Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Education Committee

March 24, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (9)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1552 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1552”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1583 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1583”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1595 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1595”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1683 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1683”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1694 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1694”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1778 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1778”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1780 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1780”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1806 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1806”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1958 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1958”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Okay. Representative House around. He's standing right down there. Representative House, you are recognized to present House Bill 1552. Mr. Chair, if I could have just a moment to get up
▶ Play
Speaker 8 0:26
on the screen. Well, I told you it was going to be second, but we had a change of plan.
▶ Play
I have to do just a little bit of computer work, and I'll ask my guests. They're over here. They can kind of start drifting over. You need a copy of your bill? No, sir. I've got the screen up now. Okay. Let's make it sure. All right. Mr. Chair. members good morning house bill 1552 I think I have talked to all of you on an individual basis I hope that I have if I hadn't all I'll be very succinct our public schools do a great job with the severely disabled children I have no question about that the the amount of resources that they do dedicate just go a long ways. Our teachers are super. They're well-trained professionals and all that, but there are some kids, and every classroom teacher, every special education teacher, every therapist, every counselor will say the same thing. There are some kids that just can't work in a classroom education environment. They can be disruptive. They can be unresponsive, unreceptive, and no matter what they do, the child does not belong there. Those are the children that I'm targeting with 1552. About 12 other states have already adopted a version of this. Mississippi is considering it right now, and there are another dozen states that are considering it across the country. Let me tell you what this bill is not. First of all, it does not take a dime out of foundation funding. It will be separately budgeted beginning this fall in the fall budget hearings by the Department of Education. It will be heard in committee, and amounts will be considered for appropriation, and we'll go from there. The program will not start until a year from September. That's the school year beginning year 2016-2017. The Department of Education will provide such rules and regulations as outlined in the bill in order to properly administer the program. Funds will be transferred by electronic funds transfer to a private institution that provides the care for these particularly disabled students. Still have to meet all of the other constitutional guidelines to understand that parochial schools generally are not allowed in Arkansas unless some other things happen which are not really of concern to this bill. The whole idea of this program is to put the child in a public school for at least one year. Give the school, give the teachers, give the therapist a year to work with that child. Most of the time, they're going to have a successful individual education program, IEP, for that disabled child as defined by federal law, and they're going to be able to do a good job. But within a year, that teacher and those parents are going to be able to sit down and make a decision. And the final decision is going to rest with the parents. Can my child get an education in this environment? Academics may be totally out of the question. A classroom setting may be totally out of the question. And that parent may then decide that they will move their child out of the public school into a private institution for their learning program. There are a number of programs throughout the State, Aspire, Access, Jacksonville's Pathfinders, where they take care of autistic kids, where they take care of Down syndrome kids, where they take care of severely physically disabled children, and provide an individual educational experience, an individual academic or education environment that that child needs to thrive to the best of their ability. It actually becomes, as far as money is concerned, a net gain for the school system because those resources that were being expended on that child don't have to be. And the amount of money that the school would receive on behalf of the parents would be limited to an amount equal to the state foundation funding for that child. It would not come out of the foundation account, but a separately maintained account. So the net result is less money has to be spent on the child by the school. The parents get an opportunity to put their child in an environment that they believe is best for their child. It does not prohibit the child from going back to the public schools at some point in time if that becomes necessary. It does not require the parent to take the child out of the school. They can still insist under all the formalities of federal and state law that that school provide the greatest opportunity they can. But sometimes just saying we will provide that child what they need is not possible. and that's just a fact of life and so we want to reach out i want to reach out to try to help those kids and this is the best way that i've been able to come up are people going to game the system sure they will they're gaming the system now do the schools game the system sure they do they game it now they'll keep a child in an unhealthy environment in order for the money we've seen it happen y'all seen it happen we know it happens not very often thank god not very often because our schools and our teachers and our parents have these kids first in mind and that's what I'm hoping for. Other states experience the best one I can compare it to is Oklahoma. First year they did this they had 11 kids. Five years later they have less than 300. That's what we're talking about number wise. So I believe it's a good program. I think it's a good chance to help a bunch of kids that might not get any other help anywhere else and Mr. Chair I'll take questions or I'll introduce my guest and then receive your questions. If you'd like, go ahead and introduce
▶ Play
your guest and let them introduce yourself and who they're with, and then if there's a question that applies to them, they can answer it.
▶ Play
Speaker 19 7:05
Hi. My name is Tennille Stanger. My husband Greg's with me, and our two children are sitting in the back room. We have two adopted children that we adopted through DHS. Both are special needs. It has been a real struggle for us to find educational opportunities for our children. We have one daughter who attends Crystal Hill Elementary in the CBI classroom and is really doing well in this classroom. She started out in the REACH classroom. She's autistic, and she is intellectually disabled. Her IQ is around the 50s. She's 11 years old and cannot read or write. So she has done very well. The CBI room classroom teaches her how to do more daily skills. It teaches her how to write her name, her address, her phone number, but it also teaches her how to go to the grocery store store and shop for basic food that she might need when she becomes independent it teaches her how to do laundry teaches her how to kind of clean the house it still does teach her some of those educational things as well but it teaches her more of the things she's going to need in order to excel in life our other son is 13 and goes to malmell middle school and is in a learning classroom he's too high functioning for a cbi classroom but he can't be in the actual regular school setting and as of last week the school called us and informed us that it's still he's too high for the cbi class he's too low for the regular school so they're basically telling us they can't help us they basically have told us to either send him to a day treatment school or put him in residential care and for us that's not an option he's our son i don't want him in a residential care i want him in my home he's a great child he has learning disabilities he has other disabilities from being physically and sexually abused as a child that he's working through. So I don't think putting him somewhere else is the right answer. I think allowing us to have the opportunity to put him in a private school where he has smaller class sizes and can work more closely with the teacher is the better answer than just sending him
▶ Play
Speaker 23 9:08
somewhere else. So please, if you can, please
▶ Play
support this bill. Hi, my name is Kim Head. Let
▶ Play
Speaker 26 9:20
me tell you some of my background. I am a big proponent of public education. I fought for some other bills on that front, but I have a doctorate in physical therapy. I worked with children that have disabilities for eight years, and my own child was on an IEP. We decided to pull him out and homeschool him due to some of his difficulties and not being able to get him appropriately serviced where he was. He attended Aspire Christian Academy, so we were driving up and down the road from Conway two times a day for an hour because that's how important it was for us to get him the appropriate services. He did make great gains there, and we saw a lot of progress. He now is in a Christian school in Greenbrier, and we have seen a complete turnaround. He is doing amazing. My other son is also in a private school, and now I also work at a Catholic high school for boys and provide learning services to kids there. So I understand this from several angles, and I've heard from several parents that this is something that would really be good for their children to be serviced if they're not appropriately serviced in the public schools. Oh, yes. I do a grassroots movement non-profit called the Dyslexia Project, which has roughly 4,000 people in Arkansas that are actively participating in that. And I've received close to 300 e-mails, messages from parents telling me about the struggles that they have in getting appropriate services for their children. And I just feel like it's my duty to speak for them. And like I said, I'm a big advocate for public schools. I'm also a big advocate for any school that will provide services to a child. And I'm a teacher now. I changed my profession because I'm so passionate about this area.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, that concludes my presentation of this bill. All right. Are there any
▶ Play
questions from the committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized for questions. Thank you, Chairman Cousart. I sympathize and empathize with you. However, I'd like to know if there is going to be state funding for private education. Does the bill provide for any state regulation of that private education once the child is placed with state funds into a private institution as it is with the service, the places like Pathway? Yes, sir. I think it does. As well as I knew
▶ Play
how to write it, Mr. Representative, It does provide that the school will be accredited by an organization you'll see there, and I don't have the tablet to call it by name, or a similar organization approved by the Board of Education for the accreditation of the school. It says there is also a provision in there, I think, on the last or next to the last page that has to do with testing or providing the parent with some feedback. Since we're talking about kids with such diverse needs, it seems counterproductive to ask the state of Arkansas to go in and supervise each child, knowing that they're going into this environment with severe disabilities to begin with. And just as you heard, Ms. Stanger, you know, her little girl in the public school is just doing great. The little boy, his needs are going to be considerably different. So we're talking about those that fall outside the net.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Thank you. Representative House mentioned that the public schools do a good job with respect to handicapped children and I don't know if there's a foundation for that I don't know that anybody does a good job really for handicapped children even the places like Pathfinder you're trying Representative House, you're trying to cause more attention to be brought to this subject and to have better options for providing good service for students with disabilities, better services than they are now receiving? Yes, sir, and
▶ Play
I swore I wouldn't get upset. My little grandson is nine years old. He just got recognized He goes to school at Cabot. He was recognized for a good citizenship award because there's a little autistic boy. And he takes care of that little fellow. He gets his backpack and gets him to lunch and watches after him on the playground. And that little guy, he'd fight a buzzsaw and a heartbeat if anybody picked on that little boy. He'll turn the cheek until his head looks like it's on a rolling pin. But when one of those other kids challenge that little fellow, he'll light into them. And, you know, he's really kind of the inspiration because he cares about those kids. And he gets it from his daddy and he gets it from his great-grandpa, probably skipped me somewhat, and his great-grandfather above that. But, yes, sir, that's what I want to see. I want to see all these kids get the very best. and sometimes in the schools because they've got so many and they can only do so much and I know that Ms. Stanger will attest to that, they're left with the option of suing the school in order to get what the law says they have to do and that's really not a thank you for the amens over there ladies God
▶ Play
bless you, thank you If nobody else has a question I have a
▶ Play
bunch of them Thank you very much For Reverend Balts, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 16:21
Representative House, nobody's more sensitive than
▶ Play
myself to these young people. We have a center, the Donnie Martin Center in Pocahontas. They have some students from Sloan Hendricks and from Pocahontas. they give them so much money does every school do that for these kids and these ladies can probably attest quicker and better and
▶ Play
more accurately than i can but there was one particular lady that i'd hope to be here and she's taking care of her autistic granddaughter due to spring break and couldn't come but they they have cake sales and auctions and car washes and everything else to raise the money to do what they need to do and when she As a matter of fact, she said I'll use her title. She's CEO at Telephone Company Employees Credit Union. And she said they just really struggled to raise enough money to keep their little private school going. So it's a struggle. $6,800, $6,600 is what we're talking about next year. That's nothing,
▶ Play
but it would sure help those
▶ Play
folks. Follow-up. I know Flynn Hendricks, I believe they do like $20,000. for three students or something like that, you know, which is good. And just wanted to know if all schools did, you know, tried to help or not. You know, you've got
▶ Play
some that have got benefactors that get a lot of money, too. I can't speak to everyone, but I know that so many of them struggle just to do what they can do. Representative Murdoch, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. thank you chairman thank you representative house and appreciate you for coming by and visiting with me on this yesterday and i think it's very very important um what you're trying to achieve i think so many times we have to go through a process to get to it so inside the bill there are some things that are concerning not what you want to do with kids getting the services that they need We all want that. But at the same time, we have to make sure that the legislation has the integrity that's necessary so that we don't hurt anything else and it may be unattended. So who decides? Now, there's some determination made that the child is not getting the services in the school that is in, and you want them to have the choice to go to somewhere else to get those services. Who decides that? Bottom
▶ Play
