House State Agencies and Govt'l Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (4)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1229
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1229”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1475
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…u're recognized to present. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have House Bill 1475, which is an act to provide statutory guidance concerning i…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1468
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1468”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1610
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1610”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
statement that was requested, and then we'll go from there. Representative Love, do you want to explain what we're up to here? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Committee. Bill 1401 that
I brought before you in regards to coroners and the death benefits, We asked for a fiscal impact statement.
As of right now, what has happened is that the Bureau of Legislative Research cannot do a fiscal impact statement, so we're going to have to have Osborne do an actuarial. So I will need a motion from this committee to order an actuarial so that we can get that done, and then you will have your fiscal impact statement. And, committee, there is
no additional cost. They are currently under contract with us to do that. but we just have to specifically authorize it. All right, Representative Gray, you're recognized for a motion.
All right, thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like to make a motion to authorize the use of Osborne, Carrero, and Associates and to recommend to the Executive Subcommittee to approve the use of the service and payment of funds. All right,
that's a proper motion. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Anyone opposed? All right, Representative Love, the motion has passed. we'll make sure the staff gets that notification to the proper people. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. All right.
Representative Brown, we promised you that you would be first on the agenda after we ran out of time for you last week. So if you're ready, you can take the end of the table and
you're recognized to present. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have House Bill 1475, which is an act to provide statutory guidance concerning interstate conventions
under an Article V Interstate Convention of States as provided for in the United States Constitution. Representative Brown, could you pull the mic a little closer? Chair's kind
of hard to hear, and I'm having trouble. Shall I start over? I heard you well enough to
know where you're going. But you can continue. Currently, our state constitution, nor are statutes, make any provision for the calling of an interstate convention.
So this bill simply provides guidelines in the event that 34 states call an Article V convention or that the U.S. Congress calls a convention. And as you have seen in this committee and probably in your e-mail and mail and everywhere, where there are calls all over the United States and in Arkansas by individuals, organizations, and states for a constitutional convention. This bill is not calling for a convention of states, but simply provides definitions, sets limitations on our delegates,
and provides a remedy if those limitations are attempted to be ignored. But most importantly, it protects us against many of the fears and concerns expressed about calling a constitutional convention, mainly that it would be a runaway convention. Quite simply, a runaway convention would be one in that the delegates might propose amendments that are not related to the convention's purpose or are not consistent with the integrity of our existing U.S. Constitution. Ultimately, the argument is that if a runaway convention were to take place,
it could simply alter our nation's constitution. The fear of a runaway convention has allowed this argument to become the principal objection to the constitutional reforms that could come from the Article V convention. This bill protects us against a runaway convention by limiting any proposed amendment to the text to the text of the proposed amendment for which the convention is called or is outside the subject matter permitted under the Article 5 application
and is clarified by the legislative instructions that we would provide to the delegate. And I'll be happy to answer
any questions. Questions from the members? Representative Walker, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you. In the event that we have a constitutional convention called, and a person chooses, who represents Arkansas, chooses not to follow the legislative directive,
is there a recourse against that person
or against his or her vote? Yes, sir. That is outlined in this legislation. on page 3 lines 16 through 24 is the oath that that delegate would take and then they would be recalled immediately
and their vote would be null
and void as I understand it this is analogous to a person who's an elector for the presidency and vice presidency of the United States. The popular vote does not really determine who the president of the United States is. It's the electoral vote in the electoral college. And when we send an elector, we give the same directions, don't we?
After we've voted, we send an elector to go cast a vote. that person casts the vote on behalf of the people of Arkansas. Yes, sir. But there's nothing to restrict that person from casting his own vote. So if that person chooses not to follow the vote of the people of Arkansas, there's no recourse until after the fact, which would be perhaps too
late in some cases. Well, their vote would be null and void, and they would be replaced immediately by their alternate.
there, Representative Walker. Pardon? Just keep it narrow. I am. There's really no recourse in this. It's basically depending upon the character of the person or person selected to do the will of the people because after the votes are taken, then you cannot undo the votes except by appeal to the United States Supreme Court in a process that takes a long time.
