House Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (13)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB59
· 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…not here right now We're going to pass over House Bill 1268 Senate Bill 59, Senator Hutchinson he's supposed to be”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1114
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1114”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB198
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB198”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB199
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…e. Do pass. Representative Bennett is recognized to present Senate Bill 199.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB200
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…been passed out of committee do pass and then let's move on Senate Bill 200 Representative Bennett you're recognized to”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1203
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “is not here We're going to pass over House Bill 1203 We're going to pass over House Bill 1240 We're going to pas…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1208
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…at are going to run some bills for their Senate colleagues. House Bill 1208, Representative Gonzalez”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1240
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…going to pass over House Bill 1203 We're going to pass over House Bill 1240 We're going to pass over House Bill 1251 We're going to pas…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1251
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…going to pass over House Bill 1240 We're going to pass over House Bill 1251 We're going to pass over House Bill 1252 House Bill 1260, R…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1252
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…going to pass over House Bill 1251 We're going to pass over House Bill 1252 House Bill 1260, Representative Vines is not here right now…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1260
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…er House Bill 1251 We're going to pass over House Bill 1252 House Bill 1260, Representative Vines is not here right now We're going to…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1268
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…tative Vines is not here right now We're going to pass over House Bill 1268 Senate Bill 59, Senator Hutchinson he's supposed to be”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB164
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB164”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
I believe Representative Lowry is here to present House Bill 1114. Representative Lowry, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, committee. Good morning. House Bill 1114 is an answer to a problem that many of us voted on in the last session. We approved photo voter ID in the 2013 session.
We did so as a statute. As you know, the Supreme Court overturned the bill based on or the act on constitutional grounds. I currently, as well as Senator King, have a referred constitutional amendment that has been filed that addresses, at least mine does, I had asked the Bureau to address Justice Corbin's decision and produce a constitutional amendment that would accordingly fit with that.
In the meantime, the best case scenario for anyone who believes that photo voter ID is necessary to protect the integrity of the ballot, we will have to wait until at least 2018 before it can be implemented. If it were referred out, the voters would vote on it in 2016. The earliest it could be implemented would be 2018. This bill that's before you today is an answer to what we can do to limit or hopefully totally eradicate any fraud in elections.
And it is referred to as creating the offense of criminal impersonation in an election. It applies to both an absentee ballot and also a real-time election day ballot if a person were to vote in the place of someone else and they were found out that they could be prosecuted under this Criminal Impersonation Act and it would be, the offense would be a Class C felony. That is the presentation of the bill and I'm free to answer any questions.
Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative, I'm looking at Section 2, and I've gone through it, and the only question I would have there is page 2, line 3, and it says vote in a city, county, state, or federal election. So it wouldn't be a crime in a school board election? Well, that's an excellent point.
I'm sure it's less of a chance since, you know, the half dozen people who show up for school board elections might notice if a different person showed up. That is an excellent point
and I think something that is worthy of amending. Yes. Thank you. If I could have a follow-up. If you could, I'm going to make this, I'm going
to be generous and let you, I'm going to give you an open-ended question so you can tell it the way you want to tell it.
Perjury generally is, I'd like to know your motivation for changing the knowledge requirement in perjury generally. This is a major change, this is a change in concept of perjury that goes back to the English common law. Why
is that necessary here? Well, we're not changing perjury laws as they currently fit. We are just adding a new section of where perjury guidelines or perjury penalties could
be applied, and it would be in this section of creating the new offense of criminal impersonation.
Okay, but unfortunately, you had Section 553.102. B, lack of knowledge and materiality of the statement is not a defense, and that applies to the perjury statute generally. It doesn't say it's only for the subsection.
It says it's for this section. It just said, however, what it does specifically say.
Okay, so you're referring to B that lack of knowledge and materiality of the statement is not a defense under this section as a reference to but this is a reference to section 1 of this bill not of the section of criminal code. That's I understand
your interpretation but lack of knowledge and materiality, this is language that's going to go in the code
and it's going to use the word under this section and when I read the code, I'm not going to know that you are referring to section one of the bill. I'm
going to be thinking it reflects the section of the code. Well, and I certainly understand the point you're making. Legislative intent obviously would be taken into account with code revision that this is referring to the issue of criminal impersonation and not the perjury statutes, per se. Thank you.
Vice Chairman Wright, you are recognized for a
Speaker 2
5:25
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Lowry, I have a few issues with this. Representative Whitaker hit on a couple of them. One, I believe you are totally changing perjury. I have a question on page 1, line 28 that says applies for an absentee ballot for a county, state, or federal election in a name other than his or her own name. How would that affect somebody going in by getting an absentee ballot for a family member that may not be able to go? Or a service member that may not be
able to go? Well, in current law, that is allowed. This
is referring to applying for the absentee ballot for you to prepare in someone else's name, not just picking up the ballot or authorizing that the absentee ballot be sent. Okay. I think that's a little contradictory, but then to go
Speaker 2
6:14
one step further, why do we need that and then why do we need line second page one through five, the offense of criminal impersonation when we already have voter fraud? We're enhancing the penalties.
