Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

February 25, 2015

February 25, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (38)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1133 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1133”
Pre-2017 bill
SB59 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB59”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1015 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HR1015”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1020 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HR1020”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1013 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ures from the regular session of the 90th General Assembly. House Bill 1013 is Act 159, House Bill 1044 is Act 160, House Bill 1072 is…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1075 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1075”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1082 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…mmittee on City, County, Local Affairs, to whom is referred House Bill 1082, beg leave to report that we have had the same under consid…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1109 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1109”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1137 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1137”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1174 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1174”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1183 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…res from the regular session for the 90th General Assembly. House Bill 1183 is Act 187. Sincerely, Asa Hutchinson. Mr. Speaker, this is…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1207 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1207”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1274 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…tate agencies and governmental affairs to whom was referred House Bill 1274 beg leave to report that we have had the same under conside…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1281 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…re committed on insurance and commerce to whom was referred House Bill 1281. Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consid…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1289 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “House Bill 1289 is Act 172. House Bill 1294 is Act 173. House Bill 1295 is…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1290 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1290”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1292 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “All right, at this time, members concerning House Bill 1292, Representative Letting moves that we re-refer this bill ba…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1297 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ures from the regular session of the 90th General Assembly. House Bill 1297 is Act 202. House Bill 1299 is Act 203. House Bill 1300 is…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1315 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “referred House Bill 1315, House Bill 1404, House Bill 1417, House Resolution 1026, a…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1321 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1321”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1330 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1330”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1346 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…gular bills at this time mr. clerk we're going to pass over house bill 1346 for today let's proceed down to house”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1348 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “House Bill 1348 is Act 217. Sincerely, Asa Hutchinson. All right.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1369 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…committing on aging children and youth to whom is refilled House Bill 1369 and House Bill 1389. Beg leave to report that we have had t…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1379 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…. Speaker, we are commuting on Agri to whom was referred to House Bill 1379. I beg leave to report that we have had the same under cons…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1385 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…your Committee on City, County, Local, to whom was referred House Bill 1385, House Bill 1418, and House Bill 1438, beg leave to report…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1389 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…children and youth to whom is refilled House Bill 1369 and House Bill 1389. Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consid…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1399 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…. Speaker, we are commuting on Agri to whom was referred to House Bill 1399 and Senate Bill 233. Beg leave to report that we have had t…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1404 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “referred House Bill 1315, House Bill 1404, House Bill 1417, House Resolution 1026, and House Memorial…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1417 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “referred House Bill 1315, House Bill 1404, House Bill 1417, House Resolution 1026, and House Memorial Resolution 1003.…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1418 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…City, County, Local, to whom was referred House Bill 1385, House Bill 1418, and House Bill 1438, beg leave to report that we have had…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1438 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…to whom was referred House Bill 1385, House Bill 1418, and House Bill 1438, beg leave to report that we have had the same under consid…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1026 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “referred House Bill 1315, House Bill 1404, House Bill 1417, House Resolution 1026, and House Memorial Resolution 1003. Beg leave to report th…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB195 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB195”
Pre-2017 bill
SB223 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…mmittee on City, County, Local Affairs, to whom is referred Senate Bill 223, beg leave to report that we have had the same under consid…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB233 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…mmuting on Agri to whom was referred to House Bill 1399 and Senate Bill 233. Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consid…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB310 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…tate agencies and governmental affairs to whom was referred senate bill 310 beg leave to report we've had the same under consideration…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB314 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “rules to whom was referred Senate Bill 314. Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consid…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
The House will be called to order at this time. I invite the members, staff, press, and guests in the galleries to stand and be led in prayer by Representative Donnie Copeland and remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance
▶ Play
to be led by Representative Greg Letting. Let us pray. Heavenly Father, thank you so much for each and every one that is here. Thank you for your mercy and your goodness to us, for your protective hand. And I thank you, Heavenly Father, that you have given us righteous men and women. Your word tells us that if the righteous are in authority, the people rejoice, but when the wicked beareth rule, the people mourn. So help us to stay righteous, to stay pure before you, and to make decisions that are for the betterment of our state and our nation. Continue to keep your hand upon everyone throughout this day and as they travel this evening. In Jesus' name we pray. Everyone say
▶ Play
Speaker 7 1:17
amen. Amen. Let the allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for
▶ Play
all alright members let's indicate our presence by pushing our yellow present buttons
▶ Play
Speaker 11 1:47
prepare the machine Mr. Clerk McGill,
▶ Play
Speaker 13 2:01
McGill, McGill, Representative McGill, Scott, Sue,
▶ Play
Speaker 14 2:10
Scott, Sue, Scott, Sue, Scott.
▶ Play
All right, let's cast at the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 98 present, the chair sees a quorum. Representative Letting, for what purpose? Leave for Representative Wright. Is leave granted for Representative Wright? All right, leave is granted,
▶ Play
Speaker 18 2:45
so noted. Representative Cozart? Leave for Representative
▶ Play
Charlene Fyke. All right, is leave granted for Representative Charlene Fyke? All right, so noted. All right, Representative John Vines moves at this time that we dispense with reading the previous day's journal. Without objection? So ordered. Are there any reports from select committees? All right, please read the reports, Mr. Clerk. Mr. Speaker, we are a committee on House
▶ Play
rules to whom was referred Senate Bill 314. Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration and herewith return the same with the recommendation that it do pass. Respectfully submitted, John Vines, Chair.
▶ Play
Are there any reports from standing committees? All right, please read the reports, Mr. Clerk. Mr. Speaker,
▶ Play
