House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (2)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1086
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…tant bills that we're going to run. And we are going to run House Bill 1086 from Representative Branscombe. And Representative Branscom…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1011
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1011”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
I'm glad to have everybody today. Thank you for showing up. We don't have a lot on our agenda today, but we do have some important bills that we're going to run. And we are going to run House Bill 1086 from Representative Branscombe. And Representative Branscombe, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Committee, for hearing the bill.
everybody strives to keep things simple and concise. I have a one-page bill for you with four sentences. It has no physical impact to anybody but to me, to my district. And what it does, it concerns the Jasper School District that a few years ago took in O'Arc and Kingston under the old boundaries. Well, when the Department of Ed come in with their new GPS mapping system, it changed those boundaries. and it messed their funding up.
And so what this bill does, restores the funding back to the old district like it should be, and now everybody's playing by the same rules. They all know where the new mapping system is. And the department has run the physical impact. There is no impact on any other school district. It affects nobody but the one school district, which is in my district. And so with that, I will close for the bill. and I appreciate a good vote. Are there any questions from the committee?
Representative Letting, you're recognized. Motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. Okay. Are there any other questions from the committee? Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak against the bill? Anyone in the audience would like to speak for the bill? I have Dr. Abernathy who would like to speak for the bill please state your name and
who you're with please Richard Abernathy Executive Director of AAEA and we just want to thank Representative Branson for running this bill
and we think it's a fairness issue for Jasper School District and we just want to show our support Anyone like to speak
against the bill? For the bill? We're going to close that. Representative Branscombe, you're welcome to close for your bill. Are you closed? I am closed for bill. Thank you, committee. Mr. Letting, you have a motion?
I move, do pass. We have a do pass motion. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, nay? Motion carries. Thank you, Representative Branson. Representative Bell has a concurrent amendment. Is it amendment? Concurrent from the Senate amendment. You're recognized, Representative Bell. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. You know, we're often told we ought to do the right thing. So we ought to concur in this Senate amendment and change ought to or in this bill,
also adding Senate co-sponsor. But I'd appreciate a good vote in concurrence. Are there any questions from the committee? Mr. Chair, I move do pass on the concurrence. Okay. Does anyone
in the audience like to speak against the bill or for the amendment? If not, close for that. I have a do pass motion.
All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Nay. Motion passes. Thank you. Amendment passes. At this time, I'd like to recognize Dr. Childress from Career Ed, and she's going to come and introduce herself and some people with her and tell us a little bit about what she does.
Thank you, Chairman Cozart, Vice Chair Lamkin, and members of the committee. Good morning. Thank you for the opportunity to address you today. I am Dr. Sharice Childers, and I'm honored to have been selected by Governor Hutchinson as the Director of the Department of Career Education. Please allow me to introduce a few members of our team here today. And if you will, please stand up when I call your name. Sandra Porter is the Interim Deputy Director with Career and Technical Education.
Marilyn Tate is unable to be here today. she's on a site visit, but she's the Associate Director for Workforce Training. Sonny McMurray is an Associate Director with Arkansas Works. And then from Adult Education, we have Mr. Jim Smith. He's the Deputy Director of Adult Ed. And Dr. Trina Miles, the Associate Director of Adult Education. And then from Arkansas Rehabilitation Services today, we have joining us Carl Daughtery.
He is the chief of field services, and with him he has his intern, Kiwana Conley. And then we also have Bridget Frazier, who is the attorney for the Arkansas Department of Career Education and Arkansas Rehabilitation Services. Thank you very much, again, for letting us introduce ourselves today. You asked me to provide you with a vision for this agency. my vision for our agency is to be the lead in equipping our youth and adults with the education and skills needed to be gainfully employed
and to meet the workforce needs of our businesses in Arkansas. So we plan on accomplishing this through data-driven decision-making, resulting in efficient, effective, and innovative policies and programs. So through the leadership of these individuals and their support staff, we hope to accomplish great things in the coming years. And with your help, we look forward to working with you. Thank you for having me today.
would like to give each individual a minute to give you their vision for their department and what they're doing if you have time today. I believe we do. Let's go. Okay. Thank you very much. Let's start with Sandra Porter, the interim deputy director. I've asked them to keep it short.
