Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

April 17, 2013 Part 4

April 17, 2013
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (13)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1901 · 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1901”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1962 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1962”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2283 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…tative Hammer recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 2283. Read Amendment 1. Amendment 1 to House Bill 2283. Represen…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1020 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB1020”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1158 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…tative Deffenbaugh, are you ready for 1158? Mr. Clerk, read Senate Bill 1158.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1921 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1921”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1143 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…we're going to continue down the calendar. we're waiting on house bill 1143 to come back from the senate at which time representative b…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB19 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ative Edwards recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 19-21. Read Amendment 1, Mr. Clerk. Amendment 1 to House Bill…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB20 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Mr. Clerk, Passover, House Bill 20-04. Representative McLean, are you ready for Senate Bill 11…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1050 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1050”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1100 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…House Bill 20-04. Representative McLean, are you ready for Senate Bill 1100? Passover, Senate Bill 1100. Representative Deffenbaugh, ar…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1115 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1115”
Pre-2017 bill
SB909 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB909”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
Voting on the bill, but the amendment has now been engrossed into the bill, but the amendment required, specifically required the department to apply for a section 1115 waiver, which gives flexibility to the state to structure the private option in the way that we need to, but it specifically lists out the waiver. That was number one. Number two, It expanded the requirement for an HSA or an independence account to be offered to the population of 0 to 138 FPL. May not be done on the exchange, but it lets the state develop the model that needs to be offered to allow for that to happen. Number three, and this was an important one, it clarified the language in the state plan amendment, which is frequently referred to as a SPA, state plan amendment, and basically just clarifies that the state is in control of that amendment. And by entering into this, the state is not agreeing to any state plan amendment that we are not in control of. So what it means is it clarifies the opt-out. It clarifies that in our statute, whatever we're doing, if the feds change the terms, it's a violation of our amendment and that we're not obligated to be restricted to to live under whatever changes they would make it's a little bit of a technical change but it's very important in terms of legal implications and it clarifies that protection that's given to the state number four it puts into code what was the case anyway which is as representative payton has often mentioned protecting employers it specifically says that employee employers who have employees between the zero to 138 FPL range who participate in the exchange, by doing so, they do not subject their employers to a penalty. So in other words, if you read that Jackson-Hewitt report that said that the potential penalties for that 100 to 138 range, if we don't enact the private option, that was quantified at about $35 to $38 million in the first year, by enacting the private option, we are protecting the employers from that penalty or that tax. This clarifies that, puts it into law, and requires an acknowledgement from the part of HHS that those employers are protected from that penalty. So that was very significant. The fifth was a clarification about medical loss ratio and MLR. It just mirrored the requirements that were already in ACA that said that 80% of an insurer's money that it collects from premiums has to go back out and pay it in claims. It's just a little bit of protection for the consumer to ensure that the dollars that they're paying are actually paid back out in services and to providers to give them the access to the quality care that they deserve. Those were the five amendments. I would simply say that a lot of it is stuff that it didn't really change too much the framework and the goals of the bill, but it specifically outlines how we're going to get there, and I think that's a good thing because it just makes it a little bit clearer. All this was done in conjunction with HHS, DHS, the governor's office, and the legislature. There is nothing here that really changes the basic framework. It just outlines it and makes it a little bit more clear and offers a little bit more protection to the state. in the case of the federal government uh decides to say that this this cannot be enacted or change the terms with that i'll be
▶ Play
happy to answer any questions question for what purpose
▶ Play
you recognize representative burris you outlined five changes of the amendment kind of summarize those would you say these are substantive or material changes are they more or less minor changes that that They don't really do a whole
▶ Play
Speaker 10 3:59
lot to the bill. They're substantive. Representative Hammer, for what purpose? Question,
▶ Play
please. You recognize. I just want to clarify one point. This
▶ Play
is changing the substantive language, but not changing the appropriation. Is that correct? Yes, sir. This is the Implementation Act. Do you feel, given the fact that in order for us to bring this up during the fiscal session, and correct me if I'm wrong, we're going to have to have two-thirds vote of the body. So would there be any wisdom, do you think, in qualifying an amendment or creating an amendment to qualify this into the appropriation so it wouldn't take two-thirds vote to bring this up and discuss during
▶ Play
