House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (5)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1263
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “of the table. Now we'll hear House Bill 1263.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1077
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1077”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1312
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…tee. I am here today to present a collaboration of 1263 and House Bill 1312 that we have merged together and think we've made a great b…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1393
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1393”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1025
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1025”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
morning, everyone. At this time, we're going to represent Representative Tucker to present H.R. 1025. You are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 14
1:00
Thank you, committee members. I appreciate your indulgence this morning. I know I'm not the only thing on the agenda today, but I know that's why everybody showed up. This is just a very simple resolution to honor and recognize our National Board Certified Teachers in Arkansas. As you may be aware, this was a program that was started in 1987 by business leaders and teachers to professionalize the teacher workforce. It essentially strengthens several aspects of teaching, including deepening the knowledge of the information
that the teachers teach to our students and also improving the methods in which they convey that information to the students. It's a voluntary process. It's a national process. It can take however long it takes the teacher to go through the certification process, one year, three years. It's a rigorous, peer-reviewed, performance-based process, but it's essentially recognized in the country as the gold standard for teacher certification. And I thought it would be appropriate to recognize the teachers in Arkansas who go through this process because of the extra effort they go through, because of the rewards it enhances for the students they teach,
especially students in poverty. There are about 110,000 national board certified teachers in Arkansas. About 2,800 of those, excuse me, in the United States, about 2,800 of those are in Arkansas. In 2014, Arkansas ranked fourth in the nation in new National Board-certified teachers, and we're doing good as a state in this regard. And so I thought it would be nice for us to recognize these folks who work so hard for our young folks and students. And they're going to be in the Capitol on Monday, and so I'd like to have this on the floor on Monday,
which is why Chairman Cozart was nice enough to put me on the agenda this morning. morning, so I'd be happy to take any questions, but pretty simple and straightforward. Representative Letting, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Motion at the proper time. Are there any questions, Committee?
Does anybody in the audience like to speak against the bill? Resolution, I'm sorry. Anyone like to speak for the resolution? Just a minute. Just a second. Representative Douglas, you're recognized.
Speaker 20
3:07
I just appreciate you wanting to honor teachers because, you know, research shows that of all the factors that you can put into a classroom, the teacher is the determining factor many, many times in the success of our children. So anything we can do to bring respect and pat them on the back, I think that this is well warranted, and I appreciate you doing that. Thank you. Thank you very much. I agree.
Okay, speak for the bill. Mr. Nagel, you're recognized. State your name and who you're with, and you will
be recognized. Chairman Cozart, members of the committee, I'm Rich Nagle with the Arkansas Education Association, and just by way of a little history,
I recall that it was Senator Argue, and let's see, I'm going to draw a blank. Anyway, the first time that the National Board licensure, this was a bill that AEA took to members of the House and the Senate in that year to begin the national board licensure process in Arkansas for the state to provide additional support and assistance for
people going through the national board and we certainly believe that a lot of teachers in the state have gone above and beyond to achieve this very high level of licensure and appreciate Representative Tucker
bringing the resolution. Representative Walker, do you have
a question? You're recognized. Thank you. Of course, I support the bill and the resolution. Mr. Nagle, I'm concerned that our national certified, National Board Certified Teachers don't appear to be serving the students who are most needed.
And if we're going to have certified teachers, that's a presumption that they are better qualified than other teachers. And it seems as if our best qualified people ought to be addressing the needs, the most urgent needs for reading, writing, and arithmetic of our children. Is there any way that you can sort of help focus certification so that it will be more directed toward the areas where it could be of greatest utility, not only to the students
but to society. MR. Kind of surprising, Representative Walker. I think that's exactly what they're doing. I wasn't sure what you meant by areas. Do you
mean licensure areas, teaching areas, or are you speaking of geographic areas? MR. I'm speaking of the places where they work. Most of them don't work in the so-called academically distressed schools.
They may start off there, but it seems to be a path. Once they get certification, they move out in many cases. Not always, I understand, but I'm just saying that it ought to be something that We emphasize, like we do with special money for principals who deal with distressed schools, we give them more money, and we give these teachers, of course, more money, too. But it seems that there ought to be a correlation between what we pay and what we get in return
for the needs of our children. It's just a comment. You know I'm one of your biggest supporters in your
council, but I'm concerned about that. CHAIRMAN BRYANT- If I may, Mr. Chairman. The Arkansas Education Association has sponsored a, I guess the best term for it is a conference of nationally board licensed teachers. We held it out at Parkview High School on a Saturday.
And in addition, we have worked with several of our members who have made special efforts to provide National Board support to candidates in eastern Arkansas and in other areas of the Delta. And I can tell you that we'll continue to do that. We believe that these teachers are very effective and will continue our work to provide support,
encouragement, and assistance to those who have National Board and for those who are seeking it. Are there any other questions? Anybody else
like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for your resolution?
appreciate a good vote. I have a motion. Representative Lidding, you're recognized. Move to pass. Have a due pass. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, say no. Congratulations, you passed your resolution. Thank you very much. At this time, I'm going to turn it over to my vice chair. as I am coming to the end
of the table. Now we'll hear House Bill 1263.
Representative Cozart, you're recognized to present your bill.
Thank you, Madam Chair, Committee. I am here today to present a collaboration of 1263 and House Bill 1312 that we have merged together and think we've made a great bill that will be good for schools that are falling under 350. These are soon-to-be Act 60 schools if they fall under that number.
And we have worked to pull these two bills together to make the best bill that we think would be allowable by the law to help these schools to stay going. I mean, I think we have a lot of schools that have already been consolidated, and we're trying to keep that from happening. So what this bill does, if the school falls below 350, which that's the magic number, that the state says they go on a consolidation list after that. So if they fall below that, but they are not in fiscal distress, academic distress,
or facility distress, or they do not have, at that time, any probationary status, this will let them continue to go on just like they were, and they will be there until they actually do fall into distress at some time. Hopefully not, but we hope they can continue on as long as they can. So this is just a bill to let these schools continue. As we all know, we go back and we talk about a school that failed a few years ago, but they were really all in
they just fell below that number they had everything going for them but they fell below that number and they got consolidated so we don't know why this didn't happen at that time but we're trying to work that out at this time so here's the bill 1263 that will help cure that and help other schools I'll be glad to answer
any questions I have one question does this have any effect on schools that have already been consolidated date, or is this forward? This is from now
on. When this bill takes effect, it will be from right then on. It does not go back and pull any schools
back, no. Okay. Any other questions? Okay. Representative Ratliff, you're recognized. Representative,
Speaker 58
11:45
this will probably help a lot of rural schools, wouldn't you imagine? I agree. That's the main thing. I appreciate you
recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Cozart, I understand the purpose for the
legislation. I know there are a lot of schools that are doing well that may not meet that threshold, but I'd be concerned about the impact of this bill on just the overall adequacy standards in the state because I know that the number 350 that we arrived at, it was It was a long, torturous process, and obviously it's kind of a higher level impact that takes place in terms of economies of scale, how the economics of these school districts work, not just individually, but collectively at the state level.
So I was wondering, do we know the impact that this legislation would have on adequacy? Has this run through any of the adequacy studies or the committees yet to understand what that kind of macro impact would be? No, we have not done
an impact just on what these schools will have as happening to them. But there again, if they're academically sound and strong, I can't see that the adequacy part is going to pay them. You know, they have the money. They're not in fiscal distress, so they
should be meeting adequacy on all levels. Now, adequacy means a lot of different things, and there's a lot of different parts of that. So adequately, they have to meet adequacy. We have to do that on the state level. So if there's anything that puts them into any kind of distress, this would kick them out of that. So hopefully, financially, they're going to be adequate, and then academically, they're going to be adequate. Now, does it put them where that they may have to share or do some online teaching?