we are committing on aging children and youth to whom is refilled House Bill 1369 and House Bill 1389. Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration and herewith return the same with recommendation to that due pass. Respectfully submitted, George McGill, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we, your Committee on City, County, Local, to whom was referred House Bill 1385, House Bill 1418, and House Bill 1438, beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration and herewith return the same with recommendation that it do pass. Respectfully submitted, Betty Overby, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are your committee on City, County, Local Affairs, to whom is referred House Bill 1082, beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration, and herewith return the same with recommendation that it do pass with Amendment No. 1. Respectfully submitted, Betty Overbeat, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are your committee on City, County, Local Affairs, to whom is referred Senate Bill 223, beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration, and herewith return the same with recommendation that it do pass Amendment No. 1. Mr. Speaker we your committee on state agencies and governmental affairs to whom was referred House Bill 1274 beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration here with return the same with the recommendation that do pass submitted number one respectfully submitted Nate Bell Chair Mr. Speaker we your committee on state agencies and governmental affairs to whom was referred senate bill 310 beg leave to report we've had the same under consideration here with return the same with the recommendation that it do pass respectfully submitted, Nate Bell, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are committed on insurance and commerce to whom was referred House Bill 1315, House Bill 1404, House Bill 1417, House Resolution 1026, and House Memorial Resolution 1003. Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration and herewith return the same with the recommendation that I do pass. Respectfully submitted, Charlie Collins, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are committed on insurance and commerce to whom was referred House Bill 1281. Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration and herewith return the same with the recommendation that do pass as amended. Number two, respectfully submitted, Charlie Collins, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are commuting on Agri to whom was referred to House Bill 1399 and Senate Bill 233. Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration and herewith return the same with the recommendation that do pass. Respectfully submitted, Dan Douglas, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are commuting on Agri to whom was referred to House Bill 1379. I beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration. Herewith return the same with recommendations that do pass as amended number one. Respectfully submitted, Dan Douglas, Chair.
▶ Play
All right, is there any unfinished business? Are there any executive communications? Please read the letters
▶ Play
from the governor, Mr. Clerk. Mr. Speaker, this is for me. I'm met on February 23, 2015. I approved the following measures from the regular session of the 90th General Assembly. House Bill 1013 is Act 159, House Bill 1044 is Act 160, House Bill 1072 is Act 161, House Bill 1116 is Act 162, House Bill 1227 is Act 163, House Bill 1235 is Act 164, House Bill 1247 is Act 165, House Bill 1258 is Act 166, House Bill 1267 is Act 167, House Bill 1285 is Act 168, House Bill 1268 is Act 169, House Bill 1287 is Act 170, House Bill 1288 is Act 171, House Bill 1289 is Act 172. House Bill 1294 is Act 173. House Bill 1295 is Act 174. House Bill 1296 is Act 175. House Bill 1310 is Act 176. House Bill 1323 is Act 177. House Bill 1324 is Act 178. House Bill 1325 is Act 179. House Bill 1326 is Act 180. House Bill 1327 is Act 181. House Bill 1328 is Act 182. House Bill 1329 is Act 183. House Bill 1331 is Act 184. House Bill 1332 is Act 185. Sincerely, Asa Hutchinson. Thanks. Mr. Speaker, this is to inform you that on February 24, 2015, I approve the following measures from the regular session for the 90th General Assembly. House Bill 1183 is Act 187. Sincerely, Asa Hutchinson. Mr. Speaker, this is to inform you that on February 25, 2015, I approve the following measures from the regular session of the 90th General Assembly. House Bill 1297 is Act 202. House Bill 1299 is Act 203. House Bill 1300 is Act 204. House Bill 1301 is Act 205. House Bill 1302 is Act 206. House Bill 1304 is Act 207. House Bill 1333 is Act 208. House Bill 1334 is Act 209. House Bill 1335 is Act 210. House Bill 1336 is Act 211. House Bill 1337 is Act 212. House Bill 1338 is Act 213. House Bill 1314 is Act 214. House Bill 1341 is Act 215. House Bill 1342 is Act 216. House Bill 1348 is Act 217. Sincerely, Asa Hutchinson. All right.
▶ Play
Members, we're going to move to the red calendar at this time. Mr. Clerk, would you please read House Resolution 1015? House Resolution 1015 by Representative Ratliff, recognizing National FFA Week. Representative Ratliff, you're recognized to present
▶ Play
your resolution. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In 1917, FFA was formed in Virginia, the first state. since then every state in the union has ffa which is future farmers of america some of you may have degrees in ffa some of you probably had ffa this is a worthwhile project there's 208 chapters in the state of arkansas there's over 14 000 members in ffa in the state as of today the leadership skills that they learn in these classes is unbelievably done a great job for all these folks and you've seen we had uh uh senator malik's daughter here that day she's one of the first lady officers that we have from arkansas so we have a lot of great leadership skills being taught to our kids so we want to be sure and and recognize us this week is national ffa week and
▶ Play
mr speaker i'd like for the radius resolution please mr clerk would you please read the read the
▶ Play
resolution whereas the national ffa organization ffa and agricultural education provide a strong foundation for the youth of america and the future of our food fiber and natural resources systems and whereas the arkansas ffa association officers and the National FFA organization officers provide leadership to the members of the inspiring and encouraging members to achieve premier leadership, personal growth, and career success. And whereas the Arkansas FFA Association currently has 14,041 members with 207 local chapters and 248 advisors. And where agricultural education and the FFA ensure a steady supply of young professionals to meet the growing demands in the science, business, and technology of agriculture, and whereas the FFA motto, learning to do, doing to learn, earning to live, living to serve, gives direction of purpose to these students who take an active role in succeeding in agricultural education, and whereas the FFA promotes citizenship, volunteerism, patriotism, and cooperation, and whereas National FFA Week is celebrated February 21 through February 28, 2015, now therefore be it resolved by the House of Representatives of the 90th General Assembly of the state of Arkansas that the House of Representatives recognizes the importance and positive work of the National FFA Organization, commends the Arkansas FFA Association officers and the National FFA Organization officers for their leadership, and recognizes February 21st through February 28th, 2015 as National FFA Week. Be it further resolved that upon the adoption of this resolution, an appropriate copy will be provided to the Arkansas FFA Association and the National FFA Organization by the Chief Clerk of the House
▶ Play
of Representatives. all right members representative ratliff has explained the resolution would anyone like to speak against the resolution or the resolution representative ratliff has indicated he is closed for his resolution so this time the question before the house the passage of house resolution 1015 all in favor say aye all opposed say no all right the ayes have it mr
▶ Play
clerk please read house resolution 1020 house resolution 1020 by representative bragg to recognize and celebrate forestry day at the capitol
▶ Play
sponsored by the arkansas forestry association on february 25th 2015 representative bragg you're recognized
▶ Play
to present your resolution thank you mr speaker uh colleagues as you've looked outside there's nothing more beautiful than a snow-covered forest and we enjoy the beauty of nature and and what we see outside and today is is forestry day at the state capitol and i hope you've had a chance to go by and see the displays and pick up some of the the trees that have been made available it is a day to recognize the the importance of the forest industry to the economy of arkansas there's over 50,000 direct and indirect jobs provided in our state. Almost 400 million dollars have been returned to landowners through the sale of their timber and so you know it's it's just a critical part of our economy that we're celebrating today. I would like to thank the state nursery that provided trees and also Arborgen that provided trees and hope many of you were able to get those trees. So I would like to also recognize a few A few members from the forestry community, Max Braswell in our gallery is Executive Vice President of AFA, and Joe Fox, our state forester. And Mr. Speaker, I'd ask you to have the clerk
▶ Play
read the resolution. Mr. Clerk, please read the resolution. whereas since 1947 the Arkansas
▶ Play
Forestry Association has served as the voice of forestry in the state's entire forestry community and whereas there are 18.8 million acres of forest land in Arkansas covering more than 55 percent of the state which provided which provide unparalleled scenic beauty whereas since 2008 the state has a net increase of 327,300 acres of forest land in Arkansas forest owners plant more than 68 million seedlings every year and whereas private non-industrial landowners are 58% of the state's forests. Forest product companies own 15%. United States Forest Service land is 13%, and 6% is held by other public entities. And whereas Arkansas forests provide more than 5,000 products, we depend on every day. And whereas forestry's added value contribution to the state's economy is $3.2 billion. And whereas forest products industry supports 24,736 direct jobs, 27,640 indirect jobs, and Arkansas families depend on the $1.38 billion in direct wages provided by the forest products industry. And whereas forests in Arkansas support habitat for more than 600 species of wildlife and fish, and the state's forest landowners manage their land to promote, protect, and enhance in habitat for threatened and endangered species. And whereas the Arkansas's forested stands are diverse in their makeup, 41% oak and hickory, 30% loblolly and shortleaf pine, 11% oak, gum, and cypress, 11% oak and pine, 5% elm, ash, and cottonwood, and 2% other forest types. and whereas timber harvesters and forest landowners follow voluntary best management practices that protect soil and water quality, whereas the state's abundant forest resources have provided important economic and environmental benefits to the state and nation since the 1880s. Now, therefore, be it resolved by the House of Representatives, by the 90th General Assembly of the state of Arkansas, that the House of Representatives recognizes and celebrates Forestry Day at the Arkansas State Capitol Building, sponsored by the Arkansas Forestry Association on February 25th, 2015, and be it further resolved that upon its adoption, a copy of the resolution will be presented to Arkansas Forestry Association President Pete Pretzman of Kingwood Forestry Services by the Chief Clerk of the House of Representatives. Thank you, and I appreciate
▶ Play
a good vote. All right, Representative Bragg has explained the resolution. Would anyone like to speak against the resolution for the resolution? Representative Bragg, are you closed for the resolution? All right, Representative Bragg has closed. The question before the House the passage of house resolution 1020 all in favor say aye all opposed say no all right the ayes have it all right that concludes the morning hour members we're going to move into the regular bills at this time mr. clerk we're going to pass over house bill 1346 for today let's proceed down to house
▶ Play
bill 1133 House Bill 1133 by Representative Balz to create a program for licensure of community paramedics
▶ Play
