House Insurance and Commerce Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (19)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB667
· 4 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…ttee. We're going to continue down the agenda. We're now at SB 667. Representative Kozart, you're recognized to present”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1486
· 3 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…ittee. At this time, without objection, we're going to hear House Bill 1486.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB701
· 3 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…hout objection from the committee members, I'd like to hear Senate Bill 701. Senator Irvin, you're recognized. Thank you so much”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB935
· 3 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…what I'd like to do at this point without objection is hear Senate Bill 935”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1455
· 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…hank you. Representative Boyd you are recognized to present HB 1455 Senate amendment concurrence. Mr.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1562
· 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…ncurred. Representative Meeks, you're recognized to present House Bill 1562. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Basically what 1562”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1797
· 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…on't see Representative Wright, so we're going to pass over House Bill 1797 at this time. Oh, I'm sorry. No, it's all right. And then 1…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1814
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1814”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1894
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Is Representative Charlotte Douglas here? The next bill is HB 1894. Representative Bynes, you're going to run a Friday. The ne…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1809
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Pitts. You've passed the bill. The next bill on our list is HB 1809. Is Representative Charlotte Douglas here? The next bill is…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1870
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1870”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1906
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1906”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1907
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…g to run a Friday. The next bill we've got on our agenda is HB1907, Representative Neal.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1931
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “The next bill on our agenda is HB1931, Representative Letting. Senator Irvin said SB466 has an am…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB466
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…genda is HB1931, Representative Letting. Senator Irvin said SB466 has an amendment. Without objection, we're going to go out…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB821
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB821”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB822
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB822”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB824
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB824”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB826
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB826”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
If we need to meet at 7 in the morning, we'll meet at 7 in the morning, but my goal is to try and get through all the bills that are on the calendar that people want to present, at least get a shot at everybody having a shot at trying to get the bill presented this week. So that's what the goal is. So that gives us two hours today, and I'm going to guess up to three on Friday. Obviously, we can schedule more meetings, but I know with the session heading toward a close and all the things going on, people are concerned about that. So I would say we would do it after session, but there's some challenges with that,
so it's probably going to be Friday. With that, and without objection from the committee members, I'd like to hear Senate Bill 701. Senator Irvin, you're recognized. Thank you so much
for your indulgence. My other bill on here is not ready, and we're working on an amendment to get that agreed upon, so it should be fast when it comes to you. That's 466, but you have right now 701, Senate Bill 701. And what this bill does is, under what is currently being done through Payment Improvement Initiative,
and actually this doesn't even deal with Medicaid, but these types of alternate payment structures of gain sharing and gain risk are utilized in the private sector as well. And one of the things, if you'll read what this bill does at the very end of the bill on page two, It talks about when a health care payer is determining that gain share or risk sharing for a physician, they cannot attribute to that physician costs that are a result of variations
in that health care payer's freely negotiated contract pricing with other persons or entities outside the physician's practice. Basically, a physician is not and cannot is not part of any kind of negotiated contracts with a hospital. That is done with the hospital and that private payer. But what is happening is that physician is being held accountable for that negotiated fee, and it's being calculated into their gain sharing and their risk assessment,
and that's really outside of their control. So what this bill asks is that we just exclude that when they're considering that as part of their formula. I'll entertain questions Members, are there any questions for Senator Irvin?
Medical Society that can help if you have questions Seeing none, is there anybody
that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill Senator Irvin, are you closed for your bill?
I am, thank you And just a side note, I did work with DHS on this Medicaid pays a flat rate, flat fee They don't negotiate contracts with hospitals so this should not affect Medicaid. Just wanted to say that for
the record. Thank you. All right, members, Senator Irvin is closed for a bill. What's the will of the committee? Representative Vines, you're recognized for
a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Good morning. Motion
to do pass. Committee, we have a motion do pass on Senate Bill 701.
All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Senator Irvin. you've passed
your bill. Thank you so much for your indulgence committee and Mr.
Chair thank you thank you thank you. Representative Boyd you are recognized to present HB 1455 Senate amendment concurrence. Mr.
Chair this should be pretty simple basically there was a cleanup language for the cleanup language for the board appointments for the appraiser board so if you have any
questions, I'll do my best to answer it, or I've got Lee Gordon out in the audience if need be. But otherwise, I'd just appreciate a good
vote. Members, are there any questions for Representative Boyd? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against concurrence in the Senate amendment? For the amendment. Seeing none, Representative Boyd, are you closed for your amendment? I'm closed. What's the will of the committee? Do pass. We have a motion to adopt the Senate amendment on House Bill 1455.
Is there any discussion? All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Boyd. The amendment is concurred. Representative Meeks, you're recognized to present House Bill 1562. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Basically what 1562
is, and there's probably a lot of confusion because I've taken a lot out of the bill that there were some concerns by some massage therapists as to what it would actually do. So the only parts that were
left in the bill basically deal with sexual misconduct. And this is out of concerns that we're starting to see more instances or more red flags concerning human trafficking. We've seen similar things happen in San Francisco, Houston, and other large cities. And again, we're starting to see that here in Arkansas. And so this is a way for us to be able to give our law enforcement the tools that are necessary to be able to crack down on any type of illegal activity. This does not affect
Senator Sample's bill that we may take up later on if it gets out of the Senate, where his bill will take the massage board and move it underneath the Department of Health. This bill would have no impact on it because all it's doing is it is allowing whoever the health inspector may be or the inspector underneath the Department of Health that still deals with the massage board, the ability, you know, to revoke licensing or whatever if they are found in violation of, as I said, the sexual misconduct or there's also human trafficking and different things
of that nature. And then at the very bottom, we deal with military licensing. If somebody is in the military and they fail to renew their license, then what this does is allow them to renew their license without having to pay a late fee. And I think that's the right thing to do for our military. So with that said, I'll be glad to answer any questions the committee may have. Members, are there any questions
for Representative Meeks? representative love you recognize for a question thank you mr chairman
representative meeks what is the stance from the massage therapy board on your bill i have not heard from miss graham
um since we've taken it out but as far as i know they're either neutral or they don't have any there's no opposition there's a lot i did have a lot of therapists from around the state email me on this but it was on other parts of the bill that I stripped out, and so as far as I know, there is no opposition to this bill. Okay. Thank you, sir.
Any other questions for members? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Meeks, are you closed for your bill? I am closed. Thank you. What's the will of the committee? Representative Lundstrom, you recognize for a motion. Motion do pass, Mr. Chairman. We have a motion due pass on House Bill 1562. Is there any discussion? All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Meeks.
You passed your bill. Thank you, committee. Is Representative Wright in the room? Is Representative Wright in the room? Okay, I don't see Representative Wright, so we're going to pass over House Bill 1797 at this time. Oh, I'm sorry. No, it's all right. And then 1798 as well, Representative Wright, so he's not in the room,
so we're going to pass over that at this time. HB1814, Representative Love, would you like to run HB1814? is Representative McGee here for 1824 is Representative Sabin here for 1870 what I'd like to do at this point without objection is hear Senate Bill 935
Representative Pitts you're recognized to present Senate Bill 935 and then we'll go back to our normal order Representative Pitts, you're recognized. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. Committee members, I'm running this bill for Representative Gossage and Senator Rice. If it's okay, I'm going to have legal counsel from the Electric Cooperative come up with me if there's any questions. The understanding that you have in front of you, there are certain times when a certificate of public convenience and necessity is not required from the Public Service Commission.
Those times would be for a replacement or an expansion of existing equipment or facilities. There are times when a distribution cooperative, instead of them doing the work, they want AECC, the Electric Cooperative Corporation, to do the work for them. That's when we found that AECC did not fall under the exemption because technically the certified territory, property ownership, or right-of-way was owned by the distribution co-op. So, basically, this clarifies that when somebody does the work under contract for them.
We've got AG's opinion, I understand, that they are supportive of this bill, and we don't know of any opposition to this bill. Are there any
questions for Representative Pitch? Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Pitch, are you closed for your bill? I am closed for my bill. What's the will of the committee? Representative Balch, you're recognized for a motion. Do pass. We have a do pass motion on Senate Bill 935.
All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Pitts. You've passed the bill. The next bill on our list is HB 1809. Is Representative Charlotte Douglas here? The next bill is HB 1894. Representative Bynes, you're going to run a Friday. The next bill we've got on our agenda is HB1907, Representative Neal.
The next bill on our agenda is HB1931, Representative Letting. Senator Irvin said SB466 has an amendment. Without objection, we're going to go out of order and go back to the top
and run HB 1797. That's 1797. And Representative Wright, I understand you have an amendment for this bill as well? I do have an amendment. Okay, so let's run the amendment first for House Bill 1797.
Mr. Chairman, committee, all the amendment does is add language that the nominal fee will be set and governed by the Arkansas Insurance Department, and the insurance commissioner is or was here.
Oh, there he is, right there, that actually came to me with this language, and he's good with it. I appreciate a good vote on adopting the amendment. Is there anyone, any questions on
the amendment? It should have shown up. All right, members, I'll give you a moment to review the amendment and see if there's any questions.
Motion. Okay, members, do we have any questions on the amendment? Seeing none, is there anybody in the audience that would like to speak against the amendment, for the amendment? Representative Wright, are you closed for your amendment? I'm closed for my amendment. I move do pass on the amendment. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Okay, the bill is amended.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Committee, what the bill does, and I'll tell you, this bill was brought to me by the, basically the funeral homeowners,
and it's regarding prepaid insurance for prepaid funerals and the issue that they came to me with was is right now when you go by prepaid funeral benefits you go to a funeral home which can can do that for you and there's nothing that's charged for that. They just do it. The situation has come up where that
when somebody passes away and for whatever reason they don't want to use the funeral home which issued the benefits that's fine, but the benefits transfer to whatever funeral home they use. Whether it's they've moved or they just don't like that funeral home, and the funeral homes are okay with that. They don't mind those being transferred. That's not the issue. But what they've come to me with and said there is, you know, we incur costs associating
that. Because we don't charge anything, we would like at least a nominal, you know, fee for that. 15, 20 bucks. Just something. Because they do paperwork. They do have to put it in the mail and transfer it and have people to do that and the insurance commissioner who do you mind coming up out is actually came in and said we'd like to do that and be in charge of that which I said that's fine because I think you're probably the best to
handle that. So that's all it does. I'd be more than happy to take any questions. Are there any questions for
members? Seeing none is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? for the bill. Seeing none, Representative Wright, are you closed for your bill? I'm closed. Make a motion. Do pass. As amended? As amended. We have a motion. Do pass as amended on the table. Is there any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed?
