Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Education Committee Meeting 2

March 24, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (10)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1791 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Present your bill, House Bill 1791. Committee and audience, we are going to try to clear as mu…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1968 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1968”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1828 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1828”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1970 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1970”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1272 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1272”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1273 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “to present House Bill 1273. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Madam Co-Chair. Committee…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1444 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1444”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1664 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1664”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1911 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1911”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1996 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1996”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Present your bill, House Bill 1791. Committee and audience, we are going to try to clear as much off this calendar this afternoon. We have a lot of House bills left. We'd like to try to get them because after today, there's not much of a good chance of getting a House bill through to the Senate. So please keep everything brief. If you are signed up to speak for a bill and you're with another group, please get one representative to speak for that group. and not three or four of you. That's all I ask because we're going to be brief. And if you don't get them out of here today, they're
▶ Play
going to die. You are recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. I appreciate your indulgence and apologize for not being in here this morning. A very simple bill, House Bill 1791, was one that was brought to me. It deals with laws that are already on the books involving hazing. And all this simply adds is one phrase kind of throughout, and that phrase is alumnus or volunteer employee of a fraternal organization. if the volunteer employee is acting on behalf of or in the name of the fraternal organization. And that's what it basically adds throughout. This came about brought to me by some friends and had some issues with a national fraternity showing up and there was no way to hold them accountable for some of their actions and we simply was brought to me, thought I wasn't real sure if we needed to run it, have it, but the more it laid around, it became quite apparent there were a lot of the higher ed folks that really liked it, and it's an accountability bill, and it just keeps everybody accountable instead of excluding any one sector. So basic bill, simple bill, would happily entertain any questions you might have. Any questions from the committee? Seeing no questions from
▶ Play
the committee, anyone in the audience would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close? I appreciate a very good vote. Do I have Representative Ratliff? Have a due pass from Representative Ratliff. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for the committee. Mr. Harris? Representative Harris, you are recognized
▶ Play
to present House Bill 1273. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Madam Co-Chair. Committee members, this is House Bill 1273, now retitled the Student Religious Liberties Bill. And I bring it back to you. Kind of ran it too soon the time before, but after the Attorney General's amendments added to it and also some heartburn that the committee members had. So we added some amendments, which gave the public school the opportunity. What we added was Part D, Page 2, a public school on Line 9. A public school may take an action contrary to this section if the public school documents a circumstance that, and they can list some of the objections that Representative Gossage had if the shirt or the paraphernalia may be deemed as inappropriate. And we also added religious expression, deeply held beliefs instead of a, I forget the wording that I used before, but it talks about a student's religious viewpoint or religious expression instead of a state religion.
▶ Play
Ready for questions? Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing no questions from the committee, anyone in the audience would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for your
▶ Play
bill? I'd appreciate a good vote so we can have a vote on the floor. Do I have
▶ Play
a – what's the will of the committee? Representative Hodges, you recognize? Motion do pass. Motion do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, no. No. Well, that's pretty split. I'm going to say that fails. That is pretty close. And if it's that close, it's not going to pass. I'm sorry. All right. Let's go down to our next
▶ Play
one. Tosh is not here.
▶ Play
Representative Tucker. Representative Tucker was here, but I think he's going to pass over that
▶ Play
Speaker 29 5:07
bill. Is he not going to run
▶ Play
that one? 1780? You're going to run 1780? 1748, sir. P20W? Okay. Well, I'm going to pass over you for right now. Just hang on. That was just on the top, so I'm getting these down through here. Representative Lowry, are you going to run 1828? All right, you're
▶ Play
up. House Bill 1828, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, Committee. As you remember several weeks back, it seems like a long time ago, the park testing bill was brought before you, And one of the issues that has come up consistently about the park test has just been the concern, the overarching concern, of whether student data, identifiable student data, is protected. 1828 in great length actually goes into that of making sure that student data is protected, that it has proper encryption. At the point that I had the bill already drafted, Higher Education, Department of Higher Education also approached me about having similar language that would cover higher education in terms of protection of this data. And so that's what you have before you is a bill that has Section 1, which applies to K-12, Department of Education, and then Section 2 that applies to protection, data protection, personally identifiable information at the higher ed level. It is, it's not a very long bill, but it is a complex bill in terms of what it does, in terms of protections for our students. So rather than going on and on,
▶ Play
I will just make myself
▶ Play
available for questions. Representative Walker, you're recognized for questions. Representative Lowry, often school districts allow, universities and colleges and even graduate students access to student data without sometimes without access to the personal identifying characteristics of individuals for use in research and study. Does this bill in any way limit that opportunity for other universities and other institutions to study information regarding student data? Representative Walker, while I certainly would not put myself out to be an expert in terms of IT and protecting data, my understanding is that there are several parts to it. One that personally identifiable information would be protected and that also there would be established an encryption standard to make sure that that data is protected while it's used. There's also stipulations about whether the information could continue to be retained by that research facility. As you remember, there have been some concerns, issues that have been out there of information that had been used and the data had, or access to the data had been compromised. And that is not just something that happened in another state, it's something that happened here in Arkansas. And so it's really what has brought on the reason for making sure that we protect this data. Mr. Chair, if I may follow up. You may. There was an issue with the Department of Education. If Mr. Tony Woods or his representative is here, I'd like to have that addressed. It involved the UCA use of data on a contract which was, which contract was being used to evaluate, analyze, and otherwise assess data that was in the databank of the Department of Education. So if I may ask a question of the appropriate person, I'd like to do so. Mike Mane is Department of Education.
▶ Play
Speaker 50 9:35
I brought Dr. Decker up with our research and technology to help address some of those questions. All right. He'll
▶ Play
go ahead. My question, Dr. Decker, is to hit. Let him introduce
▶ Play
Speaker 54 9:47
himself. Oh, I'm sorry. We'll get him all ready. Okay.
▶ Play
Cody Decker, Assistant Commissioner for Research and Technology of
▶ Play
the Department of Ed. Okay. You gentlemen are recognized. Go ahead with your question. Dr. Decker, there was an issue that involved the department a while ago that involved the UCA, University of Central Arkansas Research Department, where the director was, without an hope, she doesn't mind me mentioning her name, was Sarah Argue, and she and the university wanted to continue to have access, as it had for a number of years, to the information that the Department had, and the Department wanted to deny them the use of it. Is this the bill that you all have drafted to address that issue? Let me clarify that. I actually brought the bill forward. The Department has actually given me input as far as amendments, necessary amendments, but this is not a bill that's being put forward on behalf of the Department, so I just want to clarify that. But it's still the same question. It does address the issue. Is this a bill which would allow you all to discontinue the association with a UCA-type research associate, which makes reports to the United States Department of Education and others pursuant to contracts with either the Department of Education or the United States Department of Education, of the data that you all have under
▶ Play
Speaker 54 11:26
