House Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (7)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1203
· 7 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1203”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1245
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1245”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1227
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…work through today. Without objection, we're going to take House Bill 1227 by Representative Bell. First, Representative Bell, you're…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1197
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “We're passing over House Bill 1197 at the request of Representative Letting. House Bill 1208,…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1208
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…r House Bill 1197 at the request of Representative Letting. House Bill 1208, is Representative Gonzalez here? House Bill 1203, Represen…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1224
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1224”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1228
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1228”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
We're going to hopefully work through today. Without objection, we're going to take House Bill 1227 by Representative Bell. First, Representative Bell, you're recognized to present House Bill 1227. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate y'all letting me present this out of order. This is a bill that I'm bringing for my local sheriff's department. Many of you in border counties are probably going to find that your local sheriff's department should be appreciative of this also. Some are currently charging for these services, and if they get their legislative audit report, they're going to get dinged, depending on which legislative auditor they have.
It's kind of a subjective standard of enforcement on whether the legislative auditors write you up for charging for fingerprint services or not, because there currently is no authorization in law to charge for fingerprinting. The issue that particularly presents itself in the border counties on the western side of the state is Oklahoma charges a $35 fee, as I understand it, for fingerprinting. And so people who need fingerprinted for their job or for various other things in Oklahoma are coming to the Arkansas Sheriff's Department who aren't charging and really tying up a lot of their time.
um it's become a problem um i know it's polk county jail where they use the dispatcher as a jailer etc and it's really become a drain on resources so um allowing them to charge a reasonable fee um which we don't define in this um we uh we typically the ones who are charging charge a nominal fee already um but uh allowing them to charge a reasonable fee for those services will allow them to recoup something for the time of their people that are tied up,
in most cases, fingerprinting out-of-state people in the cases of the western border counties.
Representative Ferrari, recognize for a question. And this may be a crazy question, Chair. During the concealed carry, will you have to do the fingerprints? Does this increase the fee? It could.
You know, if a local sheriff's department wanted to charge a fee for doing the fingerprinting, it could. The state police doesn't currently, so they could always have the option of going to the state police and getting it done,
which is where, frankly, a lot of people do. I did. You know, they still would have a no-fee option if they had that opportunity. But, yeah, it potentially could. Okay. Thank you. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Bell,
just one quick question. I just want to make sure and I understand the intent of law and I like it, but I just want to make sure in regards to the state police that we're not creating an overflow for them because I don't think they charge. It's my understanding for fingerprinting and I just don't want them being bombarded with everybody avoiding paying a fee for this, overloading them because I know they're limited on their manpower and what they can do at those headquarters. And do you think that would create a problem for them?
Representative Tosh, I don't think it will create an overwhelming problem. If it does, I'll certainly be sitting right beside you trying to help correct it. I think the issue, from what I've heard, is state police aren't currently charging and they're not experiencing the overflow. If some of the county departments start charging a nominal fee, I don't think it's going to make people drive a long distance to go to a state police facility to get that done if they weren't currently doing it. It's an issue, particularly, like I say, with border counties, and where people on the Oklahoma side of the border in particular
may have a 50-mile drive to their county seat and they live 10 miles from the Arkansas county seat. They're just coming over because it's less expensive and it's also more convenient. And so just allowing these counties to collect some reasonable fee. Most of them are charging like $5. So they're not charging a lot of money, but it's just something to help recover the time that that dispatcher is spending or that jailer is spending printing that person.
Mr. Chairman, Representative Bell, just to make sure, if we realize it does become a problem for the state police from an overload, then we can always go back and, I guess, address this and include them in this bill. Is that correct? That's correct.
That's good enough. Thank you. Representative House, you recognize
for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bell, do you think the city councils and the quorum courts can limit the amount of fees charged under current
lists? This certainly doesn't preclude their ability to do that.
And, you know, political pressure is going to have a big impact on that fee. You know, like I say, most of them are charging a $5 fee currently, and I certainly don't think they're going to increase it as a result of this bill. The issue right now is you have subjective enforcement by different legislative auditors. Literally, Scott County, just to the north of Polk County, where I am, has a different legislative auditor than Polk County. They do this. They're currently charging, and they've never had a negative audit report. Polk County gets dinged every time because there's just no authorization in law, and they have an auditor who takes a stricter view of it.
So it's more than anything else. It's creating an entry for the legislative auditor so that the practice can be clarified. But, you know, yeah, you've got a point, But I don't think it's a huge concern. Seeing no other questions, no
one has signed up on the citizen's sign-up sheet. Representative Bell, are you closed for your bill? I am, Mr. Chair. Vice Chairman Wright, you're recognized for a motion. Do pass. We have a motion.
Do pass. Is there any discussion? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passed out of committee. Recommendation, do pass. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. All right, members. Without objection, we're going to drop down to House Bill 1245, and I will go to the end of the table to present that bill.
Mr. Chairman, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. House Bill 1245 is a bill that was brought to me by the Arkansas Bar Association. It actually is a uniform law, which many of you would be familiar with uniform laws. There's a national organization that puts together recommendations for these uniform laws that states can adopt to try and encourage some uniformity among various states
and also enact legislation that addresses issues that may be common from one state to another. This bill is entitled, well, it's actually the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act. What this bill does, in a nutshell, if there are co-owners of property and one owner wants to sell the property or divide the property, and the others don't, they can go to court and ask the judge to partition the property.
The judge can do that either by partitioning in kind, which means to actually make a physical division of the property, or depending on the request or depending on whether partitioning in kind may not be available, there may not be a means by which to divide property in such a way as to evenly divide it or fairly divide it, The judge could order it partitioned by way of sale, which in that event, the proceeds of the sale would be divided among the various owners of the property. This act would apply in those situations where you have owners of the property, at least 20% of the owners of the property are basically members of the same family.