You're talking about current voter fraud? Correct. Okay, which is a misdemeanor? The current statute Title 7 says that it's a misdemeanor And so those of us who believe That the ballot should be protected Believe there should be more of a deterrent So are you going to do away with voter fraud And replace it with
Speaker 2
6:49
criminal impersonation Because we've got two So then if you have both still in place Is it going to be criminal impersonation A class C felony Or is it going to be voter fraud And when making that decision How are we going to decide
Well I guess that would be up to the prosecutor
of whether they're going to charge under one or the other. I'm going to, at this point, save the committee a lot of time because I think the points Representative Whitaker have already made about the exclusion of school board and then also the question about under this section. Obviously, there need to be some changes. I'd like to make those changes and then bring the bill back. Without
objection, I'll allow you to pull down the bill. Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you.
We've got several bills scheduled to run. I'm just going to start at the top of the agenda, and if someone's here to run the bill, we'll try and run it. We may have to wait for a little while. We've got some other people that are going to run it, or maybe some people here that are going to run some bills for their Senate colleagues. House Bill 1208, Representative Gonzalez
is not here We're going to pass over House Bill 1203 We're going to pass over House Bill 1240 We're going to pass over House Bill 1251 We're going to pass over House Bill 1252 House Bill 1260, Representative Vines is not here right now We're going to pass over House Bill 1268 Senate Bill 59, Senator Hutchinson he's supposed to be
coming down to run that I believe so we'll pass over for the time being All right, we're going to turn over to page two of the agenda.
I understand Representative Bennett is going to run some bills for Senator Woods. Is that correct? So, Representative Bennett, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 198. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
members of the committee. I'm running these bills on behalf of Senator Wood and I would ask at this time Donna Tyler from the Department of Community Corrections to join me to explain these with your
permission. Ms. Tyler, you're recognized. State your name and who you represent and
you can make your statement. I'm Donna Tyler, Deputy Director of Arkansas Community Correction. Thank you, Mr. Mr. Chairman and members of the committee, Senate Bill 198 is a just-in-case bill, basically. The Department of Correction already has authority to enter into pie agreements. There is one operating now at the McPherson unit where they make wire harnesses, the female
inmates do. They are hired by a private company who pays them a wage, and out of that wage, then money Money is withheld to pay restitution and fees and if they have family obligations. The rest of it is put into an account for them to use when they get out or for whatever their purposes are. We do not have this on the community correction side, and with our efforts in reentry, we think that maybe someday someone, some private company, might want to enter into an agreement
with us where they would employ our residents at a transitional living center or a re-entry center or parolees. And if this comes along, we want authority to be able to at least explore that. Right now, no one has made such an offer, and probably putting this in statute would mean nobody ever would. But if one comes along, we would like to be able to explore it. Any questions from the committee?
Okay, and no one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Bennett, are you closed for your bill? I am. I recommend do pass. Okay, we have a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Passed out of committee. Do pass. Representative Bennett is recognized to present Senate Bill 199.
Senate Bill 199 gives the Community Corrections Department an ability to issue a warrant if there's an escape. I think we all would agree that that's a good idea. I recognize or I'd like to ask Diana Tyler to address the bill if anybody has questions.
Ms. Tyler, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. This is to correct what is an oversight from when the agency was created in 1993. The Department of Correction has the authority to issue what are basically fugitive warrants
in case someone escapes so that any law enforcement officer anywhere can arrest them. That wasn't extended to community correction in 1993. Occasionally we do have a walkaway because we're minimum security. and I will say this there has always been a warrant issued and this would that's all I'm going to say there's always been a warrant issue but this would give us clear cut authority to issue that retaking warrant that's it Any questions?
Representative Tosh you're recognized for a question Thank you Mr. Chair I just want to make
sure no way this would delay the apprehension of the No sir not at all This would just authorize anyone, anywhere to arrest him, any other law enforcement, on that warrant. It can go all over
the country. Okay, so I just wanted to make sure it wasn't going to jeopardize. No. Okay, no further questions.
I see no further questions, and no one has signed up to speak for or against. Representative Bennett, are you closed for this bill?
pass, please. Okay, we have a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? this bill has been passed out of committee do pass and then let's move on Senate Bill 200 Representative Bennett you're recognized to
present Senate Bill 200 Thank you Mr. Chairman again I'm presenting this for Senator John Wood this is a change to allow for administrative transfer
between the Department of Corrections and Community Corrections this will help with some of our burdens on the prison and place people in the appropriate facility won't change the standards or anything else for their sentences. And I'd ask Donna Tyler to address any questions that you have. Ms. Tyler, you
recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This bill is just to enhance our efforts at reentry where the state is concentrating very much and needs to
in order to cut down our recidivism. What we want to be able to do is to create a pathway from ADC to ACC to community correction as an inmate nears the end of their sentence so that we can concentrate on getting them ready to go home. It will be program and job skill heavy. What we want to do is concentrate on getting a job, holding a job, how to apply for a job, how to dress for a job, and give them work skills.
plus keep working on their anger management issues and their decision-making. We think this would be a really good step toward lowering recidivism. We have said in here that the program will be at least six months because that's what we're going to start with. It may turn out that we need to actually lengthen that program, and this gives us a little bit of flexibility to be able to make the program longer. It will move people out of ADC into our re-entry centers if they're funded, and we're very hopeful that they will be so that we can concentrate on this.
Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Tyler, I've had a little
bit of experience with this. Isn't it true this is also quite a savings transition to these people out? We would not only create or undo the logjam in the prisons, but also be quite a savings,
correct? Yes, sir. It wouldn't erase the logjam, but we're asking for 500 reentry beds, and the cost of those will be at least we project it to be just over $30.
The current cost per day in ADC is 63 and change. So we think that this definitely will save money, and we also think it will be very effective. Great. Thank you so much. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I forgot to tell you, good to
see you again, Ms. Tyler. Thank you. It's good to be here. Yeah. Just want to make sure, I know there's a program that I've been very interested in. I want to make sure this is the same one. Is this the same one that has been referred to as the step-down program?
That's exactly correct. That's what this
is. It's a step-down. I just wanted to make sure there wasn't going to be a, there wasn't a conflict in what I was, in
my thinking as to which program it was. No, sir. and a lot of this goes hand in glove with the findings of the Act 1190 committee that this legislature passed in 2013, which mandated that our agency and a bunch of agencies concentrate on reentry because we truly have too many people coming back to prison.
Our recidivism rate dependent on the year is between 42% and 44% returning within three years. that is way too high, and we're hoping to be able to cut down on that because that leaves some beds open for the new commitments. And this bill does
give you the flexibility to adjust the six months to what you feel necessary once you begin the program? Yes, sir. No further questions.
Seeing no other questions, we don't have anybody who's signed up for or against. Representative Bennett, are you closed for your bill?
this. Okay, we have a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Bill is passed out of committee. Do pass. Thank you. We're going to move back to page one and take up Senate Bill 59.
Senator Hutchinson, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 59. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senate
Bill 59, I don't know how many of y'all have ever served on the Claims Committee before. I've been on it the last four years, and for that entire time,
I've been asking the director of the Claims Committee to bring us some type of opinion or statement of facts. Let me explain how this system works. I see some new faces out there in the committee. So the state of Arkansas has civil immunity. You cannot sue the state in circuit court. so what to try to provide some remedy for those who may have been harmed by a state actor we set up a claims commission and so you can instead of suing in the courts you file a complaint with the
claims commission the claims commission is appointed by the governor they review all these claims and they issue a ruling either party can appeal that ruling to the legislative claims Committee and we are like a quasi-appellate review entity. The frustration I've had is that we'll get these reports and rulings from the Claims Commission and it says denied or rejected, awarded this amount of money and initially that was all we got.
After some complaining, they would include a paragraph as to why they did what they did. But there's nothing really to review. There's no record. There's no transcript. There's no statement of facts. There's no opinion. And so it's essentially requiring the Claims Committee to have another whole hearing and the parties having to come back and put on testimony and witness and witnesses. It's a very inefficient system. But worse than that, it's not providing very good justice, I don't think.
So after asking for four years that the Claims Commission do this and being denied for four years, I decided to file a bill requiring them to do it. They are okay with it. There's a new director who's very cooperative, and I've been very impressed with her and talked to the chairman and a couple other Claims Commissioners, They're okay with the legislation.
Senator, one question I have with regard to the findings of fact that the commission will put together, would it preclude them from even setting up a system where they might have an attorney involved say we find in your favor, submit proposed findings for our review and consideration?
Very good question. I've got a bill in Representative House's Personnel Committee for the Claims Commission
to hire an attorney to draft these statements of facts or opinions. That, I think, would be the ideal way to do it. But absent, even if we fail in getting them an attorney, I think they need an attorney regardless just for sake of justice. But if we don't get them an attorney, chairman is correct, the claims commission can ask the prevailing party's attorney to draft the statement of facts, and then they'll pass it to the opposing counsel for review,
and ultimately the claims commission will accept it or not. So there does not have to be any additional staff or expense to carry out the intents of the
questions, Representative House, you're recognized for a question. Senator, I disagree
with your bill, and here's why. And I'm asking you a question.
all cases referred to the claims commission are referred to the claims commission because the state is barred by the from suit because of the doctrine of sovereign immunity is that not correct so a legal determination in all case if it were made is that the state is not liable because it is the taxpayers that would have to make a decision whether to fund the schools or pay a claimant is that essentially it correct so the claims commission may I have liberty mr. chair
yes and for the committee's reference we don't call for questions questions are it may be accepted by the presenter at the time on occasion I may ask if there are questions but just for
clarification so if you have a question get our attention okay but I'll give
you the liberty to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The commissioners themselves at the claims commission are not necessarily lawyers or judges, are they? Correct. And claimants present claims
to the commission as a matter of conscience. It's just not right that I should suffer these damages, whether it's a matter of law. It's just a matter of right and wrong in the state of Arkansas ought, in fairness, to pay me. Is that a fair
do? I would say it's similar to a claim of equity, but you're correct. There's no rules of civil procedure, or it's not the standard courtroom.
