Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs

January 21, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1063 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1063”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1068 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1068”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
Good morning. I think it's time to begin our committee meeting. Call the meeting to order. The chair sees a quorum. Anyone wishing to speak for or against a bill, would you please make sure that you signed in over here? And we are going to hear a couple bills today. I think we're going to start with House Bill 1063. Representative Saban, you ready? you're recognized to present. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, members of the committee. With the permission of the chair, I'd like to bring Lisa Speer, the director of the History Commission, up to present with me. Absolutely. Would you like to come? There we go. Sorry. You'll have to introduce yourself and state your
▶ Play
Speaker 10 0:59
name for the record. Thank you. I'm Lisa Speer. I'm the director of
▶ Play
the Arkansas History Commission. Mr. Chair, I brought this legislation really at the request of the History Commission because they had some policy changes that all of you can see outlined pretty clearly in there. And I'm going to let the director speak to those issues and the reasons for them. What I'd like to do, though, before I hand it over to her, It's just proactively address one issue because this morning Chairman Bell told me that he'd received a couple of questions about the need to create the new fee for archival services. And specifically the questions that he said he received were about whether these were services that already existed and simply those services were being presented to the public for free, but then all of a sudden we'd be creating a new fee for that and I've been assured by the director that that's not the case and I'll let her address that issue specifically. But otherwise, I think the director is probably in the best position to explain the reasoning behind this legislation and answer any questions.
▶ Play
Speaker 10 2:13
Thank you, Representative Sabin. I appreciate the opportunity to present on behalf of the History Commission. Essentially, we're asking for your assistance with reconciling our current legislation with changes in the archival profession, particularly as they pertain to archival research over the last 50 years. I'm sure you're all familiar with sites like Ancestry and FamilySearch, and those have significantly changed researcher expectations for how information is delivered. Travel to a research facility is no longer a given. Most researchers expect to be able to do some portion of their research online. The History Commission is, of course, continuing to work on putting our collections online, but ultimately there'll be limitations on what we'll be able to provide online. We are, we have the world's largest collection of historical materials pertaining to Arkansas. We've been collecting for 110 years. We'll never be able to put everything that we have online. It wouldn't be practical or feasible. So we, what we're asking for is the opportunity to broaden the options for researchers who can't come on site. Our current legislation provides that we can make copies of material in our collection available to researchers, and we've been doing that. But generally, that's very specific things that researchers are able to pinpoint in our collection, like an ancestor's military record or a specific newspaper article on a particular date. Not everything in archival collections is so easily locatable and sometimes more extensive research is needed. Up to this point, when we've been approached by researchers who can't come on site, who need that extensive research, unfortunately, we've had to tell them we can't help you. And neither I nor the other folks who work at the History Commission like saying we can't help you. I believe that a demand does exist to add research as a service, and that's what we're asking for approval to be able to do. Of course, if this request is approved and House Bill 1063 is ultimately adopted, we would follow the established legislative process for having any changes to policy documents reviewed, and that would include a public hearing and a public comment period. What we're asking to do is in keeping with practice at other state archives, and if you have questions about what other state archives do, I can provide you with information on that. We're also asking to be able to use our cash in the Treasury for general maintenance and operations. Again, our legislation is about 50 years old, and it limits us at this point to using our cash in the Treasury for photographic equipment and supplies and microfilming. And we're an agency with a pretty small budget. Once personnel expenses and rent is taken out, we have about $134,000 remaining for maintenance and operations for three facilities. That's $134,000 total, not for each facility. So to be able to use our cash in the Treasury to support M&O would be very beneficial to our agency. We're not talking about a significant amount of cash. Our five-year average is about $33,000. So those are the changes that we are asking to make, and I would be happy to field any particular questions that
▶ Play
you have. Okay, thank you. And we'll open it up to the committee for questions. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 17 5:36
Link. I thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm sure you have, but there's always been an issue with agencies and whether you have authority to collect fees or not. Did you ever establish
▶ Play
Speaker 10 5:46
that authority? We do have the authority to collect fees for copying services. Okay. You did that during
▶ Play
Speaker 17 5:51
the last session, right? Yes. Okay, great. Thank you. Any more questions?
▶ Play
Representative Douglas? When you said the money would be, you know, placed in the bank and then go for maintenance and operations, and that's not including salary? No, ma'am. That would just be for your upkeep? And so mainly this is just going to be copying documents and
▶ Play
Speaker 10 6:18
sending through the mail? Our staff would perform research. We already copy documents and send them through the mail, but sometimes more research is needed, so our staff would be conducting research for individuals who can't come on site and then providing whatever kind of copies would be involved.
▶ Play
And is that not available online in most instances? We have finding aids
▶ Play
Speaker 10 6:40
for many of our collections, but sometimes those are just general outlines of what's available in a collection. For instance, one folder might have 100 documents in it, but the folder listing may be one sentence. So our staff really needs to be able to get in and pull it and look through. Requests from patrons for research are not always cut and dried. It may be more I'm looking for information on a topic that's very broad, and we would need to go to several sources to collect all of the
▶ Play
information that they're looking for. So you would feel that you – I've usurped my one question. May I have a follow-up? So you would feel that instead of sending them links to the information, you would need to copy that and send it to them in the mail, which seems, I'm not sure.
