Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

February 10, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (4)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1228 · 5 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…er next Tuesday at 10 a.m. We have a special order today on House Bill 1228. Before we get to that, we're going to have Representative…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1012 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1012”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1197 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…g has asked for a special order of business next Tuesday on House Bill 1197. So without objection, I'm going to set that for a special…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1236 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1236”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
Representative Letting has asked for a special order of business next Tuesday on House Bill 1197. So without objection, I'm going to set that for a special order next Tuesday at 10 a.m. We have a special order today on House Bill 1228. Before we get to that, we're going to have Representative Petty present House Bill 1012 that's referred back to committee to concur in an amendment. Representative Petty, you can move to the end of the table and present the amendment. Okay. It's actually a concurrence. The amendment's already been engrossed in the
▶ Play
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Committee, this is just kind of a cleanup that had gone over to the Senate. Senate side, and I don't have a lot more to say on it. I've presented a whole lot on this, so if you guys want to read over it real quick, I just wanted to be quick, and this was something that I had given my word that we would kind of clean up, and I would appreciate a good vote on this. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Petty, are these amendments consistent with what was discussed here in committee and also with the Department of Corrections? Yes, sir. And is it my understanding that the Department of Corrections is okay with these amendments and with the bill as presented? Yes, Mr. Chairman. Okay. And that's all I've got on that. Representative Talley, you recognized? A motion is proper time. Okay. Representative Whitaker, do you have a question? Okay. Representative Talley, what's your motion. Do pass. With amended. Concur. Concur. We have a motion to concur. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? We've concurred within the amendment from the Senate. Thank you, Representative Petty. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. At this time, before we get to House Bill 1228. I'm going to recognize the speaker. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank
▶ Play
you, committee. It is good to be back home. I miss being on this committee. Education is boring compared to what y'all are getting to go through and everything. Just wanted to take just a quick minute. I know that now we've been here a month and we're kind of getting rolling quite a bit on the calendar and we've got things coming and in my remarks today, please do not take the amount of context that it is in regard to any specific bill that you are actually dealing with or will deal with in the future. But I just wanted to thank you first and foremost for being on this committee. It's probably the toughest committee that you can serve on with the the issues that you have to face and the complexities of them it's very difficult sometimes to have to hear the legislation that comes before this committee and separate out the sponsor or the concept versus what is actually before you in the technical language of the bill and so you have a hard job you've done a great job so far and I I just want to encourage you to continue, you know, to look at these things individually, to vet them. We're counting on you. The House as a whole is counting on you to make sure that the legislation that needs to stay in this committee stays in this committee, and the ones that need to be on the floor get to the floor. So, like I said, it's a tough job. I've been in your shoes for two terms, and I know what you're having to go through. But we're relying on you, and so I just ask that you keep up the good work and that you've got to rely on the leaders that you have in this committee. Chairman Shepard, Vice Chairman Wright, you've got veterans that have been on this committee, Representative Vines and Representative Ballinger and several that have been on here. Lean on them. Rely on them. Representative Broadway is another one, a veteran of this committee as well. So lean on them if you're new to this committee. You can trust them. I trust them. And just keep doing the good work you've been doing. But I just wanted to let you know that we've got your back. We know that there's going to be decisions you have to make in here, and there's going to have to be votes you make to kill certain bills. And it's just part of the process, and it's not always fun, but it is necessary. And you play an absolutely vital role in the process. So I just wanted to lend those words of hopefully encouragement to you today, and if there's anything we can do to help you, let us know. Mr. Chair, thank you very much for allowing me to be a part of your committee today. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Now,
▶ Play
at this time, we're going to take up the special order of business, House Bill 1228. Representative Ballinger, you may present House Bill 1228. Without objection, I'm going to let, since we had to end in the middle of the presentation last time, I'm going to let Representative Boucher make a few remarks just kind of to refresh everybody's memory on this bill. Then we'll go to any questions and to the public comment and proceed from there.
▶ Play
Thank you committee I will keep this this short basically went through my presentation last time and all y'all were here so so you heard it there have been some changes some amendments that we're making on this that just helps alleviate some concerns and frankly I think will make this a better process as we go forward and doesn't doesn't hurt the intent of the bill and so I'm going to go over what those changes are that way it may may help alleviate some concerns and then also I'm going to try to chase away some boogeymen it seems like there's a lot of a lot of things that people have kind of said that this bill does that is is it's pretty pretty far from from reality and so I'm going to just try to address some of those real quickly and then we'll move move forward first off let me let me do this let me kind of go over some some of the amendments that's going to happen to the bill so if you if you look and where we talk about definitions, we're going to actually just use the word substantial burden. In the reality, there's states that use burden. Some states use substantial burden. They're pretty much interpreted the same way. So we're going to put the word substantial burden there. I think that it makes it where it's more closely affiliated with the federal RFRA. It alleviates some heart burden, some concern from some people. And so we're going to insert the word substantial in front of the definition of burden. It'll be substantial burden. There's a couple other places that we're going to do this. Now, what we're going to do, if we can get this voted out of committee, then we're going to put it on the floor, vote it out, and we'll amend it when it gets to the Senate end. Now, I've got agreements from some people that that's what we're going to do, and so these amendments will be made. We're going to vote it out today, hopefully, and then these amendments will be made before it makes it to the Senate end. The next thing is on the definitions of demonstrates. We agreed to remove that definition altogether, so that's paragraph 3 still under subsection 403 and so if you were going to delete that altogether and then something else I want to want to point out because this has been a bit of a confusion we talked about last time but I'm going to mention it again is under the definitions in paragraph 9 the state action just realize that it actually requires some sort of state action for there to be a violation and we'll get to an amendment that will make this even more clear but coming into the meat of the bill itself is subparagraph 404 and it says a state action shall not burden a person's right to exercise religion and so forth so we are only talking about a state action so private individual private individual unless there is some sort of ordinance some sort of state law some sort of something in there that creates some sort of state action there's no way that employee can sue their employer on it also in this in this paragraph you see it says rule general applicability unless it demonstrates, and we're going to remove the clear and convincing evidence from that section as well. Now, coming over to, well, under subsection 123406 in paragraph A, it's going to be, say, substantially the same thing, but if you look at the last kind of phrase, regardless of whether the state or one of its political subdivisions is party to the proceeding. We're moving that up to the top part of this to make it real clear that what we're talking about is even if the party is not, or even if the state's not a party to this, that there can be a lawsuit brought, but it's only in violation of this subchapter. And so we're actually going to remove the word subchapter here, and we're going to reference 16.123.404 just to make it real clear that what's required here is for there to be some sort of state action in order for a lawsuit to be brought so um so anyway if this this protects the individual who because of their conscious because of their religious beliefs can't go in and engage in certain activities so if it's a butcher who's a who's a muslim he doesn't deal in pork you can't make him deal in pork if it's a christian who who doesn't do same-sex weddings and then then you can't force them to do same-sex weddings you know it's it's it allows them to to go back and rely on what they're conscious and what their deeply held religious beliefs you know are and rely on that okay under 16 123 407 we we're going to include county jails we're including Department of Corrections Community Corrections we're including county jails and being exempted the reality is that already protected under a provision called our lupa and that's usually they bring federal suits they don't bring state suits I don't know that it's going to make any difference but it does make the the sheriff's feel better so we're going to do that and get sheriffs on board with it. The reality is most of the concerns that I felt like were legitimate concerns, we were able to get them addressed, and I really appreciate the help with that. One other amendment that will probably also happen on it, or I'll say will happen on it, is there's a provision that we're going to do that requires if there is repeated claims under the RFRA that they can be barred from bringing those claims. That actually brings DF&A on board with it. So we're going to amend that as well. So it prevents them from bringing claims. If they're proven to be frivolous, they can't bring them time and time again, which that's not what the intent of this bill is, is to provide some tool for someone to create a lot of hassle for people. So those amendments will be, like I said, included on the bill when it goes over to the Senate end. And if I could just address a couple more things, then I'll go to questions. Representative
▶ Play
Ballinger, I just want to make sure Additionally, I think you had discussed, or we had discussed, under 404, there would be additional cleanup, similar to what you've already talked about. Substantial would be added before burden. Any place you see the word burden, we'll say substantial burden. And by clear and convincing evidence would be struck from 404. Struck any place you see clear and convincing evidence. Thank you. I just want to make sure we had for the benefit of everybody on the committee.
