House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (3)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HJR1001
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…on a minute i'm forgetting which what's resolution number? HJR 1001.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1006
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…h that, I'm going to go to the end of the table and present HB 1006. Representative Womack.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1003
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1003”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
I do want to bring the committee up to date on the constitutional amendments process and where we are with that. Not everybody was able to be with us last night when we kind of went through it. So we're going to begin hearing amendments in depth on Monday afternoon, 30 minutes after adjournment. The agenda is online. It has a list of all of the proposals. They do include, at least currently, it includes the shells, so that if people fill their shells in between now and committee, You'll know what's out there.
When we begin that on Monday, the intent right now is to kind of go through them and kind of get a sense from the committee of whether that's one that we need to carry forward or not. We won't probably have a formal motion, but we'll have some discussions. The idea by the end of next week is to have the 42-odd proposals that are out there narrowed down to a total of about five or six from each chamber.
So the Senate will bring five or six to the joint meeting, and the House will bring five or six to the joint meeting. They can be any mix of House bills or Senate bills. But that's the intent right now. So next week, all of you need to plan on a pretty stiff work schedule. Most days we'll be meeting in the afternoon for constitutional amendments purposes after session. So we'll begin that again Monday, 30 minutes after adjournment. If any of you have any questions on that process, I think I'll take just a minute
and see if anybody has any questions on exactly how we're doing that. Any questions from members on that? Okay, if you need more detail, get with me. Regarding today's agenda, we have the intent this morning, as I mentioned to Representative House on Wednesday, is to try to clear all of the proposals related to Article 5 off of our calendar. We need to be out of here about 9.55 to be able to be in chambers by 10 o'clock.
So I would ask that everybody move expeditiously. I know Representative Ballinger's proposal and my proposal were both heard in the interim and extensively debated. Freshmen haven't had an opportunity to hear them, but we'd like to give Representative House as much time as possible since his hasn't had that opportunity to be heard on his and try to move expeditiously through it. So I try to keep debate to a minimum if possible so we can get done. If we can get everything wrapped up this morning, I only know of one bill that's been asked to be heard this afternoon,
and that Representative Love has asked to hear his 1119 this afternoon. If we can get wrapped up this morning, it's my intent to postpone the afternoon meeting and hear that bill next week. So let's try to move on through this if we can so we can all, those of us who want to get on the road and get headed home can do that. So with that, I'm going to go to the end of the table and present HB 1006. Representative Womack.
Representative Bale, you're recognized to present your
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Committee, as most of you who aren't freshmen know, back during the interim we heard this, and I had a couple hours of discussion around it. This is a proposal that would, as Arkansas has done at least four times in the past,
call for an Article V amendment to the U.S. Constitution to provide for a balanced budget. This is a little more specific than those in the past in that it contains the full documentation of how that process will work, what that amendment is, and exactly how it functions. Arkansas currently participates in at least 33 interstate compacts which is basically where states contract with each other to agree on a set of rules or process this just simply uses that ability to establish
that process and to wind up with the product that you intend via the process that you intend so with that Mr. Chair in an effort to be brief I'll take any questions from the committee and
from committee members? Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. What we're doing is joining,
at least what you propose to do, is join with other states so that this can be put on a
national ballot. Is that correct? No, sir. No, sir. Rosie Walker, I believe you were at the meeting this last summer, and this asks Arkansas to join an interstate compact, which currently exists, that agrees to specific rules and a specific constitutional amendment for a balanced budget.
It then establishes each step of the process, and you should have in front of you, If each of you will look, you should have a packet that details what that amendment is and how that process works. Right inside the front cover of the folder that I think you have there, it details exactly what the amendment is. And then I believe you have a handout there with you. Okay, you don't actually have the handout that shows the process, but the steps that happen. each state enters into the compact
when 38 states which are what's necessary to reach ratification this thing doesn't do anything until 38 states have joined it once 38 states have joined it then there are a series of if thens that take place and when those if thens begin you have the compact would then get my head right here that process begins with a call that is a agreed on call by all 38 states for exactly what it is
that congress would have to ratify and agree that the compact can be take place because compacts require congressional ratification so you get the call done at that point all the rules are specified for exactly what the amendment looks like, the location of where that event is going to take place happens, who is going to be the delegate is specifically referenced in there, how the votes are done, the length of time. Every piece of this is laid out as far as how the process works, and each structure
all the way through ratification is laid out in this. The functionality of the amendment is also in front of you in the packet for those of that aren't already familiar with it. As I mentioned earlier, this bill was filed, I think, 25 days before session or within the first couple days of early filing. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for
the question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bale, how many states have currently joined this compact?
