Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Insurance and Commerce

March 20, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (12)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1870 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…So we'll go to HB 1824, Representative McGee, are you here? HB 1870, Representative Sabin. HB 1809, Representative Douglas. HB…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1814 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1814. Is Representative Love here today? I know he wants to run…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1824 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…ants to run the bill, but he's not here now, So we'll go to HB 1824, Representative McGee, are you here? HB 1870, Representativ…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1894 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…870, Representative Sabin. HB 1809, Representative Douglas. HB 1894, Representative Vines.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1906 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Recognize to present HB1906. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1798 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…committee until 9.58. So the next, we're going to skip over House Bill 1798.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1809 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ntative McGee, are you here? HB 1870, Representative Sabin. HB 1809, Representative Douglas. HB 1894, Representative Vines.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB727 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…u all. At this time, without objection, we're going to take Senate Bill 727. Representative Bain, you're recognized to present Senate B…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB821 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB821”
Pre-2017 bill
SB822 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB822”
Pre-2017 bill
SB824 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB824”
Pre-2017 bill
SB826 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB826”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Recognize to present HB1906. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is
▶ Play
simply the amendments that were referred to verbally in the presentation last time have been engrossed into the bill. So there's really no new conversation to be had about it other than it's been engrossed in the bill, so I'd appreciate a good vote. Members, are
▶ Play
there any questions? Representative Balch, you recognize? Any questions, members? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Hammer, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. Representative Balch, you recognize for a motion? Do pass. We have a do pass motion. Any discussion? If not, all in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations,
▶ Play
Representative Hammer. You've passed your bill. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. I hope the rest of the day goes well for you all. At this time, without objection, we're going to take Senate Bill 727. Representative Bain, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 727.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. This bill was re-referred. We passed it out last week. When we went to engrossing the draft, there was a drafting concern that made one line to many to be nonsensical. And we work with many parties on this. We want to make sure this code is as clean as possible and litigation free. And I know with a bunch of attorneys in the room, that's always a laughing item. But we're trying to make sure it's clean and as straightforward as possible. And so with this, we're just trying to clean up a drafting error from last week with rerunning it through committee today.
▶ Play
Representative Bain has explained the bill. Members, are there any questions? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? If not, Representative Bain, are you closed for your
▶ Play
bill? I'm closed for my bill, and I move due
▶ Play
pass. We have a due pass motion on the table. Is there any discussion? If not, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Bain. You passed your bill. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Committee. Next, we're going to go to our agenda list. And as you can see, we're at that point of the session where people are in and out of lots of committees. So I appreciate everybody's flexibility. What I'm going to do is I'm going to basically walk down our list. If a person's not here, we'll come back to the top of the list if we have time. We're in session today at 10 o'clock, so as long as we have people that want to present bills and bills to be presented, we'll stay in committee until 9.58. So the next, we're going to skip over House Bill 1798. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1814. Is Representative Love here today? I know he wants to run the bill, but he's not here now, So we'll go to HB 1824, Representative McGee, are you here? HB 1870, Representative Sabin. HB 1809, Representative Douglas. HB 1894, Representative Vines. Is Representative Vines here? McGee's here? All right, without objection, we'll go back up to 1824. Representative McGee, you're recognized to present House Bill 1824. If you have somebody with you to present alongside of you, Representative McGee, just have the individual introduce himself and who he's with, and you'll both be recognized to present the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Committee. Good morning.
▶ Play
Speaker 22 3:45
I have with me Mr. David Roten, who's the Executive Vice President of the Arkansas Medical Society. Let me find my bill here. Which one are we doing, David? Here we go. This 1894 is a bill that I'm going to ask Mr. Rotten to explain a bit further, and I'm sure there will be plenty of testimony for and against this, but I think it's something that we need to look at and discuss. This came about primarily a couple of years ago when personally for myself what happened was we were required as physicians to participate as part of a network. We were required to participate in all of the products that were offered by an insurance company. And that puts providers in a position of potentially having to accept products that they may not want to participate in. The interesting thing is yesterday in public health, we heard a similar issue in the pharmacy field between pharmacists and pharmacy benefit managers. And this bill comes down to a fairness issue for providers. These arrangements that insurance companies have with providers in our contracts put individual physicians and their practices, not only physicians but other health care providers such as hospitals, in a difficult position. And I want to read to you just one statement or one fact that's mentioned in one of the insurance company's documents. And in their files it says this is from a major insurance carrier, and I don't want to identify who that was, but we can look that up. It says, when there's a dominant player in the insurance world, in the insurance market, as they're at – well, I've got the wrong thing. Excuse me. I'll find it here in a second, Mr. Chair. Here's where – here it was. The company has and retains the right to designate provider as a participating provider or a non-participating provider in a specific plan, any specific plan. The company reserves the right to introduce new plans during the course of an agreement. The provider agrees that the provider will provide covered services to members of such plans under applicable compensation arrangements determined by the company. Now, you know, I'm not a lawyer, but from what I understand, these agreements are tying agreements. These agreements are if you participate in one product, you have to participate in all. And in most cases, these type of arrangements are illegal. They're antitrust. The only thing is, is a number of years ago, insurance companies were exempt from all the antitrust legislation. So this bill is about fairness in the marketplace. It's about allowing physicians to choose or hospitals to choose which plans they would like to participate in. And with that, I'd entertain any questions or turn it over to Mr. Roten.
▶ Play
He may have something better to say. Again, my name is David Roten. I'm the executive vice president for the Arkansas Medical Society. This bill does one thing and one thing only, and it prohibits all product clauses in health insurance contracts with providers. This is both a fairness issue and a competition issue. We need competition among health insurance carriers in this state. All of you know that we have one dominant carrier in the state. It's very large. It exercises an enormous amount of market power, not only over providers, but it has the effect of making it very difficult for other health insurance carriers to come into the market and be successful. And one of the reasons for that are all products clauses. Basically, if you're a physician like Dr. McGee and you participate in one of their networks, they come out with a new product, and you may not like that product. That product might not be good for you as a provider. You have no choice but to accept that product, or you're out of the entire company's networks. And when one carrier dominates the market to the extent of having 70% of your practice tied up, you cannot afford not to accept that contract, regardless of how bad it may be. Negotiations means typically, you know, a good negotiation is when both parties walk away from the table with something that they can feel good about. The situation we have now in the state, the doctors and hospitals and other health care providers, you can't do that. It's one-sided, very one-sided, and this will just