Speaker 33
7:12
Good morning. I am Sandra Porter, interim deputy director, and I think I've probably worked with most of you over the last several years. This is an exciting time in Department of Career Education, in particular career and technical education, as we move into new career pathway models. We're excited to be able to share those at some point. We're working with our secondary career centers. That's where you usually hear from me is on secondary career centers. We are doing bigger and better things in career centers.
We are meeting the needs of the industries and the post-secondary. And one of the things that I think we're probably moving towards more than anything else is our regional advisory committees, where we're bringing together secondary, post-secondary, all the stakeholders, economic development, and business and industry to tell us what we need to be teaching and what do we just are comfortable teaching. So that's a new vision for us in career and technical education. Thank you.
Next, Sonia McMurray with the Arkansas Works Program. Good morning. Sonia Wright
Speaker 36
8:31
McMurray, Associate Director for Arkansas Works. and we have been in existence since January 2010 with the Arkansas Works College and Career Coaches program. Initially, we were in just 21 counties, but since that time, we have been able to show great results and impacting working with our students in middle and high school
and helping them to have a good college and career plan before they graduate. So now we're in 28 counties in the state of Arkansas. We are working with 55 career coaches across the state that work in partnership with our school counselors, or CO teachers to make sure that our students, when they graduate from high school, they are ready to go into either employment or post-secondary education and be successful. So we're hoping to continue that program through funding and continue through support through our state and local governments to make sure that our students are ready to go to the next step whenever they graduate from high school.
Thank you, Sonia. And the funding for that program goes through June 30, 2015, 15, but then there's no funding available for the next year. So we're hoping that you will look into that further and we'll look at the importance of that program in our schools. The next person that I'd like to have come up is Mr. Jim Smith. He's the Deputy Director of Adult Ed.
And Jim was on Channel 11 this morning and did an excellent job talking about adult education. It was at 550 in case any of you were
watching. Thank you very much, James Smith, and I'm Deputy Director of Adult Education. Likewise, I have worked with many of you and look forward to working with new members. We serve all 75 counties with adult education programs to improve basic academic education skills in reading, math, and language.
We also have a program that has English as a second language for those non-speaking individuals in this state who want to learn to speak English or become citizens. It's ironic that we have 95 out of the 150 possible languages in the world spoken in Arkansas besides English. That's a great task, and that's a growing community. We also have a wage program, which is started in Arkansas in 1992. It stands for Workforce Alliance for Growth and Economy. It's an industry-driven program must be chaired by a member from a business and industry,
and we have 22 of those across the state. We have 39 adult education programs, and that's dropped since I came on board as a director in 2007 from 52 down to 39. We're in desperate need of full-time and part-time teachers to reach the needs of our citizens out in the state, and that's shrinking every year, so it's more difficult to do that. We also have five career coaches who serve 22 counties in the hardest-to-serve population. They served 1,500 students last year, and those students would have normally not completed or dropped out.
Instead, they finished and earned their GED, went on to work, and have become productive citizens. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you very much. Dr. Trina Miles, she is the Associate Director of Adult Education. Good
morning. My name is Trina Miles, and I actually provide support to Jim, and what we'd like to do is continue to provide quality education to our adults in Arkansas and get
them prepared for jobs in the 21st century. We're working closely with two-year colleges. We have the Accelerating Opportunity Program in which adults with basic education skills can co-enroll in four colleges that are part of the pilot program and gain academic success as well as credential to be able to go get jobs because we know that our employers are looking for a quick turnaround and getting our adults prepared for the workforce, and we play a vital role in that.