Congratulations, Representative Wright. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Committee. We're going to continue down the agenda. We're now at SB 667. Representative Kozart, you're recognized to present
like to ask John Bethel to join me from the Public Service Commission.
Mr. Bethel, please introduce yourself and who you're with, and you'll be recognized to speak for and present Senate Bill 667. Yes, sir. I'm John Bethel, and I'm
the director of the Arkansas Public Service Commission. Mr. Chair,
what we've got is some cleanup language and a little bit of change in the law to amend the law necessary for the authorization of a public utility's evidence and indebtedness. And I'm going to let John kind of explain that a little bit to you
because he'll do a whole lot better job than I am. Thank you, committee. The bill is a minor cleanup. Currently, utilities with debt on Arkansas assets require commission approval. The two regional transmission organizations, the Southwest Power Pool and the Mid-Continent RTO, are covered by this statute. However, their indebtedness is not encumbered upon Arkansas assets,
and it's difficult for them to meet the standard in the bill and their rates are regulated directly by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission and so all this does is remove the requirement that they obtain commission approval for their debt issuances and if you have any questions on that, I can answer that for you. Representative Cozart has presented
the bill. Members, are there any questions? Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill.
Seeing none, Representative Cozart, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. We are closed. What's the will of the committee? Representative Talley, you're recognized for our motion. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Do pass. We have a do pass motion for Senate Bill 667. All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Cozart. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. At this time, without objection, we're going to hear House Bill 1486.
Representative Letting, you're recognized to present House Bill 1486. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Mr. Vice Chair, members of the
committee. I will be very brief. I do have a couple of people joining me at the table. Would you like them to introduce themselves
before I begin? before I begin? Yes, why don't you go ahead and have them introduce themselves and who they're with and that way the three of you can all present the
bill interchangeably. You'll all be recognized. Thank you. My name
is Lynn Foster. I'm on the faculty at the UALR Bowen School of Law and I basically represent the public, no official group. Good morning
Speaker 72
18:32
committee and thank you for the opportunity. My name is Howard Warren. I'm the Legislative Director of the Landlord Association of Arkansas. We represent roughly 1,000 mom-and-pop landlords who own and manage their own properties. I'm here to testify in favor of
the bill. And members, some materials are being
handed out as we speak. And again, the three of you are recognized to present House Bill 1486. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I will be very
brief with my comments because I know we have a lot on our plate and there are several people who We'd like to speak on both sides of this legislation. Currently, Arkansas is the only state in the country that does not have a warranty of habitability on the books, which basically means that a landlord could rent the property to tenants that might not be safe. Now, to be absolutely clear, it's my opinion that the overwhelming number of landlords in Arkansas do right by their tenants,
but I think we all know that there are a handful out there that might not. So what we're trying to do with this legislation is create a level playing field for all landlords. We wrote it in cooperation with the Landlords Association of Arkansas. As Mr. Warren pointed out, that group represents about 1,000 independent landlords all across the state. They support this legislation. Our goal was not to create any new burden for landlords. This bill really shouldn't affect any landlord that does right by their tenants. We also did not want to empower bad tenants.
We know that there are bad tenants out there. But we want to protect working families and good tenants and protect good landlords. With that, I think I'd turn it over to Mr. Warren for his comments. Good morning. As I
Speaker 72
20:12
mentioned, I am a landlord in Little Rock, Arkansas. My experience with warranty, though, has been from the opposite direction. My daughter was a student at the University of Arkansas in Fayetteville, and she rented from one of the large property management companies there.
Like a good daughter, she came home for Thanksgiving and was called by her roommate that the apartment was flooded. We'd had serious thunderstorms. When she got back up there, the apartment was under three inches of water. Carpet was destroyed. Her personal stuff was destroyed. The breaker box had soaked, so Swepco had pulled the meter. The heating and cooling system was blown out. This is in Thanksgiving. When she went to the complex, she requested to move to another unit. First, they told her that repairs for her unit would not be begun until February.
She asked for another unit. They told her, there's not one. She asked to transfer to another complex that the group managed, and they said, no, you have to stay where you are. You will continue to pay rent for December and January, and if you move out, we will sue you for the remaining six months of your term. The complex's management, a perfectly legal licensed management company in Arkansas, said that my daughter had to pay rent for an apartment with no heat, no light, no ability to cook, and with mildewing, fermenting carpet.
This is legal in Arkansas today, but that's not the way I do my business, and that's not the way the majority of landlords do that business. And I doubt that anybody on this committee who has children would want their child to go through the same thing. Legislatively speaking, in previous years, it's always been us-versus-them legislation. You've rarely had groups come together to find a comfortable middle ground. In 2012, there was a non-legislative commission. I was one of the commissioners. We had an equal number of landlord and tenant representatives,
and one of our unanimous recommendations was a fair and balanced warranty of habitability. In 2013, no such legislation passed, and the bills ran in 2013 were not fair and balanced. They were, once again, the us versus them. However, I've made personal relationships with several commissioners, and we continue to work on this on our own time. We spent the last year and a half meeting periodically, working things, going through this bill.
The bill you see in front of you is very detailed because it specifies what happens. We spent months on this bill playing devil's advocate back and forth. Does this help a tenant? Does this help a landlord? Does this help a bad tenant? does this help a bad landlord in trying to get the language down as tight as we could. On November 6th of last year, I called a special meeting of my organization's board of directors. All but one chapter attended. I presented the bill. We spent two hours walking through it line by line,
at the end of which I recused myself from the room so there was no personal pressure, and that board voted unanimously to support it. On December 2nd, Amy Johnson and I met with Maurice Taylor, the secretary-treasurer of the Realtors Association, to give him a copy of the bill. We discussed the bill in detail in a very friendly, very professional capacity. He had a number of good questions, but his best one that I remember was to me specifically. He looked at me and said, does anything in this bill give me heartburn? And my answer was, no, sir, this is what I do every day already.
The bill you see in front of you is not pro-landlord or pro-tenant. It's not liberal or conservative. it's not Democrat or Republican. It respects the needs of the landlord to make a profit while providing the tenants a mechanism to get repairs made. As I said, this is what we do every day. What does it do? It requires a landlord to keep up the property and specifically lists the areas. The roof can't leak, the doors and windows have to work, the heat has to operate, the plumbing can't drip and electricity can't spark a smoke alarm has to be working at the beginning
of a lease this bill respects city codes this is not a power grab of any kind if you look at Arkansas the majority of the state does not have municipal city codes because it's rural this provides a bottom floor the bill that provides a mechanism for the tenants to notify a landlord for the need of a repair the The bill provides the landlord timing and plenty of time to do repairs, including temporary repairs. For example, you could see the situation where a tornado,
you know, all the roofers are going to be busy for a while after a tornado. The bill respects that, and you can make temporary repairs to get through until such time as you have a good contractor. The bill addresses fixer uppers. There is a market in Arkansas where an older house that is run down can be rented to a qualified tenant for a discounted rent. The qualified tenant repairs the place and brings it up to standards. For example, taking an old house and renting it to a licensed plumber and discounting his rent in exchange for upgrading the plumbing. What this bill requires is it requires it to be in writing, to list the items.
That also dovetails some upcoming IRS rules that a friend of mine in California is experiencing. In the worst case, what this bill provides is if the landlord simply refuses to fix things, The tenant has the right to move out. What does it not do? The bill does not allow a bad tenant to cry wolf and break things on purpose. It does not allow a tenant to refuse to pay rent. The tenant must continue to pay the rent while the repair is ongoing.
The bill does not replace or override city code again. In many cases, it takes a back seat. Many cities have higher code standards than what is in this bill. The bill does not open the floodgates to frivolous lawsuits. 1816-110 Arkansas Code is expressly referenced twice and is expressly supported. The bottom line is we have common sense laws to protect all of us today. I live in Little Rock. I can go to Forest City or Hot Springs or Judsonia and I can drink the water safely because there is a bottom-level common sense
safe drinking law. I can go to Ozark, I can go to Rogers, and I can go or hope I can go to a grocery store and I don't have to worry about getting rotten meat because we have a bottom-line, common-sense law to protect grocery stores and restaurants. What I cannot do is go to Springdale or Mariana or even down the road across from my own home and be guaranteed that the house I rent is habitable. I respectfully ask this committee to consider this law, consider whether this is good for Arkansas and Arkansans, and consider what you would do if your daughter was forced, under threat of legal reprisal,
to stay in an apartment during winter with no heat, no light, no ability to cook, and rotting carpet. Thank you very much for
your time. Thank you, Howard, and thank you for the honor of being here today to speak to everyone in the room. I appreciate it. I've taught real estate law, both general law and Arkansas law, for more than 10 years. I've also served on a national committee to draft a uniform landlord-tenant law and I've been on that committee now for three years.
I had the honor as well as Howard of serving on the Landlord-Tenant Study Commission that he referred to in 2012. And as the committee did its research, it was confirmed that we are in fact the only state in the United States that does not have an implied warranty of habitability. The group that drafted this, and I was a part of the group, we all met on our own time, we have drafted a very, very narrow implied warranty of habitability. Of all of the warranties out there, and I have read every single one of them several times,
this is one of the most narrow. As Howard said, it's not going to expand landlord's tort liability in any way. The statute expressly states that. I would like to just mention one other thing, because Howard basically covered all my points. Thank you for that, Howard. And I know you're very busy this morning. It's oftentimes been said that Arkansas has the lowest rent in the United States. And in the last couple of days, I've done some research on that.
