House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (13)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB368
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…his time, I'm going to recognize Senator English to present Senate Bill 368.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1256
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1256”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1419
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1419”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1545
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1545”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1602
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1602”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1640
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1640”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1685
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1685”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1713
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1713”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1038
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1038”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB366
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB366”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB371
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB371”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB591
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB591”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB695
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB695”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
a few times during committee. I may have to. Chair sees a quorum. And again, good morning. Madam Chair, would you have anything you'd like to say this morning? Good
At this time, I'm going to recognize Senator English to present Senate Bill 368.
Is that what you want to do first? That's it. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Jane English, Senator. And I have before you this morning Senate Bill 368, which is basically a workforce bill trying to build a comprehensive workforce system here in the state of Arkansas.
Lots of jobs out there, and employers tell us all the time they have jobs, but they just can't find the qualified workforce. So our goal is to start in kindergarten and go all the way through career to make sure that things are in place, that everybody has an opportunity to get a good education and a skill. So there are three things in this board, I mean this bill. One is that we create a new workforce and career development board,
and that board consists of 13 industry sector, private sector folks, who will help us and guide us. And if they talk about not having the right kinds of skills, We need them at the table to help us determine what those skills are. And the second thing is that we put together a skills development fund, and that skills development fund will be used for competitive grants for secondary schools and two-year colleges who partner with business and industry in their area.
And the third is a better coordination of all of the state and federal workforce programs. We have millions of dollars of federal programs that come into the state, and we really don't know what happens, and we don't know what happens to the people who are taking part in those programs. So we've got lots of work to do. This is just a first step. I'm excited about it, and I'm ready to move forward. I have Richard Abernathy with me at the table,
which he said may be good or bad. I'm not sure. But I appreciate his support. I
Speaker 15
2:47
told her it will hurt her reputation. But I'm Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of School Administrators, and Senator English has been relentless in working on this pursuit, and for a matter of fact, for probably over a year, working with various committees, and it's something that we absolutely support. You know, we've said for several years that we have focused solely on four-year, sending kids to four-year colleges when there's lots and lots of good jobs out there with high
school, high wage, their kids are missing out on an opportunity. And we are losing some students in high school and upper middle school because what they are receiving in school is not meeting their needs and they're not seeing a relevancy for what they're doing. So we're very much in support of this and look forward to working with Senator English as we continue making and these opportunities available
for our students. Are there any questions, committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized for question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have several, but I'll wait my turn for the second and third ones. You indicated that there will be 13
industry people on the board. Yes. Will there be anybody else on the board? There are ex-officio members, but that is the board will be
made up of 13 industry sector folks. Is there a reason for excluding non-industry people from this board?
And my concern is this, in the state of Arkansas, we now have 5.2% general unemployment, But we have 11% or 12% black and Hispanic unemployment. And the people who deny these jobs that Mr. Abernathy says there are so many of do not hire black people. And I'd like to know how you can have an all-industry board to address probably the most important
problem of our times. And before I go on, the other thing goes to Mr. Abernathy, and that is where are these lots and lots of jobs? I have yet to see these lots and lots of jobs set forth anywhere. And from what I understand from the sector I represent, they can't find jobs. So I'd like for you to address that. I understand it's well-intentioned, and I generally support what you're trying to do, but don't exclude me and my people from the process and limit the participation to those who deny us their employment. employment. I think the goal of this whole thing
is to make sure that everybody has the skills and the education to be able to have a good job. One of the things that we have lacked for a long time is, even back all the way to kindergarten and elementary school, is any idea of children of what those jobs or what those careers might be out there. And the idea really of having this industry board, our former Senator John Riggs, who is on the career education board right now and also is the chairman of J.A. Riggs here, has been on the Little Rock School Board, is an absolute proponent for education and skills training,
gave us a rather serious indictment the other day of the career education board that is presently inactive. We have seven members on that board, and most of them he had never met before and really are not doing anything at all. So the whole idea is to change the course of where we're going for everybody. And I tell you honestly that I want everybody in the state of Arkansas to have that opportunity.
I don't care what color they are or what sex they are. I want everybody to have that chance. And what we have complained about for so long is that we, and what business has complained about, is that they can't find people. Sometimes it's understanding that kids need to know how to read a ruler and a tape measure. I've been hearing that for 20 years, that folks don't know how to read a tape measure when they graduate from high school. So for me, wouldn't it be nice if young people could graduate from high school with a diploma,
with some type of an industry certification, and some college credits, so that they could move on either into the workforce or into an academic setting. There's nothing that says people couldn't choose to go on to a four-year college. But what we want to hope is that people have those skills when they get out of high school that they can get a job. And we lose, as Richard said, so many young people because what we're doing does not appeal to them and they don't have a place there.
We want to make those changes so that all those kids feel like they're there for a relevant reason and we can keep them in school. Can't afford to have anybody out of
Speaker 15
8:02
the workforce anymore. from my perspective representative walker that depends on what article you read as far as the job availability but anywhere from you know 70 percent or so jobs out there would not require four-year college degree um now obviously all those jobs would not be good jobs but many many of them are um i've seen several college graduates who go and earn a four-year
college degree and then wind up not being able to find a job in that particular career field So from my perspective, we need to change the direction that we are trying to push kids. Four-year college degrees are absolutely essential for a population of kids, and that opportunity needs to be there. But so does training in other fields need to be there as well. When I visited with career industry people, they have continually told me that there's jobs available right now in manufacturing, in welding and electricians, et cetera, that they need to do a couple of things.
They need to be able to come in and pass, you know, some basic competency tests. They need to be willing to work and they need to pass a drug test. And I've visited one of my friends this past weekend, and the big issue he is having is the drug test issue. And so even though we may have these opportunities out there, we still have to have kids and adults who are willing to do those type things. So, again, I'm looking forward to this because I think we are missing a segment of our population in being able to provide them a career, not just a job, but a career.
And that's the direction that I think we probably need to go. Representative
Ratliff, you're recognized for your question. Senator, is the career ed
bunch all on board with you? Absolutely. The workforce folks, all of them, ag and business? Yes, absolutely. All right. I'll tell you, I taught school 28 years, and if you took ag drive, you couldn't rate a tape measure, you didn't pass. That was a good instructor then. Do we have any other questions from the committee?
you, Madam Chair. I don't want to let this go. You're getting rid of a board, aren't you, that's seven people, and you said it's dysfunctional because John Riggs said so. I don't know that that is true simply because he said so. But I do know that when you have only industry people on the board to try to cause people to be employed and when you have the wage structure of this state, it is little likelihood and you say you don't care about color, but it is little likelihood that you are going
to address the person's most need of employment if you are going to equalize the unemployment rate. If 10 to 12 percent of the people unemployed are black, and nobody has addressed this at all over the years, I don't see how you're going to do it without first saying that that's part of our focus, Mr. Abernathy. You have to say it's part of our focus, and we have to have a list of jobs somewhere where these people can be directed simply by saying there are plenty of jobs out here.
That's always said. But there is no empirical evidence to show that there are plenty of jobs out here and that they are available to the people in the areas where the people live, and they don't require college. But it doesn't really much matter about college anymore because we don't require college for anything anyway. So that's my point. Thank you,
Mr. Walker. Are there any other questions from the committee? Representative Armstrong, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Senator English, this program, how will you advertise it in the schools and get it out and tell students about job availabilities and the salaries and all that. Do you have a way of moving that around to motivate students
to want to get into these careers? Actually, yes. One of the things that Senator Clark has a bill and has passed and basically requires that we have this information in schools so that young people can begin to see what the possibilities are,
what the education requirements are, and what those kinds of jobs might entail and what they could pay as a future. I think one of the things that we miss many times is that we have our workforce participation rate is down to about 58%. That means there are an awful lot of Arkansans here in the state who are not part of the workforce system for whatever reason. We just cannot afford to have folks not in the system
We need that The only way we're ever going to grow as a state Is everybody has a good job and is making more money Has the skills to be able to do it Doesn't guarantee that everybody's going to step up And want to be part of that We have a lot of folks in the state Who need an opportunity for a second chance And a lot of what we're going to be doing I hope, as I say, kindergarten through career, so that nobody is left out unless they choose to be.
Would you say that public service announcements would make a good way of spreading the news about career education and be just like a kid growing up wanting to be a pro athlete?
I think so. I think one of the things that we will be doing with business and industry is to start much sooner and really encourage them to be at the table and in the schools and be advisors to some of these programs, and I think they are willing to do that. So we hope to have a lot more folks in the school system all throughout the state
to help kids understand the possibilities that are out there. Thank you,
Speaker 15
14:05
just a little bit from a school's perspective. And honestly, school is going to need some help in this area. We have career orientation class. The kids go through career orientation class, and basically that's it. There's not any career preparation or training after that. And although it's a good course, there has to be some follow-up. You know, a couple years ago we had career counselors available in some school districts.