Representative Balz, you're recognized and present your bill Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Speaker Colleagues, what we're introducing today is is a bill that is going to try to help folks that fall through the cracks that need medical assistance and try to get them to help without readmission into hospitals i'm running house bill 1133 on behalf of the american ambulance association as with any scope of practice change there there are always many interested parties and arkansas ambulance association has worked with numerous groups to try to make this acceptable with everybody it does not affect home health it does not affect any of these folks what what this does if a person goes to the er and they're sent home the ambulance company can then go and take an ambulance out to their house two or three days later they can check on them they can check their blood pressure they can make sure they're taking their meds and if they need to go back and see their doctor they can be taken back to their doctor at that point in time and it saves ambulance runs they can they just make sure that they're getting the care after care that they need that they're not getting if they're not a member of home health is what it amounts to community paramedics is a growing and numerous in areas around the country and many of these areas especially rural areas have proved to be very good tool in reducing the readmission at your hospitals working within the scope of practice for a paramedic baxter regional medical center is has done this pilot program something very similar to this and already has seen success in their er readmissions success and reduction in their er readmissions as with the success of a pilot program that brought this need for additional licensure to the attention of the Arkansas Ambulance Association I'll answer any questions at this time and would anybody has
▶ Play
anything representative Stephen Meeks for what purpose a question please you're
▶ Play
recognized thank you mr. speaker I appreciate you staying down there for questions I'm very intrigued by this idea the one question that I have is who covers the cost of
▶ Play
this program how's that handled actually what Baxter Regional Medical Center has found a savings because when they when a patient comes back in they don't get reimbursed for that so it's saving them money for them to go out it'll be done by possibly local grants or something like that if there ever is a cost but it's right now they're just realizing the savings to their rural hospital and they're saving money doing this okay so this is a
▶ Play
program that the local hospitals initiating and they're covering the cost for and the what the idea that it will reduce costs and save
▶ Play
money for yes exactly all right sounds good thank you thank
▶ Play
Speaker 57 20:17
you mr. speaker Representative De La Rosa, for what purpose? You're recognized to ask your question. Why is additional licensing required to administer this? Why couldn't just a regular licensed
▶ Play
paramedic administer this program? The license of a regular paramedic, the only way they can treat anybody right now is if they're dispatched to them. And it has to be through a 911 call. This extra license, they get additional training. It costs the same as the regular license that a paramedic gets, but it's some additional training that they will elect to take if they so desire. And it doesn't cost anything more than that, but it gets them for both fields is what it does. Did that answer your question? Okay. Representative Johnson, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 59 21:03
Question. You're recognized, sir. How many other states have
▶ Play
a similar program, do you know? I couldn't tell you that exactly. I do know that the ambulance association and the private ambulance services and everybody has brought this back from other states. So there is other states doing it at
▶ Play
this time. Representative Gonzalez, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 61 21:29
I still don't understand who is going to cover the cost. Are the hospitals just going to send these ambulance out and not bill these people?
▶ Play
well that's that's what is being done in baxter county at this time because it's a hospital-owned ambulance service and they are actually when if they have a patient that goes to the hospital and they're seen and they're sent home and then within two days they come back and the ambulance has to go back for a 911 call and get them they can't bill for that service so they're actually saving money by sending that ambulance out to check on them and not have to give service for that person that's coming back in.
▶ Play
Did that help? Okay. Representative Charlotte Douglas, for what purpose? Question. You're
▶ Play
Speaker 64 22:18
recognized. What is the difference between us sending the paramedics back out and us having that assigned to home health or some of those agencies that do that on a
▶ Play
regular basis? Some of these folks aren't qualified for home health. They don't qualify for it. So it it these are the ones that are falling through the cracks is the ones we're going to take
▶ Play
care of representative hammer for what purpose question please you're recognized representative bolts is a big part of this bill the fact that it establishes and allows for the licensure which is going to add an additional 300 hours so if like in my case I work for Celine Memorial we have our own ambulance service they could go out there and do it and probably have that skill level set now to a degree. but this bill is actually going to create the licensure and the criteria that would allow them to do that without being dispatched through the 911 call. Is that a correct summation? Yes, sir, you are correct. Okay. Follow-up, Mr. Speaker? You recognize to ask for follow-up. And with regards to the cost or the savings, they're not going to be able to, like, and I'll just say bill Medicare, Medicaid, private insurance or anything like that, where their savings is going to come in is if they're part of the medical home group, for example, and they can reduce those rates or return visits to the ER, they're saving money maybe not in that they're able to bill, but indirectly through keeping their readmittance rate low. Is that a fair statement? You're exactly correct. All right. Thank you. All right, Representative Baltz has
▶ Play
explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Baltz has indicated he's closed for his bill. The question before the House is the passage of House Bill 1133. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Passed up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 91 yea, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed. All right, at this time, members concerning House Bill 1292, Representative Letting moves that we re-refer this bill back to committee. Without objection, so ordered. Mr. Clerk, let's read Senate Bill 59, please. Senate
▶ Play
Bill 59 by Senator Hutchinson to require the Arkansas State Claims Commission to provide specific findings and facts and conclusions of law to support the final adjudication for a consideration by the commission.
▶ Play
Representative Shepard, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 59. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, Senate Bill 59 is a bill sponsored by Senator Hutchinson, and he has asked that I run it on the floor today. This bill provides for the preparation of findings of fact and conclusions of law by the Arkansas State Claims Commission in cases in which a claim is dismissed or finally adjudicated on the merits. This bill passed out of the Senate by a large margin. I believe it was 31 to nothing. Senator Hutchinson advises that the Claims Commission is agreeable to this legislation. Really, the intent behind this legislation is, and many in the House have served on the Claims Subcommittee, but it's my understanding that when a claim is dismissed and appealed, or if it's finally adjudicated and it's passed on to the legislature for review, that the Claims Commission would make the file available, but many times there's not particular information on why the Claims Commission reached a decision, and so this simply provides information that assists the subcommittee and by extension the legislature in reviewing those items and making an educated determination on appeal or in reviewing the determinations made by the Claims Commission. I would point out that this, one of the ways in which this could be accomplished is oftentimes in the Claims Commission there's a claimant's attorney involved and then there's an attorney for the state agency or the state entity that's involved. So what the Claims Commission could do is they could simply ask the attorney for the prevailing side to prepare this paperwork for the Claims Commission to sign off on and provide that to the legislature. I'll be glad to answer any
▶ Play
questions. Representative Jean, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized.
▶ Play
Representative Shepard, Claims Committee is not a court. This bill seems to be put in some type of judicial proceedings, what it looks like, just to the average person. I'm not a lawyer would you answer those concerns
▶ Play
I guess in what way do you feel that this is being we're making it like a court I'm not I'm not following the question per se well
▶ Play
the getting the the attorneys to come in and and double check by law the state is not obligated to do anything because of our tour that's
▶ Play
that's correct yes the state has sovereign immunity we essentially only make ourselves available to claims by way of the claims commission and ultimately those claims that are adjudicated have to come before the general assembly for final approval of any payment or settlement that might be made in those cases you know i think one thing i guess if the question is in regard to to findings of fact and conclusions of law, it's true that those terms oftentimes are used in court proceedings. But essentially, I think as Senator Hutchinson stated in committee, ultimately what this bill does is provide a summary of what did the Claims Commission determine to be the actual facts. Why did they reach that conclusion? With regard to the conclusions of law, that's just a short statement of, we find this way because we believe that this agency breached this particular provision or statute. Or on the other hand, we find that there's no fault. This should be dismissed. There was no claim. There was a failure to state a claim in this case because we don't find any fault. We don't find where any agency acted inappropriately or in a negligent fashion. So I don't really, while I hear the question, I don't really see it as making this any more like a judicial process. It's just simply providing a summary, is what I really look at it as, a summary that allows the claims commission or allows the legislature to make an informed decision. I think two years ago or four years ago, there were several cases that came through the claims commission that were very controversial. There were a lot of emotions on both sides of the issues. and oftentimes reflecting back to that legislators want to know well why did the claims commission find this way you know instead of dismissing it or finding for a particular amount well how did they reach that conclusion and so that just provides us an additional tool ultimately it's our call I mean that claims subcommittee and and the legislature as a whole ultimately that's our call but this just provides a tool to understand why did the claims commission reach this as this result it doesn't bind us in any way it just provides for the for them to to provide that follow-up you recognize
