Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Education Committee

February 5, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (1)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1077 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1077”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
I'd like to call this meeting to order. Chair sees a quorum. I'd like to thank everybody for coming today. We've got a packed house. Is there something special happening today here? Must be. Must be. If I can get everybody in their seats,
▶ Play
Speaker 11 0:48
we'll get started. I think I said
▶ Play
that. That's it. All right, today we are going to have Representative Collins run House Bill 1077. Representative Collins, you are recognized to run your
▶ Play
bill, and I believe you have an amendment to that bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and yes, you're correct. I do have an amendment. So, if we start with the amendment, it does four things to House Bill 1077. The first thing that it does is add co-sponsors. The second thing that it does is add an exemption for the UAMS college that's near the emergency room hospital. I talk quite a bit with the people from UAMS. Their primary concern, not their only concern by any stretch, not a concern that relieving it makes them in favor of the bill, to be clear, but their primary concern would be allowing faculty and staff carry near the emergency room. That's a situation where there's chaos. There's people going in and out with severe injuries. There's heavy security there to start with. So the first piece of this amendment, exempts, gives the college the right to continue to opt out of the law, to exempt within a half mile UAMS or any other college that has a medical school in that area. The second exemption is similar in nature in that it is a great concern, and this time it's because of the proximity to the Clinton Library. So the public school near the Clinton Library, where there are many dignitaries, there was some extreme concern that the number of dignitaries and things of that nature may create a situation which was riskier than other situations, and so there's a specific exemption for that. And then the final component to the amendment is more clarity on the faculty carry. I got many people contacted me and said, I have a faculty appointment, I have my concealed carry permit, I go to the university or the college in the evening either to teach classes or grade papers, I would really like to be included in this, but because I'm not a nine-month faculty or a 12-month faculty, your bill doesn't allow that to be the case, and so the final amendment allows those faculty people, many of whom were women, to also be included in the bill. And so that's the essence of the amendment, Mr. Chair. I'm happy to take any questions on that. The amendment is now
▶ Play
on your tablets if you need to pull that up on your tablets. Do I have any questions from
▶ Play
the committee? Motion? Mr. Gilliam, you're recognized. Mr. Chair, thank you. Just a motion at the proper time concerning this amendment. Are there any questions from the committee? If not, we have a motion. Do pass. I have a motion to adopt
▶ Play
the amendment. All those in favor, say aye. Opposed? Motion carries. You have adopted your amendment. You are welcome
▶ Play
Speaker 23 4:19
to go with your bill now. Thank you very
▶ Play
much, Mr. Chair. I decided for this presentation of the committee that I was going to walk through what I think are the key questions and try and share with you the evidence and such that I believe will give you the information you need to make the right decision on this bill for your folks. In order to do that, my presentation is going to be longer than it would for a normal bill, so one of the things I tried to do to offset the time is not invite anyone else to speak on my behalf or for the bill so that I don't suck up an inordinate amount of time. But because we're talking about something which is literally the most important thing in the world to human beings, and that is the safety of your children away from home, this has a very high emotional content. Years ago, I was doing some research on that topic, what's the most important thing to people. Gallup had done a global study, and culture to culture to culture, the safety of your children away from home is the most important thing to people. So clearly this is a subject that's of very high importance and very high nature. Couple that with the second factor, which is the way our brains operate. When we talk about certain things that generate a fight or flight reflex, like spiders and snakes and guns, and you put those two factors together and it's very easy to see that, frankly, I've laid a heavy burden at your feet. And so what I want to do is walk through it in the most thorough way I can so that we can think through this together and hopefully you'll see, as I do, that this is going to help protect the lives of our loved ones on college campuses. In order to do that, I think we have to answer three questions. I'm going to go through each question one at a time. In order to agree with me, you'll have to arrive at a yes on each successive question, one no, and I don't think you'll vote for this bill. I'll run through the questions. If you want to jot them down, that's fine. I'll repeat them as I go and try and share with you why I think the answer to each question is a yes. The first question is, does a problem exist? Is there a situation or an issue or a problem that exists, and is it worth solving? Is it worth trying to solve? That's the first question. The second question is, could this be part of the solution? Could this help us actually solve the problem if one in fact exists? And then the third question is, do the benefits outweigh the risk? or is the cure worse than the disease? If you agree with me that we have a very real problem that needs to be addressed, and you agree with me that this can be part of the solution, primarily through its deterrent effect, deterring people that want to kill our loved ones on college campuses and other gun-free zones, and you agree that we've put in the proper restraints, balance, carefully thought-through choices, so that the benefits of that deterrence outweigh the risks of accidents or other things, then I think, as tough as it is for many of us, you need to vote yes, because, again, the most important thing in all of our lives is protecting our loved ones. So let me move into the first question. Is this a problem worth solving? I want to read from the 2012 edition of the Arkansas Democrat Gazette. Oakland, California, before embarking on a shooting rampage at a religious college that left seven people dead, the gunman, a former nursing student, moved deliberately through a school building, lining students up against a wall before gunning them down execution style and hunting others down after they had taken cover under their deaths. Authorities said Tuesday, of the seven people who died, six were women. Three other people were wounded. One, Algo, 43, a Korean immigrant who was arrested after the attack, has admitted to the shooting at Ecos University, a small college in East Oakland, authorities said. Now, if that was the only report in the newspaper that year, this year, or another year, I wouldn't think that we could conclude that we do have a significant problem that needs to be solved. It could be a one-off event, a stray event, an accident of its own. But let me share with you a little more. And what I want to do is I want to cover some recent tragedy events like the one we just talked about, starting with the event that happened last night at the high school in Frederick, Maryland, where two students were killed or shot, excuse me, not killed, on a high school campus yesterday evening. Of course, we all know about December 14, 2012 in Newtown, Connecticut, where 28 people were killed and two were injured. I just mentioned Ecosch University in Oakland, California in 2012, seven dead, three injured. May 23, 2014, Isla Vista College, seven dead, 13 injured. June 7, 2013, Santa Monica, California, on the campus of Santa Monica College, six dead, four injured. February 12, 2010, Huntsville, Alabama, University of Alabama and Huntsville, three dead, three injured. I also want to mention June 5, 2014, in Seattle, Washington, one dead and three injured. Three people were shot inside a hallway at Seattle Pacific University. One student died. The gunman was tackled by a student as he was reloading his shotgun and arrested at the scene. I've asked the staff to hand out a one-pager, and if you look at the one pager in the upper left hand side of the one pager is a graph and what it shows is the number of campus shootings that have occurred by decade and as you can see from the graph there are approximately nine per year in the 2000s so that's every other month on a college campus and as you can see the trend line is not going down if anything, it's going up. In 2014, there were 43 school shootings, 40 of which involved injury or death. That includes elementary and high school along with college campuses, and again, about one every month or so on a college campus. This bill doesn't address elementary schools or high schools and it never will as long as federal law stays the same. The concealed carry laws in Arkansas affect what we do on college campuses but high schools, elementary schools are governed by federal laws so there is no ability whether we want to or not to pass similar legislation dealing with those types of schools. I want to make that really clear so as I talk about both sometimes this law only deals with the campuses and if every one of you agreed with me and wanted to do it more broadly we couldn't because of federal law the final point i want to make on question number one do we have a problem comes from an article written by professor stephen boss he's a neighbor of mine he is adamantly opposed to this law so i don't want to misrepresent that for a millisecond adamantly opposed and has been uh for for many years but i want to read what he said in a in a letter special to the democrat gazette mr collins frequently expresses his concern that dangerously ill mentally ill people have access to guns and those people might come to our colleges to harm our loved ones with their guns i share common ground with mr collins here i teach your daughters and sons in college and i I have two daughters attending college. I don't want any harm to come to your children or mine at the hands of anyone carrying guns on campus. Many are aware that dangerously mentally ill people in America have easy access to guns and can recite from memory the litany of mass shootings perpetrated by them, the Washington Navy Yard, Isla Vista, Newtown, Aurora, Tucson, Northern Illinois University, Virginia Tech, Columbine, Jonesboro, et cetera. So I understand the concern as we all do. So if you agree with me and Professor Boss, then the answer to question number one has to be yes. So now question number two. Is it possible that we can deter some of these individuals from coming to our college campuses and murdering our loved ones? Well, if a person is completely off their rocker and has no ability to think or to plan or to do any of the normal functioning things that we experience in our lives, if a person snaps and it's a completely random event and there's absolutely no forethought whatsoever, I would argue that the answer to the question is no and that this law will not help us at all. So let's look at what the research says. The most comprehensive research done on this subject was done after the Columbine shootings in 1999. It was a five-year study that was put together by the Secret Service of the United States in conjunction with the Department of Education. The final report was released in July of 2004. I have the whole report here. I'm not going to read the whole thing to you, although there's lots of important things in it, mainly because they use data studying all of these incidents and statistical techniques to move from the emotion of the issue, which I suffer from, and I would imagine everybody that's a human being suffers from, because it is such an emotional issue, to get at the data. Because, again, we're sent here by our folks back in our districts to take care of them and to think through and fight through the chaff that exists in the world to make the best decisions for their well-being. So here are some of the conclusions and some of the statements from the Secret Service Department of Education report. With regard to conceptualizing the TAC, Finding. Incidents of targeted violence at school rarely are sudden impulsive acts. Explanation. Several findings of the Safe School Initiative indicate that clearly the school-based attacks started were rarely impulsive. Rather, these attacks typically were thought out beforehand and involved some degree of advanced planning. In many cases, the attacker's observable behavior prior to the attack suggested he might be planning or preparing for a school attack, In nearly all instances for which information concerning the attacker's conceptualization of the attack was available, researchers found that the attackers had developed the idea to harm targets before the attacks, 95% of the cases studied. The length of time that the attackers held this idea prior to the attack varied considerably. Some attackers conceived of the attack as few as one or two days prior to advancing the attack, Other attackers had held the idea of the attack for as long as a year prior to carrying it out. For those incidents where information was available to determine how long the attacker had an idea to harm the target, the analysis showed that a little over one-half of the targets developed their idea for the incident at least a month prior to the attack, 51 percent. So they planned for a month before they did it. The length of time between the planning and execution of the attacks also varied considerably for the targeted school violence incidents studied. Some attackers developed their plans on the day of the attack or only one or two days prior. Others developed their plans between six and eight months prior to the attack. In cases where there was information available to establish the date planning began, analysis of available information revealed that most of the attackers developed a plan at least two days prior to the attack, 69 percent. Resolving the attack. This has to do with how did these attacks end. Finding, despite prompt law enforcement responses, most attacks were stopped by means other than law enforcement intervention. That's not a slam on law enforcement. It's just the reality, the physics of the way these things happen. Most school-based attacks were stopped through intervention by school administrators, educators, and students, or by the attacker stopping on his own. In about one-third of the incidents, the attacker was apprehended or suspended or surrendered to administrators, faculty, or school staff, so 27 percent of the time, or to students, In just over one-fifth of the incidents, the attacker stopped on his own or left the school, 22% of the time. In a few incidents, the attacker killed himself during the course of the incident, 13%. Just over one-quarter of the incidents were stopped through law enforcement intervention, 27%, similar to what it was for educators and administrators. Law enforcement personnel discharged weapons in only three of the incidents. This is not about shooting people. This is about deterring people who want to kill our loved ones from coming there and shooting them. The last thing I want to share from this report are two of the ten findings of the entire report. The first finding, incidents of targeted violence at school rarely are sudden impulsive acts. And then I also want to share the tenth finding. Despite prompt law enforcement responses, most shooting incidents were stopped by means other than law enforcement intervention. This question of who is doing these attacks, what is their makeup, and can they be influenced by the things and surroundings is really at the heart of this whole discussion. And so I've got a little bit more information on that, and if you'll continue to indulge me, and I do appreciate it because I know I'm droning on and on. There was a story in the Wall Street Journal a couple years ago, and it was a summary of what mass killers want, and it is a compilation of a lot of the research on this subject. There's quite a bit in here. It's quite fascinating. It's all consistent with the things I'm sharing with you, and if you'll, again, indulge me, I just want to read a couple of the paragraphs. In 2004, Professor Mullen, then the director of the Victorian Institute of Forensic Mental Health, wrote an illuminating study in part on his personal interviews with rampage shooters, that's the designation that they use, as opposed to serial killers and other profiles, rampage killers, who survived their acts. He noted that rampage shootings tended to follow a definite pattern, what he called a program for murder and suicide. The shooter, almost always a young man, enters an area filled with many people. What better choice than our innocent loved ones on college campuses? He is heavily armed. He may begin by targeting a few specific victims, but he soon moves on to indiscriminate killing or just killing people as the prime aim. That's what I mean by sicko crazies. He typically has no plan for escape and kills himself or is killed by police. Among the more pervasive myths about massacre killers is that they simply snap. In fact, Dr. Mullen and others have found that rampage shooters usually plan their actions meticulously, even ritualistically, for months