Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

April 2, 2015

April 2, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (24)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SJR16 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SJR16”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1529 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…speaker we your committee on judiciary to whom is referred house bill 1529 beg lead report we've had the same under consideration here…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1645 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ker we your committee on transportation to whom is referred house bill 1645 beg lead to report we've had the same under consideration h…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB975 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…speaker we are committee on judiciary to whom was referred senate bill 975 beg lee report we've had the same amount of consideration h…”
Pre-2017 bill
SJR3 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SJR3”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1239 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1239”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1371 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1371”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1377 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1377”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1610 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1610”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1779 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1779”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1790 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1790”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1904 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1904”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1007 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1007”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1018 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1018”
Pre-2017 bill
SB124 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB124”
Pre-2017 bill
SB404 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB404”
Pre-2017 bill
SB459 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB459”
Pre-2017 bill
SB462 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB462”
Pre-2017 bill
SB776 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB776”
Pre-2017 bill
SB831 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB831”
Pre-2017 bill
SB854 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…he Senate respectfully requests the return to the Senate of Senate Bill 854, respectfully submitted, A.M. Cornwell. is leave granted to…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB943 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB943”
Pre-2017 bill
SB967 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB967”
Pre-2017 bill
SB983 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB983”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
Speaker 1 0:00
representatives that meet here in the House chamber every year. Each member...
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 0:30
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
all right members the house will be called into order at this time i invite members staff press and guests in the galleries to stand and be led today in prayer by the reverend jimmy fisher who is here from Pine Bluff today as a guest of Representatives Holcomb and Ken Ferguson and then to remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance to be led today by Representative Marshall
▶ Play
Speaker 10 2:17
Wright. Let us bow our heads. God, we thank
▶ Play
Speaker 11 2:23
you for this day. I pray God for these men and these women you have so graciously placed for us our governor, our representatives of this house and their families and God I pray that their hearts are with you when they come together today to pass the laws that governs this great state of Arkansas in your son Jesus name I pray Amen I
▶ Play
Speaker 13 2:59
pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, and indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
▶ Play
All right, members, let's mark our presents by hitting our yellow present buttons. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 3:54
Let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
With 100 present, the chair sees a quorum. All right, Representative John Vine's moves that we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal without objection, so ordered. Are there reports from select committees, Mr. Clerk? Are there reports from standing committees, Mr. Clerk?
▶ Play
Speaker 27 4:54
please read those reports at this time mr speaker we your committee on transportation to whom is referred house bill 1645 beg lead to report we've had the same under consideration here with return the same recommendation do concur in senate amendment number four respectfully submitted representative prissy hickerson chair mr speaker we your committee on judiciary to whom is referred house bill 1529 beg lead report we've had the same under consideration here with return the same the recommendation that do concur and send an amendment number one respectfully submitted representative marshall wright chair mr speaker we are committee on judiciary to whom was referred senate bill 975 beg lee report we've had the same amount of consideration herewith return the same the recommendation do pass respectfully submitted representative marshall wright chair Thank you.
▶ Play
All right, is there any unfinished business? Are there any executive communications? All right, please read the letter from the Senate, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
April 2nd, 2015, to the Honorable Sherri Stacks, Dear Ms. Stacks, the Senate respectfully requests the return to the Senate of Senate Bill 854, respectfully submitted, A.M. Cornwell. is leave granted to return Senate Bill
▶ Play
Speaker 38 7:14
854 back to the Senate send the bill back to the Senate
▶ Play
Mr. Clerk Reed, HMR 1004. House Memorial Resolution
▶ Play
1004 by Representative Flowers to honor Clark Terry Jr. for his contributions to music and to promote the importance of musical performance and the music industry in arkansas
▶ Play
representative flowers you're recognized to present your resolution thank you mr
▶ Play
speaker if i could ask representative ferguson to join me yes you may thank you you. Colleagues, today Representative Ferguson and I are presenting this House Memorial Resolution honoring the work and the contributions of Mr. Clark Terry Jr. Since his wife was unable to join us this session, as she just recently lost her husband, and since we're at the end of the session, You won't hear the resolution in its entirety, but I would like to say that Mr. Terry was born a Missouri resident, but when he passed away, he was an Arkansas resident. He was a profoundly successful jazz musician who began making instruments with his brother out of household items because they couldn't afford instruments. He became a teacher, he became a mentor and he actually taught at UAPB and on his last days Wynton Marcellus along with several other musicians from all over the country honored him and came to Pine Bluff before his death and played for him. He performed on The Tonight Show with the Johnny Carson. He was a winner of many many Grammy Awards and I just think that it was important to recognize his contributions and ask for your support and thank you for your attention and if Representative Ferguson has anything to add of course he doesn't okay thank you very much Representative Flowers has explained the resolution.
▶ Play
The question before the house is the passage of HMR 1004. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed nay. The ayes have it. Resolution has passed. Members, we have some guests here today, guest of Representative Les Eves. We have Kyla Soden, who's Paige today, she's also the Miss White River Outstanding Teen and will be competing for Miss Arkansas Outstanding Teen in June, so please join me in welcoming her here. In the North Gallery, we have a guest of Representative Michelle Gray, the Israel County Judge, David Sherrill. also in the north gallery the guest of representative michelle gray and representative payton is the stone county judge stacy abe also it's a special day for a couple of people around the chamber and a member of our staff, it's Roy Ragland's birthday as well. All right, members, we're going to go to the first supplemental calendar at this time. Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 59 12:24
Clerk, read SJR 3. Senate Joint
▶ Play
Resolution 3 by Senator Williams to amend an amendment to the Arkansas Constitution to allow the governor to retain his or her powers and duties
▶ Play
when absent from the state. Representative Lanny Fite, you're
▶ Play
recognized to explain the resolution. This will probably be one of the most simple constitutional amendments that you will see on the ballot. It simply states that an amendment to the Arkansas Constitution to allow the governor to retain his or her powers and duties while absent from the state. I would be willing to answer any questions at
▶ Play
this time. I appreciate a good vote. Representative Feit has explained the resolution. Would anyone like to speak against the resolution? For the resolution? Representative Feiter, you close for your resolution. Question before the house is the passage of SJR 3. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
Speaker 39 13:56
Has everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
With 80 yeas, 0 nays, and 0 presents, the resolution is passed. Mr. Clerk, read SJR 16.
▶ Play
Senate Joint Resolution 16 by Senator Woods to an amendment to the Arkansas Constitution to encourage job creation, job expansion, and economic development. Representative Eades,
▶ Play
you're recognized to explain the resolution. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues,
▶ Play
Speaker 74 14:47
this is what I've spent the last five years doing in my regular job is economic development, and this is part of the reason I wanted to be down here. I'm going to tell you just briefly a couple things about SJR 16. If you're interested in economic development and jobs creation, this is the thing that we want to put out on the ballot and give people a chance to vote for. Three areas that I'm going to kind of focus on that this does, one is Article 12, Section 5. Currently, there are 16 cities and four to five counties in Arkansas that have decided to make a decision at the local level to tax themselves for economic development projects. Currently, the way our Constitution reads, they have limited capability of what they can do with that money, so this clarifies that so that they can use this for a variety of different economic development projects and infrastructure, things like that. The second thing this does is focuses on amendment 62. Currently, cities can bond for projects but only can do infrastructure with these projects. This allows, again, local control. Our cities have the opportunity to use this money to be able to provide incentives, other things that they want to do to attract business to their city. And then the third thing that this does is it affects Amendment 82, which was the amendment that allows us to be in the game on super projects. Currently, we have one super project that we're working on. We are reaching close to our cap. If recently it's been announced that Volvo is looking at the possibility of doing a project in the United States, If we don't do something to change this, then we would be completely out of the ball game for super projects for the next five to 10 years without some kind of change. So this gives us an opportunity to be competitive. Three different areas, amendment 82 for super projects, amendment 62 for bonding, and then also article 12 section five where cities can use their local economic development taxes. And I would appreciate a good vote. REPRESENTATIVE WHITAKER FOR
▶ Play
Speaker 47 16:50
WHAT PURPOSE QUESTION YOU RECOGNIZE FOR A QUESTION THANK YOU MR SPEAKER UH
▶ Play
REPRESENTATIVE UH I'M JUST CURIOUS WAS THERE ANY THOUGHT GIVEN TO RAISING THE CAP RATHER THAN WIPING IT OUT ALL TOGETHER
▶ Play
Speaker 74 17:00
WELL THAT'S A GOOD QUESTION UM WE ARE CLOSE ENOUGH TO THE CAP AND THEN THE CONCERN SEVERAL PEOPLE HAVE IS DO WE NEED TO YOU KNOW IF WE HAVE OTHER OPPORTUNITIES WOULD WE NEED TO KEEP COMING BACK THIS DOESN'T TAKE AWAY ANY OF THE OVERSIGHT that the legislature or the executive body has so still if it's not a good project they're still going to come through this body to determine if it's good or not we ultimately have the determination to make that decision this gives us the flexibility to at least be at the table on any project we want to consider thank you i
▶ Play
would appreciate a good vote thank you representative eads has explained the resolution would anyone like to speak against the resolution for the resolution representative house you're recognized to speak against the resolution