your control? Representative Walker, thank you for the question. My understanding is this has no direct impact on the operations with Arkansas Research Center. I do not believe it would prohibit personally identifiable information from being shared with the center so long as the stipulations as outlined in the bill were met. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Are there any other questions from the committee? I see no other questions. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 50 12:07
Cozart, we did have some concerns with the bill that we spoke to with the sponsor and did give some amendment language, but we would like the opportunity to outline some of those concerns at this
▶ Play
time, if appropriate. Okay. If there's no other questions on the committee, I will go ahead and take testimony for and against or about, however you
▶ Play
Speaker 54 12:32
want to do that. So I'll start with you. Thank you. So the department certainly appreciates the aspects of the bill that addresses privacy, transparency, and data use. There were some opportunities, we think, to improve upon the bill. Specifically, there are references on page 2, lines 24 through 28. There is uncertainty with regard to HIPAA, typically education data follows Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, and there's a concern whether or not these systems will need to be retrofitted to comply with HIPAA as well. That was one of the large concerns. Also, page 3, lines 28 through 30, where different purposes are listed. we're recommending that a fourth item is added to enable contractors and organizations such as the Department of Information Systems to help build, maintain, and support educational information systems. Let's see. And then lastly, pages 4 through 5, beginning lines 36, there is a data retention of five years specified. There is a concern with the student's electronic transcript information, having those transcripts available for institutions of higher ed after the student has left high school. Likewise, we are also recommending page 5, line 13, adding language that would allow information to be sent to institutions of higher ed for purposes of entrance or financial aid determination. That summarizes the amendments that we were proposing for the bill. Okay. Are there any questions? Representative Walker. Yes.
▶ Play
So does this mean that you'll destroy the data after five years and students who may be late in life wanting to go to college or use the transcript for other purposes will not have access to a retained transcript. Obviously, it would be a problem if you're going to destroy the data. My understanding is after five
▶ Play
Speaker 54 14:53
years of the student last attending a high school, the data must be destroyed.
▶ Play
Just to clarify. So if I'm a student, 18 years of age, and I don't apply to college until I'm 28, I don't have access to an official transcript from the institution because that data are already destroyed? That's my understanding,
▶ Play
Speaker 54 15:26
Representative Walker, with how it's currently constructed. Thank you.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you. Any other questions for them? Thank you all. Appreciate it. I have one that would like to speak for the bill. Karen Lamarill, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 74 15:44
I just ask you to keep it brief. We're really pressing for trying
▶ Play
to get some bills out today. We've already been 30 minutes on this one. So let's try to everybody that's going to speak for against the bill. as briefly as possible. Thank you, and name and who you're with, and you're recognized. I
▶ Play
Speaker 79 16:07
certainly will, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for having me. I'm Karen Lamoureux. I'm here as a concerned parent and also as a board member of our Kansans for Education Freedom. About a year and a half ago, I was reading up on the changes that were made to FERPA in 2011. In that year, the United States Department of Education gutted the FERPA legislation. They changed the definition of personally identifiable information by expanding it a great deal. It includes not just the typical demographics, but it also includes biometric information, including digital fingerprint scans, facial expressions, DNA sequence, all of that kind of thing. And one of the biggest changes they made to that law was they reduced the need for parental consent to a best practice. I think we all know what that means. So the local education agencies are no longer required by FERPA to either inform parents of data collection and sharing or to get our consent. Having said that, I found out that my child had their, or my children, had their fingerprints digitally scanned and stored into a private vendor's database. I was not notified, and I was not asked for permission to do this. This had gone on for about a year before I realized they were doing it in the media center. This is in the Pulaski County Special School District. And upon speaking with the superintendent, also learned that the Little Rock School District was using this technology in the cafeteria for the kids to purchase their lynches. I'm not opposed to this technology. I understand that the EduTech train is coming, and we're going to see all kinds of shiny technology to assist in our schools. But what I am asking as a parent in this bill is that they at least inform the parents and get our permission before using these type of interventions. That's really the meat and potatoes of this bill. It's not necessarily going to prevent people from using data. We're just asking them to be transparent with us as far as how they plan to use it, who they plan to share it with, and to please protect our parental rights and at least ask our permission before doing so. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Any questions? Seeing none, thank you. Anyone like to speak against the bill? for the bill. Would you like a close for
▶ Play
your bill? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. I've tried to be as responsive as possible to all the various inputs and concerns, and I do apologize to the Department of Ed if they had provided some language to me that we had not incorporated. I don't believe that the omissions that they referenced are fatal to the bill. I think the bill still goes a long way in protecting student data, but also protecting parents' rights, because this is an issue of consent of whether this data would be made available. One thing that I would reference is that legislative audit did come to me. They had concerns about access to information so that they could conduct audits, and we did amend that language in, so they still have that protection. So I would ask that if you feel like some of these amendments need to be added on, and there certainly is other opportunity to do that. Maybe on the Senate end, I would appreciate a due pass recommendation. As a matter of fact, I will make the due pass
▶ Play
recommendation. I have a due pass motion from Representative Lowry. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, no. No. I'm sorry, you failed your bill. All right. Would you like to do 1970 while you're there? Sure. And not the disco?
▶ Play
Sure. And not the disco. House Bill 1970 is about the remediation issue and specifically how remediation is being handled at the four-year university level. This is something that I'm very highly invested in. I had legislation drafted in the 2013 session. and one of the things that I was most amazed by when I met with the bill drafter the attempt on the bill at that time and the bill that you have before you is that I wanted to the state of Tennessee took an initiative of phasing out I don't think they phased out completely but phasing out remediation at the four year university level and instead trying to incentivize that being done at the two year level, and then maybe even hopefully addressing it at K-12. So the bill that I initially started with was to try and do that and to phase out incrementally year by year until you got to a point of about 50 percent of what is currently being spent. I don't have the latest number. I tried to look it up on the higher ed department's website, but I believe, without fear of contradiction that we are currently spending somewhere between $40 and $50 million to remediate students who we've been told are already college ready. It's an amazing amount of money. My greatest concern is that if they are remediated at the four-year college level, they are charged the same rate for that remediation course as they are for a credit-earning course, which may be anywhere around $250 a credit hour, and they get no credit for it. Now, to put that into perspective, I raised the point several years ago with Shane Broadway, who is director of higher ed, and at that time, the lottery scholarship was $2,000 for a freshman. And the point I made to him was that if a student has to be remediated in three course areas, their lottery scholarship is gone before they ever earn a single college credit. So in drafting the legislation, I wanted to try and create an approach of, since we do have so many two-year colleges, it really does not disenfranchise students to. I have a question. Yes. Are you going to run this whole bill? No, I'm
▶ Play
not. Can you briefly do this? We have a
▶ Play
little bit of time. I am. I just wanted to focus the members on, because I am going to request, and I could do this without presentation, but I wanted you to understand the significance of it, and I'm going to ask that this bill be sent to interim study and specifically directed
▶ Play
to the subcommittee of higher education within this committee. Granted. Without objection.
▶ Play
Okay. Good. One out of two is not
▶ Play