So they could have inherited that property. It could be property that was owned by someone, by one of their ancestors that was never, that the title was never cleaned up. And the practical effect of this, this is a situation that I can, at least in my practice in South Arkansas, it's something that comes up relatively frequently. You have individuals who may, they have property that may have been acquired by their grandparents, their great-grandparents could have been acquired 100 years ago, and as generations pass, there's
been no probate proceedings, there's been no cleanup of the title, and so it may still be titled in one individual's name, but that individual has passed away, and you have various heirs who are co-owners, or even in the event that it has been handled through various legal channels, you have co-owners in the same family, and what can happen is you might have one individual who wants to sell the property, and you might have others who want to hold on to the property. They want to hold on to the family farm or hold on to land that they grew up on or land
that their family has owned for generations. And so in those circumstances, many times the individual who's wanting to partition has quite a bit of leverage over the others to try and force some type of compensation or allocation that's more favorable. This act would seek to remedy that. Basically, in the event that there is heir property, property that's owned by at least 20% of the same family, and one individual wants to partition, there would be basically an appraisal
or determination of value, and then that person's interest that's wanting to partition the property would be offered to the other heirs at that value. And so those other heirs, those other individuals could acquire that interest should they so desire. If they don't, then the partition would proceed forward. So this is, I think, a good bill that allows property to be retained by family members who so desire, but at the same time, it also acknowledges and respects the
property rights of the individual wanting to partition such that they get fair value for their interest as well so it just provides kind of another avenue an opportunity for those family members to have a say or have the opportunity to acquire the property before it's sold or divided additionally and with that with the chairman's permission I would ask that professor Lynn Foster who is the Arkansas Bar Foundation professor at the University of Arkansas Little Rock
Bowen School of Law. She is also one of these uniform law commissioners. She's a representative from the state of Arkansas to the body that passes these uniform laws or makes these recommendations and I'd ask that she join me here at the end of the table. She may have just a brief comment and then obviously we'd be glad to
answer any questions. Ms. Foster, you're recognized. Thank you. Thank you very much for the chance to be here this morning. I just wanted to thank Chairman Shepard for his very concise summary of the act.
I would point out that four states have already enacted this, even though it was not adopted all that long ago by the Uniform Law Commission. And right now, five states and the District of Columbia are considering it as well as we are. It has been endorsed by such diverse groups as the American Bar Association, the Arkansas Bar Association, the Council of State Governments, the Federation of Southern Cooperatives, and the American Planning Association, and that's just to name a few. So it has a very broad spectrum of support from all sorts of different groups.
I think the subtitle for this act could be possibly Save the Family Farm Act, so. Any questions? Representative Bain, you recognize for
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. If this law is enacted, and I'm a member of the family but I'm not actually a direct heir and I wanted to buy into that part of the partition would that be available if this law was passed could additional family members buy into a family farm because we you
may see families it may be in other words you may have some families that don't get along as well as others and some may not be heirs and some may be on the outside and if they wanted to buy back into their homestead where they they also grew up, would they have that option in this situation? It would only be the ones
that are existing heirs that would already have an existing claim. I believe that only those who legally owned shares in the property would have existing claims.
Now you could always try to make a deal with one of those people and purchase their share. So that would be an option available.
Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you very much for bringing this. My question, though, is really, is this an issue not already really being addressed under our current law? I've had several practitioners tell me that they are opposed because they feel like it's just adding another layer on top of what is already done to address these types of situations.
Thank you. I think that what it might do in some cases is add a little bit of time onto the process, but it ensures that the rights of all the heirs are taken into consideration, and it gives them every opportunity to preserve this wealth that's part of their family. We have an existing statute that is in force that actually says that if you're talking about a parcel that's more than 10 acres and someone who is not a family member
owns less than 50% of that, they have to wait for three years to ask for a partition. This statute would repeal that statute, so it actually frees up the ability to contract. But it gives the heirs just a little more more of an opportunity, more of due process, a little bit more court supervision of the process to make it fairer to them. And that
helps clear up things, but so basically it's a statute that favors the heirs, as in this situation they probably should be, but actually goes to perhaps the detriment of outside people who may want to bid in as far as time goes.
Possibly, yes, but if you're talking about a parcel of more than 10 acres, it will be a lot faster than what
we currently have in the books. And I think that it does favor those co-tenants, obviously, because it gives them that opportunity. But while at the same time, the determination of value ensures that the person who's wanting to have the property partition is getting fair value for their interest. So I think it strikes a balance of respecting each interest holder's rights in the property
while at the same time respecting that the property itself in all likelihood is family property that there may be some strong interest in trying to retain. Thank you. Representative
Rushing, you recognize for a question. Yeah, I just have a question on page 8 at the bottom, lines 33 through 36. In that statement, it basically says that the court will order an open market sale
and the parties no later than 10 days after the entry of the order and agree on a real estate broker license in the state to offer the property for sale. The court shall appoint the broker and establish a reasonable commission. I can understand the court appointing, from my business, I can understand the court appointing a broker because they may not always agree, but for the court to establish a reasonable commission, that is really the job of the real estate broker, and it's not the court's job.
Those commissions are determined by the real estate company and the individual brokers running those companies. I would
agree with that, except in this circumstance, the court is actually ordering the sale. So it's not a free market negotiation of selling the property. Obviously, I think, and it may already be the case, I'd have to look back as far as whether the court, I would assume the court would have oversight any time that the court is ordering the sale of property. but it's not going to be a situation, I don't think, where the court is going to force a real
estate agent to sell property at some kind of reduced rate. I think the court will, I mean, the reasonable standard would have to take into account, I think the court would take into account what the customary charges are, but I think that that needs to be in there because of the fact that you do have the court ordering the sale and ordering the parties to contract with that broker And that's what I think requires the court to have some oversight of that transaction. Thank you.
I'd say that the court shall establish a reasonable commission. So I think that that's another point. All right. Thank
you, Ms. Foster. It looks like somebody else has signed up to speak for the bill. Alyssa White? All right. Seeing no further questions, Representative Shepard, Do you want to close for your bill? You're closed for the bill. And I make a motion to pass. Got a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye.
All those opposed. Ayes have it. Congratulations. You passed your bill. All
right, members, we're going to go back up to the top of the agenda.