The National Low Income Housing Coalition publishes rankings of state average rents once a year, and the last 10 years of rankings are on the Internet. Over the last 10 years, we have been the most inexpensive state only twice. The rest of the time, other states have been more inexpensive than we. These states are Kentucky, North Dakota, South Dakota, and West Virginia. And in every single one of those states, there's an implied warranty of habitability, and in every single one of those states, tenants have other additional rights that are not even in our bill.
So, I really don't believe that if this bill were to be enacted that our rent would skyrocket and we would no longer be at the bottom of the inexpensive rent list of the states. Thank you. Are you
ready for questions, Representative Blenning? Yes, Mr. Chair. I'd actually just like to ask the first one. The, I've been a renter and I've also been a landlord. And so I'm just wondering since in all of those scenarios, in multiple states,
and in all of those scenarios, whether I was the landlord or the renter, there was a contract, there was an agreement. And the agreement between me and the renter or the landlord, depending on which one I was, spelled out tons and tons of stuff, right? So like when I was a landlord, I would say, look, if you're willing to fix the small things, I'll give you a reduction in the rent. And, you know, if you pay early, I'll do this. If you pay late, I'll do that. If you sign a long lease, I'll do this. You know, all this stuff, right? And there were some good renters, and there were others that weren't,
and I'm sure there's some good landlords and all those kinds of things. But I guess my overall question is, what is it about the contract process where somebody goes in and makes a contract with another person that
Speaker 72
30:30
is broken? Thinking about several different cases, One can look at a case where a contract may be written in one language and the person signing the contract may not understand that language. My own in-laws are from Korea. And sometimes, you know, even though they speak fluent English,
sometimes the connotation of a language can change. There are examples of landlords who write contracts expressly knowing that the tenant cannot understand them, and they expressly dump responsibility on people who are not qualified to make the repair. in the situation you mentioned, you have a tenant, you're comfortable with the tenant, you know they can paint the walls, you're happy with that, that's perfectly fine. But would you say to a tenant who is barely able to speak English that you have to maintain the air conditioning system at your expense?
That is what we're looking at. To dovetail to this, there is a set of IRS regulations that will be published relatively soon where that type of a contract is now considered income to one direction or another. And we all know the IRS. We all love the IRS. They will be wanting this in writing. So we're dovetailing
that a bit. So if I understood your answer correctly, it's primarily that there are some language difficulties for some renters. That can be
Speaker 72
31:47
it. It also can be that the contract is simply so stacked one direction for another,
the tenant, language difficulty or not, may not understand what they are being requested to do. And Lynn may be
able to testify to that better. Thank you, Howard. If currently, if the lease does not specify a duty of repair for any one party, the law does not impose a duty of repair on the landlord. So if your lease said nothing about repair, you would not have any duty to repair the premises. Now, you know, again, this is not addressed at most landlords.
Most landlords do repair the premises and they repair them promptly. This law is a bottom, a minimum standard. It's a floor, but yet there are tenants all over Arkansas who live in housing that is not of very high quality, that has defects, and the defects are not being repaired. This is not the only case, too, where the law implies a provision in a contract. The law implies a provision that you will give your tenant possession at the beginning
of the term. is implied in every lease in all states, whether the lease states so or not. And this is just another example of that. Representative Farrar, you're working
Mr. Chair. I have rental property, and I'm a good landlord. I fix all my things, so I don't have a problem with that. Addressing you. Now, in my leases that I put out, if the property is uninhabitable, they can move out. I have the same thing.
not. Her lease didn't have the clause. Okay. Well, I think we're trying to fix the wrong problem. Why don't we fix the leases that have
Speaker 72
33:36
that clause in it instead of trying to fix the landlords? Because Arkansas law doesn't have, there's no law to force a landlord to do the repair. We've just now gone full circle. You're saying, how do we fix a lease? But there's no law forcing a landlord to
put that in the lease. If it's uninhabitable, the tenant can move out. you're trying to pass a law that says you told me that your daughter couldn't move out
because it was uninhabitable. She couldn't move out and they were going to charge her rent. That is correct. I'm asking you, why don't you attack the lease instead of the landlord? Because if you have competition, they're no longer, if you have a poor building just like my properties, if my properties are bad I'm not going to have a rent at all. They're not going to rent from me. So and that would be the same thing. I think you're trying to force the landlords instead of forcing the lease.
Because competition, well they will leave if the apartment's bad. Except
Speaker 72
34:33
that in Fayetteville you have tens of thousands of units and you have this problem with certain managers repeatedly where their lease, you can get a copy of it to inspect it and it does not have the right of repair or the right of termination so it when you have an oligarchy of a several a few landlords who control the majority of the area they have the same similar lease but you still have the choice of
not renting that property if it's if it's not in there well in her case she
Speaker 72
34:58
actually owned a Hyundai Accent she couldn't really live in the car well no but there's a and you
and I you and I are good landlords what I want to do what I want to do is if you just finish answering that question then we'll move to our next question are you finished at the
end of the table or do you still have more? Yes, sir. Okay. Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. In looking at your bill, Representative Letting, I just have one question or for anyone at the end of the table. Are you all familiar with the HUD housing quality standards? Tell me, how does this bill relate or because I heard
someone say that this is a minimum standard. How does this bill kind of relate to the HUD quality standards? Rate this as far as... Below. The
Speaker 72
35:47
HUD quality standards for Section 8 inspection and other subsidized programs actually have a higher standard than this does. So anyone who's renting to subsidized low-income tenants are above the standard of this bill to begin with.
Wait a minute. So you're saying that we're not going to even meet the HUD quality standards?
That is correct. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative
Ferguson, you're recognized for a question. I just had some specific questions about the bill. Does this say it requires you to furnish a garbage disposal? No. No. What is
Speaker 72
36:26
the waste disposal? Basically that if you have a multiplex, it requires you to work with a local garbage collection authority. If you've got a single, it's like everything else. If you think about Little Rock as the example, if you have a single family or any form of individually metered water, garbage is included with that.
So it's already covered as part of the utility. If you don't live in a city where garbage is covered as part of your municipal utility, your lease works to determine how garbage is removed. Okay,
thank you. Could I just say one more thing in response to Representative Love? because I didn't want him to be left with the wrong impression. Yes, ma'am. This in no way changes federal regulations. They still apply to federal housing. This applies to housing not covered by federal housing rules.
Yes, and that was probably my point is that the HUD quality standards are just so low. And for us to even say that we're going to pass a bill that's even lower, I just don't even have anything to say about that. So thank you for your comments. Thank you. Are there
any other questions for members? Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized. I have to
tell you, I'm personally offended by this bill. I'm a landlord, I'm a small business owner, and have been for 23 years,
and I provide a good, clean product. When you walk in the door, it smells good because it's clean. I get, the reason I go out and find properties is when another landlord who hasn't done their job, and yes, that happens in every field, I go buy that property and fix it back up and put it back on the market. That's what competition, capitalistic process that we have in Arkansas. And for a lot of us small business owners, I find this as big brother as you can get. I'm sorry I haven't heard of your organization, but I've been doing fine renting property and doing my job for years.
And for somebody to come in and tell me what's hot water, how hot is hot, or what color, or operable this or operable that, My customers come in, they look at that property, and they decide whether or not they're going to rent from me based on what they see and the decisions they make. I just don't find this helpful at all. I don't see where this is going to accomplish anything but just have another layer of Big Brother. If the customer doesn't like it, the customer can leave. If your daughter would like a place to rent in Fayetteville, she needs to call me.
Okay. If I could respond. And if all landlords were like you, we wouldn't need this bill. The market will take care of this. People can choose not
to, if they walk in and don't like it, they won't rent. And I won't survive in the real world. I'm all about the market. But if the
market would take care of this issue, we wouldn't be here today. In
the vast majority of cases, it does. And when it doesn't, I'll go in and buy that ugly piece of property,
turn around and make it look something wonderful we don't need this to tell me how to
do my job all right and again representative lundstrom this bill isn't targeting you because you do do
a fantastic job as does representative farrar but for every small business owner i'm speaking on their behalf this does not rest well with me so on behalf of them no thank you members are there any more
questions we've got lots and lots of people that are signed up to speak foreign against this bill so if there are no more questions we're going to turn to the
foreign against and so what i would just ask all those people to do is if knowing that there's lots and lots of people my preference would be for each person to be able to get up and say something that's different than what other people have said but since you've made the the trip here to get your opportunity to speak but if if somebody abuses that i don't want to spend you know lots and lots of time with just a couple individuals. So if we can't make that flow expeditiously then we'll probably try something
else. Representative Lundstrom. Do we need to limit debate? Well, let's see how it goes first and then if we need to, we will. But if the people can just say their piece and understand if the person before you said it, we've heard it. So everything needs to be said but everyone doesn't need to say it. I heard that from a wise former minority leader. So we've got speaking against the Bill first. Mr. Tim Grooms, is that correct? That is correct, Mr. Chairman. So if you would introduce yourself and who you're with, you'll recognize to speak against the bill. Thank you very much, sir. My name
is Tim Grooms. I'm the lawyer for the Arkansas Realtors Association, and I apologize in advance for a little bit of a weakened voice. I spent Friday, Saturday, and Sunday cheering our Razorbacks, and I still think we beat Kentucky, but somebody told me I was wrong, so I apologize for a little lack of a voice. It is my honor and it's a privilege and I very much appreciate the opportunity to speak for the Realtors Association against this legislation. I agree completely with Representative Letting and Professor Foster when they said that the overwhelming number of landlords
do things the right way. And thus I guess the question is do we need a bill and could the bill have any negative repercussions and we want to look at that. I also want to address Mr. Warren's situation which though tragic what happened to his daughter, and we're all sympathetic to that. Arkansas has long had a cause of action called constructive eviction. We've had a lot. If your property is unlivable, you have a constructive eviction cause of action, and you can, in fact, get out from under the lease. And furthermore, I guess one of the shining things that the Arkansas Realtor Association has done,
you have before you the landlord-tenant handbook that if you like it, then one of my partners drafted it. If you like it, I drafted it. If you don't, then somebody else did. But we've worked very, very hard. Hundreds of people have had input into that landlord-tenant handbook. And you'll see that one of the things that's been a shining example of the Realtor Association is education. And we want people to get leases in writing, to read the lease. And if they don't understand the lease, go get legal advice on that so that they don't get trapped into a situation like Mr. Warren's daughter did.