Would you not agree with that? Mr. Walker, I'm really not prepared to answer such an in-depth question, but I have Mr. Dan Greenberg here today who would be willing to address that question. Thank you. Representative Walker,
Chair would direct your attention to the end of page 3 in the beginning of page four in the bill as
well. Dan Greenberg from the Advance Arkansas Institute. Representative Walker, you raised a very interesting question because, as I'm sure you know,
electors are regulated differently by different states. You know, electors in some states don't have the capacity to go beyond their orders. In Arkansas, we don't regulate electors in the way that other states do. In this case, this regulates the behavior of delegates to a possible future Constitutional Convention in a number of ways, and one of those is that the delegate basically becomes ineligible to cast any votes once he or she breaks his or her oath.
And that's line 28 of page 3. And the bill further goes on line 32 of that page to say that if you cast a vote or attempt to cast a vote in violation of your oath, then the vote is null and void. And I do think that there's a pretty strong argument that the delegates are creatures of the state and, you know, not creatures, say, of the federal government. and that states do have the power to regulate them in much the same way
as other states have chosen to regulate the votes
of electors. And if I might add something, on lines 19 through 28 on page 2, I'll just quote, except as provided under subdivision 6B of this section, unauthorized amendment means a proposed amendment that does not reflect the amendment text in the article 5 application under consideration or is
outside the subject matter permitted under the article 5 application as may be clarified by the legislative instructions if the General Assembly has not passed an article 5 application relied on by the United States Congress to call the article 5 convention and unauthorized amendment means an amendment that does not reflect the amendment text permitted by the 34 Article 5 applications relied on by the United States Congress to propose the Article 5 convention or is outside the permitted subject matter
under this state's legislative instructions or any Article 5 application relied upon by the United States Congress to call the Article 5 convention. Thank you. Mr. Chair, to Mr. Greenberg.
Representative Walker, you've had several questions. We'll see if anyone else is in the to you, and if not, we'll come back to you.
Representative Bennett, you're recognized. And Mr. Greenberg, you may be able to help me with this. You know, if a constitutional convention is called, it's called by the Federal Congress.
And I would presume that they would be the ones to set the rules of how delegates are selected, how many delegates from each state, and what rules would apply to those delegates. So I guess I'm having trouble understanding how anything that we pass here would bind the federal government once a
convention is called. Well, I don't think that the calling of the convention or creation of rules for a federal convention is necessarily going to, you know,
implicate some sort of, you know, federal supremacy type of rule of the kind that you're supplying. I mean, ultimately, the delegates are creatures of the state. They're creatures of state law. And I think, if I'm understanding your question right, you're asking about a kind of federal preemption. And it's hard for me to imagine that that kind of federal preemption would take place. But I guess I would add one more thing. In the event that we ever have a constitutional convention,
I think that there's no doubt that there will be a great deal of litigation. There will be some sort of massive consolidation of litigation that will end up before the Supreme Court. And I do think that the Supreme Court will certainly recognize that the states and the delegates that they send have a great role in policymaking and a great role in these decisions. I find it highly unlikely that states would give up all their power. But I think that the worst thing that you could say about this bill that you're talking about is that it might have no effect at all.
But I think there's a very strong argument that it would. And so if it's the case that this bill has no effect at all, to my mind, that's not a very strong argument against the bill. This is something like an insurance policy to try to make sure that there's no runaway convention. and I think that it has a very strong chance of succeeding in that. I hope that that speaks to your
question. And if I might just follow up, and I understand what you're trying to do.
I guess my concern is if all 50 states come up with different ways that their delegates are supposed to vote and how they get recalled and whether that vote counted ahead of time or after or didn't count They have to re-meet because Arkansas says our vote didn't count. I have a hard time believing that a federal Congress who we're calling a convention to limit is going to allow all the states to make 50 different rules about how they apply. I commend you for the concept, but I just have a real fear that regardless of what we say,
that if a convention is ever called, they would be the ones to set the rules
and not us. Well, I take your point, but, of course, Congress deals with these sorts of Federalist issues all the time in that, you know, 50 different states have 50 different election codes. And there are all sorts of respects in which Congress is either very careful or institutionally prevented from, you know, creating one-size-fits-all rules for all the
states. Additional questions from members? Representative Walker, did you have additional questions?
