March 13, 2015
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (36)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1193
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1193”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1452
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1452”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1625
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1625”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1496
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1496”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1706
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1706”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB698
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB698”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1596
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1596”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1744
· 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…rs, now the question before you is the motion to reconsider House Bill 1744. all in favor say aye”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1372
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1372”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1377
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1377”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1388
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1388”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1408
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1408”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1480
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1480”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1502
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1502”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1525
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1525”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1526
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1526”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1527
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1527”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1530
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1530”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1539
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1539”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1621
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1621”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1678
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1678”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1687
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1687”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1688
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1688”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1707
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1707”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1719
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1719”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1722
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1722”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1723
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1723”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1737
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1737”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1774
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1774”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1789
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1789”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1825
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1825”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1836
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1836”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1960
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1960”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1963
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1963”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB555
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Forestry, and Economic Development, to whom are deferred to Senate Bill 555 and Senate Bill 556, beg to leave the report, we've had the…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB556
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ic Development, to whom are deferred to Senate Bill 555 and Senate Bill 556, beg to leave the report, we've had the same under consider…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
This time the house will be called to order. I invite staff, members, and guests in the galleries to stand and be led today in prayer by Reverend Dr. Christoph Keller,
who's here from Trinity Episcopal Cathedral in Litterrock, who is a guest of Representative Clark Tucker, and then to remain standing to be led today in our Pledge of Allegiance by Representative Marshall
Speaker 5
1:19
Wright. I pray in the name of Jesus Christ. Almighty and merciful God, thank you for our fair state with its geographical and cultural variety mountain people to the north and west
delta to the east gulf coastal pine woods to the south and this lovely city on the river at its center thank you for this morning's rain of which for now I think we have had about enough guide us as stewards of this good state and may your blessing never leave it thank you for this nation with its passion for rights respect for law and love of freedom from whose founding
church and state are kept separate mostly and both are yours because you are their author and the source of rights and law and freedom guide us to craft our laws with care and justice and use our freedoms wisely. Thank you for these, our elected representatives, gathered from their homes amidst the woods and hills and farmlands, guard and bless their loved ones whom they left
behind to be here. Their busy lives are filled with competing claims upon their time demands on their allegiance and interpretations of their duty give them a moment's peace and quiet to sort these out and in that peace let your grace assure and strengthen them thank you for their labor in this realm of politics
and government, a work whose sometimes fractious nature is a consequence of freedom and the good tools that you have given us for using it, the abilities to think, feel, and choose that we enjoy as creatures in your image. Even when that work is difficult, let this also always be a place for friendship, laughter, and refreshment.
And in the feelings, thoughts, and choices of these, our elected representatives,
Speaker 10
3:57
who are your children, let your grace shine through today. Amen. Amen. All right, members, let's hit
Speaker 15
4:18
Mark your presence. Prayer of the machine, Mr. Clerk. Let's cast at the balance. Mr. Clark
with 95 present the chair sees a quorum representative hickerson
you're recognized uh leave for represent leave for representative different
ball is leave granted for representative deffenbaugh all right so noted representative gates you're recognized leave representative vault is lee granted for representative bought all right so noted representative
speaks you're recognized. Leave. Leave for Representative
Speaker 25
5:39
Douglas. House. I'm sorry, House. Is leave
granted for Representative Douglas House? All right, so noted.
At this time, Representative of John Vine's moves that we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal without objection, so ordered. Are there any reports from select committees, Mr. Clerk? Are there any reports from standing committees? Please read the reports.
Mr. Speaker, we, your Committee on Agriculture, Forestry, and Economic Development, to whom are deferred to Senate Bill 555 and Senate Bill 556, beg to leave the report, we've had the same under consideration here. We have to turn the same to the recommendation that they do pass. Respectfully submitted, Representative David Hillman, Vice Chair. Is there any unfinished business?
No, sir. Any executive communications? All right, this time, members, I'd like for us to welcome our doctor and nurse of the day. We have with us is our doctor of the day, Dr. Mikesh Sharma from Hot Springs, and we have Ms. Brenda Hewitt with us as our nurse of the day. Let's welcome them.
All right, members in the East Gallery, we have with us today is guests of Representative Clark Tucker. We have family and friends that are here today with us, so I'd like for us to welcome them at this time. We have Ms. Julie Keller and Michelle Lee, and we also have Representative Tucker's parents are with us, as well as his wife and children today. So let's welcome them. in the north gallery as guest of representative uh charlotte douglas uh we have with us uh hunter
dedman who's a student from east point school in greenwood and uh he's a leader in their school Cub Scout. He's working, I have a note here that he's working very diligently towards his bear patch. And he also serves as a greeter at First Baptist Church in Greenwood, and he's the grandson of former state representatives Mary Beth Green and Rick Green. So let's welcome him with us today. From Monette, the Buffalo Island Central West Elementary is here today
as guest of Representative Sullivan. And I'm not sure, I think the West Gallery is where I'm being examined. Let's welcome them. And then in the East Gallery, we have the Little River Leadership Group and the Sevier County Leadership Group. Today, there's a company by former Representative Fonda Hawthorne, and they are guests of Representatives Deanne Vaught and Nate Bell.
All right, members, we're going to move to the red calendar at this time. Representative Wright moves that we place Senate Bill 698 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment. Without objection, read amendment number one,
698. Representative Wright, you're recognized to explain
the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mine is Senator Hutchinson's bill, our amendment came out as do pass.
Representative Wright has explained the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment? For the amendment? Representative Wright, are you closed for the amendment? Representative Wright is closed for the amendment. The question now before the House is the adoption of Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 698. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. All right, the ayes have it. The amendment has been adopted.
There concludes the morning hour. All right, Representative Speaks at this time recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment one to house bill 1193 read amendment number one mr clerk amendment number one to
explain the amendment thank you mr speaker
this is just amendment to add linda collins smith's name to this bill and i would really appreciate a good vote all right you've heard an explanation
of the amendment would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment represent speaks are you closed for the amendment representative speaks is closed for the amendment all right the question now before the house is the concurrence of Senate amendment one to house bill 1193 prepare the machine mr. clerk
all right has everyone voted all right let's cast the ballots mr. clerk with 89 yeas
Speaker 46
11:58
zero nay and zero present the the we have concurred with the Senate amendment.
Representative Wardlaw, for what purpose? Representative Wardlaw, for what
purpose? Motion. Let's hear the motion. Mr. Speaker, after voting on the prevailing side in consideration of Alps Bill 1744, I move for reconsideration. How
did you vote? Nay. That is a proper motion. It is debatable. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized to present your motion.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Yesterday I voted no because I was real concerned about the places they were going to be reading these license plates up and down our highway system. And I have a rested assurance from Representative Douglas that he's going to work with myself and others that had the same concern on an amendment in the Senate. So if you would, join me in helping us get this bill to a Senate committee where we can get it amended to fix all the concerns. Thank you. All right.
Representative Wardlaw has spoken for the motion to reconsider. Would anyone like to speak against the motion to reconsider? for the motion to reconsider representative bell you're recognized speak for the motion members representative douglas has
agreed to uh language to amend language in the senate that will address the concerns that i i've expressed and uh bill will be having to come back here for concurrence in the amendment and i'll certainly uh be speaking against it at that time if we don't get it amended appropriately but at this point i'm satisfied that we can go forward based on the
agreement we have. All right, members, Representative Bell has spoken for the motion to reconsider. Would anyone like to speak against the motion? For the motion, Representative Wardlaw has signified that he's closed for the motion to reconsider. Members, now the question before you is the motion to reconsider House Bill 1744. all in favor say aye
all opposed say no the ayes have it motion carries now the question before the house is the passage of house bill 1744 prepare the machine Mr. Clerk has everyone voted
all right let's cast out the ballots mr. clerk with 81 yeas one nay and three present the bill has passed representative Gossage you're recognized at this time
you're recognized at this time for your
Speaker 68
15:45
motion Mr. Speaker, colleagues, I move that we suspend for the duration of the regular session the portion of House Rule 41 that imposes the two-day calendar rule. This proper motion is not debatable. All
in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. All right. The ayes have it. The motion carries.
All right, Mr. Clerk, we're going to pass over the first item on our regular bills calendar. Let's move to the second item, and please
read House Bill 1625. House Bill 1625, Representative Tucker, to provide notice of proceedings in juvenile dependency, and neglect cases to the attorney ad litem and to add new protections to children in custody
with regard to juvenile dependency and neglect cases. Representative Tucker, you're recognized to
present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to thank Dr. Keller for that beautiful prayer this morning. Anytime you all are in Little Rock from across the state, please feel free to come to Trinity Cathedral, just a block from the governor's mansion. So, anyway, I'm here to present House Bill 1625 this morning. It was brought to me by the Administrative Office of the Courts, the Attorneys Ad Litem Program. As you all may be aware, Attorneys Ad Litem are the attorneys in a case that affects the rights of a child.
Of course, the primary consideration in any case that affects the rights of a child is the best interest of the child, but the Attorney Ad Litem is the one who specifically has the role of advocating for the rights and best interests of the child. I'll be glad to report, as I'm sure you're happy to hear, that this is primarily a cleanup bill given the agenda for today. The primary substantive difference is that in cases of dependency neglect, notice has to be provided to the attorney ad litem instead of to the juvenile, and there are several reasons for that. The best couple of reasons are, number one, if the juvenile is notified in a situation
in which they're under the care of the person who might be subjecting them to neglect, then it might inhibit the ability of the child to review the information that they're served with or take the appropriate legal action in response to the document or anything along those lines. Secondly, in these circumstances, many times there are cases of abuse, and it's appropriate for the attorney ad litem to provide information to the juvenile on an age-appropriate basis. All adults are continued to be served under the current law. That part is not amended. It's just notice to the child is through the attorney ad litem. The rest is primarily just
clean-up language, for example. In one provision, we changed the language from an illegitimate juvenile to a juvenile for whom paternity has not been established, which is just more appropriate language in 2015. That's basically it. I'd be glad to take any questions. Seeing none, I'd appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of
the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill? Representative Tucker, would you like to close for your bill? You recognized to do so. Colleagues, as you
vote today I'd just like to remind you
that my children are just sitting right up there so I'd appreciate a good
vote. The question now before the house is the passage of House Bill 1625. Prepare the machine Mr. Clerk. has everyone voted alright let's cast out the ballots Mr. Clerk
87 yeas 0 nay and 0 present the bill has passed Mr. Clerk we're going to pass over the next item on our calendar this time if you would please move to House Bill 1452 please read House
Bill 1452 House Bill 1452 with Representatives Bain and Shepard to authorize the Director of the Department of Environmental Quality to waive licensure requirements for operators of solid waste management facilities and to authorize withdrawal of
Representative Bain, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. House, this bill will allow in limited circumstances waivers to be issued by AEDQ. Back in 2011, we passed a law that basically said anybody that's doing collection need to have a landfill permit. Well, we actually have some, including one in my district. They actually incinerate hazardous materials and they already have hazardous material incineration permits and they take in household waste as a courtesy to the community. But whenever they do it, they actually have to hire a landfill operator to come sit and watch them take it in.