Representative Wardlaw, there are two states currently in the compact. It has passed chambers in, I believe, six states. Four states this session, it's pending in, I believe, 12 others.
Can you name any of those states that have already joined the compact
and the ones that have passed their
chambers? It has passed and is enacted. The two states are currently in the compact commission, Aralaska and Georgia. It has passed in chambers or multiple chambers in Arizona, I'm sorry, Wyoming.
Yeah, Arizona, Wyoming, Mississippi. It passed the House last week and I believe is in the Senate today or I believe it's in the Senate today and should pass the Senate based on the whip count that's down there. Mr. Chair, with your permission, I want to ask Mr. Nick Dranis from the Compact Commission to come here and maybe provide a little more direct answer to that question. Yeah, please come to the end of
the table and state your name and affiliation for the record.
Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, thank you so much. My name is Nicholas Dranias. I'm the president and executive director of Compact for America Educational Foundation, which is acting as a compact administrator for the Compact for Ballast Budget Commission. There are currently two states, Alaska and Georgia, in the compact. Four states have passed one chamber. It includes Arizona, North Dakota, Wyoming, and Mississippi. Mississippi is anticipated to go to the final chamber this coming week
and is in the lead currently. We also have commitments to file or filed bills in a grand total of 12 states. If you'd like me to list the remaining states, I'd be happy to do so. Suffice it to say that Texas, Florida, Carolina, Oklahoma, New Mexico, Missouri, and a number of other states that are not coming
to my tongue right now, but the bottom line is this, Mr. Chairman, we have at least a third of the number of states needed to complete the compact moving forward this session, and And the goal is to have all 38 states in the compact no later than July 4th, 2017. And the reason why we're picking that target date is the debt is a crisis. If we don't start moving on fixing the national debt, it's soon going to be too late. This amendment applies a tourniquet. And we can't allow the blood all to rush out before we apply the tourniquet.
And the most important aspect of this amendment, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee, is simply imposing some limit on the federal government's borrowing capacity and giving the states a seat at the table because the states are familiar with balance budgets. The federal government hasn't had a balance budget since 1997. So it's time for the states to lead, to educate Washington what it means to be fiscally responsible, and we're hopeful that Arkansas will be in the lead. Mr. Chair, if I might
provide just a little bit of follow-up to that.
He's due. Rev. Ward-Law, Arkansas has, as I said, a pretty extensive history of supporting federal balance budget amendments, and over the last 100-odd years has made four different requests for a balance budget amendment for a convention call for the purpose of a balance budget. What makes this one unique is sometimes those in different states are worded differently and various other things. this makes sure that they are all identical so that they can all be considered.
And it just keeps everything in an orderly process and establishes an orderly process for things to happen. So it's something Arkansas has
frequently been supportive of. Representative Walker, you recognize for a question? Thank you. This is basically
a follow-up, and I appreciate it, Mr. Chair. I think that in 1997 when the budget was last balanced, Bill Clinton was the president. That's correct. At this point, the states that are
opposing it, which have signed on, seem to have low population. My concern is that the compact does not call or allow for voter participation in determining whether or not there is a balanced budget amendment. The process being used circumvents the vote of the people. Am I incorrect? Representative Walker, it follows
the process established in the U.S. Constitution, and the U.S. Constitution does not allow a vote of the people for amending the U.S. Constitution.
There are two avenues in Article 5 to amend the Constitution, and that is by a vote of the U.S. Congress, which is then referred to the states. And there are two avenues for that within the state once Congress refers it. The Congress can refer it to a state convention or to the state legislatures for ratification. The second process is the states-led process, which James Madison wrote about extensively when he put it in. But it allows a state legislature, the state legislatures, if 34 of them come together to make a call,
to request that an amendment be added to the U.S. Constitution. That's the only two processes the U.S. Constitution permits. There is no provision for the people to amend the Constitution like there is in Arkansas. There's no possibility of a referendum. Thank you.