▶ Play
help make it fair. Thank you. Would you agree that the best way to create a competitive market in the insurance industry is to restructure how we do health insurance in Arkansas so the process is not designed in such a way that only one company can survive rather than get into the mandating contracts one way or another between commercial enterprises? That would certainly
▶ Play
help, Mr. Chairman. So if in
▶ Play
Arkansas for the last umpteen decades we've had less insurance competition than we've had in the last two years by what I'm going to call a relatively significant margin, why would this be something that all of a sudden is needed today versus 15 years ago, eight years ago, or sometime in the past when we're clearly headed in the other direction with regard to the level of competition in our health insurance
▶ Play
market? This is actually something that has been needed for the last 10 or 15 years. We have hesitated to bring this issue to the legislature. You know, we don't like to get the legislature involved in these kinds of issues if we can avoid it. So we've tried in every other way that we can to get out of these kind of contracts. We've been unsuccessful. And so ultimately that's why we've
▶ Play
come to you this year. Would you agree that when you create a scenario where people are not required to deliver on a given contract, then the contract with all of the parties involved can't be delivered. And if the contract cannot be delivered, then what we're really talking about is passing on more costs ultimately to the health insurance and health system in Arkansas. In other words, costs are going to go up if
▶ Play
we do this. Does that make sense? I understand your question. I don't think I agree with you, though, because what will happen is right now the other carriers that are in our state, They don't have this market power. They don't have a level playing field because of the all-products clauses. If they take a new product to the market, providers are, it's easy to say no because it doesn't comprise much of your practice. Are there members that have questions?
▶ Play
Representative Ferguson, you're going to ask for a question. From the insurance side, for the contract that they're making, the provider sign, can the insurance company selectively choose the contracts they sign? I mean, do you understand what I'm saying? The insurance company has the option of choosing the contracts, but the provider does not. Is that right?
▶ Play
These are contracts that are issued by the carrier. I know,
▶ Play
but before they get to that point, the carrier is negotiating a contract with the business or whoever they're contracting the insurance with. You're talking about the employers that purchased
▶ Play
the coverage? Right, so they can choose.
▶ Play
They get to negotiate each contract is what you're saying, but then when it gets to the provider level, they don't. Is that right? That's kind of right.
▶ Play
Members, are there any other members with questions? Representative McGee has explained the bill. Is there anybody here to speak against the bill? Seeing none, is there anyone to speak for the bill? Seeing none, I want to take a two-minute recess. Without objection, committee, can I take a two-minute recess? Seeing none, we're going to take a two-minute recess. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 22 13:37
Thank you, Mr. Chair. After the discussion during the temporary recess, I think what I'd like to do with the committee's permission is pull this bill down and have some discussion with other parties involved. And if we might can get it back
▶ Play
on for Tuesday. Sir, first of all, I appreciate your tremendous graciousness, and I apologize to you for my behavior of doing this in this type of a fashion. I apologize that I was not wise enough or smart enough to speak with you before the meeting. So please accept my apologies. I'm very much appreciative of your graciousness. Yes, we will do exactly what you said in our next meeting. You will have the option to go at any point during the meeting you'd like, and thank you very much, sir. You're a true professional and a patriot. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1870. Is Representative Saban here? Representative Sabin, you're recognized to present 1870. We have an amendment for House Bill 1870, and Carol's getting that amendment loaded. So, members, when the amendment shows up, let us know that you can see it.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 15:09
Thank you.
▶ Play
Am I recognized, Mr. Chair? Would you like me to start? I'm waiting for the amendment to show up on the screens. It
▶ Play
is on the screens. You recognize, Representative Sabin. Thank you. You recognize to present your amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This amendment is just an attempt to accommodate all parties who've approached me with small technical changes that they were interested in. And in this case, the four parties are Central Arkansas Water, the PSC Public Service Commission, ADEQ, and CenterPoint Energy. And so this amendment represents the changes that they've requested in their entirety, and I'd appreciate a good vote on the amendment. Members, is there
▶ Play
any questions for Representative Saban on his amendment? Is anyone here to speak against the amendment, for the amendment? Representative Saban, are you closed for your amendment? Yes, I'm closed. What is the will of the committee? Representative Letting, you're recognized for a motion. I do pass. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Sabin. Your amendment is adopted, and you recognize to present House Bill
▶ Play
1870. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members of the committee, I bring this bill because I think we all agree that private property rights in this country and in this state are sacrosanct. And when we talk about the power of eminent domain, we usually talk about it in the context of allowing the government to have access to certain property only in cases in which there's a very obvious public good. And even in those cases, we're pretty strict about how we allow the government to exercise eminent domain when it comes to seizing private property. And certainly, beyond the government, I know we often allow utilities access to eminent domain as well. But even in those cases, again, we're talking about a very well-defined public good. The question in this case really has to do with allowing private companies that aren't necessarily providing a utility service to Arkansas residents and that obviously aren't an agency of the government, allowing those private companies to exercise eminent domain. And even more specifically, this bill is about oil pipelines, private oil companies putting pipelines not to Arkansas residents or businesses, but through Arkansas property in order to convey their product across state lines and to use it really for a commercial end. And we've had experience, obviously, in recent years with private pipelines like the Exxon Pegasus Pipeline that ruptured in Mayflower and caused damage to private property and caused health impacts to residents and others in Arkansas. And now what we have going on are actually two private oil pipelines being proposed and really already being constructed across Arkansas by companies that in other parts of the country have had incidents, including an oil spill in downtown Los Angeles that was well-publicized, and that caused a lot of damage again to private property and again exposed residents there to health risks. And so, again, I bring this bill to you because there are residents of Arkansas that you're going to hear from today in their testimony who are having their private property seized simply because a private company wants to convey oil across our state to sell it commercially. And so if you look through the bill, I'm going to summarize because I know we're short on time here, but it's very straightforward. There are basically four things that this bill does. It makes the oil companies liable for any damage done to a landowner's property during a survey. It ensures that the landowner receives notice when an oil company is considering seizing its property. And that landowners are also aware of their legal rights, because oftentimes this process is confusing. And landowners can be threatened, and they don't understand that they actually have rights when somebody's coming in and saying that they can exercise eminent domain to seize their property to put an oil pipeline through it. The third point is that it requires the oil company to demonstrate the necessity of the pipeline to the Arkansas Public Service Commission. That eminent domain is necessary to build the pipeline and that the public good of the pipeline justifies the use of eminent domain. And that's critical because if we're going to, again, allow eminent domain to be exercised, there needs to be a true public good that's being realized as a result of that. And then finally, fourth, it requires a permit from the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality, ensuring that the pipeline project is environmentally sound. And I think that's what we all want, again, in light of recent incidents here in Arkansas and elsewhere in the country. If we're going to allow eminent domain to be used in this way, if we're going to allow this oil to be conveyed through Arkansas, then we need to ensure that it's not going to cause any damage or health effects to our population. And so that's what the bill does. Again, I'd be glad to answer any questions, and I'm going to pause here because the people for whom I've brought this bill are here to testify on their own behalf.