But I do think the laws of equity, I would compare it to case inequity. But if we're going, and this
is a question that's somewhat argumentative, but why do we need to follow legal procedures in the Claims Commission rather than just abolish it altogether and let it go to court if we're going to follow
to be honest with you, but because we're expected to review whatever they do.
regardless if it's based on law or based on equity based on the mood of the commission that day whatever they do we are authorized and required to review it if there's an appeal we don't have we don't follow we don't have precedents and Lexis sitting up there searching case law when we're reviewing those cases either and the claims committee is also comprised of mostly non-attorneys.
So I'm not trying to change the standard. I'm trying to convert this into a courtroom with all the rules of evidence and requiring citations. But what I am trying to do is give us something to review, as opposed to a de novo hearing where they have to come back and we're hearing it for the very first time. And that is unfair to the parties, and it's inefficient, and I don't think it reaps justice either.
And I think we are pursuing justice. It may not be the same rules as a courtroom, but I think we are trying to achieve justice for our citizens, knowing with knowledge that this is taxpayers' dollars that we're awarding. And right now I think it is neither efficient nor is it fair, and it does not produce the best form of justice that we can do given the limitations. One last question. Two scenarios very similar.
A state trooper is pursuing a suspect at a very high rate of speed, loses control of his automobile, crashes into someone, causes death and injury. Damage. A state trooper, second scenario, a state trooper is driving down the road, texting on his cell phone, talking to her girlfriend, boyfriend and runs a stop sign has an accident and causes injury and damage and death what are the rules of justice or what are the rules of law that cover
that situation in in either scenario and one the state trooper is carrying out a mandate of government something he is authorized to do that is dangerous and does cause sometimes accidents, but it's a government function, while on the other hand, she is basically operating as a private citizen operating an automobile on the streets. Now, law would say ordinary rules of negligence might apply in that case.
So, when you start dealing with sovereign immunity and the rules of law, what is the distinction to be made by non-lawyers sitting on the commission without the benefit of a counsel, without the benefit of counsel on both parties, without a complete staff, investigation, introduction of evidence according to the rules of evidence, how can they do this without this being a court? Well, I share your concerns.
I don't think it's a very good system that we've established, and I'm trying to make an improvement to it. But I think it's still flawed. And I'm not asking for an opinion, a judicial opinion or legal opinion, to be written and provided. It's merely a statement of facts, saying what testimony they relied upon, what was stated, the facts of the case, something for us to be able to, without having to call up every witness again,
They can say, Witness A said the following, which I had much credibility, and based on that we've determined. So I'm not asking for them to cite legal opinion or just simply a statement of facts. But I'd share your concern. I think this is going to make it better, but there is still a – I think we could do a lot, lot better in providing justice to the people of Arkansas than we're currently doing with our current system.
Thanks, Mr. Chair. Senator Hutchinson, I have a couple more questions just to make sure that for my benefit and maybe the committee's as to the procedure of the Claims Commission. Your bill applies basically when a claim is disposed of, either by dismissal or final deducation by the commission. Is that correct? And there is an appeal. And there's an appeal of that decision. but it would cover the waterfront as far as the commission's through with
it. Correct, except inmates. I don't require them to write a statement of facts if an inmate appeals
because that happens a lot. And even before the claims commission, oftentimes there are attorneys involved in the presentation of the case, both for the claimant and the state actor that's before the commission. The
state always has attorneys, and most of the time the claimant
does as well. And then the legislature, our task then is upon a dismissal, the claimant could appeal to the General Assembly. Is that correct? Correct. Does that go to claims subcommittee? Correct.
Okay. And upon an adjudication, if there was an award of damages, we still have to approve the award. Is that correct? That is also correct. And that goes to claims subcommittee? It does, and then it goes to the full budget committee. And we approve either, it's usually all in one bill, that we approve sometime towards the end of the session. What does the Claims Subcommittee, and I think this is what your bill is addressing, ultimately what does the Claims Subcommittee look at or receive as you review either an appeal of a dismissal
or the actual adjudication from the commission? Is it the same in both instances? Do you get the same information? So
we get the same information regardless. Each case is extremely different. Sometimes the parties will submit to us stacks of documentation, but it's up to the parties to do that. And sometimes they don't submit anything,
and we've literally got one paragraph to try to review. but there is no opinion no statement of facts from the actual commission who ruled on initially and
do you get the claims commission's complete file on the case I don't believe so because it's always different
I believe it's the parties have an opportunity our staff calls the parties and they have an opportunity to present documentation
and then finally and I appreciate you answering my questions but I wanted to, for my benefit and everybody's benefit, to understand the process. Your bill, with regard to these findings, in fact, and conclusions of law, there's not going to be any precedential value in the document itself. The subcommittee or, as the General Assembly, we could completely disregard anything that's said in there. What your bill is aimed to do is provide at least kind of some guidance or help to educate as to what you're looking at.
Is that correct? That is absolutely correct. Okay, thank you. Representative Ferrari, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. I think in a roundabout way you just asked my question, for those that aren't attorneys in here, all you're asking for is clarification of what the committee before you said in a written form so you can make a decision. That's
it. Okay, thank you. Representative Vines you're recognized for a question Thank you Mr.
