May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 10, 2026
SR27 M. Pitsch TO ENCOURAGE THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO DESIGNATE THE BUTTERFIELD OVERLAND MAIL TRAIL AS A NATIONAL HISTORIC TRAIL. 30:36
Senator Mathew Pitsch presented Senate Resolution 27, urging Congress to designate the Butterfield Overland Mail Trail as a national historic trail and explained the need for the resolution after learning Arkansas lacked such a designation.
[30:46][30:51][30:55]
The chair asked for any questions, received none, and the Senate moved to adopt the resolution, with all members voting “aye” and the measure being adopted.
[31:26]
HCR1008 Vaught B. Davis TO RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE OF ORGAN DONATION TO PUBLIC HEALTH AND TO SUPPORT AND ENCOURAGE ORGAN DONATION AND AWARENESS. 31:48
Senator Breanne Davis introduced House Concurrent Resolution 1008 to recognize the importance of organ donation to public health and to promote awareness, citing the 113,717 Americans awaiting transplants and over 290 Arkansans on the waiting list.
[31:56][32:00][32:36][32:38]
No objections were raised, and the Senate voted unanimously in favor, adopting the resolution.
[33:07]
SB561 #1 J. Hendren TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS TAX REFORM ACT OF 2019; AND TO REFORM THE SALES TAX, INCOME TAX, PROPERTY TAX, AND FRANCHISE TAX LAWS OF THE STATE. 33:30
Senator Jim Hendren offered Amendment 2 to Senate Bill 561, adding a House co-sponsor to the bill, and moved to suspend the rules to consider the amendment.
[33:46][33:58][34:06][34:09]
The motion to suspend the rules carried without objection, and the amendment was adopted and sent to engrossing.
[33:46][33:58][34:06][34:09]
SB571 #1 J. Hendren TO CREATE AN EARNED INCOME TAX CREDIT, AN INCREASED STANDARD DEDUCTION, AND AN INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX REDUCTION; AND TO PROVIDE FUNDING FOR … 34:25
Senator Jim Hendren presented Senate Bill 571 and a related amendment; the amendment was adopted without objection and the bill was reported for third reading and sent to engrossing.
[34:26][34:32]
SB374 Rapert TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PENALTIES RELATED TO ADMINISTRATIVE INSPECTION WARRANTS EXECUTED BY THE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY. 34:46
Senator Jason Rapert explained technical corrections in Senate Bill 374, changing the penalty for ADEQ inspection-warrant violations from an unclassified misdemeanor to a violation and revising the required mental state language.
[34:47][34:59][35:15][35:46]
After the explanation, the chair called the vote, and the Senate recorded 35 yeas and 0 nays, passing the bill to the House.
[36:30][36:54][37:00]
SB375 Rapert TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING COURT REPORTS THAT ARE REQUIRED UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989. 37:11
Senator Jason Rapert moved Senate Bill 375, which amends the Arkansas Juvenile Code to allow either a printed or digital court report by changing a single word to “or,” and noted the bill’s purpose to resolve conflicting reporting requirements.
[37:16][37:25][37:56]
The Senate voted unanimously, with 35 yeas and 0 nays, and the bill was transmitted to the House.
[38:14][38:29][38:39]
SB440 Bledsoe TO BAN USE OF MEDICAL MARIJUANA IN FOOD AND DRINK EXCEPT IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES. 39:16
Senator Cecile Bledsoe introduced Senate Bill 440 to ban the use of medical marijuana in food and drink products that could appeal to children, incorporating the Medical Marijuana Commission’s rules and requesting a 24-vote threshold for passage.
[39:25][39:38][40:12]
SB441 Bledsoe TO ADD RESTRICTIONS REGARDING ADVERTISING OF MEDICAL MARIJUANA AND USE OF CERTAIN SYMBOLS. 56:01
Senator Cecile Bledsoe introduced Senate Bill 441 to codify the Medical Marijuana Commission’s existing rules and add new restrictions on advertising medical marijuana, including limits on audience exposure to minors.
[56:01][56:04][56:14]
Senators Keith Ingram and Mark Johnson questioned how the bill’s 30 % limit on programming that appeals to persons under 18 would be determined, with Bledsoe explaining the Medical Marijuana Commission would work with broadcasters to set the metric.
[56:41][57:07][57:11][57:41][57:45][58:16]
The discussion also compared the proposal to past restrictions on tobacco advertising such as the Joe Camel campaign and raised concerns about how the law would affect pregnant women using medical marijuana, with Bledsoe noting the bill would require consumer alerts for pregnancy.
[58:50][59:08][59:14][59:19][59:22][59:29][1:00:05][1:00:11][1:00:42][1:00:56]
After debate, the Senate voted 33-yes to 0-no, meeting the 24-vote threshold, and the bill was ordered transmitted to the House.
[1:04:24][1:04:44]
SB451 J. Cooper TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR PROFESSIONS AND OCCUPATIONS TO OBTAIN CONSISTENCY REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHEC… 1:05:28
Senator John Cooper presented Senate Bill 451, a red-tape-reduction measure that would standardize criminal-background-check criteria for occupational licensing and provide a statutory framework for disqualifying offenses and waivers.
[1:05:36][1:05:48][1:06:21][1:06:51][1:07:27][1:07:58][1:08:30][1:09:03]
He explained that current licensing boards lack clear guidance, leading to inconsistent disqualifications, and that the bill would clarify terms such as “moral turpitude” and establish a pre-license background-check process.
[1:06:51][1:07:27][1:07:58][1:08:30][1:09:03][1:09:40][1:10:14]
The bill, developed with input from the Attorney General’s office, state police, and the governor, was debated briefly before a roll-call vote, with one senator objecting to rolling the vote.
[1:12:01][1:12:20][1:12:25][1:12:41][1:13:28][1:13:50]
The Senate approved the measure by a vote of 34 yeas to 1 nay and sent it to the House for consideration.
[1:13:50][1:14:01]
SB513 B. Johnson CONCERNING A SUSPENSION OF A PERSON'S DRIVER'S LICENSE FOR POSSESSING A CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE. 1:14:08
Senator Mark Johnson introduced Senate Bill 513, which would give courts discretion to avoid suspending a driver’s license for a conviction or no-contest plea involving a controlled substance, thereby helping CDL drivers in rehabilitation retain employment.
[1:14:20][1:14:33][1:14:45]
Following a brief discussion, the Senate rolled the vote and recorded 35 affirmative votes with no opposition, passing the bill and transmitting it to the House.
[1:14:56][1:15:04][1:15:26]
SB550 G. Stubblefield TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING LIQUID LIVESTOCK LITTER UTILIZATION. 1:15:55
Senator Gary Stubblefield introduced SB 550, noting his 45 years of farming experience and explaining that the bill would shift CAFO permitting authority from ADEQ to the Arkansas Natural Resources Commission (ANRC) and require ANRC to adopt regulations no less stringent than existing ones.
[1:16:07][1:16:38][1:17:08][1:17:44][1:18:14][1:18:46][1:19:23]
After debate, the Senate voted 25 yeas to 5 nays, passing SB 550.
[1:52:23]
SB311 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISQUALIFICATION OF JUDGES. 1:52:49
Senator Alan Clark presented SB 311 to amend Arkansas law so judges must recuse from cases involving current or former staff members or their attorneys, aiming to reduce bias and the appearance of bias.
[1:52:57][1:53:26][1:53:34]
The Senate rolled a vote and approved the measure by a margin of 26 yeas to 6 nays.
[1:54:49]
HB1343 Hawks M. Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PUBLICATION OF THE ANNUAL FINANCIAL REPORT OF THE COUNTY. 1:55:28
Senator Mark Johnson explained HB 1343 would require counties to publish their annual financial reports electronically (including on websites or social media) while still mandating a one-time newspaper notice.
[1:55:32][1:55:58][1:56:28]
The Senate rolled a unanimous vote of 34 yeas, 0 nays, passing the bill.
[1:57:14][1:57:18]
HB1523 Petty Bledsoe CONCERNING THE TREATMENT OF FEMALE INMATES AND DETAINEES IN CORRECTIONAL OR DETENTION FACILITIES; AND CONCERNING PREGNANT INMATES AND DETA… 1:57:32
Senator Cecile Bledsoe introduced HB 1523, the “Women’s Dignity Bill,” which restricts shackling of pregnant inmates, mandates prenatal supplements and reporting requirements, and limits restraint methods for female inmates.
[1:57:44][1:58:09][1:58:44][1:59:15][1:59:48]
The Senate voted 35 yeas, 0 nays, enacting the legislation.
[2:01:23][2:01:39]
HB1689 C. Fite Pitsch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PENALTIES FOR PASSING AN AUTHORIZED VEHICLE STOPPED ON A HIGHWAY. 2:01:54
Senator Mathew Pitsch presented HB 1689 to increase fines for vehicles passing stopped emergency-response vehicles from $35-$500 to $250-$1,000, citing recent accidents and support from law-enforcement organizations.
[2:02:10][2:02:31][2:03:01]
The Senate unanimously approved the bill, 35 yeas, 0 nays.
[2:05:05][2:05:10]
HB1565 A. Davis Dismang TO PROVIDE FUNDING FOR A NATIONAL CANCER INSTITUTE-DESIGNATED CANCER CENTER IN THE STATE THROUGH CHANGES IN THE LAWS RELATING TO THE SA… 2:05:23
Senator Jonathan Dismang described HB 1565, which would fund a National Cancer Institute-designated cancer center by modifying taxes on tobacco products, while Senator Terry Rice voiced opposition based on personal-freedom and tax concerns.
[2:05:37][2:05:42][2:06:06][2:06:17][2:06:48][2:07:22]
The Senate passed the measure with a vote of 22 yeas to 10 nays.
[2:09:51]
SB431 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE CONTROL ENFORCEMENT DIVISION SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION. 2:13:18
Senator Larry Teague presented two budget measures-SB 138 for the Education Department and SB 431 for the Alcoholic Beverage Control Enforcement Division-and invited any questions.
[2:13:19]
The Chair moved to batch and roll the two bills, and no member objected to the motion.
[2:13:33]
A roll-call vote recorded 35 ayes and 0 nays, approving the combined budget bills and forwarding them to the House.
[2:13:45][2:14:09]
Senator Teague then announced that the budget will be considered the following day and reminded members to submit any member-originated bills for upcoming sessions.
[2:14:22]
Matched: “…ed at 9.35 a.m. delivered to the governor for his approval. Senate Resolution 31 by Senator Sturge to congratulate the Melbourne High School…”
TO CONGRATULATE THE MELBOURNE HIGH SCHOOL LADY BEARKATZ FOR THEIR ACHIEVEMENTS.
Senate will come to order. Madam Secretary, please call the roll. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Everyone please rise, including those in the gallery. Senator Cooper is recognized. He has a special visitor, special guest, and he will make an introduction and the his guests will lead us in a word of prayer to
introduce you to my 12 year old granddaughter from st louis this is emily she's a sixth grader 12 years old and she plays soccer softball basketball likes to read and she plays the violin and school orchestra and leads co-leads a bible study group after school and i was talking to senator rapert there a little bit ago and he said she plays she's uh plays a violin in an orchestra she didn't play the fiddle in a band so
if you'll bow with us we'll let her lead us in prayer dear heavenly father thank you for this day you've given us And thank you for all that we've gotten to do today. And thank you for just how special it is that we get to gather here. Thank you for all these senators, and they've just gotten to do so much for our state and our country. And thank you for the courage that it takes to stand up and do something brave and make their bills and just do so many great things for our country and make change. Dear Lord, please hope that we have a nice day today and that we can just make good changes. Thank you for everyone that gets to be here. In
Let's start out with announcements. First, I want to recognize our Arkansas State Treasurer, Dennis Milligan, and his family is up here in the gallery behind me. His wife, Tina, is there, and their grandchildren, Gabby, Gracie, and Jackson, if you would give them a round of applause. Senator Cooper is recognized.
