House Education Committee Special Meeting
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (10)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB117
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…d? Motion passes. Mr. Chairman, are you prepared to take up Senate Bill 117? Yes, I'm going to try to”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB554
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB554”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB843
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “And you are recognized to present Senate Bill 843. You may proceed. Thank”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1817
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1817”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB833
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB833”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2224
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2224”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB2224
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members of the committee, Senate Bill 2224 is a, basically it's a pretty simple bill. It talks about C…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB250
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB250”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB518
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB518”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB66
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB66”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members of the committee, Senate Bill 2224 is a, basically it's a pretty simple bill. It talks about CPR instruction for grades 9 through 12 to make that a permanent in high school. I actually have Barbara from the Heart Association and also, I believe, well, this morning we had some people from the Board of Education.
I don't know if they're back yet or not, to speak to this bill. And so with your permission, Mr. Chair, I'd like to let them talk a
little bit about it. They are recognized to add anything that they
see fit to the presentation. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Barbara Kempi. I'm the Government Relations Director for the American Heart Association, and we are coming to you today on this bill because back in 2011, we worked to get CPR as a requirement
or the teaching of the psychomotor skills as a requirement in the health and safety class. The state legislature and the governor have worked very hard to make sure that we have automated external defibrillators in our schools because, as many of you know, we've had several children die on basketball courts and in baseball games. And we think that these students are first responders, can be a first responder. And the Heart Association has gone so forward, so much forward with our CPR that now we can
do hands-only CPR. And so in 2011, in the frameworks for the 9th through 12th grade health and safety class, CPR and the psychomotor skills for CPR, which are the actual compressions, is now part of the frameworks. And so what we want to do is make sure future generations are trained in CPR, and we just want this bill will make CPR, the teaching of the psychomotor skills, a permanent part of that health and safety class. Every six years, the frameworks change for the different grades or the different classes and the different courses,
and we just want to make sure that CPR remains part of that health and safety class for 9th through 12th grade, and that will ensure that Arkansas has future generations of lifesavers that potentially could save the life of a family member or a co-student on
the basketball or football field. Before we get to questions, what's the current practice in terms of any sort of CPR training in the schools? Is it something some schools may have classes?
Is there any sort of uniform curriculum in that regard? Laura
Speaker 14
2:56
Bednar, Assistant Commissioner of Learning Services, Department of Education. We currently teach those psychomotor skills in our current frameworks within our health classes, somewhere within grades 9 through 12. And as Ms. Compey said, this is not requiring anything new. It's just ensuring that it will continue. So every child now is already taught those skills. This is just reinforcement that it will remain.
Thank you very much. Representative Dotson, do you
have anything to add? Just one thing. If you'll notice in the bill, this is not a certification process. So as far as the actual costs involved, we're not certifying the students. We're just teaching them
the basic skills. Any questions from the committee? Committee, do we have any
questions? Representative Dotson. Representative Talley, you're recognized. Is there any concern without certifying those kids, if a student does actually perform
that on an individual, there's no kind of liability? I know it's still the Good Samaritan process, but there's no problem there,
is there? No, sir. Arkansas passed a Good Samaritan law back in 1999 for Arkansas, and so people are covered. And basically, you know, if somebody has sudden cardiac arrest, they're dead. And what I tell people is, are you going to sue somebody because you brought them back to life? So, and the Good Samaritan Law takes care of that. Thank you, Representative Talley. Representative
Linderman, do you have anything, sir? Yes, sir, thank you.
Do all of our public schools now have school nurses that would be capable of demonstrating this? I
think many of our schools have nurses, but this can be taught by the health and safety class teacher. If they're certified in that course, then they can teach it. There are online instructions. We actually have, the Heart Association has CPR Anytime kits that can be bought. You can learn CPR in about 22 minutes with a DVD. So they can learn from offline instruction, but then actually practice the actual psychomotor
skills, which is what we have. Paula Smith, a school nurse consultant, that could demonstrate that. But yes, CPR is very easily learned online or just by the actual classroom teacher.