▶ Play
Yeah, we'll have consistency in that. Issue of polygamy, there's a Supreme Court decision, Reynolds v. United States, that was under the clear and convincing standard that says polygamy is that there's compelling governmental interest. Least restrictive is to make it one spouse. So that has already been adjudicated. There's no way that this bill leads into polygamy. Parental rights are already if you're going to take someone's parental rights you're already under the clear and convincing evidence standard so we're not increasing a standard there and if you have the protection of a child it's already been adjudicated that there is compelling governmental interest to protect child so you can't abuse a child domestic violence there's RFRA has never ever ever ever been used successfully successfully to protect somebody in domestic violence case these are all red herrings thrown up to in order to and frankly what I'd say is if someone's using one of these arguments I think you should question their motive there's something else going on there because anybody who's an attorney who's going to use one of these arguments they're you know that they know better than to know that that's the case so there's there's no you know there's no provision for that and no provision for discrimination you know the the Civil Rights Act of 1964 it's already been adjudicated that civil rights are compelling governmental interests so there's no way that you're going to be able to use anything that's a protected class, you can't use a RFRA to discriminate against it. Now, there is kind of a balance that is struck. That's the point of this RFRA, is it makes it where, just like right now, if you are a landlord, you have, you're actually under Arlupa, which is the same standard that protects prisoners, and, you know, landlords still are not able to discriminate, but if it's a situation where there's someone who can prove that they have a deeply held religious belief, and they're renting out their garage apartment under our lupa they have some sort of protections well this actually would would provide those same type of protection but they're not as necessary under our lupa or under land use because they already have our lupa this just provides those same type of protections for other people in other places and you know i'd be happy to answer any questions we went through a lot of questions last time so you know i you know i would like to try to make sure we have plenty of room for for the
▶ Play
public to to have their comments as well So, Representative Ballinger, I do have a question or two, and you and I have spent quite a bit of time, even this morning, talking through some of the concerns that I had and some of the language that you've actually addressed here. Is it correct that after these changes are made that this bill becomes substantially identical to the federal RFRA that was voted on in 1993 that was sponsored by Senator Chuck Schumer and was signed by President Clinton. That's correct. And the federal RFRA is still the law today, is that
▶ Play
correct? On federal cases. So in 1997, it was the part that pertained to the states was struck down on federalism grounds, basically saying federal government doesn't have the right to create these new protected standards within the states. And so that's why most states went after 97 and started creating state RFRAs.
▶ Play
And with these changes, have we moved closer to the traditional strict scrutiny or the Sherbert test that had essentially been the law since 1963? That's correct. Basically, that's where we're at. How many states have passed a state RFRA? Like
▶ Play
this, it's somewhere around 20, but then there's several other states that have constitutional amendments that is a state RFRA. And then there's several other states that interpret their – through their Supreme Court, they've had rulings that puts them back under the Sherbert test, the strict scrutiny. And so all but 11 or 12 states currently have some form of protection just like
▶ Play
this. And are those states – are those only southern states, or are
▶ Play
there other states that have passed this? No, Michigan has passed a RFRA. I think New Hampshire has passed a RFRA. There's several other states. I mean, honestly, when it first happened, it was pretty broadly acceptable that everybody wanted religious protections protected. It's only become recently that it's been even controversial. Thank
▶ Play
you, Representative Ballinger. Are there other questions? Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. I'm very hesitant to ask you any questions, Representative, just because there were so many questions. And thank you, Mr. Chairman, for really clearing up a lot there that really gives me added comfort. Can you just, for us non-attorneys, give us the poor man's version of what this does? I'm sorry I'm so slow, but if you don't mind, just once again, just kind of in a nutshell, what this does in conjunction, and you and I had some conversation yesterday and really cleared up a lot of it for me, but if you would for
▶ Play
our audience, for our committee. What it does is it takes an incremental step closer and puts us back into the position we were prior to 1990 in protecting religious freedoms. Currently in Arkansas, a law could be considered to be constitutional as long as it's generally applied to everybody and it's not pointed at some particular religion. And so it creates really a low standard. So as long as people don't make it real clear that they're picking on one religion, then most statutes and ordinances and so forth could be considered to be enforceable. Well, this just moves it a little bit closer to saying that if a state actor or a city decides to infringe, or not decides, if they pass a bill and it does infringe liberty, it gives a tool. It's not a get-out-of-jail-free card. It's not an automatic hey, you win. It gives a tool to try to balance it out and make it where the individual, the citizen, has the ability to say, hold on a second, this does infringe on my First Amendment rights. And so it gives them the ability to have that defense or
▶ Play
adjudicate that. Mr. Chairman, may I have to follow up just very quickly? Yes. So just to make sure I understand, this is really just taking us back to the I Miss Mayberry days, really. I don't know if it goes that far back, but it goes back to 1990. Yeah, that's not
▶ Play
Mayberry. And frankly, between 1993 and 1997, we had a federal RFRA that already provided these protections. The problem is in 1997, they said, those don't apply to states. And I understand that. It was on purely federalism, you know, you could call it state rights ground. But now the states have the obligation, I think, to go back and provide
▶ Play
that protection. Excellent. Thank you so much. Thank you. Okay, seeing no further questions, we're going to move over to the sign-up sheet. speaking against the bill, Michael Mosley. Mr. Mosley, if you would take a seat at the end of the table, state your name and who you appear on behalf of,
▶ Play
Speaker 52 18:46
and then you would make your statement. I'm Mike Mosley. I'm here on behalf of the Arkansas Municipal League. We're a 500-member city organization. I'm a constitutional lawyer. I defend cities across the state. Lawsuit under this law gets filed. I'll be the one to defend it. I've just heard about the amendments. This is the first I've heard about the amendments. I haven't seen the amendments. I'd like the opportunity to see the amendments. I don't know why we wouldn't do that before we passed it out of here. But without seeing the amendments, I do have some concerns about the bill that I'll share with you briefly. The Arkansas Constitution already protects religious freedom and conscience rights. It says no human authority can in any case or manner whatsoever control or interfere with the right of conscience. In 1993, the state passed the Arkansas Civil Rights Act. If a person feels like their religious freedoms are being violated, they can sue under the Civil Rights Act and argue that it violates their religious freedom under the Constitution. This would be simply duplicative of that. I submit to you, though, that it would also encourage lawsuits, just like what happened with the Whistleblower Act when it was enacted. There wasn't a lot of whistleblower lawsuits, even though we protected whistleblowers, the state Supreme Court did. But when the Whistleblower Act got filed, you saw extreme uptake in those lawsuits. It's probably the most common lawsuit I defend. Whether the lawsuit is frivolous or not, it still costs cities money to defend it. Just a finding that it's frivolous still costs thousands and thousands of dollars each lawsuit that comes along. I think this is an increased burden on the courts, too. I think that it will create more lawsuits. You know, I think this is the opposite of tort reform. And I haven't used polygamy as an example. I haven't used child abuse as an example. I've sent around actual cases where in other states people are not using this to protect religious freedom. They're using this to avoid reasonable laws. People are using this to avoid zoning laws. People have tried to use this to say that marijuana is a sincerely held religious belief. Remember, this protects any sincerely held religious belief, whether it's in the New Testament, the Old Testament, the Koran, or the Church of Steve. This is a sincerely held religious belief. So in each case, how does the court determine what a sincerely held religious belief is? Do they use the Bible? Do we put the Bible in the code? It's not just the Bible. So what happens is you have to hire experts, and that's thousands of dollars, too, in every case. And so as written, we oppose it.
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Mr. Mosley, you mentioned the Arkansas Civil Rights Act, and you mentioned the Constitution protecting religious freedoms. On what standard will they review an ordinance, we'll say city ordinance or a law? If you're going to make a claim under the Civil Rights Act or you're going to make a claim just based on the First Amendment, what standard of review do they use?
▶ Play
Speaker 52 22:00
That's a great question, Representative Ballinger. As you said, 19 states have enacted the law. So the other states, the other 19, are using their own constitutions like I'm advocating we do. We've already got this in our Constitution. I suspect they would use strict scrutiny. The way that our Constitution is written, it provides more protection than the First Amendment does for
▶ Play
religious freedom. You're guessing that they would apply strict
▶ Play
Speaker 52 22:22
scrutiny? I think it would be a
▶ Play
guess to say they wouldn't. Well, and that's my point, I guess, is that if we pass this law, the statute, then what standard would they use?