▶ Play
Speaker 10 7:35
Well, not all of the information, the primary documents and the archives have been digitized and are available online. That's what I need to know. So this would really be copying, locating and copying material that's not currently available online. If it's available online, we would just direct a researcher to that
▶ Play
online link. So some of the information you have on site needs to be
▶ Play
Speaker 10 8:02
digitized and put on? We have hundreds, probably thousands, of cubic feet of archival collections going back 110 years. And we've just really started the process of digitizing, and we're going to continue. But our current license limits us to 10,000 items from our collection, and we probably have 10 times or more that many. Yeah, okay. Thank you very much.
▶ Play
You're welcome. Thank you. Any other questions from committee? Is there anybody in the audience that would like to
▶ Play
speak for or against the bill? We've got a question. Representative Ladyman? Yes, I have a question. Can you define in general terms maybe, I'm a little confused about the definition of research services and archival services and the fees. I mean, can you give an idea of generally how much these fees are and what the process would be
▶ Play
Speaker 10 9:01
to establish that and define what services you're going to charge fees for? Currently we charge fees for copying services, so providing print, photocopies, digital scans, photographic prints, copies of audio-visual material, and that fee schedule was revised last year and approved by a legislative subcommittee, revised to bring most of those fees down, actually not increase. So research services would be different in that our staff would be devoting more of their time to locating information within the collections. What we've been doing thus far are really kind of quick reference copying requests, things that are easily locatable within the collection. A researcher knows a specific newspaper article that they want us to locate or they give us their ancestor's name and we look for their Confederate pension record. That doesn't take a lot of our staff time. Research would be, research services would be more involved. Using staff time, we would probably put a limit on it, maybe up to two hours. That's kind of in keeping with what other state archives have done. And if we haven't found the answer to your question in two hours, it's very likely we're not going to find it. Thank you. You're welcome. Any other questions, my committee?
▶ Play
Speaker 46 10:27
Representative Gray? Thank you. To follow up
▶ Play
on Representative Ladyman's question, can you tell me what the fees will be for the research? Do you plan an hourly fee or just explain the fees
▶ Play
Speaker 10 10:41
a little better? Sure. Well, our fees would have to be set by our commission. We have a seven-member commission, and likely it would be an hourly fee. What many other states have done is to provide some amount of time, generally in half an hour or an hour, for in-state residents at no charge, and then a second hour at anything that ranges from $10 to $20. It's a fairly low fee. and then a separate fee schedule for out-of-state residents where they pay for every hour or every half hour of research. Okay, thank you. Any other questions by committee? Representative
▶ Play
Link? All right, to come back on the fees,
▶ Play
Speaker 17 11:30
now this kind of got my interest going, and your commission will establish that or board or whatever it is, will it be done by rule? Will it still come before this body of rules and regs? So ultimately, just to let, especially the first-term folks know, that we will still have authority, and thanks to the First Amendment one on the ballot, we will have full authority over what those fees are before they're actually put into place. Thank you. Great point.
▶ Play
Any other questions about committee? We'll give the audience one more chance to jump in. Anybody like to speak for or against the bill? Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Move, do pass. Thank you. I'm sorry I skipped a
▶ Play
sip. Representative Saban. I'm closed. You're closed. Great. Thank you. All right, we have a motion of do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, say no. Okay, congratulations, Representative Saban. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. Thank you very much. All right, next on the agenda. I'm not really sure. House Bill 1068 by Representative Hammer. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. I present your bill. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. It looks like a Baptist church, everybody in the back of the church building from here. Mr. Chair, with your permission, I'd like to ask a couple folks to go ahead join me for sake of time if you don't mind please. Scott Perkins with the Association of Counties and Doug Curtis, Selene County Clerk if chair permits. Absolutely. Thank you. Mr. Chair, I'd like to recognize I have Lyna Gildredge, who's the vice president of the county clerks, also in the audience that signed up in the event. Members have questions at the appropriate time. And if you would, you want me to have guests introduce themselves for the record. Please. I'm
▶ Play
Doug Curtis. There we go. I'm Doug Curtis, Saline
▶ Play
Speaker 98 14:04