line, parent makes the final decision. After one year, being in that school for one year and working with those teachers in that school and letting the school do the very best they can, and then I would envision that if they feel like they're doing all that can be done, that they would sit down with that parent. And there's some notice requirements, 60 days notice and things like that. But in the final analysis, who's responsible for that child? And that's the parents. they would make the final decision whether to
▶ Play
pull that child out and accept the scholarship funding. Okay, and the last follow-up, and I think Representative Walker went there earlier, the accountability as we try to be responsible for the dollars that are spent, so when those dollars are sent from the public to whatever institution, there has to be some level of accountability, And I think that the bill, and it may address it somewhere, and that's why I'm asking you, how that is accounted for. You know, if we're going to spend it and we make a choice to spend it, so far we have not done this. If we start making choices to do that or when we do that, there should be a mechanism of accountability for that. That's not saying don't do it, but what I'm trying to make sure that there's a mechanism to account for what is being done, because when we send that money out, we need to make sure that those services are being properly done in an accountable fashion by approved people, approved institutions, et cetera, just accountability. What do you say about that? There are two
▶ Play
provisions in this bill that I came up with that I think that give us, the state taxpayers' representatives, accountability. Number one, the payments will be made on a monthly basis. If a parent becomes dissatisfied with the services they're receiving, and they can pull that child out. That's number one. The second way it's accountable, the scholarship recipient, which is actually the private school, will have to account to the state of Arkansas for the attendance of that child. Now, exactly what services are being rendered a particular child, I wasn't smart enough to craft that kind of language without just regulating them like you would the regular public school. And then we're going to eat up all of the scholarship money an additional overhead is what would happen. So that's the best ways I knew to come up
▶ Play
with it. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. How do we guard against if someone is just wanting to get into a private situation, they can't afford it because it's their choice, a parent's individual choice, is what you're saying, and they just say, okay, I'm not happy with the services. I want to get into this private situation anyway. I can't afford it, so I'm going to make this election. How is the state and the public school protected from that? Now, again, we're not arguing about services now. We're talking about, okay, how is it?
▶ Play
You don't, and that's an honest answer. That's game in the system. And I said I'm not going to tell you that somebody's not going to game the system. And they can, and they do now. But here's what I'm thinking. You're getting generally the best education you can get for your children in the public school or in one of the bigger private schools, and the money involved. So $6,800 in a top-flight academic institution, such as Catholic High, or we'll just stick with that one, is rather expensive. And so it doesn't seem realistic that a parent would pull their child out of a public school that has this entire range of services to put them in an institution where they're only going to get paid $6,800 a year for whatever services they do get. The market tells me that that really wouldn't be a smart option. Could somebody do it? Yes, I suppose they could, but I'm counting on the teachers to convince that parent that leaving their child in that public school and that situation is the better thing for their child, and I think it is in most cases if somebody
▶ Play
wanted to do that. Yes, sir. Representative Ratliff, did you
▶ Play
have a question? Representative Walker, you're welcome for another question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My concern is that really nobody really wants to do anything to help disabled children. You know, they're the ones who are more or less the last to be served. And I'm concerned that somehow or another there'll be better focus in the public schools in whatever private schools may receive public funds about actually delivering services to the students rather than simply providing funds. And I don't know that your bill does that. Maybe it's a good first start, but I have real reservations about it for that reason. There's just been... I'd like to ask Representative, I mean, Mr. Hernandez, perhaps the commissioner, a question about that because I don't, and it goes to the State Department's stance on this. Well, if I could
▶ Play
still have the table, I think I can address your question in this fashion. Florida had the same question. What they found out is that when they began to let some kids go into the private schools, they had an overall increase in the quality and quantity of services provided to their special education kids who remained in the public school, and I think you invite competition in that situation where somebody says rather than tens of thousands of dollars being spent in the public schools, I can take $6,800 in the private and get better service. I think that's some of the market force involved. That's speculation, but they did find a better quality and quantity of service in Florida after they instituted this program a number of years ago.
▶ Play
I'd like to know, Dr. Hernandez's position, if you're speaking for the department, with respect to shifting funds from public schools to private schools which are unregulated. It just says private. It doesn't say charter. It doesn't say parochial. It says private. But shifting to private schools which are unregulated, which may or may not have a track record of delivery of services at the whim of a parent or the will of a parent, what's the position of the department on that?
▶ Play
Do you know? My name is Department of Education. Representative Walker, we have no position on the bill, but I did want to go back and clarify. There was some question earlier about the money that flows to public schools that end up going to private schools. And there were questions about donations and things like that. There is a required amount of set-aside funds in Title VI and title monies that go in federal dollars that if it's a private school that's serving kids from a resident district, that that money flows to them for those purposes.
▶ Play
So this $6,000 would be in addition to that? It would be my understanding that would be so. So if we approve this bill, then we're approving maybe $13,000 to $14,000 per student to a private school? I don't know
▶ Play
if that amount is accurate, but there is an additional amount of federal funds that do go to
▶ Play
Speaker 87 26:32
the private schools for purposes of services of these kids.
▶ Play
Follow-up question, and that goes wherever the child goes? Yes, sir. If they're disabled under the federal definition.
▶ Play
It's the kids' money, right? It just flows through the state, but it actually follows the
▶ Play
child wherever they go. That's my understanding. Thank you. Representative Murdoch, you're recognized for a question. Mr. Hernandez, on that same line, so as that money flows out to the private institutions, I know in public charges there is some accountability, but in private institutions, if we vote to do this and pass this, then you have no way of knowing what happens after it leaves us. In this case, is there any trailing accountability from a federal standpoint? Because there's a lot of federal dollars that we get into the state of Arkansas. So are we okay, allowed to let that go out without accountability? From
▶ Play
the state perspective, my understanding in this bill, and I may have read it incorrectly, but it states in there that the school districts that are approved by the department to be able to participate have to meet the standards of accreditation. And if you've looked at the standards of accreditation, that's a pretty lengthy document, but it sounds like it tasks us with treating a private school in much the same manner, and that's the required 38 certified teachers, I mean, the whole gamut of accountability. Okay, so there
▶ Play
is going to be accountability, as you understand it, for where this is going to. So they're going to be held under that same standard, or at least that standard of delivery
▶ Play
and service. Is that correct? Debbie Jones, Assistant Commissioner for Learning Services. Either the standards by which public schools are held or private school accreditation association. For example, ANSA. The state board does have to approve which accreditation body that they will use. The difference being ANSA, you may have a child going to a private institution, and ANSA will provide accreditation to that institution, sometimes in the cases where the teachers aren't certified. So it's different. It's a different accreditation body, but they will have some type of accreditation association approved by the State Board of Education.
▶ Play
Thank you. Just to follow up, when you asked me about accountability, I thought you were talking about tracking money. When you talk about standards, absolutely. They've got to meet some pretty tough standards. Talking to an administrator yesterday, they said that really one of the biggest problems they had in getting the standards is just not having enough money to get some of the facilities and things, that this would help them meet those standards if they knew that they could get a little boost. Otherwise, they were at bare bones on money. So thank you. I appreciate the question. Representative
▶ Play
House, is there any transportation money involved in this, or does that flow in that same money? They're responsible for transferring them. Okay. That was a question the chair and the vice chair had up here. So, is there any other questions on the committee? Mr. Brant, Mr. Gray has questions. I'm seeing you.
▶ Play
Representative Gray, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative House, forgive me, because I think it's a really big step here. that you're taking and absolutely respect the cause behind it. So forgive me if this is somewhat repetitive, but can you address the concern that if we're looking for an opportunity to help find funding to assist these children to go to schools, would you address the concern? Why wouldn't we just find funding to help our public schools have better programs to address children with these issues?
▶ Play
Speaker 19 30:28
If you don't mind, I'm going to ask Ms. Stanger to answer your question because she's experienced in that. A lot of times you're kind of put through the loop and you have to go around and around and around. With our son, he just can't function in the larger classroom. So a private school has a lot smaller classrooms. It's really hard for the public school to have less than 28 or more in a classroom. So that is not really good for him.
▶ Play
Speaker 88 30:59
What were you really – go ahead. But if you ask them to do something and
▶ Play
Speaker 19 31:05
they don't do it, then what happens? Yeah, if you ask them to do something and they don't do it, then normally it leads to a bad situation. We, when we put our son into the mom-in-the-middle, we set him down with very straightforward and said, look, we've lived with him for eight years. We know what's going to happen. These are the guidelines. This is what's in his IEP. This is what we need you to follow in order for his safety, your safety, and for him to be able to learn, and it just kind of went by the wayside. So we've had numerous follow-up IEP meetings, and we'll be having another one next week to discuss this is what needs to take place. And unfortunately, you know, the parents are with those kids, and we know what our children need in the school system to be successful in the school system. And just going and going and meeting with them, a lot of times they'll say, we just don't have the funding, we don't have the needs, we don't have the means, we don't know how to handle this. Our son has reactive attachment disorder. nobody understands how to handle that and it's not the same for every single child every child reacts differently to a different treatment for that so it just makes it more difficult i think a lot of the bullying that's going on in the public schools that's been one of our main concerns with our son last week he got beat up because he is different and so just dealing with some of those issues where it is a smaller classroom you're taking them away from some of the other children who have some of those same issues and you're allowing them to function in a loving and more nurturing environment necessarily probably in the public schools um it would just be more beneficial for him thank you mr chair thank you representative house thank you represent walker you recognize yes
▶ Play
i'm concerned though it just giving it to the parent's option because if a parent just doesn't like a situation or a teacher or whatever then the parent at will can just take this child not from one school, but to many schools that are private, and at least with the public school, you have some protections. You have the right to appeal adverse decisions. You don't have that right in a private school situation. You can go through the Department of Education, if I'm not mistaken, Dr. Hernandez. There's a special ed appeal procedure protocol, and the objective is for this to be decision that's made by professional persons in consultation with each other so that the due process rights and the substantive educational rights of the children can be protected and realized. And this means that sometimes some parents don't make the right decision, even though these two will. But they may not be fully informed. It may just be something that's on an uninformed basis rather than an informed basis. And I think that you have to have a reference to some protective situation for the child. Remember in the courts, the courts do not let parents make these decisions by themselves. They have attorneys ad litem and others to help protect the interest of the children because in all due respect to parents with disabled children, it's a problem for them, too, because they don't have the answers either in many cases. So I'm really, Representative House, in all due respect to you, troubled about this. I'm not convinced that a quick fix like this is in the best interest of the children, and even though it could be done on a limited basis for these particular parents, I don't know that for the students statewide it's in their best interest to do it with this particular bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 26 34:43
Yes, sir. Respectfully, I've come across many parents and been involved with many parents from all different backgrounds, educational experiences, severity levels of the disability, and the opposite is what I have seen to be true. The parents that are most involved are the ones that would go for something like this, and they would look at all of the options, and they would have meetings, and they would be very involved in their child's education and they would want the very best for them. I struggle more with the ones that would not be able to decipher all of those things out for their children. If their children was in a situation where they would proceed through this process and this paperwork and go through the avenues necessary to take them out of that environment, those would be the parents that I would be more concerned with, not the ones that are very involved and educated and involved with getting them out of that environment and putting them into a better situation.
▶ Play
Speaker 19 35:52
We have had an experience with the appeals process, and we've actually had Jenny Dunn from the Special Education Department of Pulaski County at our IEP meetings, and she was there to set up our son's IEP,
▶ Play
which is not working. Well, that's not the appeal procedure. If you have that, if it's not working, then your review is with Dr. Hernandez and the Department of Education. Because if the county is not performing its duty as expected, then there should be a review by the Department of Education.
▶ Play