That direction may need to be looked into. Bottom line, teachers, they're used to the four-year college program because that's the direction they went. They're fairly successful, and so that's the world they know. All kids aren't going to do that. And so we have to have a way to show students the jobs that are available, where they're available at, the salaries that are out there, and more than just one time. It needs to be an ongoing training process. When Senator Riggs was speaking down on the Senate end on this, I told him they can't solve our problems and we can't solve theirs.
The only way this is going to work is by all of us working together to do that. And we need business leaders to come in our school and show those kids what's available for them. And, you know, Representative Walker may be a job board out there that shows students what's there because they don't know what they can't see.
You know, one way you could get done by asking the industry to go into the schools and tell the students what's available and start earlier than when a kid gets in high school. They need to be prepped from kindergarten up. I think that's the plan.
Representative. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Yes. Just very,
very short, but what I see is coming from an education background is that we've got great programs out there. Representative Ratliff was in one, but we have not had a system to connect all of those and have consistencies for all kids in the state. We may have pockets here or there that are doing it right,
and this gives us a way to have a statewide system to get the best delivery for all kids. Am I correct in looking at it that way?
I think that's exactly right for kids and adults. We want to make sure that we don't leave anybody behind. Thank you. Is there anyone in the audience who would
like to speak for the bill? against the bill.
All right. Would you like to... Did we have another? Okay. Mr. Walker? I
was looking for the financial impact statement, but what you proposed to do obviously is going to cost some money. And if it's going to be statewide, it's going to cost more money. And if it's going to be targeted to a certain group of people, it's going to cost more money. Is there a financial impact statement, or is this going to be something that is passed with an expectation of success without any financial basis for it.
I think that probably when we start looking at all the resources that are out there, making sure that we're directing those resources to the most effective means is going to be. Right now there is no cost to this that we've been able to identify. But we spend a lot of money in the state on education and training and yet we don't really have good results. We're 49th in about everything. My goal is we're no longer 49th
in a couple of years. That means we're going to be taking money from the budgets of existing agencies to fund you. Then where's the money coming from? I understand it's got to
be some money for it. There's money already there. Where? Inside of all these agencies and all these budgets that are there. And what we're going to do is look very carefully at all the money that is being spent right now to determine whether it's being spent wisely or could we do some different things with those resources. So that
means you'll be invading the budgets that we've approved for the agencies to do
the work that they have agreed upon. And I don't see how we can do that. This seems to be sort of a supergroup that will be able to go into the workforce agencies and take from their budgets to do what you want to have done. Otherwise, I don't see what you're talking about. There's plenty of money out there, you say, but I don't see how we can pass budgets for particular agencies and then for particular work and then go to those agencies and say, well, we have this here and you've got to give us some money to do this or that without having some idea of what the cost or price tag is.
For that reason, I'll be voting against it. It'll probably pass. But I don't see how you can just have unfunded mandates for good purpose work to address an issue of serious importance.
I think one of the things that you will find that I have been most excited about is that the governor has appointed a workforce cabinet, and I can tell you that the folks that are on that workforce cabinet are all dedicated to making a better system here in the state. One of the reports I had yesterday was, I don't know how many of you are familiar with the Workforce Investment Act,
but two of our agencies, on their own, because of the new leadership, have begun to sit down at the table and look at all of the programs that they all have to ensure that they are not duplicating those programs and trying to figure out a way that they can all work together to make sure that their monies are not all being spent in improper ways. So it isn't always a matter of new money. It's a matter of folks sitting down and figuring out that we have a new path we want to go down
and how are we going to make that happen? We always assume that there has to be more new money. It doesn't always have to be new money. It means how do we encourage people to sit down and talk
Speaker 66
20:14
recognize for a question. Thank you, Chairman, and thank you, Senator English, for bringing this forward. I do agree, certainly, that it's always good to do a reassessment of assets, if you will,
or programs that we're currently administering in the state, and let's go and look at it, let's review it, and let's see how it better fits or best fits. So I agree with you on that. And I think that's what this does in a lot of ways, is that it's going to do a self-assessment of our current program and then try to maximize those monies and those programs to benefit the whole state. That's the goal, correct? Okay. So with that in mind, my only, or not my only, but my main concern would be is that at the table of decisions,
the decision makers on these various boards and commissions or whomever will be in the decision-making positions, that we have a diversity of people at the table. So many times when we are addressing the needs of many of those that are overlooked, So many times they're not at the table or leadership from those areas of the state are not at the table. So my only encouragement as we do this is that we make sure that this table is inclusive of people that may say things that people at the table would just not consider
only because they just don't come from that population or they may not understand the things that affect that population. So many times there can be good intentions by those that bring forth legislation or policy, but because all the right people are not at the table, and sometimes those people at the table will say things that will make people uncomfortable, but it's only because they're trying to advocate for those that have been overlooked. So as we try to get there, and I'm assuming that we're all trying to get to the same place,
so my encouragement, please, is that as we try to get there, that we make sure that we have people at the table that from all, they're diverse and represent all areas, and especially the underdeveloped areas. Because really and truly, as you look at workforce development in the state of Arkansas, obviously there's parts of our state that are doing real well. They have lots of jobs, they have lots of opportunities, but typically it's the same areas and with some of the same issues that continue to struggle that I think the focus really needs to be on.
So that being said, I'm encouraged by this. I'm encouraged by the reassessment, the reevaluation. I just want to make sure that we have proper representation in doing that. So I guess I don't have a question. I just want to say thank you and hopefully we'll have
that. Thank you. Representative Armstrong. Thank you. Thank you, Madam
Chair. Do you have any commitments from the industry that's helped to support these type programs? I'm not sure what you mean.
You know, some companies like Toyota and stuff, they'll come in and they'll pay for part of the training and stuff. What you're doing, you're training them to work for this particular company where they can get output and get
workers in. Well, I think that's an absolutely fantastic model that Kentucky and other states have managed to put together. Wouldn't it be wonderful if we could do something similar like that with some of our industries here in the state? I think that the State Chamber of Commerce has been very much on board with this, has been a huge supporter.
and the business and industries that they represent and all the builder, the construction people, the automobile dealers, all these folks out there who really would like to work together with us to help make good things happen. They're citizens, they're taxpayers, and they would like to see the state grow as well as being able to find qualified employees. Maybe
you could find some out-of-state entity that would want to come in and help. That's possible. Especially from some bordering states.
That is quite possible. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you,
Madam Chair. Representative Diffenbaugh, you're recognized for your question.
Thank you, Madam Chair. You know, listening to the, if this is a rift as to how to handle this, there are other ways to implement this, just like you mentioned Kentucky. Is that right? Yeah, I think one of
the things that we're finding, and as I say, I would like this to be the, I wish we were the tip of the spear, but unfortunately we are not the tip of the spear.
Other states have been looking at building a workforce system for 10 years. We're just kind of late coming to the game, but in reality, those business and industries that are looking at the state and that want to expand or grow here in the state are the ones that we have to start worrying about because otherwise they're going to find someplace else to go. And where we used to think that the most important thing was tax incentives, those things are the icing on the cake now.
They are not the main driver of whether a new company comes or whether a company that's already here chooses to expand. In fact, one other thing, a couple of weeks ago, the Arkansas business had an award program, and one of the businesses that was one of the awards was a technology company here in Little Rock. Grew up here, started here, and when he made his acceptance speech,
The one thing he said was, I'd like to be able to grow more, but I can't find the people here to come to work for me. Well, those are the kinds of things that we need. It's not just manufacturing. It's transportation and logistics and information technology and all kinds of different types of fields that we need to be able to work with those folks and make something happen. Mr. Gray.
Thank you. Okay. Of all the years that some of us have been in public schools, I've watched that over and over.
One of the problems over and over is to have youngsters unmotivated and not have any good prospects or any good field to go into that they're interested in. So I made a statement, but would you agree that we've got to do something here to draw these youngsters into
the workforce? And I think that's really one of our major goals, is not to lose these people, kids, adults, whatever. We need everybody.
Representative Gray, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator English, thank you. No one can be a bigger supporter of workforce education in Arkansas than me or people from my part of the state. But in this bill or in your package, to follow the same lines that my colleagues, Representative Walker and Murdoch, have laid out, is there any guarantee or at least emphasis on the geographical regions of the state that are somewhat underserved
or at least require more resources or more dedication to make programs like this work? And what I'm saying is, in some of our more, affluence is not the correct word, that more successful areas of the state, some of these programs are a lot easier to implement and don't take as much time or as much dedication or follow through to make it work as it would, say, in my part of the state. I don't see any formal statutory stuff.