County Clerk. Scott Perkins, Association of Arkansas Counties Communications Director.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, with the permission, I have a handout that kind of summarizes some of the key points and also refers to an Attorney General's opinion that I requested with the Chair's permission. Distribute these to the members, please. Yes, sir. Thank you. All right, proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thanks. What House Bill 1068 is intended to do is to inject some clarity into the law and consistency through the state or throughout the state for writing candidates. That's kind of it in a nutshell. One thing I want to put everybody's mind at ease, the bill does not alter any writing candidates' deadlines for notice of writing candidacy, political practice, pledge of affidavit eligibility, which are due no later than the party filing deadline. so this in no way, shape, or form alters any of the other aspects of the law related to that. What this bill does is add a consistent, clear deadline for writing candidates to notify each county board of their intent to run in the race in that county, and this directly addresses the lack of legislative clarity. I wrote for Attorney General's opinion on this matter, and there are quotes from the Attorney General's opinion, which I have the hard copy with me if anybody would like to see it, But one thing I'd like to draw to your attention is in the first paragraph that legislative clarification strongly warranted, in my opinion, to resolve any uncertainty that may arise regarding candidates' qualifications. Evidently, in 2009, there was a law that was passed, and as sometimes is the case down here, there were a few unattended consequences that occurred. And one of the unattended consequences was that it left vague the deadline upon which writing candidates had to file. And so that's what this bill is intended to do. And if you'll flip to the back page of your handout, the 90-day time frame that is referred to in this bill allows the county clerks and commissions ample amount of time to program their election machines or, in the case they're printing paper ballots, it will give them adequate time to do it so as to make for a more transparent election and less confusing. And this bill accomplishes clarity and defines this deadline and help assure consistency throughout the state of Arkansas. Be
▶ Play
glad to answer any questions. Are there any questions about committee
▶ Play
members? Representative Walker. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Has there been, and this is addressed to you, Mr. Hammer, and to the county clerk, Has there been a substantial problem with write-in candidates in the election process? Mr. Walker, if it's all right with you, could I let
▶ Play
Doug Curtis speak to that? And maybe he can cite a personal situation. I'll help give you a little
▶ Play
comfort. Representative Walker, the last general election we had, We had a situation where we had a very large ballot. We got notice, it was after the filing deadline, we'd already had our ballot set up. We had to go back in there and create some room on the ballot, put the line down there for the write-in candidate. If we would have known that on the startup of all of this, it would have made our job extremely easier and not have to go back in and reset everything. So it's just kind of getting everybody on the same page on a level playing field.
▶ Play
Well, may I follow up, Mr. Chair? I didn't understand that to be the purpose of writing candidates, and I don't see that as major. But the second problem is there are some races and positions that don't have a 90-day period after filing. For instance, you run for school board positions. I think you file by July, August. Then the election is in September. So that would mean that a write-in candidate would have to give notice before a candidate seeking that office, and some other offices as well would have to do so. I think there are some city council positions that may require, may only be a two-month notice period.
▶ Play
So why 90 days? Well, now your school boards and your municipalities are under totally different laws than what your county and your state officials are. You don't have near long big elections on those right there. You've got your deadlines, and there is not a deadline. It's just simply clarifying the deadlines for these to be sent to the County Board of Election Commissioners. May I
▶ Play
have one more, please? Yes, sir. If you are not applying this to all elections, do you not feel that it would be better for you to self-amend Mr. Hammer the complaint so as to make sure that write-in candidates don't have to file earlier than other persons who are seeking the office? Whatever the office
▶ Play
Speaker 86 20:15
is, do you want to speak to it? Mr. Chair, can
▶ Play
Speaker 98 20:21
Scott address that question? Yes, sir. Mr. Chair, thank you, committee members. Representative Walker, the proposed amendment to 75205 doesn't adjust already the threshold that a write-in candidate, by the party filing date, no later, would have to file for their candidacy. So this doesn't allow a window for candidates to come in later than anybody else. This is simply addressing the notification required to each county board. So there's three thresholds that right-in candidates already have to meet by the party filing deadline. This is just to notify the county board. I hope that answers your question, sir.
▶ Play
I don't think so, but I have exhausted my questions. Yeah, let's move to Representative Link.
