Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs Committee

April 10, 2013
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (11)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB634 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB634”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2065 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2065”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1205 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1205”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1570 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1570”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1009 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1009”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1029 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1029”
Pre-2017 bill
SB719 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB719”
Pre-2017 bill
SB914 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB914”
Pre-2017 bill
SB959 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB959”
Pre-2017 bill
SB961 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB961”
Pre-2017 bill
SB992 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB992”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
and I was going to get that taken care of okay there were more members here a minute ago I guess everyone went and got a cup of coffee and they're headed back I'm a house bill 2065 that's a concurrent Senate amendment senator stub a field of my bill to revise the procedures for filing for office for a nonpartisan could you guys bring that up and take a look and I would accept the motion that's an excellent motion and I will accept that one the motion is to concur and Senate amendment on 2065 all those in favor aye all is opposed okay if anyone's in the room to run a bill come on up here please and sign in so far I have Senator Sanders and Senator flowers senator flowers you're recognized this is Senate bill 634 let's give us a minute we'll bring it up on our tablets thank you thank you you're recognized Senator flowers thank you madam chair and good
▶ Play
morning committee I'm here on Senate bill 634 and what it does it repeals that provision of the law that we put in place in 2009 that limited the number of voters a person can assist I think it should be repealed there is no good invalid reason that the law was put in place if you all will recall or if I can jockey memories. In 2008, we had a contested primary Senate race over in East Arkansas between Senator Jack Crumley and Arnell Willis, a representative, and that was an open seat. The primary was contested. There were a lot of allegations of voter fraud, but the fraud and the abuses that occurred that were reflected in the hearing that the Senate held to decide that race was all about absentee ballots and all about either the poll workers or the clerks mismanaging and mishandling and even losing absentee ballots. A total of 100 absentee ballots were misplaced, and I think Senator Altus can recall that. We had the Senate State Agencies Committee met, and the committee of the whole met in the Senate and decided to race for Mr. Cromley. And at the present time, there is no limitation on a poll worker assisting voters, even though there has been in our history more evidence of abuse by poll workers and county clerks than a regular citizen who assist a voter. So I'm asking for consideration of a good vote, and I'll be happy to take any questions. Thank you, Senator
▶ Play
Flowers. Yeah, so from what I can tell, all you're doing is repealing that
▶ Play
one section. Yes, and I've talked actually to Senator Ferris, Steve Ferris, who sponsored that bill, and he has advised me there was no good reason for him to do that. That was a pile-on. They did some election reform back then and limited the number of absentee ballots that a person could bring in or come in and get for a person to two. But it was all about absentee ballots, and it was all about mishandling and abuse by the clerk or either the poll workers. Okay,
▶ Play
and none of us would know about pylons in a bill, would we? we've all gotten ourself in trouble when we find out you know there's that two lines way down in there that we didn't see okay thank you any questions from committee members there's one person here to speak on the bill and I'm I'm hoping I get the name right carbon is that even close a CA are Carlson please excuse me I'm not I'm not reading that L correctly okay miss Carlson you can take the end of the table and right right down there by Senator flowers and identify yourself for the record
▶ Play
my name is Dixie Carlson I'm an election commissioner from Brendan County Arkansas I want to speak against this bill, because before I was an election commissioner, I was a poll worker, and I witnessed what very organized, what they called haulers, that would come in in cars, vans, and even sometimes a big church bus. The hauler was the driver of the vehicle, and he went in and helped every one of those voters vote. Then he took them home, the haulers, and brought back other voters that he helped. So I imagine in a whole day there's no telling how many people that got voted with the hauler helping them. And I think that would be an abuse. does anyone have
▶ Play
any questions for miss Carlson thank you miss Carlson for your testimony is there anyone else to speak for the bill if not there is someone to speak against it mr. Soffer good morning madam chair
▶ Play
Speaker 32 7:06
committee it's with regret that I have to go ahead and identify yourself real quick I'm sorry Stuart Sofer I'm speaking as the Jefferson County Election Commissioner okay thank you go ahead I regret I have to ask you to do not pass a bill sponsored by my own senator and I understand the reasons but experience in our county regardless of the reason the limit was put on the number of disabled voters someone can assist it's turned into vote hustlers and the limit of six and by the way each assist is recorded the limit of six by an individual other than an election official or deputy county clerk has really toned down the number of attempts at bringing perfectly healthy folks in there and telling them how to vote I think a person should be able to be assisted by someone of their choice but when it gets down to one individual assisting more than six voters which is the current limit it's opening some doors and for that reason and I've talked off some of the folks in our County they are opposed to it and I ask you to please not pass this bill out of committee may I answer any
▶ Play
questions does anyone have any questions for mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 39 8:35
Sofer representative Richie thank you madam chair and this may be for senator flowers more than the speaker but I apologize for being a couple minutes late is this my understanding correctly this is removing the restriction that you can't assist more than six voters
▶ Play
at the polls that's what this is that's correct and if I might respond this is not something that is clandestine behind some closed doors this is a public venue it's in a polling place the assisting person is limited to helping that voter with marking and casting the ballot they cannot comment they cannot interpret anything on that ballot they are merely there to assist someone who has asked them to assist it's a public forum poll workers are there to watch and there's no good reason why it should be that a poll worker or poll workers and county clerks should have unlimited access when they have more motivation to influence a vote than a private citizen. So I'd ask you to just think about this logically and understand that a voter ought to be able to have someone that they trust to go into that booth, and it's an open booth. It's there. It's in earshot of a poll worker or any watchers that are there. So if there is abuse, as Mr. Soffer has described, we would know about it. But the history in our state has always been that there has been abuse by poll watchers county clerks if I mr. so for
▶ Play
your testimonies over and there were no questions for you sorry that's how committees roll if I can ask question if I'm not mistaken this is only for disabled voters that is that is we're not talking about we're talking about specifically disabled voters that's what the
▶ Play
bill says is that correct that's that's the title in in this part of the code, and people can be disabled in terms of their ability to read well, to recognize names, to they may be physically limited in terms of being able to actually pull a lever or, you know, some people have all kinds of frailties and disabilities. So there's nothing in the law that defines it, but it's for the purpose of helping a voter cast or mark their ballot. Okay.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Hutchison. Thank you, Madam
▶ Play
Chair. Senator, since we're on the subject and everything of disabled voters, how do you – I mean, I guess that could consist of nursing homes too right or they're disabled but that would be absentee wouldn't it or something right I'm speaking at
▶ Play
the poll at the poll at the polling place not absentee ballots I understand ma'am I
▶ Play
got you thank you thank you representative Hickerson thank you madam chair if senator flowers if a person wanted to assist more than six could they not sign up to be a poll watcher can poll
▶ Play
watchers assist poll watchers right now under the law are they have an unlimited they have no limitation on the number of voters they can assist but to your question about can they sign up to be a poll watcher or a poll worker that's left to the discretion of the Election Commission the local Election Commission they approve who gets to be the poll watcher and that's partisan and we all know that yes
▶ Play
ma'am but they would have a means of assisting more if they requested or asked I mean to either work or or be a poll watcher I know most most county election commissions love that people volunteer because they they don't have enough but I'm just saying would that be they're able to do that if
▶ Play
they're a watcher or work it depends on the local local election Commission and who they allow to be a poll worker okay thank you very much and then my point is this it's all about trust and it's all about the voter being able to select one that they trust who they believe is credible they believe will not do something contrary to what they have
▶ Play
Speaker 72 13:52
informed Thank You representative Dobson Thank You madam chair clarify for me if you would and I apologize you may have covered this in your presentation slightly late currently there's no restriction on poll workers county clerks or deputy county clerks to assist anyone that's correct so we're only you're wanting to lift the restriction for to that it limits it to six for someone other than a poll worker who is for all intents and purposes unbiased doesn't know the person doesn't have a dog in the fight as far as as far as but this is somebody why would somebody how would somebody know more than six disabled persons unless they were purposely bringing them in
▶ Play
for the purpose of voting is a particular way well people have church families that do that people have neighborhoods you know in my community I know many people who care enough about their neighbors and their neighbors want them to take them to the poll to help them
▶ Play
Speaker 72 15:06
and you don't think a poll worker could could
▶ Play
assist that particular person well my point is this the history in this state has been more abuses by the poll workers in the county clerks and deputy clerks that's our history and and when this was put into the law in 2009 after that case over They're in Marion in East Arkansas with the Senate race between Jack Cromley and Arnell Willis. That, I read the transcript. It's about a six-inch, three-volume transcript. And it was all about abuses by the county clerk and the poll workers. It had nothing to do about people other than poll workers, county clerks, or deputy clerks assisting voters. Thank you. Representative Bell. I just want a
▶ Play
clarification. I've heard the term poll watcher thrown around and intermixed here with poll worker. And poll watchers, as I understand the law, aren't included in the scope of this at all and are partisan or representative of candidates, et cetera, and aren't allowed to approach voters at all except to observe and sign the poll book, et cetera.
▶ Play
am I correct in that right and right now I mean it's poll workers that have no limitation it's county clerks and deputy clerks that have no limitation and that's I think something that any person ought to have the right to do as well if if a voter asks someone to assist them. Poll watchers are just there, maybe for a candidate or something, but, you know, to help keep the integrity of the process. So I'm pretty clear
▶ Play
on that. I was hearing the term being mingled with poll worker,
▶ Play
and they're clearly very different positions. Yes. But my point was, it's a public forum where that voter is voting and that person assisting is present. So if there is any abuse, there are sufficient persons there that can make a complaint or challenge. I guess looking at the timeline of how this would occur, We've got the law
▶ Play
that says that they can't be in the polling place, I think, more than five minutes. There's a time limit. How does this person keep coming up with these more than six voters that they're assisting? Are they going out picking them up? Are they waiting outside the door of the polling place to assist them? How are they encountering more
▶ Play
than six people who need assistance? What's the mechanism here? They come from their communities more than anything, Representative Bale. You have people that don't have transportation. You have people that cannot, that are not mobile, that have limited ability to read and write. So we're talking about, you know, it's not like a steady stream, but within an election cycle, it may not be that somebody would be bringing six people to the poll in one day. But it could be that between the time early voting starts and on election day, that that person may be asked to assist more than six people, six voters.
▶ Play
Okay. I mean, you understand what I'm saying there? it would appear to me that you would almost have to be out soliciting people to that needed assistance to encounter that many in almost
▶ Play
any situation I can think of well trust me I mean I know people in churches that ask for people to assist them to make sure they take them to get to the poll elderly people that call on individuals in the community that they trust to help them get to the poll and make sure their ballot is marked and cast I mean it absolutely I agree okay we've
▶ Play
got several other people want to ask questions not to cut you off but I guess I just did representative
▶ Play
over be The picture that came to my mind when you first started talking, and I'm not going to tell you, I know they do this because I don't, but what I thought about was like the senior citizens bus that they might take people to vote that wanted to go and didn't have a ride. You know how they go pick
▶ Play
them up? Right. And a lot of times seniors are at their senior citizen centers. That's what I'm talking about. And it's not just about needing a ride, but needing assistance in marking and casting that ballot. Right. Some people are challenged with the ability to see, and not only to see, but to read. And so, I mean, certainly we understand that there is a literacy problem in Arkansas. We talk about that all the time when we speak of education. Okay,
▶ Play
hang on. Let's not go off on that. Representative Miller. Pardon me, Representative Klemmer. I'm not even seeing correctly. And then Representative Miller. Thank you,
▶ Play
Madam Chair. Senator Flowers, I want a question. Do you know when this law was put, the law that you're trying to change, was put into place? In 2009. Okay.
▶ Play
And it was sponsored by Senator Ferris. I had a long conversation with him. I've researched this law, and he told me that this had nothing to do with the election reforms and the problems that existed in 2008 as a result of that race over there in Marion between Crumley and Arnell Willis. That race was challenged, and the Senate had to decide it, the Senate State Agencies Committee. They deliberated for more than two days, and what came out of that was all of the abuse, with the absentee ballots being lost, literally just lost. There were at least 100 ballots that could not be found that they had actually counted. And that had more to do with something going awry in the county clerk's office or the poll workers. Okay. Well, you answered my question.
▶ Play
I just didn't know how long it had been in effect. And I was here in 09. I just didn't remember. It must not have gotten discussed. I wasn't on this committee in 09, so I didn't remember that. Could I continue, though? see I've got a circumstance want to see if you would agree or disagree sometimes if you accept a ride to the polls people expect to be able to mark someone else's ballot because they did after all give them a ride to the polls and the person who is that the voter is now beholden to the person who gave them a ride. They gave them a ride to the polls. So I actually don't dislike the law that's in place because we had this problem. We had people that wanted to mark their own ballot, but they were being escorted all the way back. So in essence, because they took a ride from that person, they felt obligated to let them come back. And we had to stop and say, do you need help with your ballot? Because a lot of people that didn't need help were getting unwanted help. And essentially, they were losing their privacy at the polls because they took a ride from someone to the polling place. They no longer felt able to say, stay away. There's a question in there. And I was going to ask, that's what started to say, have you
▶ Play
not seen that also as a problem? No, that shouldn't happen. And the way our law is set up now, the voter, it's the voter who requests the assistance of that person. And so for someone you're describing as having to get a ride, that's not what this is about. It's about needing assistance because of some inability to mark and cast your ballot. The voter makes a request of a person. So it's more than just getting a ride to the poll. It's about needing some help. And as I said before, this is a public and open venue where this occurs. there is in the law now a provision that the person assisting cannot comment or interpret anything on that ballot and that they are to help assist marking or casting the ballot according to the wishes of that voter.
▶ Play
That's what's in the law. Senator Flowers, we have no way to enforce that, though. Because they are supposed to be outside the earshot of everyone else, or otherwise they don't have a private ballot. I mean, if I'm having to say out loud who I'm voting for at this location, and Representative Hickerson is the poll worker, if she can hear me say who I want this person to help me vote for, then I don't have a private ballot. But also, if that person is telling me who I want to vote for, or isn't marking my ballot the way I say I want them to because I'm disabled,
▶ Play
there's no way to enforce that it's the same what you're just no I don't agree I mean and and and if you if you that same scenario that you're describing would happen in the instance of a poll worker assisting a voter or a county clerk or deputy clerk assisting a ballot a voter mark or cast their ballot but the thing is, in polling places, and I've been in polling places since I was 18, the room is not that large, and poll workers are in close proximity to the voter. Okay, Representative Miller, do you
▶ Play
have a question? Yes, ma'am. Thank you,
▶ Play
Madam Chair. Senator Flowers, a couple of things I need some clarification on. number one the the current law you said you done a lot of research on this and I'm gonna rely on that the current law states that you cannot help more than six people is that in one polling location or is that period period in
▶ Play
the election cycle and the exception is for poll workers our county clerks or deputy clerks
▶ Play
so right right now I mean I'm obviously I have to get help every time I go vote and and to representative Clemmer's point you know when you're in this situation no you don't really have a private ballot this last go around my 10 year old son helped me and to be cute voted against me I got that changed but but anyway my point is I've also gone into a polling place and had an actual poll worker of course I'm from Hebrew Springs and I've been there all my life and folks know me but had a poll worker come assist me with my with my ballot now obviously they knew how I voted but I wanted to vote and it's just kind of catch-22 deal there what was I didn't care if they knew how I voted but what do do the current poll workers they there is no limit on how many folks they can assist that's correct then why do we need to change this because if there is someone there who can legally assist who is a legal poll worker who there would be no question of their integrity or their motive we have the assistance already in place why would we need to change this for any outsider to come in and assist more than six people
▶ Play
well I think there is a question of integrity and credibility of the
▶ Play
poll worker would that question not also lie with someone who is just a random outsider but that's
▶ Play
the choice of the voter it's the voter Well,
▶ Play
