I don't see the reference to F2C I just see that it says nothing so section F applies to a third party person or entity or to the documents contracts, agreements anyway, if it's related to a grant but it does not say anything about the section that I read at the bottom of page 2 I mean, the two sections seem to be in conflict with
one another It doesn't specifically mention F2C
but it doesn't specifically mention any other subsections either because all subsections are included within Section F. And so, I mean, the language doesn't say nothing in subsection F1, F2A, F2B, F2C, F3, F4, and F5 applies because those are all included within subsection F. And so
Speaker 225
2:46:31
you're confident that the exemption that is there on the last page, that if the flow of money is one way, if it's private to public, then the provisions of
this bill do not apply at all. Yes, sir. And I'll give you one more reason for that. Statutory, it's also a rule of contract interpretation, but also statutory interpretation. If two provisions of the same contract or two provisions of the same law are in conflict with each other, then deference is given to the more specific provision. And so in this case, the more specific provision is, in cases of grants or other unilateral funding, Section
Speaker 426
2:47:07
F does not apply. Thank you for that clarification. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Are there any other questions?
Representative Bill, you're recognized for a question. Representative Tucker, you know, you and I have talked about this a number of times, and you've certainly worked hard to try to accommodate some of my concerns. And as I've told you the other day, I think I'm almost there but not quite there. And my concern still goes to any other purpose language related to the operation and administration of a public school. And that's at the top of, I believe, page 4. Yes, top of page 4. We still have some language referencing that, any other operations language.
And I'm not sure I understand exactly what ramification that has there. But as I told you, former Representative Nichols and I had many circular arguments about this topic. And I've always been an advocate for transparency in this legislature. But what I don't want to see is I don't want to see the guy that has a trash contract being subject to, that's part of the operations administration of that public school. And I don't want to see the guy that has a trash contract or somebody supplying milk or, you know,
janitorial services or whatever else being subject to FOIA could you address that a little bit
sure i'm not exactly sure which language you're referring to representative bell
uh it would be near the end of i believe it's right at the top of page three go what i'm looking at is on line seven and eight and uh i was just reading back through it looking for any of those references and i caught that and maybe i may be looking at it in an exemption section but uh it appears to me that that does go back and require those folks to be subject to FOIA and that's my
concern okay so I think if you'll look with me on the main provision where it applies is going to be on page two line 21 if the contract relates to consultation evaluation information or any other purpose related to the administration or operation of a public school or school district is that going to
be in that's yeah i mean you're dealing with a purpose related to the operation administration i mean clearly providing trash service is part of the operation yeah um you know
this looks like as as as i've told you several times the transparency regarding the educational operations is in my opinion a very separate issue from transparency related to everybody that's that contributes to the operation of the school and i think you know what happens to the guy that comes to do um to wash the brick you know is that person now subject to foia um it would appear that this makes it quite clear that they are and that's that's my concern i think i think your bill
goes further than what i could be comfortable with and i i'll
just say quickly if i can turn it over to mr heller too that'd be great but basically if that work were being conducted by school district or ADE I don't think there's any question it would be subject to public disclosure and the part of the reason for that is not only because educational policies and procedures should be disclosed because the public has a right to know but the public also has a right to know how their money is being spent and so it to make sure that there are proper procedures followed
when a when a contract is bid out and the money is being spent appropriately and everything along those lines and so that's basically the rationale
Speaker 449
2:50:43
and I'll turn it over to Mr. Heller. Mr. Chairman, Chris Heller, lawyer with Friday Firm in Little Rock. Representative Bell, just as a practical matter, when the State Board of Education authorizes the Department of Education to operate a school district in academic distress, all of the contracts, such as the kind you're concerned about, remain with the school district. So all
of the services the transportation the teachers contracts all those things are contracts with the school district not the department of education so they wouldn't be covered by this
bill gentlemen we're going to have five minutes and we're closing so we need
to get on the roll i just want to make sure i understand you correctly so it's it's your testimony to the committee that nobody who is performing a service outside of the educational component would be affected by
Speaker 449
2:51:42
this bill that's my testimony because as as what i've seen so far
representing the little rock school district all of the contracts are going to remain in place and even even with representative cozart's bill which i know has been withdrawn but even under 1733 the requirement was going to be that people would remain employees of the school district so contracts would be with the school district. So the intent of this law and the intent of the law that allows takeover of schools in distress doesn't change the Department of Education into a contracting party. What this bill is
addressed to is the possibility that the department would want to consult with outside entities about the actual operation, the governance, the management of the school district and not routine service contracts. I know that's the intent of the bill, and I think given the current law concerning academic distress, I think it would be limited to that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. President Gossage,
Speaker 449
2:52:57
today? I'm not representing any party. I just agreed to review the bill for Representative Tucker and to testify about my experience probably helping to respond to hundreds of FOI requests for a number of school districts and public entities. I've probably answered more than 20 for Representative Walker alone.
Are there any other questions? I see no other questions. Is there anybody in the audience that really, really needs to speak for or against this bill? No, sir. Against? For? I have no one. Oh, you'd like to close for your bill? Appreciate it. Good vote. What is the will of the committee? Mr. Saban. Mr. Saban, you have a motion? I move to pass. I have a due pass for Rep. Saban. All those in favor, say aye.
Aye. All those opposed, say no. No. I believe the no's have it. I'm going to call that a no. I have two hands. We will do a roll call. I mean, I have nothing to do. Representative Letting. Aye.
Speaker 186
2:54:25
Representative Murdoch. Representative Murdoch Representative Deffenbaugh Representative Harris Representative Harris Representative Eubanks Representative Radliff Representative Gillum Representative Gillum Representative Walker Representative Bell
Representative Bell Representative Balz Representative Representative Douglas Representative Lowry Representative McElroy Representative Armstrong Representative Gossage Representative Saban Representative Hodges
Representative Gray Representative Lampkin Representative Lampkin I'm sorry your bill has
failed Thank you Thank you committee for being patient We will try not to do that I do owe you all dinner No, sir, we are not. We are done till
Tuesday morning, 10 o'clock, maybe 9 if we possibly can.
Agenda
HB1442
HB1443
HB1444
HB1895
SB226
SB894
SB366
HB1623
SB789
HB1913
HB1586
HB1552
HB1650
HB1651
HB1652
SB999
HB2007
HB1605
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Representative Julie Mayberry
Unverified
Lakeisha Shavers
Unverified
Speaker 25
Speaker 32
Speaker 39
Speaker 42
Speaker 46
Speaker 51
Speaker 58
Representative James Ratliff
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh
Unverified
Representative Nate Bell
Unverified
Speaker 141
Greg Crabtree
Unverified
Speaker 166
Speaker 169
Speaker 186
Speaker 193
Speaker 180
Speaker 198
Speaker 201
Senator Missy Irvin
Unverified
Speaker 212
Speaker 225
Speaker 229
Senator Jake Files
Unverified
Senator Alan Clark
Unverified
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Speaker 266
Speaker 267
Speaker 273
Speaker 278
Speaker 298
Speaker 304
Speaker 313
Speaker 196
Speaker 318
Speaker 322
Speaker 319
Representative Reginald Murdock
Unverified
Speaker 331
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Speaker 346
Speaker 353
Speaker 358
Senator Jim Hendren
Unverified
Speaker 367
Speaker 301
Speaker 380
Speaker 387
Speaker 342
Speaker 328
Representative Mary Broadaway
Unverified
Speaker 416
Jacob Fleuroy
Unverified
Representative Sue Scott
Unverified
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Representative Clarke Tucker
Unverified
Speaker 433
Speaker 426
Speaker 449
Speaker 453
Speaker 70