the fiscal session? Yeah, and it's a good question. You ask it in committee. Depending on your perspective, the good news is by passage of this act, the legislature has significant input in the way this plan is developed, implemented, and monitored. All of that's already in the bill. Now, to your specific point, I would say that, as I said in committee, given the attitude and the approach of the administration and the way that they've approached this appropriation and the fact that we're standing here having done what we've done, I think it's safe to assume that in order to get a three-fourths vote to renew an appropriation in the fiscal session they are willing to do whatever it takes it to make substantive changes to the bill if they need to be made and the good news is substantive changes to a bill in a fiscal session requires a two-thirds vote which is a little bit lower than a three-fourths votes that is required for an appropriation so if we need to make substantive changes to this bill in february when we're back in less than a year two-thirds of the body can make that determination And if two-thirds of the body feels that way, they can do it because that's what it takes to pass
▶ Play
that appropriation. But would we not lower the threshold of the ability to talk about by qualifying it into the appropriation and do an amendment? Wouldn't that take it down a little lower so we wouldn't have to have the two-thirds vote? I'm not sure I understand. Okay. Then let me ask you the second question, if I may. It would be my last question, if I may. As a legislator who maybe is not sitting on one of the committees that's going to be involved in the rulemaking process, At the end of the day, what control am I actually going to have over those rules if I'm not a member of one of those committees that the rules are going to be
▶ Play
promulgated through? Let me say two things, and the first is that, number one, and I hope that you all understand what I'm saying, is that I have as much invested interest as making sure this works as anybody. And if I've got my concerns, anybody that has their concerns, we're going to work with DHS throughout this entire process. And I've said them and I'll say it right here. It's kind of like the Godfather. If you'll ever watch, you know, there's a lot of a lot of good metaphors you could pull from that. But at one point, you know, well, never mind. But the point is, if I even feel like at a certain point, the spirit of this legislation isn't being honored, I'll be the first one to stand up, whether it's the summer or the fall and say, don't move forward with this. We're not moving forward. I'm not voting for this appropriation in the fiscal session. This thing's off. If I even feel like, if I just don't even like the way I feel like it's going, I'll be there. So the point is, that's a little bit more vague, and I'm not saying that that's necessarily a policy reason to vote for it, but we're going to be monitoring this every step of the way. There's protections in the bill that require that they submit any rules and regulations 30 days in advance before they're even promulgated. That's an enhancement of that process that gives the legislation more oversight. Specifically to you, as I've mentioned before, I've already used your committee that you're chairing in the interim as a little bit of a point to be made that the legislature, even though we adjourn, still has significant input in this entire process. If for no other reason we have governing ability in the interim, we have auditability in the interim, and most importantly, we're back here in less than a year approving appropriations again. I think the administration understands that and is willing to take the input. It's going to be our job to make sure we offer the input that they need to get this program implemented in the right way.
▶ Play
Speaker 21 8:23
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Harris, what purpose? You reckon it is? Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Burris, I mean, I think it would be an opinion if these were major changes or not. Sitting in public health, I just, as I'm getting questions and phone calls, Just in a short time, we've been able to read the amendment, and the public hasn't even had a chance to see it all that much. Would you, looking at it, just to clarify for the public that may be watching this live, this does not
▶ Play
Speaker 25 8:57
cap spending, is that correct? That's correct.
▶ Play
Okay, thank you. The legislature caps the spending. We are the appropriators. We've passed significant reform this session, including pilot programs in the Delta by Representative Ferguson and Representative Wardlaw, an office of Inspector General, a smart card verification program, Senators of Excellence, Payment Improvement Initiative. We've passed almost 10 reforms that I believe control the cost. I think we've put in place a program by requiring HSAs and different things on the private option that control the cost. And if it doesn't control the cost, we're back here in less than a year approving that appropriation that can. But it's our job to do that. We can't delegate that appropriation power or that governing responsibility to anybody else. It's up to the 100 people in this room and the 35 people on the other side.
▶ Play
Speaker 27 9:43
Can I have one more question? In all due respect,
▶ Play
since we were kind of held at bay today, I mean, wouldn't it have been a better amendment to maybe have made this more into a block grant to make it where there was a cap on spending? I would have been happy to
▶ Play
hear that in public health if you would have had it drafted. Well, maybe
▶ Play
I can do that and have it ready. Okay. All right. Thank you. Representative Meeks, for what purpose? You recognize? Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 31 10:09
Burris, again, you know, I appreciate all the work that you have done on the bill. But my question is, is now that there is no penalty at all for employers to going from the 100, I guess, to 138, is there any concern that you're going to have a dumping effect, meaning these employers will save money because they're not having to provide health care for their employees? employees they have zero penalty so they're going to dump them all into the private option which will basically exponentially increase our cost is there been any numbers or anything done on that to know what that might be yeah and i
▶ Play
think here's the the it's a good question and it's very real and i think it but the problem is it goes back to just some of the root problems in an ACA. You've already got in that law the incentivizing of employers to structure their payment or their employment or their employees around those requirements that are set out there. That's already there. So all we can do is by offering this private option is to allow to protect the employers in that bracket. But again, you've got the, you've got, if we didn't, if we didn't enact a private option, what you would have is a huge gap. You would have a huge gap between certain minimum wage and a little bit above employers because they don't want to cross that 100% marker because then they're in the penalty range. So you've got them keeping them below 100 by shifting hours, keeping wages low. They'll bring them in over 138 because the penalty still exists no matter what. And all you're doing is cutting out that very basic middle, low income, minimum wage, working class. This at least protects the employer in that regard. You've got a lot of incentives in ACA that would encourage employers to play games around the system. That's going to happen no matter what. This at least protects them in a certain respect, and I think levels of playing field in a lot