▶ Play
i did tell representatives i was going to speak against this bill i find it morally repugnant to be frankly honest about it when we did the big big river steel project two years ago we were told we were going to borrow 125 million dollars give it to this company and then pay back that loan at interest, and that would help develop that steel mill. That was great as far as it went. When you put a paper and pencil to see how much money actually went to that project, we actually took $600 million away from the taxpayers and presented it to that company. Why $600 million? Number one, $125 million. Number two, about $175 million in interest. Number three, $270 million in tax credits. Number four, free land. Number five, job development costs. Number six, development of that land. Number seven, expedited environmental protection permits, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. So what started off as a good idea of a $125 million loan cost the taxpayers $600 million. reason that this proposed constitutional amendment, in my opinion, is dead wrong is because it takes off the limits, number one, of how much money a legislature can borrow and give to a corporation. It's corporate welfare, pure and simple. Number two, it puts no limits on what a city or county can borrow payable back with a debt payable back by tax revenues, general revenues, and it removes all of those limits. This is not a good bill. We have a history, if you studied Arkansas history, and I know most of you have, we had the Holford bonds where people would go out and borrow money in the name of the state and use real estate as collateral. We had railroad bonds that people would go out and borrow money to build railroads and it bankrupted the state this is so outlandish that i'm sorry i can't support it and i find it just to be another case of corporate welfare and and i won't support it it's one thing to take money and invest it into an enterprise and if the enterprise makes money great we get a return on my our money but if it loses money then we lose the money and we know that going in but just to give away money in the hopes that things will work out great is a disaster waiting to happen talk about just for instance let's talk about steel mills whether you're talking about new core or big river if the coal band goes through at the federal level prices on energy are going to go up about 400 percent four times the current electric bills now what kind of economic model are those folks are going to have to operate in does it make any difference they've already got the 125 we've got to repay the interest and they've got the 270 million in tax credits plus the land and everything else what is the state left with a debt for that reason i'm going to urge you to
▶ Play
vote no on this thank you representative walker for what purpose
▶ Play
question you recognize for a question representative house are you familiar with the effort by several states including Arkansas, to lure the film industry to Arkansas and to Louisiana? Yes, sir. And how that turned out in Louisiana? Yes, sir. I am very familiar with that.
▶ Play
Speaker 86 21:26
Would you share that with the members of this house? Yes, sir. We
▶ Play
were asked in the Agriculture Committee to approve another scheme to provide tax credits and benefits to the film industry. I looked it up on the Times-Picayune record. I'm sorry, I don't have personal knowledge, so I'll tell you where my information comes. The state of Louisiana spent $4.28 of taxpayer money in order to receive $1 of tax revenue. Four to one, $4.28 to one. And that's what we're winding up doing. We're spending more money, and we're not getting the kind of return. We're spending taxpayer money, and we're not getting a return where we're getting the money back. And for that reason, I'm dead set against
▶ Play
Speaker 89 22:14
it. Representative Hammer, for what purpose? Question, please. You're recognized for a question. You
▶ Play
referenced about not getting a return on your money as a result, and you cited the steel mill and everything. I remember sitting in this chamber, and we were told by other entities that wanted to use not only maybe taxpayers' money, but maybe membership money like the teacher retirement system to invest in that. So I'm just curious, how does all that tie in together with what this SJR 16 does? And if there's a risk that we're exposed at one level, would that risk transfer to those other entities that are invested in those projects or what this would
▶ Play
allow as well? Well, understand something. There's a difference between investing and risk. The teacher retirement invested, was it $125 million or $75 million? I'm sorry, I don't remember the figure, and their board of directors voted to invest in this enterprise, and if that enterprise makes money, the teacher retirement will get a return on it. They also got tax credits, which we authorized by a piece of legislation a few weeks ago. They can now sell, the teacher retirement can now sell those tax credits to other businesses and investments, which they can use to diminish their tax liability to the state of Arkansas. So the teacher retirement is making money on their investment. If that investment goes through, they stand to make more money. If it fails, they stand to lose money. So that's fine investment. The state of Arkansas is not exactly in the same position. We're giving the money away. If it fails, we've got some jobs, but we're not getting back in terms of revenue, in terms of taxes, is what we tax those workers and those investors that we're putting out for them to come here to begin with. I hope I've answered your question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative
▶ Play
House has spoken against the resolution. Would anyone like to speak for the resolution? Representative Douglas, you're recognized to speak for the
▶ Play
resolution. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, we've got problems in this state. Our prisons are full. A third of our people are on some type of Medicaid. We've got issues. And the solution to these issues is jobs. We've got to create jobs in this state. And the three pillars of economic development are workforce. We have addressed that in this session with a series of bills that Senator English sent down and we passed. We have to train our workforce. The other is infrastructure. this amendment if the voters approve it and remember this is us sending it to the voters of the state of Arkansas the citizens for them to approve if they approve it this will help with local infrastructure there the ability to to build the infrastructure needed to bring jobs forward the other part is economic incentives and I agree with the representative house It is repugnant that we have to buy people off to come to the state and bring jobs here. But it's a fact of life. The old saying, and I don't like this, but if we don't do it, someone else will. That's the facts of life, though, that we have to realize. The thing is, in this whole situation, remember, at the end of the day, whether it's tax incentives, whether it's job incentives, whether it's just giving money away on Amendment 82, that all comes back to this legislature, this House and the Senate to decide if it's a worthwhile project or not. I'd hate to see us lose out on some good projects. And, you know, I happen to be from Bentonville, and a little old company up there talked about reshoring effort to bring manufacturing back to the United States. And in talking to some companies that are called manufacturing site selection firms, they get with manufacturers and see where the best place in the country is for them to locate their business and whenever i ask them where is arkansas on your screen they say it's not on the screen because we're not doing a good enough job in some of these areas and this is a tool in the toolbox to try to help get on the screen i don't want to be looking back 20 years from now if i'm still alive which i doubt it will be the way it's going but uh i don't want to look back and say boy i wish we could say thank god for mississippi but uh they've passed us you know we've got to work to to bring jobs back to the state. That's what we need to solve the problems of prison overcrowding, Medicaid, putting people to work, giving them opportunities to better their lives is the most important thing we can
▶ Play
do. Representative Walker, for what purpose? Question. Recognize for a question.
▶ Play
Yes, Representative Douglas, you are familiar with our efforts to attract the film industry, which we lost to Louisiana and Louisiana is now bankrupt having to rededicate its Medicaid or its tobacco funding in order to be solvent. Do you favor just opening up the entire treasury of the state without any kind of limitations or regulations in order to attract jobs at any price? no sir representative walker i do
▶ Play
not and thank you for that question because if you remember the a new bill came to offer more economic incentives to the film industry and we didn't let it out of committee it died in committee the thing is on all of these you have local government that has the say on whether these incentives are offered in their areas whether they're passed you have the state legislature here to be the final say on this we can always turn them down if they're not a good investment i have people all the time every day i get an email somebody in nigeria has this great investment offer for me and i turn it down it's that simple if it's not good if it doesn't have the proper cap rate or rate of return we can turn it down but if we lose out because we don't have the tools available we'll never get that opportunity again it's opportunity lost but with that i would encourage
▶ Play
you to vote for this bill representative house for
▶ Play
what purpose you're recognized for a question Representative Davis, this is not a gotcha. It's an honest question. We've heard our economic development people report back to us that this incentive or this action or this initiative brought in 100 jobs or 1,500 jobs or 2,000 jobs. Have you ever heard of them giving us a report that we invested $1 and got so many other dollars in return for that investment? Have you ever heard a report of how much money, when we have put into a project, how much money
▶ Play
we have gotten back? In other words, you're saying what our rate of return was on that investment we made? I have not heard of that report, and that's something that we should insist on. Whenever we get these companies in here, these incentives are offered, we must and should insist on getting a report back, a scorecard on that, an investment return.
▶ Play
With that, I've taken enough time. Thank you. representative health has spoken for the resolution would anyone like to speak against the resolution representative bill you're recognized to speak against the resolution
▶ Play
this is a hard one we all want more jobs in our communities but corporate welfare is wrong it's just fundamentally wrong to take the money of the time the taxpayers of the state and give it to corporations. A little while ago, I think a little over a year ago, I had asked our BLR to get some information from me, from AADC, specifically just how much had payroll increased at companies that had received incentives, etc. What I discovered at that time, and I don't remember the exact numbers, so I don't want to overstate it other than to say I know it was in excess of $100 million that we had given out in incentives, and there was something on the order less than 10,000, and I want to say it was around 8,000 jobs created for $120 million cost. I encourage you all to get your calculators out and look at that cost per job and decide if you think that's something, if we're getting a good return on our money. Aside from return, we have a free enterprise system in this country. As long as government's in the business of picking winners and losers and deciding which companies get those benefits versus the ones that don't, we're moving away from free enterprise and not towards it. I hope you all make your vote very carefully. I know this is a tough vote. It's tough for me to be standing here saying
▶ Play
this, but it's time we took a stand. Representative Bell has spoke against the resolution. Would anyone like to speak for the resolution? Representative Lowry, you recognize I speak for the
▶ Play
resolution. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I know sometimes it's very effective to throw out words that all of a sudden are flash words like public money going to corporations. All of a sudden that catches our attention, but really what this also does is it enables partnerships that have taken place very effectively across our state, private public partnerships between cities and chambers of commerce. It enables that. Some of those partnerships that have been very effective have been shut down recently by a Supreme Court ruling, City of North Little Rock I believe was a party in the case, of them being able to cooperatively work with their chamber of commerce in recruitment in retention of companies of trying to expand their economic development i know we have invoked the word local control a lot during this session but this is the ultimate local control resolution you're giving power back to your communities to be able to to negotiate for themselves economic development projects now there there may be aspects of this that have to do with with state uh investment but the most critical part of this is enabling our local communities to be able to build their economies and i would appreciate a good vote representative larry