in advance. Like serial killers, massacre killers usually don't have impulsive personalities. They tend to be obsessive and highly organized. Survivors typically report that the shooters appear to be not engaged, but cold and calculating. When they're doing their preparation, what are they thinking about? Part of the calculus of evil is competition. Dr. Mullins spoke to a perpetrator who gleefully admitted he was going for the record. Investigators found that the Newtown shooter kept a score sheet of previous mass shootings. He may have deliberately calculated how to maximize the grotesqueness of his act. Many other perpetrators pay obsessive attention to previous massacres. There is evidence for a direct line of influence running through some of the most notorious shooters from Columbine in 1997 to Virginia Tech in 2007 to Newtown in 2012, including their explicit references to previous massacres and calls to inspire future anti-heroes. This article goes on to say these people are just trying to get attention and they're filled with their own grandiosity. There are reports that the Aurora Theater killer was studying and had up on his computer the status of concealed carry bills in Colorado as he studied their progress through the legislature. He studied the theaters in his area and found which one had posted no concealed carry allowed because in Colorado, as it is in Arkansas, concealed carry is normally allowed in theaters. He drove past several theaters that were closer and showing the movie that he was after and had more people in them to specifically go to the theater that had no guns allowed before he murdered his people at the theater in Aurora. The final point I want to make on this subject of can we do something by putting protection in place, the threat that maybe somebody could stop them to help deter these people from choosing college campuses, comes from a paper written by a college student named Brooke Siegler. As you recall, two years ago, we passed a law which allowed the college boards to make a decision on this. And all of the boards took that charge very seriously. NWAC actually invited me to speak to their board before they made one of their decisions. I've had reports from the University of Arkansas that while they did not agree to do this, they absolutely looked at their own security procedures and other things that they could try and do, and it really spawned, fostered this idea of what can we do to help protect. At ASU, this student wrote a paper that talked about the process ASU went through in making their decision. I just want to read one part of it where Brooke talks in her paper about the two police chiefs that ASU brought in to speak to their board. One of them was the campus police chief, and he was against the law. He encouraged them to opt out. The other was Chief Yates of Jonesboro and Chief Yates, I'm going to quote from the paper now, Chief Yates who has two sons, this was in 2013, Chief Yates who has two sons that attend ASU and has taught a few classes at ASU does not think we should opt out of the law. He believes that allowing faculty and staff to carry a concealed weapon on campus would be a deterrent for potential shooters. He used the following statement to back up his claim, and now she quotes Chief Yate. With just one single exception, which was the attack on Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords in Tucson in 2011, every public shooting since at least 1950 in the U.S. in which more than three people have been killed has taken place where citizens are not allowed to carry guns. So I would submit to you that it's realistic and possible, I would go so far as to say probable, that allowing some form of concealed carry on a university campus will be a deterrent to some of these cold, calculating killers to help protect our children. Now, with your indulgence, I'll move to the third question, which is, is the cure worse than the disease? Do the benefits outweigh the risks or not? The place I'd like to start has to do with the concealed carry law itself. personally think the state police do a fantastic job with our concealed carry program and one of the measures that i use is reading the newspaper every day and i'm convinced that there are people that would love to expose concealed carry holders as very problematic prone to all sorts of bad behavior and other things and my personal belief is is that if concealed carry holders in arkansas were having all kinds of trouble managing their weapons for the purposes with which they're allowed to carry it, we would be reading about it on the front page frequently. I'm not seeing the stories. If you are, then maybe you won't agree with me that the benefits outweigh the risks. Here are some of the requirements for the license. The director of the Department of Arkansas State Police shall issue a license to carry a concealed handgun if the applicant is a citizen of the United States, is 21 years of age or older, does not suffer from a mental or physical infirmity that prevents the safe handling of a handgun and has not threatened or attempted suicide, has not been convicted of a felony in a court, doesn't have any record unless they've been pardoned, does not chronically or habitually abuse a controlled substance to the extent his or her normal faculties are in pair, and And then it goes on to define what that means. The same thing with alcoholic beverages. And then it goes on to talk about the training that the people need. And the training is primarily in following the laws, the concealed carry laws. In order to get the license, a person needs to pay for background checks. A person needs to give authority for their medical records to be reviewed. And a person has to pay for the training and other money. People that go through this process put in time, energy, and effort and have their backgrounds checked. These folks are not the problem. These folks are the good guys and ladies. What else have we done to try to minimize the possibility of risk or accident? Number one, and this was the greatest fear when I first introduced this, keeping the weapons out of the hands of students. Again, I go back to the emotional nature of the issue, the safety of our children away from home, the great fear we all have that there's going to be some 18-year-old drunk fest in a room with guns shooting all over the place. I share the fear. I have two sons currently attending the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville along with a daughter who's on the same campus. I understand the fears that we have in those situations. So number one, there's no student carry. If you're a student, even though to get a concealed carry, you have to be 21, so the 18-year-old thing is out anyway, but even if you are, you're not allowed. You must be an employee of the university. Number two, dorm rooms. There's no storage in dorm rooms. We wrote that into the law last time. That stays in the law. There's no storage in dorm rooms so that if there's a drunken party in one room and they know that a professor lives two doors down and they think that professor might have a weapon, he can't or she can't store the weapon in the dorm room either. Number two, you're only allowed to carry on the college where you work. Why is that? Well, when we're more familiar with our surroundings, when we're able to build in habits, when people are familiar with us, we're less likely to make a mistake. An accident is less likely to happen. We're less likely to overreact or not understand a situation as it unfolds. People, the expectations are all much, much more common, more common, and so, again, I believe it reduces the risk substantially. Number five, when it comes to prohibited places, this does not change the fact that athletic events remain on the prohibited list. Athletic events are separately prohibited concealed carry per the concealed carry law. That's not just college athletic events. That's all athletic events. So football games, basketball games, et cetera, there's no concealed carry for anybody at athletic events. Number six, we put in those exceptions, those additional exceptions that we covered when we went to the amendment. And, again, if somebody were to say to me, I'm totally fine with this except you missed one. There's an agriculture building somewhere that has these chemicals for some lab, and if somebody were to shoot that, you know, there's an explosion. I'm wide open if there's some other situation which is unique and poses a very specific danger, not something which becomes an escape hatch so that every school can say, well, you know, this shouldn't cover me either. And I think that the two that we put in here very well and fit those examples. The last thing I would say is today seven states already do what we're doing. And there are about 13 additional states that are working on legislation that's similar. So it's not like this is such a wild and out-of-the-box idea that nobody's doing it, nobody's looking at it. Although I will agree with you that we ain't 49th in this. We're on the forefront of thinking about how do we protect our loved ones. So in summary, I know it's an emotional issue. I know I have placed a great burden on each one of you. I respect each one of you and your ability to think for yourselves and decide for yourselves how are we going to best keep safe our loved ones on college campuses. Do we have a problem? Are there mass murders and shooters? Do they do these things? Number two, since they're plotting, can we deter them with the knowledge that Arkansas campuses are not completely gun-free zones, where they can plan out to the minuscule amount of time and keep themselves safe until law enforcement can arrive, five minutes, ten minutes, or whenever down the road. And number three, we have built in enough safeguards so the risk of an accident or accidents does not overcome the tremendous benefits that we could get from this. The concept here is to move forward. I would say make a little, sell a little. Let's get comfortable with this. People have said to me, well, you're a hypocrite, Collins. I mean, what do you have against students? I don't have anything against students. I'm a firm believer that the state police are doing a fantastic job with the concealed carry law. law. But I can also see the fear in a mom's eyes that something we do allows an 18-year-old drunk boy to get a gun and think he's a cowboy. I get that. So that's why students are not allowed. If we find 3, 5, 10, 12 years from now that this is working wonderfully, we can look to expand it further. But for now, I would submit to you that we've got the right balance to help protect our Kansans on college campuses. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'm happy to take any questions. Before I take
▶ Play
questions committee, I would like to state, ladies and gentlemen, that I will have one question each. And after you've asked that question, you may get back on the line to ask another. I've got a feeling we have a lot of questions, so I'd like to have everybody have the opportunity to ask a question. So we will be taking questions, and Representative Murdoch, you're recognized first. Thank
▶ Play
you, Chairman. Before we get started, I'd like to, if you would allow for UAMS to come to the table to explain their position on the amendment that was mentioned earlier, if that's possible, Chairman. That's fine. Thank you. If UAMS.
▶ Play
Speaker 40 34:36
I made clear they're not in favor of
▶ Play
the bill, correct? I made that clear. Yes, sir. You're very clear. But I want to hear their testimony. Certainly.
▶ Play
Speaker 43 34:53
Sherry Ducca, UAMS. First, I would like to give my appreciation to Representative Collins for making that clear. We've had discussions, and he's been very upfront about it, and we've had very candid, somewhat constructive conversations. While the amendment does address the specific area of our campus, in the Little Rock area, the main campus, it certainly does not deal with the vast majority of our problems. And our position on the bill probably would be no different, quite frankly, with or without the amendment. Because the ER, we have a full police force on campus. Our police don't have to come from anywhere. They're there. They're trained with ongoing training, continuing education. and they're trained to respond to these types of situations. Our vague problem is we're a very complex campus, quite large. There's no borders between the ER, the hospital, or anything else, and it would be cost prohibitive. Representative Harris, do you have something? Is she speaking on the amendment?
▶ Play
Is that the question? Or is she again? No, she's speaking on the amendment, I believe. Okay, just making sure. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 43 36:18
Continue on. I'm sorry. I'm not sure what else I need to say, but I'll be happy to expand on anything if I haven't made that clear. Thank you, Chairman. Representative Letting, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, I believe you referenced a shooting at the University of Alabama Huntsville in 2010. Was that correct? Can I go? No. Can I go? Yeah, I don't have any questions. I have one for her. I do, too. You may want to stay on the table. Yes, I think, yes. The shooter in that case, who's now serving life without parole, was biology professor Amy Bishop, who had been denied tenure, and that was her final semester at that college.
▶ Play
Is that correct? Yes, I believe that's correct. Thank
▶ Play
you. Representative Sabin, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, I was listening to your statement. And in terms of the many statistics and studies that you quoted regarding the way that these active shooters meticulously plan and deliberate before they take their action. I'm just curious, I could probably take that same data and make a totally different conclusion that someone who was going to engage in this kind of behavior would simply reconfigure their plan in order to target the staff member or faculty member first. And therefore, this would act less as a deterrent than just simply a opportunity to take out the person who might most effectively stop the shooter. And so my question is, having heard the hard data, the evidence you presented, do you feel that you have hard evidence that this is actually a deterrent? Or do you think this is just simply your opinion or your best guess as to whether this would actually act as a deterrent? I think
▶ Play
when you use the expression hard evidence, I think I have the same evidence for as any other person would have against, which I would say is not conclusive hard evidence. I would say that what we're talking about here is how people behave. And what we've learned, as Chief Yates said, is that these folks choose gun-free zones. They're not interested in a military-style operation where they have to fight somebody with a gun. The reason they don't pick as frequently a place like a Walmart Supercenter or the library or a restaurant is because concealed carry is allowed. As Chief Yates said, all of the mass shootings since 1950 that he was aware of occurred in gun-free zones. I don't think that's a coincidence. You may not call it hard evidence, but if you or I put ourselves in the shoes of somebody that was planning something, Would we choose somewhere where you thought we might face another person with a gun if we had the option to have many, many innocent lives that would get us on TV to shoot them and know that we would not face a weapon? I think that's fairly straightforward logic, but I understand it's not proof. We'll get right
▶ Play
back to you. Mr. Gossett, do you have a question? Mr. Armstrong. Representative Collins,
▶ Play
you and I have talked about this issue several times, but you missed the main issue. The main issue here is mental illness, and how do you take a gun to cure mental illness because if you could just tell me, are you going to go out and single these people out and how are you going to determine who's coming in with a gun to fire? You mentioned the Colorado incident. This person was highly intelligent, so if I understand right, and it's hard to take a gun and control mental illness because they don't think. They are thinking about one thing, and that's what they're going to do, their mission or their objective that they're going
▶ Play
to accomplish. Yes, Representative Armstrong. What I would submit to you is mental illness takes many different forms, just like the criminal profiles take many forms. There was a serial killer profile, and there are several others. I didn't read them all in the research that I was sharing, but this particular killer profile is somebody that plans meticulously, and the form of mental illness has to do with a grandiosity-oriented complex versus some other mental illness where perhaps they're not able to think or plan or something else. This particular profile, though, actually does those things. And I agree with you, if we have an active shooter walking in to start shooting, while it may be true that in some isolated case, a professor or someone else would actually stop an active shooting, I'm not recommending we pass that for that possibility. I'm recommending it because all of the profile killers that we're talking about religiously choose gun-free zones. Again, as Chief Yates said in the last 50 years, the one thing that is similar is the fact that they choose gun-free zones. They don't choose the place where they might run into a person with a concealed carry permit. And why would you, if you had the option, why would anybody attack someone where they thought they might run into more force if they could accomplish their objective by choosing a place where you didn't have to worry about that?