▶ Play
Speaker 31 12:06
of ways. Okay, but we don't have a number as the potential and the cost of that, and No, and
▶ Play
at the end of the day, as a conservative, I believe that labor is a market, and so I think if an employee is worth a wage, they're going to get it paid, and this is just a little bit of a protection for the employers in that 100 to 138 bracket.
▶ Play
Thank you. Seeing no other questions, I would appreciate it. I appreciate the question for a purpose. Two
▶ Play
short questions, please. Let's hear them. We recognize them. All right, sir. Is there a safeguard in this bill and the plan to
▶ Play
Speaker 39 12:47
keep, let's say, our neighbor states, don't pass it or whatever, to
▶ Play
keep people from coming in our state? There was a, in the actuarial analysis, there was a factor figured in for a migration effect. If we were to offer a benefit that maybe a neighboring state doesn't, that was factored into the cost on the analysis. But I'll just tell you briefly that I believe in the opposite effect. I think if you look around us and if we stabilize our state budget, we stabilize our health care system, employers are going to be able to come here knowing that they don't have a penalty. I think, not to mention with the regulatory and tax reform that we're putting into place, you might as well hang a sign on every entrance sign into the state of Arkansas that we're open for business. We're stable in our state budget. We're moving in the right direction in terms of regulation and taxes. And we're not going to raise your taxes because we've got a crisis in our Medicaid system. We're protected from all that. I'm more encouraged about the incentive that this bill creates for employers to come here and open businesses, knowing that they're protected from the chaos that other states around us are going to be seeing in their health care system. And
▶ Play
the second question is, I'm not saying this is a bad thing. This could be a good thing. Is this insurance option that we have on this private, Is it based on a captive insurance plan? I think, generally speaking, in
▶ Play
a lot of ways, it is. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Collins, what purpose? Question. You're right for us. Representative Burris, do these amendments address many of the concerns
▶ Play
that you heard throughout the debate in the House last week? Yeah. I think, generally speaking, a lot of the concerns were how is the state specifically protected in the legislation, and how do we have guarantees that we're going to get the waivers that we're requesting these amendments address both?
▶ Play
Representative Deffenbaugh, for what purpose? You recognize. Hang on
▶ Play
just a second, Representative Deffenbaugh. I'm sorry. Oh. I made John mad
▶ Play
last time. I think you're on now. You hear me? Yes, sir. There's plenty I don't understand. And we keep talking about we can just, you know, if things don't go like we want to, that we're just going to shut it down. And so, you know, the thing I've wanted all along is, let's say after a couple years, and we get 250,000 people, whether it's private option or Medicaid or a combination of both, and it doesn't go like we want to after two years, how are we going to tell them or what are we going to do? Are we just going to cut them off or say this is the Fed's problem now or, you know, what's up
▶ Play
with that? Yeah, it's a legitimate question very much so. We've got a renewal vote in three years that's required, which is when the 100 percent match is over. We don't just have to take – the default position is that the plan expires. And essentially three-fourths of this legislature, both chambers, has to renew it. But I think that, and again, I'd say that if the legislature chose not to renew it, then we're back at a lower Medicaid population than we are today. My hope is that it will work, people will get coverage, access the health care system in the right way, and we're going to produce long-term savings to the state and federal government by reforming the way that we approach our entitlement systems, and I think it's going to work. If it doesn't, frankly, from a budgetary standpoint, the state's better off. Alright. Seeing no other questions, I know how complicated this all is. You've all shown an incredible amount of patience. I know how tired you are of seeing me down here talking, very much so. And my hope was that I wouldn't be down here again. Point is, this is a good bill. It accomplishes a lot of what is a priority for members in terms of coverage, but it does it in a way that protects our state budget and I think provides the best quality of care for the consumers. And I'd appreciate another good vote on this bill as amended. Thank you.
▶ Play
Does anyone wish to speak against the motion? Representative Westrom, you recognize to speak
▶ Play
against the motion. thank you mr speaker members i do think this motion moves this legislation in the in a better direction but i've got two concerns and both of those concerns revolve around the issue of conflicting language if we have an appropriation with triggers based on the enabling legislation that has changed and the two don't match, my concern is which one, if either, rules if that's challenged in court. And I don't know that. Maybe one of the attorneys in here can address that. Would it nullify any triggers that we have in the enabling legislation if we've got a conflict in the appropriation? It is getting late. If we have conflicts in the appropriation, the enabling legislation. And then my second concern is more about the process and the way we've done things and the correct way to do that. We voted on an appropriation to fund a program after the enabling legislation was passed. Now we're talking about changing the enabling legislation after the appropriation has already been passed and not going back and changing the appropriation. I believe the right thing to do if this enabling legislation is amended is to amend the appropriation to match and clean up that issue and resolve any of these conflicting language problems. This would just allow members to have an up or down vote to fund or not to fund the program that is amended and the program that would be in place. So I think this amendment is moving in the right direction, but I'm going to have to vote against it because I believe it's going to create this conflict in the language. And I don't believe it's right if we don't go back and amend the appropriation after we amend the enabling legislation. So I'd encourage you to vote against it as well.
▶ Play
Does anyone wish to speak for the motion, against the motion? All right. Brimson Barrister has
▶ Play