right. And as a voter, I've had a choice of bringing in my own assistant or bringing in or asking the poll worker to assist me. What are we trying to gain by, I mean, are there that many instances where folks want to bring in a public, I'm going to call them a public assistant, who would have already assisted more than six people on election day?
▶ Play
well I would disagree about calling them a public assistant I would think more of it as a private assistant the voter chooses and not someone who the election the local election Commission chooses and I think people that are voting have should have a right to trust and bringing in that person that they do trust and believe in their integrity and credibility as opposed to someone that might be unknown to them might be someone that they
▶ Play
don't trust would you agree that anyone has the opportunity to get an absentee ballot and vote at home
▶ Play
with whoever they want helping them well that could be problematic particularly now that we have put in place more laws that make it more difficult to obtain a an absentee ballot persons may need help in getting an absentee ballot and now people are that would normally assist are restricted to two absentee ballot so things are problematic but if a person wants to go to the polling place. I just believe that that person who needs assistance ought to be able to choose the person to assist them. Well, I agree. I
▶ Play
just... Thank you for agreeing with me. I do agree with that. By all means, I just don't... I'm just afraid that if we lift a restriction, lift this six-person limit, that we're going to be opening the gates of opportunity for more cases of abuse. That's my personal opinion. Would you disagree? I would disagree with that, Representative Miller. I
▶ Play
mean, like I said, the history does not prove that out. And this law just became effective in 2009. So it was just put in place in 2009. prior to that we didn't have a restriction and there has not been anything since to suggest a need for a restriction only as to absentee ballots what is what
▶ Play
has happened to suggest a need to remove this restriction well people who
▶ Play
were not aware of the law in the last election were encountered at at the the polling place when they were there to assist a voter that they couldn't and mr. Sofer was one of those persons who got into it with a lot of people in my community and it was something that surprised a lot of individuals and I was asked to run this legislation to repeal that law representative Bell
▶ Play
immediate consideration madam chair immediate consideration is non-debatable I always have to trust you look at my handy-dandy motions yes immediate considerations and it's non-debatable all those in favor aye all those opposed Okay. The ayes have it. All right. Then what is the wishes of the committee? Representative Nichols moves do pass. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? No. No's have it. Sorry, Senator Flowers, your bill did not pass. Next up is Senator Sanders, Senate Bill 914. You're recognized, Representative Westerman and Senator Sanders. Thank you very much, Madam
▶ Play
Chair. Members, what you have before you today is something that has gone through a whole lot of work. It is the creation of the Office of Medicaid Inspector General. This bill is, the goal of this bill is to consolidate and coordinate Medicaid integrity functions under one office, an independent office, so that we as taxpayers, we as elected officials, we as the general public can have confidence in the administration of a very important program. I think we all have seen, I think some members here have been on audit a time or two and they've read audit reports and they've seen things and they've seen recommendations that have come down. And what this does, and I want to add that this bill has been worked on not only by Representative Westbrook and myself, but also the Department of Human Services, also the governor's office, also lawmakers, providers who have a lot at stake. But I would also be remiss if I didn't point out we've had the assistance of other Medicaid inspector generals from other states who take a great interest in maintaining the integrity of the Medicaid system. And that is what we have done. This is a key reform effort that does, in fact, reform the current system that we have, but also sets us on a path for the future to make sure that we have the utmost confidence in what our state government is doing. And what this bill does, it creates independence, and that is key. If you look at other states that have done this, two of the states that we worked with in particular were the states of Texas and New York. Independence is key. The agency, the inspector general, would be appointed by the governor. He or she would be confirmed by the Senate. And what is a process now that is internal to the organization would have new light, new openness, and a greater level of reporting and oversight from the legislature as well. And that is built into this bill. The individual who would be hired, he or she, would be someone who would have to have a significant amount of experience in the area of investigation. that that is spelled out in the middle what this bill does not do it does in fact create two new positions but what this bill does is actually move existing assets within DHS puts them under the office of Medicaid inspector general so so again we're taking existing assets consolidating and coordinating those activities if you look at the reports and the findings of states like New York and Texas and other states that have the OIG the efforts that they pursue more than pay for themselves this is something that the federal government takes very seriously CMS Medicaid Medicare the federal government has a inspector general that looks into these matters this gives us the opportunity to be proactive and reform a system that we believe is in need a reform and I'd be
▶ Play
happy to take any questions representative Hutchison you madam chair would disrespect already I'm sorry represent it's okay would this inspector have full access to all information that he needed, but he had full authority of that in this bill.
▶ Play
Yes, Representative. He or she would have access, and that is clearly spelled out. As you know, the Medicaid program is complicated. One of the things that is utilized in that is a pretty significant IT backbone, And this bill actually speaks very specifically to that component, but it also speaks very specifically to the things that he or she would be looking at and cover and have jurisdiction over.
▶ Play
I guess what I'm saying is I'd want to make sure that they had all access to all freedom of information. If you're going to stop it, you've got to know
▶ Play
Speaker 153 38:31
it, right? That's correct, Representative Hutchison. Thank you. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Clemmer. So if I'm reading this bill right, I'm going to ask you if I'm reading it right, and I witness some abuse or fraud, or if I'm working in a dentist office and I have someone who receives transportation from 100 miles away, you know basically authorized by Medicaid I as a dentist could call this hotline that's going to be set up and say you know I enjoy having the business from 100 miles away but why was Medicaid paying for a cab to sit here all day while I worked on this
▶ Play
individual yeah representative that that's good that's good question and if you'll in the bill when you are reading it correctly you we have in place today and this move very clear this doesn't supplant any of the efforts that Attorney General Dustin McDaniel and his staff is has pursued in terms of the Medicaid fraud control unit this is to work in concert with them there is an existing hotline today that is utilized that information would be forwarded to do this office so yes do you think
▶ Play
that's used very often this is the Attorney General will speak to that I can't
▶ Play
I can't answer to the I can't answer to the use of the hotline but he's standing up and if you might look at me it's not your okay okay dh okay it's dhs is hotline it is well it is I know that it is used but what and and there have been multiple times I can go back to my early days in the capital when I was a lot skinnier and a lot had a lot more hair and less haggard well could you have the governor now maybe it was not great but you know there they were we've had other hotline set up in state government just to get to the point I mean this this is something that this streamlines the process representative and I think it I think this
▶ Play
would satisfy any concerns you have I just want to see if that's what part of what the goal is just to make it more stream I'm not gonna use that word streamline but to make a better system for receiving
▶ Play
and following up on complaints correct thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 165 40:55
representative Wilkins thank you madam chair senator this is creating new
▶ Play
jobs right to two new jobs what's the appropriation for this I mean we my point is we all we seem to be auditing everything that
▶ Play
Speaker 156 41:12
is possible audit right now so what's the appropriation for these new jobs yes the total the total of
▶ Play
preparation is and again this to be very clear representative we're moving a lot of existing assets so out of a out of an appropriation of 1.9 million the only ad that you have to that is I believe it's under $300,000 in addition addition to what's already being utilized and to your point you are correct sir I think that some of the complaints that the provider communities have had is there's audits coming from every direction and sometimes they don't know you know one went from one day to the next who's going to audit them this is put in place to consolidate and coordinate many of those functions within state government and I think I think that's why the provider community supports this and certainly you've enjoyed working working with those folks
▶ Play
Representative Altus. Thank you, Madam Chair. As a matter of fact, last night I was reading the NCSL national publication, and most of the magazine was about the inspector general office, and they were talking about how the other states had started this office, and it was being very successful in at least eight But my concern is, over the years, I've been on audit for 12, 14 years or whatever, and we've reviewed all these cases where all these huge amounts of abuse and fraud have taken place, and we've referred them to the prosecutors, and they won't prosecute. And that really makes me mad. I mean, that really upsets me. I mean, I've gone to some of these prosecutors, and I've called them names, basically, and gotten their face, and I can't make these people prosecute. What makes you think this bill is going to make these people prosecute? For instance, page 5, line 25, it talks about inform the governor, the attorney general, the president pro tem, the speaker of the house of this fraud, waste, and abuse. And then in lines 30, it talks about referring these cases to the appropriate law enforcement agencies. but I don't see any teeth in this bill and what what do we have in here that says we will definitely go after these people we will definitely prosecute these people is there anything that that instructs the Attorney General to to go after these people or anything in this
▶ Play
bill that puts any teeth into it well let me say this representative Althus I think it's I think it's very important have an open transparent structure that that reports not only to us in terms of what's going on but also reports to the governor what we have seen if you read that I've read the same article and in our work with some of the other inspectors general what you see is this is this is a this is a little higher profile your rate you're raising it up I do want to say I do want to say that that the Attorney General's office their Medicaid fraud control unit has I believe done an excellent job at prosecuting waste fraud and abuse in the state of Arkansas and we've been privy to some of that and it's been out there that's their specialty many cases represent about this local prosecutors don't prosecute Medicaid fraud and a lot of it is because it requires specific expertise and it requires knowledge of both not only state rules but also federal rules federal guidelines that are issued by by CMS and it can at times be very tricky I think what our action here today would send if it is the will the committee to pass this is that one we take this very serious and we are setting up a structure by which we would go after this and it would be identified and it would be referred to the appropriate law enforcement agency there there are
▶ Play
Speaker 178 45:56
other law enforcement agencies representative else representative Ritchie thank you madam chair
▶ Play
Speaker 39 46:01
center you made the statement that this is basically moving existing resources primarily to fund this program what are those existing resources are moving on and how does DHS feel about that their resources are being well I've taken taking the speaking for DHS
▶ Play
and the governor at times no this is we've worked with them on this in fact we they do I mean director see we can come up here they do they support this function they support doing this I think it's a good they think it's a good reform so if they didn't we probably wouldn't be
▶ Play
here any other questions from committee members representative Hobbs
▶ Play
thank you madam chair senator Sanders I see on page 4 line 33 I believe it was where it also talks about hiring extra deputies and assistants and so forth so how many people do you actually or how many jobs do you actually see this office creating
▶ Play
what what that what that yeah that that's the authority to have that what we have is that they will have a line item in the budget in terms of positions and that's what we've that's what we've moved over so they will not be able
▶ Play
to hire outside of out of there so how many positions do you actually see this office 30 35 positions okay and I understand you correctly that currently the AG's office is following up on Medicaid fraud there's the Medicaid
▶ Play
fraud control unit within the office of Attorney General and that is that is their key function is to is to prosecute Medicaid
▶ Play
fraud okay so then help me understand why
▶ Play
we're creating a whole new agency well we're actually not creating a whole new agency we're taking existing resources that take place today there's an auditing function there is there is a lot of function within the Medicaid system before everything anything is ever referred to would be referred to the the office of the office in the Attorney General's office so it's not just the function of prosecution and identifying fraud but it is there are other functions that take place within Medicaid integrity program integrity which is I think it's it's spoken to pretty clearly in the bill so it's not just a prosecutorial function and this office does not have prosecuting power that is the Attorney General's office and
▶ Play
maybe to clarify on that a little representative house there there already is a program integrity unit within DHS and in the Medicaid fraud control unit is in the Attorney General's office the function of that program integrity unit is to audit and make recommendations to law enforcement we're just taking the program integrity unit out of DHS and putting it into the office of Medicaid Inspector General which will be outside of DHS and
▶ Play
if I if I might also say representative there are a lot of things in terms of you know when they audit and they find something an error and if they go to recover money that was paid in error that's that's not that's not anything that would need to be referred to the Attorney General this is sort of the normal function of program integrity the federal government mandates that we have Medicaid integrity functions as part of the Medicaid program and we have we have that today our point is what this does is makes it independent and it makes it to where where there is more oversight and that there is consolidation and coordination on those efforts and today and if you have you can talk to individuals in the provider community they will tell you sometimes We just, as Representative Wilkins said, I mean, sometimes they don't really know where it's coming from. Sometimes they feel like they're getting audited here or questioned here, and
▶ Play
what this will do will consolidate that. Okay, so I've heard testimony before that, sitting in health committee or whatever, that we are currently looking at Medicaid fraud and identifying it. but are you telling me you don't think we are doing
▶ Play
that I think that's happening today what what I would simply suggest to you and I would commend the the NCSL article to read is that there is a better way and this is a significant reform and this is this is a reform that will ensure that not only we have the confidence but the public has the confidence that we are doing everything to ensure the optimization the running of the Medicaid of the Medicaid program that we were doing everything within our power to identify and eliminate waste fraud abuse did I understand
▶ Play
you to say that you think it will take another three hundred thousand dollars on top of what we're currently
▶ Play
spending and that is that's just in positions of actually hiring an inspector general hiring a deputy counsel for that position
▶ Play
as well so you don't see us like taking current
▶ Play
Speaker 198 51:23
positions and just we have to do that in
▶ Play
this case and I will tell you too and I think it's detailed in the NCSL article there or one of them either maybe about one of the other organizations they talk about sort of the function in the financing of integrity operations OIGs in terms of how they're paid for they pay for themselves and a lot of times we we hear people say if you do this it's going to save this money but this is a hard dollar amount this is this is something that does in fact pay for itself
▶ Play
okay and I'm sorry I haven't read through the whole wheel yet but is this like a pilot project to make sure
▶ Play
Speaker 201 52:07
it will pay for itself no
▶ Play
this is establishing the office so it does not pay for itself then I guess well I just
▶ Play
later would come and repeal this Representative, I don't think there's any question in terms of the audit and the integrity functions of Medicaid programs across the country that the intent there is for them to recoup and go after waste, fraud, and abuse and recover. And if you look at even in our own current setup, that is happening today in terms of the financing piece paying for itself. they bring in more than what they take rather what this what this does is it consolidates and coordinates all those functions under one office okay so could you tell me how much
▶ Play
they have recovered then you said that it that it is already paying for itself do we have an amount that has actually been recovered I know
▶ Play
that I wouldn't want to give an amount it's it's a significant amount of money I don't know what it is right off the
▶ Play
top of my head but we can get that information to
▶ Play
you that would be great because I did hear you say it is paying for itself
▶ Play
thank you many times over represent Wilkins pardon me represent Nichols thank you madam chair my question this is trying to find waste fraud and abuse in the Medicaid program how will this work or how will we regulate waste fraud and abuse if we go to the premium support or private option that that we've been discussing in the health care arena will there be jurors jurisdiction over waste fraud and abuse by this IG over the programs that will be paid for for those between 130 hundred thirty-eight percent of the poverty level yes representative Nichols they would have jurisdiction over that with that jurisdiction overlap with the state
▶ Play
insurance department currently in terms of the fraud investigative capabilities I believe this committee and others actually if it won't and if you can you read in the bill it actually talks about reports from the insurance department on insurance fraud proper so I mean I think that there again there's there's coordination you're not going to have you're not going to have two things happening at once this is this is a
▶ Play
this is a coordinating arm okay is this part of the packet of bills that we're going to see to try to deal with the whole Medicaid and Affordable Care Act issues well I think what yes I mean
▶ Play
this is a this is a significant reform to the existing system and it's one I obviously I care very deeply about representative Western carriers very deeply and others I mean this is one that I'm working on and I think it yeah this is this is a this is a key element and you know I think it's I think it's significant and it needs to be done and I think it ensures I think it's going to ensure the optimization of and the operate optimization the operation of our Medicaid program today and I think even moving forward representative into what you outline moving forward if we choose to do the private option I think this this will all be very very
▶ Play
Speaker 213 55:49
helpful okay and I assume represent Westman's for that aspect of it
▶ Play
yes I'm very much in favor
▶ Play
of this bill madam sheriff I might if I might say I've had a little help recover the integrity functions of Medicaid now according to the last year in terms of recovered funds is totaled seven million dollars I'm sorry seven million seven million dollars thank
▶ Play
you on a less than two million dollar budget I didn't understand that connect oh it's currently two two million dollar budget that runs the unit and they've recovered seven under two million under two million okay thank you representative Wilkins thank you