I think that's possible. We've talked about that on a lot of little schools already, that they're going to have to teach some courses, is possibly online that they can't afford the teachers for, that falls into place for
Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. I have given you my commitment that I'll vote for and to put this bill, but I have some serious reservations that I'd like to have expressed. I did think
I'd sign up to speak regarding the bill, and that was yesterday when I expected that it would show up. So these will constitute my comments rather than coming there. In order for something to be done in the education field, it should be it should meet at least two tests when you say it should be academically sound and financially feasible. And in terms of academic soundness, A school which has the 350 standard is just arbitrary.
I don't know how you came up with it, how anybody came up with it, but it's because it's arbitrary. But it's very difficult for a small school to provide the same quality of education as a larger school, all recognize that going back to the Kona report and many other reports. And I don't see how our desire to save our communities by keeping our schools there is going to ultimately be beneficial to the state. It will be a temporary palliative, but I don't see how it's beneficial.
It's not financially sound to have fewer course offerings which will cost more, well, maybe the same course offerings which will cost more on a per capita basis than they do in larger schools and when you start combining two grades or three grades first and second with one teacher or second and third the nobody's in education says that that makes any sense I don't know how you deal with it and I
know you want to save the school districts and save the communities but Do you think that at some point you're going to address what Representative Sabin did and that is whether or not under Lakeview this meets the expectation of Lakeview? And I guess where I'm going, Representative Cozart, I understand that you wear two hats, but don't you think at some point we're going to have to have county consolidation and in
In every county, there will be one school and maybe some residential schools as well so as to accommodate declining enrollment and declining populations so that all students will be able to have not only the courses but the other things that constitute a school. It's not only academic outcomes that you're expecting. You're talking about societal outcomes. You're talking about teaching kids and people how to get along with each other, and you're causing them those people in small schools to have to be judged in
accordance with people like Fayetteville and Benville and Fort Smith I don't see how you can do it but I'll vote for it because I told you that I would and I keep my word but at some point since you all have the leadership I think hopefully you all will address that and try to make some sense of all this further to accommodate everybody who has a concern about something and to give them what they want on local control or whatever. Thank you. Representative Walker,
thank you for your concern. I think everybody at this table is concerned about our students across this state. You mentioned something about saving the state money and that you didn't think that was really going to be that good to help save our communities. I think this will exactly save our communities. If you take the school out of your communities, you have lost your community. and that community does not thrive anymore. That's a proven fact that a lot of towns die when the schools die. So that's one of the reasons. You talked about classes that have more than one grade in it.
Well, I came through that when I was in the third and fourth grade. We had a split class, and I think I learned a little more that year because I was learning fourth grade along with third grade. So I won't say that's always bad. It may be bad for the fourth graders because they're having to listen to what the third graders are being taught too. But adequacy is a very big issue, and we've dealt with that in this state. And we're still dealing with that. This interim, we'll be talking about adequacy again. Representative Saban, I'll come back to you. You know, I don't know how far down this will get, but when they can't meet adequacy, then that's going to be another issue.
Okay. I'll put him on the list now. Okay. We'll put you back on the list, Representative
Speaker 20
18:43
Saban. Representative Douglas, you're recognized. You know, we talk about economics, we talk about the school, we talk about finances, we talk about academics, but where are we talking about the kids that are affected? And when we go to these schools that are consolidated and we talk to those kids,
it absolutely disrupts their lives to be consolidated. Many of them can no longer play in athletics. They can't be in clubs. Their life is spent on a bus. And until we understand that the focus needs to be shifted from consolidation, which has been there's no data to show that we've saved money or we have really improved the academics by consolidating.
And until we understand that this is a way to save education in Arkansas is by letting these schools stay small and meet the needs of these kids in their local environment where they're supported by, you know, their parents. And the parents can get to the parent-teacher conferences. They're not traveling 30 or 40 miles to do that. So until you've lived in a situation where your school has been taken and your kids can no longer participate and their opportunities have been shifted,
then I think it's hard for us to understand how valuable this is to a small community and to the kids in that community. The virtual possibilities that we have on the Internet now allow us to bring quality education into these remote situations. So I think we're a different society than we were when we passed this bill. And I would just say that, you know, I would wonder if you would agree with me on that, Representative Hozart.
Representative Douglas, I do agree with you, and I thank you for speaking for the bill. We have Representative Douglas and Representative Murdoch, and I have worked many hours on this, and we've come together to get this bill as good as we could get it and as lenient as we could without worrying about the issues that we were talking about of letting it be too far down that they were going to turn around and fail real quick or have some adequacy issues right off. So those were real concerns. Transportation was one of the big issues that Representative Douglas just mentioned.
I know Representative Murdoch has talked about that ever since he's been here, about the long bus rides that these kids have to ride. So when you consolidate those kids and they've got to ride 45 miles, that's a long way. And we want to try to keep these kids
for a question. Well, Representative Douglas and Representative Coulson took my mind. I just say what they said. Is that a ditto?
question. I appreciate that, Madam Chair. And I promise I'm not going to harp on this too much because I'm very sympathetic to all the issues that have been raised, both by Representative Cozart, Representative Douglas, and others, Representative Murdoch, by extension, absolutely. But my concern really is just that, you know, in spite of that, you know, we're trying to address this issue legislatively when the courts have already given us guidance on this issue.
and obviously they've given us guidance on the issue because there's a constitutional issue at play because our state obviously guarantees an adequate education in our constitution. So when we ask these questions about how this law will affect adequacy in light of how the court has already ruled on that, my question is just have we consulted with the Department of Education or the Attorney General's office? Are there people here in the committee room right now who might be able to speak to that,
just so that we're all aware that if we go ahead and pass this law, that we may be, again, having to kind of reintroduce issues that have already been adjudicated? I believe there are people signed up
to speak for and against this bill, so I believe you'll find out those questions. There, again, adequacy, I think that's something we're just going to have to monitor, and we do that every school, everywhere. I think if there is some adequacy issues, then this waiver will fall away. for that school, and hopefully there are schools that can make this work, and really all we're
trying to do is give them a chance. I think that's all they ask, is let's give them a chance and see if they can do this. You know, the magic number of 350 was really negotiated pretty hard to get down to that number. Is it a magic number? It is for some. It's not for others. There's some that can't probably make it really good above that number. There's some that can make it good below that number, and it really has to do with your area, your community, but all we're asking for is to give them a chance. Let's try this. Laws are laws. They can be repealed. They can be changed. They can be amended. There's a lot of things
that can happen to them, so we're
we'll recognize you for a follow-up question. I'll try to be brief. The schools, I think Representative Radliff asked about the retroactive effect of this what we have I mean I guess I've been on the losing side of this so many times we tried to keep little black school districts from being consolidated with larger white school districts or
maybe even smaller white school districts where the black kids would be subjected to long bus rides and those concerns at the time were of no concern to the court. The question was whether or not the law had to be followed. Lakeview is one of those absorbed districts for whom the lawsuit is named. And Elaine, kids now get up at 5 o'clock in the morning and get home at 8 o'clock at night. That makes no sense. But it seems as if we ought to
and then if you consolidate small districts and they're poor generally with others that are small and poor, they have no millage. So whatever local revenues they can amass cannot be comparable to those in the cities where you have a greater tax base. So the concept of equality that Representative Sabin, I misspoke because he was doing a little pacing this morning.