▶ Play
has spoken for the resolution would anyone like to speak against the resolution for the resolution representative ferguson you're recognized to speak for the resolution
▶ Play
thank you colleagues i hope to ask nate bell representative bell a question before he left and i certainly understand the the corporate welfare argument but we've seen this happen in northeast arkansas when we lost toyota and then we got big river steel it's not just about the industry that you helped start, but it's about all the satellite and spinoff industries that come as a result of that. So you may not get dollar for dollar for the first business that comes, but certainly all of the satellite industries that come as a result of that. And you may not like it, but all of the states around us are doing it, so if we're going to compete as a state, we really
▶ Play
need this vehicle to do that. Representative Walker, you're recognized for
▶ Play
your question. Thank you. Representative Ferguson, have you seen any data which show for the surrounding states like Louisiana that substantial investment in industry which has sought corporate assistance in order to get started has actually resulted in any substantial benefits to the state? And have you seen any documented evidence that has shown that the spinoffs have been, in any particular amount that's measurable. I've been looking for them. I haven't seen any. So if you could
▶ Play
tell me where I could find them, I'd appreciate it. Right. I mean, obviously I don't have it with me, but I mean, I'm in West Memphis and we are the perfect example. We lost Toyota in 2007 and it went to Tupelo, Mississippi. And I've seen for myself driving through there all of the industry that's developed as a result of that. And the film argument really doesn't hold weight with this because that's a completely separate tax that some states have struggled with giving too much tax credit to the film industry. This isn't about film industry. But I don't have any empirical data with me, but I can tell you just from being close to Mississippi and seeing everything that's developed as a result of the industries that have come there, that it absolutely has had a
▶ Play
great economic impact. Go up, please. Can you recognize for your follow-up? My question is, how can we lose something we never had? We lost the film industry, and New Orleans, Louisiana got it, and 200 or more million dollars has bankrupt them. Did we benefit by losing that? Well, that's what I'm saying. The film argument is not
▶ Play
a good one. I'm very familiar with the film industry because, you know, I lived out in Hollywood for five years, and I'm very familiar with that drain that's going to other states. I know Michigan has struggled for the same reasons. This isn't about the film industry. This is about Toyotas and Big River Steels and those kind of industries that you bring to your state. And you're absolutely competing with Mississippi and Texas
▶ Play
and Tennessee to do that. Representative McElroy, for what purpose? Motion, please. Let's hear your motion. Immediate consideration. All right, there's a proper motion. It's not debatable. All in favor of immediate consideration, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. I'm going to rule the ayes have it. This time, the question before the house is the passage of SJR 16. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 39:08
Thank you.
▶ Play
has everyone voted alright let's cast it to ballots Mr. Clerk with 70 yays 22 nays and 1 present the resolution has passed alright members before we proceed any further I'd like for us to welcome our doctor and nurse of the day. We have with us Ms. Brenda Hewitt as our nurse of the day, and our doctor of the day is Dr. Masood. Let's welcome them. Mr. Clerk, let the record reflect that the morning hour ended prior to the consideration of joint resolutions, please. Members, we're going to go back to the main calendar at this point. We're going to pick up with the concurrence and Senate amendments. Okay. We're going to pick up with House Bill 1239, Mr. Clerk. All right, members, Representative Mayberry recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1239. Please read Amendment 1, Mr. Clerk. amendment number one to house bill 1239 representative mayberry you recognize to explain the amendment thank you thank you mr speaker members
▶ Play
i want to remind you we had 80 votes in the house to get it over to the senate in the senate we had 34 this is a very good bill the senate amendment made this revenue neutral zero for fiscal year 16 so it's made the bill even better. I would appreciate a good vote. Thank you. All right, members. You heard an explanation
▶ Play
of the amendment? Would anyone like to speak against the amendment? For the amendment? All right, Representative Mayberry is closed for the amendment. Question now before the House is a concurrence of Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill at 1239. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Everyone voted. I was cast with the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 88 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, we have concurred and sent an amendment 1 to House Bill 1239. Representative Tosh recommends that we concur and sent an amendment 1 to House Bill 1779. Please read the amendment, Mr. Clerk. Amendment number 1 to House Bill 1779. Representative Tosh, you're recognized to explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker. Fellow colleagues, this is the amendments that we promised would be made on the Senate end. This amendment aligns with the Senator Hickey's bill that we passed here in the House just to make sure that there was no conflicting language. I'd appreciate a good vote. All right,
▶ Play
members, you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment? For the amendment, Representative Tosh has signified he's closed for the amendment. the question now before the house concurrence and senate amendment one to house bill 1779 for the machine mr clerk Everyone voted. All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 85 yeas, 5 nays, and 0 present, we've concurred in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1779. Representative Tosh recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1779. Please read the amendment, Mr. Clerk. Amendment 2 to House Bill 1779. Representative Tosh, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Explain the amendment. Mr. Speaker, again, fellow colleagues, this is just to add Senator Hickey as a co-sponsor of this bill. I'd appreciate a good vote. All
▶ Play
right, members, you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment? Representative Tosh signified his close for the amendment. The question now before the House is a concurrence of Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1779. Preparing the machine, Mr. Clerk. Is everyone voted? Let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 91 yeas, 1 nay, and 0 present, we concur in Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1779. Representative Murdoch recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1377. Please read the amendment, Mr. Clerk. Amendment number one to House Bill 1377. Representative Murdoch, you're recognized to explain the amendment. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, it's just the same bill that left here a few weeks ago. It comes back from the Senate with a couple of changes, specifically sponsors that were removed. Appreciate a good vote. all right members you've heard an explanation
▶ Play
of the amendment would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment representative murdoch has signified that he's closed for the amendment the question now before the house is the concurrence and senate amendment one to house bill 1377. prepare the machine mr clerk Let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 68 yays, 12 nays, and one present, we've concurred in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1377. Representative Murdoch recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1377. Please read the amendment, Mr. Clerk. Amendment 2 to House Bill 1377. Representative Murdoch, you're recognized to explain the
▶ Play
amendment. Thank you. Same thing. Excellent. Thank you.
▶ Play
All right. Members, you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment? Representative Murdoch, would you like to close for the amendment? He signified he has done so. The question now before the House is the concurrence of Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1377. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. everyone voted let's cast out the ballots Mr. Clerk with 68 yeas 12 nays and 2 present we've concurred in Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1377 Representative Murdoch recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 3 to House Bill 1377 please read the amendment Mr. Clerk Amendment 3 to House Bill 1377 Representative Murdoch you're recognized to explain the amendment Thank you. Appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment, for the amendment? Representative Murdoch has signified that he's closed for the amendment. The question now before the House is the concurrence of Senate Amendment 3 to House Bill 1377. Prepare the machine, Mr. Kirk. Has everyone voted? I was cast at the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 67 yeas, 13 nays, and two present, we've concurred in Senate Amendment 3 to House Bill 1377. Representative Murdoch recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 4 to House Bill 1377. Please read the amendment, Mr. Clerk. Amendment number 4 to House Bill 1377. Representative Murdoch, you're recognized to explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Appreciate a good vote. all right members you've heard an explanation of the amendment would anyone like speak against the amendment for the amendment our representative murdoch has now signified he's closed for the amendment the question now before the house is concurrency senate amendment four to house bill 1377 prepare the machine mr clerk everyone voted all right let's cast it to ballots mr. clerk with 69 yeas 13 nays and two present we've concurred in senate amendment 4 to house bill 1377 representative wright recommends that we concur and Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1371. Please read the amendment, Mr. Clerk. Amendment number 1 to House Bill 1371. Representative Wright, you're recognized to explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thank you, colleagues.
▶ Play
I just made some technical corrections to the bill we sent out here the other day that tightened up the time periods within which you have to have a PV hearing, parole revocation hearing. Appreciate a good vote. Members,
▶ Play
you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment? For the amendment, Representative Wright has signified he's closed for the amendment. The question now before the House is a concurrence of Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1371. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Everyone voted. all right let's cast it to ballots mr clerk with 94 yeas zero nay and one present we've concurred in senate amendment one to house bill 1371 representative sabin recommends that we concur in senate amendment two to house bill 1904 please read the amendment mr clerk amendment number two to house bill 1904 representative sabin you're recognized to explain the amendment thank you mr
▶ Play
speaker colleagues this amendment truly does make a good bill even better it kind of narrows the focus of the bill it's agreed upon with the Arkansas Bar Association I'd appreciate a good vote thank you alright members you've heard an explanation
▶ Play
would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment Representative Saban has signified his close for the amendment the question now before the house is concurrence of Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1904 prepare the machine Mr. Clerk everyone voted let's cast it to ballots Mr. Clerk with 57 yeas 23 nays and 4 present we've concurred in Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1904 Representative Bell recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1610. Please read the amendment, Mr. Clerk. Amendment number 2 to House Bill 1610. Representative Womack, you're recognized to present the amendment.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, I'm here because Representative Bell gave his word from the well the other day that he would not be back to present another bill. He didn't know that we would be back on this bill, so I'm here to help him keep his word. This amendment very simply corrects the drafting area and adds two words. I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank
▶ Play
you. All right, members, you've heard an explanation. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment? Representative Womack has signified he's closed for the amendment. The question now before the House is a concurrence to Senate Amendment 2 to House Bill 1610. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. so everyone voted all right let's cast the ballots mr. clerk with 92 yeas one nay and zero present we've incurred in senate amendment two to house bill 1610 we're going to pass over the next item on the agenda. We're going to move to the second supplemental calendar at this time. Without objection, Representative Bentley recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 4 to House Bill 1645. Mr. Clerk, please read the amendment. Amendment number four to House Bill 1645. Representative Bentley, you're recognized to explain the amendment. Colleagues, we've
▶ Play
traveled a long journey with this HB 1645, and we're finally back here with an amendment. I think we all can live with a great bill that will help our drug courts give their participants a restricted driving permit, and hopefully we will come hear some good results from this. Thank you for a good vote. It's my amendment, my bill, and I'd appreciate a good vote. all
▶ Play
right members you've heard an explanation of the amendment would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment representative Bentley has signified that she's closed for the amendment the question now before the house is a concurrence of senate amendment 4 to house bill 1645 prepare the machine mr. clerk everyone voted let's cast out the ballots Mr. Clerk alright with 92 yeas 0 nay and zero present, we've concurred and sent an amendment four to House Bill 1645. All right. Without objection, Representative Beck recommends that we concur and sent an amendment one to House Bill 1529. Please read the amendment, Mr. Clerk. Amendment number one to House Bill 1529. Representative Beck,
▶ Play
you're recognized to explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This is an amendment from the Senate side. It really makes a bill a better bill. It gives about a five-year window to clean up anything in the bill that we did before, and I'd appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the
▶ Play
amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment? Representative Beck has signified he's closed for the amendment. question now before the house is a concurrence of senate amendment one to house bill 1529 prepare the machine mr. clerk All right, has everyone voted? Let's cast through the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 75 yeas, 11 nays, and 2 present, we've concurred in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1529. members before we move back over to the regular senate bills i overlooked earlier we have some special guests representative payton we have pastor tim crumpton of cleveland county baptist church and hebrew springs and his son andrew in the north gallery representative payton would like for us to help welcome them. representative smith for what purpose your point of personal privilege is granted
▶ Play
will yield the well to you at this time thank you mr speaker colleagues i made two apologies this morning first to Senator Elliott, sitting to my right, your left, in the North Gallery. And I just want to tell you that I think I made a new friend. She's a gracious lady. She received me warmly. And it's always been something that when someone asks for forgiveness to be granted forgiveness, it makes a big difference. And so I think I made a new friend. So thank you. Thank you very much. Secondly, I met Representative Shepard, and I offered my apology to him. I didn't understand why this bill was important to him, and he explained it to me. And I even mentioned to him, and he said he was good with me. I had mentioned to Senator Elliott earlier this morning and then to Representative Shepard that if I ever got into trouble, I would want to hire him. to represent me he's good at what he does and I appreciate him so after both of those conversations we've cleared the air and I think I'll be a I hope this apology makes a good legislator and even better legislator and I ask you to work with me and forgive me for my emotions
▶ Play
getting the best of me thank
▶ Play
Speaker 180 59:57
you all right members we're going to go back
▶ Play
to the regular calendar Representative of Vines recommends we concur in Senate Amendment to House Bill 1790.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:18
Read the amendment, Mr. Clerk. Amendment number one
▶ Play
to House Bill 1790. Representative Bynes, you're recognized. Famer, Speaker, friends, hopefully for the last time I bring you House Bill 1790. This was the cleanup bill for local option elections. We thought it was a cleanup bill the first time, the second time, and now the third time I've brought it to you. I think everybody in this Capitol or anybody in this branch or any branch of state government has looked at this. This last amendment we changed. Secretary of State back to county clerks at the request of Secretary of State. We had some conflicting language there, so we made that change. Makes no substantive law changes. It was simply a cleanup, and I think after the third time, we got this baby cleaned up, so I would appreciate a positive vote. All right, Representative Vines
▶ Play
has explained the amendment. Would anybody like to speak against the amendment? Or the amendment? All right, the question before the House is concurrence in Senate Amendment No. 1 to House Bill 1790. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Is everyone voted? Is everyone voted? Cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. 83 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present. Amendment is passed. Our members will move on to regular Senate bills. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 943. Senate
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:05
Bill 943 by Senator Elliott. To improve the level of insurance for health care in Arkansas and to require that health insurance information regarding the health care independence program be provided to enrollees of the health care independence program. Representative Ferguson,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Thank you, colleagues. Thank you, Speaker. I think there's been some misunderstanding about what this actually does. It's really just, it's an extension of what Representative Copeland did, saying that the private option ends December of 16. And this is just, it just adds some additional notification language that's actually a cut and paste from Senator Hendren's bill that created the task force. It's just to inform people that it is ending, but the task force is working on these things. That's all it is. It's just an additional notification about the task force, and Senator Hendren is good with the language and is supportive. All
▶ Play
right, Representative Ferguson has explained the bill. Would anybody like to speak against the bill? Representative Copeland, you're recognized to speak
▶ Play
against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thank you, colleagues. I really didn't have—I looked over the bill quite a bit. I didn't have a huge problem at first with the bill until I realized that what they did is basically taken my notification, which was very simple, just that the program ends used the same language as was in SB 96. And then they added, and many of you had this concern about us confusing people and added all this language. So that was a little bit of a concern, but I could live with that. But the problem I had with it was I was never once contacted. I was never once told they were going to piggyback on this notification. And so I felt like, you know, at least I should have been notified that they were going to add this and put it in there. And so I am down here speaking against the bill. I felt like it, you know, just out of courtesy, it should have been vetted between us. I did have one of my colleagues come to me just before Representative Ferguson. Again, I realize she's running this bill, but I felt like there was just a professional courtesy that needed to be extended, especially since my bill was to be very simple, and that was the issue that several of you had, that it was going to be confusing. Now we're adding probably 10 times the text to the original notification, so I'd ask for a no vote. representative blake for what purpose question
▶ Play
uh representative copeland are you against the bill or uh against the process that that this bill came about well you know
▶ Play
Speaker 198 1:04:55
we we've talked a lot about the process
▶ Play
uh and so yes i would say i'm i'm i'm more against the the process of how that happened uh than i am against the bill itself i feel like it does as many of you had concern it does add some confusion and i have no animosity toward at all toward representative ferguson because we've not even spoken about it so no animosity toward or anybody for that matter but it just felt like the very thing that you guys had a problem with that it was going to add confusion really this this adds to that confusion so i would appreciate a no vote yes sir representative hammer for
▶ Play
what purpose question please recognize in the additional language that's been added to it did it change anything as far as the content of what the message was was the messaging changed any by the additional language or or how did it cause it to be uh any more confusing or not could you
▶ Play
Speaker 195 1:05:52
speak to that please that's that's a great question uh representative hammer you
▶ Play
know i i'm learning that a lot of times that if a bill is written i've read this bill three times and i'm not sure and i'm sure people that are much more familiar with the health care industry would be familiar with i don't even know really what they're trying to tell people i i feel like the the the intention is is pure uh but again i believe it would be confusing so i i can't honestly tell you uh if it's in line with with what i was intending to do or not which was simply to say the program's ending, which we all tend to agree, I think. So, thank you so much. Representative Copley has spoken against the bill.
▶ Play
Would anybody like to speak for the bill? Representative Ferguson. Representative Hodges, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Speaker. First of all, I'm speaking for the bill because this is my first time ever getting a well speaking for a bill. So I wanted to do that before session was out today, but really, in all seriousness, we're just making, I mean, I was against the initial letter going out. I didn't think it was a need for it, but if we are going to send one out, we need to let people know the details of what we're doing with the private option, that we are forming a task force to research the options rather than telling them that the private option is going to end. So I think we're making an okay bill a little bit better. So I'd appreciate a good vote. All right, Representative Hodges
▶ Play
has spoken for the bill. Representative Ferguson, would you like to close for your bill?
▶ Play
Sure, and I do want to say to Representative Copeland, And Senator Elliott had talked to me about it when we first passed your bill out of committee, and I really wasn't even aware I was on this bill until it got ready to come to the Senate. So I apologize. I would ordinarily work through that process of talking to someone. But it is just to clarify. I think people are concerned that if you say the private option is ending in 2016, that there would be some confusion. And the three sentences that are taken from the task force language, they address the vulnerable populations, in other words, populations that we probably would have moved off of Medicaid onto the private option that now will need some resources for health care. And it also says that the task force is going to identify who the newly eligible people are that are on the private option now and who those individuals were that previously were on Medicaid. It's just to notify people that, yes, the private option is ending, but the task force is working on solutions, particularly for vulnerable populations on Medicaid.
▶ Play
Representative Collins, World Purpose. Question. Recognized. Thank you. Representative Ferguson, isn't a big part of the intention of this bill is, since the letter may spur some questions, to actually save money in the phone calls and answering some calls by giving people a little bit more information and maybe we can save a little bit of money by having fewer calls to try and understand
▶ Play
