House Public Health, Welfare And Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (15)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1901
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1901”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1935
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…down it. Okay. Representative Wardlaw, you want to present House Bill 1935? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1402
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…. We're going to move that up to the active calendar. Also, House Bill 1402 by Representative Wilkins. We will move back to the active…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1691
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1691”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1968
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1968”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2227
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2227”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2228
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…me make sure. I needed to move a couple bills off deferred. House Bill 2228 by Representative Wright is currently on the deferred list.…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB228
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…off deferred were 1402 by Representative Butch Wilkins and House Bill 228 by Representative Wright.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB161
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB161”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB575
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB575”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB788
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB788”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB810
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB810”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB840
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB840”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB852
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB852”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB857
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB857”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
I did, in fact, again, have too much coffee this morning, and I'm ready to do some business. So, we're going to run through it. Until Phil gets back, let me make sure. I needed to move a couple bills off deferred. House Bill 2228 by Representative Wright is currently on the deferred list. We're going to move that up to the active calendar. Also, House Bill 1402 by Representative Wilkins. We will move back to the active calendar.
Does any other member have a bill they'd like to run or move to active? Okay. 1935 is active. In fact, you wanted to run that today, right? Okay, yeah. In fact, just let's start running through it. I've got a list here. For the committee to know, we've got 32 active bills, 70 on deferred.
We're still one lower than the Senate. They're at 33 active. So we're still ahead. We've got a few. I think for the most part we've got medium to low-level bills today. So there's going to be some discussion on some, I'm sure, but we're going to try to run through them as fast as we can. Representative Ferguson. Okay, the numbers that came off deferred were 1402 by Representative Butch Wilkins and House Bill 228 by Representative Wright.
So those bills are back on the active calendar. Let's start with Representative Steele. You want to present House Bill 1901? Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
It's a pleasure to be in your committee. I appreciate you calling me up so quickly. Members, this is House Bill 1901 as part of a couple of privacy bills that I filed. There's an identical bill to this one, almost identical over in education that deals with higher ed. But this one deals with employers in general, and it's a pretty simple bill.
I don't think it's a burden on employers. It simply asks that, it requires that they not ask for personal networking information. That would be basically, it prohibits employers from requesting your personal Facebook or Twitter usernames or passwords or private email. It specifically does not deal with emails that employers have as a whole. Some major companies use programs like Lotus Notes and things like that. It does not prohibit them from getting information off their own programs.
It also clarifies that we're only talking about individuals' private account information, nothing related to the business. It also has an exemption there for some employers ask some employees to set up a Facebook page for the business or something like that. It excludes those. This is just people's personal information, and this is actually a more real problem than I realized when I filed the bill. I had at least one gentleman send me an employment contract, and in the employment contract it required that should they need it,
he would be obligated to hand over his personal account information so they could go and look at his private messages. We want to make sure employers are not tempted to do that because in this jobs market I think people would agree to just about anything to get a job, and we understand that. But this is really aimed at major employers to try to keep them from being tempted to put in employment contracts that their employees turn over personal account information. I'll be happy to take any questions. Thank you for the presentation. Members, any questions?
Anybody in the audience like to speak for or against the bill? If not, what's the pleasure of the committee? Motion to do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you, many. Members, I'm going to explain just a little bit of whatever logic I'm going to use in doing this. So I think, generally speaking, I'm going to try to alternate between House and Senate. It doesn't get much fairer than that. And then also maybe save some of the members of the committee's bill towards the end as we don't get too bogged down. Just that way we can clear the room a little bit and have members still left.
So that being said, next I'm going to recognize Senator Malek, 852. You're recognized to present. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, this is a bill
Speaker 14
4:40
regarding the Board of Examiners and Counseling. Really, it's just clean up. It's language that's recommended by the Bureau and by their auditors because their existing statutory language just authorizes them to charge fees.
And now we really want to be more descriptive in that. in that. So the amendment simply says to impose reasonable fees for applications, licenses, examinations, and other administrative purposes that the board deems necessary. So it's really not a change. They don't intend any change in the fees that they're charging, but it was just something requested, again, by the bureau and auditors to be more descriptive, and I'd be happy to answer any questions. Thank
you, members. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question.
Speaker 14
5:27
fees, though? Well, they've got that authority
now because they can set fees. This is just descriptive on specifically what they're for and they don't have any current plans to but their existing language of just that they can impose fees would allow them to do that. They have no intention. This was just requested that they add some specifics to their authority. Okay, thank you. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Members, any other questions? Now, anybody in the audience like to speak for or against the bill? Okay, if not, what's the pleasure of the committee? Motion do passed by Representative Hank Wilkins. All in favor say aye.
Any opposed? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, members. Next, Representative Wardlaw, are you at the table? He just stepped out. Okay. Everybody tell him I called on him, though. I'll dig down it. Okay. Representative Wardlaw, you want to present House Bill 1935? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and
committee. I'm going to let Jim introduce himself for the committee
Speaker 23
6:30
Say your name for the record please Thank you Mr. Chair Jim Cooper with the Arkansas Healthcare Association Thank you You're recognized to present the bill Thank you very much 1935 is intended to say that Those of the frail elderly that qualify today For nursing home placement across the state Will remain to be qualified and cannot be denied payment based on any changes in the criteria for nursing home placement
unless you, the legislature, so choose to change those regulations. And that pretty much sums up the bill. Heck of a presentation. I would say it would be hard to vote against kicking grandma out of the nursing home, but I
won't say that. Somebody else made that case once. I forgot his name. Anyway, members, any questions? Okay. If not, anybody in the audience would like to speak for or against?
Okay, members, what's the – oh, I'm sorry. Yes, ma'am? Okay. If you'll join us at the end of the table, I don't have you on the sign-up sheet, so if you'll say your name. For the record, you'll be
Speaker 26
7:50
recognized to speak against the bill. Okay. Is this the microphone? I'm Elaine Eubank, I am President and CEO of CareLink, and I just am concerned that I don't fully understand what the bill does, because it says it's eligibility for long-term care, which is more than just nursing home care.
So I would ask that we have an opportunity to really look at it and talk about, because my concern is, and I know others like AARP have the same concern, we just learned about it within the last 24 hours, and it could limit older people's access to home and community-based services. So I'd just like a chance to study it and to really determine that that is not the case, because in my reading of it, it could, and a lot of people that we serve in
home and community-based services are long-term care, and they're categorized as nursing home level three patients thank you members
any questions if not thank you for your testimony if I'm judging facial expressions accurately mr. Allison would you like to testify against or just speak on thank you
Speaker 33
9:04
mr. chairman I would like to essentially reiterate the comments of the previous commenter asked for time to review the bill and express concern that freezing eligibility under
the current criteria for nursing facilities services explicitly could impede the payment improvement effort that we're engaged in and lead to increased costs over time and does more than simply protect against elimination of level three services but could also impede improvements in the way that we pay for service and the balancing of services between the institution, the institutional setting, the non-institutional setting.
So certainly agree that the issue merits discussion will be bringing this subject matter to this committee and others in the coming months, but don't believe that a freeze to some historical eligibility level would be
mr. Allison members any questions thank you for your testimony anybody
else in the audience would like to speak for against a representative Ward law you're recognized to close for the
bill committee I gave miss Eubanks my word before committee started that as this bill progresses to the Senate if in fact there is some problems with the definition in this bill changing that we would amend this bill in the Senate and bring it back for House concurrence. I just feel like we're at the end of the session. We don't need to stall anymore. We need to move forward as quickly as possible,
and we will have a whole other committee to go through, and we will amend it to fix her concerns. According to Dr. Allison at the end of the table a while ago committee, we are a term-limited legislature nowadays. If we leave this thing to rulemaking ability, they can do those things without our approval. All we do is review at that point. All this bill does, it says they have to come to the General Assembly or to the people for a vote on a referendum or initiated act. And it gives us a little bit more lead way of what's going to happen with this Medicaid system.
We need to protect grandma all possible. Thank you, committee. Appreciate
a good vote. Thank you, Representative Wardlaw. Members, you've heard testimony on the bill, the presentation. What is the pleasure of the committee? representative ferguson you're recognized for motion do pass any discussion on the motion all in favor of do pass say i'm any opposed congratulations you passed your bill thank you committee um next senator chesterfield then we're going to do representative westerman
so senator chesterfield you're recognized to present five seven
five Thank you, Mr. Chair, ladies and gentlemen of the committee. We have worked with both labor and workforce to make this a non-controversial bill. What it does is simply define what misconduct is on page one. It also increases the penalty for knowingly receiving fraudulent payments from employer from the unemployment compensation commit group.
It provides health benefits to be continued except if there is a reduction that is absolutely necessary. Employees' bargaining rights are protected, and we think we have a great bill that both labor and workforce services have agreed to, and I'd appreciate any
questions. Okay. We have a sponsor's amendment that we're going to add, Representative Wilkins.
amendment. Okay. The amendment is being handed out to you. It just simply adds Representative Wilkins as a co-sponsor on the bill. All in favor of the motion? Aye. Any opposed? Okay. So the amendment is now part of it. Were you finished presenting, Senator Chesfield? Yes, I am, and I'll be happy to take questions. Are there any questions for Senator Representative Meeks?
Thank you. On page, let's make sure we got it on the right one here, page 4, Line 20, starting line 21-22, it's got scratched out. It's a penalty of 10%. It raises the penalty to 15%
raising that penalty? We have found that too many times people, well, not too, well, too many times it would be good. Individuals have received overpayments of benefits knowingly, which constitutes fraud,
and we feel that if we increase it, then we decrease their desire to engage in fraudulent activity. Thank you. Appreciate it. Representative Link. Senator Cheshawil and page,
it's sort of page two, page three, I guess. I'm sorry, page one, page two, bottom page one. It talks about the misconduct in connection with the work shall not be found for instances of poor performance unless the employer can prove that the poor performance was... Tell me what line you're on, sir.
I'm sorry, line 35 of page 1. I guess my question is how have we given, I know we've given it thought, how would we go about proving that poor performance was intentional? I'll have
to yield to workforce services. But it does say an individual's repeated act of commission, omission, and negligence would be one of those things that we could look at. but i'll yield that to one person and they'll be able to
to the committee yes sir my name is ron caulkins i'm the assistant director for unemployment insurance okay you can testify thank you mr chairman yes as senator first of all let me start out by saying this section one is uh arkansas coded annotated 11-10-514 it's the what deals with the discharge disqualification when there's misconduct. And in the last session, there were several amendments made to this section.
And what we're attempting to do with this section is just reorganize the order in which that section is written for clarity purposes. We're not changing anything that has to do with the misconduct disqualification. It's just a reorganization. And this change to the poor performance was something that was changed in the last session.
And how you go about approving it, it is, as Senator Chesterfield said, We just have to look at the work history, and if there's repeated acts of negligence or poor performance, and if individuals have progressive discipline and have been warned about it and are still not able to improve their performance, then that would be considered misconduct for disqualification purposes. And it would be considered
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. and we do have labor has agreed to this bill which gives them protection and gives the employer
we have a couple more questions senator representative hammer thank you mr. chair I was two questions please senator Chesterfield by taking the penalty from 10% to 15 is there a track record that fraudulent activity is a significant
significant problem in this department area, or I was just curious if that was a preemptive move, or?
It is a preemptive move, and there have been examples, too many examples, really, of individuals getting unemployment compensation undeservedly. So we want to cut down on the fraud that has taken place, and we feel that by increasing the penalty to 15 percent, we'll be able
to do that. Okay. And I just don't know the answer to this question, Rita Manson. When they collect a penalty like that, Where does that money return to the system?
Is it put back in? It goes to the unemployment compensation
fund. Okay. And then the next question, and maybe you touched on this a second ago, but the way it reads constitutes significant proof. I'm trying to go back and find that line. How do you prove, how would an employer, or can you give me an example of how an employer could prove significant
sufficient proof? An individual's repeated act of commission omission or negligence despite progressive discipline constitutes sufficient proof of intentional poor performance. So that's going to be documented by the employer
you're keeping personnel records etc such as that and that that's the where you go to cite the proof for the action that would be taken that is correct okay thank you thank you okay representative warlaw thank you mr.
chairman senator mr. Ron can you tell me I was reading page one and I guess it's lines by basically same lines as reading a while ago 35 36 and it says miss conduit cannot cannot be used for instance of poor performance unless the employer can prove that the poor performance was intentional can you give me a definition of what misconduct would be and and why
you couldn't use that misconduct includes on line 32 misconduct in connection with the work
includes the violation of any behavioral policies of the employer as distinguished from deficiencies in meeting production standards or accomplishing job duties its conduct in connection with the work shall not be found for instances of poor performance unless the employer can prove that poor performance was intentional this is workforce services bill to get it in compliance it is also agreed to and agreed to bill with labor we wanted to make sure we protected the employers rights but we also wanted to make sure that we am we protected the employees rights I guess what I'm trying to get at
is I don't I don't want an employee to be able to receive workman I guess unemployment insurance if they were fired for misconduct and the way I read this it doesn't it doesn't protect that I think you have to read the totality of the bill
for the protection workforce has worked very hard on this to make sure that the employer is protected from this kind of activity labor has worked very very hard because it wants to make sure that its rights are protected.