But the concept of equity and the other Lakeview concerns is still there, and I hope that while you do this, Ms. Douglas, I told you also I'd support it, but I think that we ought to have a study to see whether or not we can make these districts more financially feasible and academically successful, because we'll have to use the resources of some other people. Anytime I go through Bisco, which was consolidated with Hazen, I'm very chagrined because you have a city hall there and no city government, and you have no resources and no police, but nonetheless you have the kids being on buses going to Hazen.
I mean, all of it makes no sense, especially where you have no retroactivity. But I think that you all are acting in good faith, and I give you that credit, and I ask that you go further with the study commission of something, Mr. Cozart as our chairman, to see whether or not the unintended consequences can be better addressed as we go forward in the future. Thank you. Thank you, Representative Walker.
I agree with what you're saying on that, but I never have been one that wanted to take kids out of the country and put them in the city. I'm a country boy, and I think that's the best place in the world to grow up, and I think more of our city kids need to
this problem. Okay. I saw him. Okay. Representative Bell, you recognize for a question. Madam Chair, I actually didn't have a question. I was considering a point of order, but I just would request that members stay in questioning
and not making statements. Okay. Okay. Any other questions from the committee? Okay. I believe we have a representative from the Rural Community Alliance. Oh. Okay. Okay, then we have Mr. Rich Nagel from AEA to speak against the bill. I'm sorry.
Mr. Nagel, you recognize. Please state your name and
who you're with. Thank you. I'm Rich Nagel with the Arkansas Education Association, and it's good to be able to testify in the room rather than in the hall, as Representative Cozart said. This bill is House Bill 1263 is concerning to us because it states that the school district
may not be in violation of standards for accreditation as set forth on page 2, lines 14 through 16. We have before us in this assembly several bills that are pending, all of which attempt to reduce some of the standards for accreditation. And therefore, we feel it's difficult to know what will be required under this bill once the session has ended. The minimum salary schedule bill has not been put in, introduced at this time.
we also have concerns about several of the bills it's bills to increase class sizes pay teachers to teach classes that have many more students than the standards provide a bill that would change the requirement of a school having to have students in the required classes rather than just offering the
class even if no one attends bills that will waive all of the standards and and really allow school districts to waive many many requirements similar to charter schools and then there's a house joint resolution that will even cap the amount of education expenditures at some at this point unknown percentage of the
state's expenses so for all of these reasons as well as many that have been mentioned I think we know that an adequate education can be provided for 350 students because that was the legislation that was enacted at the time following the Lakeview ruling. I think, however, there are serious questions about whether an adequate education can be provided below 350 students.
And I think that's the area and the area of focus that should be done before adopting this measure. Happy to answer any questions that you might have. Okay. Representative Murdock,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
Chairman. Mr. Nagle, what evidence was given with this? And you imagine you were around when the 350 number was established. I just imagine you had something to do with when that happened.
What made that number magic? What made that number work? Because what I'm hearing surrounding that number is arbitrary, and it was not a magic. There's nothing magic about 350. How was 350 scientifically proven that that was a number that
we needed to use versus any other number, greater or smaller? Well, I think the adequacy consultants at the time, Alan Auden and Larry Pikus, both well-known adequacy experts used throughout the United States.
I'm quite confident that in their work with the House and Senate education committees that they looked very carefully at whether or not a school district of 350 students that would receive a proportionate reduction in funding from 500, which is the optimal school size that's used in the funding matrix, that given all of the costs and all of the needs of students
and the standards for accreditation, that it could be done at that time. And I believe there's good evidence in the record in those reports to show that. I mean, otherwise, they would have never settled on 350. So Pike is an ordinary source, is what you're saying to me?
that was done. Yes, sir. Thank you. Okay. Representative
Harris, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Richard, you represent teachers, is that correct?
Well, you know, actually we have retired teachers, students, educational support professionals, teachers, guidance counselors, media specialists, wide array of members, but primarily classroom teachers. Yes, sir. Can I ask a follow-up? Yes, sir. So
as I'm trying to understand this whole concept of consolidation and you being against this,
and thank you for your testimony helping, you know, further this bill. But in consolidation, teachers lose jobs most of the time. Is that not correct? Someone loses. Generally speaking, I would
say yes. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Any
other questions? Thank you, Mr. Nagle, for your testimony.
Thank you. Okay. Now we have Ms. Carr from the Rural Community Alliance wanting to speak for
Speaker 108
34:18
the bill. State chairman who you're with, please. Renee Carr. Rural Community Alliance. I'm the Executive Director. Thank you, Madam Chair Lampkin. I'm also a proud graduate of a very small high school. It's been a number of years now, but
rural special. And with me here today, sitting over here, is a 2006 graduate of Elaine High School. She was a member of the last graduating class before they were closed. And her academic achievement, her capabilities. I would stack up to anyone from any size school. Rural Community Alliance has 2,000 members in 64 chapters across Arkansas. And the past 11 years have been very
trying times for the state of Arkansas, particularly rural Arkansas. And I don't think I can overstate the detriment that Act 60 has caused to our state. 68 school districts have been consolidated due to Act 60, and this law that was touted as administrative consolidation only has proven otherwise. The case history of 11 years shows that 98 schools have been closed due to Act 60.
Now, that's 53 high schools and 98, well, 45 elementaries for a total of 98. So students and families have not been well served by Act 60. As much longer bus rides have reduced family time at home, it's reduced parent involvement in schools, It's reduced student participation in after school and extracurricular activities.
And Act 60 has changed the landscape of Arkansas. As you go through the state, you'll see abandoned school campuses that sit idle and that are decaying. And in most cases, business commerce in those areas, because of this, has ceased. now speaking about those that would be impacted we have 28 school districts with 450 or fewer
students these small school districts have a cloud of uncertainty hanging over them because of act 60 this bill that provides a waiver would remove that cloud of uncertainty so that these small school districts can get back to the main focus of educating students without having this hanging over them. Rural Community Alliance is pleased with the considerable work and effort put forth
by Chairman Cozart, by Representative Douglas. They addressed our concerns and put together the strongest, best bill that we're seeing here today. So I ask you to vote for this bill. It's a vote for students. It's a vote for schools. It's a vote for families. It's a good vote for Arkansas. Please pass this bill. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am.
Any questions? Thank you, ma'am, for your
presentation. Does anyone want to speak against the bill? Okay. For the bill, Mr. Alexander, Randy Alexander. Please give us your name and
Speaker 111
38:23
who you represent. Randy Alexander. I represent rural schools
and I introduced the legislation in the 2013 session that would have put a two-year moratorium on Act 60 and I also chaired the Interim Study Committee that looked at consolidation and the impact of that. So I can answer some of the questions that have been raised. Probably the most convincing evidence that we saw in our interim study was from the National Association of Educational Policy, NAEP.
Some of us know that. It's called the Nation's Report Card. They looked at all of the consolidation research for a period of 95 years, from 1915 to 2010. And their conclusion was there is no evidence to support that this is a good idea. They said the goals that were commonly expressed as the reason for consolidation were to improve education and to make education more efficient, to save money.