Is there any emphasis on concentrating on the underserved geographic areas? I think that is a big
part of what we're going to be doing. But you can't have one size fits all. What works in Camden doesn't work in Jonesboro. And so it's really kind of up to those communities, too, to determine what do they want to be when they grow up and working with the business and industry that are in their communities. I don't think anybody is going to set out and say this is what you have to do. I think this is just a framework for being able to move forward,
and it doesn't answer all the questions, and it doesn't set everything in policy. I don't think that's something we want to do. I think we need to figure out where we want to go, and this gives us that
opportunity. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Motion at the
proper time. Okay. Any other questions? Okay. Representative Murdoch. Okay,
Speaker 66
29:20
in that vein, thank you Chairman, in that vein
Senator English, do you think that with us going to go to the table with the flexibilities in our mind of being able to address different regions of the state in their particular issues, do we need to have, in your opinion, language in the legislation that will require, if you will, that certain, that we have a representation
to right now, and I don't know exactly what everything in the bill says, you may have this, where we can say from each congressional district you may have this many people or some type of way. What I think we're concerned with is that the table, even with good intentions, may not have, as a decision maker, enough of the people that really need to be at the table. So that's the concern. Again, I haven't read it all. You may have that there, but
some teeth in it that says, we're going to have you at the table. We know you've been overlooked. We understand that one size don't fit all, so we're going
to have you there. is that possible or is it there no it's not there this is a framework and what it does is it does three things it sets up a new board it sets up a skills development fund and it requires that the department of career education do a kind of an assessment and overall
look at the programs that we've got here in the state who names that board the governor names that board Okay You understand our concern, don't you? I understand that I think you're going to see some other things You know, the Workforce Investment Act That I referred to a little bit ago Is coming down And it's going to be part of what we're doing And that's a federal program And it has lots and lots of folks at the table From all parts of the state
And everybody has to have their own Workforce Investment Board And so I think that you're going to find that all of these things are going to work together to make some good things happen in the state. As I said, I think I'm pleased with the Workforce Cabinet because that's what everybody's doing, is sitting down and figuring out how do we make this work, how do we use all the resources that we have. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. No more questions? Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed
for the bill. You're closed. What are the wishes of the committee?
Representative Douglas, I believe you have a motion. Motion do pass. Okay. We have a motion do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Opposed? No. Okay. Congratulations, Senator. You've passed
Speaker 14
32:19
your bill. Thank you very much. Thank you. I've got one more. Okay. Senator Bill 371. Yes. Rotate out there. Okay. Keep your break.
I don't have to go to the meeting like I thought. Senator,
you're recognized to present SB 371. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Jane English. And this is a small bill that we've sort of worked on together to try and figure out how we can make resources more available to some of our young folks who are in school and using NSLA funding
and ALE funding, if a superintendent so chooses, to help those young people take technical courses at two or four year colleges. Representative Murdock, you
Speaker 66
33:26
you. Great bill, but we're already doing this, right, in various parts of the state.
I know in my part of the state
Speaker 15
33:36
we've been doing it for years. President Murdoch, Richard Abernathy, executive director of AAEA. The law currently allows that to be done for remediating kids. And, you know, the term remediation obviously has a negative connotation to it, and we'd like to take that out. And so you can build a relationship with institutions of higher ed for remediation, for career and technical, for concurrent credit. And, you know, a lot of kids that we send over there need to be remediated because they've lost interest in school.
Okay. And so this expands that opportunity if a district and a higher ed wants to pursue this route. Thank you. Any other questions? No other questions? Anybody
in the audience like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Would you like to close for your bill, Senator? I'm closed. What's the will of the committee? I have a due pass from Representative McElroy.
All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed your bills. Thank you. Both of them. All right, here we go. Senator Clark, if you want to move to the end of the table where I
You will recognize and present Senate Bill 366.
Senator Allen Clark, there we go. Thank you all for serving. Thank you for being here this morning. SB 366 comes from, just a little background, I've met with hundreds of public school educators
over the last three years, and a reoccurring theme that I've heard over and over is this. if the legislature can remove the bureaucracy from what we do we can compete with any private school and with any charter school anywhere and I believe that visiting with a former, I compliment KIPP a lot over in Helena West Helena because I've been there and see what they do I've got a lot of great public schools in my district that do wonderful things but I bring this up because a former superintendent at Helena West Helena
after hearing me mention KIPP said this. If we had the permission to do what KIPP is doing, we could do a lot of the same things just as successfully. She meant waivers from certain rules, and she is correct. This bill is one of three that I am running that comes directly from educators, not education organizations, but from educators. SB 366, let me tell you first what it does not do because it's been bantered around that it does.
It does not raise class sizes, does not increase class sizes. It is a permissive bill. No one will be forced to do anything, but it allows the following. If a teacher wants to teach an extra class during a conference period or to teach over the maximum 150 a day, they can if there is a need in the school district. It must be voluntary. The teacher must be reimbursed. there must be a contract signed for the extra work the teacher must be reimbursed for the extra class period
and or for the extra students over 150 on a prorated basis now that means if a teacher teaches an extra for the conference period they get prorated based on a teacher making with a $40,000 salary could conceivably make as much as $61,000 through this Because you'd get reimbursed for the conference period, prorated on how many periods there are in the day, which would be substantial, plus for every student over 150.
So a teacher was already teaching five classes with 30 and taught another 30, they could earn as much as another 50% more of their salary. The main knock against the bill is that teachers work very hard, and the conference period is very important. And therefore, teachers would be too tired to do a good job. Granted, teachers do work hard, and planning is important. But to say no to this bill is not to acknowledge that teachers and administrators are professionals. They know what they are capable of, and they don't need me or the state looking over their shoulder.
We should also acknowledge that, at least that's what they tell me, we should also acknowledge that teachers do not exist in a vacuum at the school. I'm the son of a teacher, a very good teacher. In addition to teaching, he drove a school bus in the morning, drove a school bus in the evening, He drove a bus to ball games at night whenever he could and on Saturdays if there was a band or choral contest, et cetera, somewhere. He filmed the football games at the school. He raised a garden. He painted houses and worked in restaurants sometimes because he was determined to feed his family
while still doing a great job as a teacher because he did a great job at anything he did, as most of our professional teachers do. He taught me that I could work 16 hours a day. I've never done that up until being in the legislature but he told me that I could that I could work 16 hours a day for weeks at a time get way too little sleep and sit at the end of this table and present bills I hope intelligently so let's let professionals decide what they are capable of and let's let teachers
be reimbursed for what they're good at and I'm open for any questions
a question Thank you, Mr. Chair Senator Clark, thank you My mother is also a teacher so I can echo some of those same stories Help me understand the 150 student a day limit
I think is the number and too often when we leave this room or leave this building we hear education policy unfortunately we talk about money we talk about teachers we talk about administrators we talk about facilities when are you guys going to talk about the kids then we get in here and we have administrators and teachers unions and everything else and we don't have the kids so my question is while I don't doubt and my mother would be very upset with me if I said there are teachers
capable of teaching more than 150 students a day and i don't know of many teachers that if they saw a need wouldn't volunteer to step in to help teach more students if they need to but i wasn't in the discussion at the time that um whether the legislature or the department of ed developed the 150 student a day number but i would hope that at some point they decided that was the point at which a teacher could be most effective. And are we by, even voluntarily, allowing that number
to be moved, are we putting the quality of education, even from the best of teachers, with the best of intentions, are we moving that bar for the students at all,
possibly? I don't think so. I mean, because I'm going to go back to KIPP at West Helena, where teachers are working way more hours. and part of what they do is to tutor at night. And according to the Washington Post, number two school in the state. And the traditional public school right beside them said,
allow us to do more of what they do. That wasn't specifically what they were talking about. They were talking about being able to hire a chemistry teacher that wasn't certified. That's what they were talking about. But I don't think they're bad rules. We should have guides. We work at our business. We employ people for eight hours a day. But we have times when we need people to work more hours than that. It's always on a voluntary basis. And I have employees begging me for overtime. And kids are very important. And if I thought this would hurt kids, I would have never agreed to present this bill for educators.
But what we do is important, too. You know, what doctors do is important. I mean, look at the hours that doctors put in. So, again, this is not for everyone. That's why it's completely voluntary. People have to know their own limitations. But it's not just up to a teacher knowing their limitation. It's also up to a professional administrator to choose because this gives them the opportunity to go to their best teachers and put them in front of students. And this is especially an issue for growing schools who have the maximum children in a class across the board and kids move into the district.