But again, even if you do get trapped, we have constructive eviction in Arkansas that gets you out of that situation. For the Arkansas Realtors Association, our issues were this. If we pass this bill, is this going to have a positive effect on rental housing in Arkansas? If you pass the bill, could it lead to an increase in rents? And if you pass the bill, could it have a negative impact on housing supply in the state of Arkansas? And you've got to really, I think, consider the answers to those questions as we go forward on this bill.
As Professor Foster told you, we've passed out the 2014 study for the National Housing Coalition, and I'm incredibly proud to live in a state that we have the most affordable two-bedroom housing in the United States. Only Puerto Rico has less expensive two-bedroom housing than Arkansas. I believe Arkansas tenants really care about what their rents are. And if we had a room full of Arkansas tenants and you told them there's a bill that's going to pass, that really we've heard the overwhelming number of landlords, it's probably not going to impact,
but it could result in increasing your rent. I have a feeling we'd have an overwhelming rush to oppose this bill from tenants. With respect to Professor Foster, she wrote a 2013 Law Review article in the UALR Law Review, and she noted that there were not a lot of studies on this, but the most recent study she could find was a 2011 DePaul University Law Review student comment which concluded, and I'll quote it, to the extent that this comment attempts to determine whether or not the implied warranty is related to higher rent rates,
the conclusion appears affirmative. That's in Professor Foster's Law Review article that she wrote. We think that if this bill passes, we'll have increased litigation expenses, and we think we'll have increased insurance premiums. I think you'll hear some testimony about that in a few minutes. Those expenses are going to get passed along to tenants in the form of increased rents or you're going to have some fixed rate properties as opposed to a market rent property, a fixed rate property such as Section 202, Section 8, Section 42 low-income housing
for the elderly and the low-income Arkansans that if they can't pass those expenses through, you could have those properties suffer financial distress, you could lose those properties, and you could certainly remove the incentive for people to develop those properties for the elderly and the low-income housing Arkansans in the future. And that scares the Arkansas Realtors Association to death. You're going to hear today from the Arkansas Affordable Housing Association. You're going to hear from the Arkansas Bankers Association. These people invest, these institutions in your communities invest in housing and rental housing, and they're
very concerned what happens if expenses go up. What does that do to the quality of their loans, and what does that do to their desire to make additional loans for rental housing in Arkansas in the future? Will this make housing better in Arkansas? I believe Professor Foster said, and we have no reason to doubt her research statistics. I have the utmost respect for Professor Foster. She said Arkansas is the only state that doesn't have a warranty of habitability. So I guess that means Tennessee has one, and thus guess Memphis has no substandard housing. I was in Nashville over the weekend. Let me absolutely
assure you, Memphis, Nashville has substandard housing. What about New York City, Detroit? I don't believe this. Now, now, Detroit's not that bad. I understand. I understand. The Arkansas Realtors Association thinks there's better ways for us to attack. There are certainly some bad landlords. No question about that. There are bad tenants. There are bad landlords. But we think the better way to address that is let's all work together to come up with housing codes, adopt it at a local level with local input.
Let's work to see how we fund and make better enforcement of housing codes to weed out those bad landlords. Boots on the ground with regard to weeding out bad housing and bad landlords has and always will be the best way to address that problem. Just a couple of few things to talk about the bill. If you look at page 1, line 30, you'll see that the bill says that a landlord shall ensure that the premises and all common areas are, quote, safe, end quote.
What does safe mean? Does that mean, for example, if someone busts into apartment complex and shoots people, does that make the landlord liable? There was a court in the District of Columbia that held just that fact. Mr. Grooms, excuse me, I'm just trying to get a bead. In other words,
one of the points I made a few moments ago was we have lots and lots and lots and lots of people to speak, and so I just want to make sure that we're going to give folks a chance to say their piece. So if you could kind of, you know, just
hit some highlights and close so we can get some other folks a chance, it would be greatly appreciated. And if we miss a critical point that's not made by someone else, I'm open to you coming and seeing me and saying, hey, this point wasn't made. Does that sound fair? Yes,
sir. Thank you. Thank you. That's the nicest way I've ever been asked to speed up in my whole life. I appreciate that. You're welcome. Page 3, line 24 of the bill requires a landlord to deliver a writing to disclose all defects in the premises. What if you're an out-of-state landlord?
We have a lot of properties in Arkansas that provide quality housing for tenants, and these people are not even in Arkansas. What if you don't know about a defect? Do you pick up liability? We don't have a requirement in Arkansas that you make a disclosure when you buy property. And now we're going to create one when you rent a property. We disagree with the proponents of the bill about tort liability. There is a section of the bill that says they will not expand tort liability. But then they refer to 1816-110, and 1816-110 just quickly says that a landlord doesn't have responsibility for a defect in the property
unless there is an agreement for a duty to maintain and repair. Well, they're asking you to pass a duty to maintain and repair, which wipes out the protection of 1816-110 and leaves landlords exposed to criminal acts liability, to slip and fall liability that they don't have today. The result of that is going to be, it's going to be an increase in premiums. It at least creates an ambiguity in the law that's going to lead to litigation, and it's going to lead to increased litigation expenses, increased premiums,
and that will get passed through to Arkansas tenants. We hear about the landlord-tenant laws in Arkansas. I'm proud to tell you that 20 years ago, this General Assembly passed fair housing laws, the ultimate protection for tenants. It protects tenants from discrimination, and we went beyond that and protected borrowers from fair lending liability. We have lots of protections in Arkansas. We heard about Mr. Warren and his lease provision. Arkansas has a provision of the UCC, 4-2-302, that makes an unconscionable lease provision void.
I want to close and just tell you, we don't think this bill will improve the quality of rental housing. We think this bill will result in increased liability, both in tort and for the acts of criminals. We believe that it will lead to increased rent for our Kansans and will reduce the supply of rental housing. And for those reasons, we are proud to tell you that the Ernst & Realtor Association vigorously opposes House Bill 1486. Thank you
very much, Mr. Groom. Representative Love, you're recognized for a motion.
minutes total, so 10 minutes on each side? Correct. Okay. We've got a motion on the table to limit debate to 20 minutes total, 10 minutes on each side. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Okay, we'll start the 10-minute calendar for each side. Quincy Ross, you are recognized to speak for the bill. Actually, I had a question on something. Oh, I'm sorry. Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. Thank you.
This does not count against the time for and after if you're going
to start a question now. I had a question for the gentleman. Sir, I didn't get your name. I'm sorry, Tim Grooms. Mr. Grooms, earlier in your testimony, you said that you did agree with Mr. Letting in regards to most of your landlords are in compliance, correct? Yes, sir. I'm just trying to understand. If most of the landlords are in compliance with what Mr. Letting is trying to pass, how would that figure into a price increase?
because the law creates a potential liability in tort and for criminal acts that's going to lead to insurance premiums increasing, and those insurance costs have to either be eaten by the landlord or passed along to the tenant. Okay. All right. Thank
you. All right. Barbara, are you going to be our timer? Oh, you've got timers right there? Okay, good. We've got fancy timers. I love this. Quincy Ross, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
Speaker 137
52:01
Mr. Chair, I am Quincy Ross. I was wondering, is it possible for me to pass until after Ms. Amy Bradley-Hole speaks?
So as long as Stacy Fletcher and Jamie are comfortable with Amy Bradley speaking next, I'm comfortable with it.