▶ Play
So Representative Sabin, this process is already regulated today and your bill proposes adding two new layers of regulation, ADEQ and the PSC. So are those groups coming to you and asking to regulate this because of problems they've uncovered? I was not approached by the Public
▶ Play
Service Commission or the Department of Environmental Quality. I was approached by Arkansas residents, citizens, voters, the people we represent. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Lowry, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. You talk about the different requirements that would be put on your notification. Are you implying that there is not a required notification at this point? Well,
▶ Play
this isn't what I would call an enhanced notification. It's a notification that allows citizens to understand their rights under the law. Okay. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? I guess
▶ Play
so. You're recognized for a follow-up.
▶ Play
Okay. So the implication that was left with me is that currently we don't have these protections of notification, But you've just now said that actually this is an enhanced notification, correct? Well, that's correct,
▶ Play
and again, I think that when we hear from some of the citizens for whom this is a personal issue and an issue that affects their own private property rights, perhaps there will be some understanding of why our current notification procedures possibly are inadequate.
▶ Play
Okay, okay, I'll look forward to hearing that. Thank you. You bet. Representative Farrar,
▶ Play
you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. So I'm reading your amendment, and it exempts natural gas pipeline? Correct. Why are you exempting natural gas pipeline instead of in place of oil? Well, basically for two
▶ Play
reasons. One is that I wanted to keep this bill pretty targeted. I know there are other eminent domain bills that have been brought this session by other members of the legislature. it made sense in my mind to focus on the issue that I was trying to address on behalf of the citizens who approached me. Number two, we are obviously experienced a particular problem with this form of energy through oil. And we've, again, seen what happened in Mayflower, we've seen what happened in other cities and states around the country. There's a particular issue with pipelines that convey oil. And so I'm less concerned with natural gas than I am with oil in this particular case. Can I follow up? I can ask for a follow up.
▶ Play
So you don't think, I guess, in your opinion that natural gas is not as dangerous as oil?
▶ Play
I'm just not talking about natural gas in this particular legislation. It wasn't a matter of whether I'm making a value judgment necessarily. It just, this is a targeted bill for a particular issue that we've actually experienced in Arkansas within the last couple of years. Just the oil company,
▶ Play
just for the oil. Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you. Representative Sabin, in Fayetteville and in other places around the state, we have a lot of very low-income people, and being able to afford energy in all its forms, oil, gasoline for the automobiles, and all these things, the price of those products is very, very, very important when you have a very low budget. And in my zeal to ensure that all Arkansans can afford the basics of life, I get really, really concerned when we propose things that could raise their prices because if you and I can't drive our vehicle because we can't afford to, that's less likely to be the case. But a lot of these folks are really struggling to pay for gasoline and other products. What impact does this have on the cost of energy in Arkansas?
▶ Play
Well, let's talk about that for a second because one of the things that you and I have in common, Representative Collins, is that we're both free market capitalists. And I think if you're going to be a free market capitalist, you have to understand that price is set by the market, that there's supply and demand, and it's not the government's job to ensure the price of a product that's sold by a private company. And it's certainly not the government's job to get in the middle or give a private company special rights through eminent domain to make their product somehow cheaper or to help them commercialize their product better. That's certainly not, that to me seems like big government. That sounds like a socialized economy. That sounds like a fascist economy where the government conspires with private companies to help them convey their product to the consumer. So when it comes to prices, I think prices ought to be set by the free market. Thank
▶ Play
you, Representative Lowry. You're recognized for a question. Yes, thank you, Chairman.
▶ Play
I want to follow up on that line of commentary. It's also, would you agree that it's also not the government's place to put extra regulatory burdens in the place of being able to deliver a product
▶ Play
that also fits a public good? Well, I think the hardest thing that we do here at the legislature is figure out how we do regulation. Because you can't have no regulation. Because, I mean, ultimately, those of us here, we're here to represent the citizens of Arkansas. And we're here to represent the people who vote for us. And I think we all understand that there's certain things that the government does that involve some degree of regulation. And we try to minimize that as much as we can so we don't interfere with the free market. And the question is just the balance. And I think that it's an ongoing process for us to gauge that balance and to respond to situations as they occur. In this case, we're responding to a real situation that's affecting real people whose property rights are being affected. And so it's going to be up to you on this committee as to what you feel the proper degree of regulation is. But we shouldn't regulate too much, but we can't not regulate at the same time. So that'll be your decision. Thank you. Any
▶ Play
other questions from the committee? Representative Frey, are you organized for
▶ Play
a question? On your oil, I'm sorry, thank you. On your oil pipelines, is there a regulation on size of oil pipeline that
▶ Play
you're going to? We didn't regulate the size of the pipeline in this bill. I know that there's a small place where it's mentioned, but we're not adding any additional regulation in that respect. And I want to, this
▶ Play
is probably going to sound, another question, probably going to sound a little silly. If you regulate pipeline, and we're starting to drill oil in southern Arkansas, and they have to have pipes under the ground to the tanks, are we covering that?
▶ Play
Well, I mean, so we've been drilling oil, obviously, in south Arkansas for over 100 years now. This is about how those companies get the right to the property that they would be running the pipelines under. I mean, if they're running pipes to their own tanks, chances are they own the property. If they don't own the property, then they can approach any landowner just like they could approach you or me. The question is whether or not they can exercise the same right the government has to use eminent domain to just about seize land for less than the value that they could get on the private market. And the question is whether you put yourself in the position of the company or put yourself in the position of the landowner. I mean, if it's your land, wherever the pipe is going, I think you want to get fair value for it and you want to have the right to whether or not you give them that land to do that with and that it shouldn't just be seized from you, and it certainly shouldn't be seized from you using the government to do that. That's big government. Representative Ball,
▶ Play
is she recognized for a question? Representative Saban from what I'm kind of hearing and I actually have a pipeline that runs across our farm I've got concerns would you be interested in pulling this and put it in interim study
▶ Play
well what I'd like to do is have a hearing on the bill right now I don't understand the question because you could say that about any bill that we present in the legislature
▶ Play
members are there any more questions If not, we've got a lot of people to speak for and against the bill, so I'd like to move that we limit debate to 10 minutes per side. All in favor? Any opposed? Thank you very much. We'll limit debate to 10 minutes per side. So is there anybody that would like to speak against the bill? If not, Allison, and I apologize, I only have one name for that person. Allison, you are recognized to speak for the bill. and you're the first speaker of several, and there's 10 minutes total for the group. I'm going to read the other names, and if the individuals, sometimes these folks are in groups, want to pick and choose who goes next, et cetera, I'm very open to that. The next three in line are Jason Hall, Alan Hooks, and Kurt England. Allison, if you would state your name and who you're with, you'll recognize to
▶ Play