And they have a choice of either going and trying to hire another teacher mid-semester on a half-time or part-time basis. That's one of the reasons the School Board Association and the Administrators Association supports this, who all of us know may not be the best teacher that's not already employed, versus taking a top teacher who's willing to do it and wants the extra pay to teach for the rest of that semester with a contract for one semester at a time.
And if you read through there, it says voluntarily, voluntarily, voluntarily. And so you're only for a semester at a time. And if it's not working for you, and if it's not working for the administrator, if it's not working for the teacher, I think next semester, one, there may not be a need. And, two, if there is a need, then people are going to say, no, I can't do this. But good questions.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Senator Clark. Mr. Chair, I have another question, but it's not a follow-up, so I don't mind getting back in line.
We'll put you back in line. Thank you. Reverend Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Representative Cazard, and I, too, have a follow-up. I take it that
Speaker 128
43:57
you are motivated by KIPP for this? No, no, this came from... Wait a minute, that's not my
question. I was just making a comment. that's a preface. Okay. Well, I took it as a question. I'm sorry, Representative Walker. I just take it that you're motivated by KIPP because you made reference to KIPP saying that
they're able to do things that public schools can't do. But don't you think that you're stretching it when you have these teachers already teaching 150 students a day, especially in the areas where Mr. Gray lives and where the area I represent and where Mr. McElroy and Mr. Armstrong and Representative Ratliff, among others, work where you have, which KIPP doesn't have to have, disability students, special education students, special needs students,
especially within a context where we know that small classes produce better results. and those teachers cannot do 150 students a day with all the problems that they have, including discipline problems and things like that, and do it well. I understand that you want to give some people an opportunity to make some more money, but what is the evidence, the objective evidence that you have that this can work
other than anecdotal evidence that is just not quantified in any way that we can know? Anything in writing that you can relate us to that says that this has potential for dealing with the most needy children in the areas of greatest
need? I don't have that. In answer to your question about those with small class sizes, if you have small class sizes, this is not even needed. unless you have a place where you're going over class sizes.
So all that's going to happen in that case is you're going to have more students put in a class, and they would need a waiver for that. But sometimes we need to try new things. Until the Wright brothers went to Kitty Hawk, we didn't know whether we could fly or not. Two years from now, if this isn't working, we can come back and change it. But I am very confident, again, in teachers and professional administrators being able to decide what they can do.
I'm back in line. Okay, you want to go back in line? Okay. Representative Def,
is Def involved? You have a question. Go ahead. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Clark, I was just curious, I can see it both ways, did superintendents approach you about this, or teachers, or is it a combination of both? I'm just curious. Combination of both. Okay. Thank you.
Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Senator Clark, in my real life, I'm a farmer, so an employer. And there are times where I ask my employees to volunteer, and I'm a lot happier with them if they do. Sure. Can you address that
concern as it relates to this? Sure. I've always tried to be transparent, and I think that's probably the most valid concern.
and again but I also trust the system I trust that my teachers have a state senator and state representatives if they didn't have anyone else that if someone forced them to volunteer I would certainly be interested just as interested I am in helping the school and helping those teachers who want to I'd be interested in helping those teachers who didn't want to if someone tried to force them to do so Thank you Senator. Thank you Mr. Chair Representative Walker, you recognize the question.
Thank you. I'm back in line. Now, Senator, you know schools have to objectively be operated. And when you start talking about things like best teacher here and best there, that's a subjective consideration just like it is for doctors or lawyers. Sure. I mean, it's a matter of somebody believing that somebody is good or bad. There's no way. We have not ranked. To your knowledge, have we? We haven't ranked teachers in terms of who's best qualified. And when you start talking about who's best qualified in local school districts, don't
you deal with a problem of the morale of the teachers who are not selected for these bonuses? Because it becomes a pay bonus. If you can take a regular salary of $40,000 and then make an extra $20,000 by teaching an extra class, I don't see how you do it. Now, my question, since I have to have a question, is what is the – other than that somebody likes this, do you have any educational justification for changing something that appears to be
working in most of the state except for those areas of poverty and underprivilege?
That's a very valid question. and if we were trying to just change the rules, we're not. The rules stay in place. This is for very special situations that I think you're going to see happen very little because superintendents like to save as much money as they can and they're going to pay a substantial, I mean, they could pay up to 50% more
to ask a teacher to do this. School boards like to save money. So it's a special situation that's not going to occur that often. And so we're not looking at changing the rules per se. And by the way, we don't rank teachers all the way up and down, but we do have a teacher of the year every year, the current ones out of my district. I wish she were here today to testify. I'm not going to speak for her since she's not here, but I think you'd find what she has to say very interesting.
I don't think she would believe it's a popularity contest, Representative Walker. Are there any
other questions on the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience? We do have one that would like to speak against the bill, and that would be Mr. Nagel. You're recognized to speak against the bill. If you will state your name and who you're with, you will be recognized.
Speaker 159
50:50
I'm great, Rich, how are you? Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, I'm Rich Nagel, Interim Executive Director with the Arkansas Education Association. I have a few points to make about the bill. We have some strong concerns about it. Initially, Senate Bill 366 was introduced to help small schools.
But as you can see from the bill, it's not limited to just small schools. It applies to all schools. We understand that under the bill, teaching another class in lieu of a preparation period is voluntary. But I think Representative Gray made a good point sometimes of how people get volunteered. We also understand that teachers in small school districts generally have lower class size, or sorry, lower salaries.
And they may volunteer to make more money. We also understand that many teachers in small districts may already be teaching four, five, or six different subjects, it's important for teachers to have adequate time at school to prepare for teaching students. Adding another class to this already overburdened schedule is, in our opinion, professionally undesirable
and educationally unsound for the students. Without a preparation period, a teacher will not be able to participate in professional learning communities with other teachers, who oftentimes share the same preparation period. Finally, well, actually not finally. I have one more point after it.
The bill also, as pointed out, raises the class load without any limitation for teachers at the secondary schools. And finally, and maybe most importantly, this bill will allow school districts to save quite a bit of money. If they get enough teachers to volunteer to do a seventh class, they won't need to hire as many teachers.
And I think it's important for the committee to understand that already, school districts are spending, on the average, about $1,000 less per teacher than they're sent through the matrix. And for some 33,000 teachers in the state, That amounts to about a $33 million savings on their part,
not taking into account other costs that they may have associated with salaries. So for this reason, we have to speak against the bill. Be happy to answer any questions that you might have. President Walker, you're
Some superintendents, do you not agree? already believe that they have the power and exercise it, in fact, to give extra pay to
teachers whenever they want to, such as in the form of stipends, as in Little Rock over the years. They just give stipends to anybody they please. And the problem that I have is that when you give a superintendent the ability to give extra pay without following a schedule, You open up the opportunity not only to discriminate, but to give favor and to cause other problems of teacher morale and also teacher preference and things like that.
I mean, I just want to make sure that we have uniformity and the teachers are
Speaker 159
55:17
equally respected. How does this bill do that? Or does it? Well, I think pursuant to this, if this bill were to pass, a school district would have to adopt some kind of policy, written policy, concerning additional pay for teaching
an additional class period, a seventh class period in most instances. As far as discretionary, you know, people would be asked maybe something along the line of, we really need you to be able to teach this class, would you be willing to volunteer? I think that would be permissible under here. But as far as paying people an amount of money, a stipend, or something else without an actual policy in place,
I don't think that's permissible under the law, not saying that it's not being done anywhere, but I don't think it's consistent with the law. I hope I answered
your question. how you can use them a system to allow for instance a person who's not a teacher who has no degree to earn more and who has no real professional job to earn more than any certified
teacher i just don't understand that and i think that what you have to have is salary schedules and those schedules have to be adhered to, and no superintendent, in all due respect to Mr. Aberneth and anybody else, no superintendent should be allowed to deviate from that just to favor somebody that he or she may wish to favor by way of giving him extra pay.
Speaker 159
57:16
I mean, that's just not sensible. In response, I think in the last session, Representative Deffenbaugh had a bill that required school boards
to review very carefully raises that were given to all employees under from one year to the next that I think probably would have uncovered the things that you're talking about, Representative Walker. The bill didn't pass, as I remember, but it was well thought out and well intended.
