House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (10)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1507
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1507”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1297
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1297”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1616
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1616”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1785
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…this committee. Representative Douglas will be bringing us House Bill 1785, and he wants that to be placed as a special order of busin…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2023
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2023”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2096
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2096”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB785
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Representative Cozart has a motion for House Bill 785 to be a special order of business, And that's Representativ…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB425
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB425”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB712
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB712”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB752
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB752”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
Okay, members, we appreciate everybody being here today. Please, everybody that's here, make yourself at home. If you want a cup of coffee, please go ahead and get one. You know that, members, our calendar is extremely large. We are going to get through as many bills as possible this morning. Of course, we're going to give Representative Hammer all the time he needs on his bill. This afternoon, we are going to come back and meet 10 minutes upon adjournment of the House.
Once again, we're going to see how much of our calendar we can get through. Mark is going to contact the Senate. We have several Senate bills that we know are coming our way, plus several on the calendar. We're going to take some time on Tuesday to see how many Senate bills we can work through. and hopefully getting some good work done today along with Tuesday. We might need to meet twice on Tuesday. So just kind of giving everybody a heads up where we are.
A lot of stuff coming through. We want to make sure we give everybody who is presenting a bill an ample opportunity to present their bill and have it heard at this committee. Representative Douglas will be bringing us House Bill 1785, and he wants that to be placed as a special order of business for March 26th next Tuesday. That will be our second special order of business. The chair will entertain a motion to that effect.
Representative Cozart has a motion for House Bill 785 to be a special order of business, And that's Representative Douglas. With that, Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Thank you, sir. Just for
the sake of time, could we invite Scott Richardson with the Attorney General's office to be seated at the end of the table with me, please? Yes, sir. I'd like to begin by clarifying a few things that were said the other day
and try to straighten out the thought process on dealing with House Bill 1507, which is a school choice bill. Just to remind you of the groundwork, that there is a grandfather bill that is sitting on the Senate side, ready for passage, that regardless of what happens with the other three bills that are out there that are dealing with how to move forward, that would be a safety net. With that, I would also just like to remind you that part of the intent of 1507,
and it's more than just intent, in reality it achieves one of the objectives or one of the issues that was mentioned by the Supreme Court when they ruled the present school choice bill unconstitutional, one of the things that they mentioned was that there are so many different aspects of school choice throughout our laws, but none of them are under one bill. The purpose of this bill is to bring all the reasons that were currently in law found in various places into one bill
so that it would help parents know and understand what their choices are when it comes to school choice. So in a way, we might say that this is a cleanup bill, and it is a good bill for parents because they can look if they're entertaining the idea of school choice and be able to see all the reasons, all the rules, and all the laws under one umbrella, which is an issue that the court identified as a problem that parents were having to go to too many difficult places to find the information.
So this information brings this bill into one location, which is a good thing and will satisfy one of the issues of the court forthcoming. The second thing I would like to clarify, and I think there were some miscommunications the other day, is surrounding the issue of contiguous school districts. Contiguous school districts, as it applies in the current law, which is maintained in House Bill 1507,
is that if you are in a school district that has been identified as in academic or facility distress, you may school choice to a district that is contiguous to your school district. So if, and I'm going to use mine as an example, my district as an example, if, not that any of these apply, this is for scenario purposes, okay, if Bryant School District should be in academic distress
and a parent wants to school choice out using the reason of academic distress as the reason, they would have to go to a school district that was contiguous in nature. So they would have to go to Bauxite, Benton, or to Little Rock. That is where the contiguous aspect of the law applies as it is currently written in the law, so there was no change to that. Now, the list of other reasons why students make school choice that are listed for you
have all been brought together from where they were already existing in law with the exception of the last two. Those were added to expand the opportunities and reasons. If a parent chooses to exercise any of those reasons as to why they want to school choice, the contiguous aspect of The law does not apply. So in a sense, for all those other reasons, it's open choice. So this bill has the flavor of school choice on the basis of academic or facility distress being used as the reason.
But for all the other reasons that were noted as stated in the law, you could skip over school district if you wanted to and choice to that school of your choice, provided the two agree within all the other parameters that are built into that law. So that kind of addresses everybody's issue. It may not settle all of it, but it addresses the issues of where does open choice and where does school choice apply in this law. The other issue that is sensitive to everybody is with regards to the race factor.
In 1507, there are allowances that the race factor can be used as a reason to school choice out. So the question becomes, why is it even in there in the first place? Well, part of the reason that it's in there in the first place isn't because I'm trying to make a statement. Because as far as I'm concerned, and I hope you all take me at face value when I say this, I've been down here for three years, want to be back for three more, finish out my career as a member of the House of Representatives.
And I think that everybody around here who knows me and will fairly judge me realize as far as I'm concerned, we all bleed red and I don't care what color you are on the outside. That's not the issue. And that's the way it ought to be in all of life. Okay? So I just want to be, and I'm going to be real straightforward and I'm going to be real blunt about this because I don't want any miscommunications. I'm not racist. And race is not the big issue to me, for the record. The reason that I'm leaving the race factor in there is because when you look at what got us in the problem in the first place
and why we're in court in the first place, it was because you had all these other reasons floating around out there and all these other bills and all these other areas, and when the court looked at it, they said, well, there are all these other reasons, but how in the world can parents find them unless they're going to take all that time and effort, which we shouldn't do as lawmakers, make it harder on the parents to see the reasons. And yet the decision was on the basis solely of race. Now, I've got a copy in front of me, and it goes back to a Supreme Court ruling.
And, Mr. Chair, before I start to do this, because of a matter that happened on the House floor, I would like to read a paragraph out of this, but I'd like to do it with the Chair's permission so that you know I'm citing a case before the Supreme Court, or we can go get copies made however the chair directs. You
can go ahead and read that, Rip Smith-Hammer. And if a member of the committee would like a copy, they want to make sure they get one.
But go right ahead. And at that point, I may defer to Scott if he wants to speak to the finer points of that,
if that's with the chair's permission. Absolutely. Okay. It says, As in the administration of the public schools by the state and local authorities, it is permissible to consider the racial makeup of schools and to adopt general policies to encourage a diverse student body, one aspect of which is its racial composition. If authorities, if school authorities are concerned that the student body compositions of certain schools interfere with the objective of offering an equal education opportunity
to all their students, they are free to devise race-conscious measures to address the problem in 789 general way and without treating each student in different fashion solely on the basis of systematic individual typing by race. That's the words of the Supreme Court. The reason that I've chosen to leave a factor of race in the reasons why you can choice in or out is because I believe that the Eighth Circuit Court is going to look at how we deal
with the issue that specifically has dragged us into court in the first place and are going to want to know, did we just completely push it away or did we address it in the least offensive manner? And in my personal opinion, and I understand we've got opinions all around this table, the way in which it's addressed in 1507 as amended, we are achieving what the Supreme Court stated in their ruling.
So will we be dragged back into court in the future if we adopt 1507 with the amendment that conforms to this language? We can be dragged into court for anything. But the Supreme Court has already set a precedent and has already ruled on this matter and how in the world or why in the world, Of course, they are the Supreme Court. They can do what they want to do. Would they rule against themselves having already established that precedent? So 1507 takes on the challenge that has us in court in the first place.
It allows for open choice for reasons other than if you are claiming academic or if the school is in facility distress, thereby you must apply the contiguous reason for why you're going to school choice. And, Mr. Chair, with your permission, I'd like to ask if you would allow Scott to comment on what I just read about the Supreme Court because he may be
able to clarify it a little tighter if that's agreeable to the chair. Yes, sir, Representative Hammer, and Scott, before you go ahead and kind of comment on what Representative Hammer just presented, what is state law as it pertains to a segregated school or state policy in terms of desegregation?
Can you give us a quick little primer on what policy is, what's the state's position, what is the law,
Speaker 21
12:16
if you could do that quickly? Well, it's mostly driven by federal law, starting with the Brown v. Board case, that the state does have an affirmative duty to address segregation in the schools and pass laws that apply that. I think the case that most directly applies to that question would be from 1985 when the
full-aid circuit and the Luroff School District case held that the state could be liable for segregation in the Pulaski County schools based on history, a number of factors, one One of which they said, the adherence to a particular policy or practice with full knowledge of the predictable effects of such adherence upon racial imbalance in the school system is one factor among many others which may be considered by a court in determining whether
an inference of segregative intent should be drawn. So there's sort of two sides to the coin as I see it. On one hand, we want to be moving to a race-neutral application of our laws so that race is not a part of them. On the other hand, though, we have to acknowledge the history in our state and the many cases that have held that the state has an obligation to address schools that are racially imbalanced, schools that are racially isolated.
When Brown v. Board said separate but equal is no longer an option, when we find schools and school districts where you have this separation, we do need to ask the question of whether or not that comes from segregation. And if there is a policy put forward that could impact that racial isolation, then we need to take a serious and deep look at that. So I think the case that Representative Hammer was reading from, it's the Parents Involved
versus Seattle Schools case, that discusses what school districts can do now to take diversity into consideration to try and promote diversity in student populations. And it said a majority of the justice agreed that there is a compelling interest in avoiding racial isolation.
So given our history, given the number of desegregation cases that are out there, the number of desegregation orders that are out there, that's a policy that we would advise the General Assembly to consider deeply is how the districts relate to each other and how our policies affect those school districts as they relate to each other in
terms of racial balance. Do these, the federal policy, the Brown versus Board of Education decision, which
governs state policy, does it pertain to the internal workings of a particular district Where we don't, we have a school district in a particular town in a particular state, and on the west side of town and all the schools, it's all the white folks, and on the other side of town, it's black folks. And we don't want that. And so then we have, of course, we have an effort to integrate our schools.
Does this also apply to school districts? yes and
Speaker 21
16:06
the terminology is there's you have intra district desegregation which deals with how the schools within a school district relate to each other you have inter district desegregation which deals with how do school districts relate to each other and how do schools in different school districts that are
nearby each other how do they relate to each other in terms of racial imbalance And
why is that racial imbalance there? So how do we kind of justify? There are some school districts in the state that are majority-minority. Is that correct? Yes. I mean, that's just the fact. And maybe there's a school district next to them that's the opposite of that.
Okay. When you have situations like that, are we following federal law, are we compliant, when currently we might already have situations like that due to, you know, people moving, economic patterns that might have shifted in communities? Where are we now in terms of being compliant with federal law as it relates to state policy?
Speaker 21
17:34
Well, and there are a lot of factors to consider in if we find racial imbalance, does that flow back to prior acts of segregation? There are a lot of factors to consider in that. One of the concerns we have is that in this 1985 opinion, the Eighth Circuit and the Federal Court found that the state does have an affirmative obligation to assist districts in desegregating, in removing segregated conditions of segregation.
And that's why we've spent 20 years under what's called the 1989 Settlement Agreement in Pulaski County, ostensibly to help eliminate conditions that arose from prior acts of segregation. We feel like we're poised to make the case to the court that that task is done in Pulaski County, but without court guidance in other areas, it's difficult to say what the obligations are going forward.
So there is some sense, and our laws need to be aware of those differences among school districts and try to help those conditions, or at least not further any conditions that might have been the result of prior segregation. So the court will look
at what a possible consequence would be of anything that we do here.
They're going to look and see, you know, okay, there may not be an intent to resegregate, but there could possibly be a consequence. That may very well be
Speaker 21
19:22
a consequence of the policy. Right. More than the stated reasons for an action by the legislature, they will look to the effect of those actions. And as the Eighth Circuit said, they'll look to the effect of those actions,
the predictable effects of such adherence upon racial balance in the school system as one factor among many others may be considered in determining whether an inference of segregated intent should be drawn. So I certainly wouldn't suggest that anybody here has segregated intent. I don't believe that. I don't think that's true. And if I could go to court with each one of you and have you explain your intent, that would be an easy case for me. But what the court will look at is the effect of the actions taken, the laws passed, and the policies of the state on the school districts.