bad, right? Alright. At this time, Representative Hodges, you are recognized to present HB 1968 first.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee members. I'll try to be as brief as possible. House Bill 1968 creates the Teacher Preparation Quality Act, and essentially all we're doing here is requesting that the Arkansas Department of Education really just assemble a report, and the report being how well we as a state are educating, preparing, and placing our teachers in the state of Arkansas. So a couple of things I just want to point out. You can see in the bill on page 1, line 34, a data system to track the effectiveness of teacher preparation programs by following teachers is already established. The Arkansas Department of Education already collects, I believe, all of this data that I'm requesting in this bill. It'll simply be a matter of them pulling together the different pieces of it into the single report. What are we measuring here? We're measuring, if you'll look on page 2, you'll see on line 23 student academic achievement, student academic growth, which I think is important here for teachers to know that we're not just looking at how your students are performing, but also how they're improving when that teacher is placed. Because I know teachers can't choose who their students are, and there's a lot of different circumstances that teachers come into, so we also want to measure how their students are growing once they take over that classroom. Also measuring student demographics, teacher placement, teacher mobility, and teacher retention. And then you'll see there the Department of Education is going to collaborate with the Arkansas Department of Higher Education to make this report available on their website within 30 days, and that's each July 1st. I've also provided you with some documents. If you want to look them over, you can. I've worked with the National Council on Teacher Quality who really specializes in how we are preparing our teachers and the accountability of the programs that we have in the state to prepare our teachers. A couple of things to highlight there, you'll see kind of have five tiers on how we evaluate our teachers or how we evaluate the programs. They put us in sort of the fourth of five tiers. The next page has a snapshot of where we are in the state. You'll see with the X's and check marks, we only have one of the check marks in that box. I won't harp on that, but if you are interested, that's an interesting report to kind of get a picture of where we are as a state. I spoke with the Arkansas Department of Education, and I believe Ms. Pfefford, is there anything that you would want to add to this? I believe that the Arkansas Department of Education is okay with the bill. There is a fiscal impact to it as far as just the man time and the resources to compile the data to issue the report. But I've been told that they're okay with the bill. The higher education, I don't think, is opposed to the bill. The deans of the education colleges and such, I haven't heard that they are. If there is, they can speak to it, I guess, but I haven't heard that. So I'm not aware of any opposition at this time to the bill, but with that, I'll take questions.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, are you recognized for a question?
▶ Play
Thank you. This basically seeks to regulate teacher colleges that prepare teachers. Is that correct? Not regulate, just collect data on the teachers that they're educating and sending into the workforce. I
▶ Play
wouldn't necessarily say regulate them. Does this bill, Mr. Chair, may I have a follow-up? We keep everybody here. All right. Does this, are you aware that a great number of the teachers in Arkansas are, operate under what's known as an ALP or something like that? I'm sorry, I don't know what you're referring to. It's an alternative licensing program. Are you aware of the fact that many of our teachers come into the public schools under an ALP? Are you aware of that? No. Well, not all teachers who teach go through a teacher training school. Are you aware of that? Sir? All right. Well, I don't know how you can, how we can address this then. From what I've been told by the
▶ Play
Department of Education, again, they already have a program in place that are monitoring the teachers within five years after they're placed in the schools. We have one on the way.
▶ Play
Speaker 108 28:01
Good afternoon. Ivy Pfeffer, Arkansas Department of Education, Assistant Commissioner for Licensure and Educator Effectiveness.
▶ Play
You're recognized, but if you want to restate your question here.
▶ Play
I will. Isn't it true that a good number of your teachers would never be involved in a teacher preparation accountability snapshot because they don't go through teacher training
▶ Play
Speaker 108 28:36
programs? It's my understanding that this bill would not just be to higher ed. It would be for any teacher preparation program. So it could include
▶ Play
our non-traditional programs. It could. Do you all have anything in place now
▶ Play
Speaker 108 28:52
that addresses this subject? We are currently, we have the first report was produced last May and will be updated again this year. It's called our educator preparation performance report. The difference is the metrics that were used in that initial report are more of input measures rather than outcomes, more of looking at the numbers in educator preparation programs, the number of completers. This would focus on what happens after people complete a preparation program, be that a traditional program or a
▶ Play
non-traditional program. If I may follow up, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Now, does the department have any evaluation of any of the effectiveness of any of its teacher training programs that it has put in place up until 2014 that we can see in writing? Any objective evaluation that addresses that subject other than I feel good about it? Not currently. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you. That's all I wanted. are there any other questions okay I ain't ready for that no other questions committee anyone would like to speak against the bill in the audience for the bill would you like to close for that bill
▶ Play
yeah members all I would say is I think we're about three-fourths of the way in the state right now as far as this data is mostly already being collected We're pretty much simply just asking that the department bring the data together and publish this report online. As I've been told, the U.S. Department of Education is kind of already moving in this direction. So I think this would be a valuable report for us to have to see how we're educating, preparing, and placing our teachers. So I'd appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
What's the will of the committee? I have a motion to do pass from Representative Lenning. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. No. The ayes have it. You have a new partner in crime, Representative Walker. Hold on and take just a second. We've got to get a sheet.
▶ Play
Speaker 120 31:23
Representative Letting. Representative Murdoch Representative Murdoch Representative Deffenbaugh Representative Harris Representative Harris Representative Eubanks Representative Ratliff Representative Gillum Representative Gillum Representative Walker Representative Bell Representative Bell Representative Balz Representative Balz Representative Douglas Representative Lowry Representative McElroy Representative Armstrong Representative Armstrong Representative Gossage Representative Gossage Representative Saban Representative Hodges Representative Gray Representative Lampkin Representative Lampkin I'm sorry
▶ Play
with the roll call you have failed your bill Would you like to present House Bill 1664? Sure. There is an amendment for that bill. That has my name on it, but that has been amended to his name. So that we'll have a
▶ Play
Speaker 77 33:13
Hodges. It will be Hodges now. Your amendment to that
▶ Play
bill is from Senator. everybody gets the amendment I'd like to make a motion we adopt that amendment all those in favor say aye any opposed no you are recognized to
▶ Play
present the bill as amended thank you Mr. Chairman this amendment for have we adopted the amendment Are we good now? We're on the bill? OK. House Bill 1664, it's a bill that protects the local control for procurement decisions regarding group life and supplemental insurance for school district employees. We've amended it to agree upon the language that remedies the scope concerns with the bill. You'll see now that we've deleted the word disability. This is because the term has been redefined in previous legislative tweaks, and this just cleans that language up. The language in procured by that we've added to the bill before any independent school district. This language serves the purpose of authorizing and protecting the local purchasing decisions regarding group life insurance policy decisions. And finally, the language in Section B was inserted to specifically define the type of insurance policies this addresses, which remedies concerns about the potential for a broaden scope for the bill. In short, the bill just protects the status quo regarding school districts having the ability to make their own group life insurance decisions. It does not have anything to do with health insurance and is specific in scope. It's been discussed with DFMA, and their minimal concerns have been addressed. It's been discussed with the task force chairman on school insurance, Senator Hendren, and he doesn't oppose what we have in the bill, so I'd appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote. Any questions?
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. I guess I'm always asking, but this morning we had opposition by a large number of the legislators to a policy of payroll deductions, and you have it here on page two. 2A line 32 to 36. And the argument there was that by having a different kind of system, the people could go and get their own insurance, and you would not allow payroll deductions. I'm trying to understand why it's appropriate to have payroll deductions some places but and not other places in the name of competition when you all assert that you want to promote competition. I mean, obviously, this is supposedly a bill to promote competition, and that is in the setting of insurance. I don't know why that should be our concern at this point, but why is it our concern? Why is it the concern of this committee to promote competition when the employees are already in a situation where they get insurance on a competitive basis. I don't
▶ Play
remember the bill you're referencing from this
▶ Play
morning. But I'm asking about now this one. Since you weren't there this morning, I want to know about this one. Why is this bill necessary? I was here this morning, I believe, but I don't know. I asked you a question. This was in joint budget this morning. So I'm