speak for the bill. Hi, my name is Allison Millsaps, and I'm actually here on behalf of my mother-in-law, Clara Dotson. She had to work today, which she's done for the last 40 years, for a piece of property that she and her husband bought back in the 1970s. They bought it, they cleared it, they built a house, they built a farm, they raised cattle and sons on it, and her husband died back in the 1990s, And she kept the property because, like a lot of Arkansans, she doesn't have a big 401k or a 10-year plan or any kind of retirement. She's put all of her life into this property. And she currently has three energy easements on it. She has an HVAC line that goes this way, a distribution line that goes this way, and then a natural gas line that goes this way. And then in October of 2013, she got a knock on the door from a gentleman from an oil pipeline company. And they said that they wanted to survey, and she thought about it and decided that she didn't want to do it based on the easements that she already had on the property and worry about the future property value. And they immediately condemned the property for three months. They told her, if you won't give it to us, we'll just go ahead and take it. It was a horrible experience. I don't know if anybody here has ever been through condemnation before, but you worry all the time. It's hard to sleep. It's expensive. It's very expensive for landowners. So it was just this really terrible experience, and Warwick's bill, one of the things that it does is the notification, that was a huge issue for us. We were left in the dark. We didn't know what was going on. Nobody would talk to us. We didn't know where on the property the land was going to be, so things that we had planned to do for years we couldn't do. We didn't know if it was going to be above ground or underground. We just didn't know anything, and they were not open with us at all. So it was an incredibly frustrating and horrifying experience. So just the notification alone in Warwick's bill would give peace of mind to so many people. I work with a group that deals with eminent domain. It deals with people who are at risk for eminent domain. And I can't tell you, I've talked to hundreds of people over the last year in the state of Arkansas, and the system that we have regarding eminent domain is broken. It's not working. work talked about balance we're out of balance people feel powerless and and you have this opportunity and you've done some really good eminent domain bills you have this opportunity to help protect us and I think that um I think that we you talked about raising the land raising prices a little bit Mr. Chairman and right now part of the reason those prices are so low is because there's a discount on development caused by eminent domain. So people are paying those prices. It's just not always the people at the end. I'm lost. I'm sorry. It's my first time. But thank you very much for hearing me.
▶ Play
Thank you very much. Representative Lowry, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for your testimony. One of the things that you pointed out was that it was very difficult in your mother-in-law's case to know where to go for help? Absolutely. Representative Saban's bill adds several more layers of regulatory authority, so there's going to be more entities. And, you know, unfortunately, the more government entities are involved, the more finger-pointing can happen. It's not our job. Go to them. Go see them. That's true. So would that not? No.
▶ Play
Actually, I think it would be a wonderful thing. And just where he puts in the bill that people would be given the statutes when the people come, That is huge, because we didn't know even which statutes to go to. And I love lawyers. I have a lot of lawyer friends. But it's expensive to go to law. I mean, it can be a little expensive, and it's hard to know what's going on. I think having the Arkansas Public Service Commission involved would be awesome. And requiring the certificate of need, that too, I mean, I think that's good. And as far as the EIS goes, of course we should be having an EIS. I mean, these are big pipelines that they want to put through. We can't protect ourselves. The landowners, we can't protect ourselves. You can help protect us. And I think an environmental impact study and requiring that these companies go through a process to determine need, that's a really good thing. That's
▶ Play
a good thing. Well, again, a follow-up, Mr. Chair. The essence of my question is that now, and whether you feel like it's deficient or not, at least the regulatory authority is pretty centralized. It's pretty focused. You should know where to go. if you add several layers, does that not complicate the process? I wouldn't think so. I
▶ Play
mean, no more than it is right now. I really don't. I mean, this is honestly, I really don't think so. And if you're given instructions when they come to you of where you need to go to, that solves the problem right there. Because right now, you don't get absolutely nothing. You get a knock on the door, and if you're lucky, maybe a month later, you'll get a letter saying, we want to do a survey. But there are no resources provided to landowners. All right. Thank you
▶ Play
very much. Thank you very much, Allison, for your testimony. The next person, well, first, does anyone speak against the bill? Seeing none, the next person to speak for the bill is Mr. Jason Hall, and there are almost five minutes remaining. Mr. Hall, if you state your name and who you're with, you're recognized to
▶ Play
speak for the bill. My name is Jason Hall. I'm a landowner. I work at Arkansas Nuclear One. I do probabilistic risk assessment. This pipeline is going through my land, and I did a quantitative risk assessment to determine the fatality risk due to this pipeline. In the last 10 years or so, there's been five deaths from pipeline based on the U.S. Department of Transportation Pipeline Hazard and Material Safety Administration. and currently at home I don't have any risk but adding this pipeline will increase my risk the diamond pipeline is going to be either a 20 or 30 inch crude oil pipeline 1440 PSIG it'll be 136 feet from my house and also 140 feet near a transformer high voltage transformer adding any risk to my family and my house is unacceptable especially when it's significant. I evaluated this by a probabilistic risk assessment, and the easement that they gave me showed no mention of safety at all. I had no assurance that my safety was any way being looked at. The Keystone Pipeline included a frequency analysis, but the Diamond pipeline does not have any analysis at all. FISA has shown that there's not a pre-construction safety analysis or environmental study for this project. Arkansas has no law governing oil pipeline sitting. A limit of a quantitative value of one e to the minus six per year risk increase is used in other regulatory areas. In California, the protocol school site pipeline risk analysis requires a quantitative pipeline risk analysis with the value of one e to the minus six per year. If it's greater than that value, then they'll do a mitigation measure to lower the value. If it's less than one in a million or one e to the minus six per year, then there is no safety significance. That value is used in industry facilities with hazardous chemicals in the United Kingdom and the Netherlands. Target cancer risk is also based on this value. The NRC uses this value to determine risk increase as well. So how does this compare to the 1e the minus 6? I've determined it's a little bit higher than that. It's 4e the minus 6 for a 30-inch pipeline and 3e the minus 6 for a 20-inch pipeline. That's based on the values from Plains pipelines as agreed on. From there you would determine your pool size based on how many barrels from the release. There's up to a million gallons can be released through the mountainous Arkansas hills which would cause the head to drain down even with successful isolation that they're proposing. The occupancy of the area is also a consideration. The rupture area could affect the transformer. The transformer could be a significant source of ignition. Nobody's looking at any of this stuff. Then you can have a fire or explosion. What could be done from this change in risk? Risk insights could provide the design of this pipeline. Nobody has looked at this. The location from the home could be looked at. Code of Federal Regulation 49, 195.210 pipeline location, this law is not being followed. Where a pipeline right-of-way must be selected. I just want to let you
▶ Play
know we're getting down to the last minute of the four side.
▶ Play
The pipeline right-of-way must be as far as practical. And they only put in these isolation valves in high consequential areas. Is my house in a rural area not high consequential? If it affects anybody, it could. And they're providing compensation. Is this compensation for safety? That's one of my questions that I have. Sir, are you finished with
▶ Play
your comments, or are you still going, sir?
▶ Play
Well, I'd like to also 49 CFR 195.452, if there's a potential ignition or proximity. We just crossed the 10-minute mark, so if you'd please wrap
▶ Play
up. And then if there are any questions, I will allow questions for this speaker.
▶ Play
I'm going to wrap it up. Near an ignition or proximity of a power source, there's supposed to be isolation valves near the pipeline, on the pipeline, and nobody
▶ Play
has shown that this has been done. Thank you,
▶ Play
sir. Representative Hodges, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You seem to be kind of saying that these pipelines are dangerous to the point of life and death. You mentioned there were five deaths in the last ten years. Was that in Arkansas or nationally? That was nationally. Okay. A quick follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. Thank you. A quick Google search here. The National Weather Service said that there was 26 deaths in 2014 from lightning. So I guess my question would be, do you really think, all things considered, that the safety issue is really