a closer motion. I want to close because that was an important point, but I think it's also addressed. The special language on the appropriation outlines generally what these triggers are. They're the same triggers and concept that are in this enabling legislation. It doesn't say that they're not in conflict. One doesn't say that this podium is black and the other one says this podium is white. still lining out the clear goals. The legislation is going to be a little bit more specific on how we get there. But even beyond that, the legislation is the guiding force in this. The legislation clearly states that if all of these principles and tenets aren't met, then the act isn't implemented. And so all the protections and all the triggers are still there. There's not direct conflict between the special language and the bill that we'll eventually be voting on. One's a little bit more specific than the other, but they both state everything has to be met in order for the act to be implemented so there's no real conflict there and with that being said I'd appreciate a good vote on this
▶ Play
motion all right the question before the house adoption amendment number three to Senate bill 1020 prepare machine mr. clerk everyone voted is everyone voted is everyone voted cast the ballot 73 a 20 too many four yeas 22 nays and zero present amendments adopted read amendment number four amendment number four to senate
▶ Play
Speaker 56 20:52
bill 1020 represent burris you recognize i'm sorry this just adds the emergency
▶ Play
clause to it it was supposed to be on there anyway but got stripped out in one of the votes that we've taken, so this just adds back to the
▶ Play
emergency clause. Does anyone wish to speak against the motion, for the motion, not the question before the House, is the adoption of Amendment 4 to Senate Bill 1020, prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk? Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots for 73A, 23, and 0 present, and the amendment's adopted. Mr. Clerk, please send the bill to engrossing. Representative DeSteele recommends we concur and sit on Amendment 1 to House Bill 1901. Read Amendment 1, Mr. Clerk. Amendment 1 to House Bill 1901. Representative DeSteele, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, this is just
▶ Play
an amendment from a couple of major employers in Arkansas to make sure that inadvertent reception of this information is not in violation of the statute. Appreciate a good vote. Does anybody wish to
▶ Play
speak against the amendment for the amendment? If not, the question before the House, the adoption of the concurrence is in Amendment 1, House Bill 1901. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. cast the ballots 92 a zero 93 a zero name zero present you concur in the amendment representative steel recommend recommends we concur in senate amendment two to house bill 1901 read amendment number two mr clerk amendment number two to house bill 1901 and steel you recognize thank you mr speaker same
▶ Play
thing senate watered it down a little bit still a good bill appreciate Good vote. Does anyone wish to speak
▶ Play
against the amendment for the amendment? If not, the question before the House, the concurrence on Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1901. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots for 91 yeas, 0 nays, 0 present. You concurred in the amendment. Members, to give you kind of an update of where we are here before, we're going to continue down the calendar. we're waiting on house bill 1143 to come back from the senate at which time representative burris is going to have another public health meeting and then we're going to come back and vote on the bills as engrossed but until we get the bill back we're going to go ahead and go down the calendar a little bit i don't suspect it will be very long we're waiting on the senate to vote on the appropriation. I think it will be hopefully here in the next 15-20 minutes. Okay. Representative Edwards recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 19-21. Read Amendment 1, Mr. Clerk. Amendment 1 to House Bill 19-21. Representative Edwards, you recognize. This is an amendment by Senator Fowles that changes the
▶ Play
word private to comply with some constitutional provisions. Appreciate a good vote. Does
▶ Play
anyone who will speak against the amendment for the amendment? If not, the question for the House, So concurrence in Senate Amendment 1, House Bill 1921. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Is everyone voting? Is everyone voting? Cast the ballots for the 88-90-ay, 0-ay-0 present if you concur in the amendment. Representative Gillum recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1, House Bill 1962. Read Amendment 1, Mr. Clerk. Amendment 1, House Bill 1962. Representative Gillum, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Ladies and gentlemen,
▶ Play
this is the amendment that I told you I was going to add when it went to the Senate with the language that the judges had recommended be in this, and I would appreciate a good vote on this, and I'll explain on Amendment No. 2 what we did to undo Amendment No. 1 here in a minute, but it's a technical thing.
▶ Play
does anyone wish to speak against the amendment for the amendment if not the question before the house the adoption of the concurrence of Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1962 prepare the machine Mr. Clerk has everyone voted has everyone voted cast the ballots 90 a 0 9 0 present you concur in the amendment Representative Gillum recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1962 read amendment number 2 amendment number 2 to House Bill 1962 Representative Gill, let me recognize.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. All right, once we got the First Amendment on there, it turned out not everybody was happy with that one. So what we did with this amendment was we took out all the controversial stuff that everybody was upset about. So now what you have before you is an agreed-upon bill that everybody's happy with that hopefully will end this saga that I've had to deal with. So thank you very much for a
▶ Play
good vote. Does anyone wish to speak against the amendment for the amendment? the amendment. If not, the question before the House, the concurrence in Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1962. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 90 a, 0, 9, 0 present. You concurred in the amendment. Representative Hammer recommends we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 2283. Read Amendment 1. Amendment 1 to House Bill 2283. Representative Hammer, you recognize.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. All this does is add the Senate sponsor on the other end. We've already talked about this, cleared it out of here without any opposition. Appreciate a good vote to add the Senate sponsor on the other end. Thank you. Does
▶ Play