▶ Play
saying, now why is this bill necessary? From my understanding, this bill really just keeps the status quo of what we have, and most of the school districts are in support of that. I think Tony Pruthra was here. They said they were okay with it. From my understanding, it prevents them from being lumped in with other state employees for insurance purposes, which I believe most school districts were
▶ Play
opposed to. Wouldn't it be better for the teachers and the others to have the opportunity to combine with others in order to get better policies at lower rates? I don't believe so.
▶ Play
I think what I have in this bill is appropriate. Any other questions?
▶ Play
Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like closed for that bill? I'm closed. Thank you. Do we have a motion? Representative Saban, do you have a motion? Yes, Mr. Chair. I move to pass. Do you have a do pass motion from Representative Saban? As amended, sir. As amended? Yes, sir. As amended. Okay. All right. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Motion carries. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thanks, committee. Thank you. At this time, Representative Douglas. How many are you going to run? Two.
▶ Play
Speaker 13 38:31
Two? Two? Okay. Might as well just go on now.
▶ Play
For those that are asking, and there are a few, all those bills that have failed here the committee before will be heard last. we're gonna let everybody that has not ran a bill run first and then we will hear the failed bills at the very last there are about five of them and if you don't want to run it that's fine but if you do want the chance to run your bill again we will do that experience we will hear night one nine one one if you guys want to get prepared, we will hear
▶ Play
Speaker 77 39:24
1-9-1-1. There's an amendment for that
▶ Play
bill, sir. There is an amendment. Amendments
▶ Play
being handed out. Welcome to make a motion whenever you want to on the amendment. Okay. We got all the parties together on an amendment for this. ADE, all the letters, AAEA, we're involved. So it's a good amendment and I'd like to have a due pass. I have
▶ Play
a due pass a motion on the amendment from Representative Walker. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed no
▶ Play
you are welcome to present your bill as amended okay this house bill 1991 a very easy concept to grasp for for teachers in fact it's not for teachers it's those other than teachers let me read the title an act to amend provisions to the arkansas code concerning duty-free lunch periods for classified not certified but classified employees and for other purposes just some bullet points on why this is a good idea presently there's no provision in the law for a full-time classified public school employee to receive a lunch period that means a lot of our nurses if they have an emergency during lunch you know if they're asked to man the phones in the you know in the office during lunch or have lunch duty they're not mandated to have a lunch this bill defines a classified employee there's also a definition for an emergency because we do recognize that there may be instances where a person's lunch can and should be interrupted in case of an emergency especially for nurses the bill goes on to define a full-time classified employee which means an employee who works 35 hours a week or more which comes out to seven hours a day minimum. It provides that a public school or school district shall provide at least one 30-minute uninterrupted duty-free lunch period during each student instructional day for a full-time classified employee, except in the case of an emergency. Current law does provide that a classified staff that works more than 20 hours a week receives two 15-minute breaks. So in putting the bill together we felt that someone who gets a 30-minute lunch period should not also receive the two 15-minute breaks. So we've tried to be easy on the school districts on the time off and compensate that. A full-time classified employee who does not receive a full duty-free lunch shall be compensated at his or her hourly rate of pay for each duty-free lunch period missed. And that is the way that it is presently done for certified teachers. There's a great need for this. I've had lots of emails thanking us for running this bill and giving them some relief during their school day. So I'd be glad to answer questions and would like a favorable vote. Are there any questions? oh the bill the amendment has to be passed first correctly we've already done it oh geez i'm so sorry i'm in a fog okay resident walker you
▶ Play
have a question all right let me get the audience involved in this would anybody like to speak against the bill for the bill y'all are just not participating today. I warned you, didn't I? I said, I knew I'd give him. I was just kidding. Okay. You're welcome to close for your bill. It's a knee-jerk reaction for those guys who just get
▶ Play
up out of their seats. I know. I'm closed. Mr. Walker, as a motion, sir.
▶ Play
I have a motion to do pass for Representative Walker. As amended. As amended. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Thank you. Thank you, committee. Yeah, pass your bill. I think I've seen Representative Flowers here somewhere a while ago. There you are. Would you join us at the table, please? She has an amendment for her bill. We have an amendment for this bill, but this will be House Bill 1996. Yes, Mr. Chair. Okay, we
▶ Play
Speaker 147 44:07
have an amendment for that bill. Like it's pretty simple?
▶ Play
Very simple. We can get this done in like a minute. Would you like to explain your amendment? Yes. So this amendment basically strikes through a couple of other areas to achieve what I was trying to achieve with the bill. And
▶ Play
I can go further into it now or after
▶ Play
we adopt the amendment. Let's just explain the bill, and so we'll accept the amendment. Do I have a motion for the amendment? I have a motion due pass from Representative McElroy. All those in favor say aye. Opposed, no. You
▶ Play
can present your bill as amended. Thank you so much. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, Committee, for hearing me explain House Bill 1996, And I bring you this bill which grew out of some meetings that I was able to participate in to learn more about all of these distressed statutes. And all of the issues that are happening with our schools. And as our standards have raised, which they should be raised, That also, as it was explained to me and as I've seen, puts our state board in a position of being responsible for all of these schools, a couple of that are in my district, that will be subject to takeover. And that are in takeover status as a result specifically of academic distress. And my explanation is pretty simple. This is about creating an objective consistent process for schools that will be taken over, or then that are in takeover status. As it relates to the focus of the work of the state board in that role. And that is to focus on academic performance. That is the trigger that sends a school into academic distress. That is the trigger that sends them out. And what disturbed me in thinking about all of the possibilities and in reviewing this statute is that in that five year period before, and if you all will take a look at the handout, basically there are three areas that are stricken. That's what the bill is. But at the end, in section E, it says, if by end of the fifth school year, following the public schools or school districts classification of academic distress status of the public school or school district in academic distress has not corrected all issues that cause the classification of academic distress, the state board, after public hearing, shall consolidate annex or reconstitute the school district under this section. In my mind, if after five years of an effort on the part of the state and the community and the schools that bringing that school back up to standard has not been reached, then that should be a last resort and within the authority of the State Board to engage a process for annexation or reconstitution or consolidation as a last resort. And then the second issue for me is local control. When you start talking about reconstituting districts and schools, closing schools, annexation, And that is typically, that typically occurs either because a school is in fiscal distress and can't afford to continue, which I have no problem with. We shouldn't have a problem with that. Or that's a community decision. We've seen bills right now where districts want to annex, where districts have worked together to consolidate. That should be a community effort. effort. That should be the role and the decision and the input of schools that will be affected. So for me, if Dalloway School District, as it's taken over by the state board, if within that five years they decide to close Dalloway School District, those children, number one, will have have to go outside of their immediate area and go to Pine Bluff High School and White Hall High School. And the same could occur to Pine Bluff High, theoretically. And I just think that, and I think that all of the people in the legislature and the people in this room who really do value local control would agree that that should be a community decision and that should be something that is outside of the purview of regular activities when the focus should be on academic performance and the test scores that trigger this academic distress statute. And so I don't want to talk too much. Those are my two major points. And I guess the last thing that I would add in closing is that when you look at the statute, is why I gave you a copy, within that five years, it is a long laundry list of tools that the state board can and should use, whether it's dissolving the school board, getting rid of the superintendent, all of those things as well as any of the things that need to be done to address the academics. So when you talk about leadership and the district, those kinds of things are within in their authority, but I just don't understand how reconstituting a district or annexing a district, closing a school would have anything to do with raising the academic performance and standards of a school or of a district within that five-year period other than moving children who need help to another school, and then pushing that problem to another district or another school. So I'll close with that, and I would definitely be open to any questions. Are there any questions? Representative Douglas,
