Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Education Committee

March 3, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (8)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1395 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…you. Representative Gossage, you are recognized to present House Bill 1395.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1366 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1366”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1372 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Representative Meeks, you're recognized to present 1372, House Bill 1372. I believe you have an amendment for that. Is that right? T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1241 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1241”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1370 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1370”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1377 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1377”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1581 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1581”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1591 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Bill 1581. Okay. Okay. we recognize the speaker for house bill 1591 1581 excuse me”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Okay, members, let's find a seat so we can begin our day's work. We'll start this morning with House Bill 1366. Representative Branscombe, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Madam
▶ Play
Chairwoman. This is a technical cleanup for an amendment that the Senate, I guess, called changing from president to chairperson. Hold it just a minute, Representative
▶ Play
Branscombe. We need to have a little more quiet in the rooms, please. We can't hear it, Peter.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Branscombe. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman. This is a technical cleanup on the bill that I brought last week that was on a technical cleanup. And we're going to do a little more technicality cleaning up. Changing from chair to president to chairperson. There was a couple of places they failed to edit out chairperson or president and it needs to be the chairperson. And that's all it is.
▶ Play
Okay. Any questions? Representative Letting, you're recognized. Motion at the proper time. Any questions by the committee? Is there anyone in the audience who'd like to speak for the bill? Is there anyone who'd like to speak against the bill? Okay. Is he closed for his bill? All right. Would you like to close for your bill, Representative Branskin? Yes, ma'am. I'm closed. Okay. Representative Vleding, you had a motion. Move to pass as amended. Okay. Do pass to concur. Okay. We have a motion of do pass on Bill 1366. All of those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, nay, or no. Okay. Your bill passed. Congratulations. Thank you, committee. The speakers will
▶ Play
be next meeting in the House
▶ Play
Bill 1581. Okay. Okay. we recognize the speaker for house bill 1591 1581 excuse me
▶ Play
thank you madam chair committee i appreciate letting me go before we get into the more lengthy bills with discussion today what i am before you today to ask for support for is the creation of a task force to study the realignment of higher education. And first and foremost, I owe an apology to the Department of Higher Education and to some of their staff because in my schedule I was unable to call them and give them a heads up about this. But just very briefly, I have spoken with some of the university systems about this idea of looking at the feasibility of realigning higher education into a limited number of university systems in the state. And over the summer and in the fall, just attending some conferences and looking at some different information around the country, realized that we have a lot of independent university systems in the state compared to a lot of the states around us, and especially those states that we continually refer to back as the states that we want to model for economic development. And so what I wanted to do instead of just coming in with a bill that did all this, I wanted to actually study it, look at this to see if the financial savings that have been kind of on a cursory glance that we've been able to identify are real savings that we could have to be able to put back into higher education in the state of Arkansas. And so that's what you have before you is the creation of a task force to study that over the remainder of this biennium and then to come back at a predetermined date with some recommendations as to whether or not that we need to move forward with this idea at the time. Okay. Are there any questions by the
▶ Play
committee? Mr. Walker has a question. Mr. Rocker, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Speaker, you know I always have at least one question for you. Saving money is not the only objective of this legislature, I hope. What is your view that if you reconfigure the colleges and the junior colleges are the two-year colleges in the state, that it will have a devastating economic effect upon the communities in which those colleges are located. Now, you recall, I opposed having all these community colleges in the first place, but aren't they economic engines that help maintain communities that are, in so many cases, otherwise not justifiable? Representative Walker, what I'm proposing
▶ Play
here is not to close down any of the existing community colleges or universities. What I'm proposing to do is create a task force that would study whether or not all of these existing universities and community colleges could be under just a limited number of university systems, but not actually closing down the campuses is not what I have in mind at this time at all. So if I did not articulate that, then I apologize because that's not what the goal of this is. And it's not just to save money. I think you keyed on something important there as well. It's maybe to find a way to increase services for these areas, maybe by helping to align some of the systems that we maybe have that are redundant that might create hopefully a better higher education environment for the entire state. It's not necessarily to be punitive to any particular university or anything like that at all. It's just simply trying to see if maybe we can do things better than what we've been doing them now, taking advantage of some great ideas that other states maybe have that maybe some of our universities wanted to do but just haven't been able to do because of the way that we're aligned.
▶ Play
Yes, Representative Walker. You're recognized for a follow-up. Thank you very much. I'm concerned because whenever you begin affecting the governance of a place, you start affecting the economics of that county. I'll just use, for example, Phillips County. When the seat of Phillips County started off as Phillips County Junior College, and when you move that and you made it a part of a larger system, you move the seat of governance to Stuttgart, Stuttgart is now viable while Helena, in all due respect to those who may be here from the Helena area, Helena is sort of like a war zone. So when you do these things, they're always, anytime you do something, there is a cause and effect. And I'd just not like to see any more economic disaster as a consequence of your good intentions with this bill.
▶ Play
And Representative Walker, I can appreciate that. That's why instead of just coming in this session and proposing some master plan, I felt like this was prudent. And in discussions with the governor and President Desming, they were in agreement that this was a more prudent way to go through to look at what maybe those consequences might be for the idea. Maybe there's some unintended consequences that haven't been thought through yet, and that's what this task force would do would be to come back and provide some thorough assessment of both the pros and the cons of an idea such as this and whether or not it was feasible for the state to move forward in this fashion or whether or not it was better off to leave things like
▶ Play
it was. Yes. Any other questions by the committee? Is there anyone in the audience that wishes to speak for the bill? Against the bill? Okay. Would you like to close? Oh, I'll take a motion from Representative Balls. Motion to pass. So what I have to do first. Okay. Okay. Speaker, would you like to close for your bill? I'm sorry. I'm closed, Madam Chair. Okay. Thank you. Okay. We have a motion. Do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Against? No. Congratulations. Your bill is passed. Thank you, committee,
▶ Play
and thank you again for the indulgence
▶ Play
on the schedule. Okay. Next bill, man. House
▶ Play
Speaker 38 9:20
bill 1372. You want me to do it? No.
▶ Play
Speaker 40 9:24
It didn't take me long over there. No, sir, Mr. Barrett, 1372. Is that Meeks?
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, you're recognized to present 1372, House Bill 1372. I believe you have an amendment for that. Is that right? The amendment
▶ Play
is in gross, Chair. Senate gross, okay. You're
▶ Play
Speaker 47 9:46
going to represent the bill? Okay. Thank you. This is a bill that has already passed out. Again, it is just allowing a private school to decide whether or not they want to allow concealed carry on campus it passed out of the committee already one time and so I'm hoping that it will pass again we just wanted to again tighten down the language a little bit there was some concern originally that it would actually do more to restrict than allow and so we just made a couple of changes on page 2 line 6 we changed to where it would tighten it down to the same language that you already see in statute which is a building or event so with that said I'll be glad to take any questions are there any questions committee I'm seeing no
▶ Play
questions committee is anyone like speak against the bill for the bill would you like close for that bill he's closed what is the will of the committee I have a due pass from representative Diffenbaum all All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say no. Congratulations, you passed your bill again. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Gossage, you are recognized to present House Bill 1395.
▶ Play
Speaker 61 11:20
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We've had this on the markup for quite a while. Been working on this behind the scenes for a long time. Actually got a lot of feedback before this bill was ever filed. I appreciate all the feedback that I've gotten from members. I was approached a few months ago about presenting a bill from the American Diabetes Association in regard to allowing trained volunteers to administer insulin at school. I just want to cover a couple of pieces of information before we get started. I have some real experts with me here today. I'm just a pretend expert. There are two types of diabetes, type 1 and type 2. Type 1 diabetes is known as juvenile diabetes, and only 5% of the population has that. The more common, obviously, is type 2. 95% of diabetes cases are of type 2. Two particular issues that arise with diabetics are hypoglycemia, which is low blood sugar, and hyperglycemia, which is high blood sugar. We already have in statute the ability for school personnel to give glucagon, which is what is administered during times of low blood sugar or hypoglycemia. This bill just adds the ability for trained school personnel to give insulin to students. It's a very, very limited in scope bill. Let me tell you how limited it actually is. First of all, there cannot be a school nurse available. School nurse is available, he or she is going to administer if needed. The parents have to have requested it. The doctor has to have provided a note, a letter saying that they concur with that. Someone at the school has to volunteer to do this. that volunteer has to be trained and then an emergency has to occur when the school nurse is not present all of those circumstances have to be present before this bill ever becomes effective i would submit to you that's not going to happen very often and if you have a child the essential question is do you want would you want someone at the school under those circumstances in an emergency situation in which no school nurse is present would you prefer to have someone with training or not that's all this bill does now with me today I have Connie Fetters from the American Diabetes Association she's going to provide with the chair's indulgence a little more information. State your name
▶ Play
and who you're with and you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 64 14:38
Thank you. My name is Connie Fedders. My background, I'm with the American Diabetes Association. My background is as an RN, a registered nurse, and I'm also a certified diabetes educator. As a certified diabetes educator, part of my job is to help families learn how to manage diabetes. As a registered nurse, I have worked in schools as a school nurse, and I have also worked to help train school nurses and school districts on how to manage children with diabetes. House Bill 1395, as he said, does consider two components which we think are vital to helping children with diabetes. Type 1, you know, it provides autonomy for children, and as he said, it just provides the ability for someone to be able to give insulin if the school nurse is not available. Type 1 diabetes is a chronic disease. With type 1, the pancreas doesn't make insulin. People with type 1 diabetes have to take insulin at least once a day, more than once a day, several times a day actually, and our school children are required to have insulin at least once a day during the school day. Current data shows that there are about 15,000 children every year diagnosed with type 1. According to the last school nurse's report done in Arkansas, we have about 1,000 children in our state who have type 1 diabetes spread throughout our schools. Diabetes is a disease where the management is done almost entirely by lay people. You do not have to be a nurse to take care of diabetes. Treatments for type 1 diabetes, they're designed to be done by lay people using technology approved by the FDA for use by lay people. Children with diabetes become quite proficient in taking care of their diabetes themselves. Most children are pretty proficient by the time they're in junior high. However, all children still need some oversight. Presently in Arkansas, the only person able to assist a child with diabetes is the school nurse. So in 30 states, we have passed a bill that has given the opportunity for someone to be trained so that if the school nurse is not present, someone else can help that child with insulin. In all 30 of these states, it has been very positive. It has been worked into their Nurse Practice Act without any problem. It has not shown to have any adverse liability issues. and the thing that has happened is that it's made a safer environment for our kids with type 1 diabetes. We already have prepared training materials for use to help people learn how to administer insulin and give it in the schools. This bill does not mandate anything. It simply gives the child with diabetes and their family further support for safety in the school environment. I hope that you will agree that it's time to expand our horizons and work together to learn from the experiences of the states that have passed this legislation so that we can provide this additional safety net for our kids with diabetes.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Harris, you have a question.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I have a follow-up, too, if that's... You are granted your follow-up. Thank you. Just like anything, I believe even sending your child to public school, it's a parent's choice on everything. In this situation, from the nurse's perspective, this insulin and everything, it can already come pre-done.
▶ Play
Speaker 64 18:31
Is that correct? Yes. The way that, for those of us in the room who are over 50, which is quite a few of us, the way that we used to look at insulin is not anything the same anymore. You had the old syringe, you had to pull it up, you know, all of this. Today's insulin, half of our kids in school, almost half of them use an insulin pump. An insulin pump is a little device that is pre-programmed. You put in your blood sugar. Sometimes it even comes over from your glucose meter. You put in the carbohydrate grams. It figures the insulin. You push a button. It administers it. For those children who are not on insulin pump, insulin now comes in a little pen device, and a needle goes on it. You don't draw up the insulin. You dial up your dose. The insulin is given. So it is much more convenient, and, you know, we've
▶ Play
definitely improved that. All right. So for some, this could be life and death. But Representative Gossage, my question now comes to you. Who's responsible in case something goes awry with the child, the person administering the shot?
▶ Play
Speaker 61 19:42
Well, in this bill on page 3, line 19, it doesn't change the liability laws in Arkansas. It's continuing. You know, we have immunity, unless someone were grossly negligent, which basically means they did it on purpose, not be held liable for trying to help someone. And, again, we're talking about, I personally have been in several situations, not necessarily with a diabetic, but in other situations where just a little bit of training sure would have been nice. And I don't think we have to worry about a liability issue here. Certainly, I think anyone that volunteers to do this and goes to get the training to do this is going to do everything in their power to make sure that they do right by that child. Thank you
▶ Play
for that clarification. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. How much training is involved for the person that's going to administer the treatment for diabetes?
▶ Play
Speaker 64 20:46
I can't really give you an exact hour training. The training would include, you know, some information about diabetes as well as specifically about the child and about the insulin administration. So I can't give you an exact hour if that's what you're hunting for. But, you know, the school, the physicians involved, the school nurses, definitely the parents of that child would all be involved in the training. And there is already a good training has been set up in the 30 states that it has already passed. So we
▶ Play
Speaker 79 21:28
don't have to reinvent the wheel. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Thank you very much. Did you define a while ago what nurse being available meant? Was that in the building, or is that give me that
▶ Play
Speaker 61 21:49
definition? Like so many things that we do, you know, you can't always just trump common sense. I can go back, you know, to Ozark, which I'm most familiar with. We have six campuses, and some of them are very close together. They share nurses in some cases. A nurse can be from one building to the other in five minutes. So certainly under those circumstances, a reasonableness would dictate that you would just call over and get the nurse to come over. In other cases, we have an Altus campus, which is about 20 minutes away, and that might not be something we would want to wait on. I think that's dictated by circumstance, and we always just have to rely on people's judgment sometime of being reasonable about this. And
▶ Play
if I could have a follow-up, Mr. Chair. You may. When you say nurse, are we defining that as a RN as opposed to an LPN, CNA? Where do you draw the line on who can administer these at this
▶ Play
Speaker 64 22:55
point? Currently in your schools, you have both RNs and LPNs.
▶ Play
And they're both allowed to administer? I believe
▶ Play
Speaker 64 23:03
they are both allowed to administer, RNs and LPNs are both allowed to administer medications, yes. But a CNA would be able to get the
▶ Play
training if a parent wanted them to be their designated personnel? If they were the volunteer, yes, someone
▶ Play
Speaker 64 23:17
else could, yes. Thank you. Thank you very much. Representative Gossage,
▶ Play
I have a question. Do we keep information on every student that has this issue so that they would know a little bit of history about them in
▶ Play
Speaker 61 23:35
that school district? I would like to tell you that every diabetic student in Arkansas has a health management plan on file in the office. I believe that they probably do, but, I mean, I'm not going to testify that every one of them does, but that would be the intention. Any student with a medical condition that needs continuous monitoring, has a health plan in the central office locked within the nurse's station, or if there's not a nurse present, they have their health records also in that same vicinity, usually. Any other questions,
▶ Play
committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you. Ma'am, what is your name again? My name is Connie Fetters. Ms. Fetters, you're with the Diabetes
▶ Play
Speaker 64 24:24
Association. I'm the state advocacy chair for the Diabetes Association. I don't work for the Diabetes Association. I'm a volunteer with
▶ Play
them. You indicated that there were 30 to perhaps 40 states that have passed similar legislation. Yes. Has there been any evaluation of the experiences of those states with respect to the administration of insulin to insulin-dependent children? Anything in writing that we can see other than anecdotal
▶ Play
Speaker 64 24:59
references? Yes. Actually, there is finally one piece of literature. This is, you know, it hasn't, it's been, you know, there's one piece of literature. Let me just finish that. Just in January or December, I believe, of last year, two of our major diabetes centers, one in Colorado and one in Texas, did a study to, and it was just done with parents, in the states where the legislation had been passed and where it had not been passed. And we did show out of that study that parents were very satisfied with what had happened in the states where it was passed. There wasn't, and their satisfaction was actually better than in the states where it wasn't passed. There wasn't any discussion in this study about whether we found, you know, more problems or less problems or anything like that. I believe that we will find in the next few years that this will be looked into much more specifically and we will have more comprehensive data on that area. But right now there's only one study that has been done.