Thank you, Mr. President. Also, Emily's brother is back here with us today. He's 14 years old, eighth grader, and he plays soccer, baseball, basketball in his honor choir in school. And that's my grandchildren. And their parents are sitting up here in the gallery, Alyssa Wade. So thank you all for having them here today. Senator Martin Johnson of Ferndale. He's recognized. Thank
you, Governor. It's my honor today to have with me as a guest my dear friend Rick Edwards. Rick owns a security company in Little Rock. He's also a pilot. He's a Vietnam veteran, as I told Senator Wallace, and he has, through the state police, flown Governor Hutchinson and the previous four governors of Arkansas around the state. And I think he did a good job doing that. So please welcome him, and I'll ask Lee that he be given privilege to the floor. Without objection.
Senator Ricky Hill of Cabot. Thank you, Governor. I want to introduce the page today. We have Alex Hopper back here. He's an 18-year-old Cabot Sr. who's headed to the University of Memphis on an ROTC scholarship with the Marines. And so he's one of our future service members. I'd like to say thanks for him being here and appreciate it and appreciate his future service. Senator Hickey.
Thank you, Governor. I appreciate you. Members, I'd like to have your attention for just a minute. I would like to introduce someone and also give you a short story, if you don't mind. Ronnie, would you stand up, you and Sue? Thank you. This is my father-in-law that lives over in Dallas. His name is Ronnie Love, and that's his wife, Sue, that's with him. Of course, my wife's also sitting up there. Ronnie was a veteran, and he served active duty in the Army in Vietnam. What some of you also may remember is about a year ago, whenever I was in the tax task force, I had to leave sitting between, at the time I was sitting between Senator Hester and Senator Sample, and I had to leave because Ronnie had to have emergency surgery. And what they found out is that he had cancer and the cancer was not good. And there was talk of a transplant that didn't transpire. It was in the same organ as one of our colleagues that here recently that we lost. But anyway, Ronnie, what you need to know is that at that time, a lot of members, a lot of people in this body started praying for you. And anyway, for you all that understand this stuff, Ronnie's AFP number was up to 10,000, which is very, very high, which after that prayer, and he was able to get on some other drugs for the cancer, that has dropped down to 61, which is an absolute miracle. So I appreciate you all for the prayers. Ronnie does. I love Ronnie and his wife, Sue. And if you all would just, please would, just welcome him
I have two pages today. William Killow, who's 13 years old. He's in the seventh grade at Searcy, Arkansas, at Alph Junior High. He likes golfing, hunting, fishing, basketball, and tennis, and participates in K-Life. and with him is Johnny Bell, age 12 in sixth grade at Southwest Middle School, is also from Senator Dismang's district, but his dad and I lived together in law school together, so I don't know if that's a mark against Johnny or not, but let's make him welcome, give him a big round of
Folks, I have a page today. Elizabeth Barfield, if you stand up, please. Elizabeth, there you are. Elizabeth is 13. She's in the 8th grade in Blymouth Middle School. She's in gymnastics, loves cheerleading, does crafts, is with the FBLA, and is in an interact club where they just go out and help the community. And she's also in gifted and talented. Elizabeth, welcome aboard. Her mom and dad, Mark, Christy, and her older sister, Star, are up
Mr. President. Back here is Britton Edwards, one of the pages today, along with my grandchildren. He's an 18-year-old senior at Brooklyn. He's involved in the FFA and archery. And his parents are Tom and Candace Edwards. And I'm not sure if Tom's up here, but that's Candace up here. And she's the circuit clerk in Craighead County. So thank you all for welcoming them today.
Senator Davis. Thank you, Governor. Tomorrow, we are celebrating World Down Syndrome Day a day early. So a way that we raise awareness for that is to wear crazy socks. And Gigi's Playhouse will be here with us tomorrow. They're a Down Syndrome Achievement Center. And they're going to be having free breakfast and coffee tomorrow morning from 7 to 9 at the Capitol Hill building. So please come tomorrow with crazy socks. They can be mismatched or they can be whatever you want. But I'll have Everly with me, our sweet precious baby with Down syndrome, and so we can take pictures with crazy socks and celebrate with her. Thank you, guys.
Senator Pitch. I would like to introduce one of my constituents. I think he's also a constituent of several of you in Northwest Arkansas. He's the president and owner of Bedford Cameron Video with multiple facilities, both in Fort Smith, Northwest Arkansas, and over in Oklahoma. but we're trying to get them to come here. Mr. Jeff Beecham is up here in the audience. Please make him feel welcome. Any other announcements?
over at the Red and Blue Events Center, they're going to be watching the Hogs vs. Texas baseball game and hosted by the Manufactured Housing and ABC. Hope to see everybody there. Any items to be read across the desk,
Madam Secretary? Yes, sir. Will your Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was first Senate Bill 52 by Senator Mark Johnson compare the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed? Retirement. Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was first Senate Bill 217 by Senator Sample compare the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed? Retirement. Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred Senate Bill 264 by Senator Garner, compared the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Public Health. Committee on Engrossed Bills, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 459 by Senator Hammer, compared the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Joint Budget. Will your Committee on Agri, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 563 by Senator Malik, recommend do pass? Calendar. Committee on Agri, to whom was referred to House Bill 1654 by Representative Jett, recommend do pass? Calendar Committee on City County Local Whom was referred to Senate Bill 6 by Senator Garner Recommend do pass Calendar Committee on City County Local Whom was referred to Senate Bill 492 by Senator Garner Recommend do pass Calendar Committee on City County Local Whom was referred to Senate Bill 562 by Senator Wallace Recommend do pass Calendar Committee on City County Local Whom was referred to House Bill 1306 by Representative Rye Recommend do pass Calendar Committee on City County Local to whom was deferred House Bill 1590 by Representative House, recommend do pass. Caller. Committee on City, County, Local, to whom was deferred House Bill 1624 by Representative Coleman, recommend do pass. Caller. Committee on City, County, Local, to whom was deferred House Bill 1639 by Representative Whitaker, recommend do pass. Caller. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, to whom was referred Senate Bill 396 by Senator Rayford, recommend do pass. Caller. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, to whom was referred Senate Bill 527 by Senator Bledsoe, recommend do pass. Counter. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, whom was for Senate Bill 565 by Senator Rayford, recommend do pass. Counter. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, whom was for Senate Bill 252 by Senator Hammer, recommend do pass as amended number one. Counter. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, whom was for Senate Bill 514 by Senator Dismayne, recommend do pass as amended number one. Counter. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, whom was for Senate Bill 291 by Senator Rayford, recommend due pass. Amended number 1. Community on insurance and commerce to ami manner inferred House Bill 1564 by Rep. Gray recommend due pass. Amended number 1 Councilor Committee on joint budget to whom refer to Senate Bill 48. Comeger 2. Committee on joint budget to whom refer to Senate Bill 126 by joint budget do pass as amended number one. Committee on joint budget to whom was referred Senate Bill 131 by joint budget recommended do pass as amended number one. Committee on joint budget to whom was referred House Bill 1082 by joint budget recommended do pass as amended number one. Committee on judiciary to whom was referred Senate Bill 544 by Senator Irving recommended do pass. Committee on judiciary to whom was referred Senate Bill 547 by Senator Blake Johnson recommended do pass. Calendar. Committee on Judiciary to whom was referred Senate Bill 551 by Senator English recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Judiciary to whom was referred Senate Bill 250 by Senator Clark recommend do pass to concur in House Amendment No. 1. Calendar. Committee on Judiciary to whom was referred Senate Bill 318 by Senator Davis recommend do pass to concur in House Amendment No. 1. Calendar. Committee on Judiciary to whom was referred House Bill 1548 by Representative Gonzales recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Judiciary, to whom was referred House Bill 1662 by Representative Dalby, recommend do pass as amended No. 2. Calendar. Committee on Public Health, to whom was referred House Bill 1251 by Representative Eubanks, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies, to whom was referred Senate Bill 401 by Senator Blake Johnson, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies, to whom was referred Senate Bill 487 by Senator Elliott, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was first Senate Bill 524 by Senator Ballinger recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was first Senate Bill 557 by Senator Teague recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was first Senate Bill 457 by Senator Ballinger recommend do pass as amended number two. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was first Senate Bill 573 by Senator Leading recommend do pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was first Senate Bill 574 by Senator Hammer recommend do pass as amended number one. Calendar. Put one on there. Committee on State Agencies to whom was first House Bill 1429 by Representative Dodson recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was first House Bill 1505 by Representative Beck recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on state agencies to whom was referred House Bill 1341 by Representative Kavanaugh. Recommended do pass as amended number two. Calendar. Committee on transportation to whom was referred House Bill 1683 by Representative McNair. Recommended do pass. Calendar. Committee on transportation to whom was referred House Bill 1784 by Representative Rye. Recommended do pass. Calder. Committee on Transportation, who moves for House Bill 1631 by Representative Vaught, recommend do pass as amended number one. Calder. Real quickly, Madam Secretary, I was informed by a couple of senators that it is still extremely difficult to hear in the back. Is there any way we can just go to the volume knob and turn it up and leave it up? Is there... I think you have a number right there. There's no volume. No, not on yours, but somewhere, because consistently the Senators can't hear in the
the volume. Okay. Thank you for that. We'll get the—we'll see. I can easily speak loud, but we'll see what we can do. Okay, go ahead. Dear Mr. President, this is to inform you that on March 18, 2019, I approve the following measures from the regular session of the 92nd General Assembly. Senate Bill 400, Act 495, Senate Bill 469, Act 496. Sincerely, Asa Hutchison, Governor. File it. Dear Mr. President, this is to inform you that on March 19, 2019, I approve the following measures of the regular session of the 92nd General Assembly, Senate Bill 5, Act 510, Senate Bill 144, Act 511, Senate Bill 298, Act 512, Senate Bill 393, Act 513, Senate Bill 394, Act 514, Senate Bill 408, Act 515. Sincerely, Asa Hutchison, Governor. Follett. Dear Mr. President, we are committed on enrollable bills to whom we refer the following, Senate Bill 266 by Senator Irving, Senate Bill 292 by Senator Raypert, Senate Bill 310 by Senator Raypert, Senate Bill 341 by Senator Irving, Senate Bill 494 by Senator Sample, Senate Bill 495 by Senator Sample, Senate Bill 384 by Senator English. Compare the enrolled copies with the original and find the same correctly enrolled at 9.35 a.m. delivered to the governor for his approval. Senate Resolution 31 by Senator Sturge to congratulate the Melbourne High School Lady Bearcats for their achievement Senate Resolution 31. Calendar. Senate Bill 600 by Senator Stubbeffield, requiring the study of at-large electric Okay, I'll just... Oh, it's green. Now it's working. Okay. Senate Bill 600 by Senator Stubblefield, requiring the study of at-large, at-scale electric generation projects and requiring a study of the reuse of carbon dioxide and enhanced oil recovery through dietary recovery. Senate Bill 600. Senate Bill 600 by Senator Stubblefield's Energy Committee. Senate Bill 601 by Senator Elliott to authorize and expedite necessary improvements to the Little Rock Nine Memorial on the State Capitol Ground, Senate Bill 601. Senate Bill 601, State Agencies. Senate Bill 602 by Senator Dismane to establish the Small Wireless Facility Deployment Act, Senate Bill 602. 602, Insurance Commerce. Senate Bill 603 by Senator Clark to require the Department of Education to provide certain levels of support to certain public school districts based on reading scores and to amend the purposes on which national school lunch state categorically funds may be spent. Senate Bill 603. Senate Bill 603, Education Committee. We're now going to move to the business agenda. Senator Pitch, Senate Resolution for third reading. Senate Resolution 27 by Senator Pitch to encourage the United States Congress to designate the Butterfield Overland Mail Trail as a national historic trail. Senator Pitch is recognized. He has the floor on the resolution. Thank you, Governor. Senate Resolution
27 is one of those deals. I went home last weekend. The lady who runs our Metropolitan Planning Organization asked, do we have a Senate resolution, a House resolution, or a joint resolution for the Butterfield-Overland-Mail Trail? Because all the other states that it traversed had that, and that put them eligible for grants in the future, and so we immediately tried to rectify that when we found out nobody in Arkansas had done that. This resolution is putting us on notice to Senator Bozeman through the Secretary of State. So with that, I'm closed.