▶ Play
madam chair senator most of us sitting here at this table have run in the past on smaller government and one of the things I hear when I go home is how come we have all these hundred thousand plus jobs in the state capital now understanding this bill it's going to create two more how am I going to explain that to my constituents well I think what I would I'll
▶ Play
be happy to go with you back to Bono in fact I'd love any excuse to go up to northeastern Arkansas but what I think you can say is this representative Wilkins I think you were particularly positioned to do this because you have worked in law enforcement you have worked in you've worked in in the area that I think is a good function of government and in fact it enforces the rule of law and I think what we're doing here today is adding to that function to actually protect taxpayer dollars to actually go after and recover funds that were improperly used or properly billed for so to the contrary I would my advice would be you should go back and tell them that you did do this and why you did it and the fact that what you're doing is ensuring that their government is running effectively and that that we will not tolerate cheating but you will
▶ Play
agree that most of us here at this table campaign no smaller government
▶ Play
yes that's right that's right and smaller government is not just positions but smaller government is money and I think what what you've seen and what we've seen in the experience that other states have had and even in our own unit and I think we will be better positioned to recover more money government is also budgets and recovering money adds back to the bottom line of the state government so I think you can you can say that
▶ Play
with a straight-faced representative thank you sir represent vaultus thank you madam chair you kind of talked around about this I think representative Westman said that there was a program integrity unit somewhere buried over at DHS and is that program integrity unit that's presently yet DHS is this all going to be combined under the office of inspector general and will they all work together and and is that unit going to be put in charge of this unit at DHS rather than being is it going are they going to work for DHS or are they going to be in charge of the fraud at DHS they will
▶ Play
work for the office of inspector general okay they will work for the office inspector general they will not be in the same place that they are currently they will they will be in that office and who's going
▶ Play
to push this guy's buttons the inspector general who's going to be his boss that would be the governor okay so he reports directly to the governor
▶ Play
he doesn't report to the director and he there if you will look in if you will look in in the law you will see that there is there is coordinating functions with obviously if if he's working or she is working on functions in DHS there is there is there is collaboration and coordination that would take place with within with the director within the
▶ Play
agency okay but this is integrity unit at DHS is going to make beaten now working with and for the inspector general that's correct okay
▶ Play
thank you very much represent Hutchison thank you madam chair wouldn't would you say that it would be a probably a safe hedge to say that you know in response to the like bigger government that since everybody's gonna be insured there's more people's gonna be on the insured program that three hundred thousand dollars would be like a safe bet into taking care of things in a much better
▶ Play
manner well represent much tonight I can only speak for one elected official and that's that's myself and I will tell you as one who believes in in limited government and smaller government this also someone who also believes in the integrity of our government I think there's absolutely no problem I have no problem philosophically personally with this if I did I wouldn't be here pushing it it's a good
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:56
question representative Hobbs and we're going around the room again with with our second
▶ Play
round here thank you thank you madam chair I think I think this is an important topic to discuss and ask questions on yes
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:09
I would agree and that's why I'm letting you ask a question again
▶ Play
representify I appreciate that madam chair thank you okay let me give you for instance I know within DHS they have people hired to review or or to approve claims I know for instance a while back there was a dentist I think hired to approve met Medicaid procedures or procedures that were paid by Medicaid and since I can in this instance this person said he just didn't really review them he just kind of rubber stamp them saying he felt like they were needed because the dentist had said they were needed so with some like that work for this new inspector general's office or that person remain within DHS represent
▶ Play
about I'm not aware of the situation that you outlined that well I think what you're talking about is is that that is and you may be better able to answer this in terms of prior authorizations yeah yeah yeah clearly clearly I mean so what would happen what the OIG would do that would stay within the Medicaid agency but what the OIG would do would actually be to look at those processes that are in place are we doing the right thing in terms of and again I've not heard this criticism but I suspect when if we pass this and the OIG is hired you probably ought to go talk to him or her and and speak to that but they would be looking at sort of the processes in place within the agency as well not just looking outside thank
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:49
you thank you madam chair thank you there is no one to sign signed up to speak for or against the bill you're
▶ Play
recognized a close for your bill thank you very much committee certainly would appreciate a positive vote on this represent Western I move
▶ Play
Speaker 239 1:03:06
do pass now there's a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:10
close for you all right the motion is do pass okay the Motion is due pass. All those in favor, aye. Aye. All those opposed? The ayes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Next up is Senate Bill 1029.
▶ Play
Speaker 245 1:03:40
Good. I hope you have that on this one because he wants to have spent government on this. Yeah. Okay, fiscal impact. Here we go, babe. They've asked for another person. Do you want
▶ Play
Speaker 249 1:04:11
to? Okay, King, this is the one you're going to run, right? Both bills have got in here. I want to run the election prompt. Which one? What number is that? Tell me which one is. He's coming to Bono. Whoa.
▶ Play
Speaker 20 1:04:27
Okay. Representative Ferguson, you're going to be presenting
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:32
this. I thought I saw Senator Ingram in the room. Okay. Yes, he had to leave. Okay. All right. folks this is Senate bill 1029 we've heard it once you now have the fiscal impact it's not the total fiscal impact it doesn't include but we'll talk about that in a minute represent
▶ Play
Ferguson you're recognized thank you madam chairman it's as you say this bill it is it an act to ensure that candidates for office are qualified to require criminal background checks for candidates before the election and to prevent candidates convicted of certain crimes for running for public office it provides additional tools to law enforcement to enforce current law prohibiting felons or others convicted of an infamous crime from holding office it provides notice to would-be candidates if they have a conviction that might disqualify them of potential fines of $1,000 to $25,000 if they're removed from office after they've been notified and they run anyway. The Arkansas Constitution bars a person from holding public office if they've been convicted of embezzlement of public money, bribery, fraudulence, or other infamous crimes. Statutes make it a felony to sign a political practice pledge, which includes a pledge that the person has been convicted. I see this. I think this bill protects voters. It assures that the person that they elect will not be disqualified from serving later and leave the people temporarily with no representation until there can be a special election held. And as you know, that's a very expensive process if that has to happen. I know probably none of us of candidates want to pay the $22 and have to go through a criminal background check, but there are instances, and, you know, I'm from Crittenden County, so I think I can speak to that, where people know they've been convicted of crime and run anyway. or there are we had a school board election where the person actually didn't know that the crime she convicted disqualified her for school board and we've still not replaced her so I think this is an important bill to assure that that that we don't end up with voids in the election process where the people are not represented and I have Attorney General Dustin McDaniel here if you need to ask questions and we do have a fiscal impact the the approval was made by the state police for the personnel to do the criminal background checks I think that was the question and it actually works out really well but they'll be paid forty four thousand a year and they're already twenty six thousand permits behind for conceal and carry permits so this person not only will they try to to take care of the backlog in concealing carry permits, but they will be doing these criminal background checks.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:52
You are aware that the state police also asked for two extra personnel just for the concealed carry, so that one doesn't fly here. That explanation on this person, this person is an admin person. The two people they've got for concealed carry are separate. $44,000 is the total salary that's packaged and everything for the person they're asking for? Yes. And they'd be working how long on just these permits? I mean, pardon me, Jesse's background checks, my guess is a maximum six weeks from the time people file until...
▶ Play
Wait, Randall, I'm not sure. Is this state? Maybe the Attorney General can answer that.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:08:27
Okay. Thank you. Identify yourself for
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:08:30
the record. Good morning, Madam Chairman. I'm Dustin McDaniel. I'm the Attorney General. And my understanding from state police that in addition to the two personnel that you just described, described this person would in fact be assigned to assisting with reducing the backlog of concealed carry permits because obviously they would need a person to work on the background checks during the heavy season which of course is every election season but also what are you gonna do with that person the rest of the time that would be my question though you either bring somebody in only when you need them which would be fine and state police certainly could do that or you bring them in and you put them to work on things that are needed so in addition my understanding from state police is that in addition to the two persons that are that you just described this person would in fact be working on assisting with that backlog when they're not available and then available for other purposes and it's perfectly fine with me frankly if they don't have anybody except for as temporary help when needed you know every other year the Secretary of State's office tells us that there are more than 10,000 persons a year who run for office they you know quarter million dollars worth of fees roughly would come in it would be I would think better than revenue neutral eventually for state police and they could do other things okay so
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:07
every other year this forty four thousand dollar a year person would be spending six weeks on doing background checks approximately from the time during the filing period if that's what I've I'm hearing if they have a person full-time which I don't know that
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:10:22
they would well there's a there's a there's a companion bill
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:26
there's a companion bill to this that was in personnel this morning and I held it up until this bill was heard today the companion bill is by the same sponsor Center Ingram asking for that one person for state police just for this position you do do you know by chance off the top of your head how much the concealed carry permits bring in two million dollars a year and they're on track to bring in almost a half again more than that this year and the number permits that are being and it cost them 200 and approximately 230,000 I think to run the unit if I'm not mistaken that was the information that I got from Kim Arnall and the state police when I met with them let's get back to this
▶ Play
Speaker 266 1:11:15
bill shall we representative Nichols thank you madam chairman
▶ Play
I passed the bill out a couple years ago on expungements and how does and I know in the expungement or statues or ceiling statute certain information is still discoverable by law enforcement but but may be sealed to the public how does an expunge expungement work in this particular arena I don't
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:11:51
think it would make any impact I'm looking around from a smart lawyer get over your smart lawyer but I I don't think that it would make any difference on with
▶ Play
regard to your bill I am concerned about it because it it doesn't say that like certain occupations even though the the offenses may have been expunged the certain occupations still still release for those I guess for nurses or teachers or
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:12:35
some others so I I guess one of them. Well, licensing boards like nursing and any other lawyers, dentists, they determine their own standards. But the standards to run for office are set by the Constitution and bounded by statutes such as your expungement law, which would say that the effect of an expungement is that it never happened and you can still run for office. And so all we're doing is notifying people that, hey, you've got a conviction here. And it's also not just notifying them, but more importantly, it's notifying the Secretary of State and the Attorney General. So if I get a notice that a guy running for constable in Jefferson County, just to pick a county, I didn't mean to single anybody out, but, you know, in any random county, was convicted of a felony 15 years ago. And he has been notified, and he's running, and he knows about it. The Secretary of State's office, the Attorney General's office, can take action to say, you're not running. Because people don't realize that there's nothing in place right now other than somebody signing on the dotted line to keep a convicted felon off the ballot. And if you find that someone is a felon, uneligible to serve, it's actually up to you as the candidate opposing that person to basically bring suit or do something about it. And how are you supposed to know about it? So there needs to be something in the system so that the public has some confidence that who I'm voting for, for school board, the legislature, constable, City Council is actually eligible
▶ Play
to serve but you know I think writing hot checks has been considered an infamous crime and I'm worried and we may have had somebody serving in the legislature who had done that 15 20 25 years ago But I think if they had had that expunged, I would hope that they
▶ Play
Speaker 268 1:14:54
would be able to run for office. If they've had it expunged,
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:14:59
they would be eligible to run for office.
▶ Play
But I'm not sure if your bill covers that. That's just a concern that I have. It's just not clear.
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:15:08
It does. This bill doesn't determine whether you are eligible to run or not. This bill has nothing to do with whether you are eligible to run or not. This bill is a transparency bill for the candidates themselves, the Secretary of State and the Attorney General's office, so that you know that there's perhaps a question. This is somewhat a companion bill to Representative Branscombe's bill, which attempts to define infamous crimes. We work to assist Representative Branscombe on his attempt to define infamous crimes. By definition, that statute is incomplete because the legislature could create some new crime tomorrow that's not articulated in that statute that would have elements of fraud or deceit that the Supreme Court would interpret to be an infamous crime. But certainly, if we're placed on notice that a candidate for school board was convicted of a homicide 20 years ago in Montana and he's signed on the bottom of his political practices pledge saying, oh, no, I've never been charged with a crime. And as ludicrous as that sounds, I've discovered in the years that I've been attorney general that it happens every cycle. Unfortunately, it happens literally every cycle. And there's really no method in place to filter those folks. And if they had a proper expungement, then that's there too because obviously the burden would be on the state to show that someone needed to be removed from the ballot. But right now I don't even know who to go after. I mean, I've got some power to remove people from the ballot or from office, but how am I supposed to know?
▶ Play
And once they're elected, it's up to us to remove them, I guess, correct?
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:16:50
Yeah, and interestingly enough, we've got stories of city council members and school board members from around the state where even when the town found out that they had an old conviction, nobody wanted to do anything about it. The case that you described of the candidate who had been charged with felony hot checks and pleaded guilty to misdemeanor hot checks, which is clearly an infamous crime, uneligible to serve even if elected, never was removed from office, never was removed by the members of the General Assembly. And when running for a county office, his opponent just said, well, I don't want to get in the middle of trying to get him taken off the ballot. That would be sort of messy. And he lost, but he never should have been on
▶ Play
Speaker 276 1:17:44
the ballot. Thank you, Mr. General.
▶ Play
Representative Bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm glad we've got a couple of smart attorneys here because I have a question just as to
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:17:56
how this law actually functions. Okay. And I have with me Assistant Attorney General Colin Jorgensen, and if it's helpful for him to answer a question, I would ask the chair to recognize him at the proper
▶ Play
time. As we look at this, candidate provides the waiver, background check is conducted, information is transmitted then back to the Secretary of State's office. At that point, somebody makes a judgment as to whether a crime is an infamous crime or not. I'm very uncomfortable with the Secretary of State's office being in the position of deciding if something is an infamous crime and whether it moves on down. It appears that we're taking the executive branch and putting them in the position of making what is essentially a judicial determination here. They don't make that decision. This
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:18:46
bill would not give them the power to make that decision. Frankly, the bill doesn't give me the power to make that decision. What it says is if there is an offense, if there's a conviction, if it's a felony, it's automatic. If it's a misdemeanor, then you're right. It's up to the courts. Now, the legislature has attempted to assist us with Representative Branscombe's bill that articulates the following crimes are deemed to be infamous crimes under the Constitution. But that's why under this bill, all you do is if there's something there, you send the candidate a notice. You send him a letter. Say, look, you've got this conviction. You may be well aware of it. It's not an automatic disqualifier. You run if you want to. But we're placing you on notice, and if the courts, you know, and we're sending this over to the AG's office. And the AG's got the power to evaluate it and investigate further. But if the AG brings a case and the court decides that you knew about it and you ran anyway, then that's where the fine comes in. And so you've got the option of walking off as a
▶ Play
candidate. With all respect, I'd like to draw your attention to the top of page 3, lines 4 and 5. 3, lines 4 and 5. A candidate has been convicted of an offense under subsection A of this section. the secretary of state or county clerk promptly shall now if we drop back to subsection a that lists the list of crimes which includes infamous crime if there's a crime that's not listed in the in the two prior items there somebody's going to have to make a judgment of whether or not it is an infamous crime and that is placing the county clerk or the secretary of state in the position of deciding if that is an infamous crime or not in the plain language of the bill unless I'm completely misreading it. I think realistically,
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:20:54