So we have an agreed-to bill. I'm not sure how we can assuage your concern, except we've worked very hard over the last month or so, to get a bill that workforce, which is designed to protect us as a state, and also to protect the employers and the employees, have worked very, very hard, and I'm sure they understand what intentional is and employers do as well. So that is the best I can do as far as answering your question. Thank you. You're welcome. Oh.
Okay, Representative Harris. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Chesterfield, is any way where I'm looking at this bill, since we're a right-to-work state, Is this going to make it any harder for the employer to have to prove, you know, if they're in the
Speaker 100
21:32
right for firing an employee? It is our opinion that it does not. Okay. Because I was
looking at, you know, just the burden of proof. So you feel like it's not?
We do not. Okay. Thank you. Okay, members, any other questions? Representative Meeks, you recognize
for a question. Thank you. On page 8, starting with line 20, it talks about an otherwise eligible individual should not be denied benefits with respect to any week in which he or she is in training to enhance job skills, et cetera, et cetera. If the training has been approved by the director, is there going to be any huge impact as far as paying out of benefits are concerned during this time?
Or are we doing that and we're just clarifying it in law? Just clarifying it in law. The individual can be paid now. Now, we want to make sure that as we put people to work and we're training them to go to work, that we don't also penalize them for having unemployment insurance. We don't want them to be penalized. And so what we want to do is to encourage people to go back to work. It would be a detriment if they went to job training, if they had to come back and lose everything they had been receiving until they can get a job.
so that's what this is for okay thank you thank
you for clarifying representative overby do pass as amended
at the proper time okay thank you members any other questions if not would anybody in the audience like to speak for or against the bill okay members uh representative over do you
like to close senator i close senator i'd appreciate i mean representative i'd appreciate a
good vote thank you thank you uh representative Boberby, you're recognized for motion. Pass. Okay, thank you, as amended.
Members, any discussion on the motion? If not all in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, members of the committee. Kind of in a bad mood now. Representative Westerman had to go over to Revin Tax to cut some taxes, and it reminded me that I'm sitting over here in public health, and I like Revin Tax a lot more. So, point of that is, Representative Westerman had to go over there, and it will not be running his bill right now, but he'll be back.
Let's do Representative Hobbs, 1691. And remind the chair that
Okay, Representative Hobbs, you're recognized to present your bill. I think you have an amendment is that right I do okay can we pass that out and it's on our tablets and that
the tablet is the main body of the bill and then there is an amendment to that as well
okay we're going to distribute a hard copy of the amendment and I assume we can entertain a motion to adopt the amendment at the gate and then a motion to adopt the amendment even faster than I expected So any discussion on the motion to adopt the amendment? If not, all in favor say aye. Any opposed? Okay. The amendment's adopted. Members, as soon as you have that in front of you, we will discuss the bill. And in terms of who's on deck and who's in the hole, we'll do Representative Wilkins 2227, you're on deck.
And Representative Cozart, you're going to be in the hole. So that's a baseball analogy. It's not a bad thing. Mr. Chair, before I
present, since you admitted you're in a bad mood, will that reflect at all on your judgment of my bill?
Since I did what? Oh, no. It speaks very highly of the amendment.
Thank you, Ms. Chair. If so, I yield to Mr. Cozart at this point. I think they've got it,
so you're recognized. Go ahead and explain the bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I also have with me Craig Cloud with the Development Disabilities Providers Association. He has been great to work with me in shepherding this bill through the different providers and different associations and so forth. As you know, quite often when we craft legislation, we may be cast too broad of a net and then have to come back and look at it again. And this is what that bill basically does. And I'm just going to let Craig explain that since he works in this field
Speaker 129
26:07
and has a better understanding of it. All right, Mr. Chair. This bill actually would amend our current criminal record check requirements that are applicable to a variety of health care service providers across our state, and it would add a certain number of offenses that are nonviolent, non-sexual, non-predatory to the list. It would allow those individuals who have actually completed their sentencing, their probation, and would allow the service provider the opportunity for these specific offenses
to choose to hire this person back. They would notify Department of Human Services. Department of Human Services would issue a clearance letter for these individuals. And the main portion of this is for these certain offenses. It allows individuals who have made mistakes, who have rehabilitated, and who have a desire to return back to the workforce, would be excellent caregivers, would be excellent in our field. It would allow them the opportunity to return if the service provider so chooses to hire them and feels comfortable with their ability to provide the services.
Services will be provided in a congregate environment and would be an environment that is actually supervised and where staff would be available to work with that person as they discharge
their specific duties. Okay, thank you for the testimony, Representative –
or, I'm sorry, did you have anything else, Representative Hobbs? I think that gives a great intro to what we're trying to do. And also, you may be aware, but a few years ago, several different providers, such as early childhood education, development disabilities providers, and those who provide services for aging and long-term care, came together and they decided that instead of each organization having their requirements to keep people from working,
that they would come together and agree upon certain crimes that would prevent people from working for either five years or ten years, and, of course, certain violent ones, I mean, they would just be prevented forever. And these same groups came together, and they are the ones that identified these nonviolent crimes that they felt like a provider could have some leeway if they know the person, know they have rehabilitated,
and they want to hire them, it just gives them the freedom to
do so. Okay. Thank you for the testimony. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would you, I can't find that particular list. Could you give us an idea of what kind of past crimes they're making atonement for and would be considered under this?
Speaker 129
29:02
The list of crimes that would be considered for the waiver under this particular bill? Yes, sir.
It's on page two of the amendment, step by receiving forgery, financial identity fraud, resisting arrest, criminal impersonation in the second degree, interference with visitation, interference with court-ordered visitation, prostitution, or patronizing a prostitute. Okay, and these folks are going to be working in what setting or
environment, please? They're going to be actually working in
Speaker 129
29:32
the environment that's actually listed here at the bottom. I'll be working in a long-term care facility. It's licensed by the Office of Long-Term Care, Intermediate Care Facility,
Developmental Day Treatment Clinic Services Center, Group Home Licensed by Division of Developmental Disability Services, a child care facility, church-exempt child care facility that's operated by the Division of Child Care and Early Childhood Education. And I might add that the providers have met to develop this. We met with the Department of Human Services and have agreed upon language with these particular offenses. And if I may
add, I see some shocked looks on the faces out there, but it doesn't say
a provider has to hire these people. What it simply will do if this bill passes, which I hope it will, will allow the provider again, and there will be disclosure where the provider knows it's in the past, but the provider, again, if they know the person and they feel comfortable with this person working with their particular population, then the provider will apply for a waiver through DHS, and then that will allow them to hire that person.
driving intent behind why we're opening the workplace in these particular settings back up to this population of individuals? Is it a work shortage of CNAs? Is it what's the driving reason for why we're making this exception? I think,
Speaker 129
31:08
Representative Hamer, the ultimate driving, excuse me, reason first and foremost is there are individuals that are capable of working in our environment that have completed their restitution, their fines, their penalties as sentence.
They've completed that. We do have work shortages in our area, but first and foremost, it allows the opportunity for that individual who has rehabilitated themselves, expressed the opportunity to do so, and then it allows that provider with the faith that they have in that person to provide that service and that employment gives them that opportunity to do so. And first and foremost, it allows that individual an opportunity to return to work, to become a tax-paying citizen of our state,
to provide the care that they're capable of doing in the environment in which they're capable of doing if they've completed their sentence, their appropriate rehabilitation, and the provider so chooses to hire and bring that person back
to employment. Okay. And then, Representative Henry, if I may add to that, this is personal with me, and had it not been, I probably wouldn't have even known that this law existed, to tell you the truth. But my daughter has a best friend, and she's here to testify for the bill
so she can disclose what she wants to about it. Wonderful young lady, grew up in our church. you know, known her most of her life, and again, I'll let her disclose what she wants to, but she got into some trouble. She has since made full restitution, satisfied the court, is now off probation. Her harsh desire is to work with young children in a daycare setting, and she was working at our church daycare. Pastor knew what had happened. The director
knew what had happened and she's wonderful with kids but when licensing came in and did the criminal background check they said you can't work here any longer so she called me saying you know I know I messed up it's my fault but this is what I really want to do and and again she continues to teach classes on Wednesday nights with the little ones she teaches Sunday school she takes care of My son, Jonathan, who has Down syndrome before and after work.
She's in my home. I trust her explicitly. But, and the provider, once I, the director called me and said, y'all, can you do anything? Pastor called, can you do anything? And so this would help those other Savannas out there that, yeah, messed up, but they served, you know, satisfied the courts. And, again, a provider does not have to hire that person, but this gives them some leeway so if they want to, the state doesn't say, come and say, you can't do that.
Mr. Chairman, may I have latitude for a couple more? And trust me, I'm all about what you're talking about. I think that's great. And, hey, who hasn't made a mistake? These are pretty severe ones, though. So let me bring it to this question. If we pass this law and we provide the avenue for that to happen and the individual is hired with everything that this law is giving in the form of protection and that person reverts back to their old ways, say identity of theft, et cetera, and an event occurs, who's going to be liable for that person's action at that point given the fact that they've hired a person with this history?
who does the burden of making restitution and being responsible fall on? Well, that would be
upon the provider that has made that decision. And I believe there's language that states, you know, this is like a one-time waiver. So if a person recommits one of these crimes, then that disqualifies them from working. So if the
provider hires a person knowing that they've got a past and full restitution has been made and their debt to society has been paid
and they hire a person with that, then they're assuming the responsibility to that if that person reoffends, then the provider is going to be subject to being held liable in court. Well, I don't know if you can
answer that or not. But I think, again, what we're talking about is, I mean, even if they go out and steal something else, then obviously I think whatever their employment is, that would be grounds for dismissal.
But as far as liability, the person that commits a crime would be liable for it. Now, if there's, you know, and again, we're not talking about crimes of abuse so that, you know, we're actually putting a population of people at risk. So I don't know if that helps
or not. I'm just trying to establish where in the law it says that if a company hires somebody and they re-offend,
are they free of liability and does it solely fall on that individual, number one? And number two, this would be like a second strike-you're-out kind of bill. We'll give you a chance to re-acclimate back into the workforce. But after the second offense, you know, and if that person's under probation and they have a second offense, does, and they're still, can they be hired if they're still under probation or do they have to get the terms of probation done?
Speaker 129
37:01
Representative Hammer, if I can refer to the language, the person must complete the probation or parole supervision, paid all court-ordered fees or fines, including restitution, and fully complied with all court orders pertaining to the conviction or plea.
before they would even be eligible for the provider to consider them for re-employment for the named offenses. And then subsequently, subsequent to employment, if the person should plead guilty or no contest or is found guilty to any offense in the subsection of this section, they would be immediately disqualified from employment, as would any other individual that was hired subsequent to employment that committed an offense.
Okay, one last question. Are family members going to be made aware that somebody is working in a facility that this law has been applied to, or is that going to be protected information
Speaker 129
38:02
that families wouldn't know that? But the particular bill right now does not include that language. You know, I'm not for sure, you know, of the rights of the employee as it relates to particular reference checks and things such as that.
I'm not for sure what the legal allowances would be. But I may, you know, add that the bill specifically allows the provider the opportunity to make the choice and choose to hire this person based on their belief. And as Representative Hobbs said, there's, you know, a provider here that's willing to testify for these certain exceptional circumstances where these individuals have made restitution. They've followed all court orders. They recognize the mistake that they've made.
it allows them that opportunity to return and allows that provider if they feel so comfortable to hire that person to bring that person in that environment okay thank you
thank you mr. chair for the latitude yeah members we have about half the committee signed up for questions so we had a good run we got some bills passed and this but it's okay I mean if people have questions we need to slow down I will say I try not to exercise too much discretion from up here too often but I'll just try to be trying to be cute I'll just say I think
this is a good bill essentially what you're saying and then I'm going to go into the questions but essentially what this bill does is it gives choice to the provider to hire somebody if they so choose and assume the liability for hiring the person that they choose but also am I correct in that okay and then on the so that's on the employer side and on the employee side I'll say you You know, I've had the ability to work very loosely around just some different things, more around drug and alcohol abuse issues here in the past four years
and transition houses and different varieties. But I just say, members, as a legislature, it's always easy to pass more bills, to send more people to jail for silly stuff, and then make it harder for them to do something once they get out, and we wonder why the cycle keeps getting bigger and bigger. Sometimes things are good bumper stickers, but it's not very practical. People have to do something. And I think if an employer wants the opportunity to let them do something and assume the liability, we ought to let them do it, especially for the list of within certain restraints, which I think they're in the bill.
