House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (8)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1485
· 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…1485. Representative Lampkin, you're recognized to present House Bill 1485 first. Okay. All right. Thank”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1439
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Thank you. Would you like to run your other bill? Yes, sir. House Bill 1439. House”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1534
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1534”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1750
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1750”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1596
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1596”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1597
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1597”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB179
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB179”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB325
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB325”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Representative Ratliff, would you like to go ahead and present those two bills first? You are recognized to present those. Representative Ratliff is going to present House Bill 1534. Is that correct? 1534 first, and he has another one after
that. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This bill is House Bill 1534, and I am presenting it today for Representative Ferguson.
She had other commitments due this morning. This bill is an act that requires the Arkansas Higher Education Coordinating Board to develop an action plan to address prevention of unplanned pregnancy for other purposes. It sets up an action plan that they'll set up and get some grants and things and try to do a better job on unplanned pregnancy for those college kids. Anybody got any questions?
Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is this limited to
college kids? I think so. It's for higher ed. That's what the bill
says. is there any to your knowledge is there a corollary authorization for students who are not in college who may have the same condition that could probably
true sir but why do we want
to give more favor to college kids who probably have more advantage than the
ones who are not in college well i wish mr represent fergus was here to answer that for you
because she just asked me to run it I'm not opposed to it but it seems as if it
should be for anyone well yes well we've got Planned Parenthood and some things through DHS and things I guess that we'd use for those this is a higher ed deal for the colleges
if I may follow up Mr. Chair you may it's my observation that Planned Parenthood doesn't fare very well out here So my concern is still the same. How do we benefit all those who have the same condition rather than giving advantage to those who may have already been advantaged by being given an opportunity or at least taking the opportunity to be in college? And you've said that you're running this for someone else. I'm not opposed to it, but I am concerned about it.
Well, maybe if we can get started here with this plan and college kids, maybe with this, if it works
good, maybe we can bring it on down to the rest of them. Representative Gray, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Ratliff, wouldn't you agree to Mr. Walker's question that this bill is addressing that almost 75% of the pregnancies were women between 18 and 19 years old, and that what this bill does is recognizes that
the community college and universities are a good place to start to reach some of these women, and that's why we're addressing it this way to begin with. Yes, sir. Yes,
sir. Thank you. Also, that would help provide some of these TANA funds and things that we use in college and help them get in college and maybe get things going their direction. Are there any other questions for the committee?
Seeing none, does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill for the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. What's the will of the
committee? Representative McElroy has a due pass. All those in favor say aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed
your bill. Thank you committee. Now I have House Bill 1750 for Representative Ferguson again. This act is to amend the provision of the Arkansas Code concerning governing boards and community colleges and four-year colleges like when what happened here is when you have
a merger between a two-year college and a four-year college, they're saying you probably don't need both boards at that point. 1750. House Bill 1750. House
Bill 1750. Are you ready for questions? Yes, sir. Are there any questions?
Representative Walker, you're recognized. I guess I talk too much. But is there some benefit in having institutional mergers?
Yes, sir. I know that we have a lot. ASU has a lot of mergers with different colleges like Newport. they've got a lot of little satellite I call them satellite colleges that the kids and folks don't have to drive as far to get the same education and so on you got ASU BB got that John Deere program that's a one-year two-year program I mean it it's an excellent program and it's all under the head of ASU and University has several junior colleges like at Batesville and so on so
it works real well if I may you mr. chair you might two things it would seem as if if there were two independent boards to begin with this would be a disincentive to consolidation and the second thing is that it seems like most Most of these colleges, which remain after consolidation, they operate with advisory boards.
Yes. Do you maintain under this bill the advisory board? It says you've got
a local board for the community colleges will be established. All right. I
understand Mr. Gray is saying it's okay, and I'll pass on it. Are there any other
questions of the committee? Seeing none, I think we have someone.
No one signed up. Anyone would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for that bill? I'm closed. Thank you, sir. What's the will of the committee? I have a due pass. All those in favor say aye. Opposed? No. Yep. Congratulations, you passed your bill. I'm going to recognize my co-chair, Representative Lampkin to present one, maybe two. We'll see.
And she's going to do this one first. 1485. Representative Lampkin, you're recognized to present House Bill 1485 first. Okay. All right. Thank
you, colleagues. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I will never again say this is a simple little bill, but it's not as bad as you think. This bill actually is going to establish a task force to overlook or study the best practices for special education programs in Arkansas.
And the bill itself is really divided into three parts. The first part lists the members, the makeup, what the organization is, and its purposes. Its purposes are on three and four, and what it's to do is to call in various people with, I guess, a stake in the game and discuss certain questions and how they're being handled in special ed today to see what are some of the best practices that we have in Arkansas. or maybe we'll reveal some things that we shouldn't do or some things that we could do better
or some things that we put too much emphasis on. In other words, to me, it's sort of a general review of the special education programs in Arkansas. And I was asked to run this bill because I taught special ed 20 years, but I know it's changed a lot. But that's the purpose of the bill, like I said, is to establish the best practices. What's working? We need to know what's working and what doesn't work we need to change. So the purpose is to establish the best practice for special education through a legislative task force.
The bill provides for the appointment of the members and describes its purpose and responsibilities. And that's basically it. Do you have any? I'll take questions. Are there any questions,
committee? Seeing no questions from the committee, is there anyone like to speak against the bill? I have some signed up to speak for. Bailey Perkins, is that right?
You're recognized. If you would go to the end of the table and state your name and who you're with, you'll be recognized to speak for
the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right, now my mic is on. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Good morning, everyone. My name is Bailey Perkins, and I'm representing Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. We are supportive of this bill and urge your support of it as well.
We have a constitutional obligation to ensure that all children receive the advantages and opportunities afforded by an adequate education. This includes children using special educational services. Nearly 52,000 students in Arkansas between the ages of 6 and 21 have an IEP, or an Individualized Education Program, to help them succeed. Special education covers a broad spectrum of needs from helping students with physical, developmental, and behavioral disabilities to aiding students with ADHD and dyslexia. So it's
important that students are placed in the right environment and given the right resources based on their specific need. The state has made great strides when it comes to special education. Our graduation rate for students using special education services has slightly improved over time, but there's still a significant portion of the student population falling through the cracks because they aren't receiving proper assistance, and we must address that. So it's critical to know the best practices, use targeted strategies, and ensure that students' needs are being met so that
our state dollars devoted to special education are used effectively. This hospital creates that platform to study and address needs for special education in three ways that we think are critical. One, it includes opportunities for inclusive stakeholder engagement and input. It includes a variety of people that care about special education, from the governor's office to legislators representing all quadrants of the state, parents who have children using special education services,
advocates for citizens with disabilities, and even the Department of Education. So it would be a collaborative effort where experts with various perspectives gather and develop strategies to better serve the needs of children using special education services. Secondly, the efforts of the task force include evidence-based research of best practices, reflection and analyses on Arkansas's current practices in the special education, so that that can be used as the basis for comparison and making recommendations.
All state investments should be grounded in solid research and effective practices, And so the task force will review areas that influence special education, like teacher preparation and licensure for special education, requirements for professional development, discipline practices for students in special education, the use of outside services, facilities, equipment, et cetera. And lastly, it allows for a sufficient amount of time for the task force to meet and submit a substantial recommendation to the governor and to the general assembly.
So with all those different things said, we ask that you support this bill and create a task force for special education. Thank you, and I'll open the floor for any questions.
Are there any questions? Thank you. Anybody against the bill? I'd like to speak against the bill. I have another one for the bill. Shirley Rinnicks, not sure how that name is pronounced. I believe she's coming up. She is going to be recognized. Now, if you would recognize yourself and who you're with, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
Yes, my name is Shirley Rennix, and I'm with the Citizen First Congress. And being a special needs parent, I support this bill because I understand what special needs children need. I understand that children are not responsible for the condition that they're in. I understand that as being a whole of a state and of the United States, that we should offer our children that have special needs.