from talking to the Secretary of State's office, I don't need to speak for them. They're here if they intend to speak, and clerks. The simple thing is, is if you've got a misdemeanor conviction on there, especially one that's articulated, but even if one that's not, send a letter and say, hey, you've got a misdemeanor conviction may or may not make that matter to you running weird the clerks are specifically not going to be placed in a position of being finders of law it isn't up to them to decide if somebody is eligible to run they wouldn't ask for that responsibility they're not required to take on that responsibility and I wouldn't ask them to somebody's got a conviction you send them a letter and say and and say hey you got a conviction if you know about it great if you don't know about it here it is and it's been just be advised that somebody someday may question whether or
▶ Play
not you can run why don't we say that in the bill if you have a misdemeanor conviction of any type then you're going to this communication is going to take place we
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:21:53
don't it says infamous crime there may have been a specific discussion about
▶ Play
that but I don't recall it because if the definition of infamous crime as we've struggled to define it it's clearly out there and this this is placing somebody in the position of having to decide, is this an infamous crime? Was it a traffic ticket
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:22:10
or what was it? The smart lawyer tells me that we, you know, Bill Clinton told me that BNAG is the greatest job because, you know, if you you don't have to appoint anybody, you don't have to disappoint anybody, and if anything goes wrong you just blame it on the Constitution, and that's really worked for me for about six years now. And they wanted to follow the language of the Constitution, which the founders didn't make clear enough for us, and we are stuck with it. I love our Constitution, and that's my whole job. We all swear our oath to support and defend the Constitution. Sometimes it's not eminently clear. So I think that there would be more justifiable criticism if we wrote something that went beyond what the Constitution were to
▶ Play
allow. You understand, I mean, the legislature typically defines or drills down items that are in the Constitution so that they are more clear, and what I'm troubled by here is the determination of what is an infamous crime is essentially a judicial decision. I think everybody agrees on that, and right here in the plain language of this bill, we're stating if it's an infamous crime, then the Secretary of State or the clerk shall. Somebody has to decide if it's an infamous crime, and this bill doesn't say if anybody Anybody has any misdemeanor that they're going to disseminate this information. It says felony, et cetera, or infamous crime. That's asking. I believe it's unconstitutional because of that, because I believe it's asking the executive branch to
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:23:47
make a judicial determination, and I think there's potential challenges there. Well, respectfully, it's not unconstitutional. I mean, the Constitution clearly says that we have to make laws that the executive branch has to enforce. For the executive branch to enforce laws, they have to interpret things every day. Giving some discretion and latitude is appropriate. More importantly, to tell somebody you have to go beyond what the Constitution would require, and all misdemeanors certainly is beyond what the Constitution would require, would add a second layer. You know, if what happens is a clerk doesn't send a letter to somebody because they had misdemeanor conviction for something you know we'll deal with it when the time comes you know I think realistically what they will do is err on the side of caution they won't try to implement some in-house analysis and if there's a letter they send if there's a conviction they send the letter and they'll let
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:24:47
the lawyers figure it out okay I've got several other questions from committee members here represent Richie you're next thank you madam
▶ Play
Speaker 39 1:24:56
chair I'm all for the background checks and making sure we don't have people with felonies and such in running but that's my concern is if we're we're sending them a letter notifying them of the conviction then it's kind of up to them what they do which I'm like that seems to be kind of like what it is where we are now because usually people know whether or not they've been convicted of a felony before they run I would hope but so what exactly how do how do we pursue it and I guess I'm how do we make the determination of whether or not the Attorney General's office is going to pursue this if this person you know gets the letter they still decide to run and then at what point do we decide yeah we're gonna pursue this person or I mean who's gonna who's gonna follow up on
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:25:52
Well, as with all prosecutorial decisions, it's going to be with the attorney general, whomever that is at the time. But they will have a staff who will understand the law. And if, yes, sending the letter to the candidate is a due process protection, it is a pragmatic step that most folks, they know that they're felons when they sign the political practice pledge saying they're not felons. They just count on the fact that nobody's going to check it. Once it's checked and they get a letter saying, hey, we'll give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that you forgot this felony conviction you had in Montana 15 years ago, but we found it, and here's your chance to back out. If you don't, by the way, you need to know that a copy of this letter has also been sent to the Attorney General's office. office, and if you decide to go ahead and run, the AG's office will be in a position to act. Now, why not just send them a notice saying, hey, we found this conviction, and you're off the ballot, which is frankly what I wanted to do. Why not just do that? Well, you have due process problems that you will never overcome with that because people, there's a time constraint from the time you have to file to the time the election is held. of ballots have to be printed, and that would be the unconstitutional delegation of power, as Representative Bell was talking about, to somebody to make the decision going, hey, we saw this conviction. He's off the ballot. If he wants to sue us to get back on between now and May, more power to him. Now, that's the way I wanted to do it, and that's the way I told him to write it for about a year, but that would have been unconstitutional. This is the appropriate way to give everybody adequate time. You leave the burden on the state. People have their presumption of innocence, and, you know, you keep the – not the presumption of innocence. That's a criminal term. But, you know, the preponderance – the burden of proof here is on the state. And so that's why it's structured the way it is.
▶ Play
Speaker 39 1:28:01
A follow-up question. Yes. Now, what about, I mean, I've heard a criticism that, you know, that this information should just be made public so everybody would know. I mean, what would be the problem with just making it
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:28:16
public? I think there would be big problems with just making it public. There we go. First of all, your ACIC report, all persons' ACIC reports are confidential as a matter of law. It's a Class D felony to release people's ACIC reports. ACIC reports are only possible because of agreements with NCIC, the National Crime Information Computer. So we're accessing FBI databases when we run these reports to begin with. This is a law enforcement function. No non-certified law enforcement can go run these things on anybody. That's why we have to house it at the state police to begin with. These are very sensitive documents. And you don't forfeit that right just by virtue of you running for office. The idea that we're going to make your NCIC report available for public consumption six times a day at public expense has been an idea that's been floated and shot down repeatedly by the General Assembly, and my office has consistently opposed it and continues to oppose it. still have the right to be protected by law on issues of privacy and that also extends to the FOIA exemptions that are contained within this act because when you sign your background check waiver which is just exactly what you'd sign if you went to work for Medicaid just exactly what you'd sign if you went to work in a nursing home just exactly what you'd sign if you went to work in a bank we're not asking any more of somebody that's gonna administer even a small school district has tens of millions of dollars that get administered we're not asking any more of a school board member than what we'd ask of a teller which is let's run your background check and make sure you're
▶ Play
legally are allowed to be here thank you thank you representative over be not that I want to stop all this talk but I think this is good bill and I just want to make a do pass motion at
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:30:30
the proper time thank you so noted representative Hutchison
▶ Play
thank you madam chair I like this bill too also mr. attorney general but well I well I got you here and I might
▶ Play
Speaker 298 1:30:45
not never have another chance I feel a power line question coming you
▶ Play
know I really like to ensure that that the candidate for offices are qualified okay and is it you know you talking about a position that would require another forty four thousand or somebody did and made that a job, you know. I would defer to state police on what it is they're paying the people. Okay, when I get stopped, or I've only been stopped one time by a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:31:21
state trooper in my life. This is not confession time. Well, okay, well, okay. But if you have a question, go ahead. I
▶ Play
thought you might be proud of me, Madam Chair. But what I'm saying is, isn't it like that quick they can tell if I have a felony, like that quick? So that shouldn't cost that much money, right? The data is
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:31:46
already there, right? The data is there, but you're talking about a certified law enforcement officer in the field. He's not able to print out a report that could be disseminated. I mean, that's an investigative tool. It's not even admissible at that point. I mean, you know, it's something to give the officer information in the field. If you're talking about doing it for 10,500 candidates in the course of a few weeks, then certainly that's a bigger task.
▶ Play
Well, maybe my colleagues might not go for this, but, you know, when I come down here to Little Rock to File, maybe I could just run right over there to the ASP and do it myself right there,
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:32:26
huh? Well, I think that's pretty close to how it's going to work. When you pay your filing fee, you're going to sign the waiver. 99% of candidates are never going to hear another thing about it. Most of us have never been convicted of even a misdemeanor, much less a felony. All right,
▶ Play
here's my other thing. Here's my biggie, okay? I don't want to, you know, I like this. I really do. But if you go through this and you're qualified to run, I don't know if now's the time to talk about this or what, but like I say, I'll never have you in front of me again, maybe. I hope so, but, you know, I got you now. I'm here. Uh, let's see, if you're qualified to run, and then sometime during the campaign somebody comes out and says you're not qualified by a certain reason, I don't think that ought to be able to happen to a candidate.
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:33:28
You're talking about the political misuse of people's back. Well, that's one of the reasons why, in addition to federal law and state law and all the privacy concerns on keeping ACIC reports confidential, I certainly support that. This law will help you with that because right now, if somebody says, you shouldn't vote for candidate X, don't you know he got convicted of something 10 years ago and they never did get that expunged? He's a felon. Everybody knows that. It's going to be in the paper tomorrow. Right now, that rumor can spread and does in a lot of political campaigns. And there's nothing to say, hey, look, I've filed, you know, I've signed my campaign pledge. I've signed my background waiver. The Secretary of State's office has looked at me. The Attorney General's office has looked at me, and I'm on this ballot. And you can look to this law to defend people in that regard because now you can show people. Well, if I'm on the ballot, it's because somebody's looked at it, and you're not just taking my word for it.
▶ Play
In my case, you know, when you can't prove your innocence until after the election, that's not very funny. We've all been there, but I can
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:34:39
tell you that this law will help, in my opinion, this law will help candidates to fend off those kind of things. Could we add some language to it?
▶ Play
I don't think you have to. I think it's I think it's perfectly situated to do
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:34:56
just that as is I'll take your word for it thank you sir thank you thank you madam chair okay
▶ Play
representative altus thank you madam chair most of my questions have been answered but because I was just concerned about the the mechanics of how this is going to work so so when you apply when you when you sign your pledge and pay your filing fee, then at that time, how does this work? Do I pay the secretary of the state the $22 or do I have to go to the? I think you make
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:35:29
the check payable to state police. But I give it to the secretary of state. Well, you know, or if you're running, you give it to whoever you pay your filing fee to. Okay. If you're running for county office, you know, you give it to the clerk. Okay. But it's all one stop. You don't have to go somewhere else. When you pay your filing fee and you sign your political practices pledge, At
▶ Play
the same time, you put one more signature and one more check, and it's done. Okay. So if I've killed 100 people in Montana, and then it comes back that I've been guilty of homicide, but yet I got out of prison early or something, then that's going to come to you, and then a letter will come to me, and then that's it? Nobody else is going to
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:36:16
know about it? Well, it'd be pretty public as soon as, assuming that you stay on the ballot and say, oh, no, I'm fighting it, and stay on. As soon as the AG's office files to have you removed as being ineligible to serve by virtue of your felony conviction, I think the public will know
▶ Play
pretty good. So then you will prosecute or
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:36:35
whatever? The attorney general and local prosecutors have concurrent authority.
▶ Play
Okay. But if you choose not to run because you're notified, then no one
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:36:45
knows. Okay. So, line unless, and to be clear, it is already a felony to lie on your political practices pledge. And if, you know, the local prosecutor wants to charge you with perjury because, hey, you lied on your political practices pledge, that would be up to the
▶ Play
local prosecutor. Okay. Page 3, line 30, it says court. Is that a district court, circuit court, county court, federal court? What kind of court? It'd have to be circuit court.
▶ Play
Circuit court? Okay. Thank you. Representative Miller. Thank you, Madam Chair. I guess up front, I don't have a problem with doing background checks. I've run some bills requiring background checks myself. I don't have a problem subjecting myself to one. I know what I've done, and I guess my big concern is we're talking about setting this up, hiring another person, going through all this, and we don't really, it's just simply for the purpose of notification. or we don't have you've said repeatedly that the county clerk and secretary of state's office will not deem a candidate eligible or ineligible they don't have that authority even if they clearly see that or there's a possibility of a candidate that has been convicted of an infamous crime, they would not, the county clerk or the secretary of state, would not have the authority to say, hey, you know, sorry, but you're ineligible. So basically, all we're doing is just letting people know what they've been convicted of. Well, no, you're letting the
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:38:48
attorney general know. And that's where the enforcement comes from. The Attorney General has the power right now to remove people, but we don't know who to go after. I mean, unless we run a criminal background check on everybody in the state that's holding office or seeking office, which we certainly wouldn't do without some either cause or a waiver by the person, how are we supposed to know? So, I mean, I keep getting reports of, oh, there's a constable down in X county, and he's a convicted felon, and finally he resigned because everybody in town figured out he was a felon, but nobody had done anything about it. Well, how am I supposed to know that that person – I mean, I can act if I have some reason to know, but I can't act if I don't know. And so, like I said earlier, I'd love for it to be as simple as if you get something comes back that's X, Y, and Z, you're off the ballot, done, no more time wasted thinking about you. But due process, again, we blame the Constitution, due process is afforded to everybody. And if someone resists and says, no, by golly, that wasn't me, that was my twin brother that committed that homicide in Montana, that wasn't me, they can go to court. You know, I mean, we would have the burden of proving. And so it would require a judicial determination, which I
▶ Play
think is what Representative Bell was alluding to earlier. would, I think that this whole process, not necessarily, I mean, I know this is reaching out beyond this bill, would be a lot easier if we had, if we could clearly define what infamous crime is.
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:40:49
Would you agree? I would. And if we wanted to amend the Constitution, that's the way to do it. But in lieu of amending the Constitution, the courts have tried to give us guidance, and with Representative Branscombe, the General Assembly has tried to give us guidance, but it's still going to be a murky question at times. Thank you. Representative Bell. Thank you, Madam Chair.
▶ Play
I wanted to make sure I understood something correctly. When Representative Altus asked the question about fee collection, you indicated that that could be paid to the clerk or the Secretary of State along with filing fees. Don't the parties collect the filing fees? And if so, would that be paid? I guess it's just I want to make sure that I'm understanding the collection
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:41:46
process here. I'd probably defer better to the Secretary of State's office, but at the time you submit your filing fee, what I was trying to say was that you don't pay the clerk, and it's not, you know, it's not, again, no burden is supposed to be on the clerks out of all this. You just write the check to the state police, and you do it at the same time that you sign your political practice as a pledge and you
▶ Play
pay your filing fee. Okay. So you're paying your filing fee to the party. Then you get your party authorization to go file, and you carry that with your check to the state police, to the clerk, or the secretary of state. Is that right? Yeah. Okay. I'm going to make sure I
▶ Play
add the process, clerk. Thank you, Representative Hutchison. Thank you, Madam Chair. This is a good bill. I like it, but I'm all about simple government. let's make it real simple let's make it be part of the filing fee process because I know I've experienced it and it was something I'll cherish all my life and it was an experience and I I challenge everybody to do it some time but let it be in the process that computer be right there check your background you know before you can get your name on
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:43:07
the ballot that'd be pretty simple wouldn't it would be the problem is is that would be too simple and we would we would have due process
▶ Play
well the the state police like you said the database is collected it's it's a privacy issue and the clerk wouldn't be
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:43:29
allowed to run that hmm oh if you were suggesting that the clerk just run it As you're sitting there, no, no, I'm sorry. You're talking about a law enforcement background check. You'd have to have a certified law enforcement officer, somebody designated by the state police as a law enforcement
▶ Play
agency to do it. That's what's wrong with the government, Mr. Attorney General. Everything, y'all make it too difficult.
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:43:56
Well, again, you have the power to refer out an amendment on the Constitution in this committee,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:44:01
so if that's what you all wanted to do, that's what you wanted to do it. And if we can get the Senate to meet with us, we just might not get that. All right, here we go. We've got two people signed up to speak on this bill. So I'm going to go to someone to speak against the bill first and then for the bill. Against the bill is Dan Greenberg. Thank you, Madam Chairman, members of the committee.