Thank you for speaking for the bill. Yeah, well, you're welcome.
Representative Branscombe, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hobbs, I was just going over your list of crimes. Why wasn't
infamous crime used in that? Well, if you'd like to amend it that way, I'd be glad to answer that. Now, actually, again, once I met with the providers, explained to them the situation, what my heart and what I felt like we needed to do as a state,
because I think Chairman Burris stated it very well. You know, for us, 10 years may go by rather quickly, But if you're wanting to pursue something and you have to wait 10 years to do it, I think you're going to give up. And there are some communities where, well, at least I know even in Rogers, finding these workers to do these jobs are difficult, especially good ones. And I can tell you from, again, being with my son and watching different people care for him,
the ones that I want caring for him are the ones that have a heart for it. But anyway, once I met with the providers, I kind of stepped out of it, and Craig helped to coordinate, and they got together. They're the ones that came up on this
agreed list, so that would apply across the board. Thank
Speaker 166
41:48
you. Representative Hank Wilkins, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Much of what I wanted to ask has been answered. The concern that I had was to make sure that the individual would have discharged their
responsibility to society. And I see that you've added in here, if this is correct, that there is a procedure to get a waiver through DHS so that it's not like this person, like DHS is not aware that this is happening. So everybody is knowledgeable, the provider, the state is protected because DHS is aware.
How would you answer that, Representative
Hobbs? That is correct. And again, even in meeting with them, I said, I think, and I do believe full disclosure is very important. However, someone brought the fact, well, should the parents know, like in a daycare, and the response was when do you pay for when do you finish paying for your crime now you satisfy the courts but if every time you get a new student you have to say okay this person that's working with your child stole something five years
ago and then that puts a mental picture of that person that's taking taking care of your child and instead why not you know within reason and again trust that person to take care of the child and then if something arises the way they're taking care of their child or teaching or whatever then address that situation and and then the
Speaker 166
43:29
other thing I wanted to ask about you've indicated that we're talking about nonviolent transgressions that is correct sir right and so mr.
chairman with that I have a motion at the
proper time thank you representative Harris thank
you mr. chair represent pobs you would agree as a myself being a faith-based provider and we're passing bills on human trafficking and different things and I heard gasp when we talked about some of the list but one of our things is to build people up and one thing we have to do is if there's someone who has a background check one thing as teachers or assistants we have
to go through the thorough if someone does have a something that comes back we have to get waivers through from ministers or people in the community to write a reference letter or you know something is that correct you would know more about
that okay then I will answer that so that kind of gives people
Speaker 129
44:37
yes we each of our programs fall under you know licensure certification guidelines, whether it's developed by long-term care, developed by child care licensing, aging,
or DDS, and separate from these qualifications, as a provider, we are still required to conduct abuse registry checks. This law is very clear that if the person is on the abuse registry, they would still be disqualified, irregardless. There's no strikes on that particular. Also, as providers, we're required to conduct reference checks of that individual, whether There's an individual that, as we addressed here, we would be required to conduct reference checks, we would be required to receive appropriate references on this person,
that they're people that fully believe in their ability to work, they've rehabilitated themselves, but even absent that, as providers for any employee we hire, We have to go through a fairly comprehensive process before making that person eligible for employment within our organization, which includes reference checks, background checks, abuse checks, and things such as that. So it's fairly comprehensive, as you do suggest and as you mentioned, and it allows that opportunity for the provider to continue.
there would still be a requirement for reference checks that would have to follow before that employer could choose to make the
decision to hire this person back. Right, and we do take the responsibility of hiring particular people. And Representative Hobbs, just one last comment with a question. You know, it's a sad day. Would you agree that when my wife and I had to set up an office in our home in a different location just to hire someone so they would not be around the children because
of a crime due to money and I found that to be a sad day just to help
a family out would you agree yes I agree and now I can hire them and if you get the waiver yes
that's right all right thank you okay thank you representative
Harris representative word thank you Mr. Chair uh represent hobs two weeks ago we passed a bill uh on the house floor that were introduced by representative jocks uh representing miller do you see this particular bill uh in any conflict
with the bill that he introduced on the house floor two weeks ago dealt with criminal background screening and medicaid recipient uh those persons who actually participate
in medicaid program it's okay with you representative hobs i'm not because i'm pretty familiar with that bill and and if you have anything to add, feel free. I don't think they do representative word. His bill dealt with in-home providers who receive waivers for in-home care, and it simply coalesced the requirements for a provider in a facility
with the provider that's in-home in terms of the criminal background check and drug testing. So it just linked up those requirements, whether it was in-home or institutional. I don't this I don't see this being in conflict okay so
none of the language in this particular bill will be in conflict with the one that represented Miller introduced and passed on the House floor
not to my my interpretation would be no represent or mr. cloud I actually think y'all were a little bit involved in the discussions on that do you have anything to add no sir I concur
with what you said we're in a burst okay and I think timbers also the the fact this bill only applies to group settings it does not apply to a one-on-one care right our own our
Speaker 185
48:23
thank you representative love thank you mr. chairman my question is pretty simple I was looking over the list of the nonviolent offenses that are listed here in the bill I believe it's It's on page 2, and I guess my question is along the lines of what Representative Branscomb
asked us. He asked about the infamous crimes, and I'm going to ask about the nonviolent drug offenses. Is there a reason why they were left out, this group of people were left out, the ones that could qualify for
the waiver? Again, sir, the three different organizations came together, and these were the ones that all three agreed upon. And I don't know if you want to address that properly or
Speaker 129
49:15
not. Representative Love, I appreciate the question.
And as providers, when we got together, it was our purpose at this time was to develop a list that would be an agreed upon list. to understand where you're coming from for the particular nonviolent drug offenses and individuals that have rehabilitated themselves in those particular settings, and, you know, my only, you know, answer to that is with appropriate research of those, you know, convictions at an appropriate time, you know, it's possible that certain considerations or amendments could
be made in subsequent sessions or times, but I do understand, you know, where you're coming from, but the issue was to try to strike a balance of agreement among all providers have agreed upon language, and these are the particular offenses that we came to initial agreement on as we were drafting the legislation. Now, so are you
Speaker 185
50:11
telling me, and correct me if I'm wrong, are you saying that you did discuss this group of nonviolent offenders, or are you saying you did not?
Speaker 129
50:21
As it relates to drug offenses? Yes. There was some discussion among that, but as it relates to the offenses that there was initial consensus and agreement upon by the providers, this was the agreed-upon list. Yes, there was some discussion, and I don't want to speak for the other providers, but I do feel that with the appropriate research and appropriate looking at other lists of offenses,
you know, it's possible that there could be additional and subsequent sessions that could be added. But at this time, this was the agreed-upon list of the providers, the list that we agreed upon and was, at this particular time, chosen to be included in the language. Okay.
Speaker 129
51:17
bill as well? Okay. We had individuals from the department, each division within the department that met with us. We also met with representatives of child care, long-term care, the aging, and child care.
So we had each entity that is represented by the original criminal record check act that was enacted and included when we brought all the offenses together under one umbrella two years ago. All of the providers, representatives of the provider groups that was involved in that and that are affected by this participated in this discussion. Okay. Thank you. Thank you,
Vice Chair Murdoch. Thank you, Chairman and Committee. You're bringing out some points here as we read this bill and go through those exclusions.
I concur with the concern that the drug offense is not a part of it. There's probably two areas that is considered very critical in bringing those that are offended back into the mainstream of society. And two of the exclusions that generally you hear about is the drugs and sex crimes. crimes. So I noticed that the sex crimes is not an issue here, but the drug is. Speak
a little bit more on why that's not included in this as part of that because that's very critical to understand what you're trying to do, and I certainly believe in this. I believe in the second chances. I believe in, you know, that concept, but I do have concerns I want to hear a little bit more about, if I may, and if you may indulge me on that, on the drug
Speaker 129
53:03
part again. All right, Mr. Vice Chairman, I don't, among the provider groups that actually met with the department to help draft the legislation,
I don't think there was any effort, I hope I say this the proper way, I don't believe there was any effort to preclude or basically eliminate any offense. Our first priority was actually was to develop an agreed-upon list as providers that we could come to agreement upon. And I think when we get into the Uniform Controlled Substances Act and when you get into specific offenses, I agree with where you're coming from, Representative Ward and Mr. Vice Chairman,
and it's possible at a subsequent time that we can look and delve deeper into that particular violation and create, if agreed upon with all entities, we could develop agreed upon language and agreed upon offenses within those criterias that would possibly allow that person to rehabilitate themselves and return back to the work environment. But there was no effort to eliminate any offense.
I think the primary was to develop a list that we could be agreed upon. And as you know, some offenses are actually more comprehensive than others, and before we delve deeper, there are some offenses that probably require maybe a little bit more research and a little bit more involvement before we include that. But, you know, it would definitely entertain the discussion with you and Representative Love and others as we need to in an appropriate fashion if providers could come to agreement to include those.
Thank you, and I appreciate your response, and I think what happens here, you know, as Representative Hobbs discussed, this is a personal piece of legislation, and politics is very personal.
Of course, second chances are universal, and we want that to go across the board, and the comprehensiveness that you just discussed should be administered every time that we consider doing what we're doing. Make sure you understand that I agree, Representative Hobbs. I like your piece of legislation. I like what it does for second chances and given opportunities after people have been properly rehabilitated. I just want to make sure that though this is personal, I want this to be universal because it applies in a lot of other situations where we may not be as personal.
So just make sure that we, as we do the comprehensive and the testing and the reviewing, that we keep the concept that
we have. because this is a good concept. And if I may, you know, personally, had I been in on making up the list, I mean, but I guess, again, because the way current law is written, it applies to all three different organizations. And so if you had one that was willing, which it sounds like Craig was,
Craig Cloud was willing to consider, but if you had two that were not, that would make it more difficult to even amend it to this point. And I agree with him that if this bill, you know, once it's put into action, if it works, then I think it opens itself up to adding some others to that list. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. Mr.
Speaker 129
56:18
Vice Chairman, I think, and Representative Love, I think we definitely engage the input from the legislature as we move forward.
I think, you know, this is a start. It's not all-inclusive by any means, but it's a start and allows that person the opportunity, the provider, to bring that person back. But I think in the instances that you mentioned, I think moving forward, if this becomes law, then we can have some more engaging discussion as to the appropriateness of other infractions and coming to agreement as providers so we can ensure the best circumstances exist. Okay, thank you.
Representative Butch Wilkins. Well, I think we've danced around my question quite a bit, but to cut it to the bone, what we're asking is how long will it take to pay for a crime, right? And the chairman alluded a while ago that when we're young, 18, 19, 20-year-old, we commit a lot of silly crimes. I mean, there's a lot of silly crimes out there, and some of them are drug crimes. And to think that that should follow a child, what I call a child that commits a crime for the rest of his life,
is not a very pleasant thought to me. People make mistakes. We should, once they pay their debt to society, it should be over and
done with. Don't you agree with that statement? I do, sir. Thank you.
And I think, again, you know, and yes, you know, I wanted to make sure that my friend and my constituent was taken care of. But when I've talked to other people, you know, like Craig said, he has people in his community he would love to hire.
He knows them. And, you know, a lot of us live in smaller communities. So you pretty much know the background. You know what happened. and yet you know that person would be great to work in your setting. But the state currently says you can't do it. You know, you trust them explicitly. You know they would be good at it. You need someone that you can count on. But the state says no. This will just put it back to where the state's saying you may with a proper waiver.
Thank you. Representative Mayberry, last question. Thank
you, Chairman. We talked a lot about these individuals working with child care, but I think you also mentioned aging and long-term care. Is that correct as well? And, again, it's
a group setting, not one-on-one. Right. Okay.
So kind of describe for me what that group setting would be, if you wouldn't mind, like a
Speaker 129
59:04
typical. Okay. In addition to the child care, the church-exempt child care facility,
The others would be included would be a long-term care facility licensed by the Office of Long-Term Care, which would be a nursing home environment. Subsequent would be an intermediate care facility or other developmental day treatment clinic service site that are operated by providers or a group home licensed or certified by the Division of Developmental Disability Services. All are congregate settings where there are multiple employees engaged in the provision of services
and adequate supervision and provision as it relates to the discharge of those services in those congregate environments. Let me first say that I very much like the intent
of what you're trying to do here. I very much believe in second chances. I was reading a VeggieTales book to one of my daughters one day, and it's about Jonah and that God is a God of second chances. And she stops me, and she says, Daddy, sometimes I need third and fourth chances. I said, I get that.
But with regards to some of the – we've talked some about the crimes that are not included on here, but some of the ones that are included on here with regard to theft by receiving, forgery, financial identity fraud, criminal impersonation in the second degree for individuals who have been convicted of those crimes to be put into a setting where they're working with our aging and long-term care population to me that's a very vulnerable population to some of those very
crimes that we're talking about and I I guess I just have some concern I need some assurances that we're not taking someone who may have a good heart, who wants to help people, but I know personally of people who have a wonderful heart, who want to help people. They'll give you the shirt off their back, but when their back's to the wall, they'll steal it back from
you again. So are you saying then, Representative Mayberry, because someone does it once, they're going to do it again?