Is that the protocol, Dr. Hernandez? Eventually, that is part of due process. Should the appeal not be satisfied to the parents at the school level, then yes, they can appeal to the special ed unit at the Department of Ed. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Murdoch, you recognize me. Thank you. I just wanted to join that conversation because of what the young lady on my left said that talked about the involved parents that could make that decision. I'm having trouble giving all of that decision because so many times Children with disabilities and with problems, severe, very severe problems, don't have parents with the wherewithal. But what this bill opens up is for possibly Representative House, even those that, to be honest with you, don't have the background, don't have the knowledge, and they'll start making choices I'm fearful of sometime that may not be in the best interest of the child but may be some other reason. I know many times people, grown people make decisions that negatively affect their children sometimes, and it may not even be on purpose, maybe because of their capacity. So when we say now that the only trigger is a parent making a choice, that concerns me. Well, if you look over at the public school situation through the appealant situation and even the designation of the plan that these children with disabilities are placed on, there is inclusion. There is inclusion from the professionals, the principal, sometimes even outside associations. But now with this, if I'm understanding it correctly, Representative House, it's just the parent. And so many times the parent may not be like those parents that are at the end of the table. Many times they're not. I'm trying to answer your
▶ Play
question. No, sir, you don't understand it correctly. Okay. Because if you look at the process, they have to give the school 60 days notice. They have to sign waivers to the school and to the state. They have to find a private school that will take them. They have to apply for the scholarship money. You're talking about a level of sophistication that's somewhat about that. Yours and Representative Walker's arguments are essentially strawmans. What if somebody? I'm not going to tell you that there's not somebody that couldn't do that, But you're going to talk about involving yourself now in private transportation, private involvement in that school, personal involvement in that private school. I don't think that that is a very likely scenario, but I won't sit here and tell you that nobody won't do it. And you've got to get the school to take you. And if you try bouncing around from school to school to school, go and drive in different distances, you've got kids scattered all over that are not disabled, I just don't think it's a very likely scenario that the straw man argument stands up to. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 94 39:16
you, and I appreciate your patience, Representative House. Representative
▶ Play
Harris, let me just make a statement. We've been 45 minutes on one bill. I have two pages of bills to do today, guys, or whatever we do, and we're going straight down this order. If we can hurry the process up, I don't want to leave anything out. I don't want to miss anything, but I would like to try to move things along a little faster if we could.
▶ Play
Representative Harris, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative House, just to make it clear that these private schools, I know the one in particular that we attend, they have certified staff and certified people that come in and deal with children with special needs. Is that not correct? Well, I meant typically even like at the St. Joseph that we have in Fayetteville and different ones. They have certified staff members. I refer to the
▶ Play
answer that they all gave a while ago about the accreditation process. Yes, they have to have a level of standard that has to be met under the State Board of Education in order to receive the money. I think that answers your question. Okay, thank you. Rebson Walker, if you
▶ Play
could keep it short, you've asked a lot of questions. We do need to move
▶ Play
on. Well, I appreciate it. I'm just not content with leaving this to the parent. And even though I'll probably vote for your bill, I want you to know that so many times in special ed, children become eligible for benefits because of the designation. And those children may be able to get checks because a parent chooses to leave the child within the designation. That's a parental decision that's based on a balancing decision of the parent to keep the check or to keep the kid in special ed. And I just hate to take the premise that every parent is going to do what's in the best interest, educational interest of the child, as something that's etched in stone. I think people make balanced judgments based on their needs at a particular time. So I just have to say that, but thank you very much, Mr. Chair. All right. Seeing
▶ Play
no other questions, committee, I have already had one speak for. I'm going to – Richard Hutchison, are you here? You're welcome to speak – recognize to speak against the bill. You can. Oh, we won't stop. State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized to speak against the
▶ Play
Speaker 126 42:08
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Richard Hutchinson. I'm here representing the Arkansas Citizens First Congress, the Arkansas Public Policy Panel. While we understand the issues that are involved in this and the reasons that have been given why this would be a policy decision that the state should make, we don't believe it is at this point. We believe that there are procedures, methodology that are built in place under IDEA and also the Arkansas special education law that ensure that when parties agree at the local school level that the program that the child needs in the IEP requires going to a private institution, that you can do that if it's covered under the IEP. And if it's not covered under the IEP and the parent wishes it to be, they can appeal that decision not only to the State Department, which was mentioned earlier, but there's also an appeal procedure built into IDEA, which ensures that objective third-party mediators can be brought in to make decisions about the proper placement of students. For those reasons, we do not support the bill. Thank you. Seeing no questions. He has spoken
▶ Play
against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Against the bill. Against the bill? Against the Dr. Abernathy. Dr. Abernathy, you are recognized to announce yourself and who you're with, and you are recognized to speak
▶ Play
Speaker 131 43:44
against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA, and we certainly thank Representative House for bringing this issue forward, then it does pull at your heartstrings when he brings these issues to your attention. And I do want to point out a couple of things, you know, because we are talking about extending state money to private schools, which is not constitutionally mandated, and so it throws little different requirements on this. If you look over on page 2, and it actually starts on page 1, line 36, but it's talking about the eligibility of students. And sometimes when we're having some of these discussions, we're thinking in our minds, severely disabled children. And if you look at the eligibility, you see that there's many learning disabilities that requires a school and parent team to draw up an IEP. And I'll give you an example. Lots of kids, when they enter school, they have speech issues. And so they have an IEP drawn up to take care of speech issues. Typically, they are trained and taught and grow out of that. and so they're no longer identified. But the pool of candidates may be much broader than this body may take a look at. If you look down at the bottom of page two, we're talking about meeting the standards for accreditation. At first we saw that and said, well, you're going to make the standards accreditation with the state board, but you can see the other standards on there are a little more open than that. And, of course, it brings up the issue that's been brought up here about the use of certified teachers or lack thereof. When it's talking about the financial stability, starting on page 2, line 35, you know, physical soundness of having been in operation for one year or providing the department with a statement by a CPA that says they can financially meet the requirements. I'm not sure how many additional private schools may pop up with that particular CPA endorsement. So that may be something you want to consider. It was brought up about Oklahoma's plan, and, of course, this representative house, it is based off Oklahoma's plan. I believe he said it's been in place for four to five years. That plan is also in the court system right now. Brought up about transportation, and granted, private schools will not have to offer transportation, but at the same time, transportation is part of foundation funding. that you might want to take a look at. If you look over on page 5, line 33, when we're talking about accountability on the curriculum end of it, you can see the curriculum education plan for students with disabilities attending private schools is not subject to regulatory authority. So we're not sure what they would be teaching or what program they would be teaching. But with that and the potential physical impact on the state, obviously we're opposed to this bill. Perfect three minutes. All right.
▶ Play
Anyone like to speak for the bill, against the bill? Three minutes.
▶ Play
Without objection, three minutes. It'll be less than two minutes. We appreciate Tony Prothrow,
▶ Play
Speaker 136 47:08
Director of the Arkansas School Board Association. We appreciate Representative House. He's made several amendments on this bill, and no one would doubt his passion for the children that are contained within this bill. We have some of the same concerns, and I will not be repetitive, but a lot of discussion has been about students with severe disabilities, and once again, there is no definition for severely disabled within this. And admittedly, there are worries that this could be abused in some instances. Also, there was a lot of discussion about schools that are highly specialized in taking care of this student population. But this bill allows for any private school to be able to take care of these students. In most cases, when we talk about students that are severely disabled, the cost for those students greatly exceeds $6,500. dollars. You're looking at, in many cases, over $20,000 that may be needed, nurse care, other things that are needed for a lot of these students. And in that regard, the worry is that with this limit, when we're here for all kids, is this going to limit some parents' ability to be able to make this choice? We're talking about a lot of choice around the table, but who are we talking about choice for? It may not be choice for a lot of our parents that are out there that can't afford some of these services. Also, the only requirement for the teachers in the private school is that they have a baccalaureate or a higher degree. The kids that, when we look at severely disabled, it is very specialized in training that they receive, and there's no stipulation for this in the bill. Also, there's no mention at all going to a private school. It may be far-fetched, but at the same time, we would worry about people being employed that do not have any type of background or maltreatment checks you have these kids are the most vulnerable that may be going to some of these schools and once again you're only looking at an accredited private school that would that that could be in existence now or in the future thank you mr.
▶ Play
chair thank you anyone for the bill nobody against the bill against the bill anyone not seeing any more are you against the bill Okay. I'm sorry. I didn't know what you were standing up here looking at me for.
▶ Play
I thought you just liked to look at me, Rich.
▶ Play
State your name and who
▶ Play
Speaker 141 49:43
you're with, and you're recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Rich Nagel, the Arkansas Education Association. That was the first mistake you made this session, Representative Kosar. Just generally, I won't try to repeat things that have already been said, but I think, first of all, the bill is drafted far too broadly for any student with an IEP. As a matter of policy, I think we're reminded that the general rule, that it's best for students to be in the least restrictive environment, And this bill, in our view, allows far too many students to go to a more restrictive environment. Lastly, there's little or no accountability on how these funds will be spent. For those reasons, we oppose the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, sir. Is anyone for the bill, against the bill? I think we're done. Would
▶ Play
you like to close for your bill? Yes, sir, I do. Representative Gossage asked me to touch on the finance just to make sure that's clear. It will be a separately budgeted item that will be considered beginning in the budget hearings this fall. It will then be considered for funding in January. The first funds that would be dispersed would not begin until August or September of 2016, next year. That's how the funding will not come out of foundation funding. It does not take a dime out of the school foundation funding amounts, and it's a separately budgeted item. In the big scheme of the other thing, I do appreciate the three gentlemen that all came and talked to me. I made changes in this bill based on their concrete suggestions. I told them very frankly, I don't know how to draft good judgment and good decisions. But the question is, who knows best for their children, the schools or the parents they're both important the schools are wonderful I'm a big supporter of public schools wife's retired school teacher but when we deal with a little boy and a little girl like standing right over there in that corner that needs something else give those parents the option to go where they think and they believe and they study where's the best need for their children And that's what I'm asking this legislature to do. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. What's
▶ Play
the will of the committee? Representative Hodges, you are recognized?
▶ Play
I move, do pass. I have a do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you have passed your bill. At this time, I would like to make an announcement in the audience with us today. We have some exchange students that are at Cotter High School at this time, and I'm going to recognize Superintendent Don Sharp to tell me who these are and have them stand up for us. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Speaker 148 52:52
Today I have our high school principal, Amanda Britt, and this is Britt has brought two exchange students, Chiara Dario from Italy. Chiara, please stand up. Did I pronounce it correctly? and also Yuri Yu from China well we welcome you and hope
▶ Play
you have enjoyed the show so far and it's going to get better Representative Gossage you are recognized to present House Bill 1583 thank you mr. chair before you get started on any testimony for and against from now on through the rest of the day we will have three minutes per side of a three minutes per person i'm sorry i won't do it per side but three when you testify for or against out of the audience three You have three minutes, without objection from the committee. Thank you. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 157 54:00
Chair. I was approached several times over the last couple of years to introduce legislation similar to this. School resource officers were not identified in Arkansas Code, actually, a definition from them, which was a surprise to me, so we added that at the beginning. But basically, school resource officers work at the school, but they're actually employed by the city or the county, and they can do anything else that any other police officer can do. But what they are often asked to do is travel with a group from their school district across the state. And many times in those travels, things happen. And since they've traveled outside their jurisdiction, They do not have the ability to issue a citation while traveling with whatever group they're traveling with. All this bill does, it does not expand the scope of their duties. It just includes extra jurisdiction, I guess you would say, to issue those citations. What would often happen is they're traveling along interstate or wherever they may be across the state. An incident happens. Under current Arkansas law, they have to call the local police department. They have to wait and hope that someone's able to answer the call. They've got the students and whoever else is traveling with them waiting for local police department to attend to the situation. All this bill does is it allows them to issue that citation, which will be adjudicated in the jurisdiction in which the incident happened. It will not change that. So, to me, it's just a practical consideration. It explains the scope of the duties, beginning on page two, talks about what would have to happen for the resource officer to perform those duties. So, with that, I'll take any questions. I'm just making