▶ Play
for your follow-up when we adopt this Senate bill 59 will it cause more cost more money to run claims or less or the same more money for
▶ Play
who for the state of Arkansas I don't I don't see it costing more money because I think this is a fairly minor thing that if the Claims Commission prepared it themselves, I think it's a fairly minor provision for them to comply with. And as I said, what they may do is they may say to the prevailing attorney, they may say, Mr. Attorney, we find in your favor, please prepare, propose findings of fact and conclusions of law for us to review. So I really don't see it as being anything that's going to increase the cost to the state of Arkansas. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker. Representative Collins, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized. Thank you. So I received a 25-page
▶ Play
summary of findings and facts regarding the cases for the commission. So my question is, what is the problem with the current summaries and reasons and logic that the commission is giving, the problem we have that requires making this like a court of law instead of what it is? Well,
▶ Play
my understanding is that right now they may or not provide any findings at all other than this claim is dismissed or we find in the amount of $25,000 that there may very well be no substance provided to say why was this conclusion reached other than just simply providing the file. And I don't think that, you know, I don't certainly would never want to speak for Senator Hutchinson, but he asked me to run the bill. I don't think that what he has in mind is a 25-page findings of fact and conclusions of law. I think that the testimony in committee and others in judiciary could probably address this, too. I think that what he has in mind and what, again, this was agreed to by the Claims Commission is something that is a synopsis of the facts and the conclusions reached, not to any great detail, but just to provide some additional information for the legislature to make an
▶ Play
informed decision. Follow-up? You recognize where
▶ Play
you follow-up? My question is further, for non-lawyers that currently are on equal footing on the commission with the lawyers on the commission, in terms of understanding the logic that's written in the pages and pages and pages and pages of finding and facts that are written in common language by the commission, how would they be in an equal position to the lawyers on the commission to make their arguments for their logic if they don't understand court-related phraseology like this?
▶ Play
These findings and conclusions would only be reached after the commission has either dismissed or finally adjudicated the claim. So this is not something that's going to be prepared in the midst of the discussion of the Claims Commission. This is something that's prepared after the commission reaches its decision, and then the commission would submit these on behalf of the commission as a whole, or at least those on the prevailing side with regard to how they reach their decisions. It's something that would be submitted on their behalf ultimately to the legislature. So this is not something that would be prepared in the midst of a claim proceeding. this is something that would only be prepared as a as again as a tool that that helps the legislature i mean that's the purpose of this bill is to help the claim subcommittee and the general assembly to provide some additional information so that when the claim subcommittee gets the information or the file they have something that at least tells them somewhat what's going on so it's really a tool to benefit the legislature and i don't think it would I don't think it would put anybody on the Claims Commission in a weakened position because, again, this would only be prepared after it's dismissed or after it's finally adjudicated. It would be prepared on behalf of the whole commission as opposed to any one individual commissioner. Representative Payton, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 84 34:57
A question and a request. How many questions are you planning on asking?
▶ Play
Well, my request is that you set aside the demerit I received on Monday so that I could ask a follow-up or maybe two. Well, we'll go with
▶ Play
it once, one at a time. Let's hear your first question, and then we'll move from there. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Shepard, I appreciate the spirit
▶ Play
of this bill. As the co-chair of the Claims Committee, this go-around, I've studied these issues deeply in the last 45 days to try to get up to speed. And what concerns me most about this bill is when it mentions the conclusion of law. As an attorney in understanding this, the only conclusion that I see could ever be reached by the law is the sovereign immunity, that the state has no liability in any of these cases. As a matter of fact, the Claims Commission operates on a goodwill system where they find merit and award these claims based on goodwill. So my concern is if we have a finding of fact from the Claims Commission that references a conclusion of law other than the fact that the state has immunity, How could we, under joint budget, ALC, or the Legislative Claims Committee, how could we dispute their finding of fact or their conclusion of law? Right now we have a lot of liberty, and it concerns me that this bill may be taken away from that liberty. And so could you just explain to me what merit we would have to place on their findings of fact and conclusion of law?
▶ Play
Well, the fact that the state has sovereign immunity, that would be one conclusion of law. That's what ultimately precipitates there being a claim in the first place. If there was not sovereign immunity, then a lawyer would file suit in circuit court or district court, whatever the case may be. There are other conclusions of law that can be reached. for example if someone is arguing that the state is negligent and mr walker can probably correct me if i'm wrong but in order to be negligent there has to be a duty owed there has to be a breach of that duty there has to be damage and there has to be some proximate causation was that that was pretty good wasn't it so a conclusion might be that the state of arkansas or a particular entity did not breach any duty or any standard of care in its conduct, and therefore the claim is dismissed. A conclusion might be that there has been no damage approximately caused by the state's misconduct. So therefore, that would be a conclusion of law. So conclusions of law are not just one particular issue. It's the application of law across the board. It can be numerous issues. And again, it's just to provide a tool to the legislature. I would think that the General Assembly would want to know, if a case is dismissed, why was it dismissed? This bill would allow you to know why the Claims Commission dismissed it. Did the Claims Commission dismiss it because they believed the state was not negligent? Or did they dismiss it because they believed that there was not proximate causation? Or did they dismiss it because they believed there was no damage done? I would think that the Claims Commission, Claims Subcommittee, and that the general assembly as a whole would want to understand why was this case dismissed you can take it for what it's worth the the subcommittee and the general assembly could say you know what we disagree so we're going to reverse uh the with regard to a final adjudication you might disagree that uh with regard to the amount of damages so you can make another another finding on that point so again this is just simply a tool that's available to the legislature and And it's something that I think is certainly Senator Hutchinson's intent is to help the legislature make informed decisions and understand why the Claims Commission reached some of its decisions. Do
▶ Play
I get my follow-up? Maybe next week. Representative Eubanks, for what purpose? Question.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Representative Shepard, I really don't understand what the need of this bill is. I don't know how that changes what is available to us now because the commission is represented at these hearings and are there to answer those very questions that we have as to why they did reach the conclusions that they have. So I guess I'm just a little confused as why this bill is needed. If you could answer
▶ Play
that, please. I believe that Senator Hutchinson indicated that, number one, there is no summary provided. Now, you can correct me if I'm wrong. Is there a summary provided? I don't think there is. the claims commission may or may not show up for those hearings but it gives you an opportunity to prepare in advance of those hearings and that's one of the reasons why is that that you're not having to show up at a hearing to ask a question that you have an opportunity to study that information in advance and now there may be some summary provided but obviously this contemplates something that's more extensive to hopefully provide additional information representative payton
▶ Play
for what purpose to respond to a request that he made during his last statement go ahead and ask your question you asked us to correct you if you were wrong and i hate to do that but i currently do have an email with all the cases on the agenda that does spell out the reasoning and the findings and what i'm asking of you as an attorney would the information provided by that this bill seeks would it not confine the the legislative legislative committee and take away some of our liberty because once they submit such a technical document that spells out their findings of fact and their conclusions of law, I think it would be much harder for the committee to exercise its liberty in reversing that. I don't see it
▶ Play
that way. If they're already providing you an email, all this simply does is codify the fact that they're supposed to provide specific information. Now, I don't know how extensive the testimony in committee was that on some occasions there's not specific information given. So, I mean, if they're providing it by way of an email, that's already out there. So I don't see this as restricting anything. Again, Senator Hutchinson brought this simply as a tool to help the General Assembly and to provide some additional information. I think to the extent that additional information is provided, that's a good thing and that that's something that I think is valuable to the body. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you very much. Representative Eubanks, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Well, I was going to respond to Representative Shepard's question or my perceived thought that he asked me a question about this issue. You're recognized to ask your question. Representative Shepard, would you not agree that a summary that the staff sends out to the members of the committee would be serving the same purpose as this because that's what I asked staff to do when I was serving in the interim committee on claims