We're passing over House Bill 1197 at the request of Representative Letting. House Bill 1208, is Representative Gonzalez here? House Bill 1203, Representative Hammer. are you ready to present House Bill 1203 okay and for the benefit of the committee I understand some of the members have a an event that they need to attend at 1130 so I'm looking at trying to get as far as we can and then
wrap it up about 1115 representative hammer you're recognized present house bill 1203 and I understand we have how many amendments do we one amendment that you two amendments okay staff is telling me that the your first amendment has
been rolled into the second amendment as well so do you want to present the amendment to house bill 1203 thank you mr. chair
what the amendment simply does is add a sponsor who came to me and said that he wanted to be a sponsor on the bill so that's one thing representative ward law and then the other thing is the amendment addresses a concern that came up after the bill was originally filed from the Attorney General's office and I've tried to address that in the amendment and so I would respectfully ask that the amendment be approved so we
can discuss the bill in its
entirety with the amendment. Okay, so Representative Hammer has presented the amendment to House Bill 1203. Has it been loaded? We're going to hand out the hard copy of the amendment, and we'll take a minute
or so for the committee to look at it. Yes, ma'am. Thank you.
Okay, does everybody have a copy of the amendment?
I'll take that as a yes. All right, Representative Hammer has presented his amendment to House Bill 1203. What's the pleasure of the committee? Motion to accept, adopt the amendment. Okay, so we have a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor of adopting the amendment? Indicate by saying aye.
Aye. Any opposed? Okay, the amendment is adopted. Representative Hamler, you're now recognized to present House Bill 1203 as amended. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman, and as a former member of this committee last time around, I appreciate what's going to happen in here either way, just because I know it's a pretty sharp committee, and I appreciate the dialogue that will occur in advance. Basically, what this bill does is expand the definition or redefines the definition of what is referred to as curtilage, that area upon which a person can have the opportunity to defend themselves on their property
without being compelled for the duty to retreat. The motive behind the bill is this, that if you have legal interest, and we've introduced an amendment that I think brings a level of comfort to the Attorney General's office as far as what exactly is a person's legal right to a property as it was originally stated in the original context of the bill, to bring a little tighter definition to that. Just basically, if you've got a 40-acre track of property, you've got the right to defend yourself on that 40-acre track of property
without the gray area of when is it time that you have to have the duty to retreat versus being able to stand and protect yourself. So I'm trying to bring clarity to it, and I'm just going to stop right there, and I'll be glad to take any questions.
Representative Howes, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hamerson, this is deer camp too,
right? Yes, sir. In fact, that's one of the intents I had behind the bill because I'm a member of a large deer camp, so it would be a deer camp, duck club, or, you know, anything along that line.
The parts, the individual defending himself and his family, her family, has never caused me any concern. I'm not worried about that person. I'm worried about the assailant, if we'll call him, the suspect defendant. But being a bad shot and shooting one of my kids, I may be a great shot. I'm fair. But the other guy might be a bad shot and nail one of my kids. And so I'm always concerned about that duty to retreat,
not extending to the children that my two grandkids or four grandkids are with me. Any thoughts about that aspect of it? I'm not really sure where you're going.
I'll just speak my heart. Maybe that will get to it. If I'm in that kind of a position, first of all, I don't know that my young children in your scenario would be carrying a kind of weapon to defend themselves against a perpetrator. I'll use that term, the aggressor as referred to in the law. So, you know, I think the only thing more tragic than that situation taking place in the first place
is if in a split second I have to think, now, if I have to defend myself, am I the one that's going to go to prison because I had a duty to defend my family, which is a God-given right, and I want to be protected by a law, which is a man-given right, in order to be able to defend my family in that moment without that thought even flashing through my mind. And as we, I think, have seen in cases around the nation, the hesitancy or feeling more at ease that you have that right to defend yourself
is going to be greater enhanced by the
passage of this law. I agree. Everybody in this room, all reasonable people, they wouldn't be here. I'm worried about somebody thinking they don't have to, and rather than using good judgment to get the kids or get the family out of that situation because they no longer have a duty to retreat under law. I'm going to take my kids away from that situation if I possibly can.
How do we legislate good judgment? but that's what I'm worried about.
I think that we change our society in the way kids are raised, but when you have parents, that's a whole other bill. But, you know, I think that that falls to personal responsibility of the, and I'm going to say adult, in that situation that, excuse me, they have to make that choice, is it better for me to run or not. And my issue is duty retreat means you've got to turn your back
or you've got to be able to walk backwards while you confront the aggressor. I think the one thing that this bill will help enhance and provide is that if you decide to exercise that judgment that you need to retreat with your kids, which me personally, I'm going to do whatever I've got to do to get out of there later, but I want to know that I've got the law on my side, that I've got statute on my side, that if things go south, I'm not the one that's going to get charged with a crime because I wasn't the one that was the aggressor.
Hopefully, people will exercise good judgment regardless of whatever that is, retreat or at least be in a position to defend themselves. And I don't know how you legislate what you're asking, Representative House. Representative Broadway,
you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Hemmer, I think your bill is very well-intentioned, and I may be reading it over broadly, but I'm presuming that this would also go to if I owned a place of business or commercial property or whatever it might be that may have a lot of individuals that would be present.
And I'm concerned about subjecting those individuals to a dangerous situation, to collateral damage, if you will. Am I correct in my reading of the bill, and how do we address that? I think the way we address that is, in your comments, you say
that if you're the person that owns the property, say a business that has a lot of people there, I want to give you, as a lawmaker, every right to defend not only yourself but also everybody else that is in there against the aggressor who has come onto your property with ill will in mind to do harm
and give you the full coverage of the law that says that border to border you have the right to protect not only yourself but those other people that are there if you choose to do that. Right now, the way the law is, it is so vague that there's a question as to what limits you can do that. And I think that this bill is going to, as a property owner, give you greater ability to be able to protect yourself. Because at the end of the day, let's all, if we could please, all remember this. You're the legal property owner.
