Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Education Committee

March 26, 2013
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (7)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB228 · 3 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…te the correct answer Go ahead and restate your motion Okay Senate Bill 228 We have”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1912 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1912”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2106 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…alone is here, and we are going to recognize her to present House Bill 2106. Representative Malone has some guests who are more than we…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1789 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1789”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1902 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1902”
Pre-2017 bill
HB22 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…r a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to move that House Bill 22-27 be placed on special order of business for Thursday.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB839 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB839”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
we'd like to welcome everybody to the education committee today please make yourselves comfortable we have plenty of seats available and be sure to avail yourselves of our coffee the best coffee in the capital Okay, members, we have a special order of business we're going to take up here momentarily. Before we do that, I would like to
▶ Play
recognize Representative Hobbs for a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to move that House Bill 22-27 be placed on special order of business for Thursday.
▶ Play
Speaker 12 1:00
Okay 2227 or 228 Oh you know what I think
▶ Play
Speaker 14 1:10
you're right This paper I had had the other one So I
▶ Play
appreciate the correct answer Go ahead and restate your motion Okay Senate Bill 228 We have
▶ Play
a motion for a special order of business Thursday For Senate Bill 228 All in favor All opposed? Motion passes. Special order will be set for Thursday, Senate Bill 228. Thank you, Representative Hobbs. Members, today we're going to try to address as many House bills as we can here this morning. This afternoon, our plan is to come back upon adjournment and take up just Senate bills. We have a backlog of Senate bills that we need to go ahead and work through our committee. So let's just plan on 15 minutes after adjournment. We're going to come back here, and it will be Senate afternoon in the House Education Committee. And with that, Representative Malone is here, and we are going to recognize her to present House Bill 2106. Representative Malone has some guests who are more than welcome to join her at the end of the table. You are recognized to proceed.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. And if I could very quickly, I'm going to ask my
▶ Play
Speaker 26 2:47
guest to introduce himself for the record. Yes, just good morning to everyone. Thank you for having me here today. I'm Colonel Keith Clemmer. I'm the Deputy Adjutant General for the state of Arkansas. Otherwise, for the state agency, state military department, I'm the Deputy Director working for Major General Wofford. Thank you. At this time, I'll
▶ Play
go ahead and begin presenting 2601 members. And this is a very simple bill, so it shouldn't take up too much of your time. I know you're a busy, efficient committee. All this bill does is take the current – with colleges, It takes the current percentage of 25% to 100% that colleges can cover for the Arkansas National Guard, and it's not requiring this to be done, it's simply requesting that it be done. And that's it. Very simple. Do you have anything to add, sir?
▶ Play
Speaker 26 3:38
Yes, sir. Just a couple of real brief comments. One thing that is extremely important for the Arkansas National Guard, both the Army in the air is individuals that have college degrees and our attempts to give them every opportunity to get this degree is of utmost importance. Last night I took the opportunity to run the Army National Guard statistics on individuals with degrees. Right now we have about 11.1 percent of our Army National Guard force of 7,500 soldiers that have a degree right now. Why is that important and why do we need to increase that? Specifically, the National Guard is all about readiness. It's having ready soldiers, ready airmen that can answer the call of our community, state, and nation. We have found over the years that our loss rates for individuals with college degrees is significantly lower than those without college degrees. So this is one area where we can invest our efforts and from an Army perspective our money and Air Force perspective to increase this, improve the loss rate. And just a couple of statistics from the Army that I looked up last night. Right now, the loss rate for soldiers in the Army without a degree is almost 15 percent. So 15 out of 100, we're losing that do not have a degree. Those with a degree, the loss rate is below 9, below 9 out of 100. So it's almost half. So we recognize that if we want to have ready units, ready soldiers, experienced soldiers and airmen, that we must push towards this. And also, just as an added note, it's becoming a bigger and bigger part of our profession. Right now, as an officer in the National Guard, you must have a college degree and a master's degree is preferred. In our enlisted and warrant officer ranks, although it's not required, it's used as evaluative criteria in promoting to the next rank. So in the future, we think it will be part of, it will be a requirement in our opinion. So I think it's important for us to seek ways to educate our soldiers and airmen in the National Guard, and this is just, I think, an easy way that we can do this. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you, sir. Representative Lowry, did you have a question, sir? Okay. Representative Linderman.
▶ Play
I have a comment and then a motion at the proper time. Colonel Clemer is a former student of mine, dear friend, and a product of our public education system. And I'm immensely proud of him, and I will have a motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Linderman. Representative Talley? Question? You're recognized, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 40 6:49
Thank you, sir. I just had a couple of questions. How many people, do we know how many
▶ Play
Speaker 26 6:56
people across the state are using this now and what? we don't have a good number on exact percentages because it just changes every
▶ Play
Speaker 40 7:02
semester so don't okay and and visiting with the representative malone before i understand there's not a physical
▶ Play
Speaker 26 7:06
impact on this no this basically is a it it really has a net cost of zero to the state budget as it stands right now it's really the impact is on the college budget they can just like it like it exists right now they can either choose to support right now or not support at no cost to them so it's just It's just within their budget abilities that they do this. And just increasing it, it's basically it has the same effect. They can choose not to support it. If they've got the budget, then they can support it. If it's in their priorities and in their strategic plan, then they can support it. One more question? Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 40 7:41
As far as the rules and regulations, you say that the institutions can determine that, but it looks like the rules and regulations are not set up by the college institutions. Well, the way the bill reads, it just
▶ Play
Speaker 26 7:50
allows them to. They don't have to. It just allows them. Right now, all they can do is waive up to 25%. This just increases it to 100%. But we don't know how much is being waived out there across the state right now? Right. It just depends
▶ Play
Speaker 40 8:02
on each institution. Okay. Thank you. Representative Armstrong, you have a question?
▶ Play
Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Colonel Clemmer, how will this affect the colleges and universities with ROTC program? Would that play any role?
▶ Play
Speaker 26 8:25
It would, by and large, students that are enrolled in ROTC programs already have tuition assistance, either in the form of either scholarships or they will have some other means of financing their education, GI Bill. This is for those soldiers that really need that extra hand.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Do we have any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, do we have anyone in the audience who wishes to speak for or against this bill? With that, the chair will entertain a motion. We have a motion due passed from Representative Linderman. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you very much for being here today. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Committee. Committee, our second special order of business has been canceled. We'll take that up at a later date. Right now, we are going to recognize Representative Armstrong, if you are prepared, sir, we'll recognize you to run house bill nineteen twelve you're recognized to proceed
▶ Play
at this time i'd like to bring mister chris hello
▶ Play
up here with me mister heller you are always welcome at
▶ Play
the house education committee uh... this this this bill is a transportation bail and and uh... is dealing with the form was on transportation how the school districts use different formulas and some of them used uh... formulas are very different from others and so therefore the per student rate is bigger difference so i'm gonna let mister halla have it and take it from here And this was brought about by the study by Ogden and Peikers
▶ Play
Speaker 72 10:38
back in 2006. MR. Mr. Chairman, I'm Chris Heller from the Friday Firm representing the Little Rock School District. HB 1912 is drawn from an idea that's been presented to the Joint Adequacy Committee, I think, three times so far. And it's an effort to resolve a problem with transportation funding in Arkansas, and that problem is transportation funding doesn't have any rational basis. It's transportation funding is paid on a per-student basis through the matrix funding formula without regard to how much actual transportation cost any particular district has. Richard Wilson told me he thought two-thirds of the school districts in Arkansas are underfunded for transportation because of this formula. The only reason it got started this way is because when Auden and Pikus were working on the matrix formula, they said it should be included temporarily just as a way to get some transportation funding to districts until a standards-based formula could be developed. It turns out it's not difficult to develop a standards-based formula. The Bureau of Legislative Research has done it. This bill suggests that the Arkansas Department of Education develop a standards-based formula based on route miles. The Bureau of Legislative Research has said that such a formula would be very accurate in funding districts for their a lot closer to their actual transportation cost. I have the bill contains a provision for a transition such so that no district when this bill takes effect would receive less than 75 percent of the funding it received the THE PREVIOUS FISCAL YEAR AND THEN 50 PERCENT THE YEAR AFTER THAT SO THAT THERE'S A PHASE OUT PROVISION FOR DISTRICTS WHO ARE PRESENTLY OVERFUNDED. I THINK AT THE TIME ALL DISTRICTS IN THE STATE WERE RECEIVING $300 A STUDENT FOR TRANSPORTATION FUNDING. THE BLR DETERMINED THAT ACTUAL COSTS RANGE FROM ABOUT $67 TO OVER $600. So this formula isn't fair and it doesn't really make any sense. There's another aspect to this, I think, that's not going to be apparent from the bill, and that is one of the biggest issues in the Pulaski County desegregation case, one of the biggest costs to the state is for funding of transportation for magnet schools and majority to minority transfers. If there were in place a rational state funding formula based on something closer to actual transportation cost, it would be a lot easier to resolve those issues in the Pulaski County desegregation case. And there is something else about adequacy in the Lakeview case I want to talk about. I mentioned to this committee before that I was a participant in the Lakeview case. And the state seems to have adopted the view that the best way to stay out of court and stay out of trouble with Lakeview is to keep doing what we were doing in 2007. And that's not right. Lakeview requires really just the opposite. That's why we have adequacy committees. view requires that this body, this General Assembly, determine every two years what it will take to provide an adequate education and to fund that adequate education, not to keep doing what you were doing five or ten years ago. And it's very important to emphasize that the state's own adequacy consultants have said transportation should not be a part of this matrix funding formula. So this bill would require the Department of Education to put together a standards-based formula based on route miles and to fund beginning the next school year to fund transportation in a much more fair and accurate way than it's being funded now. Representative Armstrong, do you have anything to add? No, not at this time.
▶ Play
Do we have any questions? We
▶ Play
do have an impact statement here, though. Very well. Do we have any questions from the committee? We have several people who have signed up to speak on, for, or against the bill, and we will start with the illustrious Scott Richardson with the Arkansas Attorney General's Office. Mr. Richardson, you are recognized, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 78 16:00
Good morning. This is Scott Richardson from the Attorney General's Office. This is an issue that's come up in a number of sessions that we've worked through before. The question of, is transportation required for adequacy? If so, what portion of transportation is required for adequacy, and how must the General Assembly fund it? This bill proceeds on an assumption that every route mile driven by a bus is required for adequacy. but the General Assembly has determined what the adequacy requirement is beginning in 2008 this is from the adequacy study in 2008 the education committees have determined that state-funded transportation for public education may be a necessary component to providing students with an equitable opportunity for an adequate education to the extent that a student would not otherwise be able to realize this opportunity but for such transportation being provided by the state and what sort of students does that include the General Assembly determined that it would need data on to determine each district's essential route miles for students whose access to an equitable opportunity for an adequate education would be prevented by disability poverty distance or geography so the determination was that adequacy was not a hundred percent funding for all route miles driven by the school district but that adequacy was some subset of that and the determination was that it has been for the last several biennium that the amount of transportation funding provided by the matrix was sufficient to cover the adequacy needs of school districts but that it might be good to provide additional funding to the school districts to assist with their transportation needs so this bill takes from the adequacy amount as I understand it and it's not real clear in the bill but as I understand this bill it takes the the portion from the matrix which is the basis for the foundation funding amount that is for transportation would pull that out and create a new categorical funding amount for transportation now the matrix is a funding model not an expenditure model by which we mean that the elements of the matrix are not mandated and so we expect to see variance among the school districts in how they spend the money provided in the matrix so you will find some school districts that spend more in one area and some school districts that spend less than one area and transportation is no different you find districts that spend more on transportation than what's in the matrix and you find districts that spend less on transportation than what's in the matrix let me see the the latest resource allocation funding study done by the Bureau published August 13 2012 determined that statewide districts spent approximately $274.41 per student compared with $297.50 funded in the matrix. This is $2,309 less than the amount provided by the matrix. So you have a situation where districts are using that flexibility provided in the matrix to adjust funding to cover necessary expenses. This would remove some of that flexibility and require it to be spent on one area. Essentially, we would be mandating one portion of the matrix, which the General Assembly has generally determined is a problem. It's not an option that it wants to pursue, including last session when we went through this issue in depth and a bill was passed determining that the General Assembly would not remove this element from the matrix and would continue to fund adequacy in transportation And then an amount was provided for excess transportation costs. So, and that's Act 1039 of 2011. I think one of the principles that Mr. Heller and Representative Armstrong are sort of building this around is that, Well, Auden and Picus said that this had to be done, so it must be done to meet adequacy, and I don't think that's the case. There are other things that Auden and Picus recommended that the General Assembly differed upon with them, and that's this body's prerogative. It is up to the General Assembly to determine what constitutes an adequate and equitable education and then to provide a sufficient level of resources to fund that. And so the General Assembly has made that determination. This would change that determination, but I don't see any data or evidence that accounts for the change in funding to school districts that are using that flexibility and how that would affect those school districts. So constitutionally, I think this is a risky proposition going forward.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Richardson. I have a question, and maybe this is better directed at Mr. Hiller and Representative Armstrong. I'm looking at the fiscal impact statement, and I need to get a clear picture of what the impact is actually going to be here. And if you gentlemen would come forward and just kind of clarify that.