So the natural over time movement of populations from one area to another area in the state due to economic changes or whatever, very harder for the court to peg as opposed to a specific policy that was enacted by the legislature that may have unintended consequences. Would that be correct? That would be one way to put it. Those would certainly be factors
Do we have any questions from the committee for Representative Hammer and Mr. Richardson? Okay. Seeing none, we do have some folks who have signed up to speak on the bill. Mr. Jess Askew, Mr. Askew, are you here? Yes, I am. Okay, sir. If you want to head to the end of the table, you are recognized to speak against the bill, sir. and need to be approved with the bill.
Speaker 41
21:21
Thank you. Good morning. I'm Jess Askew, and I represent the plaintiffs, the parents in Malvern, who filed the lawsuit that resulted in the Eighth Circuit appeal that we've been discussing today. So I'm the lawyer on the other side of the case from Mr. Richardson, who represents the state of Arkansas. law. I'm for school choice. I'm against this bill, and I want to be very clear why I'm
against this bill. There are two reasons. One, it continues the same sin on the discrimination based on race that I got struck down in Section F1 of the current Public School Choice Act of 1989. You can compare the language on page 5 that is struck through with the amendment or the option 8 that we have in this new bill, and the same language is there.
I've already won that case. The second point, and this really concerns me, is that all the choice options under Arkansas law are tied together in one bill with an obviously unconstitutional racial provision. Why would you put a hand grenade in the basket that contains all the eggs that you want to
preserve? You just don't do that. In the Malvern case, I tried to get Judge Dawson to take out only Section F1, which was the race provision. That statute is, I mean, you can see it. It's written out for about six pages in House Bill 1507 and struck through. So you can see it. It's a long statute. What I tried to excise out of that statute was about three lines long, and it only dealt
with race. It would have left an entire statute intact. The judge refused to do that. He threw out the entire statute. I think that was wrong. I asked him not to do that. And I've asked the 8th Circuit to reverse that and send the School Choice Act back minus the race provision. I don't know whether that will happen. I do know that when you compound the problem that I had in that statute with the race provision
by putting all the other eggs in the same basket, you're running one enormous risk of having every school choice option in the state thrown out at one time. Is that what you want to do? That's not what I want. Representative Carnine, last Tuesday you were asking the question several times, is race
a factor here or is it an option? And I don't know that you got a real clear answer from the Assistant Attorney General. It is obvious that these are separate options. There are ten transfer options in this statute under 1903. And you can tell that because at the end of number nine, it says or. So each one of these options is a standalone option. The race provision is in option eight.
You don't have to go satisfy option four and eight in order to transfer under option eight. By the same token, you don't have to satisfy option 8 to transfer under any of the other statutes or options. So these are all standalone options. They're not factors. The significance is there is some room to argue, not much, but some room to argue that But if you have a full menu of different factors to consider in assigning a child to a school,
maybe, just maybe, race could be one of those. Now I will tell you that there is no Supreme Court case that has upheld that. There is a case allowing the University of Michigan Law School to use a factor-based analysis and admitting law school applicants, and race was so far diluted by the number of factors in that that the Supreme Court said it was okay.
The Supreme Court said we're only going to allow it for up to 25 years. The School Choice Act here has had a race provision since 1989, and this bill would continue it. And there is a case from the University of Texas that is currently before the United States Supreme Court. It was argued on October 10th or 11th of 2012, and it will be decided. And it directly challenges this University of Michigan law school case. The importance of
that is there is some debate and one precedent that holds in law school admissions that race This can be part of a mix of factors, properly diluted. This option is not diluted one bit, and it involves school children. It involves first graders, not law school graduates. And the Supreme Court considerations are entirely different
Speaker 41
27:41
hear a couple of arguments, and I want to go ahead and address them, because we've had a traveling circus here, and I know what some of the acts that follow me are. There may be superintendents who argue, we need to have some race limit. We've got to have some race limit. If we don't, people are going to have a race reason for leaving my district, and that's intolerable.
That's the argument you will hear. Ask yourself when you hear that, well, why don't we have a race limit for homeschools? That same superintendent can lose that same kid to a homeschool without a race limit. Why don't we have a race limit for private schools? The same superintendent can lose the same kid for a private school without a race limit. Why don't we have a race limit for a charter school?
I'm on the board of a management organization for a charter school here in Little Rock, and it wanted to have a race-based limit on the number of children it could admit. It wanted to have a racial balance in its initial charter back in 2007. This 2007 decision and parents involved came out, and the department and the applicant properly recognized you can't do that. So charter schools, open enrollment charter schools, have no race limit.
We don't have race limits written into state statutes that govern aspects of people's lives, and that's as it should be. The 14th Amendment prohibits states and local governments from discriminating against anyone on account of race. It's plain and simple. You will have another argument that goes like this.
Race-based student assignment, race-conscious student assignment is appropriate when you're trying to remedy the effects of past racial segregation. I will agree with that as an abstract proposition of law. If a judge hears a case and finds that there has been intentional and purposeful discrimination on the basis of race in the assignment of children to schools, there is a remedy that
is required, and often that remedy requires race-based assignment of children in the schools. That was Brown v. Board of Education. That was Cooper v. Aaron. That was the 1957 crisis in Little Rock. That was the 1985 decision of the 8th Circuit in the Pulaski County case. And to be clear, the 1985 decision in Little Rock was remedying the effects that had happened under Governor Faubus's administration and in the 1960s during a period of resistance
after that. It's not something that happened in 1985. It was the current effect. So that proposition of law is a good one. The argument you're going to hear is Arkansas is so riddled with the sin of race discrimination that we can have race-based student assignment in every corner and pocket of this state. And the theory is that that is necessary to purge the state of the current lingering
effects of past racial discrimination. So the argument goes, in Bella Vista, in Texarkana, in Little Rock, in Fort Smith, Russellville, every corner and pocket of the state, there is an equal current effect of racial discrimination that must be purged through race-based student assignment. That argument was made at the Eighth Circuit. I made a joke about it in response and actually got laughter from one of the judges.
Now, I don't know what the Eighth Circuit is going to do with that argument, but it stands to reason that it is grossly overreaching. The policy of the state of Arkansas is set forth in part in its statutes. If you enact a statute that has a race-based component to the assignment of children, and Representative Armstrong, you brought this up last Tuesday, if you do that, you are discriminating on the basis of race in the name of the state of Arkansas.
Please don't do that again. Counselor, I just have a couple of questions. You mentioned in the beginning of your presentation the unconstitutionality of a portion of what you have seen in terms of the ten provisions. Could you just briefly, in layman's terms, explain from your point of view why that's
Speaker 41
33:13
I'm looking at the amendment here it has not
been engrossed yet so it's on its own separate page the second one says if either district has a population of any single minority race of more than 10 percent of its total student population so I read that to be minority race race, Hispanic, Asian, African-American, Pacific Islander, Marshallese. The percentage of enrollment for the student's race in the non-resident district is less
than that percentage in the resident district. So you have to look at the race of the child, which is constitutionally prohibited. You have to look at the racial demographics of the two districts, and the student is only allowed to go if he or she is lucky enough to have a skin color that is less prevalent in the district that he or she wants to go to than the current district. That's a race limit, and that's exactly the race limit that I successfully struck down in Malvern.
Okay, and kind of go with me, Counselor. I am the farthest thing from a lawyer you're ever going to find. Then how do we address and how do we implement policies to avoid resegregation without a provision like this in any statute that would pertain to any issue in terms of resegregation or desegregation of our schools? Very easily.
Speaker 41
34:56
Don't put race in your statutes. Don't let race be a part of the policy of the state of Arkansas. The racial segregation history that we have in the state includes a provision of the Arkansas Constitution that said there had to be separate schools for blacks and whites in the state of Arkansas. That's what you avoid. You don't legislate on the basis of race. We don't legislate on the basis of race in any other area that I can think of
except for assignment of children in public schools. Why? And no one argues that we have race-based state policies in school, I mean in private school attendance, church attendance, residential patterns. We don't do that. And one more question. And since you have
been so close to the issue, it's kind of at ground zero for all of this. In your estimation, and you may not be able to answer this, but why was the law completely struck down?
Speaker 41
36:01
because i was not able to convince judge dawson that that separate section f1 was severable which means could be removed from the statute and let the statute remain standing and i will say that the attorney general took no position on that issue. So let all of the School Choice Act be at risk for being struck down.
And some of the school districts that you may hear from this morning, Elder Radon Camden, came in and said, throw out the whole statute. Yes, F1 is unconstitutional because of race, throw everything out. That's an attack on school choice. I attacked race discrimination. And some of these districts attacked school choice. And I see that same attack in House Bill 1507 because the basket of eggs has a hand grenade in it.
Mr. Eske, thank you very much. Representative Hammer, you have a question, sir?
No, but I have a request to the chair. I think it would only be fair to the committee, and this is in the basis of searching for what is right, But there have been things that have been said, and I think it would be fair to bring Scott Richardson back up here maybe to respond to some of the things that were said just to, you know, make sure that we hear both sides of the issue so we can make a good decision moving forward.
What I'm going to do is, Representative Hammer, I have some folks. We have folks who want to speak forward against the bill. With your permission, I'd like to get them taken care of, and then at the end, can we bring Scott back? Would that be okay with you? That's fine
with me. And the only reason I'm requesting that is I think that because Scott is involved also with this case at Ground Zero. Absolutely. There may be some things that he would say that would just make sure we paint the full picture, not that it's not being, just so we can see everything and hear everything. Well,
he'll be back in cleanup when we get everybody taken care of.
Mr. Askew, thank you very much. Mr. Heller? I'm sorry. Representative Hobbs, you have a question? Mr. Askew, before you go, would you mind answering a
question or two? Be glad to. Representative Hobbs? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Askew. So if I'm hearing you correctly, do you believe that if we, through legislation, amended this F-1 section from current law, that it would stand constitutionally? I think
Speaker 41
38:35
so. There was nothing else attacked. There's nothing else.
There are some provisions in F of the current law that reference F-1 that are also racially discriminatory. But my argument to the court was, take out F1, everything else falls away. It doesn't have anything to refer to. So, yes. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Hobbs. Do we have any other questions
for Mr. Askew? If not, thank you very much, sir. Thank you. May I be excused? Yes, sir. Yes, sir. And we appreciate you coming today. Thank you.
Mr. Heller, you are recognized to speak about the bill. And we appreciate you being here, sir. MR. Thank
Speaker 79
39:22
I work at the Friday Law Firm in Little Rock. I represent the Little Rock School District. I was involved in the Lakeview case. I'm involved in the Pulaski County desegregation case, and most recently we filed a friend of the court brief in the Eighth Circuit in the Teague case, the school choice case that
that we're all talking about in the court, let us participate in the oral argument. And the reason I said, Mr. Chairman, that I wanted to talk about the bill is that I think Representative Hammer is right on a lot of important points about this bill. But I do have a couple of concerns. But first, let me talk about what's going on in the Eighth Circuit. You've heard Mr. Richardson talk about the state's affirmative duty with respect to avoiding
segregation or resegregation. And you've heard about the issues, you've heard Mr. Askew say, if you try and avoid that by considering race, he'll sue you again. But here, I think, is the answer. The Eighth Circuit is considering our argument that these types of considerations of race, such as in 1507, are perfectly legitimate in a situation where a state is trying to
remedy past discrimination. And the United States Supreme Court in the Parents Involved case everybody's talking about, there's only one thing that all nine justices agreed on. They agreed that that was not a remedy case. The decision in that case doesn't have anything to do with the situation we find ourselves in in Arkansas, where we either have a right or an obligation to take steps, to take even race conscious steps, to remedy past segregation.