▶ Play
Speaker 52 22:34
I believe strict scrutiny based on the way that the Arkansas Constitution is written. But this
▶ Play
bill goes much further than that. I guess I'd have to figure out how that would work, but if you would, you said that this has been used in other places to avoid ordinances. Can you give me a few examples of this being used effectively to avoid an ordinance in
▶ Play
another state? Yes, sir. Not just ordinances, but reasonable laws, I think. Okay,
▶ Play
Speaker 52 23:03
sure. A police officer in Tulsa, Oklahoma refused to attend or even assign another officer to attend a police appreciation community event held by a local Islamic society. I'm sorry,
▶ Play
I'm familiar with that case. I mean, effectively. In that case, they actually threw out the RFRA complaint, and it didn't stand. So some place where it actually, where they used the RFRA, and it was applied, and so it actually threw out the
▶ Play
Speaker 52 23:26
rule. In Utah, in the Perez case, they used it to allow a church member to avoid appearing for a federal subpoena to testify about child labor law violations that were alleged. It was used there. Was that a state statute or was that the federal statute? That was the federal RFRA, but if we're talking about equating this to the federal RFRA, this could be used
▶ Play
similarly. But, I mean, federal RFRA is already in place, correct? Not as applicable to the states. Yes, Chairman. So it is in place, but not applicable to the states. And Representative Ballinger's bill, you would agree, attempts to make it applicable or makes a form of RFRA applicable
▶ Play
Speaker 52 24:04
to the state of Arkansas? all? I want to be very respectful to you, Mr. Chairman. Yes, this attempts to make a more far-reaching version of the federal RFRA applicable to this state. That's correct. How is it more reaching? Well, again, I haven't seen these amendments. As it's written, it says an indirect burden. Let me give you an example of that. If we were truly simply trying to protect religious freedoms like Representative Copeland mentioned last week, the situation where you mentioned where somebody tried to pass a law to require you to perform a gay marriage, for instance. A law that said you cannot directly, this says indirectly, directly infringe upon somebody's religious freedom would protect you in that instance. Representative Copeland, let's
▶ Play
let the witness give his testimony, okay? Well, you can only speak when you're recognized. I mean, otherwise we would have complete pandemonium in here. So I appreciate it, and you'll have an opportunity to question him, okay? May I add one thing, Mr. Chairman?
▶ Play
Speaker 52 25:16
Yes. there's not a great number of examples of case law under the other state laws but if you look the cases that are being cited are all in the last couple of years it's starting to heat up but what we don't see what we have not seen are examples where people's religious freedoms are being trampled in this state that the state civil rights act will not protect that's my testimony any other questions
▶ Play
representative rushing you recognize for a question
▶ Play
yes Mr. Mosley you had you had said that you would be the one defending these cases and that you feel like there's an increase a concern with an increase in lawsuits are you aware of how many cases have been filed in other states that use a similar refer I mean can you give us an example of the 20 states that already have this in place, I mean, how much has their lawsuits gone up and
▶ Play
Speaker 52 26:16
cases been filed? Sorry, Representative Rushing. That's okay. You're fine. And I've represented Malvern, for instance, which I know is in your district. No, I can't. I can tell you that Representative Ballinger mentioned that he had seen 200 cases last week. I've had approximately a week to work on this at various angles. I can't tell you because, here's why I can't tell you, Representative Rushing, because the simple filing of a lawsuit in state court isn't easily retrievable electronically without spending a lot of money on what's known as Westlaw, which is the electronic research. So, I mean, it would cost a lot of money for me to ascertain that by using Westlaw, but I'm happy to try if this committee, if that's their pleasure. Follow
▶ Play
up, if it's okay. So basically what you're saying is that there's, from what you're saying in your testimony, is that we really don't know if that's a true statement or not. No, it is. Because we have no way to find that, and we're not aware of that right now. Respectfully. I mean, I guess what I'm saying is that there is, even though that you feel like it will be an increase in lawsuits, we haven't proven that. Is that correct? We won't prove
▶ Play
Speaker 52 27:29
it until the law. How could we prove it
▶ Play
until the law is passed, Representative? In other states, because that's what I was referencing is in
▶ Play
Speaker 52 27:36
other states. I can't speak to other states. I haven't done the research on how many lawsuits have been filed. But the lawsuits that are being filed aren't like churches trying to protect, you know, their religious freedom. It's people trying to avoid the application of reasonable laws to them.
▶ Play
Okay, thank you. Yes, ma'am. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Could you speak to the issue in this bill that troubles me that basically you can create a church or a religious belief of one person. So there's no protection for the person who may be either intentionally deceiving the government or may have some mental defect where they believe something is
▶ Play
Speaker 52 28:25
their religious belief? Yes, Representative Bennett. Maybe a church of one person is an extreme example, but let me use a better example. New Age religions believe that you, I, am God and therefore what I do is holy. People have used Corinthians to say nothing is unlawful. Can the Bible, even if we're just simply talking about the Bible. Can the Bible be used by people to represent something that purports to be a sincerely held religious belief? Yes. Whether anybody on this committee agrees with it or not, people will and have used this law, for instance, to try to avoid criminal liability for marijuana use. So I don't know about the Church of Steve. I know I said that. I do think that it opens Pandora's box to speak about what is a sincerely held religious belief. I know we may all have a common idea of what that is, but sincerely held religious belief, I couldn't simply define that
▶ Play
for you. No one, I don't believe, can. To follow up on that, given that the sincerely held religious belief, that's language that's utilized in federal statute, correct? I believe so. And that's been in statute for 22 years, you would agree that federal courts have applied that standard time and time again? I don't know about time and
▶ Play
Speaker 52 29:52
time again. I can tell you from my experience, Mr. Chairman, that it takes a long time for a case to get, for instance, to the U.S. Supreme Court. It can take 10 years. It can take 15 years from the initiation of a case. I think that we're talking about a law, the federal RFRA, that is still in a state of immaturity as far as it being construed by the federal courts. And I can't tell you how sincerely religious belief has been regarded. I can tell you that people have tried to claim something that I think that most of us here wouldn't agree with is a sincerely held religious belief. Maybe not with success, but somebody's going to hit the bullseye one
▶ Play
day. Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question. I just want to clarify And I know you were just mentioning in general terms my example last week, but I did mention extramarital as well as homosexual weddings. I didn't make a differentiation between the two. But to Representative Bennett's point about the Church of Steve, since we're on that, I think that's a catchy title. Thank you. Someone's going to use that for a domain, I'm sure. but isn't it true and having the experience I've done this multiple times to set up a church is not you don't hang a shingle and say I'm the church of Steve to get to be recognized by the IRS, be recognized by the state, there is quite a bit of work that has to be done it's quite a process and it has to be legitimate, wouldn't you agree? It depends on how you define the term legitimate
▶ Play
Speaker 52 31:35
A, and B, the standards that you've just suggested for what constitutes a legitimate religion are not in this bill. It simply has to be a sincerely held religious belief. And as I said, people have used Corinthians to suggest anything is lawful. And
▶ Play
again, going back to the mention about the multiple cases, you mentioned the marijuana case. Yeah. What was that case and what was the results of that case? Well, here's the results of the case.
▶ Play
Speaker 52 32:05
The case is Olson v. Drug Enforcement Administration. That's one of them that's in the D.C. Circuit. Here's what's going on with these cases where people are trying to use marijuana. The courts are scrambling to find ways to throw them out. And so that's why I'm not suggested here that somebody has successfully used the use of marijuana as a sincerely held religious belief. And I believe there are religions that consider it. The Bible talks about the Lord gave all the plants for our consumption. People have used that to suggest that the consumption of marijuana is lawful. I have not seen it successfully yet, but as I'll state again, these laws are relatively immature. So that particular case was
▶ Play
not successful? That's correct. Thank you. Representative Ballinger, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. You mentioned, Mr. Mosley, that you're a constitutional lawyer. Sincerely held religious beliefs. Where did that phrase first come from as far as in constitutional law? I don't know, Representative Ballinger. Did it pre-exist, the federal RFRA, by decades? I don't know, Representative Ballinger. Okay. It did. And is that a phrase that has been defined? I mean, I don't know. I mean, I'm not a constitutional lawyer, so I'm going to have to defer to your knowledge. But I can tell you, just from remembering back in law school in my study, I mean, 50 cases where they addressed sincerely held religious beliefs? And
▶ Play
Speaker 52 33:42
you'd have to educate me, Representative Ballinger, on exactly what the list are of those sincerely held religious beliefs.