We should offer them the understanding that they are just not somebody that's going to be shoved aside. They're not somebody that, even though they can't learn like other children, that we are just going to push them in a room and leave them. And we need to understand that all special needs children learn in different ways. And we need teachers that's going to teach them to understand. Because teachers had to have someone to teach them.
Special needs children have to have someone that understands that they can learn, and they can learn on their level. I support this bill and the Congress, Citizen First Congress, support this bill because we understand that everybody needs somebody to help them. Everybody understands that everybody has special needs. You are special here today that's sitting around this table. If your constituents didn't think that you were special enough, they wouldn't have voted for you.
So you are special here today. we all are special and we all need one another so I support this bill
not seeing any questions we'll move on is there anyone like speak against the bill after that I have one more to speak for Brenda Robinson you recognize speak for the bill you know the drill
Speaker 69
15:32
Mr. Chairman to the house ed committee Brenda Robinson president of the Arkansas Education Association and we do support house bill 1485 you've heard numerous reasons we make sure that students have the opportunity to learn and they're successful with the best practices, and we think that this bill would do that to bring all the stakeholders together to really look at what's best for students, because
we know that's the number one goal, and at the end of the day, we want to make sure that students are successful. So I urge
you to support House Bill 1485. Any questions? Not seeing any. Are there any other questions, committee? Does anyone else like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed
except to say I should have let those three ladies start
and I should have just stayed up there. But they said what's in my heart, too, and for me it is a matter of the heart to find out what are the best things that work for these kids. And with that, I'll close. I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized. Mr. Chair, I'd like to make
a motion at the proper time. It is the proper time. Move approval. We have a
motion of do pass. Do pass, I mean, sorry. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill.
Thank you. Thank you, colleagues. I appreciate it. And I appreciate your support for the public, too. They're all our kids.
Thank you. Would you like to run your other bill? Yes, sir. House Bill 1439. House
Bill 1439. Okay. You are recognized to run that one. All right. Thank you, colleagues. This one was supposed to be a little old bill, but it's expanded beyond that. So let me give you a little history of this bill first. House Bill 1439 was written to amend part of the provisions of the Arkansas Code concerning book depositories.
The bill that's involved that we're amending was passed, was presented by me in 2013, and it gave schools the flexibility in spending their instructional materials money for technology as the world changes, and some of them just needed extra money for that, so we gave them the flexibility. We didn't tell them not to buy books or what to buy, but they could make that choice by themselves. And the problem with it was in the last sentence it said that book depositories
basically shall have an establishment, a shipping place or establishment in the state of Arkansas. And I'm sorry it just escaped me that we had shall because that's pretty restrictive. So this year another group came forward and asked me to change one word, to change the word shall, to may, to give the bill more flexibility and make it their decision and not our mandate. May is considered less restrictive, more permissive,
and then it puts it in their hands to make a decision as to where they want to have their depository located. Basically, that's what the bill did, and that's what I want to change just to give the depositories themselves flexibility, more flexibility, and be less restrictive. And that's basically, that is what it is, just to change one word. They're an oversight of mine, I think, because had I really noticed that, I would not have had shall.
Thank you. Do you have any questions?
Representative Lowry, you are recognized for a question. Yes. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. And, Ms. Lampkin, I know that I'm signed on as a co-sponsor of your bill, but I'm going to ask a question that may seem like it's opposing you. But would this not potentially ship jobs out of the state of Arkansas? If the depositories, if the publishers are able to make a decision instead to have a depository in Memphis rather than in Arkansas, does this not potentially cut down on jobs of the depositories already in the state of Arkansas?
In my opinion, which I'm not an authority, but in my opinion it might some, but really book depositories are a thing of the past. Right now, there's only one in the state, as I understand, and that one obviously has no intention to shut down, but like printing companies, time is passing them by. Sad to say, because my husband was a printer for a long time, but the demand decreases with every year as we go to more technology.
So it might affect two or three jobs. I really
not. Okay. Well, hopefully we'll hear some testimony about
that. Okay. Thank you. Yes, sir. Representative Diffenbaugh,
you have a question? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lamkin, I don't know much about this, you know, just from what I've been told, but this one depository in Arkansas, it pretty well specializes in all Arkansas districts, doesn't it?
And by that, I mean, let's say that this depository did business out of state. And they had a certain curriculum that, let's say, Van Buren needed, you know. But if our depository or Arkansas depository sends it out of state, then where would we get our books if Arkansas depository is out of books? You know, like, you understand what I'm asking?
You have to order them from them. So is that going to cost us more money?
It depends on where you decided to order them from. I don't think that many companies order that many books anymore, and they have their sources, and that's a detail that I don't have any knowledge of. Okay. Thank you. I just wanted to give flexibility to the customer. Normally, you only have one in the state, and they stick to that state.
But logically, are the prices going to be cheaper? Usually not. If you're the only one in town, it's kind of like, you know, the company that used to be the only company in town, and they tried not to act like it. I don't know. I don't know. But I do think that in making it, in leaving it shall, we may deprive some other company of having an opportunity to open one in Arkansas. Hopefully this will open some. Okay. Thanks.
Representative Douglas, you're recognized for
Speaker 98
22:35
a question. Representative Lampkin, I'm trying to think about prices on the books. And if it's in-state already and we have that availability in-state already, wouldn't that drive the prices down to the school districts and the colleges instead of having to have those shipped great distances?
I'm just trying to think about pricing with having them local. I
don't know. It would depend on what they wanted to price. Like I said, you could look at it two ways. Maybe it would. But if the prices could be higher because you're the only one in town, like I said, I have no idea. I just don't think we should be as restrictive to new businesses, which is what this could lead to. I don't know that it will, but it could.
Speaker 98
23:30
Does it, that's what I'm trying to figure out. How does it limit competition? How
does it limit competition? Yes. The shall, if you didn't already have one, then you would have to bill one, and they might not be, or buy, and they might not want to go that far. I don't know. But we've got
Speaker 98
23:55
one now. Yes, one. Okay. And just to follow up, if I might.
And I'm wondering if having a depository in-state assures availability of the books because they have to keep them on hand so we're assured of the adoption that we prefer instead of having to maybe go to a second choice. And then hopefully the pricing is better if it's in-state. What do you think about the availability? Possibly the pricing
is better in the state, but it doesn't demand it.
Right. Right. Okay. And it depends on how exclusive or inclusive the one depository is. Okay. All right. Thank you, Representative.
Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lampton, are
you saying that in an era of technology and the ability to ship over longer distances in a lot more expedited fashion in today's world
that the requirement of a book depository is not necessary? Yes. Follow up, Mr. Chair? And are you also saying that a publisher's ability to operate a larger, whether it be in Arkansas or in another state, a larger branch rather than being required to operate on a smaller volume in some areas, that potentially their price could be
cheaper because they were able to consolidate in a single area versus many areas? Possibly. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Thank
you. Any other questions from the committee? I have going to start with the against. We have someone to testify against. David Casanelli, is that right?
If you would, take a seat at the other table. Recognize yourself and who you're with,
the bill. Good morning. Good morning. Good morning. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee, for your time today. My name is David Casanelli, and I'm representing BBA Solutions. We're an Arkansas-owned and operated company, fourth largest college textbook provider in the United States.
We purchased the depository in the last 45 days, and then suddenly we're broached with this problem we have here today. So before I get started, I want to thank Representative Lampkin for not running the bill last Thursday. I couldn't get here through the snow, so we really appreciate her patience on this so we could make our case for the depository and how it benefits the districts of Arkansas and still does today.
And just to point out, you know, we talked about shall and how that is more or less restrictive. We're here today because we won't be able to sustain the depository if that one word changes. The investment that we have to make to make sure we can maintain those inventories in a 90,000-square-foot warehouse here in central Arkansas to serve those districts would be, it would be very difficult for us to sustain that.