Thank you. Thank you. Oh, good. Representative Douglas, you are
recognized for a question. yes there's a program that i've heard mr smith talk about through department of corrections that they do with delta or if you'll just explain that i think i'm off a little bit on what the description is but it's a great program yes
ma'am thank you and i apologize for admitting that but it's called a smarter sentencing program and that started through the department of justice about
four years ago in Union County first and now is in the 13th Judiciary District, which covers five counties, I believe. That's in South Art Community College and also SU Tech. That program through Dr. Jake Walker from UCA, we tracked the students. We had a very small program. It's hard to fund out of scarce funds, but we had 59 students we tracked, and two years before they went into that program, their average income was less than $9,000, which indicates they didn't have much employment, but they had a lot of free time and possibly
got into other things. After going through this program two years afterwards, being able to track them, their average income was over $31,000. So we didn't have three hots and a cots and $24,500 for incarceration costs, and we had a productive income average. This program basically gives the opportunity to someone who has a low-grade felony charge to admit guilt, make restitution to the entity harm, which could be a person, place, or a combination, and the satisfaction of court pay all fines and improve their education,
either improve it towards earning a GED or wage certificate or CRC post-secondary training and must gain employment. And if they do, then the courts will expunge their record. Now, that program has expanded now to where David Butler, who's a prosecuting attorney, has assured us he'll have over 600 clients now go through that program this next year, so we've tried to channel funding to make sure we've got full-time teachers down there to make sure that that happens. We've also picked up another drug court in El Dorado who will,
for every hour that that student spends in adult education, will reduce that person's fine by $10 as long as they show good attendance and show progression. And the Department of Corrections has also provided us with parole officers to watch that program if that program are all 28 judiciary districts across this state at the rate of saving one person a week would cut the cost of the state over a billion dollars in 10 years and we have all the math on that be happy to share that with you if you need thank you
Chairman Cozart, do we have time for one more? Okay. Joining us today, in addition to career and technical ed and adult ed, is Carl Daughtery, and he is the chief of field services. So I'd like for Carl to give you some information about the education services that are provided to the clients that are eligible for those services
within the Arkansas Rehabilitation Services Division. Thank you. Good
Speaker 55
15:53
morning. Carl Dottere, Chief of Field Services. Our mission is to put individuals with disabilities back to work and help them live independently. We have 19 offices across the state serving all 75 counties, and we have over 90 counselors providing that guidance. Our counselors have a master's in rehab counseling, and they are certified in vocational counseling. The education that we provide to individuals with disabilities is providing those outcomes,
give you a kind of understanding how that process takes place. We take that application, and we are the experts when it comes to accommodation. We take that application, and then we provide assessment and evaluation to the person with disabilities. Then we determine their eligibility and write a plan, IPE, for that individual, the IPE, individual plan for employment. So our vision is to connect with business and industry. We're excited to tell you that last year, this past fiscal year, we put over 3,000 individuals with disabilities back to work.
So our vision is to continue to stay connected with business and industry and help our youth. One of our biggest challenges right now with the new WIOA, which is the Workforce Innovative Opportunity Act, starting a partnership and be able to be in those schools. Now we're only serving adults, but with this new WIOA, we are required to serve kids starting in the eighth grade at age 14. So that's going to be a big challenge. So we're going to need you all's support with only having 90 counselors to now start serving kids at age 14. It's going to be a big change and a transition for the agency.
So as the Chief of Field Services, I continue to look for your support. And thank you for our new director. So it is our vision. So we appreciate it. Thank you very much, Carl.
other questions from the committee? If not, thank you. Thank you very much for allowing us to be here today.
Look forward to working with all of you. All right. Today we have some pages, I believe, from the Senate end of the chamber over there,
and we would like to just let them introduce themselves and tell us where they're from, and we'll start on the far end, and let's let
Thank you very much. At this time, we would like to have Dr. Tony Wood and Corey Biggs come forward, and they're going to give us a little presentation this morning. Informational presentation, short and sweet. Thank you,
Speaker 63
18:55
Mr. Chair. Tony Wood, Commissioner of Education. And I received your message in regard to short and sweet.