Mr. Chairman, if I may just add one additional note to that. comment we deliberately designed the compact to only activate with 38 states so that there would be little chance that it wouldn't also simultaneously
represent the will of majority probably a supermajority of the population so we've tried to address the concern as best we can within what article
5 provides representative Benetcher recognized
for a question thank you mr. chair a couple
of questions one um we elect people to congress and everyone that's running right now or has been elected has run on the concept that we have a problem with our budget um why are we not trusting
those people to fulfill their campaign promises president bennett
that's that's an excellent question i think the answer to that is because they've proven that they don't follow through I think all of us are aware that it's the most difficult thing for any legislative body anywhere to do is to limit its own power and what when if you go back to what Madison wrote about this when when they were looking at putting article 5 in there was a lot of interesting discussion and one of the points of discussion was what happens when Congress no longer listens to the
people what happens when there's there's no there's a disconnect between what the states are begging Congress to do and they just don't do it. And that's specifically why this provision of Article 5 was placed in the U.S. Constitution was for that point in time when Congress just says, you know what, we're not listening to the people. The people of the United States overwhelmingly want a balanced budget. They've made it clear there's overwhelming support in every poll for a balanced budget amendment. Congress just doesn't do it. And so this is exactly the moment in time that the founders put
that in the U.S. Constitution for. Representative
Bell, certainly you're not admitting that the Republican-controlled Congress isn't going to do all the great things that they promised. I absolutely am prepared to stipulate that, Representative Bennett. We're moving on. If I
just had it. Are there any other questions from committee? We have a motion for immediate consideration.
That's a non-debatable motion. All right, if you're in favor of that motion, say aye. Aye. If you're opposed, say nay. Nay. Okay, chair rules, the ayes have it. all right do we have uh do we have a motion from the committee what's the pleasure of the committee
i have a motion do pass all those in favor say aye Aye. All those opposed say no. Chair rolls the ayes have
Speaker 49
17:05
it. Representative Bell, congratulations. Do I see a second? All right, let's roll call, please. Representative Link. Representative Link. Representative Woodlaw. Representative Hickerson. Representative Walker. Representative Douglas. Representative Ritchie. Representative
Ritchie. Representative McGee. Representative Dotson. Representative Armstrong. Representative Rep. Miller, Rep. H rackham, Rep. Ballinger, Rep. Monty, Rep. Drowne, Rep. Grey, Rep. Tosh, Rep. Fite, Rep. Bennett,
Okay, with 14 yeses, your bill passes. Congratulations, Representative Bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee.
All right, committee, we're now going to hear HJR 1003 by Representative Ballinger.
Representative Ballinger, you are recognized to
present. Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Committee. A lot of the discussion and debate should be pretty much the same. It's the same issue. I'm going to explain some of the things that make my resolution and this resolution a little different than the compact. Essentially, just like Representative Bell said, Article 5 of the U.S. Constitution provides two methods for admitting the Constitution. One is Congress proposes an amendment, and then the second way is the states propose an amendment.
And Article 5, the provision in there for the states to do was put in there specifically so the states could check in case the federal government were to get too large and spend too much money, and it was put in as a method in order to try to create some controls and constraints. And so that's exactly what I feel like our obligation is to do this. Of course, if 34 states make the call, then there'll be a convention, and it would take 38 states to ratify anything that come out of it. If you look on page 2 of the resolution, where the meat of the resolution is, starts on line 5, but really in line 10,
and it essentially says that we're going to call a convention that we'll only be able to do three things. Now, I won't necessarily be able to do all three of these things, because the states that attend will have to have an agreement of whatever amendments come out. So it may just be a balanced budget amendment. That may be all that comes out, or it may be a term limit if that's what's the decision, but essentially it would be the will of the 50 states to put out the amendment. So if you look there, there's three things that basically can be done in this convention. Impose fiscal restraints, so that would be something like a balanced budget amendment
or some other limit on spending. limit the power and jurisdiction of the federal government so that may be something like a further defining of the interstate commerce clause to to maybe put the federal government back to a little bit closer to what the original intent was and also to propose term limits so those are the three things that can be proposed doesn't necessarily mean that those three things would be proposed and I'd say that most people believe and it's actually the group that's working on this is
a bipartisan group because I do believe that for the most part people believe the federal government has gotten too big and is spending too much money. And one of the mechanisms the Founding Fathers put in for us in Article 5 of the Constitution was calling, states calling a convention in order to correct that problem. So right now 38 other states are working on the same exact language. It's been passed in three states, Florida, Georgia, and Alaska. And I would point out Florida is one of the most populated states. Georgia is the eighth most populated state. So the population, I think, in general, is pretty much in agreement that these are things that we need to have corrected.