So maintaining that word actually makes it more competitive, and anybody's welcome to open another depository if they see fit. And no one would make that investment if the ability to move these cells out of state, which changing that word to May would do. And so I would argue that it makes it more competitive here in state. Also, we don't set the prices. The prices are set by the publisher.
And the bill that Representative Lampkin ran in 2013 was forward-thinking, and we agree and are supporters of that. But we feel the depository is a vital cog in this process because we're a portal for all the districts. The prices are posted publicly. We help maintain the prices for the small districts and the larger districts. We make that information available to them. So we save the district up to 8% on their purchases by aggregating that inventory in-state.
We currently provide about $25 million worth of printed materials to the districts. 80% of that revenue is to rural districts who don't have the resources, and we help manage that process for them and provide them consultative services around the frameworks and Common Core and all the complications that have come in the last couple of years. So if this bill passes, that will only add to that confusion. Keeping that inventory in-state makes it readily available
to fit their frameworks within a 30- to 60-day period before their school sessions start. They don't order these products six months in advance. They wait until their budget and their fundings and things come into place, and they order them in the summer. We can ship those products to them within two days. Those shipments could not be guaranteed if they were provided by outside depositories or warehouse facilities outside of the state of Arkansas, and it would only move that revenue and jobs out of state. So we are obviously opposed to this, and I appreciate your time and know this,
that this only benefits the publishers out of state. It does not benefit the districts or the state of Arkansas. I'd be happy to answer any questions, and I thank you for
your time and consideration. Are there any questions?
Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. Mr. Castanelli, I spoke with you yesterday, and I appreciate the input and insight that you gave me. I'm still trying to understand how the location of the facility is per se beneficial economically to the districts of the state.
It seems like wherever you are, would you not agree, you're going to have to ship these books. So if you're going to ship them from Texacana, which is Arkansas and Texas, it's going to be pretty much as if you ship them from Little Rock, or if you ship them from Fort Smith, which is on the land of Oklahoma, or if you ship them from some larger place, which does more business. That's the first thing. And the other thing that I'm always mindful of, where is your depository?
It's in the port here in Little Rock. I see. How many employees do you actually have? You know, it's a seasonal business. Well, I understand. But how many regular
employees do you actually have? Full-time, eight employees. During the peak time, it will approach
that's a few months. Yeah, so all the shipments are made in June
and July and early August. So the only really permanent people that you have are the owners and those
close to the owners? No, we have about seven or eight full-time staff members.
I don't mean to diminish it, but, you know, I think that part of the concern is to try to promote competition rather than to diminish it. And would you tell me how this promotes competition even among book depositories in light of what Representative Lampkin has said in support of the bill? Well, I think to answer your
first question about the shipping component, what we're able to do is forecast what the districts need.
And so if they need 2,000 units of a particular adoption, and it may be sold in Monticello or Fayetteville, we're able to forecast bulk ship that to the state so then we can expedite ship it at the just-in-time point that that district needs that. So if they wait until that small window, we're in the business of ordering textbooks in that window in lots of other arenas. guaranteed that that product availability is not there.
Within one week of us owning the depository, we were contacted by the Tennessee Depository to basic. They thought we were going to close the depository. We heard that they heard that we potentially weren't going to maintain the depository, and they wanted to get our contact list so they could approach the districts directly. So by aggregating that inventory, we're able to provide about 8% shipping savings to the districts. Also, we don't set the prices.
The prices are set competitively among the publishers, whether we operate a depository. And they're welcome to operate their own depository. And the reason they don't do it is because it would cost them too much money to do it. And so we're able to pull all the resources and represent all the publishers. And we represent about 200 publishers. So this would really benefit the larger publishers who have the means to maybe have a warehouse facility outside the state
or a relationship with another depository out of state. So I think it keeps the revenue in state. And what gets lost there is the product availability and does it fit your curriculum. So if Mississippi or Louisiana are serving the state of Arkansas, who are they going to ship to first? Their districts or ours? if they have a limited amount of inventory. I've already been approached in the last month by some of the large publishers to ship our inventory out of state because they need the product,
and we've refused to do it because we hold that inventory on consignment for the state of Arkansas, and we're there to protect the districts and protect their inventory. Are there any other questions,
committee? Thank you, sir. Thank you. Thank you for your time. I have to speak for the bill, Jay Diskey. If you would recognize yourself and who you're with, he will be recognized to speak.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Jay Diskey. I'm with the Association of American Publishers. I also want to thank Representative Lampkin for her interest in 1439. I represent the Association of American Publishers, which is the major association of U.S. book publishers. Our members publish in both print and digital formats and in all fields and academic subjects. My association supports this bill, which is very simple. It seeks to change one word in Arkansas statute so the publishers are no longer required to use a private textbook distribution center or depository.
Instead, we feel it is time for the depository to become a market-driven option, as such distribution centers have become in many states. We seek this change because of three reasons. One, Arkansas is no longer an adoption state. In 2013, the Arkansas legislature repealed statutory provisions regarding textbook adoption. mandated depositories are a fixture of state adoptions, which typically require in-state inventories of adopted textbooks.
State depositories were established decades ago when publishers and shippers did not have the resources and technologies to quickly ship large inventories of state-required textbooks directly to school districts. However, in this day and age, publishers can and do ship inventories of books to school districts across the country. Number two, many instruction materials are now in digital format and do not need to be warehoused. As stated in a September 15, 2014 letter from the Educators Book Depository of Arkansas,
which I believe is the predecessor of BBA, the letter says, this year we experienced a 75% drop in schools ordering printed materials. Much of this decline is due to the State Department's repealing of the adoptions and contracts process. The other decline is due to the advancement in technology that allows textbooks to be downloaded in seconds to an iPad. Number three, depositories are cost drivers, usually about 8% along those lines for the publishers.
As point of fact, most states don't require publishers to use depositories. And Arkansas is the only, the only non-adoption state that requires publishers to use the depository when there's not an adoption. The adoption, again, was repealed in 2013. The depository requirement is a concern to any educational publisher doing business in Arkansas. These include small and large publishers, both print and digital. In conclusion, depositories should be market-driven. They should be optional.
They can add value. We don't dispute that. However, if they add value, they must have merit for school districts and publishers. However, the market should determine that, not an outdated requirement. Thank you very much. I'd be happy to answer any
questions you have. Are there any questions? Representative
Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. I am a little concerned about what Mr. Cassinelli says about the loss of 48 jobs.
and I don't know whether there's anything of that in the state of Arkansas because that would produce a good amount of revenue and some work for some people who would perhaps not have it. Do you know of any publishing companies that provide textbooks to Arkansas, I mean to the nation which are located in Arkansas? I don't know if any of
the large, I don't believe any of the large companies have publishing facilities here.
Where are most of the publishing companies located? Any number of
aren't they? Yes and no. It truly does depend. I mean, I can
think of large publishing facilities in Chicago. I can think of them in Austin. However, I can also think of some in Arizona at the moment. We have more than 150 publishers as part of our association. When I say 150, I should say educational publishers, small, large, and in between,
doing business nationwide and, in fact, worldwide. All right.
Now, the second, if I may follow up, Mr. Chair. Mr. Chair. You'll recognize for your third follow-up. Tell me, what is the economic loss to the companies you represent if this motion fails? As I mentioned. If it passes, I'm sorry. What is the economic loss to you all? If it passes?