I'm not saying that they're definitely going to do it again, but they have obviously shown that that is a greater challenge in their life, perhaps. I think we all have our challenges in life. Some people have, you know, they may have challenges with alcohol addiction or gambling or theft or whatever, and that what may be a great challenge for you is not necessarily one for someone else, but they have shown that this is an area in their life where they have been challenged.
and potentially putting them into a situation with a very vulnerable population to those specific crimes concerns me. Well, again, this
doesn't open it up to everyone. Again, it leaves it to the provider. So if, and I'm going to shorten this, but again, and I mean, I understand reservations, but again the provider has done his or her homework on this person again it
may be someone in their community they've known for a long time and if a provider is not comfortable with that person has truly been rehabilitated they don't have to hire them okay thank thank
you thank we've got two people signed up to testify and I'll just close by saying in response to that that's right right now there's a mandate that a provider has no discretion we're removing a mandate to give them discretion okay thank you for the testimony two people
sign up to speak for the bill Savannah Elkins and Amy Warren if y'all are together and comfortable you can if you'll join us at the end of the table say your name for the record you'll be recognized to speak for
Speaker 223
1:03:07
the bill hi I'm I'm Savannah. I'm Debbie's best, our daughter's best friend, and I just prepared a couple of words. Thank you for letting me come share my story and heart with you all today. A couple of years ago, I made a choice that was selfish and hurtful.
The choices I made gave me a long week's stay in jail and a criminal record. Since then, God has changed my heart and mind. I went to counseling weekly for over a year and to a psychologist to make sure that I would become mentally healthy. Shortly after I moved back to Arkansas, I started working in a preschool, and that's when I learned that I had a huge heart and huge passion for children. I can count on one hand how many days I missed within a year and a half because I loved waking up, going to school to see my kids. They were the reason why I loved it so much and didn't want to miss a day. God has given me many talents and gifts to be a creative, loving, fun, but firm teacher.
I can't explain to the full measure my love for it, but my heart does grow twice as big when I try to explain it. The most rewarding comment I could receive would be by a parent stating, My child loves coming to school because when they are having fun, they are building their confidence. And confidence was always something I struggled with for a long time until I started teaching. My goal would always be to provide an always loving and fun learning environment for them to grow. Being a preschool teacher is one of the best jobs and always rewarding. Being in the classroom is what makes me the most fulfilled and the happiest.
Ever since I was told I was not going to be able to work with preschoolers again or for a long period of time, I felt like a huge part of my heart has been missing. Even after I couldn't be in the classroom, I did all the prep work for the sub until they could find a replacement. I didn't want the kids to miss out because I couldn't be there. I do enjoy doing lesson plans, making games, and organizing material, but that's not where my heart wanted to be. I wanted to be on the floor playing the new ABC game, interacting with them, or singing a silly song about our five senses and dancing crazy being silly
loving and nurturing is the best part of being a teacher and what I miss the most I ask that you consider passing this bill so that I can better my future doing my biggest passion and letting my past stay in my past but letting my bad choices influence this law and helping helping those that might share my same passion to move forward and
you for the testimony Miss Horn hi I'm Amy Horn I am the director of the preschool where at
Miss Debbie's church and where Savannah was employed licensing is very it's changed child care licensing has changed over the last few years and the offenses listed are are extensive and good teachers are easy to find but great teachers are difficult to find even in the affluent area in Rogers you can't you you can't pay them what they're worth and when you find someone
that has a heart for working with children and does it in a way that you could only dream a classroom would be like it's it's painful to have to let them go we are a faith-based program and and I believe we we serve a God that that gives second chances and being able to do that would just be wonderful I
I'm trying not to be too personal, but Savannah teaches my children at church on Wednesday nights and Sunday school and has taught them in a period of time what I could only wish a teacher in our preschool could be doing with them. um this bill what i like about it is it it it gives the provider the option to choose to employ
a person based on knowledge of their past history with with recommendations from from other people so you're not going blindly into hiring someone who has committed an offense um you know their story you know their background and you have faith in that person and that was what was so heartbreaking is is I know her and know her story and know the road she's traveled
to become a better person and yet I could do nothing about it and 10 years is a long time to wait and just to have that option would as
a provider would be wonderful okay thank thank you for the testimony okay no questions so thank you members representative
hammer you have a question okay and I'll be brief and I'm
sorry I missed your name do you feel that with where you are in life right now and what you've experienced and the debt to society that you have paid that you are better equipped having made a positive change in life to be able to work with children and to show them not only from a practical point of view but from a personal point of view of why you make good choices and the consequences of making bad
Speaker 223
1:08:53
choices I do think I'm in the place to than I was before I it was a long road I had
to go through counseling and psycho to a psychiatrist but I ultimately it's God's power that changed my heart and my mind and with his power I can do anything forward from now and I just feel being in the classroom has made me the happiest and even though that I was told I wasn't to, the way that I handled it, I believe, um, shows that I have changed. I didn't get defeated. I didn't get discouraged. I always knew that God was in control of the situation,
and he's given me, um, just the ability to just know that he's in control and know that whatever happens, it's in his will, and I think that proves that, um, my heart has changed, because before I knew God, but I didn't know him very personally. Well, you'd be commended for sitting in front of the whole world
and sharing your testimony. You'd be commended for that, and thank you for that. And to the director, I'd like to ask you a question because it is a concern of mine that I wonder if you've thought through or if the presenter of the bill
and those who have helped craft it, if you sit down and you have two individuals and we are about to allow you certain opportunities as an employer and both of them have paid their debt to society but for some reason you just don't have a real comfort level about one but you would hire the other one how are you what's your shield of protection from being sued to say well that was just you had indigestion that day or you characterized me or you held me to a different standard I'm just curious what level of what's
the buffer that's going to stop you from being sued because you had the ability to make a preferential choice given all things equal? And I'm curious if you or somebody to speak
to that. Well, I think I do my research. When I hire someone, anyone, I do my research first. A resume can look great, but, you know, lots of people can look good on paper, but you have to dig in and find out, you know, get those reference checks.
and in this situation when you do have a background check that comes back with those convictions listed on that dig into that find out just just what journey did that person take you know that it gives you as the provider the ability to say I don't have to employ you because of this this conviction I have the option to you know to research it further and if that person is not willing to provide the information like Savannah is she you know I have extensive
information from doctors from the people that she's worked with and and personal references that are willing to vouch for that person you know that's where how I would use my discretion I also do a 90-day probationary period where with any employee where I am I monitor them I observe their performance I take evaluations from other teachers from parents just to see how they're doing to
see if they fit with our organization so I think it would be an organizational choice as well you know for the provider to decide because someone might fit in my organization having walked that road that she's rocked on but not someone else's and it gives you that ability to choose all right thank you okay yeah thank
you for the testimony questions um representative love you're recognized for motion oh i'm sorry representative wilkins i'll make the motion though okay recommend do pass
thank you uh representative love makes the motion do pass as amended members any discussion on the motion yeah all right members there's there's no serious discussion on the motion but all in favor of do pass say aye aye any opposed congratulations you passed your bill thank you mr. chair thank you committee okay members now here's the goal we're gonna go to about noon I'm gonna ask everybody to hang with
us because we do have about four or five more bills to go and they're all pretty more serious at least than they're not they're bills you wouldn't know about put it that way so with that being said I think the order we had established previously was representative Hank Wilkins if you'll join us at the end of the table you'll be recognized to present House Bill 227 2227
Okay, Representative Wilkins, when you're positioned there with your others that
Speaker 166
1:14:24
are going to testify, you may present. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. We are presenting House Bill 2227-2227, and I won't belabor this much except simply to
say that the CHMS providers and the DDTCS providers have gotten together and worked out their differences over the last several weeks, and I'm delighted that that has occurred, and with your permission, Mr. Chair, I will invite Ms. Sarah Israel, who is the Executive Director of Developmental Disabilities Providers Association, and Ms. Amy Denton,
who's the President of the Child Health Management Services Association, to make their presentation. Certainly
Speaker 242
1:15:25
you can testify. Good morning. I'm Sarah Israel. House Bill 2227 is a proactive response to concerns of the Department of Human Services that growth in Medicaid Early Intervention Day treatment services is unmanageable. They have proposed a moratorium on CHMS services, and in lieu of that, we are proposing a process to manage expansion of these services.
The bill we have, as Representative Wilkins stated, is the product of months of work and negotiations between DDPA and the CHMS Association, and DHS and DDS. Medicaid Early Intervention Day Treatment Services are provided to children with developmental disabilities, developmental delays, or a medical condition that puts them at risk for developmental delay. THE SERVICES ARE DELIVERED BY TWO TYPES OF PROVIDERS, CHILD HEALTH MANAGEMENT SERVICES,
CHMS, AND DEVELOPMENTAL DAY TREATMENT CLINIC SERVICES, OR DDTCS. THIS BILL ESTABLISHES A SYSTEMIC PROCESS TO MANAGE GROWTH OF THESE SERVICES AND ALLOW EXPANSION IN AREAS WHERE NEEDED. IT ALSO REQUIRES DHS TO ESTABLISH A STAKEHOLDERS GROUP TO EXPLORE THE FEASIBILITY of combining CHMS and DDTCS into one integrated model. It's only an exploratory effort at this far. There's no particular mandate to combine the programs,
but it is something that we've heard the department is interested in doing, so we've started work on that process, and I'd be happy to answer any questions. Okay, thank
you for the presentation. Members, any questions? Mr. Chairman, I was going to ask
Speaker 166
1:17:11
if it's a question. okay if Ms. Denton get an opportunity to make her presentation before we take a question? Absolutely. Go ahead, ma'am. If you'll say your
Speaker 246
1:17:21
name for the record. Amy Denton. I'm the president of the Child Health Management Association. And basically,
Sarah and I have been working together with our combined associations to come up with a bill we both felt like would do a really good job of ensuring access, continued access to these services for children, but while making sure they are necessary. That's all. Thank you. Representative Meeks,
you have a question? Yes, Mr. Chair. I was just
wondering if, how is this going to be funded? Is it going to be done by grants? Is it going to be done through an already budget line item or private donations?
Speaker 242
1:18:00
I mean, how is this going to work? I need to ask for some clarification. Are you talking about the funding for making the underserved determination or
the services themselves? Well, it looks like you're, and again, I might be off on this or whatever, but it looks like you're starting a pilot program or you're getting a group together to look at this
Speaker 242
1:18:28
issue. Is that correct? Yeah, that's comprised of staff from the Department of Human Services,
primarily the Division of Developmental Disability Services. and some medicaid representatives and then volunteers from both of the provider associations as well as the speech physical therapy and occupational therapy associations so it sounds like this is already going to be under what you're already
doing and won't require any additional funding at all no it shouldn't okay that's what i just wanted to clarify and make sure thank you thank you mr chair thank you uh no
other questions so thank you for the
testimony uh representative uh do you have a question representative mayberry okay i think representative wardlaw is going to beat you to it unless uh you'd like to say anything else representative wilkins okay uh representative wardlaw you're recognized for motion motion do pass okay any discussion on the motion anybody in the audience would like to speak for against i skipped that yeah yeah I've tried to slip a couple things by today but I won't tell you
what the others work as they work nobody's gonna sign speak for again so representative Wardlaw has a motion to pass any discussion on the motion all in favor say I'm any opposed congratulations you passed your bill thank you thank you Mr. Chairman and committee okay next we have we're going to do Cozart then Westerman so representative Cozart you've got two bills SB 857 and SB 840 if you'll join us at the end of the table and tell us which one you'd like
to present first you'll be recognized Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like to present SB 840 first, please. Okay, go ahead. You recognize. SB 840 is a bill by Senator Elliott and myself, and this is an act to repeal that low-voltage carbon monoxide detectors
be placed in newly constructed home what this bill uh this is a redundant bill that kind of is nobody knows who to take care of this and actually who's supposed to enforce it but basically it's under the department of health that is already in code it's in the international residential code and the code officials are the ones that do take care of this so we'd like to take this bill away and do away with it and it is addressed in the international code so okay that is the presentation
thank you members any questions for representative kosar okay anybody in the audience would like to speak for or against the bill if not representative love you're recognized for a motion motion do pass okay anybody uh any discussion on the motion not all in favor say aye aye any opposed congratulations you passed your bill thank you mr now you'll be recognized to present your other one all right this is SB 857
by Senator Clark and what this
does this is a an act to clarify the duties of the Department of Workforce this will this current law say I'm sorry representative Cozer I'm gonna stop you real
quick there is an amendment we're gonna pass that out and then I think we should probably adopt the amendment first so give us about 20 seconds no No problem.