So I'd be happy to answer any questions. Questions from the
committee? Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for questions. First of all, thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Chair, I want to just make
clear, again, Mr. Vice Chair, how many questions do I get? Well, the process, as the speaker asks us to all do, is you get
a question and a follow-up, and then you can go in the queue for another round. Two, four. All right, Representative Ballinger, I just wanted to maybe go on record and get an understanding as it relates to local control versus federal control and state control in local communities. So on one end, we're talking about local control being controlled by state government
when it pertains to religious freedoms. But on another end, you're saying that the states need to have control over things that relate to the federal government because we feel that the federal government's kind of grown out of
control. Is that correct? Well, I think you're questioning, you're trying to get to a point that's really not part of your question. But in general, let me give just a little bit of a lesson. The states, you know, come together by virtue of the Constitution, created the federal government, and basically united together through the Constitution, and granted certain powers,
their enumerated powers, to the Constitution, or to the federal government by virtue of the Constitution. And so what we're doing here, consistent with the 10th Amendment. We're very familiar
with the states and the federal government and how we came together. Very clear on that from a history standpoint. My last question is exactly what's this resolution intend to do to, I guess, does it just add teeth to what Mr. Chairman has
just brought forward or what's your anticipation? Okay, the anticipation is this is simply just a little broader than the balanced budget.
So balanced budget may be and probably would be the primary focus of this because it is generally a lot of people agree with it. But then there may be other things, like I said, that would be brought up that would essentially maybe limit the scope and reach of the federal government and also the issue of
term limits would probably be debated and discussed. Additional questions from
the committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I take it that in your contemplation of what could happen at a constitutional convention,
you would allow the possibility that the Bill of Rights would be subject to review and possible changing as well as the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments. Is that correct? No, Representative Walker, because of
the idea, the absurdity that 38 states, In fact, that a majority of the individuals actually in the convention would ever agree to touch any of those amendments is pretty incredible.
But then it would take 38 states to ratify anything. So I don't think the individuals that we'd send there would want to waste their time with something that there is no way would ever become law and would
ever amend the Constitution. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. I don't think that my question was answered. It would allow that possibility, wouldn't it? the answer
to that is probably not, even if they wanted to, because the scope of this is three things. Limiting the power and reach of the federal government, or limiting the fiscal
spending of the federal government, or putting term limits. So as long as it doesn't fit into one of those three categories, it's off. So the principal of agency would say they're only vested with the authority that we as the state gives them, and the authority would have to be within one of those three things. Representative
Hickerson, you're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Ballinger, what is the governor's position on this? And if there's someone from the governor's
office that can answer that, I would like to know. This seems to be something that he would have an interest in, you know, looking at and weighing in on.
I'm sure that he would have an interest and that would matter to me, although not exclusively because the Constitution specifically provides the legislature of each state would be the ones that would call. So essentially the Founding Fathers consider that the legislators as representatives of the people of the state should be the ones that make the call for the convention and not the governor.
Additional questions from the committee? Representative Armstrong, recognize for question. Who
approves the Constitutional Convention if we were to have another one in our state? Okay,
I guess is the question how would it be formed and who would form it? We would make that decision. But the legislative body,
but does the governor or the lieutenant governor have any input or the secretary of state
any other constitutional office? The Constitution doesn't provide for that. Now, if we as a legislature decided we wanted to have the input and wanted to pass a bill, per se,
that would have to do with how it would be done, then that bill would need
to be signed by the governor. Representative Gray, you're recognized
a motion for immediate consideration. That's a proper motion. It's non-debatable. Committee, all in favor of immediate consideration, say aye. Aye. All opposed? Say no. Chair Rule's ayes have it. But what's the pleasure of the committee?