Any questions for the Senator on the resolution? Anyone wish to speak on the resolution? The Senator closed. You've heard the resolution. All those in favor of the resolution say aye. Aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. adopted. Senator Davis. House Concurrent Resolution 1008 by Representative Vought to recognize the importance of owner organ donation to public health and to support and encourage organ donation and awareness. Senator Davis is recognized. Senators recognize she's going to explain the resolution. This is a House concurrent
resolution for third reading. resolution is to recognize the importance of organ donation to public health and to support and encourage organ donation awareness. There are currently 113,717 Americans who need life-saving organ transplants, and currently there are more than 290 Arkansans on the national organ transplant waiting list. So this is simply a resolution to encourage organ donation awareness,
and I appreciate a good vote. Any questions? Any questions? Senator has closed. Anyone wish to speak on the resolution? All those in favor say aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Resolution is adopted. Return to the House. Senator Hendren, Senate bills will send amendments. Amendment 1 to Senate
You got the second amendment. Senator Hendren, amendment number two. Yeah, members, it's not on the calendar, so I'd like to suspend the rules for amendment number two. All it does is add a House co-sponsor to this bill, so that when they engross it, they can have that person on there. So I move that we suspend
the rules for the purpose of putting amendment number two on this bill. Okay. You've heard the motion to suspend the rules. Any objection? objection, motion carried. Amendment 2 to Senate Bill 561. Again, members, all it does is add a House co-sponsor to the bill. Appreciate it. This is the actual amendment to add a sponsor. Any objection without objection, the amendment is adopted. Send to Engrossing. Senator Hendren on SB 571. Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 571. Senator Hendren is recognized. My bill, my amendment. Appreciate a good vote. Amendment. Any objection to the amendment? Without objection. Amendments adopted. Send to engrossing. Senate bill is for third reading. Senator Clark is not here. Senator Raypert is recognized. Senate Bill 374 by Senator Raypert to amend the law concerning penalties related to administrative inspection warrants executed by the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality. Senator Raypert. Thank
you. members Senate bill 374 and the one following are both technical Corrections bills from the Commission Code Revision Commission 374 is a change I will explain that at page 1 line 29 the bill changes the unclassified misdemeanor to a violation consistent with Arkansas law because the offense does not provide for jail time another concern with the sex section was the inexact mental state for the offense on page 1, line 27. The Commission suggested amending this section to convert the criminal intent required at page 1, line 27 from to from willful and unjustified to a term that's more commonly used which is knowing. This was done in conjunction with the attorney for ADEQ which the statute this particular section speaks to and his explanation for this is the criminal violation requires knowledge of the administrative inspection warrant. It's difficult to see how a defendant could argue that while he or she had knowledge of the warrant, his or her refusal to allow the right of entry inspection was unknowing. So this is the technical corrections meant to bring this into standard with our code. I'd be happy
to answer questions. Any questions for the senator? Senator Hendren? Okay. Any questions for Senator Raper. Anyone wish to speak on this bill? Is there any objection to rolling
Senator, have you closed? I'm closed. Thank you. Madam Secretary, please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Vaughn, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Raypert, Rice, Sample, Stubberfield, Starch, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35 yeas, 0 nays. The bill is passed to transmit to the House. Senator Raypert. One more from Senator Raypert. Senator Raypert. Senate Bill 375 by Senator Rappert to amend the law concerning court reports that are required under the Arkansas Juvenile Code of 1989.
Senator Rappert. Thank you, Mr. President. Members, again, Code Revision Commission Bill. If you're looking at the bill, it changes one word from and to or. And bottom line is we had two pieces of legislation that conflicted with whether it was providing two types of reports, in a printed report and a digital report, or a printed report, or a digital report. So this is simply allowing it to be or. So as long as they're making the recognition, as long as they're getting the information out there, this was consulted with DHS, and I'd be happy to
answer questions. Any questions for the senator? Anyone wish to speak on this bill? Any objection to rolling the vote? Are you closed, senator? I'm closed. Thank you, sir. Senator has closed. Madam Secretary, please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Ladding, Malik, Pitch, Braford, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? I know you're still having some difficulty in the back hearing, so I'm raising my voice. Cast up the ballot. 35 yeas, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit the bill to the House. Senator Clark, is it okay to come back to you? Are you ready now, Senator Clark? You want? Okay. All right. We're going to come back to Senator Clark after Senator Stubblefield at the end of the Senate calendar. Senator Bledsoe, got two from you, Senator Bledsoe. So both of these require 24 votes. Senate Bill 440 by Senator Bledsoe to ban use of medical marijuana in food and drink, except in certain
circumstances. Senator Bledsoe is recognized. Thank you, Mr. President. Ladies and gentlemen of the Senate, today I bring you a bill that has taken the rules from the Medical Marijuana Commission verbatim. and put them in a bill to codify them, to make them stronger. Now, when I started this, I worked extensively with the AG's office so that we would not have to have the 24 votes. But yesterday, as I was approaching the well, someone mentioned to me that it was an iffy situation. It would be safer to have the 24 votes. And I did meet with BLR and Mr. Cook and the AG's office. And so that's why I bring this bill to you. There is a divided opinion about how many votes it takes. I am codifying in this bill the exact rules on this issue from the Medical Marijuana Commission. And you may say, well, why are you doing that? It is because in other states that have allowed marijuana, some of the producers of food and candy and that type of thing that are sold in some of the marijuana stores, and I'm speaking mainly about Colorado, they are in the form of gummy bears and suckers and things that children would be attracted to. And that's the Medical Marijuana Commission had had the foresight to disallow anything like that. And so what I'm doing is just making it stronger. And also, if there is tweaking to those rules, we will know about it because it will have to come back and there will be legislation. So, again, it is an opinion. And Senator Bond, I don't know too many attorneys that all agree. So I was in the middle of attorneys agreeing and not agreeing. So that's the situation. And, again, it's for the protection of children. There is no need to put marijuana in gummy bears or any of the things that children are attracted to. So I would appreciate a good vote, and I'd be glad to take questions. Any questions, Senator? Senator Bledsoe,
chocolate? It covers anything that would be, that children would be attracted to. So even though it doesn't specific say candy bars, it would, in my opinion, cover that. And you might say, well, how do adults get it? Well, from what I have learned is that you can package a square that looks like, you know, you would break a Hershey bar into squares, and it could be packaged in a way that would not look like a Hershey candy bar to a child. It's not allowed by the rules, so all this is doing is strengthening those rules. Okay, well, that's what I'm
for a question. Thank you Governor. Senator Bledsoe, okay I understand we're talking about medical marijuana here and I want to know is Is there any prohibition that disallows children with the illnesses diagnosed under the statute that would allow them to avail themselves of medical marijuana? Can children avail themselves of medical marijuana with the conditions, if they have those conditions
that are in our statute? Yes, they can. In fact, again, this is just verbatim from those rules. And if a child needs medical marijuana, a physician is involved, and those whatever or edibles that are not attractive to those children in any situation would be given to that child. But it's already in the rules, Senator. Okay, and
but certainly as a mom, you might appreciate that sometimes we have to trick our children That's true, yes. to take medicine. Right. And so do you think this might really work against the parent who is trying to get a better physical state and healthy state for their child by not allowing them to? Right.
I understand. It is not. This is only about the selling, the commercial products, that kind of thing. Whatever you do in your home, you can do. They don't go into your home and say you can't add it to whatever, but they're talking about the selling of it, the commercial selling of these things. But if you have a child and he is using marijuana, then you can put it in his milk, you can put it in, grind it up in something and bake it. It's up to you. These rules do not apply to what you do in your home.
that that answered part of my question Senator Bledsoe but I was just thinking in terms of I was hoping that perhaps that if I had a child you know how sometimes we do get vitamins and what not we get vitamins that look like little bears and that kind of thing so I was considering if a pharmacy if we manufactured them that way and an adult had to purchase them you know not from a pharmacy or wherever they whatever the proper places they get them if something like that would be okay to do because I was hoping that was the
case but it is the case in fact uh again what you do in your home is up to you and also with the the vitamins that came up in committee the vitamins uh are over the counter so this is not going to be sold over the counter there would be a prohibition like that but if you want to do your gummy bears your vitamin gummy
bears then that would be all right okay well i'm i'm really not talking about making it in my home because maybe I would be the one who made brownies in my home, but I know many families may not be the brownie makers and they might not have what they need to make gummy bears in their home. So what I'm actually talking about is just like as a mother right now, I can go buy those pretty little vitamins and pull my granddaughter or whatever. but I was talking about maybe that same kind of parity if they were in the form of the vitamins that I can get now but they were marijuana because my child that needs that dosage needs to be full too if it were regulated something like that this doesn't provide anything like that whatever the medical marijuana rules are now
Senator Chesterfield. Thank you. Uh, Senator Bledsoe, I just want to point a clarification. This is only dealing with manufactured. Anything that happens in the home privately, this has no enforcement capabilities over it. Is that correct? That's correct. Okay. And in passing this bill as written, uh, did you consult with the Attorney General's Office, or anyone else to determine if this is going to be in direct violation to the Constitution as voted on by the people?
Yes, I did. I worked extensively with the AG's office, but as I was coming down the aisle to present this bill, someone had a question, and so we met with the AG's office, we met with BLR, I met with Mr. Cook, and the consensus was that it would be better to ask for the 24 votes and be safe. They couldn't come to a conclusion. You know, some said yes, some said no. And so that's what I'm doing today. I certainly don't want to get in a legal battle with the Constitution. and so to play it safe, even though I do not think that it is in violation of the Constitution. I think 18 votes would do it, but I would rather be safe, and I would ask for 24 votes. All right, thank you. Thank you. Senator Hill, right now. Thank you, Senator Blitzov.