▶ Play
Speaker 72 22:58
Mr. Chairman, the intent of the bill is to take only the current funding, the approximately $300 per student that's presently distributed through the matrix funding formula and to create a separate categorical fund using only that money, no new money. So the fiscal impact, if it's done that way, should be zero. I noticed a comment in the fiscal impact statement about desegregation funding. There is nothing in the bill that's intended to change anything about desegregation funding. That should be that's required by the court, is separate, and should remain separate. The only purpose of the bill is to find a more rational way to give to school districts funding for their transportation costs.
▶ Play
So potentially there would be some folks who are very, very happy with this bill and some folks who would be terribly unhappy. Is that am I taking away that
▶ Play
Speaker 72 24:18
correctly? MR. My understanding, Mr. Chairman, from Richard Wilson, is that approximately two-thirds of the districts in the state are presently underfunded for transportation. So I would say you're right. Probably two-thirds of the districts would be happy and one-third would be unhappy. And that's one of the reasons for the transition provision in the bill so that unhappiness doesn't translate into too significant
▶ Play
an impact all at once. It's funny how unhappiness translates in the legislature. So just to just so I kind of understand this, we will be we potentially maybe would be taking money currently away from school districts and allocating it to other school districts?
▶ Play
Speaker 72 25:10
MR. That's correct, because we're talking about a limited fund of money. Another big step that would be helpful is to have state funding of actual transportation costs for school districts, but that would have a significant fiscal impact. So if we're redistributing the same money, approximately one-third of the districts would lose some money. It's important to keep in mind that a lot of districts are clustered reasonably close to the $300 per student that's currently being distributed.
▶ Play
Is there a particular model that you will be employing in the bill? And please forgive me, I have not, I have cliff-noted the bill, but will you please, Is there a particular model that will be employed to redistribute this money? MR.
▶ Play
Speaker 72 26:05
Yes, sir. It's in subparagraph C on page two. The Department of Education shall provide to a school district annual state funding for student transportation based on the school district's student transportation cost as determined by a standards-based formula where student transportation cost is a function of the school district's historical route miles. So it's up to the Department of Education to develop a standards-based formula to more accurately fund transportation costs. MR. Okay. They're going to
▶ Play
Speaker 92 26:42
love that. MR. I think the
▶ Play
Speaker 72 26:45
Bureau of Legislative Research has given them a big head start with the work they've done for
▶ Play
the last six years. MR. The bad guys are going to want to talk here in a minute. Before we let them come up, committee, do we have any questions for Representative Armstrong and Mr. Heller while they're here? Okay. If not, would Mr. Wood and Mr. Kimbrell be so kind as to come to the end of the table? These gentlemen need no introduction. They will be speaking on the bill on behalf of the Arkansas Department of Education. Gentlemen, you're recognized. Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 27:27
Actually, we're speaking against the bill. Mr. Wood wanted to know, I'm Tom Cameron, Commissioner of Education.
▶ Play
Speaker 95 27:36
If you said bad guys or fat guys, you'd be half right. No, no, no. We're
▶ Play
Speaker 97 27:40
talking Tony Wood here now. Okay. Bad guys. Bad guys. I won't repeat what Scott Richardson talked about as far as the adequacy issues are concerned, but, you know, we've seen these printouts, and when you talk about winners and losers, and I think, Mr. Chair, that's what you were talking about, You take a school district such as Fort Smith that actually loses money in this, you take money out of that adequacy funding level, then the question becomes are they adequately funded. They'll argue that they have neighborhood schools that reduces their transportation cost, but it increases their teacher ratio cost. So they take the money that they have in adequacy and put it in teachers versus transportation. And I can't stress enough that transportation is a function of two things, time and number of buses. The more buses and bus drivers you have, the less time you have, but that may mean the more route miles that you drive. One of the problems that we've had with this formula, and I can promise you, we haven't seen the formula yet. We've asked for the formula and the weights that are on the formula, but we've not ever been able to get that formula from Mr. Richardson. Mr. Wilson, excuse me. So we don't know what the weights are on these things. I do have concerns about the historical route miles. Many of you on this committee have talked to me about school districts that run buses into numerous other school districts. Representative Ratliff, I think you've got one that runs in four or five different school districts. So those route miles have been reported in this. So are we going to provide additional money for school districts to run buses into other school districts to pick up kids from other school districts you know those are questions that we have in concerns with this bill as well as you begin again taking the matrix which is a not an expenditure model but a funding model and and you're going to remove some of that funding from some schools you're going to add money to some schools and we think that that's really getting into an area that that is going to create problems for the state from a legal perspective. So Mr. Wood may have something else to add, but we think, again, this takes money away from current schools. I think there's been talk about adding categorical additional money, but when you start pulling money out of the matrix and pulling it out of what is deemed to be adequacy, that's a problem. The approach here is to try to create a revenue-neutral approach, and I understand that. But when you do that, you create some adequacy issues, in my opinion. Mr.
▶ Play
Wood, do you have anything to add, sir? No, sir. Representative Linderman, do you have
▶ Play
a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I also understand when you're using the same amount of money, you're shifting it around, there's going to be some people that's unhappy, and I've got four school districts in my district, and I have a feeling that a couple of them would be unhappy with this. but in the funding formula now that we use, is there any special consideration or a greater increase in funding for rural districts, districts that cover a large geographical area with a relatively low student population or anything like that?
▶ Play
Speaker 97 30:58
Not in the matrix, but there is an additional isolated transportation funding. So, schools and districts that have isolated schools or were isolated districts, there's additional transportation money that is actually targeted for transportation given to those districts that have large square mileage or met that criteria for being isolated. MR.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. MR. Representative Douglas. MS. Sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I was just wondering if, on the flip side of that coin, whether the state has opened up to litigation, because we are not funding miles and we have kids that are on buses for two hours in Huntsville, and we have kids that are on buses for 15 minutes in Fort Smith, and whether or not that could be a function of adequacy when you have kids that are, to me at a huge disadvantage, does that open us up to a question of adequacy because they have a disadvantage of riding that bus longer?
▶ Play
Speaker 97 32:27
MR. Well, again, I don't you're talking about looking at expenditures in transportation and you're trying to equate that to a model that is a funding model. That time variable of how long a student rides on the bus is directly proportionate to the number of buses that you have and the drivers that you have to run those routes. So, you know, people, districts make choices about how many buses they're going to buy and run, how many drivers they can hire to run. They make decisions about how they're going to efficiently run their districts, whether they want to have elementary schools with 800 kids in them or neighborhood elementary schools with 350. So I don't think that you've created an inadequacy issue because you've given each school district the same amount of money to transport kids, to hire teachers, to buy technology, all the things that are in the matrix. And what this formula does and has done since its inception is said, this is the amount of money that this body, legislative body, has determined is an adequate amount per student to educate your children. Now, you get the flexibility as a district to spend it how you see fit. And so if a district chooses to buy more buses so the kids are on the bus less, that's their choice. If they choose to buy fewer and kids are on buses longer, that's their choice. If they choose to, again, organize their schools in a different way to be less efficient or more efficient with their teachers. And then you've got the issue of, in some places, competing for teachers. I mean, in northwest Arkansas, there's this constant competition for who's got the
▶ Play
high salary schedule. Well, another question, if I could follow up. When you figure your miles on your per diem, what is it a function of for the state? For the state,
▶ Play
Speaker 97 34:21
it's a function of how far I
▶ Play
drive. Why, then, do we have the standards within school districts that it's a function of the amount of students that you have in your school district. I mean, would it not be just as fair for me to say, you know, you've got five people in your family, so I'm going to give you a stipend based on the number of people in your family as opposed to the fact that you've driven to North Dakota and back? Well,
▶ Play
Speaker 97 34:48
we do the exact same thing with the number of students in a classroom. We say that we're going to fund you based upon a matrix that puts you at the standard level of number
▶ Play
of students in a classroom. But if we do that for every other state agency, it's a function of miles.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 35:05
Well, when you're reimbursing an individual, but we're not talking about the same thing. You're talking about funding schools versus repaying somebody for money out of their pocket. And the matrix was created with transportation being part of the matrix. And, yes, you could do what you're talking about. I think you'd have to do it in the adequacy study. In the actual study, you would have to do that and create language within that adequacy study to do it. Have we not done that? There's been talk about it. It's talked about. There's been reports made during an adequacy study, but nothing has moved in that direction where you're looking at doing that in a way that would pull that out completely without, again, you're running the same problem, without keeping people whole to
▶ Play
adequacy. the transportation efficiency study what did it recommend it's it's
▶ Play
Speaker 97 35:58
recommending that you look at trying to find a way outside the formula to help to
▶ Play
add money not to change the formula that's my
▶ Play
Speaker 97 36:08
understanding my recollection from a year and a half two
▶ Play
years ago yes ma'am when when i asked BLR to run costs on school districts, transportation, they come up with an Excel sheet that gives me costs and then amount of money received. Would you explain that if these are all flexible numbers and school districts are choosing to spend money here and not there, then how does the research give me a number of what they spend and then what they receive. Well, again,
▶ Play
Speaker 97 36:45
what they receive is based upon the matrix and how the matrix was first built. So you could run the same exact report for expenditure for teachers and what they receive for teachers, and you would get the same differentiation. You'd have some schools that get more money for teachers' salaries than they spend, just like we saw and have seen with insurance, if you remember. So whichever component you take, you're going to find that there are schools spending more than what is in the matrix for a student and districts that are spending less. And it's that flexibility that was created to allow these different school districts to be able to manage the best that they could with the adequacy money based upon how
▶ Play
they wanted to structure their districts and operate them. If a school is spending $272,000 and they are receiving $320,000, I'm just pulling one off the top of the sheet. Yes, ma'am. They have $100,000 left to buy a new bus, to buy a second bus if they needed to, to shorten the routes. Or they could use that money to
▶ Play
Speaker 97 38:03
increase health insurance for their participants. Right, but the point is they have
▶ Play
money left over. Right, and if you could
▶ Play
Speaker 97 38:10
look at that same district, you may find that that district gets more money for salaries than they're spending than their salaries for their
▶ Play
teachers. But if you have a district that is spending a million dollars and they're receiving $700,000 and they're behind $300,000 or $400,000, how does that speak to adequacy? I know you say it's a function of flexibility that they've chosen, but I don't see that they've, you know, if they're spending X amount and they're receiving $300,000 less, I just don't understand that that is adequately.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 39:01
Well, again, you have to go to the very high level of what does adequacy mean and what does that number mean. This year it's $6,267, $6,267 per student. That means that according to the legislative body last session, That amount of money would adequately fund schools, and it would transport students. It would create teacher salaries. It would create administrative maintenance and operation, all those things in the matrix. How you spent that and how much you spent in each of those areas was dependent upon what you chose in your district to do, how many buses you wanted to buy, how many teachers you wanted to have, how many administrators you wanted to put on the payroll, So all of those things that are allowed under
▶ Play
the operations of the school, that's the choice that they get to make. But we kind of tell them in that testimony a while ago, we say that out of that $6,200, pretty much earmarked for transportation is $274.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 40:10
Well, it's not earmarked because we don't use an expenditure model. Right. That's what was used when we backed into the formula years ago and created the matrix. We used what was being
▶ Play
spent on average when we created it. But I think that's what BLR is using to come up with the figures of what schools are spending on transportation. They're using this figure because the schools are needing that other money for technology, salaries, insurance, buildings, things, all of those other things that they kind of have in sections of recommended expenditures. So BLR is using this 274 to tell us that this is how much the school districts are receiving. Then the school districts report to us how much they're actually spending. Yes, ma'am. And when we have some of the school districts and especially these rural districts that are out several hundred thousand dollars every year. That keeps them from buying that extra teacher. That keeps them from having new technology. That keeps them from competing with these other schools, and to me that's a function of adequacy. If they have to spend, you know, that extra money that they're spending on bus miles, They have to spend that money in these other areas, and they're not equal to these other schools that are getting more than enough money because they have – could I have an agreement on that?
▶ Play
Speaker 97 41:51
Well, they're spending more because they made different choices, and they have different
▶ Play
circumstances. I'm just saying that you're – the state is reporting this.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 41:59
Sure. I mean, but we could run the same report, or BLR could run the same report on what schools are spending for salaries and benefits. And you would see disparities in the same way. You'd see school districts that get X amount per student for salaries and benefits, and there would be districts that are spending much more than that and districts that are spending less than that. So when you go to this, when you start taking the matrix apart, then you go to having to determine, because some schools will say, well, I'm having to spend more for salaries because I've got neighborhood schools, or I'm having to spend more for salaries because I have to compete across the border. I have to compete with my neighborhood schools because their salary schedules are better. Maybe they've got more transportation money left over because they don't run as many buses as we do. So you've got the same situation in each of these categories.
▶ Play
I think it's a slippery slope that we're on here with adequacy, with some school districts spending so much more for transportation. And then it could be some of these same schools that are struggling to stay open. And I just wonder if you see it that way. You know what
▶ Play
Speaker 97 43:14
we see when we have districts that are in physical distress? It's not transportation costs that gets them there. It's either facilities or overstaffing.