▶ Play
you asked the staff to do that yes sir so they didn't unilaterally just do it right I mean and so that's the purpose of the bill is to make them do that and
▶ Play
to provide that information. But the commission is still represented there to answer all of these questions. What's that?
▶ Play
All right. Representative Shepard has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? REPRESENTATIVE COLLINS, YOU'RE RECOGNIZED TO SPEAK AGAINST
▶ Play
THE BILL. MEMBERS, THIS BILL IS VERY CONCERNING TO ME, AND IF YOU NOTICED, ALL THE PEOPLE ASKING QUESTIONS WERE YOUR REPRESENTATIVES ON THE CLAIMS COMMISSION. SO IF THIS IS NOT THE GROUP BEGGING FOR THIS, THEN I'M WONDERING WHO IS. point number two we're inundated with information there's more information than you can shake a stick at i feel guilty because i can't read all the information and all the detail that's given to us in as timely a manner as i'd like number three if this was just about information the bill would not use things like required meeting standards. This is about changing the Claims Commission approach from what we've got today, which is legislators using their experience, their common sense, their reasoning skills, their listening skills, and moving us over into a court-adjudicated style proceeding. Now, obviously, this bill in and of itself does not completely transform the process we have today from common-sense-based legislators making informed decisions into a court. But it starts us down that road, and in my view, that's extremely dangerous. Thank you very much. I encourage a no vote. Representative
▶ Play
Hendren, for what purpose? that's a good try all right representative collins has spoken against the bill representative murdoch has signaled that he'd like to speak for the bill
▶ Play
Speaker 102 45:42
thank you mr speaker uh colleagues um in listening to all of your questions and concerns i certainly understand where you're going but being on the commission for the last two sessions. I am a member that says that this could be a great asset to us because a lot of us are not, though we have watched lots of legal TV, we're really not where we ought to be. And we're asked to make critical decisions. And a lot of times with some additional information that really will help us make better decisions. So me being on that committee, I just wanted to attest that I think it's a good bill and I think it can be helpful. I don't know of any other motivations that this bill may have, so I'm certainly not speaking to that, Representative Collins, but I am speaking to, for those of us that's purely on the commission, to try to make a good decision with information. This could help us make a better decision. Representative
▶ Play
Hammer, for what purpose? Question, please. You're recognized to ask your question. Thank you. Representative Murdoch, what I'm
▶ Play
struggling with is I'm not a lawyer, don't really care to be one, but I appreciate good friends who are. So what I need to know from you, having sat on the commission or anybody that comes behind you is this. As far as legislators, we can take care of ourselves. What I'm concerned about are the citizens that have to come before the Claims Commission, and I'm more concerned about them getting the right deal and getting all the right opportunities to make sure that the legislators that have to make the decisions are as up-to-date as they can. So in your opinion, And do you think that this bill achieves that goal, or does it take us further away from making sure the citizens have every opportunity for us as legislators to be well aware of what the facts are?
▶ Play
Speaker 102 47:30
I think it assists us in doing what you're articulating. I think it assists us. It makes us better prepared and better able to do what we're supposed to do as citizen legislators, which is what we
▶ Play
are. Thank you. Thank you. All right, Representative Murdoch has spoken for the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Payton recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
thank you mr. speaker uh colleagues i really did not intend to speak against it but my good friend bob ballinger back there is an attorney and we've been sitting back there talking about this bill for a few minutes and uh i think i've come down to where the key of my problem is with it, and maybe the non-attorneys in here and the attorneys will understand my position. I'm now, as I mentioned earlier, chair of the claims committee, house chair, and I do get a lot of information about these cases. I've been studying the cases that are before us now, and along with that, we will have people present to give their testimony about these cases when we have our meeting. But here's the way I see the bill before you right now. Attorneys are comfortable with it. They see the language in it, and they don't see any problem with the bill changing the present procedure in the Claims Commission and the Claims Committee. But as a non-attorney, it worries me greatly. And I think Representative Eubanks, who sat in my position during the last session seems to be bothered by it also. And so what I think will happen if we pass this legislation, the members of the Claims Commission, which is not the Claims Committee, that is a commission appointed by the governor, the members of the Claims Commission are not all attorneys. Those members of the Claims Commission that are not attorneys will sit there overwhelmed by having to find findings of fact and conclusions of law. And so the attorneys who are on the claims commission will sit there and visit just like Bob and I did, Representative Ballinger, and they will tell these non-attorneys, well you can't find that way, you can't make that decision unless you can find a conclusion of law that supports your position. Now, I mentioned earlier that the only conclusion of law that could be found in any of these cases is sovereign immunity. The state is immune from claims by its citizens, even if the state is liable. It's immune because you can't punish a state employee by taking tax dollars and awarding them to somebody that's been damaged. You know, you're taking the citizens' tax dollars and you're awarding damages to somebody and there's no punishment there. So what the Claims Committee and what the Claims Commission does is they look at these cases and they try to decide on these cases whether or not it's fair. And fair is a very relative term. And I worry that findings of fact and conclusions of law are going to overwhelm those that sit on the Claims Commission and the Claims Committee that may not be attorneys. And so if you're on the commission or on the committee and you don't think that we should be paying a certain claim or you think we should be paying a lesser amount, then I think you will be intimidated by what's required here in conclusions of law and findings of fact. I'll try my best to answer a question or two. Representative Dotson, for what purpose? I hope you can answer this question, but if the Claims Commission either accepts or rejects a claim, does that automatically come before the Committee for Review, the Claims Committee for Review, the Legislature, or is it only upon an appeal of that decision of the Commission? It only comes on an appeal of the decision. and when the claimant appeals it then it comes to ALC and and that amount awarded can be changed and of course during the time that we're in session then it comes with before the joint budget claims subcommittee claims and so the claims commission can make an award of $500,000 and then the Joint Budget Committee subcommittee claims can actually reduce that or increase it or change it and I believe that having the level of documentation that we're requesting here would restrict the liberty that we feel on the claims committee of adjusting those claims or opposing what the claims commission has done. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Ballinger, for
▶ Play
what purpose? Question, Mr. Speaker. You're recognized, and I ask your question. Representative Payton, in
▶ Play
our discussion, did I advise you that I felt like this bill was probably okay? In fact, it probably would even help further the process of the state to make sure that decisions coming out of the Claims Commission would be more
▶ Play
equitable. Yes, you did, and that's what brought me to my conclusion, that attorneys are comfortable with it and non-attorneys are
▶ Play
Speaker 115 53:16
not. Mr. Speaker, may I have a follow-up question? if you want
▶ Play
to try go ahead did you feel overwhelmed and intimidated by the attorney advising you that this was probably a pretty good bill after 30 years of business experience
▶ Play
and hiring attorneys who are on my payroll who i can fire when i want to i have always been intimidated by an attorney thank you thank you mr speaker all right representative
▶ Play
payton has I have spoken against the bill. Representative Walker, you are recognized to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It is somewhat interesting and refreshing to see members FROM THE OTHER SIDE OF THE AISLE DEBATING THIS SUBJECT, PRO AND CON, SOME BEING FOREIGN, SOME AGAINST. I THOUGHT THEY WERE ALL TOGETHER, USUALLY. LET ME SAY THAT I RISE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL. THE CONCEPT OF SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY IS NOT ABSOLUTE. SO WHILE WE HAVE THE RIGHT TO to conduct our own business, when the 14th Amendment was added to the Constitution, and the state of Arkansas embraced it, the state, even though it's the sovereign, agreed that it could not do certain things. It agreed that it could not discriminate against protected classes. And the two major protected classes within the Constitution are African Americans, are persons of color, and women. So that if the state, for instance, in a hypothetical, allowed the Claims Commission to pay all women, all men who were mistreated by some act of the state, but then it did not let women get paid under the same circumstances when they were mistreated by some act of the state, that would invoke the provisions of the Equal Protection Clause. Now, we as a legislature have already decided that findings of fact are appropriate, and they are sort of helpful to anybody in the review procedure who reviews the matter. There are a number of statutes where we have addressed that. I'll just bring one to your attention, which is before us regularly, and that's the Teach of Fair Dismissal Act. The Teach of Fair Dismissal Act requires that a school board, a group usually of non-lawyers, make findings of fact. And it's not unusual for the findings of fact to be prepared by one of the lawyers representing one of the parties. But nonetheless, the people agree on those facts. and then they vote in open public about the reason for their decision. I don't think that it's appropriate for us to not hold ourselves accountable for a standard that we have imposed upon other agencies. That doesn't keep us from making arbitrary rulings or whatever, but our search as legislators is to try to avoid arbitrary decisions. There is, in conclusion, no absolute discretion by us for denying claims, because if you do so on the basis that I've mentioned, then a person who has a constitutional claim can go into court and utilize the absence of findings of fact against the state. I don't mind. I see Mr. Hammer rising, Mr. Speaker, and I don't mind staying