That amendment is probably just to add my name
to it. Okay. Representative Wardlaw made a motion to adopt.
Any discussion on the motion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay. Amendments adopted. Now Representative Cozart, you're recognized to present the bill as amended. All right.
Thank you. The current law says extended unemployment benefits are ineligible for failure to accept or seek work. This bill lays out some reporting requirements to know the numbers. The bill requires quarterly reports to legislative counsel, the number of cases reported and not accepted and how they were resolved.
This bill also allows electronic reporting by business or refusal or failure of a suitable job drug test or other means requires the department to notify periodically an employer employer the method of reporting and it gives a civil defense to the employer who reports so basically what we're doing if somebody is on unemployment and they refuse jobs or they fail drug test all those things are reported and go back to workforce and also to that employer that did employ
them it's just a reporting reporting why the workforce is good with this bill I haven't found anybody yet that's has a problem with it
okay thank you members any questions on representative link you're recognized for a question reps because I'm
you know shouldn't say obviously but I'm for the bill too but I do have a question on it looks like page one of the amendment which is not numbered so it's down close to the bottom says m1 an employer that provides
a report with belief that it is true of a failure to take a job whether by outright refusal so and so forth is not liable for the
reporting what's that mean on m1 yes employer that provides a report with the belief that it is true of a failure to take a job yeah so but it
says they're not liable for the reporting so what's that does that mean the employer can just pretty well say what they want to and say well my bad if
you don't mind I'd like to call somebody if I think I probably answer that question this Mcnolte Mcnolte
so I'm Monty Mcnolte with Arkansas Hospitality Association we support this Phil I think your question is just that if they're not liable for reporting the information through the system someone can't say you shouldn't have reported that or say them I guess they're not liable for it and you know DWS may want to come in on that they're shaking their head yes so I guess I'm good okay
any other questions representative link okay okay members any other questions representative ward you're recognized thanks mr.
chairman also in reading this bill will there be any extenuating circumstances behind the fact that if a person refused a job because of the fact that they may not be able to locate or they may not be able to relocate to an area where they are offering the job
and still be eligible for the unemployment benefits. I
would think that's a department determination and they may want to address that. Ron Calkins, DWS,
Assistant Director of Unemployment Insurance. The issue that comes before us is the offer of work has to be a suitable offer of work,
and what we would look at is that that's one thing that we'd look at in making the determination is how far the individual may have to drive to get to that particular job, how far they're used to driving where they live in the state, that sort of thing. So that's already built into the refusal of offer of work law,
that it has to be a suitable offer of work. So in other words, if a person is offered a job and he or she may not have suitable transportation, even if it's within a boundary where that you think that it's suitable for them to accept that particular job,
but they do not have reliable transportation. All those things are
refusal. Representative, you raised another issue. If someone doesn't have suitable transportation, then we would look at that as that they're not available for suitable work. So that's another issue outside the refusal of offer of suitable work. Okay,
Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Love.
Speaker 185
1:27:20
You recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Sometimes I ask this question and sometimes I don't, but I'm going to ask it in this situation. What is the necessity, what necessitated this bill being, you know, being brought before the committee? Why is this bill necessary, actually? Walk me through the history of why we are doing what we're doing and what is the system that we're coming from. Representative, I believe
that the reason that this is being brought
is to kind of do some cleanup and basically there are a lot of people that refuse jobs just because they'd rather draw their unemployment. And I'm just being plain there. They'd really rather stay at home sometimes and take a job. So this has been an ongoing problem for years. that have happened so if they repeatedly are are refusing jobs just because they don't want to take that job this is kind of clean up to kind of help do away with that that's what we're trying to do if i may add on
of course this is not a dws bill but we did work with senator clark on it
to some degree and the concern was initially that individuals were refusing work because they'd rather draw unemployment and and that dws was not enforcing that particular section of law and our response back was well we can only enforce what we know about and if an employer does not tell us that an individual refused an offer of work then we can't enforce the law so basically what we worked out was we were in the process of developing an easy way for employers to
uh report this information to us over the internet and so it just kind of got this amendment just kind of incorporated that in into the bill and so that's what we're trying to do make it easier our employers to let us know that somebody did refuse an offer of work and then we can take it from there to see if they're they
Speaker 185
1:29:26
thank you so so prior to this bill did you find that to be an
issue that people did people were I mean because if this is not a DWS bill and I know that you all have a legislative packet I mean if there's if if you all didn't see this as an issue did you only see it as an issue since senator Clark brought it up or is this a real issue well again
issue brought before us but there are if
employers are experiencing it and not reporting it to us then we we don't know about that about that part of it but I believe it was senator Clark's belief that it is a problem in the out in the field that these issues aren't being reported to us but but as far as dws goes we we will adjudicate any you know the issues that are brought to our attention i as the assistant director don't have any personal knowledge of it being a giant issue but i'm not i don't work out in the business community so
i'm probably not the best person to be testifying toward that okay thank
you don't mind representative i am out in that deal and i am a building contractor and uh as as you know we have a lot of different people that work for us at different times and different things and i have people call me all the time and said are you hiring and i'll say well not right now they go good and i'll go why why is that and they go well i just i have to make so many contacts to see if we can find employment and and i've said what do you
mean you're drawing unemployment they go yes and they said i really don't want a job i just i have to make these contacts so if you did offer a job they probably would turn it down but you know and most of the time I do
you you I do get those calls quite often thank you representative Khosrow thank you no other questions
or representative Ward okay you're recognized for a question thanks mr. chair these jobs that that are offered do they have to be a full-time nature these are full-time
jobs or just simply part-time employment that a person could be actually rejected or turned off unemployment if it's of a part-time nature job well again we'll we'll
look at what would be suitable work for the individual and if the individual is able to establish their claim versus with part-time work then part-time work would be suitable for them so in
essence they could actually take part-time work and still be eligible for unemployment yes sir
thank you mr. chair thank you members I don't have any other questions so vice-chair Murdoch you're recognized for question oh yes DWS do you
have an opinion on this have you can you weigh in on this work just feelings or comments oh we worked with the senator
anybody in the audience would like to
speak for or against okay representative kozart would you like to close i'm closed thank you thank you what's the pleasure of the committee motion do pass by representative wardlaw any Any discussion on the motion? If not, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Chair rules the ayes have it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Thank you. Next, we're going to do Representative Westerman, and then we're going to do Representative Ferguson and Senator Irvin.
Thank you, Representative Westerman. If you'll say the bill number, and it's 1968, and, sir, doctor, I assume if you'll say your name for the record, you'll be recognized to
present the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It is House Bill 1968. Pleased to have with me today Dr. Scott Schlesinger. He's a neurosurgeon here in Little Rock. Appreciate him coming to testify with me on this bill. Just a quick side note, I studied engineering in college, and I thought, you know, if I'd taken a little bit different career route.
You could actually have a rocket scientist and a brain surgeon here, but unfortunately you just get the brain surgeon
today. So this is a bill. Representative Westerman, did
you just study or did you graduate? I graduated, but I didn't go into rocket science. So almost a rocket scientist tells that. This bill is to create access to care act The title is to lower the cost of care and increase access to care for Medicaid patients
And for other purposes And the purpose of this bill is to allow ambulatory surgery centers to be used to treat Medicaid patients This bill is a part of a package of bills aimed at reforming the existing Medicaid system to provide better access to care with better outcomes at lower cost. It will actually create a win-win-win scenario, two wins for Medicaid beneficiaries on better access to care
and better outcomes, and a win for the state in lowering Medicaid cost. An ambulatory surgery center is defined for Medicaid purposes as a distinct entity that operates exclusively for the purpose of furnishing outpatient surgical services to patients who do not require hospitalization and whose duration of services in the ambulatory surgery center is unlikely to exceed 24 hours. I just want to share with you some benefits of ambulatory surgery centers, and then I want to turn it over to Dr. Schlesinger to give you a little bit more detailed information.
Advantages of these surgery centers, number one is lower cost. The surgical facility fee at thousands of surgery centers throughout the nation averages approximately 40% less than in the hospital setting. Better choice. Patients would have more choice. Having a choice means more competitive fees and better responsiveness to patients' needs. They're more affordable. A surgery center is specialized. It's financially separate from a hospital. Its overhead is much lower and allows savings to be passed on to the patient.
For most procedures, there is an all-inclusive, clearly identifiable facility charge so patients will have a better understanding of cost before surgery. You get better quality. Morbidity rates tend to be better at surgical facilities as compared to hospitals. They're dependable. Scheduled surgery times are not likely to be delayed or bumped by nonrelated emergencies. Turnaround time between surgeries is as much as three times faster than at hospitals, which means less waiting for patients and family members. They're comfortable. Patients and their families can relax in a pleasant environment.
Children can be more comfortable at a surgical center because of its more personal setting. And they're also insurance approved. Many insurance companies and employers actually favor outpatient surgery. Some tailor reimbursement schedules as an incentive to use an outpatient center. They're also both Medicare and Medicaid allowable. I believe this is an important step in reforming costs over time. Again, providing better access and better care to Medicaid patients as we move forward trying to help lower the growing cost in our state for Medicaid services.
And at this time, I'm going to
turn it over to Dr. Schlesinger. Thank you, Bruce. I am Scott Schlesinger from Hot Springs originally, so Bruce and I go way back in addition to our rocket science and neurosurgery. In all seriousness, I feel very amazed to be here. This is much more fun than the operating room. There's lots of things going on here, and if I make any snafus or breach of protocols, I apologize in advance. This is not my domain, so I'll try my best to be to the point.
I wanted to, Bruce and I have been talking about this for a while, about something I noticed. I don't do any outpatient brain surgery. In addition to brain surgery, we do spinal surgery, and that's spine and nerve surgery. So the world of neurosurgery in terms of spine has dramatically changed since I started 20 years ago. Before I began practice in Little Rock, I was in residency in Dallas, and we would admit a patient a week before a lumbar microdiscectomy and keep them for two weeks afterwards.
Well, all that's changed. Typically, over the last 15 years, 99% of my patients who are healthy people and don't have Medicaid or Medicare that have a need for a minimally invasive spinal procedure are done on a completely outpatient basis. And from what I want to address, in addition to the cost issues to the patient and to the insurance companies, is quality of care.
The infection rate, I'm speaking from my practice, but this is well-known and well-published data, that the complication rate from total outpatient care is much better or much lower than it is for hospitalized patients with the same procedure. And this obviously is due to the exposure to or lack of exposure to such problems as MRSA,
which is a really prevalent problem in the hospital population from the hospital workers to the patients and et cetera, the incidence of hospital-acquired infections and other nosocomial complications are completely avoided in the outpatient setting. I've been doing outpatient minimally invasive spine surgery for almost 18 years now, and I've seen in my practice maybe one or two patients get an infection in 18 years in the outpatient setting.
And so this rate is unparalleled in the same population I have to deal with at the hospital setting. Now, the hospital has very important roles in our lives, but when a patient can be done outpatient, if I've had my procedures that I've had on myself, I always want the choice of outpatient care. Now, the problem with Medicaid is not that Medicaid doesn't have outpatient surgery covered from an ambulatory surgery setting, but the reimbursement rate must have been written 100 years ago.
There's payer classifications that range from $260 to as high as, I think, $360 reimbursement to a facility. So no facility can afford to allow Medicaid patients access to this safer, higher-quality environment for the vast majority of services. Now, I'm speaking strictly from minimally invasive spine care. This is extrapolated to every field in medicine, from hernia repairs to gallbladders to everything that we commonly do outpatient now,
which has saved private insurers and Medicare billions of dollars in this transformation over the last 20 years. The problem we have with Medicaid is the Medicaid reimbursement rate has not kept up with the times in terms of ambulatory surgery centers. So while we can do it, no one can. Just the cost of the soft goods, the paper sheets that we use would be barely covered
by the $300 reimbursement, so it's not feasible. But the same procedure that we're forced to bring to the hospital setting, whether it's hospital outpatient department or hospital inpatient department, ends up costing the state ten times what would be a reasonable reimbursement rate that we see from the commercial payers at the ambulatory centers. So for instance, something I deal with, a lumbar microdiscectomy, which is for a herniated
disc, that Blue Cross or the commercial Aetnas and Cygnus and Qualchoices pay to the surgery center the facility fee of $1,500 to $2,000. And I'm forced to do that at the hospital. They pay the hospital somewhere in the range of ten times that amount, affecting not only the carriers and the people paying the rates, but the patient's 20 percent. Now, that has nothing to do with, obviously, with Medicaid in terms of the patient co-pay, or maybe not yet.
But the governor and the legislature, I assume, are asking physicians to control costs or helping to control cost with episodes of care. Well, asking us to control the cost and forcing us to take patients to the highest cost environment that has the highest chance of complications and the highest rate of infection is asking me to swim across the lake with my hands tied by my back. It's a real scary situation where I could be financially responsible
for the cost of a lumbar microdiscectomy episode of care and yet not able to say, I'm going to bring this patient to the lowest-cost center. And the cost is twofold. One is the initial cost of the procedure, but if one does get an infection at the hospital or anywhere else, the cost to care of a postoperative discitis or osteomyelitis is astronomical. And so I'm being subjected to these cost issues.