Yeah. Well, we see this, again, as potential cost savings. In order for a depository to handle the materials, again, materials that can be shipped directly now from any number of places around the country, generally we see cost driver of up to 8%. And again, there may be some publishers that choose to go through the depository. We see this as a market-driven option, not necessarily something that needs to be a requirement in this day and age.
again when there's no when there's
no adoption. Thank you. Representative Gray, you have a question? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can you speak
to Mr. Castanelli suggested a fear that if the inventory wasn't located in the state and a district ordered a specific item or set of materials that we could be in line lying, as a smaller area, being lying behind other people that wanted the same material
and maybe not have an opportunity to get that
material. Can you speak to that fear? I think it's a hypothetical. I think, like, any ordering system, yeah, orders are placed at certain times, and there may be times when one shipment takes precedent over the other, But I don't know any basis in fact in conjuring that at
the moment. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You may. So in your estimation, that would be an absolute worst-case hypothetical situation.
Well, let me put it this way. At the moment, we're not hearing any school districts sitting here and talking about, one, the value of continuing the depository as a required thing. I would think that perhaps that that would be something that school districts would want to talk about. I think once this adoption went away in 2013, again, some districts probably continued to use the depository in some way, and I imagine some have not and have gone out on their own looking for materials.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any other questions from the committee? Thank you, sir. Thank you very much. Does anyone else like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Would
you like to close for that bill? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. Once again, I'll say that I look at this as maybe an opportunity to add more businesses to Arkansas and to make us appear in the light of other states and other businesses as open to business,
if that happens, and there's no guarantee that'll happen. There are very few guarantees in life, but I do think it's fair to make it less restrictive and hope that a lot of good things can come out of it. And I'm close for my bill. I appreciate
a good vote. Thank you. What's the will of the committee? I have a do pass. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed, say no.
That's pretty close. I'm going to say that's a fail. Motion, got a roll call. Need to see two hands or no roll call? All right, we have
two hands. Call the roll. Representative Letting.
Speaker 159
43:40
Representative Murdoch, Representative Murdoch, Representative Deffenbaugh, Representative Harris, Representative Harris, Representative Eubanks, Representative Eubanks, Representative Radliff, Representative Gillum, Representative Gillum.
Representative Walker, Representative Bell, Representative Bell, Representative Balts, Representative Douglas, Representative Lowry, Representative Lowry, Representative McElroy? Yes. Representative Armstrong? Yes. Representative Armstrong? Yes. Representative
Gossage? Yes. Representative Gossage? Yes. Representative Sabin? Yes. Representative Hodges? Yes. Representative Hodges? Yes. Representative
motion fails representative Douglas you're recognized to run and I'm
I'm not sure which bill. You'll have to tell me. She's got 1596, which has an amendment
to her 1597. Let's run HB 1596, and you have an amendment for that bill. Is that correct? You have it? Okay, let's do the amendment. Okay, you're recognized to do that amendment first.
if you are. You're recognized to run the amendment
Speaker 98
46:18
for 1596, is that right? Yes, sir. this amendment is going to change my bill in that it will direct that the applications for these legislative days
for certified staff will go to the personnel policies committee and if there's not a personnel policy committee it will go to the principals and then the principals will have the ability to review the applications and make a decision based on a lot of different factors within the school that are going on at that time, testing and that kind of thing. And then the other change is that I have requested that teachers that do are accepted to come down
and have a legislative day, they are required to make a report on what occurred in the committee the day that they were here. And I would take questions and ask for a favorable vote. Are there
any questions on the amendment? Representative Lowry, you are recognized for question. No question? Nobody has a question? Representative Walker, you're recognized for question. Okay. Thank you again, Mr. Chair.
Representative Douglas. Is each district irrespective of size to be provided the five days, but not less than five, but not more than 10 days, so that if there is a district of 200 students, as over against one that may be 10,000 students, you still have no less than five nor more than ten days composite
for the teachers to attend meetings here in the House Committee on Education? I
Speaker 98
48:18
at first had tried to devise like a sliding scale, maybe based on their athletic designation, like the 1As get two days, 3As. It just got kind of complicated to do that, So I just gave them a window of between 5 and 10 and would allow the PPC can negotiate those days.
And ideally, the smaller districts are going to take the lower amount of days, and the
larger districts could take the larger amount. Second, if I may. You're recognized. Thank you. So, assuming that each district took 10 days, do you have a cost analysis, even if it took five days, do you have a cost analysis to what this would cost?
Speaker 98
49:18
Well, it's going to cost about $100 per teacher that is accepted. and that would be a district cost that is already set aside as their school business account that they already have in place. This is just going to open up another option for teachers to take as school business so that money is already set aside in the districts. but as far as a total cost
you know that would be per teacher that decides to take advantage of this and I hope we'll have several that will do this but I have a zero impact on the fiscal impact are there any other questions Mr. Lowry,
has a motion to adopt the amendments? Do I have a motion on the amendment?
Do I have a do-pass motion on the amendment from Mr. Lowry, from somebody? Okay, Representative Walker may be on that do-pass. Okay. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion has been adopted. You are recognized to present your
Speaker 98
50:50
main thing that I think is a good thing that can come from this is to set up more communication between teachers and administration
about what is going on down here in the legislature. We hear, you know, we have a lot of representation down here from school districts, and I think that sometimes teachers in the classroom misunderstand what's going on down here and how easy maybe it would be to give them what they want sometimes and I think having more teachers engaged in the process and setting up those conversations in the districts I think is going to be a healthy thing.
So setting aside those days for teachers to apply for through their personnel policy committee and then those applications that would be selected by the committee would then be passed to the principals for final approval because we do not want, you know, what we would ideally want is some elementary, some middle school, some high school.
We would want a variety of teachers to come and take part in this. And then the teachers would be responsible to make a report back and, you know, with their findings. What did you learn from this? What did you pick up from committee? And pass that information then on to their district. So I think it's a good idea. I've had really good feedback from teachers that think that this could really open up communication
and allow them to understand the process of what is going on down here. So
I would appreciate a good vote. Representative Lowry, you have a question. You're recognized.
yes. You mentioned, well, first let me ask, the reference to school business days. I'm not familiar with that collection of funding that is available.
Could you explain further about that?
Speaker 98
53:17
I don't know that it's statewide, but in most districts they have designations of days that you can take for leave from school. You have sick leave, and then you have personal days that you can take for anything, vacation or whatever. But then school business days are days where you are, you know, contributing to your own personal knowledge of what you do in the classroom
or your professional development as a teacher. And those days are, some districts will put a maximum on how many you can take, and some don't. But it would be professional conferences, would fall under school business. Okay. I want to ask about the fiscal impact, and I
know that you point out that it says zero, and Richard Wilson usually does a really good job on these fiscal impacts.
But the truth is there are some financial costs, correct? We're talking about the $100 per teacher, and I assume that is per teacher per day. We're talking about having to hire a substitute teacher to cover for them that day. We're talking about per diem and mileage. Correct. Despite the fact that the fiscal impact came back zero, do you have any best estimate of really what we are talking about with the cost? If we looked at the low side of five days per school district
and the high side of 10 days per school district, what kind of range are we talking about when you factor in all the costs
Speaker 98
55:02
that I've already talked about? I think it would be about $100 per teacher because depending on what kind of substitute you get, depending on how much you pay your substitute at your school, and I think those are different. you know whether you have a certified or a classified sub those are different costs and then the mileage and you know a meal coming down here so if you're talking about five teachers
in a district you know between five and six hundred dollars for that district and if you're talking about 10 days then you're talking about a little over a thousand possibly if you had all 10 days taken, which I think is a very minimum investment for a school district to start that communication with teachers and let them see what this process is down here that so greatly affects them in the classroom. We make decisions about what tests they give, what curriculum they accept,
what insurance they have and I think that it's a good communication avenue for them. Thank you. I will want another follow-up. Put
me back in the queue, please. Representative Deffenball, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can I have
a follow-up also? Yes, you may. Representative Douglas, I do like this. I just want to make sure
one person, could they take two days or can the superintendent take all 10 days or i know you talked about the personnel policy deciding on that but we also know that there can be pressure on personnel policy to you know maneuver it'll maneuver things like they want
Speaker 98
56:54
it so how does that work well the personnel policy committees are usually voted on by the teachers so that's a good committee to have make this decision
because they represent the teachers. And I can see situations where, you know, one person might take two days. I can see a situation where you would want to have more of a variety of teachers to come down and see what's going on. And I think there needs to be some collaboration between those building principals and the policy committee so that you get the best, you know, people down here and people that are interested, so some collaboration should take place
between the policy committee and the administration. All
down here with us? Well, since you're already down here, we're safe. That's all. Thank you. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. the first thing I've told you I'd be supportive of this but I'm concerned that if we are trying to support the concept of teaching
and the profession of teaching how we can be talking at the same time about treating teachers as at will employees that's just a comment the question for me is that if you're going to limit this to five but not more than ten teachers is there some way that these some selection process so that this does not
become in effect just a gift day to the teachers and other teachers are not afforded the same gifts. And I say this because if they're coming to our committee or to the Senate committee, they're talking about coming for two hours. I think Mr. Cozart has seen to it that we get out in two, no more than two and a half hours. So an eight-hour day converts to two hours, and that looks like it's a vacation to me unless there's some particular benefit
to be derived from just coming and listening
Speaker 98
59:21
to us. Well, I would hope that they would have conversations with us as legislators, and I would hope that they would also come to the session and watch the bills being passed and understand that process as well. So I can see that being a very full day that they can take advantage of. And I don't think it would, you know, I do think they would think of it as a privilege, but not as a day off.