▶ Play
But if they had extra money for transportation, they could be putting it there like some
▶ Play
Speaker 97 43:28
of these other schools. But that's what I'm saying. What they're doing is their buildings are costing them too much, more than they've got to pay for them, or they've got too many teachers, administrators, and staff members, and they're not willing to make those cuts, which they could then take that money and put into transportation. We're not finding that transportation is what's causing districts to
▶ Play
go into physical distress. I wonder if some schools would have a different view on that.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 43:56
Sure, they might. They might. But I'm just telling
▶ Play
you the ones that we've been heavily involved in. Thank you very much for your questions or for my questions and your patience with me as a new member of this committee. I know I have talked to Dr. Gooden about this. I taught school under him, and I told him that he really made me a great legislature by teaching me to ask questions. So I'm not sure he sees it that way.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 44:27
Well, that's why we're here, to try
▶ Play
to answer your questions for you,
▶ Play
ma'am. Thank you so much. Thank you, Representative Douglas. Representative Viviano. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Dr. Kimball, do you see any value in reevaluating this transportation formula? Well, yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 97 44:44
sir. I see some value in looking at the transportation piece, but I think you have to look at it outside the
▶ Play
matrix. Okay. It seems like we have a high degree of flexibility. That term's been used here in that matrix. And will that really allow us to be the most efficient in some of these areas like transportation, having that degree of flexibility? Well,
▶ Play
Speaker 97 45:11
I think you're exactly right. But I think that's what the flexibility creates the opportunity to either be very efficient or very inefficient, depending upon what that local district and the leadership determine how they're going to operate their school districts. You know, you're familiar with Searcy School District. You're familiar with how it was run. And they had a very efficient system. And they were actually able to, you know, save money. Your community supported that school. and it's just a function of what you choose at the district level of how efficient you want to be in transportation, pupil-teacher ratios, staffing with custodial, maintenance and operation, et cetera. Some people say, sir, she got better just in the last
▶ Play
couple of years. Well, that's because two of you
▶ Play
Speaker 97 45:58
guys are down here most of the time.
▶ Play
Thank you. And thank you for your comment. Representative Catlett. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Kimbrell, you know, sometimes I feel like the matrix was etched in the marble out there, you know. And I know you're defending it all the time, but these transportation issues are such a problem for rural areas. For example, you know, the priority is get the kids there. You know, you can't have class if you don't have kids. So it looks like to me you start off by funding transportation in some of these real rural areas, such as where I live. I mean, if you go one way, it's still a long way to get the furthest kid to school. And, I mean, that's if you don't take any of the county roads. You stay on State Highway from point A to point B, it's a long ways. Now, you've been in the school system a long time. And
▶ Play
Speaker 151 47:07
do you honestly feel like we're treating these rural schools fairly, the matrix system?
▶ Play
Speaker 97 47:13
Well, I think the matrix is a fair way of creating an adequate system. Does it need some tweaking and looking at overall? I would say that's probably your call as a legislative body and as this advocacy committee looks at it again. You know, there are things that can be done. It's not etched in stone, but it's what you as a legislative body in your adequacy study get to determine what that matrix will look like, how it may change, how it may stay the same. As far as the comments about are we treating these rural schools differently or are they at a disadvantage, I think there are some disadvantages to being rural. I think there's some disadvantages to being urban. And I think that I could get on both sides and argue both sides of those because I've been in both sides. I've run a rural school district in Corning, you know, went to school in Corning. I had Paragool, which I ran 48 buses and ran them all over the place. But I ran a lot of buses so that kids weren't on buses a long time. But I wasn't able to pay my teachers what some of the districts in Jonesboro and some of those others were paying them. So I've been in both sides of that. But then I came to North Little Rock, you know, we ran buses, but it was an urban issue. I had urban issues that caused problems, you know, that created issues for that school that I didn't see when I was at Paragool. So I think the matrix was just a way of creating a number to adequately give per student to create equity and adequacy for funding. Now what we've looked at and we've done in the past is we looked at students that were hard to educate, and we call that NSLA money or poverty money. And we said there is a need there. And so this body of the past created additional funds for those students. We looked at ELL students and said these students require additional resources, and we created funding for that. So I think the matrix model, whether you like it or you don't like it, whether you think it needs to change or not change, I think it's what we have today. It wasn't recommended any true change in the last study. You still could, from what I understand. But what I think is that I would suggest that you look at this, and I've suggested this several times. You look at transportation similar to the way we looked at hard, at-risk, poverty students, how we looked at English language learners, those kinds of things.
▶ Play
Thank you, Dr. Quinn. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Catlett. Representative Carnine,
▶ Play
Speaker 158 50:12
do you have anything to add, sir? Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. One of the questions I asked you a few minutes ago privately, and I think what I'd like to suggest in this setting, and, again, it's not of my thought, but just to repeat for those who have not been part of this adequacy, and as we talk about this particular, finally on this particular bill we have before us, But at some point in time within the next, I'm guessing, two weeks, the chair would, in fact, inform us of what the plans would be, along with the Senate chair, of how we would view adequacy during the interim. This is one of the major topics. That's forthcoming. Okay. So we're talking maybe in the next two weeks we're going to look at that and, of course, look at the agenda that we review adequacy because there are lots of parts. I mean, this is just a part as for the committee, and I think both Dr. Kimbrell and Mr. Woods would agree that we have to look at all the pieces As we do this, transportation is just one of them, and it appears like to me that as we're looking at this particular bill, that it is going to be one of the things we look at. Now, the question is, do we want to do it now, but in reality then you wouldn't see the other possibilities that, say, like Richard Wilson would put on the table for us. I can't say, because it's our responsibility as an adequacy committee to make a decision and a recommendation, and then it's really up to the full body then to make all the pieces final. I mean, we get to recommend, and we do all the work, but others are going to weigh in on it too, including the executive branch, our governor. So, as we look at all that, I guess I'm asking more questions of the chair of where we're at with that process and whether we should act on this particular piece of legislation when in reality it's going to be part of the adequacy makeup. So that's my comment. I hope I haven't been too confusing, but the point is we're going to have to go
▶ Play
all back over this anyway. You are correct, and there will be a joint meeting of the Senate and House Ed Committee soon and we will discuss the issues that you covered and I'm glad that you brought that up because that's the heavy lifting that we need to be prepared
▶ Play
for very very soon well let me say this I don't want to particularly shoot down anybody's bill but at this point in time I looked at this as yes this is one of the things we do need to discuss but at the same time Representative Armstrong, and obviously Mr. Heller, all of those folks have brought, I think, a very purposeful piece for us to consider. But again, I'd like to see all the other pieces before we make that decision at this time. So I meant no disrespect, but meant it as a fact that I think it's got to be a consideration, but we may be a little bit ahead of ourselves. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Well, we appreciate your comments, Representative Carnine. Representative Devenbaugh. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Kimball, I just saw something that struck a chord. The NSLA money, can it be used for transportation?
▶ Play
Speaker 97 54:29
It can be used for supplemental education for students that are getting before school, summer school, or after school transportation. So
▶ Play
Speaker 171 54:37
that's not doing a regular term? No, sir. Okay. So is
▶ Play
Speaker 97 54:42
that federally mandated? No, sir. That is state funds, and actually, we've got a bill that will change the name of that. I hope you all will embrace it. We're going to try to change the name of NSLA funding to, what did we call it? Economically Disadvantaged Students, because it gets confused with the national lunch program, and all it has to do with is the number, but it's state funding, and it has nothing to do with any federal regulations or anything. saying these funds are actually regulated by law in your code, in the state code. So, but the code does not allow you to use NSLA money for your normal transportation cost. Okay. Thank you. I
▶ Play
appreciate it. Do we have any other questions for Mr. Wood and Dr. Kimbrell? If not, thank you very much, gentlemen. We appreciate your testimony today. We have Mr. Clay Finley is here. Counselor, you are recognized to speak for the
▶ Play
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. My name is Clay Finley. I'm an attorney representing the Deer Mount Judy School District. For those of you who aren't familiar with Deer Mount Judy, it is an isolated school district. It is in Newton County. We operate two K-12 schools, one in Deere and one in Mount Judy. Deere has about 170 kids. Mount Judy has about 100 students. I guess let me begin by addressing a point made by Dr. Kimbrell in that he calls this a funding formula, not a spending formula. but I can assure you there is no category of funding of which Dearmount Judy is in the surplus category. We are underfunded in every category, transportation, teachers. We are not making a tradeoff. We are paying our teachers the state minimum, and we are putting our kids on the bus for a long, long time. I guess I'd like to go back and talk about the study required by Act 624 of 2007. There's been some discussion of that, whether it was done and what happened to it. It was done in a way. Richard Wilson put together a PowerPoint presentation that he delivered in 2008. it is very similar to the ones if you were on adequacy committee in 2010 you would have seen most of it then as well and also again this time around in 2012 and the main point of that presentation that I think has been looked over is the fact that transportation funding was included in the matrix temporarily it It was never intended to be carried over in the matrix. That presentation given by Mr. Wilson on one of the slides, quotes from the Auden and Picus 2006 recalibration report, and which says, quote, we recommend a transportation categorical program which would average 286 per people in 2007-2008, that was temporary, but based on districts actual transportation expenditures in 2005 or 2004 2005 inflated up to the 2007 2008 base that's where we got the 286 that was in the original 2007 2008 matrix and and to be replaced by a standards-based formula in the future so that was 2006 we were going to temporarily include a fixed amount of money in the matrix until we had a standards-based formula that would deliver to school districts their actual transportation cost and the reason is clear every dollar spent on transportation is a dollar that cannot be spent in the classroom school districts in order to spend what they need to spend in the classroom need to have their actual transportation cost paid for by the state that is the was the intent of Aydin picas the recommendation that they made to this body as far as I can tell there is no reason that the matrix hasn't been modified to adopt the standard based formula other than what has now become this is the way we've always done it it It is detrimental to the students of small districts like Dearmount Judy to have to ride the buses this long. It is unfair. It is not equitable. As I said, Dearmount Judy not only do their kids ride the bus a long time, but we also then have to pay our teachers the state minimum. And let me just give you an example tell you what that means these days We're not the only district that pays a statement on them. I think there's 10 or 12 But if you pay the state minimum now There is no overlap between your salary schedule and the salary schedule of the Springdale School District a teacher with a PhD and 30 years of experience at the Deer Mountain duty school district will earn less less than a first-year teacher fresh out of school in the Springdale School District. That is the type of inequity that results from not just the transportation, but this is a big part of it. Dearmount Judy spends considerably more on transportation than it receives through the matrix. The NSLA is a good example because it was anticipated by Auden and Pike, as they say here, we recommend a transportation categorical program. They expected transportation like NSLA to be paid on need. It's a type of program that your need is not determined by your ADM. need is determined in the NSL it's by the the number of free and reduced lunch kids and for transportation it basically comes down to route miles how many buses do you want to run you know if we right now you know we're running say five buses to get kids there in an hour and a half if we wanted to get them there in 45 minutes we need 10 buses transportation funding should be based on need we would urge you to adopt a standards-based transportation funding formula like the one in the proposed bill thank you thank you counselor we
▶ Play
appreciate you being here today mr. harder mr. Ron harder with the School Board Association will be speaking against the bill you
▶ Play
Speaker 185 1:02:16
are recognized proceed, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. Mostly, I guess I just want to try to rephrase and recapture what Scott Richardson and Dr. Kimmel stated, but I would add there is no statutory, Arkansas statutory requirement to transport any student. You have some federal for students that need it as part of their IDEA plan or 504 plan, but statutorily, there's no requirement to transport any student in Arkansas. So that what Scott said was, in this whole issue, the need is to sort out a difference between the decisions that have historically been made that if you take this bill are forever more locked in based on historical route miles and what you as a legislative body may choose to determine which is what the last testimony actually was referring to do you want to define things on length of bus routes time-wise? Do you want to define it by you're not going to be required or fund as a state transporting any student that is less than X amount of miles? It could be two, it could be 22, but you could pick that number. But adopting this bill negates that option for what you could choose. How many buses would it take? How many bus drivers would it take? Those are decisions that if you just codify from a funding standpoint historical route miles, you abdicate your option for being able to use that to determine a more appropriate funding formula if you then derive a funding formula you could fund it separate outside of the funding formula and put it under a caps this is going to be for not transporting students closer than X amount of miles or that it wouldn't that wouldn't be going into the funding the district might choose to do that but it wouldn't be based on what you would have to put forth from the funding formula. So I would also, when we get into Pincus and Auden, it was very clear from the beginning and both reports, studies that they did, they made their recommendations, but it was the adequacy committee that shows which of those recommendations to adopt and not to adopt pikes and i didn't dictate what accuracy was they made the recommendations is a legislature that adopted at fifty seven requires your body inadequacy committee to determine what modifications need to be made and you have a long list of things that you have to examine and this would be a very good thing to examine but from a different perspective than just coming out from brown miles
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:53
representative was thank you mr chair so are you recommending possibly in my hearing you're right that we should revisit whether or not we should allow buses to pick up let's say inside city limits or maybe uh... you know look at that and that would cut down on our transportation costs bottom line
▶ Play
Speaker 185 1:06:17
i think you need to examine it top to bottom and that's not knocking richard wilson and the work that he did but it doesn't take into consideration whether the historic route miles are something you want to codify forevermore i think that he The wise thing to do would be to go back to the drawing board and put your dollars, how much money are you willing to put into it? Are you going to put a limit on the amount of time a student can be on the bus? So, therefore, you're going to have to fund that many more buses, that many more bus drivers. Do you want to put a limit on how close you're willing to calculate into the formula for what number you would come up with for transportation funding categorical thank you thank you
▶ Play
mr. harder thank you very much we appreciate your time dr. Abernathy you you're recognized sir
▶ Play
Speaker 193 1:07:22