Chair Senator I just want to make sure I'm clear
because I think I sat on that with you one of our sessions together when we're doing these findings of facts are the claimants going to have any opportunity these findings of facts are going to come from the commission correct so then will the claimant have will they have an opportunity to inject impose say anything or would they have to submit their own and i mean is that going to play into this
in any way well i mean they'll have every opportunity to they could submit their own they can submit anything they want to submit sure so they could submit an alternative uh finding of facts are they going to provide that
to us they'll be able they'll have the opportunity to um i mean it's like an i'd consider it like any appeal i mean the judges circuit court's going to issue an opinion but the appellate and appellant are both going to submit briefs, and those opportunities will still exist for the and they'll have a chance to review the opinion and make edits and propose alternative and then the contradictions and then, as you know, the commission will decide which version they want to issue officially.
Okay. I was just, like I said, been in there and we have had some issues with getting the rest of the story, so to speak, so I was just curious how we were going to apply that because typically we have a court or anything. We both have the opportunity to do that.
So I appreciate it and thank you for clearing that up. Representative Broadway, did you have a question? No,
sir. Okay. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Just two questions about the procedure. Would a copy of this be available to both parties, I assume?
Oh, sure. A copy of it will be sent to them before it's ever sent to the legislature, and they'll have a chance to make suggestions or edits or so they'll be very involved in the drafting of the document and they'll certainly
have copies. And then I guess my second question is, you know, the concept of statement of fact and conclusion of law is kind of a term of art legally. If we don't have attorneys involved, I wonder if the, you know, something about finding of fact and conclusions
and leave the of law, because of law kind of makes it sound like somebody's siding to legal cases and making a legal determination as opposed to a non-attorney making a determination. Well, if somebody is without counsel, first
of all, I doubt the commission would ask them to draft this. But if they did, we're not an official appellate court where there are standards. And if you don't meet these standards, we're not going to accept this.
Whatever we get, we get. And some of them may be very well written. Some of them may be terrible. But it's better than nothing. So that would be an unfortunate situation, but it would not harm either party, even if they were without counsel. If they were asked to, which I hope they wouldn't be, but if they were, they could draft whatever they wanted to draft. And if it was of little value to us, it's better than having nothing like we currently have.
Representative House, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator, I was listening to your answers to the other questions, and is it a fair statement to say that you presuppose that the Arkansas Rules of Civil Procedure now be imposed on the Claims Commission about who's going to present, who's going to have lawyers, what the conclusions of law are going to be? It all sounds like stuff that you and I know as the Arkansas Rules of Civil Procedure. Is that what you're saying? No.
I'm trying to add a little more professionalism if you want to call it that but I'm certainly not requiring them to adopt the rules of civil procedure the rules of evidence I mean it's still going to be a claims commission with non-lawyers hearing the cases and at least a lot of them are non-lawyers and the only thing I'm taking one portion of the rules of civil procedure and asking them to comply with that but certainly not asking
to comply with the entire rules of civil
procedure I see no further questions no one has signed up for or against Senator Hutchinson do you want to close for your bill please I'm done this had no questions in the senate I might that's not surprising I knew I'd open myself up for that one.
Representative Broadway, you recognize for a motion? Do pass. We have a motion. Do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Your bill is passed out of committee with a recommendation. Do pass. Thank you. I have another one. Would you rather me come back? I didn't think that would take very long. Let's see. Senate Bill 164.
Is that the one you want to present? Yes. Okay. Senate Bill 164. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. This is a very large bill, but let me ease your concerns. Most of it's just striking language. The bill does two things. it as you all are probably familiar i know represent vines is familiar we've had several schools in our state have a security program school safety program that involved having
their school personnel go get a private security guard license and with that license they were authorized to carry a weapon some some schools do it different some keep the weapons in a lock some allow teachers some do not some but we've had several schools doing that some for decades there a few couple years ago the board the private licensing security board said we're
not going to allow that anymore they grandfathered in the schools that were currently doing it but any new applications were denied and the schools who are currently doing it have until October October, their grandfather clause dies as well, and they'll no longer be able to continue the program that they've had for decades at times. So this bill sets up a mechanism by which those programs continue. I will say this is not ideal to have school personnel with guns and acting as security
officers. Ideally, we'd have a resource officer in every school, and this wouldn't have to be addressed. But we don't have the funds to do that, and the schools don't have the funds to do that. Some schools have a 40-minute response time from their sheriffs, and it is unconscionable and unacceptable to allow an active shooter in a school to have 40 minutes to execute as many kids and teachers as that shooter can. So this just gives options to the schools.
It allows them to make a decision for themselves. It does require more training. Right now there's only training that's required of any private security guard. I believe schools in that setting requires additional specific training for how to, first of all, try to de-escalate violence. And then it is chaos when you're in a school and kids running around on thin walls that bullets can go through. So there's a lot of unique factors to that environment. This bill has the state police establish a curriculum for those schools to receive training and continue training.