▶ Play
Speaker 17 21:01
You recognize for a question. That last statement kind of confuses me more. So we already have deadlines for write-in candidates, which I'm kind of going along with Representative Walker. I didn't know that was the purpose of write-in candidates. The question I have then is, let's say that everybody gets really frustrated with the candidates that are currently on ballot. They write in a new person. It's the voters that are writing in. Is that person then elected because they didn't go through the correct filing procedure? Are they not elected? I mean, if the public wants to elect someone by write-in, that's the public's choice. That's a voter's choice. if we all decide that Bob Ballinger is our new mayor of wherever by write-in because we're mad at the other two people that are candidates. We can't write in that name and they be elected because he didn't go through a
▶ Play
filing procedure on time? You can write in the night. It's not changing the candidates being able to run. It's changing that they notify the county board of election commissions that they are running where we could put a place on the ballot for someone to write their name in. In other words, they can file, but when it comes right down to it, the way the law is, it's not clear of a deadline of when they're supposed to notify the county board of election commissioners. So all of a sudden on the day before the election, they could come to us and say, okay, we're going to be running as a write-in candidate. and then at that point here it is the day before the election and we have to get things start setting up to count votes which by law they're supposed to file all of the three things but there's not a deadline on one of them which is the notice to the
▶ Play
county board I'd like to recognize Representative Bell real quick for possibly a point of clarification I
▶ Play
just I wanted to kind of recount a situation that I'm personally familiar with that happened last year that directly is in line with this. We deal with write-in candidates. Write-in candidates file at the same time everyone else does, but the law, as it's written, requires those write-in candidates to provide notification to the county clerks. What happened in the 4th Congressional District is we had a write-in candidate, and that write-in candidate did not notify county clerks that she was, in fact, a write-in candidate in some cases until just a few days before the election it created a lot of problems for the county clerks because a lot of the ballots didn't have a line on them for a write-in candidate because they didn't know they had write-in candidates so what this is doing is simply saying you filed for office at the file the normal filing period like everyone else does but you have to go ahead and comply with the law and notify the county clerks in those jurisdictions that you are in fact a write-in candidate and that you request a write-in line to be placed on the ballot. And that's what this provision does, is it eliminates that chaos that happens at the last minute when those candidates didn't, in fact, notify the county clerks or the Secretary of State that they were, in fact, requesting that to be on the ballot. I hope that helps. But there was a lot of chaos in the 4th District because the paper ballots, in some cases, had already been printed before she notified the county clerks that she, in fact, wanted that to happen. Mr. Chair,
▶ Play
may I say something? Yes, sir. And adding to that, just to reemphasize, that this is not changing any other of the requirements or anything, what it is doing, and this is recommended by the opinion of the Attorney General who looked at this very thoroughly, the previous Attorney General I might point out, is that it is allowing a date of 90 days for all this to come into compliance, which is not going to prohibit anybody, but it's going to help our county clerks run a more efficient election process and also maybe prevent from having to reprint ballots after a certain time. So it's bringing some transparency and clarity is what it's
▶ Play
intended. Thank you. Representative Douglas, you're recognized. I guess I am trying to make sure that a person's right to be a write-in candidate is not encumbered by this desire to make sure there's room on the ballot. And if we make this a law, I just feel like at some point, a county could come back and say you didn't let us know in the 90-day frame and we're not we don't have room and we're not going to accept another write-in is that a
▶ Play
possibility it is already a law that uh and as 75205 explains that the candidate notifies in writing the county board of election commissioners of each county in which the candidate seeks election but it's not explained out when the deadline is to do that. It was left out. There wasn't a problem in the Attorney General's opinion. It states in there that this was left out or used to be a deadline on it and it was changed in I think 2009 or 2011 that just left some language out about the deadline on it. So if
▶ Play
I want to run a week before the election I still can. A week before the election? No, ma'am. Okay, but with
▶ Play
the write-in? I mean, somebody wants to write my name in. You still have to file. Bob, I'm confused. Yeah, you still, and it's pretty confusing. You still have to file. As a write-in? As a write-in. But in the situation that Representative Bell was talking about, it's a
▶ Play
congressional district and then you filed secretary of state but not the county clerk representative
▶ Play
richie recognize for a question thank you mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 111 27:07
chair i mean i i think we've got some confusion on the requirements of writing candidates so what i hear you saying and i and I confess my ignorance on this at the very beginning, is that there are already requirements. If you want to be a write-in candidate, you've already got to meet these prior requirements as the filing deadline and all that which I was unaware of. So now you're just adding to that that you've also got to notify the county clerk's office so that we can make sure that's on the ballot and you can't wait until the last day. I mean, is that right by understanding that
▶ Play
correctly? That is subject to these two experts. Correct
▶ Play
Speaker 98 27:54
me. Go ahead, Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chair, if I may. Representative Ritchie, the requirement to notify each county board is already law. So it's not an adding for anything for a right-hand candidate to do to be legitimate. It's just setting a deadline for them to notify the county board. They're already required to notify the board.
▶ Play
Speaker 114 28:12
The deadline's unclear. A follow-up question, please, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Speaker 111 28:15
Sure. So this idea that I've had all this time that you could just write somebody's name on the ballot is not fact. I mean, that's fiction. Is that what you're telling me? That is correct. Okay. Representative Ballinger,
▶ Play
you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. I think that Mr. Ritchie got to the bottom of really what my question is. So essentially at this point, one thing just to make real clear, though, is the writing candidates do not have to make any kind of filing or anything by the filing deadline. It's just as it is right now, they have to, under the current law, they have to report prior to the election to each county of which they're running. Right?
▶ Play
They still have to file by the filing deadline.
▶ Play
A writing candidate has to file. Do you guys have the code on that? That may be the case. It's just all of us are surprised by that, and so it kind of brings up some questions.