▶ Play
Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You may. Thank you. What you have described to me seemed to be not a study but a survey, and it was limited to parental approval. Do you have any studies by professional persons in the field addressing the issues that so many people who are here have raised regarding that? I'd like to know a study is over against a survey. We do surveys all the time, and surveys usually are often yield the results we want to have them yield. But a study is different because it has a requirement of not only methodology but certain kinds of safeguards to address the issues legitimately. So there is no study that you know of? Well, actually, this was qualified as a
▶ Play
Speaker 64 27:09
study, but that's all right. No, there is nothing done at this point in time that has said that, you know, this is safer or this is not safer. I think we have gone by common sense that if there were problems, we would have heard about the problems. We do know in Arkansas where the glucagon can be given that, you know, from their school nurses survey last year, I believe there were around 65 to 70 kids who ended up with glucagon. And I don't believe there was any real, you know, I think when there's bad things that happen, we hear about them. But, yes, you're correct. We do not have scientific studies to validate one way or the other at this point in time. Representative
▶ Play
Gillum, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gossage, and I apologize that I did not get to peruse this bill very intently before you got to the end of the table, and I could have asked this before today, and I apologize for that, but I've noticed the last paragraph of the bill says that the State Board of Nursing and the State Board of Education shall promulgate rules necessary to administer this subdivision. Does that mean basically that both of those entities are going to get to weigh in on exactly how this is going to be administered in the school districts throughout the state? Well, that
▶ Play
Speaker 61 28:37
would be my understanding, is that they will have to comply with this new law, but they'll be able to draft, you know, whatever rules that they believe would be the most helpful in administering
▶ Play
this. Okay, so, okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Ratliff, you're recognized for a question. Representative Gossage, I taught 28 years, and I had several diabetics throughout the years, And are the nurses doing this now, or are the students still getting to take care
▶ Play
Speaker 64 29:11
of their own business? As we said, by the time a child gets to about junior high, most of them are pretty capable of doing this on their own, but they still need some help. But your grade school kids... Right, I understand that. Yeah, and now if a school nurse isn't there, you know, lots of times it's on the parents to come in and do the, you
▶ Play
know, do it. Follow-up, please. You're recognized. What about these students
▶ Play
Speaker 64 29:43
have the pumps? Grade school kids that have the pumps, their school nurses are probably still helping them. Junior high and high school kids, they're pretty much on their own. I have some acquaintances who have older kids with diabetes, and often what happens is that kids on the cell phone with their parents dealing with the issues. I've also had, having been a nurse, I've had kids in school who really did need more help than that also, even though they were older. Thank you. Are there any other
▶ Play
questions, committee? Seeing none. We go to the audience. We have some to speak for and against this bill. We're going to start with Chad McPeak to speak against the bill. Go to the end of the table, please, and state your name and who you're with, and you will be recognized. My name
▶ Play
is Chad McPeak. I am not with anybody other than being a parent of a child with type 1 diabetes. Let's see
▶ Play
if that microphone is on. Punch that little button that says push, the green light on. Let's try it now. There you go. Do that again,
▶ Play
please. Okay. My name is Chad McPeak. I am not with anybody. I'm simply representing me as a parent of a child with type 1 diabetes.
▶ Play
You're a representative. I mean, you're recognized to speak against
▶ Play
the bill. I'm sorry. Okay. For 11 years now, I've been a single parent of a wonderful child. And for the past six years of those, 11 years, he has been type 1 diabetic. It is a struggle. It is something that we deal with every minute of every day. I recall the fear that I had when I dropped my child off for the first time at school when we got done realizing that he was type 1 diabetic. it was tough. I sat in the parking lot for 30 minutes until I could get a hold of a school nurse, talk to her, make sure that he had come he had delivered his supplies, his testing equipment and everything to the nurse and then I could kind of ease off but then I came back and waited in the parking lot at lunch until I could talk to her and make sure that my child was being taken care of and then again two hours after lunch when he had to be tested again. This went on for a very long time. Now, he's had diabetes for six years now, and his testing is not as strenuous as it was before. Before, he had to test every two hours, regardless of whether he had eaten, regardless of anything had changed. We were also dealing with a situation where every four days I had to call in the children's hospital, call in his blood sugars from every two hours of every day. Now, once he went to sleep, there was a 2 a.m. check. So there was about an eight-hour gap that there was only one check in between, but I had to record everything he had eaten, the nutritional values of everything he had eaten, and the blood sugars by which it occurred after he had eaten that. We learned over time that there was many differences in the amount of carbohydrates is what Children's Hospital teaches us to operate off of, the amount of carbohydrates. But the amount of carbohydrates in bread act different than the amount of carbohydrates in the cupcake, even though they're very similar. And each child goes different on that. And without a personal knowledge of that child, a simple volunteer that does a yearly training would not be there. As the parent of that child, I was being trained every four days for two years. now i do consider myself to be an expert on my son's diabetes i've been doing it for a long time and i will tell you that i know absolutely nothing about any other child's diabetes now with six years of training on how to take care of diabetes with my son i would not attempt to do the calculations or the insulin delivery to a child with diabetes It was not my child specifically. It is a dangerous game. Now, glucagon, there is already legislation in place for glucagon to be given by volunteers. Glucagon, any ape could be trained to give a glucagon shot. It is a simple kit that has directions on the lid, and if you find the child unconscious, you deliver glucagon. You automatically assume their blood sugar is dropped to the point that they are unconscious and that you must administer glucagon. And then you call 911, preferably not in that order. Hopefully there's more than one person involved in this activity. So that legislation is already in place. There's an intent here to open up the doors to reduce the amount of nurses needed by each school when there's a child that's diabetic there. As the people here so poorly testified before, that there is no studies on all the 30 states has passed this, but it has passed because there's a fiscal requirement to have a nurse at a school with a child that has diabetes. Why? Because of insulin delivery. That insulin has to be calculated by every carbohydrate that that child eats, not by what's provided for him on the plate because children don't eat everything on the plate, now do they? It has to be looked at, it has to be calculated, and the insulin has to be delivered. Now, I don't know of any studies that has been in place to see how these states have operated without nurses, but I would grant to you that it is my opinion that any parent of a diabetic child would prefer a trained medical professional to take care of their child's diabetes over anybody that would be willing to volunteer to do so. And for the importance of insulin delivery, glucagon can be delivered by nearly anybody, but if you take your child to a children's hospital with diabetes and the doctor orders that child to get an insulin delivery, Arkansas Children's Hospital does not trust one nurse to give that shot. A registered nurse has to do the calculations for that shot. Another registered nurse, not an LPN, not a CNA, another registered nurse must come, check the calculations, make sure they're correct, and then draw up the insulin. And then a third registered nurse is required to come, check the calculations, check that the insulin has been drawn up correctly, and then delivered to that child. And people had the nerve to sit here and ask me to let a volunteer who gets training, and they do not even have the respect for somebody that has the fear for their child like me to come here with an idea on how much training they would require and ask this committee to pass this bill. Are we looking at four hours a year? Are we looking at once every six months? Because I talk to a doctor every four days, and his calculations changed, his basal rates changed, his insulin type changed. Everything changes on a continuous basis because it is a growing child. And if you have six volunteers and one of them is there every two weeks, that person that's there every two weeks has a very good chance of killing your child.
▶ Play
That's all I have to say. Mr. Oteek, would you take some questions, please? Absolutely. Representative Gillum, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thank you, sir, for coming today. As I stated earlier, I have not necessarily become an expert on this piece of legislation, but I'm curious. I'm looking at line 29 of page 1 of the bill, and I'm kind of curious about something here because I may be missing something. but it states that upon written request of a parent or guardian of a student with diabetes to grant authorization to do this. So I guess, like I said, I may be missing something here, but it sounds like that in your particular instance and that of any parent that they have to initiate this ability for anybody else to be able to give any treatment. So if you didn't feel that anybody was qualified other than you to do this, you simply would not have to send in a written request, and therefore this would not qualify for anybody. I mean, do you understand where I'm going with that? I understand exactly. It seems like that according to that language that there's really nothing to fear if you don't want
▶ Play
Speaker 28 39:00
this to apply to your child. It doesn't apply to your child. Well, yes, sir,
▶ Play
in the understanding that somebody may get that has not looked at it thoroughly, yes, sir, very much so. Now, the question that is asked of us parents in this situation is, and I've been on the other end of this phone call, do you want anybody at the school that knows how to deliver insulin that is trained to take care of your child? well absolutely i want somebody there to be able to give my child insulin well here's the situation we have a school nurse that's taking care of four different schools that's running around and is at any point in time in the day up to 50 minutes away from your child do you want anybody here that would be able to give your child insulin now at this point i haven't been asked this of insulin because obviously this bill hasn't been passed but i've been asking about glucagon. Now, I think I made it clear that glucagon was a far different subject because glucagon is always glucagon. It's always the same amount of glucagon, and it's delivered exactly the same way no matter who the child is. And that legislation is already in place, and it's excellent legislation. But what we are sitting here talking about today is insulin. And do we want anybody? I, for one, am a very lucky man, and God has provided for me the situation where my sister-in-law is a teacher at the school that my son is at so she has daily dealings with my son's insulin delivery she's familiar with how much trouble we go through to make sure the calculations are correct and she educates herself on her family member i could not imagine not having that lifeline at a school and the school tell me that the oh well we have a school nurse but at any point in time that school nurse may not be here. Diabetes is something that's constantly monitored. I have to sit down for hours with their teachers to make sure that they understand that if his face starts turning red on his cheeks and on the side of his hair but turns pale in the front, that he's probably dealing with a low blood sugar, and that would be different with each child. The symptoms that you can see, the symptoms you can smell when a child's breath is getting really fruity and you realize that they are dealing with a high blood sugar and that that needs to be dealt with. Now, my son has been very good at recognizing that his blood sugar has been low,
▶ Play
but I know of kids that are not. Okay. Mr. Chair, may I ask a follow-up? You may. Okay. You used the example of your sister-in-law there. I'm just curious, but would logic not also apply that maybe there's some other folks that might be in your position, maybe that we're not as blessed to have a family member on staff at the school might have the same ability to have somebody that they trusted to be able to do that? I'm just trying to see if we've got a consistency of logic being applied here. Oh, yes, sir.
▶ Play
Logic would apply that. Logic would also apply that if the state, if Arkansas Children's Hospital, who I believe is one of the greatest hospitals in the world, would not trust a single RN to administer insulin, that this committee should not even consider to allow a single volunteer to administer insulin. If you have people that are involved in five to six years of school to become a nurse and the state hospital does not allow them to administer a single dose of insulin by themselves, I would say that this committee has no place in asking a volunteer to do so. That is a parent's place, and although a parent can request that, that parent is being forced to do so by the states refusing to provide a school nurse there at the school with a diabetic child. It's not a matter of do you want somebody to be able to administer insulin. We want to be able to reduce the amount of money that's being expended upon nurses at these schools so that we can spread those nurses out. and say we have a school nurse at each school, even though we have one nurse that's driving around all day to five different schools and is only there possibly at the time that that child eats lunch and is not there for any emergency situation. Otherwise, we would not be dealing with the language in this bill that says if a nurse is not present, if that nurse was required to be present. It seems like maybe you
▶ Play
and I are looking at two different bills then because this doesn't seem to be about trying to lessen the number of school nurses in the state. but I will defer to that.
▶ Play
Chairman, I apologize. May I respond, sir? Yes, you may. The bill simply states if the nurse is not present. If the nurse is present, the bill would not be necessary. If the state would consider to – the solution to the problem here is not to have more people giving shots to kids. It's to have more nurses available at our schools. That's the simplicity of it. If the hospitals do not recognize an LPN or a CNA to give a shot, why would you all recognize a volunteer? It doesn't make any sense. The sensible thing here, the train of logic, as you put it, sir, was to say we have a diabetic child in need of constant medical care. Then let's provide constant medical care, not propose a bill that would allow anybody willing to take a class of who knows what's required once every four years, once every two years, once every six months, let's let that volunteer deliver life-threatening drugs to your child. That's the train of logic that I'm
▶ Play
on. Representative Eubanks, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Well, Representative Gillum touched on part of it, but in an ideal, perfect world, I suspect we would have a nurse in every classroom, or at least in every building, but But since that's not the case, I sort of got a question and a follow-up here, but have you ever been called upon to give your son or your child an insulin shot?
▶ Play
Speaker 150 45:21
Absolutely. Okay. Do you feel comfortable with your
▶ Play
sister-in-law doing that? Absolutely. Thank you. Representative Douglas,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a motion. Yes, given the amount of people we, you know, want to speak to this, I would like to limit the debate to ten minutes on each side.
▶ Play
Public testimony, ten minutes per four and ten minutes against? Yes. That's a proper motion. Yes, Mr. Bigger. You're looking at me? I'm recognizing you. I just
▶ Play
wanted to ask a point of clarification. Is this just for public testimony, and will Representative Gossage have a time to close? This is only for public testimony. Okay, I just wanted to make sure I knew what I was voting on.
