Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Education Committee

March 31, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (8)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB615 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Representative Senator Stubblefield, you are recognized for SB 615.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1597 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1597”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1663 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…, Madam Chair. this is a incur on a Senate amendment and on House Bill 1663. Brief on that we”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1961 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1961”
Pre-2017 bill
SB968 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ent? Yes, sir. Thank you. Jane English, Senator, and I have Senate Bill 968. This bill basically gives school districts the option of h…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1600 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1600”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1007 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1007”
Pre-2017 bill
SB776 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB776”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
On the amendment? Yes. Representative Walker? Yes, what did you actually do? I mean, making a bill better sometimes is verbiage. So what did you actually do to make the bill better? I'd like to have Mr. Eric Saunders come up
▶ Play
Speaker 16 0:11
and address that for me, please. Sorry to put you on the spot. Eric Saunders, Department of Ed
▶ Play
Speaker 9 0:30
Are you Were you asking about the amendment? Yes Yes, we sat down with some of the authors of the bill and just worked out some of the language trying to make sure that it didn't have unintended consequences and that it was still reflective of what it's trying to do May I follow up? Yes, I'll
▶ Play
allow you one more follow-up. It's really the same question because he didn't answer it. The question was, and it's still my first question, you indicated that whatever the changes were made the bill better. I asked what were the changes other than what did you all do and what was the procedure? What were the changes? It's a good question. Let
▶ Play
Speaker 16 1:11
us have just a second. We're going to get that right to you.
▶ Play
Speaker 9 1:36
All right. Yes, looking at the amendment, and I'm trying to bring myself back up to it, so all apologies there. Clarifying the intent on what the intent of the law was to do so that we had that clarified. Additionally, we were looking at some of the FERPA, possible some conflicts that was with FERPA in the original language concerning the transmission of data between the agencies and who would have access to that data to keep that limited. Mr. Chair, the question still
▶ Play
hasn't been answered. They're still telling me procedure. I'd like to know what you did and what is the intent and how is that reflected? I just want to know rather than just simply somebody saying we made a good bill better.
▶ Play
Is the not readable in the bill what was amended? We have the amendment here, and he's... Well,
▶ Play
Speaker 16 2:24
I mean, do we read the amendment to him? We can.
▶ Play
Speaker 21 2:31
I mean, if you want to read the amendment. Okay, we
▶ Play
will. Could I see the amendment? Yes, sir. There's a Senate amendment, so it should have been in the bill. It's engrossed in the bill, and it's a different italicization of the bill, so you should be able to see what it is.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Any other questions, committee?
▶ Play
What's the will of the committee? I have a do pass motion. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed, no? Thank you. At this time, we'll
▶ Play
Speaker 16 3:36
hear House Bill 1597. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Are we ahead of him? Yes, this was the bill that I brought to you that was that odd situation where some of the sick leave was transferred from another school. And we had some heartburn from the AAEA on some of the implications to school policy that was already in existence. And we came in and clarified that and still kept integrity in the bill. So I'd appreciate a good vote on that as well. Are there any questions?
▶ Play
Representative Defiball, you have a question? Yeah.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I thought, you know, the bill looks simple to me to begin with, but how did you change that? I don't understand how you could make that. I mean, it's pretty cut and
▶ Play
Speaker 16 4:36
dried here, it looks like. Well, we did not want to penalize the school districts. We just wanted to be able to, for the teachers to be able to collect that sick leave if they were eligible. We didn't want it to be automatic if they were under their, you know, they have to meet a 10-year accumulated leave before they collect their 90 days. And so we didn't want them to be able to do it in
▶ Play
Speaker 40 5:03
year one. So. Can I follow up? You're recognized. Okay,
▶ Play
thank you. Okay, so what it amounts to is the sick leave. I mean, when I'm reading that the sick leave is transferred can be used first. That's the way your
▶ Play
Speaker 16 5:19
bill reads. Is that right? Basically, we just want it to be in one pot. We don't want it to be, you know, identified.
▶ Play
Okay. All right. Thank you. Appreciate a good vote. Representative Walker, you
▶ Play
recognize. Yes. The teachers will still be able to have the sick leave we approved. So if they transfer from one district to another, they will be able to use it. But the only thing you're doing is you're not specifying from which part it comes. Yes, we just want
▶ Play
Speaker 16 5:57
it to be lumped together so that at the end when they retire, they're able to take that accumulated leave without taking off any from the transferred school. All right.
▶ Play
Thank you. Are there any other questions? What's the will of the committee? I have a due pass
▶ Play