Two questions. One of them is, are coaches now, most of them taught in basic CPR because that is normally where you think about a kid would be more likely to have a problem like this
in a period of high activity.
I think Dr. Bednar would speak more to that because that's a requirement for the
Speaker 14
5:42
teacher or the coach. We do have our coaches trained in CPR, and I think that is a requirement, especially for those who are traveling with the teams and are involved in coaching our sports. In addition, as Ms. Compey was saying, with this certification that she mentioned a while ago, even though it's not required that the person who will be doing that information in the classroom, be certified. We were doing some research, and most of our districts do have,
in answer to your question, the nurses, every district has a nurse that can provide the training, as well as there are many certified, especially in our high schools, that aren't coaches that are trained in CPR as well. Is
there any window in professional development for teachers that would allow them, like when they're getting their 60 hours, Is there any built-in time when the teachers could certify or learn to administer this and that? I think that's
Speaker 14
6:35
left up to a district that's not required,
but I can tell you from our district and others I know that have provided that for their entire district, but that would be a district decision. It's
not right now required within the 60 hours. Thank you.
Speaker 37
6:56
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Linderman. Representative Douglas, do you have a question now? Yes, I was going to ask if volunteers from the community could also assist with this. I taught anatomy and physiology and I know through that we always offered CPR classes
and the fire department, the EMTs, the American Red Cross, I just had people lined up wanting to come in and teach those classes, and they actually got certification. So I guess through this, could you also have volunteers from the community? Yes, ma'am. The American Heart Association has what
we call community training centers that all their instructors have to be under a specific training center in their area. And, yes, we have volunteers all over.
A lot of your communities have their hospitals do community CPR classes. So I don't think you'll have a lack of instructors that would be willing to come in and teach. But, again, the actual health and safety class teacher can teach it. Thank you. Thank you,
Representative Douglas. Do we have any other questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience wish to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, the chair will entertain a motion. We have a motion to do pass.
Representative Carnine, all in favor? All opposed? motion passes. Thank you, Representative Dotson. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, do we have any of our committee members that have any non-
uncontroversial bills they'd like to run because I'm telling you right now we made a great effort here to accommodate our colleagues on the other end of the building and we're not going to stay here very much longer Representative Linderman
This is the deal We're going to listen to this Senate bill and then we're going to do Representative Catlett. And if there's not
with that, Representative Linderman, you're recognized. And will you please restate the
bill number? Okay, this is Senate Bill 833. I apologize. I was planning on running this Thursday, but since we need to get rid of some Senate bills,
I will let the good doctor introduce herself and explain the bill a little bit more in depth. Dr. Cushman, you're
Speaker 51
10:03
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Karen Cushman, Department of Education. This is a bill to amend what everyone probably knows as TESS, which is the Teacher Excellence Support System from the last session. We consider them to be pretty minor changes. If it's okay, I'll just go over those real quickly. Some of the language that we use in training, Charlotte Danielson Rubik is what we are using,
and we changed the word categories to domains throughout the bill, and where it said descriptors, we changed that to components. Another change that I think is probably one of the most significant is at the top of page two, we added a definition for evaluator as someone who is an employee of the school district in which the evaluations are performed. There had been some talk about some districts possibly interested in bringing in outside providers to do the evaluations, and that is not what we felt the intent of the law
was, and so we added that definition. Also, we changed where it said levels to ratings, again, just trying to make the language more consistent with what Danielson uses and what we use in trainings. probably the the biggest or the most significant change was that we took out the one-half of the artifacts when this law was passed I believe the intent of that was to make sure that student growth was a significant factor in this
system but with our waiver with the US Department of Education we added what we felt was more rigorous language for growth than the half of the artifacts, and the half of the artifacts was very hard to explain to teachers and to educators and very hard to operationalize. Half, most people believe, is the same thing as 50 percent, but in this case that was not the case, and that was very hard to explain to teachers that if they had
a benchmark exam that that did not mean that they could only bring in one other piece of evidence into their evaluation and so we felt it made it easier just to take out the one-half and also in the very at the very end of the statute I believe language that says that the department will promulgate rules for the principal evaluation system which we had been piloting the principal evaluation system for two years we've had 10 districts that have been part of that pilot so we We just want to put that into rules, and I think that's the major changes.