No, I'll defer to the chair who wants to expedite matters. Representative Ballinger,
you had a question? Yes, Mr. Chair. Just real quickly, and I think you basically hit on it. To me, it seems this seems relatively non-controversial. What we're saying is the agents that we select, we want them to act within certain parameters consistent with what we've asked for. And, you know, like Mr. Greenberg said, But if the worst-case scenario is that this is never used for anything,
the best-case scenario is we may be able to have some sort of constraint on
the people who go to represent our state. That's correct. And there are, let's see, Indiana and Georgia have already enacted similar legislation, and other states
are considering it. If I may, just one follow-up real quick. But within the Article V, the call, it never grants any power to Congress to make any limitations, to do anything with the convention. All it says is that if the application is made with 34 states, then they are to call the convention together.
So my question would be then, if that's the case, if it's not specifically delegated to Congress to do that, then under the Tenth Amendment, wouldn't that mean that states would have the power to set that? Would you like to answer?
Right. And so I think what you're getting at is that it's not so much perhaps that Congress makes the rules as the delegates make the rules. You have a group of people and they make their own rules. And I like to think that this sort of measure would encourage them to be very cautious about sticking to the request of the people that sent them there
and not going off on, you know, something beyond that, you know, to use the term that other people use,
a runaway convention. Additional questions for members? Representative Bennett, you are
recognized. And I'm sorry, one last question. So am I clearly reading this that you're basically giving this legislative body the ability to select the delegates as opposed to the people of the state? I don't
think that I would agree with that, and Representative Brown and I talked a little bit about that.
I think that in order to send delegates, this body would have to create an additional set of rules in order for a delegate selection process. Now, this is one set of rules that you have before you today that I think limit the scope of delegates. But if you actually wanted to send delegates to a convention, I think that this body, the state legislature, would have to create additional rules as to how they'd be picked and so forth.
Interrepresentant Bennett, just a comment from the Chair kind of as a follow-up on that. There are a few states that have specifically passed laws that set who delegates would be, et cetera.
So there are states that have taken that next step. Off the top of my head, I know specifically of two. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Additional questions from members? All right. Is there anyone here from the public to speak for or against this measure? Thank you. All right. Seeing none, Representative Brown, you are recognized to close for your
bill. This bill does not call a constitutional convention.
It simply sets parameters for our delegates, and I would appreciate a good vote. It's a
pleasure to committee. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a motion. All right. We've got a motion. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing no discussion, all in favor say aye. Opposed, same sign. Ayes have it. Representative Brown, you've passed your bill. Thank you. All right.
I believe next on cue, Representative Farrar, are you in the room? All right. Representative Farrar, you have HB 1229. You are recognized to present. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I'd like to make a motion for the amendment. All right. And we
do have that. Members, it's on your tablet. If you want to take a moment to pull that up and glance at it. And Representative Farrar, you're recognized to present your amendment.
When I first filed my bill,
I had some concerns from the Military Museum and the Municipal League, and this solves their
problem. That's the amendment. Questions from the members on the amendment? All right,
Representative Bennett, you're right to ask for a question. Historical preservation, are they
okay with this? The military, I have not spoke with them. This was the military museum that came to me with this.
I think they had the same concerns. Are there additional questions from members? Seeing none It was a pleasure of the committee on the amendment Representative Miller Motion to adopt the amendment All right, we have a motion to adopt the amendment All in favor say aye Opposed All right, Representative Farrar Your amendment's adopted And you are recognized to present your bill as amended All right, thank you committee
When I filed this bill Just like everyone in this room probably, you know, you started getting calls and people come up to you and ask you about it. Well, I got these, and most of mine were from veterans because this is what this bill addresses. And let me read one to you. This really touched me, so I'm going to read it to you. After all the sacrifice our veterans have given, many with their lives, how can we still alive not support keeping all these memorials to honor them?
It would be to our national disgrace to do away with these time-honored monuments. They are a permanent reminder of who, as we Americans are, I humbly suggest that we never, ever get rid of them as these markers of valor are a big part of our heritage, and we honor and respect all of the generations yet to come. Truly, we have been baptized in sweat, tears, blood to preserve our way of life. If we fail to live up to this, our beloved men and women have died in vain.
So that was one of many that I've gotten on this. What this bill does is it protects activist groups like the American Humanist Association from coming in. Other states, this organization or these organizations come in and wanted to take crosses off these memorials. So I wrote this bill just to protect our amendments. I'm sorry, our memorials, and I think it's a good bill. I'll take any questions.