really do. I think we need to, everybody, not just the teachers, I think that we need to understand the process better. When I was county judge, they would actually, the auditors would look,
and see if we were using taxpayers' money to lobby. And I'm wondering when the teachers come down here, you know, it's just a natural, I guess, a natural leaning to try to get us to do what they want. And we want to take their direction, but I wonder if it's a fine line between using the taxpayers' money to come down here and lobby
Speaker 98
1:00:48
for things that they want. Could you address that? Well, the school districts are already, it's my understanding, providing an avenue for superintendents and principals to come down during the legislative session.
So that expenditure and that communication between us and the schools is already there. This would just expand it to have more classroom teachers in the conversation. Representative Lauer, you're recognized for
a question and a half. Yes, thank you. The question I
asked a while ago was wanting to look at the total potential costs of this
and not looking at the $100. So I went ahead and did some math. I'm just going to ask you if my math is anywhere close to being correct. If we were to assume that each school district, 238 school districts, took the full 10 days at $100 per day, that would be $238,000, correct? I would have to trust you on that. Plus the mileage in per diem, which we're probably, is it realistic to say we're talking about a half million dollar per year expenditure?
Speaker 98
1:02:07
You know, I talked to my superintendents in my district and the ones that have collective bargaining already have this going on, and they said that their legislative days are rarely 100% taken. So, you know, I don't anticipate 10 days per district at all, so I don't think your upper end calculations would ever come to fruition. But like I said, this is already school business,
And if they can, you know, make an application and say that this is going to further their, you know, work in their classroom and professionally, you know, enhance them in, you know, what they're, you know, wanting to do, then, you know, the application is accepted. And remember, it is an application process that could be either denied or accepted. So the money, the pool of money that is there in the district is already there.
The district and the teachers just need to decide if this is the priority for them or if they would rather take their, you know, school business days and go on a, you know, to a convention. So it's just opening up another suggestion, another way that they can learn about this process that affects them so greatly. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Are there any other questions,
committee? You will speak. I have some speak against the bill.
Dr. Abernathy, you are recognized to speak against the
Speaker 197
1:03:59
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA. We do have several concerns with this bill. And, you know, one of the concerns is the opportunity for local school board to decide how they want, what policies they want to implement in their district.
And the lack of local controls that current school boards has seems to be diminishing as we go. We have a couple other thoughts. Financial situations have been brought up several times. And it does, in fact, treat different districts differently based on their size. If I have a 350-student school district and I'm still obligated to give 10 days, that's going to have a lot bigger impact on the revenue expenditures
than if I'm in somewhere like Little Rock or Bryan or something like that, that I have 10,000 kids because you have obviously bigger budgets, but you have a lot more teachers to pull from as well. There is no funding that we can tell that's been provided for this. We understand that, you know, Representative Douglas, and I have a lot of respect for her, but she says it's in the school now. I'm not sure which eggshell it's under, but I don't believe there's any additional funding.
Representative Lowry, you mentioned about a half million dollars cost, and I would say that would be in the ballpark. You know, maybe a little high, a little low, but that's in the ballpark. So there is the impact statement, as you saw, is zero cost to the state. that we used to have impact statements that came that showed the cost to school districts because I don't believe the courts were concerned about unfunded mandates placed on the state. They were concerned about unfunded mandates placed on schools. In the last several years, we've kind of gotten away from that,
but there is a fact that it would be a cost to the schools. um we have you know some of the the talking about meals uh coming in and in a lot of districts um have policies that they don't reimburse for meals unless it's an overnight trip um and i think many uh legislative auditors would agree with that um but that policy probably could be changed um but again that would be a district decision when you look at the teacher would take
the request to PPC. PPC, I believe, if I'm reading the amendment correctly, would take the recommendation for approval or denial to the building level principal so that building level principal has the final authority to approve or deny. You know, I'm not sure if PPC is recommended to the building level principal. You know, does, in fact, that building level principal make the final decision you know some of the I think things that need to be looked at is you know if those
requests were granted such as this time period when you are in session and which I think that could be very beneficial for you to hear from teachers and administrators alike a lot of a lot of school districts out there have started their statewide assessment and you know at some point we need to make sure that we have teachers in the school and to to give assessment or give instruction and the more we pull them out the the obviously less instruction that our kids are going to miss we do have you know I don't know if this will
count for professional development credit or not you know so I guess professional development money may be an option for school districts to pay for this but bottom line you know we don't think it's a good idea we do think that that that decision needs to be made at the local level and if that local level they decide that this will be a good thing, then they can develop a policy to come down here. And I'd be glad to answer any questions. Representative
Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you.
I've indicated that I would support this. I see this as an effort by Representative Douglas to provide professional development, even though she doesn't call it that. It's a professional development day, and it has the potential for not only causing the teachers to become better informed, especially in some of the schools where civics and government and history are taught and public policy,
but it also affords the opportunity for their students to be brought with them if a school district is sensitive and wishes to allow this to happen on a field trip so that they can learn about the process as well. So it expands not only the training opportunity for a teacher, but it expands the width of opportunities available to the school district if school districts really creatively take advantage of this.
I don't know if she wanted me to say that, But I think that I see that as a possibility that enhances my respect for the bill, even though it's not put in the bill. Thank you. Representative Walker, I would agree
Speaker 197
1:09:17
with that. And I think local districts have that flexibility right now. When I was building level principal, I'd always try to bring a class down here to let them go through the Capitol and see this process. And I think it would be very beneficial if all of them would. but yes I do
provide but I do think local districts can do that currently are there any
other questions seeing none thank you is anybody for the
close for your bill yes thank you So, committee,
Speaker 98
1:10:05
I see this as a, you know, we pass a lot of things down here
that shove our policies down the throat of teachers. And me being a retired teacher, I was on the other end of that a lot of times. Mandates would come down, and, you know, we're going to change this this year. Next year it's going to be a different policy. And I don't remember ever being asked how I would feel about this policy or that policy. We need more input from the boots on the ground, the people that are having to implement our policies.
The money is there for school business. I'm just saying that this should be considered a school business opportunity for teachers to come down and give us some input on the practicality of the policies that we're voting on day in and day out that affect them so greatly. and you know I just again I just see as a great communication piece I see it as a boost
to teachers around the state to say we respect you enough that we will you know abide by this and want to support you in becoming a part of the process I see it as good for school climate in the school districts And I hope that superintendents would embrace this and say, we hope that you will go down and see what the process is and give us some feedback so that when we're making policy decisions, you know what went on in committee
and can bring that report back to us. So I see this as a great opportunity for classroom teachers to become involved and to give their input into policies, and I would appreciate a good vote. What is the will of the committee? Do
pass. As amended? As amended. We have a do pass as amended. All those in favor say aye. Aye.