I'll be happy to take any questions. Thank you, Dr. Cushman. Representative Lindemann, anything to add? Nothing. I assure you. Do we have any questions from committee? Representative Talley? Yes, sir. Do we have anyone in the audience who wishes to speak for or against the bill? If not, what is the pleasure of the committee? Representative Talley? Do pass. We have a do pass motion. Representative Talley, all in favor? Aye. All
Thank you. Representative Catlett, do you have a bill that you wish to run, sir? If
you would be so kind as to give us the number of your bill, please. Yes, sir. House Bill 1817. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is, Bill, would amend the purpose for which school districts may expend national school lunch state categorical funding.
Basically there's Arkansas Code 620-2305 allows school districts to use, it identifies two things that the school district can use these funds for, implementing components of the Arkansas Advance Initiative for Math and Science. The second, college and career coaches as administered by the Department of Career Education. And I would like to add, implementing a school-wide evidence-based program intended to close achievement gaps, including without limitation a program with an arts-infused curriculum.
Colleagues, the reason why I felt we needed this is kids learn in different ways, as you all know. Speaking to a lot of educators in here, different things motivate kids. And in my case, I was a toehead when I was in school, and a little round thing called a basketball motivated me. But that doesn't always motivate all kids. Some kids are motivated with music, some with art.
And I just felt like including the arts into that categorical fund of NCSLA money, it would help some kids that would otherwise not be motivated. Now, some school districts already do this, but I just felt like it should be codified in the law that would include arts-infused curriculum. Any questions?
I do. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm very sympathetic to the idea of
know, in high school participated in choir and all that other stuff. But I am concerned about the without limitation because it seems like that language alone alone could just have more than just an arts-infused curriculum, but something that is just completely
arts. And, you know, the NSLA money is intended to close the gaps in issues like reading, writing, arithmetic, three R's. So I'm a little concerned. Do you know what that means, why that language is in there without limitation?
Well, to me, basically, it wouldn't limit, put the limit on the arts, infused it. But here, again, you see the evidence-based program, which means it has to be proven as
working. Okay. So you find that that's the most critical reference in that sentence there, that it it has to be evidence-based that this arts-infused program is going to meet the same standards of educational improvement, then why is the language necessary there without limitation if what we're looking at is that the limitation is evidence-based? I mean, that's our limitation right there is that it needs to be evidence-based.
Why do we need that additional language? Well, I don't mind a bit amending it, sir, and taking it out if it makes you feel better, but I would, you know, I don't see the point in doing so. You're saying without limitation of program with arts-infused curriculum, meaning not limiting the arts-infused, and it has to be evidence-based. I'm sorry I don't follow you, but if it'll suit you, sir, to help me support it,
I don't mind amending it. You know, I may be the only one that's concerned about it, but, you know, I get concerned sometimes when people go, oh, well, you know, it's just one word. Well, it's there for a reason. That phrase is there for a reason, and it would help me in understanding why we have to have that second qualifying statement in terms of defining what the arts-infused curriculum potentially would be. But, you know, if it's just me, that's okay. We don't need to – I don't need to be another speed bump.
Do we have any other questions from the – Representative
Armstrong? Representative Lowry asked the question that I was about to ask. Thank you, Representative Armstrong.
Representative Deffenbaugh? Thank you, Mr. Chair.
This is just to make sure I understood it, Representative Catlett. Fifteen and sixteen, they're already in the
Deffenbaugh. Do we have any other questions from the committee? Representative Carnot.
Just so we, are you saying, Representative Catlett, that you're going to amend this or, well? You know, I'd like to go,
you know, as little time as we have, I'd like to go on with this if you can support it. But if there's a hang-up on just two words and there's consensus that I should amend it, yes. But I don't see
I mean, if you would suggest to whoever is going to be running this in the Senate
that that might be an acceptable amendment, I would certainly have. I will
do that. Thank you. Do we have any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against the bill? If not, the chair will entertain a motion, Representative Catlett. We have a due pass. Do pass. Representative Catlett, all in favor? All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Representative Catlett. Representative Piles, we appreciate you being here very much, sir.