motion. Representative Walker, all those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations. You have passed both your amendments. Thank you. Representative Letting, you are recognized to present a concurrent Senate amendment on HB1961.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll be very brief. This is that student privacy bill that we passed out of here unanimously just about a week ago. We got it down to the Senate and it was never our intent to include the Department of Education and we didn't feel like the language did, but the department said they'd feel better if we had some language that explicitly excluded them, so that's all this amendment does is carve them
▶ Play
out. Any questions? What's the will of the committee? I have a do pass from Representative McElroy. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations. You passed your amendment. Thank you. I'm going to turn it over to my vice chair, and I've
▶ Play
got to run an amendment. Representative Cozart, you're
▶ Play
recognized to run your amendment. Thank you, Madam Chair. this is a incur on a Senate amendment and on House Bill 1663. Brief on that we had fought back and forth on this bill from the beginning to try to put supplemental funding on the transportation enhanced transportation funding and we could not get the money for it so we pulled that off. That's what the amendment does. Okay. Any
▶ Play
questions? Representative Lauer, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chairman. I'm usually not
▶ Play
Speaker 63 8:01
at a loss on how to phrase a question. So I'm just going to go ahead and make a statement and then ask you if you would agree or disagree. You referenced that we've been fighting back and forth about this issue. Matter of fact, One of the discussion points was that transportation should possibly be pulled out of the matrix because we have a large number of districts who are winners, net winners, on transportation dollars, and most of them are losers. And we were told, frankly, to hold off on this until the next session, but in the meantime we're going to take care of these loser school districts with supplemental funding. Is that correct? Is that a correct assessment of the conversations that took place? Similar. Similar, okay. My question is, if we spent so much time discussing this issue, making sure that these school districts that are being hurt dramatically by their transportation costs, making sure that they're taken care of, why at the 11th hour are we pulling this money away? Well, Representative Lowry, the money was never there.
▶ Play
When we asked for it, it was a part of the study that we did during the summer. But as you know, transportation is funded to the foundation money in the matrix. And this was just a supplemental because there are some districts that do not have quite enough money that they need. There are some that make a very large sum on the transportation money. And so when you figure it in the matrix and the foundation funding, it doesn't always work out the best for some schools. So we looked at that in trying to figure out a formula. We figured out a formula. We needed $3 million. Well, we just put it in the bill to go for it, and we did not get that because it was not figured in originally. Now, we pulled that out. If you'll read part of the last bill, there will be, right before the emergency clause, it says in the amendment that the House Committee on Education and Senate Committee on Education in conjunction with the Bureau of Legislative Research shall conduct a review of the transportation funding model developed by the Bureau of Legislative Research and make its recommendations to the 90th General Assembly for the consideration for the 2016 fiscal session. So this is something we're going to look at and see if we
▶ Play
can figure out how to make this work for the fiscal
▶ Play
session. Okay. Any other questions? Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Yes. As I understood Lakeview, the matrix that was established was to cause the school districts to be substantially equal in terms of all aspects of the educational arena. And you indicated that this is going to be good for some and bad for some. and my concern is how this appears in, well, first of all, did you have an opinion from the Attorney General as to whether or not this would affect Lakeview? This does not
▶ Play
affect it. This is the same thing that's been going on. This is the same thing that the formula that they figured out years ago. It's just that some districts do not have the same amount of route miles or the same amount of student miles, and so they make a little bit of money on this. There's some that have a little bit more, and it's hard to actually get that figured out. That's why there's always been they can use, oh, and I'm at a loss for words on what they use, but there is other money they can pull their transportation from. But we were just trying to bring a little more in and try to help that, and we didn't get it researched soon enough to get it in the budget, and so we're going to try to do that for the 16 session. Okay. In other words, you'd rather me leave it alone for now? I would rather you leave it alone for now. It's just
▶ Play
going to be a problem. Representative Lauer, you're recognized for your second question.
▶ Play
Speaker 63 12:15
I guess a technical question to ask. If we were to not concur with this amendment, would that force this issue to a conference to settle it?
▶ Play
If you don't concur with this, we lose all of our foundation funding. It goes back to the formula numbers that we had the year before. Okay. Thank you very
▶ Play
much. Anyone from the audience wish to speak for the bill, against the bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 74 12:47
Yes, sir. You're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA. We support additional funding for schools. We know the work of the Adequacy Committee, but we just need to be on record that what has been done, what has been funded, may not fit the needs of the public schools. When you go back and look at the COLA that's been brought forth from BLR on the cost of living adjustments for schools, there's around 2%, and this foundation funding amount is going to be less than 1%. We have some other legislation that's been approved that has added additional cost to the schools. I'm not sure it's been considered. And now we're looking at not even taking the recommendation of the adequacy committee. So we just need to express our concerns. Thank you. Are you ready to close for your bill, Representative? I am closed.