So if we wait to see what the Eighth Circuit says, we're going to learn something very important. What role can consideration of race play in any legislation you draft in the future? And you've got that problem right now. You've got competing bills. You've got an open choice bill with no consideration of race. You've got these bills that try and comply with the state's affirmative duty to remedy past segregation, and you don't know what the Eighth Circuit is going to say would be
something you can include in a bill or not. I think the best thing for the legislature to do at this point is pass a grandfather bill, make sure the students who have already taken school choice transfers are protected, and wait to see if the Eighth Circuit says 1507 is defensible. Let me
interrupt you real quick. What you just said is a great idea, and we passed that out of this body, and the man
that passed that out of this body is sitting right next to you. So in the political process, things happened, and something happened. But I just want to let you know that the sponsor of that is sitting right next to you. I think universally everybody thought that was a good idea. So you
Speaker 79
42:50
may continue, Mr. Heller. And I saw that happen, but my hope is that that idea isn't dead, because the other option One is to start at the beginning with a new lawsuit.
If you pass open choice, Mr. Askew referred to the superintendents from Camden and El Dorado and there are people in the state who would file a lawsuit challenging unrestricted choice. Mr. Askew tells you that he and others would challenge racial limitations on choice. So whatever you do at this point brings us back to the district court when we're already in the Eighth Circuit with a case that's been argued and should be decided within the next month or two. And I just want to point out a concern about 1507 that it has in common
with every other choice bill I've seen in this session, and that is it doesn't provide for transportation. So when people come before the committee and talk about open choice as a way to give poor students the same opportunities that affluent students have, it really doesn't happen without transportation. There aren't very many students who are well below the poverty level who have somebody around the house that can drive them over to another school district in the morning and go pick them up in the afternoon.
So the bill, any choice bill that doesn't provide for transportation has a significant negative impact on poor children, and that's reflected in some of the evidence that was in this T case before the Eighth Circuit. The proof was that white kids who were statistically more likely to be non-free and reduced lunch students in Arkansas, white kids take school choice transfers 11 times more frequently
than African-American students do. So this has an impact not only on poor kids, but in a state where there's a big overlap between poverty and being black, it also has a racial consequence as well. Counselor, thank you for being
here. We appreciate you very much for your presentation. Do we have any questions for Mr. Heller, Representative Hammer? Can I ask him a question?
Yes, sir. Do you feel that the grandfather bill that's currently out of here waiting for a decision is constitutionally sound to where it could withstand any challenges as it's currently written,
as an attorney who might subsequently choose to sue us? Mr.
Speaker 79
45:21
the way. Well, let me say this, Representative Hammer. I haven't read the details in that bill, but I think any bill that simply keeps students in place who've already made transfers, I certainly wouldn't challenge it, and I think it
would be constitutional. Hear, hear. Thank you very much, Mr. Heller.
We appreciate you very much. Mr. Gordy? Mr. Gordy, we thank you for being here, sir. You are recognized to speak against the bill. Thank
Speaker 97
45:53
you, sir. Appreciate the opportunity. Good morning. It's still morning. I'm Luke Gordy, Executive Director of Arkansans for Better Schools, and it's kind of challenging to follow all the legal opinions on this issue, but I want you to think about this issue from
another angle. First, I appreciate Representative Hammer's interest in addressing choice. My concern and our concern is that it significantly limits choice. In his testimony last Tuesday, he said, and I appreciated his candor, he said, if you're interested in open choice, this isn't your bill. And that's a big concern to us. He also said that, if I understood him right, that this really is not a choice bill.
It's a choice-limiting bill in that the parents can apply to transfer, but the choice is with the superintendents, both the receiving superintendent and the superintendent who the child is requesting to leave. Our position is that there needs to be opportunity for parents to make that decision, not superintendents. As frustrating as I know it must be to the AAEA and the SBA, the schools are not their schools.
They're the parents' and the children's schools. And the school's obligation is to advance and support the most meaningful educational outcome for that child. And if that parent feels like they are not getting the best educational opportunity for that child, they ought to have the choice, not the superintendents, to decide what's best for their children. And that's the primary point I'd like
to make. Thank you very, very much, Mr. Gordy.
Do we have any questions for Mr. Gordy, Mr.
Armstrong? If you let the parents make the decision, how are you going to keep from turning the schools, resegregating the schools, and how are you going to keep
Speaker 97
48:07
them from basing it on race? Well, again, I think that the parents' right, and this is my personal feeling, the parents' right should trump a concern like that.
And we have open choice now. We have choice now for parents who can afford it. Mr. Heller touched on that. And how unfair is it that some of us or some of you who have the financial wherewithal to be able to move your child by buying a house somewhere else or by transferring to a different district, and the kids that are being disproportionately underserved are the high-poverty, high-minority kids whose parents can't do that.
Open choice provides them an opportunity to do just that. So I guess that would
be my response to that, sir. The other question is, Mr. Haller brought out that most of these parents in poverty don't have these same opportunities for transportation, where
they can go take them to school and pick them up.
Speaker 97
49:19
So what's your solution to that? Well, my solution, macro solution, would mean that we need to completely reevaluate how we're addressing transportation now.
And Mr. Heller is addressing it from the Little Rock School District perspective primarily, although he's addressing it generally across the rest of the state. Little Rock School District gets hundreds of millions of additional dollars to transport kids from one district to another. I mean, there's ways that the state could redirect, in my opinion, funding to assist getting kids to the schools that their parents want them to be in. Do we have any other questions? Representative Armstrong?
Thank you, Mr. Gordy. Thank you, Madam. Thank you, Chairman. Do you have anything else to add, Mr. Armstrong? No. Okay. Do we have any other questions for Mr. Gordy? Seeing none, Mr. Gorey, thank you very much for coming today. Thank you. Appreciate it. Scott, if you're available. I'm sorry, Scott. We have a couple more folks. I've got a little ahead of myself. Richard Hutchison. Mr. Hutchison, are you here?
Mr. Hutchison, you're recognized to
Speaker 107
50:42
speak on the bill, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Richard Hutchinson. I'm here speaking on behalf of the Arkansas Opportunity to Learn campaign, which is a coalition of various education policy groups, community organizing groups, and advocates in the state who believe that quality education should be a right for every child, regardless of what a zip code that they happen to live in.
The Arkansas Opportunity to Learn campaign believes that choice is a very important factor that should be considered in developing a quality education system for all of the students in Arkansas. But we also believe that it's important that any effort to provide such choice should provide some protections and some effort to ensure that there are protections from resegregation
and diversity. And we think it's critical that schools reflect the communities they reside in. We think that, and I'm not a lawyer, so I don't want to get into too many technical issues here, but we do believe that the issues raised by Mr. Heller have some value and need to be considered here as you look at what final decision the legislature is to take.
We also recognize the political process in the state that the legislature is in right now with various competing bills there. We think that Representative Hammer's bill is a sincere effort to achieve a solution to this problem. It may not be perfect, but then no piece of legislation is. So we think that needs to be considered as you review this issue.
Thank you. CHAIRMAN BERNANKE. Thank you, Mr. Hutchison. Do we have any questions for Mr. Hutchison? Seeing none, Dr. Abernathy? Dr. Abernathy, you were recognized to
Speaker 116
53:11
speak about the bill, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA. And just to cut the time down in future bills as they're coming for you,
this one applies for all of them, okay? There's been a lot of questions about where school administrators are on school choice. On legislation on the other end that was heard a couple weeks ago, we had superintendents speaking on both sides of the issue. We have pretty much been in a position that we want to kind of wait and see what the bills were when we're out there. About a week ago, we had approximately 20 superintendents meet specifically on school choice and looked at all the different variables that are out there.
And our position is that we feel like the legislature would be in a much better position if they would wait on the ruling for the Eighth Circuit Court. No matter what happens on the ruling, Arkansas will have school choice, period. We currently have three forms of school choice. We have board-to-board transfers. We have opportunity school choice, which is the felon school choice, and we have the school choice that is in front of the Eighth Circuit right now waiting to be ruled on. Whatever they rule on that, we still have the other two options. out there available for school districts.
We thought this body here was very wise when they approved representing Hammer's grandfather clause that allows those children to stay put. We think we have a very good idea why the Senate stopped that bill at this time, but I don't really see that bill being stopped forever. I just don't see 13,000 children be out in limbo waiting on the 8th Circuit. So our position is that you wait on the 8th Circuit ruling, which will give you a little better direction as far as what you may or may not be able to pass.
And just for the record, I have been superintendent for 10 years, and never once did I think I own that school. I thought school owned me a couple times, but we work for the communities. We work for the board. We work for the teachers. But more importantly, we work for all the children in those communities. But with that, that's, and again, that goes for the other choice, the bills that will be applying for you, so I will not be back down here again on those. Dr. Aberdeffy, will you take a question?
Representative Biviano. Absolutely. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Dr. Aberdeffy, by the way, thank you for testifying for my bill yesterday in the Senate. It's a good bill. Yeah. So based on the choices that you just defined, do you think there's any limitations to those choices? Any limitation on those choices? You defined that
Speaker 116
55:50
we currently have school choice. Yes, there are limitations on those current school choices that we have. Pick any one of them. If you pick the opportunity choice that deals with felon schools,
if you're not a felon school, then that won't be eliminated. The board-to-board transfer, there's no limitation other than the fact that those school boards and those communities may or may not approve transfers. So, yes, there are limited choices. So we really
Speaker 116
56:16
may not be a choice as much as you would like, but we have choice, yes. Thank you. Representative Linderman. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Abernathy, we've heard a lot and
a lot of testimony about school choice.
From what I am gathering from you, there are three that we know of that are floating around out there. Senator Key and Senator Elliott have a bill also. So is it your considered opinion that we would be better off to wait until the Eighth Circuit rules, and then would we need to come back in as a call special session or something to address this issue?
Speaker 116
56:59
Well, obviously I couldn't tell you whether or not to come back in, but I think the Eighth Circuit, depending on when they rule, if it was tomorrow,
you'd have a much better idea of what you need to do. But, yes, at some point the legislature will need to address it after the ruling, very likely. They may throw it out and send it back to Arkansas with no changes. I don't know what the Eighth Circuit is going to do. I do think if you change something down without the final ruling of the Eighth Circuit, you may be going directly against what they're potentially going to rule to end with. So you could be worse off than what you are right now leaving it in front of the Eighth Circuit.
I don't know what the Eighth Circuit's going to do. The attorneys that I have visited with are a little surprised that they've held on to it for this long. And they've said that if they're holding on to this long, then they're probably not going to just concur with the previous ruling. So I don't know. I'm not an attorney. But I do think it would be wise if you had all the information in front of you before you passed a policy that's going to be a choice in kids in the state of Arkansas from this point forward. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, Representative Linderman. Thank you, Dr. Abernathy, very much. Scott, you're recognized to proceed, sir. Thank you, Scott
Speaker 21
58:25
Richardson, again with the Attorney General's Office. I think the question you want to pose to me is what happened in the school choice case, the Teague case, and what's the current posture of it. and most of the description was accurate the school choice act was
challenged we defended it and argued all it was one of a number of choice options the court looked solely at the school choice act and held that it was unconstitutional because it its sole limiting factor was race the the Teague Plaintiffs did ask for that one limit which is subsection F of 618 206 to be severed out this the school districts that joined the case argued that that
could not be done because it would leave the act with open school choice which would not be consistent with the intent of the General Assembly in passing it would would work a significant change to the act and they also argued that it would produce segregation, and the district court agreed with the school districts and
held that that subsection F, the racial limit, demonstrates that the General Assembly seriously considered the prospect that unlimited choice would defeat integration and create liability on the part of the state. He held that that subsection was implemented in order to prevent adverse effect on the efforts of desegregation and may be construed as the Assembly's attempt to balance its efforts to serve the interest of students' choice and desegregation. So that's reading from Judge Dawson, the district court's opinion, and his holding on separability.