▶ Play
MY NAME IS DAN GREENBERG WITH THE ADVANCE ARKANSAS INSTITUTE. SEVERAL OF THE CONCERNS I HAVE, OF COURSE, HAVE ALREADY BEEN BROUGHT OUT BY THE COMMITTEE. THIS BILL CHARGES EVERYONE A FEE TO RUN FOR OFFICE AND INDEED REQUIRES EVERYONE WHO'S A CANDIDATE TO PAY FOR A SERVICE WHICH MOST OF US DO NOT NEED. MOST OF US ARE EXTREMELY, INDEED EXCRUCIATINGLY AWARE OF THE PRECISE DETAILS OF ANY CRIMINAL BACKGROUND THAT WE MIGHT HAVE. WHAT THIS DOES, OF COURSE, IS IT PRODUCES A SECRET LIST, A HIDDEN LIST THAT WILL BE SHARED BY A COUPLE OF MEMBERS OF GOVERNMENT, THERE IS OF COURSE A FUNDAMENTAL PUBLIC INTEREST IN PUBLIC DISCLOSURE OF SUCH THINGS AS CRIMINAL RECORDS. AND SO I FEAR THAT WHEN OUR ATTORNEY GENERAL DESCRIBES THIS IN ANY WAY AS BEING A TRANSPARENCY BILL, THAT'S NOT THE BEST DESCRIPTION OF WHAT'S HAPPENING WHEN THIS INFORMATION WILL BE CLOSELY HELD BY A COUPLE OF ELECTED OFFICIALS. IT WAS BROUGHT UP BEFORE WHEN THIS BILL WAS HEARD IN ANOTHER COMMITTEE THAT ONE PERSON IN FAVOR OF IT WAS CONCERNED THAT THERE WAS A CONSTABLE WHO WAS GOING TO, OR A CONSTABLE CANDIDATE WHO HAD BEEN FOUND GUILTY OF SOME CHILD MOLESTATION CHARGES. AND OF COURSE WE DON'T WANT ANY CONSTABLES WHO HAVE BEEN FOUND GUILTY OF CHILD MOLESTATION CHARGES. BUT I WANT TO SAY FOR THE RECORD, THIS BILL DOESN'T SOLVE ALL THE PROBLEMS OF LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIALS LIKE SHERIFFS OR CONSTABLES WHO HAVE CHILD MOLESTATION CHARGES BECAUSE THOSE ARE NOT NECESSARILY INFAMOUS CRIMES. THAT'S NOT NECESSARILY WHAT AN INFAMOUS CRIME is. So in my view this really is kind of a bait and switch. It enables people to say that they're for criminal background checks and in fact this has very little to do with what we customarily think of as a criminal background check. It's a great concern that we're going to produce this enemies list for a couple of different public officials and we're being told that they can take action if they want to. This is precisely the sort of thing that should not be permissive. It ought to be mandatory and there certainly shouldn't be no secret list that the Attorney General and Secretary of State can pass around. I want to close by addressing some concerns that our Attorney General brought up about the difficulty of making this information public for everyone. Of course, there are plenty of states in which people's background, people's criminal background is public for everyone. It doesn't involve anything radical or revolutionary. You simply have to set the state law so that it does it correctly. And there are other bills that have approached this assembly that do that. They do that in plenty of states. And of course, there are some states in which the transparency of criminal background checks is only for public officials. I'm troubled, right? I'm troubled by the notion, as expressed by our Attorney General, that we're not asking anything more than we'd ask of a bank teller. I think that's false. Bank tellers get that fee paid for by the employer. We're asking everybody who files to pay an additional fee of $22, which is burdensome and pointless, in my view. Any citizen, let me close by addressing one thing a committee member brought up. Any citizen ought to be able, and indeed is able, is able to get a background check any time. And if a citizen runs for office and he wants to demonstrate that he doesn't have a criminal background, if indeed he doesn't, he can go down about two blocks away from here and request his own criminal background check. That doesn't require any new law to be passed. That's the law now. So, you know, if you're a candidate and someone says, you know, you had this embezzlement problem ten years ago, you can go down there now. You can get a complete bill of health, assuming that there are no problems in your past. You can wave it around before your constituents. That is a problem that this bill doesn't address and doesn't solve it all I believe that there is another member of this committee who's in this room who actually has a competing proposal I'd urge any discussion of that because I believe that proposal solves the problems we're talking about much better than this one does thanks be happy to take
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:48:26
any questions represent Wagner was your question for mr. Greenberg yes madam chair
▶ Play
thank you so your main concern with this is the additional fee of $22 for someone who's they're going to pay a
▶ Play
filing fee of a couple thousand. Actually, my main concern is that we're calling this a criminal background check. And my main concern is that is the criminal background of a public official really ought to be a matter of public disclosure and public debate. I do think it's sort of silly to require everybody in the universe who runs for office in Arkansas to pay an additional fee of $22 for an almost completely useless service for the most part. because I think most people are well aware of the precise nature of their criminal history. But my main concern is that criminal history is a matter of fundamental public interest, which is appropriately discussed by the public.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:49:17
Nothing further. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you. We also have someone. Thank you, Mr. Greenberg. Mr. Sofer is here to speak for it. thank
▶ Play
Speaker 32 1:49:35
you madam chair I'm Stuart Sofer I'm speaking as Jefferson County election commissioner and it's really funny that the Secretary of State just happened to mention constable in Jefferson County I've been election commissioner in Jefferson County since 2003 I think potential violators currently and the potential violators are at the county and local level as opposed to the state national right now they know they can fly below the radar because nobody is going to do anything until they get on the ballot and there's a good chance their opposition wouldn't want to say anything ugly about them it's the southern tradition forgive me this bill or any bill requiring a background check check is a needed deterrent and that's the word the requisite word deterrent a couple years ago I received a phone call from a distraught mother when I was county chairman and also election commissioner because a felon child molester constable was either a candidate or running for reelection can you all envision a felon child molester running around a rural county with a badge and a gun that was what about to happen and she called me because as senator flowers alluded earlier I take my oath of office very seriously elections and I'm very proactive in Jefferson County and no one else would help her no one else could help her but being the county chairman at the time and the individual happened to file my political party I called him up and made him an offer he didn't want to refuse because my next step was the prosecuting attorney they lie on their political practices pledges because they know no one currently checks so just to close I would just like to suggest that a deterrent bill is necessary the cost is minimal given the cost of filing for office it's a campaign expense it's a tax deduction because you generate income so all of that is mute but we do need a deterrent answer any questions madam sure yes I don't see any
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:50
questions from the committee members but thank you thank you for your testimony there's no one else signed up to speak for or against the bill represent Ferguson would you like
▶ Play
to close for your bill it's full disclosure I am NOT an attorney I'm a dentist and I have approached this bill as a citizen and I think it's about the integrity of elections I do think people file for office occasionally or you know as the Attorney General said every cycle that no they have a criminal conviction and they think no one will find out about it and the unfortunate thing for the voters and the citizens is they get elected they find out about the conviction and then the voters are left with no representation for a period of time until there can be a special election, and then the special election costs additional money, I think it's unfair to voters to not have some stopgap measure on the front end so that candidates know on the front end if they have a felony and that if they do and they choose to run for office after a due notification, that they can be charged with and have a fine. Like I said, I think this is completely about the integrity of the process. I appreciate Mr. Greenberg's wanting freedom of information, but let me repeat that it's my understanding from the state police that the ACIC is currently exempt from freedom of information. So I trust that our attorney general has written the bill where it's constitutional. that all of the legalities are in place but I would appreciate good votes like I said it it's about the integrity of the voting process and for the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:53:52
voters thank you representative Ferguson representative Overby I'll recognize you for that motion the motion is do pass all those in favor aye aye all those opposed nay the ayes have it I see three hands for a roll call
▶ Play
represented Baird represented Baird representative Hobbs representative hopper represent climber represent
▶ Play
Speaker 350 1:54:29
clamor represent of nickels represent of
▶ Play
curve represent of curve represent of Altus represent of Altus represent of Catlett represent a Westerman representative Westerman represent of Hickerson representative Overby represent Walker represent a bell represent of Ritchie represent of Dotson represent of Dotson represent a Miller represent of Hutchinson represent a Wagner represent Wilkins represent
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:55:22
Wilkins that the bill fails thank you madam chair thank you representative Neal you're next and that is bill 1570 house bill one five seven zero there is a fiscal impact statement thank you madam chair bill number one five seven zero house
▶ Play
bill yes ma'am I have some people from DF&A here with me that'll speak to this bill today I can't take credit for the origin of this bill former representative Eric Harris approached me about doing this as a business friendly bill where the state would have a website that business could go to and do all their reporting that they're required to do and I'll let the FNA talk to that talk about that and explain what this will do okay gentlemen identify yourselves
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:56:45
for the record into the microphone thank you thank you my
▶ Play
Speaker 360 1:56:49
name is David Foster I'm the assistant commissioner of revenues with me is Stan King from DFA he is the office of administrative services administrator and Ernest Webb from Department of Workforce Services basically what this bill does is to create a single web page that an employer can go to and use that web page to launch to a variety of state web services that enable them to file reports manage accounts pay taxes get information on tax filing dates etc and it might eliminate say an employer now you might have to go to four or five different sites to achieve the same end they can go to one site launch from that site and then create or work on any particular tax type that that they need to it simplifies reporting and reporting requirements for the taxpayers or their designated representative and if I'm
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:57:58
reading the fiscal impact there it shows no revenue impact no there should be
▶ Play
Speaker 360 1:58:04
it's there'll be no cost to that there should not it will not necessarily generate any additional revenue but it will certainly simplify the process that the employers have to go through to report the taxes that are currently due and to pay those taxes and file the reports
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:58:21
that's that correct that's written under the taxpayer impact any questions from committee members seeing none what is the will of the committee whoops excuse me I am I'm sorry I have someone in the audience to speak only one no one to speak against it I have someone to speak for it if you would come to the end of the table identify yourself thank you madam
▶ Play
chairman briefly my name is Sylvester Smith State Director of the National Federation of Independent Business and I just want to let you all know that your small business community does support this piece of legislation and it would be helpful thank you thank you mr. Smith
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:59:02
representative Catlett motion do pass the motion is do pass all those in favor all those opposed congratulations your bill passes thank you madam chair senator King for bill 961 Senate bill 961 committee members my intent is to go up through noon and then dismiss for lunch at this time I have no plans to come back unless you tell me otherwise lives center king you're recognized thank you madam chair thank you committee
▶ Play
senate bill 961 is pretty clear it would just make it a felony an unclassified felony for somebody to that destroys a ballot or election materials related before the prescribed time and if you remember a few years ago we had the case of when the crumley case center crumley case and yet those type of materials destroyed and what happens is is the election materials when they're destroyed it's just like destroying evidence so that's why a lot of times that we've talked about voter fraud is very hard to catch this would just make it a punishable very punishable harsher crime to be if you destroy those ballot materials and in the Hudson Hallam case where you had you know those individuals actually destroying ballots it would make it where if they're convicted they serve a minimum one year in jail and I think that's very important to think in help stopping voter fraud that we actually punish the people that are
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:01:07
commit and voter fraud is that a pause or completion completion questions from
▶ Play
committee members I see no questions Representative Nichols Senator King, I don't want to see this get out and get on the floor and have some problems there, but I think you need to have an impact statement from the Department of Corrections on this because you're talking about an unclassified felony and a term I can tell you that it would be
▶ Play
very minimal but you know this bill's been out this is the same thing I mean this bill's been out there for quite a while but certainly willing to if it needs it it needs it so well I think
▶ Play
anything that impacts local government, anything that impacts Department of Correction. Now, maybe the Department of Correction wants to give you whether or not it covers them. I just don't want to see it get on the floor that somebody raise an issue. Has that ever happened, people on the floor raising an issue about one of my bills? That's a new
▶ Play
occurrence for me. I mean, it's strange. Yeah. But thanks for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:02:47
warning me that that might happen I see several members from the Department of Community Corrections here
▶ Play
pardon me the Department of Corrections it's page 2 lines 14 through 18 wise counsel back
▶ Play
here former senator Glover said well you know how do you know who's going to do that and you know the occurrences of that happening are extremely small because we you know mr. Hallam and and we didn't get connect convictions that I know of in the senator crumbly case unfortunately in this and part of the reason we probably didn't get convictions and I know senator Glover was involved in hearing that that they basically were destroying a lot of the evidence before it got to it and I think he he concurs with that Representative Hickerson,
▶ Play
you have a question? Yes, Madam Chairman, and this question is actually from Representative Walker. He's having difficulty with his voice today. In the Hudson-Hallam case, there was no state prosecution. What would the cost of that have been?
▶ Play
Mr. Walker, there is state prosecution. He's up on state charges. There was an independent prosecutor that was appointed in that. There was federal charges, and he pleaded in that. He has not pled in the state prosecution, but, no, there is state prosecution. going on he just has not played in that matter
▶ Play
yet okay that's the same question and what's the cost of the cost of that prosecution well the
▶ Play
cost would be if no one's convicted of voter fraud you know we these type things are not everyday occurrences with every election everywhere we know but we do know that has occurred and and could possibly will occur but you know we don't know hopefully no one commits voter fraud and this doesn't happen again and it's a zero cost but if it does happen you know I feel like they need to be prosecuted in service substantial punishment to doing so because if you start undermining the integrity of the elections and how it's then you're undermining of the confidence in the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:04:51
in the government to representative Wagner you
▶ Play
had a question thanks madam chair kind of going off of representing Nichols you have the mandatory one year in jail but but the The fine can fluctuate from $0 to $10,000. Why not a minimum fine also? Well, there is a minimum fine if
▶ Play
you want to look at the. There is a minimum fine, but that just gives flexibility to the judge on the fine portion of it, what he wants to do. Why not flexibility with the jail time? Well, there is flexibility with the jail time. There's just a minimum one year in jail. I mean he has flexibility what one to three years but so he has flexibility in that it just makes a mandatory punishable sentence that he has
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:05:48
to spend that time nothing further any other
▶ Play
questions from committee members representative Nichols I think Senator King if the Department of Corrections will provide a impact statement before we vote on the floor I think that would take care of any potential problems you might have I believe so under our rules okay well
▶ Play
why don't why don't we just get that why don't we just work on getting that right now and try and get as soon as possible we're down here
▶ Play
at you know well I'm not going to raise an objection to it but I think you just need to have it where it's available on the what's on the floor okay representative
▶ Play
Speaker 387 2:06:23
bill motion at the proper time manager representative
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:06:36
Hickerson representative bill no one signed up to speak for or against it Senator King you're closed for your bill I'm close representative bill what's your motion motion is do pass all those in favor all opposed bill passes senator King your next one you wanted to present what is the number please
▶ Play
can we go ahead and do 959 we didn't have much discussion on
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:07:08
in the Senate I don't know if that's and
▶ Play
it's just basic that's not necessarily an indicator Senate bill 959 you're recognized thank you madam chair thank you many Senate bill 951 we just came out of reapportionment and I never felt like the explanation for the dis the drawing of the districts was good enough and basically what this law would our bill would provide was a more detailed explanation other than, you know, basically the lines need to go somewhere or the geographic descriptions of the lines. I mean, we had, you know, I felt like a poor job done in the reapportionment that didn't keep cities and counties and communities together. For example, the town of Alpena, with 400 people, has three state senators. You know, Green Forest, where I know Representative Lee knows where that's at, is drawn in with Russellville, which is in her district. so we know gerrymandering occurs no matter what party's in control they they do those kind of things but you know what you need a better explanation other than the lines need to go somewhere and that's what this bill would do
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:08:24
or the intent of this bill yeah I'm reading the bill so you're saying this bill basically requires a written document explaining the reasons that's correct you know
▶ Play
it whether it's a secretary of state that has his lines that he presents or the governor attorney general whoever that is they have to explain you know for the example I gave the town Alpena they would need to explain why they split a city of 400 people between three state senators to me there's no explanation why you would do that but you know we need to know why you would do that
▶ Play
Speaker 155 2:09:04
and more explanation okay representative Clemmer
▶ Play
thank you madam chair senator King does every line have to be explained or just the ones that split counties and cities the intent is every district
▶ Play
I mean every house district and that's not hard to do as long as the reapportionment process takes and you know if you're gonna if you're gonna draw a district say Benton and Bryant and and explain it you know those people deserve an explanation about why you you need other than just a geographic reason or geographic explanation to sign it and my thing is if you're going to do something you need to be able to explain it other than the fallback position that we saw this last time of the lines need to go that you know the lines have to be drawn somewhere I very much
▶ Play
appreciate your intent I'm just trying to figure out what you know so but would it be acceptable I mean we're not going to measure the acceptability of it but we're going to have a reason