Speaker 15
58:14
you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA, and we do support this bill. I guess we look at it a little differently. I figure at some point in your school career you've had a teacher who you really, really liked, who did an outstanding job, and parents of those kids or the kids themselves
wanted to be in that teacher's classroom. Once that teacher hits 150 kids, there is no option. There's no waiver. There's nothing you can do about it. Some of those teachers, I imagine many of you know a teacher who works a second job outside of school trying to make the ends meet. this is just simply a way that if the teacher volunteers if the school volunteers and they're already at the max of 150 to give both those two people the superintendent and the teacher an
opportunity to to allow that teacher to work an extra period if they want or teach more kids than 150 there's nothing in here that's mandated you can see very clearly that either one of them have the opportunity to not volunteer to do this and we just think it opens up some flexibility that district for that teacher as well as
that school any questions committee thank you sir anybody like speak against the bill for
the bill? Not seeing any more. Would
you like to close for your bill, sir? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This bill was not. My esteemed colleague, Mr. Nagel, I think confused this bill with SB325, which you've already passed out of here. That was for small schools. This bill was not. It really was larger schools that were growing that had more of a problem with this. I did fail to mention, although
he did it for me, that this is only for grades 7 through 12. And I did, when I was bringing this bill to the House, I was not able to visit with every teacher. My apologies, Vice Chair. But I did visit with some of the teachers, and not only did I get a good response, I could say even an enthusiastic response. And, you know, if we're not going to let teachers work more, we might want to pass a law about bus driving,
but then I don't know if we'll get our kids to school. So I think we've already decided we're going to let teachers work more. Why not let them teach? I would appreciate you, committee, and I'd appreciate a good vote. What's the
will of the committee? Representative Harris I have a motion to do pass Representative Harris All those in favor say aye All those opposed no The ayes have it
Alright if you roll call I'd like to see you vote I have
Speaker 177
1:01:39
two hands for roll call Call the roll sir Rep. Letting. Rep. Letting. Rep. Murdock. Rep. Deffenbaugh. Rep. Harris. Rep. Eubanks. Rep. Ratliff. Rep. Ratliff.
Ratliff? Yes, he said yes. Representative Gillum? Representative Gillum? Representative Walker? No. Representative Bell? Yes. Representative Balz? Yes. Representative Douglas? Representative Douglas? Representative Lowry? Yes. Representative McElroy? No.
Representative Armstrong, Representative Gossage, Representative Gossage, Representative Sabin, Representative Sabin, Representative Hodges, Representative Hodges, Representative Gray, Representative Gray, Representative Lampkin,
Representative Lampkin. I'm sorry. The bill has failed. Thank you. Would you like to run Senate Bill 591? I would. All right. This time we'll hear Senate Bill 591. And then next we will hear Senator Flowers has a bill. And then next Representative McNair. And then Representative Johnson.
and that's kind of the order we're going to go in. And Senator Fowles
is in here. I'll put you right behind them, sir. Thank you. SB 591 was also brought from educators. We had superintendents that were told that in park testing that they were not going to be able to use anything but regular classroom teachers to monitor and proctor the test. and it made no sense that any certified teachers, retired teachers, substitute teachers couldn't do that.
After we brought this bill in full disclosure, Park relented and said that they could, but we won't be in session a few months down the road, and we wanted to go ahead and make it plain that if we give an assessment test in Arkansas that you will allow any certified teacher to monitor and proctor that test. I'd be glad to take any questions. Are there any questions on
the committee? Representative Lowry, you're recognized for a question. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Clark, I just wanted you
to try and give us an idea of what a big deal this is
as far as the testing window, how many weeks we're talking about, what the requirements are for how many proctors have to be in the testing center at each time. You're
more the expert on that, Representative Lowry, than I am. Well, I had to ask a question instead of make a statement. But that's where you ask, doesn't it take so-and-so and so, wouldn't you agree? Would you agree? The testing goes on for weeks. It makes no sense to take our teachers out of the classroom
and put a substitute in the classroom when we can have a certified substitute proctoring the test and the teacher is still in the classroom teaching. Okay, follow-up. You're
recognized for follow-up. and part of it is also allowing retired teachers correct yes that have still have their certification absolutely to help with these testing windows which i believe under the current park test is one four-week testing window that you have to have proctors available for and then there's
a break and then another four-week testing window so it's considerable amount of time that teachers would be out of the classroom if they had to proctor these tests correct Correct. All right. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any other questions? Representative Walker,
you're recognized for a question. At first, I thought this was an innocent bill, and it may be, so maybe you can help me. Isn't it true that all the testing takes place at basically the same time? I'm going
Maybe we can have Mr. Wood or somebody from the Department of Education come. I'm concerned. and it seemed somewhere I was told that all the testing is supposed to take place at the same time in all the school districts. We have Dr.
Hernandez going to come down. And Representative Walker, I don't present any innocent bills, but
they're all transparent. Well, it's transparent, but, you know, on the surface of it, it looked okay, and I was about to not ask any questions. Can you tell me, Dr. Hernandez? Yes, sir, that is correct. Congratulations, by the way.
Mike Hernandez, Arkansas Department of Education. Can you tell me
whether or not it's the state's policy to cause all students who take whatever the tests are, including the park test, at the same time? No, sir, that is not correct.
In the past, that was correct. In reference to the old benchmarks, there was a set time and window where kids across the state. But with the park testing windows, there's flexibility within those that a school district can choose when during those windows to either give the first part of the assessment or the second part.
Well, isn't it the follow-up? Mr. Chair, I don't want to disrespect you. You are recognized for follow-up. Isn't it the usual practice that the persons who either give or practice the test are usually the teachers? In past practices,
it has been usually a certified teacher that's required to be in the classroom, whether it be a certified substitute. but as Mr. Representative Lowry stated or Senator Clark, I don't remember who stated that
but with the park assessment it was required that it had to be a certified teacher that was on staff and since then they have changed that rule but as Senator Clark mentioned this is to ensure in case there is a future change that this would satisfy those So
this is not anything that's actual it's something that you want to have passed so that you can do it just in case Is that correct, Senator Clark? It was actual when we introduced
the bill. Park was not going to allow anyone that was not a member of the regular staff to monitor or proctor the staff.
They weren't going to allow certified substitutes or retired teachers. After we introduced the bill, they relented. What's the
rationale, Dr. Hernandez, for requiring or having required all the testing to be conducted at the same time? And that's my last question. I know Mr. Bill wants to cut me off. What's the rationale for having all the tests administered under the same conditions and same terms to all students by teachers at the same time? The State Department rationale. I don't believe
that that's the current rationale that we're under right now
as far as making sure that all schools are taking the test at exactly the same time and under the same conditions. All right. Thank you. Are
there any other questions on the committee? Thank you, sir. Is there anyone in the audience Who'd like to speak Against the bill For the bill We are closed again Would you like to close for your bill I am closed for my bill Mr. Chair That's the will of the committee We'll take that
We'll take that motion From Representative Walker Do pass all right all those in favor say aye any opposed say no congratulations you passed that bill thank you mr. chair thank you members of the committee all right representative flowers i'm sorry senator flowers i'm sorry i have one sitting right beside you that's a representative
Good morning, and thank you, Mr. Chair. Good morning, committee. I'd ask, Mr. Chair, if I could be joined at the table by Dr. Ed Buckner and Dr. Rebecca Lockman from the University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff, as well as two of my house co-sponsors, Representative Vivian Flowers and Representative Ken Ferguson who are from Pine Bluff as well
They may join you and if they speak just recognize who
you are and who you're with when you speak. Thank you Thank you. Senate Bill 695 addresses a gap in funding that the University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff traditionally has found itself looking for University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff is an 1890 institution. It's a land-grant institution. It was in 1890 that the Second Moral Act of Congress allowed grants to be distributed to historically black colleges
and universities across the country. And University of Arkansas at the time was Branch Normal College, or Arkansas A, M, and N College, standing for Agriculture, Mechanical, and Normal College. So since 1890, they have been recognized as an 1890 land grant college. And because of that designation, they are eligible and receive federal grants that require a state match dollar
for dollar each year. The funding from the grant goes for education in agriculture, research, and extension service. So we've enjoyed, since 1890 at the university, the opportunity to serve the state of Arkansas, particularly the Delta and farmers from that community in that area of the state. But indeed, it helps and benefits the entire state of Arkansas.
Under UAPB's budget, general budget, there is a clause or special language that allows the Department of Higher Ed to determine and to try to find general revenue for 100 percent of the state match. And that match fluctuates. Historically, it's been anywhere from four million or better. And we always come up short by 80% of the state match, which generally and historically
has been anywhere from $700,000 to no more than a million dollars per year. And so the university has had to look for general improvement funds or ask the feds for a waiver. What we are doing here with Senate Bill 695, we found a source of funding that is contingent. The funding source is from the electronic games of skill from Oakline or Southland that
exceed $44,800,000 each year. So above that contingent amount of 44.8, the university, in the first part of the bill, section 2, would have a process by which the chancellor would certify what the amount is that they do not have in order to get the full match. That 20% generally is what would be submitted.