Do we have any questions for Scott? Representative
Carnine. Thank you, Mr. Chair. As I look at this again, and I'm trying to be simplistic, and that is in the particular bill we're looking at now, though, race is a qualifier. Is that not correct? It's one of ten factors. It's one of several, but, I mean, in the others, I'm not sure I can quite agree with that assumption that the others are really qualifiers, but they're simply reasons to choose choice.
But race then does become a determiner in terms of the ability of one to transfer. And I think that's where a lot of us have difficulty in the fact that we've raised the race issue to that level. And I understand concerns. Obviously, in my past work, that was always looking at the thing, how can we be fair to all children and not just to some? So I appreciate your answer, and thank you.
Speaker 139
1:01:29
Representative Douglas. Yes, thank you, Scott. Would you know if there are ways for us to look at other states that have gone with open choice policies and see how this has affected the balance within their school districts in which, you know, are there races that have suffered, are there races that have benefited?
Can we learn from the mistakes of other states? That would be possible.
Speaker 21
1:02:04
We could do a study on other states and how choice has been addressed in those other states and what the effects of the choice has been. But you don't
Speaker 139
1:02:12
have some indicators that are coming from other states right now? Not before me, no. Okay. Thank
you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Douglas.
Representative Hammer? May I ask Scott a question? Yes, sir. Scott, if we don't do anything with this bill and the other two bills that are coming down the line that we may hear,
we don't do anything with those, or they're tabled or sent into an interim study, something like that, How will we as a state address moving forward if the Eighth Circuit Court rules after we as a body adjourn? Is that going to have any bearing on what the Eighth Circuit Court may decide to do?
Speaker 21
1:03:06
As I said last time I was here, our position is we would like to get the Eighth Circuit decision in because we feel like it will address a lot of the questions that come up in this difficult area, and it's very difficult to determine what are the state's obligations going forward. The Eighth Circuit will have basically three options. They can do what the district court did, which is strike the law in its entirety, in which case that transfer option would no longer be available.
It can do as Mr. Askew and his clients have asked the court, which is to strike only the raised provision, hold that it's severable from the remainder of the act, in which case we would have free and open school choice. Or it could do as we've asked the court, which is to hold that the law is constitutional and keep 618.206 in its entirety and allow it to remain implemented. I couldn't say which way they would decide,
and I also couldn't say when
they'll make that decision. And if we have the grandfather bill in place, and will that law hold in place beyond the dates that are set in there where students can continue to school choice if it goes beyond, I think it's July 1st, and the Eighth Circuit Court still has not ruled. Say they don't rule until the end of this year. Will the grandfather bill allow them to continue to school choice beyond that
if there are those who are
Speaker 21
1:04:54
not currently school-choiced? as I understand it your other bill would allow students who have choice to continue those choice transfers there's a stay in place in the case so that if the court doesn't decide until after the summer then students would be able to school choice transfer under that law and as I understand
if the 8th Circuit decided after the summer those would be able to stay in place and then because the law also allows siblings to transfer it would allow for siblings of students who have already transferred however the court rules those siblings would be able to transfer but nobody
potential scenario could be that we could sit here and do nothing waiting on the eighth circuit court to rule we've got a grandfather bill that takes
care of everybody else but anybody beyond that date would just be held in limbo until the eighth circuit court ruled whenever they decided to if we don't have another school choice bill in place to move forward with whether it's constitutional or not whether anybody's going to file a lawsuit or not we don't know but there would be students who may want a school choice but there's no option for them to do that because either the 8th Circuit Court hasn't ruled or the grandfather bill does not make exceptions for them. Is that a fair scenario?
I think it's fair. Scott, I've got just a quick question. Is it possible because of the length of time that this decision is taking, I mean, are they waiting for us to do something and then they're going to make a decision based on that? I mean,
Speaker 21
1:06:42
is that within the realm of possibility? I suppose it's possible, but I don't think the judges usually do that. I think what I would read into the amount of time it's taken is that it's just a complex issue and that the judges are wrestling with it.
I don't know that I would read anything else into it besides that. It's not uncommon on complex cases for a decision to take some time. Representative Catlett, did
you have a question, sir? sir yes just to kind of get my mind wrapped around what we're doing here and and the arguments made and i know argument a lot of a lot of things have been mentioned about why don't we wait why don't we wait well we have control now sir we don't have control in six months and as a representative of my 30,000 people that i want to represent i feel like we need to address this and um
And outside of calling a special session, there's no other way to address it until 2015. Is that correct? Well, you could, with
very much. Do we have any other questions for Scott? Thank you for your participation today, Scott. And we have Scott Smith, I believe, who wants to speak also.
And Scott Smith is the last person who we have on our list. And after that, Representative Hammer will give you an opportunity to close for your bill, and then we'll take action. Scott, you're recognized.
Speaker 153
1:08:16
Mr. Chair and members of the committee, I'm a little bit nervous in doing this. Representative Hammer was a former pastor of mine in a church I attended, so no one likes to speak against their pastor. But I hope I get an amen after everything that's said here today. But in any event, a couple of things that I want to bring up, concerns at least that I haven't heard mentioned directly with the bill.
As I see this bill, it kind of creates a fruit basket turnover. And then it puts the hardship school choice provisions that are currently already in law in this bill. It even puts some legal transfer options that are in law in this bill. And then it puts what we commonly refer to as the general school choice, which is the one that everybody spends most of their time looking at, in this same bill. It's the one that has the race provision. As you heard the attorney just Askew mention earlier, that race-based provision possibly puts everything at jeopardy.
These other provisions are already in law. There are already school choice options you have, and these are very concerning issues that I think you want to keep in law. And we commonly refer to them as hardship provisions because they usually surround a crisis or a hardship issue facing a family on kind of a case-by-case or individual basis. Examples were, and some of these were required by the federal government by way of No Child Left Behind, and I might add the federal government did not require any kind of race analysis with these school choice options,
those being students of victims of violent crimes in a particular district having the right to choice to another district or students attending a persistently dangerous school having the right to choice to another location. So I don't think you want to put those at risk. The other hardship issues are students who need to transfer because of their parents' job's sake. They work off in another location and have a right to get somewhere else. Or students who simply reside closer, much closer to another district or reside on the boundary line of one district versus another district.
So I certainly don't think it was the intent to create kind of this possible chaos around this issue, but those are issues that you need to be concerned with as well. So I would agree with Representative Hamer by pushing this bill that you do need to do something, and it is not uncommon that the Eighth Circuit has not ruled at this point in time. In fact, it wouldn't be uncommon if they don't rule until May or August or later. And we do have students and parents who need some clarity about what their rights are as
it relates to school choice going forward. So it is your constitutional obligation and responsibility to set policy for the state and not necessarily rely on another branch of government to take that action by default, if you will, in some form or fashion. Finally, I think we need to be very concerned about the possible Trojan horse effect. I don't think that's the intent here at all. But if this one provision is ruled unconstitutional and it sinks all these other choice options that are already in law out there, then that's a very serious issue as it relates to our families and our students across the state.
So those are my comments. Scott,
thank you. Thank you very much for being here. We appreciate your time. With that, we have no one else who has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Hammer, you are
recognized to close for your bill, sir. Thank you, sir. I appreciate the tolerance of the committee. A couple things briefly to say. Any arguments that are made today based on last Tuesday's comments without regards to what was said today to correct misunderstandings, I think need to be taken with a grain of salt.
I just wanted to get that one out there, because at the very beginning of today's comments, I addressed some things that were stated last week and tried to clarify and clear this up. So I would like to say that. Regardless, tough issue. That's all you do. And actually, you guys are more in a position of being a jury, I think, the way things have been presented today as much as you are about being legislators. And now you've got the case before you and you've got to make a decision.
I think we've heard compelling arguments on both sides. I think that we are duty-bound to make a decision to move forward. I think the decision that is made today is going to have precedent over decisions that are forthcoming on the other two bills if they should make it before this committee. On any given day, on any given day, anybody can take anybody into court and can sue them on any given day.
That doesn't mean that they're going to win the argument. And with regards to what seems to be the pivotal issue in this matter, and that is with regards to the amendment that deals with the race factor, I would just go back and cite to you what I read to you a while ago, that the Supreme Court has made allowances for race to be a consideration, but it cannot be the only consideration. As far as the fear of all these issues being wrapped up into one bill and the whole thing being struck down constitutionally, all that means is that if there's ten choices,
All it takes is 10 lawyers that want to go out and file 10 different lawsuits on any of the other issues or sue them all with all the eggs in one basket. It brings it to the forefront, and it sets up the challenge that I believe, if brought to court, could withstand on the basis that we have a precedent already cited by the Supreme Court upon which they've made other rulings. Finally, what got us in trouble is that race was the only factor of consideration the way the law is currently written, that has been addressed with the way this bill is written.
And with that, I will yield to the wisdom of the committee to
make a decision. Representative Hammer, we appreciate your presentation. We appreciate the time that you've taken. With that, the chair will entertain a motion. We have a do pass motion. Representative Klemmer, all in favor, say aye. All opposed? No. Motion fails. On a personal note, I would like to just say, Representative Hammer, you are one of the finest people that I know.
We appreciate the work that you have put in on this bill, and no one ever can question the content of your character. And thank you very much.
May I say one thing, sir? This is part of an ongoing process, and I want the committee to know that even though this bill has failed, One, I don't take it personally because in order for us to arrive at the end result of what's best for the students, we've got to look at it holistically. There will probably be two other bills coming down the line that I would predict would probably get the same result.
But at the same time, it may be that some of this comes back up for consideration. I'll be glad to work with anybody if it should be needed to come back up for the committee. We appreciate
you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Representative Hammer. At this point, we are going to recognize Representative Overby. She will be presenting House Bill 2023. We have an amendment to House Bill 2023. Juanita and Mark are going to get you a hard copy of that.
Thank you. Representative Overby, you are recognized to present your amendment
to House Bill 2023. Well, to make a long story short, I did not notice these two words in the student mobility,
and Mr. Wood showed it to me, so we did an amendment and took those two words out. Basically, that's what the amendment was about. Chair will obtain a motion to
adopt the amendment to House Bill 2023. Representative Hobbs, all in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion is adopted. Representative Overby, you are now recognized to present House Bill 2023 as amended.
Before you do that, though, ma'am, you are recognized to present House
Bill 2023 as amended. It's a one-page bill. It's real simple. With the Department of Education's use of different technology, as this bottom number two says for determining the area of the school district, the isolated schools have been hurt.
And what I'm asking is, instead of taking this money away from our isolated schools all at one time, is to do it a little at a time with the – it would be 10 percent-ish, a little more, a little less, over a 10-year period, so it would not just kill some of our isolated schools. By the way, Mr. Hammer was bragging about graduating in the top 18 of his school.
I graduated in the top 10 of mine. Was that OARC High School by any chance? OARC High School,
yes, it was. It was an isolated school then, and it still is. It was OARC, O-A-R-K, located in Johnson County. That's right. And it is an isolated school district. Very isolated.
It took me about two hours to get to school. I'm not
going to ask you how many were in your class. There were 10. Okay, there you go. Do you have anything else to add, Representative Overby?
Just that we need this really bad because it would be, it would literally kill some of our schools if this does not pass. Representative Linderman, you
have a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Ms. Overby. If I understand this correctly, the size of the district, according to computation, using new technology, GPS, actually shrunk the size of the district, which through no fault of their own, nothing that they did, reduced state funding.