▶ Play
Can I ask the backup? No. Representative McElroy,
▶ Play
you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, I understand what a position you are and what position we are in right now. And I want to go on the record that I love guns. I've never met one that I didn't want to own. And I have a concealed weapon license. This is not my problem. What I'm worried about is us dictating as this body to the boards, trustees. You know, they got to vote on it, and it was their decision. And yet we come back and say, we don't care what you think. Where does it stop? And you say it's about expanding. Here is a gun-free zone. And to tell you the truth, sometimes I'm worried about that a little bit. But I do respect it. I don't, you know, there's got to be some place where it's appropriate and where it's not. And it's got me in a quandary. When do we start overreaching our authority and start dictating rather than being a democracy? Do you feel that this expansion is, will it next year, will we be talking about bringing guns here? Representative
▶ Play
McElroy, I think there's a couple questions inside your question. The first one is about dictating to the universities. So for umpteen years, we had no problem dictating to the universities that they could not allow it. So we've already demonstrated that it's our decision that people have sent us here to make those kinds of decisions, and we have no problem instructing the universities how they need to manage this policy because up until 2013, we had forbidden them from doing this whether they wanted to or not. Number two, in terms of the concept of democracy, what I believe we're doing here is giving the individual concealed carry permit holder who has these other qualifications, i.e. a full-time employee on the campus where they are, to make the choice as an individual. So no, I don't feel like we're restricting democracy. With regard to your third question, which I think is a very, very important one, and I understand it, I would argue to you that the opposite effect will happen if we pass this. And here's why. This is not part of some train of gun rights stuff. I didn't even say that once. I haven't brought up the NRA. To me, this is about something very, very different. It has to do with protecting our loved ones away from home. How do we protect our people now if somebody else says they've got an argument for that and how we can keep people safe and here's the reason why and did it and it may affect some other gun law of course i'm wide open to that but but but my point is this isn't designed to start some kind of a um um you know a mad rush of any type this is a specific decision it's one decision i think huge decisions like this need to be taken absolutely one at a time. And, you know, that's how I view this. And, you know, for me, you know, this is the right thing for us to do, and it isn't the starting
▶ Play
point for something else. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Well, I'm glad that wasn't a
▶ Play
four-part question. Representative Gillum, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is for Ms. Duckett. In regard to your comments earlier on the amendment that was added that gave UAMS the exemption around the emergency room, I was wondering, you cited the police, the security force that you actually have present. I was wondering if you might address some specific numbers in regard to how large that force is and its percentage complement to like a ratio to faculty, students, you know, individual citizens that are on the campus and the ratio of security personnel to those individuals.
▶ Play
Speaker 43 46:40
Mr. Speaker, I do not have those numbers off the top of my head. I could get them in a matter of five minutes or so if that would be adequate, but it's around the clock. I mean, we're 24-7 because we never close, and we also have the responsibility out in the state where we have the AHECs and other campuses, and we're on the VA. Now, they have their own security to the VA. Our physicians go back and forth to the VA continually and children's.
▶ Play
That might be helpful. I think kind of the train of thought you were extending there was that you had a sufficient security force and everything. I think it might be helpful for the committee to see what those ratios are. And with specialized training. And that way the committee would be able to see if they felt like those ratios were sufficient.
▶ Play
Speaker 43 47:28
So, all right, thank you. If I could step away, I can get that in
▶ Play
a matter of minutes if you want it this morning. Okay, thank you.
▶ Play
I think that would be good. Representative Letting, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Southwest Experimental Fast Oxide Reactor, it's a deactivated experimental nuclear facility in Cove Creek near West Fork, Arkansas. It's also contaminated. The University of Arkansas has been working for several years to secure about $16 million in funding to clean that site. With your bill as written, would armed faculty and staff have access as to that contaminated nuclear facility? This is the first
▶ Play
time anybody raised that to me. When I had the universities talk to me, I sat down with all of the, even as Ms. Duckett said, semi-productive discussions with all of them. And anybody that brought me anything that they had a specific concern about that was unique and had a reason associated with it, I was wide opening to amending. The two specific examples that were brought to me were the Clinton Library concern and the emergency room around UAMS. Beyond a general, I'd like it the way it is, granted. So if you said you're ready to vote for the bill tomorrow, if I'll amend in an exemption for the nuclear piece, I'm happy to consider doing that, Representative Letting. We'll talk. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Ratliff, you're recognized. Representative Collins, are there any reason that you left out the private universities? Are we not worried
▶ Play
about those students and people? There's a very specific reason for that, Representative Ratliff. I believe that if you own your property, that this decision belongs to you. If the people of Arkansas own the property, they have sent you and me and the rest of the members at this table to make decisions that are in their best interest. So as long as the university is privately owned, I don't think it's our purview to make these types of decisions for them, although they do have the option, should they choose, to opt in or out. So we've given them that flexibility, but that's
▶ Play
the reason for the difference. Okay. Thanks, sir. Rep. Sabin. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, I just want to go back to our previous conversation talking about the data and statistics, because I think based on your response, we've sort of established at least that the data and statistics don't prove that this change in policy would necessarily have a deterrent effect. It's just your best guess on the subject. So I want to take on the issue of this idea that most of these shootings happen in what you call gun-free zones. I would maintain that a college campus is not necessarily a gun-free zone, that there are campus police. And in many instances, the police really have a presence that per capita on a college campus is greater than out in the general public. But I was just wondering, again, data can be used to try to establish, obviously, different conclusions. But can you prove that these shootings occur because these are gun-free zones, or simply because that's where the shooter's grievance may lie? That's where their friends are, that's where their professor, who they might have a grievance with, happens to work or to teach. That's where the person spends their time. Can you actually prove that these shootings happen simply because the campuses are, as you say, gun-free
▶ Play
zones? All I can share with you are the data. And just as you can't prove that a concealed carry holder is going to have an accident, you can't prove that. There's no way to prove it, but you and I can both agree that in any situation somebody can slip in the bathtub, and even though I can't prove that they're going to do it because they've done it umpteen times in the past it's likely that somebody will slip in the bathtub therefore if all of the mass shootings in the last 50 years have occurred in a gun-free area you can conclude that was merely an incredible coincidence if you choose but i think that is denying reality but that's merely my opinion i can't prove that it is I'll leave
▶ Play
it alone Representative Armstrong you're recognized My question's been answered Representative Murdoch you have another question Yes thank you Representative Collins you talk about that we are elected to come and take care of the needs of the people and recognize those needs Do you not think that when those that are going to be most impacted by the laws that we make here, when their input, when you sit down at the table with them as you did with the administrators and presidents of the universities and colleges, that this will specifically affect when they tell you that they do not think that it is good for them at this time and they give you their various reasons, don't you think there's an overreach of government into those situations? Don't you think that's a negative impact possibly of us doing what we're supposed to do? Do you think we may be going too
▶ Play
far with that? I don't consider that those people necessarily are a final word at all in this particular area. I believe, as you said originally in your statement, that it's the people that have sent us here. And this is an issue where we're looking at what I would consider to be part of the most important thing in their lives the protection of their loved ones away from home and you know the only polling I've seen on this which would give us a feel for where the the people would be was some polling that Roby Brock did in 2013 when we introduced this before before the opt-out provision was even suggested and that polling according to his numbers if I recall correctly was 49.5 in favor and 43 opposed, and to me, what I would submit to you is as we look at this issue and as we analyze it the way that I think makes sense against those three questions, is this a problem that we should think about and deal with, are we obligated based on reality, even though it's unpleasant and we don't want to and we wish we could make it go away, to deal with the problem. Is it possible that if we move this from the gun-free zone, which means no concealed carry allowed in the lingo, into an area where there is some potential, and then can we do that with a benefits outweighing the risk approach, which I think we've done here, that we will be protecting our loved ones? That's one of the things your folks sent you up here to do, and that's really the question on the table, in my view. Well, the polling,
▶ Play
I could give you my email, and it's been really polled quite a bit, and it may not be scientific, but it's certainly inclusive of those that have to implement what we're trying to do here. And I think that's very, very important that we listen to those that we are going to ask to
▶ Play
implement this. I would argue, sir, that if you took different groups, and you and I could probably guess, based on their political histories, which groups would feel good about a given issue and which groups would line up against it for various and sundry reasons. For example, if I was to say, let's go poll NRA members or ask NRA members, you and I would both say, well, gosh, they're almost going to be blindly for it because... You said blindly now. Yeah, I said they would almost be blindly for it because it is a gun owner rights issue, and that's very important to those folks. And I would argue that other groups of people similarly have certain things in their mind that are going to help drive their opinion. What I think that the voters have put on us is the obligation to think through major issue by major issue using our brains and our hearts to decide what's going to be in their best interest and to transcend all of these other influences on the major issues. And to me, I would boil it down to those three questions. And if there's another way of thinking about it that I'm missing, I'm fine with that. None of the university people walked me through those three questions and shared with me how that's not the case. What we heard again and again is the police will do a good job, and I totally support that they're doing a good job. I shared with you from the Secret Service report how that, not through any fault of the police, does not address the problem that exists. It's not because there's anything wrong with the police. They're doing everything they can possibly do. How in the world can they know where somebody who is purposefully trying to avoid them is going to strike first until that person has fired off five or six shots? It's an impossible task. And I believe that what we're doing is denying that reality when we continue to comfort ourselves by saying that a strong police force is enough. Let's help the police by deterring some of these folks would be my answer, sir. Thank you,
▶ Play
Chair. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you. I guess I get by being beside the speaker I don't get acknowledged. You're just on the list. It's a long list up here.
▶ Play
Several have already spoken twice. So does that mean
▶ Play
I can ask two questions instead of one? No, sir. That's the first time we had you on the list. Well, I've been on the list since it began. But is Is Ms. Duckett back yet? What I would
▶ Play
like to do for those that are – if we could, Representative Walker, I'd like to bring those that are going to be for and against the bill up and let us question them at that time, if that would be all right. Could we wait
▶ Play
on that and just direct most of the questions to Representative Collins at this time? I would have no problem with that if we
▶ Play
can have a final shot at Representative Collins. We'll get a final shot at him. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Gillum. Representative Gillum, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll try to follow that as best I can. Representative Collins, I wondered if you might could kind of walk through a little bit, maybe, of the data on the deterrence that Representative Sabin and others were illustrating earlier. Just from everything that I've read on this particular topic over the last, you know, couple of weeks and the emails that have come in and everything, you know, and actually having criminology degrees and psychology degrees, there's a tremendous amount of data that supports the concept of deterrence. And I was wondering if you might, I know that the report, you didn't necessarily discuss all of it, but if there were sections that might could illuminate that a little bit more, I would appreciate maybe addressing that a little bit. And then also, you know, just by way of observation, maybe kind of maybe discuss a little bit on what you, you know, have seen, you know, through some of your research as well on whether or not that is applicable to this particular bill that you're running.
▶ Play
Yeah, the best or biggest study, you know, about the profile of these folks is the Secret Service study that we've talked about. And the profile of the people that do these things is one where they take small slights and then they kind of get triggered by something. Maybe it's a girlfriend. Representative Lenning brought up one where a person didn't get tenure or something of that nature. and so they have a small slight and then they wind up growing these things and there's this emerging hatred and a belief that people are out to get them and so typically they'll start to say it's an individual but often times it's just more general than that and then they start to say how am I going to plan to do something and it may start as a thought of revenge but it turns into a theater and the goal is for a public theater And so there's lots of recommendations for people that are talking about the news media about downplaying all the things and not giving them that show. So one of the things that makes them choose places like college campuses or other places where there are large numbers of people, where they're going to be able to create a tremendous amount of sorrow, is because that makes for more theater. So that's one of the things that attracts them. So when you put that together with the gun-free zone, I believe that schools are an especially attractive target because of the duality of both being a gun-free zone where they know that they're not likely to run into somebody who could stop them, even though those same reports said that most of these people were not stopped by – the situation didn't end with the police. It ended some other way. I read the one example, the one in Seattle where a student actually tackled a shooter while he was reloading. There are other stories about college shooting incidents where people ran out to their car and got a weapon and participated in stopping them. But the bottom line is these people want to be able to create a massive spectacle to show the world who they are, and they want to do it where they can control the situation long enough to create that spectacle before they're interrupted. And that duality makes this a great target zone. And if we can break into that and help them think differently about what could happen if they pick a college campus, it's going to reduce that, and not as many are going to do it. Now, can I sit here and say that none of them ever will? Of course I can't. Just like I can't say there will never be an accident with a concealed carry holder. Of course there could be an accident. Most of the accidents people have talked about, though, in recent times, are things that would not be affected by this bill one way or another. For example, the student that had a weapon shoot when he was showing a weapon in his backpack in Fayetteville a year or two ago, that would have been prevented here, too. So that's kind of the literature I've got. Obviously, a person could continue to research, you know, indefinitely, but
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:10
thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lauer,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, there's been a number of challenges to the research and the interpretation of the research that's out there. And I know many times I'm looking at research, we have difficulty of being able to separate whether something is a causal effect or whether it's a correlational effect. So absent that, we have to look at the most similar situations to be able to prove effectiveness. So my question would be, of the seven states that you referenced that already have the ability to have concealed carry on campuses, what has been the incurrence or lack of occurrence as far as massacre shooting situations in those seven states? Has it proven effective over that time frame? The
▶ Play
time frames for states choosing to move in that direction is frankly way too short for there to be any answers that are any more conclusive than what we're discussing here. Okay. All right. Thank you very much.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:16
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Harris, you recognize?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, in safety situations, in schools particularly, you throw the desk down, throw chairs at the person maybe with a gun are you aware in the Dale Bumpers College which I am alumni from that those in the auditorium in the basement that those are bolted down the chairs are bolted down so there's no protection for those students are you aware of that no sir I was not so if the professor this is can I have a follow-up No, you may not.