Now, I wanted, in addition to the cost and the quality of infections, we're also, other quality measures are much, much safer at an outpatient center because of the more serene, quiet environment. I don't know if anybody here has ever had to have a surgical procedure, but it's scary. It's as frightening as it is for me to come down here to the families And to be in an environment that is more comfortable is important.
The satisfaction rate of patients is something that is being stressed, as you all know, in Medicare reform and health care reform in general. So patients should have that right. They should have the right to access and access to the most favorable environment. The physicians should be the ones to direct the patient to the safest and best environment. And I ask the committee and thank the committee for allowing me to speak to give the Medicaid patients of Arkansas that right and that chance
and to save the state perhaps billions of dollars at the same time. Thank you.
Thank you. That sounds like a good bill. That's not rocket surgery. That was a joke. Anyway, Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Um, I'm not
totally against you yet, but I want to know the answer to this one, Ted. What does it cost for this procedure right now under Medicaid if they go to the hospital?
Well, that is a really difficult-to-answer question because it's completely, you know, our research leads me to one conclusion. This Arkansas Medicaid reimbursement system for hospital care is so complicated and lacks transparency so severe that that is almost an impossible question to get an answer to. The reason for the question is, as you
said a while ago, that they reimbursed, I think you said, $300 for this procedure. At the ambulatory center. At the ambulatory center.
And then you said that private insurance is reimbursing at $1,500 for the same procedure. And you said this thing was going to save money, so
I'm trying to figure out how that goes together. Well, the fact that we cannot bring and medicate patients to an ambulatory center because the reimbursement is below cost forces us to bring it to the hospital. Now, what we do know is that the upfront reimbursement to the hospital,
and I'm only speaking for limited procedures I'm aware of, but we know the upfront reimbursement in Arkansas is based on a per diem, And then at the end of the year, some complex cost reimbursement process occurs. So the best that we can tell through people that have helped us look at this is it somewhere approaches the Medicare DRG rate by the end of the year or after the end of the year. And we know that the Medicare DRG rate for a lumbar microdiscectomy is somewhere in the $4,000 to $5,000 range.
So instead of doing it for $1,000, $1,500 or some reasonable rate that most payers pay, the state ends up paying, we guess, somewhere in that $4,000 to $5,000 range for that one procedure. Can you tell me an estimate? How many procedures
of Medicaid do you think this is in a year's time, or do you know?
Well, I can only speak from my personal, you know, practice, but my gut feeling is, you know, that numbers are available out there.
They estimated that if all the procedures that could be done in the Medicare population were done outpatient that were medically appropriate would save about $2.4 billion. I did run across that number. Now, that would be a smaller number here in the state of Arkansas, but my gut feeling is the Medicaid patient population that I see is a younger, healthier group of people than the Medicare population.
So I suspect that the percentage of Medicaid patients who would be appropriate candidates for outpatient care is fairly high. And right now, zero are going to outpatient centers that I'm aware of. I'm not aware of any centers that can afford that discrepancy. So if 50% of the surgical procedures done that were medically appropriate were done outpatient,
then the savings could be in the millions and millions of dollars. I'm just speaking
from the clinical standpoint, really. Thank you.
Speaker 166
1:49:05
Okay, thank you. Representative, I think it's Hank Wilkins. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Doctor, I wanted to, I'm intrigued slightly by your statement that the cost is sometimes
10 times as much in hospital as outpatient. And I'm going to give you a scenario and ask you to tell me what the cost savings would be, a true scenario. I've had spinal surgery three times. I don't know if it's the discectomy, whatever you're calling it, but the doctor told me it was fusion.
fusion, does that sound like the same thing? That's a different procedure on this part of it. So the fusion is a more complicated procedure than the one you were referring to? Yes. Okay. So in that case then the person would need to be hospitalized,
would need to be an inpatient? It depends. I personally perform, and there's a growing percentage of spinal lumbar fusions and cervical fusions
that are done through what we call MIS, or minimally invasive surgery. So some patients are candidates for
Speaker 166
1:50:36
outpatient care, even for lumbar fusion. So what makes the difference then as to whether or not that person would
need to be inpatient or outpatient? It's a medical decision based upon the patient's complexity of their problem and their underlying medical condition. And the goal is that their postoperative stay would be at least in terms of needing direct attention
be in terms of hours rather than 24 or greater hours of
Speaker 166
1:51:14
done some reading about the infection rates, and, of course, that's something that we all need to be concerned about because in the last of those three procedures that I had, I was given an infection by the hospital. They said they didn't give it to me, but they did. I hadn't been with anybody but them, and so it had to have come from there.
And then I was put on vancomycin, is that? Vancomycin. Vancomycin. And I had to be on it for six weeks each day, every day, and I had to have this home health nurse. You're saying that in similar surgeries that there is less chance of a person getting an infection. Well, that's a well-published fact.
That's not a conjecture. That's a published fact. In my experience, it's also true just empirically, but that's a well-published, studied fact that exposure to hospital-acquired infections or to agents such as MRSA is much lower in an outpatient environment. What's the reason for that? Well, my feeling is that if you're in a hospital setting and you are on a ward and there's a patient four rooms down from you that has pneumonia
and somebody from the nursing or care unit or food service goes into that room and then they come down to your room, It's exposure to agents that you just aren't exposed to in a healthy population coming in, getting their procedure, and going out the door. So
Speaker 166
1:53:12
it wouldn't necessarily have anything to do with the cleaning of the operating area?
I don't think so. I think most hospital-acquired infections are required in the hospital
Speaker 166
1:53:29
rather than in the operating room. Okay. The final thing. So what this bill would do really is to put into code a certain percentage for reimbursement. And I guess I'm just wondering if that's a good policy procedure for us to do.
I'm going to pass that one to Bruce. I have no idea. Yeah, I believe it's a good policy procedure because it would allow ambulatory surgery centers to provide these services. It's a code that is already being paid by Medicare, so I think it's a fair rate, and it would obviously allow more choice for patients to use ambulatory surgery centers because of the Medicaid reimbursement rates that are there now.
They simply can't take the patients in for that
Speaker 166
1:54:32
amount. So do we have a fiscal impact statement indicating what the additional, since we're going to be paying more, what the additional amount would be estimated at? There hasn't been a fiscal impact statement done,
and I'm not sure that there could be one done right now because we're not, and I don't believe we'll be paying more. I believe we'll be paying less in the long run because a lot of these procedures
that are taking place at the hospitals now for higher costs plus the complications with infections, those costs would go down. We have visited with Medicaid, with Director Allison. I'm not sure if he's still here, but I believe he's going to address some of the issues about implementing this program if he's still here. But I believe it is a good way to move forward and to save money. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you. And I just want to make sure that, yeah, for clarification, I'm doing a little bit more latitude today than I have, but generally maybe. But basically all you're doing is aligning reimbursement rates in a manner in which Medicaid patients are going to have the same access to care that Medicare and private patients do. And right now, because of the reimbursement rates are so low for Medicaid, they don't have the option to go for what could be a better procedure in a better location. by aligning the reimbursement rates, you're potentially keeping them out of the more cost,
the least cost-efficient environment. Is that an accurate summary? From my standpoint, yeah,
that is exactly right. You know, from a clinical standpoint, I really believe that the choice of what's the best safe, I mean, my job is to pick the safest environment to provide care for that patient, whatever it happens to be. So, obviously, if I'm dealing with a brain tumor or a ruptured aneurysm, I have no choice that has to be done in an acute care facility.
But for an elective process, I feel very badly when I take a 16- or 18-year-old girl or boy to the hospital and expose them to these risks that they are completely avoidable simply because their insurer is Medicaid. is the only insurer that we can't take to the ASC from an economic standpoint. Yeah, and there are procedures that are going to take place regardless.
We just might give them the ability to have a procedure. I have to take a carpal tunnel release.
It takes me five minutes to release a little nerve right here in the hand, but I have to put them in the hospital for Medicaid patients. It's absurd if
of them. Oh, I'm sorry. I told you I breached protocol already. No, it's fine. And members, I've got good news. Made it a little bit of an executive decision and ordered lunch. So we get to spend lunch together. We do have a couple more bills to run, and I don't know, but given where the session is,
I think it's important that we spend as much time as we can and get bills moving through the process. So lunch is on the way. Representative
Speaker 185
1:57:52
Love, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I mean, I believe Representative Wilkins kind of touched on my question, but initially I wanted to ask because we're looking at codifying a specific percentage of reimbursement. And since we're talking in percentages, what is the percentage that you receive now in Medicaid reimbursement?
What's the percentage set at? I'm not sure I understand
Speaker 185
1:58:24
what the question. Can you explain? Okay. Here on page, let's look at page three. Page three, it'll be line. Yeah,
I see now. Currently, it's not tied to the reimbursement rate at the facility is not tied to anything. It's set at a set rate of $260.
There's four Medicaid groupings, and I'm not sure exactly where the choice went behind on who put what codes in what grouping, but the groupings range from $260 to $360. The Medicare system for outpatient surgery, ambulatory surgery, is based upon a totally different formula, And it's based upon the procedure code value, and they pay it.
It's a Medicare formula. Blue Cross pays by groupers. Everybody's got their own system. The Medicaid is not based on a percent of anything right now. Now, when Bruce and I talked about this, what we were trying to do is come up with a way to value a fair valuation that was still cost savings to the government and taxpayers while at the same time being at a reasonable rate for the facilities.
So we said, okay, well, if Medicare patients can get their carpal tunnel released done and the pay be, you know, $800, then we'll set the rate at 80% of that for the Medicaid or $640. Did I do pretty good there? $640. So we were trying to peg it against something. It's easier. Here, you know, the assumption was that the Medicare reimbursement was at the lowest end.
It's certainly lower than the commercial payers, the Blue Cross, the Aetna, the Cygnus, and Qualtrics, et cetera. So the lowest payer other than Medicaid is Medicare, but Medicare's payment is not in the prohibitive range for most of these procedures, but Medicaid is. Okay. So
Speaker 185
2:00:47
here's my thing. because we're trying to codify a percentage for ambulatory surgery centers. And so are we prepared to do that for other providers, Mr. Westerman?
Other outpatient providers? I mean, other providers,
Speaker 185
2:01:04
period. I mean, because we're codifying. We're saying that we're going to guarantee a third percentage. We shall, it says, shall be 80% of Medicare, hospital, outpatient procedure. So I guess I'm just trying to wrap my head around what we're trying to do. And I would say if it makes
sense to do that, we should be prepared to do it. I believe in this situation it makes sense to establish a rate that can allow patients to use these ambulatory surgery centers.
So I think we'd have to look at it on a case-by-case basis. But right now, there's really no way for patients to have access to this lower-cost, better-care service if we don't set some kind of rate that's fair. I
Speaker 185
2:01:53
think, Mr. Westman, I agree in principle with what you're trying to do. I just feel like it kind of scares me that we're trying to codify a certain percentage for a certain industry. It just kind of frightens me to do that.
But not to say that I'm against what you're trying to accomplish. It's just when we start talking about certain percentages and guaranteeing certain percentages, that kind of gives me pause. I can appreciate that, and I can
appreciate that there are a lot of uncertainties with health care right now, and we're trying to blaze some new paths. And I do believe this is a good direction to take to lower cost and provide better care for Medicaid patients. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you. Representative Meeks. You can pass over
Okay. Vice Chair Murdoch. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Representative Westerman, for bringing this to us. And I'm trying to put it in a box exactly what you're trying to do here. And part of it I can understand as a legislator, and we as legislators that are non-doctors anyway, I think Representative Ferguson may understand a little better the clinical part of this. But there are two things that we're asked to do. We're asked to understand and make a decision based on economics and based upon the clinical
part of this. Now the doctor that has testified today has testified to his limited scope that he deals with and he's given some generalities on cost and care. I want to focus on the care, the economics of it. I can get to the math of it. I can deal with the math. I actually went to that same engineering school you went to. So we can work on that. We're all good on that. I want to hear that the quality of care is not going to be compromised for cost. When we talk about, I keep hearing this word about reforming Medicaid
or reforming our current health system. And the reformation and the reforming of our health system, we want to make sure that we don't compromise care and access. I'm sure you care about that as well, so I'm not saying it's a bad bill at all. I'm just wanting to get reassurance, and hopefully there will be some testimony that will come behind you that will talk about exactly what this will do to the care for the people. I think so many times, Representative Westman, when we talk about reforming, we just look at cost. And we mention care, but we just look at cost.
And I want to make sure, and I'm sure we all want to make sure, that the quality care is not going to be compromised
in this piece of legislation. Do you have a comment on that? Absolutely. And I believe that's what we've tried to stress in this presentation, Representative Murdoch, is that it's a win-win for the patient, not only in quality of care, but access to care. And it's also a win for the state in lower cost.