▶ Play
Okay. What's the will of the committee? Representative McElroy? Do pass. Okay. We have a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, nay. Congratulations, Representative. Your bill is passed. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Committee.
▶ Play
And now we will move to regular bills. All right. Now we
▶ Play
will return to our regular bills. Thank you, Chair. Okay, yeah. Senator English, did you
▶ Play
have a bill to present? Yes, sir. Thank you. Jane English, Senator, and I have Senate Bill 968. This bill basically gives school districts the option of holding their school board elections in September or November. He's there. He's right
▶ Play
there. He's right there. I wish I didn't get the coast like that. Are you ready for questions? Yes. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Senator, are
▶ Play
you aware that we've had this issue before
▶ Play
us at least three times and we have rejected that three times? Oh, I didn't know you had three times.
▶ Play
Well, the idea, it's come in
▶ Play
different forms. It was direct and then was indirect, and now it's coming a third time. What do you have to offer that those other bills didn't have to offer by then and by then?
▶ Play
I have a correction on that. This is the second time it's come before this committee. It may have come before another committee. We ran that yesterday, and this is our second time on the same bill, so it's only come before us once. This is the same bill that we defeated yesterday? Yes, it is. This is the same bill that Representative Gosling ran
▶ Play
yesterday because Senator English was not available. what do you have to say for this bill let me be a little bit different the school terms of school directors are fixed their term of years by having school boards have an option of having the school elections in September and November are you not extending the school terms for those persons who may choose to have the elections in November I don't think so. Well, the term normally is from September to September, three years hence. And by your bill, it would be from September to November, three years hence. So you're extending the school term, which is contrary to state law, and I don't know what else. But why would you do that? Just to give
▶ Play
school districts an option and an opportunity to decide for themselves whether they're going to have an election in September. for school boards or november that's all this does okay good represent grow you're recognized for
▶ Play
Speaker 148 16:53
a question thank you mr chair senator thank you i i understand in reading the bill that it leaves the option there for the districts to decide however my question is does it leave some opportunity for inconsistency that whether the whim of the school board or as the political winds blow um one time it may be in november the next time it'll be in september and um i some of the issues i think we're trying to address is knowing is the pub public knowing about these elections and if the inconsistency of back and forth does it leave that opportunity there that's that that's really
▶ Play
Speaker 95 17:33
strictly up to the school district. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator, I have a
▶ Play
question. Is this kind of a cost savings for the schools if they had it in November on the election years, they would not have to have that extra election in September? Exactly. Okay. Thank you, ma'am. Question. You recognize. What's the fiscal impact? I don't think there is a fiscal. Well, if it's
▶ Play
It's a cost-saving. It obviously has a fiscal
▶ Play
impact. I think overall there could be a cost-savings.
▶ Play
Well, it's speculative. Thank you. Representative Gossage, you recognize? I move for immediate consideration. I have a motion for immediate consideration. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed, no? Motion is passed. What's the will of the committee? I have a due pass from Representative Gossage. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Motion carries. I only seen one hand. I'm sorry. I did not see another hand. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Representative Senator Stubblefield, you are recognized for SB 615.
▶ Play
you're recognized sir thank you mr chairman thank you committee uh senate bill 615 is a very simple bill it simply exempts uh the freedom of information act on these schools that have security plans is in place, schools like Clarksville, schools like Hamilton, it not only exempts the FOI of the security plan itself, but it exempts the teachers who are involved in the plan. That's simply what
▶ Play
it does. Are there any questions? Seeing no questions, is there anyone in the audience? Oh, I'm sorry. Representative Bell, you recognize me. Mr. Chair, I just had a motion to proper time. Okay. Seeing no questions, anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Are you closed for your bill? Closed, Mr. Chairman. Representative Bell, you're recognized for your motion. Move, do pass. I have a do pass motion. Representative Bell, all those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Representative Armstrong, are you ready to present a bill for Senator Elliott? S.B. 776.
▶ Play
Recognize. Mr. Chair, I'd like to bring Mr. Massanelli up here
▶ Play
with me. Mr. Massanelli, if you would just state your name and who you're with,
▶ Play
Speaker 115 20:53
you'll be recognized whenever you're needed. Yes, sir. Can you hear me? Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman. Randy Massanelli,
▶ Play
representing the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville. You're recognized to present your bill. Mr. Chair, this is a bill to provide in-state, in-county, and in-a-district tuition for veterans and their dependents.
▶ Play
Speaker 115 21:14