▶ Play
Speaker 26 57:39
in the wheel for his question. I might, actually. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Walker. Representative Walker. Representative Walker has spoken for the bill. representative hammer you're recognized to speak against the bill and members let's try to focus in on the task at hand i know that senator hutchinson's in the building and that's causing a little bit of a stir but let's focus on what
▶ Play
representative hammer has to say i'm rising to speak against this bill but i could be convinced to change my mind if on the commission it is my understanding of what's been said today that there's a representation of attorneys but there's also a representation of what I want to refer to as laymen if in the discussion process of determining whether or not a claim should be passed or denied by the commission if the attorneys on the commission have an opportunity to share all the information that laymen need to know then what we have is the best of both worlds you have attorneys that know the letter of the law you have laymen that are not letters of the law and see life through the eyes of the common citizen so i might be convinced to vote for this bill if i had a comfort level in that and i appreciate you considering your vote thank you all right representative
▶ Play
hindrance indicated he wants to speak for the bill if charlie
▶ Play
had answered my question i wouldn't have come down here i didn't plan on doing that, and I didn't know Jeremy was in here. I served on the claims committee for a few years. And let me just say this about that. I get in trouble every time I talk, but you need to, I think what this deal is about, and I haven't talked to Jeremy or Senator Hutchinson about it. What I heard the last session or two, that claims committee has given away the state of Arkansas in some respects. And I'll tell you what, colleagues, that can happen very quickly whenever you're on that committee. That is a hard job. And with term limits we've had recently, the most anybody I guess has been on there the last two years has been down here maybe four years. It takes a little while to learn what you're doing. When I was on that committee, one of the things that happened, we had a youngster that was about three years old that was hit in the head with a rock thrown by one of our state bush hog machines going down the highway. Well, obviously, we didn't have to pay for that. But I'll tell you, things like that will tear your heart out as you see what happened to that youngster that was was ruined for life in most part and so i think we finally granted about a one and a half or two million i see prissy talking she may remember that because she probably on the highway commission at that time so there are responsibilities the state needs to take and i i'm not a lawyer either and i thought peyton was but i say he's an auctioneer so maybe that's why he went on down here but i don't think you have to be a lawyer i just think you have to be a compassionate citizen of the state of arkansas that's what this this sovereign immunity is all about as somebody said we don't have to do anything but we also have the responsibility to be compassionate as we talk about but we also have to have the responsibility to be to be responsible with the taxpayers funds and i would tell all my colleagues here that is a tough committee to serve on and if you don't have some backbone and some compassion which i think is a balancing act you don't need to be on that committee that's not an easy committee i assume is norman hodge is still on that commission down there norman or whoever what used to come he would come and we would pepper him with questions about that and frankly colleagues you don't have to be a lawyer to ask a good question you just have to be interested in what's before you and what that deal is all about with this sovereign immunity and this claims committee and for people who don't know that what we're doing is we're going to take the taxpayers money and compensate people for damages because we think that's the right thing to do not necessarily what the lawyers tell us to do and that really takes a compassionate hard job so i think what the what the intent of this bill is and that's why i'm going to vote for it is to be sure we get it right bad information gives you bad decisions good information will let you be the compassionate citizen we need to be for this state so i ask you to vote for this bill i think it's a step in the right direction even though it maybe perhaps has a bad
▶ Play
sponsor all right representative hindern has spoken for the bill representative shepherd you're recognized to
▶ Play
close for the bill thank you mr speaker i feel like the discussion devolved into a discussion of the relative worth of attorneys so let's just set that aside colleagues all this bill does is provide an additional tool to us the legislature we've heard questions and statements that information's already provided i understand from representative eubanks he asked for that information to be provided and he asked for additional information more information be provided that's all this bill does it's all this bill does there's no there's no it's these findings and conclusions are only issued after a dismissal of the case or a final adjudication so there's no there's no uh it's not the attorneys at odds with the other members of the claims commission the claims commission would come up with these and then they would agree on them and they would submit them to us if you don't like it or don't trust attorneys throw them away but shouldn't we have the most information available this is serious business i mean some of you have served on this you've seen you deal with fatalities you deal with serious injuries you deal with large contractual disputes shouldn't we have the most information available i would appreciate a good vote thank you all right representative shepherd is closed
▶ Play
for the bill the question before the house is the passage of Senate Bill 59. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? All right, let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. with 68 yeas, 23 nays, and two present. The bill has passed. All right, Representative Baltz, I see, has moved for the clincher. All opposed? Got ahead of myself there. All right, Representative Baltz moves for the clincher. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. All right, the ayes have it. Chair is adopted. Representative Gene, you're
▶ Play
recognized to present today's budget calendar. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, you go to your yellow calendar. We've got three amendments. First is House Bill 1137. It's the Arkansas State Police Appropriation. It's an amendment. Representative Davis brought this before us. All this does is strike Section 21 and codifies that we no longer need this bill to provide awarding flags to families of certain law enforcement officers that lost their lives in the course of duty. And that's all this amendment does. Any questions? I'd appreciate a good vote on the amendment.
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker, I have the clerk read the amendment. All right, Representative Jean moves that we place House Bill 1137 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment. Without objection, read Amendment No. 1, Mr. Clerk. Amendment No. 1 to House Bill 1137. Representative Jean has explained the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment? Representative Jean is closed for the amendment. So the question before the House is the adoption of Amendment 1 to House Bill 1137. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. All right. Amendment
▶ Play
1 has been adopted. Mr. Chairman, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, House Bill 1174, Department of Health, this appropriation, what this does, in governor's letter 13 that we received this is for fines for people that are interpreting for the death that are not licensed last session the 13th session we had a new law enacted that they would find people that were not licensed interpreters for the death and there i think it's a 500 fine anyway this puts a line item in their budget of 25 up to 25 000 if people that are found interpreting for the death that are not licensed and all this does is put the line item in there. And if I can answer any questions, I will. I'd appreciate a good vote. Mr. Speaker, have the clerk read it for the amendment.
▶ Play
Representative Jean moves that we place House Bill 1174 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment. Without objection, read amendment number one to House Bill 1174. Mr. Clerk. Amendment number one to House Bill 1174. All right. Representative Gene has explained the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment? For the amendment, Representative Gene is closed for the amendment. Question before the House of the adoption of Amendment 1 to House Bill 1174. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. All right, the ayes
▶ Play
have it. The amendment's been adopted. You're recognized. Colleagues, House Bill 1207, this is amendment number two, Department of Finance Administration. This is an amendment by Senator Sample from the Senate. What this does is add a west-central Arkansas economic development district into the interstate metro planning grant. and there will be now four of those metro planning districts. One's in Little Rock, one's in Pine Bluff, one's in Springdale and this will add hot springs and the grant is distributed of $90,000 if this amendment is adopted and the bill is adopted into these four entities instead of three. Any questions? I appreciate a good vote. have the clerk read the amendment Mr. Speaker all right
▶ Play
members representative Gene moves that we place house bill 1207 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment without objection read amendment 2 to house bill 1207 Mr. Clerk amendment 2 to house bill 1207 representative Gene has explained the amendment would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment it was in jeans closed for the amendment members question before you now is the adoption of amendment two to house bill 1207 all in favor say aye all opposed say no all right the eyes have it the amendment's been
▶ Play
adopted chairman jean you're recognized continue on thank you mr speaker colleagues we're going to get into the house bills we've got a couple appropriations that we need to do for this coming up fiscal year. The first is House Bill 1075, and without objection, well, we'll just go ahead and vote these separately. It's Arkansas Development, ADFA. It's an appropriation for next year. There is no GR in this bill. Can I answer any questions? I appreciate a good vote. Mr. Speaker, I have the clerk reading for the third time. Mr.
▶ Play