▶ Play
they can still go do what they're going to do and draw it however they're going to draw it they would just need to be
▶ Play
able to explain it so it could be that this district is drawn the way it is because of population movement in other districts
▶ Play
correct I mean that would correct and there are districts out there that were drawn or they're legitimate I feel like in my opinion legitimate reasons that were drawn the way they were there are other districts that in my opinion as stated before about the other examples or other reps being drawn in with other reps or that kind of thing that to me need more explanation and the people deserve it thank you representative Ritchie thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 39 2:10:39
madam chair sir I appreciate the spirit of it just had a curiosity so if in their written document they just say because the line needed to go somewhere what I mean what's the remedy the intent of this bill is
▶ Play
not to have that the intent of this bill is to say if there's a Republican governor and a Republican Attorney General which you know could possibly happen this next time and a district some district like you you make a mad or do something they need to have a better explanation other than the lines need to go somewhere and a geographic description of what those lines are if they kind of refuse to
▶ Play
Speaker 39 2:11:15
give you a specific reason I mean is there a remedy well I think that's where the press
▶ Play
and us is let's let her say you didn't give a better get do a good enough explanation and the intent of this law as it was passed it was for you to
▶ Play
do so thank you ref Sam Nichols yes like you madam chair now I'm sure that was that district was designed so you would lose I think that was the intent but and I'll publicly state that
▶ Play
and you know if I find out different I'll retract it but I think I'll stick
▶ Play
with that statement but my concern is we have three constitutional officers that make up the Board of Apportionment and they have their various thought processes that they go through on how they want to make a decision and that is very similar to the thought process that we go through it as we cast our one vote and I don't know if if if we can require or should require an elected official to explain in some document why they voted the way they voted and and I see that's what this is doing so I think it's going a little bit I don't know about the constitutionality of it the Board of Apportionment is a part of our state constitution I believe and I don't think you can dictate to them an explanation of what they're what they're doing and so So anyway, that's my concern, because I don't, you know, I think I can tell some people, I just didn't like the bill, and that's why I voted against it, or I liked it, I voted for it. That's just the way, and I think you're just getting into that area of an elected official and whatever their thought process is, and the public, you know, like your people didn't like Alpena having three Senate districts but some folks there may like it now they got three folks they can go to you know so anyway I guess would you agree that is that is a problem asking an elected official to explain why they voted a particular way in statute no I wouldn't agree I would say that
▶ Play
you know if you're if you do something and the reason is when you you can have the intent to try and gerrymandering beat somebody and let me tell you something that's that's not a partisan issue that happens on both sides it can happen ten years from now but you know what the thing about it is when you do that for ten years you could have a personal disagreement or see if somebody want to be beat but you know what if they split the town of Sherwood up several different ways or do something it goes beyond politics it goes on being honest and upfront with people about your intent and what you want to do and try to make it into law that you describe that, because the reality is, you know, a governor may be out, but those people are stuck with that kind of representation for 10 years. And the great part of our system is it's not permanent. So I'm just saying we respectfully disagree.
▶ Play
And since you brought up my district, I'd just like to say that it was Republican before Barack Obama was a state senator. so and it I don't think it was necessary drawn to help me out the majority I just had to work hard to get elected so but anyway I do have a problem with if you are directing a state elected official to explain their actions by statute there
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:14:56
are no other questions from committee members and no one I'm sorry I didn't see your hand did you raise your hand I am sorry I did not write that down
▶ Play
represent Hutchison that's okay hey thank you manager you know over the year over the years of our Constitution how many times is this but every 10 years it happens. That's true. You know, at first when I decided to run, you know, I looked at it as like, boy, it's splitting our counties up, you know, I mean, authority of our counties, you know. Then it put me in four counties, and, boy, I got to meet a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:15:47
lot of people, you know. I did, and I like that. Everybody knows I like to meet people. We're going to land this
▶ Play
plane, aren't we? You got a question in there.
▶ Play
Speaker 298 2:16:02
Okay. I agree not to agree no I appreciate it
▶ Play
did I'm through okay I didn't know if
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:16:12
you had a question okay seeing with mess with me seeing no further question Hang on. Representative Hickerson, are you assisting Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 423 2:16:28
Walker? It totally is okay. I totally understand. This question
▶ Play
is from Representative Walker. It says, would you agree that drawing lines is a political act where someone has advantage, usually to the victor?
▶ Play
Speaker 61 2:16:47
Usually to the victor goes the spoils. usually to the victor goes the spoils
▶ Play
would you agree i would agree with that and i'm not saying that this will in any way change or manipulate or do anything it would just say that you know what community there's there's there's something above the political part where you have cities and counties that have a 10-year consequence or benefit or whatever that you know what you need to tell people straight up why you drew the lines the way you did and you know what, sometimes when you can't explain something to people, you don't wind up doing it. And if that can better serve, it doesn't stop them from doing what they want to do, it just would better serve them into trying districting and be fair to people, no matter what the party is in control. Just because you have the
▶ Play
power to do something doesn't mean it's right. Representative Altus. I'm sorry, Madam Chair. Thank you. You don't have to apologize. Okay, isn't there just like the coordinators, the Board of Apportionment, whatever, aren't they instructed on like four or five criteria that they're instructed to work on and look at to balance? And isn't it fairly easy to defend just about any action in that scenario?
▶ Play
The only, you know, there are some, you're right, and they have the power to do so. This would just be giving a town or a city, while they were drawing up the way they were, a better explanation than the lines need to go somewhere. Representative Pickerson.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:18:31
Now's the proper time. Do pass. Motion do pass. The motion is do pass. All those in favor, aye. Aye. All those opposed, nay. Nay. Ayes have it. Is that it, Senator King? I've got one more, if I can keep on a roll. You might be pushing your luck. I know it. All right, what's the number? 719. 719. Senate Bill 719.
▶ Play
You recognize? Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. Senate Bill 719 passed the Senate with a lot of several good questions and debate about the intent of the bill, and it passed with bipartisan support. And this basically would say it creates a voter integrity unit, and this is something I've worked with the Secretary of State, and Mr. Boyd is here, to explain it a little bit more in detail. And Madam Chair, if it's with your permission, when needed, he could come up here and help explain this if that's okay that's acceptable
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:19:41
just come up to the table and identify yourself for the
▶ Play
record thank you but this bill would basically create a voter integrity unit within the Secretary of State you know Senator Stubblefield not both former former reps we enjoy a lot of things together ones watching old Western movies and if you looked at the newest version of true grit which we both watched the old one together and we We like the new one, but there is a, right at the start of the new True Grit, there is a Bible verse in there that says Proverbs 28.1, and it says, The wicked fleeth when none pursueth. And, you know, that's what's happened a lot in our voter fraud and why we're at, in what we do. We haven't actively pursued voter fraud. As Hudson Hallam says, when it is illegal activities, that's just the way we've done it over here. And so I always, like I said, go back to that Bible verse about the wicked fleeth when none pursueth. And this is about pursuing voter fraud. And this is about when people make complaints, there is a certain level they look into it, much like if you file a police report, something's wrong on your property, something's not right, you file a police report. This is going to make sure that someone actively goes and looks into this into a certain level. And there's the way it's set up. It's much like in the purpose and intent, it's much like the Ethics Commission. If there's a complaint filed, somebody looks into it. It's not sent to a partisan appointee board and, you know, they decide or whoever, as Representative Walker pointed out, whatever party controls that board can not pursue to look, choose to not look into it or choose whatever action they want to. This would just say that they would look into it. And let me understand. Let me help explain. When I first came in, there were 75 Democrats and 25 Republicans. And one of the Democrats, I said, well, someday maybe the Republicans will be in charge. And they told me, they said, well, that will never happen. But, you know, today we know that that actually may happen. And for you Democrats, I want you to understand that this is a bipartisan approach in that if Republicans control Election Commission and they're trying to cheat you out of election or there's irregularities that can't be explained or there's something wrong that you can have somebody actually come look into it. You know, in my case in Carroll County in 2006 when we had a lot of things going on, it was basically left up to me, and you have to hire an attorney out of your own pocket. Well, not every candidate can hire an attorney to look into things out of their own pocket. I mean, that's tough to do. so this this bill would basically go along the same premise as the Ethics Commission that if a complaints made there's a certain at least a certain level that's looked into if they go into finding more or something like that then then the amount they energy and and effort that's put in to look into it would would would continue to grow if it's a frivolous complaint it could be dismissed but there is at least something that's going to go look into if you got any mr. Boyd thank
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:22:48
you senator King mr. Boyd do you have anything to add
▶ Play
Speaker 431 2:22:54
thank you madam chairman I'm Kelly Boyd director of governmental affairs for Secretary of State Mark Martin this is a function the State Board of Election Commissioners would receive an election complaint of any type the language in this bill says that the voter integrity unit shall investigate which means if a complaint comes in they investigate it's a four-person unit the Secretary of State appoints them and it's laid out in the bill that the director of department elections a commissioned law officer on the Capitol Police staff our general counsel to serve for legal advice and then we have several election coordinators and it would be the election coordinator that typically is responsible for the political subdivision where the complaint arises they go out and investigate it and then they're done they return or they create a report turn it into the secretary who is the chairman of the State Board of Election Commissioners he presents it back to them they decide what they're going to we're not impacting anything that the State Board of Election Commissioners does now there is no fiscal impact from the standpoint that this bill requires us to use our existing staff we're not hiring people we're not asking for more people it actually I guess could be perceived as providing a savings because we're getting more work out of the same people any questions on that thank
▶ Play
Speaker 34 2:24:19
you representative Ritchie thank you madam chair I just wanted to point
▶ Play
Speaker 39 2:24:25
out the the verse you quoted Proverbs 28 verse 1 the wicked flee when no one pursues but the righteous are as bold as a line it actually means that the wicked run even when no one is pursuing them not that you have to set up something to pursue them I just want to let you know what that verse actually said that has nothing to do with
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:24:47
the bill wouldn't you agree this is the most unusual state agencies meeting we have had to start out with knowing senator King and center stuff if you'll go to movies together yes point of
▶ Play
order yes order is for the bill presenters to be forewarned that there's a minister on our body there you go there you go we
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:25:06
have a minister on staff I assume that was you that that was it that was your comment okay here we go representative Hickerson thank you madam
▶ Play
chair once again this this is on behalf of representative Walker I know you all were looking forward to a little silence from him today, but
▶ Play
Speaker 435 2:25:25
he's figured out a way. Can you
▶ Play
move away from him and sit somewhere else? I've got to leave in a few minutes. Good. Senator King, the question from Representative Walker is, why make the Secretary of State's office an investigative unit? Its duties are mostly ministerial. It is in the executive branch, and that's number one, and doesn't this put it into both the judicial and legislative branches? on the
▶ Play
first question that's a very good question and the reason is because the state board election commissioners are appointed by partisan appointees I mean they have do some have on elected officials but yet the determination of much of they do comes from partisan as you mentioned earlier the victors go to spoils and so if you have one party in control then the minority party could have trouble as I've mentioned and other people admit that you know it's been issued and and they don't go look into it or don't want to go look into it or whatever reason they want to give this would just say that somebody's going to look into it you have an elected official that's actually responsible for the people he's not as we had some Senate testimony that was inaccurate that said he's a partisan appointee well Secretary Martin is not a partisan appointee he's elected by the people just as his predecessor was was elected by the people so on that part as far as the legislative and judicial part I don't see it is that way I mean you could say that the ABC board has similar powers the Ethics Commission has similar powers so I mean in this is the intent is much like them
▶ Play
and your your fact finding is there's a follow-up here representative
▶ Play
Speaker 431 2:27:17
Walker we will be using existing employees on the staff the cost that would be associated with it obviously it's going to be using their time and their energies and a vehicle if we go out and do the investigation beyond that they won't be costs that extend beyond the normal scope of our
▶ Play
office though he's thought one more follow-up are they already not fully working already we're gonna fully work them harder
▶ Play
representative Hutchison Thank You madam chair I'm what he is there any way to and the integrity of this is there any way to what my complaint is is what about the accusations that are made during the election you can't do nothing about it that's what we can we work on that too you know in other words you know you're accused of something but yet you can't prove your innocence until after the election can we not implement something into this bill
▶ Play
Speaker 431 2:28:33
with that representative Hutchison this specifically goes to complaints of election law violation or election irregularities it could be during the election it can be after the election when it comes to life that's the scope of this bill it has nothing to do with someone making a scurrilous claim against you that you have to defend yourself for we can't that's the First
▶ Play
Speaker 446 2:28:57
Amendment issue for us thank you for
▶ Play
clarifying that representative Nichols yes sir King and I mentioned this to you earlier my problem is a giving this enforcement authority judicory authority kind of to the Secretary of State who's it's gonna be an elected official that I don't they just get it gives me concern and and do you have a thought about that about given the Secretary of State this kind of police organization to to operate in the election arena it's
▶ Play
not a fact-finding I mean it's not into this it's a fact-finding that's what an investigation
▶ Play
Speaker 431 2:29:55
is representative Nichols once this group does solely the fact finding part it's been referred back to the State Board of Election Commissioners who have that responsibility now they will take that information they may elect to do nothing with it but that is their responsibility we just will be serving in this unit to provide them a more in-depth investigation of every complaint
▶ Play
that's referred to them do you have subpoena power yes
▶ Play
Speaker 431 2:30:22
sir this law specifically provides subpoena power
▶ Play
to that entity okay now someone mentioned or maybe senator King mentioned that right now that the Commission is this partisan and there was also mentioned that we have the Ethics Commission and And that is, I think under your definition, would also be partisan, correct, because the members of those commissions receive their appointment either from the governor, the Speaker of the House, President Pro Tem, I think even the lieutenant governor has an appointment on the Ethics Commission. And that's to make sure that the various viewpoints in the political arena are covered. And I don't see that here. I think in the Election Commission now, they do have appointments coming from various elected officials. And, like, Republicans now have the Speaker of the House, so there will be the appointment from the speaker the president pro tem the Senate will be making an appointment so in those areas you get the political cover that that you want to make sure that somebody is not running roughshod based upon political ideology or political party and I'm afraid that if you put all of this in the Secretary of State's office then we lose that protection because we're given police powers subpoena power and investigatory powers to the Secretary of State and I'm surprised represent Rishi didn't say something about ministerial duties while I go but this that is something that that bothers me about your bill given the the Secretary of State this this police prosecutorial type of organization and you assume you don't agree well I mean first off
▶ Play
we do that with the Ethics Commission it is similar the other part is that that I want people to understand is here you're right the State Board election commissioners is appointed by various elected officials or partisan Democrat Republican the difference in the intent of this bill is to say if there's a complaint it's looked into it's a certain level and then there's a determination made and then it's reported it's not the thing of what we've had in the past where say in Carroll County when you had huge amounts of problems with elections you had voter manipulation you had voter suppression go on up there that was and you have complaints by people and and nothing would be done this would say that if those things are going on there's a certain level somebody looks into a complaint rather than the process now make a complaint and it could be rejected or not it's basically saying that if you go out to your property and there's something wrong and there's something going on and you make a police complaint to the police they come and investigate and look into and then he makes a report and then sends it up it basically says like I said if there's something going on or there's something and and I can assure you that most of the elections are run well here but where you have these situations where continuous fraud goes on as I'll quote Hudson-Allen this is just the way we've done it for years and you have these people make complaints there needs to be people that look into it to
▶ Play
a certain level represent did you have a follow-up well a lot of this could be handled just through the political process you said and I guess your county Carroll County you went up against those folks and you got elected correct
▶ Play