▶ Play
I have a motion. All those in favor of the motion say aye. No. Any opposed? No. The motion passes. The debate will be limited to 10 minutes per side. We have heard from the against on the first one. We will hear from A4. Thank you for coming, and we will let the other side start testifying now. Thank you, sir, and thank you. We have one for, and that is Ms. Carol Nichols. are recognized to take the end of the table. If you would introduce yourself and tell us who
▶ Play
you're with, you're recognized. Hello, my name is Carol Nichols. I'm with American Diabetes Association, and I'm also a mother of a type one juvenile diabetic. We've been a diabetic for 15 years. When we were diagnosed, she was two years old. I am here to testify into support of House Bill 1395, which will allow students with diabetes who are capable of self-managing their diabetes on school property and will allow people who volunteer to be trained and help the insulin administration. There are already 30 states that has allowed this bill to pass. When Kristen was diagnosed with juvenile diabetes, and she started school. It was very scary. When I was looking at one school district, I found out the school district did not have a full-time school nurse. The school nurse was there only on Tuesdays and Thursdays. And when I was getting her registered for school, I realized that. Well, I found out that I had a school district a little further away, and I got her into that school district that had a full-time school nurse so I did a board transferred to that school district. Now I was very fortunate to have that opportunity to you know be able to do that. We have many schools here in Arkansas that do not have a full-time school nurse. They might have a part-time school nurse who is there on Tuesdays and Thursdays or they have a full-time school nurse who is only at this school on Tuesdays and at this other school on Monday and and you know my question is as me as a parent as a diabetic I would in my situation I had a diabetic teacher who would be willing to volunteer to help me with my child now this bill is possibly not for every diabetic every diabetic is different my diabetic is different she the moon can be in a certain phase and affect her sugar so but for my situation this bill would help me as a parent of a diabetic to help train someone who volunteers to help me give insulin to my daughter doing something is always a win doing nothing is absolute failure time is very important when you have a high or a low situation as a diabetic time is against you in that circumstance how far away that teacher is can make a drastic point. It can affect that child. I am strongly wanting this bill to pass. For me as a diabetic, it would give me the option to make that choice for my diabetic to have help at that school when my diabetic nurse is not there. Thank you. Are there any questions from
▶ Play
the committee? Thank you, Ms. Nichols. Thank you. We have Deborah Jones to speak against the bill. Please state your name and who you're with, and you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 168 50:50
I'm Debra Jones, I'm with the Arkansas State Board of Nursing and on behalf of the Board of Nursing I would like to thank you for the opportunity to address this issue the Board of Nursing has read the bill and has had major discussion regarding this bill and has agreed not to support the bill we even have a representative of the older population on our board who is a diabetic and he was adamant that we should not support this bill. The goal of everybody here in this room, whether it be for or against the bill, is to protect our children, to protect our children when they are in the school. Where we differ is on the best way to protect those children and to provide them with the quality of health care that they deserve while they are at school and protect their health and well-being. With 45 years of nursing experience, I've worked in many different areas, from emergency room to ICU to med-surg. And in all those experiences, I taught patients how to care for themselves when they went home or their family members. And that is a good thing for them to be able to continue their care. They have an invested reason for learning and applying those principles of their own care. And, as we've heard today, the parent learns the signs for their individual child of when something is going wrong and when they need assistance. my biggest experience was as a resident camp nurse where I learned that the parents are giving me a great responsibility just as they do school nurses every single day to care for the health and well-being of their child and they put a lot of trust into that school nurse and their experience and their knowledge the American Diabetes Association is very knowledgeable about the treatment of diabetes. They have provided some wonderful educational tools to both the nurses, to patients, and their families. Similar bills have passed in other states, and if you look at the number of nurses-to-student ratio, you will see many of those states have a lot fewer nurses than we do. Arkansas is in the middle of the list, being 25th of having approximately 1,000 students per nurse in the state of Arkansas. Some of those states that have passed those bills have 400 students per nurse, four and a half times fewer nurses in those states that are passing those bills. They should have some alternatives to providing good health care. I've asked the representative from Ms. Fedders to give me an example of a time that a student required insulin and was not able to get it in a timely manner. And I have not gotten any examples from Ms. Fedders. In 1999, legislators passed a bill that caused classroom teachers to not be able to provide care in the classroom. Since that time, the School Nurses Association and the State Board of Nursing have partnered together to address those issues in the school and to make as many concessions as possible to allow them to delegate appropriately to unlicensed persons to provide the health care that's needed in the school. In 2013, the legislators passed a bill to develop an advisory committee. That advisory committee gave a report to the Joint Education Committee last fall regarding recommendations for the best way to provide health care in the school system. Let me just make a little clarification. Is that hypoglycemia, low blood sugar, that is an emergency that requires glucagon. Hyperglycemia is not an emergency. You have time to work with that, and giving just a little bit too much insulin creates an emergency situation by putting the patient into hypoglycemia. So we can create emergencies with the administration of this insulin that we do not create with the glucagon. Ms. Nichols also moved her child to another school so she could have a full-time nurse. The advisory committee is still working, willing to work on continuing recommendations to this group as to how to best provide that care. And I would encourage you to support the bill to continue the advisory committee. I would encourage you, deplore you, to let us have the opportunity to look at the big picture and to provide health care for all students regardless of what their diagnosis is and not limit it to just those with diabetes. Thank
▶ Play
you. Rep. Gillum, you are recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ma'am, kind of along the same line of questioning I had with the previous testimony against this bill, in looking at the language that's in lines 29 through 32 on page 1 upon the written request of a parent or guardian, that opt-in clause basically that exists there, and then also with the last paragraph that exists that gives your board the right to promulgate the rules along with the Department of Education on this, I'm just still trying to figure out where this great, huge threat to every student exists because if the parents are not comfortable with letting anybody else engage in this, then it's not going to happen. And I'm a little concerned after the previous testimony that, I mean, he claimed that and maybe rightfully so that maybe our school nurses aren't even trained to do this properly if Children's Hospital is not just letting anybody do this. And so he's actually brought up concerns that I didn't have even before this now. So I'm just curious, I'm still trying to figure out where this huge problem is, given these issues, I mean, the wording that's
▶ Play
Speaker 168 57:43
in this bill. Even if the parent requests the volunteer to administer the medication, and that volunteer does not do it correctly because they've had little or no training, because they have not had the experience that a nurse has to do the assessment and to evaluate what they are doing, how the patient is responding to them, and how they need to adjust that treatment. Those things, there's not something that you can learn in a two-, four-, six-, eight-hour class. That is something that you learn over time. And I agree, children does have a very stringent policy, and it's not uncommon. for hospital nurses to get, and even nursing home nurses, to get a second person to double check their insulin administration, their calculations. And I think we've heard a little oversimplification of the insulin pump too. It's not, there is a lot of calculation. There are many different pumps out there. You have to go through a lot of training in order to be proficient in doing that. And just Just a minor adjustment in that insulin pump can put the patient into an emergency or crisis situation. Thank you, ma'am. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Yes, it's more procedural. You gave each side as 10 minutes. I'd like for those, since there are so many people on each side, I'd like for the Chair to impose a one-minute rule on each remaining speaker so that many of the people who have come may have an
▶ Play
opportunity to be heard. I will grant that request. We will, are there any other questions on the committee for this lady? If not, thank you. And we will go to the four. And that will be Roberta Kendall. You are recognized. And you have one minute to state who you're with and your name,
▶ Play
please. My name is Roberta Kendall, and I'm actually a parent of a type 1 diabetic, and I am with American Diabetes Association, but I am not affiliated with them. I am a parent coming forward to state my case. I had something prepared, but I want to talk to you from my heart. As a parent of a type 1 diabetic, I was presented with having an opportunity to put my daughter into a school that did not have a school nurse. It was not even in their curriculum. They had no nurses. And I had to figure out a way in order to keep my daughter safe by allowing them to understand that diabetes is nothing to be afraid of. That through training and education and having the ability to understand what it means to be diabetic, that she could be taken care of and be treated like a normal child. And that's what most type 1 diabetic children want is to have normalcy. They don't want to be restricted from going to a field trip because there's not a nurse. I hate to interrupt you, but you're going to be out. I'm going
▶ Play
to give you 10 seconds to close. This
▶ Play
bill is so important to parents that are for this bill because there are times where parents are not going to be available to leave work to go and take care of their kid. It needs to be passed, because there are people out there through knowledge and experience and being able to see what is there. Diabetic pumps are very effective. It's already pre-programmed.
▶ Play
Thank you. I'm sorry you're out of time. I will see if there's
▶ Play
Speaker 183 1:01:33
any questions for her. None. Thank you. We're looking at the list.
▶ Play
Give me a sec. Mr. Nagel, Rich Nagel, you're recognized to speak against this bill. You have one minute from right now. I'm sorry, your time's up already. Please state who you're with and your name and you're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 194 1:02:36
for one minute. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Rich Nagel with AEA, speaking against the bill. First of all, and this is an important point for Representative Gilliam, Section 1 of the bill does not speak to students who self-administer. Section 1 of the bill sets forth the rights of an individual who does self-administer. The real question here is, what's going to be done with the students who do not self-administer insulin? First, Section 2 amends the Nurse Practices Act. Importantly, while the bill sets forth the rights of self-administering students in Section 1, it does not set forth clear and specific responsibility of a volunteer school personnel key areas of blood glucose monitoring, medication, both of the glycemias, and other special considerations. The bill also deletes Section 504 of the Rehab Act. And while it's true that not all students have a 504 plan, by deleting it, you're removing rights that they have. There are sufficient funds in the matrix to provide more money for hiring school nurses. Only 51% of the money set forth in the matrix is actually spent. President Gillum,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for that point of clarification. You're welcome. Along those lines, wouldn't, though, the last paragraph in which the State Board of Nursing and the State Board of Education promulgating the rules necessary to administer this, Wouldn't that give them the ability, though, to then have that work with the
▶ Play
Speaker 194 1:04:29
areas that you still had concern? I guess I would say yes, if you're comfortable with putting something in place over the objections of the School Nursing Association and forcing them to comply. That part of the bill amends the Nurse Practices Act, which they don't want to have done. So it's more of a
▶ Play
turf situation than it is anything else then? Is that what you're
▶ Play
Speaker 194 1:04:56
saying? No, sir. I think it's a quality care issue. Okay. All right. Thank you, sir. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. We are out of time on the against side. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for the bill? Representative Gossage, you are recognized to close for your bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 61 1:05:20
thank you mr. chair a number of the questions have been raised as we've gone along here i just want to address a couple of them of course the similar bill to this senator joyce elliott carried last time of course she is the senate sponsor and hopefully we'll get to make it down to her, but I don't know of anyone, and I've spoken to a lot of people, is interested in having less school nurses. Everyone that I've spoken with, including myself, would like to have a nurse in every school building in this state. And probably the only thing that has offended me that I've heard is the suggestion that I would prefer to have less care for kids than more.
▶ Play
Speaker 115 1:06:26
Anyone that knows me knows that's false. this
▶ Play
Speaker 61 1:06:37
bill is as permissive as it can be made I've already described that we're talking about some very rare situations in which there isn't a nurse available in which a parent has requested the help in which their physician has approved in which there is an emergency situation. I mean, I don't know how much more limited you could be. When it was suggested to me after I introduced this bill that it was going to put kids in danger, didn't take that lightly I didn't do a research study but I did do a lot of research I looked and I looked on the internet I searched and I searched for instances in which untrained volunteers or even Untrained volunteers had caused the death of a student or even a serious injury. And I'm sure that it has happened somewhere, sometime. But I couldn't find it because I was willing to be persuaded to change my mind. I have dealt with many emergency situations, as I have told you. In 34 years in the school, you don't do all the things we do and go to all the places we go and not have things happen. If I thought for one second that we were putting kids in harm's way, I wouldn't support this bill. I know a lot of you have been contacted by a lot of people. And I respect your vote, whatever it is. but the essential question remains just as it was when I started if a nurse is not present is it a good idea to have someone around who has been trained or is it better to not if it's better to not okay but I just can't understand how someone would believe it's better to not have a trained person available. I would appreciate a good vote. I
▶ Play
have a motion of due pass from Representative Eubanks. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, no. The ayes have it. Congratulations, you have passed your bill. I'm going to take a little moment of personal privilege. I'm passing out something. Can I borrow yours? Most of y'all may not know, and everyone in the room, this is for you, too. I'm giving it to the committee members, but Mark Hudson, our beloved analyst here, was recognized last week by winning the Agate Presidential Award. And that is quite an honor. He has been with the Bureau of Legislative Research since 1988, and he's been with this subcommittee the whole time, I believe, right? So he was honored last week for 27 years of extensive work that he's done behind the scenes and out here in this committee. So I just wanted, as a chair of this committee, to recognize him for winning an award and being honored. And I would like to see you guys honor him here today. Would you like to say any words?
▶ Play
Speaker 206 1:11:11
Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, members of the audience, thank you very much. I'm deeply honored and very humbled by it, and
▶ Play
just thank you. Thank you, Mark, for all you do. At this time, we're going to recognize Representative Murdoch to present House Bill 1377.
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:11:46
Thank you, Chairman and Committee. if you will indulge me for a moment I'm going to ask three people to join me my superintendents in the districts that I represent or at least border those superintendents if you will please come forward and they will introduce themselves at the proper time chairman if that's okay that is fine okay again thank you committee I bring you Bill 1377 House Bill 1377 and the first reason let me acknowledge why I come to the end of the table with this legislation I am a duly elected representative of District 48 which encompasses Lee County, parts of St. Francis and Monroe County I am charged by that election and that choice of the people to bring forth legislation that represents the interests specifically to them and certainly hopefully that positively affects all citizens of the state of Arkansas. But most importantly you must understand that I must come to the end of the table and I must not sit and watch as I see anything that's happening to the citizens that I am elected to represent. If I can do something to try to change, then these people that sit here that have come today to support what we're trying to do, the change we're trying to make in the delivery of education for our children, it's so important to me, or ironic to me, or even stunning to me, that so many of the emails that we have gotten and those committee members and others, is taught so very little about children and kids and the delivery and education and what they're doing, affecting these outcomes. It's been addressed from an aspect of some other things that I think you'll hear in testimony today and some of the fears that people have, that this bill does not even go down that line. This bill simply is to give school districts the flexibility of waivers that are being utilized by public charters that are joined from their population. It's not a mandate to go and hire unqualified teachers, to fire all the teachers, to all of these emails that I have of fear. and danger and stress that's not what this is it's to give flexibility to a part of the state that I represent that many of you may or may not be aware of that have become penalized by some of the rules that have been put in place for districts that have negatively impacted districts such as ours because we have issues of retention, retaining we have issues of quality of life. We have issues of economic development in our areas. Those issues have not been brought to this table. Education has been so affected by the lack of those issues becoming part of the model. The whole community being positively affected so that we can better the outcome so we can become more attractive. The Constitution mandates that irregardless of cost, that we educate our children. This bill, I hopefully, will bring to the table a whole lot more conversation than just what this bill entails. It takes a degree of boldness and courage to step out there and try to make a difference. When I came here and since I've been here, it's been my charge. I look at the representatives that I admire so much in this body, and I listen to one often in private and in public, Representative Walker, as he comes and he challenges. Representative Walker, you motivated me to make a change, irregardless of how popular it may be. Again, hopefully I'll get a chance to close, and we'll address some things that I think will come. But I wanted to make that statement. I'm here as a representative of the people that have been so, for so long, been neglected for these issues. There are expectations put there, there are standards there, but we have not been given the tools to make it work. What we need and what this bill allows for, committee, it may not be necessary in Springdale. It may not be necessary in Benton, but it may be very necessary in Forest City, in Mariana, in Helena. I'm going to let these superintendents speak for themselves in a little bit, but I want you to understand as their representative and as your colleague that this is a very serious issue, and I really hope after testimony today, irregardless of what happens to this bill, I hope that tension is brought to the many aspects of educational neglect, oversight, and maybe it's unintentional, but the pain, it still hurts, and we're here to try to fix it and try to find answers. So, with that being said, Representative Chairman, Representative Cozart, I, my bill is just what it says, to allow districts to utilize waivers if they're affected, if their population is affected by public charters. I'll take any questions. Before, after that, I would like for the people at the table to introduce themselves and give
▶ Play
their brief statements. Representative Harris, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. First, I'll preface the question. Representative Murdoch, you and I have a mutual respect for one another and a friendship. Yes, sir. So when I get ready here, you know, it's not meant as disrespect. but does your bill, though, intend a system that is working outside of the public school system that is producing good results, excellent results in some cases? Is this not a dig at that and watering down a system such as the public school system that does require licensures and different such things as that, which does not need to be changed. I mean, is that not a dig at the charter schools that actually are working, creating great results that do not require licensures or different aspects?