Clerk, read House Bill 1075. House Bill 1075. Representative Jean has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Before the bill, are you closed? The question before the House is the adoption of House Bill 1075. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. you're bit you're voting on the bill and the emergency clause has everyone voted cast up the ballot mr. clerk with 92 yeas zero nays one present the bill is passed and the and the emergency
▶ Play
clause colleagues house bill 1109 this is appropriation for next year for arkansas state library there is general revenue but it is under the balanced budget of the governor so it will receive a one percent reduction there is a little extra federal dollars in it but basically it is a flat budget can answer any questions I'd appreciate a good vote mr. speaker have the clerk read it for the third time
▶ Play
mr. clerk read house bill 1109 house bill 1109 representative gene is presented bill HB 1109 but anyone would like to speak against the bill for the bill mr. clerk prepare the machine you're voting on house bill 1109 and the emergency clause has everyone voted Mr. Clerk cast up the machine with 93 yay zero nays zero presents the measure is passed
▶ Play
colleagues house bill 1290 this is a reappropriation so this is money from the current fiscal year and that we're going to move over till next year that's got a governor letter endorsing this reappropriation it's for crowley's ridge technical institute so this is just a reappropriation money they haven't spent on some projects they're working on as far as capital improvement any questions i'd appreciate a good vote mr speaker have the clerk read it for
▶ Play
the third time mr clerk read hb 1290 house bill 1290 representative gene has presented the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill if not the question before the house is the adoption of HB 1290 prepare the machine mr. clerk you're voting on the bill and the emergency clause as everyone voted cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. With 92 yea, 0 nay, 0 present, the measure is passed, and the
▶ Play
emergency clause. Representative Gene, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, House Bill 1321, this is the school recognition program that we adopted by amendment yesterday, well, I guess last week, for the school program that's going into the governor's gif this is for the top 20 percent schools that apply for this in graduation rate grade point average and test scores they'll get some extra money if the schools were performing the governor approves this and if he has any gif it'll be funded through gif not general revenue any questions i'd appreciate a good vote mr speaker had the clerk read it for 13. Mr. Clerk
▶ Play
read House Bill 1321. House Bill 1321. Representative Jean has presented the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? If not, the question before the House is adoption 1321 and the emergency clause. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine. you're voting on the bill and the emergency clause has everyone voted cast up the ballot mr. clerk with 94 yay 0 nay 0 present the measure
▶ Play
is passed colleagues house bill 1330 this is uh back on the crowley's ridge we also did a reappropriation to bring this money forward. This puts all that money in plus an extra million dollars in appropriation from a governor's letter for general improvement, GIF. Any questions about this? I'd appreciate a good vote. Mr. Speaker, I have the clerk read it for the third time. Mr. Clerk, read HB 1330. House Bill 1330. Representative
▶ Play
Jane has presented the bill. Would anyone like to speak against it before the bill? If not, the question before the House is the adoption of HB 1330. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine. You're voting on the bill and the emergency clause. Has everyone voted? Mr. Clerk, cast up the ballot. With 90 yay, 0 nay, 0 present, the measure is passed, and the emergency clause.
▶ Play
Representative Gene, you're recognized. Colleagues, we're going to batch Senate Bill
▶ Play
104 down to Senate Bill 217, and with Representative Bain.
▶ Play
Go ahead. Representative Bain, for what question, for what purpose? For question. What's
▶ Play
your question? Can we please pull Senate Bill 195 from the batch?
▶ Play
Yes, we can do that. Okay. All right, colleagues, we're going to batch these set of bills. These are appropriations to the University of Central Arkansas, Senate Bill 104, Arkansas state university senate bill 107 arkansas state university at bb 206 and senate bill 217 arkansas state at newport any questions your one vote we'll vote for each of these bills in the emergency clause which speaker has the clerk read it for the third time mr clerk read
▶ Play
Speaker 110 1:18:26
the bills for the third time. Senate Bill 104, Senate Bill 107, Senate Bill 206, Senate Bill 217. Prepare the
▶ Play
machine Mr. Clerk. you're voting on the bills and the emergency clauses has everyone voted guess up the ballot mr. clerk with 94 yay zero nay zero present the bills have passed and the emergency clauses you're recognized representative jean thank you mr speaker the senate
▶ Play
bill 195 this is the one we
▶ Play
pulled out south arkansas community college any questions I'd appreciate a good vote Mr. Speaker have a clerk reading for the third time Mr. Clerk read the bill for the third time
▶ Play
Senate Bill 195 Representative Jean has presented the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill if not the question before the house is the adoption of SB 195 prepare the machine Mr. Clerk you're voting on the bill and the emergency clause has everyone voted cast up the ballot mr. clerk with 93 yeas zero nays one present the measure is passed and the emergency clause thank you mr. speaker colleagues we're
▶ Play
going to batch senate bills 301 all the way down to the second page to senate bill 353 these are members from the senate general improvement funds they do they do things a little different than we do at the house our our general improvement bill will be uh filed later this week and ours will be centered into the planning and developments they these are all general improvement funds i don't want anybody to think when you see these numbers that the senate's going to get any more than the house is going to get that's not going to happen so uh but but they've always had uh general improvement funds by individuals so So that's what this is, and if any of them need to be pulled out of the batch, we'll do so at this time. If not, I'll read the list that we're going to vote in the batch. Senate Bill 301, Senate Bill 302, Senate Bill 303, Senate Bill 304, Senate Bill 306, Senate Bill 307, Senate Bill 308, Senate Bill 328, Senate Bill 330, Senate Bill 336, Senate Bill 337, Senate Bill 345, Senate Bill 346, Senate Bill 347, Senate Bill 348, Senate Bill 350, Senate Bill 352, and Senate Bill 353. Any questions? None of them want to be pulled out? All right, your one vote. We'll vote for all these bills in the emergency clause. I'd appreciate a good vote. Mr. Speaker, have the clerk read the bills for the third time.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:21:59
Mr. Clerk, read the bills for the third time. Senate Bill 301, Senate Bill 302, Senate Bill 303, Senate Bill 304, Senate Bill 306, Senate Bill 307, Senate Bill 308, Senate Bill 328, Senate Bill 330, Senate Bill 336, Senate Bill 337, Senate Bill 345, Senate Bill 346, Senate Bill 347, Senate Bill 348, Senate Bill 351, Senate Bill 352, Senate Bill 353. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
You're voting on the bills and emergency clause. Has everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. With 94 yeas, 0 nays, 0 present, the bills have passed, and the emergency clauses.
▶ Play
All right, Representative Stephen Meeks, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. After the announcements, reading of the bills, transferring of the bills, putting the calendars on the desk, members amending their own bills with their own amendments, members withdrawing their own bills, finalizing resolutions, reading communications, and any remaining committee reports, I move we adjourn until 1.30 tomorrow afternoon. That is a proper motion. Non-debatable. All
▶ Play
in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. The ayes have it. all right are there any announcements representative jet you're recognized for your announcement thank you mr speaker revenue tax will not meet tomorrow morning uh 10 a.m representative hickerson you're recognized for your
▶ Play
announcement thank you mr speaker uh house transportation will meet at 10 o'clock tomorrow in big mac b watch your emails though members uh for any changes in that please so check your email check your agenda uh tonight or tomorrow morning for any changes thank you chairman you're recognized for your announcement joint budget 9 a.m tomorrow morning big mac a running members bills
▶ Play
representative lampkin you're recognized for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:24:24
your announcement education will meet tomorrow at 10 in 138 representative house
▶ Play
you're recognized personnel subcommittee of the
▶ Play
Joint Budget Committee will meet tomorrow morning 730 Rick Big Mac representative Bell
▶ Play
you're recognized announcement mr. speaker state agencies meeting for informational purposes on constitutional limits this afternoon is being canceled. Are there any other
▶ Play
announcements? All right, let's read the bills, Mr. Clerk. Senate Bill 1440, or House Bill 1440. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1440. State agencies. House Bill 1441. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1441. Judiciary. House Bill 1442. Without objection to read the bill the second time. House Bill 1442. Education. House Bill 1443. Without objection to read the bill the second time. House Bill 1443. Education. House Bill 1444. Without objection to read the bill the second time. House Bill 1444. Education. House Bill 1445. Objection to read the bill the second time. House Bill 1445. City, county, and local affairs. House Bill 1446. Without objection to read the bill the second time. House Bill 1444. Education. House Bill 1445. Objection to read the bill the second time. House Bill 1445. City, county, and local affairs. House Bill 1446. Without objection to read the bill the second time. House bill 1446. Point budget. House bill 1447. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House bill 1447. Transportation. House concurrent resolution 1006. Without objection, read the resolution a second time. House concurrent resolution 1006. Agriculture, forestry, and economic development. All right, the desk will remain open for the reading of bills until 4 p.m. and upon completion of the items named in the adjourned resolution. The house will be adjourned until 1 30 p.m. tomorrow afternoon high above the house floor and
▶ Play
Speaker 165 1:26:28
get a bird's-eye view of democracy if you can't observe the sessions in person you can follow news coverage gathered here in the press gallery and every session is broadcast on television and online at Arkansas house every arkansas has a house right inside the state capitol the arkansas house of representatives and what happens in this house affects the lives of everyone in our state as it has for two centuries the arkansas legislature
▶ Play