▶ Play
a legitimate one in this case? Well, this is a significant issue. If you compare it against lightning, is that nationally? It requires the pipeline to rupture first, then ignite. So given that that still can't occur, how is it not insignificant?
▶ Play
And it can't happen. It could be zero deaths. Sir, I appreciate you coming, and I also appreciate the database focus. As you were speaking, one of the things I was thinking to myself is, you know, we need to put in Common Core being able to convert 1 to the E-6 into a decimal, and I'm going to give it a shot, and then if you could tell me if I got it right, .0000001. Did I do that right? Yes. Thank you very much. Is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Saban, you recognize the close for your
▶ Play
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sure, I'll make this brief. One point I'd like to make is that this bill that I brought is modeled after a statute that exists in Georgia, which is a very conservative state like ours. And so this is something obviously the Georgians felt like was reasonable and that kind of struck that balance that we're trying to strike between regulation and what we're trying to do for the free market. Also, I just want to say, I don't take any great pleasure in trying to add more regulation. We, I think everybody who works with me in the lobbying community, in the citizens groups, and here in the legislature knows that I'm willing to kind of hear all sides and take all amendments. And the amendment that we adopted here earlier was a reflection of all of the comment and input that I got from everyone who was willing to contribute it. And I even asked for that from the oil companies, and I didn't get any input from them. But I think it's important to remember that the citizens that you heard from and the citizens that you didn't hear from, they don't have lobbyists. We're their lobbyists. And the reason why I decided to bring this bill, even in spite of the long odds of it passing, mainly was because this was a real problem. And these were real people. And I think it's really important to remember who we're here to represent and that private property rights mean something and that it's not the government's job to take sides between private companies and private landowners. And so with that, I do appreciate the time and the consideration, Mr. Chair, and I appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you very much, Representative Sabin. Representative Sabin has closed for his bill. What is the will of the committee? Representative, letting you recognize for a motion. Do pass. We have a do pass motion on the table. Is there any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. All opposed? Nay. The nays have it. I'm sorry, Representative Sabin, your bill has not passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. Thank you very much, Representative Sabin. Representative Vines, you're recognized to present House Bill 1894. I understand we have an amendment. We're going to get that loaded on the machines. if you want to start talking about the amendment you're recognized to present the amendment if you've got some at the end of the table to present the bill with you just have that individual introduce himself and who he's with and he's recognized and produced the bill with you as well Very well, thank you Mr. Chair
▶ Play
and you are correct, this is House Bill 1894, there is an amendment that adds some language that was requested I believe by the insurance department I think they will come speak to that as we get into the merits of the bill, but I would appreciate a motion. I guess I can make a motion to adopt the amendment to this bill. Is that a motion, Representative
▶ Play
Vines? Absolutely. We'll recognize it at the proper time. Is there anyone here to speak against the motion for the motion? Representative Vines, you recognize to make your motion. I do adopt. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? The amendment is adopted. Representative Vines, you recognize and
▶ Play
present the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. Again, thank you for your indulgence. This is House Bill 1894. It's an act to regulate insurers that offer vision care plans and establish the Vision Care Plan Act of 2015. I have with me and seated with me today is Dr. Creighton Simmons. He is an optometrist in my area in Hot Springs, and I would yield the microphone with the chairman's permission to allow him
▶ Play
to speak about the merits of the bill. Yes, sir. Just
▶ Play
Speaker 108 46:49
introduce yourself and who you're with, and you'll recognize to present the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Creighton Simmons, optometrist from Hot Springs, and I'm with the Arkansas Optometric Association. The bill, well, currently, a little background, The way the system works in Arkansas is vision care providers contractually agree with insurance companies, health care companies, and vision care plans to provide eye care and, in some case, materials to their patients. And we get reimbursed for eye exams and some materials, which is negotiated between the provider and the carrier. which we're not addressing that. What our bill does is prohibits the practice of vision care plans and carriers from requiring vision care providers to give discounts on materials or services that they don't cover or reimburse for. It also prohibits carriers from requiring providers to accept discount vision vision care plans in order to credential for their health networks. So if there's a vision plan that they would not deem tolerable, they may still have to accept it in order to continue to be on the health care panel. And the third part is to allow the vision care providers to have choice in their use of optical labs, which are provide materials, lenses, glasses to our patients and to allow us to choose who to do the lab work for us. And currently that would not add any cost to the consumer because we are reimbursed from the carrier for the lab materials also, and we contract with the labs to do that. So there would be no cost passed on to the consumer. It would be negotiated between the provider and the lab. So the fourth part would be to allow the insurance commissioner to regulate the bill. And I'd be glad to answer any questions. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Vines has explained the bill. Are there any questions from members? Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Excuse me. I have a question. Sorry. Representative Letting, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Is Commissioner Kerr to give an
▶ Play
opinion on this bill? Is he here? Commissioner Kerr, if you'd introduce yourself and who you're with. If you'd introduce yourself and who you're with, you'll be recognized and answer Representative Letting's
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Alan Kerr, Arkansas State Insurance Commissioner. I have with me Booth Rand, who is one of our staff attorneys.
▶ Play
Sir, if you'd introduce yourself and who you're with. Mr. Chairman, my name is Booth Rand. I'm a managing attorney with the Arkansas Insurance Department. You're recognized to answer the question. I didn't get the question. What was the question? Our commissioner's position on the bill. Our request to the sponsor was in the page 3 in one of the prohibited practices that was proposed that we determine what a rate was in terms of a provider reimbursement rate as being reasonable or nominal. As the committee knows, we do not regulate provider reimbursement rate fees or establish those fees. We regulate the premium rates, and we determine and regulate the policy benefits. And so we try to stay out of the insurance company and providers' establishment of what those fees are. And so the proposed language put us in the middle of referring what is reasonable or what is nominal, and I suggested that they remove that, and I think they have. Their concern, I think, is over the discounts that the health plans make them take for non-covered services. And so we wanted to be kept out of a broader regulatory authority over regulating whether somebody's vision service fee or merchandise was X amount so that I don't have to actually eventually or effectively establish all these vision services fees. So I'm going to ask
▶ Play
a similar question. So it sounds like there were some elements of the bill that you had concerns about. We're going to confirm at the close whether those were taken out. But beyond that and more broadly speaking, are you for, against, or neutral on the bill? Well, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman, as long as the corrections were made and we just now got a copy of the amendment, we are neutral on the bill
▶ Play
Speaker 118 51:50
thank you Commissioner Kerr any other questions for
▶ Play
Commissioner Kerr seeing none excuse me Representative Jett you're recognized for a question let's have a motion at the proper time Mr. Chairman thank you Representative Vines you're recognized close for your
▶ Play
bill just a couple of points in closing as I sit here and listen to these gentlemen speak this pulls down to fairness for small business and these guys all are in our communities all over Arkansas these are small business men and women other professions other specialties have passed similar laws I think dentistry passed one similar to this in 2011 session and just to close vision plans are unregulated presently in Arkansas and these professionals shouldn't be required to give discounts that they aren't reimbursed or compensated or covered for and that's what the essence of this bill and this act would hopefully this act would be so with that I'd appreciate a positive vote Thank you very much Representative Vines is closed for the bill Representative Chet you're recognized to make your motion Thank