It doesn't really add value to the process at all. And we want the ability to have ADEQ remove that requirement and give them a waiver to basically save time and allow them to schedule it without having to schedule with a third-party landfill operator to sit there and watch. All right, members, you heard
an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill?
For the bill? Representative Bain has signified that he's closed for his bill. The question now before the House is the passage of House Bill 1452. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Everyone voted. All right, let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 89 yeas, zero nay, and zero present, the bill has passed.
Members, before we move on, I want to make note of a special guest that we have with us that I was recently made aware of. With us in the North Gallery from the great state of Kansas, we have with us Senator Greg Smith and his wife, Missy, who are here today as guests of Representative Petty and our governor for the bill signing that will be taking place of the Kelsey Smith Act into law. So let's please welcome them.
All right, Mr. Clerk, at this time, please read House
Bill 1596. House Bill 1596, represented to Charlotte Douglas, to require a school district to provide up to 10 legislative days per school year, per school district. Mr. Clerk, I've been informed
that we're going to pass over this item for today.
Let's please move down to House Bill
1496. House Bill 1496 for Representatives Lampkin and Ferguson. to clarify the effect of Act 1333 of 2013 on disposal fees, funds, and reports regarding approved computer and
electronic equipment recycling programs.
Representative Lampkin, you're recognized at this time
Speaker 81
23:43
to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I guess this is for whom the bell tolls day, isn't it? anyway this 1496 is refers back to the e-waste grants program that established by law as act 1333 of 2012 the recycling grants program which i just said didn't i anyway this bill um is a follow-up to the 2013 law that we passed in 2013 we passed the law and they tried it for
two years the adeq and the solid waste districts and then they wanted to make some changes in it and hopefully improve or make it more amicable to both groups so here's basically what this does it's not a new fee it's a fee for e-waste recycling that they've collected for two years and it's deposited in what they call a trust closing fund and that trust closing fund has a 25 million dollar cap on it and then once they get past that the money is held to the end of the
year i believe and anyway then it's distributed to those solid waste districts and that's what the law is about it exchange it changes the way they distribute that money uh it there is a language cleanup in the first part of it and uh let's see it also it allows the use of e-waste money for the regular recycling program in each district. In other words, that means the money that each district gets, they may use for e-waste recycling or solid waste recycling, however they
need it. It gives them a little flexibility. The language in the bill mirrors Act 1313 of 2013, and this is the main change in the bill. It transfers the full responsibility of administration and oversight of this fund to the solid waste districts and their boards the first two years the oversight of the money uh and the and all this was held with adeq so this takes the money once it's been divided out according to this complicated formula in here it takes the money
and instead of giving it to adeq to pass out uh it goes to the the solid waste districts and they have all of the administrative and full responsibility administration oversight to the solid wave districts and their boards they also because they have full responsibility for it now and full handling of it they also want to assess themselves a 10% administrative cost in the money in other words if they get 50,000 a piece they want to take 10% a piece and put it
10% of their portion and put it in their budget to administer and handle the money and keep the records they do still have to submit regulation 28 recycling activity surveys to ADEQ in other words they still have to submit and this is a report we were talking about part of the report we were talking about yesterday except they do it once they still have to account for the money In other words, it's accountable, but they have responsibility of how it goes out and what kind of grants.
And that's the bill, as I understand it. And I'll take a couple of questions if you don't ask me about the formula because I don't understand it. Yes, sir. Representative Bell. Oops, excuse me. Representative Bell, for what
purpose? Question, Mr. Speaker. You're recognized for your question. Representative Lampkin, first of all, I want to apologize to you for not getting with you earlier. I just first read this bill last night, and my concern is that it takes what is currently a temporary fee and makes it a permanent fee when we're modifying the situation and we don't know exactly what the outcome is going to be.
That's my concern with the bill, and if you could comment on why we're making
Speaker 81
27:52
the fee permanent when we're making the changes, I'd appreciate it. Well, the way I understand it, they tried it in their legislation two years ago to see how it would work with ADEQ collecting it and distributing it, and then the counties spent it, or spent it in grants. It's recycling grant money. and um part of the reason that they agreed to let um the solid waste district take full control of
it now is because of the situation i was talking about yesterday sometimes they were later and getting their money to them and they had um uh what do you call it uh granted gave given these grants and then they didn't have the money wait and go ahead and hand out so ad eq is agreeable to this. I talked with Ryan Benefield, and he's supportive and agreeable to it, because they say their problem is backlogged, so that's why they changed it. They moved it from ADEQ control to let the districts have the control of it.
for your follow-up? My question directly is the permanency of the fee, given the changes in the structure. the the bill makes the makes the fee structure permanent as opposed to being temporary while we're making changes and i i hate to even ask you this on the floor but is it would there be a possibility of agreeing to a senate amendment to keep it um uh open for another trial period until we see how that's resolved or is this uh you know is this are we needing to go forward with it with
Speaker 81
29:29
a permanent fee we need to go forward with it they tell me so that it can be locked in the fee i believe is is a dollar and the reason it wasn't made permanent then is they were trying to decide a dollar or two dollars how much they could raise and the dollar is sufficient for now and if it ever needs to be raised i assume they would have to have new legislation but they found that the dollar would draw in enough to have the grant the pot of grant money and that's what they were concerned about so that's why it wasn't permanent in the first place thank you mr speaker yes sir
Representative Jean, for what purpose? You're recognized for your question. Representative Flampkin, is
pass in its form, the fee will still be around. Is that correct? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. I would really
explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill?
for the bill all right representative Lampkin signified she's closed for the bill the question now before the house is the passage of House bill 1496 prepare the machine mr. clerk
All right, has everyone voted? Everyone voted. All right, let's cast it to ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 46 yeas, 28 nays, and two present, the bill has failed to pass. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1706.
House Bill 1706 by Representative Ballinger concerned the investigation and prosecution of domestic violence offenses when the victim is not available to testify. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to present
your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This bill is
designed to fix a really big problem. Well, I said to help fix a really big problem. This is definitely not a fix, but it may be something that we can do
to kind of create some encouragement so that a problem could be addressed. Essentially, I had a young lady who was killed back in my district in a domestic violence situation. And what happens oftentimes is that in the investigation of a domestic violence incident, those of you who deal with criminal law know that you always rely on a victim, not always, but oftentimes you rely on a victim to be the witness and for a lot of the testimony to get the prosecution.
However, in a domestic violence situation, oftentimes the witness will not testify. For whatever reason, she may be back with the perpetrator. She may be fearful of the perpetrator, but she won't testify in the situation with domestic violence. So what this bill does is direct the individuals conducting the investigation to do so with the assumption that the that the witness won't be there to testify you hope that they will but to collect the data collect the information get the written statements and everything so that that they will uh hopefully be able to carry out the prosecution um even without a testimony from
the witness and i'd be happy to answer any questions if not i appreciate
a good vote all right members you've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like speak against the bill for the bill. Representative Ballinger signified that he's closed for his bill. The question now before the House is the passage of House Bill 1706. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Everyone voted. All right, let's cast it to ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 85 yeas, one nay, and one present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk,
please read House Bill 1707. House Bill 1707 by Representative Ballinger concerning law enforcement response and reporting during the investigation of an act of domestic violence and to be referred to as Laura's Law.
representative ballinger you're recognized to present your
bill thank you mr speaker okay this this bill also originates from the same incident the young lady's name was laura and what this is this is a little more substantial um a bill i think because what it actually does is require the investigator the initial contact to go through a series of questions while they're doing their interview process these questions are designed to to figure out whether or not or the likelihood of the individual being further violent to the point where that there's real
potential for lethality this is what's called a lethality assessment several other states have passed the same thing the questions in here create indicators because if you go out statistically you look at it depending on these answers to these questions will um can be indicators of whether or not the person later on down the road will give violence to the point where they may be killed or seriously injured so if you uh with that i would appreciate a good vote and if you have any question. One thing I want to point out is my seatmate back there explained to me that I kept
saying he or she. In this case, you know, it could be a guy or a girl that's a perpetrator, although oftentimes, more often than not, it is a man. But anyway, I would
appreciate a good vote. Representative Ballinger explained the bill and left the will. Anybody want to speak against the bill? For the bill? Rep. Whitaker, you're recognized, sir.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Most of you probably don't know, my very first job out of law school was on a Justice Department grant, trying to get some of the antiquated methods for dealing with domestic violence put into our past and bringing new approaches, integrated approaches to this problem. I want to laud Representative Ballinger for bringing this. Lethality assessments are one of the most important new crime-fighting tools we have
in the battle against domestic violence, and I'd ask for a good vote.
Thank you. Representative Whitaker has spoken for the bill. Anybody speak against? for the bill Representative Ballard are you closed question for the house passage of the bill House Bill 1707 fare the machine Mr. Clerk all voted
Clerk with 92 yeas zero nays zero present House Bill 1707 is passed Mr. Clerk read House Bill
1530 House Bill 1530 by Representative David Meeks
to prevent advertising for and providing activities involving or leading to trafficking of persons and to prohibit human trafficking tourism Representative
Speaker 114
38:05
Mr. Speaker Two years ago, Arkansas, in bipartisan support, was able to pass bills in relation to human trafficking.
We were able to strengthen our laws and to bring awareness to this horrendous crime that we face. We knew that two years ago we weren't going to be able to address every single thing and that we were going to have to come back and continue to strengthen our laws. We also know, too, with human trafficking is that they're always trying to find loopholes in the law. They're always trying to do new things in order to keep doing what they're doing.
And the reason for that is mainly because of money, and it's unfortunate. Human trafficking is one of the top three illegal activities as far as money behind weapons and drug. And, of course, you find a lot of times that with human trafficking, you'll also have drug trafficking as well so we've been continuing to work on and this is probably the first of maybe two or three more bills that you'll see this session and this deals with something called sex tourism and you wouldn't wouldn't think that this would be an issue and it
really hasn't been here in Arkansas but we are starting to see it pop up in different places where they might sell a package internationally to Cambodia is mainly where we're seeing it but we're also starting to see it where somebody will get a package to go to a city such as Dallas, New York City, and through subtle language, a travel agency, and again, I don't think it's happening with any reputable travel agency, but there are, again, there are some things that are happening where they might sell you a package to a known district where
prostitution or human trafficking is involved, and so what this does is this law prohibits that and of course it carries the penalties along with it i'll be happy to take any questions seeing none i would appreciate a good vote representative meeks
has explained the bill anyone would like to speak against the bill for the bill Representative Meeks, are you closed? Representative Meeks indicates he is closed.