This is just more for informational purposes. Okay, you made the comment, well, you cannot sell it packaged at a candy bar. Will there be any little, and I'm going to use candy bars, for example, will there be any little chocolate that you can buy or anything like that that has it in it? Well, not for children. Okay, okay, that's the reason I'm asking that question. I'm going away from children. I want to talk about elderly adults. Yes, for adults, yes. For elderly adults. Yes, for adults. Who are older, the sweet taste will make them consume it, because their taste buds will obey as they get older. So you will be able to buy a little chocolate. Yes, and
I have been told that they can be packaged in just a little section and wrapped in a way that it's not attractive to children. Now, would that actually come from a
Chair, and thank you, Senator, for taking my question. Was there an economic impact statement that went along with this as this would cause some loss of
because I'm not sure I understand. When I was in Colorado, I went and visited both a testing, a growing, and a retail facility. And the chocolate and that type of thing, if you're going to use this medicinally, is an important way of delivery. So this does not keep you from putting it in the form
of a chocolate bar to sell. Let me just read you what it says from the Medical Marijuana Commission rules. It says, a cultivation facility or dispensary shall not process or manufacture a medical marijuana item that by its shape or design is likely to appeal to minors, including but not limited to, products that are molded after non-cannabis products primarily consumed by and marketed to children. Products in the shape of an animal, vehicle, person, or character, and products that closely resemble familiar food and drink items, whether generic or branded, that are attracted to minors, including, but not limited to, candy, cookies, and brownies. And it goes on. this if you want if you want candy if you want marijuana in your candy for your child you have to do it at
for a child I'm talking about for an adult it does not keep any adult from getting anything anything that these rules say that adult can do an adult can do and this bill does not keep it keep any adult from doing
no, I'm talking about a manufacturer doing it. It keeps a manufacturing company from putting it into things that would be attractive to children. Now you can put it in chocolate, you can wrap it in something that is not attractive to children, and that's a rule that is in force already. Okay, and I can see where it's
talking about gummy bears, when it's talking about shapes, et cetera. But then when it gets down to candy and brownies, I'm not sure whether it's talking about a candy bar or not. And you
know. Well, I don't know that specifically. I've not been to places that sell it, but it's my understanding that they are following the rule to the T. And I would assume that they can put marijuana in a chocolate bar for an adult and sell it. Thank you. Senator Hendrick. Thank you, Governor. I think all of us
know there was a lot of frustration in how long it took to get this process going, and what we have here is really an implementation of the regulations and the procedures that have already been adopted and improved, and now we're coming back and finishing that up so there's no
more delay. Is that right? That is correct, Senator. Thank you. Any other questions? Anyone wish to speak on this? for against otherwise. Is the center closed? I'm closed. The center is closed. Is there any objection to rolling the vote? Okay, a couple. Madam Secretary, please call the roll. Ballinger? Aye. Bledsoe? Aye. Bond? Aye. Caldwell? Caldwell? Cheatham? Aye. Chesterfield? Aye. Clark?
vote, or change their vote? This side, anybody? Anybody over here? Okay, cast up the ballot. 26 yays, 2 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit the bill to the House. Senator Bledsoe. Senate Bill 441 by Senator Bledsoe. to add restrictions regarding advertising of medical marijuana and use of certain symbols. Senator Bledsoe is
recognized. Thank you, Mr. President. This is exactly the same thing, but it takes the rules and regs from the Medical Marijuana Commission and just codifies them, and this is about the advertising. And I'd be glad to read those rules from the Medical Marijuana Commission if you would like. But that's the same thing. I'd love to have
is recognized for a question. Senator, I would like to, could you define this on page three where it talks about utilizing television, radio, print, and it says that no more than 30% of the audience programming, publication, or website appeals to people under 18 years of age. So is that determined by what? I mean, like the Three Stooges, I mean,
that's pretty much a generational thing. Well, when the Medical Marijuana Commission met and also with the ABC board, they came up with these things, and let me read you again. I'm
Well, I think that the Medical Marijuana Commission would do that. I think that they would work with the advertisers and see what would be in keeping something that would be fair or whatever, but I will say that the broadcasters of Arkansas are for this bill. So I would think, even with them, that if it was too punitive, and maybe they have a desire to sell marijuana and to use the commercials, that they would not be for it. So
something like the Cartoon Network, obviously, although we've probably got some people in here watching the Cartoon Network, but that would be an obvious one. I'm just trying to come up with how
they determine. And I would say that if the Medical Marijuana Commission went through this and put their rules and regs on it, I'm sure that they have been through it, and that's all we're doing. It doesn't change what they can do today. If they can do it now, they'll be able to do it tomorrow after this passes. Okay, thank you.
Any other questions? Anyone? Senator Mark Johnson. Senator Bledsoe, would this be sort of a marijuana equivalent of limiting the use of Joe Camel, which was done several years ago? Maybe so. That's
for a question. Thank you. I have kind of a question kind of opposite of Joe Campbell and Marlboro Man. I would assume that, like, if a woman is pregnant, we're not supposed to drink liquor, although, you know, nobody— I'm having trouble hearing you. I said I would assume like when a woman is pregnant, you're not supposed to consume alcoholic drinks, considered bad for you. And I'm wondering in the rules somewhere if there is, if a woman is pregnant and say has some disease where she was using marijuana before she was pregnant, if she'd be able to continue to do so if her doctor says it's okay.
Do we know about that? I don't know specifically about that. But in the advertising, it will say, like when you're watching TV and you have a medicine that people are, you have a little ad about a certain new medicine that's out, and then they have this long list of, well, if you use it, you may die early or something like that. In this Senate Bill 441, there are those consumer alerts for marijuana. And I believe, if I'm not mistaken, there are four of them. And so one of them would be a pregnant. If you are pregnant, you shouldn't be using
marijuana. Well, I understand, but I don't know if that's a definitive that a doctor would still be able to prescribe it if there was an overriding reason for doing
so. Well, maybe so, but that's between the doctor and her and his patient or her patient. And, again, whatever they can do now, they can do tomorrow if this bill passes.
I'm getting that, but what I'm trying to wrestle with, I see a big difference between it being codified. Well, the senator's suspended. Okay, sure. Senator Elliott has the floor. I just see a big difference in it, and once it's codified, it's harder to change. But if, for example, what I said about the woman and the doctor, and I think it's good that it's between the two of them. That's not a problem for me. But I wouldn't want the doctor to be doing something that could get her in trouble is what I'm worried about. I'm sorry, you wouldn't want a doctor. I would not want the doctor, like it's between my doctor and me if I'm pregnant. I would not want the doctor if she decided there's an overriding reason that I still need to have the marijuana even though I'm pregnant. I wouldn't want that doctor to be in legal trouble. That's what I was getting at. The doctor to be in trouble is... In legal trouble for continuing to prescribe marijuana to me.
We don't know about that. I just don't see that happening. Again, you know, yes, it makes it stronger. It makes, if you're tweaking the rules and regs, then we will know about it. But as far as your case scenario, I can't speak to that.
Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Mike Johnson? Aye. Mark Johnson? Aye. Ledding? Aye. Mallet? Yes. Pitch? Yes. Rapert? Aye. Rice? Aye. Sample? Aye. Stuboffel? Aye. Sturge? Aye. Teague? Aye. Wallace? Anyone wish to change their vote? Anybody wish to vote, Senator Davis? Cast up. That's why I was waiting. She's a yes. Anybody else? Cast up the ballot. 33 yays, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit the bill to the House. And the 24 threshold was met. Senator Eads is recognized for an announcement. Thank you, Mr. President. I'm not sure which
gallery they're in, but I did want to recognize that they just told me they got here. The Hispanic Women's Organization from Northwest Arkansas is here visiting the Capitol today, and I want to make sure we acknowledge them. So welcome them to the Capitol, please.
by Senator Cooper, to amend the laws regarding criminal background checks for professions and occupations to obtain consistency regarding criminal background checks and disqualifying offenses for licensure. Senator. Thank you Mr. President. This
is a bill that's related to the red tape reduction task force. I think all of you know there's been a few bills that's run already concerning that and I sponsored a couple of them already. This is a major piece of legislation having to do with that and give you a little background again on that. There's 11 states that were involved in this consortium that's funded from a grant from the Department of Labor, and it's in conjunction with the National Conference of State Legislatures and the National Governors Association. And out of that effort, I was co-chair for a year of that red tape reduction task force. This bill here is the fulfillment of two of the, or at least part of the provisions, two of the five provisions that was made to the governor that came out of that task force. And the first part of that, the chapter one of that, is the non-codified language in it, and the definition started in chapter two. And from then on, it deals with the provisions that disqualify a person in occupational licensing. And what happens right now is that the provisions in occupational licensing is very loose and uncertain. And the boards are not sure what they can do, what they need to do. and the statutory guidance is very unclear so what we heard during the task force over and over again was stories like somebody would go to educational training possibly for a long time and then come back for licensing and then be told that they were automatically disqualified on something in their background. There's a couple of things about that. One is they should have had a provision to determine that before they spent all that time in education. And second of all, a lot of the boards did not realize or did not know or maybe wasn't authorized to whether they could even waiver any of those provisions or not. And some of them were not legally authorized to do that. so this puts it in statute clear guidance to what the boards can do and gives them a framework for the the offenses that will disqualify them and then it steps down like a ladder below that that gives them a guidance for how to waive how to do wavering from those offenses and the first six pages, I believe it is, sets all that framework out. And up through page four of that, starting into page five, is the waiver process that I've just been talking about. And then also within that waiver process, there is some guidance for the boards on what is the basis for wavering. And I'll just quickly go over some of that with you. It's the age of which the offense was committed, the circumstances around the offense, the length of time since it was committed, the subsequent work history since the offense was committed, employment references since it was committed, the character references, and the relevance of the offense to what the occupational license is going to be going forward. And then other demonstrated characteristics can also be considered. So that's the basis of it. The remainder of the bill, once you get through that, is having to do with cleaning up uncertain language like moral turpitude, Character, be of good character, which really doesn't mean anything statutorily. It might mean one thing to one person and something else to another. So really, that kind of language really needed to be cleaned up. And this bill, once you get past page 7, is this cleanup language, getting away from that and inserting the statutory guidance that we've done. this bill has been a lot of eyes put on it it's it was actually developed by the Attorney General's office it's supported by the state police it's also supported by the governor and one more thing I might mention concerning this in regard to what I said while ago about somebody being disqualified after they'd already been trained in something there is a provision in here a pre-license background check and what that means is that somebody can come to a board before they have invested the time in in their time and expense going through all that training they can come back to the board and get some guidance on that as to whether or not they would be later be able to qualify that does not lock in the board but it gives them a ability to do some guidance to an individual that has some kind of a background. Then the next section of it on page seven is just the propagation of rules to implement this as time goes on later and it's become in effect January 1st 2020. That is pretty much the bill uh it's a pretty good sized bill but it's easy to read to read bill and it's very clearly laid out i believe and i i would be uh ready to answer any questions uh concerning it if anybody
has any any any questions anyone wish to speak on the bill senator closed closed any objection to rolling the vote? No. No objection or no, don't roll? Not roll. Madam
rolling. Ballinger? Aye. Bledsoe? Aye. Bond? Aye. Caldwell? Aye. Caldwell? Aye. Cheatham? Aye. Chesterfield? Aye. Clark? Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismain, Eads, Eads, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Aye. Ledding? Aye. Mallett? Pitch? Yes. Rapert? Aye. Rice? Aye. He said aye. Sample? No. Stubbeville? Aye. Sturge? Aye. Teague? Aye. Wallace? Aye. Senator Clark is aye. Senator Davis, were you aye? No. Okay. And anybody want to change your vote, cast up the ballot, 34 yeas, one nay. The bill is passed. Transmit the bill. Down to the House, Senator Blake Johnson. First of two bills. Senate Bill 513 by Senator Johnson concerning a suspension of a person's driver's license for possessing a controlled substance. Senator Johnson
is recognized. Members, this bill just gives the court some levity in their dealing with suspension of a driver's license upon a conviction or no contest of a controlled substance. And it'll help the CDL drivers and things that's going through rehabilitation to keep those driver's licenses intact so they can make a living. That's what it does.