▶ Play
you Mr. Chairman a motion do pass We have a do pass motion is there any discussion seeing none all in favor Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Vines. You passed your bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and committee. Next, we're going to, without objection, drop to SB 821, Representative Davis. You recognize, present Senate Bill 821. And what we're going to do, members, is there's a package of bills that have come from the EBD Task Force on Teachers Insurance. and Representative Davis has been gracious enough to carry these bills. They're mostly right in a row you can see on your agenda, but we're going to cover those now, and then we'll go back up and give the people in between Representative Vines and SB 821 a chance to present their bills as well. So Representative Davis, you recognize, present
▶ Play
Senate Bill 821. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. These are all, like Chairman said, These are all from the Teacher-State Employee Insurance Task Force. Mostly for the whole package, we're looking at some technical cleanup language. I'll give you some talking points, and then if you have any specific questions, Mr. Bob Alexander from EBD is here to answer those. On Senate Bill 821, this limits HSA requirement to active employees and thereby excludes retirees from the requirement. It only requires employees that are eligible under federal law to have an HSA, to establish an HSA under state law. What's it? Yeah, an employee on Medicare is not eligible for the HSC. It changes a plan year to 2015 from 2014, which was a typo in the original bill, and it defines active employee. Thank
▶ Play
you very much, Representative Davis. These are basically technical corrections with the exception of the HSA, which moves it from a requirement to more permissive because the cost to the insurance fund was a fixed cost on every person, whether or not they actually contributed anything. And so this makes that more permissive, which will allow anybody to take advantage of an HSA if they'd like, but also not cost the plan money if a person doesn't want to put anything in there. Is that correct? I
▶ Play
think that's correct, but I think a lot of what you're referring to is in another bill. This one actually just aligns the state
▶ Play
requirement on HSAs with the federal law. Thank you for clarifying that for me. Members, are there any other questions for Representative Davis? Seeing none, is there anyone to speak against the bill, for the bill? Seeing none, I move, excuse me, Representative Davis, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. I make a motion do pass on Senate Bill 821. Any discussion? All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Davis. You've passed Senate Bill 821, and you're now recognized to present Senate Bill 822. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you,
▶ Play
Committee. Senate Bill 822 defines dependents such that it matches other statutory definitions. Representative Davis has explained the bill. Are
▶ Play
there any questions? Seeing none, is there anyone to speak against the bill, for the bill? Seeing none, Representative Davis, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. I move do pass on Senate Bill 822. Any discussion? All in favor? Any opposed? The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Davis. You've passed Senate Bill 822, and you're recognized to present Senate Bill 826. Thank you,
▶ Play
committee. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senate Bill 826 changes the election period to 30 days from 31 days to match federal law on election period for qualifying events. It eliminates the requirement for a retiree to submit a written waiver when declining coverage and the requirement that the retirees submit a letter of credible coverage. The waiver is an unnecessary administrative requirement. Letters of credible coverage are no longer required to be provided by employers when someone terminates coverage. It removes some of the changes made to the law by Act 331 of 2011 that were inconsistent with other provisions. It requires retirees to be covered on their last day of active employment, not merely eligible for coverage. The eligibility-only requirement was in Act 331, and we go back to the old law that required coverage. This also reinstates the requirement that if a retiree declines coverage, the retiree may make a one-time election to join the plan if the retiree declined coverage due to the other group health insurance coverage. Act 331 changed this to any other coverage, not just group coverage. I'd be happy to take any questions. Seeing no questions from
▶ Play
members, is there anyone who would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Davis, you recognize closed for your bill. Closed, thank you. I move do pass on Senate Bill 826. All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Davis. you've passed Senate Bill 826, and without objection, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 824. All right.
▶ Play
Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senate Bill 824 clarifies the contribution process for state agencies to fund their health insurance contributions to EBD. These changes match current procedures. Any questions
▶ Play
from members? Seeing none. Mr. Chairman? Yes. Also,
▶ Play
I want to let the committee know it also extends the task force. Thank you, Representative Davis.
▶ Play
One more year. I see no questions from members. Is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill for the bill? If not, Representative Davis, are you closed for the bill? Closed for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I move do pass on Senate Bill 824. Any discussion? All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Davis. You passed Senate Bill 824. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Love, you're recognized to present HB 1814 without objection. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. I'm here to present House Bill H, excuse me, 1814. I've been in state agencies with another bill, so I'm kind of discombobulated right now. Okay, as of right now, committee, what happens is that we're the only state in the nation where you could take up a private contract and bring criminal intent or prosecute a criminal conviction against a private contract. If you look in the Constitution at Article 2, Section 16, this bill right here, or the statute that we have in code, is in direct violation of Article 2, Section 16. Article 2, Section 16 says this in the Constitution. No person shall be imprisoned for a debt and a civil action. Now, I received a couple of questions in regards to this bill. Number one, this bill does not strike any of the civil remedies that landlords have in regards to removing tenants from their property. All this does is it strikes the criminal part of that in regards to the landlord-tenant contract. So with that, committee, I will ask you for a good vote in regards to this bill because, as I said, we are the only state in the nation that does this, and we need to go ahead and bring our laws in line with what we have in our Constitution.
▶ Play
And with that, I'll take any questions. Thank you, Representative Love, and just for the committee members, I just want to share with you how I'm looking to plan the next 20 minutes that we've got here. Obviously, this bill has got some controversy associated with it. We've got people that have signed up to speak for and against the bill, and there's one more bill that I want to get to. So I want to end on this bill at five minutes till 10, if it's at all possible. So just be sensitive to the time as we're asking our questions and know that there are people to speak for and against, and obviously Representative Lowell will have a chance to close for the bill. So are there questions from committee members? Representative Lowell, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. In looking at the bill and looking at everything that's been stricken, your representation seems to be that the criminal penalty is only tied to the contract, but isn't it true that this is about a refusal to vacate a property when
▶ Play
properly notified? Yes, Mr. Lowell, but here's the thing. This doesn't mess with any of the other code in regards to the civil remedies that landlords have to remove tenants. This is just basically saying that no one can be put in jail for a debt. And so it's too, I mean, the code deals with both a civil remedy and a criminal remedy. All this does is strike the criminal piece associated with it. So landlords still have a civil remedy in regards to recouping all the expenditures or all the loss of rent. So this just deals, and I work with the Bureau on this, and this is how they said that if I wanted to have this stricken, this is what we have to do. But this does not affect any part of the other part of the code in regards to what civil actions can be taken against tenants
▶ Play
to remove them from a property. And follow-up, please, Mr. Chair. And I understand that, that it does not negate what is there, but we are talking about more than just using criminal statute to enforce a contract. We're talking about a situation where someone could be deemed to be a squatter and making that property unavailable for the owner of that property to be able to use it to someone who would actually enter into a