They said there is no evidence to support that that happens, and in fact, the opposite can be true. They said that the benefits of consolidation in this country were achieved in the first half of the 20th century, and that since that time, it is more likely that schools would benefit from deconsolidation, would be more efficient, some schools obviously, that large schools are inefficient
and also don't provide as good of an education. They said the primary reason usually for this kind of approach was for a political reason. that it was something that could be done that could be stated the reason for this is we're going to be more efficient and save money but again they didn't find that to be the case and they also said the worst possible approach is for a state to set a number under which a school
is eligible for consolidation which of course is what we did and the reason for that is they said that to really see what is going to happen with this kind of approach you have to look at the individual school, and the devil's in the details, and just simply picking a threshold and saying if you fall below that, it's going to trigger this, is the worst approach that you can have. So they panned it completely. In Arkansas, the 350 is nothing more than a political number.
This does not come from Auden and Picus. Governor Huckabee was the one promoting consolidation. I've talked to several people who were there and involved in this. They said initially he wanted schools under 1,500 consolidated and then went down to 12 and 8 and whatever. It finally settled on 350, and that got enough votes to pass. The reason was at that time there were only about 10 schools in the entire state that were below 500, much less 350. There is no evidence whatsoever that says 350 or 500 or any other number for that matter is the ideal number,
the magic number that's going to ensure that at that point you have enough students to operate efficiently. In terms of saving money, the first year, which I believe was 2004 or 2005, when a lot of schools consolidated, 76% of those schools, their transportation costs, which is where they think the money's going to be saved in a large degree, 76% of the schools, their transportation costs actually went up. Since that initial year,
for every school that's been consolidated, their transportation cost of the two schools involved has gone up. In addition to this, a lot of citizens don't realize that a receiving school gets financial compensation for taking that school. I don't have the report with me, but it was something like $11 million a year for the first nine or ten years of this. And as an example, Harrisburg, which is the school that Wiener was consolidated into,
got over $2 million over a two-year period for taking this school. In terms of academic performance, in 2010, the University of Arkansas did a study that compared these small schools, and they had 21 schools that were sort of on the bubble. They were in danger at that time of falling below 350. They looked at their academic performance compared with state average, and they found that of the 21 schools, four of the schools outscored the state average in every category in the benchmark exams.
Five schools outscored the state average in every category on the end-of-course exams. Wiener, in particular, the year before they were consolidated, they ranked number 13 in the state in terms of academic performance, number 13. The school they were consolidated into last year ranked 198th in the state in academic performance. So ironically, what we did in that case was close the high-performing school or consolidate it. The high school has since been closed.
And it's now being operated under the administrative authority of one of the worst schools in the state academically. The last thing I want to mention is this has a profound impact on the community. We all know that over the past several years, population in rural communities has been going down. When you lose a school, that accelerates that dramatically. But even today, agriculture makes up the largest part of the GDP of the state of Arkansas.
Forty-three percent of our citizens live in rural areas. And I think that we need to be looking for ways to strengthen rural areas. This clearly does exactly the opposite. And again, with all the research that we looked at, there is no evidence of any improvement in the quality of education or in the efficiency of resources. Thank you.
you. Let me understand. You're speaking for the bill or against it? I'm speaking for the bill. All right. I generally believe what you say has merit, but the research from national institutions does not support the concept that you put forth, nor does logic, because if logic were
applied, then that would cause the University of Arkansas, or UCA, to be more efficiently serving their students if they had far fewer students than they have. I think that the argument that you make that's the best one is that small classes provide more opportunity for higher academic achievement because the teacher-pupil ratios are smaller and you're able to have
more hands-on learning experiences. And I think from all of the anecdotal evidence that we have, if we look at Elaine and Lakeview and my hometown, Hope, and places like Ms. Douglas is concerned about, Mr. Kossage, it is pretty clear that smaller classes provide more opportunities. And for that reason, I would support smaller classes. But I don't think that the other evidence shows that you save money by having smaller
classes, nor is there anything else other than anecdotal evidence to support the other premises except for the fact that you save communities. So how would you address? I know this is an issue because you're a financial conservative. Right now, there is an effort to raise class size by some people associated with you, and the idea is that if you raise class size, you can save money. And here we're talking about reducing Representative Fodges' class size in order to get better
academic achievement. At least at some point, we're going to have to reconcile these points of view. I'm a proponent of smaller class sizes and therefore smaller schools to an extent. But how do you do that? you make that reconciliation? I believe that the persons who speak for the bill are all in good faith, and they really want to do something good. But you're going to have to reconcile these countervailing points of view that you're presenting to us in the legislature for action. Well, you know, the
Speaker 111
48:03
study that we looked at didn't look specifically at class size. And I think intuitively it may be reasonable to think that rural schools are going to be larger. I'm not sure that's the case. You've got fewer students. You also have fewer teachers. I know when I was growing up, the class size was higher than what we have today. And the academic performance was better, according to the research I've seen. So the size of the class, I think, that would be most successful depends on many factors,
including what is the subject matter, who is the teacher, variety of different categories, so I'm not opposed or in favor of smaller or larger classes. I think we need to do what works. In regard to your comment about the research, again, we studied a document that looked at research over 95 years, and it came to a different conclusion. When I said earlier that the benefits of consolidation were achieved in the first half of the 20th
century. Let me be more specific what I'm talking about. What had been achieved by then across the country was moving from a situation where you may have one teacher teaching several subjects to teachers who were subject matter experts on what they were teaching. It moved from having multiple grades under one teacher to typically having 12 grades. As late as the early 1940s in Arkansas, we did not have across the state access to 12 years of school
for all of our citizens. We could go to eighth grade, but in some parts of the country, of the state, we could not go beyond that. That was addressed back in the 40s. So it's not that consolidation has no benefits. It's that the benefits that have been proven to be associated with consolidation. We have long moved past that. That has been achieved. And we, at this point, have too much of a good thing, I would say.
Mr. Sabin, question? Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll make my question as brief as possible. But you've mentioned a couple of times about the first half of the 20th century. And obviously, a lot has changed in Arkansas since then. I think part of the reason why we're dealing with this problem is, as you've indicated, We've lost a lot of population in rural areas of our state. We've lost a lot of jobs in rural areas of our state and therefore the tax base, local tax base has shrunk in those parts of the state. Which means that those communities often can't afford
to maintain their schools at the level that the state requires. And now subsequently that the court has required. And so the consolidation issue really came up because ultimately, it's not just a local burden, it's a state burden. And the state has to figure out a way to pay to provide that adequate level of education that our constitution guarantees in places that can't afford to do it for themselves. And that's sort of where we ended up. And so my question just simply is having to kind of make a value judgment and
knowing that it's possible that by adopting this new law that those economies of scale could be disrupted and we could end up having to pay more as a state for the maintenance of these schools. Not saying that's a bad thing, but just saying is it worth the possibility that we'll have to devote increased state funding in order to ensure adequacy across all schools in Arkansas? No, I don't think so. I mean, laying
Speaker 111
51:54
bad thing or a good thing to, you know,
are there benefits to providing more money in certain situations, this bill doesn't do that. This bill simply looks at the outcomes and says if the school is successful, if they're not in trouble academically, if they're not in trouble financially, if they're not in trouble in terms of facilities falling apart, not meeting code, and they don't have a violation of accreditation standards, they're allowed to continue. If they were to fall into physical distress and couldn't, you know, afford it, there's nothing in this bill that says the state has to step in and do that.