Appreciate a good vote. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak on the bill? Is Senator closed? Yes. Senator's closed. Any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Raypert, Rice, Sample, Stevifield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35, yay, zero, nays. The bill is passed. Transmit the bill to the House. We're going to pass over the second bill of Senator Blake Johnson's and go to Senator Stubblefield, and then we'll come back around, Senator Clark, to you. That'll be the end of the Senate calendar. And then we'll move to the House bills. Senate Bill 550 by Senator Stubblefield to amend the law regarding liquid livestock litter utilization. Senators recognize. Thank you, Governor. Senator Stubblefield is down at the well.
Colleagues, Senate Bill 550, let me say just a word or two before I present this. You know, as someone who's spent 45 years in farming, all but the four years I got out after I got out of college and a number of years before that, I speak to you as someone who's got some practical experience in this area, someone who's got some real life experiences, not an amateur. So I've dealt with what I'm talking, getting ready to talk about for all my life, all my life. And one of my colleagues, I won't say his name, Senator Hickey, told me this before I got up here. He said, you know, if you want to be effective in politics, you need to stir people's emotions. I wrote that down. Well, you know, that's true. That's very true. Well, this bill stirred a lot of emotions. I can assure you that. and there's been a lot of fear-mongering and a lot of unfounded speculation and uh thank you senator caldwell a lot of things put out there that are just absolutely unfounded unfounded let me just start by saying how many of you know what a CAFO is see the word this bill that is a concentrated animal feeding operation that's what those letters stand for. State CAFO program in Arkansas is currently permitted by two state agencies. Dry litter, which is typically poultry and but can include dairy, is regulated by ANRC. And liquid litter, typically swine and dairy, is regulated by ADEQ. Clearly the EPA has not issued with ANRC handling dry litter CAFO requirements. As a matter of fact, several states issue CAFO permits through the Department of Agriculture and not their Department of Environmental Quality, such as states like Oklahoma, Tennessee, Georgia, and Delaware, just to name a few. I was also asked by a colleague if I would go through some of these points in order to maybe eliminate some of the questions later on, and hopefully it will. This will take just a few minutes. Does this bill help CNH? Because that's one of the things that should be brought up. Absolutely not. This bill has nothing to do with CNH. This proposed bill states that all applications that are in the House right now with ADEQ must remain with ADEQ until a decision is made. CNH is currently operating under an expired general permit because they are submitted, they submitted a timely application. If they pull that application in an attempt to circumvent this process, CNH will no longer have the authority to operate and they would they would need to remove the facilities immediately. So if anything, this bill would prevent anything else from happening in that area. And by the way, those problems with CNH were not caused by ANRC. ANRC is an agency that wrote the first Reg 5 ever. And by the way, if you want to talk about a success story, as far as the phosphorus index is concerned, ANRC is to go to the Illinois River Shed up in northwest Arkansas. They are the ones that took care of that problem with Oklahoma and Arkansas with all the problems with phosphorus up there. They have the expertise as far as the phosphorus index more than any other agency. Does this weaken current, this is one of the comments that I got, and I'm sure you got a lot, does this weaken current regulatory requirements? Absolutely not. The law clearly states that ANRC must issue permits. The proposed law transfers all permits to ANRC and requires them to develop regulations for current permittees and future applicants. These regulations must be no less stringent than the existing regulations, while allowing ANRC the flexibility to implement additional regulations consistent with their current statutes. If ANRC does not, at a minimum, maintain existing regulations, all currently permitted facilities are subject to additional public notification. Can farmers opt out or waive public notice requirements? That's another, I'm sure that's another point that you received in some of your emails. Absolutely not. You've heard of the Administrative Procedures Act. This pertains to existing law that requires permits to be issued in a timely manner. Farmers generally take out loans, like any of you that are farmers or other businessmen do. They take out loans. So issuing permits in a timely manner is imperative to farmers. Because interest rates change, sometimes those banks give you sole loan to get your operation underway. You don't have forever. You can't allow the permitting process to filibuster for years while your money is available. You've got a certain time period. But they still have to have a public comment period. In the event the farmer finds that additional time is necessary, the farmer may allow the permitting agency more time to make the permitting decision. The proposed law requires ANRC to follow the Administrative Procedure Act, which does not allow for public notices to be waived or ignored. In fact, all state agencies are required to follow the Administrative Procedures Act on public notification. Next question. Does this exempt all CAFOs from regulation of Arkansas Water and Air Pollution Control Act? Absolutely not. ANRC currently regulates poultry houses, and if a farmer places piles of chicken litter near a stream, ADEQ has the authority to inspect the farm and write them up for any violations of the Arkansas Water and Air Pollution Control Act. The proposed law does not change that authorization. As a matter of fact, the AG's office has suggested language to be added to the bill that requires the two agencies, ANRC and ADEQ, to work together. Local boards can issue permits or make decisions. That's false. No, ANRC will work with local conservation districts, like you and I have in our counties, on the development of the nutrient management plan and any local issues, but ANRC will make the permitting decision. What is the timeframe of implementation? The bill requires the ANRC Commission to develop and implement regulations for the issuance of permits by January 1st, 2021. More specifically, the final rules shall be filed with the Secretary of State no later than July 1st, 2020. And by the way, the legislature still has to approve these rules. That's just an added layer of protection. Will this impact the permits moving forward? The law will not make it easier to get a permit by lowering the regulatory standards. It streamlines the process by keeping farmers and ranchers from being regulated by two state agencies. With that being said, I'll answer any questions. Senator
Senator Stubblefield. Yes, ma'am. Is this a solution in search of a problem? No, ma'am. Why this has worked poorly in the past, and that's why it's a necessity, or it's just something that—what made this come about?
It makes it easier for farmers who have swine, poultry, or dairy poultry, or all three combinations to go to one agency and get permitted. what are the
So it's the fact that you're dealing with two separate agencies now, and you would collapse all of that under one agency? That's right. We saw that, yes. But I keep reading about all of the angst that some people are having about it, And even though you read beautifully, I am still unclear as to how this makes everything better. Well, it makes it easier for
CNH Hog Farm? The original permits to CNH Hog Farm were issued by ADEQ, and a lot of the problems we've had with that permit and that problem on the Buffalo River are the result of ADEQ's failure as far as their engineering was concerned. They will readily admit that. And
then secondly, some of the issues that are being expressed to me are about the matter of about the agency being controlled by the farmers. Is it fair to say or is there any evidence that would show that any of the water systems ever attempt to control ADQ or try to use their influence of controlling ADQ
in their decisions? Or do you know of any? I don't know of any, Senator Hamer. All right, thank you. Senator Malek, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. President. Senator Stubblefield, thank you for clearing up a lot of the issues. And I know all of us are getting a lot of emails and some of them stating things that I think are not true. And you cleared up some of those. But let me ask you about a couple more. Some are saying that this does away even with the requirement for a permit, that you just get a certification. So do you still have to get a permit? Still have to get a permit. The other thing that you haven't addressed, I got one email that stated this would immediately do away with the moratorium in the Buffalo River watershed. No. All this has nothing to do with that. This same email to me stated it would allow an unlimited number of dirtier CAFOs, concentrated animal feeding operations, to be permitted in the Buffalo National River watershed.
Is that correct or not? That's not correct. As a matter of fact, Senator Malek, there has been a decline in CAFOs all across the United States. And I'm sure you're aware as a farmer why we have CAFOs, because many of our family farms, small farms, were regulated out of business. Thousands, we've lost hundreds of thousands of small farms. And because of that, now we have factory mega farms that have come in. And I will agree, as a farmer, when you concentrate large numbers of animals in one area, you do need regulations. You have to regulate that.