▶ Play
contract that they would keep, right? No, no. No, it just deals with the imprisonment. This doesn't deal with the other part of the code still deals with whatever civil remedies that they can take against the tenant to get them evicted. So this does not, this does, I mean, it's two different parts of the code. This does not just deal with, I mean, this is just dealing with that basic instance. It's not dealing with, it's not messing with any other part of the code. Okay, thank you. Are there
▶ Play
any other questions? Representative Hodges, you recognize for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I admit, I guess, on the front end, I'm not very well-versed in the law around this, but I guess in my head I'm just thinking, you know, if you have a tenant who's refusing to leave, you know, I'm thinking maybe if you say, you know, I'll call the sheriff to have them come, you know, take you out if you don't leave or whatever. Are we taking away the enforcement mechanism, say, to call law enforcement to
▶ Play
have them come remove you? No, I would say this. I would say, and this is what I'm going to compare it to. This law would be like you owing a credit card and not paying it, and then the credit card saying that they can issue a warrant for your arrest, and you can serve time for a credit card debt. That's basically all it is. It's not being able to put somebody in jail for a civil contract. And I'm telling you, when this was brought to me and after I looked at the Constitution, I'm saying, well, this law is unconstitutional. It is basically unconstitutional. A lot of people don't like to enforce it because it's unconstitutional. What we need to do is just remove it from the book so that our laws will be in congruence with our Constitution. That's basically all it is. And so if I would just liken it to that, I mean, and that's basically what it is. It's in a civil contract, we can't put people in jail. I mean, seriously, if people that owe debts on their credit cards, if a credit card company was able to put everybody in jail that owed a debt on their credit card, where would we be? It's the same thing.
▶ Play
Representative Letting, you recognize for a question
▶ Play
Representative Love, basically what you're saying is that today we are the only state in the country
▶ Play
that has a modern day debtor's prison Well, I wasn't going to say that, Representative, but yes we are the only state in the nation that actually has longer books like
▶ Play
this Representative Lowry, you recognize for a question Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman Representative Love, you
▶ Play
used the example that this is akin to a credit card. I'd have to differ with that because at some point the credit card company can cut off the use of the credit card. In this case, we're not cutting off the use of the debtor or the squatter from staying there. The question Representative Hodges brings up, it's my understanding that the Sheriff's Department would not be able to come and evict based on just a civil, more than often they would say, well, that's a civil issue. Is it not true that if you don't have this criminal statute there, then you cannot use the local sheriff to evict someone and then be able to make that property available for the person
▶ Play
who paid for the property? No, there's an other part of the code that deals with that. You have a civil remedy to evict somebody, Representative Lowry. It is, it is, it is, it's not, it's not striking that part of the code. There is a civil remedy. I mean, now, we may disagree, but I'm telling you, working with the Bureau, and I'm trusting what the Bureau says, is that this does not, this does not strike any part of that code in regards to the civil remedy that landlords have to remove tenants. This is just dealing with the fact that there cannot be, for this civil contract, the punishment cannot be jail time. Representative Farrar, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You keep going back
▶ Play
to the civil eviction. How are you going to evict someone from a property that don't pay the rent? There's a civil remedy. Now, I'm not, now, wait a minute. You have to arrest them to get them out. You have to. You can't force them to get out of your house if they don't pay the rent. You have to arrest them
▶ Play
to get them out. You're taking that away. That's the only way you get them out of your home. No. Okay. I mean, we may just disagree, but according to the Bureau, which I'm going to go back to, the Bureau has stated the only way, and this is just for in jail, for people to be sentenced to jail, Because, as you know, there's up to 90 days that they can be sentenced to jail. The only way that we can strike that is to strike this language. The civil penalty, Representative Farrar, is still there. And so you can take civil actions. But in order to, as I said, the case of the credit card or car payment not being done, basically it's the same thing. It's a civil contract, and it's contrary to what's in our Constitution. Now, if we don't want to – if we don't want to live up to what we have in the Constitution, then, you know –
▶ Play
Well, I don't – follow up. And I – I'm going to go back to what Lowry – Representative Lowry was saying. If somebody doesn't pay the car payment, you take the car. The only way to get them out of your home is you have to have them arrested because I've had to do this. You've had to have them arrested to get them out of your house. If they won't pay, you can't take your house out from under them. But you can't a car. But to me, this is what this is doing. You're taking my way of getting this person out of my property because they're squatting property.
▶ Play
But that's a little different. Can I ask you a question, Representative Farrar? Representative Love, you'd answer his question. And
▶ Play
if you're going to have any people speaking for this, we've got people that are on the list. We're going to burn off that time, and so it's going to be even shorter than it was before. So I'd answer Representative Farrar's question, then I'd love to get the people that want to speak for your bill a chance to speak. Sure. All right. That's a good answer. So what we'll do is we'll go to the for and against. And so what I'd like to move is that we've got four minutes per side. I'd like to move four minutes per side for the for and against. All in favor? Any opposed? Okay. We'll have four minutes per side for for and against. Julie Mullinex, you're recognized to speak against the bill. Please announce your name and who you're with, and
▶ Play
Speaker 150 1:11:29
you're recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Julie Mullinex. I represent the Arkansas Realtors Association. Speaking for the realtors against this bill, this municipal eviction procedure presents a cost-efficient eviction procedure. It's been upheld in the courts several times over the last quarter century. There was a recent Pulaski County Circuit Court decision that had one small portion of it that was unconstitutional that required tenants to make a deposit with the court. We have another bill that we have introduced this section to repeal that provision in this whole statute versus in this bill a repeal of the whole municipal eviction statute. We oppose this bill. We did speak with Representative Love and ask him if we could work together to not repeal the whole municipal eviction statute, but we didn't come to an agreement on that. So we have to oppose this bill and ask for you to
▶ Play
vote against it. Thank you very much, Julie Mullinex. And now, is there any questions for Ms. Mullinex? Okay, so what we're going to do is we're going to go to the recognized Dustin Duke to speak for the bill. Again, we've got a short period of time, four minutes on the four side. So Dustin Duke, Stacey Fletcher, and Lynn Foster, if you'd like to have a different order and you all agree, that's fine. Otherwise, Dustin Duke is the first to sign up, and Dustin, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I'm going to defer to the next speaker for the bill. Okay, that would be, is that Lynn Foster? Is that who's coming to the
▶ Play
table? You'll recognize Lynn Foster to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. In 2012, my name is Lynn Foster, and in 2012 I was the vice chair of the Landlord Tenant Study Commission referred to on Wednesday. As a result of that, I did some extensive research on the failure to vacate statute. I was very interested about it, how it worked. what it was exactly, and wrote an article about it. I urge you to vote due pass on this bill. In all other states, as Representative Love has stated, if a tenant breaches the lease and fails to pay the rent but remains on the premises, a landlord has to file a civil eviction to evict the tenant, civil action. And as some of you have pointed out, if the tenant fails completely to leave, Under those statutes in all states, yes, a sheriff will eventually arrest the tenant and remove their possessions. This statute has no connection to our civil statute. In Arkansas, we are the only state, if a tenant fails to pay the rent but remains on the premise, our criminal statute allows a landlord to file an affidavit with a prosecutor who represents a state. Tenants may be jailed prior to an arraignment under this criminal statute. And if, as Ms. Mullinex stated, if a tenant doesn't put down a deposit, they can't even have a trial. There's a requirement in the statute that if you plead not guilty, you have to pay into the court the amount of rent that the landlord says is due. It doesn't even have to be proven. If the tenant is found guilty or has pleaded guilty or no lo contendere and hasn't made this deposit, that tenant will be guilty of a Class B misdemeanor, and the maximum penalty for Class B misdemeanor is 90 days in jail or $1,000 fine. The statute is being enforced unevenly all around the state. It actually does not give judges the power to evict tenants, and yet under this statute, many judges do so. I surveyed all of the district courts in the state, and so I can state pretty definitively what the practice is around the state. Recently, the Pulaski County Circuit Court declared this statute to be unconstitutional in four different ways. We are the only state with such a statute. Others will speak to more specific ways in which it is unfair and fails to conform to our society's basic principles of criminal justice. And I hope you vote do pass.