speak against the bill thank you mr. chair Richard Abernathy executive director of school administrators and I think you have covered just about every possible scenario that's out there so just trying to recap this you know Transportation funding is probably one of those items that you can put a pencil to and say, this particular item is not fair. However, and I'm going to go back to the health insurance discussion that we've had. Those funds were sent out to those schools, and it has never been an expenditure model. It has just been a funding model. And so those districts have made decisions based off of the rules that the legislature provided them, and it would be absolutely unfair to go back and pull the money out and say, I'm sorry that you're not spending in this particular category, but we're going to take that money away from you. And we just don't think that's a place you need to go. However, we do think that at some point in time, you're going to have to address this issue. It's been talked about. It's been studied. It's been various recommendations that's come forth. We have sent some recommendations over the years on issues dealing with transportation, and it is absolutely unfair to school districts all around the state. And we talk about efficiency. You talk about, well, the concept of not having to transport kids to school, that's inaccurate. But can you really imagine those kids not having an opportunity to go to school? Because if you don't transport them, they're not coming. And so I would be extremely concerned as a policy decision that we just said no transportation whatsoever. But we do have an issue with that. We are not supportive whatsoever of pulling those funds out of the matrix. We would support and have recommended, you know, a separate starting a categorical type fund for high cost transportation. That recommendation came forth, I guess, this last session. But back on the efficiency model, when school districts have 600 square miles in their district and they transport kids in those school districts and other districts have 35 miles, it's not going to be equitable by funding everyone the same. So with that being said, I think you all had about enough of
▶ Play
this. Thank you, Dr. Appanatha. We appreciate you very much. Ms. Donna, you want to jump in this? Okay. With that, do we have anyone else who wishes to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Armstrong, would you like to close for your bill, sir? You've heard
▶ Play
people come up here and speak for the bill. You've heard them speak against the bill. But one statement that I picked up, yes, this formula needs to be worked on. We need a new matrix. And I think it's time for the Department of Education to work on it. And that's what this bill would do, would be based on a standard formula for root miles or some kind of matrix that's needed. Arden and Picos came up with that, and that was just a suggestion. That was a temporary fix. And also I heard that a child has to go to school, but they don't have to provide transportation. How in the world will they get an education if we don't provide transportation? So with that, I hope you look and give me a favor on this bill and vote due pass because it's something that's actually needed. It was a study done, I think it started in about 2005, and it went on for two or three years. So I'm asking you to give me a due pass on this
▶ Play
bill. thank you with that chair will entertain a motion representative armstrong did I just interpret that as a motion that you made yes yes we have a do pass motion all in favor all opposed motion fails representative Armstrong thank you very much sir Senator Burnett has patiently waited. We appreciate his patience very much. This afternoon, upon adjournment, we are going to be taking up Senate bills, since we do have many, but since Senator Burnett has been patient, we are going to allow him to run with his permission, Senate Bill 839.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:12:05
Senator, you are recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I can promise you this doesn't have anything to do with matrix and should be fairly simply explained. This is a bill to abolish the old position of county superintendent. And to give you a little bit of history, in 2005, a bill was passed that allowed counties to dissolve and to do away with
▶ Play
the county superintendent position. Senator, I beg your pardon, Representative Talley, the bill number is 839.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:12:44
I beg your pardon, Senator. That's quite all right. It's about a page and a half, so you shouldn't have any trouble reading it while I discuss it. And to give you a little bit of history, in 2005, a bill was passed, and there's quite a bit of history in this. There are attorney generals' opinions and others. But in 2005, the counties were allowed to abolish this position. It's antiquated and outdated. There are three counties in the state that have county coordinators, I believe is the term they use, district coordinators instead of county superintendent. at Union County, Craighead County, and Mississippi County. This bill is a permissive bill to allow those three counties to also abolish this position and to transfer any funds that are currently in the account to county general fund. There is a, if the funds that are available came from the, depends on where they came from, it may be shared 50-50 with the school districts. My county government, Mississippi County, this position hasn't been actually functioning for several years. this bill provides for if the position has been vacated for more than five years or not functioning that the county government could elect to abolish it pretty pretty simple i'll be happy to try to answer any questions you might have
▶ Play
senator thank you for your presentation member sure do you have question
▶ Play
senator burnett would you clarify i think here about that the funding could you talk about your bill would do with the money
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:14:39
this well i i could use mississippi county is an example uh... is a county government that asked me to introduces billers are about approximately three hundred and twenty nine thousand seventeen cents in a fun uh... this is sitting there they hadn't been used for salaries or anything else uh... there's some question on on the source of that fund i think the best i've been able to determine it came from delinquent taxes uh... and if those delinquent taxes who could be associated with the common school fund in the cat cat that the school district would be entitled to fifty percent of it that's in the bill if it was some from some other source and it would go into county general fund what would excuse me
▶ Play
if i can follow up when you say they the schools of the response entitled to fifty percent of it what do you elaborate
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:15:33
on that well uh... there's a constitutional provision if it comes from county uh... from uh... the common school fund and they're entitled fifty percent of it so that's an existing law okay
▶ Play
the schools in total you mean what with the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:15:45
five districts i think in mississippi county and they they would share uh... uh... in half of their up pro rata or how would you
▶ Play
that be you know i don't know that that's that's already in the law yes okay
▶ Play
written different ball thank you mr chair just a quick uh... question center is there a school district it would uh... lose money over this
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:16:11
no is it doesn't have anything to do with uh... production of revenue other than this money will work came as a result of collecting delinquent taxes and it's been just building up in this front over a period of time and and hadn't been utilized uh... and and we have extra money well it's sitting there in the county government can use it to have that i'm sure the school district if if if they're entitled to share can use it also thanks
▶ Play
thank you represented but we have any other questions from the committee saying none do we have anyone who wishes to speak for against the bill if not the chair will entertain a motion we would do pass a representative you banks all in favor All opposed? Motion passes. Senator, thank you very much for being here. Thanks for your patience. MR. Thank you very much, members. MR. Representative Lowry, if you are ready, sir, we will recognize you to present House Bill 1789. MR. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. With your permission, I'd like to ask Jerry Cox with the Arkansas Family Council to join me. MR. Mr. Cox, welcome. MR. Thank you. Well, House Bill 1789 deals with an issue that's been I think we can fairly say has been thoroughly vetted over the last several sessions. It first was brought up by Senator Gilbert Baker in the 2009 session, was sent to interim study. In 2011, it passed the Senate by a 30 to 1 vote and came up one vote short in House Education Committee of going on to the House. Since then, and I would thoroughly concede that the Activities Association had worked to recognize, one, that this is an issue that is with us, homeschool students. It's estimated in 2007 there were 1.5 million homeschool students throughout the United States. I think that number is up to now around 2 million. This very committee also recognized the significance of the presence of homeschool students when Representative Linderman's bill was considered allowing school districts that are at that 350 mark to maybe be able to count homeschool students in reaching that number's adequacy for their school districts. So obviously all parties have recognized that this is something homeschool students and homeschooling is something that's here to stay. And I think we've also recognized that there is an opportunity here for us to build bridges between the various entities, public schools, private schools, home schools, students, to mutual benefit. We hear the word in so many of the bills that have been presented, we hear the word fair. We hear equitable. This is the ultimate fair and equitable bill because it allows these students the full process of education. Just because they are being homeschooled doesn't mean that they should not have access to other activities that are offered. And that's what we're trying to do. Now, I will concede that there are some differences between what the Activities Association has now as regulation and what we are trying to codify here, but the main difference is that we've recognized that this is an important public policy initiative. And as such, it should be codified and not just part of regulation. And I know there are a number of questions. I know that there are also a number of a coalition of groups that will be coming and expressing their concerns. And I think what's best is for me to try and move to that process as quickly as possible. So I'm open for any questions, or we can proceed to the testimony. MR. Thank
▶ Play
you, Representative Lowry. Just want to clarify, at this committee we always want to give credit where credit is due, and the bill that you aforementioned, including homeschoolers in the general population, was actually Representative Ratliff's bill, so we want to make sure that he gets the props on that. MR. That's right. MR. I have a question, and I was here in committee when Senator Gilbert Baker presented the home of this same bill two years ago, and Mr. Cox remembers that as well. Mr. Cox, and I think you're probably best suited to answer this question because you've been here. This is something that's been a passionate subject for you for a long time. Can you describe the difference between this bill and Senator Baker's bill two years ago? MR. There
▶ Play
really is not a lot of difference between the two. What we did with this bill, we took Senator Baker's bill from two years ago. We took the current AAA policy regarding homeschool students who participate in extracurricular activities, and then I think maybe we took an item or two from another state's laws. I think about 20 states are making this work, you know, in some measure. So the short answer, Mr. Chairman, is there's really not much difference between the two. This is actually more like the current AAA policy than anything else out there.
▶ Play
That's what it's like. Mr. Cox, what is the concern that I don't see the AAA policy changing? Is your concern that they're changing leadership over time, that there could be a change, is the reason we need to codify
▶ Play
Speaker 233 1:22:05
this? Absolutely, because, as we all
▶ Play
know, the gatekeeper can close that gate any time they feel like it. And there are really two gatekeepers under the current AAA policy. You have AAA and their rules and regs. But then I got a call just recently from a newspaper in northeast Arkansas, and their school board was debating on whether or not to even allow homeschoolers to even try out for extracurricular activities. And so apparently that school district felt like they could be the gatekeeper as well. And so when a homeschooler has to pass through both of those gates, the likelihood of them really being able to participate goes way down because you've got to meet AAA requirements. And then the local school board says, well, we'll think about letting you in or not. And we had a situation in northwest Arkansas where the current AAA policy says that the homeschooler has to go a minimum of one class per day at the public school in order to participate, and they said, well, we're going to require them to be there three classes a day. Well, if they're there four, they're enrolled full-time. And so the current policy is tilted way, you know, in the direction of everybody except the student. And, Mr. Chairman, you may remember last session when this bill came up, But there was a little seventh-grade boy sitting right over there on that front row from down in CrossFit area. And he just wanted to play football. That's all he wanted to do. He was a homeschooler, and he wanted to play. And when that bill failed by one vote last session, he began to cry. And I think sometimes we lose sight of what we're talking about, kids, that are looking at us as grown people and saying, can't you all just work this out to where I can play? I just want to go play. And I think that gate is still closed to kids like that. And so this bill seeks to open that gate for them and try to do something that's good for those little kids.
▶ Play
You know, Mr. Cox, I've always kind of felt like if you've got a Tim Tebow in your community, they're going to figure out
▶ Play
a way and policies will change. Well, and Florida was one of the first states to pass such a
▶ Play
law, And it's interesting that he came out of Florida. Yeah. And, Mr. Chairman, I think we need to clarify that this is not just about athletics. This is also about other activities, band, choir, other sports. I mean, it really is an access, a fair access, free access bill. And I know actually the last count I've heard is that 28 states have initiated similar legislation. And it's not just limited to athletics. So, you know, this is about kids. And I think that sometimes we don't hear that enough in testimony about bills that come before this committee, and we're talking about kids and students, children who want fair access to, frankly, something that their families are paying for. They're paying public tax dollars, and they're just asking to be able to access
▶ Play
that. Mr. Cox, can you delineate for the committee the current policy in terms of homeschoolers being able to access extracurricular activities? I remember two years ago, I thought it was constructive. Senator Baker kind of broke down what they have access to now. If you could do that for us, I'd appreciate that. And probably, Mr. Chairman, the
▶ Play
best way for me to do that is to use the bill that's before you as a point of reference. And so with your permission, I want to call your attention to the bill itself because I believe there will be people coming and testify against this bill in a little bit. So I'd like to try to answer some of those questions before we get to them, if that's okay. First of all, on page 1, line 21 and 22, it says here that the student has to notify the principal of the school of their intentions to participate in the extracurricular activity by the same deadline that everybody in the school has to meet. So that shouldn't be a problem, I don't think. If spring baseball sign-up is January 1st, then the homeschooler just has to notify them by January 1st. Under the current AAA policy, you've got to notify the school district by July of the previous year. So if I'm going to run track in the springtime, I've got to tell the school district in July of the previous year that I want to run track. That's the way the current policy is. This one just says you've got to notify them at the same time, everybody else. You've got to live by the same deadline. The other difference is on line 23, where it says the principal of the resident school shall permit a homeschool student to pursue participation in an activity if they meet these requirements that are listed below. So that clarifies that they've got a right to try. They don't have a guaranteed right to be allowed in there. They're not guaranteed a place on the ball team or a place in the choir, but they've got to be allowed to try for that. And that eliminates some of that discussion about whether or not the local school board would allow or not allow. And then on that same page, lines 29 through 36, we've outlined three different ways that a student can show academic proficiency. And I think under AAA, their policy, it's the SAT-10. They take the SAT-10 test. So that is a difference there. And then I think that's it. I think the rest of this is in the current AAA policy. So most of what you have before you, I believe, is in their policy. I will call your attention to one thing on page 3, line 22 and 23. There was some discussion with the superintendents about insurance, and they said, well, the homeschooler needs to be on campus at least one period a day so we can maintain catastrophic insurance policies for athletes. And we said, that's okay. If it's necessary for insurance purposes, then you can require that homeschool kid to come to school one period a day. And it might be if they're there for choir, it's already going to be one period. But if it's an after-school activity, then you could say, well, you've got to take a class. And that's for insurance purposes. So we did have that discussion with some individuals, with the Administrators Association, to try to address that. But, Mr. Chairman, I would say that the vast majority of what's in front of you, again, is already AAA policy.