▶ Play
Well, and I'll say that what it is is there are factors that's taken into consideration. So things like whether or not they congregate, whether or not they have a written rule of law, whether or not you actually see those things applicable in your life. It's actually where you see it actually defined oftentimes is whether it's a conviction or a preference. So they look at whether or not the facts are involved to decide whether it's conviction or whether it's a preference. And I'm not making this up. This has been the U.S. Supreme Court has dealt with this time and time again. And so when we did this, we used what's called a phrase of art, a term of art that has been defined over and over and over again so that we don't have to worry about the Church of Steve, and that has been taken care of. And I'm actually, you know, it is surprising to me that it's not something that you're aware of. The other thing that I would have a question about is me and you had a visit, and I asked you, and you participate in a lot of national conferences and so forth where they deal with municipal law, right? I did one this year.
▶ Play
Speaker 87 34:53
You're engaged in what's going on nationally, right? As
▶ Play
Speaker 52 34:59
it relates to some areas of the law. Mainly I represent police officers, yes.
▶ Play
Okay, and so my question would be then, in your national conferences, how many people are putting on workshops to try to deal with the plague that RFRA is in these other 38
▶ Play
Speaker 52 35:13
states? I haven't seen it once, but they all seem to agree that this violates the Establishment Clause and the Separation of
▶ Play
Powers Doctrine. It has actually already been adjudicated of whether or not this violates the Establishment Clause, and it says it does not. And the fact that you're a constitutional lawyer and you would say
▶ Play
that either means that you're misleading everybody or you're not educated enough. What was the Arkansas case that was adjudicated in Representative Ballinger? It wasn't.
▶ Play
It was a Supreme Court case, sir. Okay, I see no further questions. We're going to move to the four side, Denise Shoemake. You don't wish to speak. Okay, Jerry Cox. Mr. Cox, take a seat at the end of the table, and if you would, introduce yourself and who you represent. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Jerry Cox. I'm the director of Family Council. And my comments are very brief. We are, as an organization, we've worked on this issue for the past four years. And I want the members of the committee to know that I really appreciate the attention that you're giving to this issue. We are very pleased with the amendments that Representative Ballinger has brought to this bill. I think it makes the bill better. I think it creates a situation where a lot more people are going to be comfortable with this bill. And it puts us, as Arkansas, I believe, in the mainstream of where the other states are on religious freedom. I think if you were to visit with the people in your district, you would find that there's an uneasiness out there about people feeling that religious freedom maybe has been relegated to a second-class freedom. And what this does is it reestablishes religious freedom as it was intended by the First Amendment. And so I just want you to know that we are totally good with these amendments, and we support the bill wholeheartedly. Mr. Chairman, thank you. Thank you. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a question. Mr. Cox? Yes,
▶ Play
sir. How are you scoring this bill? Would you restate the question, please, sir? How are you scoring this bill as it relates to your legislative package and your members that carry any piece of legislation for you? Considering the fact that
▶ Play
we've been working on it for about four years, It's very important to us.
▶ Play
And what would the benefit be to the passage of this for, say, Representative Ballinger and others that have co-signed on? They would be doing the right thing. That's
▶ Play
what I believe we're all out here for, is to do the right thing. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. All right. Mr. Chair, thank you so much. Thank you. Mark Whitmore is recognized to speak against the bill. Mr. Whitmore, you can take a seat at the end of the table, state
▶ Play
your name and who you represent. Good morning. Mark Whitmore with the Association of Arkansas Counties. You're recognized. Well, first of all, I've not seen the amendments, so I don't share Mr. Cox's view that they've solved all the problems. County government, I'm unaware of a problem. I've not been presented, or county officials have not been presented with any issues here. It seems like this bill's a solution looking for a problem. Our main objection to this bill is that the state of Arkansas has a 1993 Civil Rights Act we also have the US Constitution so we do not see the need for this bill we feel like it's an intrusion it's going to impact our
▶ Play
operations any questions represent for all you recognize
▶ Play
Speaker 101 39:25
for a question thank thank you how will infect your affect
▶ Play
your operations well currently the the current laws certain and you're going to inject lack of certainty and it will cause a lot of litigation. Follow the breadcrumbs. This is going to cause litigation. And you have the obligation to tell us the cost of that of litigation. You can ask for
▶ Play
a cost report. Representative Rushing, you're recognized for a question. Again,
▶ Play
I guess it'll go back to my question that I asked before. How do we know that it's going to cause litigation and cost because there's nothing proven in any other states that it has. And so everybody keeps saying it's going to increase cost of litigation, but nobody can give me anything substantial to prove that it has. So can you lend to that maybe that someone else couldn't? Yes.
▶ Play
See, you're supposed to ask for a report of what it's going to cost. That's the obligation of the House. It's House rules of what it's going to cost the state, the cities, the counties. the department of corrections recently had litigation went to the u.s supreme court on religious freedom asked what those costs were also this type of issue the department corrections won at the eighth circuit they lost at the u.s supreme court this stuff is not child's play it's complex and you're tinkering with something that's going to cause litigation I trust you have that common sense to realize that. And I want to say that it's your burden when you adopt these things to realize you're creating a mandate. And it's going to have a cost. Ask the Attorney General what the cost was and find out what the attorneys on the other side got.
▶ Play
It has a definite cost. Mr. Whitmore, I've got a few questions based on your comments. What bills do we pass that are not subject to the possibility of
▶ Play
litigation? Well, first of all, normally you control the actions of the city, county, and state by passing laws. You normally do not set up the scenario to where they get sued, personally. Well, getting
▶ Play
back to my question, what bills do we pass that are not subject to the potential of litigation?
▶ Play
Most bills you pass, the litigation you see is a declaratory judgment. It has nothing to do with suing a county official, a state official, a city for money in which both sides have
▶ Play
a token's face. Again, what bills do we pass that are not subject to the potential of litigation?
▶ Play
They all have the potential for a declaratory judgment. This bill... And they all have the potential for litigation, correct? true but if I can add this bill creates litigation in which the city county or state may be held liable for not only your attorney's fees but the opponent's attorney's fees so we'd ask that you study what the cost will be ask the Attorney General ask the Department of Corrections what does it cost to go through these litigations that have these great uncertainties and with the So the form of the
▶ Play
question we would ask is, excuse me, to our counties and cities, tell us how many of your laws or rules significantly burden an individual's free exercise of religion?
▶ Play
That's the question we would have to ask, correct? Actually, it's not. It's how would the application of it do that? Most laws are neutral. This law right here is talking about neutral laws. what happens is after you leave here we have to apply those laws and then applying them we have to make sure that our application does not under the current draft burden on the current draft indirectly burden somebody's religious beliefs and whether you amend it or not it's not the law that's broken it's the application of the execution so you're adding that element to all city County and state officials and you're putting a target on them. I can say you may sue us, bring litigation, get attorney's fees, and even if one dollar is compensated for, the attorney's fees are to
▶ Play
be paid. I guess I'm just not following your testimony because based on what Mr. Mosley told us, his testimony was this was duplicative and there were already protections in the Constitution protecting against these very things. Sure, let me explain. So I'm not following if state, if county, if the state, counties, municipalities are complying with the law and if they're not burdening individuals free exercise of religion, regardless of what religion it is, then there shouldn't be a cost to the state, county, or the locale. Now, true, with any bill we pass, particularly in judiciary, individuals can make claims based on that, can bring frivolous litigation, correct? Correct. And that's what summary judgment is for, correct? And that's what Rule 11 sanctions are for if an attorney is bringing frivolous claims, correct? Well, let me answer the question you've asked. Well, the answer to my last question, we have tools for that. Rule 11 applies, sure. Summary judgment, Rule 11, the
▶ Play
list goes on and on and on. But there's, A, there's still mitigation costs. I think what Mr. Mosley and I are telling you is the current law. I was here in 1993 when you passed the Civil Rights Act. You protect our Kansas. We have the U.S. Constitution, we have 1983, people that work for the government have more religious protections than the average citizens that work for business. And by the way, people that work for the government have the exposure of getting sued personally, going through all the time and effort getting sued. And since we are to have a standard, you're adding on to the case, for example, the Department of Corrections had. They won at the U.S. 8th Circuit. They lost at the Supreme Court. That's pretty complex stuff. So if you change the rules, you're adding more complexity. I'm just, and I guess I appreciate the testimony. I'm just not following it.
▶ Play
It sounds as if we should not take up any complex issue because potentially it might go to the 8th Circuit, which I like, by the way, and potentially it might go to the United States Supreme Court, right? I mean, I just don't, I'm not understanding that.