▶ Play
Speaker 98 29:24
Certainly, Representative. We're at 75205. I was going to start here. This is also on your handout. It was mentioned in the Attorney General's opinion received in December. But there's three things a candidate has to do no later than the party filing deadline, And that is, it's in the second paragraph of the Attorney General's opinion. Thank you, sir. Affidavit, political practices pledge, and a notice of write-in candidacy are already required no later than the party filing deadline. 75205 also requires to notify each election board of their intent to run. The deadline for that notification is unclear and not defined in 75205. 205. The thing that this kind
▶ Play
of, and you correct me if I'm wrong, it seems to lead to a little bit of absurdity because you can file as an independent candidate. There's no limitation to that. So if you're filing prior to the filing deadline, why are you a writing candidate and not an independent candidate? I mean, I think that I'm going to
▶ Play
Speaker 103 30:20
recognize Representative Bell real quick. Sure. Thank you. I want
▶ Play
to go directly to what Representative Ballinger is addressing because there's a key point that I think a lot of us are missing in Arkansas election law. So I want to talk about where we are today. Right now in Arkansas today, if you come to election day and you have not filed as a write-in candidate at the normal filing period, you could get every vote cast in the election and you are not elected. That is the way the current law is. You have to file, same as everyone else, or your votes aren't counted for you. so that this does not alter that process what this alters is right now we have a situation in law where someone can come file as a write-in candidate but then not notify anyone that they're actually running okay not notify any clerks not notify anyone else and walk in the day before the election and say you have to redo all these ballots and put a line on the ballot for write-in candidates because i'm a write-in candidate that's where the current law is what this is attempting to do is to is to say you've got to give the same amount of notice that everyone else has to do when the ballots are printed because the parties send their list of candidates the independents all have to have to be certified via the signatures a write-in candidate is just somebody that said i'm running okay so this simply allows the the time a reasonable amount of time it's it's a reasonable amount of time for the ballots to be printed for the machines to be set up to allow that person to have their right protected to have their votes counted otherwise they walk in the morning of election go hey there's not a line on this ballot for me you have to put it on there that's what current law what current law says
▶ Play
i hope that helps that that does it leads me though one other question I would just want to make sure that if the if the law generally says candidates must do this if it specifically says writing candidates must do this then then we're then we're directly on point but if it says candidates must do this I think that that someone can make a valid argument it doesn't include writing candidates because the very nature of what a writing candidate is and so my question is does the statute actually say writing candidates must meet those three things or does the statute say candidates must meet those three things. Representative Ballinger, I want
▶ Play
to just touch on that for a second and then you can go to those guys. The current law says that the parties will provide notice to the Secretary of State or that the parties will provide notice to the county clerk of who their candidates are. So the party candidates, that's how that notice takes place. The independent candidates are certified by the county clerk by their signatures there is no process for the write-in candidate other than for the write-in candidate to go hey i'm running okay so all we're saying is this allows you have to do it within that not more than 90 days out from the election so that they have a reasonable amount of time to respond and and i
▶ Play
understand that i guess that's what i mean now now i'm really conflicted because you said the only process that they have to go through is to say now i'm running Do they have to do that to file the affidavit by the following deadline? Do they have to fill out, you know, to come in and provide the notice of Secretary of State by the following deadline? If they do, then, you know, maybe we are talking about just trying to clear things up for the county clerks until that kind of thing can be corrected. But if it doesn't specifically say that write-in candidates must do these things, and that's really my question, is does the code actually say write-in candidates have to do this? Mr.
▶ Play
Curtis, would you address that? Yes. In Code 75205, it states that no votes for write-in candidates shall be counted or tabulated unless the candidate notifies in writing the county board of election commissions of each county in which the candidate seeks the election.
▶ Play
Okay, but what about you guys said that they have to file affidavit, they have to do X, Y, or Z by filing deadline. show me where it says that a writing candidate has to do that by filing deadline and
▶ Play
I'm sorry that's not one of the questions I figured would be asked so I don't know the answer to it
▶ Play
right off the bat sure Representative Bell Representative Ballinger we actually in the 2013 session handled four or five bills addressing how those filings take place and specifically addressed independent candidates within that time period that and I don't remember the code section off the top of my head but it is very specifically required that that process and it's been that way for some time that the write in candidate files at the same time as everyone else, and this notice has always been there as well. This is just simply making sure that it's done in a timely fashion as opposed to just somebody walking in the morning of the election. But other than that, the process for a right-hand candidate to be elected is basically the same as any other candidate, except for they don't have to get signatures, and they don't have to file with the party, so they don't pay a filing fee.