And you are recognized to present Senate Bill 843. You may proceed. Thank
Speaker 92
20:01
you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. Thanks for having the meeting. Senate Bill 843 was brought to me by my school district, and it allows for providing references to prospective employers, basically allows the school district officer, whoever that may be, to disclose other information than just the basic information that is typically disclosed. The reason for it is that we have had on occasion, I think probably other places,
things happen and then the teacher or administrator resign and then go repeat the offense at another school district. And this would allow someone calling for a reference to have knowledge of that information on the negative side and on the positive side. So if there's any other questions,
I'll be happy to entertain them. Senator, does this also extend to secretarial staff, non-classified employees, or is it strictly administrators and teachers? There's hiring of
Speaker 92
20:57
a current or former employee by a school district,
so I think it's open to all of
those people. So I'm getting the bad guys are saying this is a good deal, so okay. It extends to everybody. Okay. Thank you, Senator Files. Do we have any other questions from committee? Seeing none, anyone in the audience, which do you speak for or against the bill? If not, the chair will entertain a motion. Representative Cozart, you have a do, pass a motion. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion passes. Senator, thank you very much for your time.
Chairman Key, you are recognized to present Senate Bill 554, sir. You may proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This
Speaker 100
21:49
is the technical correction bill for the Department. With your permission, I'd like to ask Mr. Lassiter to join me at the table. Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman. Yes, Senate Bill 554.
This bill, as I said, is a technical correction. It makes a lot of changes to references, whether it says certificate, it changes those references to licenses, makes some correct references, code references. In Section 1, I have to point out it does define what a week means, and that is, I know that sounds funny that we have to define what a week means, but we do.
So anyway, it takes care of that. And we'd be glad to answer any questions, but as I said, most of this is correction to different references of legislation that's changed over the years. names of programs and language that just need to be updated mr. Lester do you have anything to add sir no sir with that do we
have any questions for chairman key if not we have let
Speaker 100
23:06
me point out mr. chair there may have been a lot
of correspondence on section 33 of this bill to from certain school districts and just to point out that the section 33 is striking some dates and that is in accordance with the court case and a ruling that came down and the department is merely updating that section to accommodate that court ruling thank you Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Do we have any other questions, any questions at all for Chairman Key? If not, do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against the bill? If not, the chair will entertain a motion. Representative Cullen has to do pass a motion. All in favor? All opposed? Motion passes. Mr. Chairman, are you prepared to take up Senate Bill 117? Yes, I'm going to try to
Speaker 100
24:04
run that for Senator Burnett. He had to chair a Senate Rules Committee meeting, so with your permission, I'd like to present that today as well.
You're recognized, sir. All right. Senator Burnett's bill, Senate Bill 117, establishes a capital grant program for open enrollment charter schools. Currently, open enrollment charter schools do not have access to facilities funding through our normal facilities funding programs at the department. This establishes a grant program that can utilize, and if you look on the last, on page 4, it's under Section 2,
but at the top of page 4, it establishes where those funds can come from. And it can be general revenues, it can be other revenues, and it can also be GIF. and that's Senator Burnett actually has a GIF appropriation out there to fund this if there is GIF funds available so it does not actually obligate any general revenue for this program and it also put some restrictive language there that a public open enrollment public charter school has to have been in
existence for five or more years before applying for a grant student population that is 60 percent who are national school lunch students provides transportation to and from school and has a record of academic success that is under the control of the department they define what that success is that restrictive language is to ensure that if a grant is awarded to a school of this nature that it is to a school that has established a track record of being successful so that any monies under this does not get awarded to someone who has not proven
that they are worthy or have staying power as a public open enrollment charter school. I'd be glad to take questions.