Other questions from the committee? Representative
Thank you. I understand that veterans want to keep as many of these memorials as they could, at least people who support the veterans do. I don't know if the veterans do. But I'm concerned about just keeping memorials simply because they relate to particular wars or individuals who participated in the wars. I want you to know, and I hope it doesn't offend you, I'm offended as a black person by the naming of the city, Forest City, for the general who fought that war.
and there are other places and what you're doing now is requiring that if the time comes when we want to change the name of Forest City, Arkansas, we can't do it. I don't think that memorials are time things. They relate to the time of the circumstance and Civil War memorials which denigrate black people should not be...
Representative Walker, is there a question in here somewhere? I'm trying to... Yes, there is a question, Mr. Bell. Please get to it. I will do that in my way. Representative Bell, I'll change the question. Representative Bell wanted to change the Lee Memorial Holiday. This is analogous to that
Speaker 51
22:22
in some ways, isn't it? No, these are monuments, and Mr. Walker, let me tell you this.
The Civil War was fought, and we are today what we are today because of the Civil War. One way or another, it doesn't matter.
All this does, either side of the Civil War
honors that group. Well, do you think that it's appropriate for you to allow a memorial which, say, for instance, and I can't give you the exact example of where it is, demonstrates as a part of the Civil War lynching of a black man? I don't think there's
a memorial out there that I know that memorializes
the lynching of a black man. Well, there'll be some analogous, and I'll show you.
Thank you. Additional questions from members? Representative Bennett, you're recognized for
to know what kind of cereal you ate this morning, Representative Bennett. I'm fine. Here's my two concerns on this. On page 2, lines 34 and 35, it says that essentially we'll take the greatest extent possible to preserve a monument.
Yes. Okay. And I'm all for preservation, but what is the greatest extent and what is the cost that's going to be imposed? I mean, if a monument's crumbling, what, I mean, do we have to fly, you know, I'm a little concerned that that creates a huge standard for the preservation of these monuments. And then the other thing that concerns me is, for example, the Palm Bluff Courthouse burned down, and there's a monument down there.
I think it's David O'Dodd and when they rebuilt the courthouse they had to relocate the monument because the courthouse was now where that monument is this does not allow it to be moved ever so if the courthouse gets enlarged if the museum gets enlarged if we're gonna have
if... Oh, come on. Which is hard in here. I understand
that. You know, if they... And I don't think the veterans are going to care if they move that monument. If you extend the front of the courthouse 20 feet, if you move it 20 more feet, I don't think that's a
problem. Okay. Members, if any of you have a cell phone sitting next to a microphone If you could move it, we're getting a ring sound, and Tech advises us that it's probably caused by a cell phone.
So we're trying to correct that. All right, we have additional questions? Representative Hickerson, did you
have a question? Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman. My question, Representative Farrar, was basically Representative Bennett's question about moving. Do you think you could put an amendment on there to that effect that if a local government entity, a city or a county, needs to move a monument for purposes of relocating due to a fire or they're building a new courthouse or whatever,
I would like to see them not have any hassle or have it pointed out that they're going against state statute. and give them some flexibility because I don't see that in here, but does that address it? Yes.
read the second section of your amendment for the committee. I think it would be helpful given some of the questions. Okay. It
says, It says, a state, county, or municipality that is temporarily relocating a monument
for the purpose of conducting necessary repairs, construction, improvement, renovations, or maintenance of a utility, public park, public facility, public transportation system, as long as the monument is returned to the same position and maintains the original intent of the display and structural integrity of
the monument. You're recognized. But it says temporarily relocating, And I guess in the case of Pine Bluff Courthouse, that's a permanent relocation. I mean, I'm for this bill.
Right. And I'm going to go back to the comments. I just want to make sure that if a city or a county needs to move a monument for some reason from park to park or that they would be able, or courthouse to courthouse or wherever, they would be able to do that without taking a state. I'm going to go back to the common sense
that as long as you're not destroying it or you're not moving it out of its intent, I think I'm going to go say it's fine.
Are there additional questions from members? President Farah, I have somewhat of a question. I think Representative Bennett raised an interesting point with regard to the cost side of this and would encourage you. I believe I can support the bill today, but I would encourage you to consider a Senate amendment that added a reasonability piece to that. I think it would benefit your bill, and I think taking another look at the original position language in the amendment might also be beneficial.