Question for the House is the passage of House Bill 1530. I'm not used to this double talk in my ear. my ear. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All voted. All voted. Cast up the machine, Mr.
clerk with 92 yeas zero nays and zero presence house bill 1530 is adopted mr. clerk read house bill 1678 house
bill 1678 for representative shepherd concerning the penalty for driving on a a suspended or revoked driver's license when the suspension or revocation is the result
of the person driving while intoxicating. Representative Shepard, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, House Bill 1678 simply changes the possible penalty with regard to imprisonment for driving on a suspended license when the suspension is based on a DWI, it changes it from being 10 days to the possibility of 10 to 90 days.
This bill was brought to me by some of the district judges who felt that the 10-day penalty was not a sufficient deterrent in some cases to persuade people to stay off the road when their license has been suspended. Many times these terms, such as a 10-day suspension, many times is handled by way of electronic monitoring. Again, it does not mandate a 90-day sentence, it just simply gives a possibility, a range for the judge to consider.
Representative Hampton, for what purpose? Question, please. You're recognized, sir. Representative Shepard, last week, or the first this week, we passed a bill out of here that dealt with judges ability and dwi situations and do you remember that particular bill and can you tell me how that one and this one either complement or
compete against each other honestly don't remember this bill it only applies when an individual has been convicted
or pled to dwr and you may i guess are you talking about representative rights bill I believe it was, if you want to take credit for it. Representative Wright's bill has to do with the prosecution of a DWI charge, which currently, if there's a charge, currently they have to prosecute, they have to take it to trial. And so his bill concerns the prosecution of the DWI. This bill only deals with post-conviction.
At the point someone is convicted or pleads to a DWI, their license is suspended for a period of time. On occasion, some individuals decide that they're going to continue to drive even with a suspended license. Currently, if they drive on a suspended license, the penalty is 10 days in jail and a fine of not more than $1,000. Some of the judges have asked that we simply allow them a range so that they, if they feel it's necessary they can impose a stiffer or lengthier term of imprisonment because in some
instances they feel that individuals don't take these possible punishments seriously and continue to drive even though their license has been suspended so this bill deals with after the conviction representative rights bill deals with whether it's prosecuted in the first place all right follow-up man one recognize for a follow-up thank you so does
this bill is going to speak this bill is going to address the prison time not additional suspended fees being added on top or does it do
both this bill deals with jail time for not for the DWI but for driving on a suspended
license and it only that this bill applies to the omnibus DWI act that sub chapter so this bill only applies to a suspended license it only applies in the instance where the license was suspended because of a DWI. Very good. Thank
I'm trying to figure out how to ask this to clarify. Does this only apply during the period that the license was suspended pursuant to the DWI, or does it extend beyond that? And I'll tell you where this comes up, as you probably know. People don't have the $100 it takes to get their license reinstated at the end of that term, and so their license remains suspended.
My understanding, this current statute states, a person who's privileged to operate a motor vehicle has been suspended or revoked under a provision of this act, we've changed it to say this subchapter, that's just cleanup language. The subchapter is the omnibus DWI Act. And so my understanding would be if they have not gone back to the revenue office and received their license, even though they may be out of the period of suspension,
my understanding is that this is still, if they were driving on the suspended license, It's my understanding that would still
apply. Thank you. Representative Shepard has explained the bill. Anybody would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Question before the House is the passage of House Bill 1678. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
all voted all voted cast up the machine mr. clerk with 91 yeas zero nays zero presents house bill 1678 is adopted Mr. Clerk, read House Bill 1372
House Bill 1372, Representative David Meeks Concerning the carrying of a concealed handgun By a concealed handgun licensee On the property of a private school Representative Meeks, you're recognized thank you mr speaker this is the bill we had to
Speaker 114
48:16
send back a couple of times the committee to make sure we got the wording right this bill all it does is a clarification of the law right now
a private religious school has the right to make the determination on whether or not they want administrators or staff or whoever to be able to concealed carry and again this is about protection i have a private christian school that uh they're not affiliated with a church at all and so they were not sure whether they would be able to legally do that so again what this bill does is it allows a private school to determine whether or not they want to or not and they also can determine who within that school can actually carry so simple bill and i'll be glad to take any
questions representative johnson for what purpose question you're recognized sir just to understand this school still gets
to make its decision each school on its own yeah the governing board of that particular school gets to make the decision
Speaker 114
49:13
not only if they're going to do it or not but also who within the school will be able to do it and then they can put any requirement that they want to on it uh you know as far as not only concealed carry but if they want to put more requirements like active shooter training or anything else than they have that ability to do
so thank you okay seeing nothing else i appreciate a
good vote representative meeks has explained the bill would anybody like to speak against the bill for the bill the question before the house is passage of house bill 1372 prepare the machine mr clerk all voted
all voted cast up the machine mr. clerk with 80 yeas 2 nays and 0 present house bill 1372 has been adopted Mr. Clerk, read House Bill 1525.
House Bill 1525, Representative Gossage to amend provisions of the Arkansas Code concerning public school academic facilities. Representative Gossage,
you are recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. colleagues this is a
Speaker 68
50:53
bill that was brought to me by the facilities division just clean up bill some cleanup language in there if anybody has any questions I'll be glad to answer them Representative Goss has
explained the bill is there anyone like to speak
against the bill for the bill Representative Goss is you closed he is closed for the bill question for the house is passage of house bill 1525 prepare the machine Mr. Clerk all voted
all voted cast up the machine Mr. Clerk With 90 yays, 0 nays, and 0 presents, House Bill 1525 is adopted. Mr. Clerk, read House Bill
1526. House Bill 1526, Representative Gossage to amend provisions of the Arkansas Code concerning school improvement plans.
Speaker 68
52:20
Representative Gossage, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, once again, this is a bill that was brought to me by the Department of Education. Some just minor tweaks. It does away with duplication of producing plans for categorical funds. Currently, you have to do it both in ACCEP and in the district budget. It does a couple of other minor things, but it's basically another cleanup bill. I'll take any questions.
Representative Gossage has explained the bill. Would there anybody like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Question for the House is adoption of House Bill 1526. Prepare the machine Mr. Clerk.
out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. 91 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present. The bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please
read House Bill 1527. House Bill 1527 by Representative Gossage to provide flexibility to school districts in scheduling art, music, and physical education.
Speaker 68
53:57
Representative Gossage, you're recognized to present the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, this is my bill. Under current Arkansas law, art and music were in one section. We had to go at least 40 minutes. PE was in another section. Had to go 60 minutes. Those of us who work in the school, those are typically buddy courses. They're offered at the same time. It may be when the third grade teachers all, you know, one class will go to art, one will go to music, one will go to PE.
That's when they do their planning time. These were never put together. What my bill does is it sets that as a flexible schedule. Anything between 40 and 60 minutes will meet the requirements of the law now. No one will have to change their schedule. The only question I've had asked, and I just want to clarify this, This does not limit anybody to just 60 minutes of PE. If you'll look on page two, I think it is toward the bottom, it actually says there's 90 more minutes required during the week that students have to do anyway, which can be another PE class.
So this will in no way impact any students. Again, it just allows some flexibility for local decision making. Representative Collins,
for what purpose? Question. Recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Gossage, did you run three bills in a row today as part of our ongoing celebration of the House three-peat over the Senate in basketball?
Speaker 68
55:34
Yes, Representative Collins. I don't know if you're the only one that picked up on that, but that is in honor
Speaker 157
55:44
of three years in a row winning. That's correct. Representative Branscombe,
concept of flexibility, and I don't have a problem with that. But could it be assumed sometime that the administrator or superintendent, when they're doing these classes and scheduling, that, you know, these kids,
well, we could take it down, we could take the PE down from 60 to 40 or whatever, since they have flexibility so we can study for the test more. I mean, I don't think we need to have less PE. Probably we need to have more if it's possible. And I'm just afraid that some administrators may use this as an excuse to have less
Speaker 68
56:24
PE. They're going to have between 40 and 60 minutes, and they're also going to have an additional 90 minutes during that week. So that is, I don't, you do exercise, right? Okay. I think you're going to be okay.
there's going to be lots of PE going on. I don't think we have a lack of PE and physical activity currently. That's a long debate I would love to have with you sometime. Thank you, and I
appreciate a good vote. Very well. Representative Gossage has presented his bill. Is there anyone that wishes to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Gossage, are you closed for your bill? All right, very well. Question for the House is passage of House Bill 1527.
Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Everyone voted. cast up the ballots mr. clerk with 74 yeas four nays five presents uh house bill 1527 is passed
we're skipping House Bill 1539, Representative De La Rosa to provide for petition for early admission to kindergarten under certain circumstances and to declare an emergency.
Representative De La Rosa, you're recognized. you, Mr. Speaker. Members, what this bill will do is allow parents to petition the school to accept a child whose fifth birthday falls up to one month after the cutoff date, if there is space available in the school. And I can go into the weeds on that, but I've had no issue on that
from the schools at all whatsoever. Currently, no exception is made today. We have the cutoff date at August 1st. And if your child is born at 1159 on July the 30th, they're in. And if they're born at 1201 on August 1st, they're out. We do currently make exceptions right now for out of state and international, but we make absolutely no exception for in-state. The folks that are here paying the taxes and have lived here the whole time, we make no exception for them right now.
A couple of the details. The parents have to make the request by June the 1st. The decision is made solely upon whether or not there's space. There's no other determination made, so it's absolutely fair, first-come, first-served basis, and the superintendent has up to seven days after the start of school to notify the parents whether they have been accepted or not so that the schools have time to allow for inter-school transfers that may occur. The point is to try to keep the school from having to incur the cost of adding an additional class
because they've exceeded maximum class size. This is all about flexibility and control for parents while trying to put as little burden on the schools as possible. And I will take any questions that anybody may have. Representative Bounder, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized. And I'm
sorry, this may be written in the bill, but
I'm not sure from what what you said does the school itself have discretion on how I mean are we opening it up so the school can choose to accept them or is this something that the school
has no choice but just the school has no choice okay they they accept on a first come first serve basis based
Speaker 180
1:00:45
purely upon space availability representative hammer what purpose question please
you recognize represent I was wondering if there's any allowances in the bill for school to make a determination is whether the child is mature enough to be placed with other children and what kind of discretion
there may be to allow that into the consideration factor I know children mature at different ages and I'm just wondering what allowances were made in the bill for that consideration there were no
allowances made and that's because the schools didn't want to make that determination. They thought it would be a burden on them in terms of the time it would take, the evaluation they would have to come up with. So they wanted it so that the parents made that determination. If the parents want the child to go to school and their birthday falls in there
and they believe their child is ready, then they enact and they petition the school for it. So it's up to the parents completely.
Follow-up, Mr. Speaker. Great. Absolutely. Thank you. So if as if the hard, if if the criteria that's defined in the bill is met, then the school has no option except for that. The parents want it meets the criteria, the bill and the child and the school have to take the child on the basis that there is available room for them. Is that is that correct? Yes, sir. Okay, thank you.