I'm Stacy Fletcher and I'm comfortable with it okay and then Jason whoever mr. Jason if you just shake your head we're good okay miss Amy Bradley hole you recognize to speak for HP 1486 it's okay I'd like to bring my husband with
name and and who you're with we are actually just representing ourselves yes
and in tenants across the state of Arkansas I'll make the beginning of our story brief we moved here in 2008 Arkansas for my husband's job we moved away from Florida we were homeowners in Florida but that was when the market bottomed out we were not able to sell our home in Florida so we became tenants here in Arkansas. We had a couple of really lousy experiences with landlords and houses here in Arkansas. So within two years, we were looking for our third rental home. And as we search for this home, we wanted to be smarter than we had been. We thought it would be great if we went to a reputable realty
company who did property management for a living and found a property through them. We did we found a great home in a really nice neighborhood in West Little Rock. We signed the lease assuming that by paying the rent and taking care of our property, we'd be able to enjoy many months in a well managed and comfortable home. In fact, the property management company's website states we want to grow with owners who believe in the covenant to provide a safe and healthy place to live and in return to be occupied by those who will pay timely and take care of the property. We had some initial troubles. We had an oven
that broke over the Thanksgiving holidays, took them longer than two weeks to fix the oven. But hey, in the grand scheme of things, not having an oven is not that big a deal to me. I'd prefer not to have to cook every night anyway. But then in the beginning of 2012 the ground floor of our house flooded after a prolonged period of rain. We call the property management company immediately as a homeowner myself I know how damaging a flood can be and how the home is not properly cleaned and water damage taken care of very serious issues can arise. If it were my home I would have wanted the problem to be taken care
of as soon as possible. But it wasn't. It took a few days for someone to come around and inspect the flooding and to our amazement no serious repairs were made. No real effort was made to clean the water damage. They brought us an instruction, an extraction fan and just told us to run it every once in a while. When I expressed concern about possible mold in the carpet, they pulled up a corner of a glance at it and said it would be just fine. Over the next few weeks, the rain kept falling and the house kept flooding. Numerous times we call the company to say the water was soaking the ground floor and they never did anything to stop it. By this point, our furniture had been damaged from
constantly resting on soggy carpet. As winter turned to spring and temperatures rose the damp was oppressive and the smell was disgusting I became worried about my kids health I knew living in those conditions which were ideal for the spread of harmful molds and other microorganisms could be harmful to us yet still no real attempt was made to stop the flooding or clean up from the water damage we were paying two thousand dollars in rent each month to live in a disgusting and gross home excuse me ma'am could you please make sure you speak in mic oh sorry the safe and healthy
conditions that were mentioned on the real estate company's website were nowhere to be found and the worst part we were helpless to do a thing about it as tenants in Arkansas we had absolutely no rights in this situation we cannot make the repairs ourselves we cannot stop paying rent and because we still had time left before our lease ran out we cannot even move without incurring great expenses all we could do was wait till the lease was up and then get out as quickly as possible in fact we ended up renting a new house before our lease was over so that we could get out of there a little more quickly. For a short period of time, we had to pay rent on two homes. Doing so was cheaper than breaking our lease, losing our
security deposit, or having to hire an attorney. And we feared that if we did break the lease, the landlord would give us a bad reference when we tried to rent in the future, or even worse, make a report that would negatively impact our credit score. We are very blessed to be able to afford that on top of all the other expenses and inconveniences of moving. Most families are not lucky enough to be able to afford that. To this day, I don't know who was responsible for the neglect. I don't know if it was the management company cutting corners or the landlord just not wanting to make repairs. All I know is it was wrong, and my family should not have been the
ones to pay the price for other people's wrongdoings. And I want to speak here really quickly to the comments and the questions about competition. I want to tell you that there is no competition for rental properties in this state. The rental market here is very, very, very tight, even in Little Rock. If you need to live within a certain proximity of your employment or a bus route, you don't have options. If you need to live within a certain school district because of your kids, you don't have options. If you need a house of a certain size because you have a larger family, you don't have options. I look at rental properties all the time because we're constantly kind of
keeping our eye out for if and when we have to move. There is not much out there. To be clear, I'm not wholly unsympathetic to the concerns of landlords. Remember how I said we couldn't sell our house in Florida? Because of that, we too became landlords. We hired a property management company ourselves and turned our home into a rental property in order to offset costs. The markets were not on our side, though. The amount of rent we charged only covered a small portion of our house note. Between making both the mortgage payment in Florida and the rent payment in Arkansas each month, our savings were depleted. One day we looked at our finances and
realized that if the house in Florida ever needed significant repairs, we cannot afford them. Because we have morals, we knew that we could not, in good conscience, have tenants in that house. So when our renters lease ran out, we stopped being landlords after about five years of being without tenants We can no longer make house payments and we were foreclosed on This has caused great hardship and difficulty for our family and sometimes I wonder if we'll ever financially recover But despite that, I know we did the right thing We'd never been able to live with ourselves if we had become slumlords refused to give our tenants a decent place to live Neither our values nor Florida laws would have allowed that
So to those landlords who complain that owning a rental property can be costly and that repairs can be prohibitively expensive, I say, too bad. If you can't afford to be a landlord, then you have one option. Don't be a landlord. If your personal financial solvency or the survival of your real estate company depends on your refusing to provide your tenants a habitable home, then you're in the wrong line of work. This is why we support House Bill 1486. I want to make sure you understand what this bill does not do. It does not require tenant landlords to provide luxury accommodations or unnecessary repairs.
It does not allow tenants to sue landlords in any occasion. It doesn't demand that landlords make repairs immediately or even in a really timely manner. It doesn't force landlords to repair damage caused by the negligence of the tenants themselves. It doesn't give tenants the right to offset or withhold rent payments. It doesn't make it harder to evict bad tenants. It doesn't force landlords to help with moving expenses for wrongfully displaced tenants as it does in some other states. And this bill, while it would finally make us the very last state in the nation to provide minimum habitability standards,
it does not bring the Arkansas landlord-tenant laws on par with other states' laws. It doesn't even begin to level the playing field for landlords and tenants. And in my opinion, it really doesn't go far enough to protect tenants' rights. But it's all we have, and
Speaker 149
59:54
we'll take it right now. Here's what the bill does do. Let me make a point. You only have ten minutes totally for the four, and you've taken about seven. So we have three minutes left. So for those of you that have deferred to the speaker, just understand the time frames.
Okay. You may continue. All the bill does is ensure that things like running water and electricity and a door that locks and a way to escape your bedroom in case of a fire are not luxuries that are only reserved for homeowners. It allows people, whether they are paying $2,000 or $200 in rent, the ability to move if they find themselves in a situation that is unsafe or dangerous or unhealthy. No ethical realtor should have a problem with that. No reasonable landlord should have a problem with that. And no decent human being should have a problem with that.
This is why we urge you to do pass this bill and
let it proceed. Thank you for your time. Thank you very much, Ms. Bradley-Hole. Any questions for Ms. Bradley-Hole? Seeing none, Representative Kerr, you recognize to speak against the bill. Excuse me. Commissioner Kerr. Old habits die hard. Thank you,
If you could just introduce yourself and
your position for me, please. Yes. As a reminder, I am Alan Kerr, Insurance Commissioner for the State of Arkansas. um listen to the uh the testimony um i am insurance commissioner but uh probably more so in this particular case i'm a insurance agent for 35 years in the state of arkansas in central arkansas and uh i've i've dealt with uh insureds on both sides the tenants and the landlords. The person that testified alluded to his daughter who had an apartment, a college
student. I have a college student in Conway. She brought me a lease to look at, and this particular lease had written in it that even under circumstances where the tenant died, the rent was still due, okay? I didn't let her sign that lease, pure and simple. There are a lot of different contracts out there. You have to be careful what you sign. If you are in a situation where the landlord isn't cooperating, there are remedies for that. It's a court system,
and you can take that landlord to court. Bottom line is this bill is going to create a situation where premiums go up. We're very uncomfortable with a contract that allows a tenant to withhold rent because they think something isn't being fixed. That's very much like withholding child support because you don't think you're getting enough time with your child.
Very similar situations. The landlord may need that money to make the repairs. So you're going to have an impasse there. All in all, we're very uncomfortable with the bill, and I'm going to stop right there and let someone else testify. Any questions for
Commissioner Kerr? Seeing none, Mrs. Johnson, would you like to speak for the bill? Okay, so there's about two minutes left to speak for the bill.
I'm just going to go down the list. Randy Thompson, Ron Copeland, Quincy Ross, Stacey Fletcher, and Jason were the other, and I guess Lynn Foster, were the folks that had wanted to speak for the bill. If you want to decide how to use your final two minutes and whoever you'd like to have go to the end of the table. I'm happy to defer
when Randy gets here. I just want to very quickly in my Chicago accent say two things to you.
So, ma'am, if you could tell me your name again. Or Lynn Foster. Lynn Foster, okay. And you're going to speak for the bill? Yes, sir. All right. You recognize to speak for the bill, and then we're going to go to someone to speak against the bill. If there's any time limit, the other gentleman can come. But the way this works is it's one person speaking for the bill, not two. Okay. At this point, how much time do I have? There's about two minutes, a minute and 30 seconds, a minute and 33 seconds
are left on the four side. Okay. Four, one thing.
Tort, it was not our intent at all to expand landlord tort liability. We're happy to amend the bill to change that. That was never, ever our intent. Two, housing codes. If housing codes worked, they were introduced in the 19th century, states wouldn't have implied warranties of habitability today. They just aren't effective and they don't work in Little Rock. We have a Department of Code Enforcement. It's terrible, not their problem or not their fault. They have no staff. They're months behind.
I'm sorry, sir, if that's the for, then now we're going to go to the against. And so the next person to speak against the bill is Danielle Nall. Is Danielle Nall here? Danielle, you're recognized to
speak against the bill. Thank you Mr. Chairman. My name is Danielle Nall. I am here today representing the Affordable Housing Association of Arkansas in opposition of House Bill 1486. The association consists of over
80 members representing over 12,000 units of affordable housing throughout the state. Our association is dedicated to the enhancement of multifamily housing through the promotion of professionalism and apartment management with the ultimate goal to provide quality, affordable housing for the elderly and low-income residents of Arkansas. And I'm not going to repeat what already has been said on this particular topic, but I do want to point out that for the Affordable Housing Association and those affordable housing landowners, we don't have the opportunity to
increase rents when these expenses go up. The expenses, the rents are already capped by HUD or the affordable housing industry, so they're limited, and when you can't make your cover those expenses, then those owners, if this law passes due to the increase in expenses from apartment turns due to bad tenants, because there are plenty of bad tenants out there and we deal with them on a daily basis, that use this legislation as ammunition to try to get out of leases without having any consequences, the apartment turns will increase and then
and it opens up another realm for litigation and court costs for many of the definitions that are left open and will have to be determined by the court. When those expenses are incurred, the affordable housing developments can't absorb those additional costs. If the operating expenses increase on the affordable properties, more than likely the landlords will eventually default on their loans and the property will be foreclosed, resulting in less affordable housing for the elderly and low-income citizens of Arkansas, and I don't think that's what the industry needs. increases in operating expenses will also have a chilling effect on the construction of future
affordable housing. If the expenses do not work with the allowable rents, developments will not be built. It's as simple as that. It's a delicate balance. I have several examples of what the ambiguities we feel like are in the bill, but I think most of those have already been addressed. So on behalf of the association, the proposed bill we fear will cause more harm than it will good. The legislation can be improved with clear definitions and a focus on targeting those bad landlords. We don't need to pass something that we've already have said over and over again that
it doesn't affect, it only affects the really bad landlords. Well, all the good landlords are going to be affected as well because those tenants are going to be able to use this legislation just like the tenants that might actually need it, but they'll use it to their advantage. So as drafted, the bill could have far-reaching negative effects on both good tenants and good landlords, resulting in less affordable housing for those tenants that need it most. Considering this, the Affordable Housing Association of Arkansas asks you to please vote no on the House Bill 1486.
Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Nall. Are there any questions for Danielle? No. Seeing none, Randy Thompson, would you like to speak for the bill? There
Speaker 174
1:08:35
are about 57 seconds left on the foreside. So much for my prepared speech. I'll just hit a couple of highlights. This bill is supported by the Landlord Association, which is the Rental Managers Association. I'm actually an out-of-state person.
I was born here in Arkansas, grew up here in Arkansas, graduated high school and college here in Arkansas, but live in Florida now, and I am a licensed real estate person there. I invest primarily here in Arkansas because of the investment advantages here. But I will also tell you that at this point, I also know of several out-of-state investors, California, East Coast investors that are moving into Arkansas because there is no minimum standards. And that is the primary reason they are here.
They flat out told me that. What this bill does is provides and goes for a minimum standard for the low-end landlords. It does not really affect the normal, everyday landlords. So we've hit the time limit, so if you could wrap up, that would
Speaker 174
1:09:40
support this bill because what it does is it helps the low end of our population here, and our landlord association does support it. we're trying to police ourselves and we ask you to help us support policing ourselves
thank you. Thank you very much on the against side there's still about five minutes left and the next person on our list is Cliff Hickening I apologize that I didn't do good with the name and then after that is Robin Quick and Ava Frank so those are the last three on the against side and there's about five minutes left Ms. Franks if they would like you to go next. That sounds fine with me. So you're recognized to speak against the bill. Please
introduce yourself and who you're with. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Ava Franks, and I represent the Arkansas Bankers Association. The bankers are proud to make investments all over Arkansas, especially for our housing situations. This bill creates too much liability for landlords, and that liability feeds back to the investor. If this bill passes, investors will have to take into account these new liabilities when assessing risk to determine if they can lend
the money or not, and may even be forced to review existing loans. If this bill does result in legal fees and increased premium for landlords, which it certainly looks like it will, that will impact bankers' ability to make the loans, which will impact affordable housing prices for Arkansans. and I am trying to keep myself very brief, so I'm ready for questions, but I did want to add a personal antidote. I did rent an apartment. It did flood, numerous apartments. One in particular did flood due to faulty pipes, and my landlord was wonderful.
He helped me out tremendously. Are there any questions for Ms. Franks? Seeing none, would Cliff like to speak against the bill? Cliff, if you would introduce yourself and who you're with, do you recognize and speak against the bill? My name is Cliff
McKinney, and I'm an attorney at Quattlebaum Grooms, and I'm here on behalf of the Arkansas Realtors Association. And what I'm here to do is express three specific concerns that this bill does not adequately address.
And I'm not saying that fixing these three concerns fixes all concerns, or that these are the only concerns, but I think these are three that are particularly of note. The first one is this bill requires the property to be, quote, safe. And this exact language is used in a number of states. And some states have interpreted safe to mean protecting against intervening criminal acts. In other words, someone breaking in and doing something horrible on the property. Other states have not interpreted that way. This bill does not make clear what the responsibility in Arkansas would be
for protecting against intervening third-party criminal acts. And it would be easy to add something that's specifically said, in no event shall a landlord be responsible for intervening criminal acts. But it doesn't have that, and it creates an ambiguity the courts will have to fix. The next problem I want to point out is the one-off situation. This bill seems to be aimed at the professional landlord, but what about the person who has a house that they're leasing while they're trying to rent it? And we actually heard on the foreside someone describing that exact scenario,
and they opted to take the property off the market, but there are many people who could not while they're leasing it while they're trying to sell it. Or what about someone leasing a condo for the summer or just simply leasing one house that is not a professional? This adds a great deal of additional burdens to that individual, and it's a very common situation in Arkansas. And then the third one I want to point out is the situation of what's known as an installment land sales contract. An installment land sales contract is an alternative to a mortgage that is used frequently in Arkansas,
and a great deal of property is sold in this state that manner. And the way that an installment land sales contract works is the buyer pays premium or pays a monthly amount in exchange for eventually getting to own the house, say, after 20 years. But they always have a provision that say if there's a default, in lieu of a foreclosure, it's deemed to be rent. and it's deemed to be a lease. Well, what happens in this situation? Is there an implied warranty in the situation before there's a default
but not after or vice versa? It's just simply not clear. And since this is such a common financing mechanism in Arkansas, it's concerning that that issue is not addressed. So those are three specific points I want to make. And with that,
I'll open to any questions. Thank you, Rich. Are there any questions? If not, the final against speaker is Robin Quick, and you have about one minute. Mr. Chairman,
committee, thank you for allowing me to speak here today.
My name is Robin Quick. I am employed by Rector Phillips Morris, RPM Property Management. I've been in the property management industry for 25 years, So I'm not going to talk about anything that's new. Unfortunately, everyone before me pretty much touched on the same concerns that I had. So I think what I would really like to do in my less than 60 seconds is to just reiterate that we have 15 seconds.
15 seconds. We have a stable, consistent set of laws that are understood by the landlords, the tenants, the lenders, and the insurers. This bill should not pass. Thank you for your time. Yes,
ma'am. Are there any questions for our speaker? All right, seeing none, Representative Letting, would you like to close for your bill?
Representative Letting, you're recognized to close for your bill. Thank
you, Mr. Judge. I believe time did expire on the fourth side, though. Are you still going to grant me? I'm just
trying to be fair. That was for the public to speak for and against. You still get to close for you. I would not take
Speaker 65
1:16:11
that away from a committee member. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll just be very brief. We've heard a
lot from both sides. A third of Arkansans, 983,000 of them, rent their home. I think they deserve to know that they're renting a habitable home. And I would appreciate, though I certainly do not expect, a good vote.
Thank you. Representative Letting has closed for his bill. What's the will of the committee? Move do pass. We have a do pass. Motion on the table. Is there any discussion? Seeing none. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? Nay. The nays have it. Thank you very much, Representative Letting. I'm sorry your bill has not passed. Thank you, committee. All right, the next bill on our list is SB 645.
Is Senator Hendren here or Representative? That's Representative Talley. You're recognized to present Senate Bill 645. Representative Talley, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Committee. Today
I bring before you Senate Bill 645, which is drafted to address two important topics as utilities are looking ahead to ensure adequate electrical generation capabilities and are available to meet the needs of their customers.
The first thing this bill does, which many of you are co-sponsors of, it adds language to clarify that public utilities may require properties constituting an operating unit, including property owned by the public utilities affiliates or other entities. The second thing this bill does, it adds language to clarify that an exemption claim by a public utility does not bar the utility from seeking the issuance of a Certificate of Public Convenience or Necessity or CCN, nor shall the exemption bar the Public Service Commission from granting the CCN, thereby allowing the public utility to seek recovery of the reasonable cost of the equipment or facilities through rates.
This bill was approved through the Senate unanimously, came out of the Senate with no opposition. The PSC has reviewed this bill and believes it already has its authority, but this is clarifying language on that. We certainly appreciate a good vote. Are there any questions for Representative Talley? Seeing
none, is there anybody that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Talley, are you closed for your bill? Yes, and move do pass, please. We have a due pass motion on the table. Any discussion?
Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Talley. You've passed the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Committee. The next bill on our calendar is SB 727. Senator Rice or his, Representative Bain, you're recognized to present SB 727. I understand we have an amendment. So Carol's in the process of loading the amendment now. So, members, that should be showing up on your screens. But Representative Bain, if you would like to begin presenting your amendment to SB 727.
Thank you, Chairman, committee. Yes, the amendment to SB 727 is an agreement between rate payors and rate payees working to streamline Act 310 of 1981, which actually deals with the regulatory process involved with public utilities to recover government-mandated investments. and basically those interim rate surcharges that we're all familiar with. So this amendment will resolve all concerns that we have between the rate payees and rate payors,
and this has been an ongoing process now for several weeks, and we feel that this is a fair and equitable position for all parties.
Is the amendment showing up, members, on your screens? Okay, so everybody can see the amendment. Are there any questions for members for Representative Bain on the amendment? Representative, seeing none, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the amendment, for the amendment? Representative Bain, you close for your amendment? I close, and I
We have a do pass motion on the amendment. All in favor? Any opposed? All right, the amendment has passed. Representative Bain, you recognize
to present the bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Again, this bill is essentially a modernization piece for Act 310, of 1981, which will allow us, will allow those who are engaged in the business to, when they need to go ahead and do certain things under existing environmental rules and regulations. We're not talking about 111D changes under the carbon changes. That is not included in this
piece. This is basically making sure that as costs are incurred that are obligated, that they can be recovered within a reasonable time without having to go through a rate case procedure. I've also got representatives from Synergy and AEP Swepco if you'd like to have anybody answering specific questions about the changes. Are there any questions from the
committee? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill. Seeing none.
Representative Bain, are you closed for your bill? I am closed and I appreciate it. Do pass. Representative Love, you're recognized for a motion. Motion. Do pass. We have a do pass as amended motion. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. You've passed the bill as amended. Thank you, committee. Thank you, chairman. The next bill on our calendar is Senate Bill 821.
We don't have the amendment here yet? Okay, so we're going to pass over 8-2-1 because we need an amendment that hasn't arrived yet. The next bill on the calendar is Senate Bill 8-2-2. Senator Hendren or his representative? I don't see anybody raising their hand for that one. The next bill on the calendar is 8-2-6. Senator Hendren or his representative? I don't see anyone for that one. Representative House Bill 16-38. You're recognized to present 16-38.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Didn't realize it would be back down here so soon. This bill essentially, we had a concern with local industry about some of the fire code issues. We basically got two different national and international fire codes. The state fire marshal was here earlier. He's still here. He'd be born happy to answer any questions about this. This would allow the 2010 American with Disabilities Act fire code to be the presumptive fire code that we use when we're doing building construction and design. I've had some concerns from industry as they start doing build
outs and expansions, and they're seeing some added costs from one fire code to the other. We're trying to make sure that everything is cost effective and cost efficient as we promote continued development here in Arkansas. I will also say that this bill has been amended with a state fire marshal amendment. We took it in full because we thought it was a wonderful idea, And the bill has already been engrossed, amended and engrossed. And at this point, I'd be happy to take any questions. Members,
are there any questions for Representative Bain?