anyone wish to stick against the amendment for the amendment? If not, the question before the House is the adoption of Senate Amendment 1, the concurrence to Senate Amendment 1, House Bill 2283. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. cast the ballots 92 a 0 and a 0 present you concur the amendment Mr. Clerk, Passover, House Bill 20-04. Representative McLean, are you ready for Senate Bill 1100? Passover, Senate Bill 1100. Representative Deffenbaugh, are you ready for 1158? Mr. Clerk, read Senate Bill 1158. Senate Bill 1158, Senator Sanders, the Arkansas Concussion Protocol Act. Representative Deffenbaugh, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This is
▶ Play
something that I won't make too much light of it, but after looking out among the audience, and I know there's quite a few people that played football, Some of you have probably been hit in the head too many times, so I think this is a proper... But that's all the lightheartedness. This is a bill to develop protocol in head injuries. And as it is now, most schools will have a trainer that is on the job to overlook injuries. But anyway, let me, I just took this bill out of there, and I know what it's about, but just bear with me and make sure you know what's going on. This just is a requirement that a person operating a youth activity annually shall distribute a concussion and head injury form or sheet to each person who intends to participate in that activity. Okay, so there'll be a form. then that person shall not participate in their athletic activity unless the person returns the information sheet. If he or she is under 18 years of age and has to be signed by a parent or guardian, then the requirement that a youth athlete who is suspected of sustaining a concussion or has had an injury in a game or in practice shall be removed from the game and activity at that time. That athlete who's been removed shall not return to play until the athlete is examined by a licensed health care provider, trained in evaluation and management concussions, and receives a written clearance to return to play from the health care provider. So with that, I ask for a good vote. Thanks. Representative
▶ Play
Mayberry, for a purpose, you recognize.
▶ Play
Representative Deffenbaugh, with regards to youth athletic activity, can you help with an explanation or definition of exactly what I see in the bill? It says that it does not include a college or university activity or an activity that is incidental to a non-athletic program. Could you maybe explain a little bit more exactly what would qualify and
▶ Play
what would not qualify? qualify as? The best I understand, anything 7th through the 12th grade youth athletics. And as a matter of fact, I could be wrong, and this is bad to come up here, but I think if the school is supervising even third grade on up, any of those grades, let's say third grade on up are under that supervision
▶ Play
or under that this protocol. I asked this question in committee, but I'd like to follow up with it again today. Would this apply to such as like church youth programs, upward sports and things of that nature?
▶ Play
As far as I know, no. I'm not, I don't think the bill goes that far. Arkansas activity, Arkansas activity, whatever it is, AAA, and so they don't really have any say-so in church activities. Representative
▶ Play
Viviana, for a purpose. Question. You
▶ Play
recognize. Representative Deffenbaugh, I know at my son's school, this program already exists. Is it because it's voluntary on their part, and now we need to make it a law to make it mandatory for all
▶ Play
schools? Yeah, a lot of schools do this. I mean, like I said, even as far back as I, the last time I coached football was, I don't know, 2001 or something like that. We had an athletic trainer out there that would actually look into these kind of things, And that's just extended. But I think, whereas it was volunteer, now it's it's mandatory.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Kerr, for what purpose? You're right, can I ask? Representative Diffenbaugh, I'm a little curious. It seems to me they're going to be taking every child that bumps his head to the hospital. I mean, is this not going to create a situation
▶ Play
where it's overkill? Wrong choice of words, but just overdo it. Well, I guess you're going to have some, you know, authorities on the field or on the court. They might react. They might overreact. But I think generally it's a good – I mean, I know it's a good – After all, it's football. I mean, the whole point is the butt
▶ Play
heads with the other guys. I mean, but this is
▶ Play
what this is doing is just it's, you know, we got this NFL deal going. OK, I think that kind of pattern after that is, you know, years ago and like some of us, I was just kidding about playing. But when you had those old suspension helmets, you get your bell rung and you just you didn't know you made fun of the guy with his bell rung till he shook the cobwebs out, put him back in the game. I mean, this is really just to stop that. It's just to help kids, you know, keep from getting re-injured. That's one of the big problems is getting them. You know, you get a concussion, you get a second one, it can be
▶ Play
really dangerous. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Mayberry, for a purpose,
▶ Play
you recognize. Representative Deffenbaugh, I wholeheartedly agree with the intent behind the bill, but it does seem to be pretty broad scope. You had mentioned, and maybe I've misunderstood, but it sounded like you were saying this applies just with the schools because of the Arkansas Activities Association, but the bill says that it's the Department of Health that's going to develop these protocols based on something similar to what the AAA does to protect all youth athletes engaged in youth athletic activities in Arkansas. And to me, that sounds like that could be, you know, virtually anything, not just with regards to what we typically think of as violent sports or anything, and not just with regards to schools, that it is really a big open door.
▶ Play
Would you agree? Yeah, I think so. And I don't want to fake my way through this. I'm not positive if it reaches as far as you say. I just don't know. I just know anything like this is certainly going to help, even if it is 7 through 12. And I will try to look into it more and see, you know, if it goes farther than I think. So I ask for a good vote. Does anyone wish
▶ Play
to speak against the bill, for the bill, for the bill? Representative Gossett, you're recognized to speak
▶ Play