▶ Play
my hand up a little longer
▶ Play
Representative Walker you're recognized Thank you Representative Gossett for this bill I don't understand why a resource officer is going to be accompanying children on a field trip but my question becomes may he issue a citation to the students if they get into a fight on the bus and then cause let's assume a student comes from what's your district? Ozark is one of my districts let's assume it's Ozark and he comes to Little Rock and while on the bus in Little Rock the resource office is there two students, 8th grade students get into a fight and the resource officer issues a citation and that means that the students upon the citation would have to come back to Little Rock so would the resource officer to answer the citation, is that correct? That is correct. So that puts a real hardship not only upon the students but upon the situation. I'm just trying to understand why you would give the resource officer that power to one, well, can you answer that question? Why would you give the officers that power, especially if there's a fight worthy or some other event worthy of a fence? You'll have an officer in any county or any city able to make the arrest. I understand timing may be a concern, but you're going to create more time by having the person be in a position to have to come back from Ozark, in my hypothetical, to Lira.
▶ Play
Speaker 157 57:52
Well, certainly if there's an officer standing there in your case, in your situation in Little Rock, I guess they could issue the citation, but that really wouldn't change anything. The students would have to come back to Little Rock if a local officer issued that same citation. Basically, it would be left up just like it always is to the discretion of the officer, whether the offense that occurred is worthy of issuing that citation under the circumstances. and the kinds of things that happen on school trips run the gamut. Most of them are going to be misdemeanors, of course, and that's why the citation of the officer would already have authority if he witnessed a felony to make an arrest. That's already under Arkansas law. But, again, there's a whole range of things, minor in possession, fights, vandalism. Again, you just have to rely, as the representative of the House just said, you can't if someone uses bad judgment that certainly could happen but we hope that's not the case follow up
▶ Play
follow up yes sir and on the last page of the bill it reads if the person who is to receive the citation refuses to sign the citation the school resource officer is required to arrest the person and deliver him or her to the local law enforcement agency having jurisdiction So in my hypothetical, students have a fight from Ozark and then Little Rock. Then the person refuses to sign, the eighth-grade kid refuses to sign the citation. Then the officer is required then to turn the kid over to a local law enforcement under arrest?
▶ Play
Speaker 157 59:34
Yes, sir, just like the officer that would be in Little Rock who was on duty and represented Little Rock. I mean, it would be the identical situation.
▶ Play
I'm totally uncomfortable with police officers having that kind of power over kids. But they do already, Mr. Paul. Not really. I mean, school resource officers are limited in what they can do. They
▶ Play
Speaker 168 59:53
don't have the same. In what way are they limited? Well, they first of
▶ Play
all have to follow the school rules as a part of the compact that they have with the school district. School rules predominate over the city rules. Just because two kids have a fight, first, second, third, or fourth grade, that does not rise to the level of it being a criminal offense. Well, if that is the case, then
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:00:15
they would follow that same role while they're in Little Rock. Well,
▶ Play
but under your rule, it gives them much more authority. Under this, it gives them much more authority. I am totally opposed to this, and I will try to get a roll call if necessary. Representative
▶ Play
Walker is finished. Does anyone else like to have a question? Representative Deffenbaugh, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative
▶ Play
Gossage, I'll put it in the form of a question. Wouldn't you think that – I know how school trips can be. So wouldn't you think that having more authority on that bus, let's say it's like a long trip, would actually enhance the ability for the adults to control the youngsters, because I know things can get out of hand, and it just seems like the more authority you have, the better off you are on controlling your students. Would
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:01:22
you agree with that? I would agree with that, Representative Deffenbaugh. I think you and I come from a similar line of thought, and I think the same line of thought that Representative Walker has. I'm not interested in sending young people to jail or any of those sorts of things, but we all know that from time to time for the safety of students and because of situations that occasionally arise on trips, you may be out in the boondocks. I mean, you may not be traveling through town when these incidents occur. You may have stopped at a store off the way. It may be a substantial distance to whoever the closest police officer were. And these things, again, are not going to happen very often. It gives them the opportunity to issue a citation, which, again, they already have that authority in Arkansas. It just gives them the opportunity when
▶ Play
they're traveling with their students. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Are there any other questions, committee? I'm passionate about this issue so I want to be heard again are you aware I'm sorry you are now recognized thank you very much are you aware that in Pulaski County especially in in the schools Maumelle Jacksonville and the other communities Sherwood where you have resource officers. They use their police authority to arrest children and put them in the judicial system for things as little as fights to the chagrin of the judges who have to hear those things. And they basically are black boys. Are you aware of that?
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:03:13
No, I'm not particularly aware of
▶ Play
the situation in Little Rock. The opportunity for discrimination is very evident. And part of the path to prison begins with the resource offices exceeding the authority of the school in their rules. So have you thought about that in presenting
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:03:35
this bill? Yes, Representative Walker. You had spoken to me earlier about your concern about young African Americans being disproportionately arrested and charged with crimes and having jail time, and I share your concerns about that. But this gives them more opportunity. Thank you. No, sir, it does not give them more opportunities to do that. I would disagree with that. If there's a problem in your local school district with the way that situations are being handled and that you disagree with that, you know, I don't know what happens in Little Rock. I can't say. I'm only here part of the time. But I certainly would make my voice known to my local school board, my local school administrators if I were unhappy with that. I understand that, but I'm telling you what I would do, and I certainly understand your concerns and certainly don't want to. Injustice is not what I'm seeking here. Representative Gossage. This doesn't change the offense that's going to happen
▶ Play
or the way it's going to. The only thing it does is just shorten the time period of it happening the way it's handled.
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:04:59
Is that correctly? That would be correct. Again, under the scenario that we had posed to us, instead of the Ozark officer issuing or not issuing the citation, we would leave it up, I guess, to the Little Rock police officers to issue the citation. It doesn't change the ability for the citation to be done. It just allows the officer that's traveling with the group to do the same thing that a local officer can do. Are there any other questions?
▶ Play
Seeing none of the committee, I have Paul Kelly to speak against the bill. State your name and who you're with, and you're
▶ Play
recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Paul Kelly. I'm the Senior Policy Analyst at Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. We oppose House Bill 1583 because it provides yet another way to encourage school resource officers to force juvenile courts to intervene in school discipline problems that are better addressed by the school. What is now being called the school-to-prison pipeline arose because of a combination of zero-tolerant school discipline policies and an increase in the number of school resource officers in schools across the country, including Arkansas, where some juvenile judges now report that one-third of their cases are coming from schools. This school-to-prison pipeline has become so widespread that the U.S. Department of Education and the Department of Justice recently issued a joint report providing guidelines and principles that include the following. Principle, ensure that any school-based law enforcement officer's role focuses on school safety and reducing inappropriate referrals to law enforcement. A quote, it is important that schools recognize that any arrest or referrals to law enforcement can have negative collateral consequences for students and that students of color and students with disabilities may experience disproportionate contact with law enforcement in the justice system these officers roles are to focus on protecting the physical safety or preventing criminal conduct of persons other than students students schools should ensure that school-based resource officers not become involved in routine school discipline matters So why do I call them routine school discipline matters? We've been, Arkansas Advocate has been charting and spotlighting school arrests for over four years. We've found that schools, one, are not required, nor do they, track the number of arrests or citations issued at schools. You have 30 seconds. The Arkansas Crime Information Center is currently the only state agency that tracks that. We are arresting 6,000 kids a year at schools for two things, simple assault, which is a physical altercation that involves no weapons and no injuries, or intimidation, which is bullying. This legislation extends the practice. Your time is up. You need to
▶ Play
close quickly. I'll give you 10 seconds.
▶ Play
All right. This is not good public policy. It gives new authority outside their jurisdictions to participate in practices that are detrimental and unnecessary to students' behaviors at school. Thank you for your testimony. Is there anyone who would like to
▶ Play
speak for the bill? You are recognized This is it
▶ Play
Speaker 131 1:09:21
Thank you Mr. Chair, Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA And we do support this legislation We've had resource officers go to various events for several years And the parents expect it The kids expect it And it does create a little safety environment for those trips and our resource officer has always just kind of been considered part of the
▶ Play
staff. Thank you. Anybody against the bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 200 1:09:52
I'm not going to speak. I just want to record the public
▶ Play
policy panel. Okay. Anyone for the bill? Seeing no more. Would you
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:10:04
like a close for your bill? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I always attempt to work my bills before I run them. Neither of the folks who just said they didn't support the bill had spoken to me before coming to the table. I hope in the future that they will. Representative Walker, I certainly heard what you had to say, and I'd always be willing to work with you on any initiative we could to address your concerns because I would have the same concerns. However, as I said, I think this is a practical application to a situation we have. The students can already be arrested by the local authorities. This isn't changing anything about whether they can or cannot be arrested or what's going to happen to them. It just allows the authority of an officer traveling with a school to issue a citation for a misdemeanor. I would appreciate a good vote. Representative Balch, do you recognize? Motion do
▶ Play
pass. Yes, sir. I have a motion do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, no.
▶ Play
Speaker 203 1:11:12
No. Rule to call. Rule is yes, sir. I
▶ Play
have a rule to call yet, but it is. I do call it yes. I only see one hand. I only see one hand. Representative Walker, you are a roll call king
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:11:31
Representative Letting Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:11:41
Letting Representative Murdoch Representative Murdoch Representative Deffenbaugh Representative Harris Representative Eubanks Representative Eubanks Representative Ratliff Representative Gillum Representative Gillum Representative Walker Representative Bell Representative Balz Representative Douglas Representative Lowry Representative McElroy Representative Armstrong Representative Armstrong Representative Gossage Representative Sabin Representative Sabin Representative Hodges Representative Gray Representative Gray Representative Lampkin Representative Lampkin Congratulations, you have passed your bill What was the roll? Ten
▶ Play
to two, sir. Ten to two. You know? I'm ready. You want to do it? Okay. Representative Douglas, you are recognized to present your bills, two of them, if you want. One or two, however. Two, okay. First off will be House Bill 1595. We are going to try to go to 12 o'clock today and print as many bills as we can get in the next 40 minutes, and then we will come back after session, 15 minutes upon adjournment. It should be around 4 or 4.15.
▶ Play
Thank you, committee. This bill, 1595, is what I call a 360 survey bill. As a part of a district's school improvement plan every year, they have to make decisions about what kind of performance objectives they're going to write into their performance plan for the next year. And I'm seeing that there would be a need statewide for us to have some common way to survey a community about what those needs are. This bill would provide for what I'm calling a 360 survey that would allow students, teachers, community, businesses, administrators, everybody to participate in a survey. It's not an evaluation at all. And then that information would become part of the ACCEP plan, and they can base performance objectives on that for the next year. then those would be measurable and I think it's a good way to drive improvement into a district before things get desperate and they have to go on improvement so I think it's a it's an improvement to the improvement plan so I would answer your questions if you have those questions from the committee represent back roll you
▶ Play
have a question in this it starts out with
▶ Play
require and I know I'm here loud and clear from my teachers at home that they don't have time to teach for us requiring them to do so many things. Who does it require specifically, I guess, my question? Well,
▶ Play
a lot of districts right now already have surveys that they put out to the community in order to get information back. So this is not a new concept. this would just put a platform out there that would be consistent statewide and the teachers the only responsibility they would have would be to answer their own survey which you know is not going to be you know a huge time and I think they will want to do this because it will give them a voice in you know what improvements
▶ Play
Speaker 215 1:16:04
they think are needed in the school Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative
▶ Play
Douglas, you're always so good faith. But I would like to know if there is any empirical evidence that surveys have been able to, anywhere, have been able to make a meaningful mark upon student achievement in addressing the subject of academic distress. We're actually looking at a great
▶ Play
plan that they have in Hawaii for these surveys. And we're in the process of asking if there would be some ability for us to use some of their surveys that they have. And, you know, you and I have discussed education before, but unless you know what the problem is, you cannot address it. And I think this would open up the school improvement plan to things that have not maybe been considered in the past, climate in the school, finances, you know. I've listed several things down there that could be