All those opposed, no. No. The ayes have it. You have passed your bill. Congratulations. And your other bill is House Bill 1597. You are
Speaker 98
1:12:45
recognized to present that bill. This is a bill that, again, affects teacher sick leave. And it's in a very narrow situation,
but this was brought to me by a teacher that had this situation actually happen to them. When you transfer from one district to another, many districts will accept your sick leave from that sending district. So let's say you brought 15 days in with you to your current district. Then you start accruing sick leave at your current district. there was a situation where the district never allowed the sending district's sick leave to ever be taken
so that when that teacher retired unbeknownst to them they had 15 or 20 days left that the district would then not pay them for because many districts pay you for your sick leave when you retire. This would just clear up that situation and say that all sick leave is put into the same pot and they're not designated as either being from the sending district or from the current district
so that those days will be a part of your retirement package when you leave the district. And, you know, the teachers can expect to get that full amount. I'd be glad to take questions. Are there any questions,
committee? Seeing none, does anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill?
No questions from committee? Would you like to close from your bill? I'd appreciate a good vote. What is the will of the committee? I have a due pass from Representative McElroy. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, committee. I appreciate it. Senator Clark, you are recognized to present Senate Bill 325.
Mr. Chair, I'd like to ask Superintendent Ronnie Cazare to come to the table
with me. All right. If he would go ahead and recognize himself and
time. Ronnie Cazare, Superintendent, Wachita School District.
Thank you. Senator, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. SB 325 started out being a small school bill, and then once we introduced it, we had large schools contact us that very much appreciated the bill.
What it says is that if you offer the 38 core courses and someone doesn't take them, and in a small school that is very possible, that for a semester or a year someone doesn't take a course that you will not be dinged and put on probationary status for that. Mr. Kazar came to me weeks ago and we began to work on this with some others and it was interesting that a rather large school contacted me
and said that they had been dinged and had to spend a lot of man hours to try to get it reversed because all of their calculus students took AP Calculus. So, therefore, it shows that they didn't meet standards because they don't have Calculus I. And that's certainly something that you can foresee as being a problem. From there, I will take questions and, at the proper time, allow you to hear from Superintendent Kazar.
Representative Walker, you're recognized for questions. Yes, I'm real concerned about that and I'd like for
Mr. Woods or somebody from the State Department of Education to address this before the superintendent does. Mr. Wood, would you like to step forward please? Tony Wood, Commissioner of Education. May I proceed?
You may. Mr. Wood, did that actually happen where all the students took AP course and the district got cited because it did not offer it otherwise? I don't know the
Speaker 215
1:17:47
specific instance, but it certainly could have happened and probably did. Can
you tell me the rationale for citing someone for not offering a course when all the students have opted to be in another course that is more required and probably will enhance their learning even more so?
Speaker 215
1:18:16
No, sir. I can't give you any rationale for that other than that's the rules and regs under which
we operate. Then what's the justification for punishing a district in that context? I don't
that are in place. Thank you. Are there any other questions?
Representative Ratliff, you're recognized. Mr. Tomlin, would this bill fix that problem? It's my understanding that it would.
Thank you, sir. Are there any other questions? Anybody? No. Seeing no other questions, is there anybody in the audience that would like to
speak against the bill? Mr. O'Count, do you speak against it, sir,
from the advocates? You do? Okay. I have one coming to the table to speak against the bill. Thank you. Mr. Wood?
Go ahead. If you'll recognize yourself and who you're with,
you'll recognize to speak against the bill. I'm Jerry Dorlikowski with Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families, and I wanted to thank Senator Clark for calling me one snowy morning and offering to visit with me about this. Our concern with the bill is not that we not be able to – We think there are cases where we might want to be able to do this for a smaller school,
but the problem we're concerned about is that there's no lower limit to this. So if a school had four classes they couldn't offer, there's no lower limit. There's no length of time. How many classes can they not? How many years? I could see a school that never had a physics class over four or five years' time or never had three or four different classes. So although we see a need for legislation like this for certain situations,
we'd like to see some kind of where are we going to bottom out, how many standards are we going to let slide before we say stop, that's too many. With this, we don't have any way to do that. Our two other concerns, we acknowledge the concern that big districts may have or districts where they have an AP class, but we feel it's more appropriate to address that in the standards of accreditation.
It seems ludicrous to me, and I would have to agree that an AP Calculus class wouldn't meet the same requirement as Calculus I, is the example they've cited here. I think the fix is not this bill. The fix is in the standards of accreditation. But even if you did fix that problem with this bill, you're going to create a lot more problems. And the other problem with it is if you remember your definition of adequacy that the state put forward, the first
component of that definition of adequacy, and I have it here. I'll read it because we probably don't all have it memorized, but the standards included in the state's curriculum frameworks which define what all Arkansas students are to be taught, including specific grade level curriculum and a mandatory 38 Carnegie units defined by the Arkansas Standards of Accreditation to be taught at high school level. So you would have to change your definition if you're going to allow 38, fewer than 38
units to be considered adequate. And also, anyway, I just think the place to make the fix we're talking about here as the good reason for this is in the standards, not by lowering the standard for everybody. And I think, just to sum up, it's a problem when we don't have a lower limit where we could even have a school that offered 20 units or something like that. Are those kids getting an adequate education if we don't have a lower limit.
Thank you. Any questions? Representative Gossage,
Speaker 222
1:22:40
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think what you have suggested is that there could be, in some cases, where school districts for whatever reason attempt to suppress students from taking these courses that are part of the standards. is that what I'm hearing you say? I think there might be
a case where a district didn't have a teacher
for one or more classes and it's been anecdotal but I've visited around the state for years and years so that this has happened where one student that wanted to take one class has been told I really funneled into another class Follow up, Mr. Chair?
Speaker 222
1:23:32
have a remedy for that. If someone believes that a superintendent or principal or whoever is using these kinds of techniques to suppress students from taking courses,
you know, we have an ethics law in Arkansas, I'm fairly certain trying to subvert the rules of the state and legislation in this state would apply to someone who
does that. Would you agree with that? I haven't seen very many superintendents brought before the Professional Standards Board or the ethics, but I may have missed an example or two of that, so perhaps I have.
My bigger concern is that there's something wrong with the school if they have children that don't want to take these advanced classes and that aren't encouraging their students to take as many classes as they can. I think there could be a case where you have a school, a small school, where you won't have any kids that want to take four classes, but is that a good thing? Is that adequate education, and do we want to promote that?
I'm concerned that there's no lower limit. I could see it happening with a class, but I would feel better about the bill if it just said one class could be
just don't like not having any kind of bottom line. Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. I see your concern. And my questions to the director dealt only with the hypothetical presented in support
of the bill being offered. You raised a broader question which I think that goes beyond the representations of Senator Clark. And I'm concerned that a district that includes everybody in an AP course not be punished for it because all students really, would you not agree, should be in those AP courses rather than just the few who are so designated.
And the exception should be where you have a course that is required and everybody can't be in it, but it ought to be that the course should be made available to those students who cannot otherwise qualify because they cannot maybe read or do not have the sufficient comprehension. And I don't see that this bill necessarily addresses that, but if it goes to what the hypothetical was and it takes away a citation for causing all students to be exposed to
the same learning experiences, it would seem to make sense for that. But your concern, is it not, is that this will take away more than it will give to school districts. Is that a fair reading?
Yeah, I just have concern. I know it makes sense in the case they've mentioned, and I fully agree, and I would like to see this bill just tweaked and amended a little bit because I think it could be a good bill. But I have concerns about how far below the 38 units we go and how many schools have problems.