That's right. My understanding also is that the State Department worked with you on this to help phase out the funding so that the school districts could find ways to fund the
schools that survive, is that correct? Yes. Mr. Branscom Gossage, and I worked with the State Department, who's got our health, the Education Department, and they helped us write the bill.
Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have
Speaker 139
1:19:42
have any other questions? Representative Douglas. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair, Representative Volgary. Do you know how many schools were shrunk due to this new GPS? Are we talking about just one school that's being affected by your bill, or
are there several? Mine was the worst, my understanding was. I'm not sure. We might ask. Mr.
Speaker 139
1:20:03
Abernathy might know or Mr. Wood might know.
Is there a list? Yeah, I'd like to see a list of who's affected and how much that's going to affect them every year. Do we have a timeline?
Speaker 177
1:20:19
That would be great. Tony Wood, Department of Education. We surveyed all the districts in the state of Arkansas, isolated districts, and actually those districts file an affidavit in regard to the square miles contained in the district. It actually made changes in all those districts. In most instances, the change was so minute that it did not impact their funding.
There was a case that it was significant. My recollection is, I think, $567,000 of significance. We feel that a phase-out, given the situation in a number of these isolated districts, is appropriate to phase this out. Yeah. Just
Speaker 139
1:21:00
to follow up, do you have the list of, like, maybe the schools that are affected and how much money is that money now going back to you?
Speaker 177
1:21:15
No, ma'am. This year the funding is flowing as it has. There's actually special language that would continue that through next year, and then it was hoped that this would be a permanent fix in regard to phase out the money to conform to the actual formula that calculates that density and the funding thereof. And
Speaker 177
1:21:39
there clearly is a list. There's only one district that it moved the density to the extent that it impacted them financially.
Speaker 139
1:21:47
So none of the other districts are going to be impacted financially? No, ma'am. This is the only one that's going to be affected by this bill? Yes, ma'am. I see. Okay, thank you very
much. Thank you, Representative Douglas. Do we have any other questions for Representative Overby? If not, do we have anyone in the audience who wishes to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none. What is the pleasure of the committee, Representative Catlett? Motion due pass. Due pass as amended, Representative Catlett?
We have a due pass motion as amended. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion is adopted. Thank you very
much, Representative Overby. Thank you so much, and
my children, thank you even more. Members, the vice chair is going to make an announcement. Representative Hammer just presented his bill, and he did it under extraordinary circumstances.
With that, Madam Vice Chair? Yes, just kind of so you'll know what's going on, Mr. Hammer's father was found dead this morning about 9.30, And he kind of was able to set that aside and come and present his bill. So y'all keep him in your
prayers. His father was in Conway. We asked Representative Hammer if he wanted to continue in light of this. He said he did. So most certainly our thoughts and prayers are with Representative Hammer and his family.
with that Senator Hendren and after Senator Hendren does his bills Representative Gillum you will be recognized Senator Hendren I think showed up on day one to present his bill he has been very very patient we appreciate your patience Senator we apologize and you, sir, are recognized to present as many bills as you have.
Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman. And we will try to accommodate you the best that we possibly can. You're recognized, sir.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It's been good to be back down here and watch you all work. You're very thorough, and I appreciate that. Now, you don't need to be that thorough on these bills. These are very easy. Okay. Senate Bill 712 is the one I'd like to have you all take a look at, if that's okay, Mr. Chairman. Senate Bill 712, committee. And if I could ask Director Broadway, he might need to answer some of the technical questions on this. I think it's a pretty straightforward bill, but if you have some technical questions, I'll ask if the bill came as chairman for him to answer some of those.
But what this bill basically does is we have in place in many of our universities some scholarship caps, and for various reasons those caps have come to place over the years about how much student aid a child can actually use as they go to college. What this basically does is remove some of those caps from kids who are military and their spouses who are using those GI benefits and other military benefits for tuition assistance so that they can get the maximum use of those benefits that are available.
And it does some of the same thing towards a federal Pell Grant. So it's going to make it easier for some of these kids to use some of
the financial aid that's available to them. MR. Thank you, Senator Hendren, for the presentation. Do we
Speaker 199
1:25:18
have – Senator Broadway, do you have anything to add? He pretty well summed it up. I will add, too, Mr. Chairman, and I'm not sure Representative Klemmer is aware of this on Representative Hammer, but he is also dealing with his mother-in-law who's in the hospital with congestive heart
failure. So – We were aware of that, so he's really getting it from all fronts.
We truly – we are that sandwich generation. Thank
you, Senator Broadway. wait, do we have any questions for Senator Hendren? Seeing none, do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against the bill? If none, what is the pleasure of the committee? We have a do pass motion. Representative Ratlitt, all in favor say aye. All opposed? Motion passes. Senator Hendren, thank you very much. What's your next bill number? Senate Bill 752.
Senate Bill 752. There is an amendment to this committee. Mark and Juanita are going to get the amendment out to you, give you an opportunity to look at it. I believe that it adds Rep. Hobbs as a co-sponsor, changes an effective date. With that, Senator Hendren, you're recognized to present your
amendment, sir. SEN. SEN. You explained it, Mr. Chairman. That's exactly right.
It adds Rep. Hobbs and it makes it where the report that I'll be talking about in the The main bill
is not really effective until the 2014-15 school year. Thank you, Senator Hendren. Do I have a motion to adopt the amendment? We have a motion to adopt the amendment. Representative Carnot, all in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion to adopt the amendment passes. Senator Hendren, you are recognized to present
Senate Bill 752 as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This bill comes from a desire to make more awareness for our parents
and for the people in school districts about how their school's doing. I spent 15 years on our school board in Gravit, and I have to tell you that if you ask me which of my schools were excelling and which were having more difficulties, I might have a general idea, but specifically year-to-year, as a school board member, I wasn't aware of that. And I know that the parents and some of the people in the community didn't. So what this bill does is it tries to put in place a grading system that everybody's pretty familiar with, ABCDF.
And I've been working with the department, and they may want to comment on it, about what do we categorize as an A and a B and a C, because that's the challenge, obviously, in any grading criteria is we want to be fair. We want to be comprehensive. There is a grading criteria system that schools use. A lot of it's federally mandated. And what I've done with this bill is basically say until you all develop a system that is better, you'll do that. Now, the original bill is set immediately, So they would have had to have this in place by October of this school year,
and it would have basically taken the ratings that we have right now, which if you see on the front page of the bill are exemplary, achieving, needs improvement, needs improvement focus, and needs improvement priority, and change those to ABCDF, because that's the grading criteria basically that we have now. And I'll tell you, that's not a very good criteria, but it's all that we have. And the reason I say that is parents don't understand the difference sometimes between needs improvement and needs improving focus and achieving so what I've asked the department to do is you guys are the experts in education you
develop the grading criteria and bring it back to legislative council for approval and I've given them the entire school year of 2013 to do that so that it'll be in place by 2014-15 and again the purpose of this bill is to try to through the awareness that the community and their parents will have encourage school districts to improve I'm a big believer in public education my kids are all products of public education but I'm also big believer in us looking things squarely in the face if a school needs help let's get it to help if the school
is excelling let's recognize schools that are excelling and really most of our schools and I explained this to our superintendents at our Kiwanis Club last week most of our schools are going to be in the BC range maybe some in the D range. And the attempt of this bill is those schools that are in the average just encourage them and motivate them to become an A or a B school. So that's the purpose
of the bill, and I'll be happy to answer any questions. MR. Thank you,
Senator Hendren. Representative Catley had a question, sir. MR. Yes, Senator Hendren, thank you for bringing the bill here. But what you're doing, it appears to me, is making a very complex issue simple.
And there's a lot of factors to be considered in these grading criteria, social, economic, status of the district. Have you considered that, sir? Is that brought in your attention? I
have. And, you know, you're right. It is a complex issue. And within a couple weeks of the beginning of the session, I met with the department and I said, I'm not going to tell you all how to categorize this because it is complex. And I recognize that school districts that come in from different socioeconomic backgrounds or have struggled for years but are making performance,
we need to take those things into account in how we assess those. And I think that I have confidence that they'll be able to do that, and they may want to speak to the fact that I think they can and will do that. And I know some of the discussions that have already had because of this are we don't just look at performance, but we also look at progress, and I support that. A school district that has been struggling but is showing great gains, I don't want to give them an F or a D. We need to take into account the fact that they're making great strides, but we also have to, I think, look realistically at the situation.
And so I trust that our experts with working with the school boards, the administrators, the superintendents, the department can come up with a system that, while it is complicated, can come up with a rating system that is comprehensive enough to give us a general picture. Thank you. Mr. Chair, if
appropriate, at the proper time, I'd like to hear from the Department of Ed on this issue. Well, the
bad guys are in the corner, and I think they're going to come and give us a rundown.
Mr. Wood, before we get started, would it be okay if Representative Deffenbaugh asked a question real quick?
out of curiosity, Senator, have y'all, would there be any system of appeal? Let's say a school district's not going to agree that they got a C, and is that final? Is that what we're looking at?
You know, it depends on how the regulations that the department develops are written. As I said, if they want to put that in, again, it's going to have to come back to the legislative council to be approved under the system there is right now that i've kind of just forced the issue there's not you you have this criteria and this is what it is but if the department wants to come back and put that process into their regulations there's nothing i don't think that would prohibit them from doing that okay thanks i appreciate representative
hobs thank you mr chair since i've been added as a sponsor i hesitate to ask
questions but i think i need to know this um when in the bill it says schools and i heard you say school districts so will it be individual schools within the district that will receive the ratings in each school great all right and and the other question currently do we not have a rating of like a one to five or something on our schools that what we have
is what's in the bill that's the ratings that we are in the process and i think a lot of that is driven by some of the federal legislation that's passed so where A is exemplary and B those are the ratings
that are given to school districts now okay so so even though you may know your grade of your school it really doesn't give a lot of information as I said so right because people
just don't as I said if you look at that you talk to school board members in this is you and you ask them is your school a needs improvement or is it a needs improvement focus or is it a needs improvement priority and what are the differences most people aren't going to know right so and I would also say the criterion that we are doing gratings now based on this criteria I think that we can do
better than this I think that department can come up with a more comprehensive as has already been mentioned that takes into account other factors besides what we
Speaker 177
1:33:58
Tony you're recognized to give us a rundown I think the first thing that comes to mine is the comparison that you could draw in the discussion that I've listened to for a number of hours regarding school choice. This is also a complicated subject, and there are very positive comments that could be associated with the traditional association of an A, B, C, or D grade,
and then, as some of you have mentioned, there are aspects of that that are problematic. The most helpful aspect of this in the current time frame that we're dealing with is the amendment that was presented to you this morning. Without the amendment, my comments would be dramatically different. We would not have an opportunity between now and October 15th when school report cards will be issued for next school year to have implemented this type of system. We'll put forth our best effort if this is the guidance that we're given
to make this apply in an appropriate way. Thank you, Mr. Wood. And Madam Vice Chair.
Mr. Wood, would you agree that if we do go in this direction and a school is given a letter grade, I mean, they will have a full opportunity to also explain why, I mean, if they either appeal, but they could also, I mean, we're going to send out a report card, correct?
So they're going to know, are we still sending them out or have we decided they're online? What are we doing with the report card? They're online. Okay. Well, all right. So we're making them available online. Will the school have a chance to basically explain what their argument would be, why they don't deserve
I'm confident in that response. So essentially the ABCDF is a rating we all understand,
And if there are qualifiers to that that draw attention, the parents could go and look. And are they going to be aware of those ratings? I mean, they're going to be searching
Speaker 177
1:36:08
for that anyway online. I think your comment of qualifiers that are brought to it is perhaps one of the most important things that's been said in regard to our rating of school districts. I spent a number of years in a superintendent's role in communicating with my communities in regard to the evaluation measures that were applied to our school district.