I would also point out that in the case of a lot of these schools that were closed, they were not in physical distress. Wiener, for example, had a million dollars in the bank. They were not asking the state for any additional money. They had a millage that was 4.4 mils higher than the school they got consolidated into, a condition which exists to this day. They provide 45% of the revenue to the Harrisburg School District, and they're a small part of it. So this bill is not to try to say that small schools should get more money because they're small.
It's simply saying if the outcome shows this school is successful, it's meeting needs, it's not any distress, why would we kill that school? Okay.
Speaker 126
53:24
Thank you, Madam Chair. Product of a rural community, small school, and farm-driven part of the state. And so my question would be to the research of the success of the small schools or the consolidated schools.
I don't think anybody at this table wants to be the one to vote against families, communities, or schools. But my question would be, in the smaller schools, the parents that are engaged, whether because they are economically able to be engaged or geographically able to be engaged, in an academic sense, in a college-bound sense, I understand that the smaller class, smaller school sometimes don't suffer.
What I see, so my question would be to the research, is sometimes the vocational side of these smaller schools or the workforce preparation in the smaller schools that they're struggling not to be in academic distress or fiscal distress, so the in-school activities, not the after-school activities that they would miss out while they're on the bus, but the in-school activities like participation in Future Farmers of America or Future Teachers of America suffer a little bit in some of these smaller schools because the superintendents or the financial gurus of this district are having to cut some of that to either stay
out of fiscal distress or spend more time studying for benchmarks or other tests and less time in activities that give these students a well-rounded education, not just the 3R education. So my question would be to the research. Was there any research on whether the vocational programs or the offerings of these consolidated schools were better than the smaller schools that they were before consolidation?
Speaker 89
55:08
specifically at that. And Douglas, of course, won't have immediate consideration.
go ahead and do that? Let me talk to her. Okay. Okay, thank you. Any other questions? Anyone else to speak against the bill? For the bill? Superintendent Thurman? I'll recognize you. Tony Thurman? Okay. Anyone else? Tony?
Mr. Thurman. Oh, okay. Yes, ma'am. Oh, okay. Okay. State your
Speaker 131
55:55
name, please, and who you represent. This is Tony Pothrow. I represent the Arkansas School Board Association. I appreciate being mixed up with the superintendent of the year. I've never been close to that.
Speaker 131
56:08
Thank you. asba supports this bill one of the new testimony here i don't know that's been pointed out yet or
not but when you talk about a number if the number of 350 was the determiner of whether or not a school district was physically sound or academically sound there would not be districts of thousands of students who we see put regularly into fiscal distress or into academic distress and i think that needs to be pointed out there meet so many factors that enter into the success of a school district that go way beyond this 350 number and one other thing I would like to point out is that as it was talked about earlier so many of these kids we do know
that one identifier of a kid's success in school is that they have something within the school of which they are a part of and so many of these small communities we have students that are there that are a part of the activities and when they move to a larger school we see a lot of times a point of disconnect that may take place there. So for those reasons and others that have been mentioned here, Arkansas School Board Association is in support of
this. Okay. Any questions? Mr. Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you.
I've said I'm going to support it, but I'm still trying to see how it makes sense. I will say that a school district that's small has to have a superintendent and a principal. And if you're going to have 300 students or 250 students in a class, what is the economic sense of having, by our rules, a superintendent and a principal in a school where you don't have enough teachers or other resources?
I mean, don't we have to look at this thing more panoramically than simply that? Now, I'd just like to know that it does not make sense to have a superintendent for a school of 300 where in some schools you only have a principal for a student body of 500 or 400 and assistant. Cost is one of the things that bothers me here. And when I'm willing to do it, continue to make the payment, I want to make some sense of it.
Speaker 131
58:24
Can you help me make some sense of it? Well, I think you've just thrown out a couple of numbers there, Representative Walker, of 250 or 300. I think that there are others that would say that 1,500. When you look at pure economy of scale, the larger that you are, especially as you get closer to that 500 number, if you've got a district that has 1,500 students or 2,000 students, economy of scale may show financially that that may or may not be the most feasible financial situation for a school district that would be best.
However, once again, you can't base it on a number because there are those districts that are out there that have those large numbers who we see, once again, getting into fiscal distress. So it's
about management. It's about many other factors. Okay. Thank you very much. Any other questions? Okay. I've been informed that the Arkansas Association of Educational Administrators and the Arkansas Public School Resource Center both support the bill
but don't want to testify today. So that leaves us with what are the wishes of the committee? Oh, wait a minute. Would you like to close for your bill, Representative Cozart? I am sorry. Madam Chair, I
would love to close for this bill. I would like to address a few of the concerns. I do hear Representative Walker's concerns for county schools. I don't always agree with a county school system. I've been on a school board for 10 years. That was much of the talk at that time.
Of course, that doesn't affect this bill, but I think that's something we'll be looking at in the future, you know, is to talk about that. Class sizes, I think a lot of things in rural schools are done differently. I think the class sizes still have to meet the standards of the state. I can remember when I was in school and many, many, many, many years ago that our class sizes varied a little bit, and they probably were a little larger than what they are now. The main things about a rural school and a big school and the things yesterday and today,
we do a lot of things in a different way. We have more classes. We break down mathematics a whole lot further than we ever did back then. We break down every subject into a lot of different classes. So the kids are being offered a lot of things, and the rural schools may not be able to offer quite as many of those things, but they do offer the subjects that are needed to meet adequacy, and they have to do that. That's one of the things, and we will keep a close watch on that. Some of the other things, oh, gosh, you know, each school is different.
I believe Representative Alexander talked about that, that all schools are different. Some schools are going to fail at a higher number. Some schools are going to fail at a lower number, and they're going to have academic issues. They're going to have financial issues. They could even have facility issues and be a large school and have something going on. So I think what we're trying to do is give these schools that are doing the right thing a chance to apply for this waiver, to continue on, and if they can't make it, then they can't make it.
But we want to give them that chance, whether it gives them one year or 20 years. We don't know what that outcome is going to be. But those communities, those small communities, if they want that school, they'll get behind that school, and they'll save those schools. So I would appreciate a good vote, and I thank everyone that worked on this bill. We worked hard on this, and there was a lot of people involved in it, and I
thank each and every one of you. Thank you, Representative. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a motion. Motion to pass. Okay, we have a motion do pass. on the bill.
All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations, Representative, you've passed your bill. Yes, sir. Thank you. I'm sorry. Okay, back to the end of
Me too. Representative Collins, if you will take the end of the table,
Thank you very much, Mr. Chair and Committee. What we're going to do first is we're going to introduce an amendment. That amendment is sponsored by three of the members of this committee. So as they make their way down to the table to present the amendment, I just want to give a 30-second summary of where we were in our two-and-a-half hours of discussion last time
so that we don't need to cover that ground again. I'd suggested that there were three things that we had to agree on in order to agree that this Professor Carey bill was the right way to go for the state. The first one was that we had an issue in our state and in our country with people killing folks on college campuses. The second thing was that perhaps concealed carry on campus could help us deter some of those killers. And the third thing was that the benefits outweighed the costs, that the benefits outweighed the risks.
And in the committee, we had a 10-10 vote. so I've been talking with some of the people that voted against the bill and on that third arena the benefits and the risks that's really where they had some ideas that they're now going to introduce and I support that as a way to amend this bill so that we can move forward together and help protect our kids on college campuses and so with that I'll yield to the amendment sponsors You are recognized
to present your amendment to this bill You did a great job
Thank you Thank you, Mr. Chair and Committee. First off, I'd like to thank Representative Collins for working with us and addressing our concerns. and it's been a pleasure to work this out and make it hopefully what we think makes it a better bill.