Speaker 114
1:02:12
Representative Meeks, for what purpose? You're recognized. So my understanding is if they have 100 spaces for kindergarten, that school has to go all the way up to 100. But is there any allowance to stay below the cap? Because you could have, you know, three weeks or four weeks in, a student move in and then all of a sudden, by the time you're two months into the school, instead of being at 100 capacity, they're now at 105, which could create issues. any provision to keep some wiggle room
in there? Yes, sir. It's set at 90% of capacity. Availability
is determined at 90% of capacity, and right now the maximum capacity for a kindergarten class is 20 students, so if there are 17 or less, that's considered available. If there are 18, 19, or 20, the class is considered full for the purposes of this, and that was specifically to give that wiggle I'm wondering
does this tie in with other laws in the state if that child is accepted, will that school get the per diem for that child or because of the any other laws or criteria in the law that school would have to take that child but wouldn't be able to get the money that goes with that.
that child because of any other conflicts with state law. When
the child is accepted, the funding comes with it. They're they're enrolled in school just like like
any other child. OK, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Beck, for what
purpose? Question. Recognized. And I apologize if I miss this, but what happens when the child goes in the first grade now Is this going to affect that transition? Are we going to create where a child is going to preschool
and now they'll get caught up and held back in the year when they get to the first grade type of? Because they're going early in the
Speaker 189
1:04:17
preschool is my point? Or will they just be held in preschool an additional year? I'm having a hard time hearing the question. Could you repeat it? No. Okay. Okay, if
the child starts kindergarten early, right, what happens when they get ready to go to school? Are they just going to stay in kindergarten an additional year, or would those align up with the school year, too?
rate. So they would be starting. They would still be four years old for a very short period of time when they start, but they would progress through the grades at the same rate that every other child does. There wouldn't be any delay
question. Yes. So when they got to the first grade, there wouldn't be any restrictions for them to go ahead and just go straight into the first grade?
They wouldn't have to help? No, sir. Thank you. They would progress
at the same rate. I'd appreciate a good vote. anyone wish to speak for or against the bill representative de la rosa you wish to close for your bill you closed representative de la rosa is closed for her beer consideration for the house is house bill 1539 mr. clerk prepare the machine
With 59 yeas, 14 nays, one present, House Bill 1539 is passed. We'll now vote on the emergency clause for this bill. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine.
With 64 yea, 13 nay, 1 present, the emergency clause fails. Mr. Clerk, read House
Bill 1408. House Bill 1408 by Representative Cozart to modify the personnel policy requirements for school districts.
Representative Cozart, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, this is a little bit of cleanup language on personnel policies for staff of a school. And what this change is, this is necessary to bring the school district policies into place when there are some changes in the legislative process that we make rules or regulations or there's a federal rule or regulation that comes down and it's during before contracts or during the time of that.
So what this does, this allows this to be placed in and changed and is adopted by the school boards. And then, but no later than the 30th of June is effective date on these changes. But anyway, it's different policies. This does affect classified and certified. The added language specifies that the change is necessary under conditions listed. It also sets a timeline for those changes. And that's what I tried to do. I'd be glad to answer questions if I could.
I see no questions. Thank you. Does anyone wish to speak for or against House Bill 1408? Seeing none, Representative Kozart, do you wish to close? Representative Kozart is closed. Question for the House is passage of House Bill 1408. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine.
Has everyone voted? First of the clerk, cast up the ballot. With 87 yeas, 0 nays, 0 present, House Bill 1408 is passed. Clerk, read House Bill 1836.
House Bill 1836 for Representative Cozart to amend the Arkansas Governor's Scholars Program. Representative Cozart, you're recognized. Colleagues, this is a bill to
do exactly what it says, is to amend the Governor's Scholars Program. Basically, there's always been a Governor's Distinguished Scholarship and a Governor's Scholarship. And what this does is it's going to combine both of them, and it will be the Governor's Scholarship.
program and um it will still have the 375 scholarships has always been available same amount of money what this does it will it just basically states that after the first 300 if all of this all of the uh counties are not represented represented in this deal that the uh every county has to be represented. So there will be somebody if they're not a 32 to qualify, it will go
down to the next one in that county. So if if your county is not caught in the 32 a CT, it could go for a lesser amount. I don't know what those could vary. So but there will be 375 all 75 counties will have to be represented. Glad to take any questions. Representative Collins,
Speaker. So Representative Cozart, if in your county there were three children with perfect scores and all of them had been given to a certain place, but in my county I had the highest score
and I got a two, and that was the highest score in my county, your perfect score, one of your perfect score kids would not get their scholarship so I could get one?
Do I understand that correctly? That is correctly. there will be at least
Speaker 211
1:11:55
one from every county representative drown for what purpose question recognized um this does not this does include homeschoolers and private schoolers correct
yes it is all all even homeschool yes appreciate a good vote
anyone wish to speak for or against this bill Seeing none, Representative Cozart, are you closed for your bill? Cozart is closed for his bill. For consideration of the House, House Bill 1836, Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine. Has everyone voted?
is everyone voting mr. clerk cast up the ballot 57 yeas 19 nays 2 presidents house bill 1836 passes mr. clerk read
a house bill 1737 House Bill 1737 by Representative Branscombe, providing that administrative rules promulgated
by state agencies shall not become effective until reviewed and approved by a legislative committee. Representative Branscombe, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Speaker. This is the enabling legislation for Amendment 1 that was passed by the voters back in November. It's a pretty straightforward bill. There is some stuff in it, in case you were wondering. And it's a good bill that we've got to pass because of Amendment 1. So with that, Mr. Speaker.
Representative Meeks, what purpose? Question, please, about the stuff. I think he's still in the well-purposed. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The question I have is, when a rule of regulation comes before the body for review, does this law say
that that has to go before the rules and regs committee, or does it say that we're going to send it to the committee that is germane to that topic? So if it's something with the Agri Department, is it going to go to Agri, or is it going to go to rules and regs? Can you kind of go into that a little bit for us?
So it will go before the rules and regs, then if that's passed out, then it will come before the council where everybody has a chance to vote on it. And let me say that I've spent more time on this building bill than I have done since I've been down here. It is my intention with working with Senator Samples, who's co-chair with me with the legislative council, that it is not our intent, and I don't believe it was the people's intent when Amendment 1 was passed, to micromanage any agency. I mean, those of your second and third termers know that kind of taken on infamous crime,
and that's kind of what I anticipate this to be. You know, we don't care whether the highway department has what color paint they use to stripe the roads. And I don't care on the Game and Fish a little regulation. but if the game of fish wanted to close down a certain area for hog hunting or not allow dogs to run per se then that is kind of big and i think the legislators who we get all the griping
about anyway when these agencies do something they should come before us and explain to us why they're doing it and what they're doing it and if they're right which most of the time they are then it'll pass out but because of amendment one and it did pass then that kind of gives us a little skin in the game to approve a lot of these rules that Senator Samuel's eyes both agreed that are big rules. None of the Mickey Mouse stuff that none of us want that have time to mess with anyway. Representative Tucker, what purpose? Question. You're recognized. Representative
Branson, apologies for not getting to you before. I'm just curious about the process. Is it just an up or down vote from ALC or is there any appeals process for an adverse decision or just
kind of How does that work? Yes. I'd say it would be an up and down vote, and there is an appeal process. You know, this is also kind of, you know, we're going to learn this as we go because it is new, and it is new enabling legislation, and every one of you guys are going to have a say in it, especially if any agency has anything that you think is big,
then we'll bring it here, and we'll hear it out.
Follow Mr. Speaker. Can you clarify what the appeals process would be, Representative Branscombe? Do what now? Can you clarify what the appeals process would be? I guess you'll bring it before the chairs
and say, guys, we need to look at this again, and then we'll say probably we'll do it. Representative Hickerson, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Branscombe, I know we touched on this when this first came up, but it was my understanding that there was going to be an amendment or some changes as regards to the wording for Arkansas Game and Fish and Arkansas State Highway Commission, which are constitutionally independent agencies. Is that going to be done in the Senate now? No, I have talked to
the highway this morning, highway department this morning, told me that when they give me those regulations, the amendments that they wanted, I took them to Ms. Marty, Garrity, and she worked with it, and then they went to her, and she explained to them, and now they are good with it.
So they actually, they are good with the bill.
Follow up, Mr. Speaker. uh so so senator samples is not going to be
Speaker 233
1:18:05
amending the bill in the senate uh no no not that i know yeah right representative hammer go ahead question mr speaker which
you look mighty fine sitting up there by the way ask as many as you want mr hammer
some of us have bills that have been held up in committee or have been put on pause because we're waiting on this piece of legislation i think to go through because it was going to be covered by this so would you elaborate what's going to happen if we don't vote this bill through as far how it's going to impact what the citizens voted on amendment one and for those of us that have some bills that are kind of just in the holding pattern based on what happens here today this bill's got to go through I'm sorry
this bill has to go through I mean it is the enabling legislation for the constitutional amendment now if it were to fail which I don't think it will but if it were then and you're talking about bills that you've talked about and you know you and I have talked well this is going to be covered under this I don't know probably if this doesn't go through then you would
need to proceed on with your bill Brief follow up, please. Yes. OK, so my last my last question wants to really drill down on is what happens if this bill does not pass right now as far as how it's directly going to impact Amendment one?
Will we are we put in a no no win situation? Because if we don't vote this through, we have violated Amendment one or what's the challenge that's going to happen if we don't pass this out of here today? I will refer to my legal counsel. Any
Speaker 219
1:19:52
of you boys want to? I don't know. That's a good question. Thank you, Mr.
Speaker. Thank you, Representative Branscombe. Does anyone wish to speak for or against the bill?