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:19:20
Is this? No, sir. Let's go to the bill. The document says that a district where it's working, this is a choice. Representative Harris, that if a superintendent of school board, if they see that they see waivers that they think can help their particular situation, then they can make application to the State Board of Education, they'll have to prove it in documentation how this particular waiver can help us. It's not a mandate, it's not a blanket, but it's for you to have the choice for what's needed, and the big impetus behind that is what you're saying. One glove does not fit all for education and for reaching children. So if we can give flexibilities to various districts that have various situations, various demographics, then therefore we're gaining with the options and the flexibility. But if it does not work for a district, then that district does not choose. Can I have a follow-up? You're recognized for a follow-up.
▶ Play
I mean, but what you're talking about, though, is exactly what is intended for, Without what you need to do, though, is what charter schools and public schools was intended to do, is to compete for the public schools to continue to work harder with the charter schools for better results. Do you understand what I'm trying to say? No, sir, not really. So there's no exodus from the public school to go to charter
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:20:49
schools? Yes, there is. There's a great exodus. That's why we're trying to level the playing field with this bill. There is an unleveled playing field because there are certain rules for public charters that our public schools don't have, and they're drawing our population. So that necessitates a leveling of the playing field so that we all have the same rules that we're playing by. I think that's my question.
▶ Play
There's a competition, which is the point that public schools can arise to the challenge to be just as good as a charter school. You're using some terms that
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:21:24
I may not use when you say just as good because I think the public schools are good as well, but I think they can utilize possibly some of this flexibility to make them better in certain areas. But I don't want to say that charters are better than public or vice versa. I just want to say that we all want to try to get to a point of delivery to reach our children and our populations for a positive outcome. Okay, I'll have to
▶ Play
go back to the bottom of the list, but if you can, put me there.
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:21:52
Thank you. May our chairman, or all these questions for me, is it not proper that I introduce, because they may have...
▶ Play
If you would like to go ahead and have them introduce themselves and who they're with, and if
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:22:03
the question comes to them, they're ready. And can they
▶ Play
Speaker 228 1:22:13
have their brief statements as they introduce themselves, please? I'm fine with that, yes. Okay. Good morning, Mr. Chair. John Hoy, Superintendent, Helena-West Helena School District. In my brief statement, I'll simply say this. Act 890 of 1999, subtitled the Arkansas Charter Schools Act of 1999, was established with the legislative intent of providing opportunities for teachers, parents, pupils, and community members to establish and maintain public schools that operate independently from the existing structure of local school districts as a method of accomplishing the following, one, improve student learning. Two, increase learning opportunities for all students with special emphasis on expanded learning experiences for students who are identified as low achieving. Three, encourage the use of different and innovative teaching methods. Four, create new professional opportunities for teachers, including the opportunity to be responsible for the learning program at the school site. Five, provide parents and pupils with expanded choices in the types of educational opportunities that are available within the public school system. And six, hold the schools established under this act accountable for meeting measurable student achievement standards. The act was a bold and innovative approach to allowing organizations the ability to experiment with educational concepts with the intended outcome being that of finding new ways and approaches to improve educational outcomes for our children, all of our children. Now, more than a decade later, we have 18 open enrollment charter schools operating in the state. Many have now been operating in the state for more than a decade. Those include Academics Plus, Arkansas Arts Academy, Kip Delta Public Schools, Emboldened Area Charter School, Haas Hall Academy, and Lisa Academy. I come forward this morning with three simple questions. One, has this bold and innovative approach to education been a success? Let's assume the answer is yes, and I make that assumption on the continued operation of a number of charters over many years. Question number two, if I have assumed correctly, and the answer to question number one is yes, has the flexibility allowed as a result of the waivers granted to these charters contributed to that success? Again, I assume the answer is yes. And I make that assumption because each waiver requested is scrutinized before being allowed and during each renewal cycle. So my final question, question number three, is does it make sense to deny those same bold, innovative approaches and flexibilities to schools serving the same students in the same geographic area? I make no assumption here as to yes or no. I leave that to this body to consider. I am human and prone to faulty assumptions, so let's consider the possibility that the answer to question number one is no, and this bold and innovative approach to education has not been a success. In that case, both question number two and number three seem irrelevant, and the bold and innovative approach would have failed to produce the legislative intent of Act 890. Let's now assume that open enrollment charter schools are successful, but the waivers allowed have not contributed to the success. In that case, question number three still seems to be irrelevant, which would lead me to the immediate conclusion that the waivers are unnecessary for any school, including open enrollment charter schools, and that all schools should be held to the same high standards. House Bill 1377 seems to allow affected public schools the opportunity to take advantage of the flexibility granted to open enrollment charter schools so that they can have the opportunity to be just as innovative as open enrollment charter schools. Have open enrollment charter schools been successful? Have waivers been granted, contributed to the success? Should we deny other public schools the opportunity for the same success? Those three questions, properly considered, might serve as a guide for what has the potential for a significant change in the way we educate all children in Arkansas.
▶ Play
Good morning. I am Tiffany Hardrick, currently serving as a superintendent of the Forest City School District. And I come to this body with a unique perspective in that I have served as a co-founder of a charter school that experienced success as well as operated as an assistant superintendent and a superintendent in a district. When I think about the need for this bill, it's more about me being provided an opportunity to implement those best practices that I know are in the best interest of kids. When I think about the list of waivers that are available, some of those same waivers allowed me to experience success in a charter. I was not successful in a charter because I was in a charter. I was successful because of some of the flexibility that was granted to me that allowed me to do what was in the best interest of children. One example would be extended day, extended year. Whenever you serve students that are behind and are in need of remediation, there is no magic bullet to improving student achievement. It is simply time on task. And so how do we do that? We increase the amount of time that students are on task. And so we have extended days and we have extended years. We know that some of our students are struggling in literacy. The data speaks to that. So what do we do? We ask for a waiver that allows us to extend the amount of time that we offer students literacy or expose students to reading as opposed to another subject that's mandated through standards. And this allows us to implement best practices without violations of standards. And so for me, this is more about giving an opportunity to implement those best practices in a district that needs a bold approach and we're in a time where we need to do what's best for kids. This is not a waiver where I'm asking, a bill where we're asking for a waiver to do harm to adults. The key purpose is to implement those best practices that have proven to work, that I've personally had an opportunity to implement, that allow kids to experience success. Forest City is in a position where every decision that we make, we must make it for kids. And so I ask that you strongly consider allowing us the flexibility to do what we know are best practices and are in the best
▶ Play
Speaker 232 1:29:22
interest of children. Thank you. Good morning. Willie Murdoch, Superintendent, Lee County School District, Mariana. And you may notice the last name. I am happy to be here and thank Chairman Cozart and Co-Chair Lamkin for the opportunity and the committee and those that are sponsoring the bill, especially Representative Murdoch. Now, he has sat through many, many conversations with me, much pillow talk and debate over the last 20-odd years as it relates to education and particularly the last 13 to 14 years as it relates to public schools and charter schools and open enrollment charter schools. If nothing else comes out of the bill, I'm glad that we have an opportunity to share with, not only with our community, many of them are here today, men of action and several other people are here today, we've seen the impact of the open enrollment charter schools on our district. But, however, I'm glad that we have the opportunity to share with the community and the state that several folks don't even understand that there are so many waivers that open enrollment charter schools have that public schools do not have. Just that opportunity to share for that communication to be out there is very important to me. Open enrollment charter schools, of course, the very definition is that they're independently operated and they are allowed more flexibility and autonomy than traditional public schools. Now, the Lee County School District has always been able to work through all of its challenges that we've had. You've seen us in the paper last year a lot lately, having some success lately, and we are very proud of that. However, despite many of those challenges, many of our students, even despite those, we are very resilient. We've always had resilient students in the district who are able to go beyond high school and pursue careers that are worthwhile. But I want to stay before you long. I know you've given some folks one minute, so I'm not going to take too much longer. All that we're asking the committee is to consider is to allow us to have waivers, those things that we know that many of the open enrollment charter schools have. We think that fair and equitable treatment for all of our students is what we're looking for. If we're trying to educate all the children of Arkansas, I think that the waivers would be the best thing for us to look at. Now, public schools do not have the selection criteria as many of the open enrollment charter schools or even by self-selection or parent selection. My district has to take – parents give us the best they have, and we work with those students, and we've been able to do that. Even in the era of competition, and I hate to say the word competition, there should not be the word competition in education. We are here to educate all students. And so allowing us, and I think about one of my coaches used the term, that dog just won't hunt. It won't hunt. It don't hunt. We have to make sure that we have fair and equitable education for all of the students. So please just give it considerable thought. I'm not asking for the exact same waivers. I'm asking what's best for my students in Lee County. And I would like to have more flexibility in the law. and I'm asking you for your consideration. I thank you for that. I
▶ Play
have questions whenever you are ready for them. Yes, sir, Chairman.
▶ Play
Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. I think of all the bills that we filed this year, the mail I have gotten shocked me the most on this. I thought when I saw my email started flooding with email, I would be getting ideas from teachers saying thank you so much for opening up so that I can think outside the box. I want to be innovative but I've kind of felt constricted. I have these great ideas but I haven't been able to implement them. I thought I would be getting a lot of thank So I think the question I would ask is, where is the misunderstanding between, you know, what you're trying to do with bringing innovation, new ideas to the table, and the fear that we are seeing with licensure or with maybe even dismissal?
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:34:01
I really can't answer that. Obviously, you know, I get the same and probably more emails as the sponsor of this bill, and that's what the overwhelming cry have been is, you know, they're personally worried about their employment and also about us putting on the school districts, placing unqualified teachers in classrooms, watering down education. That's not the purpose of this at all. So I really can't speak to that, and maybe someone that is speaking against the bill will have an opportunity to answer that question for you and I. I can't answer that. That's not the intent
▶ Play
of this bill at all. I just have one follow-up. You recognize for a follow-up? Will the public schools still fall under the ABCDF grading system? They won't be able to get a
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:34:53
waiver from that, or do you know? No, the bill as it's written is whatever waivers that are available to the public charters they draw from their population. That's the way the bill reads. Now, I think one thing to continue to that we bring out during this testimony is that districts, as the superintendents have intimated, they'll try to use what applies to them to make them better. That's all this is, is to give them those flexibilities to make them better. So there may be several districts that don't use this at all. But if it's something that can make it better and a better option and delivery for our children, why is that a problem? Representative Ratliff, you recognize for a question. Give me
▶ Play
one type of waiver you'd like to say put in Lee County School.
▶ Play
Speaker 199 1:35:43
Well, one of the waivers we've been
▶ Play
Speaker 232 1:35:48
looking at is the extended year, extended time. But when we look at personnel policies in regards to teacher fair dismissal, law, we would love to have some flexibility in that, just as the public open charter schools have. We would like to have some flexibilities if we need them. We'd like to study some of the flexibilities or some of the waivers to see what's best for our kids, and not what's best for grown folks, but what's best
▶ Play
for kids. Thank you. Representative Armstrong, they
▶ Play
recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Murdoch, you know my heart is with the children, with the children. I believe in educating them, and I know your situation in Lee County and all in the Delta, because I preach all the time we need jobs in the Delta to bring the school district up where we'll have a tax base. But one question I have here is why not consider conversion charters? You can get, you can accomplish some of the same things with conversion charters. We have one here in Little Rock a conversion charter, maybe two and some of these things that you just mentioned would be a lot easier to accomplish with a conversion charter. Well, and, of
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:37:06
course, the superintendents can answer that if they like. Would you like to
▶ Play
Speaker 228 1:37:11
address that? I'll address it. Mike's already on, Representative Armstrong. I have no problem with the idea of conversion charters and the application thereof. As a matter of fact, I'm not that bashful in terms of my intent. When I was still at the department and I was aware that I would be going to Helena West Helena as an appointed superintendent, I shared with a number of my colleagues at that particular time that if I survive year one and make it to year two, I would probably apply for a charter school in Helena, West Helena, along those particular lines. And I would apply for, and again, I'm not bashful in terms of which waivers, I would seek all of those waivers that Delta Charter School has. My logic is this. Have they been successful? If so, have the waivers contributed to it? If so, why are we being not allowed to do the same thing? So to be quite honest with you, it may be a moot point. My concern was that if I applied for all of the waivers that I would run into some opposition along the lines of either teacher fair dismissal or the hiring of teachers. I will tell you, I suspect there's at least one person prepared to give you some examples where, and I've had conversations with Scott Showery. His example is he cannot hire LeBron James to coach unless he has a waiver to do so. And my thinking is, is I would like to be able to have that same flexibility to do the things that he does. Will this bill make it easier? I think so. Going conversion charter route, it has a lot of requirements and stipulation. I don't mind chasing those down. I would rather not have to chase them all down, but if I have to chase them down, and if I survive year one, make it year two, I will probably chase them down anyway. My concern is, in public schools, we have to do an awful lot of paper chasing just to get what we need. If this thing has been successful, in a decade would seem to be enough to determine whether it is successful, quite a paper
▶ Play
chase. The follow-up I'd like to have, as you know, a lot of charter schools have failed. Not all of them are successful, and no one thing fits the need of everybody. So we got to look at it from that angle. And there's a study that's been already submitted to public charters versus public schools. And if we could see what this study is going to bring out, this study was supposed to be done last year, I think you're well aware of it, because I put in for the study and we hadn't got any results back. But hopefully this time we'll get some results, and maybe that'll answer a lot of those questions out there.
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:39:55
And if I can follow up, Representative Armstrong, and I do appreciate what you do and what you do for education, and I do know your passion, but as Superintendent Hoy mentioned, and what you're saying has not been the pushback that meeting on this committee has gathered in our emails. That has not even been addressed. But again, I guess it will. But to your point of conversion charter, that gives those same waivers that we're really debating or discussing, whether you get them through conversion charter, which is a highly regulated route that's a lot more cumbersome for these districts that already have much paper to chase that's been articulated. But if you're getting the same thing anyway, Representative Armstrong, then you're still ending up with those waivers. You're still with those flexibilities. So if we think it's okay through conversion charter, now you're just sending me through another door. But I'm ending up with the same flexibilities if I go conversion charter. So what door I go through should not be the issue. It's the end as we're trying to get something to improve our children. So if we go conversion charter, what does that change? But you're not
▶ Play
changing the laws for all the school districts. But you're allowing them to use them.
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:41:09
The conversion charter is there for all of them.