You've got the legal right to be there. This law is intended to give you greater protection to protect you, your family, or whoever you deem has the right to be there. And the people that are going to be the aggressors in this case, most times, are not going to be operating under a legal umbrella. They're there to do illegal activity, and we're handcuffing the legal citizens by not giving them this full right and
privilege afforded under this law that's being presented. If I may follow up However, are you taking away the right of an employee or someone that is there
That you may inadvertently shoot, kill, whatever From taking any action for the damage caused to them Well, I think as a property owner I have the
right to tell those employees that are concealed weapon permit carriers Or those that have legal right I think it's currently allowed under law that I, as the owner of the property, can give authority permission to whoever I want, and this bill doesn't change that at all. So that becomes the responsibility of the property owner to make that decision.
If it was me personally, and, I mean, this is just my own philosophy, if I've got a business and they come to me and they say, hey, I've got a concealed weapon permit and everything, I'm going to say, as long as you do what's right with it, that's fine. And again, I guess maybe it's just a difference of opinion is the way you look at it. The aggressor is the one that's coming on the property and that is going to be taking aim at those employees. At that point in time that that occurs, I want the property owner to be able to fully not only defend themselves,
but also those employees that may or may not have that concealed weapon. and whether or not he's a bad shot or she's a bad shot or not, I can't control that. All I can do is control by this bill, giving
them the full right to defend themselves. I may not be clear in my question. I'm just somewhat concerned about the employees that may not have a gun, and in your effort to defend them, accidentally shoot and kill one of them.
It seems to me that this law would take away any redress that the family would have if someone was killed or maimed in crossfire. We may just have to agree to disagree because I
don't see. You don't think your bill does that? Does
your bill do that or not, or do you know? No, I don't think
it does at all. In fact, if anything, I think it's a bill that allows the opportunity to get the bad person away from the crowd because now we are giving somebody the legal full right
that border to border of their property, they can put a shield between them and the employees, well, between the employees and the bad person by removing the cloud of, well, I can go up to this point, but if I go beyond that, it's a different set of rules. And that's what I see this bill is doing is pushing, giving greater opportunity to push that person away from the employees in your scenario and giving them a greater right to defend them. Thank you. Thank you.
Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. There's a couple of questions. Is that okay? Representative Hammer, thank you for your bill. Number one, the background of this intent, who proposed this effort to be placed in the policy, or is this just something that you personally have a desire to see changed or expanded? Well, I've not been
asked to run this bill on anybody's behalf. This has been on my mind for a while. And I thank you for bringing that question up because I do want to point out this is not a full-blown stand-your-ground law such as has been controversial in the state of Florida.
And I stopped at the point that I did because, quite honestly, I don't want to fight that other fight. I want to get it down to where if you're a property owner, you've got that legal right on property which you have legal interest in. And I'm a property owner. You know, I'm a member of a really large deer camp. So I have seen, not personally, but I want to be in a position that if I am put in that situation, I don't want to have to worry about if I defend myself, am I going to go to prison
because the closeness of the curtilage defined in the current law is going to be used against me because bad guys don't care whether you're standing inside that curtilage or not. If they've got intent
to harm you, they're going to hurt you. Good point. And my follow-ups, you mentioned stand your ground, but before we go there, is there any statistics from crime or justice system around cases that relate to people intruding on deer camps? I've talked to a few representatives that have deer camps,
and people trespass on their property from time to time, but they don't take their guns out with the intent to shoot those trespassers. So are there cases of this that are at some height that has caused a problem in our state that deems this
policy necessary? I think that there's probably been cases, maybe not necessarily on the deer camp, that would probably have benefited from this law being in place to ask me to call any of those up specifically. I couldn't, but as a lawmaker, this is my philosophy, my attitude, right or wrong.
If we can get something in place to prevent and to give private property owners greater protection, why should we have to wait until after the worst event happens before we put a good law on the books to give them greater protection
to keep it from happening? Last question. You mentioned stand your ground, and as you well know, that open carry, other gun-related instances are going to come up this session. Across the hall, they're taking up guns on our campuses and having the legal right to carry anywhere there. If we get to the point that Stand Your Ground is before us,
wouldn't one eliminate the other? I don't
know that it would or not, and I don't want to cast a net, but I think a Stand Your Ground law may be a little harder to get through in the state of Arkansas than this. And really what this boils down to is we're talking about people that have legal right to be on their property, and that's what this bill focuses on.
And if it's your property, in my opinion, you ought to have the right to defend yourself in the event somebody comes on your property to aggressively do you harm without the cloudiness of the way the law is currently written. I
agree, and, you know, where I'm from, I'm just fearful to Representative Broadway's point. Like, you know, I see a lot of young men without any license to carry. And in any instance, it could be a real harsh shootout, in my opinion, if this went bad and were on somebody's property.
So I respect where you're going with it, but I just need to get some clarity. Thank you. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. May I respond to that, Mr. Chair, real quick? Briefly, yes. Always remember, please, at the end of the day, the law-abiding citizen has the right to be there and the other guys don't. we should not inhibit somebody from being able to defend themselves because for a split second, when seconds count, something flashes through their mind that if I defend myself, I may be the one going to prison, which that has been the case in the nation in a few cases.
Thank you. Thank you. I have a few questions, and some of these may be, they may end up being poor questions, but I'm just looking at the amendment which we just got and I'm not sure well I mean I'll ask the questions you can respond to them number one a person has a possessory property interest we've used the example of a deer club or a hunting club if as I understand this if that hunting club is
incorporated which many of them have started to do then the individual actually does not have a possessory property interest and so I'm I guess my concern is the language possessory property interest and whether that is in some instances too broad and in other instances maybe it may be not as far as you intend for it to go and so how would you respond to that yeah I could see the issue coming up that a
business if you're incorporated or have formed an LLC even though it may be a single member LLC a single member single shareholder corporation you individually actually have no possessory property interest in in property of the LLC or corporation so how would you respond to the to that question I'm just looking for some clarification make sure I understand what was really intended And what was
intended was that, in the way the language was originally written, that
there was an example given as, okay, I know that I'm in line to inherit my family's farm, but the event hasn't occurred that I've actually inherited it, but the will shows that I do. So do I have a right, legal right, to be on that property, you know, with those other standing? I'm not a lawyer, okay? I'm just telling you, okay? And so it was suggested that in order to tighten that up to make it current privilege or current right that you have the privilege now to be on that property that this would be the term
that could cover that. And I would answer the question also by saying that whoever it is that has legal right to that property also has the rights to say you can carry your weapon on this land or you cannot and it and it falls back on whoever is the legal property owner to do that just like if you walk into a business and says no firearms here but that's my response right or wrong right but i
don't think that the fact that the property owner says you can carry on the premises that
would not provide a defense i mean the the defense currently is that if you're in your dwelling or your curtilage uh your bill changes that i do like i think that the original term property interest was ambiguous. I think that probably you've moved in the right direction. I just am concerned that if you're given consent to go on to someone's property or your family's property or your company's property,
that is not necessarily a possessory property interest. And then my second question is, might this actually erode the law to some degree with regard to individuals who don't own the home or residence in which they live? Because we're striking, we would be striking the language referring to dwelling and replacing it with a possessory property interest.