Anyone against Representative Link, what purpose? Speak for the bill. You're recognized. members i've been fortunate since
Speaker 244
1:20:28
i in my first term i got put onto the rules and regs subcommittee of legislative council and then this last time i've got to chair the committee and was very glad to see the ballot initiative one go through or it's not amendment one but it's ballot initiative
one which i think has become what amendment 95 or 96 or whatever it is to our constitution and and it is it is up until i think 04 2004 2005 the body this body during the interim had a say over rules and regulations agencies would bring the rules to the rules committee or subcommittee of legislative council and they present that and then we'd be able to say yes we approve of this no we don't approve of this and then there was uh where there's a lawsuit brought or whatever
there's a question brought before the courts and the courts said that during the interim this body the legislature does not have a say we can only make rules and laws but we can only approve rules when we're actually in session so during the interim we had no authority and so as a result all we could do is say yes we like your rule or no we don't like your rule it didn't matter i mean you know a great example maybe a poor example but a great example is this this last interim we had i think 22 rules implemented by abc that we said we don't like
and they did it anyway because we had no authority during the interim whatsoever and that's why the voters gave us this they clarified it with this constitutional amendment about initiative one whatever the amendment numbers could become and they've clarified that yes you do have authority during the interim. And so Representative Branskin's bill, he's worked with Marty Garrity on, and she's worked with me on summit too, is trying to clarify how we do that. And of course the question is, do we include game and fish in the highway department or not? And that's probably
the biggest, I wouldn't call it sticking point, but that's one of the biggest concerns of us. And I guess there's a bill coming from the Senate that does not include them, and then our bill does and probably we'll meet somewhere in the middle and figure out how much of them that we do include but in here there's emergency provisions so those of you particularly in the agri this is particularly important that sometimes a situation will come up where we find that whatever new insect of the world is attacking your crops and the agriculture community does not have time to
come before our body and get approval to use a new pesticide and implement a new rule, this does have in it the emergency provisions so that they can take immediate action and fix the problem and then come before us and say, here's what we did, we hope it's okay. And so anyway, this is, I've looked through it, Rep. Sam Branscom has put more work into this and I've probably seen him do anything in his life. And you're welcome.
and it is good language to start with i think i think that as we go forward and progress we may find a few things we want to tweak for the next session but i think it's good language going forward and i think we can feel comfortable passing this out and knowing that we can use our authority as was given to us by the voters and and make sure that our agencies are following the intent of the laws that we write remember most of these rules come from laws we write we'll write a law that says we want you to implement a rule that does x and then we can make
sure that they're following our intent that we thought of when we wrote those laws so i think it's a good bill
and i hope everybody will vote for it thank y'all representative link has spoken for the bill does anyone wish to speak against the bill any other one anyone else for the bill Representative Bransom do you wish to close Representative Bransom indicates he is closed for the bill Consideration before the house Is house bill 1737
Mr. Clerk prepare the machine Everyone voted Mr. Clerk cast up the ballot With 89 yeas, 0 nays, 0 present, House Bill 1737 passes. Mr. Clerk, pass over House Bill 1549, House Bill 1523, and please read House Bill 1719.
House Bill 1719, Representatives Petty and Link, to allow the award of flags upon the death of an emergency medical services licensee. Representative Petty, you're recognized. Present your
bill. greetings and salutations colleagues this bill enables the department of health to award a flag
to the widow or a family of an emergency medical technician or a paramedic if they are killed in the line of duty in the state of arkansas so besides giving a flag there's no fiscal impact on the state and i would appreciate a good vote hearing representative petty's
presentation does anyone wish to speak for or against the bill seeing none representative petty wish to close representative petty indicates she is closed for a bill bill before the house is house bill 1719
Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine. Everyone voted. Everyone voted. Mr. Clerk, cast up the ballot. With a vote of 88 yea, 0 nay, 0 present, House Bill 17, 19 passes. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1723.
House Bill 1723, we're Representative Scott and all to amend Arkansas law concerning the licensure, certification, and permitting of active duty service members returning military veterans and spouses and to declare an emergency. representative scott you're recognized present house
you colleagues let me begin with an apology deanne vaught
representative deanne vaught had asked that her name be put on this bill and i inadvertently overlooked it so i apologize to her for that veterans returning from active duty identify finding a job as their greatest challenge to transitioning to civilian life nearly 35 percent of working military spouses require a license or certification for their chosen profession but are more likely to have moved across state lines
in the last year we lose many service men and their spouses annually to other states In addition, we lose the children of these dedicated families who would attend good Arkansas schools. Bright, smart children along with their families are leaving Arkansas. House Bill 1723 will keep our servicemen and their families home here in Arkansas. Let's give our servicemen and women along with their spouses the welcome home they deserve.
Giving consideration of military training and experience as a substitute for state-issued credentials is the right thing to do. Our veterans can return home, get to work, and build a future for themselves and their families. The best part of this bill, however, will be to send a very important message to our service people. We want you to come home, to work in Arkansas, and stay in Arkansas. Thank you all for a very good vote. you've
heard representative scott's presentation of the bill does anyone
wish to speak for or against the bill seeing none representative scott do you wish to close all right representative scott is closed for a bill consideration the house is house bill 1723 mr. clerk prepare the machine You're voting on the bill and the emergency clause. Everyone voted.
Mr. Clerk, cast up the ballot. With a total of 91 yeas, 0 nays, 0 present, House Bill 1723 passes and the emergency clause. Mr. Clerk, read House Bill 1480. House Bill
1480, by Representative Blake, to amend the law concerning the preference of municipal bidding. Representative Blake, you're recognized.
Present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This is a bill that was brought to me by the Muni League. It's not a mandate. It's a very permissive bill. It actually mirrors state statute, state procurement law. And what it does is it allows the cities the ability to give a preference to local companies. And local companies is strictly defined in the bill as a company that has at least one staffed office in the city
and has paid taxes to the county that the city resides in for the previous two years. So it puts a cap on the preference of 5%. And like I said, it's just allowing those cities the flexibility to do business with local companies. And I appreciate a good vote. Representative
Blake has left the well. Does anyone wish to speak for or against the bill?
Seeing none, Representative Blake, do you wish to close? Representative Blake indicates he is closed for Bill. For consideration by the House is House Bill 1480. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine. has everyone voted
clerk cast up the ballot with 78 yeas 2 nays, 0 present House Bill 1480 is passed Mr. Clerk, read House Bill 1502 House
Bill 1502, Representative Fielding, to amend the law concerning county cost of living adjustments. Representative Fielding,
you're recognized, I present your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, this is a JP bill. All of us, the board majority of us came out of the Quorum Court. 740 JP's out there looking at you right now this association counters bill was Arkansas a quorum court association up from its executive board as you know every other year the legislation we said the maximum minimum pro dem for county officials in 2009 I think what is done we didn't clarify in the bill
just at a piece as district officers. So the AGM opinion that I requested from them, it said that because of the language we didn't classify them, then they did not fall under the 3% per dem that is set every other year that we said. So, and this is a local control. This only set the 3% on the maximum. This bill will not mandate the Quorum Court to raise the per dem. This bill will not raise the minimum per diem rate at all, only applied to the maximum rate of the per diem based on county population.
Appreciate a good vote. And your JPs do too.
Prior to Representative Fielding's presentation bill, does anyone wish to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Fielding, do you wish to close? representative fielding indicates he is closed for the bill question for the house is consideration of house bill 1502 mr. clerk prepare the machine
everyone voted is everyone voting mr. clerk cast up the ballot with 82 yeas 2 nays 0 present the bill is passed mr. clerk we're going to pass over
House Bill 1710 Mr. Clerk please read House Bill 1388 House Bill
1388 we're representing Ward Law to limit the fee levied on cattle for the funding of brucellosis control and eradication program.
You're recognized, Mr. Thank you, Mr. Rieger. You know, members, all this legislation we've done that we've failed over fees, I want to tell y'all, I brought you one. you can rest assured that we're capping a current fee so that they can never raise it and that's all this bill does it does allow emergency clause in place something happens in our cattle industry where they have an emergency and need more money they have to come to us first they cannot raise a fee beforehand they have to come to us first and they only get to do it for one year so I appreciate a good vote
representative Warlaw has presented his bill anyone wish to speak for or against Bill. Seeing none, Representative Ward-Law, are you closed for your bill? Representative Ward-Law is closed for the bill. Consideration of the House, House Bill 1388. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine. Mr. Clerk, cast up the ballot.
With 87 yeas, 0 nays, 0 present, bill passes. Mr. Clerk, read House Bill 1825.
house bill 1825 representative davis to amend the arkansas arc to amend the arkansas amendment 82 implementation act representative davis you recognize
thank you mr speaker members this bill comes from the uh from adc and it's it looks a lot like just some technical corrections because what we're doing is changing a few words to make the enabling legislation behind Amendment 82 more closely match what Amendment 82 actually says. Does anybody have any questions? All right, appreciate a good
wish to speak for or against the bill?
Seeing none, Representative Davis, are you closed for your bill? Representative Davis indicates he's closed for bill. Consideration by the House is House Bill 1825. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine. Everyone voted. Everyone voted. Mr. Clerk, cast up the ballot.
With 85 yeas, 0 nays, 0 presents, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House
Bill 1960. House Bill 1960 by Representative Ratliff to regulate the branding and marking of livestock and to allow Arkansas Livestock and Poultry Commission to contract with a private entity to administer the requirements for branding and marking livestock.
Representative Ratliff, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This little bill here, what it does is it allows livestock and poultry to transfer this over to what we were planning on doing to the Arkansas Cattlemen's Association, and We found a couple of things in here since we passed it out of the AG that we want to amend. So we're gonna try to fix that in the Senate. If you got any questions, please, please ask them.
You've heard Representative Ratliff's presentations. Anyone wish to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Ratliff, you wish to close for your bill? Representative Ratliff indicates he's closed for the bill. For consideration by the House, this is House Bill 1960. Mr. Clerk, please prepare the machine. As everyone voted.
Mr. Clerk, cast up the ballot. With 86 yay, 0 nay, 0 present, House Bill 1960 is passed. Representative Bell moves that we place House Bill 1963 on second reading for the purpose of amendment. Without objection read amendment number one Mr. Clerk. Amendment number one to House Bill 1963.
Representative Bell you recognize to present your amendment. Representative Eubanks couldn't be with us today, and this is his amendment to his bill, asked me to present it for you today. The bill adds in a protection for people to be able to sue. This is an arbitration bill, for those of you that aren't familiar with it, and it just ensures that people retain the right to sue in court in addition to the arbitration process. With that, I'd appreciate a good vote.
You've heard Representative Bell's motion. Does anyone wish to speak for or against the motion? Representative, are you closed? Well, consideration of the House is amendment number one to House Bill 1963. All those in favor signify by saying aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations. Your amendment passes. Mayor's Clerk, read House Bill 1621.
House Bill 1621 by Representative Wallace to amend the requirements of issuance of a special license plate for a disabled veteran. Representative Wallace, you're
recognized. you mr. speaker this is a bill that we need to clean up the language it is specifically not a new license plate bill but it is a bill which will help a lot of our disabled veterans there's three clauses three sentences in this
bill the first one says that if you're a disabled veteran with a rating of 30 percent or more you're allowed to have a disabled veteran license plate and that's a license plate that has the DV we see it in all the counties the third category third sentence says you need to have a car to put the license plate on which makes a lot of sense the second sentence is a rub it currently says in
order for a disabled veteran to get this license plate he must be a member a lifetime member of the disabled veterans association and I believe that was a mistake in the language that was put in inadvertently but that would cost the veterans about two hundred dollars to have a lifetime membership to a private organization and my bill excludes that and
does anyone wish to speak for or against the bill?
Seeing none, Representative Wallace, do you wish to close for your bill? Wallace indicates he is closed. For consideration of the House, is House Bill 1621. Mr. Clerk, please prepare the machine. has everyone voted has everyone voted Mr. Clerk cast up the ballot with 87 yeas, 0 nays, 0 presents
the bill is passed Mr. Clerk please read House
Bill 1722 House Bill 1722, to prohibit the use of e-cigarettes on campus of state-supported institutions of higher education. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
This bill just brings e-cigarettes under the same rules on campuses that regular cigarettes and higher ed and the two years both supported the bill. I appreciate a good vote. Having heard an
explanation of the bill, does anyone wish to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none representing Ferguson, are you closed for your bill? Ferguson indicates she's closed for her bill. For consideration for the House is House Bill 1722. Mr. Clerk,
prepare the machine. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Mr. Clerk, cast off the ballot With 58 yea, 18 nay, and 3 present, the bill is passed Mr. Clerk, read House Bill 1687
House Bill 1687 will represent to Ballinger to amend the law concerning ballot questions and to add clarity
to the format of a ballot question. Representative
Boundry, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This bill is in response to a circuit court case in Washington County where there was some question in regards to what the ballot title is supposed to actually read.