And it would be submitted to the Chief Fiscal Officer, the FNA. And that office is then to certify or determine whether that is the correct amount. And after that, the amounts above the 44-8 that the university needs would be set aside. Any other money that the university would not need above the 44-8 would go back into
general revenue. But that's basically it in a nutshell. I would be happy to answer any questions as well as Dr. Buckner or Dr. Lockman. This as far as I know is in, I don't know of any opposition to the bill. So I'd appreciate good consideration and a good vote from this committee. Representative Lauer, you're recognized for
a question. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Senator, and I will have a follow-up, too. Is the University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff the only university that is falling short of whatever amount that they
would need to get the state match? That's correct. Now, University of Arkansas at Fayetteville is an 1862 land-grant institution. And since they were designated to be an 1862 land-grant institution, they've done something a little bit different. And I can't explain to you exactly how they did it.
But they have actually transferred most of their funding that they get through 1862 grants to the Division of Agriculture. But UAPB, yes, is the only 1890 land-grant institution in the state of Arkansas that does not. And because of that, you know, I guess the other part of your question, there is no other school to compare it to in terms of funding.
But as far as I know, the 1862 match is
Okay. So, there are other universities within the state that have similar deficiencies. They just don't seem to fit in this same narrow category. Is that
correct? No, I did not say that. There are no known deficiencies for the 1862 match.
For the 1862 match. Right, but there is no other 1890 land grant institution in the state
of Arkansas. Okay. All right. Thank you. Representative Armstrong,
you're recognized for a question. The 1890 land-grant colleges was established back for basically black to major. Would you say that was right? I know you've got 17 of them across
the country. Yes. It was established in 1890. It will be 125 years old.
They'll be celebrating in July in Washington, D.C., these 1890 land-grant institutions. These were institutions that were designated by Congress to receive this status. And so it is historically black colleges and universities that received the status 1890 land grant. Thank you, Senator. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
during the Civil War and the 1890 grant was for the Agricultural, Mechanical, and Normal College for Negroes. That's correct. specifically and the purpose of it was to equalize the 18 the federal funding
for agricultural programs or certain types of programs that's correct and it is your contention that they have never been equalized for the University of Arkansas at Pan Bluff to the extent of a difference of 20% that's correct and you therefore have never been able to fulfill the mission set out both by Congress and by the institution approved by the legislature of the state That's correct. So you want some equity now to help you at least through this shortfall? Yes, sir. Thank you.
You have another question? He took four. He took your other two. He didn't take mine. He took five. You recognize for a question, Representative Armstrong. Motion at the proper time. Seeing no other questions from the committee, does anyone like to speak against the bill in the audience for the bill? I have a motion of do pass from Representative Armstrong. If you are closed, ma'am.
I am closed. All right. I have a motion of do pass from Representative Armstrong. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say no. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. Aye. Representative McNair, your patience has paid off. What bill? 1419, sir.
House Bill 1419 will be presented by Representative McNair. You are recognized, sir. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee.
Mine's very simple. So House Bill 1419 is allowing school board members to attend school board meetings electronically when they're away or out of town. I brought this earlier in the session, and there were some valid concerns about the bill.
We had those all taken care of through an amendment, I believe so, and I've shared them. I hope everybody has read the amendments. This bill is strictly permissive. The school district may or may not, but if they choose to use it. There was also a question about a vacancy issue, and that has been covered by a previous bill that was passed out. Basically, no cost to it. Schools can do it right now electronically.
They just can't be counted as their vote. And like I say, all the amendments, I think, have been taken care of, I hope so, to cover everybody's concerns. If there is any questions, I'll try to answer them. Representative Bell, you're recognized for a question. Just a motion to the proper time, Mr. Chair. Are there
any other questions from the committee? Does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Are you closed for your bill? I am closed. I have a motion to do pass from Representative Bell.
All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Rep. Johnson, you are recognized to take the chair. House Bill 1602, and I believe you have some people who would like to join you at the end of the table. Bring them on in.
to talk about the bill. Mr. Chairman, thank you very much. As everybody's getting over here. Where's Daniel and Bobby? I'd like Daniel Gray and Bobby Lester to come up. I have with me the interim school board president, interim superintendent, Scott Beardsley, and Patrick Wilson, who are attorneys that helped crafted this bill, and then former Representative Mike Wilson,
who's just a pain in my side. All right. At any time, if any
of them speak, just recognize who they are and who they're with. We're hoping
it's just him, and we're done quick. Okay. Okay. But what I'm presenting
to you. Representative, could you pull that mic just a little bit closer? We can't already hear you. Certainly. What we're presenting today is Bill 1602, that is putting some new rules in place for a school board that is broken off from a previous school board, school district.
So are we ready to present? Yes, sir. You're ready. Okay. I want to let Patrick Wilson explain the bill. I'm
Patrick Wilson, the attorney for the Jacksonville North Pulaski School District. The detachment statute was already in place. All we are attempting to do in this bill is spell out a little bit more about how you actually do the detachment process. the bill 1602 just provides some options for how the division of assets goes the state board is
involved in that process it spells out a little bit about how that is to take place and provides some options on financing needs of the detaching district that's pretty much all that the bill is designed to do. It's important to note that while the Jacksonville North Pulaski School District is the first, so far the only, district that has gone through this process, this is not geared toward the Jacksonville North Pulaski District. It will apply to everyone going forward in the detachment process.
Those are my basic comments. I'm happy to
try to answer any questions. Are you ready for questions? Are there any
questions on this committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized. I know. Patrick, Mr. Wilson, you do understand that whatever we do here is subject to Judge
Marshall's approval? Absolutely, and I believe that's noted
in the statute. And that whatever we do will be subject to his modification, if he so chooses.
after he hears the position of the Joshua interveners? Absolutely. The federal court
certainly has a strong role in this process. I won't be passing an opinion on
this one way or another because I don't know how it will affect this situation. So I just want that noted. Are there any other questions? Representative Gray, you're recognized for
a question. It's a motion at the property of the town, Mr. Chair. All right. Are there any other questions at all?
No other questions? Anybody else would like to speak against the bill for the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? Yes, sir. I close for my bill. All right. Representative Gray, let's hear your motion. Motion do pass. I have a motion do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, say no. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Are you leaving?
Representative Broadway, I'm going to ask for a motion to suspend the rules for House Bill 1256.
I have a motion from Representative McElroy to suspend the rules and pull that out of pending. We do have fiscal impact on it, and this is a motion you will have to vote on. So all those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed pulling it out, say no. No. All right. The motion passes. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. You are recognized to present House Bill
1256. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair, and I appreciate the indulgence of the committee. Had there been a significant fiscal impact, then I probably would have waited the time.
However, as you note, there is no fiscal impact of this bill. If you all will recall, approximately a month ago, I presented a bill to you, 1255, which was actually signed into law yesterday, regarding the Building Better Futures program. This is a companion bill that basically allows for students in high school to participate in the Building Better Futures program through concurrent education. I did not run the bill at the same time because there were some concerns initially with this bill by the superintendents as well as school boards.
Now the new bill is a joint effort. It has been amended, and it's my information that all are in agreement and support with this bill. You will note that there was some vague language in the old bill that addressed the distance where a school district may be, in the old bill, may be obligated to transport a student to a lengthy distance to a Building Better Futures program, and we have narrowed that down to 50 miles.
Another thing about this, frankly, is this is a forward-looking bill. Currently, there are no Building Better Futures programs. Pulaski Tech has made application, but what we are doing is when these programs are actually implemented, that this will immediately be able to be implemented by the high schools. so with that I would seek to answer any questions that you may have I also have
a person who assisted me with drafting the bill to answer more technical questions again if you have any you ready for questions you ready for questions no
questions All right. Is there anyone like to speak against the bill in the audience for the bill? Are you closed? I am closed, and I'd appreciate a
good vote. Thank you. Representative Armstrong, do you have a motion?
I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, say no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair and committee. Representative Saban, if you'll take the end of the table, we'll hear your bills. House Bill 1545, I believe, is correct. You? Okay. Yes, sir.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, House Bill 1545. And this bill is pretty much what it looks like if you all had a chance to take a look at it. I was approached by teachers with the Arkansas National Guard. They were interested in making sure that they were paid under the teacher compensation schedule rather than the state grade classification scale. I put this bill out a couple weeks ago. I don't know of any opposition. I think it's pretty uncontroversial, and I'd be glad to answer any questions.
Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing no questions from the committee, does anyone in the audience like to speak against it, for it? Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed, Mr. Chair. I have a do-pass motion from Representative McElroy. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. This time we're going to hear Senate Bill 1038. You're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Johnson asked me to run this bill for him, and it's coming from both the University of Arkansas and the Department of Higher Education, and mainly the federal government has just changed some of the accrediting agencies that they recognize. This is basically a cleanup bill, just ensuring that we acknowledge that in our statute as well. John. Are there any questions?
No questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience would like to... Do you have a question? Okay, we're on hold for a sec. Giving Representative Harris a chance to catch up. Everybody okay? Any questions, all from the committee. Is there anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for that bill? I'm closed, Mr. Chair. What's the will of the committee?
I have a due pass from Representative Armstrong. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no?
Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Eubanks, you're recognized. To present House Bill 1713. 1713. They're falling out pretty quick now.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I've asked Dr. Hernandez from Department of Ed to sit at the end of the table to basically explain all the issues involved in this bill. They brought it to me and said it was a cleanup bill, and that immediately sends up red flags because they're usually trying to hide something somewhere. But I asked some other people to look over it, and they said it was okay. So So at this time, if you can recognize Dr. Hernandez, I think he can explain any questions the committee may have.
Dr. Hernandez, you're recognized. Mike Hernandez, Department of Education. This is our typical, or every session we have a cleanup bill, and this has various sections that are doing many things. An example is taking out references to things that are no longer in the language, for instance, On Section 1, the Minimum Foundation Program Aid Act is no longer a valid name, so we replaced that with Public School Funding Act.
There are several sections in there, and I'd be happy to answer any questions on any particular sections, but those are mostly cleanup bills. The only one I did want to point out is there is one in particular that we're looking at. I want to make it clear there is a provision. Let's see if I can get to that right section. It has to do with the community eligibility provision, and it amends Code 6-2303, basically taking out a reference in federal code to allow us to be able to use community eligibility for purposes of NSLA funding.
and currently schools that do part of their feeding programs, they're allowed to do provision to feeding and then regular feeding. This will allow them to do the new federally mandated community eligibility provision. So that was one of the main ones that I wanted to point out, but I will be happy
to entertain any questions. Representative Harris, you
recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Hernandez, on page 2, line 25, strikes out the Public School Choice Act of 2013.
And does the Opportunity Public School Choice Act 2004, what is, if you could explain that. Let me get to the right. Sorry, I've got a lot of them
here. You said it was on page 2, I'm sorry. Yes. What's the bill? House bill. 1713.
Page 2, line 25. Yes, what that is is it's taken out and references the Public School Choice Act. schools that are in academic distress are able to use the public opportunity school choice, and so that's just clearing up that there's not confusion between the two school choice acts. Okay. All right. Thank you. Are there any other questions?
Seeing no other questions, is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed for the bill, and I make a motion due pass. I have a motion due pass from Representative Eubanks. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative Murdoch, you are recognized if you'd like to present a bill. House Bill 1640.
House Bill 1640. Thank you.
1-6-4-0. Here you are. Thank you, Chairman
Speaker 66
1:37:46
and Committee. Last session, I passed a bill, which is now Act, I think, 1288. And what it did, it allowed for the Department of Education to do a survey of all the districts in the state concerning the transportation miles cost, all of the issues associated with transportation. This legislation just now asks that the ADE and their public transportation and facilities,
academic facilities and transportation committee establish a one-way, a maximum one-way transportation time. So it takes the survey that we did with the last act and let's say let's put it together now and let's come up with a transportation time, maximum time that will be beneficial for the best outcomes for our students. All right, take any questions.
Can you hold just a second? Just checking some technical things. Yes, sir. Representative Lauer, are you recognized for a question? Yes.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And Representative Murdoch, you know, I'm very, I've been following your progress on looking at this issue and hopefully we'll be able to address maybe in the next session looking at transportation funding
and maybe pulling it out of the matrix so that there's not these inequities. But the question I have is on the procedure for filing a complaint, What would be the ramification of a complaint filed against a
Speaker 66
1:39:42
school district that does exceed the maximum? Well, right now, we don't have those penalties here. I would think that if that's something that can be advocated in the rules as it's implemented by EDE,
they may come up with something and then come back to review, and we'll review it as a
Okay. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. So as written, this is mostly to try and produce a paper record of acts where that has been exceeded so that we can – I know that you've actually conducted a study that gives us information, but putting this process in, is it just to collect a record so that we could move towards some type of a penalty?
Speaker 66
1:40:32
Well, I really had not focused on the penalty, to be honest with you. What I had focused on is the efficiency of us maximizing our information that we gathered from the survey to now we put something in place that makes sense for the outcomes. And so I had not really gotten into if someone chooses not to do what's been put in place, then what is the penalty? I think that is something that you write may need to be considered at the appropriate time. Okay. All right.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Walker, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Murdoch, I support having a time of transportation, but you're going to give it to someone else to set up the time without any standards. And I guess my question relates to the fact that the students who ride buses in areas of your concern and throughout much of the state, have to ride a bus for at least an hour, sometimes an hour and a half each way, and then they stay at school for seven hours,
and then when they get on the bus to go home at 5 or 5.30, they are denied extracurricular activities, an opportunity to have a full student life. Does your bill allow whomever is going to be making these time judgments the opportunity to put all of those things
Speaker 66
1:41:58
into perspective? I would hope, Representative Walker, that those very things that you just mentioned will be the components that the academic and facilities and transportation committee
will take into consideration as they try to take the data and produce for us something that is efficient and effective that will prevent some of the things that you just mentioned from continuing to happen. That has been the practice as we know it. That's what precipitated the survey and ultimately this legislation to hopefully somehow prevent the continuance of such behavior. So it is my hope that what will come forth will be different from what we experience now so that we will be better. That's my hope. Follow-up, Mr. Chair.
You're recognized. What is the number of students now, according to your survey or other information, as provided by reasonably competent sources such as the State Board of Education? of the number of students who travel for more than an hour and a half a day to get to and from school without any participation in extracurricular activities or extra work on campus. I don't have a survey in front of me, sir. So we're just talking about something where we don't know the impact.
No, sir. Could we ask Mr. Wood or somebody from the Department of Education how many people are currently affected by the long bus ride? Tony Wood, Commissioner of Education You heard my question Do you know the approximate number of students
who are affected by one-hour-and-a-half-plus round-trip bus rides to public schools in the state of Arkansas. And I think this issue may be raised in the Mount Judy case. I don't know that number. I can try to get it, but
at least for the commission, to have this in no use. If it's only two or three kids involved, there is one kind of consideration. If you have thousands, then that's another kind of consideration.
and if it's a few districts there's one consideration and if there are multiple districts that's another consideration would you not agree? I would thank you are
there any other questions? Rebs of Eubanks you recognize
for a question Representative Murdock I appreciate what you're trying to do here is trying to decrease that time that those students have to spend on the bus we always hear about unintended consequences down here, but is there a possibility that for some of these
rural districts that this would apply to and that it may require them to purchase additional buses and hire drivers, and it may have a financial impact on them as well? I know what you're trying to achieve, and that is worthy, but I'm just... Thank you. Did you want to say
Speaker 268
1:45:15
something, Commissioner? Well, just that there is a specific process for waiver that's addressed in the legislation, draft legislation.
Thank you. Representative Douglas, you recognize for a question? I, too, have been very concerned about transportation over the last session. And in talking to a lot of the superintendents, they are willing to make those financial sacrifices for the kids. And getting two small buses to run a route instead of one 90-person bus, you're going to have some more expenses.
But what are we talking about here? We're talking about kids on a bus for several hours, and, you know, they get to school tired. They, you know, everything we are about is making sure kids have the best opportunity they can to learn. And if this is what it takes to get them to school quicker in a more efficient way, we need to figure out how to do that. So I appreciate your efforts in being an advocate for kids.
So thank you. Thank you. Any other questions? Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? State your name and who you're with
Speaker 15
1:46:58
and you're recognized to speak against the bill Thank you Mr. Chair Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA and we applaud what Representative Murdoch is doing
bringing this issue to light because there are certainly issues with transportation out there depending on districts and geographical locations. Some of the concerns that we have on this is i remember the impact on the study that was completed and it was millions and millions of dollars the best i recall there's not appropriation for this so that means the millions and millions of dollars will be coming from school districts school districts who have just passed a 63 increase in foundation funds depending on the district you're at and your
transportation difficulties, you cannot do this. Now, there is a process for a waiver. I understand that, and I know all of you understand that just because there's a process for a waiver doesn't mean a waiver is going to be granted. So it is a funding issue. It is certainly an issue that needs to be addressed. We just don't feel like this bill is
going to address that. Representative Walker, you are recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
You are with the Arkansas Association of School Administrators. Do you have any empirical evidence which would allow a reasonable estimate or even guesstimate of the effect upon existing school budgets in the areas where transportation distances are long? Do you have any idea at all? Other than when the study came out?
other than just read the study,
do you have any empirical evidence that would allow you to justify the position that you have asserted in opposition to Representative Murdoch's bill? Empirical evidence, no. Common sense, yes. Well, thank you. I think he's dealing with his common
sense, too. Thank you. Are there any other questions? Representative Lauer, are you recognized?