I think your bill is, I'm comfortable enough with it personally to vote for it today, but I think those two changes would greatly improve the bill and would encourage you to consider those as you move forward. Okay, if
we pass it out today, I'll amend it on the Senate to address those problems. Additional questions
from members? All right, so anyone here from the public to speak for or against? Oh, I'm sorry. Representative Drown, I had you on my queue for a question. You're good? Okay, anyone here from the public? I show a Kevin Carr here to speak against the bill.
Mr. Carr, you're recognized. I'm sorry. Mr. Butts, you're recognized. Please identify yourself for the record and state who you're
Speaker 106
28:51
with, and you can proceed. Yes, I'm Greg Butts, director of state parks. Clarification, not here to speak against the bill. I'm sorry I came in late. One of the clarifications that we're uncertain about deals with interpretive panels and exhibit galleries that we have in the various historic parks.
It's not about the monuments. That's not the question. and so I would ask if we could work on that particular aspect of it if you know you've been to our state parks you understand we have exhibit galleries that tell the story of history or natural resources and under the definition of what a monument is it mentions plaque and I think it goes into artifacts and so the concern would be that we could never
change an interpretive panel. Maybe that's been cleared up by the museum, and I just haven't seen that yet, so I apologize for extending this. So I would ask that we could work with the representative on that particular issue. So we're not opposed to it, just
want some clarification. Okay, Mr. Betts, for purposes of clarification for the chair, are you suggesting that you're comfortable to continue to work with the representative as far as he moves the bill forward, or are you wanting to pull the bill down? Well, just if
Speaker 106
30:10
we can work with him, we're not opposed to the bill.
I just want to clarify one particular thing on
exhibit galleries. Okay. I very much appreciate your testimony. Are there questions from the members for Mr. Butts? Mr. Holcomb, Representative
for Representative Farrar, if that's okay. That's appropriate. Representative Holcomb, you recognize for a
question. I would just like to make sure that we get this amendment on here because the – excuse my voice, I'm a little strained. The David O. Dodge statue was at Pine Bluff High, was moved to the Jefferson County Courthouse.
That's been a controversy for a number of years, and there's a move now to move it to the Confederate Cemetery in the Sulphur Springs area. So I just want to make sure that we don't do something to eliminate that if the people there decide to move it and keep it in the structure. But I just want to make sure we allow them to make a move if they feel like they need to. can you respond to that we'll work we'll
work on we'll work on then the amendment we'll get to thank you just make sure we'll clarify all that
there's any walker you are recognized for a question who
could you tell me what penalty there is for a person entity or community that violates this ordinance? This isn't a bill. It makes it a Class D felony. It's a Class D felony.
Punishable by jail time. I'm not an attorney, but
I think it's $10,000 one year, up to one year, up to one year. Follow-up, please. You're recognized for follow-up.
So in the example of Mr. Holcomb, it seems as if that behavior had taken place that he described, then one or more persons would already have committed felonies. Would you not agree? I will amend it on
the Senate end to fix that problem. Thank you. All
right, and committee, due to the late stage of the session, we are getting to the point that we essentially kill members' bills if we don't allow them to start advancing.
Any amendment would come back before this committee for concurrence. The only way that this bill could advance is if it advanced in its current form through the Senate. So just with that, I just want to remind everybody that that's how things would work going forward. We do have Representative Flora making a commitment
to this. Representative Bennie, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If I might just clarify, when you say you're going to amend to fix Representative Holcomb's issue, are you talking about so that any city who voted in the future or just to exempt the Jefferson County?
No, we'll fix it for the whole state. Okay, thank you. Representative Flora, do you have some idea of how you would construct that fix? I think it is a bit difficult to construct that fix in this bill. So do you have some thoughts that you
might be able to share with the committee? No, right now, but I will get with Representative Hochulman and Bennett. We'll see where the concerns are, and then I'll bring it back to the veterans that brought me this bill and see where they're at with it
also. I'll work on it hard. so committee uh any further discussion at this point or if not i'm gonna go ahead and see if
there's additional folks for against all right anybody else from the public here speak for against this bill all right i see a hand out there uh sir if you uh i want to state your name and uh tell us whether you're for against the bill you can take the end of the table State your name, who you're with, and whether you're for or against the bill. My name
is Tom Bird, and I'm for the bill.