but it was a harder road let me tell you you want to talk about as representing Nicholson You would agree from your background, and I know your background very well, about fighting for the little guy. When you have that going on in election, let's say Republicans are in control and the same thing happens, and you go through an election mess like what I did. It makes it harder for you because you go through a campaign, the pressure of a campaign, you're busy, and you get into election night and you get complicated, and you're on the election commissioner's turf, basically. They have an extreme amount of power to determine and do what they want to do. And they really have had nobody watching them for years. And that's why we've got to this point. But this bill would say, instead of you having to hire an attorney, which a lot of candidates don't have the money to do, I was able to come up with the money out of my own pocket to hire attorneys and watch the whole process. This would just say that, hey, somebody's going to come into it, look into it, as Mr. Boyd is continuing to point out, and have some fact finding. and I think people deserve that whether you're in the minority party or the majority representative Altus
▶ Play
Speaker 453 2:35:21
I'd like to move immediate consideration we have someone to
▶ Play
Speaker 96 2:35:27
speak with um okay it and before
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:35:29
I recognize that we do have one member in the public who wants to speak against this can I
▶ Play
Speaker 453 2:35:45
move to limit debate three minutes
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:35:52
yes sir you can the motion is to limit debate for three minutes all those in favor I I was opposed all right we're limiting debate for three minutes I'm gonna recognize miss Susan in men to come up to the table and speak against the bill miss Inman recognized that there's three minutes total time
▶ Play
Speaker 456 2:36:26
thank you madam chair representatives I'm Susan Inman I am a Pulaski County Election Commissioner I hold a seat on the State Board of Election Commissioners and I'm president of the Arkansas County Election Commission's Association I will speak very briefly this bill is part of a larger package of bills that will effectively make a complete overhaul of our elections administration the state I'm only going to speak to this one because it's the one that gives the investigative authority to the Secretary of State's office that option is currently in place for the State Board of Election Commissioners they have the authority to do the same investigation this is if this bill just goes by itself it would create a redundant investigatory process I would encourage you to consider placing consideration of investigations under a partisan election official when currently that option is available through a nonpartisan board. I'll certainly answer any questions. Seeing no questions, thank you. Thank you for your testimony.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:37:40
Senator King, would you like to close for your bill? You have a minute, 44 seconds. I would like to close. It's not redundant. It's just forcing people to
▶ Play
go look into it. You're not sending it to a partisan board that can shut it off. If you're getting cheated out there in the election or there's something going on, it doesn't go to a partisan board and can be rejected and decided on. There's a certain level to be complained. And, folks, let me tell you, we didn't get the Hudson Hallam, the Crumley, and the bad publicity for Arkansas elections by accident, okay? It happened because of reasons, and we need to be correcting those reasons. Folks, we need to change. We need to actively pursue voter fraud and those complaints and look at prosecuting people and putting people in jail. If they're going to undermine the integrity of the elections, folks, people in Arkansas won't have confidence in their government if we can't have confidence in our elections. And, folks, what's been proven in the media and everything that's went on the last few years out of Arkansas needs to be stopped, and the status quo
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:38:47
needs to be changed. I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you very much, Senator King. you stopped with 46 seconds to go Representative Altus Representative Altus moves do pass all those in favor aye all those opposed the ayes have it thank you Representative Meeks for House Resolution 1009 folks let's go back up to the top of the calendar concur in Senate amendment representative Wright cannot be here I opened up the amendment it added the word immediately proceeding mayoral instead of just proceeding and that is the Senate amendment and I would entertain a motion for us to concur in that Senate amendment so move representative Catlett thank you the motion is to concur in Senate amendment for House bill 2229 all those in favor aye all those opposed thank you representative Meeks you're recognized thank you madam chair and in the
▶ Play
words of Monty Python now for something completely different has nothing to do with elections members I'm coming back to you a second time to take a look at house resolution 1009 after my first attempt some of the members had some concerns. I've tried to address them, so I'm not going to go back into them. I'm just going to make one or two brief statements, and then I will bow to the wisdom of the committee on this. After that meeting, I had the state historian go back through the records, and he found this for me. This is a photocopy of a resolution that this body passed in 1827. In 1827, Arkansas was a western state and they found themselves in a similar circumstance where the federal government controlled a vast majority of our territory and they passed a resolution that's a point of order yes sir Arkansas was not a state in 1827 the territory of Arkansas in 1827
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:41:01
that was a point of order you could You've just asked him that. Okay, sorry. Go ahead,
▶ Play
Speaker 236 2:41:07
Representative Beaks. I will concede that point. It
▶ Play
does say Territory of Arkansas on the journal photocopy here, so I will concede that point. But the Territory of Arkansas at that time passed a resolution, the body or the precursor to this body, said that to advance then the interest of general government as well as those of our own territory, your memorialists would respectfully suggest that the laws of the United States regulating the primary disposal of the public lands should be so altered as to permit the same to be disposed of in a manner proposed in the bill introduced in the Senate of the United States by the Honorable Thomas Bennett, a Senator in Congress from the state of Missouri. So to kind of get to the point here, at one point when we were a western territory or we were in need of having our lands transferred to us, we had other states that helped us in this matter and all I'm asking for is for Arkansas to do the right thing and to help our Western states. Utah, Idaho, Nevada, Wyoming, Arizona, Colorado and New Mexico have all passed regulations or set up committees in this manner. South Carolina is an eastern state that has also passed a resolution in support of this movement and so all I'm asking for this committee is that Arkansas when we were in time of need we had the help of other states and what I'm asking is for Arkansas now when other states need our help in this matter that we reciprocate and with
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:42:34
that madam chair I'll take any questions Thank You representative Meeks any questions from committee members No one is here to speak for or against the resolution. What is the will
▶ Play
Speaker 39 2:42:55
of the commit representative Walker? thank you manager represent Walker would like to know what exactly you're trying to accomplish with
▶ Play
this resolution trying to support our Western states and getting the federal government to give them the land that's rightfully theirs imagine Arkansas if 60 or 70 percent of our land belong to the federal government and we had no say-so in it this is a situation those states find themselves in isn't it
▶ Play
Speaker 39 2:43:27
a judicial determination as to whether or not it is there's no that would
▶ Play
be an act of Congress legislative and this is just to encourage Congress
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:43:37
to to make that step I would like it noted we're a very helpful committee to each other, aren't we? We don't need any poll workers to come in here and help our people. We help each other, don't we? Alright, any other questions from committee members? Okay, seeing none, what is the will of the committee? Representative Hobbs moves do pass. All those in favor, aye. All those opposed? The no's have it. all right thank you committee Thank You representative Meeks representative Nichols you're recognized for do you want to do Senate bill 992 first okay we're going to do House bill 1205 first 1205 House bill
▶ Play
yes this is the the bill that I brought up the other day state employee careers procedure until the early 1980s the previous procedure for state employees was set by statute and they have some problems with it they're not constitutional and then as you notice we've gone through a lot of code revision stuff and that ended up being in code revision and they just wiped it all out
▶ Play
Speaker 465 2:45:23
we're having a hard time hearing you okay is this much better
▶ Play
thank you sir Mike okay as I mentioned the state of boy procedure used to be statutory but it was taken off the books in the early 80s and this is an attempt to to put it back in the legislature's control if you want to call it that by having a procedure that is based upon Arkansas law now the currently if an employee is fired and that decision is upheld through the grievance procedure the C GAP procedure then that ends the the process now if okay Terry here can correct me on this but I think the way it works now if the employee if C GAP says they should not have lost their job then the agency can appeal that to DFNA but there is not a similar appeal for the employee what this bill does it puts in a non-binding procedure where a trained mediator will hear the case develop the facts and if the parties cannot reach an agreement which is what mediation is about, this expands the mediator's duty to provide a recommended resolution of the case. And so this will only apply to adverse actions of a serious nature. You're not going to get your nickel and dime grievances going to this, but those where an employee has been demoted, disciplined for more than 14 days, terminated, And it brings what I think would be some fairness to the table, and it will protect the employees and also give them a little bit, what I would say, a fairer system to have their grievances resolved. Now, Representative Bell had some issues the other day with the impact statements that were in there, and I think that has been addressed director George Hopkins from teachers is here if anybody else would like to hear what he has to say about his problems have been resolved with with the amendments but I'd be happy to take any questions and in this exempts if
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:48:07
I see this correctly this exempts any school district yes institution of higher education HTD and the Game and Fish correct okay all of those are excluded from this and I have a question currently do you have mediators in the personnel
▶ Play
Speaker 471 2:48:27
department yes Kay Terry Department of Finance Administration currently we don't have any meters in OPM but various agencies are utilizing mediators today Department of correction has some DHS has some mediators we have a couple trained in our office I think what representative Nichols is trying to do here is get more trained mediators out there to resolve a lot of these issues and we will ensure that there will be more training provided in this area
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:48:55
I see a future for me any questions from committee members represent Valtas thank you
▶ Play
madam chair I'm just not understanding the whole purpose of the bill that first of all is it is it totally engrossed all these amendments have been engrossed is that right
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:49:30
it appears everything's engrossed at this point I'm just judging yes it appears everything
▶ Play
is engrossed I thought everything has been engrossed but the mysterious looking at the the current one but what she has here I know we're writing a short calendar and you know I will get with her and if this passes see it says amendment to
▶ Play
does away with all sections that deal with arbitration for state employee grievances instead this bill provides a statutory procedure state employees to file a grievance so that seems like it's pretty major changes here does away with all arbitration and
▶ Play
there's not arbitration grievances there there is not arbitration of employee disputes now the agency DFNA was concerned about an arbitrator having final and binding authority and there's some constitutional issues involved in that whether we can delegate that type function to to an arbitrator so that's why we have a mediator instead to make a recommended resolution of the problem so this
▶ Play
is changing the whole procedure
▶ Play
Speaker 475 2:51:05
for grievances and arbitration it is adding to it I would say
▶ Play
is it is adding a step that right now it is just the executive order that comes from the governor dictates how grievances are to be heard this adds a step of a mediator for certain cases so so the governor's for this bill never has no problems with the bill now this is a major change to what I had originally proposed that was a very tight type of grievance procedure with final and binding arbitration this does not do that because if I had my way I would have that but as you know you have to compromise that
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:52:04
is now on record that
▶ Play
you compromised so you have a future as
▶ Play
a mediator so can you just briefly or I'm sure you can't briefly explain what what the difference is but kind of run through that a little bit I'm I'm kind of familiar with how unions work and so could you kind of briefly explain the difference between the way it used to be in the and
▶ Play
then the way you're changing it to okay in most gigan contracts with private sector employers there is a agreement procedure in the last step of that procedure a lot of times is is arbitration okay and so that's where we go and and and the parties have agreed the parties have agreed for that arbitrator to make a a final decision and they both agree to agree to it and not appeal it and so that's a very fair system now it's questionable whether we can do that in state government because can we delegate authority to an arbitrator I recognize that I think there are arguments on both sides of it but in order to get the legislature back involved in the Greer's procedure for state employees this is what I've come up with and it's it's not as strong as a bill that representative Lee was a co-sponsor on two years ago but okay I've got a I've
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:53:45
got something I've got to add real quickly there was one more amendment okay and it's out there now on your tablets okay we need to I'm assuming represent Nichols you're gonna move
▶ Play
to adopt all those in favor I
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:54:10
all is opposed okay the amendments adopted thank you for bringing that to our attention represent Valtas your tablets not updating is anyone else having problem pulling up the amendment can you read the is the amendment just that
▶ Play
okay just updated okay good the amendment says the office of OPM of division management services of the Department of Finance administration shall establish a procedure for the filing, hearing, adjudication, and appeal of grievances by state agencies. So it's the rulemaking authority that, and I'm sorry, I thought we had already taken care of that. So did we. Not a problem. We've got it
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:55:13
taken care of now. All right, committee members, any questions? It's not often Ms. Terry's here in the committee. I miss you being on personnel. I know. You see each other daily. Representative Clemmer. forgive me
▶ Play
if thank you madam chair forgive me if you said this and I was looking at something else and I missed it what is the problem that you're trying
▶ Play
to correct representing Nichols well what really got me interested in this is that the grievous procedure that that state currently has the grievous committee made a decision and that was favorable to the employee and the director of that particular agency agent said I'm not going to accept the grievance committee's recommendation so that got me thinking about the whole whole thing and there just needs to be a fairer system and that's and I'm not sure that yeah I think federal law even may even require the state so that they receive certain federal funds to have a grievous procedure so it's just bring a little fairness it could miss
▶ Play
could would you allow miss Terry to comment also on this from your perspective yes ma'am
▶ Play
Speaker 471 2:56:47
the major thing this this does This, from my perspective, really encourages mediation. We have a fact-finding process, as Representative Nichols alluded to. We've got that process set up. It can take a lot of time. It can take on part of the employee and on the part of the agencies. This bill encourages every agency to utilize mediation and make sure that we have more trained mediators out there so we might have better determinations. It also, I think, allows for more representation by counsel when mediation is to take place.
▶ Play
As to the problem, though, excuse me, just for follow-up, but as to the problem, what have you seen? Well, I thought
▶ Play
Speaker 471 2:57:30
the process worked okay. I understand Representative Nichols' concern that he would like to have more mediation and like to have – I do think his point that an employee was not allowed to appeal the final decision to the chief fiscal officer because the way the process works now, the grievance board makes a determination. If the agency, if they rule in favor of the agency, it's pretty much done with. If they rule in favor of the employee filing the grievance, then that agency can appeal that final determination to Richard Weiss, the chief fiscal officer of the state. And I think this will allow both parties to make that appeal. so that would be the primary problem that we had in the past okay thank you any other questions from committee members
▶ Play
represent of office thank you madam chair I'm still not understanding it but but I I think I understand that that okay I come from the business sector and I I had I used to own several businesses and I had an employee handbook and in And my employee signed that handbook when they went to work for me. When they broke a rule in the handbook, I fired their rear right then. And then that was the end of the story. No mediation, no grievances, none of this other stuff, okay? And that was the end of the story. And so what you're saying is if I'm a department head or an agency head and somebody breaks one of the rules and I fire them, then they can file appeals, go through grievance procedures, and not arbitration anymore, though, right? No arbitration, but
▶ Play
only grievance procedures. Only grievance procedures. And then mediation. Mediation by definition means the parties have to agree to the settlement. Okay, and how long can we drag this out, and how much money are we talking about? I don't think there's any additional time really involved because we already have this procedure. It's just that I think we're bolstering it some with going to the mediation route, and Denny, I'm representative of offices, I know you always made the right decision, but sometimes supervisors make the wrong decision and this gives a neutral look at those facts okay and that's all this bill asked for is to have a neutral take a look at the facts and hopefully that neutral can work the parties where they will reach an agreement and if not then the mediator can tell the FNA well this is what I would have said that's all it does
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:00:24
okay thank you thank you see no further questions from committee members and no one from the public to speak for or against it I'm assuming you're
▶ Play
moving do pass yes ma'am move do
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:00:40
pass good motion from represent Nichols is do pass all those in favor as amended all those in favor aye all those opposed congratulations represent Nichols would you like to adopt the amendment for the Senate bill and then wait and run it another day till Senator Burnett gets
▶ Play
here yes let's do that
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:01:01
Senate bill 992 and has it
▶ Play
been loaded this is a senator Burnett spill senator Burnett's amendment and I move its adoption the motion is to move the adoption of the amendment for Senate
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:01:18
bill 992 all those in favor all those opposed okay we've adopted the amendment and then you'll tell Senator Burnett to come back and run it correct okay see no further business unless there's something I'm missing is there anyone here in the room that wants to run a bill if not I'll accept a motion to adjourn
▶ Play