And as long as you share what those indicators are and have open dialogue, I think it can be very appropriate. There was also a good comment made by Senator Hendren in regard to the fact that we may have schools that have tremendous gains, And even though we looked at a status, we'd want to recognize that and not characterize that as being an F school. I think a tremendous amount of reflection and consideration will have to be given
to try to come forward with something that is appropriate. But as
it stands, I mean, again, we've got to still deal with rules of implementation, but you believe that there would be an explanation. it wouldn't just be that your school gets an A or a B or a C without explanation. And so that rationale would be there. Yes, ma'am, without any question. Okay. Thank you.
Speaker 209
1:37:39
The way I'm reading this, and I think I've understood the explanation, is they're currently getting this exemplary, and you're just trying to make it more readily understandable for the general public. So you're not changing anything about how they're currently graded. I'm not right now,
but what I'm giving the department is I think they're going to want to change that.
Speaker 29
1:37:58
I understand. Okay, thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative
Linderman. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think Representative Eubanks hit on what I was asking.
Do we not do a rating system now for schools? We do. When I had students in school, we got a letter in the mail, and if my memory serves me, the school was supposed to put this on their website and also publish this in the prevalent newspaper. Is that correct? I believe that's correct. Okay, so this question may be for both of you all. Is this bill an improvement over the system that we're doing now, and if so, what's the improvement?
Well, I think it is, and the reason is, as I already said, for 15 years as a school board member, while we've been doing that, and I just got off the board in October, if you ask me what the grade of if our middle school or if our lower elementary was an improvement focus or an improvement or an exemplary, I couldn't tell you, even though we got that report every year. But in that annual report, they came to me and said, your elementary school is a D. I would remember that, and I would be determined to try to figure out why and how we can fix it.
So I think it's going to be a real tool for school board members and for parents. And the other thing that I think why it would be better is because I've seen how the criteria that a lot of this federally mandated criteria that goes into this system we have now is generated, and I don't think it's as comprehensive as what we need. I don't think it recognizes progress. I don't think it allows as much opportunity as we might want for qualifiers. So I think we can do much better, and I think this will be much better and better for the decision-makers and for the taxpayers and the parents.
Speaker 177
1:39:47
Representative Linderman, I can see that you're looking at me. I want to speak out of both sides of my mouth. Number one, the bill currently, without the opportunity for the department to have the time frame, in my opinion would would actually not be better than what we have right now and i'm going to allude to an example of what we have right now in just a second with the opportunity that is provided should you choose to direct us in this direction i think there is an opportunity for it
to be better and my example of that representative is i'm just going to use my district one of my three elementary schools, and I still say my district. I've had some guidance that that's not the case anymore. But Westside Elementary is a high-achieving elementary school. Actually, statistically, in the year that we were rated as a 1, and it was always interesting to go to a civic club and address, many people would think of a Category 1 as
being a positive. By definition, a Category 1 is a school in need of immediate improvement. That's the exact quote of the definition of the language. My Westside Elementary was categorized as a level one school, even with the achievement levels both in math and language arts, I think both in excess of 89% proficient. You can explain that, but as has been alluded to several times there there is a complexity in doing so so I think
there's an opportunity to improve thank you thank you
mr. chair do we have any other any other questions from the
committee representative Dickinson you recognized thank you mr. chair I have received an explanation of some opposition, and let me just read it to you, and you will address it, if you will.
The opposition says that it's misleading that many of the high-scoring schools in the state with proficient and advanced at about 90 percent are needs improvement schools. Can you address that, please? I think that
the opposition that you're talking about comes to a blunt enforcement of part one of this bill, which is I don't anticipate ever happening.
Part one was simply a response to the fact that we could not get developed a proper assessment tool prior to the filing of bill deadline. Part two is what I anticipate will be done. Now, I will tell you that some say, well, then it's pull part one out. Part one is also a motivation for the department to work with schools to develop part two, which is how do you want it to be categorized? Because I agree with some of the criticism that, as I've said,
there are some problems with our current assessment mechanism, and much of that is not the department or even the state of Arkansas is doing. But what this bill does is it says you guys go figure out what's the best way, the most comprehensive way to assess that. And if you don't, then, yeah, we're going to have something, and that's what Part 1 is. I fully expect that we will never see schools rated A, B, C, D, F by the definitions that we see here on the beginning of this bill. All that is is a mechanism to say that we're serious about this and we're going to have something implemented by the following school year.
And as Tony said, originally this bill said just go do it starting this next school year. They're having an entire year and a half now to come up with a more comprehensive grading system, which will take care of, no matter how you do it, there's going to be people who aren't happy about it. Anybody who gets below a C is not going to be happy about it, and they're going to start griping about the criteria. But that does not mean that we refuse to give this tool to people. Representative Talley.
Speaker 235
1:43:58
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And are there any consequences to the different grade levels for the schools other than just?
No, it's not. But, you know, this may be, again, a tool that we could eventually use for those things. But, no, it's not. The consequences are a motivation for schools to improve and, again, a recognition of schools who are excelling. I think the community should have pride when they have a school that is an A school or a B school. I've seen that work in our schools. When we have a school that is excelling and they come up with programs where they put flags up when they do so many advanced or proficients on their thing, that works.
And I want to see that developed across the state. Representative Hobbs. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Hendren, would you share with the committee
what happened in Florida when they went to the A through F rating? Well, there's people here with far more details and specifics on that who may want to speak to it. But I'll just say in general terms, here's what happened. is the number of schools that were rated F when their process was implemented was, I think, over a couple hundred. Within a few years, that number had, using the same grading criteria, had decreased dramatically because there was incredible pressure for people to move forward to get off of that
list. And that's what I want to see. I want to see all of our kids in schools that are improving and motivated to do that. So that's really the driving factor, again. And not just that. as much about the schools that are in the middle the beat that's where most of our schools are i want to see them motivated to become an a school so but if we don't put some pressure that's just not going to happen on its own and and
i assume that pressure was driven from the local level rather than from the state level correct thank you thank you mr chair thank
you representative hobbs do we have any other questions from the committee do we have anyone in the audience that
that wishes to speak for or against the bill mission name here recognize speak for the
bill thank you mister chairman my name is gary newton i i said here today and supported this bill As a parent of two fifth graders in the Little Rock Public Schools, I became very interested
in the ratings and the levels of performance in schools when my children began the process of looking where they're going to go to middle school. Two years ago, the system was the 1 through 5, and there were very in-depth reports online through the Norm site. Parents that had the motivation to go and look, you could get very detailed information. When the new system was implemented this last year to coincide with the federal government's requirements, it, as Senator Hendren shared, imposed those names exemplary, achieving,
needs improvement, needs improvement focus, needs improvement priority. It was hard to reconcile the new categories with what had happened in the past. And the reason was, of the 1,080 schools in Arkansas, five were considered exemplary. Needs improvement priority, the lowest category, there were 48. So that means essentially 1,030 schools were in that great middle, eventually the B through
D range. We saw our high-performing elementary school go from one of the top 25 in the state to be lumped into one of the lowest performing middle schools in the state in the needs improvement category. So it didn't give a parent as a consumer good information upon which to base that decision for their child. So the reality is we have a system now of one through five levels. This bill is elegant in the fact that it compels an understandable system where parents don't
feel further detached from the schools, but feel more engaged in a system that they can understand. The challenge will be that middle, how to determine what is a B, what is a C, what is a D. But we believe that Sunshine is the best disinfectant, and if you see truly how the performance and gains are of these schools, and I would say that performance and gains weigh very heavily. Right now, on the performance side, you can have, as was said earlier, a high-performing school that has not as much room for gain.
They might even drop in gain by a point, but that would force them into the needs improvement. So we're looking forward to a very good consumer-oriented system whereby parents can make informed decisions for their students. Thank you very much, Mr. Newton.
Do we have any questions from Mr. Newton? If not, thank you very much, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Do we have anyone else from the audience that wishes to speak for or against the bill? If not, Senator Hendren, do you like to close for your bill?
Thank you, Senator. The chair will want to take a motion. We have a do pass motion as amended. Representative Hobbs, all in favor? All opposed? Motion as amended passes. Thank you, Senator Hendren, very much. Representative Gillum, if you are prepared, sir, you are recognized to present House Bill 1297. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, Committee. With the Chair's permission, I'd like to invite Dr. John Shields to sit with me in case there's any technical questions
that he might could assist with. Dr. Shields, welcome to the House Education Committee. We're glad you're here. Representative Gillum, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. And, committee, it's an honor to be in front of you today for my first time this session to be here with you. I bring before you House Bill 1297, and I know your time is valuable and there's rules committee and lunch
and a lot of things going on, so I'll try to keep this as brief and concise and informative as possible. What this bill does, just I'm going to be straight with you and tell you what we're trying to do here is basically clean up an unintended consequence of a bill that was passed last session. concerning accreditation on schools and trying to crack down on some of these diploma mills and things that were going on. What we're trying to do here with this bill is to allow the schools in the state
that deal with ministerial vocations to be able to conduct business like they need to, and basically just making sure that they advertise appropriately what their intent is, that religious modifiers are in the names of both the school and in the classes and the degrees that are being awarded so that there's no miscommunication, there's no confusion out there as to what that degree is. And as you know, a lot of times churches will ask the question on their search committees
and when they're hiring people, you know, have you obtained a ministerial degree from a seminary or another institution? And so it's a requirement that a lot of churches have, and that's what we're trying to do here is meet this need to make sure that when students go and get a music ministry degree that they can obtain that and then find the appropriate employment. And so, like I said, I try to be concise as can, and with that I'll entertain any questions you might have.
Do we have any questions for Representative Gillum? do we have anyone in the audience that wishes to speak for or against the bill senator broadway senator broadway you are recognized
Speaker 199
1:52:04
to speak on the bill sir thank you mr chairman and i appreciate uh... representative gillam and dr shill as well, and my comments are not aimed at Dr. Shield.
We have had a relationship with he and his association for some time, and so he is the reason I speak is not concerned about him, rather somebody else who may come in who has not been affiliated in Arkansas. And I feel important just to make you aware as policymakers of concerns, and I've expressed this to Representative Gillum as well. In terms of a fly-by-night operator who may come in, and, again, it's like Dr. Scheel and I were talking about in the hall the other day,
it's the few that make it bad for the real, you know, for the ones who are trying to do good. It's the few out there that come in, set up shop, say they're accrediting schools, and open up these diploma mills. And so the concern from our standpoint that just needs to be expressed to you, and we've talked about possible ideas maybe to amend it. It would take some time, possibly look at other states, so I'm going to yield to the will of the body here.
But in terms of a student not knowing, say somebody comes in and sets up a school and says they're accredited. they're not when you think of an accredited school you're thinking recognized by some entity such as the US Department of Education which high schools all the public institutions are recognized by that entity this would not fall under that these the types of schools that we're talking about and the
concern would be what dr. shill does is they put in their catalog on the front I guess first page, isn't it, in the catalog that this is not recognized by the U.S. Department of Education, and they have worked with us in terms of their course titles to ensure that if you're taking an English course, it is English for religion or English for Biblical studies not everybody will do that and so you could have someone come in that
student thinks they're taking an English course by an accredited institution and it is not it will not transfer either a high school we've had issues with high schools who students who have called us with a high school diploma from a fly operator tries to enroll in a college college calls us and says we don't know who these people are student never knew that they didn't go to an accredited high
school and so now they have no high school diploma and so the same thing with a college degree someone could offer an English course that student thinks in representative Clemmer and representative Hopper can probably speak to this, too, in terms of how many students actually read the entire catalog cover to cover and understand. But like I said, Dr. Schill, they have done this in their catalog, but not everybody will. And so the concern is for that student who does not see that, who thinks they're enrolling
in an accredited institution that will allow them to transfer to UCA or to Fayetteville. Keep in mind, not everybody, like in Dr. Schill's case, most of these are going into the ministry of some kind. That's not always going to be the case with some of these other operators.
by mail or whatever. Senator, I just have, just for my own clarification on this, because we've had a pretty busy day,
from your perspective, where's the rub here? What gives you heartburn on this bill particularly?