you could have an individual where you have family members who reside and dwell but don't possess or own the property. And so that's why I'm saying I've got concerns kind of on both ends of the spectrum. How would you respond? I would be afraid that replacing dwelling with possessory property interest, we may actually create some ambiguity for individuals in their own dwelling
as to whether they are in fact entitled to use deadly force without the duty to retreat. I
would respond this way and say that what I sense out of the committees at this moment is there's a majority that feel that the bill is in the right intent, and if it's a matter of terminology that we need to change in order to address those issues that you may have, especially to the lawyers that are on this committee that I'd be agreeable to work with you to get that right terminology as long as the intent
of what I want to see happen that is to give that person that has the legal right to be on that property the ability to defend themselves to the extent of the property line and I'd be agreeable to that however the chair after those questions are answered.
Well I mean ultimately it would be your call as to whether you want to pull it down and have further discussions, and I don't know what the sense of the committee is, and some of these questions may be questions that could be resolved after
some time to reflect on the amendment. Those are just a couple questions that I had based on reviewing this here over the last few minutes. Why don't we go ahead and take these questions, and you can make a determination as to whether you want to proceed or pull it down. Representative Whitaker, you recognize for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think you may have touched on something that concerned me because I, and no discredit to you, Representative, because lay people do this all the time and in common language we all say things like this.
You continue to refer to the property owner. The truth is, related to what Mr. Chairman said, a possessory interest can be what we call a leasehold as well. So I can rent a place and get a possessory property interest in it. during that term of that lease and under the terms of the lease. Ponder for a moment the conflict that might raise if the owner, the person that holds what we call in the law the freehold,
has conflicting views of gun ownership on his property than the person who has a valid legal lease. And for a moment, think this landlord did not have the presence of mind to put that in the lease that I don't want people possessing guns on my property. Your bill, as the language you're using here, that possessory property interest, would be granting that lessee, the person leasing the apartment or house or business
or whatever you call it, warehouse, anything you want, would also have the right to avail them under this law, under your proposal, no matter what the property owner felt. Do you see what I'm
saying there, and how would you address that? I'd address it by saying this. If the chairman wants to flush out any other questions around the committee, if it boils down to a question of this term, I'll pull the bill down and we'll get to the comfort level because, again, I sense that the committee is agreeable to this,
but the issue that's been raised with the use of this term, I can work back, and when we come back through, Maybe it will be a short process to get it through and address that issue if I'm reading heads right. Thank you. That's your call. Do you
want to pull it down? I want to pull
it down, but if there are any other questions other than
that one. I've got two more. Representative Bennett, do you have an additional question? Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I understand the intent of what you're trying to do. I have a couple, you know, we lawyers always think of the worst case scenario. Let's say I have a box at the races, okay? I have a possessory interest in that box at the races. I have a date. my ex-boyfriend shows up and my new boyfriend thinks that he might be about to do damage to me or do some kind of physical
violence, whether or not he has a history. Can my new boyfriend now
but you see what my concern is I understand
the deer camp I understand some of the issues but but when we start extending I'm worried about the deletion of curtilage too because in a lease situation a lot of times you don't get the parking lot you don't get the area around you, and that's a concern, but even more, we're now extending it, and we run into this problem in a number of areas of law when whether what you do is criminal or illegal is based on your reasonable belief, and it's really easy to come up and say, gosh, I reasonably
believed that that guy that was headed my direction looked scary.
Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question.
My life's not nearly as exciting as Representative Bennett's, but Representative Hammer, and again, that was my concern about someone that was leasing a property, and that's been well established.
Wouldn't it, and I have, in fact, I got a call from a constituent as I was walking in who has the opposite concerns about her children. She's a minority living in a, you know, all-white neighborhood, to be quite honest, and has concerns there. So I'm very much for people being able to protect themselves. But I also understand we've had some horrible tragedies happen. But really, with the Constitution giving us the right to protect ourselves,
wouldn't the ultimate property be ourselves? And that kind of solved all this. If each individual had that right and we could find that balance between protecting the ultimate property ourselves and our children and everybody else, and find that to Representative Bennett's about that reasonable finding some language that really and truly makes it where you're really under a threat. But the ultimate property, I believe, to protect is the individual,
and I believe that's what the Constitution gives us. Would that be the ultimate, our personal selves would be the property? That way we clear up all this, do you lease, do you have the parking lot, not, et cetera. I think I know
where you're going, and I would say I would agree with you, yes, and I think this is a step in that right direction. And, Mr. Chairman, unless
you have any other questions? Okay. That's all the questions we have, and as I understand it, you would desire to pull it down?
What I'd like to do, Mr. Chairman, is pull the bill
down, and I'll work on the terminology to get to the comfort level. I think that I sense that everybody has around the table, and I'll bring it back in, and hopefully when I come back in we'll be able to focus on that one issue and move
the bill out of committee. Okay, without objection, we're going to allow Representative Hammer to pull the bill down. It will stay on the regular agenda. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Hammer. Thank you, Representative Hammer. Committee members. Next on the agenda, House Bill 1224.
Representative Boyd, you're recognized to present your bill. Representative
Boyd, you're recognized. Mr. Chair, thank you. Committee members, thank you for the opportunity to
be here. Is your mic on, Representative Boyd? It
is. This bill is, as it currently reads, in just Fort Smith District Court.