▶ Play
Representative Lowry, can you – and thank you, Mr. Cox. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Lowry, can you talk a little bit about the fiscal impact and how that relates to this bill? kind
▶ Play
of give us a rundown on that. Well, the fiscal impact is that the schools actually stand to gain funding. On page three, if you look just above lines 20 and 21, the student would be counted as an enrolled student by the resident school district. So in that case, the school would be able to count them as an attending student. be able to to gain the foundation funding that would come
▶ Play
with that thank you represent larry um do you gentlemen have anything to
▶ Play
add before we take questions i do have one thing mr chairman with your permission somebody might say well how many kids are we talking about here how many kids are we talking about there are about 16 000 homeschool kids in k-12 these extracurricular activities are going to be 7th through 12th grade, as we all know. That's where you do choir and band and athletics and all these things. So we're probably dealing with a pool of about 5,000 kids altogether, but most of the homeschoolers that I know of aren't interested in participating in extracurricular activities at the public school. So I would just, my best educated guess would be that you're talking about maybe 500 kids statewide. And you can kind of do the math to divide that by the number of school districts that we have. But you're kind of getting down into single digits per school district. And so it's not like there are going to be swarms of homeschoolers coming over to the public school wanting to participate. I think you could probably, most school districts, you could count them on one hand, the number of kids that are actually going to go over there and say, I want to be in the choir, I want to be in the band, I want to play ball. So that's just kind of put it in perspective a
▶ Play
little bit. Thank you, Representative Cox. And, you know, we have several, before we get to questions, we have several folks who are signed up to speak for and against the bill, and I would just ask respectfully that we keep your comments brief and to the point. We have two representatives who have been waiting patiently. I want them to get their bills heard today. So with that, do we have any questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Representative Linderman. Okay, I've got a few questions. I was contacted by a superintendent that has 3,200 kids, and he said they've had one request to do this. You said there are several things in this bill that are in current AAA policy, and they have just recently adopted that. Why are we not waiting to let that see how that works and see if we need to put something else
▶ Play
in statute? Well, what we have seen is that, as Mr. Cox mentioned earlier, is that there has been misinterpretation at the local district of, for instance, the baseline number of one class. I mean, one school district is using that to say, well, that's just the baseline. We can actually offer more. So there's already a problem there. So also in my conversations with the Activity Association, I've found in their wording that there's also a problem in that it allows the student to either play for the school district that they are in or the attendance zone. And it leaves a pretty good loophole in, for instance, Pulaski County School District where a student could actually go to a different attendance zone. And, of course, the Activity Association says, well, that wasn't our intent, and we would catch that administratively. Those kinds of things, they need to be caught by school districts. They need to be caught by Department of Education. All the other oversight that we have with homeschooling and not another entity that says, well, we'll fix that later. I think the main issue is that we need to send a message to these students that they are wanted. And I don't know that a regulation that's passed by the Activities Association and then loosely interpreted in some ways to actually exclude them does that. I think we can send a signal to these students that they are invited, they are wanted, and that they would be allowed to participate, and
▶ Play
this law would do that. Are there not now special homeschool activities, I understand, or sporting events? I know we've got a 4-H group that I work with, and we've got livestock shows, that homeschool students participate in, are there not organized homeschool clubs and teams now?
▶ Play
With your permission, I think I can address that a little bit. In Little Rock, there are many opportunities for homeschool kids because there are 500 families in the Little Rock Homeschool Association. So when you get 500 families together, that's the size of a small town. So they do a lot of extracurricular activities. But as you know, when you get out into smaller communities, there may only be a dozen homeschool kids in a 50-mile radius. And so this really helps those kids, I believe Representative Linderman, more than the ones here in Little Rock. It helps the ones out in the smaller areas where they just don't have the numbers to do a football team, for example, or something like that.
▶ Play
One last question. You said it's about kids. A student that leaves a public school system and goes to another school, in most cases has to wait 365 days. They've got to wait a calendar year before they can participate. Would this not give a student or a parent that chose to homeschool their child, would this not give them an advantage over some of these students that are, what we would
▶ Play
consider traditional students? Representative Lauer, you may want to address that, but at the very last part of the bill, on page 3, lines 27 through 31, I think addressed that issue. So, you know, we've attempted to address that issue there at the very end there about, you know, eligibility and so forth. If
▶ Play
they're academically ineligible to participate in interscholastic Interscholastic activity, they're not eligible to participate as a homeschool student in a resident school until the beginning of the following school year. So we do deal with that issue. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Linderman. Representative Deffenbaugh. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Two things. Each one of you may have referred to one of these. I would say this, if I was coaching still, I'd be beating the bushes and looking. I think it would be a big advantage to some district or an advantage. But I looked on the amendment, and I missed something that concerns me, and that is in the AAA guidelines, their SAT 10 test determines the eligibility per semester. Isn't that right? So what about this test? Do we know what test is? I mean, we've talked about norm reference. I'm still not getting at which test that is. And are we going to do it each semester? When we talked, I thought that's what we had said. Are they going to be, on your bill, are these youngsters going to be tested for both semesters for eligibility? That's what we're going to
▶ Play
get ahead of. Okay. And thank you. I appreciate the question. The language in here where it says nationally recognized norm reference test, that's language that was actually lifted out of the current homeschool law where it talks about testing and so forth. And so there was no magic as to where that language came from. It just came out of the current law. But the way this is written, it would be annual. Now, somebody may be able to clarify for me. I do not remember if the current AAA policy is to test them every year or every six months. And Representative Deffenbaugh, you may have read that since I have. I just don't remember what their policy is to test how often. But, you know, that's the way this is written, where they would do it annually. And that's when homeschoolers are currently required to test. They're required to use a nationally recognized norm reference test. that is approved by the state board, and they take that every year. And so sort of the intent behind that was that they would be able to take that homeschool test that they do every year already and just present their scores. And that way they wouldn't have to go hire somebody to give them another test. That was kind of the spirit behind that. All right. Thank
▶ Play
you. Thank you, Representative Deffenbaugh. We have any other questions? Representative Hobbs. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, I see on line 20, page 3, you state that they will be counted or that student will be counted as an enrolled student by the resident school district. So I don't see in the bill, and maybe I overlooked it, where how much of the foundational funding then would be paid to the school for that student. Well,
▶ Play
it really doesn't say that. The other thing that we have dealt with, though, is where it is stipulated that for insurance purposes they would have to attend a minimum number, there would be the one class. That would guarantee at least one-seventh funding. As far as how much funding comes from them being able to count that student, I mean, it's silent on that. That's correct. I guess that would be between the school district and the State Department of
▶ Play
Education. And Representative Hobbs, I'm sure there are other people in the room who could address that way better than I could. But it's been my understanding that it's been policy. If a student is there part-time, they can claim them for partial funding. But that's my
▶ Play
understanding of it. Okay. And yet they'll be counted as a full-time student for enrollment purposes for the ADM? That would be a
▶ Play
Speaker 270 1:40:20
question more appropriately asked of the department. Okay. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Hobbs. Do we have
▶ Play
any other questions? Representative Lampkin. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just as a point of clarification, since we've talked so much about transportation, this says on line 18, a homeschool student who participates in an interscholastic activity may be, and then line 24 says transported. Does that mean transported to and from the home or to the school from the school to Norflit and back wherever they're playing.
▶ Play
If you read line 25, Representative Lauer, you want to answer that? No, I have. Okay. It's very clear that it is to and from the activity so that the kid's not having to drive himself, you know, 50 miles to a ballgame. He can ride the bus with everybody
▶ Play
else. That's what it means to the game, not necessarily to practice every day. That's correct. That is
▶ Play
correct. Thank you. Any other questions from the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:41:26
committee? Representative Douglas? I had a superintendent in my district that had a very interesting take on this, and they said that they really welcome with open arms these kids coming in and participating because they feel like if they can get them on campus, they may win them over for the entire day. And I thought that was a great positive way for, you know, for them to have feedback with potential kids that might come into their school. She felt like that she could win them over. I wondered what you thought about that.
▶ Play
Well, I appreciate that attitude. And I will say this, I've been, as many of you know, I've been doing this for quite some time. And the current attitude of the Department of Education right now has been much more welcoming toward the homeschoolers. Dr. Kimbrell and his folks have done a really good job of extending that hand of hospitality to the homeschoolers, where when I first started doing this, it was all stiff arm toward the homeschoolers. And it's been nice to see that change of attitude. And I
▶ Play
think it's been good for everybody. Thank you, Representative Douglas. Seeing no more questions, we're going to let Lance Taylor with the AAA come up and recognize him. Of course, he will be speaking against the bill. Lance, thank you for being here today. We appreciate you very much. And while you're getting comfortable and getting seated, can you clarify for us the eligibility requirements and if there is any sort of difference between a potential homeschool athlete and an enrolled athlete? Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And with your permission, I'd
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:43:26
like to bring Dr. Joey Walters. Absolutely. Doctor, thank you for
▶ Play
being here today. Thank you. There are some differences, and
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:43:36
that was our concerns when they amended the bill. What we had, and I'll tell you the difference between ours and their bill, is what we wanted to make sure that happened is that we treated both groups equally. And to be eligible at a AAA member school, you had to pass four academic classes and, of course, have a 2.0, a C average, or you do not have the right to participate. You have to do that. You have to earn that right. And they took that out in their amendment because that's one thing that we wanted to make sure that was in there. That's what we used. Bill Ballard, who's a homeschool testing coordinator for the state of Arkansas, he came and he found the SAT-10 test for us. And he also told us that the homeschool students were doing a great job at home and they could bring to the superintendent of the school because we required it to go to the superintendent that they could show them that they were passing four academic courses and show them the curriculum. and also showing the test scores so we were going to make sure that we treated all the students the same and that's the criteria that we put in there that for the superintendent to make a decision yes you can participate or no you can't based on this our academic scholarship requirement that all our students have to follow in our schools
▶ Play
and we're going to and that might be something representative larry if you want to hop in real quick But from your perspective, and based on what Mr. Taylor just said, I think that, you know, participation for everybody, as long as everybody's on the same, everybody's doing the same things, everybody's being tested the same way, the eligibility requirements are the same. Can you, based on what Mr. Taylor just said, where are we here?
▶ Play
Well, I don't have the Activities Association guideline in front of me, but from what I remember of reading is that it does allow the presentation of the SAT-10 results and nothing more. It doesn't refer to passing four classes or any of the other. It just references the test. The one thing that we have done differently is rather than using, and this came up in conversation with Lance and with some other entities, They specifically reference SAT-10, but, you know, next year it could be called something else. We've used the phrase norm reference test to be able to allow that flexibility so that we're not caught in between legislative sessions, for instance, if all of a sudden we say SAT-10 and then next year the norm reference test has a different name that the homeschool students are caught in the limbo. So by using that more generic language, which really is very similar to what they have, we referenced that it would be a test, a norm-reference test, that is approved by the State Department of Education. So we feel like that there is adequate oversight. And these students are being tested every year, which, if I understand correctly, is unlike the
▶ Play
public school students. Okay, so I just want to get some clarification. are enrolled athletes at a public school, is the bar set a little bit higher for them than it's going to be for homeschooled athletes participating in our programs? I would just have
▶ Play
to say at the point that the Activities Association did adopt a guideline, they made the determination that the bar was not different. All we're doing is just codifying that bar.