Agenda

HB2065

0:54 - 1:54 2 segments 2 speakers

SB634

1:54 - 33:34 100 segments 12 speakers

SB914

33:34 - 1:03:52 118 segments 19 speakers

SB1029

1:03:52 - 1:56:23 170 segments 21 speakers

HB1570

1:56:23 - 1:59:39 12 segments 4 speakers

SB961

1:59:39 - 2:07:28 33 segments 6 speakers

SB959

2:07:28 - 2:19:07 48 segments 12 speakers

SB719

2:19:07 - 2:39:36 68 segments 14 speakers

HR1009

2:39:36 - 2:45:00 19 segments 4 speakers

HB1205

2:45:00 - 3:01:08 60 segments 7 speakers

SB992

3:01:08 - 3:01:43 2 segments 1 speaker

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
96 segments
Senator Stephanie Flowers Unverified
46 segments
Dixie Carlson Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 32
9 segments
Speaker 39
13 segments
Representative John K. Hutchison Unverified
25 segments
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 72
3 segments
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
20 segments
Representative Betty Overbey Unverified
6 segments
Representative Ann V. Clemmer Unverified
20 segments
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
16 segments
Senator David J. Sanders Unverified
54 segments
Speaker 153
1 segment
Speaker 165
1 segment
Representative Butch Wilkins Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 156
1 segment
Representative Denny Altes Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 178
1 segment
Representative Debra M. Hobbs Unverified
15 segments
Representative Bruce Westerman Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 198
1 segment
Speaker 201
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
73 segments
Speaker 213
1 segment
Speaker 239
1 segment
Speaker 245
1 segment
Speaker 249
2 segments
Speaker 20
1 segment
Representative Deborah Ferguson Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 260
59 segments
Speaker 266
1 segment
Speaker 268
1 segment
Speaker 276
1 segment
Speaker 298
2 segments
Dan Greenberg Unverified
10 segments
Representative Wes Wagner Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 350
1 segment
David Foster Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 360
4 segments
Sylvester Smith Unverified
1 segment
Senator Bryan King Unverified
54 segments
Speaker 387
1 segment
Speaker 155
1 segment
Speaker 423
1 segment
Speaker 61
1 segment
Speaker 431
9 segments
Speaker 34
1 segment
Speaker 435
1 segment
Speaker 446
1 segment
Speaker 453
2 segments
Speaker 96
1 segment
Speaker 456
3 segments
Speaker 236
1 segment
Speaker 465
1 segment
Speaker 471
6 segments
Speaker 475
1 segment