▶ Play
approached. Follow-up, Mr. Chairman? You're recognized. Well, my concern, of course, is that the bottom line is still the same. Whatever you do in terms of the State Department's role, it is in defining, I mean, it is with respect to the term academic distress. And my question really goes to how, what is the experience? What is the documentation of this experience that surveys improve student achievement? Is there any documentation anywhere? Well,
▶ Play
the survey is not going to improve the student achievement, but the performance objectives that would be based on the survey could very well drive that change that we're talking about. So you look at what's going on in your community and your school and you develop a way forward to meet those, you know, you're going to see your strengths and you're going to see your weaknesses. And I think that's how you drive student achievement improvement.
▶ Play
Any other questions from the committee? Seeing none. Anybody like to speak against the bill? for the bill okay I've got one starting and I'll get you next we'll get you thank you mr. chairman Richard
▶ Play
Speaker 126 1:19:00
Hutchinson Arkansas citizens first Congress the public policy panel we support this bill we are always looking for constructive ways that we can build more dialogue more involvement and more connections and partnerships between schools and communities, between parents and schools, between students, among students, parents, and the community at large. While the bill in itself is not going to automatically cause things to be different, it is providing a mechanism that we hope can actually generate some positive differences. Thank you.
▶ Play
Anyone? It's against the bill? Okay. You're recognized to speak against the bill. State your name and
▶ Play
who you're with, please. My name is Erica Ivey. Oh,
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:19:52
thank you. My name is Erica Ivey. I'm a teacher at Parkview Magnet High School in the Little Rock School District, and I'm here with the Little Rock Education Association and Arkansas Education Association. The reason that I decided to speak against the bill is sort of twofold. I'm an English teacher, And if anyone in here has ever taught English or been in an English class, everyone takes English. And so we typically get the surveys and the handouts and everything else that has to happen within the school goes through us. We're losing valuable time in our classroom because of surveys. I know I've given at least three, if not four, this semester. Some of these surveys take five minutes. Some of them take 45 minutes. Some of them take an hour. And that's time that I could be using to help my students and to teach them. And if we continue using this class time for things such as this, we're not going to have any time anyway. I mean, we already have to test in March, and once March starts, we're pretty much done because we have so many tests that we have to give. And by adding these things, it compounds and becomes, it's an untenable situation for us.
▶ Play
If I might answer that, a very interesting part of the study that's gone into this is the possibility of us putting this to the districts through a phone app. And so this can be, and then it will lead directly into district information collection so that this is not going to be a part of class time. This is something that, you know, those that wish to participate can put on their phones and do that survey wherever they are at night. They don't have to be on the school premises. So I think that's a great possibility moving forward to be able to address this time out of school. So I hope you're okay
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:22:09
with that. Well, the problem that I have with that is that not all students have cell phones. Not all students have access to computers. And so that's a disservice to those students who don't have those materials. I don't know. And plus, you know, it's a possibility. If it said it in the bill, I would be, you know, and the students that actually had, couldn't get the technology, they had a way to participate as well, I'd be fine with it. But given that it's a possibility and you don't take those kids who don't have that sort of technology into account, I would still have to say against. Any
▶ Play
questions? Thank you. Does anyone like to speak for the bill? Yes, the bill.
▶ Play
Would you like to close for your bill? I appreciate the questions and the concerns, and all teachers are concerned about their class time, and I certainly want to be sensitive to that, and that's why we're working very hard to come up with the tool that will be very forward-thinking and not usurp class time. and, two, we'll be able to drive this innovation and this performance into a school maybe that we have not been sensitive to in the past. So I would ask for a good vote, move for a due pass. Are you offering a due pass? I did,
▶ Play
thank you. All right, I have a due pass motion from Representative Douglas. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed, no. I'm sorry the no's have that one
▶ Play
you have oh me you are welcome to present your other bill alrighty this is 1683 on school bullying we have a situation that's of course new and I'd like for Superintendent Stubblefield if he might to help me answer some questions on this. This is to establish a district's anti-bullying policy and the potential release of a name of the social media account holder who has bullied another student through an electronic act over social media. What we have is we have some social media out there that is that you do not have to put your contact information in. You can be anonymous. And this has become a problem at school with kids being bullied, and there's no way to make other children accountable for that bullying. So this is going to establish a process whereby you can ask for that contact information when it is an act that occurs that is, you know, against the district school bullying policy. I'd be glad to take questions. I'm going to go ahead and recognize the superintendent. If his
▶ Play
state is naming who he's with, that way you can answer questions if asked.
▶ Play
Speaker 237 1:25:37
Jeff Stubblefield, superintendent of schools at Charleston Public Schools. Would you like to add anything to that? Each month or possibly each quarter, there are new and new programs being developed, and they generally start on the college campuses and from different individuals, and they're anonymous sites at which you can get on. you remain anonymous, and the only recourse you have is to try and investigate, but often students, characterizations of students, issues of students that they have no recourse on because they don't know where it's coming from, and from time to time, the only thing that you have is an opportunity to possibly try and get the provider to shut it down around the school. That was the only recourse we had with YCAC, is to try and get them to remove the access around the school, but other providers, from time to time, aren't near as hospitable. Any questions from the
▶ Play
committee? Seeing no questions from the committee. Does anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would
▶ Play
you like to close for you bill i'm closed i will mention that we've had some contact with facebook and some of the other social media and they're very interested in developing a policy you know working with us further on this and and using it as a national model so i think this is very forward thinking of of my superintendents to come to me with this this problem and and this will probably be just the beginning of a policy that will be developed. What's the will of the
▶ Play
committee? I have a motion to do pass from Representative Ratliff. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed this bill. Thank you, committee. Representative Fite, you are recognized to present House Bill 1694. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you,
▶ Play
committee. This is my first time before you. I have a fiscal impact statement on House Bill 1694. I don't know if you have that in front of you, but the revenue impact is zero, showing no impact on state treasury. And if I may invite Mr. Mark White from Department of Human Services to join me. You may. Let
▶ Play
him go ahead and introduce himself and who he's with, and then he'll be ready.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:28:35
Mark White, Deputy Director for the Department of Human Services. You're recognized at any time.
▶ Play
The overall goal of this bill is to ensure that children who must be placed in foster care through no fault of their own at least have the opportunity to remain in their school of origin if it is in their best interest while ensuring financial support to school districts. As you know, DHS strives to ensure that children in foster care remain in their school of origin, if at all possible. This reduces the trauma that a child experiences when entering foster care by not only leaving their family of origin, but leaving their school, their friends, and their community and teachers. This bill adds language to the Education Code to mirror the language in the Division of Children and Family Services section of statute to further clarify that children in foster care may remain in their school of origin if in their best interest, enroll in a new school in a timely manner if appropriate, and have access to educational programs, academic resources, and extracurricular activities that are available to all students. This also adds a new subdivision to the Education Code to allow students in DHS custody to be counted for average daily membership in the school in which they are enrolled and therefore be included in the district's public funding determinations. It strengthens language regarding collaboration between DHS and school districts to develop a transportation plan to ensure continuity of education services to the extent reasonable and practical, provided an additional expense will not be imposed on the school district. And then finally, it defines more clearly the youth in foster care who would qualify as homeless under the federal McKinney-Vento Act. and I would appreciate a good vote and I will take questions at this time. Any questions from committee?
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Perhaps this is for Mr. White. What is the number of students in a given day who are eligible for public education or any education who are designated as foster children? I'm going to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:30:53
look. I know that at any typical time we have around 3,000 open cases in our foster care system, and so any one of those children may well be enrolled in school. I apologize. I don't know an exact number offhand, but
▶ Play
it would be somewhere in that range. If I may follow up, Mr. Chair. Thank you. So are those children pretty much geographically distributed throughout the state? I believe so,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:31:24
but I can't tell you that for certain. But that's my understanding that generally they are distributed throughout the state. And as
▶ Play
a part of that follow-up, so it would not be of an impact to any particular school district that we know?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:31:38
No, sir. And in the majority of cases, we are able to allow that child to remain in their original school district where they started at. We do have cases, though, where it's necessary to move them to a different district. And, for example, if you have a child who has particular special needs, there's a limited number of foster homes who are capable of handling a child in that situation. And sometimes it's necessary to move that child quite a distance away. And in those cases, as a practical matter, they have to go into a new district. But in most cases, we try to leave them in their same school district whenever possible. Representative Ratliff, you're recognized for a question. Okay, my
▶ Play
question kind of goes along with what you did. Does the money follow that child? That's the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:32:22
purpose of this bill is for the money to
▶ Play
follow that child. I know in some cases you all have to move these kids because of maybe, you know, they move them from this school and then they stay there a week, two weeks, and all of a sudden they move them again because parents are trying to catch up with them and things along that line. So it creates, you know, I like the idea of the bill, but thank
▶ Play
you. Are there any other questions? Committee, Representative Murdoch, you
▶ Play
recognize your question. Thank you, Chairman. So, obviously, this is more practical in a situation where there's districts that are fairly close to one another, obviously. It teaches districts, so, you know, going from one county that's abutting another county, but still we're being able to, because for traveling, obviously, practical reasons. So you're talking about, so have there been some isolated incidents, representative fight? What has precipitated this bill? Just in looking at the
▶ Play
overall foster care system, one of the biggest traumas for children is not only leaving their home, but leaving their school and their friends, and we're just trying to find ways to reduce that trauma. Thank you. Any other questions, committee?
▶ Play
Seeing none, is there anyone like to speak against the bill? Or the bill? Seeing none, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed, thank you What is the will of the committee? Representative Walker has a due pass motion All those in favor say aye Any opposed, no Congratulations, you have passed your bill Thank you, Mr. Chair, thank you committee Thank you committee Representative Gossage, are we going to pass over 1726?
▶ Play
Speaker 254 1:34:14
Much to my chagrin I will not
▶ Play
be running that bill Okay Okay, Representative Tucker is not in the room, and Representative Ratliff, you are recognized to present two bills for Representative Tosh. At this time, we'll present 1778. Okay, Representative Tosh
▶ Play
has crossed the hall, and he's got another thing going, so I'm going to present 1778 for him. to require state institutions to hire Ed. If they require an essay, he wants them to keep this essay on file for one year. So if there's a question, the parents could look at it or, you know, if they say the essay wasn't that good or something, they'd go ahead and judge a scholarship application. That's the extent of it. You got any questions? Any questions, committee?
▶ Play
Seeing no questions. Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Are you closed for your bill? Closed, and I'd recommend do pass. I have a do pass motion from Representative Ratliff. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed that
▶ Play
bill. At this time, you will present House Bill 1780. Okay, on House Bill 1780, it's to amend the provision of Title VI, Arkansas Code, concerning the teacher excellent and support system. And after Representative Tosh and I talk with ADE, we're going to have another session between now and then, and we've already got a bill that extended out to four years. He agreed that we'd just pull this bill down and look
▶ Play
at research and bring it back in two years. Thank you. Okay, no action on this bill? No action. No action. Okay. At this time, Representative Vaught, you're recognized. to present House Bill 1806, 1806.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. House Bill 1806, this bill just deletes some obsolete language, some obsolete code that we have. So it is also supported by Arkansas Farm Bureau, Arkansas Rice Federation, the Poultry Federation, Arkansas Agriculture Council, or it's the Agriculture Council of Arkansas Farm Credit and the Arkansas Association of Conservative Districts. So I would appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Any questions, committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized. Yeah, you're saying this
▶ Play
bill is to create conservative districts. You mean conservation districts? No, it is supported by
▶ Play
them. Okay, and what does the bill really do? It just deletes some obsolete code. It brings everything back up to code.
▶ Play
Okay, well, I'm always suspicious of that. Yes, I do know. Well, I haven't had a chance to read it, so I won't have any comment.
▶ Play
Thank you. Any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, anyone in the audience would like to speak against the bill? For the bill. We're going to have a roll call right off. Are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. Thank you. What's the will of the committee? I have a due pass from Representative Ratliff. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Wasn't that easy? Not like a lot of them in here. All right. we are going to pass over representative gray is not in the room and represent Lowry has asked to pass over his till this afternoon