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:47:13
Mr. Taylor do you have anything to add to that Yes sir and with your permission I brought our rules because
▶ Play
I didn't know They were on our AAA website
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:47:23
We're going to have Mark come down there and pass those out Again we do follow the academic scholarship requirement to be eligible for all of our students I think more importantly too is we have great concerns with several areas of this bill First of all, if you're in a AAA member school and you transfer to another school, and if you're not eligible, you're not eligible for 365 days. And that's one of the first rules that you're going to see on here. And we didn't want to treat anybody differently, and we didn't want to encourage anybody that might be on the bubble or even below the bubble of that two-point to drop out to become eligible. And there's a big difference between what we have and what this bill has. And that's a big concern because we do not want to add to the dropout of the public schools. And that way, that's why we put that 365 days in there not to be eligible, so it's the same for
▶ Play
all, both sides. I guess I'm still kind of, and I want to make sure this is clear for the committee. We passed this bill. So are the eligibility requirements going to be the same for everybody? No, sir. They will not be. Okay. Mr. Representative Lowry, I'm going to
▶ Play
give you a chance to respond to that. I would say that that comment is not unique to this bill. The Activities Association guideline is doing the same thing, so
▶ Play
it's not a unique argument. Okay. Anyway, we're going to have to get the bad guys involved in this here in a little bit. But before we do that, do we have any questions for Mr. Taylor, Representative Deffenbaugh?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Taylor, I've been fortunate enough to talk to all y'all and talk to Representative Lowry, so I've got a little perspective. One accusation that had been leveled against your guidelines is, and I don't know if they're true, but a couple different school districts supposedly have already not allowed a student to participate or sign up, and another superintendent supposedly added the number of periods that he wanted a homeschooler to go to. So, anyway, whether those are true or not, how does your guidelines handle something like that if, let's say, the superintendent just doesn't cooperate? Yes, sir. Well, I think that's a communication that we're going
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:50:05
to have to work with the AAEA and us to make sure that they understand. I think a lot of them don't understand on the outside right now, the homeschoolers, as long as they meet that academic scholarship requirement of passing four and having a two-point, then they're only going to have to be enrolled that one period. Of course, there were several reasons for that one period. One was for the school insurance, which is up to $25,000 to cover those students. We have catastrophic insurance for all students from $25,000 up to a million and a half if something bad happens that will cover those students as long as they're enrolled one period today. And they did amend that and include that, which is very important to make sure that these athletes are safe and can be cared for out there on the fields and the courts. Thank
▶ Play
you. Thank you, Representative Devon. Madam Vice Chair.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. On C, you have the deadline for July 1st. and I guess I'm not clear why that's necessary. You don't know who's going to try out for basketball on July 1st for the public school kids. You know, that's way ahead of a date that you would sign up for sports. Anybody that
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:51:25
school choice or board-to-board transfers, everything has to be done. Our eligibility is all based on being enrolled in that school by July 1st now. So if a homeschool student even thinks, doesn't have to make the decision, if he just thinks that he wants to participate, the only thing he has to do is notify the superintendent, they look at that academic scholarship, and in that, let's say it's track, let's say it's baseball or anything like that, it will give them time to know that they're going to play. And Representative Clemmer, just like basketball, it doesn't start in October. Well, that's true. As I said,
▶ Play
the tryouts are usually in the spring. But now for kids that move into the district, oftentimes provisions are made for them on sports. Right, and somebody
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:52:07
makes a complete and bona fide move. If a move, a family makes that, then we would waive that rule at the AAA to let them go ahead. And if they could prove to the superintendent that they met the academic scholarship requirement and have the two-point, we would have to make the same provision for the homeschool students if their parents made a complete and bona fide move from one school district to the other. So if a kid moves
▶ Play
from one school district to the other, do they have to tell you by July 1st?
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:52:34
No, ma'am. That's why we would make the provisions for
▶ Play
these students. Okay, so that's what I'm saying. We're going to try to treat them the same. But if you're making an exception to the July 1st policy for someone who moves in, a homeschooler has already lived in that district, has already been paying taxes in that district, but you're not making any exception. I mean, I understand that teams need to be set in advance. Let me ask you this. So if I were a parent of a homeschooler and my kid wanted to play sports, if basketball tryouts, well, I mean, my daughter's a dance team coach, so they already had tryouts. They're about to have tryouts right now for next year. So if I knew that, and I was a homeschooler, But could I go, say, let a child participate in those tryouts now? Yes, ma'am. As long as they're
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:53:32
enrolled one period a day, because they wouldn't be eligible, of course, into the new school year because they're coming in after the July 1 date. But they could go tryout as long as they're enrolled in that one period a day.
▶ Play
Yes, ma'am. But it almost sounds like you've got to catch 22 there, though. You can't tryout unless you're enrolled. So, in effect, it seems like you could almost be making more than July 1st deadline. Do you follow what I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:53:59
asking? Well, again, you want to make sure when those kids try out, and let's say it's spring football, let's say it's dance right now or cheerleading, and you have one of those, unfortunately, when somebody gets hurt out there, you want to make sure that those kids are covered with insurance. And being enrolled one period, we can do that, and so can the school. So, again, they would not be eligible, but they would have that opportunity to try out and participate. And then by the time July 1 rolled around and they notified the superintendent and they could meet that academic scholarship requirement, they would be eligible. Could they
▶ Play
enroll at the beginning of the semester? No, ma'am. Well, they could, I
▶ Play
Speaker 292 1:54:35
guess, if they were. I mean, if
▶ Play
you're just talking about for the purposes of trying out and being on. So they could come at semester. Well, I mean, are we, or wouldn't. But you're not saying that. Could they enroll in the middle of the semester? Because if someone moves in, they can enroll. Yes, we would make that provision. Yes, ma'am. Okay. So they would be, if a kid decided they wanted to try out, the rule would be go sign up for a class. That's correct. So that you're eligible for try out. And if that class is, now, if that class is a sport, if the sport is a class, is that enough?
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:55:14
If it's during that seven-period day, yes, ma'am. It just says they have to be in a class that doesn't say academic, doesn't say activity. And, again, another thing. But
▶ Play
if you haven't made the team yet, you couldn't probably get in the class. So you'd probably need another class. I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:55:28
sorry I cut you off. As long as it's during the seven periods, they would be allowed to. Okay. It can be that activity. And another thing that's different between our bill and theirs, for non-athletic competitions, and I'm talking about band and choir, speech and debate and things like that, you have to be in band class. You have to be in choir. You had to be in speech of debate to be able to compete after school. That's a requirement, and that's why it's in our bill. We had the Julia Reynolds from the Band Association, their executive director, and Tom Streak from the Choir Association. They were also involved in this decision-making.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you. I appreciate that information. I think
▶ Play
you got everything. Thank you. Representative Hobbs. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I see that in paragraph C, it says a public school district may permit. So the way that reads, I assume it's kind of what Representative Deffenbaugh alluded to a while ago, that a school district does not have to allow a homeschool student to participate if they don't want to. Is that correct? Again, that's where the superintendent
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:56:37
makes that decision to make sure that that student has met the academic scholarship requirement, that they pass four classes and they have a 2.0, then they would be
▶ Play
allowed. Okay, so even though the language says may permit paragraph C?
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:56:54
They have to have that because if they do not meet that academic scholarship requirement, then they probably would not be allowed to because they're not meeting the
▶ Play
same standard. So it goes along with the following. Okay, thank you for that clarification. So if a school district just tells a homeschool student you can't try out even though you meet these qualifications, what do you have available to you to enforce them to follow these rules? I'm sorry, I didn't say that very clearly, sorry. But if a school district tells this homeschool student they meet the requirements to participate, But the school superintendent should say, well, our school district isn't going to participate in that. Do you have any way to enforce these rules with that school district? I don't know if you're saying, can I
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:57:44
make them? No, ma'am, I don't have that kind of authority. It's a AAA office. We do not have that. But I would communicate with that superintendent, and that's what Dr. Abernathy and I would both, from the AAEA and from us, I think we could get that point to all the superintendents in the state. And I think that's something that we're doing this spring because, you know, later on this year they will start adopting policies. Most schools have not done that for next year yet, but they will begin doing that here. And we go out to nine activity districts in the spring in April, and where all the superintendents and principals come to our meetings and vote on new rules or proposal rules, and we will discuss this with them at those
▶ Play
meetings. Okay. And if a parent should run into a roadblock, is there some kind of an appeal process to the AAA?
▶ Play
Speaker 305 1:58:33
Yes, ma'am. We have appeals for everything. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Hobbs. Do we have any other questions for Mr. Taylor? Representative Ratliff. How many
▶ Play
Speaker 306 1:58:45
students do we have participating like this right now in homeschooling and public schools? None. The
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:58:50
rule goes in effect July 1. Okay. It's coming year. We just voted the rule in August. A lot of y'all were here last time. If y'all remember, y'all asked us to take care of this. And we went out and we talked to the superintendents, and 70% of the superintendents supported this and voted this rule in based on what y'all asked us to do from this committee last session.
▶ Play
Thanks, sir. Thank you, Representative Ratliff. Do we have any other questions for Mr.
▶ Play
Taylor? Madam Vice Chair. along the lines thank you mr. chair for taking another question from me along the lines of what representative Hobbs was asking with the language saying may and if the school district didn't want to let the student enroll and then they decided they wanted to bring suit I'm wondering if that current language would support the school district's option with that language. And I guess my question is, we've written some confusing bills here, but I'm not sure that that's as clear as it ought to be. I would prefer a wording of shall and if the circumstances are met. I think that would make the guideline a little bit clearer to the school districts and might head off potential lawsuits or challenges. But that would just be, would you agree that that might help people understand what the law is? Because I think that may in there is kind of
▶ Play
Speaker 274 2:00:33
confusing. Thank you. Representative Clemmer, legally I can't answer that, I don't think. We did pass it through our legal counsel. I had Scott Smith on this committee, too, because he has that ability to look at it and tell us what he thought. So we put him on this committee. He was part of this committee. And we also ran it through several times through the school board association. They came over, both Kristen and both Ron came over and sat down, and they took one side, and we would take the other, and we would flip-flop. And we tried to make sure everything
▶ Play
was clear. I understand. And as long as you're making it clear what the intent is in your training sessions, it may be just fine. But I can see why someone might have pause for concern there. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Douglas, I'm going to entertain your question here momentarily, but I want to get clarification from the Department of Ed on these eligibility requirements before we go forward. And if there's someone from Dr. Kimbrell's bunch who's available to just, you know, Dr. Kimball, if you're able to, I think just for clarification of the committee, and I know it's a long day and I don't want to keep you here longer than necessary, but the eligibility requirements per this proposed legislation, will they be different for homeschooled athletes as opposed to our currently enrolled athletes in public schools? So I think let's kind of get some clarification on that, if
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:02:06
you can help us out. When you talk about eligibility, are you talking about
▶ Play
eligibility for funding or eligibility for participation? I'm talking about eligibility for participation. Is everybody going to be measured the same in terms of how we grant eligibility?
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:02:23
I don't know how you could do that. And, you know, when I've looked at this law, I'm not sure because it's an oar in there about which assessment. So I don't think that because there is the option of a nationally normed test that if a homeschool student used that, we don't norm reference tests our high school students at this point. We have criterion-referenced assessments. So I don't know that there's any way to really equate that
▶ Play
to. What's the current practice? As far as eligibility is concerned? For homeschoolers who want to participate
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:03:11
in extracurricular activities. Mr. Taylor would have to answer that. We
▶ Play
don't have anything to do with it. Okay. All right. Well, this is something I think is really important. I mean, I think that, you know, we need to make sure, you know, if you're going to participate, everybody who is participating on a football field or on a basketball field or wherever it just needs to be, from my estimation, the requirements need to be the same.
▶ Play
Madam Vice Chair, do you have a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Hudson may have just whispered the answer in my ear, but I might as well ask it anyway. Okay. Can a parent request to come to school for standardized, the same standardized test that a homeschool parent, can they request their kid
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:03:57
be tested? Well, they can't come to the resident school to test. We have a process set up where they're assessed at different sites around the state through our homeschool office.
▶ Play
But they can request the same test. You're just not?
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:04:08
No, ma'am. The law actually specifically says that homeschool students will take the nationally normed, I believe it's SAT-10 at this time. Isn't that right, Jerry? It's whatever the board approves. Okay. Whatever the state board approves. It has to be a norm reference test, though. Right, and I
▶ Play
understand that, but there seems to be some question about whether it's the same test, and then the law is not going to allow them necessarily have the same test.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:04:41
That's right, because only in this law do we require a norm-reference test. In the rest of our laws for students in traditional public schools and charter schools, they have to take our ACT-TAP assessments, which are criterion-referenced assessments. So we don't have the option of expecting a homeschool student to take those same exams. So the homeschool
▶ Play
test, the homeschooler's test, has actually got a little bit more of a, what's the word to describe it? Well, I mean, it's norm reference. I mean, it's more reliable. Is that the word
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:05:18
we want to use? Well, it depends on what you want to define. I mean, a norm reference test is exactly what it does. it's based upon a normed set of students across whatever arena you're talking about. In the case of SAT-10, you're talking about a nationally normed assessment based upon content standards that may or may not be state standards. So it's not based upon what we expect students to know and be able to do in Arkansas.