or weakening any of those regulations. the back on the buffalo river the moratorium was i think implemented uh in 2015 and it was for five years so what agency is going to determine whether that moratorium is made permanent what agency yeah this your bill doesn't go into effect until 2021 right that will still be on the purview of adq and they'll make that decision whether to keep the moratorium in place exactly Thank you. Senator Hill, then
Senator Clark. You okay, Senator Clark? Okay. Senator Hill, then Senator Flowers. Senator Hill. Senator Stoverfield. Yes. You're familiar with the broiler industry, right? With what? The broiler industry. Chicken houses. I
am very familiar with the broiler industry. Okay. You know they put rice shavings in them, right? Exactly. And if you took the rice shavings out of those broiler houses, would you have liquid or dry
manure? You would have liquid manure. Thank you, sir. And I would elaborate on that further, if somebody would like. One of the differences, and by the way, broiler houses are under ANRC. They regulate dry litter. But poultry litter and swine litter are basically the same. The only difference is when poultry houses, their chickens poop. They have rice hulls. They have shavings on the ground that absorb that. They windrow it. They stir it up for a whole year. Many of them don't clean out for a year. It's considered dry litter. If those were in hog
Sorry, Senator Chesterfield. Senator Flowers. Thank you, Senator Stubblefield, for clearing up some of the issues. and it seems to me like you've addressed pretty much all of the issues that have been brought to your attention in terms of the concerns that the people of Arkansas have put to you. Would you say you have? I've tried
to Senator Flowers. Anytime you deal with the environment you know you do stir up a lot of emotions and I will confess to you there is no one in this state that loves agriculture and also loves our natural, our environment in the state as much as I do, our natural resources. I don't want dirty water. I want clean water. It takes clean water to operate a farm. We do everything within our power, you know, as farmers to try to maintain the environment, take good
care, and be good stewards of the land that we have. So that, now from what I understand, your bill, existing regulations would be maintained. And even if beyond 2021, when the transfer to ANRC takes place, then if those minimum, if the regulations that we have now are changed after 2021, there has to be notice to the public, including environmental groups? If those regulations change, they cannot change to
the weaker side. They have to be more stringent, and they would still have to be approved by the legislature. But also, would there be notice to the public? There would be notice to the public. And let me say one more thing. With all of the public relation and all of the attention that CNH has created in the last six years, how many of you think that ANRC or any other agency is going to put a CAFO next to the Buffalo River or any other waterway or any residential? Do any of you really believe that they would do that? I would want to be the head of that agency if they did. Senator Dismayne
I mean I think I know the answer but and I just want to want it stated one more time because it is important to me on on this particular issue the CNH hog farm this will have no impact on its current application its process or anything else and and just to confirm uh what they have in place right now will continue to be under ADUQ, and it's not going to be transferred in any way because of this bill. Is that correct? That's
Any other questions? Anyone wish to speak on this bill against for Senator Bond eagerly seeks to speak against? Senator Bond is recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you,
Governor, and we've previously disclosed that one of my law partners does represent the Ozark Society in litigation, just to be clear about that. But let me say this. I don't see anywhere in the bill where it says the rules will be more stringent. I don't see that in the bill. Sponsor may point that out when he comes back up. We've received information from the Beaver Water District, from CAW, which is the water there in my district, and from Ed Bethune saying this is a bad idea. If you think back to the mottos of our state, we've been the bear state, the wonder state, the land of opportunity, and in 1995 we became what? The natural state. And in that act of 1995 that made us the natural state, sponsored by a representative from Texarkana, actually, Dennis Young, it said, in that, it noted our unsurpassed scenery, clear lakes, free-flowing streams, magnificent rivers, and many other things. This is a step back. This is not a step forward. We know what's happening in the Buffalo River. We know the water is degrading in the Buffalo River. It's not a time to shrink from that. not a time to change something. It's not a time to make it easier. It's a time for us to truly embrace that we are the natural state. And if we're going to do something like this, it's not something that we should do quickly at all. We should make dang sure that we are protecting our natural resources, not destroying them. Y'all remember just a few weeks, a few days ago in budget, Bella Vista came and asked for 10 20 million dollars because of the stump dump right and I asked in budget to Senator Hinder and I said this is a problem that's developed over years and years and years isn't it and he said yes and I said that's kind of like what could be happening in the Buffalo River yes now is not the time to shrink from the work that has been done by ADQ the efforts that they put in after allowing CNH into the rivershed. And listen to the people who are experts, CAW, Beaver Water District, and even former Congressman Ed Bethune, who say this is now not the time to shrink from our motto, which is the natural state. I would appreciate
answer questions. Senator Hammer. Thank you. Senator Bond, I heard your concerns. The problem I have is the reason we're even having a discussion about the C&H hog farm and potentially what people are perceiving to be fears of what may come in the future, citing that as an example, all happened under the jurisdiction of then ADQ when that permit was issued. So, help me rationalize why we should feel safe leaving it with ADQ, no disrespect to the current leadership, but why we should leave it there now when they were the ones that got us in the problem in the first place. Well, and I think that's pointed
out, if you'll look at the two, I think they're on your desk, from CAW and from Beaver Water District particularly, no doubt it was a mistake. I think Governor Beebe has even said one of the biggest regrets that he had of his governorship was that this happened on his watch, but we all know it now, and ADEQ is on top of it at this point, and so I don't think the time to change it, and with this bill particularly, like I said, I don't see anywhere in here that says things will be more stringent, and the sponsor may point that out when he gets up here, but I've reviewed it, and I don't see it, so I don't think we should change it
you take a question? I will attempt to take a question from Senator Desmond, yes. No, simple question, same one I had earlier. Again, my concern is with CNH and how this may or may not change the position that they're in right now. Do you believe that the bill, 550, right, wrong, or indifferent, as far as your viewpoint on the bill, does
it have any implications for CNH as how they've moved forward? I was not in the committee discussion on the bill. It is my view of review of the bill that it's possible that CAFOs could now apply through ANRC and the local commissions for a certification or to allow them to apply for a liquid CAFO permit. That's my review. I'm sure the sponsor disagrees with that, but that is my concern, and I think that's a legitimate concern. Does the
Farms? I know there's litigation going on with regards to that, and I think AEDQ has denied an ongoing permit to CNH. And I will say that I think the Ozark Society is involved directly in that litigation. So just to be clear. Well,
the natural state. Senator Blake Johnson is going to speak in favor of the bill. Senator Blake Johnson. Then I've got Senator Clark that wants to speak on the bill, for the bill. And Senator Hill wants to speak for the bill. Anyone want to speak against
the bill? Okay. Senator Johnson, you have the floor. Members, these agriculture producers of poultry, hogs, and cattle feed this state and feed this great nation. This would unify the process for their permitting so they could continue to feed this great state and great nation. It will not change the issues that they have in the Buffalo River. But these producers are the original naturalists and they make their living off the land That is regulated. I would appreciate a good vote on this bill
Anyone would speak against the bill, okay, we're going to Senator Clark. Are you gonna? Still want to speak on the bill. Senator Clark can speak on the bill. You want to speak against? I didn't see anybody that wanted to speak against the bill. Well, we went from questions to speeches, but we'll take another question before we close. We're just trying to keep it rolling. Senator Clark will speak. Keeping the state, the
for debate. that's kind of like you know are are we against war of course we're against war and of course we want to keep this a natural state the first vacation I can remember family vacation that we went on mom and dad say pennies and nickels and dimes in a jar and we went to dog patch and stayed on the Buffalo River and I've been canoeing and hiking there ever since and it is truly a national treasure I live in Garland County so I've spent my whole life on Lake Ouachita, which is billed as one of the cleanest lakes anywhere. I've also spent my life on Lake Hamilton and Lake Catherine. And in the 70s, Lake Hamilton and Lake Catherine both had the distinction of being named in a national magazine as in the top 10 dirtiest lakes in the country. So I've seen both sides. And none of us want the Buffalo River to be polluted. I also probably have worked with ANRC more than any other legislator since I work with water. For most people, ANRC is just letters. The Arkansas Natural Resource Commission works on water issues, is over water issues, and they do a great job. They take it very seriously, and that's really the main reason that I came down here. That and the fact that I'm also a small businessman. and one of the most difficult challenges I have is dealing with the government and it's not that I don't do things legally because it's just it's finding out what the laws are and then dealing with those laws and when you can put things in one branch versus two so that you're dealing with one agency and things are already dealing with one agency versus having to go here and figure out what they want and then going over here and figuring what they want if you can put it in one It just makes life a lot easier. And the easier we can make life for our small farmers and for our farmers in general, the better. This is a good bill. The hype and the anti—out there and the angst is just superstition. There's nothing real about it. It does not affect the current situation on the Buffalo River at all. But it's a good bill. We need to pass it. I appreciate your consideration. Anyone wish to speak against?
Anyone wish to speak on the bill? Senator Hill is going to speak for the bill, and then we'll go back to the bill's sponsor to get Senator Ingram any other questions. We'll flesh all that out before we close. Go ahead, Senator Hill. This
is just in reference. I want to make a comment first about my friend Senator Bond, what he said a while ago. I brought the bill up here, too, and he is correct. I do not see anywhere in here where it said it strengthens. But also, as I continue to read on, do not see where it weakens either and so I am not an expert I'll just say I do have a master's degree in ag business I do have a farm been in farming business for 51 years we'll continue that as long as the Lord allows me to but I am not an expert by any means and so I will say I support this bill and I have worked with the ARNC on many occasions personally and professionally and they can do this job and will not weaken this bill in any way.
is recognized. Thank you, Governor. We've talked about the dry poultry litter and that that is not exempt from federal soil and water requirements, correct? Correct. But hog waste is, is not under the federal water, it's not exempt from the limited liquid animal waste, correct? No, that's right. So that isn't covered. The other question that I've got is, if you look on page four, I mean, I think it was stated earlier that the liquid livestock litter management plan is subject to approval by the board of directors of the conservation district, but I think it said ANCR it was stated, but that's not correct according to this bill, is it? No, ANCR will work
with the local conservation district and maybe take some input, but they make the final decision. The local conservation district makes the final decision,
not ANCR. No, no, no. ANCR makes the final decision. Not the local conservation. Help me with that language there, starting on three, on page four, because I think, as I read it, a liquid livestock litter management plan is subject to approval by the board of directors of the conservation district where the majority of the land of which the liquid livestock litter management plan is located. I don't see anything in there about ANRC. They put together a plan,
I mean, it says, I mean, if I read this, and maybe I'm misreading, it says that the local directors of the conservation district is subject to their approval, not ANCR. What line are you on, Senator? Look on page 4, line 3
Okay, show me that. Now, where is that? That's line 989. Well, that's where they appeal. They appeal it, if I read that correct. But the approval lies with the directors of the conservation district. You see, it says it may appeal the board's disapproval of the liquid livestock litter management. Right below what you're talking about on parentheses 2, lines 7 through 11, that's where the appeal goes to. If I'm reading that correct.
Yeah. A person requesting to implement a liquid livestock litter management plan may appeal the board's decision. Disapproval. Disapproval of the liquid livestock litter management plan.
That's an appeal. Yeah. I got that that's an appeal. But my point is that it's been represented that ANCR was the approving agency. But that's not really true. It is the Board of Directors of the Conservation District, and then if that individual or that firm is turned down, they have a way to appeal to ANCR. But if it's approved, the approval comes from the Conservation District. It would be only challenged if they
questions for the senator before he closes? Senator closed? Yeah, I'm closed. I just want to say one thing. You know, the leading industry in this state is agriculture. Still the biggest industry. employees of most people, either directly or indirectly. We've worked together, and it was that way when we were declared a natural state. We still
is a big part of this state. I would appreciate a good vote. Madam Secretary, please call the roll when you can. Ballinger? Aye. Bledsoe? Bledsoe? Bond? No. Caldwell. Aye. Cheatham. Cheatham. Chesterfield. Aye. Clark. Aye. Cooper. Aye. Davis. Yes. Dismain. Aye. Eads. Eads. Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, No. Irvin. Irvin. Blake Johnson. Aye. Mark Johnson. No. Letting. No. Malik. No. Pitch. No. Raebert. Raebert. Rice. Aye. Sample. Aye. Stubbeville. Aye. Sturge. Sturge. Teague. Aye. Wallace. Wallace. Anyone who did not vote wish to vote? Anyone wish to change their vote? Senator Cheatham is present.
not voting. Senator Cheatham, present. Senator Flowers is I. Senator Eads is I. Anybody else over here? Okay, Senator Bledsoe is I. Senator Sturge is I. Anybody over here? Is that not vote? Present. Senator Raper, present. Present. Senator Raper, present. Senator Ballinger? Senator Ballinger?
he doesn't get in here he's not going to have a vote okay we're about to cast up the ballot everybody happy cast up the ballot 25 yeas 5 nays the bill is passed transmit to the house senator clark senator clark is the last of the Senate bills, then we will move to the House bills. It's a relatively short list. Senate Bill 311 by Senator Clark to amend the law concerning disqualification of judges. Senator Clark.