And I'll turn it over to Mr. Massanelli. Mr. Chairman, this bill specifically gives in-state tuition to veterans released or discharged within three years of their discharge and that in-state tuition to their family members includes spouse and dependent children. It also extends in-state tuition to spouses of armed services members no matter what state they're in, as it does with veterans as well. This is about, this is going to be odd hearing from me, but this is about a million-dollar hit to the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville. But we see this as an investment. We're willing to do this. We want to do it. We need more veteran population in the state to come back and start businesses, and we think this is a good way to do it. We've worked with the Veterans Coalition, the Military Officers Association, the sponsor of this bill, and we support it. And I'm speaking solely for the Fayetteville campus
▶ Play
100%. Rep. Bale, you're recognized for a question. Yeah,
▶ Play
and my question, I'm not sure which one of you is best able to answer it, but my question goes to kind of a narrow situation that I'd just like some clarification on. I know that there are a number of folks who aren't completely documented in this country who go into the military as a means of a gateway to citizenship. Would this bill require that they have completed that citizenship process to be eligible for this, or does this go around that? Representative Bell,
▶ Play
Speaker 115 22:47
I do not know the answer to that.
▶ Play
I'd have to get you an answer on that. Because I don't see language in the bill that has that requirement, and we do have state laws other than that that would offset that. So I think there seems to be an apparent conflict in the state law there if we pass this bill. Well, basically it's conflicting with the federal law because the federal law allows that. So I got this bill yesterday. I understand, Representative Armstrong, and I just, you know, this is actually the first time that I've looked at the bill, but I do have that concern because it does appear that should someone serve in the military and not complete the citizenship process via the gateway that they have there, that this bill would still allow them to have in-state tuition. I would like to have that clarification. Let me say this. A lot of these people that serve in the military that's not got full citizenship in this country, they've got top security clearances and everything else. I absolutely agree, Representative Armstrong. It does appear that it would conflict with an existing law, and that's my only concern. And they do have a legal status. Absolutely. Again, stipulate
▶ Play
Speaker 66 24:01
that. It looks like it might be an apparent conflict. Are
▶ Play
there any other questions? Seeing none, we have anybody that would like to speak against the bill. Anyone else for the bill? Would you like to close for
▶ Play
Speaker 66 24:21
your bill? I'm closed, and I move do pass. I have a do pass motion from Representative Armstrong. All those in favor say aye.
▶ Play
Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you've passed your bill. Well, Senator Collins-Smith, you are recognized to take the end of the table to present SB1007. This is our last bill of the day. Maybe.
▶ Play
For the morning day. Well, we'll make sure you get out and steal the morning. Colleagues, I am proud and appreciate you guys for hearing this bill this morning. The reason that I filed this bill was there was an absolute outcry across the state when families and history teachers with the master's degrees were looked at the history program and they were cutting out the beginning of history. An absolute outcry. there were a wide swath of citizens parents, educators, those with advanced degrees doctors in histories and concerned grandparents this is a review bill to fill in the gaps where the education department is trying to take out history prior to 1820. There should be an outrage that prior to the American history to the year of 1890 allows 9th to 12th grade social studies classes to be taught in proper context for their mastery. And it continues an early and already ongoing voluntary American history review process being created by ADE for the 8th grade by U.S. history after a three-year gap in instruction on this top. It allows for local control by allowing the classroom teachers to determine what review is relevant for their individual students and classrooms thank you and there's no additional cost to the teachers as they may use resources that are already available to them there's plenty of resources for that period of time how can our children and grandchildren remain their freedoms in this nation if they don't know their heritage. There are people who are alive today who were in the Vietnam War, World War II, Iraq War, etc. Do we want to cut those histories out? Don't forget that there's no additional cost to this. Again, the information is readily available. If you do not pass this bill, there will be no review on George Washington in those years, the Revolutionary War, signing of the Declaration of Independence. Would you want the Civil War cut out? So I bring this bill to you, and I have Barbara Gordon with me to talk to you about the curriculum, and her name is Barbara Gordon. May she be recognized, Mr. Chair. Barbara, if you would recognize yourself
▶ Play