What this will say is just provides clarity that if a municipal city council sends out a question to the to the citizens it will say for or against that ordinance if it's initiated act by the citizens then it'll say for or against the initiated act if it's a referendum a repeal of an ordinance it'll be for or against the repeal and so that's basically what this bill does if anyone has any question i'll be happy to answer it if not appreciate a good vote have you heard an explanation of
the bill does anyone wish to speak for or against the bill
Representative Ballinger you wish to close for your bill Representative Ballinger is it Close for his bill For consideration for the house is house bill 1687 Mr. Clerk prepare the machine Is everyone voted Is everyone voted Ms. Clerk casts a ballot.
With 88 yay, 0 nay, 0 present, the bill is passed. Ms. Clerk, please read House Bill 1688. House
Bill 1688 will represent to Ballinger to amend the law concerning municipal initiative and referendum petitions and to extend the time for circulation of municipal initiative and referendum petition representative bound you recognize thank you mr speaker all right what
this does is pretty simple and straightforward um if you're going to have a referendum currently you have 30 days to collect the requisite amount of signatures this would just extend it to 60 days and to be and to be clear there's there's a chance that this may this number may be amended um when we get over to the senate end but as it sits right now what you're voting on in 60 days and i'd be happy to answer any questions if not just an opportunity for a citizen to affect its government and you're just expanding that a little bit so i appreciate a good vote
all right we've heard an explanation of the bill does anyone wish to speak for or against the bill Seeing none, Representative Ballinger, are you closed for the bill? Representative Ballinger indicates he is closed for his bill. For consideration of the House is House Bill 1688. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine. Is everyone voting? Is everyone voting?
Mr. Clerk, cast up the ballot. With 88 yea, 0 nay, 0 present, the bill is passed. Mr. Clerk, please read
House Bill 1377. House Bill 1377, I represent as Murdoch and all, to allow a school district to be granted the same waivers that are granted to an open enrollment public charter school
that draws students from the school district. Representative
Murdoch, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Colleagues, I bring to you House Bill 1377. I guess it's a bill that many of you have talked to me about. We've had a chance to really vet this inside the chamber. and the reason why after it got out of committee that I held it for so long is because I wanted an opportunity to talk to both sides and I've even showed up at gatherings where I was not
invited just so that I could try to explain the legislation, the intent of the legislation, try to answer some of the real fears of the possibilities of the legislation if it's passed because it was very important to me that I answered questions for a very transformative piece of legislation that really changes the delivery or the possibility of changing the delivery
for many of our districts. And I think that's important that I take time and answer questions as best as I can and be attentive to any questions that members or non-members, constituents in general may have that's what I've been doing many of you've asked what are you waiting on you know I like it many of you told me to throw it away because you don't like it many of you've heard as I've heard via email and some through phone calls of the fears and some
of the praise so that's what this is this is a legislative process we come to the table we bring something that we think could be good for the people, we debate it, and we make a decision and we go forward. That's what this is about. This bill simply gives the opportunity for school districts that have been affected by public charters, that their population have been affected to have the same waivers, the same rights to do business, if you will, as
they have. The process is this. The local school board, the administration, and the state board of education are all a part of what happens. This is not a mandate that if this passes that all of a sudden a superintendent can just go and get rid of everybody that he or she don't like to go hire their relatives a lot of the fears that we have is not what this process is not the intent of this legislation the intent is that a particular school district
if they see a waiver on this list of waivers that that public charter currently enjoy and they see it as an opportunity to better the delivery to our jewels our children to better to give them a better chance at realizing the American dream, then this is an opportunity. Much of the conversation has been about grown people protecting their nest, protecting some
things that are very important to them, which are important to me. But the delivery of education in certain communities, in certain areas, is not working. I'm not here to cast blame. I'm only here to try to provide an opportunity to give flexibility to those that we charge, school boards, administrators.
We charge them with the task of helping to educate our children. we're charged then to be innovative and creative in our thinking as to how we do that now we get results that make us say something is wrong sometimes we can just look at the data and we can say something is just not right and when we look at it over a number of years we say this is just not working and if we truly care about the jewels the children then we would challenge
the adults, including those in the chamber and those that we trust with our children. We would challenge them in various ways from standards, certainly accountability quotients that the Department of Education use, all of these things, and then in the legislature we create legislation that says we're going to challenge you upon this opportunity, we're going to give you this chance but you need to use it in a positive way that's our part of it this legislation gives an opportunity
it's not carte blanche it's not a lot of things of the emails that you've gotten that says that we're going to diminish education we're going to water down education that's not the intent of this we have performance standards that we must meet in the public school in the public charters, they must meet performance standards. So therefore, as a CEO, I'm not going to put anyone knowingly on a project or in the classroom that's going to yield
negative results. I'm not going to do that knowingly. Now, do I want some flexibility sometime to be able to try to yield a better product that may not be currently being happening with the current situation, do I want the flexibility sometimes to try to better affect that with some flexibility? Yes. Now, that don't necessarily mean getting rid of someone because of where I come from,
if the superintendent that I know so well, if she goes and get rid of them, we don't have many people. So we're about trying to better. If you look at a study that was recently published, you'll find that one of the greatest fears from this bill, the possibilities of fair teacher dismissal act being a waiver that may be selected but if you look at public charters and what they have used and the waivers they've asked for that has not been present that's not got anything that's even been utilized very much for the
research says so and then let's just say there's a situation with whatever waiver that you may want to a district may want to impart listen to the process the process says that the legislative body the local control the local school board in conjunction with the administration and the state board of education has opportunity to review your plan after it's submitted evaluate it to see if it can reach those targets you're also accountable for what you plan so there's so much in there
to protect us. But what it does, it allows school districts specifically, in the Delta, specifically where I come from, that their populations have been affected by the advent of public charters in the neighborhood. And this is just something to level the playing field. This is an attempt to level the playing field. Now, does this answer all the questions and ills of education? No.
That's not what this does. But this does give some flexibilities to those that we charge. And it's amazing when we charge them with so much, but we don't want to give them tools to fix it. If we truly care about the end product and the jewels, the children, then why are we reluctant to give them flexibility through a process? we're not just opening the floodgates to diminishing education
the classroom, the relationship with the classroom teachers that's not what this is I must trust and whenever we pass legislation we must trust somebody that's going to enact it and I must trust local school boards, that's what local control is I must trust superintendents who are charged with the performance measures along their local school board. And I must trust the State Board of Education that if these waivers, whatever they may be, that you request,
if they don't make any sense, if they don't meet the standards, that they will kick them back. That's what this is, you guys. It's that simple. Now, those that are against it is a whole lot of just fears. And I guess when you bring those fears to me, and I've heard them, I have those fears too. If it was that way, I would be scared as well. If it was that way, but that's why the measures are put in place to hopefully prevent that and mitigate that.
That's what this is. It's only my effort to try to help a group of people that, well, excuse me, really the whole state, but I do represent selfishly, I will say. I represent District 48, and we've really been affected by this. So politics being local, as it is, but I think you all in your various districts can take this, and through proper administration, it can help a lot of people.
Because it just gives you the opportunity. You don't have to do any of this. Last thing before I take questions. We know in everything in life that one size generally don't fit all. And where we have flexibilities, we have a chance many times. And this is a effort in that vein. And I hope that it's taken that way. and prayerfully, I pray that it's ultimately used that way.
I will say this, that I held the bill for a long time because what I've been interested in, you guys, is someone bringing me anything besides a fear. I've been listening for solutions. I've heard some get close, but mostly what I've heard is just fears. I've even heard that I really like this. This really makes sense, but I'm just scared. And that's why we have these things in place, hopefully to mitigate that if something is happening, because I don't want anyone treated bad. This is to help our jewels and to help our teachers
in the total delivery of education. Thank you, and I will take questions if you have any. Representative Meeks, what
purpose? You're recognized. Thank you for addressing the question. I really like where you're going with this. I really like the flexibility. The question that i have is um why limit this to just schools that are in competition with open enrollment why not allow this flexibility to schools across the state or is that something that maybe you hope to
to to do or pursue in the future
well i'll be perfectly honest with you representative meeks it was it was you know politics being local as it is it made sense to me for what i was feeling so you know with something going on in my area for the last 12 years or so and i want to level that playing field certainly it gives uh great thought to what you're saying uh i i just didn't go that far with it all right thank you
thank you mr speaker representative douglas for a purpose
Speaker 291
2:01:37
you're recognized i would ask you representative murdoch if you were getting the same feedback from your superintendents as you go to the education forums, as I did, we were in some of the same ones. And the superintendents were pleading with us to give them a way to compete with charters. And I feel like this is our response as a legislature to our superintendents that ask us to give them a vehicle for that.
and I wondered if that was if you would agree with me
on that most certainly you heard that in committee and you hear that consistently that they have asked for that and and I did respond to the call but I tried to look even a little further than that as I made a decision to bring this legislation and as I held this legislation to listen to others to see exactly if there was some things that I was missing, but I certainly heard them, but I wanted to make sure and continue as it
moves forward, prayerfully if it passes, it passes on with me still, with a listening ear. I'm still in the listening business, but I'm only listening to the things that will help our jewels and help this become a better product. The fears, I understand, but we must be bold and innovative and step out here, and I thank you for a good vote.
Rep. Cozart, he's left the well. You've left the well. You've heard the presentation of
the bill. Does anyone wish to speak for or against the bill? Rep. Walker, for what purpose? I wish to speak against the bill. Rep. Walker, you're recognized to speak against the bill. Mr. Speaker, fellow legislators,
I rise to speak against the bill despite the fact that it is presented by my dear friend Reginald Murdoch who is my ally in many issues of importance to our constituents who have the basic similar characteristics across the state. we had this debate in
the education committee and it narrowly passed it is a debate that will go on I should like to address some of the presentations that were made or representations that were made that were both emotional and persuasive. He's saying, grown people are not the ones for whom this is about.
I remind all of you that when our children go to school, they are entrusted to grown people. It is the grown people who will provide them the necessary education that we hope for them to get. And it's not simply the book learning that we are addressing. It is the education that we call in the broadest sense. Education is simply not dealing with test scores and grades
and things that are addressed such as academic distress. it's causing people to know how to deal with the basics of education, reading, writing, and arithmetic. But it's also causing people to learn how to get along with each other, to learn how to respect, to appreciate, and understand authority and to appreciate it, to learn how, while in school, to know what the adult rules are
that they may be called upon to implement and to respect and be governed by as they get older. So we must not disrespect the grown people. Children make no decisions when they are in school. They are subject to the decisions of grown people. And it is important that we are careful about those grown people however you may feel about Representative Murdoch or about me
the main people who address students are teachers and we must say that whatever the school is it doesn't matter what label you give it public, private, parochial, charter the teachers are important and because they are important they must be respected They must be respected by having their expectations of employment honored.