So it's, my understanding is not talking about any other court except Fort Smith District Court. The way the current language is, it reads in a way that implies that there will be one clerk for each of the three district judges. This bill clarifies that there really is one clerk, which is the current practice. So it's been reviewed by the judges. This is what they've asked me to bring, and so that's what it is.
Are there any questions? no questions anybody representative gray you got a question you're recognized you got a motion at the proper time any other questions see no other questions what's the motion got a motion do pass all those in favor say aye all those opposed ayes have it congratulations you've passed your bill
out of committee thank you all right we're continuing down the agenda house bill 1228 and members i'll remind you we're going to wrap this up at 1115
as a courtesy to some of our committee members that have another engagement at 1130. And Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to go to the end of the table and present your bill. We may end up, we have several signed up. This may be something we'll have to get as far as we can and then take it up, pick back up on Tuesday. But I want to give everybody a heads up before we begin this, and I've talked with Representative Ballinger about that as well.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm going to be short and respect everybody's time. This is a bill that I know there are new people on the committee, but this is a bill that actually is very similar to one that was ran.
in 2011 actually passed out of this committee passed out of the house and then one that was ran in in 2013 that was passed out of the senate and and of course the senate committee and then actually died here after a roll call so my hope is that a lot of people have been exposed to the bill and they understand it but i'll give you a brief history of it essentially before 1990 the law in the united states of america was if you're going to fringe on a person's religious freedoms what you had to do is prove that you that in your infringing on the person's religious
freedom that you had a compelling governmental interest and that you're what the activity that the government was doing was the least restrictive means possible so essentially from 1960 to 2000 or to 1990 that was the law in the united states well what happened the attorneys on this uh on this panel on this committee will will understand this phrase and a lot of other people were well too is bad facts make bad laws well you had a bad set of facts that went before the supreme court and i think the supreme court may have made a bad decision that degraded the the the protection
of religious liberty essentially what they said is instead of it being least restrictive means compelling state interests and least restrictive means it had to basically be a neutral law that is applied actively to everybody so the situation at that um a lot of people in agreement in fact all of Congress almost voted unanimously to pass the federal RFRA. Originally, federal RFRA applied to any federal law and any state law. It just basically was an attempt to put the compelling governmental interests and least restrictive means back into the law.
So essentially what they were doing was trying to create that heightened scrutiny again. Well, it took just a few years before the Supreme Court ruled that the federal RFRA, as applied to the states is unconstitutional, ruled that on a federalism grounds, basically said the federal government doesn't have the right to create additional rights within the states. So in that ruling, they said the states can do it, but the federal government can't do it. So what happened after that, for a number of years, states started passing state
reference. Either it happened through their constitution in places like Alabama, or it happen through through legislation just like we're trying to do right now and so or actually in some of the states the the Supreme Court essentially created a heightened scrutiny a strict scrutiny and essentially created it so as of right now there are 38 states that have a heightened scrutiny that essentially put it back to the standard it was prior to 1990 so essentially that's kind of the background of where we are and we're wanting to do the same thing essentially
We feel like the First Amendment right is one of our first rights. Our religious rights is something that's inalienable. That is, if government has any legitimate function, this is one of the things that we ought to be doing as a government, is protecting people's religious liberties. And I just don't see how we can argue that it's not our job as legislators to find ways to protect people's religious freedoms. Now, having said that, before I start going through the bill, let me give you a little bit of understanding of how this is actually being applied different places. and the reality is it's actually not night and day it's not you know this bill is not actually
creating havoc anywhere essentially it's been mentioned somewhere around 200 times in different court cases in different states majority of the time it's it's been um prisoners who have claimed it and the cases are thrown out in this case this refer actually doesn't apply to to prisoners and department of corrections or department community corrections so that that part of it is is not applicable, where it actually has been used recently, and it has created, in fact, I think the members of the committee got some concerns with the bill, and one of the concerns they have
is a municipal burden, and it has actually caused municipalities to have to overturn their ordinances, but these ordinances that's happened recently, they're ordinances that prohibited the feeding of homeless people, and so the church said, listen, that's part of our deeply held religious beliefs. We have a right to feed homeless people. And so, you know, the state doesn't have the right, the city doesn't have the right to pass an ordinance that prohibits us from doing it. And so they've overturned those ordinances and allowed the churches, the ministries to continue to feed homeless people. So that is the municipal burden that's mentioned here. And so that is
basically the only place that it's actually been applicable to really make an impact in the last several years. But what it does do and the impact that it does have is it causes state actors when they either pass an ordinance or when they engage in policy from a governmental standpoint to take into consideration whether or not their action is going to infringe on someone's religious liberties, which is I think exactly what should happen. I'm going to go ahead and go through the
bill real quickly and just kind of let you know what it does. The first part of the bill, like many, is the legislative intent. I kept that short just because frankly most of the time it doesn't matter. But one thing I did want to point out is on paragraph 3 in the legislative intent is we have Article 2 of our State Constitution. And if you all haven't read Article 2 of the State Constitution, it is wonderful. It's great. But Article 2 of the State Constitution, Section 24 says, states that there is no human authority that can in any case or any manner whatsoever control or interfere with the right of
conscience and that's all we're doing essentially here is is implementing not interpreting the Constitution but we're essentially implementing state law that it would be consistent with our state Constitution all right under the definitions there may be some things that we'll have to come back to in questioning but for the most part most of it I think is is pretty much pretty standard one thing I do want to point out that we in that case we do in paragraph 9 we define state action and the reason why I want to interpret I want you to point that out is because it becomes important to the content of the
bill all these do but in particular state action does if you come on down to the next next section it's really kind of the meat of the bill it's what actually now implements the heightened scrutiny the strict scrutiny standard and it says a state action so make sure you point that out that you notice that a state action shall not burden the person's right to exercise religion and And they come down here and it says, unless, you know, you can, you have the right to do it if there's a compelling governmental interest. And there's some things that have already been interpreted in the Constitution, U.S. Constitution, and in the state Constitution, like protecting the interests of a child.