and who you're with, you are recognized to speak.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. My name is Barbara Gordon. I have experience with homeschoolers and private school and public school over right at 30 years of working with that. I'm certified in multiple areas with the state of Arkansas. For brevity's sake, actually, I was asked to help with this after the outcry came about, and I studied it myself, so I guess I'm representing myself and the people with whom I've talked. To cut it down to a nutshell, if you'll look on the bill, it's Section 2. The A underneath there, it says the following social studies or history courses offered in grades 7 through 12 include a relevant review of the United States history, and it mentions the period that's left out at the high school level. The only limitations in this bill is that the classroom teacher considers it to be relevant because under guidelines we are right now specified to teach only the standards for each individual level course. And if a teacher sees that they have students who have not covered the material in five to seven years, that courses such as civics and U.S. history and also since 1890 and also American government requires them to have knowledge of, in order to accomplish the learning objectives of those courses, they need to be able to review them. There is absolutely a plethora of material. As she said, there's no cost online for free. This bill changes not one word that has been written or put together by the group that wrote the social studies curriculum standards as they are. It does not change one word. It simply says that the teacher can take time and review so that there is mastery of learning. I, as a teacher, am concerned about mastery, so that there is mastery of learning and learning in context. It maintains local control, as we've already said, including the liberty of the individual teachers to accommodate the needs of their individual students and classes. With my background, my master's work is in special ed. I have multiple certifications at the graduate level in special ed. it's not enough to just cover material and check a box and say okay well we've covered that I want it to be understood this bill encourages research based instructional techniques such as the accommodation and implementation of modifications in the individual classroom to meet unique student needs repetition of concepts with expansion and deepening of concepts and increasing grade levels and difficulties for mastery contextual learning, and connecting new knowledge to old. There's a lot I could say, but I know
▶ Play
y'all are short on time. All right. Are there any questions? Representative Walker,
▶ Play
I'll get you first, and I'll get Representative Deffa Ball next. Thank you. Thank you. I'm a little apprehensive about us telling the Department of Education what courses must be included as a requirement for anything, and there ought to be a process that would seem that your views could first be filtered through the Department of Education. But I guess the question that I really have, there are two, and they relate to each other. You're giving the teachers, and that means teachers throughout the state, and you have maybe a thousand teachers of history, you're giving them the discretion to determine content of course or whether to teach something. And the other thing that I see here is that the teachers may or may not teach African-American history, and I've heard you say nothing about your qualifications, anybody else's, to address that. And, of course, it gives me a concern because the kind of history we teach doesn't include necessarily all kind of history. So I don't think that we should be. Do you think that we should be, and this goes to the senator rather than to the teacher who has, who is just e pluribus unum. You know what that is. I have a specific answer. So my question is, Senator, why should we legislate these matters rather than rely upon the State Department of Education to address them and then to give us some general format so all of the districts can have uniformity in terms of some uniformity in terms of the teaching, especially since all the students are expected to be graded pursuant to uniform standards.
▶ Play
First of all, to answer your question, you mentioned black history. This does not take out black history. Matter of fact, would you want to take out black history? What's next? if they can just out of remember this just happened colleagues this is the first year they're trying to remove history prior to this year in this bill there's an outrage from the people because we have to know where we came from if we want to be able to teach our children a free state that we're a free nation and so representative walker i don't i think we tell education department among and we make laws all the time when we see something that's not right that's our job to clean things up this was noticed in an immediate outcry when it was published and i have to say to you i can't imagine not supporting a bill that doesn't cost anything and that it will make sure that you review the very beginnings of our history in high school years
▶ Play
after they've been without for a long time
▶ Play
thank you representative deffenbaugh you're recognized Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Gordon, or Senator, I think it's imperative we do this. I don't have any problem with, and you may have said this, Ms. Gordon, but is there room to get from 1820 on back with the new standards and that together? Is there room for that, do you think?
▶ Play
Let me address that. That's the reason that I didn't want to go any further in this bill is because those standards are supposed to go into. I really believe that we should do more. I believe that that area should be taken back up to the high school level. But my fear was that it would do what Representative Walker inferred just a few minutes ago, that it would throw things in chaos because the standards are in place and they are supposed to be effective as of July. So to me, this was a stopgap measure in order to allow the instruction to be presented in context as much as possible and for mastery. So I agree 100% with what you're saying, but I didn't want there to be complete chaos. I don't know how we could ask them to change what they've done that's supposed to go into effect in July, completely change it here at the end of March. I just don't know how we could do that. And if I may, I mean, we can always look at that later. And as far as one of the things that in our discussions with staff at the ADE that they said that I really believe could prevent something like this in the future is that they agreed that they would put, it was my understanding that they agreed that they would put curriculum standards up to public comment like they put some of their other policies, because this literally is policy. And then I did, if it's all right with you, want to address the African-American history. It is not mentioned anywhere in the bill explicitly, and the reason it's not is because they assured us that the beginnings of American history through modern times is covered in that course. So that's why we didn't include that course in this bill at all.