for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Unfortunately, I can very easily speak for this bill. This is a situation that is really under-recognized in Arkansas and across the nation. In my office back home, a young man was hit the first play of the football season, and last year he didn't get up. He'd had several minor concussions over the past few months. Nothing really bad, just had his bell rung. The doctors here at Children told him he was extremely fortunate that he wasn't dead. That once you've had multiple concussions, even if they're minor, It raises the chances greatly of death or disability. I know a lot of times we overreact, but there are times where we underreact. After I found out about this young man who was not able to come to school for the rest of that semester, he attended school half days the second semester, And even now, it's not the same young man that he was when this happened. What I've discovered since then is any number of young men who suffered these problems, thought they were over it. Only you don't completely get over it for a long time. I could give you an example of a young man who was a college football player at UCA. A straight-A student, 31, on the ACT, had had multiple concussions in high school, called his home his freshman year in college, crying. He was ready to commit suicide. It all related back to the concussions when he played football in high school. The problem is people do not recognize the seriousness of minor concussions in football. Minor concussions accumulate and can cost kids their life. any one of us have known great young men who have played football when they get out of school some of them turn to drugs and other things you know this was an epiphany for me when i started thinking about some of the young men back during my day who after they got out of high school did some things that were really odd and strange from the way that they were in high school and it dawned on me what i didn't know and i'm not going to say every one that had those turns later on in life were caused by this, but I have to suspect possibly it was. They do get depressed. They do change. They do have declining mental capabilities. I don't know what the extent of it really is, but to ask for parents to be notified of the potential problems and the things that you see when your child is having problems from concussions, let's face it, none of us are experts. We all want our boys to be tough. Get in there. That's part of the problem. It's a male sport dominated by male thought of knocking somebody's head off and being tough. You guys know I don't come down here very often. I don't know if this is a good bill or not, but it's a darn good idea.
▶ Play
Representative Mayberry, for a purpose you recognize.
▶ Play
Representative Gossage, I have tremendous respect for you coming down here and speaking to this, and I am in absolute agreement that this is a very serious issue that we need to look at closely. But in the examples that you gave, if I understood correctly, you're referring to young men who were participating in high school athletics, in high school football, which is already covered through the Arkansas Activities Association. The bill even recognizes that it's a recognized national leader in the development and implementation of concussion protocols for student athletes in grades 7 through 12. And so those individuals were already under the protocols that we're talking about here, or should have been anyway, should have been. Let me restate that. The AAA had already implemented these, and it should have applied to them. And it does apply on a go-forward basis to these kids who were playing football, who were in those grades 7 through 12. It's just that as I read this bill, it seems to be much more broad-scoped with regards to any kind of athletics or any kind of associated activity, whether it's violent or not, and it just seems to be just extremely broad. I'm sorry, that's not a
▶ Play
question. No, I don't want to drag this out forever, but basically, no, the AAA has instituted some rules. They are working with Dr. Naismith, who is the foremost authority in the nation. He works at UMS Children's Hospital, and he is the one that's helping formulate this. And I could go on for quite some time. There's a baseline test that every kid needs to take before he starts in contact sports, which actually gives you the level of functioning that they have so that if they get hit in the head, they retake the baseline exam, you can determine what their deterioration level is. once they've come back to the normal level, then they can play sports again. But it's not too broad. I think it does include other – it would be a wonderful thing for everybody to receive this information, and it's not requiring to do anything other than notify people of the seriousness of this situation. And, you know, I guess the worst thing would happen is somebody's going to have to get the forms, and believe me, they're online. It's a very – I've run them off myself for our own coaches. It's very simple. Every little league organization will have these like that. Parents are going to sign them. Great. Some places are really going to take this to heart. They're going to do a great job, and some kids are going to be better off for it. That's the worst that's going to happen is that we're going to help. But, I mean, I really don't see that much. I know we don't like to get involved and make people do things.
▶ Play
This is one time we need to. Thank you. Does anyone wish to speak against the bill or for the bill? Ripson Deffenbar, you close the bill. The question before the House is a passage of Senate Bill 1158. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 93A, 1, nay, and 0 present. You have passed the bill. Read Senate Bill 909. Senate Bill 909 by Senator Ingram to amend the eligibility
▶ Play
Speaker 106 43:02
requirements for the Workforce Improvement Grant Program. Representative Talley recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
Colleagues, I bring before you today Senate Bill 909. This deals with four two-year colleges participating in a pilot program that will allow students to work on obtaining both their GED and post-secondary technical certificates at the same time. This saves time, as you can imagine, and gets the people into the workforce more quickly. Because they don't have a GED yet, they're not eligible for financial aid. This bill makes technical corrections that allows these students to be eligible for the state's workforce improvement grants.
▶ Play
So we would appreciate a good vote. Does any of you who wish to speak against the bill, for the bill? Not the question before the House. Pass it to Senate Bill 909. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 91, yea, 0, nay, and 0. Present, you have passed the bill. Read Senate Bill 1050. Senate Bill 1050 by Senator Elliott to amend the Arkansas Code concerning Advisory Committee on Public School Academic Facility. Representative
▶ Play
Carnine, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This is a bill that's really quite, I think, one of those that we had in 2003 when this body entered into an agreement to assist in the actual maintenance and the building and all of the things that need to be actually completed in the facilities in the state and public schools. After a while that was disbanded after they had actually done their business. However, after 10 years, we are now back in the same situation of changes, much more technical. It's an advisory committee to the commission, which actually is voluntary. The engineering societies recommend people who would, in fact, serve on a voluntary basis to four-year terms as maximum in electrical engineering, civil engineering, architecture, technology. It's a good bill. It's reinstituted on the request of the Department of Education. Appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Does anyone wish to speak