Agenda

CALL TO ORDER

0:03 - 9:05 26 segments 8 speakers

HR1015

9:05 - 12:43 11 segments 3 speakers

HR1020

12:43 - 17:13 13 segments 3 speakers

HB1133

17:13 - 25:15 28 segments 9 speakers

SB59

25:15 - 1:05:43 121 segments 15 speakers

HB1137

1:05:43 - 1:07:01 3 segments 2 speakers

HB1174

1:07:01 - 1:08:42 4 segments 2 speakers

HB1207

1:08:42 - 1:10:34 6 segments 2 speakers

HB1075

1:10:34 - 1:11:54 4 segments 2 speakers

HB1109

1:11:54 - 1:13:18 5 segments 2 speakers

HB1290

1:13:18 - 1:14:39 3 segments 2 speakers

HB1321

1:14:39 - 1:16:14 5 segments 2 speakers

HB1330

1:16:14 - 1:18:07 7 segments 4 speakers

BUDGET BATCH

1:18:07 - 1:19:26 6 segments 4 speakers

SB195

1:19:26 - 1:20:30 3 segments 2 speakers

BUDGET BATCH

1:20:30 - 1:23:26 8 segments 5 speakers

ANNOUNCEMENTS & BILL READING

1:23:26 - 1:27:06 15 segments 6 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Jeremy Gillam Chair Unverified
59 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 7
1 segment
Speaker 11
1 segment
Speaker 13
1 segment
Speaker 14
1 segment
Speaker 18
1 segment
Chair Unverified
25 segments
Representative James Ratliff Unverified
2 segments
Representative Ken Bragg Unverified
4 segments
Representative Scott Baltz Chair Unverified
10 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 57
1 segment
Speaker 59
1 segment
Speaker 61
1 segment
Speaker 64
1 segment
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
7 segments
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Unverified
33 segments
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson Unverified
31 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 84
1 segment
Representative John Payton Chair Unverified
20 segments
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Chair Unverified
22 segments
Speaker 102
4 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 115
1 segment
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 26
1 segment
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
7 segments
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
2 segments
Representative John Baine Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 110
1 segment
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
3 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 165
2 segments