Let me ask you this. I'm sorry. So if someone that comes behind you in this format of how we do for and against,
if someone comes and speaks against what you're saying and they're in a medical, So they're designated as the people that should know, that should know, and should inform us of what they know. And if they speak against what you're saying in terms of quality care, the care part of it, not the math, but the care part of it, because we can verify the math, then we as legislators, how are we
to take that? Because they're supposed to know. And I believe the facts are there that the infection rates are lower. No, I'm saying if they speak against it
Well, I would like to see their data If they want to speak against it But, I mean, I don't know whether they
will or not But I guess we'll find out Right, that's what I hope to hear as well So if everybody comes behind you, affirms what
you're saying And all the clinical people affirm it Then I'll agree with it and I'll make the motion Thank you, Jessica I'd like to address your concern When I said I'm speaking from my limited area, I want to amend that by saying my limited area in spinal surgery and nerve surgery.
But the statistics I quoted is not limited to spinal and neurological surgery. It's well-known published data of the Ambulatory Surgery Center health care delivery that the infection rate is less than 1% overall of all surgeries, hernia repairs, et cetera. And it is my only mission as a provider is to pick the safest environment and the safest procedure or the best procedure or no procedure at all for the patient.
That's my job, and Medicaid doesn't allow providers to do their job in that regard, at least in allowing access when the provider, whether it's I had a hernia repair, I wouldn't have even dreamed of doing that at the hospital inpatient and being exposed to whatever complications might occur. And it's not just infectious. There's also complications that should never occur, that the wrong side, wrong levels, wrong person, wrong antibiotic or wrong drug.
These complication rates are well, never events. I'm sorry, I had a brief lapse of memory. But the never event rate, well published in the literature, is much lower in the outpatient ambulatory surgery center environment. So this is not data that I use for my patients. It's data I use when I myself have sought care or my family has sought care, which is what my job as a physician is. So as a legislator, I hope that you will give patients and physicians the right in the Medicaid population to have a choice.
It's about choice. And the choice here is not the economics or, as you said, it's going to be easy to figure out if you can get through the lack of transparency to compare to in the hospital reimbursement. But you've got to give, we've got to have the ability to choose the safest, best environment for the patient. And I
agree with that. But let's make sure that the implication that you're making, you may not be intending to do this, but so far all of this says that the hospital or the inpatient facility is not as good,
it's not going to take the necessary precaution, it's not going to be as adequate as outpatient. And you may not be trying to say it that way. You are Representative Westerman, but there are some serious implications of what you're saying that I'm sure when the hospital or whomever else testify, they're going to want to clear that up because I don't think you mean it that way, but that's the way it's coming off, is that these infections and these other preventable never should happen. Instances will happen inpatient, will not happen in this legislation that you're presenting now.
So there is an implication there that you're going to have to
stand behind, so be careful of that. Excuse me, one last statement in that regard. One last amendment. One last amendment to my amendment. But the statements I'm making is just that's published data that we're not talking about a particular surgery center versus a particular hospital. We're talking about post-op hospital care versus ambulatory surgery surgery care is well-published data. It's not me making it up or the Honorable Mr. Westerman making it up either.
Yeah. Okay. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a question. I
had not seen this bill until today, so I just had a few questions. Does this cover hospital-based ambulatory surgery centers only, or is it private outpatient surgery centers as well? Well, I'll
let Mr. Smith speak, but I believe it was intended for all ambulatory surgery centers
regardless. Okay. And the fee we're talking about from Medicaid, is that the facility fee?
Is that what we're talking about? Yes. Not the doctor's fee, the facility. Correct. Okay. And to address Representative Love's question, Blue Cross pays based on RVU. You asked about the RVU on line 22. Most fees are tied to RVU, like Blue Cross pays. I don't want to quote exactly, but 130 or 140 percent of RVU, and that's based on Medicare rates. And then Medicaid typically is about 50 to 80 percent of that. So, I mean, all those fees are tied to RVU.
So my other question is, does this cover all outpatient procedures or just in a row? It would be all outpatient procedures. And just in response to Representative Murdoch, unfortunately, outpatient centers are safer than hospitals. The answer is yes, they are safer, and they are cheaper. And for some reason, Medicaid payments have driven these patients to the more expensive option.
I guess that's all. Thank you. I like
those kind of questions. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Thank you. This may
sound like the third time, but just for the record, I want to ask you, Are you saying that outpatient centers are safer places to have these
procedures than hospitals? Certain procedures in certain patients. It's very patient-specific. In other words, if you came to me and you needed a carpal tunnel release
and you had terrible heart disease and other problems, then I would do you in a hospital setting. It's based on anticipated medical needs. So it totally depends on the patient and the procedure. And the
position that you're taking is based on fact outside of your opinion. It's based on reports that are generated either by some independent reporting sources. Absolutely. Okay. A couple other questions, if I may, pretty quick. Just a quick one, please. Thank you.
I'm asking you this question on the basis of a comment you made a minute ago in your testimony. Do you feel that the lower reimbursement rate is discouraging physicians from seeing Medicaid recipients as a whole, whether it's in the day-to-day operations of a clinic or in a setting
such as a surgical center. I don't think that the Medicaid reimbursement to facilities has anything to do with physicians willing to see Medicaid patients unless the physician specializes in outpatient procedures,
in which case, for instance, orthopedic surgeons I know of that only do hip or shoulder arthroscopies and the like that limit their practice to outpatient procedures may not be willing to see Medicaid patients because they have no logical place to do their procedure. So indirectly, yes, but directly, no. Okay. And in the
context of the intent of this bill, will Medicaid patients have greater access to needed services that currently they're being denied or limited to accessing?
I believe yes. And then the last question is, do hospitals, and I'm trying to sort this out based on comments you made, so I'm asking the question, do hospitals lose money or save money under this plan? And the reason I'm asking that is if the rate goes up, it seems like hospitals would want to compete with the outpatient centers if the reimbursement rate goes up. Can you kind of help me
sort through that or am I misunderstanding? You know, I'm going to speak for a guess.
My guess is the hospital's outpatient departments, the ambulatory surgeries facility that they run would make more money, but their inpatient revenue would drop because the numbers would drop. And on
their inpatient side that you just mentioned right now, are they basically losing money at the reimbursement rate?
Can you speak to that? That I cannot comment on because I don't know. But the best that we could tell, they are at the end of the year, most of the hospitals are something called cost reconciliation.
that Arkansas is among one of four states that I believe still uses that system. So to the best of my knowledge, I can't think that they're losing money, but I don't know. Okay. Thank you.
Thank you. We have one more question. Representative Mayberry. Thank
you, Mr. Chair, and I'll make this quick. Just want to clarify that this bill would not preclude you as a physician, as a provider, from directing a patient for a particular procedure to a hospital setting
if you thought that that was in the best interest of the patient. Is that correct? Oh, absolutely. It just allows you to think. This would just broaden your options and being able to determine the most appropriate setting to get the best outcome for that person. Absolutely. And one quick follow-up is just hypothetically speaking, if someone needed patellar tendon surgery, would you suggest an ambulatory surgery center or
a hospital? Hypothetically, I would do anything that had to be done to me outpatient that was appropriate.
Thank you, sir. Okay. I think that's all the questions from the committee. So does anybody in the audience like to speak for or against? If not, you want to say, well, Representative Westerman. We're going to let you close for the bill. Would you start your closing by taking a question from Vice Chair Murdoch? I don't have a question for him.
I was wondering, is Medicaid or anyone here in the building, in the room, that can give me some input on just how you feel about this and your thoughts on it? If Andy could help me out. I believe that was a request for DHS
to enlighten us or talk on the bill. Yes, just talk on the bill, not for it.
Speaker 33
2:16:34
I'd be glad to. Andy Allison, Director of Medical Services at DHS, we're not testifying for or against the bill, as Representative Murdoch indicated. You know, we do currently reimburse ASCs on the front end in a way that's very similar to or almost exactly what we would reimburse an outpatient hospital setting, which is, I think, really the appropriate comparison here. I think the question of whether it's an inpatient versus an outpatient or ASC setting is a different
issue, you know, the overnight, et cetera. And that is more of a utilization choice or clinical choice that I think would be better served and addressed through payment reforms like episodes of care as opposed to the fee-for-service rate schedule. We've focused our efforts at DHS on really the more global episodic approach which takes directly into account issues of quality, setting of care, et cetera.
We haven't chosen to focus first on improving the fee for service schedule, in fact we're trying to get away from a focus on the fee for service schedule. This bill addresses what is an imbalance in the total reimbursements to the ASC versus the outpatient hospital setting driven primarily by that back end sort of cost related reimbursement that happens, you know, funded in part through hospital assessment fees, but primarily through
the federal government and federal taxpayers. And those payments to outpatient hospitals on the whole are pretty comparable to the original payments that we make to them. So it's a very substantial component of the reimbursement is that back end. And I think that's what this bill addresses, and even though the reimbursement would be increased substantially for ASCs, I don't believe, along with that cost-related reimbursement on the back end for Medicaid, that it would still quite bring it up to the outpatient
cost. Now, it may be neutral for the state. It would cost federal taxpayers, I think, a bit more on the outpatient side. Because of that differential, for every, you know, for every case that is, for every surgery that's performed, every service that's performed on the ASC side, one for one that would actually be a savings to the state. On the flip side, as the surgeon has commented and as, you know, as history would suggest,
if you increase reimbursement, if a service is profitable and it's been testified, we wouldn't necessarily argue that it's unprofitable now on the ASC side, that it might actually induce some demand. It might mean that there are more procedures done in the state as a whole regardless of setting if we pay more and increase that payment to the ASC. If you balance those two, we're not sure that it would cost the state or taxpayers on net.
Again, so for each individual service that goes from one setting to the ASC, it would likely save money, there's a possibility that either because of the administrative cost of making this happen or more likely induced demand, that that could offset the savings. But we can't predict it would cost, we're real hesitant to say it would save, and
we're not opposed. Okay. Okay. Before, Chairman, so there's an indeterminate there. That's why you didn't speak for or against, so it's not as clear.
But go ahead, Chairman. maybe you can
help us. Well, I don't want to, I think this is a good bill obviously and I don't want to get too argumentative, but Dr. Allison, because I mean you and I are friends these days and so if, but. That is really good to know. I appreciate that. In order for some of what you said to be accurate, I think implicit in your comments that perhaps by levelizing these reimbursements procedures would go up, implicit in that is that Medicaid patients aren't getting
the same access to care that a private insured or a Medicare
Speaker 33
2:20:55
patient does get. I did not mean to imply that. I just meant to draw the connection between the amount of payment, the profitability of that service, whether it's medical care, whether it's Medicaid paying, some other service, some other payer, the more you pay, oftentimes the more you'll see. was expressed differently in the questioning before I came to the
microphone here in terms of is access sufficient now we don't have we don't have any indication or evidence that it is insufficient currently under with the rates that we pay well and I understand your comments on
fee for on moving towards the episodic reimbursement and I agree that there is great potential in that but I think the the spirit of that it really is at the heart of this of this legislation but and I guess I would say would you agree
that if even though we are moving maybe toward potentially towards a different reimbursement model that deals more with episodes versus fee-for-service while we do have fee-for-service shouldn't the fees be equitable as to ensure access for for people just no matter what
Speaker 33
2:22:10
coverage they have I would agree in principle yes If the rates of reimbursement are as far apart as they are currently between the outpatient setting and ASCs, that can be a much more powerful counter incentive than any incentives
that we could positively introduce through the episodes of care. For example, if we were to share savings on what amounts to the choice of setting, outpatient versus ASCs, and we share half of those savings to the state by moving to the ASC, that's just half the difference, whereas if, you know, the core reimbursement is, you're only making up for half that difference in reimbursement to the outpatient versus the ASC, so it's
no more than half as effective as fixing that original imbalance. That's a long answer, but I agree with you. In this case, with the disparate reimbursement rates, the episode cannot address that underlying differential. Okay. Back
to the original question right now, Chairman. In this particular case, in your opinion, do you think that we are, do we need this
Speaker 33
2:23:30
Well, as I said before, we're not testifying, I'm not testifying in favor nor against the bill. Our efforts right now are focused on payment improvements which are a bit broader in nature and are designed to improve both quality to encompass the choice of setting of care as well as to incentivize efficiency within each setting of care. That really is our focus. It was our choice to begin payment reforms with that episodic approach as opposed to
going to the underlying reimbursement rates. For example, we're one of the only states, I think, and one of the only payers that still uses a per diem for inpatient reimbursements. So that's similarly outdated. We chose to focus on episodes of care first. I was trying to go around to get you to go back to
where I really wanted you to be. I've been listening to birds long enough to see if that would work. So you finally did get there. So thank you, though. I appreciate that.