what's next? Absolutely. That was one of the concerns that we had in committee when Representative Copeland said the private option is going to end in 2016 is that people's insurance actually would have to be renewed at the beginning in January of 2016. So we just wanted, we didn't want this plethora of phone calls going, oh, my gosh, my insurance is ending and what am I supposed to do? So this was to sort of create some comfort for people to know that the task force is working on the vulnerable population aspect of Medicaid. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 211 1:09:55
Farrar, for what purpose? You're recognized. Will this letter be written in a simple language where I can understand it? Do what? Will this letter be written in such a simple language where
▶ Play
I can understand it? It's three sentences that will come after the January 16th day. I
▶ Play
Speaker 211 1:10:13
think the way it's written right now, it's just real complicated, but it
▶ Play
will be written in real simple language. Yes, this is just cut and paste from the bill, but it can be identified very simply. I appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Thank you. All right, Representative Ferguson has closed for a bill. Members, the question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 943. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Is everyone voted? Everyone voted. Cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. 54 yay, 24 nay, and one present. The bill is passed. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 1007.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:11:03
Senate Bill 1007 by Senator Colin Smith et al. To amend provisions of the Arkansas Code concerning United States history
▶ Play
courses and public schools. Representative Gray,
▶ Play
you're recognized to explain the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This bill, or the idea behind this bill, was brought to Senator Colin Smith by a number of constituents and teachers alike. Starting this next school year, history prior to 1890 is being only, they're only going to be taught it once, and that will only be in the fifth grade. So they're not going to be taught it repeatedly throughout high school so that they can get a mastery of our history. And I feel it's very important to know where you are and where you're going to know where you came from. I do not want to lose that history. So that's all this bill does, and it does not mandate anything. It gives the teachers the liberty to add it into their curriculum as they feel right. and there's no extra cost to the state or to the schools this information is readily available on the internet and textbooks that they already have this is essentially for the teachers they've asked to be able to teach history prior to 1890 in their classrooms so i would appreciate a good vote thank you representative graz explain the bill would anybody like
▶ Play
to speak against the bill for the bill. Seeing none, the question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 1007. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Is everyone voted? Is everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. 61 yea, 7 nay, 2 present The bill is passed Mr. Clerk,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:13:09
please read Senate Bill 124 Senate Bill 124 by Senator Johnson to make technical corrections to Title 17 of the Arkansas Code concerning professions, occupations, and
▶ Play
businesses Representative Vines, you're recognized to explain the bill Thank you, Mr. Speaker Friends, this is Senate Bill 124 It's part of those bills that we batched the other day the technical corrections This one got held back because I had to make you an amendment. Again, technical correction, clean-up language, so I appreciate a positive vote. Representative Vines has explained the
▶ Play
bill. Would anybody like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Seeing none, the question for the House is the passage of Senate Bill 124. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Is everyone voted? Is everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. With 83 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill is passed. Mr. Clerk, please read
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:14:15
Senate Bill 983. Senate Bill 983 by Senator Woods. To create the open data and transparency task force to determine the best practices for the state to achieve the most efficient system for maintaining and delivering the state's public records and data.
▶ Play
Representative Letting, you're recognized to explain the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, I'm presenting this bill on behalf of Representative Micah Neal, the House sponsor who can't be here with us today. We produce a lot of government data and it can be put to some really great use and we'd like to make sure that it's out there for companies that would like to use it in a responsible way. As an example, those of you who were here two years ago might remember that we passed the open checkbook bill. We spent half a million dollars doing that. It was a great idea, but had that data been out there available for private entity a company could have done that and the state wouldn't have had to spend any money so all this bill does is going to put together a group of people that's going to spend the next year looking at what state data we could safely and responsibly put out there for private entities to uh to help generate great ideas appreciate a good vote representative letting has explained the bill would anybody like to speak against the bill Before the bill? Seeing none, the question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 983. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Is everyone voted? Is everyone voted? Cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. 53 yea, 16 nay, and 2 present. The bill is passed. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 404. Senate Bill 404 by Senator Clark
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:15:57
to increase the amount of lottery revenue available for lottery scholarships. Representative Hammer, are you recognized to explain the bill? Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Speaker. I think this is the last lottery bill we'll be dealing with this session, and you can go out on a good note by voting for this bill that Senator Clark, I'm carrying this bill for, will be able to put $600,000 to $700,000 average dollars back into the lottery by making adjustments in two areas. I'll be glad to answer any questions. Representative Lundstrom, for what purpose? A question.
▶ Play
You're recognized. This money is already in the education
▶ Play
budget currently, that is correct? Yes. So we're not allocating new money? No, we are not allocating any new money. As with any new startup, of which the lottery started several years ago, as we've rocked along, we've had to make adjustments. Two areas that Senator Clark identified where there was areas that we could actually retrieve money back from areas where it was being spent and redirect it back to our constituents. One was in the area of the $200,000 that was set aside to cover the hotline for gamblers with problems to call in. And then the other one was in the area of higher ed, where they were charging a fee to administer the scholarship application. I think they had like $800,000, and Senator Clark working with the Department of Ed, Department of Finance and Administration, and also the governor's office, they've all worked together in order to be able to realize they don't need $800,000 to administer it. So it's just redirecting that money back. Thank you. thank you this is one you can vote for and feel really good because it's about six to seven hundred thousand dollars it's going to go back in your kids pocket instead of higher ed or to the gamblers hotline thank you all right representative
▶ Play
hammer has explained the bill would anybody like to speak against the bill for the bill seeing none the question for the house is the passage of senate bill 404 Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Is everyone voted? Is everyone voted? Cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. Bill 75, 79, yay, 2, nay, and 0 present. The bill is passed. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 776. Senate
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:18:38
Bill 776 by Senator Elliott to provide for in-state, in-county, in-district, local, or resident tuition for veterans and their dependents, regardless of their residence. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized to
▶ Play
present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
Colleagues, this is a simple bill. All it's going to do is provide in-state tuition for military if they serve 90 days and they have to use it within three years. So it's a good bill. It's going to take care of our soldiers. Some of them relocate into the state, and some of them will probably stay. And they serve a great purpose for this country, to keep our freedom. Representative Collins, for what purpose?
▶ Play
I have a question. You're recognized. Representative Armstrong, is there any provision in here for honorable discharge,
▶ Play
Speaker 228 1:19:26
other than honorable discharge, dishonorable discharge? No, it's not. I
▶ Play
didn't see any. but I'm sure that there's provisions in the federal bill that provides for honorable and dishonorable discharges. Colleagues, I'd like to have a good vote. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 229 1:19:42
All right. Representative Armstrong has explained the bill.
▶ Play
Would anybody like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Seeing none, the question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 776. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. everyone voted everyone voted cast up the ballots mr. clerk 84 yay 0 nay and 0 present bill is passed House is going to stand at recess until 245.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:21:01
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
The House will be called back into order at this time. Mr. Clerk, please read the letter from the governor. April 2,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:22:28
2015, to the Speaker of the House, Dear Mr. Speaker, this is to inform you that on April 1st, 2015, the following measures from the regular session of the 90s General Assembly have been approved. House Bill 1008 is Act 866, House Bill 1041 is Act 867, House Bill 1059 is Act 868, House Bill 1084 is Act 869, House Bill 1137 is Act 870, House Bill 1152 is Act 871, House Bill 1155 is Act 872, House Bill 1599 is Act 873, House Bill 1638 is Act 874, House Bill 1674 is Act 875. House Bill 1706 is Act 876. House Bill 1707 is Act 877. House Bill 1777 is Act 878. House Bill 1788 is Act 879. House Bill 1797 is Act 880. House Bill 1874 is Act 881. House Bill 1886 is Act 882. Sincerely, Asa Hutchinson. Thank you, Mr. Clerk. All right,
▶ Play
members, we're going to pick back up where we left off earlier. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 967. Senate Bill
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:23:32
967 by Senator Woods. Too many ethics laws of the state of Arkansas.
▶ Play
Representative Sabin, you're recognized to present Senate Bill
▶ Play
967. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, you may remember yesterday I brought you House Bill 1901, which was the House version of this bill. We were trying to move things along since the Senate had dragged its feet. seem to be the required inspiration because the Senate has now sent us SB 967, which is identical to what you passed yesterday with one exception, a small amendment that allows county political committees also to make political contributions to campaigns. That's the only change. I'd be glad to take any questions. Otherwise, I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you. All
▶ Play
right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill, Representative Saban has signified he's closed. The question now before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 967. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
Speaker 125 1:24:46
Building on the bill, hands emergency clause. as everyone voted cast
▶ Play
up the machines Mr. Clerk with 92 yeas 0 nay and 1 present the bill and its emergency clause have passed alright this time members we're going to go we're going to go to the second supplemental calendar consideration of some logistical matters that we're going to be dealing with we're going to go at this point to Senate Bill 975. Mr. Clerk, read Senate Bill 975.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:25:52
Senate Bill 975 by Senator Hutchinson et al. To amend Arkansas's law concerning the free exercise of religion to enact the Religious Freedom Restoration Act and to
▶ Play
declare an emergency. All right, without objection, Representative Ballinger, You're recognized
▶ Play