▶ Play
I'm the last one, right? No, you're not. I will put
▶ Play
Speaker 139 1:04:04
you back on the list. Oh, man. Well, what about these others? I'm treating
▶ Play
everybody equal today. Oh, man. So he needs a gun. Point of order, Mr. Chairman. Point of order. I understood you to say that you were going to let the people who had positions to be heard before we entered into further questioning of Representative Collins. If you're going to do that, I think that we – did I misunderstand you?
▶ Play
No, sir. I said if somebody's here to speak for or against the bill, if they have an opinion of for or against, we will hear them at the time we hear the public. I don't want to continue bringing someone up that will speak for the bill on Mr. Collins' side when we can do that at another
▶ Play
time. All right. That's basically what I'm saying. Well, I deferred my question because I wanted to be able to ask him questions after you followed the other protocol that I expected, and I guess I misunderstood you. I could put you back on the list if you would
▶ Play
like for, sir. I would like that. Mr. Letting, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The director of the Gene Tyson Child Development Studies Center, the child care facility on campus, has written to express concerns because their facility is regulated, heavily regulated, and those regulations include the regulations of firearms. He's concerned that this bill, as written, would put them in conflict with those regulations. In addition to those concerns, he's just concerned about children, they're curious, digging through purses, backpacks, drawers, and accidentally coming across someone's firearm. How would you address those concerns? That's a good question, Representative Lenning.
▶ Play
Federal regulations trump state regulations. In fact, our concealed carry law says that anywhere that federal regulations prohibit the carry of concealed weapons, we support that in the Arkansas law. So if there are areas, and there are plenty of other areas, for example, police stations on university campuses, stadiums on university campuses, some of those are covered federally, others are covered by our law. So those remain exempt for those reasons. With regard to accidents, if I was watching four-year-olds, the last thing I would do is leave the room with a weapon in it. So I'm hopeful that the people we have watching our youngsters are going to avoid those kinds of accidents. But just as I can't prove that there will never be another shooting, it's equally unprovable that there will be an accident, Even though you and I both agree, it's likely that over time there will be
▶ Play
an accident. Representative Bale, you're recognized. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, Representative Letting earlier brought up the University of Alabama Huntsville shooting. Were you aware that Professor Bishop did not have a concealed carry permit?
▶ Play
I was not aware of that, Representative Bell. What I would submit is in the hundreds and hundreds of cases of shootings, if one was to dig through those, one could find an example that would make any point one would want to make because there are hundreds and hundreds of these and each one of them has their own specific cases. The challenge is we don't have the luxury of dealing with a specific case. What we have to do is take the amalgam of all of them and say what can we learn from this and what can we do to make our loved ones safer now one of the things we've been doing over the years is adding more and more police force which is a wonderful thing we've also been doing more and more training which is also a wonderful thing we're designing protocols we're doing in-school shooter drills we're doing that in all of our schools all of those things are wonderful components to the solution and i'm in favor of all of them. The challenge is, as the graph that sits in front of you shows, we don't have a complete solution. We're still in partial solution mode because the number of these incidents is rising. It's not going away. The solutions that exist today are not working as well as they could, and my belief is very strongly, based on all the things I've shared with you, this would be a key component in helping us to solve the problem. Representative Harris, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and
▶ Play
I apologize. I need to be on my best behavior because Mr. Speaker's in here, and I need to be on my best behavior, and I do apologize because this is a very important subject, and my children will be going to college, too, and Representative Collins, you know I've worked with you on this bill now for going on my third term, and I've had concerns, and you've worked with me on those concerns, and so this hasn't been something we just come together. I mean, we've worked on this. I've worked on this with you, and so in my particular college that I'm an alumni from, those are the issues I see. So in this bill would you think that the students would be safer if that professor could carry because otherwise there is no protection for those students? I do. First of all I appreciate
▶ Play
you being a co-sponsor of the bill, Representative Harris, and you're right you had a very thoughtful point of view on this and we've had a dialogue for many years on it. I do think the students are safer. The number one reason for that is not because I think any given professor is quick draw McGraw. That's not the reason. What I believe is that the professor with a concealed carry permit is a very responsible individual who understands the laws and understands how to use the weapon well enough and understands the appropriate way to manage the situation well enough so if, God forbid, there was an active shooter situation, that that individual would be helpful in that situation. But that's a minor part of this and it's not a sufficient reason to vote yes for this bill. It's not sufficient. The sufficiency comes from the fact that these murderers choose our college campuses because they expect to find no one with anything to throw at them but an eraser that's part of the reason they choose these venues and if they had to fear that then their meticulous planning and their control of the situation would not be possible and they can conclude that very easily that's the reason that public shooting events like this virtually without exception happen in gun free zones. And when you mix in children, our loved ones, it makes them an even bigger target, and we need to do more to protect them, and that's what this bill
▶ Play
will do. Thank you. Representative Walker, did you want to ask Ms. Duckett a question? Is
▶ Play
that right? Yes, and also I have several for Mr. Collins.
▶ Play
What I would like to do, since we did have a couple of questions for her earlier from Suthers, I would like to bring her back to the table, let you ask her questions a question and then
▶ Play
you will have to get back on the list for the others we are still rotating you are recognized Representative Walker Mr. Duckett thank you the UAMS has a number of related facilities that provide emergency services as I understand it and some are not simply in Little Rock
▶ Play
Speaker 43 1:12:04
there across the state. Through our AHECs and other programs,
▶ Play
we virtually cover every county in the state. As I understand it, you have quite a few people who are involved in your enterprise there, and they are part of a university environment. Would you explain just what the rationale is, other other than that you already have adequate safety features and police features in place for the opposition in general to this bill, as your university has determined it to be. Yes, sir. It
▶ Play
Speaker 43 1:12:48
starts with the overall safety and everything centers around the safety of our patients, students, faculty, and employees. And also under our accreditation by the Joint Commission, which supervises us through CMS, which qualifies us or disqualifies us for Medicare and Medicaid patients to be able to see them. One of the sections specifically addresses safe environment. And in our opinion, the ban of the guns on the campus totally does make that a stronger, safe environment. I respect that there are people that don't agree with that, and Mr. Collins and I have discussed that, but that's basically our position. So the ER situation doesn't really solve. We're so integrated, it would be virtually impossible to know when somebody's coming from one section to the other. We have 1,300 faculty and about 2,800 students on campus most days, and there's just no way we can keep up with that. In addition to that, we also run a Head Start program, which we would have employees there, and obviously that's small children, and we have the aging programs, and we have the AHECs, those around the state. So we're just a complex institution and not a typical hospital and not a typical four-year. Does that?
▶ Play
Yes, thank you. Representative Walker, I will allow you one more since
▶ Play
you didn't get one on the first one, if you'd like to have your second question. Well, I'd like to. You all have a number of people who study, who fit the label of handicapped, 504, IDEA, and they are on your staff. And it's known that many of the people that you employ have mental problems anyway. almost by law because the law prohibits discrimination against people who have mental problems so is there anything that this bill does in order to prevent people who have mental problems from having concealed weapons I'm not an expert
▶ Play
Speaker 43 1:15:17
on the concealed weapon law but I would assume there are ways around it but I don't know I think they have to take some sort of testing but that's not an area I feel I can respond to, but on our campus, we have the Psychiatric Research Institute, which is inpatient and outpatient, so that's at the main campus. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. I hope you all understood that Representative
▶ Play
Walker did not get his question the first time around, so that's why I gave him two that time. Representative Sabin, you are recognized. Approving the action.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Well, I don't want to follow that now, but thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, as you can probably tell, I'm trying to follow a line of questioning while being respectful of the chairman's rules here. So if you'll forgive me, I'm going to go back to what we were talking about. You're forgiven. Thank you. Based on our previous exchanges, I think we've established you haven't proved the deterrent effect of adopting this policy. that you haven't proved the connection between gun-free zones and the prevalence of these kinds of shootings. As Representative Lowry pointed out, a correlation does not equal causality, which means on all of these points, your guess is as good as mine. And that's important because I'm not the one trying to make a radical change in state policy. And I'm also not the one trying to quote data and statistics to make points that really can't be proven. But if I were to sort of follow your logic here, my question is why stop with faculty and staff and why not just allow anybody on a college campus, including the students? Because if this truly would have a deterrent effect, if it truly would establish that it's not a gun-free zone and that would end all school shootings, why stop with faculty and staff? Those are
▶ Play
good questions. So for example, Ms. Duckett just said she believes that it's a safe environment at UAMS today. Correct? Didn't she just say that? So that's a guess. Right? So it's a guess. Correct? I mean, using your logic and your methodology, that would make that a guess. So what I would submit is that the data that I've shared with you is based on the profiles of the way these people behave And based on the number of incidents and the way these incidents unfold is an overwhelming set of data that suggests this could very well be something that helps us. I believe that the risk-reward tradeoff, the cost-benefit analysis, the benefit versus risk analysis, is the reason to move more slowly by not allowing students. because I understand the risk of an accident, even though you can't prove there will be an accident. So many, many people have told me there will be an accident. I could have simply said to each one of them, you can't prove that, so you're wrong, but that would be a silly answer because the risk of an accident, accidents happen. Nobody can prove they're going to happen again, but since they always happen, it's very, very reasonable to presume there will be an accident. So one of the things I did to adjust to that reality is make adjustments in how we do this. And that is, by not allowing students, I believe that the maturity level of the faculty and employees, just based on their years on the earth in general, is going to be something that makes that group more likely to not have an accident than a person who's more likely to be younger. Similarly, I think that that still is enough to deter somebody that's going to want to coldly, calculatedly go somewhere where they can carry out their desires without interference. So, you know, you may argue that, you know, a hundred things happens and you can't prove that it's going to happen again, just like I can't prove the sun's going to come up tomorrow. But I think if you're going to deny the sun's going to come up tomorrow, That's more a denial of reality than a logical, delineated, statistical answer. Representative Letting,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Going back to my last question, it's been communicated to me by university staff that they know of no federal law currently prohibiting guns at their childcare facility.
▶ Play
Representative Letting are you ready to vote for the bill if I give an exemption for whatever it is that you just mentioned, the nuclear and that is that really what we're down to? because if it is, I'm more than happy if the stumbling block to agree I'm just continuing to point out the flaws in the current bill again, I don't think there are flaws I think if I put those in there then what you do is you'll go find some other area and say, hey, this is a new concern and so that's different than I think the seriousness with which we ought to address this issue I would say the safety of our infants at the child care facility is absolutely a serious issue. It's not a game. I agree that it's not a game. And so the answer is, how are we going to protect our loved ones? That's the central question. And if what we're really talking about is how do we implement this, I'm happy to sit down with you and correct the
▶ Play
flaws that you see, sir. Representative Gilliam, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. and I mainly just kind of wanted to have an opportunity for Ms. Duckett to present the data that she came. But if I might, though, before she presents that data that I had asked, Representative Saban's line of questioning kind of spurred a question on if I might be allowed to ask that question. You may. Go ahead. Okay. As I stated earlier, I mean, there's bountiful amounts of statistics that kind of back up, I think, your statement and not just the reports that you uh have presided but uh there's there's multiple studies that have been done on deterrence to prove that it actually you know does exist and everything i was just but absence all of those other studies and stuff i was wondering if uh what your thoughts might be on using a kind of a more of a real world example possibly that we experience on a daily basis and kind of maybe if you concur with my thought process on this there's been a tremendous amount of increased traffic of the membership of the General Assembly attempting to run bills in Judiciary so far this time, simply because my colleague to my right here is not on Judiciary Committee. I was wondering if that might fall into an example of deterrence and what that does, because now everyone seems to want to run a bill in Judiciary because Mr. Walker is not on Judiciary. Is that a logical fit into the concept of deterrence? Sir, your case remains unproven. All right. Thank you for allowing
▶ Play
me the question. If Ms. Duckett has
▶ Play
those answers, I'll be ready to hang on. I believe she has those answers,
▶ Play
and I'll let her go ahead and share that with the
▶ Play
Speaker 43 1:22:45
committee. Mr. Speaker, as I understand the question was regarding the number of police officers on campus?
▶ Play
Yes, ma'am. and then the percentage ratios of those law enforcement personnels and security personnels to the overall, you know, personnel makeup that is present on your campus while those officers are present. Okay, I'll kind of explain
▶ Play
Speaker 43 1:23:11
as we go there, and then if we need more information, I'll be happy to give it. We have a total of 54 officers on campus. Of those, 49, those are armed policemen and trained, you know, through the same thing as the Little Rock Police or anything else would be, an ongoing training. Then in addition to that, we have eight uniformed, unarmed security guards who would cover duties would be what you would typically think a security guard would be, checking doors, you know, that type of thing, offering assistance. But the police force itself is 54 that are armed and trained to deal with these kind of situations. Here's where I have difficulty with the percentages, and let me see if this gives enough information. We have approximately 1,300 faculty and approximately 28 to 2,850 around in there in students. I can't put a number on the traffic daily, though, to get what I think you're truly asking me. That wouldn't count visitors. That wouldn't count patients. That wouldn't count, you know, people that maybe they're interviewing or whatever. So does that adequately respond to you? Yes,
▶ Play
ma'am. I understand the limitations of time in gathering that data, so I
▶ Play
appreciate it very much. Thank you. I believe we're through to you, Ms.