Mr. Chairman, what is the department's position on this bill? Well,
permission. Dr. Kimbrell, you need no introduction. You are
Speaker 110
26:20
recognized, sir. Thank you, sir. The department's really neutral on this. There's, like we said, there's no money tied to it at this point in time that comes out of the public school fund or the facilities fund. They're looking for ways to help create facilities for charter schools.
Thank you, doctor. Do we have any questions for the chairman? Mr. Lowry, do you have a
question, sir? I think Representative Armstrong. Representative Armstrong, sir, you're recognized. You talk about these open enrollment public charter schools, and you said they had a five-year success rate. Most of the open enrollment charter schools, are they the ones that's having the problems prior to becoming an open enrollment charter school?
Speaker 100
27:10
Is that the case in many of these? No, most of these, I think, have been established independently
of any previous track record. Okay. Okay. Thank
you. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Armstrong. Representative Lowry. Okay. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. I thought there for a second that Mr. Armstrong and I were channeling each other. He was going to ask my question. Isn't it true that the specifications here, the five years or more, the student population,
that it's written in such a way that it only applies to one such
Speaker 100
27:45
school? I believe that at this point in time, yes, there's one school that would qualify under this. Now, others could qualify down the road, but as analyzed, I believe the KIPP Delta is the one that falls in this category, as having the time frame, the performance record, and the percentage of NSLA students. Follow-up, please, Mr. Chairman.
Yes, sir. Unless I'm missing it, the section that specifies all of these specific guidelines are in language that's not going to be codified. So how do we know that this language would apply to future applications?
Speaker 100
28:26
Well, it's also included in the GIF appropriation bill, and I'm not sure if that's codified or not. I really don't have that in front of me. that the state department still has to abide by this.
Even though it's not codified, they would still have to abide by that legislation. It would go into their deliberations for determining if a grant would be made available. And keep in mind, right now there's no funding here. It kind of sets a framework for a future funding source if one becomes available. All right. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Thank you, Representative Lowry. Representative Armstrong? So what you're saying, Senator, is that if a school, if another charter, open charter, comes online and have five years of success,
that they could come back and apply for the
exactly right. Contingent upon funding. Contingent upon funding. I think Senator Teague illustrated funding and appropriations very well, and appropriation
is just opening an account. What about the 60% in SLA? In what regard, Representative? Would that alter or mean anything in this situation with the open charter?
Speaker 100
29:55
Well, that would just depend on the changing of that school's population. Thank you.
Thank you, Representative Armstrong. Representative Catlett. Senator
Key, you've been around here a long time. You take for granted some of these definitions, the difference between charter and public. Mr. Chair, if you allow me to indulge this question in the committee's time, I want you to explain to me the difference between charter and public and the amount of students that
they can is there is there a minimum for charter okay
Speaker 100
30:37
it is not a traditional public school that is defined by a region a geographic region that we call a district it is defined by a charter a contract if you will that that they submit to the state Board of Education, run it through the department, and in that charter they establish what students
they're looking to serve, the area they're looking to serve in, whether it's an inner city in Little Rock or whether it's Helena West Helen in the case of KIPP Delta. But those contracts get approved, they have a number of provisions in there, they can waive certain requirements in the state rules and regs and they become a school treated as a school district those students are treated as public school students just as if they were in a
traditional public school. Okay so there's no minimum.
And Mr. Lassiter got close so in case I mess up he can. There's no minimum. I mean the charters can operate.
Speaker 100
31:50
help me. I think they establish what their population to serve is, and that's part of what they have to submit for approval to
the State Board. Jeremy Lasseter, general counsel with the department. Yes, sir, that's correct. There's no minimum number of students that they can have. I think the smallest one that we might have is
somewhere in the 50s up in Bowdoin, but of course they're going to be counted on to, make sure that they make all their finances and meet the things they said they're going to do in the charter. So they're not the same thing as a school district, so they're not held to the same numbers. You'd have to think of them as individual schools. Okay. Thank you, Senator.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members. Thank you, Representative Catlett. Do we have any other questions for Chairman Key? Seeing none, do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against
the bill? You're recognized, sir. Mr. Munns, you're recognized. I'm assuming you're going to speak against
Speaker 132
32:55
the bill. Yes, sir, Mr. Chair, you're correct. Mr. Mertens, you're recognized. Thank you. Mike Mertens with AAEA, and I appreciate the opportunity to speak here today. Some of the concerns we have have already been mentioned.