▶ Play
My suggestion is, is that if it's not broken, why add the uncertainty? And I think anybody will tell you that if the Eighth Circuit favored the Department of Corrections in their case about the beard, and then the U.S. Supreme Court ruled against them, that this isn't child's play. And you're injecting into this. First of all, this bill injects part of the Arkansas Constitution that none of the other RFRAs have. Also, you've amended stuff here on the fly. And on top of that, you're asking people that are applying laws, like if somebody calls for a marriage license or somebody calls a person's arrested and they're wearing their religious gear, do they get disrobed and put into prison gear? You're asking people to make those decisions between 2 o'clock at night and 4 o'clock in the morning. make those decisions that are already tough enough and if you don't believe it will cost ask for a cost report that's what we do around here y'all
▶ Play
ask for a cost report I think we'll be the judge of what we do around here and secondly I think I'll reserve my comments thank you for your testimony Representative House you recognize for a question
▶ Play
thank you Mr. Chair hey Mark Yes, sir. You used the example twice, and like a lot of people, when I saw that the Department of Corrections lost a lawsuit at the Supreme Court, that an inmate is allowed to have a beard for religious purposes, I presume he was Islam Muslim. Yes, sir. But did the cost in litigation, was the cost of the litigation caused by the inmate asserting his rights or by the Department of Corrections denying him his rights? I'll say this. The Eighth
▶ Play
Circuit would agree that he didn't get denied his rights. The U.S. Supreme Court said he was denied his rights. And my observation is that either way, when you inject a different standard, in which we're going to apply part of the Arkansas Constitution and part of what you are contriving here today into the mix. So the litigation cost is going to be incurred both by the department, which I'm sure was substantial, and you have to pay the other attorney's fees, which is added on whether or not they're – oftentimes you'd have to settle a case. If it's that close, you might have to end up settling. And I'm just saying that you're injecting uncertainty into this process, And a lot of people would consider that to be unnecessary because we have the 1983 Civil Rights Act. We also have the U.S. Constitution and the 1983 itself. Yeah, let me interrupt you because you said all that.
▶ Play
Okay. But the bottom line was you had an individual who had a sincerely held belief that's documented by his faith and the Department of Corrections. And to use another department's answer to a question in another committee, why do you do that? And, well, we've always done it that way. And so an individual stood up and said no. So the cost was really because we've always done it that way. Now, taking it a step further, I have a branch of my family that are Jehovah Witness. I love them very much. They're great people to hang out with. I don't necessarily cotton to their beliefs. But they have been persecuted for not saluting the flag in the classroom. They have been persecuted for not voting because of their faith And by officials of the school system By officials of city government, North Little Rock in particular When they came and asked for use of a public facility
▶ Play
So should they just not assert their rights? My impression is that they have rights now They have the 1993 Civil Rights Act And we suggest that this will create more complexity to the litigation. They have the rights now, both under the 1983 Civil Rights
▶ Play
Act and the U.S. Constitution. Is it really asking too much of the public schools? Is it really asking too much of city councils to stop and assess? Are we substantially burdening this person's free exercise of religion? I think they
▶ Play
do that now. That's my suggestion, is they observe the U.S. Constitution, the First Amendment, that has a stable set of precedent, and that this process here, this Bill Hill, will create a complexity because there's no precedent for it. That it's obviously going to create... But did the Department of Corrections stop and make that assessment? Supreme Court said no. Yeah, I don't know. So that's the point.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you. Representative Beck,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Yes. Thanks for coming. Sure. The question I have is you opened this up saying that you were concerned about the cost of all this, and to be honest with you, I find that offensive because what is the cost to make sure that someone's religious freedom is not? I mean, at what point would you say, you know, is it $50? Is it
▶ Play
$100? What is that point? Well, I wasn't saying about defending religious freedom. My belief, true belief, is that the U.S. Constitution and the Civil Rights Act protect people's religious freedom. What I'm suggesting is that the bill that y'all created or what Mr. Ballinger is drafting today on the fly, that its impact will not be known for years because we'll have, like Mr. Mosley said, it takes years for these things to go through the court system. So one set of lawyers, say you had a retired Eighth Circuit judge, and he thinks the decision is this way. Then you have a retired U.S. Supreme Court judge. He thinks it's different. Well, this just adds an extra layer where there's going to be more litigation, more settlement on those issues. I don't know that it's needed. I'm not aware of county government trampling on people's rights. That's
▶ Play
my observation. Can I follow up? but if that is the case then then your your your claim of all the the court cases that would come forward all right if you're not infringing on people's rights so these cases wouldn't come forward and if they do if it's frivolous lawsuits I'm not a lawyer obvious but if they do come forward we do have protections in there to
▶ Play
keep that from happening true the relegation will proceed but that doesn't necessarily there are rule 11 protections but I'm suggesting there'll be more litigation. I think that the firms that handle these cases will pursue more of them because of this this act and that that may not be recovered by the court or not. I mean that doesn't necessarily
▶ Play
come to true. But would you agree it does give a additional level then of security to those people
▶ Play
or another avenue that they can use to? It enhances their ability to
▶ Play
pursue litigation. That's my perception. All right. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Could you explain why, or let me back up, the cost that will occur to the county before lawsuits happen here? I mean, I think it's, having been a former city attorney. I understand this process. I'm not sure everybody else does, but before this ever gets to a reported case, there's going to be a lot of costs. Well, first of all, I think that there's going to
▶ Play
be a significant amount of, I mean, after y'all finish your work up here, I mean, a lot of laws you need, and we go out and tell all the folks what just happened, tell them what laws have been enacted. This law, just the process of the different officials are going to decide does that impact in any way my behavior and if you ever do get sued if you do you've got depositions you've got policies and stuff that you deal with and that litigation takes time people police officers have to go deal with the litigation and i i don't think there's any doubt if you follow the breadcrumbs there'll be more litigation from this bill and that that time and the attorneys for the city and the counties and the state and the schools is not recoverable from our standpoint.
▶ Play
And I guess really what I was trying to get to, I'm not concerned about the increased cost if we're truly protecting essentially a mainstream religion or some, you know, current religious belief. I'm more worried about the individual who doesn't want to cut their grass in the city because they believe that the tinfoil hat on their head says they don't have to. And the processes that a city or a county has to go
▶ Play
through. Let me make this point. The bill that is written here today talks about not participating in the assessment of penalties. And we already have every courthouse, if you've been in a courthouse for five years or longer, or assessor or collector, they constantly have people that say they don't owe their taxes. Some of them say for religious reasons. Some of them say because they read the Constitution differently. Some of those folks, I've gotten certified letters from people that said, here's the deed where I deeded my property to God, Jesus, and the Holy Trinity, and I'm not going to pay my taxes. And what's going to happen to me is they're going to latch on to something of this nature and pursue it and we're going to be litigating whether or not somebody owes their personal property taxes or their other taxes and the way the bill is written it talks about an incidental burden and a compelling state interest on participating in penalties and interest and programs and I just truly suggest that that's broader than our U.S. Constitution and our Civil Rights Act and that's what I believe it will result in and you can disagree with me but I do get to leave here or six months from now, Mr. Mosley and I and schools and folks have to deal with this. And without that certainty, I think there's no doubt there's going to be more litigation. Some of it could have been handled under current law. You're just going to create more of it in my mind. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question. Mark, thank you for coming. You used the word contrived, which I took offense to,
▶ Play
Speaker 137 57:19
because contrived is to create something that's not there. I've not seen the amendments at all, and so that would be my
▶ Play
observation, but go ahead. You know, and something I've learned around here in the short month I've been here is two things. Everything's an emergency. We've got to do it now. and secondly the cost only comes to bear if you don't want it if you want it the cost doesn't matter if you don't want it the cost and then the threat of lawsuits and now I figured out why most lawmakers are lawyers because all the rest of us sit here and we're scared to death to make a decision because we're scared we're going to get sued which is real smart on you lawyers parts to be quite honest But what I notice is in your legislative package, when you guys passed the water-sewer connection that we passed yesterday. I'm a county guy in that city. When we passed that legislation, so someone gets sued for sewer and water connection, there was no threat of lawsuits there because that's what was wanted. So my thing is you have not been able to ascertain. You ask us to get cost analysis of what the cost is, but we didn't bring that up. You brought that up that there's the fear, gloom, and doom of all the cost that it's going to cost. And if you're that concerned about it and your cohort's that concerned about it, I would have thought y'all would have figured that out. You would have had that cost here today. But what I've heard, you don't even know how many lawsuits have been filed. They've not been successful, and you don't know what that cost is. So we're going to make a decision today based on what you think may happen. Let