Motion to pass. I have a motion from Representative Womack to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Aye. Ayes have it. I
Speaker 49
27:45
have two hands, Representative McGee and Representative Walker. Call the roll. Representative Link. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Wardlaw, Representative Hickerson, Representative Walker, Representative Douglas, Representative Ritchie, Representative McGee, Representative Dotson, Representative Armstrong, Representative Miller, Representative Holcomb, Representative Ballinger, Representative Ladyman,
Representative Drown Representative Gray Representative Tosh Representative Fite Representative Bennett Representative Womack Representative Balinger Your
resolution has passed all right uh representative douglas are you in the room
okay i'm sorry i'm sorry doug house douglas house let me get it let me spit it all out there all right sir you are recognized to present uh hold on a minute i'm forgetting which what's resolution number? HJR 1001.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. If you have read House Joint Resolution 1001, it is the simplest, cleanest request to Congress to
propose a convention to the Congress, for the Congress to call a convention. Let me get my word straight. The reason I brought this resolution is for the lack of one word in the Constitution in Article 5 and the addition of one single letter. The absence of the word purpose does not appear in Article 5. The one letter in Article 5 that is apparent is the letter S,
amendments. Convention to propose constitutional amendments, plural. Based on a very strict reading of Article 5 and also a particular congressional research article that all of our congressmen have been given access to, there is considerable debate whether, number one, a convention of the states based on a state compact is valid or whether the states or Congress can limit the
purposes of a convention. The word purpose doesn't appear. It just says the Congress shall call a convention to propose amendments. It doesn't limit it as to number. It doesn't put any conditions or qualifications that Congress can impose. Nor does it say that the states can petition the Congress for certain amendments or for approval of a compact. Speaking of compacts, I'm afraid that there is a defect in that reasoning
in that the Constitution also... Representative
House, are you speaking on your bill or another bill? Yes, sir, my
bill. Okay, keep it on your bill. Yes, sir. The reason that my bill is offered is because it doesn't put conditions, it doesn't address any qualifications, it doesn't limit it as to the number of amendments. It is strictly in accordance with the exact wording of Article 5. If the Congress decides that it must ratify a compact before it is available,
which the Supreme Court has ruled that it shall, If the Congress were to rule that any conditions on the applications are not acceptable, then I am concerned that the applications of the states will be disregarded by the Congress as it has disregarded some 400 other applications for a convention in our history. If we want a constitutional convention, I think this is a good insurance policy.
I think because it sidesteps any of the arguments that have been brought by a lot of authors as to whether there may be limitations, conventions, qualifications, time limits, and all sorts of things. It's a very, very broad division of authority on Article 5. The Supreme Court has really not ruled on these subjects. The Congress has not legislated on these subjects. So if we want a convention to consider amendments, then this is the resolution that would be appropriate to do so.
Mr. Chairman, I'll be glad to accept any
questions. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Representative. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Representative House. I think this has been my concern about a lot of these calls, And I just want to be sure that I understand it is your legal opinion that we cannot place any limitations on the call for a constitutional convention under the
current law. Is that correct? Pretty close. I don't think Congress is bound to accept any limitations that deviate from the exact wording of Article 5.
Based on Congress's history, it has never proposed an amendment that would limit its authority or the authority of the federal government after the first ten amendments. I don't expect this Congress or any other Congress to ever vote or approve a process that will limit its authority. Additional questions from the committee? All right, is
there anyone here from the public to speak for or against the bill?