So thank you. Committee, what this amendment does is addresses training and notification. Being in emergency services for 30 years, I felt like, and my colleagues felt like, that I have a concealed carry that I've gone through the course and have passed it. With that said, an active shooter situation on a campus is nothing like a concealed carry class.
So with that, what we're wanting to do is if a person decides to carry a weapon on a college campus, they have to have an Arkansas concealed carry, not from another state. They have to attend an active shooter class. They have to pass that course, and they must let the law enforcement of that campus or jurisdiction know that they are in there with a gun. because the campus security or local law enforcement,
if there is a shooting on that campus, they're going to be coming in there and looking for the bad guy with the gun. And for the safety of the students, for the safety of the teacher, and for the safety of law enforcement, everybody has to be on the same playing field. Also, one other portion of it is that the weapons cannot be taken around the daycares. And there is a provision in here for continuing ed each year of eight hours.
And at this point in time, I'll turn it over to my colleagues for their comments, or we will
take questions. Look at all those hands go up. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized. Who
sets the curriculum for the training that these people are going to take?
It will be, they will train with the jurisdiction that they are with, if it is the college campus which is done by the American, I mean, Arkansas Justice Institute or the LIDA programs or wherever the jurisdiction of that campus gets their training, they will train with these individuals. Can I follow up,
Mr. Chair? Yes. Are they equipped to train people in hostage situations or urban warfare-like training?
Because that's what it goes into. That has to do with the active shooter course. All that is in that course. I have been through some of that training. And the best case scenario in an active shooter situation, it's chaos. And the concealed carry does not address those issues. When the person, the teacher with the weapon,
They need to know what law enforcement is doing in that situation, and law enforcement needs to know that the person inside knows what's going on with that situation also. It's just the knowledge of going through the course and getting them trained. If I may, Mr. Chair, follow up, and this is my
last follow-up. Is that your third one? It will be your second
one. Well, I thought he already was on, too, so I'm going to skip you and come back to you.
Okay. Thank you, sir. Representative Saban, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd known that this amendment was coming. My first opportunity to see it was this morning when I came into committee, and so my question has to do with the fact that the two most significant parts of the amendment, the one that, in your words said, would require the active shooter course, as well as the other one, part of the amendment that says, you know, that you cannot carry this gun into a daycare or child facility.
Those two sections of the amendment are two of the only sections that use the word may instead of shall. And I thought that was curious just because obviously, you know, we're kind of going out of our way to force this policy on our universities. And, you know, obviously they said they didn't want it. We passed a different version of it two years ago. They all voted, obviously, not to do it. Now we're saying we want you to do it. But this amendment, which is supposed to be a compromise, is adding these two elements.
But yet, again, the only two sections and the most important sections use those words may instead of shall. And I think that's significant. And I'm just asking why that is and if that can be changed so that it's understood that we shall require a licensee to complete the active shooter
Speaker 126
1:10:22
course, not may, require. Representative Sabin, that's an excellent point. That question was debated amongst the three of us. And if I can answer it the best I can,
what you guys did in the 89th General Assembly was pass this with the option, correct me if I'm wrong, for the universities to either opt in or opt out to allow concealed carry on campus. So today, if a university decided to opt in, they cannot require any additional training. They can just opt in to allowing concealed carry on campuses. So what we did with this was saying, now that the attempt of Representative Collins' bill
is to take the opt-in and opt-out provision out of the concealed carry on college campuses, We're at least giving a tool to the university administrations to say, okay, you took the opt-in or opt-out clause away from us, but now we may require extra training if we so choose. Is it all
right? You can follow up. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I just want to make sure I understand this. So we're saying the universities have to allow these people to carry these weapons,
but they don't have to require them to go through the active shooter course and the only reason why i'm not understanding that is i thought the whole point of this amendment as a compromise was that if we're going to force these universities to allow these people to carry weapons at the very least they ought to be required to go through an active shooter course because if that situation were to arise on campus it would be to everybody's benefit and for the safety of all concerned, that the people with these weapons are
as trained and as prepared and as ready and as coordinated with
Speaker 126
1:12:19
law enforcement as possible. I think the goal and the intent are to that concealed carry on campus, the universities have the opportunity to require this training. Today, they do not have the ability to require this training. If any campus opted in today before representative Collins bill was introduced they cannot that as it was written they cannot require any
additional training so what we're doing is not we are saying to colleges and universities you have the opportunity and the option to require additional training if you so choose if you're if concealed carry licensed people are going to carry on your campus so in effect we're leaving it up to the universities and colleges to decide which I hope and it was our desire and hope that they would decide that extra additional training is required but don't
lose sight of the fact that today as the law stands today there is no additional training required nor is there any additional training required in Mr. Collins's bill the only place additional training to address is in this amendment and it's given the college universities leadership the opportunity to require this training.
Speaker 58
1:13:39
Representative Saban if you look on this page one on 2a it's a training program should administering this session shall consist of and the cost of training of this subject shall not cede we've got a lot
of shells in there that's going to take
care of that. Well and that's what I had said there there are shells everywhere just not in sort of what I would think is the most important part of the amendment, which is because those other shalls only apply if, you know, the campus ops in. It's like we're forcing the campuses to do everything except require the active shooting training, which to me was the essence of the compromise. But, again, I understand you've definitely answered my question.
So thank you. Representative Armstrong, be recognized
for a question if you still would. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you very much. On page one, section 2A, really 2D, it reads,
a training program under this subsection shall be made available at least one time every three months. It shall be made available. And that concerns me. Does that mean that all 35 to 40 colleges that we have here shall have on campus a training program every three months?
And does it mean that there is going to be something like a training director? And obviously if there's going to be a training program every three months and it's got to go on for every five years, it's going to have some expense. In your amendment, have you made a cost analysis of what it would take to implement this? And the other part of my question, since you're trying to get it through, is what do the universities say about this, even with the effort of my friends to try to work through this and to help a bad bill become good?
I mean, what do the universities say about this, after
all? Do they still want it? Thank you. Your local law enforcement and local jurisdictions are constantly training with the continuing ed on these kind of active shooter type situations. They constantly train. So I don't feel like that's a big issue. And there's courses all over the state and in towns
where folks can get this type of training through the LIDA programs or, you know, there's local companies or, you know, private companies that do this also. So that's, you know, the training part is not a big issue. I think they can get that any time they want to. As far as the colleges, we have visited with some. All are not on board. Some are more comfortable with it, with the training. So, you know, that's kind of where we are on that.
Representative Hodges, you are recognized for question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You kind of touched on my question a little bit there, but I was just curious if you could describe to us a little bit more who it is that's putting on this training, who's administering the programs. And it says that the programs have to be reasonably accessible. And so I'm just wondering, are there enough of these programs statewide that staff on all of our public campuses really have access to them?
Yes, they are. There's, as I said earlier, you know, there's local, I mean, private companies that do this. I know of several of them that will even come to your local police department or local campus security or whatever, and they're really reasonable in price, and they will put on an active shooter course at your facility. So, you know, it's really just kind of scheduling, you know, when everybody can get together.
And your local jurisdictions do train a lot. And you can't say enough about the training of this because that's what you've got to have in these situations. I'll come back to Representative Armstrong.
He was next if you want some questions. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Did you all do a physical impact on this amendment?
Representative Armstrong, this is higher ed. It does not require a physical impact.