Now, as I said, there's no law requiring that right now, but the schools that currently have this type of a program have, on their own accord, established very significant and strict training requirements, and this bill would not address what they're currently doing because they are going beyond the call of duty and training their people. But we do put in code that for future schools who may not have the same conscience as these schools do,
that they have to follow state law. The rest of the bill simply abolishes the board. And there is a lot of reasons for that. I've FOI'd a lot of their decisions, and I hate to go into nitty-gritty details because I don't want to cast aspersions on people, but it is a board that has not been following the law, to be quite frank,
and granting people licenses who do not legally qualify for a license, including two months ago granting a sex offender license to go into people's homes and over the objection of the state police. So the state, this is merely a, I mean, there's no interpretation. The law says if you don't have a criminal background, if you don't have a criminal record, you're authorized to get these license, go through the training, you get these licenses.
The state police is already doing all that work, checking the criminal background check, doing everything. They make recommendations to the board, and the board waits 90 days sometimes and has a meeting, and the applicants are having to be delayed and delayed and delayed. And then when the board does meet, it's a crapshoot as to whether or not they're going to follow the law. So that's the purpose for abolishing the board. It's not necessary. The state police is already doing it and is fully capable of doing it.
It saves a little money for per diem, but the state police has already been burdened with all the staff work, and they can continue doing that and actually makes it more efficient for the applicants because they don't have to wait 90 days or 120 days for
a board to meet. So that's a bill. Representative
Armstrong, you're recognized for a question. Who governs the board? They're governor's appointees,
but nobody governs them. So like the medical board or the nurses' association board or the pharmacist's board,
if a pharmacist is taking too many pills that he's also prescribing, they're required to pay fines, go through extensive rehab, take regular drug testing in order to have their licenses reinstated. You're telling me our governor, whomever that may be, appoints these members to this board and nobody governs them and they're just able to run ruck shop and that's the reason we're abolishing it as opposed to regulating the board and putting tighter restraints. It's one of the
reasons we're abolishing it. The other one is it's unnecessary and
inefficient and unlike other boards where there may be some interpretation or qualifications that require some expert review if you pass a criminal background check and you take the training, you get a license. They've been taking people who do qualify, they pass a criminal background check, they do the training, the state police recommends license,
and the board will deny them because I don't want to impose motivation, but they'll deny those who are qualified and make exceptions, which they don't have the authority to make exceptions in law, but they do make exceptions to those who are not qualified legally. So in the abolishing language, there are no
rules or standards or best practices or guidelines for these board members to follow in order for – I just don't want us to get in the wake of – well, first of all, I guess, let me back up.
Does the governor want this done? Is he okay with it? He's okay with it. Okay. His
see more boards maybe be abolished if they're not governing themselves accordingly. Is that the assumption that I should take
from this? Well, I think if we have boards who are not following the law repeatedly and they've been called on it and continue to fight the law,
then yes, they should be abolished or reconstituted or something. I just think before
we, and it's my own personal opinion, but we'll meet about it on Monday. I'm sure you'll give me an earful. But before we do away with them, we set them up for a purpose, and they should have rules, regulations, guidelines, or they should get kicked off the board if they're not. Well, they don't have that, but they have
Speaker 109
46:39
statutes that they're supposed to follow that they do not follow, so I don't know why we think they'd follow additional rules. Well, then
we should just kick them off, but thanks a lot, Senator.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Senator. Many of these 87 pages also cover things like polygraph exams, voice stress analysis, burglar alarms. Could you briefly enlighten us why all these amendments to how that's done are included
in this bill? I asked the state police
to look it over, and those were the recommendations from the state police. Updating some things, if they're going to take on the responsibility, they wanted to clean up some stuff. So that's all their language, and I think it's all clean up. They took this chance to make some changes in the law that needed for a while. So just so
that their comfort level with becoming the new administrators of all of this stuff suddenly is higher.
They're very comfortable. More confident they can perform these duties. Yes. Thank you.
Great. Seeing no further questions, we do have a few individuals who have signed up to speak against the bill. The first is Jordan Brown. Mr. Brown, if you want to take a seat at the end of the table.
Next is Senator Hutchinson there. And if you'll state your name and who you're speaking on behalf of, and then you
may make your statement. My name is Jordan Brown, and I'm representing the Arkansas Security Alarm Association. We're an association of about 90 alarm companies throughout the state. And I would like to speak against this bill. I have served on this licensing board in the past. I've been the chairman of it, and I would like representation on that board. To do away with the board means that I have to answer to somebody who doesn't have to
follow the same rules that I do. There is an appeal process in the rule or in the law, I'm sorry, in the law. If you look in the stricken language, 17-40-351, letter C, the applicant may appeal the decision and we're talking about the denial of registration, and then when you get into the rules, it talks about how to appeal the process. So I don't feel that the Board is breaking any laws at all by hearing an appeal of a denied applicant, that they are simply following the process that's laid out in the law and
then in the Board rules and regulations. I think I probably send a lot of you an email. Thank you to those of you who have read it. But again, to us, this is very much taxation in the form of licensing fees without any representation at all. And now we just have this director or whoever he may appoint creating the laws and the rules that we now have to follow. We would simply like a say in those rules. And I would entertain any questions. And thank you, sir, for replying to my email.
MR. Seeing no questions, thank you, Mr. Brown, for your statement today. Last on the list, we have, is it Randy Perry? Mr. Perry, if you'll take a seat at the end of the table, state your name and who you represent, and then you may make your statement.