▶ Play
and represent Murdoch has asked us to pass over his represent Walker has asked us to pass over his All those in favor of that one.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you are recognized if you would like to present that bill. All right. Ms. Douglas is not here. Representative Douglas is not here. Representative Armstrong is not here. Yes, sir. Represent Armstrong, you are recognized to present House Bill 1958. Man, I was on a roll. We have some information that we'll be passing out to you on this bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have some people that I want to join me up here at the podium. Come
▶ Play
on up. I'm going to make a little statement while you're down at that end. They can go ahead and join you. We have a bunch of people signed up to speak for this bill, I believe. Yes, sir. And they're all from the same place. I would like to just do one representation from them, and it doesn't matter. They're welcome to set the table, but I really don't want to take five people to speak for the same bill for the same thing at this time. We're really kind of crunched on time. So pick your people. Thank you. Okay. Okay, this
▶ Play
is an act to amend the National School Lunch Program. And so what I'm going to do instead of me going out, outlining everything, I'm going to refer to my people that I have around the table here and let them talk, and then I'll come back. If
▶ Play
you would introduce yourself and state your name and who you're with, and then you're recognized. Hi.
▶ Play
Thank you very much for allowing me to speak. I'm Lynn Donald Carver from Springdale. I was a member and co-chair of the Governor's Task Force on Best Practice for Afterschool and Summer Programs, and I'm here to talk about the Positive Youth Development Act and the importance of afterschool and summer program for students in Arkansas. The task force found from their work that students who are involved in after-school and summer programs are much less likely to engage in risky activities such as committing a crime or using drugs. And the top reason that parents use after-school and summer programs is to keep their children safe. We also know that quality after-school and summer programs inspire our children to learn. So surveys of elementary and middle school students in our state's 21st century community learning centers programs showed gains in school attendance in grades in standardized test scores and improvement in behavior 80% of summer program participants in Arkansas either gained or maintained their reading levels so we know that after school and summer programs can decrease the achievement gap between our lower-income students and their peers with more advantages. Additionally, we know that after-school and summer programs have a track record in helping young people learn workforce skills such as leadership, critical thinking, teamwork, and these are the skills that our business and community leaders are telling us that they need for future employees to have and to learn right away, and this is a good place for students to learn those. Additionally, we know that juvenile crime is most likely to occur between the hours of 3 and 6 p.m. when many students, many children are left unsupervised because their parents are working. We know that if they're engaged in after-school programs, they have interesting and fun activities. They are with adult positive role models and that this can help prevent risky behavior and has been shown in some instances to decrease crime in communities. I live in Springdale. we do not have a Boys and Girls Club or YMCA we have a lot of pockets of summer programs where some students have interesting and helpful activities in the afternoon sometimes transportation and certainly the cost of programs can be a barrier but we have found that our 21st century community learning center programs are very strong we have programs at the Jones Center our resource officers do a summer program where they engage with students at the summer are feeding sites, and all of the kids that are involved in these activities are showing gains and positive improvement in their behavior and in their school attendance. We know that if we have an opportunity to get some funding for the Positive Youth Development Grant, that there will be grants available to communities throughout the state to help support these kinds of programs, and we think that this is a positive development and something that can help improve educational outcomes for students all across the state. We know that the NSL funds are to be used to help close that achievement gap and summer and after school programs have a track record in doing that. We also know that the recommendation is that money be spent from the NSLA to be used on proven interventions. After school and summer programs are proven interventions that work. The rules and regulations of this act stipulate the kinds of programs that can receive the grant funding and outlines quality standards and the evaluation requirements so that we can collect data to find out just how these programs work and how much of an impact that they can have. We know that Arkansas has made a great step forward in improving our educational system by the investment that we have made in pre-K, early childhood education, and we're seeing amazing results from that. We firmly believe that investing in after-school and summer programs is a way to protect our investment in early childhood education and see the continued growth and improvement in our students throughout their school career. Thank you for your time and for listening to me.
▶ Play
Speaker 287 1:44:49
Mr. Chair, my name is Rich Huddleston. I'm Executive Director for Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. I'm here today to talk about why NSLA funds are being recommended as they use to fund the Positive Youth Development Act and Quality Afterschool and Summer Programs. As you all know, the NSLA categorical funding that was established to meet the additional needs of struggling and low-income students in the state's response to the Lakeview case years ago. But unfortunately, NSLA funding has been diverted to so many additional uses beyond its original purposes, and now its effectiveness is questionable at best. Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families first reported on this issue back in 2010. We found that a relatively small number or percentage of the funds were being spent on strategies such as extended day and after school and summer programs that research shows could have a major impact on improving educational outcomes and reducing gaps for low-income children. And so our research clearly found that not enough funds were being spent on the things that really work. And the original purposes of the law has been expanded now so much that we've gotten away from the original list of the things that we know really work. The Office of Education Policy at the University of Arkansas has been critical of both the distribution methodology of the funds and the extended number of purposes for which the funds may be used. In one of their reports, they stated that, quote, due to general lack of focusing of the poverty funds by districts, it is difficult to assign cause or even correlation to poverty funding and achievement. Pikes and Anon in their September 2014 desk audit report on behalf of the education committees recommended that more NSLA funding be used for tutors, people support, extended day after school and summer programs. And the Bureau of Legislative Research in their 2014 report, Success in High Poverty schools recommended a number of strategies for reducing the achievement gap. Most of the strategies in their report have other funding streams, either through foundation funding or through other categorical funding, but the only funding source really for after school and summer programs, quite frankly, is NSLA. The legislature itself has acknowledged the need to reduce the permitted uses of NSLA state funding. In April of 2013, the education committees amended the 2012 adequacy report to add a recommendation to prioritize the allowable uses of NSLA funding. Then the legislature added language to the Education Funding Bill, Act 1467 of 2013 stating, the evidence presented to the House Committee on Education, the Senate Committee on Education, and the 89th General Assembly indicates that the method in which NSLA state categorical funding is distributed should change. School districts should only be permitted to use NSLA state categorical funding to fund evidence-based programs directed at approving student achievement for economically disadvantaged and low-performing students. The bill further required that a study be committed to make a recommendation on changing NSLA funds prior to the 2014 fiscal session. Despite our prodding, No committee study was ever completed, and during the fiscal session a year later, the education committees unfortunately informed the legislative leadership that basically their recommendation was to take no action on NSLA funding. And so even though there was a requirement in legislation 2013 that the Education Committee has come up with recommendations for changing the targeting of NLSA funds, that's not happened. We feel that NLSA funding is a perfect source for funding the Positive Youth Development Act and Quality Afterschool and Summer programs. Its purpose is to improve educational outcomes and close the gap for low-income students. It's supposed to be spent on proven strategies that will help do that, strategies such as these types of programs. These types of programs are already an allowable use of these funds, and you all have the ability to make that happen and promote more effective use of these funds on things that we know work. And so I think there's a long history of research on this topic going back a number of years, and the legislature has recognized that this is an issue. And so given all that, we feel it's entirely appropriate to take a small percentage of NSLA funds off the top to put it into a strategy that we know will help improve educational outcomes for low-income students, especially given what we know about things like summer learning loss for low-income kids and issues like that. So I'll leave it up to my other colleagues to answer any questions about the effectiveness of these programs, but I did want to speak a little bit about why this was selected as a potential funding source for this
▶ Play
Speaker 288 1:50:14
bill. So, thank you. Identify yourself.
▶ Play
Turn your mic. Chair, due to time, my name is Rennell Woods. I'm former executive director of the after-school program in our area in Craighead County. First off, a volunteer, part-time janitor, and then worked my way up to the executive director position and a former ambassador of after-school programs for the state of Arkansas. Just, you know, working all my life for the past 13 years in this issue that has saved my life and many, many in our area and around our region providing these after-school programs. And we work with our school districts. We've worked with eight superintendents in our district and area, and everybody knows this is a great idea. It's a great opportunity for our children in the summer and after school when all the summer losses. But we don't know exactly. We hadn't figured out how to make this work before this idea came about. I wouldn't say they thought this might be the greatest idea, but I think that it is a great idea, and it's a new day for us, And I thank you all for being your leadership and providing us with bold legislation that will be the best interest for our children for the state of Arkansas.
▶ Play
Representative Murdoch, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Chairman, and Representative Armstrong and the group that's bringing this. Obviously, it's a very important issue as we try to address those needs in those districts where there's low performance. I guess this is a small bill that does a whole lot, though, And there's a whole lot of questions just in the implementation, Representative Armstrong, of this. How is this going to be implemented? Is there collaboration with the districts? You know, where's the input here? I understand, I mean, the advocacy for it is fine. I know there's a lot of people here to advocate for it. I'm good there. And I understand the need. But the implementation of this, how is this going
▶ Play
to work exactly? You already have summer programs that's established with school districts. You already have after our tutoring. So this is only to go to improve and help really, really strengthen those programs. And the physical impact is very small. I got a physical impact statement of zero. And we're only asking 2% of the NSLA money. And, you know, we did a study back in the summer in Pakistan, and recommended this is a good way to improve education. Again, I'm good with that, but I'm not debating whether it's good or not. The implementation is going to go back with the school districts. They will have an opportunity to use this as a good pattern to increase the level of student learning, maybe cause them to set goals and all that. This is a good program, and it basically gives the schools a tool to use. Maybe I'm not understanding what the program
▶ Play
is. Maybe that should be my question.
▶ Play
What is the program? Okay, I'm going to
▶ Play
Speaker 287 1:53:16
refer that question over to one of my colleagues. Okay. Representative, back in 2011, Senator Johnny Key sponsored a piece of legislation that you all passed. I've heard of him. Yeah, I know you have. And he was very passionate about the issue, and he created the Positive Youth Development Act. And that program, a lot of the administrative infrastructure has been set up, I believe there have been rules and regs that have already been passed. But because there's been no funding for that program, we've not been able to implement it. And so the administrative infrastructure is already there at the state level, working in conjunction with the local school district. So we would not have to do all this from scratch with that infrastructure already in place. And basically, this is just a funding source for the program. Okay, so this is just
▶ Play
a funding piece for some Enabys legislation that was passed. and that legislation is what do you know the act where we can find that act 166 okay I'm good just read what you give me read my handout right that's what you're saying okay I'll read the handout okay I'm
▶ Play
good thank you Reverend Lauer you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question yes thank you Mr. Chairman and I'll also have a follow up if you'll grant that to me I want to direct my question to Mr. Huddleston you referenced and I also want to echo of what Representative Murdoch said. I think that this is a good direction, and Representative Armstrong, and I have talked about this. My concern, though, you reference how the Adequacy Committee and the interim study we've looked at wanting to make sure that NSLA money is only spent in appropriate areas, but would you not agree that it's a big leap to go from categorizing what should only be spent to actually an earmark? Because this is an earmark of NSLA. Is that not a large jump from the discussion that took place in the interim? Well, see,
▶ Play
Speaker 287 1:55:16
part of the problem, I mean, I think I mentioned this earlier, was that the original list has been expanded so broadly now that pretty much for the most part, you can spend NSL funds on just about anything you want. And I mean, anymore, it really does not have to be targeted to these low-income students that we're really trying to help. And in the research out there, in terms of the things that have been shown to work, I mean, we've done a couple of reports on that issue, but, you know, Pikus and Auden also reached some similar conclusions, so it's not just advocates, that high-quality after-school and summer programs, we know work, especially in reducing summer learning loss, but also during the school year. And so there's a very strong research base for this program. And, again, we're only talking about taking 2% off the top. So it's not like we're saying, you know, let's put 15% or 20%. And, I mean, especially when there are some districts, quite frankly, that still, even though we passed legislation dealing with the issue of unspent balances a few years back, there are still some districts out there that still have some big balances. And so we don't think that 2% is really a huge amount to ask for, given what we know about unspent balances and given what we know about how the money is really not being spent on one of the population for which it was intended, but on the