▶ Play
me just respond that you can easily find out what the Department of Corrections and AG spent on that last case. That's pretty easy. You can tell what they spent on attorney's fees all the way up on that one case about that beard, okay? And that's accessible. What I'm suggesting under House rules, when you have a bill, and this bill is talking about suing and money and attorney's fees, that each member of this committee has the opportunity to ask for a cost report. I wouldn't ask to give her a cost report. I pretty much know it's going to increase the cost. I mean, that's, you know, trust me a little bit on that. But another thing about the contrived part is you're taking a part of our Arkansas Constitution that has been dormant for the most part for the last hundred years. And y'all just had issue three, and you're about to draft legislation about issue three during this session. Well, you're suggesting that this legislature is going to draft legislation to interpret that provision of the Constitution that's been sort of dormant for 100 years. This bill doesn't look anything like the other bills in the other states. It's got that Arkansas Constitution thing crammed right in the middle of it. So add that to the lawsuit the Department of Corrections just had, that they won at the Eighth Circuit, they lost at Supreme Court. Can I
▶ Play
ask you, of the other states that have passed this, what states sounds like you're pretty familiar with the other states and what they've done compared to our what we're proposing can you tell me which states are closer to ours I really can't, I'm sorry you really have not studied those
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:39
other states I know that they don't have part of the Arkansas
▶ Play
Constitution crammed in there well they wouldn't have Arkansas's Constitution because they're not
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:45
Arkansas what I'm suggesting is that makes it you're creating, see what way lawyers work is that we have this decades of well I know how you work thank you and you by adding that you're just going to create more litigation that we feel I mean working for county government we hear about any kind of litigation I'm not familiar with county government trampling on people's rights and I'm suggesting that this is going to create more issues for us and you can either I'll give you a quick example in 07 y'all passed a law and what the county clerks said you're going to make it work 14 year olds can marry each other man and a boy and a girl. And nobody in the legislature believed us. Well, we were right. So six or eight months later, y'all had to come back and repeal it. And it was a national problem. And we're sort of saying from a county government standpoint, the city government standpoint, that there's no doubt this is going to create issues that we don't think are necessary. Now, you can get upset with me or you make it, you know, but I'm just telling you that we're in the business. We know that just having to answer the questions for law enforcement, just have to answer the questions for the county clerks. I mean, the county clerks just got sued. We're getting sued. We really don't need this to
▶ Play
complicate what they do. That's what I'm saying. And, again, I'll finish up with this last comment. Again, there's a thread of being sued, which is constant here, if you don't want something to pass. but you nor the last gentleman were able to give us any substantiated evidence of that and there's this great thread of it but there's no substantiation of it.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:32
I'll make you a promise. You give it about a year after this passes and you tell me how many seats show
▶ Play
up. This is just going to happen. I'm sorry. It
▶ Play
will. All right. Representative Ballinger, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I promise to keep it short this time. Just two questions, if I may. The first question is, and it goes to what Representative Copeland was just asking, is what you're saying is you have no, basically in other states, the 38 other states that have a heightened scrutiny, you can't explain at all of any increased lawsuits that have happened in those states?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:11
what i will say is in the time that i read your bill three days ago and now i've not done an intricate study on what cost it'll have
▶ Play
okay but you're but you're saying you don't know of it because i have actually done the research but you're saying that there's not been to your knowledge knowing i mean you're a person who's been out you you represent counties you've been around you've met with other other county officials in other states and you have no imperative evidence of the increase in litigation in other states absolutely not okay and then my next question is that if you don't mind could you point out within the bill where where the Arkansas Constitution will be codified the provisions from the Constitution are you talking
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:57
about your amended bill the one
▶ Play
I know well the amended bill will be consistent in this area but show me where where we'd actually be codifying that
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:06
section of the Arkansas Constitution well first of all on page 2 you reference 5 through 7 and that's our implementation of
▶ Play
article okay I'm sorry but that's your you're referencing legislative intent correct I was in about your lady let him finish sorry he's
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:24
not on the stand yeah I'm reading from your bill page 2 that the intent of this law which I don't think I'll put it in there for superfluous reasons is page 2 lines 3 and 4 provided a claim I'm sorry 5 implement article 2 so this part of this intent is implement article 2 section 4 of the Arkansas Constitution and states and it goes on I believe it's in here another location can I help you with
▶ Play
16 123 405 which page I'm sorry it's on page 3 and starting in line 26 yeah the Basically, okay, yeah, page 3, lines
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:00
25, no, I'm sorry, 26, 27, 28, 29, to affect, the interpret, or in any way address portions of this subchapter, article 2, section 24 through 6. Can I bring you back to line 24, though? I guess. You're looking at a different document than I am. Okay,
▶ Play
well, the provision right under 16.1, 23, 405. And what does it say? Let me
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:26
say one thing real quick. What you're asking is for law enforcement and county officials and all that stuff to interpret a 150-year-old part of our Constitution. Actually, will
▶ Play
they ever see this because will the Constitution be codified at all anywhere once it's codified? This part on page 3 will. Okay, but what does it say right before that? It says this subchapter does not, right? The part I'm
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:52
written out of here, this subchapter does not authorize the government to entity to burden religious belief, does not affect, interpret, or immediately address the portions of sub-chapter 2426 of the Arkansas Constitution and the First Amendment that prohibit the laws respecting the establishment of religion. So this
▶ Play
bill specifically says it does not include Article 2, correct? No, it says it doesn't affect it. Right. Yeah, and it doesn't interpret it. It doesn't include it. This is in pursuance of Article 2, but as our legislative intent, we want to enforce Article 2. I mean, this was in our legislative intent, but it won't be codified anywhere, correct? To answer your question,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:30
what you're saying is what this legislation's intent is, is to implement that article, an article that's 120-something years old, and it's not intended to affect it. Right. So you're asking law enforcement folks like me and Mr. Mosley... And it's not intended to interpret it either. ...to try to figure out how our folks can implement that constitutional provision in your law,
▶ Play
but it's not trying to change it. Right, correct. Representative Rushing, you're recognized. Thank you. I'm going to go back just a little bit in the conversation. When Representative Bennett pointed out the tinfoil hat and not mowing of grass, and kind of at that point it was kind of like us that are sitting here on the committee and we're not attorneys, we're not smart enough to figure this out, and then we have no common sense to be making these decisions. But you referenced that people were already having a problem with people not paying their property taxes based on religion. So this problem is already going on. So there's no proof that it's going to increase this problem. There's already this problem going on, correct? Yeah, what I'm suggesting is they're going to come in here waiving this act. And they're
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:39
going to go, not only wasn't going to pay my taxes before, there's no way on God's earth I'm paying my taxes now because the legislature says I don't have to. Well, they weren't going to pay them before anyway, right? I'm just saying, you know, ask your county assessors and collectors because I think you're adding that situation. Seeing no
▶ Play
further questions for Mr. Whitmore, thank you for your testimony. Speaking for the bill, J. Fred Hart, Mr. Hart, Mr. Hart, you recognize to present your testimony. Hit that button. There you go Please also introduce yourself for the record and also who you
▶ Play