▶ Play
President Harris, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Ms. Gordon, if I'm not mistaken, when I was in a history major, and not all kids go to college, so just to be clear, so this is why it needs to be taught in K-12, but the fact is that those are the, there's two courses. It's 1820 through is taught in college in those two sections.
▶ Play
Is that not correct? Well, yes, and it was my understanding that they were taught similarly to that up until these go into effect in July. And that was one of my biggest concerns. My fear is that the college level, which is tending at times to focus on more modern events, is pushing down into the public schools. At least that's what I'm getting from the folks who don't agree with me in our discussions. And my concern is that the vast majority of Arkansans do not go to college. I wish they did. If I could change that, I would in a second. But they do not. And the period that we're asking that the teachers in the classrooms evaluate and say, do I need to review this for this child, is covered in fifth grade. So that could be seven years since they have covered that material when they are taking some of these classes. And in regards to as far as the curriculum itself, Something I did want to mention that might be relevant is the – I've actually – actually, I took this from a letter that – from some of our correspondence with the ADE. in the civics class they listed non-learning expectations that reference the period of time that we want the classroom teachers to be able to review that's a high school level civics class in the U.S. history since 1890 they referenced non-learning expectations that reference and need background knowledge of the period we're wanting reviewed that the committee and that the ADE has approved to go in to effect July. Nine different learning expectations refer to the period that we're talking about. And then also there are several learning expectations in the U.S. government. I didn't write the exact number down. I could count them quickly for you because I have the correspondence. I'm sorry. I'm going to
▶ Play
interject here a little bit. We are going to run out of time, so you can go ahead and finish
▶ Play
with your question and then. MS. Okay. No, I just want to, before anyone asks for my transcript, I switched majors to child development. MR.
▶ Play
Did you really? MS. Thank you. Yes. All right. Thank you. MR. Are there any other questions, committee, before I go to testimony?
▶ Play
Speaker 148 40:22
Seeing no other questions. Oh, I'm sorry, Representative Gray, I missed you. You're recognized. MR. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Mr. Walker touched on this. I don't think there's anybody at this table that thinks it's a bad idea to review this portion of basically the founding and the creation of our country. My question would be to the part that mentions relevant. Can you address the concern that a teacher in our part of the state may find a portion of this relevant, whereas someone in Pulaski County or, say, southwest Arkansas may find other portions relevant? And so we're not getting a uniformity across the state in this period that we're trying to address? First of all, this is a review. So we leave
▶ Play
it to the local control of the teachers that have that classroom. They will know whether those children are brought up to speed, if they have knowledge of that. If they need a review, those teachers will make that decision. This bill asks for the review for those reasons. We allow the teachers to handle that. No one knows those children better than the teacher. So it leaves that up to them. And remember, we change bad laws all the time. This just happened. This is this year that they've changed this. So I think it's our job to make sure that they review some very critical history in our United States, and I think the children deserve that for the future. Thank you. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a short question.
▶ Play
Speaker 16 41:54
So the question would be, when I have a child or a grandchild in 11th grade U.S. history, you're contending that the new standards that we are going to have come into effect this summer in July will not have U.S. history from start to finish. They're going to just have a period of years and there will be some years that will be left out. So when I'm thinking U.S. history, everything, they have narrowed the focus of what they're going to be getting in the 11th grade.
▶ Play
That's correct. And a matter of fact, when someone from the Department of Education came and said, well, just what part do you want us to teach? I'll tell you, I want them to teach from the beginning. It's critical that we teach that. And, yes, the reason for this bill is because the Department of Education has decided to not teach before that period of time. And we have to teach our children
▶ Play
Speaker 16 42:57
well. So they're not taking up before 1820, 1890. Is it okay if I answer you?
▶ Play
Yeah, just a very short answer. The title says 1890 to the present. That's, as a classroom teacher, I can tell you, that's what they will focus on. from 1890 to the present. In fact, in the testimony in the other committee, the ADE assistant commissioner said they want to teach modern U.S. history.
▶ Play
Speaker 16 43:38
So, yes, the answer is yes. Okay. I do see a need for going back, and if I think they're going to have all of U.S. history, I would say that that would need to be in the class, unless there's an explanation of it given to the parents, It doesn't cover all of it. Would that be
▶ Play
what you're contending with this bill? Well, it obviously makes sure that the teacher, if their students have missed four or five years of learning history or have not had a review in that time, it certainly has them, and those teachers will know, and they will be able to review that area. But we need this bill to give instruction, to give review if the children do not know in their classroom or if they feel like they need