I have Mr. Dranius here to, he says he's neutral. Mr. Dranis, you've got to pick a side. Mr. Dranis, you are recognized to speak against the proposal. Mr. Chairman, members of the
committee, the fact of the matter is a textual analysis of Article 5
in light of common understandings at the time of the founding make it very clear abundantly clear that the states indeed target and control the amendment process. The one word that Representative House has omitted from his analysis is the word application. Congress calls a convention on application in the singular of two-thirds of the states. So before you can even analyze what the call consists of, you have to understand the word
application. And it's very easy to figure this out because there are dozens of applications in the history of the Continental Congress preceding the Philadelphia Convention, all of which, all of which ask for specific things, things like let's repay the loans we made on the boots that we bought for the Continental Army, and there are many other examples that I could provide with hyperlinks, courtesy of Google Books, to the original documentation. So the common practice at the time of the founding was for applications not to be just
this naked, non-substantive trigger for something, but to actually be a petition and to specifically lay out what the states wanted. And so when you read Article 5 in light of the actual history and meaning of the word application, it becomes very clear that it would be bizarre from a founding perspective to think that the convention wouldn't be limited to what's specified in the application because Congress's duty in responding to the application is to shall call the convention,
which means automatically grant the relief requested. It doesn't have any authority to do anything else. So on a textual analysis, this is quite easy to dispose of. And as a 19-year attorney with 10 years of constitutional law practice and one Supreme Court win, I can guarantee you there is simply no chance that an argument that the word application is going to be ignored in interpreting Article 5 will prevail. Furthermore, one of the things that's important to underscore is the word amendments in the
plural doesn't mean anything. It was common practice at the time of the founding era to use the plural to signify and encompass both the singular and the plural. It was just an economy of style. And how do we know this in Article 5? read the part about Congress making amendments, it says Congress shall propose amendments in the plural. And yet we know Congress proposes amendments both singularly and in multiple batches like the original Bill of Rights.
So the actual practice of Article 5 with respect to the plural use of the term amendments shows that there's nothing mandatory about having to submit more than one amendment. So respectfully, Mr. Chairman, that's my testimony correcting the record on the legal analysis. Thank you, Mr. Janias. Are there questions from
the committee for Mr. Janias? Seeing none, Mr. Janias, you're excused. All right.
Is there anyone else here from the public to speak for or against this bill? Sir, I don't have your name. If you would, if you'll take the end of the table and identify yourself and let us
know if you're speaking for or against, we would appreciate it. My name is Charles Wright. I'm just a citizen from Stuttgart, Arkansas. I'm speaking against the bill, short and sweet. The only convention, constitutional convention that there's been was supposed to have had limitations on what it was.
They were limited only to amend the Articles of Confederation, but the Articles of Confederation were thrown completely out, and they were substituted with the Constitution. Now, we're glad today that we have the Constitution, but no, if there's a constitutional convention based on the history of the only constitutional convention that's ever been,
they could throw out anything that they wanted. Now, sure, the states have to ratify, but what happened to the states that didn't ratify the Constitution right off? They became their own nations for a little while, and they were out on their own. Voting was suspended in consideration of the United States. They were not speaking
on the bill. You're providing a history lesson, which we're all familiar with the process of establishing the U.S. Constitution.
So with respect, you need to
speak to the bill. Specifically, I'm against the bill because of the Constitutional Convention. that's part of it, and because that there is not a limitation on what can happen once that it does go to the Constitutional Convention. Thank you. Are there questions
from the committee? If not, you're excused.
Anyone else here to speak for or against the bill? All right, Mr. Michael Ferris. Mr. Ferris, are you speaking for or against this bill? All right, Mr. Ferris will be speaking against the bill. If you would, go ahead and identify
Speaker 90
40:06
yourself for the record. I'm Michael Ferris. I am the Chancellor of Patrick Henry College, but I'm appearing today for Citizens for Self-Governance.
Like Mr. Dranius, I'm really speaking against the analysis. This application would be a wide open convention and could consider things like Bill of Rights issues and the 13th and 14th Amendment. The one that was just passed, Mr. Ballinger's bill, Representative Ballinger's bill, could not consider those things. And so I would just simply say if the desire of the committee is to have a wide open convention and consider anything, then this is the vehicle.