That is a compelling governmental interest. If you've got to take a child out of a home because he's being abused, there's a compelling governmental interest. So there's nothing in here that gives a right for a person to rape a child. That's actually foolishness. And one of the things I want to point out is, by the way, 38 other states already have a heightened scrutiny. And this isn't, none of those things are happening in other states. We don't have a plague in Alabama because of the fact that they have a, I mean, it just, it's not a reality. The next thing is that it has to have a compelling governmental interest. And then the plan has got to be the least restrictive.
So there may be a thousand different ways that you can accomplish this governmental, this, you know, your compelling governmental interest. But what you need to do is you need to pick the four or five that doesn't hurt a person's religious liberties. okay then if you go on down one thing i do want to point out because it has provided some confusion and this area it has provided some confusion to to the business industry because what they're worried about is whether or not a private individual who is an employee of a private
company would have the right to then sue the private company if you infringe your religious liberties and the answer to that is yes absolutely you do under the federal constitution but not under this refer because this refer requires state action so it's the first has to be a state action has got to be some sort of ordinance passed state law passed there has to be some sort of you know policy set by the state before you ever have the right to to file a lawsuit what this says is that if there's an ordinance passed that says you know it that that a individual has has the you
know some sort of absurd thing that you know an individual has a right to discriminate against Muslims because the fact that they're Muslims and that that ordinance itself would create the state action that a Muslim who's discriminated against would be able to use this riffraff they were terminated or if they were being being fined in some way it would provide that defense in that situation and then we have the exemptions on here that I talked about department Corrections community Corrections and then the emergency clause which you all are familiar with and I would be happy to take any questions of course I'd like to get this thing done today if it's possible that may not be possible I do understand people have come to speak on this and I
I don't want to cut off the public from having that opportunity to speak, but I
would be happy to answer any questions. Representative Drown,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just have one question. Sure. In regards to, because I'm not a lawyer, and you had mentioned compelling governmental interest. Is that set in stone, what is governmental interest, or is there something that could be interpreted to undermine this bill in the future? The answer is yes.
There's something that, I mean, it depends on how the courts define and change what compelling governmental interest is. That's a little bit difficult because there's a lot of case law on it. So compelling governmental interest is something that is fairly well established under case law. So if it was to be some sort of new absurd thing that they could interpret to make it where this bill had no effect, it's possible. Laws are degraded all the time. So that may be possible in the future.
But this is the best way. This is the highest scrutiny that we can put
on it, essentially. Representative Bennett, you recognize
for a question? Has right of conscience been defined? Well, actually,
within this bill, I don't think that we actually define the right of conscience. What we deal with is what the government really has the ability to work with, and that's more the action. So it gives the ability for a person within their conscience to carry out their religion as they see fit
or to carry out whatever their deeply held religious beliefs,
which is defined. Follow-up, and thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, I guess, again, my concern is we're putting terminology in there without a definition, and I know there's, vaguely at the back of my mind, there's some kind of right of conscious bill for health care practitioners or something like that. I just didn't want the terminology to be unclear.
And that's a good point, but if you notice, Ms. Bennett, within the content of the bill, we really don't deal with that. So we're not defining what, and we're actually not even working with conscious essentially What we're dealing with is what is well-established, actually, and been dealt with over and over again, is the standard that has to be met before you infringe on a person's religious practices. Representative
Copeland, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Representative Ballinger. Thank you, Chairman. And I don't know how else to ask this because I'm not a lawyer, so I don't understand a lot of what's going on here. So let me just put it in my world, and maybe this will help at least me as a non-lawyer. I'm a minister. We have all different types of situations at our church. I'm approached on a regular basis about conducting marriages. I've even thought about opening a wedding chapel.
And I've had this happen because we have homosexual couples come to our church. We have unmarried couples living together, coming to the church. And let's just say in this bill that a homosexual couple comes to me, they're there almost every Sunday, and asks me to marry them. In good conscience, according to the scripture, I can't marry them. And, you know, I'll try to give them all the advice I can give them, but in good conscience I cannot marry them and won't.
and then conversely the couple that's living together they left their spouses for no biblical reason they want to get married in good conscience i can't marry them so it's not about homosexuality or or you know heterosexuality it's about scripture for me personally i'm not imposing on anybody else here just on me so does this protect me i opened my wedding chapel not at our church but a private business and i want to do that but now i'm encumbered because i have to
marry both of them what does this do for me or does it do anything for me
in that in that instance the answer is currently it does nothing for you um the the reasoning for that is you talk about two private entities now under current arkansas law you know there's no protected class for the individuals who want to marry each other there's no protected class for the people who were cohabitating who want to split up, you have your absolute right. Now, where it would be some benefit is if there wasn't an ordinance
that had been passed that said you have no choice but to do that. If you do that you're discriminating against some protected class, then the RIFRA would provide some defense for you if you're saying this was a deeply held religious belief there would be provision for that. But currently there's no obligation for you to do that. In fact, currently under the article of law you're not allowed to marry same-sex couples so so it would not it would not um apply to you currently the the question is in the future how would that work if i may follow up if uh and already asked the
chairman so if if this uh so what i hear you saying is if i open my wedding chapel at this moment before this law um i'm already protected but if if the entity or the municipality that i've moved into, had an ordinance that I had to marry heterosexual couples that didn't have the right to remarry, or I had to marry anybody that wanted to get married for any reason, this protects me. It would
provide you a defense, so you'd be able to defend yourself based on the RFRA.
Right. Thank you so much. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. But is it, would that sort
of ordinance even be allowed to be passed? Yes, it would, and it has. So that recently in Fayetteville, the exact ordinance had passed. Now, your question, I think, goes to whether or not. To perform a marriage? Actually, yes, ma'am. That's the ordinance 119 in Fayetteville would have done that.
If homosexual marriage or marriage of transvestites or whatever were legal in the state of Arkansas, it would have done that. Now, the reality is right now that's not where we're at, and I don't think that would be a problem, and that ordinance doesn't exist. So, you know, I would hope that that wouldn't be an issue. All
right. I don't see no further. Well, Representative Talley. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. But would this keep the actual city council from passing that ordinance?