Thank you, sir. Representative Seidman, you are recognized for question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess I'll just return to the other part of my first question, which is subsection I, number one, the part of the amendment that addresses the daycare and child facility. That's the other place where it's may instead of shall. It says a licensee may not carry a concealed handgun into a daycare or child care facility that is located on the campus of a public university, public college, or public community college.
I'm just curious why may instead of shall in that area as well. Representative. Thank you,
Speaker 126
1:19:21
Representative Sabin. The answer will be very similar. The daycare on campus was something that Representative Letting, I believe, brought up the first time this bill came. So as the current law stands, there was no, if a college or university decided to opt in under the laws that were passed in the 89-10 Assembly, there are no exemptions for the daycare area.
So once again, we left it to the leadership of the colleges and universities that they have the option to keep concealed carry permit holders from carrying guns in these areas. Once again, we left that discretion to the layers of the respective campuses. You want to follow up? I promise this is
the last thing. I just want to make sure I understand this very clearly.
So the only two areas in which we're allowing college campuses discretion when it comes to the rules applying to whether concealed carry, people with concealed carry permits can bring their weapons onto campus. We're giving them discretion of whether or not they can require active shooter training. And we're giving them discretion as to whether or not they can let those people go into a daycare or a childcare facility on campus. Under this amendment. Under this amendment. So otherwise, the campuses don't have discretion on any other issues.
Those are the only two areas in which the campuses have their
Speaker 58
1:20:56
own discretion on this issue. There's also football stadiums and, you know, athletic events and all that in the actual bill.
In the bill. Okay, fair enough. Okay, thank you. Is there anyone
that would like to speak against the amendment for the amendment?
Would you like to close for
your amendment, Representative Balton? Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, we've done a lot of working together on this. We're not against weapons in any shape, form, or fashion, but we are for safety of the kids and the teachers, and we just feel like this would be a better, more workable solution with training. Thank you so much. Appreciate a good vote. Representative Eubanks, you're recognized.
I move we adopt the amendment. I have a motion to adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Motion carries. Amendment is adopted. Mr. Collins, you are recognized to present House Bill
1077 as amended. Members, again, we talked about this bill extensively before. In the last discussion, I also had made some amendments.
One of those amendments gave the colleges to opt out if they were within a half mile, UAMS within a half mile of the emergency room in Little Rock, another amendment within a half mile of the Clinton School. That amendment was engrossed separately since it did not become part of the bill in the last committee. So those exemptions that I presented in that amendment are still in this new bill. Beyond that, there is the concealed carry law itself, which dictates many exemptions which apply to college campuses,
for example, football stadiums and other things. So what this new amendment does is add in the daycares, And just as Representative Gray said, moves the college's decision-making option choice to require the active shooter training. And again, as I would summarize this, there were three things we have to agree on in order to feel that we're making progress to protecting the lives of our loved ones on campus.
The first one is that there is a problem. The second one is that it's possible to deter some of these killers from coming to our campuses and that concealed carry could be a part of that solution. And then the third thing is that the risks and benefits were balanced in such a way that the benefits exceeded the risks. And I think what this amendment does is reduce the risk of problems, reduce the risk of accidents to a level that more of the members of the committee can feel comfortable.
I realize that's not 100%, but it's difficult to get to 100% in life. And so with that, Mr. Chair, I would appreciate a good vote to
questions. Thank you very much. This is active shooter training. I have two questions, with the Chair's permission. will there be records of the active
shooter training so that someone will be able to know who received the training who gave it under what circumstances yes Representative Walker
subject to the Freedom of Information Act so that people in the public may know Representative Walker
this will be treated in the same fashion that the concealed carry license information is treated. So the way that's treated, sir, is the state police maintain a database of concealed carry holders.
This training will be documented by campus security or the local police that the colleges have worked with. Those records will be available in the same form and fashion as concealed carry license holders, which means law enforcement will have access to this. There's also a section at the end of that amendment that says that the holder of these certifications will be required to give the notice of those certifications to any other law enforcement that has jurisdiction if they request it. So this information will flow to law enforcement, but it will stay in the law enforcement realm.
It will not be public information, sir. If the universities are going to be authorizing people to have weapons and to be on campus with them, why doesn't the public have an interest in knowing about who the persons are who have been given license? Because otherwise there may be a presumption that everybody has the right to carry them.
And then we'll just be in a situation where there is great fear and other things on campus. I mean, I'm just trying to understand the public advantage in not allowing in a university context at least teachers and administrators to know who have been through the training and who's authorized to carry guns on campus. I mean, at least the teacher in a class ought to know, or perhaps security people on campus
ought to know, or in some cases, students ought to know, I would imagine, if they are within the
zone of protection. So our concealed carry laws obviously are designed for people that have been issued a concealed carry license to be able to carry the weapon in concealed fashion, and this is very, very consistent with that. the universities will have the option to require this additional active shooter training so that the individuals will not only have the concealed carry license,
but also this additional training if the colleges want to opt for them to have that. The fact that those individuals are then the ones that are eligible to carry on the college campus where they work will be information available to law enforcement so that, for example, God forbid we're in a situation where there's an active shooter incident and law enforcement arrives at the scene and they want to understand who in those buildings may legally be carrying a weapon, they will have access to that information in a very quick fashion. So the access to the information is for the use of law enforcement
in ensuring that we minimize risk, maximize safety, protect our children, but it is not designed to be used for others to make employment decisions or decide which individuals they may or may not be happy with. Is that your second
follow-up? I'll have to come back to you, Representative. I have some more in line. Representative Harris, you're recognized.
Representative Columns, I hope you would disagree or disagree. Question, you know, some amendments, you know, you've conceded on, and it still is not going to make people happy. And so I appreciate you going ahead and doing this, and the representatives who did make the amendments, I appreciate it. But I hope that in the places that is gun-free zones, that they do not mark them as gun-free zones because in those places, those innocent
lives could become targets. And so I hope the And universities use very, they use discretions in that area. Would you agree or disagree? I would agree with you that they need to follow the concealed carry law of
the state of Arkansas in making known or not known any of their decisions. I would just suggest that they simply comply with the concealed carry laws. And in that sense, I agree with you, sir. Thank you. Representative Sabin, did you have a question?
you called on me, Mr. Chair, I thought Well, you kind of gave
me that look, so you're recognized. I'm sorry if I did, but I appreciate the recognition. I guess now that the amendment's been adopted into the bill, I've just got to know, why wouldn't we require the universities to have the active shooter training since that's such now a huge selling point for coming back and trying to pass this
bill? Representative Sabeman, you and I disagree.
I believe, on the capability of a person with a concealed carry license and the fact that he or she may be there to deter killers from coming to campus. I think we may also disagree on the capability of that individual to act in this situation. I think what we experience in our everyday life, whether we're talking about going into a Walmart or going into a restaurant, is that these individuals are able to manage themselves. The reason that I was amenable to the amendment was because, number one, I thought it was very well thought out,
and I really appreciate the work of Representative Balz and Gray and Ratliff to design that amendment. I thought they were very sincere in their belief that they had reservations about the risk-reward profile of our move forward and that this was something that was near and dear to their hearts in terms of reducing the fears and the risks from their standpoint. And so maybe I'm not right, and maybe I'm wrong, and maybe something like this and giving the colleges the option to do something like this makes this a better bill.
And so in the interest of making sure that we're taking in all of the good, hard thinking and putting ourselves in a position to have a bill that the majorities that are needed to pass legislation can feel good about, I'm willing to move forward here. But if a college were to say we're not going to require this, I'm fine with them to have that ability to just believe, as I do, that the concealed carry license is enough for a person to behave on the campus.