Just a background statement, which is really a summary statement in regard to delivery of broadband for the youngsters across our state, and perhaps it's from a philosophical standpoint. I have no question today that the importance in the environment in which we live of making access and all of the attendant tangents that run off of just using broadband as the subject is absolutely essential. As an agency or respective of the role that I play,
I don't have any ownership in regard to providing that service to our kids. I just want to see that it's provided. I want to see that it's done in a cost-effective manner. I want to see that citizens of Arkansas have the opportunity to recover those tax dollars that they've paid in regard to E-rate reimbursement. And that's really where we are coming from. We certainly want to be part of a partnership that encompasses all of the individuals that are going to make this happen
in the way that I think we all want to make it happen. I know the subject has evolved over a number of months. As an agency, months ago, we went and asked to visit with the incoming speaker, Representative Gillum, along with President Pro Temp, in talking with Senator Dismane. Much the same message that I've shared with you from that point in time, there has been involvement of the process. Probably one of the most significant aspects is the appointment of a new director of the
Department of Informational Services, and Mr. Myers would be with us today were it not for the fact that he's traveling, and perhaps at some opportunity in the future, we can come back and share the involvement as this process continues. As far as the history that is behind us current to date, Mr. Biggs is with me. He's been with our agency for a short period of time. The background on specifically why he is here is because of the importance that we associate
with one of the factors that I mentioned specifically in regard to E-rate reimbursement. Back some time ago, a determination was made, actually was made by me, that we would move E-rate reimbursement process over in our agency. It had been a responsibility of DIS, and reluctantly we actually took that responsibility on. It's a huge responsibility. He will give you some background in regard to why that choice was made, but it was felt that the importance required that an expert in the field
come to have specific total responsibility in regard to E-rate reimbursement. Mr. Biggs' background as an attorney brings a set of tools in his toolkit to help him learn that process. He actually came in certainly knowing a lot more than I even know today, but has grown tremendously in understanding. We also contracted with a recognized expert in the field of E-rate that serves a number of states
that he will allude to a little bit further in his comments in trying to see that we do this in an appropriate manner. So, Mr. Biggs,
Speaker 70
22:29
I'll yield to you. Thank you, Mr. Wood. Just to dive a little bit deeper into that
Speaker 68
22:34
background. Would you introduce yourself, please, Father? Yeah, Corey Biggs from the
Speaker 70
22:39
Department of Education. Thank you. To dive a little bit deeper into the background, Part of the reason that ADE made the determination to move E-Rate under our agency as opposed to DIS on behalf of our agency,
as it had been done in the past, is because of a couple of issues that date back to 2012. As many of you probably know from recent reports, the state application, The application for the state's network for e-rape funding has not been fully funded, again, dating back to 2012. And the stated reason for that was an issue that USAC, which is the Universal Service Administrative Company,
they're the quasi-public agency that administers the e-rape funding program for public schools on behalf of the FCC. they had taken exception to a contract renewal date that ran afoul of E-rate rules. The rules state that there's a certain window in which state contract renewals need to occur, and it had been the accepted practice within the state of Arkansas that those contracts were renewed at a date that fell outside that window.
That had been going on for at least a dozen years without incident, but USAC noticed it in 2012, and they have subsequently flagged each of our state applications since that time. Altogether, there's probably, we think, about $15 million in funds that we have applied for but have yet to receive at this point if you date back to 2012. and moving forward, ADE has assumed responsibility for filing that state E-rate application
starting with the 2015-2016 funding year. The deadline for that application is March 26th of 2015. With regard to attempts to recover the $15 million that's outstanding, we have a memorandum of understanding with DIS, and we've been working very closely between our two agencies to try to accomplish that, to answer any review questions that we can for the FCC and for USAC. As part of that process, we sent a delegation from ADE to Washington, D.C.
to meet with representatives from the FCC back in December. At that point, we also learned that there is an issue that has come up from their perspective. We think that it's really a case of them taking a view that is informed by what we know about technology and about broadband in 2015 and sort of retroactively looking through that lens to what happened in 2012 and before. But that issue is with regard to what they deem as duplicative services.