Speaker 199
1:56:10
I think it's more the consumer protection standpoint, and I don't know how to write it to where I've thought about
how you could write it to where people like Dr. Schill would be okay, but you try to block someone else, and I
Speaker 199
1:56:31
don't know, Representative Gilliam and I talked this morning if it's that their nexus is in Arkansas
because one of the concerns is online, with the advent of so much online, that somebody could be based somewhere else but offering courses in Arkansas or diplomas in Arkansas, nobody would ever know it because they would not they would try to go around our exemption process. So it may be that there's some way to work, some kind of language that would satisfy, I don't know. We're not aware of any state that has an exemption like this, but we haven't looked at all 50 either.
So it's just a concern from the consumer standpoint, not about, like I said, Dr. Sheil. It's just the consumer understanding what they may or may not be receiving when they think they're going to an accredited institution. So I just wanted to
make you aware. Madam Vice Chair. Thank you, Mr. broadway and and representative gilliam for talking to us about this bill would um would there be some way that before student either enrolls or before they're awarded a credit
sometime during that first semester that they could be mailed you know more or less a disclaim a full disclosure document or something that they had to sign you know we have students sign things all the time to say, you know, I recognize that, you know, the hours I'm seeking may not transfer. I
Speaker 199
1:58:01
believe Dr. Shield does one. But again, the concern is not everybody is his organization, but it could
require, yeah. And I'm wondering, even though if it's not addressed by this bill, and of course the
bill filing deadline is over unless we find something we could amend to, but I mean, could that be implemented in rules somehow? Because, I mean, I think, by and large, that's a problem even with some of our technical-type courses that students don't realize that these are not likely going to feed towards a four-year degree. And it slows them down, and eventually
Speaker 199
1:58:35
it derails a number of them. That's a very relevant point and very relevant question. That is something probably could be done by policy that we take to our board.
I'm looking for my attorney. So if this university college is doing this, rather, it wouldn't affect this bill, but that would be something that I'm glad to know they're doing because it just seems like it's, again, kind of consumer protection, full disclosure.
Thank you. But we still have the question of how are we going to protect students from these organizations that may not be based in Arkansas who offer these classes
but do not fully disclose they're not transferable. I mean, we're
Speaker 199
1:59:22
still at that issue. Yeah, that's going to be the challenge, always going to be the challenge in trying to administer that and making sure that those students are aware of it and understand it. And employers. We had, in fact, Representative Klemmer with the bill that was in the last session. Representative Klemmer asked if we were doing training for the institutions to recognize diploma bills, fake degrees, and those types of things.
And we had a training session, thanks to her suggestion, for all of the registrars from the institutions after that session, training them on how to be on the lookout for these types of diplomas. And so they're more trained in how to look out for them. The other concern is employers don't always recognize that. But we've tried to provide as much information available out there for employers as well. Madam Vesther.
Your comment just engendered a question. Did we not ask for Department of Higher Ed to put something on the website? And did we do that? Yes, ma'am. Great. I was looking at that earlier.
Thank you. Representative Carnine. Just as a notation on this, and this is to Senator Broadway, it is true, is it not, that many times universities and colleges, for example, even with advanced placement,
may indicate that they will not, in fact, accept them for credit. Is that correct? That's correct. So, you know, this whole idea of trying to be transparent really is up to the individual thing. Even if you say to students, it's buyer beware to the parents because you better check with the specific institution. And I think that's correct in that respect. I think this is a worthy, you might say, effort, but at the same point in time, I'm not sure how you can control it, particularly without a state, private universities, public universities.
Speaker 199
2:01:37
And that's a challenge we face for Representative Carnine without a state, and because of interstate commerce and all these challenges, they're required by federal law to come through our process. But obviously there are some who do not want to be found who will try to skirt around that process. And back to my comment about the few making it bad for the rest. But that's why I wanted to speak on the bill. It has nothing to do with Representative Gillum and what he's trying to do or Dr. Scheel. It's just a concern we would have for protecting the student and consumer by the fly-by-night operator.
Representative Carnot. Can I ask one additional question, because as we talk about this in interstate commerce, are we opening ourselves to litigation regarding, I guess, from the standpoint of a student who obviously ends up finding out they don't have credit? I mean, is it still, are we really talking about buyer beware here, or if somebody gets
on an online course and finds out they can't transfer it, how much responsibility? Is there any litigation out there, Mr. Broadway, that you're aware of that, I guess you might say false representation? I know in many instances there's state legislation regarding individuals that provide transcripts with semi-bogus degrees correct so do we get into that arena with this also let me give my general
Speaker 268
2:03:22
lawrence attorney for the department of higher ed currently we've not had any lawsuits in arkansas over that particular issue and with this bill what you're doing is you're allowing them to be accredited and if it goes through and that school's accredited then that student wouldn't have the recourse to come back I can say they didn't know because it would be the school was accredited. It would say they weren't accredited by the U.S. Department of Ed or the Council of Higher Education.
That's what they're exempting by allowing them to accredit. So the school is accredited, but it's
by a certain body, not by those bodies. And, again, if I might, on this one, if I remember, and, again, my memory is a little shaky on this, but it seems or I'm thinking about that there were some lawsuits filed regarding not just the accrediting of a program, but actually that there were, I guess, some sort of fancy words and so forth.
This is such and such accrediting the agency. In other words, that in itself was the problem. The agency accrediting wasn't necessarily, it was for a profit base, and this is essentially, I mean, you could get a month and get a Ph.D. in some sort of area. So, again, we've had this in the past. Wasn't there some federal lawsuits regarding the fact that certain agencies were set up
that were not accrediting agencies, and they were actually, it seems like it was out of Florida, but maybe my memory doesn't serve me correctly. Member? There have
Speaker 268
2:05:13
been some federal lawsuits over this kind of issue, And the accrediting bodies, I mean, there are accrediting bodies out there, and other states that do allow them. Not all states, but some do. Florida is one that allows for these private accrediting agencies to exist.
And there's still that whole kind of a buyer beware. They're supposed to be notified that they were accredited and who they were accredited by and that that accrediting body isn't recognized by the U.S. Department of Education or not recognized by the Council of Higher Education. So just
because you're recognized by one of these, accredited by a third party, doesn't mean the University of Florida is going to accept that transfer. Exactly. Okay. Thank you. Representative Carnot, do you have anything
else to add? No, I just wanted to make the point that it appears to me that there's, you know,
whether it be an accrediting agency or whether it be the state, whatever, it's really you've almost got to say buyer beware. You better check ahead of time. If you don't, then obviously, and the same thing when people bring you transcripts saying, oh, by the way, I have a Ph.D., a doctorate, or a master's degree, they may achieve that within 30 days. So, again, I don't know how you solve those issues. Thank you,
Representative Conlon. Do we have any other questions from the committee?
If not, do we have anyone that wishes to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Gilliam,
would you like to close for your bill? Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman. And I really do appreciate Director Broadway and the working relationship that he and I have. We've looked at this thing from a couple different angles, and we'll continue to do so. Even if, God willing, this committee votes this bill out, we're still going to keep looking at this and making sure that we've got good policy.
That's what we're interested in here. Going back to some of the questions and everything, I do just want to make sure that everybody's clear. What we're trying to do here is make sure that people in ministerial vocations have those opportunities. And they're going to schools that have a religious modifier in the name of the institution in order to be able to get in this particular subsection here. So, you know, it's not like they're going to, you know, White County Tech.
It's not the way the names are going to be done. They're going to be going to, you know, the John Catlett School of Jesus. I mean, there will be some religious modifier in there. And so it's going to be a very obvious tip-off to the entire world as to where they got their education from. And that's what we're seeking to do with this, to make sure that it's very obvious that when they receive a degree, a doctorate of education, it's a doctorate of religious education, so that we do not have any confusion or any kind of misrepresentation.
And with that committee, I sure appreciate a positive, favorable vote. Thank you very
much, Representative Gilliam. We appreciate you being here. Dr. Shield, thank you for your time as well. With that, the chair will entertain a motion. We have a motion to do pass. Representative Eubanks, all in favor? All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you very much, Representative Gilliam, Dr. Shield, for your time today. Thank you very much, committee. Representative Murdoch, you are recognized to present House Bill 2096 when you are ready, sir.
Representative Murnock, you're recognized. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Committee. I know I'm standing between you and lunch real quick. This is a clean-up bill from Act 1159 of the 88th General Assembly. That act said that as of July 1 that a state agency can no longer charge fees. And we have two technical colleges that were left out of some legislation that later allowed to impose tuition and other fees that a college must do.
And we have two that were not a part of that. And this cleanup bill will just allow those two technical colleges to be able to impose
tuition and fees. Members, clarification, this is Bill 2096. Make sure it's on everybody's tab. Representative Carnot, do you have a question? I have a motion. Okay, do we have any questions for Representative Murdoch? Seeing none, do we have anyone that wishes to speak for or against this bill. Seeing none, the chair will entertain a motion. Representative Carnine has a do pass motion. Do pass. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you,
Representative Murdoch, for your time. Thank you. Representative Nichols, you and Senator Senator Sanders are recognized to
present House Bill 1616. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee.
You know, a lot of times we bring things to the committee that we learn in our everyday life, and I'm here because of my daughter having an issue, and I think Senator Sanders is here because his wife has the same issue, and so we have come up with some legislation that would allow some very talented band and choir folks to the students to be able to follow their passion, and right now the way the rules of the education department or structure
that makes it very, very difficult. I think we have satisfied the Ed Department on this bill, and I don't think they are, as far as I know, they don't have any problems with it now. I'll let, as my co-sponsor, Senator Sanders can speak.
Speaker 288
2:11:29
Well, this is a very bipartisan bill because it involves choir and band, not so much Democrat and Republican. But thank you for allowing us to be here. One of the things this does is simply aligns, I think, what is, you know, the Department of Education, we expanded the requirement that kids, actually
grades one through six, receive a minimum of 40 hours a week or minutes a week in music instruction. It was implemented in 2002 and then action in 2005. Department of Education expanded the requirement to include students in seventh grade because of middle school level frameworks. and school students are, some of them are in grades 5 through 8. The expanded requirement for 7th and 8th grade may not currently be enforced in all the school districts in the state, but the good news is here in Pulaski County it actually has been enforced, actually for this year,
and I think it's because the Department of Education is doing a good job of running the school district. what this basically allows it basically allows a student to have the choice to go after to do band or choir and that's simply what we're asking for kids want to follow their passions if they take a particular interest in that that's essentially what we're asking
for we appreciate you I'm going to do a Jimmy Jeffers real quick bad guys are y'all okay with this okay
everybody okay with this Okay. We have any questions from the committee? Yes, sir. Representative Deffenbaugh. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to make sure you
all know a couple of complaining parents just showing up and, you know, like the – No, I'm just – I had to fool you. Were you not – they want to take both these? Is that what you're saying, or what are you asking for? Right
now in the sixth grade, they can take both.
When we get to 7th, the way the rules were implemented, they could not. And in fact, the other day I had a handout for the committee from an endorsement of this from the State Choir Association. I don't know if it's still up at the desk or not. But anyway, it's like my daughter told me, one of her students who's getting his master's degree in music education, I think, at a university in Illinois, that if this rule that we have
now had been in effect when he was going through middle school, he would not have been able to follow his passion and would not now be getting a master's degree. She also told me of a band director here in Little Rock, same thing. That rule would have kept him out of it. So we're not touching high school, just that middle school level. We have any
other questions? I'm sorry, Representative Deffenbaugh, go right ahead.