represent. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Jay Fred Hart, Jr. I'm an attorney in Little Rock. I'm just representing truth and justice as I signed up. I happen to believe very deeply this bill. I'm not here on behalf of any organization. Since I haven't appeared before the committee before, I'll introduce myself. My name again is Fred Hart. I'm an attorney here in Little Rock. I graduated from Catholic High in 1967 at the University of Dallas in 1971 in the Arkansas Law School in Fayetteville in 75. My family is Fairmark and so my father grew up in Little Rock and my mother grew up in Connolly County so I have some roots here. Let's turn in and speak very deeply on behalf of the board. There's been a lot of misinformation here in my judgment this morning. I've heard from Mr. Mosley Mr. Whitmer that we don't need this bill because the protection law exists. What I have not heard from Mr. Mosley and Mr. Whitmer is a decision from the Arkansas Supreme Court granting the same protection that this bill grants. If they have that case, I'd like to hear it. I'm not personally familiar with it. In fact, at the end of his testimony, Mr. Whitmer stated that the Arkansas Constitution protections are largely dormant. I don't understand how you can have a provision that's dormant at the same time speak with assurance that it grants the same protection that this world grants. But even if Mr. Mosley and Mr. Rittemeyer could cite a case, it could always be reversed. The Arkansas Supreme Court has been known to reverse itself, as those other courts. This legislation would lack this into place. Mr. Moseley referred to people claiming that the right to possess marijuana is some kind of constitutional right in particular in criminal cases. Mr. Chairman, I don't know if Mr. Moseley has any criminal experience. I do. When I lived in Fort Smith, I spent two years in the Sebastian County Public Defender's Office, and I raised a lot of creative defenses in this general office. The defense is along the same lines, and they generally didn't go very far. And the reason is because Judge Don Langston and Judge John Hyland and the special county juries had the sense to see through our arguments. So at the end of the day, Mr. Chairman, I think you're simply going to have to trust that the judges had the sense to be able to separate out the wheat from the chaff. We also heard from Mr. Whitmer that there's going to be a flood of litigation descending upon the counties and the cities and the states. First of all, as has been noted by the committee, where is the record in the states of this tsunami of litigation? Where is it? If it's true in Arkansas, it will be true in other states. I'm not personally familiar with that. But again, I don't know if Mr. Whitmer has ever been in the private practice of law, but let me tell you somebody who has, that in general, attorneys in the private practice of law are looking for some way to get paid, like other businessmen or other entrepreneurs. And there is a tremendous discipline in not taking for those cases from the standpoint that you're going to end up spending a lot of your time and quite possibly and typically spending money out of your own pocket because your clients normally don't have the money to pay your attorney's fee. They don't have the money to pay the out-of-pocket expenses. And so typically in these kind of cases, the attorney is investing his or her time and probably some of their money to finance the case. And so I would urge to the committee that this is a powerful discipline in cutting down a furthest litigation. Does it exist? Sure it does. And as the chairman pointed out, we're arriving with deals with that. You can address the attorneys who are filing furthest lawsuits. It's already there. There will be furthest lawsuits. There already have been. There's no way to protect it. Unless you want, ladies and gentlemen, to just abolish the courts. You could do that. I'm not advocating that, but you could do that. That would eliminate furthest lawsuits. unfortunately the downside would be worse than the upside. Let me conclude with one other thing, ladies and gentlemen. Representative House made a reference to having relatives with Jehovah's Witnesses. And I'd like to talk just briefly about some real history, the history we didn't hear from Mr. Mosley and Mr. Whitmer. And because there is And in this whole idea of religious freedom, a series of cases, and some of you may recall going back, in fact, this is the original religious freedom cases, had to deal with blood transfusions. And some time ago, for reasons that I don't know how to call, I decided to do some research on this, and I came up with a couple of fascinating AOR annotations, and the attorney's no AOR, is generally the gold standard of research. And it is a fascinating question. The Jehovah's Witnesses and some other groups have religious objections to blood transfusions because they view it as a violation of the political prohibition of making blood. And it's a very strong prohibition. It's a very strong, important tenet of their case. Now, the other side of the coin, obviously, is that blood transfusions for the general public are fairly common, they're not particularly expensive, they're not particularly painful, they're not the sort of things that would, in fact, typically they're life-saving, it's a matter of life and death, and so this is a case, I would urge the committee members, where you have some real traction, you want to talk about the world and the world of race living, and when it really counts, these kind of cases are the ones that, where the rubber road meets the road. And in my research, the central case seemed to be, as I recall, the application of the directors of Georgetown University, which was a D.C. Court of Appeals case, which is the highest apparent at that time that these cases had gone, eventually in the District County Court of Appeals, because the District County were the federal courts of the local courts, and they were actually really against the individual. Now, there cases going both ways there are cases in which the courts have allowed the person to refuse blood transfusion there are cases as in the application director of georgetown university where they required it they ordered georgetown university hospital to administer blood transfusion against i think it was a woman's uh well so ladies and gentlemen these are the real issues and And why am I telling you this? Because I think if you read these cases, and you're looking to read that, particularly the Georgetown case, what you see is a reasoned, dispassionate, and very intense analysis by the judges of the balance and interest. And where it really is compelling, where you really do have some traction, and I would suggest to you that you're going to see the same sort of thing on the part of the judiciary in Arkansas, that they're not going to take this thing for this. and argument that I don't have to pay my taxes because I'm the Church of Steve or whatever. I mean, we have judges who from the most part have a lot of common sense, and I know the chairman is a lot. I would just like to say for the record that I'm a graduate member of the West Circuit Court of Appeals, especially the members of the state of Arkansas. But anyway. We'll make sure that's duly noted. He's aware of that. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And in the end, ladies and gentlemen, yes, you can create all kinds of marginally variables. We could, we could come in with a bill that's like a phone book, all kinds of exceptions. And then we would have been complaining about it's too burdensome. You know, I think it's the reasonable and the correct balance of an important right. Religion matters, ladies and gentlemen. The free exercise of religion in our tradition is very important. And, you know, if Mr. Whitman's counties or Mr. Mosley's cities are truly, truly violating the important fundamental rights of individuals, then, ladies and gentlemen, they should be sued. That's why you hold the courts. So, anyway, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thanks, sir. We're
▶ Play
going to appreciate your testimony. We are going to shift gears here for just a minute, ladies and gentlemen. And we, Representative Ballinger, I believe, has an amendment, and we're going to address that. It's on your tablets now. Take a look at those. We're going to let Representative Ballinger present that. Then we'll come back to, well, we'll take some questions, of course, and then we'll come back. We have about five folks, it looks like, still left to speak for or against. But let's address the amendment first and then see where we are going forward. Representative Bounder, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just wanted to deal with this so
▶ Play
that we can make sure that we're dealing with the actual bill that we're going to pass out, so I appreciate the recommendation. I'm going to go over this real quickly. If you want to look at your tablets, you can see it on there. You see that any place that it dealt with the word burden, we changed it to substantially burden. If you look under the definition section, they basically just reproduce that. That's because the numeration would be off because we deleted the demonstrate definition in there that makes it consistent with the other changes that we're making. Then if you look under the next section where it defines state action or where it deals with state action, where it defines state action, we remove the language that, no, I'm sorry, all that is consistent with what it was before. Then, of course, burden is now substantially burdened, so that's been changed, that definition. And then you come down onto page two in the middle where this is the section that dealt with a private individual bringing a claim even if the state is not a party to it. We just wanted to make that clear. A state action shall not, I'm sorry, this actually is the part that says the state action shall not substantially burden a person's right to exercise religion even if the substantial burden results from a rural general applicability. This actually is the section where we remove the clear and convincing evidence standard out of that. so I apologize I'm kind of just went over the amendments as well so and then down here in where it says delete line one through five of page four this is the section that I was referencing just a minute ago that deals with the change in the application where it's a private party that's but it still requires a government state action we did that just to clear that up so basically took the last phrase off from that paragraph put it up to the first just like we said we're going to do and instead of saying subchapter it actually references the subchapter to make it real clear what we're talking about is is a state action is required before that lawsuit can be brought and then we included the the language that actually exempts jails from the from the the bill as well so I'd be happy to take any any questions
▶ Play
any questions for representative Ballinger in the amendment. Hold on, Representative Armstrong. We've still got some folks that we want to let be heard on this one. If there are
▶ Play
no questions, I'd make a motion to pass on the amendment.