▶ Play
It's there, you guys. Representative Harris, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Hopefully I can stay with what. I guess coming back to the issue, when I've heard Ms. Ford, Ms. Virginia Ford up in Washington, D.C., what they did with the charter schools up there in that area to help the urban students kind of create a better atmosphere with schools. I wasn't downgrading the public school. What I was talking about was creating competition, and I know you said that was a bad word. That wasn't what I was referring to because sometimes you do sound bites and say, you know, but I don't want that to be misconstrued. But what I was talking about was bringing up the level of education for the children. And I think you even alluded to that and bringing longer days. But I think, would you not agree that if we kept that in place, it just brings up the level? And I know you've done a great job in your school district, and I commend you for that. And I think it's been a great job. But I don't want to diminish one group to bring the other one down. And I think that's what
▶ Play
maybe we can make some balance. So, you know, I think I will just kind of stay with that word competition if it's okay. And I'll ask for the same reprieve that, you know, that doesn't become my sound bite. But anytime you're talking about choice and parents having choices and you can choose between one or the other, there is some level of competition that exists, right? Everyone should, every district, whether you're a charter, private, you should work to provide a quality product to the people that you serve. And so for me, what we're, in its simplest form, what we're saying is if we're going to compete and thus provide a quality product, we need the opportunities to provide those quality products. We're not asking for additional funding. We're asking for an opportunity. We're asking for an opportunity to analyze the data, and based on our data, make a determination what's on the best needs of our kids. I have analyzed the data in Forest City. I've determined that we have some literacy challenges. I have determined that I need more time to teach literacy. Therefore, I'm asking for a waiver that would allow me to extend the day without having to go through
▶ Play
a process of a conversion charter. Follow-up, please. You're recognized for follow-up. Do we not
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:44:00
have that in place now with nontraditional licensure? So I will give you a, I think it would
▶ Play
be a good example. In Forest City, we had a science teacher who was certified to teach biology, but she was a first-year teacher, so she was on a provisional license. I needed her to teach physical science. She has passed the physical science praxis. However, because she's on a provisional license, we could not add physical science and her teach without me having a standards violation. But I could have gotten a waiver for a substitute for 90 days and it had not been a violation. But was that really what's in the best interest of kids, if I have a certified biology teacher that has passed a physical science practice? So those are the type of situations that we often find ourselves in in the Delta when we're trying to recruit and retain qualified teachers. Because we want the best teachers. We all know that if you want to move to school, you've got to have the best teachers. But we often find ourselves in situations like that when we really just want to be able to make the best decision for
▶ Play
kids. All right. Thank you. Representative Walker, it finally got around to you. You're recognized. Thank you. You have one
▶ Play
minute. Thank you. I thank you very much. I think that if I just spoke my name, it would take a minute. Let me suggest that, Mr. Murdoch, you refer this to the study commission. I think the issues that are presented are significant. The answers are certainly not going to be agreed upon today, if ever, really. I don't think you have the votes to pass this. I signed on to support it, but I don't think that I can support it for reasons that I will state. But I must say that I am most impressed with the testimony of the three superintendents, and they give a basis for the study. Mr. Hoyle's points should be addressed, and they need to be addressed with something other than the emotion of the hour. Ms. Hardrick's points are well taken, in my opinion. Public schools should not be competitive environments. They should be places where all children should learn, and it bothers me to a great extent where we go and brag about my child is the superior kid in this school district. That necessarily means somebody else's child is inferior, and we've been working as a race of people to overcome the notions of inferiority and superiority as we go on. And Ms. Murdoch has pointed up many of the problems that she faces in just being able to operate a school and to do it well. I am not prepared to say that school districts will do well if they mistreat teachers. And you mistreat teachers and employees unless you give them some opportunity for a fair hearing under circumstances where they have been accused. Since the public policy of Arkansas is to cause, is to try to induce people to become teachers and to work in public schools, so you want to do things that cause them to want to be there. And you want the children to want to be there, and that will happen more if you have teachers who want to be there. The other things of charter schools, which are chagrined
▶ Play
to me, include larger class sizes. Are you asking a question?
▶ Play
Well, I'm moving to the longest questions, I swear. Well, let me do this. Let me do this, if you will. Let me first ask the chairs leave to consider having this matter referred to a study commission. and to have the three persons here along with the charter advocates address some of these issues I mean I'd like to make that in the form of a motion before we have further discussion if there is anybody
▶ Play
who's willing to go with that I'm not going to take that
▶ Play
motion yet let me finish my question Isn't the issue that you are facing Ms. Murdoch, Ms. Hardring, Mr. Hoy, the issue of ways that I fail you to confront it and the fact that when all the white people leave a district, they leave behind children who are the least educated, the ones that teachers don't want to work with. And that creates the problems that you have. The budgets go down with the revenue going down with the loss of the
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:49:16
tax base. Let me interject, if I may. Because I certainly understand and respectful of Representative Walker's testimony and anticipated this. But if he has a question, then we could answer a question. That was a question, in
▶ Play
all due respect. Isn't that the real issue? I mean, Mr. Hoy, isn't that really the issue? I mean, you don't want to say, obviously, blackheads can be educated without white people being present. But when you take the economic base away, you're talking about putting up the economic base, Mr. Murdoch. When you take the economic base away and then you tell a group of people with limited resources that they can't, I'll finish, Mr. Bell. Mr. Bell has a point of order. Mr. Bell, I'll finish this and you may make your point of order if you wish. But I'm going to finish my question irrespective of your
▶ Play
point of order. If you could just state
▶ Play
that in a short sentence, that would be great. My question is very simple. How do you address this when you have the socioeconomic factors that I have described? What I
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:50:19
don't want to see people drawn into, Representative Walker, as much as I respect your position, is that's a developed position research by you. You're asking, putting people on the point about your research and your thinking that you espouse. so well, but that's not this bill and that's not what we're really here to address. Not saying that your point don't have a point, but I don't know that the people at the end of the table are prepared to even answer your point from your point of view. Well, let them do it. Representative Bell,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question if you still have one. Well,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, just a moment. I mean, I ask a question. I'm entitled to have an answer from the superintendents whom he brought here. I'm sorry, did you ask that to the superintendent? I asked it to the superintendents, not to Mr. Murdoch. He and I are going to be friends when this is over. We're going to need to hurry
▶ Play
and move on. I want to let them answer
▶ Play
Speaker 232 1:51:10
your question and then we're going to move on. What Lee County is asking for in the bill, we're asking for fair and equitable treatment
▶ Play
for all students. Ms. Harden? I think that the issue for Forest City is the students that we serve, regardless of their socioeconomic background and their current situation, We're asking for an opportunity to provide that group of students with the best education possible, and there are waivers in here that I think will allow me to provide them with the best opportunity in Forest City. Which ones are they is my question. So some of the ones right off the top of my head, extended day, extended year, waiver from courses such as possibly, you know, from school to school is different, but maybe some of the exploratory extracurricular courses, There's an extra history when I could do an extra literacy. You know, I would have to assess each individual school, but those three right
▶ Play
off the top I could name. You're not
▶ Play
talking about getting rid of Fair Teacher Dismissal. I'm sorry, Rep.
▶ Play
Walker, you're out of time. Representative Deffenbaum, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I may be way behind on this deal, but I still can't come to grips with a waiver being granted to a public school that will allow that public school to hire an uncertified person. I don't get that. I just can't see that in here. So how do you rectify that? What is
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:52:44
that bill saying to me? Thank you, Representative Vaughn. Currently, what you have allowed as Superintendent Hoy has testified is that we have put in place already in our state for our children what you just said that you can't get a hold of. That's what we live under now. Public charter schools are allowed to use those very teachers in the classroom that you just state. Now, and I'm not in no way saying that they cannot deliver it as it needs to happen. Now, I'm not in that debate saying that they're not delivering a good product. What I'm saying to you is as I try to level the playing field, that is being allowed. That has been, and there's a school in the area where I represent, Kip Delta, Representative, that have now over 1,000 students, and they seem to be doing, quote-unquote, well with that with their teachers. So the allowance of non-certified teachers issue didn't start today. We're just trying to level the playing field, Representative. And this body did not affirm that. This was done prior to us. But as we sit here today, and when we took the oath, we come here to represent for those that we represent. And that's where we are. I'm not debating good or bad. I'm saying what is, and it
▶ Play
should be level. Okay. Thank you. I have no more questions, but I am going to make a statement. From now on, questions on this committee will be one-sentence questions. We will not make statements from the committee. if you want to make a statement we will have a motion for debate and then we will debate that issue from now on and I'm talking to every one of you one sentence question mr. chair
▶ Play
I understand you're the chair and you can set the rules but I would suggest to you that that rule is intended to apply to me and I do think that it would be subject to some discussion from time by time I'm not the only one to ask a question that's long but the point is that you should not be announcing a rule that applies to one member especially on an issue so important and I would just ask that when you announce a rule you discuss it with us and let us have some input into it because this after all is not a dictatorship no sir it is not but
▶ Play
that is the rules of the committee it is questions we are having too many statements from more than one person representative Walker and I'm going to control this committee as I should and I believe that everybody in this committee would appreciate that from other ways. So if you want to speak to me now in private, I will be welcome to speak to
▶ Play
anyone in my office in private. But from now on, that is the rule. Well, I'll do it in public and private. I
▶ Play
want you to know that. Representative Douglas, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Speak to me, Representative Murdoch, about you know, let's move outside Arkansas. Where are we? 35th or 37th. What could this do for us being able to compete internationally to bring down some of these barriers that, you know, could bring some more innovation, some things that are doing in other states, possibly, that we're not, you know, that we've been slow to the table on?
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:56:07
That's a good point, and I think it gets us more global. I think the way education is moving globally, nationally, it gives us, you know, whenever innovation is allowed and outside-the-box thinking is allowed, you would tend to think that it would make for better chances for just making us a better, more competitive, producing a better child, making teachers better. Everybody becomes better, I think, when there's an ability to be innovative. So I just don't think there's any negativity to it outside of what we bring to the table when we hold on to our own vestiges and those things that control us. Are there any other questions from the committee?
▶ Play
I'm going to go to the audience. We have three that have spoken for the bill that were on the list, so I'm going to go to against. Mr. Nagel, you are recognized to speak against this bill. You would please state your name and who you're with, and you will be recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 280 1:57:33
Brenda Robinson, President of the Arkansas Education Association. Rich Nagel, Interim
▶ Play
Speaker 194 1:57:41
Executive Director of the Arkansas Education Association You're recognized We have serious concerns with
▶ Play
Speaker 280 1:57:49
House Bill 1377 The bill does not define the number of students that are drawn from the public school district in an open enrollment charter school and a school district that does not have to identify many If an open enrollment charter school draws a few or two students, it qualifies to petition the State Board of Education for the same waivers as a charter school is in question. Number two, the bill does not consider whether the school district has lost students to an open enrollment charter school, has an increasing or decreasing or stable enrollment. Under this bill, a school district that has lost at least two students could apply for waivers even if its overall enrollment is increasing. Number three, like you, we've been wondering what types of waivers can be granted to an open role charter schools in Arkansas. Well, I went on the Arkansas Department of Education's website, and it listed commonly granted waivers. The list, and of course, that's just what they listed, but I'm sure you could go to any of the standards and decide what waivers that you wanted. But it includes waiving the licensure requirements for teachers, administrators, and superintendents, guidance counselors, and media specialists, waiving elementary class size requirements and secondary teaching load of 150 students, waiving requirements for alternative learning environments for students who experience difficulties in a traditional classroom setting waiving gifted and talented program for students waiving provisions for school nurses waiving the school year starting and end dates waiving the maximum salary requirements for teachers and classified employees and waiving the fair dismissal and fair hearing acts for teachers and classified employees. Most of the common waivers deal with lowering the standards for personnel, student support services, and programs for students with special needs. Is there any data to support how lowering those standards improve student achievement? I want you to know that educators are deeply committed to the success of every student. To achieve this goal, it is imperative that we have qualified licensed teachers and shared accountability and the resources to ensure the best possible educational outcomes. The AA believes that the standards and rules approved by the General Assembly and the State Board of Education and the Department of Education exist to help ensure a quality education for students. A public school seeking waivers should be required to provide the same documentation or student performance expectations required to open enrollment charter schools and to be held to the same standards for keeping the waivers. Under House Bill 1377, school districts receive waivers, but they are not required to do anything different or make any improvements. Districts receive the right to waivers, but shoulder no additional responsibility for better student or school performance. We encourage students to get diplomas, degrees, licensures, certifications, and pass tests, but then we devalue all the above by waiving them for staff and schools. AA believes that this bill is unnecessary. There are provisions in our current education code for school districts to make application to the State Board of Education to become a conversion public charter school, as Representative Armstrong also stated, and to seek waivers from the Arkansas education laws that include adopting research-based school and instructional designs that will focus on improving student and school performance and addressing school improvement status and partnering with public school districts and public schools to address the students' needs in a geographical location or multiple locations. This bill allows waivers for the services that students deserve. Students deserve highly qualified licensed teachers. Students need consistency, not turnover of teachers. Licensed teachers have shown a commitment to education by seeking certification and doing the work it takes to earn a licensure. In short, students will not receive the quality standards that they deserve if this bill passes. This concludes our testimony.
▶ Play
Mr. Nagel, you have a
▶ Play
Speaker 194 2:03:08
statement. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Only one. There was testimony that a waiver is needed for an extended school day or school year, and I'm really not sure that a waiver is needed for either of those. A waiver is needed to adjust the start date or the ending date of the school year, but for a day and a longer year, I don't believe a waiver is required.
▶ Play
Thank you. Mr. Harris, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just wanted to ask you the question. You kept on saying not knowing, you didn't know what the waivers would be. There kept on being that question. Would they not, would there not be the same waiver issues that the charter schools have? And I mean, because the bill was pretty specific in
▶ Play
Speaker 194 2:04:22
that area. Yes, sir. The school district seeking waivers is limited to the waivers that are granted to the charter school and that is drawing their students from them. But it is conceivable that a school district could be losing students to more than one charter school, and then you would have multiple waivers in which you could apply.