▶ Play
Duckett. Thank you. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized. Representative Collins, you mentioned the shooters coming on campus and stuff. Do they show a certain behavioral pattern? How can you determine who to watch and all of that? You didn't mention that. In your research on this bill, did you see any behavioral patterns that
▶ Play
a serial shooter follows? Yeah, that's a very interesting question. And what the Secret Service report spends a lot of time saying is there's no way in advance to say, here are the demographic profile or any of those kinds of things. What it is more is a behavioral profile. And it's the kind of a person who seems overly upset over small. They kind of make a mountain on a molehill, the problems that happen in life, and they're regularly blaming others. And then when they hit one of these, that can kind of trigger this behavior of, you know, wanting to cause harm to others. So it's a behavioral thing. The report goes on to say that these people did things that indicated to others that they were maybe getting ready to do something like this. Most often it was other students. Very rarely it was adults. Sometimes it was in the planning. For example, one of the examples they used was some shooters went out with their parents and shopped for camo clothes and holsters and other things of this nature, which was kind of outside of their normal behavior, and then was also making comments to other kids about wanting to do some bad things to other people. So the bad news is we can't look at an individual and say because he or she is X, Y, Z tall and is this or that age or is any of those kinds of dynamics. But when somebody is in this mode, there are some signs before they actually do something, which, you know, is there a way to make that part of the solution? I don't know what it is. I'm very supportive of it. And if there is, I wouldn't submit for a moment that this is a panacea. That is not my proposition. This is not a panacea. I wouldn't say let's disband the campus police forces, let's forget about all the other protocols we use. That is not my position at all. This is part of a solution to a problem that exists, a problem that's not going away. If anything, from the numbers in front of us, the problem's getting worse, And what we can do here is help diminish the problem as we continue to look for additional things to diminish it further. Because I don't think we can do too much to help protect our loved ones from murder
▶ Play
in public places like college campuses. Thank you, Representative Collin. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:27:38
Chair. Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Yes. I think one thing we're missing possibly here today is the scenario from a female's point of view of being in an educational situation where you're in a classroom with 25 students, there's no back door. There are no windows. There's one way in, and that shooter's going to come in through that door. I can't remove my students from there. All we can do is possibly flip a table over and get behind it. It brings me much comfort as a mother and as a female teacher to know that possibly maybe I don't have a gun. Maybe I don't feel comfortable with a concealed carry. I do have my concealed carry, but maybe I'm not the one in that hall that's designated maybe as that person that could have that concealed carry. But if I know a teacher next to me who's an ex-Marine or, you know, someone that's, you know, been around guns, they do have that concealed carry, and they can step in. When I can't do anything, then that brings me much comfort to know that there would be qualified people to be able to do that. wouldn't you agree Mr.
▶ Play
Collins yes ma'am although I would include you in that group if I was in the classroom next to you and I knew that you had your concealed carry that would enhance my own comfort one of the things about a weapon is it takes away a lot of the differences between the physical strength of one person or another and I'm high confidence the state police would not have granted you your concealed carry permit if you were not competent to use it effectively as we see over and over and again with the 100,000 plus concealed carry holders in Arkansas. Thank you very much. Please, committee,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:29:41
remember that from a woman's point of view of feeling safe in an environment where you are locked into a classroom with no way out. Thank you. Representative Murdoch, you are recognized. Thank you, Chairman.
▶ Play
I have one question or two parts, if that makes sense, if
▶ Play
Speaker 189 1:30:04
we can do that. Is that a McElroy
▶ Play
question? Well, it will be real quick, though. Representative Collins, as we look at it, and my phone is blowing up from those that are having input and watching this live stream. So the impact that this may have on academic or educational accreditation standards, that's a question that's kind of been danced around. But that's a direct question that if you can answer that, that you have addressed that question specifically. And in the second part of it, I'm getting emails, is the recruitment and retention of qualified staff. There are people that are educators, doctorates in their particular fields of education, and that's what they want to be there to do. They're not signed up necessarily for, in all due respect, to be the line of defense for those type of assaults. They are very serious, and the campus security, as it is, feel very comfortable in taking care of that. So can you address that as to how it may affect our staffs as well as accreditation and standards? Yeah, this is
▶ Play
the first time I've heard anybody bring up the notion that somehow this would impact accreditation standards. What's the question? I think the answer is there's no impact at all on that. I wouldn't understand how that would have any impact. That's the first time somebody's brought that up to me, so I don't come here with prepared remarks with regard to that, but there should be no impact on that at all. With regard to individuals making a choice to say something like, I'm not going to work at this university because it's located in my home state of Michigan where it's very, very, very cold, and I don't like the very, very, very cold, I agree that that individual, because we live in a free country, wouldn't necessarily go to work in a university that's very, very cold. And another individual that would say, you know, I don't like a state that has concealed carry on a campus would say the seven states that don't have it and Arkansas. And then however many other of the 13 that decide to pass it in their session, those are all off my list, right? Much like somebody may make a choice based on the weather or based on whatever other factor, I couldn't say for sure what any individual would do. So I understand that an individual, but I can't imagine and have heard nothing to suggest that there's some, you know, wholesale movement of people to choose where they're going to go to work based on this issue. We're not seeing it in the other seven states. Something like that would start to be noticed very, very quickly, and it's not happening. And then I think your third one had to do with sports, and, again, I would say the...
▶ Play
No, I didn't. No. I'm sorry. That wasn't me. That was in your mind. Okay. I didn't see anything about sports. All right. but just to finish that up I do think that's why it's so important that when you met with the university personnel and they gave you the input from their staff and faculty they didn't mention that well but I'm just saying whatever they mentioned because they were definitely against this the majority of them are against this so for whatever reason it was I'm saying that's what we have to listen to because those are the people that you're mandating this for to some degree
▶ Play
sir I'm mandating this for the people of Arkansas It's your voters that I'm mandating this for, and in my view, those are the operative group. It's the 30,000 people in my district. Obviously, you've got the 30,000 in yours, and are we going to keep them and their children safer or not? And that's the question that I think we're answering here today, and that's the primary question. Now, how we do things and implement them, I would submit to you, I've listened very, very carefully. We just heard Ms. Duckett, and she said, look, you're not going to make a change of this bill that's going to make me support it. And I've spent a lot of time with the university system saying, okay, well, you tell me then what it is that you're most concerned about, right? Well, the first answer is we'd like to keep the decision for everywhere ourselves, which I understand, right? And then you start backing that down, and I can grasp the distinction between an emergency room, you know, in downtown in a city where you've got lots of people, some of which are gunshot victims or knife victims in an emergency room, where you have extra security because of the dangers and confusion and chaos associated with the situation itself, where you're already on guard for some type of a problem because of the venue, this emergency room hospital. And so I said, not to get her to say yes with the bill, because I knew no matter what I said, she's not going to agree to the bill, no matter what I said. But in the interest of your 30,000 people and my 30,000 people and the other almost 3 million people in Arkansas, that made sense. And so I put that in there for that reason. And so I think I listened to
▶ Play
those things. And I'm speaking from the interest of those people just as you are. So when the opt-out clause is not there, then you take away their input, their local responsibility, if you will. You're just totally taking that away. You're governing that. You're mandating that. Leave that in, and it becomes a
▶ Play
good bill. We used to mandate that they couldn't do it up through 2011, right? And now what we're doing is we're giving the decision to the individual concealed carry holder who works
▶ Play
at a university. In order, Mr. Chair, we've got an ongoing debate here. We do have a debate. We need to stay on to the bill and one question, and we've over that question. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Representative Abel. I have two more on the list, and Representative Walker is next. I'm sorry, I have three more on the list, and then I'm going to go to public opinion for the sake of time, if you're okay with that. I have Representative Walker, then Representative Letting, and Representative Gray. And Representative Sabin, would you still like to stay on that list? Okay, that's the four. I'm going to leave
▶ Play
those four there. Please keep it short, and let's move on. Representative Walker, you are recognized. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Your outland approach to this is full of holes, which I will not try to identify, but I would like for you to tell me if there are any studies or any evidence that you have which demonstrates that analogous laws in those states where let me start over. Do you have any evidence that shows that in those states, those seven states where you have passed this kind of law, that they are safer than the states where you haven't
▶ Play
passed it. As I shared with Representative Lowry when he asked me that question, it has only recently occurred in the seven other states, and there's not nearly enough data points to make a conclusive answer one way or the other that would distinguish them one way or the other. So the answer to your question is no, sir. Well,
▶ Play
mine differs from his, if I may, because I was dealing with, I mean, my understanding That's a second question, Representative Walker. I'm sorry. All right. Thank you, Your Honor. and then I'll be on the next go-around. Representative Lettinger, you're recognized.
▶ Play
I have a point of clarification, please, sir. When we're allowed to question, if the person we're questioning pose a question back or a discussion, and then if we're not allowed to finish, then that leaves an incomplete. Is there a way that we can do it where we can get to some? If
▶ Play
that was going to take a second different answer, then I would say that's another question. But
▶ Play
when it comes from the respondent, that he poses something that causes you to respond, is that in order at that time?
▶ Play
I just don't want to debate this bill like we got into a while ago. I understand that you guys have a lot of questions. We have a lot to do on the table today, but we're getting into debates back and forth, and I don't think that's the purpose of this committee, to debate back and forth. That's the purpose. Well, it is a purpose, but not in length like y'all. You had about four questions in your questioning back and forth a while ago. I understand. Can we try to keep it in one question, a response, and then move to the next one? Just with completeness.
▶ Play
That's all I was asking, Chairman. Okay.
▶ Play
Thank you, sir. Representative Walker, do you feel like that was a complete question or not? Well, it was a complete question, not a complete answer. Representative Collins, can you give him a
▶ Play
complete answer on that? Well, so he'll understand. And I wanted to know, he said, it's not enough time. I mean, how much time is enough time? Some of these laws have been on the books for several years or more. And ordinarily, you get some idea of whether or not they, of what the impact is within a period of time. Apparently, there has been no impact study here that would guide your suggestion to us. I mean, I take it that's right, isn't it? I have not funded a study, sir, no. Thank you. Representative Gray,
▶ Play
you are recognized. You're next. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question's been answered.
▶ Play
I had one more. Yeah, I had one more.
▶ Play
Representative Letting, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, no one here today questions your commitment to student security. Everybody here at this table has the same goal. We're all working to the same thing. this isn't about whether we like guns we don't like guns it's about making sure we get the policy right my district is very small but it encompasses the entire University of Arkansas campus in Fayetteville I have heard from a lot of people about this in the last several weeks and the overwhelming response has been in opposition from students from professors from from parents who are very concerned about this many of them cite the accidental shooting on campus two years ago by a staff member who was also a student and a marine as as an example of why they're afraid of this. If this is the best policy, why have all 52 campuses rejected it the last two years? Why have 98.8% of all college campuses in the country rejected this policy?
▶ Play
I would submit to you that if you talk about policy administrators at universities, that group of people in my view is going to have one point of view. If you talk to the the people of Arkansas, the only data point I have on that would be what Robby Brock had from 2013, where 49.5% were in favor of this policy and 43% weren't. That's right, but
▶ Play
I'm sure that included a lot of people who don't work at the universities, have children at the universities. I would disagree
▶ Play
with you, sir, that the people at our universities across the state come from all of the households in Arkansas, and as you know, they come as best as we can possibly make it, equally from all of the regions of the state. So this issue applies to every Arkansan, not just university professors and their bosses.
▶ Play
Well, I also included students and parents in my comments. I've heard from a number
▶ Play
of them. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Rep.
▶ Play
Sabin for the last question. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and it's a simple yes or no question, I hope. Representative Collins, in your answer to my previous question about whether or why you didn't include students or other members of the campus community in this. You said it's because you wanted to move slowly, I think was the word. So my question is, is it your intention, is it your goal, is it your hope, if you were to pass this bill to eventually also include students and other members of the college campus community as being able to carry concealed weapons on campus?
▶ Play
I have absolutely no intention of doing any more with this because I believe this will be sufficient to deter. I believe the fact that these cowards that do their planning, in my view, the thought that they could run into the concealed carry holder is enough to stop them. They don't need to run into multiple concealed carry holders. So I believe that this bill, as written today, takes care of that and moves us forward in protecting our loved ones, and I have no plans to do any more with it.