Would it protect – I mean, would it – they could still move forward with this, but it
would just give the citizens the right to go – That's correct. It wouldn't prohibit that. It just gives – all we're dealing with here is the rights to religious protection of citizens. So if that ordinance is passed, then at that point the person, if they're infringed on or they will be infringed on, they can say, I have a defense by virtue of the Conscious Protection Act saying that I have the right to do this. And there is the – once again, they've got to – it's got to be consistent with the deeply held religious beliefs.
So it couldn't just be arbitrary. Representative
Whitaker, you're recognized for a question Thank you, Mr. Chair Representative, if you could please cite specific examples where city or county ordinances in the state of Arkansas have directly infringed upon the religious rights of Arkansans that were not already protected by the First Amendment
Okay, there may be situations
that I could actually point directly to if I had done some research. And I'm going to tell you that there are because that happens inadvertently. Occasionally that happens. So I'm sure there's lots of cities that said, oh, no, we have a rule against people wearing their hat inside city offices, but a person who's an Orthodox Jew and wants to wear their yarmulke on Holy Days, they're being prohibited. Constitutionally, actually, the First Amendment wouldn't protect that because if it's generally a rule against wearing a hat,
it's broadly construed but what you could do is most of the time hopefully they'd come back and they'd back off that rule sure that's happened, that's the way things go. Now we may be visiting and you may be asking more important about the ordinance 119 I can't say that that's ever happened because of the fact that the ordinance
was stayed before it really got in effect. And not in particular, usually when we bring legislation because there's been some history of persecution. And I'm just wanting to hear some specific instances where
Arkansans were persecuted for their religious beliefs by cities or counties. I would say
that actually isn't the most often we don't bring legislation because people are being persecuted. We usually bring legislation because we feel like policy could be shaped in a better direction. And, you know, I think that the right of conscience, the religious liberties are important and should be protected. And that's consistent with the Constitution of Arkansas. So that's really why this this is being brought. And what I'd say is that what this would do is make it where that city before they pass that ordinance saying you can't wear your hats would take into consideration,
okay, we have a significant Jewish, Orthodox Jewish population that could affect them. And then that ordinance will never be put into place. Thank you. Representative
House, you're recognized for a question. Representative Boundary, just
as I'm sitting here with these four ladies and if i get permission from the lady that lives in my house and we really feel religious about it can can we get married now uh under this law well are you're currently married
i only have five you only have five no no i'm sorry you i'm sorry you could not because there's already been it's already been adjudicated a compelling state interest to to provide one one family and you know one husband and wife a couple so now the issue is that could change in the future, and if that changes, especially by virtue of the Supreme Court decision, then the RFRA would have no application. So essentially, this does not apply to that situation. There may be other problems that come to lead to that, but the RFRA will have no problem with that. We're getting religion
over here, and we really feel deeply about it. You can see
the smiles on your face. No, it still wouldn't apply because you have a compelling governmental interest to protect that. I'm sorry,
ladies. Thank you. Representative Bain, you
recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I kind of had some concern last time this came through about potentially opening up new causes of actions for cults or other people who may be a religion of one. They may be the only one that has that view, that belief. And I'm reading the definition
on exercise of religion, and I'm concerned about this. It talks about whether or not the exercise is compulsory or central to a larger system of religious belief so I'm wondering how far off the beaten path religiously someone could be and bring a cause of action saying that you know you're violating I'm just wondering how far on that slippery slope we're getting with
it we're not changing we're actually using language consistent with Supreme Court decisions now so deeply out of religious belief there's a whole lot of different indicators that are taken into consideration. You know, is there written rules? Do you attend it regularly?
How does it manifest itself in your life? You've got to prove that it's truly a conviction in order to do it. So all that is an area of law that's not
really being touched by this bill. Representative Gray,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I've received several emails regarding this subject. Most of them are in opposition to this bill. One of the things that stands out in every email that I've received,
does this create a situation where it can be claimed that ordinary interactions with the government, such as paying taxes, registering to vote, attending a public school, could be modified to meet the demands of the individual group because of risk of litigation? No, no, it wouldn't.
You realize what we're doing is bringing it back up to the standard it was prior to 1990. So prior to 1990, there weren't groups that were getting exempted from paying taxes. There weren't groups that were getting exempted for anything because of the fact that you had to prove a compelling governmental interest.
All that case law is already there saying you have a compelling governmental interest to collect taxes. That's already in place. So the reality is all of that is, you know, red here and trying to avoid it. I mean, the reality, there are some people who, one, they like the idea of the religious liberty being degraded and being pushed down, and then there's other people who are completely honest, and they're representing their entities, their agency, and the reality is this, in some very small way, ties their hand from engaging in any behavior that would violate
on someone's religious practices, and so because of that, they're representing their interest to keep make their job easier i don't like it i think it's wrong but but it seems like they're really reaching with some things that just don't make
sense and that's that's one of them frankly okay committee i've got one more question down here uh represent petty and then uh my my plan is to adjourn we've had a lot of members who have had to leave for a prior commitment and And we'll pick back up on this bill Tuesday at our regular meeting.
Speaker 146
1:16:06
Representative Petty. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Gray addressed the question that I had. Chair, I
would make a motion, if that's all right, to set this for special order of business, if you don't mind, on Tuesday, if we can do that, so that we can be sure that we address this directly, so that if anyone comes back, they can make
sure they're here. Okay. Okay, well, without objection, we'll set it for a special order, 10 o'clock Tuesday, and obviously that will be the first thing we take up.
Okay, thank you very much. Okay. Seeing no further business without objection, we're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1227
HB1245
HB1203
HB1224
HB1228
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair
Unverified
Representative Nate Bell
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Joe Farrer
Unverified
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Speaker 15
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Representative John Baine
Unverified
Representative Mary Broadaway
Unverified
Representative Laurie Rushing Chair
Unverified
Representative Marshall Wright Chair
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 68
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Speaker 54
Speaker 106
Speaker 107
Representative Donnie Copeland
Unverified
Representative Justin Boyd
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative R. Trevor Drown
Unverified
Representative Brent Talley
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Speaker 146