Seeing none, is there anyone to speak against the bill? Oh, excuse me. Representative Jett, did you have a question for Representative Bain? Yes, sir. Thank you. Do you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr.
Chair. I think you answered my question, Representative Bain. Lindsay, Farm Marshall folks are on board with this. They are here, and they'd be
happy to testify if necessary. But, yes, they actually provided an amendment. We
Speaker 198
1:23:59
took it in full. We thought it was a great amendment. You just shake your head yes. Thank you. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Yes. All right, is there anyone to speak against the bill, for the bill?
Seeing none, Representative Bain, are you closed
a motion to do pass. We have a do pass motion on House Bill 1638. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Bain. You've passed your bill. The next bill on our calendar is Senate Bill 726. Is Senator Files or a representative here for... Representative Murdoch, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 726, and I understand you have an amendment,
so you'll be recognized to present the amendment. And we also have a handout going around. Thank you.
You recognize Representative Murdoch. Thank you, Chairman.
Is the amendment showing up on your screens, committee members? Amendment showing up on folks' screens for Senate Bill 726. Do you recognize or
Speaker 149
1:25:45
explain the amendment? The amendment just simply excludes those that deal with the oil and gas exploration. They're being excluded from the bill.
Representative Murdoch has explained the amendment. Are there any questions on the amendment? Seeing none, does anyone would like to speak against the amendment, for the amendment? Representative Murdoch, are you closed for your amendment? I'm closed. Representative Love, you recognize for a motion? We have a motion to adopt the amendment. All in favor? Any opposed? The amendment is adopted. Representative Murdoch, you recognize to present SB 726 as amended. Thank you, Chairman and Committee.
Speaker 149
1:26:26
This bill simply is an act to promote fair and equitable allocation of liability in construction contracts. Current indemnification laws in Arkansas are placing contractors and subcontractors, the indemnitor, in a position where they are required to assume risk and liability in a construction contract for which the indemnitor is oftentimes not responsible or liable. We think it is the right thing for each party to be responsible for their own liability. So what this bill simply does is limits the liability to those that have caused the problem in a particular fault cause.
So we just want to make sure that we properly assess that. If you notice real quickly, there is a map that is part of the handout, and it shows you the states that have the limited form of indemnification. we currently have the intermediate form and we're trying to go to the limited form so that we can protect those Representative
Murdoch has explained the bill are there any questions for Representative Murdoch? my understanding is we have someone that would like to speak against the bill
and also a handout and so there's a handout coming around from the gentleman that would like to speak against the bill Michael D. Michael Parker. So, Michael Parker, you're recognized to speak against the bill. Please go to the end of the table and introduce yourself and who you're with.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Michael Parker. I'm an attorney here in Little Rock with the Dover-Dixon-Horne Law Firm. I'm also a tax counsel for Associated Industries of Arkansas, and I'm here speaking on behalf of Associated Industries of Arkansas in opposition to the bill. Briefly speaking, we view this not as an issue of indemnification, but as an insurance industry protection bill. the Associated Industries of Arkansas opposed this bill in the previous session and it still opposes this bill in this session
the reason for it does not relate to indemnification this deals with construction contracts the issue is whether in an industrial context if a contractor comes on site there are contracts that require that the contractor indemnify the industry for any injuries that occur to their folks while they're on the site and also oftentimes to provide insurance that carries something called additional insured coverage.
Now, the reason for this is because when a worker is injured on site and works for a subcontractor, contractor, then the subcontractor insures that under workers' compensation. That limits the exposure of the employer. However, it is customary, it's in many, many instances, that the injured worker then brings a lawsuit against the industry under theories like unsafe workplace.
In the absence of a provision like this, you have the insurance, the contractor's insurance company representing the, trying to minimize the contractor's exposure, and the industry company representing it and trying to minimize its exposure, in so far as percentages of liability. The problem with that is it leads to long, drawn-out litigation and controversy. It takes up a lot of man hours and dealing with it, things of that nature. The industry
has responded to that by requiring that the contractors that come on site under their insurance policy indemnify the industry regardless of who the loss is. It centralizes the risk, the loss, in the contractor's insurance company. So the contractor's insurance company, through the additional insured coverage, insures all the parties. It minimizes the controversy, the settlements proceed, and it is viewed as a savings clause. Now, you've seen two handouts.
One has to do with the general trend of what we call anti-indemnification coverage. Anti-indemnification coverage says that you cannot require a contractor personally to indemnify the industry for any percentage that might be attributed to this unsafe workplace-type controversy. It limits the contractor's liability. But, you know, in the industrial context, it's not about the contractor's liability. It's about the insurance company backing it up.
So the chart that, the black and white chart that's been passed out to you shows that notwithstanding the fact that anti-indemnification coverage is close to 50-50, I guess, 25 states or 26 states have prohibited anti-indemnification clauses in contracts, which we don't really support either because it limits the right to contract. But that's not, as I say, what the issue is really about. It's about the insurance coverage. A much smaller number of states have prohibited additional insured coverages
in the manner that this bill does. So we believe this bill is an extreme measure. The states that do prohibit, and you'll see this is the last column in the chart, additional insured coverage not allowed. That's what we're trying to move Arkansas into. The states that do that are shown with the white dots. So there are about 10 states that have prohibited that. But most of the states, even those states that prohibit additional the anti-identification, have the anti-identification provisions, specifically permit the insurance coverages.
So, and that's most of the states here shown with the diagonal lines. So the distinction here is between the states with the white dots, a distinct minority of states that actually prohibit the additional insured coverages and the states that have the horizontal lines that are the diagonal lines that permit insurance requirements. So the primary issue here is whether or not Arkansas should prohibit industries with the thousands of jobs that we provide in the Arkansas marketplace from requiring centralized risk in insurance companies and in insurance contracts carried by their subcontractors when they come on site.
I'll be happy to answer any questions. Are there any questions for members?
Representative Love, you're going to ask for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And maybe I should have asked Representative Murdoch, but now that I see Commissioner Kerr here, is what's the insurance commissioner
stands on this bill? Commissioner Kerr, you're recognized to come to the end of the table and
answer the question. Alan Kerr, Arkansas Insurance Commissioner. We have reviewed the bill and find it's a good bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Commissioner Kerr. All right, so we've got lots of people to speak up that have signed up to speak for and against. So what I'd like to do is move that we limit debate to eight minutes per side. So there's a motion on the table to limit debate to eight minutes per side. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Okay, so we'll start the timer. Eight minutes per side. And the first person to speak for the bill is Rick Barrows.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee members. My name is Rick Barrows. I'm the president of Multicraft Contractors based in Springdale. We have just over 500 employees doing primarily industrial, mechanical, electrical, millwright, and fabrication services, and also connected to the new construction markets. I have been in the mechanical industry, the mechanical trades, for almost 50 years.
Our business has grown to last year we broke a million hours of labor for the first time. We have .62 as an experience modifier. We're a very safe company, and for us to keep all those people busy, we have to accept contracts, And many times this language is extremely unfair, and it makes it tough to sign. We believe that these other states have corrected this for the right reason,
and if it's fair there, it would be fair here as well. I would like to defer to Mr. Marty Clark at this point in time to better explain the insurance side
of the issue. Well, Mr. Burroughs, what we have is a list of for and against in order, and so what I want to do is give us a chance to go back and forth and say the name of the person you wanted to bring up. Mr. Marty Clark. Marty Clark is, I think Marty has signed up to speak for the bill, so when we get to the next four, if Mike Malone is willing to let Marty go next, then we could do that.
But right now what I'd like to do is recognize Courtney Little to speak against the bill. Courtney Little is for the bill alright is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill seeing none the next person on the list to speak for the bill is Mike Malone is Mike Malone here to speak for the bill Mike Malone you recognize to speak for the bill
and there are nine minutes remaining Thank you,
Mr. Chairman and committee members. My name is Mike Malone. I'm with Malone's Mechanical, a small business contractor that's been in business 40 years. And over the last 15 years, indemnification clauses have come up to where it's almost made it impossible for us to sign contracts to where it makes us held accountable for some other people's negligence.
And one thing I would like to, the map that y'all have right there, there are five states that border Arkansas right here that touch our borders. And all five of those states have limited form of indemnification. And I have went through and on the Internet, I took four of our opposition and looked at the locations in those five states. and they have 64 locations in those states that are currently under the limited form of indemnification.
And two of those states are Texas and Oklahoma, which mirror this language that's in this bill. And we had a contract one time that had over, it was over $5 million that had such language in it that we couldn't sign that it held us accountable, even though we may not have been at fault. And I'm just asking for a yes vote for SB 726 as fair for all contractors.
Members, are there any questions for Mr. Malone? Seeing none, Marty Clark, you're recognized to speak. Excuse me. Is there anyone who could speak against the bill? Seeing none, Marty Clark, you recognize, speak for the bill. Appreciate
the time. We'll make this quick. I know you guys are probably tired. My name is Marty Clark. I'm with Brownhiller Clark Insurance, president of that insurance agency in Fort Smith, Arkansas. We specialize in construction insurance. We see all sides of the issue, and essentially what is happening is that contractors are often forced to accept liability.