▶ Play
So you answered yes or no. So it was in the bill. Okay, thank you. I
▶ Play
have a question for Mr. Nagel. Mr. Nagel, do you understand how many kids could be pulled out of the school before those waivers take effect? Is it 1, 10, 20? Do we have
▶ Play
Speaker 194 2:05:07
a number? The bill just says students, Mr. Chairman. That is plural. It's more than
▶ Play
one. More than one. Okay. I'll probably have to ask the author of that bill then. Are there any other questions from the committee? Okay,
▶ Play
Speaker 294 2:05:28
thank y'all. Thank you. Andrew Bagley for the bill. State your
▶ Play
name and who you're with, and you're recognized. My name is Andrew Bagley. I'm the
▶ Play
Speaker 296 2:05:44
president of the Helena West Helena School District Advisory Board, and I want to thank all of you for taking time to hear our testimony this morning. As a previous teacher in Helena, West Helena, and E-Lane School Districts, I'm a current instructor at Phillips Community College at the University of Arkansas, and the son of public school educators with over 80 years of service, these issues are very near and dear to my heart. HB 1377 recognizes that the landscape of public education has changed and that if traditional public schools are to survive then the rules of the game must be changed to reflect the altered circumstances of our current situation We live in a time of great change when public schools are expected to do so many more things with ever-changing technology in an environment that some might describe as increasingly competitive and others might describe as hostile one thing is certain change has come traditional public education must be given the tools to meet the never-ceasing alterations of this educational reality in order to do that we cannot continue to be bound by the frameworks that define the success of public education for previous generations just as we no longer go to the one-room schoolhouse we cannot allow ourselves to be restricted by what worked well for my parents and for me that is why I offer this testimony today not only for myself but on behalf of our entire board which author which unanimously authorized to speak on their behalf our schools are in a fight for survival helena probably provides the starkest example in this entire state of the need for hb 1377 our school district currently has over 700 students living within its boundaries that attend the charter school located downtown the rules by which we play are not the same the rules we must abide by make it impossible for us to rapidly respond to the change in public education landscape so that we can compete on a level playing field against whatever our charter school critics claim we don't do i was a proud member of the arkansas education association my entire public education career. I served as president of the Elaine chapter. I understand the anxiety of my former brethren about this legislation. However, the facts indicate we, the professional educators in this state, must change as well. Charter schools have the ability to act quickly to remove an ineffective teacher. Traditional public schools are bound by the Fair Dismissal Act that represents a pendulum that has swung too far in one direction. It can take years to remove ineffective teachers and it takes administrators focusing almost like a laser beam on that teacher to beat that documentation burden necessary to fire someone for incompetence. Furthermore, the same is true of school administrators. It might be easier to get something passed in the United States Congress than it is to remove an ineffective principal. This is not right and the public schools suffer because of this. the charter schools sell that they don't put up with non-performance the playing field should be level and the helena west helena school district should have the same rules that its charter competition does otherwise we are being asked to shoot a three-point shot from the nba line while the charter schools get the high school line to shoot it from hb 1377 will at least get us to the college line but this is not about termination of people most of our teachers are hard-working dedicated and loving individuals giving us their best every day for the students in their classrooms i have two grandchildren that my wife and i are raising that are in the hell in the west town of public school systems and i can attest to that but currently the charter schools have much more flexibility in who they can hire to work in various positions both as teachers and administrators. They can hire people who are dynamic educators with training in a wide variety of fields that the Helena West Helena School District cannot. And I have two examples that I think demonstrate this quite effectively. One is the charter school in Helena is able to have John Brummett teach journalism, one of our state's most highly regarded journalists. The Helena West telling the school district can't do that because he's not certified. And so that is an opportunity that those kids can get that ours cannot. This example happened to the Helena West telling the school district this year. We have problems with math and science teachers in particular. We had math openings. We had a lady who wanted to come to work for us who had been previously certified in another state but because of the bureaucratic entanglements that it took to try to get her where we could hire her in the meantime kip delta hired her so instead of our kids having a quality math instructor they got a long-term sub who didn't even have a college degree arkansas could not let that continue our kids deserve the same opportunity that the kids in the charter schools are getting and i could rattle off issues like these in every academic area and i know that everybody's wanting to go to lunch and so like my wife tells me sometimes you got to just wind it down but this this affects our ability to survive and so i don't want to to shortchange it but this this affects every academic area even affects athletics they can hire coaches who are not teachers that are experts in their sport which we can't do either it's also true for administrative leadership this is not true just for teachers scott shiree has been recognized nationally as a dynamic educational leader fortune magazine i think was one of the the publications that recognized him for that he has a bachelor's degree he is not certified to be a superintendent the helena was telling the school district could not have considered an individual like him to lead our district i ask the following questions is that right is that fair does it make sense i submit to you that the answer is no and this bill will go part of the way to recognize to rectify this uneven unfair unjustified and unlevel set of rules representative harris mentioned competition well the current situation as it is today would be like putting the one-legged man in the butt-kicking contest against manny Pacquiano. We can't compete if the rules aren't the same. And that's all HB 1377 seeks to do. Level the playing field. Make the rules of the game the same. Give us a fighting chance. The people of Helena West Helena want what's best for their kids. We want our kids in Helena West Helena School District to get a world-class education, and I know we've had our problems. but this is one tool we can use to start to have a school district where 700 don't leave they come back and they are beating down the doors to come back so i ask you to please support hb 1377 and if anybody has any questions i'll be willing to try to answer
▶ Play
represent walker you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question i have my one question and i'll do my best to be in one minute. Do you recall when the Marvel schools in your area were required to integrate and all the teachers left and formed the Marvel Academy and the white students went over there? Do you recall that they went to a private school? The private schools did not have any requirements imposed by the State Department of Education do you know whether those schools did that school did better than the public school mr. Walker the
▶ Play
Speaker 296 2:13:58
data from the private schools is very limited I would submit to you could I elaborate just a moment if you know there are some ACT scores that are reported from time to time that show that they do okay. I do not approve of those institutions that were founded in our area clearly for that purpose. And I think I've spoken with my feet by the fact that the children that live in my house are in the hell in the West
▶ Play
town of public schools. I don't see other questions. We have Thank you. I have Richard Hutchinson to speak against the bill. This is the last against I have on the sheet. State your name and who you're with, and you
▶ Play
are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Richard Hutchinson, and I am with the Arkansas Public Policy Panel in Citizens First Congress. I'll be very brief on this. I think a lot of discussion has already been made. We certainly support trying to make sure that schools are innovative and that they're doing the things they need to be doing and trying to find out the things they need to be doing to improve the quality education. All schools need to do that. There are reasons that policies are put into effect both through state board regulation and through law and through law at both federal and state level, for that matter, to ensure that schools are doing the right things. Charter schools were, when they first began to be a part of the policy discussion, the idea was that charter schools would be laboratories of innovation that schools could then take from and adopt. And there's some evidence that that has happened and worked, and some evidence also that charter schools do no better. than a lot of traditional public schools, but that's not really the debate here. The debate here, as I've heard, seems to be wanting to have a level playing field. What I think has not been mentioned in this discussion is the fact that in the 2013 session of the Arkansas General Assembly, a rather comprehensive piece of legislation was passed which allows schools, whether they have any children or not, as a part of a charter school, going to charter school, to petition to become districts and schools of innovation. The term waiver is not used, but basically that law allows them to develop a plan that will get them exceptions from pretty much a wide variety of different policies and rules and legislative requirements. Specifically, however, that law does not allow them to get a waiver from the Teacher Fair Dismissal Act. And I would argue that there is very little evidence that indicates that making a teacher and at-will employ someone who basically you can walk in that day and say, I don't want you here anymore, is going to be something that will lead to improved education in schools. I don't think there's any data or research out there that shows that. And you repeal that, that's in effect what you make those people to do. As the public policy panel and the Citizens First Congress, we want schools to be better. We want them to be accountable, and we will work with the schools in our communities to make sure that happens. But we do think they ought to be that this bill simply goes too far.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Murdoch, your recognized question. Thank you, Chairman.
▶ Play
Speaker 210 2:18:08
Is the implication, if I'm understanding you correctly, that you're making is that the public charter delivery system, you say that that does not do what needs to be done for our children. Is there an implication?
▶ Play
No. I think what I've said here very simply is that there are provisions already in state law that allow schools to experiment with all schools, whether they have students in charters or not, to be able to apply to the State Board of Education and make changes in the way they do things and which laws and rules apply to them. They have to come up with a plan to do that. That plan has to be bought into by the community and by the employees in that district. But that's a good thing because you're much more likely to be successful if instead of you're imposing something on some people, you are developing something. And we would argue that you can do that now under existing state law. This proposed bill is not really necessary and goes way too far. We understand the concerns about level playing field, but we think that we've already provided in state law some ways to deal with that that could be much more effective than this bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 210 2:19:34
But your answer was yes to public charters. You're not saying they don't deliver a good form of
▶ Play
education? The research out there shows that some charter schools do better than traditional schools. Some charter schools do about the same, and some charter schools don't do as well. Charter schools are a part of the system we have in Arkansas, and that's not going to change. But simply, but they are a part of it. And we don't think we have the research yet to say that we want to just make all charters.
▶ Play
Speaker 271 2:20:04
Are there any other questions? Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you. I have a Mr. Larry Owens to speak for the bill. State your name and who you're with,
▶ Play
Speaker 305 2:20:20
and you're recognized. I'm Larry Owens, and I'm just Joe Q. private citizen. I've spent more than, I guess, 40 years working in public service and bureaucracies, and my last endeavor had to do with serving as the mayor of Hughes, which is in the heart of the Delta. I don't have anything planned written that I can read to you but in a discussion I had briefly I believe it was yesterday on this particular issue in private with Representative Murdoch he heard some things and thoughts that I shared with the group that I was discussing with and he asked me to come in and talk about those I come out of the area that Representative Murdoch serves in, out of a rural community. As a matter of fact, I did attend a one-room schoolhouse a long, long time ago. But since then, I have had the opportunity to attend university as well as serve, as I said, in both state, federal government, and now in municipal government. I have, I think, was motivated somewhere along the way to have an appreciation for education and learning. And I thought about, after the discussion with Representative Murdoch, what is a teacher? What, by definition, what is a teacher? And my wife is a teacher as well as serves as a school superintendent. Like the Murdochs, I have, by virtue of being married to her, have to tolerate and listen to a lot of things going on. And thank you so much in the school system. So after thinking about that, I decided a quick definition for a teacher was one who imparts knowledge and inspires people to have a lifetime quest for learning. That's my definition of a teacher. Then looking at this situation, and I appreciate many things that's been said here for those that affirm and approve this House Bill 1377. But I would like to challenge those that's listening and think about this thing to look at certification versus qualification, certification versus qualification. The idea is in order for one to impart knowledge, you have to be qualified. In order for one to motivate and inspire people to do things, you have to be qualified to do that also. So these words, flexibility, I've heard that. I've heard innovation. I think if we look at some of our leading people in private industry, those people were innovative. The person that a young man developed, the Internet system, we lost the man out in the Silicon Valley. He was an innovator. People that think outside and non-tradition and not harnessed or regulated by government bureaucracies tend to do things very well. not to say that regulations are there, but I come from a military background, law enforcement background, where there is structure. But also I think that teachers have heard a lot about this Fair Dismissal Act. I think that's one of the main concerns. But I do believe that if you're paying someone, and especially expending public funds, taxpayers' money, that there should be some expectation of production. So I don't believe a teacher should sit around and not do their job and still be paid. Now, I had six daughters. My daughters, we have four of those daughters, did attend university and do quite well. I, too, served as one of the speakers before as a single parent for a good period of time. So I do appreciate education. I do believe and have observed that schools, public schools, are not allowed the opportunities that private schools have. So I'm told I'm not an educator. Matter of fact, I was dissuade by being an educator when I was in undergraduate school by my history professor. And he told a lot of us undergraduates that we, going out to teach school, we hadn't been in the world long enough and didn't have that knowledge base we were talking about. And all we were doing was going out spreading ignorance, you see. Now, that may not be true. But I did take that, and I did not pursue a career in teaching, as it were. I will leave with this, and that is I do believe the public school is given the opportunity. We call it this flexibility. We call it which leads to them being able to do some of those things. Like, for example, we had a real problem over in Hughes. I've been over there working intently for 10 years with trying to get a vocational ag teacher over there. We found a person that was in business, had an ag degree, but he was not certified. We had connections all the way to the United States Department of Agriculture in Washington where we wanted to make that school have a blue ribbon ag program. That person couldn't be hired due to constraints by the Department of Education. So I do, I know we are waiting on lunch here pretty soon, but I would like to say that I affirm and support listening to all the discussion that we've had here, this bill, House Bill 1377. Thank you. Are there
▶ Play
any questions, committee? Seeing none, would anybody like to speak against the bill? I have Dr. Abernathy to speak for the bill. One minute, please. That's all you asked for, so that's all you're going to get. You're
▶ Play
Speaker 307 2:26:04
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Richard Abernathy, executive director of AAEA. You know, this bill is about two things. Level on the playing field. You know, back when I was coaching at Alma, I used to love to go over to Van Buren and Mr. Deffenball's team and just beat the tire out of him. And we could do that because of the level playing field. I'm not so sure if both hands were tired behind my back I could do that, but probably could, Coach. The second thing that we're really missing is this is a local control issue. You know, where everyone's acting like that all these boards are going to go out and start asking for waivers, start asking for these waivers that are approved by charter, such as fair dismissal, that may not be the waiver that those boards are asking for. It may be something entirely different, but it gives them an opportunity to level the playing field so they can compete. If you think it's just going to be carte blanche waiver approval, that's not going to happen. Those local boards, before they approve something, will still be going through their communities because if they get too far out of line, their communities will bring them back. So that's the two choices, I think, is just leveling the playing field and being able to have local control. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Are there any questions? Reckon Walker, you're recognized for questions.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. With respect to leveling the playing field, how can the playing field between Hills, Arkansas, which I have represented, where I've represented Mr. Owens and his wife, or Mariana, ever be made level to Springdale or Fayetteville or for that matter, Cabot? How can you do it? If you can answer that, I'd like to know.
▶ Play
Speaker 307 2:27:46
No, you can't answer that, Representative Walker. That's a good question. I don't know if
▶ Play
you ever can, so. I'm sorry, you recognize? But if we can't, at this point in time, make all schools in the world equal, is this a good step toward bringing us into an arena where we can, you know, approach that bar of, you know, getting everybody to this, you know, same equality? I do
▶ Play
Speaker 307 2:28:30
think that's the case, Representative Douglas. I think you heard some very passionate testimony from Helena West Helena today that they have some things that they really think would improve their schools. Does anyone in this room not want Helena West Helena schools to improve? So if that's what their decision is at that local community's level, that they need some waivers to improve their students and improve their student achievement, why not give it to them? Let's try something different because what's been happening may not have been the most effective. And, again, it goes back to my opinion, and I'm a big believer in just local control and let those communities make those decisions. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any other questions, committee?