▶ Play
against the bill, for the bill? Not to question before the House. Passes to Senate Bill 1050. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast the ballots. 77, yea. 6, 9, 0. President, you have passed the bill. reach Senate Bill 1115. Senate Bill 1115 for Senator Key to amend provisions of the Arkansas Code concerning cyberbullying of public school staff. Representative Klemmer, you're recognized. Members, I am,
▶ Play
thank you Mr. Speaker, I'm running this bill in the House for Senator key, and to be honest, deals with a problem that I wasn't sure we had here in Arkansas, but evidently it's happened in his area, and it's happening around the state, and that is that students are engaging in cyberbullying against teachers. They are creating fake websites, fake Facebook pages, and signing up for pornography under the teacher's name and potentially, I guess, engaging in some things that could be very harmful for teachers professionally because of what the kids probably think is a stunt. And this is 11-15, and I'll answer any questions I can, but I really honestly just got the bill a little bit ago.
▶ Play
Oh, boy, I get a lawyer question.
▶ Play
Nicholas, what purpose? You recognize. Going to be easy on you, does this cover college instructors like
▶ Play
yourself? Let me see. I was thinking that legislators might benefit from something like this too, but that was just a thought. School employee, a full or part-time kindergarten through grade 12. So we'd have to let the next legislative session keep us from being bullied. But by and large, I would say we're dealing with people over the age of 18. so many things that teach so many well the kids are under 18 for the most part that the teachers are dealing with making them potentially in a in a an abusive situation or you know their their professional character is frequently called on the line when it comes to the kids ripton williams for purpose what you should
▶ Play
recognize i'll do my best what penalty or
▶ Play
violation or fine are we imposing upon a young person who may be committing a prank? Hang
▶ Play
Speaker 126 48:39
on. A class A misdemeanor. Ripsome a hammer
▶ Play
for a purpose. You recognize? With regards to the way schools schools handle and their individual policies in dealing with cyberbullying such as that in nature, this wouldn't interfere with their ability to exercise discipline over that child. And in reality, couldn't it help give schools and school boards an opportunity to maybe go beyond their limitations by having a law such as this to help reinforce this problem or address this problem? I think I'm going to take an
▶ Play
answer that my attorney colleagues might like. I think that would be conjecture on my part to make that assumption. I mean, it seems like a logical thing, but I'm not going to be able to speak with authority on that.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Williams, for what purpose? You recognize. Ms. Clemmer, are you aware that
▶ Play
a Class A misdemeanor is up to one year in jail or a $1,000 fine for
▶ Play
a kid committing a prank against a student? I am more so now. I'd probably forgotten how long they could spend in jail. Cyberbullying is already a Class B misdemeanor, and this is saying cyberbullying of a school employee. As you know, though, it would depend on them being prosecuted as such. And I will say that for students that are engaging in this kind of behavior, again, they are risking the teacher's career, potentially putting the teacher at risk of being, again, perhaps charged with a crime of some sort themselves by signing them up for pornographic websites and mailers. I mean, there's a list of things on here. Thank you very much. I appreciate a good vote on behalf of Senator Key. Does anyone wish
▶ Play
to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Hammer, you're going to speak for the bill. You're recognized. Thank you.
▶ Play
Hey, I know it's late, and on a serious note, something about this subject we all need to be mindful of. I'm going to tell you, my wife is a public school teacher, and don't think for a minute that they are not the targets of kids who are younger than them. Some of them, and yes, I understand the far-reaching, perhaps, effects of this bill being K through 12, but also at the same time, there are 16-, 17-year-olds that are charged with crimes in an adult court. I just want to remind you of this one thing about this. It seems to me like last year or sometime in the recent history of this legislative body that we had to address an issue of this as far as student to student because kids were going out and killing themselves, committing suicide because of how other kids were cyberbullying them on the Internet. Kids don't care if they're 18 or not. Adults are just as important in this matter as are the kids. So I would just like us all to keep that in mind, too, if you would, please. Thank you for a good vote. Does anyone wish to speak
▶ Play
against the bill, for the bill? Representative Klammer,
▶ Play
you recognize close for your bill. Due to the advances in electronic technology, I was going to say that Senator Key texted me to say, be sure to mention that the school folks, I don't know who the school folks specifically are, but the school folks ask him to run that bill, ask him to file that bill. And
▶ Play
I'd appreciate a good vote. The question before the House is passage of Senate Bill 1115. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Council the ballots. 78, 6 and 81 present. You'll pass the bill. Reps. Burris, we are recognized for an announcement.
▶ Play
Okay, members, we are going to have a public health committee meeting in 30 minutes. That will be to concur on the amendments, and then we'll come back into session, do final passage on everything. It's kind of my understanding. But the committee shouldn't take too long because it's pretty similar to what's already been discussed. But that's the last final, I think close to the last final thing that needs to happen today. So public health
▶ Play
at 8.30. We'll stand in recess until 8.45.
▶ Play
Head off, everybody. I know 8.15 would be better. That's how long it takes to transmit the bill. So I understand it's 30 minutes from
▶ Play
now. That's how much time we need. They're grossing the bill. It's just taking a little time. I'm ready to. All right, but, hey, one last thing here. I've got a letter from the Senate requesting return of House Bill 1878. Whose bill is that? Is that okay? Leave granted to send House Bill 1878 back to the Senate? All right, Mr. Clerk. Send the bill to the Senate. Stay in a recess until 8. Oh. It's the only thing we've got on the calendar tomorrow. Can we just do it tomorrow? Is that okay? Okay. Hey, we'll take it up at 845. There's food back here. Give everybody about 30 minutes to at least give it up at 845.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB1020