And I don't think they're going to twist arms, but I think sometimes kids aren't encouraged to do what they can do because it's easier
if we don't have to have that teacher. We agree.
Speaker 98
1:27:21
Thank you. Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Just a thank you, Mr. Chair, clarification. This is not changing the SMART Corps. This is not changing college prep requirements.
Those things are still in place so that all students are graduating with what they need to be college proficient. So explain to me why we're not going to be fearful of we're not watering down our curriculum because of this. Are you asking? Yes, sir.
Okay. Senator Clark. We are not changing the standards. The courses still have to be offered by law. Same graduation requirements have to be met.
And so, you know, if I shared the same concerns, and I would certainly, if we had problems, I'd be the first one to come back. If I may tell you, just anecdotally, when I was a senior, when I showed up for my first day of my senior year for physics, I was told we only had two people in that class, so we wouldn't have physics. Now, I can tell you if we'd have had the law then that we have now, we would have had physics. I would have been brave enough to have demanded it, and my parents certainly would have.
So I think we have the selfishness of students who are wanting to go to college and wanting to do the best they can that are not going to be turned away knowing the law. I think we have their parents. I think I have a great group of superintendents that have just the opposite problem, is especially where you have a small census, they are knowingly having to talk kids into taking classes both above and below their levels so that they meet some numbers, so that they don't have to spend hours driving to Little Rock
to try to explain why they did the right thing. And then often, as Mr. Kazar can testify, not getting a waiver. I even had three students years ago, this is not something new for him, that wanted to take AP courses, and they asked for a waiver and didn't get it. But no, we would not in any way dilute the standards. Superintendent would you like
Speaker 210
1:29:51
one of the things that was
mentioned is the checks and balances on this one of the things in the bill was that they we would have to go to the ADE with this information so they would be able to check back and say you know This district is annually not offering this course. Representative Gossage made a great point on that with ethics, with Facebook. I mean, if you try to stop a student from taking it, we're going to get blasted as a district. The bottom line on this is, though, what we deal with, the changes that we're asking education to do
are to bring students more to the college level. And so when we have students that want to take college courses, but we can't offer them because we don't have a student taking a contemporary history in the school district, that's not fair to students. And it goes back to the choice. And what we do, you know, every parent, we sit down and do a career action plan with our students trying to help them go to the next level. We offer every course. We give them a list. What you need to realize is that if we just offered the 38, it would be cheaper than what we do by trying to get these students to take college courses, to take some of the AP that they don't have to take in the 38.
And that's the bottom line. When we get into helping the students, we want to make sure they're taking the courses they need, not the courses that the district has to have to meet standards. The reason it's not a standards issue, I believe, because as we've gone back and tried to fix this, standards has tried to work with us, but standards' hands have been tied based on the legislation, and so that's why we brought it to y'all to try to fix.
Any questions for Representative Walker? You're recognized for
a question. I apologize for being the one that asks most of the questions, but I'm trying to understand how having students, all students, take college courses
Speaker 210
1:32:05
hurts any student. You know, that's my issue. I would love to see WSD all not offer senior English because all of our students are taking Comp 1 and 2. But the way the law is now, we'd be put on probation
because nobody was taking senior English as a fourth-year English. So that's what we're trying to do is to offer the opportunities and not just college. We have students, you know, we're pushing career tech. You know, the governor came through with the computer tech class, and we have to, you know, get students interested in that. That's not one of the 38. That was added. Now we have to make sure someone's in it. That's a good course. It's not the problem with the course, but it also takes away from, you know,
Some of our students getting in the 38, when you're dealing with the smaller districts, then you do get into that. When we've got a graduating class between 30 and 40 students, then you do see that being an issue. And, you know, when we have to tell students, I mean, I've dealt with this with my own children, and I don't have any more in school, so I can't put them in the courses they need. But it's kind of like, what are we going to do? someone has to take this course or it analyzes the district and
common sense doesn't outweigh the standard. That's why I talked to Senator Clark about this because I've been fighting it for 10 years to just try to use a little common sense on it and hopefully we can get there. Are there
any questions? Any other? Representative Ratlitt. How many units do you offer? Above 38?
Speaker 210
1:33:54
I don't have the exact figures. I would say we probably offer about 10 different courses. We try to do all the college that we can. We also pay for that. We pay for textbooks. We had the big textbook debate earlier. The college textbooks cost us more than our high school textbooks. It cost us more to go beyond the 38. But that's what our parents expect. And that's what we want for our kids. Follow up. How
many hours are your kids getting out, college hours when they graduate?
Speaker 210
1:34:26
Right now, we've had them that have gone over 30 in the past. The big issue that I'm trying to deal with as a district is to make sure the hours are useful. Yes, yes, sir. You know, right now we have 12 that I guarantee can go anywhere. And so I'm trying to focus on getting them, you know, more that are useful. you know lakeside brought out the the new plan where they're hoping to have students graduate with an associate's degree right um washington would love to do that the way the standards are
there's not a not a chance because we have to have students in these 38 courses or we're going to get in trouble for it um you know we use our teachers to teach comp one we're using our teachers to teach algebra college algebra um we did biology this year which we got with the college and they were able to work with us so we could give a four-hour college course. That's what we're trying to do. My ultimate goal is that we graduate students that move forward to the workforce.
That's what it's about. Thanks, sir. Any other questions, committee? Is there anyone who'd like to speak against the bill? All right, you recognize. If you would state your
Speaker 242
1:35:49
name and who you're with, you're recognized. Richard Hutchinson, Arkansas Public Policy Panel. I'll be very quick. We agree with the concerns that have been raised by Arkansas advocates. We think that probably we need to look at some tweaks in the bill and also that the State Department and the State Board need to take the lead
in adjusting the language in rules and regulations regarding the standards to address some of the issues that have been raised here. Thank you.
Are there any questions? Does anyone like to speak for the bill? State your
Speaker 197
1:36:28
name and who you're with, and you're recognized. Richard Abernathy, executive director of AAEA, and we do support this legislation. I think Superintendent Kazire has said it very well,
the issues that are being faced out there with schools, and ultimately school districts having to force kids into courses that they don't want, don't need, or there's better opportunities, simply to keep the school open. And we think this is good legislation we'd like for
you to consider. Seeing no questions. Does anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Any other questions from the committee? Would you like to close for your bill?
I obviously should have let Superintendent Kazar have done all the speaking.
He did such a good job, and I appreciate him bringing the bill, and I would appreciate a good vote. What's the will of the
committee? I have a motion do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed no? Congratulations you've passed your bill. Thank you Mr. Chairman. Thank you members of the committee. Senator Clark if you could stay at the end of the table for a few minutes I would like to present your other bill and I would love for you to stay with me. I'm going to come to the end of the table and present Senate Bill 179. Will?
you, Madam Chair. At this time, I'd like to present Senate Bill 179 by Senator Clark and others, and by quite a few that are sitting on this committee or on this list also, and others.
This is an act to require school districts subject to DSEG order to notify the Department of Education and provide a copy of the desegregation order and amend the Public School Choice Act of 2013. what this bill basically does it takes the school choice act that we had last year and it sunsets in I believe in June is that correct in June and this will continue it on and take that sunset clause off and then it also adds some language
and I may have to get Senator Clark to help me a little bit I'll try and you can chime in anytime it changes some dates of when they may apply it moves everything one month back from I believe it was from June to May to apply and they have to be notified by July the 1st instead of August the 1st and that gives them a little more time to prepare so if they're not accepted they can go on and go to another
avenue. This also basically the main language that's changed in this is to have a district show their desegregation order, which we have quite a few districts in Arkansas that are under desegregation order. And so this School of Choice Act would not apply to them as long as they are under that order. So they have to submit that to the Department of Education to show that they are under desegregation order or not under that order.