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I guess I'm following up on Representative Walker's question. At the point that we are not mandating what the maximum time would be,
we're leaving it to a commission to develop that, and I'm sure that school administrators would have input into that. I'm really just curious why you would oppose it in terms of saying it's going to cost dollars when that maximum time has not even been established yet? I'm just going
Speaker 15
1:49:37
back to the study that showed if you cut the transportation mileage back down from this number to this number to this number and the cost with that. Now, I'm assuming that all of us in here would not want to be on a bus two hours,
probably not an hour and a half, and just go back to that study, and there is a cost factor. When you talk about input with the commission, sometimes we have input and sometimes we don't have input. So there's too many unknowns to this. And if it's not an issue, then let's go ahead and place in the bill that if there is an additional cost on this, that would be picked up by the state. You recognize for
follow-up? Yes, thank you. I would certainly understand your opposition
and for a point there I actually was going to ask Representative Murdoch why we're not setting the maximum and I appreciate that he's going to allow the commission to look at that but would you not agree that for us to establish funding before the fact would almost be like writing a blank check for the commission to determine what would be the maximum time allowed if there's separate funding thresholds for each of these times
that if we said we're going to allocate money that almost is an invitation to go ahead and see how far we can stretch the money we're going to say okay we've got enough money for an hour and a half so we're going
Speaker 15
1:51:10
to say an hour and a half and I understand that concept as well and again I do think it is a worthy topic for additional study and come up with some valid recommendations so you know exactly how much it does cost. Because we're all just guessing.
You know, in some areas of the state, not only is it the length of the time, it's also trying to find the number of bus drivers to accommodate that. Because when I was at Bryant, we put a bus out on the interstate with a big banner on it that said, looking for drivers. And we did not pick up very many, by the way. So in some districts, it is hard to find enough drivers now. So if you do have to split some of those routes up, you will be trying to find additional drivers. But I understand where you're
coming. All right. Thank you. Motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair.
Are there any other questions? Thanks, sir. I have one that would like to speak against the bill. I'm sorry, for the bill. Mr. Finley, you are recognized. If you state your name and who
you're with, you'll be recognized. Thank you. My name is Clay Finley. I'm the attorney representing the Dearmount-Judy School District. Mr. Walker, I wanted to answer your question you had about the number of kids impacted. The study, there were 106 bus routes that were over 90 minutes. The average number of students on the bus was 49.
So around 5,000, 5,200 kids are riding the bus currently, one way more than 90 minutes. And I guess one other thing I wanted to point out is the longest bus route turned out to be 167 minutes. That is two hours and 47 minutes one way. That's five hours and 34 minutes a day on the bus. And really the only thing you need to agree to to support this bill is that there is an amount of time that's too much to be on a bus.
If you believe that, you can support this bill. We've got a waiver provision where necessary. So I think that's the only question you need to ask yourself to support this bill. I can answer any other questions if you
have any. I have a question. What district was the longest ride in and what were
the circumstances under that? According to Mr. Wilson, when he presented the study, the longest ride was in the Little Rock School District. It was a magnet student who was riding the bus for 167 minutes one way.
In the Little Rock School District? Yes. That's amazing. Are there any other questions? Representative, anybody have a question? Thanks, sir. Does anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Murdoch, would you like to close for your bill?
I'm closed, thank you. Representative Walker, you have a motion? I have a motion to do pass from Representative Walker. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed? No. I'm going to call that a pass. I'll say that's a yes. That was very close. Congratulations, you passed your bill.
President Douglas, you have a very quick bill. Actually, I have two bills left to run, if y'all can hang with us. I have Representative Douglas and I have Senator Irvin, if she gets here. So we'll run Representative Douglas, and those will be the last two, and we'll be out of here. At this time, I would like to ask for a, do I need a motion?
Yes, without objection. Without objection, I will have a special order for Thursday for bills, we're trying to find them here, right there, House Bill 1442, 1443, and 1444. Those are Representative Mayberry's. There's no objection. We'll put those on special order. Thank you. You're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Very quickly, most of you guys know in going through the forums that we have visited
for all the different educational organizations, the one resounding theme was we need some more efficiency in our school district, especially in reporting. And thanks to one of our superintendents, he's actually in Representative Harris' district, and we've all worked together to put together this bill. And I'm going to let my superintendent, Mr. Woolley,
explain how this is going to make things more efficient for school districts to report. Thank you,
Speaker 287
1:56:25
Representative Douglas. David Woolley, Superintendent of Schools in Alma. This bill is strictly an efficiency bill. Representative Douglas asked us to look at what we could do from our standpoint as a school district to minimize the amount of paperwork and reporting to the Department of Education. Almost everything we know and do in schools is electronic these days, either within e-school,
e-finance, other data systems. It's all electronic, and the Department of Education and the Department of Career Education has access to all of that. However, we continue to be asked to, in addition to having all of that electronically, we continue to be asked quite often to recompile and resubmit much of that same information. This bill simply increases the efficiency of schools and school districts, teachers, administrators by eliminating the duplicative reporting of data and information that the
Department of Career Education and the Department of Education already has access to through the various electronic systems that we have. It doesn't reduce the data or the information in any way that the department collects. Both departments have a duty to assure compliance with laws and rules, and this does not change that in any way. In fact, the bill actually reemphasizes that point. It simply allows school personnel to hopefully save a great deal of effort
by eliminating us doing the same thing twice. Are
you ready for commercials? Oh, commercials. I'm ready for a commercial. Take a break. Are you all ready for questions? We are. All right. Do I have any questions from the committee? Wow. Everybody's ready for lunch. Anyone in the audience like to speak against this bill? For the bill?
Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. Thank you. I have a motion. Representative Walker. I have a due pass from Representative Walker. All those in favor say aye. Anyone against? no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you. Do you have another bill? Really, actually, we're at 12 o'clock. Would you like to hold? What's the will of the committee? Do you want to hear more bills, or do you want to go eat lunch? I think this is unopposed. You want to give her five minutes? We'll give you five minutes.
Okay, all right. This is just simply a bill not to alter any curriculum, or it is just to it's a bill on teen dating violence, and bill number? I'm sorry, I gave my bill
away. House Bill 1685. 1685, is that correct? Okay. House Bill
1685. 1685. And we're finding that in the health curriculum, even though teen dating violence and healthy relationships is included, it is not being covered. And we're hearing from state police, we're hearing from teachers
that this is an invasive problem in high schools and junior highs, which begins with bullying. So we are asking that the health teachers designate October, which is Domestic Violence Month, to cover a unit on teen dating violence. And then the second semester, it's just a semester class. If they teach the second semester, we're asking that they put that curriculum in the month
of February. And that's basically what it is, and we have resources available through the Coalition for Domestic Violence, which is who I have sitting beside me if we have any questions. Representative Walker, you're recognized.
Oh, my gosh. I guess you chose the month of February
because that's a contentious month in junior high school for youngsters who are getting ready for the Valentine period. Yes, we
Are there any other questions? Seeing none, anybody in the audience like to speak against the bill, for the bill? You closed for your bill? Closed. Representative Saban, you have a motion? Mr. Chair, I move to do pass. I have a do pass motion. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, committee, for your diligence. I have a little light statement for all those that are the 1733 fans. If you will come to this afternoon deal, we'll be talking a little bit about 1733.
I didn't say I was running, and I said we'd be talking about it. On adjournment. We will be reconvening. We'll give 20 minutes after adjournment. If it's after 4 o'clock, if we adjourn at 4 o'clock, we will not have a meeting, though. That's too late. So if we adjourn before 4, we will be here at 4 o'clock or 20 minutes after adjournment. Plan on 20 minutes after adjournment. Thank you. No objection. We adjourn.
Agenda
SB368
SB371
SB366
SB591
SB695
HB1419
HB1602
HB1256
HB1545
SB1038
HB1713
HB1640
HBDOUGLAS
HB1685
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 1
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Speaker 15
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative James Ratliff
Unverified
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Speaker 49
Speaker 66
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Speaker 14
Speaker 99
Speaker 115
Senator Alan Clark
Unverified
Speaker 128
Speaker 159
Speaker 167
Speaker 177
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Representative Justin T. Harris Chair
Unverified
Senator Stephanie Flowers Chair
Unverified
Speaker 209
Speaker 146
Representative Ron McNair
Unverified
Speaker 229
Representative Bob Johnson
Unverified
Representative Mary Broadaway
Unverified
Speaker 108
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Speaker 245
Representative Jon S. Eubanks
Unverified
Representative Reginald Murdock
Unverified
Speaker 103
Speaker 271
Speaker 268
Clay Finley
Unverified
Speaker 287