In very general terms, the state's network that we've been operating off of for some time is AppScan, and AppScan is what most schools around the state, if not all schools around the state, have been using for data transmission for things like student grades and school finance to send that information to the Department of Education. outside of that the vast majority of arkansas schools have contracted with private providers
in their areas for connectivity in the classroom the fcc views that situation as them being asked to pay for the same service internet service twice once for abscan and once for the private provider connectivity that each school district has been getting that's entered into a contract And we took exception to that with the FCC, and we will continue to work with them in response to review questions on that topic should we get them.
We view the data transmission as completely separate from the connectivity, so there's really no duplication of services there. But that's a potential secondary issue that we may be dealing with going forward. To assist us with that, as Mr. Wood alluded to, we've also contracted with an organization out of Edmond, Oklahoma, called Funds for Learning. They've been among the leading experts in the field of E-rate dating back to 1997 to the beginning of the E-rate program.
And they come with a very good reputation. They come with good relationships with the FCC. They accompanied us on that trip to D.C. And in addition to what they're doing to support our state application, they have also been providing support to each school district around the state as they file their own individual E-Rate applications for district-level purchases of technology. And they have also made available through an agreement with ADE license,
one per school district for a tool of theirs called E-Rate Miniature, which is intended to streamline that process. the application process at the district level. Among other developments since ADE took over are several announcements from the FCC and from their chairman over the last couple of months. They have obviously been changing a lot about the E-rate program and trying to increase funding for that, trying to increase the ways in which it can be utilized for broadband
and for 21st century technologies. And as a part of that, they've been encouraging states to do certain things, such as building their networks in certain ways and making sure that they can connect their schools in ways that they are incentivizing through the E-Rate program. So in short, we've come to the conclusion that we know that a solution is needed to bring more affordable higher-speed Internet access to Arkansas students and that any proposed solution also needs to address concerns over potentially duplicative services
and needs to position the state to capitalize on E-rate funds and particularly to capitalize on the opportunities that were created with the changes by the FCC. Where we're at in the process today is that ADE has made our best attempt to help the state arrive at that solution. We issued an RFP, a request for proposals, on December the 5th of last year. That bid window closed on January the 16th.
And the basic network design that's contained in that RFP is for the Internet to run on private provider networks and for that connectivity to be purchased by ADE. and then for any connections that need to happen to take that Internet access from the private provider networks and run them to a single demarcation point at each school district, which the Department of Education would then pick up the tab for transporting it from point A to point B.
and then each district would have the choice as to whether to use it in their district or to maintain their current relationship with their private provider one-to-one. Obviously, that would take time. Nobody's going to ask any district to try to get out of any existing contracts with their private provider. So that's the basic structure, and we, in our minds anyway, and with the way that we've budgeted, we've been looking at trying to do that for roughly the same $11 million
that we've been spending annually with DIS for AppScan up to this point. And we believe that that's a likelihood, though where we're at as of today is that those bids are at the Office of State Procurement and they're going through their process to make sure that everything's up to their standards. And then we have an evaluation team, and again, working between ADE and DIS. That evaluation team is expected to review those bids when they are released by the Office of State Procurement,
committee? Representative Walker, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm probably not up to snuff on this, but are there some districts who have had the benefit of broadband over the years, while some others have not?
Speaker 70
31:40
Representative Walker, we've seen plenty of reports on this, and each one is slightly different. But in general, we think that there have been some connectivity issues, but largely they've been issues of affordability. So that some schools have been able to connect for less of a cost than other
schools around the state. Well, do you have some way for determining the schools that have been less able to afford the connectability feature?
Speaker 63
32:16
I think there's a two-tiered answer in regard to your question. A, all schools have had the opportunity in regard to the APSCAN network in providing financial data to the state as well as student records data. Part B is a number of districts, for varying reasons, have chosen to go well beyond that level of service that is provided by APSCAN. So clearly there are districts across the state that have greater resources in regard to providing broadband and technology to their students than other districts.