▶ Play
you're recognized for questions. So let me see if I
▶ Play
can kind of summarize what I feel like I've taken away from what your explanation is. Yes. When a school district is taken over, it is taken over in whole. And you want that school district to be left whole during that five-year takeover. And any parceling or changing of the district parameters or closing of schools would not be acceptable because it was taken over as is, and you would want to leave that during that five-year period. Pretty much what I would add,
▶ Play
it was taken over as is for the purpose of addressing academic distress. So if the purpose of the state board is to take over a district because the locally elected school board has not been able to or cannot do what it needs to do to bring a school district or a school up to standard for the benefit of the children. If we're saying that these test scores are what tell us that this school is in trouble and the school board, the state school board, needs to take over because this community needs help. This school board can't do it. So we have the resources. What you're saying is we have the resources as a state board and the capacity to make that change, to help bring that school up to par based upon the trigger. The trigger is based on academics, purportedly, right? So if the objective criteria is based upon these test scores, as well as the criteria that the school board would use to determine whether or not that school or that school district would be returned to the community and allow them to duly elect another school board then I just would question where in that five-year period reconstituting a district or making it not whole as you use and I think that's good terminology would do anything to achieve the goal of raising the academic performance of those students and
▶ Play
i follow up if i could uh i just i'm just sitting here trying to think and i'm i'm i'm thinking i could come up with with ways that reconfiguring uh grade levels within a school or or moving you know populations to to better buildings or you know might be might speak to academics, and if you pass that, would we be in, you know, it would constrain us to do some of the changes that we might need
▶ Play
to do. If I can respond to that, I would just say that in the situation that would address facilities, If the facilities are so detrimental to learning, then in my mind, I believe we have statutes that address facilities' distress. So I guess what I'm saying is this wouldn't do anything to limit the authority where other issues come into play. So if there's fiscal distress and a school within a district or a school district can't afford to continue to exist or need some time to get their finances together, that's authority, I think, where it's reasonable where that should come into play, including facilities. But I don't think that this would preclude the state board the flexibility that they have. And if you look, again, at all the other tools that they have to work with in order to, again, focus on academics, those tools are still there. And I would just add that, again, uniformity, I think, is very important. I don't know if I've said this analogy or this example, but I think that it would be a really grave mistake to, I don't even want to say empower, but to saddle the state board with the responsibility or the authority to do one thing in one school district that could be different in another and that could have really detrimental effect on that community. And I use Dollar Way because, you know, Dollar Way is very challenged. And in a situation with academic distress, not facilities, not fiscal, it's within the authority of this school board to look at that community and think, well, they're not really going to be able to, within five years, make this work. So after a year, we'll just go ahead and close them and send the students to Whitehall and Pine Bluff High, whereas they could take over for a city and give them the full five years. And I would say, as a representative of a district that includes Dalloway, that would be patently unfair to my community and to a school in my district if that was in their authority to do it. And something like that so imbalanced were to happen.
▶ Play
Speaker 164 56:39
Thank you. President Lauer, you are
▶ Play
recognized for questions. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Your bill references removing certain options, and I know that you would agree that these options are all permissive, that the State Board of Education may do any of those things. So I'm going to liken back to something we've heard throughout this session from Mr. Walker about evidence-based information. Do you have any evidence-based information where this disillusion or consolidation option has been used and that it has been proved to be detrimental? I would have to say no because based on what I've learned so far is that in this state, up until recently, there was only one school that had been taken over due specifically and solely to academic distress. And so we couldn't. But what I do know is that it would be imbalanced and patently unfair if the school board, the state school board, were to use that authority with one school and not another. I just don't see where the authority could remain, but again, as a last resort. for any school taken over specifically and solely for academic distress. You're recognized. Yes, follow-up. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 81 58:14
you, Mr. Chairman. So again, I would come
▶ Play
back. Since we're looking at a list of options that we're not requiring the Department of Education to order, permissive, why should we remove an option from them, or, as Representative Collins sometimes will say, a tool from the toolbox, if that tool has not been proven to be ineffective. I think the only thing that I've heard is that it may be unfair. No, well, I'm sorry.
▶ Play
Speaker 168 58:46
But I would ask, I mean,
▶ Play
why would we remove it if it's not been shown to be ineffective or if it's been shown to actually be detrimental? Well, and I don't think that I just made the point about it being unfair. I think that there's a possibility of unfairness when there's not uniformity. So I think that uniform application is important. I think that local control is important. And I think that we have seen, maybe not in this circumstance, but we have seen where school districts have been closed or schools have been closed, and it's had a detrimental effect on communities and on the students. But I think that the primary point that I would raise here is that, again, because there are a lot of things that aren't a part of the authority that could work, And I don't know that it's necessarily good policymaking to throw every toy in the bathwater, if I can use that analogy. There are a lot of things that could work. But I would just say, again, that if this statute affords authority and tools for a school district, I mean, for the state board, to be able to address academic distress, I would say then that those particular tools aren't a fit, and they aren't created to apply in a uniform way to the school districts across the state.
▶ Play
Representative Douglas, you recognize your
▶ Play
question? I'm still trying to process this, but I'm wondering if a more like a system, instead of having it open-ended saying, you know, these are the steps and outline those steps that you would want the process to go through before you get to that end process, which would be, you know, what, in your opinion, would be so detrimental to the school. You know, a process of making sure that they, you know, go through all of the, you know, ways open to us to make sure that the school is improving, you know, facilities, the fiscal and everything, and maybe outline a way or a process for that and then make this the last resort, like you said. But I think we would need to have something more specific on paper as a process, a system.
▶ Play
Speaker 167 1:01:53
As I've talked with people at the
▶ Play
department about how this works, I believe that they do outline a process, and they do outline a plan. And the thing that I actually raised that as a question and an issue, and the thing that I heard pretty consistently is that one size does not fit all. And because the districts are so different, that would be really difficult to do, number one.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yeah. Are there any
▶ Play
other questions? Representative Walker, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman Cozart. Thank you, sir. Representative Flowers, I think I know what you're trying to do. I don't think that it is being very clearly presented in all due respect. It's not the premise of your bill that there are a lot of districts in academic distress and other kinds of distress that need to be addressed in some way, but whatever way it's addressed it should be uniform and without there being deviations from district to district, which allows for arbitrariness and perhaps unfairness. Fairness. Is that basically the premise of what you're trying to do? Yes, Representative. And when you talk in terms of annexation, you're really talking, and you're usually Pan Bluff, White Hall, or Dalloway White Hall situation. You are aware that the state is allowing the creation of white halls adjacent to places like Pan Bluff, which means that you have a successful district right next to an unsuccessful district and therefore you would want to be in a position where one of the options available would be rather than closing, say, the Dalloway schools in your example, just merging the Dalloway schools with Whitehall so that they would deal with the problem together rather than just leaving one over there where it can't deal with them by itself due to various factors over which they have no control? Well, I wouldn't say that because I think part of what I'm also trying to say is that in terms of reconstituting a school district or reconstituting a school, I'm saying that that should be the decision of those schools and communities involved. I'm saying that the state board on high should not be in the position unless it is a last resort issue as it relates to academic performance should not be in the position of doing what the community can and should be doing. Are there any other questions, committee?