They must not work in fear, in fear that their jobs may be terminated after they have written contracts at will simply because someone feels that someone else may be able to do a better job. Our laws have been carefully crafted over time, and the federal laws also require that when people are employed,
they must be paid fair salaries. We have spent a lot of time addressing the issue for state schools of pay and pay equity. We have come to the point where we say that we must have minimum salaries for teachers, and to that end, we have come up with a state salary schedule. That state minimum salary schedule has to be honored in public schools.
We've also said that there has to be a salary schedule so that teachers are all treated alike, so that you cannot just give some teachers one wage and other teachers doing the same thing another wage. That is what we call respect. That is also what we call equality. We've also said we want to keep teachers. And in order to keep teachers, we don't try to find fault with them unless and until there is good cause for doing so.
And once we have hired teachers, what we say to them is that we, if they have problems trying to meet the expectations of the environment then we'll work with them to identify the problems that they have address those problems so that they may improve and then retain them if improvement occurs and if improvement doesn't occur then give them an opportunity to be terminated that is known as the fair teacher dismissal act that has been a
part of the law of this state for at least 25 years. It should not be aborted simply because some other entities that we have allowed to be developed do not have to be governed by that. It was never intended by the legislature that private schools would be regulated by the state of Arkansas. And to an extent, by allowing charters, have allowed them not to be regulated as much, but there are minimum regulations.
But we should not disregard what we have put into place. We know that Arkansas cannot prosper unless teachers are paid well and are respected. These are the grown people about whom we speak. We can know that Arkansas cannot prosper unless teachers have a reason to go to a place. The very thing that Mr. Murdoch talks about is the very thing that will discourage people from coming to the Delta.
If Delta employees know that their wages are going to be low and whatever they are, they can be eliminated at will. Who wants to stay there? What we'll have is another system of separate and unequal education. and to an extent it will be easier for lawyers to address that because the Constitution clearly says that you cannot have two sets of districts, one superior and another unequal and inferior.
The state's duty has been set forth in very clear terms. In all of our discussions, no one has mentioned the obligations of Lakeview. Lakeview and the Supreme Court's view is something from which this legislature cannot retreat. If this bill is passed, it gives a conflict with Lakeview, which necessarily will create another case because it allows circumstances that Lakeview addressed
to be waived, and I dare say THAT THE SUPREME COURT WILL NOT RETREAT FROM LEGVIEW. IT SAYS THAT ALL SCHOOL DISTRICTS HAVE TO BE EQUAL WITHIN A CERTAIN RANGE SO THAT THE FACILITIES AND SO THAT THE COURSE OFFERINGS AND SO THAT AT LEAST THE STANDARDS ARE UNIFORM WHEREVER YOU ARE, YOU CANNOT WAVE THOSE THINGS. THOSE THINGS ARE NOT WAVEABLE. LEGVIEW,
WHILE IT ALLOWS SOME FLEXIBILITY,
It does not allow the flexibility of
this bill. Now, the comparison should never be to charters. In the past, the same argument could have been made with respect to private schools. I happen to have had the privilege of being able to attend a private school and a public school, and I studied the subject. And it was very clear as I studied the subject that public school children do not do as well in the grades,
say in Ivy League schools, as those students who come from the upper scale private schools. But when they go into the elite schools, they all seem to do as well after a short period of time. So you cannot make any real distinction between the basic education of the public school people and those who have been given the elite education. It is the opportunity that is present.
I want you to know that the issues facing the Delta and facing East and South Little Rock are the issues of poverty and race. And while we want to address them, no one has come up with a good solution. The reason the charters do better is that they skim the cream, if they do better at all. And they do not have to keep the same students because if they don't like their students, if they don't want to keep the students, they put them out and then they go back to public schools.
And then those adverse statistics, which may diminish the charters and their reputations, will become the product or the consequence of the public school. Nor do they have to take all the students. THEY DON'T HAVE TO TAKE STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES. THEY DON'T HAVE TO TAKE STUDENTS WHO HAVE LEARNING PROBLEMS. THEY CAN PICK AND CHOOSE. PRIVATE SCHOOLS HAVE ALWAYS BEEN ABLE TO PICK AND CHOOSE. THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT IN STATE LAW THAT SAYS PRIVATE SCHOOLS
MUST TAKE EVERYBODY. SO WHEN YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT SCHOOLS THAT EDUCATE THE PUBLIC AS OVER AGAINST THOSE THAT ARE SELECT, YOU CANNOT MAKE A COMPARISON TO THOSE. I want you to realize that really where we have come is here. We know that when you have a group of middle class and upper class people who live in a particular neighborhood, if you put a school in the midst of that neighborhood, those children are going to do well irrespective of what you do.
And if you give them tests, they're going to score well. You don't have to teach them at all. They'll score well. But if you put that same school in the midst of an impoverished neighborhood, or an all-black neighborhood or an all-Hispanic neighborhood, you know what the outcome is going to be. But Lakeview says that whatever that neighborhood is, we have to address the problem, and we have to address it using the same basic standards, recognizing that the outcomes are going to be different,
but we work to improve the outcomes within the framework that Lakeview has set forth. And I think that we don't deviate from Lakeview. simply because my district and the children in my district happen not to be meeting the standard expected for success in life. We don't relieve those standards in order to accomplish something that is nebulous.
Our jewels, as they have been called, certainly they are jewels, but all children are jewels. Our jewels are no more jewels than anybody else's jewels. All of us want the best for our children. I have never seen a parent who did not want the best for his or her children. But we must, as a legislature, remember what we have done from where we have come, how we got here, and what the burdens upon us are as we go forward. We all have a burden to provide good education to our children
within a context of rules and regulations, and we cannot make exceptions in terms of having an environment where the expectation of learning and high achievement is present. Now, in all due respect to all those of you who support and still support segregation, you can allow this to take place, and we'll just stay in court another 30 or 40 years.
But the lesson of Little Rock is that the monies that were spent on Little Rock, as Senator Hendren, then Senator Hendren came to me, was, look, we're spending all this money and nothing is changing. But something was changing, Senator. The money wasn't being spent on those children, and the state found that out. The money was being spent on the children who already were learning and on the schools to develop them. And we can't have that happen and then expect that the children who are the intended beneficiaries of the state's largesse are left in isolation and then they are punished for having been students without any kind of recourse or redress.
I ask you all to think about this. I want to ask you to vote against it. I'm going to vote against it, despite my friendship with Representative Murdoch. I do know that it does give us cause for concern. And there is no reason to think in terms of people. Some of you say, well, you always threaten a lawsuit. You don't have to think in terms of a lawsuit. All you have to do is look at Lakeview. You look at Lakeview. It doesn't matter whether you live in Fort Smith or Alma or Hope, my native home,
or whether you have left Monticello and gone to Cabot, as one of you has. The point is that wherever you are, the standards have to be the same. How are you going to measure people unless you measure them by the same standard? And how can you measure them if you don't hold the persons who are responsible for their education accountable? I do not seek to be relieved from accountability, nor do I seek waivers from accountability.
I ask you all to give serious consideration to my remarks. I understand that about 30 of you, you know, anytime I come up here, about 30 or so of you have said that you're going to be against whatever I say. Well, that may be the case. But you are talking about now not giving release to Mariana, Arkansas, where you have the KIPP schools, or to perhaps Helena. You're talking about giving it to the state. There is nothing that the KIPP schools do, for those of you who are interested, that cannot be done by public schools.
In fact, KIPP, I must tell you, was started in Little Rock. KIPP won't acknowledge that, but they started in our incentive schools. And because of the bad faith of the Little Rock School District during that time, they eliminated them. They weren't called KIPP. They were called incentive schools. And everything that KIPP is doing was done here. And those children in racially isolated, high-poverty schools were being, their education was being enhanced and the communities prospered.
They had field trips on the weekend. They had special detention after school. they had in-school tutoring, they had one-on-one reading recovery and programs like that. That's all KIPP is doing, and that can be done by public schools. I apologize to Representative Murdoch and to the other members who are of my race for taking the stand in opposition to a progressive member of our race.
But I do feel that this is a larger issue that we must all address as a society and certainly as this legislature, taking into account what the Supreme Court, all white members have said. And that is that you cannot have different rules for poor people and for rich people, for the haves and the have-nots. And we need to keep that in mind whatever we do.
I thank you for allowing me this time and for listening to me. It seems that most people have been attentive, and for you, for that, I am
grateful. Thank you. For what purpose, Representative Douglas? Motion. Representative Walker is still in the well. I can't take a motion until he exits the well. For what purpose, Representative? Motion. Let's hear that motion. Moving me to consideration. Proper motion. Non-debatable. All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. I'm going to rule the no's have it. Anyone wishing to speak for the bill?
REPRESENTATIVE SULLIVAN YOU FOR WHAT PURPOSE? YOU REGOND I SPEAK
FOR THE BILL. THANK YOU MR. SPEAKER. FIRST I WANT TO THANK MY ESTEEMED COLLEAGUE AND REPRESENTATIVE MURDOCK AND I HAVE WORKED CLOSELY ON THIS. IN FACT MET WITH SOME OF THOSE FOLKS WHO WERE opposed. And one of the questions we asked was, what is more important? Student achievement
are a raft of waivers. And the people that we are meeting with said they were of level importance. You know, folks in real time are going to a school where they can choose achievement or they have to choose lower achievement, but with licensed teachers and schools that can't waive some of these things. I was astonished to hear that people would put anything but student achievement first. It's of prime importance and of utmost importance. The people that were talking
to us were protecting their paradigm of the way schools have operated in the past. And folks, it's time to put consumers and put children and put families first. There are real decisions being made real children real families are moving into representative murdoch's community and they can choose a school that's achieving or they can choose a school that is is held down by waivers those are real decisions and i strongly support this bill and i strongly support the opportunity
for families to go in to make those choices and i also strongly support those schools being able to choose success, and that's what we're doing today. Thank you. Representative Sullivan spoke for the bill. Does
anyone wish to speak against the bill? For the bill. Representative Murdoch, do you wish to close for your bill?
Recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, colleagues. and especially Representative Walker for coming to the well and expressing the things that you believe and have lived for for so long that is not taken lightly by I don't think anyone in this chamber and certainly by me, I really appreciate the intensity for which you fight for that that you believe.
I do want to say in closing, I don't want to belabor it, but I do need to say it because a couple of things that you said I need to respond to because it goes beyond this room and so many things that you said are factual but I do want to deal with some of the things that I think are not factual that are but are real fears factual versus fears when we talk about the the classroom teachers and what will happen to them as a result of this legislation this legislation does not
enable in any way for teachers or any personnel, it does not open the gates for them to be treated unfairly. There is a process of at least three levels and including various other state laws that are already in place to protect people in the workplace. Now, if someone chooses such a waiver, and I think there's an assumption being made that we're automatically, because is on the list, it's going to be chosen.