This bill is the exact bill that Tennessee has already put in. The only difference is we put grave markers in there because I'm one of those people who goes out and puts the flowers and the wreaths and all this stuff on the graves. They've had a lot of problems with the plaques and stuff, the bronze plaques that they put on the marble. A lot of those are coming up missing and stuff, and we figured they're being sold for scrap. But the reason for this is to keep, you know, the mayors
and city council and stuff, they're temporary. They're every two, four years, whatever. And there's been some incidences in some of the states that they've actually wanted to remove all of the war stuff in their cities there's one in indiana that was talking about taking a tank out because it symbolized war but this whole thing's about our veterans i mean that's the reason we're here able to talk y'all where you are i am where i am
because of our veterans fought for this stuff so that's basically what i've got to say
on it Are there questions from the members for Mr. Byrd? Seeing none, Mr. Byrd, you're excused. Thank you. All right, members, I think that concludes testimony for and against. Representative Farrar, you are recognized to close for your bill.
I guess I just want to clarify that this bill is to protect the monuments, to protect our heritage from the veterans like Mr. Byrd that serve.
So I just appreciate a good vote. it's the pleasure of the committee as amended all right representing Ballinger has a move to do pass as amended discussion on the motion all in favor say aye opposed representing Ferraro you've passed your bill we'll look forward to seeing that Senate amendment all right Representative Womack
I believe you have a bill to present you're recognized to present House Bill 1468 Representative Womack you are recognized
Thank you Mr. Chair and committee members this is a very simple bill I will read you about three sentences. What it does, it adds reasons that state employees can share their leave time.
The three reasons they can, new reasons that they would be able to share time are the birth of a biological child, the placement of an adoptive child in the adoptive home of the employee, or the placement of a foster child in the foster home. and it gives them a little leeway with time there as for what's in the best interest of the child is determined by the Division of Children, Family Services, and the Department of Human Services. State Employees Association is in favor of the bill
and there's no known opposition at this point and I would appreciate a good vote and I'm happy
to answer any questions. Okay, Representative Gray, do you have a question? Okay, I saw your hand there.
Okay, Representative Walker, you recognize for a question. This obviously has some impact, financial impact. I was
told it is not because these are not additional days. They're days that are already figured in that one employee simply gives to another one. So it's basically all just a direction of employee's sick leave.
Yes, sir. So that it could be utilized by others who are in dire circumstances. Yes, sir. Thank
you. Additional questions from members? If not, anyone from the public here to speak for or against the bill? All right, seeing none, Representative Womack, would you like to close for your bill? I would just appreciate a good vote. It was a pleasure to committee. All right, I hear numerous due passes. We'll recognize Representative Holcomb's discussion on the motion.
All right, all in favor say aye Opposed Representative Womack, you've passed your bill Thank you And if you'll come back up here, our chair is going to run House Bill 1610
Representative Vail, you're recognized to present House Bill 1610
Thank you Mr. Chair House Bill 1610 is a measure to supplement what many of you have seen in my HJR 1013 which is a constitutional amendment what this bill does in really simple terms is when we have an election and there are no opposed candidates on the ballot,
it simply allows the Election Commission an option to enter the vote of the candidate for themselves and not go through with the formality of an election when nobody's opposed. Most offices are set by Constitution, and thus HJR 1013 that I'll be presenting to you later. This addresses some of the city offices, municipal offices, and school boards, et cetera, and just simply says we're not going to spend taxpayer dollars to hold an election
when there's nobody running against anybody. So pretty simple bill. With that, I'd be glad to take
any questions. Okay, are there any questions about committee members? Representative Walker, you recognize the question? Mr. Representative Bell, isn't there just a value in putting before the electorate annually the fact that there is an occasion for an election so that people will maintain support for the system. I can see where
can you not see where incumbents may hold an office for 8, 10, or 12 years and it never appear on the school ballot or on the city council ballot and therefore cause people to lose interest in the process itself. Representative Walker, I certainly think that
there are a number of people in society who lose interest, and I'm looking forward to your support on House Bill 1422. Well,
the question that I'm raising really is
more so. I mean, if we're going to have elections for some, why not have them for all, irrespective of the fact that a person is unopposed?