▶ Play
Speaker 301 1:56:48
things that we know work. Right. Okay. And for my follow-up, and this
▶ Play
may require requesting someone else, the Department of Education or possibly the AG's office to answer this question, It may only be a small piece, but it does trigger us looking at the matrix and changing it from a funding formula to a spending formula, if you're earmarking. And I'm just kind of curious to hear from the department and AG's office how that affects us in terms of adequacy and the administration of the funding matrix. All right. We have both of them at the end
▶ Play
of the table. If you both would address who you are and who you're with, and then you'll be recognized for a question or make a statement.
▶ Play
If you want to make a statement about that. My command is the Department of Education. Representative Lowry, to answer your question, the way I, of course, I'm definitely not an expert in reading bills. I'm getting there. But the way I understand this, the wording of it says the amount of funding distributed to a school district, basically the amount distributed for NSLA purposes. And so whatever that amount ends up being, for instance, in fiscal year 16, we would then reduce that funding by 2% that would go to the districts. That's not in line what was presented via the adequacy committee where it stated that there's still the three-tier system of funding that would go out to districts. So to do that wouldn't be the same process that has been outlined in law and wouldn't be the same process that was recommended by the adequacy committee. Now, how that affects us from a legal standpoint, I will defer to the AG's office. Rosalyn
▶ Play
Speaker 304 1:58:26
Middleton, Assistant Attorney General for the State of Arkansas. The concern here is that this is contrary to the recommendations in the adequacy report and to depart from the recommendations by either any time we have the adequacy report as evidence of how we are funding an adequate education. So that passes muster on the Lakeview because that serves us the evidence that the court says we must have. to even depart from that recommendation. We need evidence. There's no evidence here to support taking what they say 2%, which comes out to approximately $2.4 million, $4.2 million and redirecting it to somewhere else. So because it's not in the adequacy report, I'm facing problems of being able to defend this bill
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:59:13
if this bill is challenged. Okay. Well, thank
▶ Play
Speaker 287 1:59:21
you for that clarification. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chair, can I address that question? You may. Again, we'd just like to reiterate that in April 2013, the Education Committees amended the 2012 adequacy report to add a recommendation to prioritize the allowable uses of the funding. And then, again, in Act 1467-2013, there was a charge given from the legislature to come back with some recommendations about how to do that. And so you can make the case that, quite frankly, that given that the legislature passed legislation saying that you need to come back to prioritize the funding better, this bill is right in line with the spirit of Act 1467, 2013, and the amended April 2013 adequacy report. So I think, I mean, I'm not a lawyer, so let me just say that up front, but I think I would respectfully disagree in that there's lots of precedents here that it is consistent with what you all have already done and what changes that were made to that previous adequacy report. And quite frankly, this is more consistent with the original NSLA legislation that the court signed off on, because after the Supreme Court signed off on it, that's when it's been amended numerous times, both through law and regulation, that we've added a lot more allowable uses to it. So I would say that this really puts us more in line with the original legislation and what the Supreme Court signed off on, and also what you all, in the amended adequacy report and legislation directed your colleagues to come back and do. That's just my non-lawyer opinion. Representative Ratliff, you have a question.
▶ Play
Yes. We're sitting here talking about NSLA funding here. Couldn't each individual school do this on their own if they wanted to add that to their program and that way they'd have
▶ Play
local control? They will have local control, but a lot of them are not doing these programs after school and summer programs to help improve education. That's the reason why we hired Picos and Arden to do this study
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:01:34
and took their recommendation. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you recognize me. Well, I want you to understand I'm an equal opportunity questioner. And Representative Armstrong, I would like to know So what evidence is there, what empirical evidence is there that summer programs have actually worked, I know theoretically they should work, but have actually worked to narrow the achievement gap in Arkansas between poor students and middle class students or between black and white or Hispanic and white students? When you use summer type programs, like for three weeks to nine weeks. I can
▶ Play
Speaker 315 2:02:30
only make a statement of what
▶ Play
happened in the Little Rock School District. That's when I was a part of the Little Rock School Board. They brought in a summer program and we saw drastic improvements in test scores the next year. And I have some other that's up here. Mr. Walker is going to help
▶ Play
me answer more about that. Well, if I may, Mr. Follow-up? You're recognized for a follow-up? I didn't see that evidence. I heard people say that, but I saw no empirical evidence that established that fact. And if you could direct me to it, I would be
▶ Play
happy to have it. Well, the only thing I can go by, Mr. Walker, is data. They say they had the data, so that's the only thing I can go by and we saw some data to show some improvement. Let
▶ Play
me let one of my other colleagues try to help me with that. Thank you. I do have several pieces of data that we have collected that I would be happy to give to you. I will say that in our state's 21st century community learning center programs they are collecting data and do have to show improvement specifically and so the coordinator of that program was supposed to be here but I don't see her in the audience and I will make sure that you get that the whole committee gets copies of that information but we have seen improvement with students who are participating in those programs have improved their grades, they've improved their school attendance rates, their standardized test scores have gone up and their behavior has improved we have documentation to show that and that is in Arkansas elementary and middle schools who participate in that program. In addition, in Arkansas, I mentioned before, 80% of the participants in summer programs either gained or maintained their reading levels. We have years of documentation that the task force on best practice for after school and summer programs looked at when we were studying what recommendations to make to the governor. And so I have a book this thick of studies that have been done across the country looking at after school and summer programs and the results that they have are very dramatic. In fact, I have one piece with me here that I'll make sure that you get before I leave that shows math scores going up for students who have participated in these programs. So they looked specifically at math scores. We have students who are improving in all areas of STEM. It's amazing what can happen when the learning time is extended but what happens is not what goes on in the school day. It's something that builds on what happens in the school day. So we have students who one of our programs in Springdale High School was able to recover high school credit for Marshallese students so that the graduation rate for those Marshallese students, I think there were 18 students, and all of them graduated on time even though they were behind. We need to
▶ Play
rush this up and not drag this out. So we are way past time that I told you we'd be out of here. So I'm going to go to testimony if there's no more questions. Go to testimony. I've already had all your testimony on the end, so I'm going to go to anyone against the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 131 2:06:05
Dr. Abernathy, you are recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA. We do have several concerns about this bill, so we just want to be clear. It does not go, does not follow the adequacy committee's recommendation. We are, in fact, talking about pulling four-plus million dollars away from schools to send to a grant opportunity. That could have a negative impact on our smaller rural schools particularly, especially when you don't have those programs available in your area. It's going to be hard to apply for a grant to partner with them. That's certainly an issue. We have schools who are already able to run and partner with these particular groups to form after-school activities, et cetera. So that's their local decision on what they feel like is the best use of those NSLA dollars. So we did not support this legislation, and we do support leaving those funds with local district to make their decisions. Mr.
▶ Play
Walker. Thank you. Mr. Abernathy, you recognize that not all schools have this problem with the achievement gap. And you understand that many of them are middle class and moderate to upper income districts. So when you start talking about using this money, as Mr. Armstrong suggests, he's really talking about having that money allocated in such a way as to address the places where the problems exist, rather than having each district have a pro rata share? Well, I think the
▶ Play
Speaker 131 2:07:38
NSLA dollars, all districts have poor kids, poor and free and reduced lunch to kids, which is what generates those dollars. Those particular kids do have certain needs. And it's like the programs have been expanded. The opportunities have been expanded for districts to choose to spend that money. The most recent ones come from this session is talking about career and technical programs. And, you know, yes, will it benefit those poor children? who might be able to participate in some of those career and technical opportunities that will be available at some point in time. We think it would. We think that's a
▶ Play
good use of those dollars. Thank you. I'll allow one more for you at one minute. We are going to close this out in three minutes. Everybody understand?
▶ Play
Speaker 126 2:08:32
One minute. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Richard Hutchinson, Arkansas Public Policy Panel. We support the bill. I think the reason we support it is that we know the evidence is clear that summer and after-school programs, quality programs, can make the difference. The evidence is there. I'll be glad to share it with you. One additional point I want to make very quickly is that we are already creating another gap in this whole area because what is happening is that schools that have access to resources, schools that have families with money are putting a lot of money into summer and after-school programs. There are many, many school districts, including rural districts, that simply cannot do this at this time. We need to find money to fund the Positive Youth Development Act. It's ridiculous that we would pass legislation doing that, and here we are four years later still not finding any money to fund it. Thank you. Thank you. Does anyone
▶ Play
like to speak against the bill? We have one minute.
▶ Play
Speaker 136 2:09:39
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Tony Protho, Director of the Arkansas School Board Association. We appreciate Mr. Armstrong and his attention to these matters, and we're not here to dispute the research, But once again, we do think that this is delving into an expenditure model for the matrix instead of a funding model. There's no hold harmless for districts. If there are districts out there that receive over a million dollars each, even if you take a 2 percent, you're looking at $20,000. They're going to have to cut from their budget somewhere. That could place districts in financial hardship because they have programs and personnel that are currently in place that are paid for by these funds. Also, legislation in past and in this current legislation have enacted uses and requirements for these funds, and some of it discretionary also. In this session, for example, you saw I introduced House Bill 1444 for school nurses, Senate Bill 371, concurrent technical courses. And when districts have opted to put these types of programs in place, once again, there's no phase-in that we can see on this, and it will be immediate starting with this upcoming year.
▶ Play
Thank you. To who? Do you have a question? To the representative? Yes. Okay, I'll allow that. Thank you real quick. Representative Armstrong, can
▶ Play
you please address those funding concerns, please? The funding concerns that I just heard. That's been enumerated by the various speakers about what specifically can happen to districts where it impacts their budget and it's taking money away from them and they've got to make up for it in other areas because we don't want no unintended consequences. Well, I don't
▶ Play
think you'll have any unintended consequences. This program here is going to strengthen them. It's going to cut back on, and if I'm understanding your question right. No, the money, I mean, what
▶ Play
they're saying is going to happen. Are you saying that's not true?
▶ Play
Well, let me finish. Go ahead. What I'm saying, this is going to cut back because you don't have to do a lot of your programs uh trying to bring them up to par you know extra help and all that and and it what it does it increase the educational ability of the students and pick up your test scores and stuff like that so schools won't go under academic distress it's just helping out and it's also a hip to society it's cutting back on the saying is from the cradle to the prison it's cutting back on programs like that because it's helping kids stay out of trouble set goals it's cutting back on bullying it's saving the taxpayers a lot of money and i think that's what nsl was set aside to do maybe i didn't answer your question let me know if i didn't ask it okay
▶ Play
representative armstrong would you like clothes
▶ Play
for your bill yes so let's let's look at this you talk about budgets and stuff like that a lot of school districts they're not using the money properly to do what it was supposed to do or or what it was set out to do. So this is the only thing we're saying, hey, you take 2%, and that's what you use to do the programs that this money was set aside to do. And it's just a small amount that we're asking to improve education, to cut back on, as I said earlier, from the cradle to the prisons. It's to turn around. I know we passed some bills here, the technical part of it, to help create technical programs and get people ready for jobs. so this is all this is doing this is making sure that they have enough money to run these programs summer programs and after school programs and make sure that they run effectively and with that I'm closed I move due pass for my bill I
▶ Play
have a due pass for Representative Armstrong all those in favor say aye any opposed no roll call You guys do not even give me a chance to call this. I'm just going to start roll-calling everything. Sorry about that, Mr. Chair. Let the chair make the call, then you can roll-call. That's the last time I'm going to say that. The bill fails. Now, if you want to roll-call, I'll listen. Roll-call. I see two hands. I've seen one. All right, you've got two hands. All right, guys, we're going to be roll-called.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:13:53
Representative Letting Representative Letting
▶ Play
Speaker 205 2:14:00
Representative Murdoch Representative Deffenbaugh Representative Harris Representative Eubanks Representative Eubanks Representative Ratliff Representative Gillum Representative Gillum Representative Walker Representative Bell Representative Balz Representative Douglas Representative Lowry Representative McElroy Representative Armstrong Representative Gossage Representative Gossage Representative Saban Representative Hodges Representative Gray Representative Lampkin Representative Lampkin I'm sorry your bill has
▶ Play
failed Thank you Mr. Chair At this time we are going to recess We'll be back after adjournment of the session 15 minutes upon adjournment
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1552