▶ Play
That is our last question from the committee. I've already turned one down. We're going to go on. We're going to let you catch him on the last end of it. When he closes the bill, I will open it back up for questions. Not many, but some. I am going to go to the audience, but I'm going to read something before I go to the audience. This is a reminder for those providing testimony on the bill today. Please show respect for the legislative process and others testifying on this issue, even if you disagree with their opinions. Properly and respectfully address the committee members as representative and the chairman as chairman or the vice chair as madam chair. After the chairman has recognized you, clearly state your name and the organization, if any, that you represent. Address your remarks to the chairman and to the members of the committee. Keep your remarks focused on the bill, please. And that is being discussed. Keep your remarks brief and to the point in discussing your support or opposition to the bill. You're welcome just to walk up there and say, I oppose this bill. State your name and who you're with and say, I oppose this bill, and go sit down if you want to. You can talk about it, but please keep it brief. Please observe proper decorum at all times. All pictures, printed materials, and props, if you plan to present in this testimony, must be approved by the chair before you do that. Thank you for traveling to the Capitol and being part of our democracy today. Thank you. At this time, we will open it for the audience, for those that would like to speak against the bill. And I have Dean Patterson first. Do you have a group with you, Dean, of more than one? Yes, sir. I'm speaking among students. Okay. State your name and who you're with and who you might – how many are you going to be speaking
▶ Play
for? My name is Dean Patterson. I'm with students from across the state of Arkansas, and I'm speaking for myself and with students across our state. All right. You're recognized to speak. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Committee, Congressman Collins, everyone here today. My name is Dean Patterson. I'm one of the many students from across the state that have met here today to voice their concerns, those that can be here and not. We as students in my Lower Rock School District and in the public education system have been taught some very clear goals and very clear messages, one of which is to question the authorities that be when we have concerns with what is at stake in our futures. I sit here today as one of the thousands of students that is making the most critical decision in their lifetimes the decision of what is the next step in our education as I leave my high school I will be making that decision do I stay in the natural state where I've been born and raised grown amongst the thousands of my fellow students and teachers that have raised me as a member of our education system or do I take my education outside of the state that decision is one that thousands of students are making and the brain drain that is possible when we put students safety at risk in their education system is one that harms the future of our state as a whole. My question for the committee and for the bill put forward would be of one, what is the relationship between local control and the power of this piece of legislation? The university radio station at the University of Arkansas, KUAF, lies directly across the street from the public library. Will we allow concealed carriers to be in such close proximity to a public venue that hosts a substantial youth population every day. I take us back to when Representative Collins, he should remember that in 2013, on the day a Fayetteville Legislative Forum was held, a former Marine and grad student in KUAF pulled out his pistol and shot off his finger. Luckily, no one else was hurt, and Representative Collins never made it to the forum. Furthermore, Leverett Elementary School lies directly across the street from the north side of the U of A campus, where we allow campus carry in the parking lot directly across the street where children are constantly present the fact that so many amendments have been brought to the floor on this bill already that representative collins has heard the voices not only today but from the weeks where he's been crafting this piece of legislation shows there are thousands of overlaps between public institutions where local control and city ordinances take place on what is the use of guns and this piece of legislation i ask that members of the committee and our congressmen question what is that relationship between local control and state control on gun legislation and that question is the pertinent one in how we're able to make these forms of reforms in keeping our campuses safe because if we cannot trust the public education system to keep us safe how will we be allowed how will we be able to trust the public education system on our university campuses to attract students from across the nation and to allow our campuses to be one of the top 50 public education systems in the nation as we seek to approach the status point that Arkansas can be. That is the question of these points of legislation, and that is the question of what does safety mean for me as a student. Thank you. We have a question
▶ Play
for you if you'd entertain a question. Yes, sir. Representative Gillum,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would just, as a point of clarity maybe for the committee, in your presentation there you mentioned I think at the beginning that I guess the fundamental question for you as you decide on your next step would be public safety but then most of your presentation kind of presented more on local control as a point of clarity could you maybe focus down on is it local control that high school students are most concerned about on selecting their higher education or is it public safety what questions of local
▶ Play
control have a ramifications on what are those questions of public safety. So in the event that we do not know where our guns can be on campus, when there are no drop-off points, you know, when you walk out of the line that divides the 500 meters outside of a school zone that you can have a gun, we don't know where those guns are going to be. That's a question of public safety that's not, that's a question of local control that intercedes on the question of public safety that's not answered by these points of legislation. And that's what's really brought up and is most pertinent by all of the amendments that
▶ Play
have been brought to this bill so far. Fair enough. Good answer. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Harris, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you for being here. My question, going back to your speech there, which is well thought out and well done, you have a radio voice, But going back to QUAF there, this bill, do you understand that that was bad timing on the day of the legislative form at the chamber? That person had no business taking that gun into the radio station, should not have carried that gun into the radio station. And this bill has nothing to do with that. Is that correct? Well, I would say that's up to the ramifications of
▶ Play
the legislation once it's passed. However, that gray area is what really is a problem of public safety, is that we don't know where the demarcation lines of where can we and not have guns. Where can we and not have guns on our campuses and in our public zones? And that's a question of safety
▶ Play
that concerns me as a student. Okay, thank
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:50:16
you. Representative Douglas, we have a question. Yes. I don't know if you could possibly be a student of past wars that we have been a part of
▶ Play
or not. That's not my question. Are you
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:50:31
asking him that, or is that just a statement? That's a setup. I'm assuming he's not, because he's not jumping on that. But maybe a little-known fact about Japan, when they were proposing to enter into war with America, And they made the decision not to invade our homeland, but to fight us on foreign soil, because they knew that everyone in America had a gun. And if we don't think that us having guns as a nation is something that other nations think about, we are missing, you know, what history is telling us. And then if we don't translate that into microcosms of situations, whether it be a school zone or whatever we're talking about, but that same deterrent that those guns made to Japan not invading our homeland is exactly what happens in the mind of someone that's planning to invade or choose their war zone. So would you agree with me that that history could show us some lessons about defense? Yes, ma'am. I would certainly
▶ Play
agree that the prowess of the U.S. military and, you know, Arkansas gun owners,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:58
we have a great history and culture of ownership in Arkansas. No, I was not talking about the military. I was talking about private
▶ Play
Speaker 217 1:52:07
citizens with guns. So thank you very much.
▶ Play
Yes, ma'am. Thank you. Okay. No other questions for you, sir. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Committee. I have Mr. Paul Calvert to speak for the bill. State your name and who you're
▶ Play
with, and you're recognized. My name is Paul Calvert. I'm from the Faulkner County area. You'll probably see me down here quite a bit. I'm with myself. I'm not with any particular organization. To me, this is kind of a small thing to ask for teachers just to be able to arm themselves. Why would we prevent teachers from being able to arm themselves? And that's a pretty small thing to ask. We're not asking for teenagers to be able to carry guns on campus. And I think something that's maybe worth looking at is that, and this is only for concealed carry holders, too. If you look at statistics, according to Texas on ncpa.org, licensees were 5.7 times less likely to be arrested for violent offenses than the general public. Licensees were 14 times less likely to be arrested for nonviolent offenses than the general public. and i mean why would we be afraid of these people from what i understand there there's some speculation that they might even have lower crime rates than the police and the police are allowed on campus with their with their firearms so i think it's i think it's kind of a no-brainer on some level to let teachers carry especially if they have a concealed carry permit because they're they're they've gone through background checks they're generally statistically upstanding citizens beyond the average, and far beyond it, apparently.
▶ Play
I'll take questions. Are there any questions, committee? Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. Thank you. I will remind everyone, we do have to be in session at 1.30, so this committee cannot go past 1.30, so I would love to get out of here before then. If we do not, then we will continue this another day, but we are hoping that we have an hour and a half. I would love to expedite this in any way possible, but we will take testimony. Andrew MacArthur against the bill. Andrew, state your name and who you're with, and you're recognized. My name is Andrew
▶ Play
Speaker 231 1:54:55
MacArthur. I am with the students as well, and I'm going to keep it short because I know we are a bit stressed for time. I just want to talk about some of the holes, and I'm not trying to just poke holes in Representative Collins' plans. I'm trying to talk about what we could do better. For example, first off, the RAs are considered Arkansas staff, and I know Representative Collins said that RAs would not be able to have anything on dormitories, but if there is no line in between what is a dormitory, could they have it in a parking lot, and would there be a drop box for their concealed carry gun? In addition, campus contractors, like construction workers, and third-party employees of the campus, like food service workers, would they also be able to have these weapons? Like I said, this is not just to poke holes in it. This is just to point out that a two-and-a-half-page proposal is not adequately it does not adequately outline the rules and implementation of guns on the campus. And I just ask that you recognize the possible harms that this could pose because it is not thought out and is not in-depth and because it is better to rely on good foresight than a terrible hindsight. Thank you. Are there any questions from the committee? If not, thank you. Thank you for your
▶ Play
time. Mason Jewell if you would state your name and who you're with that you're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 235 1:56:36
my name is Mason Jewell I'm also with the students and thank you mr. chair and thank you to the committee for allowing me to speak as many of you are probably all of you know sporting events are a huge part of campus life and a huge part of the entire university system and with those sporting events come tailgating, which I'm sure all of you have been to a tailgate. They're very hectic. They're very loud and rambunctious, and there's not a lot of control over what goes on at the tailgate. There are campus police, and obviously it's very heavily populated by campus police and maybe municipal police. So I was wondering, like the UAMS exception where there is a concession to allow the ER to not have these concealed carry permits, will there be any exceptions for organizations, not organizations, but things like, excuse me, these tailgates or campus parties or something like that? Just because there have not, I'm not aware of any statutes that state this or explicitly cover this. Yeah, that's all I have. Are you
▶ Play
asking us a question? That was my question. Well, we're not taking questions
▶ Play
Speaker 235 1:58:00
from you. You are to make a statement to us. Well, then I think that is a problem, that there are no statutes. They clearly cover what is to be allowed at a tailgater or other event like
▶ Play
that. Are there any questions from the committee? Thank you, sir. Thank you. Are there anybody for the bill? Is anyone out there for the bill? Not on the committee? At this time, I have no one on the list to speak for the bill, but if someone does want to speak for the bill, please approach the bench and let them know at this time we will you have one i have one for the bill if you would all right take the take the end of the table tell us who you are and who
▶ Play
Speaker 242 1:59:06
you're with and you're recognized i'm nancy emmons from hot springs village and i'm very much for the bill um i'm a mother I'm a grandmother, and as the representative said at the end of the table, many of the buildings have no windows. They have one door, and you have a shooter come in that one door. Our children are just like bowling balls because we have found not only in Arkansas but in other states. They have walked in the door and killed our children because nobody was there to protect them with anything other than, as she said, crawl under a desk. So what we need to understand is while there are people who object to this, there are mothers and grandmothers who are very much for this because we send them to the schools to be protected. And if someone has a gun. And I do, and I have my concealed weapon. But if someone has a gun somewhere that can help the children, that's what we need. You see, they know that we don't have anything in the school. That's why they come in there, because they know that there's nothing in there to protect the children. And as a mother and a grandmother, I ask that you pass this bill. There are more out there that are for this bill that are not for this bill. I can tell you that. Thank you so much for
▶ Play
your time. Are there any questions on the committee? We have a question for you, ma'am, if you would. Representative Murdoch, you are recognized for a question. Let's hear it.
▶ Play
Your last statement that you made was there are a lot more people that are in favor of this than not. Yes, sir. And certainly I'm respectful of the people. If you listen to my questions to the Representative Collins, they have been along that line. Because of the responses that many of us are getting against this is the reason why you're hearing some of the line of questions. So you made a statement that there are many that are for this, but they are not doing as you've done, come to the end of the table to communicate that to us. So do you understand what we're responding to when we're getting all of this opposition? Do you understand that? I do understand that, but
▶ Play
Speaker 242 2:01:51
I also understand that the citizens of Arkansas have no clue that they have the privilege to come down here and do this. And I want to tell you, we have been all over the state. We have been all over Garland County. We have been all over many counties, and one of the things that, besides the private option, which I'm not to bring up, but the other question has been the safety of the children in school. What are we going to do? And so, as I said, as a mother and a grandmother, I am here to support the bill. I want something there that can stop someone who our children are looking down the barrel of a gun with no protection. Yes, ma'am. We all agree with that.
▶ Play
I was just talking about the last part about other people. I know why you were here.
▶ Play
Speaker 242 2:02:35
You did a good job, but other people. There is. I just told you. But they're not here. We were all over. They don't have to be here. Your people are not here. We have got to understand.
▶ Play
The list is very long. Well. Point of order, Mr. Chair, we're
▶ Play
Speaker 242 2:02:51
back to debating again. I bet I can make my list longer than
▶ Play
yours. All right. Thank you. All right. But on the next on the list to speak against the bill is Anastasia Lindell. State your name for the
▶ Play
Speaker 248 2:03:15
record, and you're recognized, please. Hi, I'm Anastasia Lindell, and I'm also with the students. And thank you for the chairman and for the committee. For the sake of time, I was going to read some tweets, including one from the student body president of University of Arkansas, they're all against this bill, but I'm just going to state my opposition to it because I think it's very unnecessary, and it'll be hard for me to focus knowing that my teacher is armed, and I feel like we have state police or, like, college police to deal with issues like that. Thank you.
▶ Play
Are there any questions, committee? Thank you. Oh, I'm sorry. You have one. Rep. Walker,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Thank you. Why would it be very difficult for you to focus with your professor obviously having a gun in his or her presence while you're in class? I just don't feel like
▶ Play
Speaker 248 2:04:12
weapons, like they don't belong in the school environment. I have police on my school campus in case something happens, and teachers, I don't think that that responsibility should be on them because they're educators and it's not their responsibility to take care of us in the case of a school shooter scenario, even though I know most of them would. But I don't want my teacher to always be worried, like, where's my gun? Like, where did I put it? Making sure that it's safe. I want them to focus on teaching me because I don't think it's fair to put that on them. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Is there anyone for the bill?