▶ Play
Thank you. Any questions from Ms. Foster? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill, we have Dustin Duke and Stacey Fletcher signed up. So Dustin Duke or Stacey Fletcher, Dustin Duke, you're recognized to speak for the bill. And there are about just under two minutes remaining.
▶ Play
Speaker 156 1:16:27
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm here to speak today in favor of the bill. I'm an attorney here in Little Rock. I do a lot of work in landlord-tenant law. First, I'd like to point out that, in fact, in the civil process, if someone is evicted under the civil process, the sheriff comes out at that time and removes the person from the premises. So the civil eviction process allows for the sheriff to come out and remove a person that's found to have breached the lease for nonpayment of rent or any other reason to come out and take that person away from the premises. That's already in the civil process to evict. So, in fact, the criminal statute right now that's on the books that we're debating today does not even have a remedy for removal. The sheriff can come out and they can charge someone with a crime. In most jurisdictions, in fact, they just cite. Here in Pulaski County, they give a citation. They don't actually even arrest. And then they go to court. If they're found guilty, they're oftentimes fined. They can be jailed, but there's no specific procedure in this statute even to remove the tenant and their property from the premises. In fact, that's the civil eviction that has the remedy. We're running to the end of your time,
▶ Play
sir, so if you would close, please. And
▶ Play
Speaker 156 1:17:47
as Professor Foster pointed out, this bill is unconstitutional in a number of reasons, a number of areas. It's not just one small area. It's unconstitutional across the board, as Judge Wright found. In the case that he found that on, the tenant was accused of not paying $22,000 in rent. She would have had to put $22,000 into the registry of the court in order to preserve her right not to get put in jail if she's convicted.
▶ Play
Thank you very much for speaking for the bill. Representative Letting, you're recognized for a question. Is there anybody here from the Sheriff's
▶ Play
Association that might offer their opinion on whether or not they have an opinion on this bill? Is there anybody from
▶ Play
the Sheriff's Association in the room? I don't see anyone there. Okay, thank you very much, sir. Representative Hodges, do you have a question? You're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll try to be quick.
▶ Play
If this law was ruled unconstitutional, then why are we addressing this at all? Wouldn't it have been
▶ Play
Speaker 156 1:18:42
moot? It was ruled unconstitutional just in Pulaski County. It's being challenged in other counties, but it's not been ruled on yet by other circuit judges. The Attorney General's Office decided not to appeal that decision. They were given notice and did not appeal that decision to the higher
▶ Play
court. Thank you very much. Representative Lauer, you're recognized for a question. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. I can't
▶ Play
find my citation, but do you believe it would be accurate? The information I have is that in 90 percent of cases, the tenant leaves the premises once the criminal notice has been given. Does that not make it a very effective tool? I mean, we're talking about a small number of people who are actually having to go to court. The same can be said
▶ Play
Speaker 156 1:19:32
in civil, though. Over 90% of folks that are sued on their credit cards default as well. So the remedy in the civil would be the same as it would be in the criminal as far as generally if someone knows they're breaking the lease, they're going to get out. If someone knows that they're going to lose the lawsuit, they don't respond and they lose civilly. So, in fact, in the civil, the sheriff can go out there as little as if someone doesn't respond in five days. They only get five days to respond in a civil suit. If they don't respond, the circuit clerk issues a writ. The sheriff goes and executes that and removes them. It can
▶ Play
be as little as five days. The point I'm making is not that 90% default or whatever, that of those who fail to vacate and are given a criminal citation, 90% of them then do respond to the criminal citation, whereas they had not responded positively to the civil proceedings, correct? Well, they don't respond
▶ Play
Speaker 159 1:20:26
either. I guess I don't understand the question. So
▶ Play
you're disputing the fact that, and like I said, I couldn't find the citation, but it says that 90% that are given a criminal notice do at that point then finally respond and leave the premises. So would that not still be an effective tool in the toolbox? deferring to the Chairman, tool in the toolbox for those who are wanting to protect the value of their property. I'm saying that 90%
▶ Play
Speaker 156 1:20:55
of the people that are civilly evicted leave, 90% of the people that are criminally charged with this offense leave. I'm saying across the board, yes, 90% leave. If I could just share with
▶ Play
the committee, we have four minutes until the session starts. So what we're going to do is we're going to have a separate, another committee meeting that we're going to set up for Monday. So we're going to meet at 9.30 Monday morning. Hold on, don't leave yet because we still have four minutes left. So we're going to have a meeting on Monday at 9.30. I apologize to some of the senators and others who I'd committed. We were going to hear their bills today, and those bills are going to be at the top of the list on Monday. But today what we're going to try and do is finish this one up. Representative Love, would you like
▶ Play
to close for your bill? Representative Collins, are you saying that we're going to take this bill up Monday? No, sir. If you
▶ Play
can close for your bill, we can close and get a vote in before 10 o'clock.
▶ Play
Okay, well, Committee, what I would like to say is that this bill just brings us in line with what's in our Constitution. We all took an oath to uphold our Constitution. If you look at Article 2, Section 16, it says that no one should be indebted for a civil contract, or no one should be in prison for a civil contract, and I would ask that you would vote due pass for this. I'll make a motion to do pass and ask for a favorable vote.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Love has moved due pass on his bills. Are there any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor? All opposed? Representative Love, I'm sorry, but your bill has failed. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, committee, I appreciate your indulgence today. I appreciate the indulgence of the members in the audience who didn't get a chance to speak as much as they'd like. And we're going to set up a special meeting for Monday morning at 9.30 a.m. And with that and without objection, we are adjourned. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1906

0:11 - 16:41 49 segments 7 speakers

HB1870

16:41 - 45:31 92 segments 9 speakers

HB1894

45:31 - 53:41 28 segments 7 speakers

SB821

53:41 - 57:11 14 segments 2 speakers

SB826

57:11 - 57:50 1 segment 1 speaker

SB822

57:50 - 58:41 5 segments 2 speakers

SB824

58:41 - 59:38 3 segments 2 speakers

HB1814

59:38 - 1:23:15 78 segments 10 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Charlie Collins Chair Unverified
89 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
2 segments
Representative John Baine Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 22
8 segments
David Roten Unverified
10 segments
Representative Deborah Ferguson Unverified
4 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
31 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
19 segments
Representative Joe Farrer Unverified
9 segments
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
1 segment
Allison Millsaps Unverified
11 segments
Jason Hall Unverified
12 segments
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
5 segments
Representative John T. Vines Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 108
5 segments
Representative Greg Leding Unverified
3 segments
Alan Kerr Unverified
2 segments
Booth Rand Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 118
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
10 segments
Representative Fredrick J. Love Chair Unverified
20 segments
Speaker 150
3 segments
Lynn Foster Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 156
9 segments
Speaker 159
1 segment