▶ Play
I'll move to the audience. Is there anyone in the audience? Do we have a sheet? No, sir. Mr. Hernandez would like to. Okay. Mr. Hernandez, speak against the bill. Dr. Hernandez. We'll start first. you state your name and who you're with and you are recognized to speak against the
▶ Play
Speaker 50 1:05:36
bill. Mike Hernandez, Department of Education. I have with us our general counsel. And just some, before we outline, we just really want to outline some concerns we have. One is, you know, we would very much be in favor of having the multiple tools that are available to our state board to be able to make decisions and deal with districts as appropriate. So some of the concerns that Mr. Lassiter will outline for you just go to the point of addressing some of the things within this bill, the tangents that could roll off of this, but I'll allow Mr. Lassiter to expound on that.
▶ Play
Speaker 181 1:06:13
Jeremy Lassiter, general counsel with the Arkansas Department of Education. The first thing I'd like to mention is to, and it's a very basic point, it has to do with Lakeview. The Lakeview line of cases stated very clearly that it's the state of Arkansas that has the constitutional responsibility to provide an equal opportunity for adequate education and that when local districts fail, the state has the duty to step in to do something about that. Representative Flowers makes some very good points about why the state would not want to dissolve a school or annex or consolidate a school district. Those are very good points. At the same time, I agree with Dr. Hernandez, where you'd still, I think, want at least that option on the table if there ever came a time where it was necessary. And my time as general counsel with the Arkansas Department of Education has been about seven years now. I don't remember any time before we had consolidated or annexed a school district based on either academic distress or fiscal distress. There was a time that we had to do to dissolve a school district for standards of accreditation issues, but that was an extreme case, and it certainly wasn't something that was in the norm. And one thing, the last thing I'll ask everyone to remember is that when it comes to academic distress and fiscal distress, the standard used to be two years, that if a school district could not get out of academic distress in two years, it was a mandatory consolidation or annexation. I think during the last legislative session, you all changed that to be five years. And the reason why you did that was to allow a three-year time period where the department could work with local districts to build capacity through the community advisory boards. And so that was a good change to the law. And it's also a tool that the state board has at its disposal. So I think probably the summary statement is that it's not a closing of a school or consolidating or annexing a school district. It's not something that is one of the top choices for the State Board, but it is something, I think, that if there were ever an extreme enough situation out there, that you would at least want to have that option available.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you recognize. To Mr. Lasseter. On to Dr. Hernandez. You have a situation where the State Board is able to act independently of the staff, And in the situation that you have here, unlike the situation in all time in 2002, the staff did not make a recommendation for takeover. If we're talking about objective decision making and things like community control, do you not feel that the staff should have a role in determining, at least making recommendations to the board which a school district may address, especially where the state has had effective control over those same institutions for more than five years itself. In other words, the state's already had a dead little rock under control for five years. Then you take it over and say there's nothing you can do. That's question one. And I'll ask Chairman Cousart for a second question, if you can answer that. First of all, when you talk about the Alzheimer
▶ Play
Speaker 181 1:09:38
incident, that happened under another entirely different law that's been repealed by the General Assembly. So I really can't comment on that. That law was repealed many years ago. There's a different statutory process that was set up. But secondly, in terms of the staff's role, when it comes to academic distress, this is a little bit different than fiscal distress, when it comes to academic distress, all of those decisions are within the authority of the State Board of Education. And so our role as a staff is to provide a recommendation if we're asked. It's to provide information and data that we can to inform the decision-making of the State Board of Education. And, you know, that's how we've operated.
▶ Play
The second question is Chairman Cozart gives you a second question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Chairman Cozart. Do you, did the State Board of Education have control of the Little Rock schools in southwest Little Rock for five years before the takeover? No, sir. If I may, isn't it true that you had Dr. Wiley and other people there, in effect, directing the instruction in those schools?
▶ Play
Speaker 181 1:11:02
No, sir. Dr. Wild provided recommendations. They provided technical assistance. But in terms of directing the instruction in those schools, that did not happen. All right.
▶ Play
I've exhausted my questions at this point. I haven't exhausted my questions. I've chosen to not ask anymore. Are there any other
▶ Play
questions? Thank you. Anyone would like to speak for the bill? Against the bill? For the bill? Alright, would you like to
▶ Play
close for your bill? I would. I recognize that this is something that goes against the status quo. And I recognize that I don't have empirical data, and that is because we have not had any, we're just now starting to see the impact of the law as it exists. And what I would just leave the committee with is that we have a statute that affords our state board the authority to take over school districts that are not performing based upon academic criteria that demonstrate that the district is in academic distress. We have over 200 school districts and one state board. We have raised standards where more schools will be impacted. and my primary focus is about fitting the authority and fitting the toolbox to match the focus and the purpose of what we're supposed to be doing in addressing schools and academic distress. And secondarily, I would add that there should be uniformity. I believe that you just heard representatives of the state board indicate that it hasn't been used. So if those tools haven't been used, they don't really need to be used, and the authority affords for those tools to be used as a last resort. Why not ensure that that uniformity is applied for our school districts in the state? And finally, I would say that any time you talk about annexing and consolidating and reconstituting schools and school districts, We have school boards that are elected to do that work, and when those school boards are dissolved and we have a state entity taking over for a particular focus, that focus should be on the academics and not reconfiguring school districts. That is the role of the community, and if we really do value local control, then I would just encourage and ask the committee to consider that. and I would ask for a good vote. Okay. What's the
▶ Play
will of the committee? I have a motion of due pass from Representative Murdoch. As amended. As amended, correct? All right. All right, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, no? No. I'm sorry, your motion has failed, or your bill has failed. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair,
▶ Play
Speaker 154 1:14:35
and thank you, committee. At this time, here's
▶ Play
what's going to happen. We're going to hear one more bill. We're going to let Representative Mayberry present her bill. Everybody else is going to have to come back Thursday morning. We will hear the ones that have failed. She has all the people with her today, so I'm going to let her present. Yes, ma'am. Thursday morning. Yes, ma'am. Mr. Tucker, Representative Tucker, Thursday morning, you will be in line first. Representative Douglas you will be in line second Representative Armstrong you will be in line third and we will set a time to present these and we will hear the other two that's on amending. Yeah we've got two people that are holding on fiscal impact so we're going to hear the house bills finish them up first thing Thursday and we'll hear all the senate bills on Thursday. Sorry guys we're running out of time and a lot of people need to be gone and we're going to hear one We're going to close this at 6 o'clock, at 6 o'clock. So you have 15 minutes or less to present this. I have people that have commitments tonight, and 6 o'clock is our deadline. So you are recognized to present House Bill 1444.