Thank you, board. Listen, my name is Randy Perry. I'm a vice president of a company called Guardtronic. I'm also the evil board member that's been referred to.
I'm a current board member appointed by the governor. I have been married for 40 years, close to 40 years now, so I think I'm pretty stable. I've served in the military. I've retired the National Guard as a first sergeant, served overseas in the war duties. I've got 35-plus years experience in the alarm industry, and now what I'm seeing is something that was basically, I guess, put out for some parliamentary reason last year that just ran forth and suddenly came back again, and I did not have a chance to get to the Senate to speak to it
or there would have been questions asked, Mr. Hutchinson. There would have been some questions asked for you, sir. And I've seen this, and I've seen you say that bad things are done. First of all, the board does not see anybody that does not receive a denial. And in honor of that, they also do approve stuff like right now there's companies that come out and try to produce training materials for alarm companies to follow what they have to do for levels of training, which the state has established over the years.
Many years ago, it was just a wild, wild west setup, and this has provided a very good forum to bring people in, get people adjudicated out, and bring forth and have some very, very good things happen to it. And I've been, you know, I don't know how some people have been associated with it. I've only been on the board this one time, but I've been worked with it for over 20-plus years. So I'm pretty well aware of what's came from the board, what's gone out from the board, and it's been very beneficial. For a real quick example, If we throw anybody out that says they did not do a Class A misdemeanor, okay.
There was a man in California, 64 years of age, that came before us at 64 years of old. He came forth, and he was denied by the fact that at 18, he gave a girlfriend a drink of beer that was 17. That was a Class A misdemeanor. By the way, the state states that he's thrown out, no more discussion, out he goes. The man had no more issues in his entire life, no more reports, no more thing. So, yes, he was granted a license to be a security officer. And I think that's a very equitable thing we have to do.
And to take it out of a board that you have people right now, the board of the seven members, four are already within the police officers group already. So to say that they don't understand what's coming up, what's being said, is really, I think, a little less appropriate. And I, as a fairly stable individual, managing the company, I've had a pretty good idea that I can manage several things myself. And I was appointed by the governor, the past governor. I believe the current governor would not have any problem with me on that board either.
Of what I've done, where I've been. There's things that have came up before, and there is questions that have come up. Every case is individual. And now you're going to put one individual, whoever that may be, non-elected, appointed, to take over a situation, revamp, re-change, rewrite, redo something that's not completely broke. If there's a particular issue, I'm all for changing. But to say this, just throw out everything, to me, folks, it would be almost like saying one of your representatives brought forth a bill somebody didn't like.
Well, let's get rid of all the House, get rid of all the Senate, and let's have the government do all the decision-making. There's a point where that leaves us away from being representative of what we're required to do. I know it's a little bit stretched on that point, but that's the way I feel. And honestly, I wouldn't have got up at 4.30 this morning and drove down here if this was not important to me. I have a business to run, so I've got to go back and forth, and I do serve as a willingness to be there, and I'm more than happy to come here, and I really do thank some representative. There was a Micah Neal who helped me come here, and Mr. Bobal Ballinger,
which I've known for a long time, allowed me to find how to get here to make my statements. I do want to thank them personally for their time, that they allowed me to get here, and I do want to thank the judges here for hearing at least my time and
my moans and groans. Thank you very much. Representative Tosh,
you're recognized for a question Thank you, Mr. Chair Were you serving on the
board a year ago, sir? No, I served here I started here in January this year
Are you familiar with the fact that that board last year passed a restriction or a rule that stated that people that also was applying for a security license had to have a federal background check. Also, if they were applying for a private investigator's license, had to have a federal background check. And when this was questioned by the board, to the board, as to why a person that was applying for a duplicate license
had to have two separate background checks and pay two separate fees, and they changed this last year, and no one could give an explanation that is a burden on people out here it's an extra expense on people and those are the type of the decisions that was coming out of that board that affected people out here that was simply trying to start a small business or trying to make a living and it never made sense to anyone the state police had no control over that situation because this was a change made by that board are you familiar with that at all i said and listened to part of
No, sir, I'm not aware of it completely, but I do know part of it had to do with arrest or reciprocity issue between states. Not all states recognize training coming from someone else at different levels, of which you try to establish a general outline for everybody. Now, I'm not trying to make a statement for that exact issue, and I apologize, because I don't know all the details. If I had the minutes, I'd be happy to look it back up and give you a little more rendition of my own that. But, no, sir, I'm one not have extra. I would like to give it away with all having to redo our fingerprints every two years.
State of Oklahoma, you do fingerprints once and you're done. But that's been required. We have to do that. And as far as that one goes, I know there's also, sir, there's always an AG staff there present at every meeting, and they give their input, output, if there's something that strikes them odd or where, the board then will listen and hear that also. And I don't remember anything that was stirred up. Did there anything that would cause that? And, no, as a board member, I don't want to impose anything additional burning upon anybody.
But there sometimes becomes a question, and that's why an individual issue on how they were presented needs to be looked at. But I apologize
for not having a direct answer, sir. Well, that's okay. I appreciate you attempting to explain it. My point is simply this, that the board was making decisions that were overreaching and requiring further regulations on individuals out here and an added expense to them. And when questioned as to why, no one could really give an answer other than if it's just something they wanted to do. And I found that kind of odd that, you know, common sense wasn't being applied,
especially when we were trying to deal with helping people to start businesses and make a living, that they were being imposed with this extra expense. So I just wanted to know if you could explain that to me.