311, an act to amend the law concerning disqualification of judges and for other purposes. Did you know that in Arkansas a judge can hear a lawsuit involving a member of his staff or a case involving a family member of their staff? Arkansas circuit judges hold nearly unlimited power to take children from their parents, determine prison terms, and manage jury trials. This bill would help reduce bias and the appearance of bias by amending the present law on judicial recusal so judges cannot hear cases where a member of their current or former staff is a party
or a lawyer on the case. I'll be glad to take any questions. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak on this bill in any way, shape, or form? Is the senator closed? I'm closed. I appreciate a good vote. Any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismaine, Eades, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Senator Malik is a no. Senator Pitch is a no. Senator Elliott is a no. Senator Raper is a no. Senator Teague is not voting. Senator Chesterfield is present. Anybody else? Senator Ingram, present. Anybody else? cast senator sample no vote going once he said no right he's a no vote senator sample no vote going once going twice cast up the ballot 26 yeas six nays the bill's passed transmit it bless you down to the house moving to the house bills we got four of them Senator M. Johnson. House Bill 1343 by Representative Hawks and Senator Mark Johnson to amend the law concerning publication of the annual financial report
of the county. Senator Mark Johnson. Thank you, Governor. This bill is sponsored by Representative Hawks and a whole bunch House members, as well as myself and Senator Rayford. It allows a county to file, to publish its financial report, its annual financial report, its budget, to the public using electronic means. In other words, they can post it on the internet. It specifically says they can have their own website they could even my understanding even use Facebook or they could put it on a website that currently exists that's maintained by the Association of Counties but the idea is to make it easily accessible by members of the public who want to look at the county budget to kind of head off a question in that regard it still requires a one-time publication in a newspaper that is general circulation in that county. If there are no other questions, I appreciate a good
vote. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak on the bill? Is the senator closed? I'm closed. Senator has closed. Any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Hitch, Rayford, Rice, Sample, Stubbofill, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their
ballot. 34 yeas, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Return the bill to the House. Senator Bledsoe. House Bill 1523 by Representative Petty and Senator Bledsoe concerning the treatment of female inmates and detainees in correctional or detention facilities and concerning pregnant inmates and
detainees. Senator Bledsoe. Thank you, Mr. President. Ladies and gentlemen of the Senate, House Bill 1523 has been called the Women's Dignity Bill because it's aimed at improving conditions for incarcerated women. In 2008, five states enacted such form of the Dignity Bill, including Kentucky and Arkansas's neighboring state, Louisiana. The legislation that I present today, Arkansas's Dignity Bill, is a collaborative effort with Criminal Justice reform advocates with the Justice Action Network, legislators, and the Department. We also appreciate the support of this reform package by Governor Hutchinson and Wendy Kelly at the Department of Corrections. I'd like to take just a few minutes to read some of the reforms that are included in the bill. This reform legislation sets restrictions on corrections regarding the use of shackles restraints on female inmates during pregnancy or labor. Correctional officers shall not restrict pregnant inmates while in labor unless they present a reasonable risk of flight or pose a safety risk to self, child, the officers, or medical personnel. If at any point the medical professionals request the restraints to be removed, they must be removed. If correctional officers decide restraints are necessary, the officers must report their finding within 10 days regarding the flight or safety risk that was posed to the Board of Correction. The reform sets forth necessary prenatal supplements and nutritional snacks for pregnant inmates as the standard. Officers must use the least restrictive method of restraint. This includes prohibition of using leg restraints on pregnant inmates, only using forward-facing restraints for the protection of herself and others, and only soft restraints can be used. The reform prohibits pregnant inmates from being shackled to other inmates. The reform specifies that pregnant inmates only be assigned to bottom bunks and be provided access to non-profit educational information. And ladies and gentlemen, this bill came out of the House with 96 votes, and I would appreciate a good vote, and I'd be glad to answer any questions.
you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, Senator Bledsoe, for bringing the bill. I'm sure you remember our colleague in the House, Representative Sharon Dobbins, who fought so hard for this bill, and I know she's somewhere very, very much thanking you for bringing it, and I appreciate it, too. Thank you
Any other questions? Anyone wish to speak on the bill? Is Senator closed? I'm closed. Any objection to rolling the vote? Before we do, you okay? Okay. Please roll the vote, Madam Secretary. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eads, Elliott, English, Phillipo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Ludding, Malik, Pitch, Rayford, Rice, Sample, Stubblefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote, seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35, yay, zero, nays. The bill's passed. Return the bill to the House. We're going to pass over Senator Dismane's bill momentarily. And we're going to go to Senator Pitch. House Bill 1689 by Representative Feight and Senator Pitch to amend the law concerning the penalties for passing in an authorized vehicle stopped on a highway. Senator Pitch is recognized. Senator Pitch has the floor. Thank you, Governor.
House Bill 1689 is a bill where we deal with those who go in when everybody else is coming out. It's supported by the Arkansas Police Chiefs, the Sheriff's Association, the State Police, and the Ambulance Association. On February 28th of this year, we had a motor vehicle accident on Highway 62, Illinois River Bridge. During this time, a camera was set up by law enforcement as first responders and law enforcement were on scene. And numerous times, passing vehicles literally came within inches of them. On this date, the very same day, two Washington County Sheriff's Department vehicles in separate issues were hit by passing cars while working on an accident on Interstate 49. This is an ongoing and very serious threat to first responders, and it's one I believe most people support. We have had no opposition to this bill. What we are doing is putting more meat behind the fines. Instead of $35 to $500, we're upping it to $250 to $1,000 to protect our first responders. Any questions? Senator Garner, recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr.
was a first responder on the side, a cop on the side of the road, and there were 18 wheelers where I couldn't get over. Now, I read the law, and it said basically if you can't safely get over, you're not required to get over. The problem is the cop got upset, pulled me over, and was going to attempt to write me a ticket even though I knew the law, explained it to him, and said that. So I'm fine with doing the increased penalties, but I think there has to be an understanding that this is now a more severe punishment and that if we're going to do that, we need to make sure that the entities that are on the road we all care for understand that sometimes you can't get over in very rare situations. If I didn't have that personal experience, I wouldn't be bringing it up.
I would concur totally and we specifically did not change what you're supposed to do. You can slow down or you can move over at the regular speed. We didn't mess with that. We just wanted to put the deterrent,
something that was real. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak on the bill in any way, shape or form? Senator has closed. Any objection to rolling the vote? Madam Secretary, please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubberfield, Teague Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Cast the ballot. 35 yeas, 0 nays. The bill's passed. Turn the bill to
by Representative Davis and Senator Dismayne to provide funding for a National Cancer Institute designated Cancer Center in the state through changes in the laws relating to the sale, and taxation of tobacco products, cigarette paper, and e-cigarettes. Senator Dismayne is recognized. Thank you, Governor. So the same bill as
yesterday, I think I've done the very best I can to go around and clear up any concerns that members had in the room. If you plan on supporting the bill, I'd ask you to go ahead and take your seat. Senator Rice, I actually got a note. He got an urgent constituent need out in the front here. But with that, again, I'd be happy
Speak on the bill. Thank you, Governor and colleagues, since I have the one that kind of left us up today. You know I have some hearing problems. I did not hear yesterday where they had stair-step the age limit in rather than going to 21 all at once. That is my opposition to this bill. I appreciate the work on the national cancer designation. Tax me when you need to tax me, put a fee on me when you have to, but when you take my personal rights away. And again, I don't smoke. Did a little at one time. I'd rather people not smoke. And we can make things that we say, you're not going to do this. When you told me that as a young person, you pretty much assured I was going to do it. And a lot of you, you're guilty too. So while there's many things, and Senator Garner addressed it all the other day, and that's my problem. Out in rural Arkansas, and I know it's in the city too, but we have kids that come out of high school and they go to work and some of them work for me over the years and they go ahead and get married and they may have kids and they're humping it every day to make a living, but they smoke. They don't smoke in my store. They don't smoke in my warehouses and they don't smoke in my trucks, but they can smoke on breaks. And that's where I'll let them. So that's a problem I've got. Understand this. With all the stuff we're hearing out of D.C., with stuff that we do down here, all people hear is no, no, no, no. We're taking
your rights away. Again, tax me and fine me when you have to. But don't take your rights away. Thank you. Anybody else wish to speak on the bill for, against? Senator is closed. Madam Secretary, call the roll. Flippo. No. Flowers. Aye. Garner. No. Hammer. Aye. Hendren. Aye. Hester. No. Hickey. Hickey. Hill. No. Ingram. Aye. Irvin. Aye. Blake Johnson. Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson. Aye. Letting. Aye. Mallet. No. Pitch. Yes. Raper. Yes. Rice. No. Sample. No. Sample. Yes. Stubbafil. No. Sturge. Aye. Teague. No. Wallace. Anyone wish to vote or change their vote? Senator Hickey is no. Anybody else? Anybody over here? Anybody over here? Cast up the ballot. 22 yays, 10 nays, the bill's passed. Return the bill
your question. I'm going to roll through these amendments fast. If you've got an objection, use your voice so I can hear you. He just stated the amendment. Any questions on the amendment? Without objection, the amendment is adopted. Senator Grossing, next. Amendment 1, Senate Bill 499. This
is for Governor's letter 11, Decreases the Hospital and Medical Services Line, In Search and Appropriation for Nursing Home Closure Costs, Nursing Home Quality Care Grants and Long-Term Care Facility Receivership. I'd answer
any questions. You've heard the amendment. Any questions? Any objections? Without objection, the amendment is adopted. Send to engrossing. Next amendment. Amendment 1, the Senate Bill
100. This is for Governor's letter 11. Increases the data processing line item in the operations appropriation by $2 million. And increases the community services appropriation by $850,000. Increases the residential services appropriation by $2.15 million. Any questions or
objections? Without objection, the amendment is passed. Send to engrossing. Next. Amendment 2 to Senate Bill 103. This act for the Department of Human Services,
Division of Child Care and Early Childhood Education, for Governor's Letter 11, decreases the child care grants appropriation by $5 million in order to reallocate appropriation to various needs in the Division of Youth Services.
Bill 110. Members, this is Arkansas Economic Development Commission, based on Governor's letter 10, changes the funding source of three appropriations within the bill, Division of Science and Technology, State Operations, Rural Services Division, State Operations, and the Division of Science and Technology, Arkansas Manufacturing Extension Network, State Appropriation, from the Miscellaneous Agency Fund to the Arkansas Economic Development Commission Fund.
Any questions or objections? Without objection, the amendment is adopted, send to engrossing. That's all the amendments. We've got two bills. Are we going to batch these two? Yes. Without objection, we're
Madam Secretary. He needs to tell them. All right, members. I have two bills. I have Senate Bill 138, Joint Budget Committee Education Department, and I have Senate Bill 431, Department of Finance Administration, Alcohol and Beverage Control Enforcement Division Supplemental. I'd answer any questions.
Questions? I move that we batch and roll them. Batch and roll them. Any objections? Any questions? Anyone want to speak? The senator is closed. Madam Secretary, please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Mallott, Pitch, Ray Rice, Sample, Stubberfield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote, seeing none, cast up the ballot, 35 ayes, 0 nays. The budget bills, both of them bashed together, have passed their Senate bills, sent them to the House. Senator Teague is still at the podium, so he must
have an announcement. I do, Mr. President. Members, budget at 9 tomorrow. Members' bills again tomorrow. If you have a member's bill and you want to have it heard tomorrow, you need to tell me or call it and tell staff. I expect we'll do member's days every day from now on out, just so that if you have a bill that you need to run, we can get that done. A peer review meets sometime. Tomorrow, a peer review meets tomorrow morning at 7.30.
Senator Johnson, Blake Johnson. Transportation in Old Supreme Court at 8.45 in the morning. Thank you. Senator Stubblefield has an announcement. Thank you, Governor.
Members, Tax and Revenue Committee is meeting 10 minutes upon adjournment per chairman. Senator Hendren is recognized. Members, I've got some bad news. We had
10 bills on the calendar today. Tomorrow we have right now over 40. So plan on a full day tomorrow. We are going to start at 1 because working through lunch and that kind of calendar is not going to be productive. Plus we've got more work doing the committee. So good news is you're pushing stuff out of committee, but it's going to be a full day tomorrow. Any other announcements?
the morning at 8 o'clock. Agriculture, 8 o'clock. Any other announcements? We're going to convene at 1 o'clock tomorrow. 1 o'clock, 1 o'clock. Any other announcements? Any other announcements? Senate is adjourned subject to the clearing of the desk.