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, I went back and I watched the video of our discussion the other day, and I just thought, you know, maybe they just didn't understand what those amendments were that I was suggesting. to put on there. So, unfortunately, I can't put the amendments on here until it gets into the Senate, but I wanted you to see those corrections so that you know exactly what we're talking about. We were talking in fictitious words, and now you can actually see with my little handwritten notes there the changes. Now, I will tell you these changes come directly from AAEA. I was actually given some changes two weeks before that and made some corrections and made those amendments and then was told a day before the meeting that they weren't good enough. So we changed them again to clarify them, and that's what we're doing here. First of all, it starts out, the nurse employed by a school district shall be evaluated on his or her nursing performance components annually using evaluation tools developed and provided by ADE that may be incorporated into a district standard evaluation form. We also made it clear that the partial evaluation on the nursing components would be evaluated by the school nurse and striking out the other part. Just to make sure that a nurse is being evaluated on nursing components and also from whoever is considered her boss, the principal, the superintendent, someone else who would normally do that. If you look at the next page, to clarify the area that some of you might have had concerns, we have taken out the words at each school to make it clear that there is a registered nurse in the school district, so not necessarily at every school campus. We would love to have that, but that's not what this bill will do, so we wanted to clarify that. And then also, if you look down a little bit further, it was not my intention to start this in 2015. That was an oversight on my part. So the 1 in 750 ratio would not begin until 2016. That's a year and a half on down the road. Plenty of time to make some adjustments if needed. I want to back up a little bit and also point out that the RN in the school district would not begin until July 1 of 2017. Plenty of time to make some adjustments to budgets and to plan and to find nurses and to even allow nurses that might be LPNs to become RNs. The other thing that I want to point out is some of you were concerned that this is just going to be overwhelming to the school district. So hopefully you got on your desk today, I had our pages delivered to each one of you, information supplied by ADE. I will tell you some of the numbers might be off just a little bit we have discovered some data is not always 100% perfect but to give you an idea the majority of the school districts already meet that 1 in 750 ratio so the mid and exceed that 1 in 750 ratio if Gurdon can have one nurse per 188 students why can't all school districts do it they receive the same amount of funding per student that all the other school districts do again we're not saying you have to have one nurse per 188 it's one nurse per 750 and the majority of those school districts do that I would like to also pull up because there were some questions that might not have been adequately answered and I'd like to have Nell Smith come forward from our Bureau to explain a little bit about how our funding is done and you should have also gotten on your desk information from the Bureau that all those on the Education Committee received this summer. They spent a great amount of time researching where money goes and is allocated, and I'd like her to just explain so you can hear from the Bureau exactly where money. Excuse me for just a second. I need to make
▶ Play
a statement about the amendment that you have on there. This is really not an amendment. Okay. She's just making a written, handwritten deal on what this amendment will be. Correct. She is promising to you, if you pass it out of this committee, she will do that before she gets to Senate. So there is no amendment, but this is what she's planning on doing. So I just need to make that clear. Thank you for making that clear. Because we didn't
▶ Play
have that on the tape. That would be
▶ Play
on the Senate side. I can't make the amendment here. All right. Nell, you're recognized. State
▶ Play
your name and who you're with, please. My name is Nell Smith. I'm with the Bureau of Legislative Research, and I need to read a little statement before I provide any information. I've been asked by the sponsor of the legislation to explain certain aspects related to the bill, to this committee. However, the Bureau of Legislative Research is nonpartisan and impartial. And as an employee of the Bureau, I cannot advocate for or against the bill or the issues presented by it. So I'm just going to let you know about the foundation funding. There were questions about whether nurses are included in foundation funding. And as some of you may know, the foundation funding is based on a school of 500 students, and foundation funding includes in the formula 0.67 of one full-time nurse for every 500 students, and that number is based on the 1 to 750 ratio. So it is in the foundation funding. Any questions from the
▶ Play
committee on that? Seeing none, you may continue. Can I just also ask her
▶ Play
to explain that the school districts already have also been using NSLA money to meet, to exceed some of the needs, if you could just also explain that a little bit and remind them how much money has been applied and how much money has been used. According
▶ Play
to your research, you've already publicly given out over the summer. Sure. We looked at how much of the matrix funding is provided to districts for nurses and how much is spent for nurses from foundation funding. And in 2012-13, districts received $81.16 per student for nurses, and they spent from foundation funding about $42 per student. They spent about $81 in total per student on school nurses, and that's because they used other funding for that purpose. They used about $19 million in foundation funding, and they used about $9.6 million in NSL funding and then various other sources. Thank you. All right, any questions?
▶ Play
All right, there's no questions, committee. are you ready well i i have one
▶ Play
one more thing that i need to address there's been a lot of concern about why can't an lp why do we have to have an rn why is the rn so important and i'd like phyllis um to come up and and explain um if we have and just kind of back me up on this and just make sure that we're really clear um we have
▶ Play
certain i'm watching my time we have seven minutes we we have certain take
▶ Play
a vote at two minutes to six we have certain qualifications and licensing needs for teachers. And if a teacher is teaching a class that they're not licensed to teach, I'm sure that teacher or that school district is going to get into trouble, right? So we have LPNs that can do certain things. RNs that are a step above that can oversee the LPN. And right now, if we have a school district that has an LPN that does not have an RN supervising that nurse, that nurse could face some legal challenges and a fine of $1,000 a day if someone wanted to report that school nurse. I don't want any LPN to get into trouble. That's why we need to make sure that we have an RN license to oversee that LPN. Could you address
▶ Play
Speaker 209 1:24:03
that for me? I'm Debra Jones and I'm with the Arkansas State Board of Nursing. We do the regulation of nursing. The LPN scope of practice does not include the assessment, the diagnosis, or the care planning that is required to do the individual health care plans that students many times need in the schools. Since it is not within their scope of practice to do those. And it is in the Nurse Practice Act very clearly says that the LPN works under the direction of an RN, a physician, a dentist, or an APN. So if the LPN cannot show that they have the direction of one of those advanced license persons, then they are in violation of the Nurse Practice Act and subject to disciplinary action, which could include sanctions against their license, including a hefty fine by the Board of Nursing. Now, we are not looking to discipline any nurses. We do not want nurses to violate the Nurse Practice Act, but if we get a complaint that they are doing so, we have to investigate it and take the appropriate action. But we are not out there looking for them just for the sole purpose of discipline.
▶ Play
Representative Deffenbaum, you have a question?
▶ Play
Yeah, it's quick. I see the clock from here. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to make sure we're voting on one nurse per school district. I'm going to ask this all in one question. One nurse per school district. and if that one nurse has to be LPN unless they've already been in that district and the ratio is 1 in 750, any part of that, if I'm wrong, just tell me.
▶ Play
Okay, 1 in 750 starting in the year 2015, 20, I'm sorry, 2016. okay so on down the road giving time for schools to adjust and then the other part is is that you must have if you only have one nurse in that school district to meet that ratio it must be an rn unless you hire an lpn and contract out with an rn to oversee them that is possible and that is being done and it is okay to contract out we don't want any nurses to lose their job we've got some nurses who are doing some really good work out there. But I would encourage any LPN to go back to school and become an RN and then that solves that problem.
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:26:49
Thanks. Thank you. President Ratliff, do you have a question?
▶ Play
Speaker 215 1:26:56
So what I'm hearing here is you're saying it's illegal in the state of Arkansas to have an LPN at school.
▶ Play
Speaker 209 1:27:06
No. We're saying that the LPN has to work under the direction of an RN, an APN, a physician, or a dentist. They do not work independently. They have one year of training. There are many, many LPNs that are exceeding their abilities as an LPN. They should be RNs. They are fantastic nurses. Exactly. But their licensure requires them to work under the direction of a higher license.
▶ Play
So this does not do away with LPNs. LPNs can still be hired. They just have to have an RN supervising them. We want to make sure that our kids are being taken care of. Representative Letting,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Immediate consideration. I have a motion for immediate consideration. Proper motion, non-debatable. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. Ayes have it. Ayes have it. Thank you. All right. What's the will of the committee? Got a move to do pass. From Representative Letting, all those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? I'm sorry, you have failed your bill. If she needs to bring it back, she's got to have a motion
▶ Play
Speaker 117 1:28:31
to punish the vote, but it's good. This bill will be dead.
▶ Play
You'll have to have a motion to expunge if you bring it back. All right, that's going to conclude for today. The ones that did not get heard today come back Thursday morning. You will be first on. I gave that order a while ago. Yes, sir. And then we will be taking up Senate bills and finishing House bills. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1791