Well, I know there's – I'm sorry, I didn't mean to – if you'd like me to answer back, I'll try a little bit. I know there's also other people serving the board that are experts in those particular fields, and I am not an expert in that particular field. So I will look it over, and there are the laws there and also the standards there, and
we'll review those, sir. Thank you. Seeing no further questions, thank you for representing.
Okay, we've got one more person signed up to speak. Roger Martin. Okay. Thank you. May I close real quick? Sure, and I think we've got one more question for you. Okay. Well, I'll
take the question, I guess, then close. Representative
Armstrong, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator, how will this, you know, we're anticipating some other form of guns on campuses coming back, but how will this impact school security at this level,
and will this in any way allow for teachers to bear arms now? it will
allow each school district to determine that so it is most school districts do not allow teachers but there's an existing one that does and original draft I had did not allow for teachers but I did not want to I don't think it's ideal for teachers but I did not want to interrupt an existing security program for a school that has worked for them for numerous years so it
does allow those school districts to make that determination. Can
I follow up Mr. Chairman? So now that's a little bit deeper than I guess we'd like to go but if these teachers are allowed based off of this law will they know that they now have the option to bear arms if they meet the requirements to seal? No. It
is not like Representative Collins' bill in that any teacher cannot make a decision I'm going to carry you. I'm going to go down and get my license. I'm going to carry a gun.
the school has to select them. Superintendent, school board, whoever it is, has to select them. Like the same resource officers. Like a resource officer. And then they will be granted, but they can't apply on their own to become a private security guard and then
carry on campus. One more, Mr. Chairman. I'm sorry. Are these resource officers required to go or undergo, and I don't know this, any specific additional training? Yes. Okay.
They will be. The state police will be designing a curriculum.
I don't want to put it in the law because it will change as needs change, but the state police is tasked with designing and maintaining a curriculum that's specific for schools and active shooter scenarios. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Senator. So just to close, first of all, I do not want to cast aspersions on any individual commissioner, And I don't know them, and I'm sure they're wonderful people. But I do know that they have been granting review and giving exceptions.
And the law says if you've got criminal background, you are not entitled to a license. Now, if they want to come to the legislature and have us change the law to where we allow misdemeanors or after so many years, then they'd be entitled to do that. But right now the law says you can't, and they're ignoring the law and granting additional licenses, saying the law is not fair. Well, the law is the law, and, again, that's where our job is to address that,
not to have commissioners ignoring it and granting. And some of them have not been a misdemeanor offense from 20 years ago. Some of them are on the sexual offenders list and now being allowed to go into people's homes. There is an appeals process with the state police. The state police, just like they have one for concealing it. Representative Tosh probably knows better than I do, but just like they have one for concealed carry, if you get denied, you have an appeals process, a hearing judge. That same process exists.
If this bill were to pass, they would have an appeals process and be able to be heard. But the state police would simply be applying the law, and if the industry wants us to change the law, then they can come down and ask us to but the law is the law and it should be followed and I appreciate a good
vote Thank you Senator Hutchinson What's the pleasure of the committee? Do pass Representative House you're recognized for a motion Okay we have a motion do pass
Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye Any opposed? Bill passes out of committee with a recommendation do pass all right committee we're going to go back to the agenda and I don't think we're going to have any other bills to run today but I want to go ahead and go through just to make sure I believe we were down to House Bill 1282 Representative Wright we're going to pass over that correct? yeah I was going to talk about it
House Bill 1283 Representative Wright we're going to pass over that Senate Bill 55, Senate Bill 56 those are Senator Woods we're going to pass over that We've already taken up Senate Bill 164, and then we've taken up Senate Bill 198 through 200. House Bill 1345, Representative Hillman, we're going to pass over that. House Bill 1349, Representative Harris, I don't see him. We're going to pass over that. House Bill 1351, Representative Broadway, we're going to run that next week.
Is that correct? And likewise for House Bill 1352. and then my house bill 1362 we're going to pass over that as well so I believe we have gone through all the bills currently on our agenda and I'll remind the committee we will have a special order of business Tuesday at 10 a.m. on house bill 1197 if you could hold on just a second
Representative Broadway, were you asking for a special order? Did you want a special order on yours, or is it sufficient that we just take it up on Thursday? I think you had somebody coming in. Okay, I just wanted to make sure we got it taken care of. Okay, so we'll have a special order on House Bill 1197 on Tuesday at 10 a.m. Seeing no further business without objection, we're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1114
SB198
SB199
SB200
SB59
SB164
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair
Unverified
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Speaker 2
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Representative Dwight Tosh Chair
Unverified
Representative Donnie Copeland
Unverified
Senator Jeremy Hutchinson
Unverified
Speaker 77
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Speaker 81
Representative Joe Farrer Chair
Unverified
Representative John T. Vines
Unverified
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Speaker 109
Jordan Brown
Unverified
Randy Perry
Unverified