▶ Play
Thank you. Do we have anyone to speak against the bill? For the bill? Oh, I'm sorry. Four against the bill. Is that a kind of? State your name and who you're with and you're recognized. I'm John Bacon. I'm
▶ Play
the CEO for East Stem Charter School here in Little Rock. I think this is such a great discussion because what I'm hearing today as a person who worked for 13 years in a traditional school district and has spent the last seven in an open enrollment charter environment is real discussions about what's best for kids, what rules need to be in place, what rules really get in the way. And so it's a wonderful discussion to be talking about. You know, charters seem to be doing some things right, which I love that acknowledgement because we're talking about trying to, you know, say if it works over there, let's move it over here. In my opinion, that's always been the whole point. the charter system was we should be innovative experimental incubators we should get waivers because we believe that some of these rules are really getting in the way if we prove that you can get the job done and that rule was not necessary then I think that should move to traditional school districts that's the way this should work and I should be given the opportunity to stretch the waivers even further and so I think this is a great discussion I I would say as a charter CEO, I would have no issue with this law being passed. The thing that I think we all need to keep in mind that I've heard mentioned several times is leveling the playing field. So I'd like us to take a look at all aspects of leveling the playing field from a funding perspective across the
▶ Play
board. I think that's a great discussion. Are there any questions? Yes.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Now, Mr. Bacon, you were in Little Rock, and you were in public schools. You obviously were aware that the Little Rocks, were you aware that the Little Rock schools had the incentive schools from which KIPP was formed 14, 15 years ago. KIPP comes from those incentive schools, and they were working. And the Little Rock School District took action to try to eliminate those things. They had double funding after school, extended day, field trips that was working in little rock and persons in the community decided that they would change that so they go to kip and you all put it over there it works pretty good now in private why couldn't it have continued to work good in the public schools i was never a part of any of those discussions but i would tell you i worked uh in some of the most disadvantaged middle and high schools in little rock school district with high minority high economically disadvantaged populations and i know the challenges that those schools are facing but you also know that those those incentive schools worked and they had extended day they had extended week they had everything here that you all are now touting as the as the as the savior for or an alternative for public education if they can work in public schools as they work for a long time well i would say open enrollment charter schools are public schools and so i think we're talking about the whole we're all on the same side of this because we're all talking about what's best for schools in our public environment but I think that as I said my whole goal is for for us to try and see how we can innovate and then make those things become part of the norm and if we fail and we hit on things that don't work obviously those should not be passed back to school districts and I think the school districts have great ideas in many cases of things that should work I think it's it takes all of us putting
▶ Play
our heads together to come up with the best ideas. Thank you. Are there any other questions? Thank you. Anybody in the audience for or against? Are you for? Okay. State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 320 2:33:40
Mr. Chair, members of the committee, Scott Smith with the Arkansas Public School Resource Center. Again, we'd like to acknowledge the historic nature of this debate and the movement forward of the concept, I would just point out that the idea of being able to obtain waivers, as has been mentioned, is not something that's foreign to either side. But there's also one point to acknowledge as well as with regards to opening moments. They have to accept greater accountability with regards to the waivers, and that point has not been discussed here. So I think that's one thing as we move forward, we look at this, is what kind of accountability might we request of someone who's accepting
▶ Play
these greater allowed waivers in
▶ Play
this area. Question? Reckon Walker, you're recognized. Thank you. In charters, isn't it true that you don't emphasize qualifications? In fact, whenever you want to have somebody put in a position, irrespective of qualifications, you put them in, just as we do in the state of Arkansas, like we did, in all due respect, a fellow who worked out real well, but the person who was head of the Department of Higher Education, the person who was head of the Clinton School, and I understand that the governor has now named a person who has no public educational experience to be head of the State Department of Education. So if we can just change the qualifications at will, why don't we just let these people do whatever they want to do? Does that make any kind of sense, Mr. Smith, in route to trying to privatize the entire public school system of Arkansas is that a question well first
▶ Play
Speaker 320 2:35:21
of all I don't I don't run charter schools so that's a generalization that I don't necessarily feel comfortable responding to on behalf of any particular charter school second of all I would also acknowledge that just having a certification or piece of paper doesn't necessarily make you qualified and that there are people who come from many varied areas of experience who would do a great job as as teachers in the classroom or commissioners of education based on their life experiences and other professional experiences out
▶ Play
Speaker 207 2:35:51
there. Mr. Chair, just one question.
▶ Play
You're recognized. How many state boards of education have eliminated qualifications as a condition for certification? Or have eliminated certification? I mean, it has to mean something. How many states have done it? Well, the federal government itself has acknowledged. No, no, I'm asking about the states. I'm not asking about it. I only want my question answered. How many states have eliminated certification as a condition for public education teaching? Well, I don't know the
▶ Play
Speaker 321 2:36:21
specific answer to your question. That's the answer to my question. Mr. Chair,
▶ Play
Speaker 320 2:36:28
can I respond? If it's to his direct question, you may. I would just simply respond that the feds themselves have recognized this by way of creating a possibility of not having to have a certification to allow someone to qualify for teaching spots out there.
▶ Play
Thank you. Are there any other questions, committee? Thank you. We are going to stop the debate, and we're going to let you close for your bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 210 2:37:03
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee, and all of those that have joined this debate. When thinking about bringing this legislation, this is what I needed to happen. I needed this conversation to this level at the table because for far too long, there has been areas specifically in the state that have been overlooked, whether intentional or unintentional, and we now suffer greatly from that. I so appreciate the testimony on both sides, to be honest. I do want to make sure that sometime when we get off the point of what this legislation was intended for, it is not at all to put our children in classrooms with unqualified teachers or to put our teachers that we so appreciate, our certified teachers, traditional teachers as we call them, we so appreciate them. We have great programs out there, the National Teacher Certification Board, that program that was here yesterday. We have great, great teachers in our schools. But the reality, and I don't know why we're resistant to this reality, is that there needs to be flexibility. That one glove, one size, excuse me, one size does not fit all. I think that when you look at the 18 public charters that have been approved in this state and the charter board that we now have and all of this that lends to flexibility and it says something to the point of success to some degree, then there has to be some affirmation that flexibility and innovation and ingenuity has a place. Now the opposite side of this continues to be that there's an erosion. I don't see the erosion present without an assumption or assertion that those that's in administrative positions currently now, we're not and do not care about the outcomes for our children. I don't believe that, committee, public. I believe that on both sides of the aisle that we have compassionate people. Now, can we work together to try to get somewhere? Certainly, the genesis of this legislation starts for me at home. Politics is local. We feel this at home. You've heard from the superintendents and others that articulated our issues. And also please understand that there has been a system put in place that penalized us and continue to penalize us for things that we are not in total control of. The quality of life issues, jobs, people don't want to live in other areas so it affects your ability to retain. We have people that come but they don't stay long. We're penalized for that. So then if we have a homegrown person that wants to come back and give back to his community or her community that has a bachelor's degree in biology and will pass the practices because passing the practices if you read the bill is a part of this. Same thing that they have to do. But they have a commitment. And they can do the job. Why not? That's not saying if there's a certified teacher available that they won't be utilized. It's not what we're saying. But we're saying let's open it up, let's give each other a chance, and let's be flexible. I think, as a representative of the people in District 48, that I must do what I'm doing. It's been asked that I pull this down and put it in a study. We have waited long enough. I'm pushing forward, and with that, I ask the committee for a good vote. Thank
▶ Play
you, Chairman. I have a motion from Representative Eubanks for due pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, no. No. Roll call. I would call that a do-pass, but we will, if I see two hands, we'll have a roll call. I see the two hands, we'll do a roll call. Y'all are quick to judge on that before I even
▶ Play
Speaker 206 2:42:08
make the call. Representative Letting. Representative Murdoch. Yes. Representative Deffenbaugh. No. Representative Harris Yes Representative Eubanks Yes Representative Radliff Representative Radliff Representative Gillum Representative Gillum Representative Walker No Representative Bell Aye Representative Barks Yes Representative Douglas Yes. Representative Lowry. Yes. Representative McElroy. No. Representative Armstrong. No. Representative Gossage. Yes. Representative Sabin. Representative Sabin. Representative Hodges. Yes. Representative Gray. Representative Gray. Yes. Representative Lampkin?
▶ Play
Speaker 330 2:43:23
No. You want to vote by the chair? Yes, sir, you have
▶ Play
Speaker 318 2:43:45
ten. Yes, sir, because the speaker's not here. Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Yay! We
▶ Play
are not done. We have two more bills. We're going to run one short one, and then Representative Lowry is going to run his bill. At this time, I'm going to turn it to my co-chair, and I'm going to stay in this seat and run my concurrent amendment. Madam
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:44:06
co-chair, you're recognized, too. Representative Cozart, you're recognized to present your bill. House Bill 1370. Thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chair. Committee, all this does is just adds an emergency clause onto the bill that I ran about a week ago and that's all the amendment
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:44:27
is. Appreciate a good vote. Are there any questions from the committee? Is there anyone in the audience? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against the bill? What is it? Okay. Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed, Madam Chair. What are the wishes of the committee? Representative Letting? Do pass. As amended, okay? Do pass to concur, ma'am. Okay, do pass to concur. We have a motion of do pass to concur on Bill 1370. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations, you've
▶ Play
passed your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, committee. At this time, Representative Lowry will be recognized to present House Bill 1241-1241. You're going to earn your money today. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. You're recognized. Thank you, committee. I know the general rule of thumb is not to be the person between you and lunch, so I will share that dubious task with Representative Murdoch. It's not all on me, okay? First, I would ask adoption of an amendment to the bill. And let me just give a little bit of an explanation. At one point, the bill actually referenced transitioning from the park test in the current testing cycle to a previously used assessment test. We removed that, but we did not remove the reference to it in the emergency clause. So the amendment that you have before you is really just clean up to remove that particular reference from the emergency clause. This is Bill
▶ Play
1241, and this is the amendment that he is presenting at this time. He has just presented his amendment. Are there any questions on the amendment? I make the motion that the amendment be adopted. I have a motion to do pass on the amendment. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed? Say no. Your amendment has passed. You are
▶ Play
Speaker 340 2:46:50
recognized to present your bill 1241. Thank you very
▶ Play
much. As amended. Thank you. I know this bill has been languishing on the committee agenda for some time. House Bill 1241 is entitled in an act to delay the use of the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers, the PARC assessment. It's kind of a misnomer because actually the bill is not to delay the use. It is to actually terminate the use of it. The reason it has been languishing on the committee on the agenda is because I've been attempting for a number of weeks to reconcile whether there was any opportunity for us to transition to an alternative test. One of the other things that was actually looked at was the possibility of being able to get a waiver from the Federal Department of Education to suspend assessment for the current testing cycle just because of some of the reports that we've been receiving about the problems with the implementation of the park test. All of those efforts proved fruitless, so the bill that you have is much more streamlined. It specifically states that the use of the park test and association with the park partnership would terminate by the end of June. And that is also an amendment. The Department of Education had asked for some additional time to be able to finalize the processing of scores. what i would share with you right now going on all across the country there is revolt tied to the park test just in the city of chicago alone the head of the school district said that to administer the park this year is absolutely not in the best interest of our students we're receiving reports in new mexico that hundreds of students have protested the taking of the park test by walking out of their schools in new jersey and other states thousands have refused to take the test one student says it feels like we're being pressured to take a test that we feel like we're bound to fail because of a lot of things on the test that we never went over one of the one of the main complaints about the park test has been you know there's i think there There was a giddy feeling about this idea of having a real-time test where the students are sitting in front of a computer terminal, they're answering the questions rather than just filling in scantrons. So the giddiness, I think, was an expectation that if you're doing real-time testing, you're going to be able to get real-time results. But actually, what we know about the PARCC test is that results will not be available until October. I'm going to be inviting to the end of the table some representatives of the Guidance Counselor Association that will speak to the negativity of that, the fact that we should be using assessment tests to also be able to aid, for most, improvement. And in the cases of not being able to, excuse me, we're interrupted by popcorn entering the room. Point of order, Representative Gossage. There's no food at
▶ Play
the table. I'm sorry. Go ahead. He has to share.
▶ Play
The ability to be able to provide improvement plans for the students is going to be delayed until November or December. Well, by that time, half of the school term has gone by. So really, then you end up having a test that is not going to be very effective in being able to engineer improvement in the students. One of the questions, one of the things that a number of us have heard over the last, as far as nine months ago, is there has been a constant chorus of comments of lowered expectations that we've been told, please, you know, you can expect that they're going to be low scores. We've also been told that there's no ability for us to be able to use park evidence or assessment and to show longitudinal improvement or lack of improvement. There's no way to be able to compare it. As a matter of fact, I think the question that had been asked and answered was that it would be like comparing apples and oranges to the benchmark test that we have. So we really would have no longitudinal evidence that would be benefited by the park test. Now having said all of that, we are still going to have to proceed with the testing and the testing is going to be starting very soon. The testing cycle, excuse me, will be, the testing will be in two parts. One part starting extremely soon, I've had the information here in front of me, sorry. The performance-based assessments window is between March 9th and April 9th, so an entire month is going to be used just for testing that window. It will take four weeks if the weather cooperates, and that doesn't seem to be something that we can expect in our future. The end-of-year assessment window, then, the second part of the test is April 27th through May 22nd. It will take the school's two uninterrupted weeks to complete this assessment with all the students each school will be testing of course as I've already said during the month of March and May and the total in chair time for students and it this varies depending on grade level but we're even with third graders we're talking about 13 to 15 hours of in chair time for testing depending upon the grade level I've had one person compare that to that this in chair time would be just several hours short of how how much time is taken for the Arkansas bar exam the park rollout has been as one official in New Jersey said it has been a debacle and it continues to be so most the information we're receiving now are from schools from administrators from teachers we've We've not even heard the anxiety from the students yet, and it's starting to happen as the examples I already gave with New Mexico and the students in New Jersey protesting the taking of the test. There are a lot of problems with this particular test. It's not ready for prime time, but yet we are committed to a $9 million contract just for this academic year. The hope that I have for this particular bill of discontinuing use of the park is that we will be able to send to the governor's task force on Common Core a clean slate, an ability for them to be able to look at all potential assessments and not be overburdened with the specter of park hanging over their heads. Some have asked me, well, why not let the task force be able to make that decision? Well, unfortunately, if there's any consideration of PARC, to really fully consider it, you have to wait for the results to come back in October. And that timeline really does not fit well with the task force being able to look considerably at where we're going to move with Common Core and where we're going to move with assessment. That process has to start immediately. So I think the cleanest slate that we can give to that committee is to remove any doubt of whether the park assessment tests are going to be continued. That's basically my opening statement. I know I do have some witnesses that I'd like to bring forward, and I know there also will be some questions. You're
▶ Play
recognized to bring them forward. You can state your name and who you're with and if
▶ Play
Speaker 346 2:55:30
you're recognized. My name is Robin Finley, and I am with the Arkansas School Counseling Association. I serve as the technology chair, and I have now for 10 years. I'm no longer a counselor. I was a counselor. I'm now a federal programs coordinator for a school district, and I have with me another member of our board, Tanya Shelton. My name is Tanya Shelton. I'm also representing the Arkansas School Counseling. Press the
▶ Play
button. Turn that mic on, please. There we go. My name is Tanya Shelton. I'm from the Arkansas School Counseling Association as well. I have been a school counselor for 10 years at Alma High School.