▶ Play
Don't we generally consider the norm reference a little more rigorous or more maybe valid measure of student achievement? Not necessarily,
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:05:57
because we have an assessment where we're validating the learning of the content standards in our state. So we're actually measuring what students learn that's being taught in the classroom and expected to be taught in the classroom. A norm-referenced assessment takes all kinds of experiential pieces into play also and things that may or may not be a part of our content standards. That's why we're going to the Common Core State Standards where there are 44 states, and we've got 22 states that are going to have the same assessment. You know, we've had those conversations with committees
▶ Play
before. I guess the reason for this line of questioning, thank you for your indulgence, Mr. Chair, is that it's not just like they're going to go take any old test they want. I mean, norm reference test is a valid measure of educational achievement. It may not be what has been taught in the classroom, correct, but it is still a valid measure. I guess we're saying that they're taking these different tests, and maybe one isn't the same as the other. Well, it's not the same, and we're saying it's really not able to be the same. So I think that that's not a good –
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:07:10
I mean, I just don't think that's the right argument. Well, it's not – you can't compare the two. You're comparing an apple to an orange. So, you know, my suggestion would be and has been that when we move to the electronically delivered assessments that we have all students, homeschool students, charter school students, traditional public school students, all take the same assessment because we can deliver it that way. But we would have to change the homeschool law. And I can tell you
▶ Play
Speaker 311 2:07:39
I'll be long gone before I'll bring that
▶ Play
up. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for leaving. Mr. Taylor and Dr. Kimbrell, I think it's less about the veracity of the testing. Would homeschoolers be required once a year to prove eligibility via a test, and that would be it, while our public school athletes, are they required to prove eligibility on a semester basis? That is correct. And again, I
▶ Play
Speaker 274 2:08:12
wanted to add, the reason why Bill Ballard, who's the homeschool testing coordinator, came up with the SAT-10 was several reasons. It's the only test available right now where they can go to the school and their testing coordinator can electronically do it right there in front of them. They can take the test, hit a button, they have immediate feedback. And another good point, it was only going to cost the schools $12.95 per test. And he came up with the SAT-10 test because he thought that would be the easiest way for the homeschooler to be tested and have immediate feedback without having to be shipped off and come back with the
▶ Play
results. We relied on Bill Ballard for that. Representative Lowry. Each semester. And thank you, Mr. Taylor. Representative Lowry, what are other states, what is their model in terms of, and maybe this is something Mr. Cox can answer, but what model are they using in terms of eligibility
▶ Play
requirements? I would need to defer to Mr. Cox. I mean, there's 29 states, and they all have different standards. I think Virginia just tried to pass it as well. So, Jerry, if you
▶ Play
will bail me out, please. I don't have all the state laws right in front of me, but I will tell you this. When my staff sat down and looked at all the state laws, this this is more restrictive than what most states have believe it or not like in i believe louisiana the homeschool parent just shows a gpa of a two five and they say you're good to go and they don't even have to test uh down there and i'm not saying we ought to be like louisiana necessarily but i believe if you sit down and look at this law compared to the other states you're going to find that it is more restrictive on the homeschoolers than in the balance of the rest of them. Because, like I said, some just take the parent's word for it. They show a GPA, and that's good. One of the reasons that GPA is not included in this particular bill is because every time we've said, well, let the homeschool parent assign a GPA, then people say, oh, well, they'll just cheat. They'll just make something up. So we didn't even go there because we knew that somebody would say, well, the parent will just lie about it. And so to Representative Klemmer's point, we felt that a nationally recognized norm reference test is a pretty good measure. And one of the reasons that that's more fair to the homeschooler is because he may not take the same curriculum that a child in the public school takes. They may not read Great Expectations in the ninth grade or do some of the other classes exactly the way the public schools do them. Now, are they getting an education? Yes, because they take the Iowa Test of Basic Skills every year, and they have done quite well on that every year as a whole. And so that was the reason we didn't pick the other test is because they're already taking the Iowa Test, and that's mandated by the State Board of Education and it could change if the Board of Education decided to do a different test. So anyway, but the short answer to your question is this is more restrictive
▶ Play
than a lot of states have. Thank you, Mr. Cox, very, very much. I'm
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:11:43
sorry, Representative Douglas, you are recognized, ma'am. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. I do have a very large contingency of homeschool kids in my district. very active groups, and they are eager to show you any kind of testing requirements because they're confident in, you know, the level of, you know, competency that their kids have. So I don't think for the homeschoolers, they're eager to take a test or to show you their classes that they take online, whatever it takes. My question is, you know, and this may be Mr. Lowry that could answer this, they are very excited about this bill because they see it as more of an opportunity for them to have a little bit more equal footing to get into the programs in the public school. So there's something about this bill that is, you know, that is optimistic for them over what the AAA has offered, even though they're excited about that also. But taking this out of the hands of just a local school to make the determination and making it a statewide one-level playing field, I think, is what they see as a big improvement for having this, you know, on the table. So, Mr. Lauer, you might speak to why we need this as opposed to the law that we have now
▶ Play
and answer my question. Well, we hear a lot of talk about choice and access, and that's really what this is about. This is the ultimate access to educational opportunity. And as Dr. Kimbrell spoke so eloquently about homeschool and not wanting to revisit the homeschool law, homeschoolers, I mean, they are set to a very vigorous test and have been for a number of years. You know, the homeschool law that was put into place was not done lightly. And the testing standard that the students are held to certainly is not a light standard. And, frankly, I find it amusing after knowing that the homeschoolers have gone through so much in terms of being able to prove their adequacy in terms of educational achievement that that's what this discussion has come down to. There is no question, and the numbers bear it out, that homeschool students are meeting educational adequacy in terms of their achievement. Now the question is, are we going to be fair in terms of allowing them full access to educational opportunity? And I think we've really belabored for far too long this point of whether they are eligible, whether they should be eligible to participate. They have proven in almost a generation now of homeschoolers have proven that they're performing well. Now we need to give them an opportunity to be able to perform well in other avenues, whether it's athletics or whether it's in the
▶ Play
performing arts. I don't think that's a point of dispute. I think for clarification of the committee, there potentially will be two different sets of eligibility standards, and the committee needs to be aware of that in order to make a decision. The involvement of the homeschoolers, I don't think, is particularly the question, but we do need to know as a committee, are there going to be different eligibility standards and for clarification? And I think we have done that, and we appreciate Dr. Kimbrell. We appreciate Mr. Cox and all those who have illuminated us in that regard. If I may just
▶ Play
follow up. I mean, the truth is that there are different standards just by virtue of the homeschool law. I think that's what Dr. Kimbrell was saying. There are different standards, and I think it can be well supported that the standard the homeschool students are held to is a very rigorous standard. So for us to be able to deal with this issue has nothing to do with this bill. It has to do with going back and revisiting homeschool law, which we've already heard no one wants to do. because it does open up, there's no telling what it opens up. It opens up comparisons between public school and homeschool students that probably no one really wants to get into those discussions. The point is the adequacy of homeschool education has been thoroughly proven. I mean, it's been proven year after year in terms of their numbers. And I don't know that, you know, there's no bill that we bring that's perfect, but we can't let perfect be the enemy of the good. We just can't. This is something that's about kids. It's not about adults quibbling or squabbling about what should or shouldn't be done. It's about kids and giving them opportunity. And so I hope the
▶ Play
committee will consider that. And we absolutely will consider that. And the job of this committee is to vet legislation. Our job is to test-drive legislation. Our job is to ask serious questions, hard questions, and I think we have proven that with the fine legislation that we have passed out of this committee. This bill will be no different. I think you as a sponsor and those who have come test-filed on your behalf for and against the bill have done a great job in that regard. With that, do we have any more
▶ Play
questions? Representative Linderman. This is my second term. I was here and have dealt with this. We charged the AAA, or we charged a group, to come up with a solution to this problem. I have a beautiful young lady that participated as my page as a homeschool student. I count them as close friends. Representative Lowry, you said your bill closely mirrors this. I'd like to hear from everybody. If we've got this as a document that can be modified and changed as we need it, do we need a bill filed that we can only change every two years by statute? Why not keep this as a close model to your bill that can be tweaked as it is needed by the schools, by the Homeschool Association, and by the AAA? I'd like to have everybody's answer to that
▶ Play
one. Well, I'll be glad to jump in and give the first answer to that. I don't remember saying that it closely mirrors it because there are some significant problems with the Activities Association's guidelines, and if this committee two years ago gave them a firm mandate to fix this, then we've got a lot to be upset about because the AAA guidelines do not fix it. It is inequitable that homeschool students would have to notify the school district by July 1. That's not a requirement that's put on public school students. We've spent a lot of time here talking about different standards for public schools and homeschool, but we ignore that one. That's a significant flaw in what the activities associations put forward is putting this what I think is an over rigorous, over strident regulation that July 1. The other issue is that we're finding this permissive language has really turned this proposal into just a suggestion. You know, we are elected to come and protect those, in many cases, who are not able to protect themselves, okay? These homeschool students that want this opportunity are not given the opportunity to be able to come before committees many times and argue for their opportunity, and I think that we've been elected to do that. I don't think that we've been elected to pass on to a quasi-official organization to solve our problems. We should be doing that. And as the chairman said, that's why we go through this process, is to make sure we thoroughly vet the legislation we're putting into place. I don't believe that the activity association guidelines were thoroughly vetted. And now we have an opportunity through a thorough vetting, through a thorough examination of all the implications, all the ripple effects. Dr. Kimbrell talked about that, the ripple effect of even looking at the homeschool law. We're doing that, and I think that we owe it to our constituents and the students that Representative Douglas has referenced to be able to give those students that chance. And, you know, this has been amended numerous times. We've taken input from the administrators, and we've tried to compromise. Now, the essence of compromise is that you're not going to get the perfect. You're just going to get the doable, and that's what we're trying to accomplish. Representative Lindeman,
▶ Play
do you have anything to add? Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 274 2:21:15
Taylor? If you'll look down on E number 5, at the end it says the assessments are determined by the AAA Board of Directors and the approved assessment for the 2013-14 is a SAT-10. The reason why Bill Ballard, who is the Homeschool Testing Coordinator, we use that right now because that is the only test electronically that you can do right now and have immediate feedback at the school. I'm sure that the testing people out there will come up with different tests. Our board has flexibility to add those tests to this so we can give the homeschoolers different tests that they can take. But right now, the SAT-10 is the only test that they can come to school. Testing coordinators can test them and get immediate feedback. And that's why we just, right now, the board of directors only approved the SAT-10.
▶ Play
Do we have any other questions from the committee? Rep. Deffenbaugh. Well,
▶ Play
I was kind of going to respond to Mr. Linderman's request. Can I do that? All right, as a coach, I don't know why July 1st is such a big sticking point because the truth of the matter is the way athletics are in this day and age, they're basically signed up all year. That's not even – there's not even a – I mean, even if you play baseball in the spring, the coaches, they know it. It's just – it's a – how would you say it? It's just an ongoing thing. I mean, we're not asking anything extraordinary because it's just the normal way athletics work now. I do want to speak to that. Okay, so I just don't – I didn't want to respond to that. I don't see that
▶ Play
that's a sticking point. Thanks. Thank you, Representative Deffenbaugh. Do we have any other questions? We have allowed Mr. Taylor a little extra time because his organization will be directly dealing with this. If there are any other questions, we appreciate you gentlemen coming today. We appreciate it very much. We do have some other folks that want to speak primarily against the bill. We're going to give everybody an opportunity to do that. Mr. Knight, if you are still here, and we're running up on 1230, and so I would just with all due respect ask those who are speaking for or against the bill to try to distill your comments the best that you possibly can.
▶ Play
Speaker 323 2:23:37
Thank you. Mr. Chairman, thank you very much. I'm hungry, too. Danny Knight, I represent the AAEA, and I've had the opportunity to serve on this committee for 12 years when I was a school superintendent. this committee governs the activities of this state this committee has the authority to put schools on probation this school this committee has the authority to make sanctions against schools we've worked real hard to come up because I remember meeting with representative clamor and I think the lady was from Monticello rather than cross and I spoke with her about 30 minutes. And we promised this committee we would come up with a workable plan. All we're asking you to do is give us the opportunity or give these folks the opportunity to implement this plan July 1. Richard Abernathy and his staff will meet with every superintendent in this state and encourage and entail them what's going to happen if this doesn't take place. I don't think there's a superintendent in this state. Once they realize what's going to happen by this, it's not going to be a big deal. And boards will make the decision. We're for homeschool participation. I was last in Levin. But we have give these rules and regulations a chance. Seventy better percent of our superintendents in this state said yes in this state. Yes, we want to do this. We will do this. So, Mr. Chair, I'd appreciate a good vote, a down vote on this. I've had the opportunity to work with this guy since about the first day of the session, and I got to know him, and his heart's in the right place, and I know Jerry. But also the superintendents of schools, their hearts are there, too, for these
▶ Play
homeschooled kids. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Knight. We appreciate your time today. Mr. Harder, you are recognized to speak this bill on behalf of school board association
▶ Play
Speaker 324 2:25:44
ron harter arkansas school board association association
▶ Play
Speaker 185 2:25:48
and i will as brief as i can be in terms of enrolling the homeschool to take at least one course it's a constitutional issue article fourteen section two it's a one sentence part of the constitution no money or property belonging to the public school farm or to this state for the benefit of schools or universities shell ever be used for any other than for the respective purposes to which it belongs if you're going to take school facilities school equipment and the student doesn't enroll for even just one course it runs follow of article fourteen section two so just to protect the state from potential suit enrolling in one course is it's good fail safe mister harder
▶ Play
visited uh... hate to interrupt you uh... by virtue of them being involved in an extracurricular activity is that not a credit hour it is that not stated in the bill now
▶ Play
Speaker 185 2:27:05
there's there's in in the bill if you're not enrolled in your only doing extracurricular you're not getting credit for a course written larry you believe that but that insurance purposes requiring to enroll for insurance purposes is different than the constitutional thing and it is and don't go
▶ Play
anywhere because i want to do that we to respond to this because I want the committee to be aware on this. We have a little disagreement here. We want to make sure we get this clarified. Representative Lowry, you could respond
▶ Play
to that. Well, as Mr. Knight said so eloquently a while ago, this committee is given a lot of power and a lot of authority, and if you pass this bill, the bill says that by virtue of participating, the student is an enrolled student. It becomes law. It answers that question. But in many cases, there is a class tied to the activity. It's not just, I mean, we did want to address the insurance issue, but the bottom line is in most cases there is a class tied to that activity. Okay,
▶ Play
Speaker 185 2:28:15
Mr. Harder, can you respond to that? The language on page 3, lines 20-21, where it says, counted as an enrolled student by the resident district is very unclear even if even if participation in the extracurricular activity counts as enrolled I'm not sure how you would define that you have an eight period day extracurricular would be a ninth period is that one ninth is that one 8th, the way it reads and language really does matter. Once this is passed and it goes into this book, all this discussion is really moot. It just is. How does it read? And so to me, lines 20-21 says that's full funding. And then you're talking about a different level of funding for one student to take extracurricular than for a traditional student who is enrolled for a full day. Okay. To that
▶ Play
point, lines 22 and 23 required to be at school no more than one period per day if necessary for insurance purposes.