I don't know of any public support for such a wide open convention. People want to limit the power of the federal government, not just have a wide open convention to consider anything and everything. I have a document here, a two-page history of how we got the Constitution, and it was widely understood. I was taught that in grade school, high school, law school, the idea that we were only supposed to amend the Articles of Confederation. It's just not true. Federalist 40 makes it very clear that the authority for the convention did not come from the resolution of Congress
that said only amend the Articles. That was simply an endorsement with no more authority than a National Pickle Week resolution for Congress today. The authority for the convention came from the states, and the states called the convention, named their delegates, gave them instructions, and their instructions were to render the federal constitution adequate for the exigencies of the union. So I'm not in favor of wide-open conventions. I am in favor of limited convention, and you've just passed two limited conventions. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Ferris. Is anyone there questions for Mr. Ferris? Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. So you disagree with Mr. Ballinger's analysis, which we approved by a majority vote? No, I agree with him completely. So that the convention could be limited rather than wide open? The one
Speaker 90
42:09
Mr. Ballinger's bill is limited. It's limited to impose fiscal restraints on the federal government, limit the power and jurisdiction of the federal government and to impose term limits
there's no way you can get a consideration of the first amendment into that rule of germaneness that you all
just approved follow up Mr. Chair yes and committee we do need to begin to start thinking about wrapping up we've got to be upstairs
in just a few minutes so go ahead in your reference to the constitutional convention you indicated that it was called for a more limited purpose but then it went ahead and addressed wider issues And you suggest that if you have a convention, even though the call may be for one thing,
they can do whatever they want to. Do
Speaker 90
42:54
you disagree with that? I do. It's not what I said, and it's not what the history reflects. The language only to amend the Articles of Confederation did not come from the official call for the convention. The official call for the convention came from the state legislatures, and the state legislatures said, render the federal constitution adequate for the exigencies of the union. That was their instruction, and that's exactly what they did. The language, only amend the Articles of Confederation, did not come from the official call.
It came from an endorsement measure passed by the Confederation Congress in February of 1787, and that was not the official call. James Madison makes this very clear in Federalist 40. That was not the source of their authority. The source of their authority was the calls from all of the states. And the states told them, render the federal constitution adequate for the existencies of the union. They obeyed their instructions thoroughly. It was not a runaway.
The constitution was properly adopted. I think we all, regardless of what position we take on this issue, whether it's wise today to have an Article V convention or not, regardless of that, every one of us in this room should be on the side of this. The constitution was lawfully adopted because it was. It undermines our faith and our fidelity of the Constitution to believe it was unlawfully adopted. We need to know the history, and we need to have faith in our founding fathers that they did it right.
All right. Representative Ladyman, you're recognized for a question? I call for immediate question, when appropriate. Representative Ladyman, I think we're about wrapped up, and I didn't recognize you for a motion. Mr. Ferris, you're excused. Representative House, we do need to wrap up, but I would like for you to have a couple minutes to close
if you'd like to do so, sir. Thank you very much. I appreciate the other analysis of it, of the issue. And it has all been outlined in this document,
and I'll provide any member of the committee or the public with it. It's a congressional research service. In 1920, the states applied to the Congress to propose an amendment to reapportion the House of Representatives, and there were sufficient number of states to do so. Yet the Congress did not call a convention at that time. That was a limited call. I don't know which legal analysis is correct. In fact, none of us know, except from what we can glean from history, what's been done in the past. That's the purpose
of this House Joint Resolution 1001. If the Congress says it's not going to recognize a compact. If the Congress says it will not recognize limitations as to subject matter, then you have a bare bones complete application to the Congress for a convention for proposing amendments in front of them. And if 35 states present that, then the
Congress would have very little recourse than to call a convention. I appreciate your concern about a runaway convention. A year ago, I shared that same concern, but I am now convinced now that the Congress will use every method, regardless of whether they're Republicans or Democrats, to oppose a constitutional convention that could limit their power. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee, and thank you, members of the public. What's the pleasure of the committee?
Representative Miller, do you have a motion? All right, we have a motion. Is there discussion on the motion? If not, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, same sign. Representative House, your bill has failed. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Folks, Representative Brown is here to present,
but I don't think we have time to give her justice to her proposal because hers is somewhat substantive. Representative Brown, are you okay with coming back the next time we meet? Because we're ten minutes away from having to be in chambers and we would have to stop you mid-presentation. If you want to go ahead and start, I'll allow you to start, but I hate to split you up. Okay. Well, with that committee, I think at this point We do have a very limited amount of stuff that we would take on this afternoon.
I think we'll go ahead and forego the afternoon meeting and plan on meeting again next week. So keep your eyes on the calendar. With that, no further business coming for the committee. We stand adjourned.
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Representative Richard Womack Chair
Unverified
Speaker 9
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Nicholas Dranias
Unverified
Representative Camille Bennett Chair
Unverified
Speaker 45
Speaker 49
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Charles Wright
Unverified
Speaker 90