▶ Play
to bring them up to speed. Thank you. All right, we're going to go to testimony from the audience. First off, I have Chuck West against. Chuck, are you ready? If you will take the end of the table and state your name and who you're with, you'll recognize to speak against
▶ Play
the bill. any place down there as long as there's a mic in
▶ Play
front of you and get that mic up a little
▶ Play
close so we can hear you and turn it on like that yes sir uh thank you sir my name is my name is chuck west i am a u.s history teacher currently i have been teaching u.s history For the better part of 15 years, I teach at Little Rock Central High School. I'm here to express my concerns about this bill for a number of reasons. First and foremost, I believe, is the – I believe it's going to lead to a negative impact on students. In fact, the current curriculum, which is set to go into effect July of this coming summer, was designed with the input of teachers, college professors, and members of the Arkansas Department of Education. with students is the primary focus it is designed to address some concerns I think that most of us could relate to you know if you think back to your own high school experience I graduated in 89 myself we never got past 1950 and I think if I want my students who will be voting in next year or two to be educated voters they need to have had some time after that there's a as you know an unlimited number of demands but a limited amount of time the other thing is this is that the focus now is not simply on rote memorization of dates and facts and so forth but I'm trying to teach the process scholarship and methodology is a big component of this bill I've noticed that there's a emphasis on local control I do feel as though it's important to note that actually I have no local control and my district did vote for board members but but that's no longer in place so I am concerned about that I'm also concerned about the impact on me is simply a professional I am I've been doing this for a few years I know my students well I know when they're sick I know what they did over spring break I feel
▶ Play
like I'm gonna interject again we're gonna need to hurry these up so I don't mind your testimony and if you could stay directly on what it does but we're gonna give everyone else three minutes and you're about a minute and a half into yours and I'm without objection from the
▶ Play
committee three minutes okay you got another minute and a half all right well I'm finally I'll say this I'm relieved it sets a very bad precedent I believe that this is micromanagement. It is coming not from educators. It is actually not what I teach when I teach Jeffersonian politics. This is not in line with what Thomas Jefferson would have said, and I suppose that's about all I would like, and I
▶ Play
know that pretty well. I have a question for
▶ Play
you from Representative Harris. You just mentioned one of the best presidents in the United States. John Adams is my favorite. But Thomas Jefferson would not be taught. Is that not correct? Well, first of
▶ Play
all, I think that you have to give some credit to the professionals who would be able to incorporate that when necessary. That's not true at all. I teach those principles all the time, Jeffersonian ideals. I think what's important is this. This would reserve some time so that we could teach things that were mentioned earlier, things like the Vietnam era, things like the Reagan Revolution, things like economics of the 1990s and the early 2000s. I would think that you would like for us to be able to talk about the September 11th attack. As it is right now, it's very difficult to get that far. This would preserve some time. In an ideal situation, we would do everything all the time. But as you all know, that's simply not practical. I
▶ Play
Speaker 162 48:42
have a very important follow-up. You are
▶ Play
welcome to ask for a follow-up. You mentioned something about professors being involved in this. Yes. Yes, sir. And the problem I have with that is I've heard from a lot of the professors nowadays they're not of conservative mindset. I mean, when you say that, is that a plifera of all across the board or just of one mindset?
▶ Play
at? I'm not sure I understood that question sir. Was everyone brought to the table? Well everyone is a lot of quite a large number. I know that as the bill indicates that there are lots of professionals involved. Scholars both at the college level and also at the secondary education level. Okay
▶ Play
thank you. Yes, sir. Any other questions? Thank you, sir. Thank you. Dr. Carter. Yeah, okay. I have Ken Yang to speak for the bill. State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized to speak for
▶ Play
Speaker 170 49:54
the bill. Thank you. My name is Ken Yang. I'm actually with Arkansas. Three minutes. Three minutes. Got it. I'm actually with Arkansas Family Council. and y'all know my boss Jerry Cox and he usually is the one that testifies and his staff typically doesn't testify but I found myself inclined to and because this is a very important bill and a very good bill and I'm going to if you indulge me I'm going to go about it a different way from my experience. I learned all of that history that the previous teacher said was stopped at 1950. I learned from the very start of America to the very end. I'm a first generation immigrant. My dad fled communist China in 1949. I can't imagine my parents coming here knowing that their children want to learn how great America is and why we became that great. This bill does just that, that we are the greatest country in the world, that we talk about the 13 colonies, that we talk about why the pilgrims came to America for religious freedom, that we talk about the Declaration of Independence and the signing of how Jackson was nine years old, Hamilton was 21, Burr was 20, Madison was 25 years old, John Jay 30, Jefferson 33, and to make us all feel better, Benjamin Franklin was 70. But that was a joke. But I remember doing a report on Eli Whitney