It is a it's limited to a small number of charter schools that would apply. maybe just one. It's not really a capital grant program because one of the allowable expenditures is for instructional material that's written in the bill. And I guess my suggestion would be that if money is going to be put in this fund that it needs to be needs-based and go through the same
process that all schools go through to get to get approval for partnership money and that would conclude my remarks on this I'll be glad to answer any questions thank you mr. Martins do
we have any questions from mr. Martins if not thank you very much sir do we have anyone who wishes to speak for the bill Anyone who wishes to speak against the bill?
Speaker 136
34:20
Jerry, you're recognized. Thank you. I'm Jerry Derlikowski with Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families and Senator Keyes-Wright. This is familiar. I had these same concerns on the Senate end and was hoping some of them would be addressed. My main concern, and it's probably just because I've worked around here too long, is on page four, line three through six, and then seven and eight.
It sets up a general revenue fund to pay for this, but the fiscal impact statement refers to general improvement money, and that inconsistency, I think, is just raises a question to me about what's going on with this. And my other concern is more broad. I'm not opposed to charter facilities being funded at some point, but I think it would be good through our adequacy, and this may not, you know, get any funding, as he said.
I just think it's a question because the general, the fiscal impact doesn't match. But I do think it's something we should address during our adequacy study, and I think we have some traditional schools that don't have adequate facilities. I think safe, warm, and dry, a cave with a fire, meets that definition, and I think we really need to improve those. But I think charter schools need some support, too. I think all of it needs to be looked at, and I think doing that through the adequacy process,
which was the argument this morning on not doing transportation, but doing that as part of the adequacy process would be a much more fair and even across and take care of all of our charter schools, not just this one. And one of the things, Senator Elliott, she asked if they would make an amendment to this to make it apply to all the charter schools, and I may have misunderstood, but I thought
the sponsor, Senator Burnett, said that he would do that, and I don't see that amendment. So that's my concern also. Any questions? Thank you, Mr. Jerry. We
appreciate you very much. Mr. Harder, do you have anything you'd like to add, sir?
Speaker 139
37:00
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. Ron Harder, Arkansas School Board Association. In part, I'd actually like to speak to the bill. I echo what Jerry Derelykowski raised as far as this would be a good issue regardless of the outcome of this bill for the interim study for the adequacy committee. But what I don't understand about the bill, and we testify to this on the other end, There's very specific permissibility for the use of facility funding for a traditional public school, and this bill very specifically goes outside of that boundary so that within the regular foundation funding, the 62-odd dollars, 6,200-odd dollars,
That includes instructional materials. It includes technology. It includes most of what it normally takes to get your students the things they need, and that comes out of your foundation funding. In this bill, it's specifically permitted to be used as part of what otherwise appears to be a facilities funding grant. So the lines are on page 2, items, lines 11 through 19, and we don't understand the why of that.
But so I ask that as much of a question of why it's included in the bill, because it doesn't make sense to us. You're setting up a separate and unequal playing field for the use of the funds between traditional and charter schools. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Harder. Do we have anyone else who wishes to speak for the
bill or against the bill? Seeing none, the Chair will entertain a motion. Can I close, Mr. Chairman? Excuse me, Mr. Chairman, you may close.
Speaker 100
39:05
Thank you. Well, I'm glad to hear that AAEA may be willing to consider opening the partnership program to charter facilities, but somehow I bet if we ran that bill, they'd probably be down here saying, oh, we don't need to do that. So this simply gives another avenue because we have closed public charters to facilities funding ever since the inception of the partnership program, and there are reasons that we did that, and we've taken care of a lot of the priorities.
This, Senator Burnett's bill just simply gives us an avenue to make some funding available if funding becomes available through a program like this to help a very, in essence, a carved-out segment of our students who, because of decisions of previous General Assemblies, have not had access to facilities funding through the schools they attend. And so I think we can address going forward some of the concerns if they become problematic.