to present Senate Bill 975. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Okay, here we are one more time. Senate Bill 975 is essentially the federal RFRA. What we've done is we've Arkansas-nized it, I guess. We've made it apply to the appropriate Arkansas code. We've referenced the right things. There's one change where we exempt the Department of Corrections, Community of Corrections, and other institutions, which was a part of the House Bill 1228. And essentially, what we started with and what I said from the very beginning with 1228 is it was a RFRA, very similar to the federal RFRA. only what we've done is we've went out and we've gotten jurisprudence from cases and bring it in and that we've we've gotten definitions from cases and bring it in however the confusion that was associated with 1228 and the misconception that was associated with 1228 has caused enough of enough problems that we figured we'd go back to the drawing board work on something that we can have some real unity on and try to get everybody together on essentially the the whole purpose and intent of the bill which is that to get get for our people a strict scrutiny standard a heightened protection so people can believe what they want to believe without having government interfere with that and so that's what we're getting done with senate bill 1975 our citizens when we're done are going to be protected they're going to have the ability to have to have a defense or claim when they have their religious protections uh their their religion's burden and And that's essentially what we're looking for. And so I would appreciate a good vote from my members. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Bentley, I apologize, but I think Representative Ballinger had left the well. Yeah. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill, Representative Bennett, you're recognized to
▶ Play
speak for the bill. thank you mr speaker colleagues as a legislator as an arkansan and as a christian today i come to you very proud of us i'm proud of our process i think even when this body has had differences we have all worked together in a very bipartisan method to work out our problems and i think all All of us should leave here giving ourselves a big pat on the back. This is a great way for us to end the session here before Easter to protect our religious freedoms by passing a bill that does just that. This bill is clearly and directly modeled after the Federal Religious Freedom Act, and it does provide many protections to us in the state of Arkansas. I particularly want to thank all the corporations that came out and helped make this a better bill. So I appreciate Representative Ballinger's hard work. I appreciate everyone else's hard work that has gone into this. I think this bill is a great replacement for 1228. And I really want to thank all my colleagues and appreciate a really good vote on this. All right, members, Representative Bennett has spoken for the bill. Would anyone
▶ Play
like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Walker, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I WISHED MS. BENNETT HAD REMAINED, BECAUSE WHEN SHE GAVE CREDIT TO THE CORPORATIONS AND THE OTHERS WHO LOBBIED TO CAUSE PRINCIPLE TO PREVAIL OVER OPPORTUNISM, She did not mention, and I know that she did not mean to exclude them, all of the people in the state who set forth their viewpoints in opposition to this bill, who lobbied those of us here who landed the Capitol steps and who sent emails and the like, as citizens should do, in order to cause us, we legislators, to do our job sensitive to the needs of our people and respectful of those needs. So I want to make sure that those people are also recognized for the influence that they had upon the compromise legislation that you have before you.
▶ Play
Members, Representative Walker has spoken for the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? I'm going to recognize Representative Miller at this time to
▶ Play
speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Folks, this isn't easy, and I'm down here mainly as a matter of principle. We voted on a bill in this chamber four times that was voted on and approved four times. And it went to the governor's desk. And I, for one, do not appreciate someone hiding behind this body when they're unwilling to take a stand one way or another. Because of that, I will ask that we do not vote for this bill and we let a decision be made on the second floor concerning HB 1228. Thank you. Members, Representative Miller
▶ Play
has spoken against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Brushing, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, some of you may or may not know this, but contrary to popular belief, I did not run my campaign on the private option. I ran my campaign on the RFRA. I ran my campaign trusting in Bob Ballinger and trusting that he knew what needed to be in a RFRA. Bob Ballinger has come out here and spoken and said that he supports this RFRA. Therefore, I think that we need to be behind our colleague that has spent the time and the efforts to make this right for everyone as not to jeopardize what could happen with the RFRA in place that might put us into some kind of legal issues so therefore with his blessings I'm giving my blessings to this same RFRA and I would appreciate a good vote representative rushing has spoken for the bill
▶ Play
representative Ballinger would you like to close for your bill you're recognized to do so at this time I
▶ Play
sure appreciate my colleagues and you know this is the thing is I really feel like the bill that we passed before passed out with a with a supermajority vote. It was a good bill. However, what I would say is that bill was a good bill because it's based on a long-standing jurisprudence. It was based on a federal RFRA passed in 1993. It was based on the jurisprudence that came from the interpretation from federal courts since 1993 it was basically based on the language on the bill that is based that is sitting before you the protections that were afforded in in that bill is essentially the same protections that are afforded in this bill before you there's maybe some peripheral things that are not not there but the essential what is important in order to give the strict scrutiny standard and to our in order to protect our our businesses and our people our citizens are there I don't like the fact that we had to come back and we have to vote on this again I don't like that although what I do like is maybe we'll be able to go out of here with some unity we'll be able to go out of here with some clarity we'll be able to go out of here and not voting for what the media and everybody else outside of Arkansas thinks is a bill that is designed for discrimination but maybe we can go out of here with a bill that's designed to protect the religious freedoms the right of a person to believe what they want to believe and I'd appreciate
▶ Play
a good vote members the question now before the house is the passage of senate bill 975 prepare the machine mr. clerk voting on the bill and emergency clause as everyone voted let's cast it to ballots Mr. Clerk with 76 yeas 17 nays and 2 present the bill and its emergency clause have passed alright members we're going to go back and pick up on the first supplemental calendar in the regular senate bills category uh mr clerk please read
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:36:30
senate bill 831 senate bill 831 by senator sanders to authorize the director of the division of medical services of the department of human services to determine that a medicaid provider is out of business and that a
▶ Play
medicaid overpayment cannot be collected representative lundstrom you're recognized to present senate bill 831
▶ Play
thank you mr speaker sadly in arkansas we do have businesses that go out of business and unfortunately sometimes doctors go out of business but the state of arkansas has to continue to pay those medicaid funds even though they're not coming in we're still required when that doctor sends the medicaid funds in we're still required as a state to pay them back out even though the business is gone and those funds are no longer being funded the taxpayers must do that so in order to get our money back and to quit paying, we have to, as a body, say, no more. There's no more money. Sorry, federal government. There's no money coming in. There's no money coming out. I would answer any questions. If not, I would ask for a good vote. All
▶ Play
right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill. Representative Blundstrom has signified she's closed for the bill. So the question now before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 831. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. has everyone voted all right let's cast the ballots mr clerk with 97 yeas zero nay and zero present the bill has passed all right members i apologize for this inconvenience but those of logistical matters that I discussed earlier coming into play for us now and also considering the fact that the air conditions and things are not working. We're going to take a break for a few minutes, take care of a few items. We're going to come back in here at 345. So we're going to recess until 345. We're going to finish up the calendars, a couple of acknowledgments, housekeeping items, and then we're going to get everybody out of here and get you home. So We're going to be in recess until 345.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:39:36
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
All right, members, the House will be called back into order. before we move to the last three items on our calendar I want to acknowledge Representative Sabin has some guests that have come to watch us as we finish out in the West Gallery from the Parliament in Kenya we have the Honorable Captain Clement Wambugu and then from the Kenya Construction Authority We have Samson Lacoba, Paul Kiriki, and Nancy Milgoan. We also have Mr. Burkett Wooten from the Arkansas Contractors Licensing Board that are here today's guest of Representative Sabin. Let's welcome them. All right, if it pleases the body, we're going to take up our last three items of business for the session. From our calendar, we're going back to the second supplemental calendar. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 459.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:43:45
Senate Bill 459 by Senator Johnson to clarify the penalties for certain offenses in the criminal code, to reorganize certain criminal offenses, and
▶ Play
to make technical corrections to Title V of
▶ Play
the Arkansas Code. Representative Bennett, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 459. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, in the interest of saving time, I'm going to explain 459 and 462 at the same time. These both are record-keeping corrections. Our prosecutors track offenses under the statute that defines the offense. ACIC and the FBI track it under where the penalty is in the code. We're combining those two provisions so that everybody's tracking them under the same code section. And I would appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an
▶ Play
explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Bennett signified that she's closed. the question now before the house is the passage of senate bill 459 prepare the machine Mr. Clerk has everyone voted cast the balance Mr. Clerk With ADA's one nay and two present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:45:23
Senate Bill 462. Senate Bill 462 by Senator Johnson. To clarify the penalties for certain criminal offenses not contained in the criminal code, to reorganize certain criminal offenses, and to make technical corrections to statutes involving criminal
▶ Play
offenses. Representative Bennett, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 462.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, ditto outside Title V. And I'd appreciate a good vote. Members,
▶ Play
you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Question now before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 462. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. has everyone voted let's cast it to balance mr. clerk with 81 yeas zero nay and zero present the bill has passed before we move on to the next bill representative eaves didn't want to be left out today and he has guests in the west gallery We have Ms. Carla and Dwayne Burrow, and he'd like for us to welcome them. All right, Mr. Clerk, this time would you please read our last bill of the session. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 1018. Senate Bill 1018 by Senator Hutchinson concerning the offense of abuse of a minor.
▶ Play
Representative Bennett, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 1018. Last one. Okay, Senate Bill 1018 brings us up to compliance in some of our sexual offender statutes. This sounds odd because we're providing that someone can be removed from sex offender registry. But what has happened is, particularly in the case of a spouse who may have been charged as an accessory to sexual offense by maybe the father, they have now been removed from the sexual offender statutes if they were not involved in sexual offenses. This allows the removal of those people, which will also, we hope, increase the reporting of those offenses. Sometimes spouses are afraid to report because they will also be charged with sexual offenses. All this does is let them ask the court to be removed. It does nothing to remove them. And I'd appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard
▶ Play
an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Ben to signify she's closed for the bill. The question now before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 1018. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Let's cast it to ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 87 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed. Representative Ballinger, for what purpose? Motion. Let's hear your motion, sir.
▶ Play
Motion that we recall House Bill 1228 from the governor's office. That is a proper motion. It is debatable.
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to present your motion. thank
▶ Play
you mr speaker this is the thing we have have a couple options here as far as far how we handle this and how we go out i can tell you that i don't like the idea of house bill 1228 being vetoed and anybody anywhere being able to say that it was vetoed because there's something wrong with house bill 1228 we all know that they're well most of us know there wasn't anything wrong with 1228, except the perception. All of us who voted for it know it was a good bill. Most of us know that we essentially voted in substantially the same law into place today without all the misperception. What I would say to you is, I don't want it vetoed. I'd rather leave here and have that bill in the House. And so what I'd ask is that we get a vote, a positive vote. I understand some people don't want to vote for it because they like that bill and they think that one should become law but it's not going to so if the choice is between allowing it to be vetoed or having it back in the house let's have it back in the house
▶ Play
so i appreciate a good vote representative ballinger has explained the motion would anyone like to speak against the motion representative copeland i believe you rose first so i'm going to recognize you
▶ Play
thank you mr speaker it's a very difficult thing one that because we're at
▶ Play
the end of the day we're at the end of the session but you know the mr speaker rightfully so has told us the entire time that we're to honor the process and we have we have done the right thing we have gone through all the right motions we've done everything that we were asked to do and then now we're having to recall a good bill i love representative walker i love his son's jerk chicken more than that but i do take exception with the the thought that this has been a pure process when we've had colleagues spit on cursed at and bullied and so it is it is my firm conviction that we should not recall this this is a good bill we should stand for it i resent that every one of you that voted for this is now being put in this position when there's nothing wrong with this bill and ask for you not to recall
▶ Play
it members representative copeland has spoken against the motion to recall would anyone like speak for the motion representative hammer you're recognized to speak for the motion thank you
▶ Play
mr speaker in the hospice world that i serve in i tell people as they're dealing with death, I say it's hard to be practical and emotional at the same time, but practical will serve you best in the long run. What I see this is, is not getting in a fight with the second floor. What I see this is, the sponsor of the bill, who is really the owner of the bill, has said to us i want it back earlier on the other end we saw what happened to a member when they took over a member's bill basically stole it from him against his will and that taste that it left in that person's mouth our representative i don't care about the second floor right now i don't care about the senate right now our member has asked respectfully for that bill to come back here and give it a decent death and a decent burial if it's going to be resurrected and live on it can live on another day we're all walking out of here with something that a lot of us don't like and some of us love but the reality of the matter is we voted and he wants his bill back and i'm to vote for it and lay all the other issues to the side because he's asked for it back and he has poured his blood sweat tears emotions energy and probably lost a few years of his life over this deal and i'm going to respect it because we're the house we're not anybody else we're the darn house and our house member wants it back and that's about as strong as i could say it representative vines it's his bill let's give it back to him appreciate
▶ Play
a good vote members representative hammer has spoken for the motion to recall would anyone like speak against the motion to recall representative payton you're recognized to speak against the
▶ Play
motion to recall This may not be as much about for or against as it is why I'm going to vote against. There were three bulls out in the field. And the farmer went out and hooked his truck up to the cow trailer and headed down the driveway. And the young bull looked at the middle one and he said, where do you reckon he's going? The middle one said, I don't know. And the old bull said, I'll tell you where he's going. He's going to pick up another bull. and I've got most of these cows out in this field and I'm not going to share them with anybody and I don't care if he brings another bull back that bull is out of here and the middle one said well I ain't been here near as long as you and I ain't got near as many cows in this herd but he said I don't have enough to share with anybody so that new bull is going to be out of luck and the third one, the youngest one he said well I ain't been here too long and y'all been good enough not to run me out of the field and treat me okay and some of those cows are looking at me pretty favorably And he said, I'll help you. We'll make sure and throw that third bull out. Later that afternoon, the farmer came back, and they looked down that driveway. That trailer looked like it was loaded really heavy. There was a big old hump on a bremer bull's back showing through the slats in the trailer. And that old bull, he said, I can tell you right now, I was a little short-sighted this morning. I reconsidered, thought about it all day, and that was awful mean of me to say that. You know, I probably ought to do the neighborly thing and introduced him to a few of my cows. The middle bull said, yeah, you know, I've got 12 or 15. I can spare one or two. And they looked around, the little bull's gone. He's down in the corner, snorting and pawing and growling at that new bull as they unloaded him. And they said, ma'am, what are you doing? And he said, I just want that new bull to know I'm not a cow. Now, Walmart didn't call me, and I've not been castrated, and I want you all to
▶ Play
know I'm voting no. Representative Payton, I spoke against the motion to recall. Would anyone like to speak for the motion? Representative Shepard, you're recognized to speak
▶ Play
for the motion. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, colleagues, I speak in favor of the motion to recall. I think that, as Representative Hammer alluded to, the sponsor of the bill has asked that it be recalled from the governor's office. I think that that should carry great weight as we debate this, as we decide this issue. There's been a lot of hard work that's gone into these bills over the last two or three days, and Representative Ballinger has worked very diligently, Representative Bennett and many others in this chamber and other chambers have worked very diligently on this. I would say this is an opportunity for us to conclude our business, to close this issue, to bring some finality and closure to the session and to the remaining issues that are out there. I think we set aside who put us in this position or if anybody put us in this position. The fact of the matter is it's our responsibility to make the decision now and as a result I would ask that we vote to recall the bill and let's wrap up our business today and i would appreciate a favorable vote all
▶ Play
right members representative shepherd has spoken for the motion to recall representative ballinger would you like to close for your motion i apologize representative deaf and ball i've already acknowledged representative ballinger for
▶ Play
the close thank you mr speaker hey i appreciate all y'all i mean i know why you guys are not won that bill back just like i said and i understand that the issue is i don't think that we're making any difference by not calling the bill back i don't think anything is happening positively by that and i am believe that there will be negative or potential negative repercussions by not calling the bill back i believe that you know this is something i've worked on a long time in fact 12 28 we put a whole lot of work into it and i don't want to do that you know it's not about me i know a lot of you guys have put a whole lot of work into it and caught a lot of flack over it and i I haven't gotten spit on. But the reality is we are finishing up 1228 with the bill that has now been signed into the law, that is the law in Arkansas right now. We have a strict scrutiny standard.
▶ Play
Speaker 276 1:59:08
Guys, let's call this bill back. Finish up, go home, get some sleep. then go about the business
▶ Play
thank you all right members representative Ballinger is closed for the motion to recall House Bill 1228 from the governor all in favor of recalling House Bill 1228 from the governor say aye all opposed to say no I'm going to rule the ayes have it the bill will be recalled. Representative Stephen Meeks, you are recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker. I move that in accordance with provision of House Concurrent Resolution 1004 of the 90th General Assembly, the Arkansas House of Representatives stand in recess subject to, one, reconvening at the call by proclamation of the Speaker of the House of Representatives and the President pro-temper of the Senate, or two, adjourning Sonny Dye on or before noon on May 8th, 2015.
▶ Play
That is a proper motion, not debatable. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. I'm going to rule the ayes have it. Members. Before everyone begins to leave, I want to say thank you. You've put in, let's say, 81, I think today is 81 days of tremendous effort, tremendous work. I said back last March that I believed that we would face anything that came at us. I had faith in you, and you delivered every single day. I hope everyone has a fantastic Easter weekend, and we're going to, we'll be notifying you of when we're going to be coming back in for the official adjournment, and we'll be accompanying that with some orientation work for the interim. And with that, I'm going to recognize Representative House for an announcement.
▶ Play
Ms. Kay Donovan informed me that about half of you have not settled an administrative expense debt with her desk, so please go by there and take care of that. She says thank
▶ Play
you. All right, members, Representative Branscombe has an
▶ Play
Speaker 286 2:02:13
announcement. Members, next week you will be receiving a packet from the Bureau that contains a booklet outlining the duties and services performed by the Bureau staff during the interim. In addition, in the packet will include a thumb drive that contains a PowerPoint presentation containing an overview of legislation enacted by this General Assembly. This presentation will be useful if you want to use it for civic groups, constituents, and other organizations. If you have any questions, get a hold of Marty
▶ Play
at the Bureau. All right. Representative Ballinger. I'm sorry. There was actually an announcement I was supposed to make and obviously forgot about it. The Congressional Prayer Caucus Foundation has documents at Kay's desk. just you've got that sheet on your desk it's a great organization if you want to go in there and sign up to basically say that that's going to be your focus your peripheral consider your your responsibility here you can go by k's desk pick it up if you sign that that'd be great thank
▶ Play
you all right members thank you again y'all have an awesome weekend we'll see you next week oh representative meeks i have my apology hold on members representative stephen meeks has an
▶ Play
announcement thank thank you members and colleagues before everyone leaves let me have your attention real quick we would be remiss before we left if we didn't stop and say thank you to the people who helped make possible what we do so I So I want to thank the staff, and not only the
▶ Play
Speaker 290 2:03:47
staff here on the front, the staff in
▶ Play
the back, our security, all the people here at the Capitol, and then finally the last thank you that I think that we need to give is to our Speaker of the House who's
▶ Play
Speaker 291 2:04:00
done a wonderful job managing the session.
▶ Play
you, sir. Members, Representative Walker is antsy to leave. So y'all have a great weekend. Thank y'all so much.
▶ Play