that, you know, under the new standards, we probably wouldn't talk about Eli Whitney and mention the Cotton Gem, that I wouldn't look on microfilm and read the Pennsylvania Gazette. And yes, I'm old enough to know what microfilm is. But we need to learn about our past, about the mistakes we made, whether it's manifest destiny, slavery, the French Indian War, but also about our successes and what makes us a great country. George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, Alexander Hamilton, and I can't imagine being an immigrant, having a lineage where we fled communist China, that we don't talk about those things that make us a great country today. And I asked teachers in the Department of Education to answer the question of not what you can't do for our next generation, but what can I do so that the students of our next generation learn these things. Because in other countries, they have over 2,000 years of history that they teach in their schools, and yet somehow we seem to have a problem teaching roughly 275 years of history. So I ask this committee to please vote this bill out and to support it. Thank you so much for having me. Thank
▶ Play
you. Colleagues, we have five minutes before the next. Here's what I'm going to ask. I would like to give her time to close. I have more for and against the testimony, but we have another committee starting, actually other royal committee starting in five minutes. so if you're willing to let her close for this or you want to hear more testimony I'll give them two minutes if you want to bring them up Dr. Jones if you want to come up
▶ Play
they have some questions Good morning, Debbie Jones Assistant Commissioner of Learning Services I just want to speak on the bill the ADE does not write standards this is a thorough process set forth by the rules that are written, which are written to the law. On this particular, on the social studies standards, we had 47 districts involved in the process. Some of those districts sent multiple teachers. We had four institutes of higher ed, Arkansas Virtual, Economics Arkansas, the Federal Reserve Bank, the Butler Center, and Economics Arkansas all participated in the democratic process. The standards further require that our teams review state standards from across the nation, that they study and consider evaluation from national groups and organizations, that they include Arkansas teachers, instructional supervisory personnel, and administrators, and that we have a paid external review of the standards by recognized content experts when these teachers came to the table to write the standards which is a two two week long intense prod project during the summer a lot of the comment you heard from the teachers was to correct that concern that we could not get to contemporary history so they intentionally set forth on this time period however within that committee they decided that they would write review units. For example, in the U.S. history the unit is designed to be a three to four week process to review the very important subjects mentioned here today. So that's already in process. Two of those units are completed and teachers along with Arkansas Department of Ed are now completing the third part of that. These standards have been approved by the State Board of Education and And should this review be required of the civics course, okay, this is my final point, it will, for the civics course, which is a semester-long course, it will use almost a fourth of the instructional days should they use that review unit.
▶ Play
Thank you. All right. You may close. You have one minute
▶ Play
to close. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. just to address the things that were not mentioned not once did Mrs. Jones talk about the children and what they should be learning we are a young country if we cannot teach the history of this nation to teach patriotism then what are we doing you will see changes in the years to come and they won't be pleasant this is not just coming from educators it's families, grandparents called and we're outraged when they found out this information our job is to correct errors That's what we do. We pass laws to correct errors, and I'm asking you to do that so that there may be review of our history, the beginning history. And this does not change one word of the standard. It encourages review. I am closed in my view, and I'd like to have a good vote. What's the will
▶ Play
of the committee? I have a motion to do pass from Representative Douglas. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. Motion carries. You have passed your bill. thank you thank you and uh without objection we are adjourned i know meetings are starting i possibly might have to have a concur motion this afternoon or tomorrow on a bill's coming out of the senate but we will call of the chair
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1600

0:16 - 3:41 14 segments 5 speakers

HB1597

3:41 - 6:37 16 segments 7 speakers

HB1961

6:37 - 7:43 5 segments 2 speakers

HB1663

7:43 - 14:48 23 segments 6 speakers

SB968

14:48 - 19:03 22 segments 7 speakers

SB615

19:03 - 20:37 3 segments 2 speakers

SB776

20:37 - 24:55 21 segments 4 speakers

SB1007

24:55 - 57:05 88 segments 12 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative John W. Walker Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 16
13 segments
Speaker 9
3 segments
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
46 segments
Speaker 21
1 segment
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 40
1 segment
Chair Unverified
26 segments
Representative Greg Leding Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 63
4 segments
Speaker 74
2 segments
Senator Jane English Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 148
5 segments
Speaker 95
1 segment
Senator Gary Stubblefield Unverified
2 segments
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 115
4 segments
Speaker 66
2 segments
Barbara Gordon Unverified
17 segments
Representative Justin T. Harris Unverified
4 segments
My Name Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 162
1 segment
Speaker 170
6 segments
Brittany Stockton Unverified
5 segments