This state has already, as you talk about Lakeview and remembering Lakeview, has already authorized conversion charters, and a school of innovation was just passed in the last session. So the flexibilities are there through various means. So certainly because the door that I'm knocking on today is in response to a competition, so to speak, to a public charter and not a private school.
That's another thing that's not factored. A public charter, which is funded by public money. Right now, we don't fund private schools per se, but the public charter is different. So the public charter that's being allowed to be there, and many years ago, Representative and to all, this was allowed for. However, I did not create the situation. When I got here, it was there. So the only thing I'm trying to do is to level the playing field
to give those that are in the fight, in the battle, in the trenches, a chance. Simple as that. I have several other things here that I will not even go into. I would just say, please understand that my motivation and my passion is for the Jules and for those, Representative Walker, that go into the classroom every day and teach them. They mean so much to me, and they've meant so much to whatever I've become. So there is no minimizing teachers at all in this legislation.
At all. Please understand that. Again, thank you so much, and I appreciate a good
vote. All right. Representative Murdoch is closed for his bill. Question before the House. House Bill 1377. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine.
Is everyone voting? Has everyone voted? Ms. Clerk, cast up the ballot. With 58 yeas, 18 nays, and 3 peasant, the bill is passed. Motion for a clincher. All those in favor signify by saying aye. Any opposed?
Ayes have it. The bill is clenched. all right friends we're going to skip over the uh senate bills uh i believe we have a couple items of business though before you leave uh and the budget calendar also we've got we're going to we're going to skip over those we'll take those up i'm assuming monday uh
representative shepherd for what purpose motion let's hear your motion mr speaker having voted on the prevailing side in consideration of house bill 1789 i move reconsideration representative shepherd uh
how did you vote i voted nay proper motion it is debatable you recognize to come
to the well to present your motion mr speaker mr speaker uh yesterday we voted on house bill 1789 I voted against the bill. I had some concerns about the upper end of the penalties that could be charged. After discussions with the highway department, I understand that they are willing to amend that down on the Senate end. The other thing about this bill that I didn't understand
at the time that it has been made clear to me is that right now I believe the penalty that can be charged is $500. If otherwise, the next alternative is actually pulling people's permits for signs and other items. This bill simply was an attempt to provide kind of an incremental step short of having to take such a drastic step, and thus I would ask for a favorable vote on reconsideration. For what purpose, Representative Ballinger? He has
left the well. Anybody wish to speak against the motion? Representative Ballinger, you recognized to speak against the motion nobody wants to go
home do they thank you mr speaker i i honestly i just would like to know what the upper end is so if somebody else could uh could tell me you know my problem is still my problem until i know what what that amendment
is going to be because the ten thousand dollar fine sure seems like a high fine to allow our people to be fine. So if somebody can speak for it and let us know what that is, that would
be great. Thank you. Representative Ballinger has spoken against the motion. Is there anyone who wishes to speak for the motion? Against the motion? Representative Shepard, would you like to close the motion? Thank you, Mr.
Speaker. With regard to Representative Ballinger's question to be quite honest this this is all just come about in the last four or five minutes actually a little longer because it was prior to Representative Walker's speaking so no disrespect I just want to be honest it was about 45 minutes ago probably so I had talked with the highway department Scott Bennett I said that was my concern would you be willing on the Senate end And if it does come out to move that down, they indicated that they would.
No specific amount was discussed. Again, the main idea here is that this allows some incremental step short of the alternative now, which is they basically just have to go to pulling permits. And so that's what I know. I want to be completely honest with the chamber. And thank
you very much. All right. Representative Shepard is closed for his motion. The question for the House is motion to reconsider of House Bill 1789. All those in favor signify by saying aye.
Any opposed? I'm going to rule that ayes have it. question now before the house is passage of house bill 1789 mr. clerk prepare the machine
Mr. Clerk, cast up the ballot. With 53 yay, 22 nay, and 0 present, House Bill 1789 is passed.
Do I see five hands? We will sound the ballot. All right, ladies and gentlemen, I'm going to read to you from our house rules. This is rule 100.
This is from rule 100 for those that want to follow along in the rule book. When contested, any representative except a representative's voting by pair vote and the speaker and a substitute speaker who is not present and in his seat shall have his or her vote eliminated.
Broadaway. Streiton, Representative Broadway. Brown,
Lanny Feith, Gates, Gossage, Michelle Gray, Michael John Gray, Hammer. Hendren. Hillman. Holcomb. Jet.
McGee, Mayberry, McElroy, McGill. Representative McGill is not present in
the chamber or in his seat.
Strike Representative McGill. We will, at this time, Mr. Clerk, we will discontinue the sound of the ballot with a vote of 50 yays. 22 nays, zero present. The bill has failed.
All right, folks, we're going to move just as quickly as we can, but we've got a little bit of housekeeping we need to address before we get out of here. Without objection, we're going to re-refer House Bill 1762 from Judiciary Committee to Aging Children and Youth. Hearing no objections, so ordered, we're going to re-refer House Bill 1944 from Education Committee to Committee on State Agencies.
Hearing no objections, so ordered. Representative Bain. Moves. Moves, we re-refer House Bill 1456 back to committee. Representative Bain, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I ask to send
this bill back to committee. It's a good bill. I want to make it better.
representative bain has explained his motion does anybody wish to speak for or against his motion representative bain are you closed for your motion uh you've heard the explanation of represent representative bain's motion all those in favor signify by saying aye any opposed no mr clerk re-refer that back to house bill 1456 back to committee representative stephen meeks for what purpose motion mr speaker i think it would be appropriate
thank you sir after the announcements reading of the bills transferring of the bills placing the calendars on the desk members amending their own bills with their own amendments members withdrawing their own bills finalizing resolutions reading communications and any remaining committee reports I move we adjourn until 1 30 Monday afternoon it's
proper motion not debatable all in favor signify by saying aye opposed say no sorry but motion's going to carry other announcements
representative drown has uh if y'all if you would give it give representative drown your attention. He's got something you're going to want
Speaker 320
2:40:00
to hear. Recognize Representative Brown. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Just to let everybody know, Representative Eves just welcomed a brand new grandbaby boy into this world. Grace and Michael, mother and child,
are doing fine. Anyone else? Any other announcements? Representative Ballinger, you're recognized.
Joint Energy will meet at 10 a.m. on Monday morning in Room 171. So we're going to actually hear some bills, so if you look over them before we meet, that would be great. Thanks. Representative David Meeks, you're
Speaker 114
2:40:35
recognized. Be a part of history. We are holding the last, or we hope the last, Joint Retirement Committee meeting on Monday at 10 a.m. in Room 130. Other announcements? I
don't see anybody. If no further analysis, read the committee reports, Mr. Clerk.
Mr. Speaker, we are committee on journal engrossed in road bills to whom referred a shell bill, House Bill 1655 and House Bill 1705, beg to lead the report, we had the same under consideration. and herewith return the same, having been substantially amended and engrossed in compliance with House Rule 39C. Respectfully submitted, Jeremy Gillum, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are your Committee on Aging Children and Youth.
Tumors deferred House Bill 1045. Beg lead report, Patton Sangham's consideration. Herewith return the same recommendation. It do pass as amended, number one, Representative George McGill. chair mr. speaker we your committee on city county and local tumors for House bill 1680 begley report bad same under consideration herewith return the same recommendation that do pass as amended number one respectfully submitted representative Betty over be chair
mr. speaker we your committee on insurance commerce tumors for the House Bill 1734, beg the lead report, we had the same under consideration, herewith return the same with recommendation, do pass as amended, number one. Respectfully submitted, Representative Charlie Collins, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we, your Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom is referred House Bill 1906, beg the lead report, we had the same under consideration, herewith return the same with recommendation, do pass as amended, number one. Respectfully submitted, Representative Charlie Collins, Chair.
Mr. Speaker, we hear Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom has referred Senate Bill 487. Beg lead report, we've had the same under consideration, herewith return the same as the recommendation. Do pass, amended number two. Respectfully submitted, Representative Charlie Collins, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we hear Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom has referred Senate Bill 796. Beg lead report, we've had the same under consideration, herewith return the same as the recommendation. Do pass, respectfully submitted, Representative Charlie Collins, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are Committee on Age and Children and Youth.
Tumors referred House Bill 1608, 1671, House Bill 1673, House Bill 1674, House Bill 1755, and Senate Bill 794. Begley to report we've had the same amount of consideration. Herewith return the same recommendation that they do pass. Respectfully submitted. Representative George McGill, Chair. The desk will remain open for the reading
of bills and upon completion of the items
named in the adjourn resolution the house will be adjourned until 1 30
Speaker 1
2:44:19
p.m. Monday. From our children's education to banking laws and from the courts to agriculture, certain members serve on five joint committees along with members of the state senate.
These committees deal with the state budget to energy and information and technology. You're welcome to visit the viewing gallery high above the House floor and get a bird's eye view of democracy. If you can't observe the sessions in person.
Agenda
CALL TO ORDER
SB698
HB1193
HB1774
HB1625
HB1452
HB1596
HB1496
HB1706
HB1707
HB1530
HB1678
HB1372
HB1525
HB1526
HB1527
HB1539
HB1408
HB1836
HB1737
HB1719
HB1723
HB1480
HB1502
HB1388
HB1825
HB1960
HB1963
HB1621
HB1722
HB1687
HB1688
HB1377
HB1789
ANNOUNCEMENT AND READING BILLS
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 1
Representative Jeremy Gillam Chair
Unverified
Speaker 5
Speaker 10
Speaker 15
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Representative Nelda Speaks
Unverified
Speaker 25
Chair
Unverified
Representative Marshall Wright
Unverified
Speaker 46
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Representative Nate Bell
Unverified
Speaker 68
Representative John Baine
Unverified
Speaker 81
Speaker 16
Representative Lane Jean Chair
Unverified
Speaker 84
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Speaker 109
Speaker 114
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 134
Speaker 135
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Representative Bob Johnson
Unverified
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Speaker 157
Speaker 159
Representative David L. Branscum
Unverified
Representative John T. Vines Chair
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Speaker 180
Representative Rick Beck
Unverified
Speaker 189
Representative Bruce Cozart
Unverified
Speaker 155
Speaker 211
Speaker 233
Speaker 219
Speaker 244
Representative Rebecca Petty
Unverified
Representative Sue Scott
Unverified
Representative Charles Blake
Unverified
Representative David Fielding
Unverified
Representative Andy Davis
Unverified
Speaker 199
Representative James Ratliff
Unverified
Speaker 269
Representative Deborah Ferguson
Unverified
Speaker 291
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative Dan Sullivan
Unverified
Speaker 207
Speaker 314
Speaker 316
Speaker 317
Speaker 167
Speaker 80
Speaker 320