But at this point, it's very unlikely that those concerns are going to come to fruition. And with that, I'd close for the bill. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. Chair, we'll obtain a motion. We have a do pass motion. Representative Carnot, all in favor? Aye. All opposed? No. Motion passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Key, since we have you here, are you prepared to run Senate Bill 518?
Speaker 100
40:42
Yes, I am. That would be the last one I have, Mr. Chairman. You're recognized, sir. Okay. This bill, Senate Bill 518, changes minor change to the Professional Licenture Standards Board. It increases the number of members of that board to 16, and the addition is the director of the Division of Child Care and Early Childhood Education, or his or her designee, would be added as a non-voting member. We also changed licensure levels here for a couple of positions to reflect the birth
a kindergarten licensure and then a kindergarten through grade 6 licensure to more, to better align the members of that board and those licensure requirements. It also makes some changes to remove the congressional district restrictions. Right now there are some restrictions there that some of these positions have to represent the four congressional districts. The department actually asked for us to look at changing that because sometimes it creates
a problem finding qualified people that are willing to serve on a board like this in the four congressional districts. So this was something that we agreed to do at their request. But also in Section 2, it has some technical language in there that just outlines how the board positions will be filled if the membership is changed as we're doing here.
I'd be glad to take questions. Dr. Cushman, do you have anything to add, ma'am? Do we have any questions from the committee? Seeing none, do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, the Chair will entertain a motion. Representative Carnine has a do pass motion. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion passes. Mr. Chairman, thank
Speaker 100
42:46
you very much. Thank you, and I appreciate the committee coming in this afternoon and helping us out.
We will be there 10 o'clock in the morning on our end, and if you all have any bills you want to bring down, we'll try to work in. Mark's going to start
Chairman. Representative Linneman, looks like you're batting cleanup today. Are you prepared to run the Senate Bill 66 and 250? Yes, Mr. Chairman.
While I'm waiting on some technical support to come up here for Senate Bill 66,
I would like to go on record to let everyone know that I have been asked to do this due to my expertise, not because I'm sitting on the end of the table, just
for y'all's knowledge. Representative Linderman, you are recognized
to present Senate Bill 66. Thank you. Senate Bill 66 is a bill that was brought to me early by Senator Joyce Elliott, who needs no introduction. Her expertise, her passion, and her love for education and children is well known.
A district of innovation simply is a designation that works with the Department of Education to designate certain schools or certain school districts to apply to the Department of Education to have new ideas, new methods, and new techniques of teaching in order to try to increase student learning. When I started teaching, I was sitting there. When I started in school 50-some years ago,
everyone sat in the same classroom and we were taught the same way. Now, as I go back to an elementary school where I do on a regular basis, the learning is totally different. And I had a teacher that taught about 15 years, and she said, I have learned so much about how students learn and how to present the lessons. And the learning, when I hear someone talk about our failed education system, two things happen. One of them is I cringe, and the other one is I get mad. I want to challenge them to go to Brooklyn school and go to that elementary school, and you go look.
And I don't think that it's the exception. I think it's the rule now. Three things that are being done in different schools. One of them is A Leader in Me, which is great success with student achievements. I mentioned Brooklyn Elementary. They have a program called Watch Dogs where they bring in dads of great students. That has been an amazingly successful program. I can't imagine why any elementary and probably even middle schools are not doing this program. They do new things.