So if they're not under that order, they have to show that they are not. so that's based I'll let
you add whatever you want to add a couple other little tweaks it establishes capacity at 90% because if you're at capacity for a grade you don't have to take children it also has one other little date change that actually slowed us down a couple of weeks that AAEA asked for it moves the time when you determine what the school census is
for determining the 3% which by the way is still in there, uh, to October 15th, uh, instead of in the summer so that they, they know way ahead of time, uh, what number, uh, that they'll be judging that
3% from. I believe that's the, about covers it. Okay. Are there any questions by
the committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized. Yes. Thank you. Now, the school choice seems to be most prevalent around Little Rock in Bauxite, Cabot, Bryant, Lone Oak, and Conway.
Let me make sure I'm right about that. Can you tell me why this is not a racial bill and why it does not have both racial effect and racial purpose? Absolutely. I'm glad
you asked that question. In Senate Ed, two years ago, when we discussed this bill with the Sunset Clause,
the El Dorado superintendent came and testified. Springdale superintendent came and testified. They were sure that they were going to lose bunches of students. Since you have the statistics there that you're looking at, and I don't have them, you will see, you'll have to look way down the list, but I think you'll see that both of them gain students. As I brought up back at that time, Hot Springs School, which is covered under the DSEG order so they can't lose students, actually gains, the county schools are mainly white,
and they gain 600 kids a year into their elementary school through their magnet school programs. So I can't tell you that everyone that changes does not have some ulterior motive from a minority of them, but most of them change for the same reason my daughter did. They think they've got a better opportunity somewhere else. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes, sir. You're a direct answer for follow-up.
I wasn't in the debate when you all began this choice matter,
but are you aware that the courts have consistently knocked down freedom of choice plans as being anti-desegregative and promoting racial isolation and prejudice? And I'll cite to you the case of Clark v. The Board of Little Rock. It's a 1983 case that's still good law. I understand that the legislature passed it and somehow the view seems to be that whatever the legislature wants to do, it can. But I don't see how you
can just authorize people simply because of their prejudice or their preferences to be around like people who may be richer or are better situated, the opportunity to leave a district and go to another district. How do
justify that? How do you require a high school senior who's a National Merit Semifinalist, Mr. Walker? Representative Walker, I'm sorry. How do you require a National Merit Semifinalist senior
to miss physics his senior year because it's not offered or to burn spam on Bunsen burners in a chemistry class that he actually did have when he has a school three miles down the road that he could have attended. How do you justify that?
Well, then what you do in that situation is that you afford that student an opportunity to go to that school, but it's a district offering and it's not a prejudice offering. Now, the choices that are being made for the most part are lower grade choices before you
get to the situations that you talk about where you have some schools like Central High School in Little Rock and maybe Parkview or maybe some of the others where you have higher course offerings but this is not generally the typical choice situation and there are many other options to this I mean you can you can allow those students to go to college early other things but this This is not something that is absolutely necessary.
It only gives people an opportunity to get out of a majority situation or one where they don't want to confront their prejudices and go some other place. So obviously I don't have enough votes here to stop this but I want it on the record at least from one person that this is both racial motivation and racial effect and that is demonstrated not only by the statistics, but by the history in this state of freedom of choice.
And while there is a clamor for it, I hope that all of you recognize that we came here to try to overcome prejudice,
rather than to have been reinforced. Point of personal privilege. Thank you. I'm not a member of this committee, but I am bringing this bill. And to make the statement that this is racially based is not only unfair, it's wrong. that should never be done unless you have some proof of that you have just made statements against my character
I really do because you are sincere and you are good faith and I don't believe that you have personal racial animus now I want to make that very clear but I am saying that you're the successor in all due respect if I may finish this I'll not say anything else on this Okay, make it brief, please. All right. The statistics are very clear that since you have had choice, it has been the persons who have taken advantage of it have used that choice
to resegregate and segregate schools and to have people isolated on the basis of race and socioeconomics. And I apologize. This is emotional to some of you on the other side, And I want you to know it's not only emotional to me on this side, but it's also legal, and it's something that we have to address as a society and as a state. Thank you. Thank you, Representative
Walker. Any other questions? Is there anyone in the audience who'd like to speak for the bill?
Yes, sir. Please identify yourself for the record, and you may proceed.
Speaker 254
1:47:19
I'm Jimmy Cunningham. I'm superintendent of the Hampton School District, and we are not here to resegregate schools. I'm not here to resegregate schools, and I know that's an issue. But the thing that I like about the bill, a couple things. One is that we move the date to May the 1st instead of June the 1st.
If it's May the 1st, then we have an opportunity to address our staffing problem. And the other thing is that it allows a sibling of a student to attend the school where his brother or sister is attending. That will not help my school district. I mean, in my district is East Camden, General Dynamics, Lockheed Martin, and a lot of my kids that's in my district go to an adjoining school, which is fine.
But before, you know, I just think it's wrong that we don't allow those kids to go where their parents want them to go. So those
you. Question. Question. You recognize Representative Walker. What's the racial effect of the transfers that have been made on the choice in
Speaker 254
1:48:43
your district? I am about 30% minority, and I can't think of a minority student that has transferred to another district.
That's right. So all your transfers have been away. Yes,
sir. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Okay. Are there any other questions by the committee? Would you like to close
for your bill, Representative Cozart? I would, Madam Chair. I thank you for the questions. It seems that everything has to be racial in this committee lately,
and I hate that, that that has to happen. I don't believe that this is a racial issue on school choice. There may be some things involved, but it is an opportunity for any child that wants to go to another school, whether they're black, white, Hispanic, Asian, whatever. they are, they can go anywhere they want to go if they choose to go up to that percentage. So I don't believe it is a racial issue and I would appreciate a good vote.
Okay. What are the wishes of the committee? Representative Lowry, you're recognized.
Do pass. Okay, we have a motion of do pass on the bill. Are there all those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. No. Ayes have it. okay do i see two i don't see two hands and there's two okay all right we'll roll call are you ready uh yes sir representative letting
Speaker 159
1:50:28
representative letting representative murdoch representative murdoch representative deffenball Representative Harris Representative Eubanks Representative Ratliff Representative Gillum Representative Walker Representative Bell
Representative Baltz Representative Douglas Representative Lowry Representative McElroy McElroy? No. Representative Armstrong? Representative Armstrong? Representative Gossage? Yes. Representative Seiben? Representative Seiben? Representative Hodges? Yes. Representative Gray? Representative
Gray, Representative Lampian, Representative Cozart. Yes. You got ten
votes. Okay. Congratulations, Representative. You passed your
There he comes. I don't think we have anything else today, ma'am.
No? Okay. Thank you, sir. Committee, I would like to remind you
of shale bills that were filed yesterday. If you have all your shale bills filed, you have seven days to make those into a bill. And then if you're in an education on those, you're only going to have, it's going to take three days to get your impact if they do come through K-12. So that's going to be real close to getting them in. So I advise you to get your shale bills done and back as soon as possible.
If you have a bill on the agenda and deferred and you're not going to run it, please withdraw it if you do. And if you have anything on there that you're just not going to run, please withdraw it so we can clean this calendar off, see exactly what we have, and we can move on. We will meet back here after session, 15 to 20 minutes. We'll give it a little leeway. After adjournment of session. Thank you all. If no objections, we're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1534
HB1750
HB1485
HB1439
HB1596
HB1597
SB325
SB179
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Bailey Perkins
Unverified
Shirley Rennix
Unverified
Speaker 67
Speaker 69
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Chair
Unverified
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Speaker 72
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh
Unverified
Speaker 98
Speaker 116
David Casanelli
Unverified
Speaker 140
Speaker 159
Speaker 179
Speaker 183
Speaker 100
Representative Mark D. McElroy
Unverified
Speaker 197
Speaker 187
Senator Alan Clark
Unverified
Speaker 210
Speaker 215
Representative James Ratliff
Unverified
Speaker 222
Speaker 224
Speaker 220
Speaker 242
Speaker 175
Speaker 254