▶ Play
Speaker 185 2:29:33
Insurance purposes is an optional thing. And if you, because that's the catastrophic thing. to protect the student in the extracurricular activity so that from a constitutional standpoint, it's really a separate issue. It may or may not. It seems pretty nebulous to me that it would actually cover it from the constitutional standpoint, but the reason that was added had nothing to do with the Constitution. It had to do with insurance.
▶ Play
Okay. Do you have anything to
▶ Play
Speaker 185 2:30:07
add, Mr. Harder? One other thing that I did want to add is this whole thing over the testing, lines 29 through 36 on page 2, because it's or, little a on 31, 32, a minimum test score of the 30th percentile, that is a really low bar, on a nationally norm-referenced test in the previous 12 months. There's nothing that requires that test to be at the student's grade level. There's no specificity of what is supposed to be included in that test. SAT-10 is a very different test than Iowa Test of Basic Skills. This state has, and the department can address this better than I, but it has had different lengths even on Iowa Test of Basic Skills. So that if we're really going to try to be fair, It is fair to make sure that the student is being academically challenged as evidenced by a broad-spectrum norm-reference test.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Harder. We appreciate you very much. Next, we have AEA who wants to speak on the bill. Ms. Moore,
▶ Play
Speaker 333 2:31:33
you're recognized. I am Donna Morey. I coached high school sports for 27 years. And when we started this discussion this morning, it was about fairness. The AAA is the governing body of all extracurricular. In fairness, they need to allow this system to be in effect to make sure it works well. But speaking about fairness with kids, my high school students had to be in school a half a day in order to play in any sport. Even on, especially the day after we were on the road until 2 in the morning, they had to be at school at least a half a day. So for fairness, I think the standard should be for all the students. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you, Ms. Morey. We appreciate you. Dr. Campbell? you're recognized speak on the
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:32:33
bill sir thank you sir when representative Lowry brought up the issue of not really sure how this funding is going to work it kind of brought our ears up too because we're not real sure so we've got some as the conversation has happened we've got some concern about how this actually reads and I think I won't rehash what Mr. Harder said, but I think it could be read that this is a full funding. So if I enroll Jeremy in my school, I enroll Jeremy, but he only has to be there for one period a day. But I enroll him, I get to count him, I think that's a problem, one, funding problem, and I think it's an adequacy concern that I have. It may not be, but it is, to me, about what we do for kids. But Mr. Lasseter and I were trying to see how, because we do have some students, homeschool students who are coming to our schools, and we're trying to build that collaboration back. I mean, I would love to see more collaboration between homeschool students and our traditional public schools. And many times, representing Douglas, we can get them back because they get back in there and they get making friends, and it works well. And other times it's just a good combination of what a parent wants for their child. But I wanted Mr. Lassiter to explain how the current law is on homeschool and how this effect of this law could kind of muddy the waters there, and I want to make sure we don't muddy those waters because, as I said, I told Mr. Cox I'm not looking to change homeschool law in any way, but we are kind of muddying the waters here with the current school law if we put this law in place because of that funding issue and the enrollment issue.
▶ Play
Speaker 337 2:34:21
Jeremy Lasseter, General Counsel for the Department of Education. And as Dr. Kimbrell mentioned, we do allow homeschoolers to participate in various academic endeavors in traditional public schools. We do that in academic classes through distance learning programs, and it is a good thing. And the reason why we can do that is that you look at the criteria that's already in law for what you have to meet in order to be counted as a part of the ADM. the first part of that criteria is that you be a resident of the school district this bill addresses that the second part of that criteria is that you be enrolled in the school district this bill also addresses that the third part of the criteria is that you be enrolled in a curriculum that meets the standards for accreditation for Arkansas school districts that's not a problem for one period of athletics after that it could be because you're only allowed to count athletics once for the purposes of for PE it's not a problem for fine arts those are already academic courses so it's not a problem for that but but again if you go past the one time for athletics and then you look at what the bill also includes for non scholastic activities such as special interest clubs and organizations those things aren't counted as a part of ADM so one thing that you would be creating is a bit of tension a bit of conflict between what you're allowing for in this bill and then the current criteria for what is allowed for
▶ Play
Speaker 339 2:35:43
or for counting students as a part of a district's ADM. Okay, I think we
▶ Play
have one question, and then we're going to recognize Representative Lowry to close for his bill.
▶ Play
Madam Vice Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So it's your contention that the language that's in this bill could not be interpreted to be the same as that language for homeschoolers that come for one period of day to take calculus or whatever, What I'm saying is
▶ Play
Speaker 337 2:36:16
that as the bill is currently written, I would have a hard time definitively telling a superintendent that might call my office, how do I get funded for this person? If someone, for instance, called me and said, why aren't you as a Department of Education sending me the full foundation funding amount for this individual who is only here for one class period, I would be hard-pressed to try to explain to them in this bill why
▶ Play
they couldn't do that. If that were corrected, would there be opposition still to this? Well, I
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:36:49
don't know how you fixed all the opposition, because you've seen the department's opposition. We're concerned about the funding, and when the conversation began, and then that question was asked by one of the members of how that funding would work, and it kind of tweaked our interest because we weren't real sure either, but we kind of thought maybe the representative had an idea of how he wanted this to happen. When we began then researching the law back here, we found that we do have some criteria that is in current law that requires that. But when you look at the homeschool law, which is very specific, there are some restrictions there also. So our concern was, one, how do we fund if this is in law as it's written? And then, two, what would we fund for? If it's the key club, do they get a period for that? Typically, there's not a class period for that. So how do you fund for that? In some schools, if you play baseball, in some schools, it's after school. You don't play baseball during the school period. So there was questions. That's some concerns
▶ Play
that we have. My last follow-up is a follow-up here. The other concern that I had, and I really was trying to be as open-minded as I possibly could be on this, I had an e-mail, someone who's watching us live, says we've had two schools refuse to allow this. Three weeks ago, two northeast Arkansas districts, not my home district, thank you, or my original home district, have turned this down. So do we have, for the year coming forward, how are you all going to respond? to that if a school district said, now we don't want to do that, because evidently the school board voted to say no to that. Well, and again, that's under the
▶ Play
Speaker 97 2:38:39
AAA rules and regulations, not under the current law. So I can't answer. You'd have to ask Mr. Taylor to answer that question. Well,
▶ Play
we can hold that for another day, I guess. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair, for your
▶ Play
indulgence. Thank you, Madam Vice Chair. Representative Lowry, you are recognized or closed for your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and thank you. committee, for your patience in listening to all the testimony. Let me clarify just a couple of things. First, one, you know, the discussion about testing. The SAT-10 can be and would be used contemporaneously. There's nothing in the language of the bill that says the SAT-10 would not be used. We just use generic language so that if the testing was referenced, if the test standard or the test itself changes next year, students are not in limbo until we can come back and amend it. So we're using a norm reference test. Several issues that I've wanted, and I don't want to belabor this because I know this has gone along quite a bit of time. You know, I appreciate Jerry Cox being with me with the family council to answer a lot of the questions, and he's a good advocate. I think even he would probably admit he's not as good an advocate as John Whitehead of the Rutherford Institute, who spoke before the Virginia Education Committee about the issue of their own Tim Tebow bill. And one of the things he said, this is very much a taxpayer issue. Now, that's important because we've been getting into this discussion about dollars and cents. It's a taxpayer issue, and parents of homeschooled children pay the same taxes other families pay to support the activities and programs of the public schools. They should have access to those programs, including athletic programs. I have appreciated the forthrightness of all the various groups that have come to me over the last several weeks in trying to see if we can arrive at language that we're satisfied with. Obviously, we're not satisfied with the Activities Association guidelines that have been developed because of everything that's already been referenced, even what the vice chairman referenced about school districts that have said they've dug in and said we're not going to support this. And it is one of the problems of having a non-governmental entity govern these issues. They had a 70 percent to 30 percent vote. What enforcement do we have over the 30 percent that said no? Absolutely none, unless you pass this law. This is a rather historic testimony for me because for the first time I'm actually going to quote John Brummett on this issue. And in 2011, John Brummett said this, and I'm paraphrasing from a column by Max Brantley, where John Brummett said he lamented the defeat of the so-called Tim Tebow law in 2011, which would allow homeschooled children to compete in athletic, musical, and other competitions for regular public schools. He sees it, and this was John Brummett's writing, he sees it as another case of adults' interests, in many cases school superintendents, being placed ahead of children. And that really is what we're talking about. Time Magazine had a similar review in 2012 where one writer said, I don't understand the self-anointed public school advocates who are simultaneously decrying homeschoolers for being separatists while throwing up walls to keep them from participating in high school athletics or other activities. That's what this is about. We're trying to bridge the gap. We've heard, and I referenced incorrectly, sorry Representative Ratliff, I thought it That was a great bill, and you should be given full credit for it. Anything that we can do to bridge those gaps, maybe even help clarify those misperceptions of homeschoolers as wanting to be adamantly separatists. Representative Douglas gave very eloquent comments about the fact that these students want to be involved. And if we can create a situation where the students are maybe given an opportunity to be able to see that there's a lot more available for them in their public schools, and if the one thing that hooks them in, the one thing that brings them in is being able to participate in sports or maybe the spring musical or play in the band or sing in the choir. If that's the one thing that pulls them in and in many cases can maybe help some of these small school districts that have low student populations, but more importantly, help students who are, we're charged to educate them, whether they choose to attend the public school or private school or they choose to be home school. We're charged with that, and that's why I think it's so important that this committee be given the purview of that rather than a quasi-official organization. And so for all these reasons, and again, I appreciate your patience, I ask that you would please vote do pass on this bill. With
▶ Play
that Seeing no one in the audience Who wishes to speak for against the bill Or any more questions from the committee The chair will entertain a motion Representative Lowry Do pass We have a do pass motion All in favor All opposed Motion passes Mark call the roll
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 2:44:18
Sir. No.
▶ Play
Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. No. No. No. No. No. Motion fails, seven votes. Thank you, Representative Lowry. Okay, committee, we're going to do one more bill before we break. This is a representative. I'm sorry. We have had Representative Steele has a very quick bill. We have Representative Dotson, who has waived the whole time. We're going to pick him up this afternoon with your permission, sir. It's coming up on 1 o'clock. Representative Steele, you're recognized. This is House Bill 1902. This is House Bill 1902. Representative Steele, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
It's a pleasure to be on your committee. Members, this is House Bill 1902. This is a companion bill to House Bill 1901, which is virtually identical except it pertains to employers, general employers, and I ran that over in public health, welfare, and labor this morning. Basically all this bill does is it prohibits an institution of higher education from requesting from its faculty or students, or any employees for that matter, or students' personal social networking information. Basically they cannot require as a matter of course your password and user name to accounts like Facebook and Twitter and things like that. This came about because I've seen several employment contracts that require people when hired with certain companies to, in the event needed, give up that information. And I don't think employers or institutions of higher education should be tempted to request that information or make it a condition of employment or a condition of the student enrolling in their schools. So this prohibits them from requesting that information. There are some exceptions. Any account that is purported to represent the university, one of my favorites recently was the Dave Gearhart for governor, or we've seen some that pretend to be Jeff Long and things like that. Those would be exempt. So if there's some student that's using university trademarks or pretending to be a personality in the university system, then the university would be exempt under this law. But I'll be happy to take any questions. I think it's
▶ Play
fairly simple. Do we have any questions for Representative Steele? Seeing none, do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against the bill? If not, what is the pleasure of the committee? We have a do pass motion. Representative Cozart, all in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you very much. We will re-adjourn after the session today, 15 minutes upon adjournment. Excuse me, Representative Eubanks, we will reconvene here, 15 minutes upon adjournment of the House.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 2:48:36
Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB2106

2:30 - 9:46 26 segments 6 speakers

HB1912

9:46 - 1:12:14 180 segments 19 speakers

SB839

1:12:14 - 1:17:14 19 segments 5 speakers

HB1789

1:17:14 - 2:48:22 292 segments 24 speakers

HB1902

2:48:22 - 2:48:37 1 segment

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative James McLean Chair Unverified
92 segments
Representative Debra M. Hobbs Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 12
1 segment
Speaker 14
1 segment
Representative Stephanie Malone Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 26
12 segments
Representative Homer Lenderman Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 40
4 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 72
18 segments
Speaker 78
11 segments
Speaker 92
1 segment
Speaker 97
65 segments
Speaker 95
1 segment
Chair Unverified
42 segments
Representative Mark Biviano Unverified
4 segments
Representative John Catlett Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 151
1 segment
Speaker 158
1 segment
Representative Les "Skip" Carnine Unverified
8 segments
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 171
1 segment
Clay Finley Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 185
22 segments
Speaker 193
5 segments
Representative Ann V. Clemmer Unverified
34 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
50 segments
Jerry Cox Unverified
36 segments
Speaker 233
1 segment
Speaker 270
1 segment
Representative Sheilla E. Lampkin Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 274
33 segments
Speaker 292
1 segment
Speaker 305
1 segment
Speaker 306
1 segment
Speaker 311
1 segment
Speaker 323
4 segments
Speaker 324
1 segment
Speaker 333
3 segments
Speaker 337
5 segments
Speaker 339
1 segment
Representative Nate Steel Unverified
3 segments