▶ Play
Representative Bell, you're recognized. Motion, Mr. Chair. What is your motion, Representative Bell? Motion to limit debate to 15 minutes
▶ Play
per side. That is public testimony you're talking about? That's correct. We have a motion to limit debate to 15 minutes per side, for and against. That is a proper motion. All those, that is non-debatable. All those in favor, say aye. Opposed? Motion passes. Debate will be limited to 15 minutes per side. The time of the clock right now is 12.06, so we will finish at 12.36 at the latest with debate. Our next one against the bill. Actually, we may not take that long. We don't get any fours. So you only get 15 minutes for the against side. Aaron Bartell. Aaron Bartell. Is that right? Correct? Close enough? You are recognized. State your name, and then you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Speaker 257 2:06:11
My name is Aaron Bartells, and I'm also here with the students. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Aaron Bartels, and I'm also here with the students, and I would like to state my opposition to this bill, but due to time constraints, I would like
▶ Play
to yield my time to the chair. Okay. Any questions? No questions. All right. Next, do we have anybody for? Are you for? I have one for take the other table. State who you're with and your name, and you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
My name is Dan Greenberg. I'm with a limited government organization called the Advance Arkansas Institute. I want to try to keep this very brief. I just want to suggest that it's easy to imagine things, and we all have vivid and powerful imaginations, and we can draw whatever conclusions we like in our mind, but probably a better way to look at these things is to look at what's actually happened, to look at the evidence of the world. And if you look at the evidence of the world, you can, for instance, you can compare concealed carry states with non-concealed carry states. And I think the best statistical evidence suggests that crime rates are lower and it's less dangerous to live in states that protect Second Amendment rights. We occasionally hear these predictions of danger when we extend Second Amendment rights to people, but in fact, I think that when you look at Arkansas history, you can see that, I mean, for instance, we had a change in carry rights two years ago, and there were some predictions that this would lead to, you know, wider use of guns in dangerous ways. Even though we've more or less extended carry rights to the populace at large due to a change in law two years ago, we haven't seen the kind of change that the advocates of danger and the doom and gloom people predicted that we'd have. I think that the evidence of the real world shows that when we extend Second Amendment rights to people, you don't see danger. Instead, you see safety. And I think that if we're guided by the facts of the world, by real experience, you will see safety. And I also think that we ought to respect our constitutional rights. I've got one question for Mr. Greenberg.
▶ Play
Would you entertain a question? I have a question. Representative Letting. Well, only if
▶ Play
it's an easy question. It's very easy. Representative Letting, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Greenberg, you said you were with a limited government organization. Wouldn't this bill actually be placing an added mandate on our schools and therefore be
▶ Play
expanding government? Well, I'm not sure that that's right because I think that government agencies really ought to try to protect our rights, to do things like, you know, practice our religion and respect our freedom of speech and respect our Second Amendment rights. And there are cases where government agencies don't always do a good job of that. And I respect and appreciate Representative Collins in his attempt to make sure that we can practice our rights. MR. Yeah. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:09:19
you, Mr. Chair. MR. Are there any other questions?
▶ Play
Representative Saban, you're recognized. MR. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Greenberg, is there any place you think somebody should not be allowed to carry a
▶ Play
firearm, concealed otherwise? Sure. In my home, if I don't want them to. I mean, I think anywhere on private property, the person who runs a private property should be the decision maker there.
▶ Play
I should have clarified my question. I meant public property. I apologize. Public buildings. Government buildings. I think as a
▶ Play
general matter, that's the right principle. I'm not sure what public building you're thinking of. I mean, I can tell you, for instance, in Texas, they have procedure where, I mean, I don't know if they let you carry guns in nuclear reactors or anything like that, so I don't really know exactly what public building you're thinking of, but where a place is open to the public, in Texas, for instance, I think most places that are open to the public allow people to carry, you know, if they pass appropriate tests and so forth.
▶ Play
Speaker 261 2:10:19
Are there any other questions, Committee?
▶ Play
Thank you. At this time, Tom Coulter, against the bill. State your name, and you are recognized. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. My name is Tom Coulter. I'm also here with the student group, but due to time constraints, I just want to state my opposition
▶ Play
to the bill. Any questions? Thank you. Anyone for the bill? Back to against. I believe it's C.J. or C.T. Fowler, whichever one that is. Yes, sir, it's C.J. C.J., okay. Kind of thought that, wasn't sure. Yes, sir. State your name, and you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 266 2:11:05
My name is C.J. Fowler, and I'm here with the students. Due to time constraints, I will keep it down to just one point, but that point being that although Representative Collins' amendment does make an exception for the Clinton School, The Clinton School is not the only university that brings in high-profile speakers, and I would worry that my education, if I chose to go to such as the University of Arkansas, would be limited because speakers would not come. And I state my opposition to the bill. Thank you. We
▶ Play
have a question for you. Representative Bell, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you. I'm curious, are you or any of the other students receiving class credit for being here today? I don't believe so. No, sir. Thank you. I
▶ Play
have Representative Lowry has a question for you also.
▶ Play
Representative Lowry, you're recognized. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate the well-thought-out comments that have been made by the students. One of the concerns I have, though, is that, and I know that you're not trying to represent that students are a monolithic group that you speak for. I would ask, are you aware that in 2013, when this was first passed, one university did survey students, University of Central Arkansas, and 56% of the students said that they supported this legislation?
▶ Play
Were you aware of that? I was not aware of that, no. Okay, thank you very much. Are there any other questions? Thank you. Is there anyone for the bill? I'd like to speak for the bill. If not, Grace Lytle, does that sound right? State your name, and you're
▶ Play
Speaker 269 2:12:50
recognized. My name is Grace Lytle. I'm with the students group. Due to time restraints, I would just like to state my opposition to the bill.
▶ Play
Are there any questions? Thank you. Anyone for the bill? We have one for the bill. Take the end of the table, please, and state your name.
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:13:18
and you're recognized. I'm John Emmons. I'm from Hot Springs, Arkansas. I'm a retired Navy man, and my wife, I might mention, that testified earlier, she used to be scared of guns. She'd say, I'd tell them, hey, there's a gun right there, and you better get out of here. But after she went through training, she's a dead-eye hitter. and she's not scared of them anymore and I know a lot of these young people they've not apparently not been around guns they don't understand that and whereas I have in the Navy and I have done research of it of the years there was a university up in Seattle Washington I cannot recall which one it was I think it might have been in Seattle Pacific but a professor up there did a survey with people in prison what is the one thing that keep you from picking somebody out as a victim. I said, if I knew they were armed. Okay, then the professor up in the University of Chicago did the same thing years later. I believe his name is Lowry, and he even wrote a book about it. And that research also indicated that they, the criminals said that if there was any doubt that they were armed, I'll bypass them to go for somewhere else. And I'd like to bring your attention to the fact that I don't know of any of those mass killings, but what there was not, they were in a gun-free zone. I mean, all criminals are not stupid, you know, and so they go to the gun-free zones knowing they're not going to have any opposition. And that's happened over and over, and that's all I have to say. Are there any questions for
▶ Play
us? Thank you. Ezra Smith, you are recognized.
▶ Play
State your name, and you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Ezra Smith. I'm a junior at the University of Arkansas, and I will be very brief, but I hope to demonstrate to this committee that this bill is totally unworkable. I think the best example I can give you is that at the U of A in Fayetteville, my college, there are many zones that are designated as high security areas by the Department of Homeland Security. These are nanotech laboratories. These are chemistry buildings. And I have to pose the thought, will the Department of Homeland Security allow those who have concealed carry to carry within those zones as many of these exercise export control over materials within? Seeing that as the case, would we be having to invest in metal detectors, cubbies for weapons as they left them outside? I mean, what are our protocols here? And seeing as that there is likely none spelled out in this legislation, I would ask that this committee vote against this bill as it is entirely unworkable. Thank you. I'll take any questions. Any questions? We have a question. Representative Hodges, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, and I want to thank all of you students for coming out today. I know it's not easy to come in here and address this body, but, you know, August 28th of 2000 is a day that I won't forget because it was the day my sister began attending classes at the U of A in Fayetteville. It was also the day that a professor was shot and killed in his office by a student who then took his own life. And I guess the struggle that I have approaching this issue is, you know, to me that the system of that day and the system that all of our campuses currently have failed, that professor who was killed, John Locke. And so I guess my question is, does the fear of a weapon or does the fear of an accident from a weapon trump the rights of these individuals to protect themselves? Let me say this. I am a gun owner. I have grown
▶ Play
up around guns. My stepfather was a deputy U.S. marshal and taught me to shoot. I have no fear of using a weapon. I've been trained to properly do so. I don't think that your question is pertinent to this topic. The issue is it's not addressing the problem. If we're afraid of students being vulnerable, if we're afraid of an active shooter scenario, which, of course, everyone in this committee in this room is, we have to look at what the solution is. The solution is not allowing concealed carry members to carry weapons on campus. They're not trained for an active shooter. A six-hour weekend course does not train you properly to defend students or people. There's no one on the list. Do you want to talk again?
▶ Play
Do you have another question? I'm sorry.
▶ Play
Representative Gillum first. Sorry, Representative Hodges. Along those lines you just mentioned on the active training courses, would it be then appropriate possibly for the universities, if this bill was to pass and become implemented in law, to actually offer those courses for all of their faculty, maybe more extensively than they even do presently just in the event that there was an incident to occur. And I realize that your specific points earlier had to do with certain locations that were exempted, but Representative Hodges' question spoke to the core of the bill, which was allowing individuals to protect themselves in the situations, and he offered the example. But I was just wondering if you might could maybe elaborate on maybe your thoughts on the university's role in preparing their faculty and staff for active shooter situations? Well, I
▶ Play
think absolutely. If this training you're talking about is an unarmed training, sure, I find the expanse of that is probably justified. If you're asking if the University of Arkansas should expand trainings to concealed carry license holders, I'm not sure if that's their duty or their place to do so. Representative Bell
▶ Play
you have a question you're recognized thank you
▶ Play
Mr. Chair you mentioned active shooter training and as someone who wore a badge and a gun for a few years as a law enforcement officer I've had a little bit of that what I know as a citizen of the state of Arkansas is that if my life is on the line I really don't care what level of training someone has if I'm facing an armed assailant sitting in a room full of students who are unarmed and someone comes through the door and I have the choice while my life is on the line of defending with a book trying to throw a chair at them or have someone next to me who has any level of training and something other than a book I'm going to be very thankful that they're there. My daughter is a student at the University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, and frankly, she's more vulnerable because there's nobody there with anything other than a book and a chair in that classroom on a daily basis. Do you have any reason to believe that someone would be better off with a book and a chair versus someone with some level of training there to defend and protect them? I think to address this scenario,
▶ Play
If you and I were engaged, I as a student, you as a concealed carry license holder, in an active shooter scenario, I think if you look at studies, it is more likely that you, in trying to defend myself and any other students, are more likely to hit me than the active shooter. And so I would say that, yes, I would feel more uncomfortable with a second gun in the room. Follow-up, Mr. Chair?
▶ Play
You are the end of the list unless Mr. Hodges wants back on. He deferred to you. Go ahead.
▶ Play
You made a statement in your response that elicited a few chuckles. That's a pretty broad statement. What evidence do you have to back up your statement?
▶ Play
In front of me, none. I'm happy to step away and provide studies and evidence. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Representative Hodges, do you have a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:21:23
question? You're recognized. Thank you. I guess my point is that under
▶ Play
the current law, UAPD was neither capable of deterring this student nor preventing or intervening before the student took the life of this professor. I cannot say whether Professor Locke would have chosen to carry a weapon on campus if this law had been in place or not. All I know is that under this legislation, he would have had that right and the opportunity to do so, and maybe the outcome would have been different. We are talking about a lot of hypotheticals and a lot of anecdotes in here, but this is one concrete example that I just felt needed to be aired. And again, I guess my question is, does the fear of any weapon from maybe any students or other faculty trump the constitutional right of, say, this professor to have had the opportunity to defend himself in this situation?
▶ Play
I just feel as if that this is not, one, a question that I can rule upon. It's also speaking entirely towards a hypothetical that I don't feel comfortable engaging in, not to mention that it was the death of a professor at my own university. It seems very inappropriate to air it out at this committee at this
▶ Play
time. Representative Harris is first, if you don't mind, Reverend Walker.
▶ Play
Speaker 246 2:22:41
I'm popular today. You're recognized, Representative Harris. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. This is an easy question. I had to ask it of someone, so I'm going to ask it of you. Are you aware that myself, I don't know about other committee members, but I've been contacted by staff members of my local university to vote for this bill. Are you aware of that? Am I aware of
▶ Play
personal correspondence between you and staff members at a university? No, sir, I am not.