Mystery Reader. That is a huge deal. If you ever get asked to come and be a mystery reader or serve as a watchdog for a school, you need to do that. But Senator Elliott's bill is a district of innovation. They do look at and they see a need or a desire to increase student learning. They would, it is set forth in the bill that 60% of the employees would have to agree to this. The school administration or the school district would then petition the Department of Education
with certain ideas for certain goals, certain outcomes that they would try to achieve. They could be designated as a district of innovation for four years. that could be canceled at any time if they fail to meet their goals or they are not performing at the expected level. But this is simply a way for school districts, for teachers, for administrations
to look at new and innovative ways to engage learners, to bring the community in and things like that. This is not a charter school. My daughter teaches in a charter school, and it's amazing to me when I go there at the innovative things that they're doing and all the kids that are walking around smiling in the halls, and it is a completely different atmosphere than what I saw 40 years ago when I was a kid in school. So with that, I'll let Dr. Abernathy make any statements that he would like,
but this is certainly, I think, an outstanding way for a local school district to try some new and innovative approaches to increase student learning. I believe
Speaker 145
47:31
Representative Linderman explained that bill very well. The only other thing I would add is there have been several groups working on this particular piece of legislation just to try to add a little more flexibility in the school day if they go through certain procedures and follow a certain process.
So I'd be glad to answer any questions. But, again, I think Mr. Representative Linderman has planned it extremely well. Representative
Linderman, do you have anything else to add? Not at all, sir. Do we have any questions from the committee? Representative
Deffenbaugh. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Make sure I'm reading this right. Let me see. Where is that? All right. Let's see. I guess it's page one, yeah, page one, part B, it's line 32.
Does that mean a teacher can teach any way they want to after they get permission? Is that the way I'm reading now to obtain necessary exceptions from laws, rules, local policies to
improve educational performance to students from the Commissioner of Education? Okay, those exceptions would have to be granted by the Department of Education, but those exceptions could be maybe the length of the class period. It could be certain techniques that may not be traditionally taught.
It could be even an outdoor classroom that there could be. But, again, it does have to be approved by the Commissioner of Education. This bill is a partnership working with our Department of Education, and under their guidance and their approval, there are certain outcomes that are expected that they will be investigated, but they could very possibly get some exceptions to what we would consider to be current guidelines
or requirements in the school district, yes. Thank you. Thank you, Representative Devin Ball. Do we
have any other questions from committee? If not, do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against the bill? With that,
Chair, I move to do pass. Representative Linderman has to do pass a motion. All in favor? All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Representative Linderman and Dr. Abernathy. One more, Representative Linderman.
We also have with us Senate Bill 250. I'm waiting on backup coming over here for this one. This one is a bill that was ran by Senator Cheatham, and this is a bill that clarifies definitions and record retention requirements for the ethical guidelines and prohibitions for school board members,
administrators, and employees. It is a fairly short bill. If you'll notice, there is simply it's a cleanup bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Representative Linderman. That's
correct. In one section of the bill, we're trying to clarify that these requests don't have to remain on file indefinitely, but instead in accordance to the states or the school districts, whichever is applicable record retention policy the other part of it is to clear up some confusion
that we get pretty much on about a monthly basis when school districts submit their applications for approval and so we've tried to clear up that definition to make to clarify the standards on the front end thank you mr lasser do we have any questions
from the committee do we have anyone who wishes to speak for or against the bill from the audience seeing none the chair will entertain in motion? Make a motion. Do pass. Representative Linderman has to do pass. Motion. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Representative Linderman. Representative Carnine, do you have anything to add? Okay, committee, that's it for today. This is the plan for Thursday. We're going to do as much as we can on Thursday. If it runs late, we will have lunch. We're not going to hang out to dry like we have been the past couple of meetings. So we're going to try to get as much as we can in the
morning we are at this point not going to have an afternoon meeting on Thursday we're going to see how it goes maybe next week if we see the need we will have an afternoon meeting but as of now Thursday 10 o'clock and if we run late we will have lunch chair will entertain an adjournment motion meeting adjournment
Agenda
HB2224
SB833
HB1817
SB843
SB554
SB117
SB518
SB66
SB250
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative James McLean
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 14
Representative Brent Talley Chair
Unverified
Representative Homer Lenderman
Unverified
Speaker 37
Speaker 51
Speaker 58
Representative John Catlett
Unverified
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong
Unverified
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Speaker 71
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh
Unverified
Speaker 82
Representative Les "Skip" Carnine
Unverified
Speaker 87
Speaker 92
Speaker 100
Speaker 110
Speaker 121
Speaker 107
Speaker 132
Speaker 136
Speaker 139
Speaker 126
Speaker 145