▶ Play
Obviously, if we had time, we could look up the code. I don't know if someone else can. and I remember actually specifically the bill that former representative Andrea Lee carried that dealt with independent candidates and that makes sense but writing candidates is kind of a bit of a different creature than an independent candidate who's filing to run for office and if it says writing candidates then then that's you know this may make sense because we're not really adding anything new other than just providing some help and clarity to a county clerk but if if it doesn't say writing candidates then really we're kind of fundamentally changing what a writing candidate is and saying that they have at least a 90-day notice period before they can actually run. And
▶ Play
I'll sit here on camera and tell you that the law categorically does require that currently. It absolutely does. And, you know, we could argue the policy of whether that's a correct policy, but
▶ Play
that's another bill. Well, and if you tell me that it has the words writing candidate in it, I'll just go with that. But if you're wrong, I'm going
▶ Play
to be mad. I'm not wrong. I know that piece of the law and it absolutely does make
▶ Play
that requirement. Okay, then I'm satisfied. Mr. Chairman, I believe I have found that in 7-5-2-5 on down it says in subsection 3, the notice of writing and candidacy, the political practice pledge and the affidavit of eligibility are filed no later than the last day of the party filing period. Representative
▶ Play
Representative Drown, you're recognized for a question. I'm good. You're good? We'll move to
▶ Play
Representative Bennett. It's a question. Isn't it one of the purposes of this is to allow the Election Commission and the Secretary of State and the counties to vet the candidates to be sure that they're qualified for the position that they're running for and for any challenges to be
▶ Play
raised? Did you want to answer that? I'm going to say I don't think that that's really the intent of this because I'm not sure that's under their purview or jurisdiction. This is more a matter of just establishing a timeline that would allow the clerks to make sure the ballots are all printed properly. You know, one thing, and I think Doug could speak to this and clarify what I'm about to say, but there are certain laws regarding the printing of the ballots with regard to font size, and part of what you run into is you only have so much space to get it done on, and you can speak to that in a second. But one thing this will do is help make our county clerks be able to produce a ballot that is more transparent and more efficient, and that's one of the sidelines. But to your question, I don't think that it does, but the 90 days does help make sure that other aspects of the law have ample amount of time to make sure that they're all done instead of it being at the last minute and something going wrong. Doug,
▶ Play
do you want to say anything to that? Yeah, I don't think the intent of the bill is, from my point of view, is like the last election when we had a Senate candidate run. It was in several counties. Then you're having an interpretation by a county clerk that, okay, well, they didn't meet the deadline. They did meet the deadline. Do I put them on the ballot or not? So what you're doing is you're getting everybody in line. Okay, here's the law on it. It's very clear that they have this deadline that they have to meet. So the intention of it is just to clarify the deadline on whenever they have to notify the county board of election commissioners. I think
▶ Play
it's important just to make a quick point that the previous Attorney General's opinion said made it very clear that there historically has been a certain number of days, and that was somehow mixed up in 2009. So I think we kind of might be going over plowed ground here. We still have Representative Miller for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess first of all, let me say that when I came in this room, my lack of knowledge filled it up. So this is probably a really ignorant question, but how do you write somebody in when you're voting on the voting machines?
▶ Play
Representative Miller, it's programmed into the machine that you do have a write-in, and whenever you touch that write-in on it, then a keyboard comes up, and you just type their name into it.
▶ Play
Well, thank you. I've never seen that, so that answers that question. So, actually, these names, if someone goes, registers, does the whole thing 90 days prior, whatever, their names are not, they do not appear on the ballot. You still have to physically write them in. That's right. And so we have, we know that only those names that have been registered are eligible to be elected. That's right. We
▶ Play
have situations where Donald Duck and Mickey Mouse was put on there. Right.
▶ Play
I've done that. But why wouldn't we just put them on the ballot and just save the whole write-in process? That's not what
▶ Play
the law is now on the write-in.
▶ Play
Speaker 76 41:27
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I was just
▶ Play
curious. All right. Let's move along.
▶ Play
Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Miller, that was one of my questions, so I don't think that's an ignorant question at all, and I appreciate you asking that. Is not what we're saying, Representative Hammer, is that the write-in, you could have names written in, any name written in, but under existing statute, they're not going to be elected no matter how many votes they get if they didn't do this filing as a write-in candidate and this statute would require them to do it 90 days in advance of the election? I'm going to give my answer. Is that
▶ Play
a clarification? Can you clarify that for me? I will clarify subject to these two gentlemen correcting me because they're more rehearsed in law. We're not changing any of the requirements for write-in candidates. What we're saying is these requirements have to be done 90 days before the election.
▶ Play
Is that a fair way to say it? You recognize for a follow-up? And just to clarify, if they're not done, it doesn't matter how many votes they receive, they're not elected. If they should receive a winning number of votes, they didn't follow the process, so they're not elected. Is that
▶ Play
correct? I'm going to repeat the question back to you and just make sure I understand what you're asking, make sure. If this law passes and they do not comply by 90 days before and people write their name on the ballot and because they haven't complied with the 90 days, they would not be elected. Is that your
▶ Play
question? Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Okay. Representative Ladyman,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Well, could we give an answer to that question, Mr. Chair? But I want to clarify with Scott and with Doug. You want to answer that just to
▶ Play
Speaker 98 43:32
make sure? Write-in votes would not count if they don't comply to that notification.
▶ Play
Which they also could have their name written in and not have fulfilled the other three requirements and their votes not count also. So that's one of the benefits of this bill is to make sure that all the requirements have been complied
▶ Play
with. Thank you. Representative Ladyman. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Well, I want to frame my question a little bit here, and I apologize, as Representative Miller did, for my lack of understanding of right-hand candidates up front. But I want to look at it from a different view. I always understood that the write-in candidate line was for me, the Arkansas voter, to write in anyone I wanted to. Not the person running, but for me, a citizen, to be able to write in. That was my right to vote for anybody I wanted to. And it surprises me that everybody has to sign up for this because that seems like that's a normal candidate to me. So it seems like the problem here and what you are asking for, and I understand your issue and your problem, is that you have to redo the ballot. You have to add a line for a right-in candidate for those offices where there is someone running. My question to you is, why could we not have a right-in line? And I understand the length of the ballot and all that. This last election, we had a very long ballot. And I know that creates some problems. But it seems simple to me to add a line for right-in and allow me, the Arkansas voter, the right to vote for Representative Miller or anybody else that's not on the ballot.