0:12 - 2:56 8 segments 3 speakers

HB1272

2:56 - 5:34 11 segments 4 speakers

HB1828

5:34 - 20:45 53 segments 8 speakers

HB1970

20:45 - 23:03 9 segments 2 speakers

HB1968

23:03 - 32:59 29 segments 5 speakers

HB1664

32:59 - 39:25 23 segments 5 speakers

HB1911

39:25 - 44:19 17 segments 4 speakers

HB1996

44:19 - 1:16:01 85 segments 13 speakers

HB1444

1:16:01 - 1:28:52 41 segments 8 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
66 segments
Representative John T. Vines Unverified
3 segments
Representative Justin T. Harris Unverified
4 segments
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 29
1 segment
Representative John W. Walker Chair Unverified
93 segments
Speaker 50
5 segments
Speaker 54
9 segments
Chair Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 74
1 segment
Speaker 79
5 segments
Representative Grant Hodges Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 108
4 segments
Speaker 120
3 segments
Speaker 77
2 segments
Speaker 13
1 segment
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
16 segments
Speaker 147
1 segment
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 164
1 segment
Speaker 81
1 segment
Speaker 168
1 segment
Speaker 167
1 segment
Speaker 181
7 segments
Speaker 154
1 segment
Representative Julie Mayberry Unverified
17 segments
Nell Smith Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 209
4 segments
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 205
1 segment
Speaker 215
1 segment
Speaker 117
1 segment