Thinking about a Padawan joke, but it's probably not appropriate. We have two questions, Representative Love and then Ferguson. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. I just wondered
why the disparity now in the fees? These, I think it's been
Speaker 33
2:24:57
brought out before, although I can't remember how far back, the beginning of time we've had these, you know, we've had these fee-for-service rates in place for a very, very long time.
I think my staff told me the 1990s, early 1990s for these rates. They simply aren't routinely updated. That's, you know, that's one of the sort of negative byproducts of trying to maintain a list of, you know, thousands of reimbursement rates as they tend to become very outdated. So at one point in time, there was some rationale and some, you know, I think probably better justification for the rates that are paid, and it simply hasn't been revisited.
Okay, members, I don't have any other questions, so thank you for your testimony, Dr. Allison. Anybody else in the audience to speak for or against? If not, Representative Westerman, do
you want to close for your bill? Okay. I think the doctor had a question for Director Allison, but we'll pass that, and I will just go ahead and close. We have an opportunity here to make a difference in access to care for Medicaid patients.
We have an opportunity to provide a better environment for them to get that care with better outcomes. We have an opportunity to potentially lower costs as we move forward with Medicaid reform in the state. So I would ask for a good vote. Okay. Thank
you for the presentation, members. What's the pleasure of the committee? Got a motion to pass. Any discussion on the motion? If not, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee.
Thank you. We have two. Representative Ferguson is going to run. Is it just one bill, Representative Ferguson? You do have two. Okay. I think she did. Now, lunch should be arriving any moment. I figure we can just keep going. So, oh, that's right. we've got representative ferguson's bill then we're going to do 161 and the goal will be to wrap up by about 1 115 so and lunch will just be waiting for you if you choose if not you can
just go on get wherever you want mcdonald's down the street uh representative malone do you have a question okay um okay representative ferguson it's senate bill 810 senate senate bill 810 first members and then we're going to do 788 is that right correct okay so 810 first and 788
you're recognized to present okay this is an act to allow the Department of Health to be appropriately reimbursed for medical supplies and services right now they only charge I think an encounter fee and
aren't and can't really charge patients and get reimbursed for that and I'm I'm actually going to let Robert Breck from the Health Department sort of explain the bill to you because part of the TB things they've taken out, they've quit getting money to pay for tuberculosis medicine, and that's why that's been struck from the bill. But I'll let him explain. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Robert Breck with the Health Department. What this will do, currently under a statute that was passed in 1989,
the department can only ask for reimbursement from insurance companies or from individuals who might pay cash or otherwise. We can only charge what our exact cost for providing that service is. What's happened with the Affordable Care Act, we are going to be expected now to bill for services because presumably everybody is going to be insured. And so those monies that have flowed through CDC to the health department and through other federal grants to provide immunizations, provide care for tuberculosis patients, that money is going to decline, and we're expected to bill for those services.
What this would do, it would allow the department to bill insurance companies for the usual and customary reimbursement costs that insurance companies would pay. For instance, flu shots are about the only thing now that we actually charge insurance companies for. We can only charge them $30 for a flu shot when they would gladly pay us nearly double that. But because of that statute, we can only charge the $30. What we're afraid is going to happen, if we can only charge for what the exact cost is,
as the monies dry up from the federal government, we won't be able to provide those services for those who otherwise are not able to pay. I do want to point out that this, although we would be able to charge a customary fee, we would provide services to anyone, whether or not they could pay for the service or not. I'd be happy to answer any
questions you might have. Okay. Thank you, members of the committee. Are there any
Speaker 238
2:30:06
questions? There are no questions. Oh, Representative Wilkinson.
Wilkins, excuse me. Mr. Chairman, motion is prompted. Okay,
there are not any more questions from the committee. Are there anybody in the audience to speak for or against? Seeing none, Representative Wilkins, you recognize? Motion do pass. Motion do pass. All in favor? All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you,
committee. Okay, you have another bill. Right,
for Senator Irvin, it's Senate Bill 788. Okay, go ahead. You can testify.
Okay. This is just an amendment to the Medicaid Fairness Act that was passed when? Ninety-five? Oh, two thousand. No? Two thousand five. Sorry. And what's happened in the due process now, the administrative law judge, we're asking that be moved to the health department instead of DHS, because with DHS doing it, with them making the decision and then having the judge, it sort of becomes an incestuous process.
So we want to move the administrative law judge to the health department instead of the EHS so it's a fair process. I'll let Mr. Ivers explain it, and if you have questions, he's an attorney, so I'm
sure he can answer. David Ivers with the Arkansas Medical Society. As Representative Ferguson said, the bill was passed, I mean the law was passed in 2005. This amends it by having – primarily because of the payment improvement initiative, we
felt like it needed to be updated and some clarifications made, and as part of that, for providers, we felt it was important to have the administrative law judges separate from the Department of Human Services, and as part of the compromise with the Department of Human Services on the bill, the department will now also have the right to appeal, whereas before they did not. Otherwise, the bill just clarifies some of the misunderstandings that have occurred since the original law was passed and the differences in interpretation and deals with payment reform.
And the bill has been agreed to by the Department of Human Services and the governor's office. And it's supported by all of the provider associations
a question. Representative Meeks. Thank you. On page, I think it's to, yeah. Now, page 2, it says on line 10, I'm sorry, I lost my place here for a moment, it says to constitute an adverse decision, an agency decision, need not have a monetary penalty attached but must have a direct monetary consequence to the provider.
Could you give me an example of something that doesn't have a monetary penalty but has a monetary penalty consequence, what that might be?
Yes, this actually came about because what we found is that, for instance, in a long-term care facility, the Office of Long-Term Care may cite the facility a deficiency. For instance, recently we had a dispute over whether you could have one person or two persons in a room in an assisted living facility.
And although the Office of Long-Term Care did not assign a monetary sanction on the provider, Obviously, the deficiency by saying you can only have one person in this room was of direct economic consequence to the provider since it cut in half the amount of reimbursement that they could receive. And so this just allows the provider to appeal even when there's not a monetary sanction. Okay, thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Harris. Yeah, it just makes the appeal process fair, and it takes it out of the hand, you know, the person who's making the decision. It's not also the person who's the responsible party. Representative
Harris. Okay, please explain to me the purpose of taking, I mean, again, you did in the opening, but taking the administrative law judge, the whole DHS, the purpose of that, again, so I can understand.
Right now what happens is that if the department is, for instance, you're fighting a recoupment against the department, the department also hires the hearing officers and conducts the hearing on your case. And frankly, there was almost no chance that you were going to ever win these appeals. and over time it became such a point of contention between providers in the department that we felt it would be best
to just simply house the hearing officers outside of the department as is done in various other states. Okay.
problem or? Well, remember that we didn't have this statute until 2005, so it's, you know, it's over time. Okay. All right. Thank
Can you give me just a real brief
explanation of a scenario that would take you in front of one of these judges? Just give me an example real
quick one. These are usually just routine audits that are conducted at providers And, for instance, if it's a question of medical necessity, the provider felt that, for instance, the physician may have felt that the service was necessary and the department comes back and says, no, you know, we disagree that the patient didn't need that.
And so then you just have a dispute over whether or not the department can recoup the money. And so the provider then appeals
the recoupment. Okay. And is the general public ever in this kind of a position coming before these judges, or is this more a provider versus DHS type scenario? These are
provider appeals. There are beneficiaries also have the right to appeal. There's a separate statute and provisions for the beneficiaries. For the individual themselves. In most cases, the beneficiaries have already received the services and have no real interest in appealing it.
It's the provider who's going to be hit with having to pay
the money back. Okay, and I'm just curious, does the phrase do not defend or can somebody get it up to just before this court and DHS says, hey, we're done and, you know, we're not going to pursue this anymore and just, you know, it just be an issue that as far as they're concerned, they're
not going to pursue it anymore? obviously the department could take that position and occasionally in the
reconsideration informal reconsideration process things are worked out but if it doesn't get worked out in reconsideration the department will defend it in the appeal okay so and if a provider
say has it hired an attorney and been out you know monies up to that point having an attorney represent them before you know in order to get up to that point and say DHS just says we're not going to pursue it anymore, you win, we quit, is there any recourse for DHS to have to pay back those attorney fees that that provider has had to be out
in order to get it up to that point to
good idea, but no. You know, there's a shell bill out there drafted for that, and that's why I was wondering is if this dealt with this or not because that's one thing I see is that it gets right up to that point And agencies can walk away, and individuals or providers have been out thousands of dollars of attorney fees, and it's just their way of walking away from the table and no reimbursement being able to be done. So how many times does that happen?
Do you know? Do you have any
idea? No. I'll just say that the department pretty vigorously contests and rarely walks away completely from a case. Rarely. yes okay very good thank
questions from committee representative word you recognize mr. chair and
going back to represent the Harris the response that you gave represent the Harris on the judges and you said that they were currently they was housed with DHS yes
sir and you are just simply moving them out and so they are still more or less affiliated with DHS you
just simply moving them away from the DHS they will be employed by the Health Department, but in order to maximize the federal match, there will be a memorandum of understanding between the Health Department and the Department of
Human Services for compensation. Follow-up, because earlier when you made the statement, you said that being housed
there with DHS, a person's chance of actually winning one of those particular cases were very, very slim. So by actually housing them in a different area, but yet still being employed by DHS, you think that that was increased an individual chance for actually winning one of these particular type cases? Well, they'll be
actually employed by the Health Department, not by the Department of Human Services. So if I wasn't clear on that, they will be employed by the Health Department.
And they are currently employed by the Health Department housed with DHS?
No, they're currently employed, housed, everything right now takes place at the Department of Human Services. Under the bill, instead of the hearing officers or administrative law judges being at DHS, they'll be at the health department. So they would then be employees of the health department? Yes, they have time. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Okay, is there anyone else? There
are no other questions from the committee in the audience.
Is anyone here to speak for or against? Okay, seeing none, what is the pleasure of the committee? We have a motion do pass. All in favor? Those opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, committee. Thank
you. All right, we've got one more bill, and then I think lunch will just kind of be a, if you've got it at your convenience, if you'd like something else, obviously feel free when it gets here, I mean.
Yeah, I saw you looking. When it gets here One more bill I think so SB 161 Representative Wardlaw is ready Just remember we're all going to be missing each other in about 30 days So I'm glad We get to spend a little QT together Yeah, I'll miss you Alright Representative Wardlaw, you're
recognized to present You ready now? He's still talking Thank you, Mr. Chair SB The C161 is basically just cleanup language.
It changes the name of a nurse practitioner to match the names of those across the United States. Cleans up a little bit of other language. It's totally agreed upon by medical society and other groups. I'd be happy
to answer any questions. Have you all ever noticed that Representative Wardlaw's presentations never change? It's always a small bill. It doesn't do anything. So, anyway, I respect the consistency. I'm here for you, Mr. Chairman.
Oh, man. Anybody, I get better than getting grumpy when I'm hungry. So, I get sarcastic, I guess. Members, any questions? Okay. Anybody in the audience like to speak for or against the bill? If not, what's the pleasure of the committee? Motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Congratulations. Is anybody else here to run a bill?
If not, I need to do a couple. We had some. I need to move just a couple bills off to third. And, yes, lunch is on the way. It's going to be here. Members of the aisle, anybody, I'm assuming there's going to be about 20 boxes. I don't want to waste it. Yeah. Yeah, it was from my favorite spot in Harrison. Yeah, it's in Marshall on the way down.
Representative Hammer wanted to move 1868 and 1869 off the deferred, so with that objection, she's still ordered. I believe I got all the rest of them. So seeing no other business, we will stand adjourned until 10 a.m. Thursday. Amen.
Agenda
HB1901
SB852
HB1935
SB575
HB1691
HB2227
SB840
SB857
HB1968
SB810
SB788
SB161
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative John Burris Chair
Unverified
Representative Nate Steel
Unverified
Speaker 14
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Speaker 23
Speaker 26
Speaker 33
Speaker 32
Senator Linda Chesterfield
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 166
Speaker 53
Representative Kelley Linck
Unverified
Ron Caulkins
Unverified
Speaker 71
Speaker 55
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Representative Justin T. Harris
Unverified
Speaker 100
Representative Betty Overbey
Unverified
Representative David L. Branscum
Unverified
Speaker 129
Representative Fredrick J. Love
Unverified
Speaker 183
Speaker 185
Representative Butch Wilkins
Unverified
Representative Andy Mayberry
Unverified
Speaker 223
Speaker 242
Speaker 246
Representative Bruce Cozart
Unverified
Representative Ward
Unverified
Speaker 274
Speaker 282
Speaker 91
Representative Bruce Westerman
Unverified
Speaker 310
Speaker 236
Speaker 330
Representative Deborah Ferguson
Unverified
Speaker 240
Representative James L. Word
Unverified
Speaker 238
Speaker 353
Speaker 173
Speaker 378