Representative McElroy, do you have a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, I appreciate all the work you've done, and especially the people that have tried to make the bill, you know, more palatable for us. And, you know, I've been really torn about this bill because I realize what you're trying to do. It's just that I've heard so much about local control this time.
And won't this bill, if I vote for it, take away local control from the Board of Trustees? Sir, I
would answer you that it moves local control even further down the food chain to individual control. And the university boards, they still have an option. The option is to require the training if they choose to do that. But you're right. we're giving the choice, the decision, to conceal carry all the way down to the individual
concealed carry holder, obviously complying with whatever training requirements the universities opt to require. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative
Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, when you said maybe I'm right, maybe I'm wrong, I don't know a time when you've ever told me before you've ever been wrong. The first time for everything, Representative Walker. How about you? I've been wrong a number of times. I changed my vote
several times. Here's what I'm concerned about. If you have these training courses, obviously you're going to have training courses. It's going to be available, so it's got to be some course. That means people are going to be in the courses. Obviously, you can't have one-on-one training. I don't think you can contemplated one-on-one training, because if you have 40 universities and you have one-on-one training and you have 100 people wanting this in each one of the schools, you have 4,000 people or maybe 400 or whatever, that's not contemplated that you'll have one-on-one
training. But that brings me to this conclusion. If you have group training, then the persons within the groups know the identities of the other people who are taking these shooter courses. So if they can know the identities of the people who are in these shooter training courses,
why can't the public know? Sir, in concealed carry today there are also courses, and these courses happen all over the state, and many of those courses are multiple individuals in those courses.
And so we're experiencing that today with the laws, and yet our FOI approach for concealed carry classes seems to be working just fine. So I'm just modeling this, and the people with the amendment are just modeling it after the way we treat CCL holders and giving them the same level of access, i.e., within law enforcement, once those things are certified, as we have for concealed carry holders. I'm sure it's going to work just fine. If there are problems, obviously we can fix them in the future,
but I'm not anticipating any based on how well the CCL approach is working everywhere else. Seeing no other questions, I'm going
to move to the audience. Does anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Seeing no one rise quickly. You are recognized and closed for your bill. I'm closed, Mr. Chair. I'd appreciate a good
vote as amended. Representative Lowry, you're recognized for a motion.
Yes, I move. Do pass. As amended? As amended. I have a motion of do pass. as amended. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Motion carries. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. Representative House, you are recognized to present House Bill 1393.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, set your watch. I will tell you what I need to tell you in three minutes or less. During the summer, I was a member of the Joint Performance Review Committee. We were charged with doing an assessment in Arkansas of the two-year, four-year institutions, our trade schools, to some extent the public schools, and with an emphasis on K through job rather than K through 12 or K through 16. One of the visits we made was to a job competition, a job skills
competition down in Hot Springs, and we viewed a number of trades, welding, carpentry, plumbing, automobile mechanics, cosmetology. During the cosmetology exam, we saw something and talked to some of the instructors. There were approximately 2,000 cosmetology students in all of the 62 schools in the state of Arkansas. Of those 2,000 students, about 200 of them could look for jobs and find jobs. Digging a little deeper and visiting other schools and then requesting
some additional information, I mentioned 62 schools in the state. There are approximately 157 people in institutes of higher education, that's the two-year universities, and the tech and both tech schools, about 167 grand total, 324 students in state institutions. The Department of Labor, the Workforce Service people project that they have an opportunity to obtain one of 69 jobs in this state.
So we have 324 kids in our state institutions, about 2,000 kids in all of our institutions. I say kids, young adults. And there are about 2,482 total barbers, beauticians, hairdressers, hairstylists in the state. What really brought this bill to my attention was as I was sitting in the budget committee, I saw an $800,000 appropriation for a new cosmetology building at one of our two-year institutions.
Doing a little research, kind of looking through how much money was appropriated to these schools, I found about $4 million that we're spending in those appropriations. Yesterday, I obtained some additional information that we're spending about $2.2 million extra in the high schools to teach this as well, making it a total of somewhere around $6 million that we're spending for cosmetology training to fill a grand total of 69 jobs in this state, maybe 200 if you believe the instructors.
The bill that was prepared would have directed the Department of Higher Education not to allocate money to the schools of cosmetology. The reason for that was you've got state institutions in competition with private institutions. And there are certainly plenty of schools to go around. This morning I announced this decision and visited with some of the four-year institutions about four or five weeks ago.
Asked for comment, heard nothing, but thank you. We needed somebody to look into it. But this morning, the two-year institution organization came up and talked to me and asked me to visit with them, asked me to pull the bill down, and I will do so. I want you to be aware of what we're spending our money on and what we're getting and what the opportunities. I think we are misleading these young people into believing they have careers. True. Many of them want to work in their backyard, their little shop, their kitchen,
their extra place in their home. A lot of them go on to do other things and different things. But in terms of job training and the educational component, it's not a very productive-looking scenario. Based on what I've just told you, Mr. Chairman, I'd like to pull the bill down after I've entertained any questions that anybody has. You'd like to take questions from the committee? Representative Harris has a
Mr. Chair, if that's okay, I mean, I was just kind of curious, Representative House, the issue with what you may take issue with, you know, because one of our pushes is children, our kids aren't college bound. So we've got to get them ready for a trade, and I think that's an excellent idea maybe for them to get ready for another trade other than college. And one thing you said in there that maybe I take issue with, you know, not wasting money in the two-year maybe,
but have them ready for a trade as soon as they're out of high school with a license or something. What's your issue with in high school? Are they not ready once they get out of high school, or what is your issue
there? No, I have no issue with high school. As a matter of fact, the figures I quoted you are the institutions after high school. um the um as a matter of fact some of the private schools are actually providing the training in the high schools uh and the high schools and that's a local school board decision they actually
pay the private institutions to come in and teach the courses in the high school So I'm talking the 62 schools total include high schools. There are 324 people enrolled after high school, the two-year, four-year, and the trade schools. Does that answer your question? Yeah, and maybe since you're pulling it down, I'll
ask more later, and you can get that information of where your issues are and bring it back to the committee.
Well, I guess the real issue is we're spending about $6,750 per student for jobs that don't exist. That's what you need to get to the bottom of. Okay. All
right. Thank you. Thank you. As Representative House has said, he's going to pull
this bill down. Are there any other questions to the committee? Mr. Chair, I won't try to bring this bill
back up. Thank you, Representative House. Thank you, Mr. Chair, for your time, members of the committee. I appreciate you taking time. Do you want to leave it on deferred, put it on deferred?
Take it off deferred where you take it completely down. It's on a regular agenda now. I can move
it to deferred if you would like. Leave it on deferred, sir, and I won't try to pull it back down. We will move this to deferred. Is there any other business to come before this committee today? If not, without objection, we are adjourned.
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 5
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Speaker 14
Speaker 20
Chair
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 58
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Representative Reginald Murdock
Unverified
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Speaker 90
Representative Justin T. Harris
Unverified
Speaker 108
Speaker 111
Speaker 122
Speaker 126
Speaker 89
Speaker 82
Speaker 131
Speaker 132
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Speaker 68
Representative Jon S. Eubanks
Unverified
Representative Scott Baltz
Unverified
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Chair
Unverified
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Speaker 183
Representative Mark D. McElroy
Unverified
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Speaker 76