▶ Play
Is that not possible? I'd like to break in real quick and invite Rob Hammonds from the Elections Division to the end of the table, and if you would, state your name and title. And maybe you could provide us a little bit of clarity as to the process as it currently
▶ Play
Speaker 164 45:33
stands. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I am Rob Hammonds. I'm the Director of Elections for the Secretary of State's office. To kind of stop and give you guys, before the water gets too muddled right here, kind of explain it to you. To become a candidate in the state of Arkansas, to gain ballot access, you have one of three ways. You pay your filing fee with a party. You also, as an independent, can gather signatures to be certified either by the secretary of state or the county clerk, depending on the office in which you seek. You also have the write-in candidacy. That write-in candidacy is a little bit different than anything else, as it appears going forward. The writing candidate in a situation, all candidates, as they file, file during the party filing period. Okay? They all have the one-week term when everybody came to file and came to see us this year, this past year in 2014, and file. That is the notification that, yes, I am running for this position. When there is an extra stipulation for writing candidates as they go forward, as they've talked about, the party filing, once you've paid your party filing fees, you file with the Secretary of State's Office or the county in this situation, then the party notifies those individuals that, hey, these are my candidates. They've met the criteria. They are currently a, should be a candidate on the ballot. Independents are very much the same way. The county clerk or the Secretary of State's Office has to verify each of those signatures to verify that they've met the criteria to be placed on the ballot. The write-in candidate has to meet neither of those boundaries. It's basically the free access to the ballot itself. but you have to notify the county that you are going to be placed on the ballot which is kind of the point which which we're at right now a writing candidate files during that party filing period the political party practices pled i mean all their uh their pledge affidavit and everything else is there notified in 205 when they file those it states to the county or the secretary of state's office and we will notify the county that hey you have a writing candidate available coming to you in this situation, 4th Congressional District this last time, second as well. This is where it differs. We've told the county that they will have a writing candidate. That candidate still by law as it currently stands in 205 has to notify those county board of election commissioners that I am going to appear on your ballot to be tabulated. There's a difference between appearing on the ballot and being tabulated and counted. When you have a situation where you're at right now, this is a deadline that would be imminent for the county clerks, is what they're trying to tell you, is in the production of the ballot. We have federal deadlines that we have to meet for those ballots to go out. We have to have a ballot out 46 days prior to any election in the state of Arkansas by UACAVA standards, which is our federal standards for overseas military and absentee. if this situation was they notified a candidate for write-in notified a county board of election commissioners after that deadline you've already facilitated the fact that a voter could be losing votes by anybody overseas being allowed to vote on them that is the predecessor to making sure that line appears on the ballot in time so they do have fair access and they do have a fair chance of anybody being able to vote on them at any given time you want the ballot to appear the same from very beginning day to the very last day. We do our ballot draw for the general election 72 days out prior to, or 75 to 72, and for notification. And those names have to be drawn, everybody appears, and in place. At that point in time, the county board can say, yes, there is a writing candidate, yes, they have notified us, and that line will appear on the ballot, because a line does not automatically appear on the ballot in the state of Arkansas. It only appears once the county board of commissioners by 205 have been notified. That's their notification to put that line there. Otherwise, it will not appear. And, yes, you can write in Mickey Mouse, Donald Up, Bob Marley. We've seen a bunch of them over the years, just about everything in between. But it's not about the name that appears there. It's about the tabulation of the name that appears there. The county board of election commissioners have to be told that, yes, this person did certify, they did file, and their votes will be tabulated. I hope that's clarified at some for you guys. If I can provide any more information, I'll be
▶ Play
glad to. Thank you for coming to the table. If you'll just hang
▶ Play
out there a minute, I'd appreciate it. I'd be glad to. Yes, sir. Mr. Chairman, can I clarify my question and shorten it up? Can a line be added that says write-in candidate and how difficult would that be to do for every candidate?
▶ Play
Speaker 164 50:13
For every race or every candidate? Every race. Every candidate. Race. Every ballot race. Every ballot race. I'm sorry, every race. Got you. Okay, good. That would just have to be in statute that that would be there. You would have to rewrite current law as it stands to have a write-in appear at every available race in the state of Arkansas. That does not currently appear in code. Code as it stands is you have to file during the party filing period, and then that line appears. There is no standard write-in line across the board. Thank you.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. Are there any other questions by committee?