Agenda

CALL TO ORDER

0:00 - 8:03 19 segments 9 speakers

HMR1004

8:03 - 12:43 12 segments 4 speakers

SJR3

12:43 - 14:31 7 segments 4 speakers

SJR16

14:31 - 41:03 79 segments 15 speakers

HB1239

41:03 - 42:45 5 segments 2 speakers

HB1779

42:45 - 45:40 10 segments 3 speakers

HB1377

45:40 - 49:41 10 segments 2 speakers

HB1371

49:41 - 50:51 4 segments 2 speakers

HB1904

50:51 - 52:06 2 segments 1 speaker

HB1610

52:06 - 53:48 5 segments 2 speakers

HB1645

53:48 - 55:38 5 segments 3 speakers

HB1529

55:38 - 1:00:27 13 segments 5 speakers

HB1790

1:00:27 - 1:02:14 6 segments 3 speakers

SB943

1:02:14 - 1:11:08 34 segments 10 speakers

SB1007

1:11:08 - 1:13:16 7 segments 3 speakers

SB124

1:13:16 - 1:14:30 6 segments 3 speakers

SB983

1:14:30 - 1:16:02 3 segments 2 speakers

SB404

1:16:02 - 1:18:52 11 segments 4 speakers

SB776

1:18:52 - 1:24:00 18 segments 8 speakers

SB967

1:24:00 - 1:26:14 7 segments 4 speakers

SB975

1:26:14 - 1:36:57 30 segments 8 speakers

SB831

1:36:57 - 1:43:59 15 segments 3 speakers

SB459

1:43:59 - 1:45:32 5 segments 3 speakers

SB462

1:45:32 - 1:47:13 6 segments 2 speakers

SB1018

1:47:13 - 2:04:24 53 segments 14 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Speaker 1
1 segment
Representative Jeremy Gillam Chair Unverified
91 segments
Speaker 10
1 segment
Speaker 11
2 segments
Speaker 13
1 segment
Speaker 27
2 segments
Chair Unverified
26 segments
Speaker 38
1 segment
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Chair Unverified
19 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Chair Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 59
1 segment
Representative Lanny Fite Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 39
1 segment
Speaker 74
7 segments
Speaker 47
1 segment
Representative David Whitaker Unverified
1 segment
Representative Douglas House Unverified
17 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 86
1 segment
Speaker 89
1 segment
Representative Kim Hammer Chair Unverified
14 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
11 segments
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
4 segments
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Unverified
17 segments
Representative Julie Mayberry Unverified
2 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
5 segments
Representative Reginald Murdock Unverified
4 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
3 segments
Representative Richard Womack Unverified
1 segment
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
1 segment
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
1 segment
Representative Brandt Smith Unverified
4 segments
Representative Andy Davis Chair Unverified
24 segments
Speaker 180
1 segment
Representative John T. Vines Unverified
4 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
10 segments
Representative Charles Blake Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 198
1 segment
Speaker 195
1 segment
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 211
3 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Chair Unverified
3 segments
Representative Robin Lundstrum Chair Unverified
3 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 228
1 segment
Speaker 229
1 segment
Speaker 125
1 segment
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
16 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Chair Unverified
10 segments
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
3 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
2 segments
Representative John Payton Unverified
4 segments
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 276
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 286
2 segments
Speaker 290
1 segment
Speaker 291
1 segment