Well, once again, Representative Walker, it's simply taking taxpayer dollars and expending it for what you're suggesting is publicity purpose. No, I'm not. I'm asking, you know,
you're trying to save money. Have you figured out what the cost saving of this is going to be? Representative
Walker, it's impossible to know. That's right. Because there is no way to project at what point in the future someone will
be unopposed. This simply, again, this bill is very simple. If all candidates on that ballot have no opposition, then it allows the election. And it's a local option. A local election Commission has the opportunity to decide whether they believe that it's in the best interest of their their citizens to do that so it's certainly not something that we're mandating on them it simply adds another option representative Ballinger you recognize
for a question one thing that I know of an instance
where a there was a city of an election and I guess assume it was a special election for a school board member and and they actually had the election but nobody because it's uncontested nobody showed up to vote I believe that occurred in Darnell yeah and so what but in this case what I would would ask is and you may have a good answer for this why doesn't this
include school board elections I believe this actually does include school board elections if you'll go to the page I believe number one section it's line eight I believe we're
and Section 2 addresses that. Okay. I will take a look at that then. I
believe it's page 1. Let me make sure that I'm not – I'm sorry, Representative Belger, it's page 2. Page 2, okay. Page 2, line 8, addresses school elections. Okay, great. And once again, members, to Representative Walker's point, this simply allows the local election commission the option to do that. Many of them currently already in law have the option of just doing early and absentee voting and not doing an election day. This just gives them a third option, which would be to not go ahead and have the formality of the election.
Representative Drown, you're recognized for a question. I think this is a good bill. We're going through this right now in Pope County, Pope and Van Buren. We have a special election for state senate. We have one candidate. The election commission, I have heard a lot from them, phone calls over the last few weeks, dealing with this very issue and trying to figure out and asking the question, why are we forced to spend the money when we already have the winner? So I appreciate your bill.
Well, you know, you can do a look back, and I haven't taken the time to do the research, but I think all of us know of situations in our local communities where we've spent several thousand dollars and say in some cases many more than that to go through the formalities when there weren't any contested elections. This, again, just allows a local option to
Speaker 143
44:04
move on past that if the local authorities so choose. Representative Ballinger, you recognize your question? Thank you, Mr.
Chair. And I don't know that you'll know the answer to this question,
but if we had an emergency clause in this bill, would it help the folks who are in his district going to vote on one person? No, Representative Ballinger. County officials, state
and district officials, that method of election is set in the Constitution. And once again, I do have HJR 1013 that I'll be presenting to you all as we consider constitutional amendments that addresses those additional offices within this same line of topic. This is just simply attempting to address via statute the ones that we can correct via statute.
But in the Senate race, it has to be addressed via the Constitution. And the earliest that we could do anything would be if you all chose to refer that and the people adopted it in 2016, in 2017, the legislature would then be empowered to address that legislatively. Representative Walker, you're recognized
for a question. Are there any other questions from committee members?
Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill? All right, seeing none, we have
a motion. Representative Hickerson? Motion do pass. All right,
is there any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. All opposed say no. Representative Bale, congratulations. You've passed your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee.
committee that's all the bills that I've been notified anyone intends to run today is there anyone present who has another bill that they want to present all right seeing none I would do want to take just a moment to advise you all again on the importance of our constitutional amendment process and wrapping it up.
We do have, looks like, some rough weather coming later today, but at least as of right now, I do plan to go ahead and consider constitutional amendments this afternoon. We will try to keep that brief and monitor the weather. Listen for the announcement when we go into session. That might change. So let's pay attention to the announcement at the end of session. Additionally, keep in mind we have approximately 40 measures that we have to have narrowed down prior to Monday.
That's going to take a considerable amount of work on your part. At this point, I think it's very likely that we will have an extended meeting tomorrow after adjournment. So I would ask everyone to make sure that your schedules reflect that. I think we owe People's State the opportunity to give these due diligence and to refer them a quality set of amendments. So I just ask all of you to try to take the time to be familiar with the measures that are out there and come prepared on
Thursday to begin to narrow this field substantially. With that there being no further business to come before the committee. We stand adjourned. That's Womack.
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Frederick Love
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative Karilyn Brown
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative Camille Bennett Chair
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Joe Farrer
Unverified
Speaker 51
Speaker 49
Speaker 90
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Speaker 106
Representative Mike Holcomb
Unverified
Tom Bird
Unverified
Representative Richard Womack Chair
Unverified
Representative R. Trevor Drown
Unverified
Speaker 143