Are you in a position to provide those of us who would like to have that list? a list showing the districts that have more capability and the duration of that capability over time as well as how those students have been advantaged in those districts in comparison to the students who have not had the opportunity to have broadband have been either advantaged
Speaker 79
33:26
or disadvantaged. Actually, I think the best reference from the Department of
Speaker 70
33:34
Ed at this point is to the report that was prepared for the legislature by CT&T and was presented in December of last year.
Well, I'm concerned. That did not address my question. I read that, and what I discerned was that approximately a fourth of the districts did not have broadband.
Speaker 70
33:57
Is that correct? My understanding was from their characterization that roughly 35% of school districts around the state did not have affordable, high enough speed access to meet national connectivity standards. That meant a greater number, a third.
So since they didn't have it, I take it that there is some advantage to a district for having broadband, or at least to the district students. Is that correct? Yes, absolutely. Which means that those, that third of districts that did not have that connectability or aspect of school operations were disadvantaged on a comparison basis. So what I would like to know, and I don't want to get into a long debate, but can you give me, and this goes you, Dr. Wood,
can you give me a listing of all those districts which have had the advantage as well as those who have not had the advantage?
Speaker 63
35:04
I think that, and I'll ask Mr. Biggs to correct me if I speak in error, I think there is a standard established as reported in the report of acceptable broadband based on that standard.
All districts, to my knowledge, have had broadband at different levels. And specifically in regard to your question, I think we could identify a standard and perhaps use the standard that was used in the study for the legislature and provide a list of names of districts relevant to
that. Well, I'm a little concerned because of the concept of Lakeview, which is that all students, all schools are to be equal. I read something that was sort of disturbing in yesterday's paper. It involved a coach in North Little Rock who teaches six courses in a day's time, and then he has to go and coach.
And he's compared to people in Springdale, for instance, where the coach doesn't have any classes, according to the report. and there's no way that that coach can be equally treated to the coach in Springdale and it's on the basis of wealth. So I'd like to just be in a position to make this wealth comparison and see how it follows down to student achievement and also equal opportunity for all people or whether or not we have allowed a wealth factor to creep in
which causes some districts to be wealthier and more advantaged and their children to have more opportunities than the rest of the people in the state. Representative Walker, are you about finished up? That is my concern, but I'd like to have that list of schools, and there is some evasion to giving me that, and the idea seems to be I'm going to give you what we've already done rather than what I want, so I'd like to have the chair. Well, you've asked for quite a few
questions, so I know we have some other things we need to move on
to. Sure, I understand, but I'd like that from Mr. Woods at the earliest possible time.
Thank you. Thank you, Dr. Wood and Mr. Biggs. We appreciate you coming today, and thank you for your information. Are there any associations out there that did not get introduced the other day when we were here? If not, I have one thing. The agenda, if you notice on the agenda that Representative Hendren has about four or five bills on there,
he has asked me if you would like to comment or talk to him about any of those bills, that you would like to see anything different done to him, amendments to him, anything that you have, please contact him. Those will go on deferred after today. And so if you don't like them, tell him. That's what he wants to know. So I'm just going to give that to y'all and let y'all talk with him and anybody in the audience. If you want to talk to Representative Hendren, he would like to have the input from y'all on those bills.
Any other business before this committee? If not, I'll entertain a motion. Motion to adjourn. All those in favor say aye. Aye. You're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1086
HB1011
Department of Career Education Presentation
Education Commission Presentation
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair
Unverified
Representative David L. Branscum
Unverified
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Representative Nate Bell
Unverified
Senator Missy Irvin
Unverified
Speaker 16
Speaker 33
Speaker 36
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Trina Miles
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 55
Speaker 9
Speaker 60
Speaker 13
Speaker 63
Speaker 70
Speaker 68
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 79