So this would make you be allowed 40 minutes of both?
Well, the sixth grade, we have a statute dealing with the sixth grade, and Jeremy, I'll be able to correct me on this, but the seventh and eighth grade was governed by the rules. Okay. All right. Thank you. Appreciate
it. Representative Deffenbaugh. Thank you, Mr. chairman how many minutes are we spending now we're adding 40 but how many we do
it now well they can take a semester-long course in the seventh and eighth grade
now so I thank you the 40 minutes comes from the one through six grade mr. well Well, I'll tell
you, I've heard testimony, not being an educator, and I'm, you know... Just like I'm not a farmer. My wife is a band. She was really interested in band and music, but that wasn't ever my talent.
But I'm trying to figure out, I've heard testimony from different officials that we've already planned most of the minutes that the teachers have every day. Now, where's this going to fit in is what I'm going to ask. Because what I hear from many of the teachers, maybe I'm off base here, But what I hear from them is we don't have enough time to teach.
Now, maybe some of that time should be used for music. I don't know, but it looks like here that we're making this a mandate. So what about the kids in those grades that doesn't care anything about music or whatever? I don't know. This gives the ones who want
Speaker 288
2:16:22
to have the choice to go choir or band that opportunity to choose. So you've got it
calculated how they can still do that an extra 40 minutes a week and still complete all of the hours that they've got to have.
Speaker 288
2:16:36
Not an extra 40 minutes. It just gives them the choice to do band or choir, not both and cram them in. It gives them a choice to kind of pursue, as
Representative Nichols says, kind of pursue what they want to do. Well, it says a student enrolled in grade 7 or grade 8 shall participate in visual arts instruction, appreciation, and application or performing arts. It doesn't say they have a choice there.
Speaker 310
2:17:19
there. Go right ahead, sir. I'm Jeremy Laster. I'm one of the bad guys in general counsel for the Department of Education. And I think the confusion may be that in our current standards for accreditation for this grade, for these grade levels, we require visual arts instruction appreciation application and performing arts instruction appreciation and application.
So I think I don't want to speak for the sponsors. I think what they're wanting to do is because students have to take both, they have to choose. and they want to be able to give them an option to choose to take one or the other? That's correct. So right now the standards require both. They're giving them an option. They're changing that to be able to give them an option to choose one or
the other. So you're saying if they want to do performing arts, they don't have to do visual arts. That's correct.
They get to choose. Is that what
Speaker 288
2:18:13
you're saying? That is correct. The kids in the 7th and 8th grade would have the opportunity to choose. between one or the other.
Why would we need to add 40 minutes then? I don't understand that.
Speaker 310
2:18:25
Let me answer the 40 minutes piece. The 40 minutes is in law, but it doesn't apply to these particular grades. It applies to the elementary grades. So the 40 minutes would not
Okay. Well, I don't know if I'm clear, but I'm settled a little, I guess.
may be glad she's not here Representative Linderman I'm kind of having some of the same heartburn I think that Representative Dale is A student enrolled in grade 7 or grade 8 That means one of those two years must participate in one or the other of these.
What about students that choose not to? They want to take a business course. They want to take an agricultural course that is available in some schools, grade 7 and or 8. Does this affect their ability? I mean, I taught school for 30 years, and you've got X number of minutes in a day. And so, and again, that word shall right there is causing me some problems. I would really like to hear maybe from Dr. Kimbrell or someone to explain the scheduling of these students in grades 7 and 8.
Let's get Representative Klemmer. She has a quick question and clarification, and then we'll get Dr. Kimbrell.
Thank you, sir. I want you just to tell me if my assessment is correct. Currently, kids have to take visual on that list and performing on that list. They have to take both currently. This allows them a choice. So instead of having a semester of visual arts and performing arts, one semester of each, this would allow them to have a whole year of just music instead of having to stop your music and go to visual.
Speaker 321
2:20:32
Is that correct? You are correct. Thank you. Dr. Kimbrell, do you agree with that assessment? Yes, sir. That is exactly what this would do. And just in the seventh and eighth grade, for grades five and six, it would remain. There is no minute requirement for the seventh and eighth grade, but so what you've got is in seventh and eighth grade, you've got students who are scheduled period by period. right now are having to, in seventh and eighth grade, we're pretty stringent on what those
requirements are. You know, you've got certain requirements in the seventh grade that you've got to take in math, language arts, science, physical education, health and safety. We You begin also with our American history. You can do that. So they don't have many choices. And so what you currently have is that a student will have to take a visual art and a performing
art each year. This law would let them choose to do one or the other for the whole year. So if a student wanted to be in the choir and also the band, they could do both. Currently they can't do that. Thank
you, Dr. Kimbrell. Representative Dale, do you
have anything to add? Yeah. Is that going to – I still think it's adding extra classes.
Is that going to add new teachers? No,
Speaker 321
2:22:15
sir. It wouldn't add any additional classes or teachers. What it may do is require some students to get into one of those issues that we run into in schools all the time when you've got favorite teachers or you've got favorite subject areas where some kids don't get their first choice, you know. Thank you. We have any other questions
from the committee? Seeing none, anyone who would speak for against the bill? Seeing none, do we have a motion?
Motion, Representative Cozart, do you pass all in favor? All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you very much, gentlemen. Representative Dale, this is going to be the last one of the day, excuse me, for the morning. Senate Bill 425. This will be the last bill before we break to lunch. And just a reminder, we will meet back here 10 minutes upon adjournment of the House, and we will be taking up members' own bills.
And after we get those busted out, if there's anybody else on the Senate end or non-members of the committee, we'll take them up as well. Representative Dale,
you are recognized to present Senate Bill 425. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm carrying Senate Bill 425 for Senator Johnson. And I'm pretty sure I understand this bill very well, but I'd like to ask Mr. Tony Woods to help me present this, and I think he maybe could present it in a more understanding way than I could.
There is no question that Tony Woods can do that because he's explained it to me about 30 times with great patience every time. So, Mr. Woods, you're recognized. Tony Woods,
Speaker 177
2:24:01
Department of Education. Just briefly in background, Now, in order to assure that every student in the state of Arkansas has the dollar amount of adequacy that you as a General Assembly have determined to be appropriate, the 98 percent has always been trued up. If a district did not have 98 percent of the collection on their assessment,
the department would come in and provide those dollars to bring it up to a 98 percent collection rate. That actual amount is used in the formula for the printout that is sent to school districts for their funding for the coming school year. In the event that they collect above the 98 percent, currently they fund back to the department the dollars above that. Now, these are dollars that are generated by the uniform rate of tax on 25 mils. The reason we're coming before you is we've had an instance develop.
I wasn't smart enough to look to the future that there could be a situation where growth and assessment in the state of Arkansas in a particular school district in conjunction with the number of students in that school district could generate on the uniform rate of tax the dollar amount greater than the base level of funding or the dollar amount of advocacy in our state. Currently, we had eight districts that exceeded that level.
Today, we only have seven. One is actually dropped out of generating that amount of money. We had two FYs, both FY11 and FY12, in which we did not pay up to the 98 percent because a number of those districts had already exceeded the per-student funding amount of adequacy. So we did not pay that. The law is very clear in regard to paying up to the 98 percent regardless of what dollar amount they have generated.
Two of the districts have chosen to go to the Sixth Circuit and bring suit. I don't know what the outcome of that will be in regard to us having the exposure to go back and pay up the dollar amount to that 98 percent, but we're coming to you today to try to correct that for the future. In essence, we have districts that already are generating, within that 25 mils, dollars above foundation aid. The courts have been very clear, and certainly we'll follow the guidance of the Supreme Court, that those dollars will stay at home.
This is specific to the 98%. It's a completely different discussion than the dollars that are above foundation aid, and so that's why we're bringing that to you. Let me clarify one additional thing. In the event that a district was only a few dollars short of generating that dollar amount, even though they had collected at 95%, we would bring up to the percentage required to give that dollar amount.
So there will not be any districts, if you choose to support this, that will not continue to have the dollar amount of advocacy as assured by the 98% collection rate. Tony, and,
of course, we've had me, you and myself and Dr. Kimberl, we've talked about this at length, because I want to make sure I have my brain wrapped around it. And just once again, I want to go through it just one more time, and I'm going to make this, this is going to be the sixth grade version. We assume everybody in the state of Arkansas are going to collect at least 98 percent of their local property tax assessment.
If a district or if a county collects 95, but within that 95, they've hit foundation, which is $6,500, $6,400. they're there what we have done in the past is we have come in and gotten them up to that additional from 95 from 95 to 98 explain what that formula is after you've hit foundation funding funding where the state doesn't have to kick in
the foundation explain the formula where we true them up
Speaker 177
2:28:18
from 95 to 98 just give you an example I won't reference the school district but one of the districts that is pursuing this, they actually have an assessment of, I'm rounding, $7.3 million. They actually have excess revenue above foundation aid, this is for FY11, of $1,160,000. Their collection rate was 95.45%.
Specifically going to your question, if we trued up to the 98%, we would pay that district an additional $226,997, although they already are above foundation funding in excess of a million dollars. And what's
the formula that you use to give them that money?
Speaker 177
2:29:07
You take the assessment that was certified in the prior year, abstract of assessment, well 25 mils is applied to that, 98% of that dollar amount.
And then if we're short, or if they're short under the 98%, it's just simply that percentage they're short applied to that to convert
to a dollar amount. On top of the foundation that they've already hit. And also, just to clarify, no one's losing any money on this deal. And this is only applicable to a few districts where, and correct me if I'm wrong, they have a very, very high property tax rate or value, but in their school district's low enrollment
Speaker 177
2:29:52
population? It's not specific to property tax rate in the context of number of mills voted because the 25 mills, as you know, is at 25 mills. It is specific to the dollar value of assessment with one additional factor, and that being student population. A combination of a low student population and a high property assessment will
reflect that. And I'm thinking of a, without naming any names, a very nice retirement community where my father lives.
And no kids live there. But there is a school district that encompasses a large part of that retirement community. So there is a skew there. And this goes, I think, a long way to correct that without anybody being hurt. Do we have any questions from the committee? Seeing none, do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against the bill? If not, what's the pleasure of the committee? We have a do pass motion. Representative Catlett, all in favor? All opposed?
Motion passes. Thank you very much, Representative Bell. Committee, we will meet back here 10 minutes upon adjournment to take up members' own bills. Thank you for your patience today. We will see you 10 minutes upon adjournment this afternoon. Meeting adjourned.
Agenda
HB1507
HB2023
SB712
SB752
HB1297
HB2096
HB1616
SB425
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative James McLean Chair
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 21
Speaker 41
Speaker 45
Speaker 54
Representative Debra M. Hobbs
Unverified
Speaker 78
Speaker 79
Speaker 89
Speaker 92
Speaker 97
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Speaker 107
Speaker 116
Representative Mark Biviano
Unverified
Representative Homer Lenderman
Unverified
Representative Les "Skip" Carnine
Unverified
Speaker 139
Speaker 33
Representative John Catlett
Unverified
Speaker 153
Speaker 159
Representative Betty Overbey
Unverified
Speaker 177
Speaker 141
Representative Ann V. Clemmer
Unverified
Senator Jim Hendren
Unverified
Speaker 199
Speaker 213
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh
Unverified
Speaker 227
Speaker 113
Speaker 209
Speaker 29
Representative Jody Dickinson Chair
Unverified
Speaker 235
Gary Newton
Unverified
Representative Jeremy Gillam
Unverified
Speaker 250
Senator David J. Sanders
Unverified
Speaker 268
Representative Reginald Murdock
Unverified
Speaker 288
Representative Robert E. Dale Chair
Unverified
Speaker 310
Speaker 314
Speaker 321