0:28 - 54:04 155 segments 24 speakers

HB1583

54:04 - 1:14:13 65 segments 12 speakers

HB1595

1:14:13 - 1:24:20 35 segments 8 speakers

HB1683

1:24:20 - 1:28:00 11 segments 3 speakers

HB1694

1:28:00 - 1:34:40 28 segments 7 speakers

HB1778

1:34:40 - 1:35:49 3 segments 2 speakers

HB1780

1:35:49 - 1:36:24 2 segments 2 speakers

HB1806

1:36:24 - 1:39:09 9 segments 3 speakers

HB1958

1:39:09 - 2:15:15 110 segments 20 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
70 segments
Speaker 8
1 segment
Representative Douglas House Unverified
42 segments
Speaker 19
10 segments
Speaker 23
1 segment
Kim Head Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 26
8 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
52 segments
Representative Scott Baltz Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 54
1 segment
Representative Reginald Murdock Unverified
25 segments
Department Of Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 87
1 segment
Brittany Stockton Unverified
3 segments
Chair Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 88
1 segment
Speaker 94
1 segment
Representative Justin T. Harris Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 126
7 segments
Speaker 131
12 segments
Speaker 136
7 segments
Speaker 141
2 segments
Speaker 148
1 segment
Speaker 157
19 segments
Speaker 168
1 segment
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Unverified
2 segments
Paul Kelly Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 200
1 segment
Speaker 203
1 segment
Speaker 205
6 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
18 segments
Representative Mark D. McElroy Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 215
1 segment
Erica Ivey Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 230
7 segments
Speaker 237
3 segments
Representative Lanny Fite Unverified
7 segments
Representative James Ratliff Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 254
1 segment
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
2 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
14 segments
Rich Huddleston Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 287
20 segments
Speaker 288
1 segment
Rennell Woods Unverified
3 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 301
1 segment
Speaker 304
3 segments
Speaker 296
1 segment
Speaker 315
1 segment