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My understanding is that there is a federal right to express yourself in a political manner. And that, like Representative Lederman, I think he indicated that the right may belong to the citizen rather than to a person who's a candidate. So are you saying that a citizen under federal law, and I guess a state law too, cannot express himself politically by declaring himself for a particular candidate and against others by having a place to express that on the ballot? It doesn't seem that the candidate presumes an affirmative action on the part of a person who is elected to run. but some of us would like to designate people from time to time like perhaps even running for speaker I mean there may be afforded ordained determination to have a speaker but some might can make a motion that there that a particular person be a speaker be the speaker and that person would have a right to at least express him or herself so I'm trying to see how you jab the right to express yourself politically with a limitation that's for the convenience of the clerk. Representative Bell? Representative
▶ Play
Walker, I'd actually like to respond to that because and you can and they can as well. The right now I don't want to be President of the United States. I have no interest in it. Okay? If you don't have to declare yourself as a candidate you could be elected to offices that you have no desire to serve in some of us have been in local community organizations where we got elected offices we had no desire to serve in I don't personally and I'm just going to express opinion here I don't believe it's good for the process for us to have even permissible for people to be elected offices that they don't desire to seek so declaring the declaring that they're seeking the office should it should be some prerequisite to the policy. That's just my opinion. And now, we'll go back to
▶ Play
questioning. Yeah, and Representative Walker, who was that directed at specifically? Representative Walker, your question?
▶ Play
In all due respect, the clerks are being submitted as the experts, and I submit in all due respect that their opinions are personal opinions and that all of us have equal weight, at least in voicing our opinion about what ought to be, especially since the political process is supposed to be sacrosanct and that people ought to be able to express their viewpoints in the election process. So I think the question about just the convenience why is it that the convenience of the clerk takes precedence over the right of people to politically express themselves however they want in the absence of a person running for office? Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman, my response would be that we are still, a person still has the right to write that in. And I think we're bringing a whole lot of issues in on top of this bill that really need to be addressed in other areas other than on top of this bill. This bill is simply going along with what the Attorney General of the State of Arkansas says is a cloud over the election process and can bring clarity to it by addressing just this one point. If others want to take on other avenues, that's great. But this one is just saying that we are not interfering with the opportunity for people to have that right. We're just bringing clarity to an area that is unclear right now and saying 90 days is what it needs to be
▶ Play
declared by. Thank you, Representative Hammer. Are there any other questions by
▶ Play
committee? Representative Hickerson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hammer, actually we're just voting on these eight words in this statute. The statute's already there. on write-in candidacies except for these eight words correct yes ma'am just one follow-up certainly would you think that um later on in the session we might look at the other stat this entire statutes concerning write-in candidacies and maybe it would be something this committee could look at later on yes ma'am go ahead and you know i mean i i don't have any objection to this because this is not substantially changing the statute other than just putting a a deadline on there they've still got to fight they've still got to do all of these things to be a winner should they get enough write-in votes correct yes ma'am this
▶ Play
does not as originally stated in the opening comments this doesn't change anything else and I think this discussion is great if nothing else it is a warm-up hopefully to what's going to come as a discussion on the House floor and I think we're all a lot more educated in in this process and some clarity has been brought to that but if there are other areas that as a result of the discussion today that have come up that people feel the original statute needs to be changed then go after it but But otherwise, I think that this bill speaks for itself, that we're just trying to make for, again, a more transparent process. And if this is in place, it is going to make those who are going to the poll a whole lot more educated as well. Thank you. Representative Ritchie, you
▶ Play
recognize for a question? Well, I was going to make a motion. Okay. Hang on just a second. Is there anybody, are there any other questions from the committee? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against the bill? Representative Hammer, would you like to close for
▶ Play
your bill? Again, the reason this is before us is because the Attorney General of the State of Arkansas has recognized that there's an area that needs to be cleared up. I think it would do justice to the voters of Arkansas in order to heed the wisdom of the Attorney General's Office of the State of Arkansas and bring clarity. I profess I am not as knowledgeable in all the election laws, but when one area comes up that needs to be addressed as pointed out by the Attorney General's office, I think it would do well if we would follow that encouragement and clear it up for the voters of Arkansas. With that, I'd ask for a favorable vote of do pass. Representative Bell, you're recognized for a motion. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Move do pass. All right, we have a motion of do pass on the bill.
▶ Play
All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, say no. No. No. Congratulations, Representative Hammer. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. Thank you. Thank you, committee. All right, with no other business, we'll end this meeting. Thank you. But your position...
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1063

2:43 - 13:06 39 segments 9 speakers

HB1068

13:06 - 58:27 159 segments 20 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Richard Womack Chair Unverified
26 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 10
21 segments
Speaker 17
5 segments
Chair Unverified
9 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 46
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
1 segment
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson Chair Unverified
7 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
28 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
22 segments
Speaker 98
7 segments
Representative John W. Walker Chair Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 86
1 segment
Representative Nate Bell Chair Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 111
4 segments
Speaker 114
1 segment
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 103
1 segment
Representative R. Trevor Drown Unverified
2 segments
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 76
1 segment
Speaker 164
10 segments