SR27 M. Pitsch TO ENCOURAGE THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO DESIGNATE THE BUTTERFIELD OVERLAND MAIL TRAIL AS A NATIONAL HISTORIC TRAIL.
30:36 - 31:485 segments2 speakers
Senator Mathew Pitsch presented Senate Resolution 27, urging Congress to designate the Butterfield Overland Mail Trail as a national historic trail and explained the need for the resolution after learning Arkansas lacked such a designation.
[30:46][30:51][30:55]
The chair asked for any questions, received none, and the Senate moved to adopt the resolution, with all members voting “aye” and the measure being adopted.
[31:26]
HCR1008 Vaught B. Davis TO RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE OF ORGAN DONATION TO PUBLIC HEALTH AND TO SUPPORT AND ENCOURAGE ORGAN DONATION AND AWARENESS.
31:48 - 33:305 segments2 speakers
Senator Breanne Davis introduced House Concurrent Resolution 1008 to recognize the importance of organ donation to public health and to promote awareness, citing the 113,717 Americans awaiting transplants and over 290 Arkansans on the waiting list.
[31:56][32:00][32:36][32:38]
No objections were raised, and the Senate voted unanimously in favor, adopting the resolution.
[33:07]
SB561 #1 J. Hendren TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS TAX REFORM ACT OF 2019; AND TO REFORM THE SALES TAX, INCOME TAX, PROPERTY TAX, AND FRANCHISE TAX LAWS OF THE STATE.
33:30 - 34:256 segments4 speakers
Senator Jim Hendren offered Amendment 2 to Senate Bill 561, adding a House co-sponsor to the bill, and moved to suspend the rules to consider the amendment.
[33:46][33:58][34:06][34:09]
The motion to suspend the rules carried without objection, and the amendment was adopted and sent to engrossing.
[33:46][33:58][34:06][34:09]
SB571 #1 J. Hendren TO CREATE AN EARNED INCOME TAX CREDIT, AN INCREASED STANDARD DEDUCTION, AND AN INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX REDUCTION; AND TO PROVIDE FUNDING FOR INCOME TAX REDUCTIONS THROUGH NEW TAXES ON CIGARETTES AND E-CIGARETTES.
34:25 - 1:52:49281 segments38 speakers
Senator Jim Hendren presented Senate Bill 571 and a related amendment; the amendment was adopted without objection and the bill was reported for third reading and sent to engrossing.
[34:26][34:32]
SB311 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISQUALIFICATION OF JUDGES.
1:52:49 - 34:46
Senator Alan Clark presented SB 311 to amend Arkansas law so judges must recuse from cases involving current or former staff members or their attorneys, aiming to reduce bias and the appearance of bias.
[1:52:57][1:53:26][1:53:34]
The Senate rolled a vote and approved the measure by a margin of 26 yeas to 6 nays.
[1:54:49]
SB374 Rapert TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PENALTIES RELATED TO ADMINISTRATIVE INSPECTION WARRANTS EXECUTED BY THE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY.
34:46 - 37:1110 segments3 speakers
Senator Jason Rapert explained technical corrections in Senate Bill 374, changing the penalty for ADEQ inspection-warrant violations from an unclassified misdemeanor to a violation and revising the required mental state language.
[34:47][34:59][35:15][35:46]
After the explanation, the chair called the vote, and the Senate recorded 35 yeas and 0 nays, passing the bill to the House.
[36:30][36:54][37:00]
SB375 Rapert TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING COURT REPORTS THAT ARE REQUIRED UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989.
37:11 - 39:169 segments2 speakers
Senator Jason Rapert moved Senate Bill 375, which amends the Arkansas Juvenile Code to allow either a printed or digital court report by changing a single word to “or,” and noted the bill’s purpose to resolve conflicting reporting requirements.
[37:16][37:25][37:56]
The Senate voted unanimously, with 35 yeas and 0 nays, and the bill was transmitted to the House.
[38:14][38:29][38:39]
SB440 Bledsoe TO BAN USE OF MEDICAL MARIJUANA IN FOOD AND DRINK EXCEPT IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES.
39:16 - 56:0162 segments14 speakers
Senator Cecile Bledsoe introduced Senate Bill 440 to ban the use of medical marijuana in food and drink products that could appeal to children, incorporating the Medical Marijuana Commission’s rules and requesting a 24-vote threshold for passage.
[39:25][39:38][40:12]
SB441 Bledsoe TO ADD RESTRICTIONS REGARDING ADVERTISING OF MEDICAL MARIJUANA AND USE OF CERTAIN SYMBOLS.
56:01 - 1:05:2840 segments9 speakers
Senator Cecile Bledsoe introduced Senate Bill 441 to codify the Medical Marijuana Commission’s existing rules and add new restrictions on advertising medical marijuana, including limits on audience exposure to minors.
[56:01][56:04][56:14]
Senators Keith Ingram and Mark Johnson questioned how the bill’s 30 % limit on programming that appeals to persons under 18 would be determined, with Bledsoe explaining the Medical Marijuana Commission would work with broadcasters to set the metric.
[56:41][57:07][57:11][57:41][57:45][58:16]
The discussion also compared the proposal to past restrictions on tobacco advertising such as the Joe Camel campaign and raised concerns about how the law would affect pregnant women using medical marijuana, with Bledsoe noting the bill would require consumer alerts for pregnancy.
[58:50][59:08][59:14][59:19][59:22][59:29][1:00:05][1:00:11][1:00:42][1:00:56]
After debate, the Senate voted 33-yes to 0-no, meeting the 24-vote threshold, and the bill was ordered transmitted to the House.
[1:04:24][1:04:44]
SB451 J. Cooper TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR PROFESSIONS AND OCCUPATIONS TO OBTAIN CONSISTENCY REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS AND DISQUALIFYING OFFENSES FOR LICENSURE.
1:05:28 - 1:14:0820 segments3 speakers
Senator John Cooper presented Senate Bill 451, a red-tape-reduction measure that would standardize criminal-background-check criteria for occupational licensing and provide a statutory framework for disqualifying offenses and waivers.
[1:05:36][1:05:48][1:06:21][1:06:51][1:07:27][1:07:58][1:08:30][1:09:03]
He explained that current licensing boards lack clear guidance, leading to inconsistent disqualifications, and that the bill would clarify terms such as “moral turpitude” and establish a pre-license background-check process.
[1:06:51][1:07:27][1:07:58][1:08:30][1:09:03][1:09:40][1:10:14]
The bill, developed with input from the Attorney General’s office, state police, and the governor, was debated briefly before a roll-call vote, with one senator objecting to rolling the vote.
[1:12:01][1:12:20][1:12:25][1:12:41][1:13:28][1:13:50]
The Senate approved the measure by a vote of 34 yeas to 1 nay and sent it to the House for consideration.
[1:13:50][1:14:01]
SB513 B. Johnson CONCERNING A SUSPENSION OF A PERSON'S DRIVER'S LICENSE FOR POSSESSING A CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE.
1:14:08 - 1:15:558 segments2 speakers
Senator Mark Johnson introduced Senate Bill 513, which would give courts discretion to avoid suspending a driver’s license for a conviction or no-contest plea involving a controlled substance, thereby helping CDL drivers in rehabilitation retain employment.
[1:14:20][1:14:33][1:14:45]
Following a brief discussion, the Senate rolled the vote and recorded 35 affirmative votes with no opposition, passing the bill and transmitting it to the House.
[1:14:56][1:15:04][1:15:26]
SB550 G. Stubblefield TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING LIQUID LIVESTOCK LITTER UTILIZATION.
1:15:55 - 1:55:28138 segments23 speakers
Senator Gary Stubblefield introduced SB 550, noting his 45 years of farming experience and explaining that the bill would shift CAFO permitting authority from ADEQ to the Arkansas Natural Resources Commission (ANRC) and require ANRC to adopt regulations no less stringent than existing ones.
[1:16:07][1:16:38][1:17:08][1:17:44][1:18:14][1:18:46][1:19:23]
HB1343 Hawks M. Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PUBLICATION OF THE ANNUAL FINANCIAL REPORT OF THE COUNTY.
1:55:28 - 1:57:329 segments3 speakers
Senator Mark Johnson explained HB 1343 would require counties to publish their annual financial reports electronically (including on websites or social media) while still mandating a one-time newspaper notice.
[1:55:32][1:55:58][1:56:28]
The Senate rolled a unanimous vote of 34 yeas, 0 nays, passing the bill.
[1:57:14][1:57:18]
HB1523 Petty Bledsoe CONCERNING THE TREATMENT OF FEMALE INMATES AND DETAINEES IN CORRECTIONAL OR DETENTION FACILITIES; AND CONCERNING PREGNANT INMATES AND DETAINEES.
1:57:32 - 2:05:2328 segments6 speakers
Senator Cecile Bledsoe introduced HB 1523, the “Women’s Dignity Bill,” which restricts shackling of pregnant inmates, mandates prenatal supplements and reporting requirements, and limits restraint methods for female inmates.
[1:57:44][1:58:09][1:58:44][1:59:15][1:59:48]
The Senate voted 35 yeas, 0 nays, enacting the legislation.
[2:01:23][2:01:39]
HB1565 A. Davis Dismang TO PROVIDE FUNDING FOR A NATIONAL CANCER INSTITUTE-DESIGNATED CANCER CENTER IN THE STATE THROUGH CHANGES IN THE LAWS RELATING TO THE SALE AND TAXATION OF TOBACCO PRODUCTS, CIGARETTE PAPER, AND E-CIGARETTES.
2:05:23 - 2:01:54
Senator Jonathan Dismang described HB 1565, which would fund a National Cancer Institute-designated cancer center by modifying taxes on tobacco products, while Senator Terry Rice voiced opposition based on personal-freedom and tax concerns.
[2:05:37][2:05:42][2:06:06][2:06:17][2:06:48][2:07:22]
The Senate passed the measure with a vote of 22 yeas to 10 nays.
[2:09:51]
HB1689 C. Fite Pitsch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PENALTIES FOR PASSING AN AUTHORIZED VEHICLE STOPPED ON A HIGHWAY.
2:01:54 - 2:10:2028 segments7 speakers
Senator Mathew Pitsch presented HB 1689 to increase fines for vehicles passing stopped emergency-response vehicles from $35-$500 to $250-$1,000, citing recent accidents and support from law-enforcement organizations.
[2:02:10][2:02:31][2:03:01]
The Senate unanimously approved the bill, 35 yeas, 0 nays.
[2:05:05][2:05:10]
SB431 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE CONTROL ENFORCEMENT DIVISION SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION.
2:13:18 - 2:14:265 segments2 speakers
Senator Larry Teague presented two budget measures-SB 138 for the Education Department and SB 431 for the Alcoholic Beverage Control Enforcement Division-and invited any questions.
[2:13:19]
The Chair moved to batch and roll the two bills, and no member objected to the motion.
[2:13:33]
A roll-call vote recorded 35 ayes and 0 nays, approving the combined budget bills and forwarding them to the House.
[2:13:45][2:14:09]
Senator Teague then announced that the budget will be considered the following day and reminded members to submit any member-originated bills for upcoming sessions.
[2:14:22]