▶ Play
Speaker 346 2:56:09
My first statement here is that we gathered a great deal of data from the Arkansas School counselors. and one of the things that I took were questions from the board to ask just several different questions. We did a survey originally that we surveyed, we allowed any school counselor just to talk to us about testing and how much time had been taken out of their day, out of their year to actually prepare for park, to prepare themselves, to prepare the students and we got over 500 responses in a week's time from school counselors, which is a good amount of results. Then we went on further from that because we wanted to know about the PARC trial, which the month of February was designated as the time for the PARC trial. And I'm also part of technology in a school district. And so there's been a great deal of collaboration between the counselors, the technology people, trying to get everything prepared, trying to get the students prepared, the teachers trying to teach about the tools, and so I just have two words to sum all that up, and then we're going to talk about the data. Too much. That is what it is, okay? Too much. The responses we've had from the teachers, this is too much for us to try to have to do. I started to bring a pile of emails. There were over 184 just since December with regard to changing instruction about the park what we're supposed to do about the park changing what we're doing with the computers it is too much we went to the trenches which are the counselors and we asked them because most of the counselors are the ones who are their building administrators for the testing or they may even be their district administrator for the testing. So in this last bit of information that we got, what I'm going to do is I'm going to read you some of the data and Tanya's going to read you some of the responses because what we did was we asked them just to answer the questions and then we asked them if we had any comments about those categories. Again, we received about over 200. Some of it had to do because of the weather. Some of them didn't even get to finish their park trial because of the weather conditions But we had over 200 counselors respond to our survey. So the first question, one of the first questions that we asked was, after completing the park infrastructure trial, how do you feel the technical aspect of the trial went? And we gave them the option of great. We had very few technical issues. Okay, we had some technical issues with either testing website or computer issues or Internet connectivity. And then the third response they could use was problems. We had several technical issues with either bandwidth, software, website, and or computers. So of the results of the 200 respondents, 76% of those said that we had some type of technical issue whenever we did the trial. So I'm going to hear some comments
▶ Play
about that. One of them is we had seven classroom teachers administering the test. We had our tech guy, curriculum coordinator, principal, assistant principal, and counselor moving in and out of classrooms, helping with any logon difficulties or other issues that required individual attention to a student. So as you can see, just in the infrastructure trial alone, there were numerous people who had to be involved and pulled from instruction. There were also people who claimed that their AT&T went down for a while, so they didn't have Internet, which meant that they couldn't even perform the test. There were updates that had to be done on the computers, Java updates. Some of these disappeared somehow during the trial. Two days after one of the trials that we did, we got a message from Pearson that their site had been down. We were struggling trying to get on there and look at it, and no one informed us that their site was down. So a lot of educational time was wasted just trying to test this out when they
▶ Play
Speaker 346 3:00:18
knew their site was down. One of our next questions, after completing the park infrastructure trial, do you feel you had enough personnel to administer the test successfully? So again, we went with the categories of great, okay, and problem. And over 80% of the schools that responded said we did not have enough personnel to successfully administer the test. Tech support on campus during the trial was
▶ Play
a must. You need someone to be able to check the screen, refresh, make sure students are progressing. I would like to also just add that teachers, certified teachers, are required to give this test, which means that in a room we figured out that one person is not enough. As our students are being kicked off, someone has to restart the test for the student. What's also difficult for the student is that it's not just testing their capabilities. It's also testing their technological know-how. If they don't know how to operate the system while on the trial, we could say, okay, you need to click the blue arrow. We can't do that in the actual test, so students are going to have to understand the technology on their own. We decided it's going to be at least two people in each testing site plus a tech person. So two certified teachers and a tech person in each room is the only way that we can see this being successful.
▶ Play
Speaker 346 3:01:36
The next question, after completing the PARC infrastructure trial, do you feel your students were prepared technically for the computer-based test? a great okay and problems over 70 percent of them felt like that the students had some type of technology technology struggle with the test 70 percent mine had one that said little students hands kept
▶ Play
hitting the control and alt keys which shuts down the test totally if this happens on the test they get a zero some of the teachers logins didn't work high school students are fairly tech savvy. However, why would they be tested using embedded tech tools that are not regularly
▶ Play
Speaker 346 3:02:17
used in the classroom? The embedded tech tools are part of the PARC test nav set. That's a whole different story that we could spend all day on. After completing the PARC infrastructure trial, do you feel your students were prepared content-wise for the test? Again, great, okay, in problem. Over 89 percent said we did not feel our students were prepared content wise for the
▶ Play
test. 89 percent. Some of the comments were students complained about the level of difficulty and reading passages were way above grade level. Most students did not get past the non-calculator session in a limited time frame. Last year we did a paper pencil trial and we had two 10th grade autistic students that I read the test to, and they were reading Madame Bovary, which is something I didn't read until college. So the passages are extremely difficult.
▶ Play
Speaker 346 3:03:14
Okay, that's our conclusion. Do y'all have any
▶ Play
questions for us? Are there any questions, Committee? I have Representative Armstrong for a question, if
▶ Play
Speaker 79 3:03:25
you still are interested in that. Yes. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Representative Lowry, since you're going to since this bill is saying end this test at the end of 2014-15 school year what if we're still going to get federal funds and stuff will we still be able to get the federal funds for this common core and how does this tie in? I just want to know how you're
▶ Play
going to end it with Well, and I will tell you the whole issue of federal funds has been very frustrating um we really are our hands are tied by a lot of things but the the issue of federal funds is tied to not having an assessment we're continuing with the current testing cycle as much of a debacle as it's probably going to be but it at least keeps us from being in jeopardy of losing the federal funds so all this does is it allows us to go through the current testing cycle and then we will terminate. In other words, we will not renew the contract with Pearson for the park test to proceed past this school term. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hollages, you have a
▶ Play
question? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Now that Lieutenant Governor Griffin has been tasked with the Council on Common Core and looking at where we go forward in this, including testing, my question is why not just allow the students to take PARC this semester and then let that task force or that Council decide which test to take and why should we, I guess, preemptively exclude PARC from that discussion? Okay.
▶ Play
And actually I addressed that in my opening statement that the park results will not be back until October. So for continuing park to be evaluated at all, that means the task force really would not be able to even start its work of looking at the different options until October, November. But the other issue is that I think one of the greatest enemies of good decision making many times is the status quo. Whatever is already in place, it has so many pressures. There's arguments like well it's too big to fail. We've already spent $9 million. Why do we want and I just don't think that those are valid arguments that the task force needs to be addressing. There are a lot of other potential alternative assessments. There's also the potential of the state being able to develop its own assessment and I think that those are much more valuable innovations than keeping something that has so many failures in it. Thank you. Sorry, Mr. Opening Remarks.
▶ Play
Are there any other questions? Representative Eubanks? Representative Lowry, I
▶ Play
sort of agree with Representative Hodges about the study that's supposed to be taking place, but you're saying that we won't have the results until October. Based on the feedback that we've already gotten this morning, I think we're already getting ample feedback. So I think those individuals are going to hear that before those results come back in October anyway. So I don't know if I've got a question here or not.
▶ Play
Speaker 129 3:07:00
I guess he'll agree with that. I don't know. I don't know if I would agree with that. Just for time's sake, let's try to
▶ Play
hurry our questions as much as possible. People are hungry and we have 20 minutes before we have session. So Representative Douglas, you recognize me.
▶ Play
Yes, Representative Lowry, if you could just tell us about the consortium and the increased cost that is being borne by having a diminished amount of people in that consortium.
▶ Play
Right, and that is a significant issue. Many of you know that the consortium originally consisted of 26 states. One by one that has been whittled down to now, I believe last count, is that there are only nine states that are active in the consortium. That is going to, if we were to continue the contract, obviously the costs are going to exponentially increase because now you're talking about only nine states involved. The other issue is that, you know, the whole reason for Common Core and a common assessment test, a consortium, would be so that you could have apples-to-apples comparisons with other states. At this point, there are no border states to Arkansas that are involved in the park. So that is where most of the migration would happen between state to state. So that argument for continuing park, then, is not even a viable argument anymore because we really have no need for that kind of comparison.
▶ Play
Representative Deffenbaum, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
thank you mr thank you mr chair uh representative i just got to make sure here we're voting to delay the test right but what did you say i mean are we just making a statement or uh is it really going to delay it i
▶ Play
didn't understand what you said well and i mentioned that in the opening that actually the title of the bill is a misnomer we're we're ending the use of the park test after this school term. Okay, thanks.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Douglas, for that correction. Do we have any other questions? No other questions? I have no other questions for you. Thank you. And I do have one that is here to speak against the bill. Is it Phoebe Bailey? You're recognized. If you will state your name and who you're with and you're recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
My name is Phoebe Bailey. I am representing Arkansas ASCD, and then I'm also director of Southwest Co-op in Hope, Arkansas. And first thing, Arkansas ASCD definitely wants to say thank you for having the bill amended from its original form and giving us the chance to get through the school year and not create the chaos of stopping in the middle and losing federal money. We also appreciate and support rigorous standards and assessments that go with those and realize that with PARC this year, because of setting cut scores, we would get scores later than we normally do. That happens any time we change assessments. we are not saying this is going to be a perfect test we have heard enough stories that we know that there are going to be issues but i was also a classroom teacher when we started the benchmark and not only were the kids stressed that first year we had students cry and we also had teachers cry so we've been there done that to that aspect i think what our request is is to let the committee that the governor has appointed, let them do the work. Even though they're not going to have the score results, they're going to have data from PARC. They're going to have data that surrounding states, whether they're using Smarter Balance or Aspire or their own test, they're going to see what the other states are doing, and they're going to have comparisons. Instead of legislating and saying you have to do this, you can't do this, let the committee actually do that work. Because we've always had our curriculum frameworks, whether they're standards, whether they're common core, whatever we call them, and whatever assessment we've had, we've changed vendors numerous times. MAT 6, all the different IWAs, and, you know, SAT 9, SAT 10. So instead of, and we've never legislated and said this one has to be the vendor, this one cannot. So our request is let the committee do their work. They're going to have the data from the testing, and let's just see what works.
▶ Play
Are there any questions, committee? Representative Douglas, you're recognized. So are you saying that
▶ Play
it would be best to, you know, we've got a critical decision-making process here at hand. We have to have a test ready during the school year, and we won't have these results back until? Even though we
▶ Play
won't have the actual scores, we'll know what happens within the next, I would say, week when I've got schools in my co-op area that are going to start testing, weather permitting, next week. And I will probably know the night of the first test, whoever tests first in my co-op, by that night I'll be able to tell you if it's going well or if it's not, because teachers and principals, they call, they let us know. So even though we may not have a score report, we'll know if the test worked or not. But that's part of the bill right
▶ Play
now. We're going to go ahead and run through this cycle and then start the process to decide on the next test that we'll take. Yes,
▶ Play
just leave it open instead of legislating and saying this one's not in the option. Just let everything be an option and let that committee that the governor's appointed decide which assessment we're going to use to measure our standards, whether it be PARC, whether it be Smarter Balanced, whether we make our own, but just don't eliminate something, don't eliminate a vendor when we have not even taken the test yet. So the question is, you do not think that by
▶ Play
the testimony that we're having that this has already shown that it is not working? It will not work. It is not working. I think there are going to be issues.
▶ Play
And, I mean, I can tell you pros and cons in my co-op. I've had schools that I thought would not be able to do anything and have had success when we did our pilot last year. also have had some you know it's so yes there are going to be issues and we're going to have problems but i just i mean i think if the governor has faith in the committee he's putting together let them have the input and decide rather than legislating what vendor we have to use or don't have to use are there any other questions
▶ Play
Speaker 130 3:14:06
committee thank you thank you is there anyone
▶ Play
One for the bill. I speak for the bill. Mr. Darlikowski, you're recognized to speak against the bill. Hello,
▶ Play
Speaker 375 3:14:34
I'm Jerry Darlikowski with Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families, And I want to thank Representative Lowry for visiting with me about the bill, and I appreciate what you do for education. But every now and then people have a different opinion. But I'd like to urge you today to let the Governor's Council make this decision. Let them evaluate. They'll have the information he's just relayed to you. I don't feel like we have a rush to judgment here. I know he mentioned the timing question. and he said, you know, October is too late. It's going to be off the table. I just think if October is too late for the governor's council to know, then how can they know right now? I think the more time we have and the more study, of course I'm an old time come from a research background and I never think that's a bad thing. I think we don't have to make this decision today or in this session. I think depending on what the governor's council says, we can make that decision. The Department of Education, I'm sure, will have their instructions based on what the council's findings are. And I would just encourage you. I'm not going to debate whether park's a good thing or not. I don't think there's been enough study yet, and I'd like for us to wait and make that decision with the governor's council. Thank you. Are there any questions? Thank you.
▶ Play
We have nobody else signed up, or would you like
▶ Play
to close for your bill? Yes, I would like to close. Committee, thank you so much for hanging in there. I hope some of you got some of Representative Gossage's popcorn to hold you over. We have ample evidence that the park test is not the best option going forward, and I have great respect for the governor's task force. I think it's amazing. Last I heard, I think we heard yesterday from the governor, that over 700 people have applied to be part of that task force. And so I know we're going to get a great cross-section of people who are going to be able to have meaningful input in where we go forward with Common Core, with assessment. I think to be most effective in that process, though, we need to remove from that process something that we already know is a failure. We know just by the fact that 26 states were originally in the consortium. For some reason, they're down to nine. One of the advantages that we have, I've always said this about being in Arkansas, we have the advantage, maybe we're a little bit behind the curve or whatever, but we get to hear the failures that are out there. And I'm just going to close with this one, if you don't mind, one parent in New Jersey and I know it's anecdotal but this parent wrote this and I think it's a great closing for talking about how we have failing schools and what this parent says is that I can guarantee you that because of the park test we will be failing but the failing is going to be that we will be failing our students we'll be destroying the trust between administrators teachers students and parents our children are struggling Parents are stressed trying to support them. Parents all across the state and across the country are starting to connect the dots and realize that this stress is not caused by a flaw in the students, but rather in the inappropriate curriculum and the testing. The tests matter because we've spent massive amounts of money already. We cannot afford to go into the task force process and have something hanging over the heads of those members, this argument that it's too big to fail. So we need to continue what we've been doing. As I said a while ago, the greatest enemy of innovation, the greatest enemy of thinking outside the box is status quo. If we retain our connection with the park test, that status quo is going to overshadow any of the great thinking and the great innovation that I think is going to come forward in the task force. So for these reasons, I would ask you, thank you, one, for hanging in there, and I would ask you for a due pass. on this bill. Matter of fact, I will make the motion as a member of the committee. No, actually, Representative McElroy wanted to do
▶ Play
it. Representative McElroy, is that due pass as amended? I have a due pass as amended. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. No. Ayes have it. Thank you very much, committee. That will be all today. Without objection, we will adjourn.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1366

0:44 - 2:49 7 segments 4 speakers

HB1581

2:49 - 9:47 22 segments 9 speakers

HB1372

9:47 - 11:30 4 segments 3 speakers

HB1395

11:30 - 1:11:45 171 segments 21 speakers

HB1377

1:11:45 - 2:46:12 275 segments 30 speakers

HB1241

2:46:12 - 2:47:01 4 segments 3 speakers

HB1370

2:47:01 - 3:19:30 91 segments 14 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
14 segments
Representative David L. Branscum Unverified
2 segments
Representative Greg Leding Unverified
2 segments
Representative Jeremy Gillam Unverified
25 segments
Representative John W. Walker Chair Unverified
49 segments
Speaker 38
1 segment
Speaker 40
1 segment
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
87 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 47
2 segments
Speaker 61
22 segments
Speaker 64
24 segments
Representative Justin T. Harris Unverified
15 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 79
2 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
16 segments
Representative James Ratliff Unverified
3 segments
Chad Mcpeak Unverified
25 segments
Speaker 28
1 segment
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 150
1 segment
Carol Nichols Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 168
14 segments
Roberta Kendall Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 183
1 segment
Speaker 194
10 segments
Speaker 115
1 segment
Speaker 206
4 segments
Speaker 210
50 segments
Speaker 228
14 segments
Senator Joyce Elliott Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 232
10 segments
Speaker 199
1 segment
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 280
11 segments
Speaker 294
1 segment
Andrew Bagley Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 296
17 segments
Richard Hutchinson Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 271
1 segment
Speaker 305
11 segments
Speaker 307
6 segments
Speaker 320
5 segments
Speaker 207
1 segment
Speaker 321
1 segment
Speaker 330
1 segment
Speaker 318
1 segment
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
34 segments
Speaker 340
1 segment
Speaker 346
14 segments
Tanya Shelton Unverified
8 segments
Representative Grant Hodges Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 129
1 segment
Phoebe Bailey Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 130
1 segment
Speaker 375
4 segments