0:00 - 22:07 73 segments 15 speakers

HB1901

22:07 - 24:09 7 segments 2 speakers

HB1921

24:09 - 24:44 3 segments 2 speakers

HB1962

24:44 - 26:24 5 segments 2 speakers

HB2283

26:24 - 28:10 5 segments 2 speakers

SB1158

28:10 - 42:59 43 segments 6 speakers

SB909

42:59 - 44:10 3 segments 3 speakers

SB1050

44:10 - 45:55 5 segments 2 speakers

SB1115

45:55 - 55:03 34 segments 7 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative John Burris Unverified
38 segments
Chair Unverified
47 segments
Representative Bruce Westerman Chair Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 10
1 segment
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 21
1 segment
Representative Justin T. Harris Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 25
1 segment
Speaker 27
1 segment
Speaker 31
3 segments
Representative John K. Hutchison Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 39
1 segment
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
1 segment
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 56
1 segment
Representative Nate Steel Unverified
2 segments
Representative John Charles Edwards Unverified
1 segment
Representative Jeremy Gillam Unverified
2 segments
Representative Andy Mayberry Unverified
7 segments
Representative Mark Biviano Unverified
2 segments
Representative Allen Kerr Unverified
2 segments
Representative Bill Gossage Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 106
1 segment
Representative Brent Talley Unverified
1 segment
Representative Les "Skip" Carnine Chair Unverified
4 segments
Representative Ann V. Clemmer Unverified
10 segments
Representative Darrin Williams Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 126
1 segment