Through indemnification agreements, that liability is transferred down to a lower-tiered party To make it really quick, there's three types of indemnification, broad form, intermediate, and limited. Broad form is represented in red on there. That's very dangerous stuff. That's where somebody can transfer their sole negligence and make another party responsible for that. That's not allowed in Arkansas. Arkansas is an intermediate state, which means that as long as the lower-tiered contractor is at least 1% at fault, just any fault at all, he can be held to have to indemnify the remaining 99% of fault for that other party.
So it's a fairness issue. The lower tiered are always getting sort of the liability shoved down their way, and it's just certainly not a level playing field. It puts businesses like the guys that just testified at risk because oftentimes they don't have insurance that covers the obligations they're being held to contractually. So my point is it's a very fair issue. It's something very needed in Arkansas. Arkansas is behind the curve. As you can see from the states, the trend is certainly towards limited indemnification
to where everybody's responsible for their own negligence. And that's what we'd like to see and encourage you guys to support. Thank you
very much. Thank you. Is there anyone like to speak against the bill? Seeing none, Courtney Little, you're recognized to speak for the bill. And there are about five minutes or so
left. Good morning. My name is Courtney Little. I represent Ace Class here locally, and we also have an office in Northwest Arkansas. I'm also a licensed attorney in the state and represent a number of subcontractors,
contractors, architects, other people in the industry. I'm here today to be for this bill because as a subcontractor, we are forced to ensure a risk that is unknown to us. Not only do we have to ensure the percentage of liability that we may have in any incident, but we're also picking up responsibility for other parties. And as has been stated before, the doctrine of fairness is that we should be responsible for our own actions and not the actions of someone else. So not only do we pay an additional premium for ensuring that unknown risk,
but we also have to bear the burden of that later. So if an incident does occur, our rates go up, and we have to push that on. Sometimes it's made some subcontractors uninsurable due to actions of others, and that just doesn't seem fair to us. I'm also on the National ASA Board, and we're lucky in Arkansas. It's a pretty good market. People are pretty fair, but people are getting home with that. But nationally, the reason there's a movement to that is that more and more subcontractors are running into these contracts where they're being held liable or their insurance is having to pay for losses that were not caused by them.
So we're trying to bring Arkansas up to the median here. We're behind the times a little bit on this, And ultimately, it should be more cost effective for the owners because they can ensure this risk, this known risk, as a volume buyer and as a person who's, you know, taking care of that risk better than somebody, a subcontractor who is two tiers down having to ensure that unknown risk to the subcontractor who then has to pay, is paying more for the same risk assessment, then has to mark it up and then, you know, pass it on to a general contractor who then has to mark it up again.
So we feel like it's also better for the owner to control the documents on their own insurance, get it done the way they want it done, and pay the premium themselves
and control that product. Are there any questions from the committee members? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? Seeing none, the next person signed up to speak for the bill is, I'm going to brutalize the first name, Hay or Hex Bisbee. You are recognized to speak for the bill.
Speaker 221
1:42:52
and there are about three and a half minutes left. Mr. Chairman, committee, thank you very much. Most everything has already been said. I would like to add just a few additional elements. One, like any good thing, it can be taken too far and we are witnessing where manufacturers or industrial have taken this protection to the nth degree. In that specific example whereas we as a contractor may be found at 1% fault. The provisions, this case study, our employee was at a site. The employee
was injured by the manufacturer's party as they were operating a piece of equipment and hurt our employee. We as the employer took care of our employee. We paid their medical bills. We gave them light duty, got them back to work. However, the employee did seek legal protection against the industry later on. Unfortunately, this contract did exist, and the manufacturer asked us to assume responsibility a second time for the injury. We had already dealt with it and took care of it in the way we should have through workers' comp, and workers' comp should protect us as an employer
from having to deal with it a second time. Unfortunately, because of the contractual obligations that we were forced to sign to get this done, we had to deal with it a second time. So we are asking for this bill to be passed and approved to prevent us as the employer from being tackled a second time. The last element is just that, again, these manufacturers that are operating in Arkansas successfully are also operating successfully in our surrounding states with these provisions. Thank you.
All right, members. That was the last person signed up to speak for or against the bill, so I'm going to give one more opportunity. Does anyone like to speak against the bill? Would anyone like to speak for the bill? There's still a couple minutes left for that. Seeing none, Representative Murdoch, would you like to close for your bill? You're close for your bill? What's the will of the committee? Representative Love, you're recognized for a motion? Motion do pass as amended. We have a do pass as amended motion. Is there any discussion on the bill? If not, all in favor?
Aye. Any opposed? The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Murdoch. You've passed the bill as amended. And now, sir, I'd appreciate if you would come up and sit in the chair because the next bill on our list is House Bill 1655, which I'm going to present.
much, Mr. Chair. So this is House Bill 1655. The first thing we need to do is put an amendment on it. And the way I'd explain the amendment is by saying the bill itself is large and complex, and it involves lots of different groups. And lots of those different groups have come together to align on this bill.
including the Attorney General, the PSC, manufacturers, the utility folks. And so in order to get everybody to agree, the language needs to be very crisp and clear, and every word counts. So this is our final effort to get every word perfectly laid out in the bill, and so it's basically grammar in several different places to get that kind of closure. And with that, I'm happy to take any questions on the amendment.
Speaker 149
1:46:40
Okay, Representative Collins, I've explained his amendment. Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience to speak for the amendment? Against the amendment? Seeing none, what's the pleasure of the committee? We have a due pass on the amendment. We have a due pass on the amendment. All in favor? Those opposed?
Congratulations, your amendment is passed. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.
So this is a comprehensive bill to update the utility rate setting schematic. And this bill has been worked on for weeks and weeks and weeks. So what I'm just going to do is top line some of the key things that the bill helps us do because the last time there's been a significant upgrade was many years ago. So the first thing the bill does is moves to more of an annual review of costs and rates
versus an every three-year review. What we've tended to have in the past is data that's several years old, which then gets updated in a big, lumpy fashion, which can mean you have big rate increases and things of that nature. So what we're going to be doing instead with this new regime is looking at things annually. And there are limits to how much rates can go up. And it also will ensure that the investments that the utilities are making, that they're going to be able to get their expected and approved regulated rates of return.
The second thing it does is it puts in place what I'm going to call database decision making. and it's called evidentiary standards in the legal lingo, but what it basically means is when you're making your case with the regulators, they're going to be looking at data, data you bring to them, data that comes from other places, so we're going to be using data and evidence as an important part of the decision-making process.
However, it does not take away the authority of the regulator to make decisions as needed. The third thing that it does is it strikes what I'm going to call the optimal balance between economic development, job opportunity creation, and respecting the rates of our residential payers. And what this means is different rate payers in different classes, for example, a big manufacturing plant compared to a one-room apartment are going to have different needs
and have different impacts on the system. So this new approach balances in an optimal way the needs of ensuring that the lowest cost customers see that reflected in their rates, but at the same time we're being fair and maintaining residential and other ratepayer rates at low and reasonable amounts. So the good news here is I expect Arkansas to continue to have residential electricity rates
that are below the regional average and at the same time put ourselves in a position where we're going to be able to do a little bit better job at reflecting the efficiencies of some of these other rate payers at the same time. So this work that was done, and a lot of people spent a lot of time on it, have led to alignment across the board. So the governor's in favor of the legislation. The Arkansas Economic Developers Association supports it.
The State Chamber of Commerce supports it. The four investor-owned electric utilities, Swepco, Oklahoma Gas and Electric, Entergy Arkansas, Empire Electric District support it. the three investor-owned natural gas utilities, Centerpoint, Arkansas-Oklahoma Gas Source Gas, Arkansas Municipal Power Association, Arkansas Electric Energy Consumers Association, the Arkansas Gas Consumers Association, and our Commissioner, Ted Thomas, all aligned that this is the right way to go.
Speaker 149
1:51:03
And with that, I'm happy to take questions. Okay, are there any questions of the committee? Seeing none, is anyone here to speak for the bill? Against the bill? Seeing none from the audience, Representative Cosby, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed, Mr. Chair. Do we have a do pass motion? All those in favor?
Do pass as amended, sir. Excuse me, do pass as amended. Thank you. All those in favor, signify by aye. Aye. Those opposed? Congratulations. Your bill has passed as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I know everyone is getting
tired, so I'm just going to go to the end and see if maybe we can try and squeak in one more before noon. noon.
Is there any representative or senator that has a bill on our calendar for today that is confident he or she can run the bill in five minutes or less? Is there anybody that has that? If not, what we're going to do is we're going to adjourn today, and then we will have a meeting on Friday and pick up, and I'm confident we'll be able to get through the rest of the calendar on Friday. So without objection, we are adjourned.
Speaker 224
1:52:39
Thank you. Good job, my friend. Thank you. I'm glad Marshall got theirs worked out. Did they get it worked out? Good. I need Mike to get his worked out now. That's good that I always have on yours. Good. Yeah.
Agenda
HB1906
HB1870
HB1894
SB821
SB826
SB822
SB824
HB1814
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlie Collins Chair
Unverified
Senator Missy Irvin
Unverified
Representative John T. Vines Chair
Unverified
Representative Justin Boyd
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Frederick Love
Unverified
Representative Mathew W. Pitsch
Unverified
Representative Marshall Wright
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Bruce Cozart
Unverified
Senator Jonathan Dismang
Unverified
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Lynn Foster
Unverified
Speaker 72
Speaker 83
Representative Joe Farrer
Unverified
Speaker 88
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson
Unverified
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Tim Grooms
Unverified
Speaker 137
Speaker 145
Kathy Haney
Unverified
Speaker 149
Alan Kerr
Unverified
Danielle Nall
Unverified
Speaker 174
Ava Franks
Unverified
Cliff Mckinney
Unverified
Robin Quick
Unverified
Speaker 65
Representative Brent Talley
Unverified
Representative John Baine
Unverified
Representative Joe Jett
Unverified
Speaker 198
Michael Parker
Unverified
Rick Barrows
Unverified
Mike Malone
Unverified
Marty Clark
Unverified
Courtney Little
Unverified
Speaker 221
Speaker 224