▶ Play
You know, you are such a jokester. I'm just asking the question, yes or
▶ Play
no. No, I am not aware of that. Thank you, sir. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Well, I guess my concern is that if you can allow, if the state can allow or even suggest to people that they bring guns to class with them as teachers, the next step is to require them to do so because then they'll have a duty to protect these students rather than to teach. That's a concern. Wouldn't you agree? I would agree, sir. Thank
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:23:47
you. Are there any other questions? Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you for your time, Mr. Chairman. Anyone for the bill that would like to speak for the bill? Aaron Giggson, does that sound right? Against the bill. State
▶ Play
Speaker 283 2:24:09
your name and you're recognized. Yeah, my name's Aaron Gibson. Sorry, my handwriting's not super fantastic. Anyway, I just want to actually discuss the three discussions Representative Collins presented at the beginning of his discussion. I actually have them all I can't hear you. I'm sorry, stay close
▶ Play
to the mic. We can't hear you. Sorry about that. Give an
▶ Play
Speaker 283 2:24:35
example there. So the first question Representative Collins posed was, is there a problem currently on our campuses in Arkansas? The answer to that question is absolutely not. Between the years of 2001 and 2013, there were a total of four gun-related deaths on an Arkansas education campus. None of these deaths would have been avoided had there been concealed carry on that campus. And on that same point, during that same time period, from 2001 to 2013, you were more likely to be killed from a lightning strike in the state than you would have been to have been shot on a university in this state. So is there a problem? No. Second, if there was a problem, would this be an equitable solution to the problem? Also no. There is actually no, we keep talking about how, you know, these sorts of gun-free zones attract shooters. There is not a single shred of evidence that supports that. There's no single shred of evidence that deterrence is going to help prevent a mentally unstable person from coming and shooting up a campus. They are clearly there, they clearly are not going to be stopped by a person with a gun. They are there to, one, shoot people and then get shot themselves. Having guns on campus is not going to prevent them. And, you know, adding guns to the equation is simply going to make it more likely that innocent civilians are shot. And so finally, do the benefits outweigh the risks? Absolutely not. There are very little, if any, benefits of this bill, and the risks include increasing potential deaths of innocent civilians and decreasing pedagogical efficiencies of the classrooms. That's all. I'll open for questions.
▶ Play
Are there any questions? Thank you. Does anyone like to speak for the bill? I have Joel Anderson against the bill. You are recognized to come forward. If you would state your name and who you're with, you are recognized. You have two minutes and 28 seconds basically left for the against testimony. Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 288 2:26:42
Chairman, members of the committee, thank you. I'm Joel Anderson. I'm the Chancellor of the University of Arkansas at Little Rock, And it's certainly not my intention today to be contentious in any way, but hopefully to say some things that may result in better legislation for the people of Arkansas. I should say, first of all, that two years ago, Mr. Collins worked with us, and we appreciated that, and we appreciate the consultation he's done this year. I'm sorry that we've not come out together on it again, but in any event, I want to thank him for that. I appreciate his commitment to public service as well as that of all of you around the table here today. And for the record, I ought to say that I grew up on a small farm out east of Swifton in northeast Arkansas, and guns were a big part of my life as I was growing up. So it's not a strange subject or a strange phenomenon at all to me. But I would ask you not to approve this legislation for a number of reasons, but I will try to translate on, to focus on just a couple of these. And I should say, first of all, that the presidents and chancellors who work at universities have children and grandchildren who go to college and who feel the issue of safety concerns there for their children just as much as anyone else. And I think it would be fair to say that in any given year, there's probably no group of people in the state of Arkansas that think more about issues of safety on campuses than they and their colleagues on campuses do. But I think that what I would particularly emphasize is that two years ago, the legislature gave boards of trustees discretion on this. I think that was very appropriate. These are individuals who are entrusted with the fates of the institutions. They are a cross-section of the people of Arkansas, and they get close to the campuses and the issues and problems that they deal with. And it was their judgment very broadly across the state that it would be better if campuses did not permit guns other than authorized law enforcement personnel. I would not be surprised if at some point in the future if that discretion remains there that some campus might make a different decision and so far as I'm concerned if they think that's best for that campus they're entitled to do that so I really think that the judgment of the trustees should be taken very seriously and that any other body should be very hesitant to substitute its judgment for that of the people who are given that direct responsibility. I want to mention one other concern that I have, and that is I do not want to have several hundred employees on campus carrying guns. From time to time, every president and chancellor, every vice president, every dean has someone across the desk from them that there's kind of mutual unhappiness, And there's a separation of the ways that needs to take place. You have 30 seconds to finish this up. Thank you, sir. Either side can be unhappy with the other. And I just think that if we have more guns in the hands of more people on campus, we're going to increase the likelihood that we have some deadly use of a gun that otherwise would not be taking place. So I would ask you to consider that. I'll stop with that, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Thank you. Rebson Gillum, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll ask the same question of you that I asked of Ms. Duckett earlier concerning UAMS's campus. Do you by chance have the security personnel to student and faculty percentage ratios? Mr. Speaker,
▶ Play
Speaker 288 2:30:44
I can tell you that we have 31 sworn officers of the law. We have 16 additional folks who are dispatchers and security officers who do not carry guns, and we have two administrative personnel for that group. I don't have ratios, and that would have to be calculated carefully because we have a limited on-campus resident student population. We have many, many commuters, so at any one point in time, the number varies. And, of course, we have evening classes as well, so the ratios, I can certainly develop those for you, but I don't have them as a sit-year. How many students do you have enrolled? This spring, we're just over 11,000.
▶ Play
Okay. And how many faculty and
▶ Play
Speaker 288 2:31:25
staff do you have? 1,300, round figure. Okay. And you
▶ Play
said you had, how many armed officers do you have? 31. 31.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you, sir. Appreciate it. Any other
▶ Play
questions, committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized. Yes. You indicated that you have a concern about the various employees that you have who may be disgruntled, who may have some concern about their employment status or their other working condition, and having guns in their position poses a great threat to the welfare and safety, at least a threat not necessarily great to the welfare of the supervisor. One of the young men mentioned that the chance of somebody being affected by a gun in the state of Arkansas is less than being struck by lightning. My observation is that a lot of people in the state have had situations such as that that you described and that that seems to be of a greater concern by far than arming people to work on campus. Would
▶ Play
Speaker 288 2:32:41
you agree with that? Well, I would, and I would be concerned not only for the supervisor who has an employee that may be disgruntled, but sometimes supervisors lose their cool as well. You know, sometimes they need to be replaced. I would have a concern sometimes about contentious situations between students and faculty. I think it's better if neither of them is armed in those circumstances. Thank
▶ Play
you, Chesner. Representative Bell, you are recognized. Thank you. Chancellor, back in 2013, when the first version of this was enacted, there were several news articles that indicated that the University of Arkansas at Little Rock had a policy advising students who might think they were about to become the victim of a rape, et cetera, to, and I quote at least one news article, of nod and try to move away as their defensive strategy. um that was recommended by according to the news articles i've looked at by the university safety expert was is that the policy of the university of arkansas at little rock um or you know are we back to throwing books and chairs well i can say
▶ Play
Speaker 288 2:33:58
that's not the policy of the university of arkansas at little rock i i don't i can't speak to that beyond that
▶ Play
Numerous news articles did quote the University of Arkansas at Little Rock So I'm trying to get the
▶ Play
Speaker 288 2:34:16
clarification here Well, if I may, what I would say in response is That our campus has a safety record That is on par with Fayetteville, Jonesboro, UCA And is often better in the FBI statistics year after year and we've not had anyone killed on the campus from a gun in 40 years. We've had one shooting seven or eight years ago, and that was an off-campus circumstance that just moved to a parking lot, and nobody was killed in that case. But
▶ Play
you're not aware of any such policy
▶ Play
Speaker 288 2:34:50
of nodding? No, no. I don't know where that would
▶ Play
have been picked up. Are there any other questions? if not thank you that is the end of our public audience comment and at this time Representative Collins, would you like to close for your bill?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, I would. And again, I appreciate the committee's indulgence in all the time I've taken today. As I said when I started, I tried not to suck up additional time by lining up the room with people to speak for the bill. For example, there's a group at the University of Arkansas called Students for Concealed Carry, and I'm sure they would have been interested in coming and other groups as well. But I think that if we think through these issues ourselves, we're going to be able to focus on the right things. I also listened as intently as I could to the people speaking against the bill, and there was one that went through what I believe are the central questions. In other words, when you separate the wheat from the chaff and all of the emotion as this issue clearly drives, But you really come back to those three questions, and I appreciated the one individual who spoke against the bill that top-lined those. And again, that first thing is, do we have a problem or not? Now, this individual said, no, we don't, that in Arkansas we don't have a problem, that mass shootings are not an issue. So he answered no to that question. Secondly, he said, is there any possibility of a deterrence? He said, no, if these people decide to murder our kids on campus, they're going to come in and murder them. and that's it. And then number three, he said, with regard to, you know, is the risk outweigh the benefits, you know, the risk clearly outweigh the benefits because of the risk for accidents and other things. If you agree with that, then of course I would expect you to vote against the bill. I just think that the evidence, frankly, in terms of what happens in our country is decidedly, I would say almost overwhelmingly on the other side. With regard to the notion of a situation we can all envision and are fearful of, as the Chancellor mentioned, of a conflict, a personal conflict, you know, in place, you know, in a classroom. Can I tell you for a fact that there will never be an accident? Just as no one can prove there will be one, I cannot prove there won't be one. But as Representative Hodges said in regard to a similar situation at the University of Arkansas almost 15 years ago, as Representative Letting brought up that we had at Alabama just three or four years ago, today, without allowing professors to have concealed carry, we have situations where there are difficult conflicts between members and people wind up getting shot and killed. So I agree those situations are tragic. I cannot sit here and tell you this is a panacea for that, but I can sit here and tell you that the absence of it doesn't work, and that's why we need to move forward with this. We're doing it in a very responsible way. We're taking a group of people that are concealed carry holders that have gone through a process that does not make them law enforcement. It has no intention of making law enforcement, and it gives them the zero prospect of being law enforcement. That's not what the concealed carry program is about. They're not doing police work. They're simply familiar with the concealed carry laws. They've had deep background checks. They understand where and how and what to do with their weapon, and it is not designed for them to become police officers, and there's no question that this has nothing to do with that at all. So in summary, Mr. Chair and committee, I would simply say we have an issue in the country, including Arkansas, of the potential for mass shootings in places like our college campuses where we have lots of innocents, where there's a gun-free zone, and these people can plan and plot and not have to fear about somebody stopping them. Number two, if we move forward with this bill and allow faculty and full-time staff who are on college campuses and have a concealed carry permit to have their weapon, we will have the potential to deter some of these folks from choosing our campuses to kill people. And number three, the way we've designed the bill, the exceptions we've put into the bill, put us in a position where the benefits will greatly outweigh the risk And with that, Mr. Chair, I'd appreciate a good vote. Mr. Lowry, you have a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:39:41
motion? Mr. Chair, I make the motion do pass.
▶ Play
As amended? As amended. We have a motion to do pass as amended. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. I didn't call it yet. I'm going to call the bill, fail. Roll call. Need two hands. I have two hands. Call the roll.
▶ Play
Speaker 302 2:40:20
Representative Letting. No. Representative Murdoch. No. Representative Deffenbaugh. Yes. Representative Harris. Yes. Representative Eubanks. Yes. Representative Ratliff Representative Gillum Representative Walker Representative Bell Representative Balz Representative Douglas Representative Lowry Representative McElroy Representative Armstrong Representative Gossage Representative Saban Representative Hodges Representative Gray Representative Lampkin
▶ Play
Speaker 313 2:41:22
Mr. Chairman, do you want to vote? Yes 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 If you only got 10 affirmative votes, it needs 11. It was 10-10, so it failed, I think.
▶ Play
Now it's for 10-10, I think. Hold on. Now it's with the tie. It's a tie vote. It takes
▶ Play
11 to pass. Motion fails. Thank you very much, committee, Mr. Chairman, for your time and attention.
▶ Play
Speaker 310 2:41:56
I don't think you have any other business today, sir.
▶ Play
Is there any other business for the committee? If not, I'll take a motion to adjourn. I have a motion to adjourn. All those in favor say aye. You're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1077

1:30 - 2:42:12 483 segments 43 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
77 segments
Speaker 11
1 segment
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
146 segments
Representative Jeremy Gillam Unverified
22 segments
Speaker 23
1 segment
Representative Reginald Murdock Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 40
1 segment
Speaker 43
18 segments
Representative Greg Leding Chair Unverified
11 segments
Chair Unverified
19 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
15 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
5 segments
Representative Mark D. McElroy Unverified
3 segments
Representative James Ratliff Unverified
1 segment
Representative John W. Walker Chair Unverified
25 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
4 segments
Representative Justin T. Harris Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 139
1 segment
Representative Nate Bell Chair Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 189
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
1 segment
Dean Patterson Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 217
1 segment
Paul Calvert Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 231
4 segments
Speaker 235
5 segments
Speaker 242
8 segments
Speaker 248
4 segments
Speaker 257
2 segments
Dan Greenberg Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 261
1 segment
Tom Coulter Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 266
2 segments
Speaker 269
1 segment
Speaker 270
4 segments
Ezra Smith Unverified
10 segments
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 246
1 segment
Speaker 283
6 segments
Speaker 288
18 segments
Speaker 302
2 segments
Speaker 313
1 segment
Speaker 310
1 segment