▶ Play
All right. It's a proper motion. You've heard the amendment from, this is amendment, I guess, one. Is that correct? That's correct. One, our first one, to House Bill 1228. All those in favor signify by saying aye aye any opposed amendment is adopted thank you are there any but hearing no more further questions I'm going to turn the chair back to the chair but also
▶ Play
were to yeah all right we're going back to the public comment sheet here and I'm over down to is it Frank LeBlanc LeBlanc if you would, take a seat at the end of the table, state your name and who you're appearing on behalf of. It's on. Yeah, Frank LeBlanc. I'm here on my own behalf as a citizen
▶ Play
Speaker 163 1:21:08
of Arkansas, a resident here of Little Rock. I also happen to be pastor of Westover Hills Presbyterian Church. as we've heard as the committee's heard through the different testimony that's come up already in the world of commerce most forms of discrimination are against the law the business owner can't discriminate in hiring employees or serving patrons on the basis of their race or religion or their national origin we decided that as a nation 50 years ago that we would be better off by limiting the power of prejudice in our society. But there are classes of folks who are not protected that way. And as I read this bill, I became concerned about that. I'm concerned that by creating a defense of sincerely held religious belief, this legislation seems to target groups that were not included within the protections of the Civil Rights Act or other legislation, namely our gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender citizens. It seems to be taking advantage of that historic omission and to protect discrimination against them, in essence restoring power to prejudice. And if it's combined with SB 202, which would limit the powers of local governments to provide further protection for these citizens, then you would lock us into a place where a community that saw fit to extend greater freedoms from discrimination would not be able to do that. And that's wrong. That's wrong because full inclusion into the opportunities of a free society is as much a biblical value for sexual minorities as it is for any racial, ethnic, national, religious minority. Discrimination is not holy and I urge you to not take us back to times before 1964 or empower prejudice in the name of religion. Thank
▶ Play
you for your time and attention. Thank you. Seeing no questions we'll move on to our back to our list. I'm going to recognize Paul Calvert. If you would to take a seat at the end of the table, state your name and who you
▶ Play
represent. My name is Paul Calvert. I'm from Faulkner County area. I don't represent anybody in particular. I represent myself. I'm here on behalf of Liberty and Justice. First of all, I would like to kind discussed the issue of discrimination. It's often seen as a dirty thing that we should not do, but discrimination is simply choosing one thing and then rejecting another. Discrimination is indeed holy in many cases. I mean, and sometimes it's not even a moral issue at all. I may discriminate against certain types of food. I don't like broccoli, so I discriminate against it. That's a good and moral thing to do, and so it's not inherently evil. We all make choices whether based on who we make choices for who we marry and other things that we prefer over things we don't we don't prefer it's not evil to discriminate from from an inherent standpoint and when we're dealing with private property and private individual rights then discrimination is is essentially pro-choice that's what we do we choose that's the discrimination is about and that's what choice is about is discriminating that's not a bad thing to discriminate. When it comes to government though, discrimination is a problem. When the government says that because you're black you don't, you have to go to the back of the line in the courtroom for your case or because you're only four feet tall and the tall people get to go to the front of the line. So that would be an illegal form of discrimination in my opinion because it would be unjust. On the other hand, in my private business, if I want to tell people that, you know, you can't come into my candy shop unless you take your shoes off, well, that's kind of stupid on my part, but it's my right. It's my property, and maybe nobody will come to my business, but that's my right. I have the right to be stupid on my own property, and I shouldn't be shut down by the government for that. I think another issue with this particular bill is that a lot of times, conservatives want to promote local control and I think a lot of times that is a good thing however a lot of times the well one of the main reasons why we have government in the first place is because we try to prevent powerful people or groups of people from trampling over the rights of those who are weaker this can come in the form of a large man bullying a small man or it can come in the form of a local group of people forming a majority and then imposing their opinions on a minority of the citizens who have other opinions. I think kind of the main point of this bill is to prevent local bodies from bullying minorities. In this case, religious minorities who can't compete as far as on the field of votes to get their ordinances passed. In Fayetteville recently, there was a piece a piece of, there's a law passed on the city level, and the local people actually managed to overturn it after working really hard, and I thought that was pretty stinking cool. I don't think that happens very often, but they really worked hard on this, from what I understand. Let me think what else here. I touched on this earlier. Local control is often good, but I believe it can be good to ban local communities from making certain laws that violate people's rights, and I think that is what this is attempting to do. I think we agree the Arkansas Constitution does and should protect a person's right to their religious beliefs. I believe this bill gives citizens some tools to fight against a local government body that is running roughshod over their rights. I think citizens need that. I think one of the purposes or one of the points of having a legislative body is to actually make rules that are consistent with and enforce the Constitution. I think that's probably part of Mr. Ballinger's goal here is to help actually implement the Arkansas Constitution as it's written as opposed to just kind of leaving it in the shadows or to run dormant as it may seem. One last thing. I
▶ Play
Speaker 82 1:28:04
would like to state that I am disgusted that
▶ Play
taxpayer-funded groups are using their power to fight against legislation that helps to restore our rights. To me, this sounds like a serious conflict of interest. I should not have to compete with taxpayer-funded lobbyists. This needs to stop. And I feel like some of the people who are lobbying against this are doing just that. I have to come down here with my own money, spend my own time, and I have to come down here compete with my own tax dollars lobbying against legislation I think is good I think that's just wrong I will take questions all right seeing no
▶ Play
questions thank you for your statement we're gonna go back to the against list Marie Maynard O'Connell if you would take a seat at the end of the table state your name and then who you represent. You may make your statement. My name
▶ Play
is Marie Maynard O'Connell. I'm the pastor at First Presbyterian Church here in downtown Little Rock. And I didn't put it on the sheet of paper, but I probably should have. I'm also on the board for the Center of Artistic Revolution. And that is a civil rights and youth group for lesbian, gays, and transgendered individuals. And some folks would think that it's strange for a pastor to have chosen to be on that board. But my sincerely held religious beliefs led me there. When I first heard about this bill and listening to the representatives talk about what they are finding difficult to discern about whether or not we should vote for or against it, I found myself thinking probably most of the people in this room are wanting to support this bill because of their sincerely held religious beliefs and the desire to protect everyone else's. I'm coming from a place where my religious beliefs have led me to understand that there are people who are not protected, that their civil rights are not engaged. And that is, as Frank mentioned earlier, lesbian, gay, transgendered folks, people who don't gender express the way the rest of us do. The reason why I ended up joining the board of CAR was because I was so troubled by how many youth who identify as different, frankly, come to contemplate suicide. I mean, they are more than four or five times likely than their peers to contemplate suicide, and often they are more successful. What I realized was that the apparent purpose of this legislation comes in direct response to Fayetteville's attempt to enact a non-discrimination ordinance to protect people who were gay or lesbian identified. And those folks aren't currently protected by national, federal, or state legislation. If in the city of Fayetteville they thought that they needed that ordinance and then it was overturned, I kind of want to support the city's ability to make those decisions. However, I know that the people who are making the decisions here today are going to do it on the basis of their conscience. And you're going to do the best that you can. I think the best that I can do right now is to say that as a Christian, sometimes we are called to stand on the side of those who don't have rights, who need them to be protected. And our rights as Christians are not the ones that are really under threat today. the reason that this bill is before you is because it was thought that the ability of those people in Fayetteville to be able to put up a non-discrimination ordinance to protect themselves and protect people that they liked somehow threatened other people's religious rights their deeply sincerely held religious beliefs and I would just like to stand on the side of those who are not protected by the law to say that it is a Christian obligation to do that I'm against this bill with all of its amendments and I would strongly encourage everyone to think very seriously about how it would actually play out it would end up preventing local municipalities from protecting the people that they need from making legislation that they want I don't know anything about how much it's going to cost or not cost I do know that this would probably set back the ability of me to be able to tell the youth that I I work with, that the world is getting better, and that someday they will have the same protections that everybody else does.
▶ Play
I'd take questions, too. Representative Rushing, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Yeah, thank you. I do have a question, and you had said that your religious beliefs led you to be in the group that you're in, and I understand that and I respect that, but I also, I sit here and I look at Representative Copeland who has said that as a pastor he's against these things so while you're for them he's against them both pastors of church why should he be forced to perform these marriages you're willing to do it it's going to protect him from not having to do something that goes against his religious beliefs but you're still being able to adhere to your religious beliefs because you say and you're going to do it so they still have an opportunity to get married somewhere if it ever becomes legal or whatever, but Representative Copeland shouldn't be forced in order to have to do this if it's
▶ Play
against his religious beliefs. Is that correct? I think perhaps you misunderstand. I don't think anything about this bill is forcing individuals or pastors to perform religious ceremonies that they are opposed to. The state cannot control that. What I'm saying is that our current laws, legislation, it was mentioned at the very beginning, you know, RIPAs and FERPAs and and civil rights acts do not currently protect the classes of individuals who are gay lesbian transgendered or queerly oriented people that do have different gender expression those individuals are not protected by law and when we enact a law such as this saying that the sincerely held religious beliefs of the religious majority we should remember that this is still whether we like it are not probably a Christian nation, that those individuals are the ones that are going to need our protection. And so I don't think, you know, the pastor and I would have any problems at all with, I don't think I would be required under this law, or if we didn't have this law, to perform marriage. That's not what this is actually about. This is about the state's ability and the municipality's ability to enact ordinances for the protection of people. And we're saying, well, Well, you shouldn't be able to do that because it's against some people's religiously held beliefs. Okay,
▶ Play
seeing no further questions, thank you for your testimony. We've got two more individuals signed up, and then that will conclude the public comment. Stephanie Nichols to speak for the bill. If you would, take a seat at the end of the table and state your name and who
▶ Play
you represent. Mr. Chair, members of the committee, my name is Stephanie Nichols, and I'm an attorney from the Jonesboro, Arkansas area. I am not here at the request of any organization. I'm here to represent myself, but maybe even more than that, I'm here as a mother. I'm here as a parent. I am here because I want to see Arkansas do the right thing and protect freedom of belief. The federal RFRA was passed 22 years ago. We have not seen the hypothetical scenarios that have been played out as threats against this bill. Those aren't reality. The taxes issue, it's already been settled by the U.S. Supreme Court. It is a compelling governmental interest. We all have to pay our taxes. I don't always like it, but we have to do it. That's settled. The Department of Corrections, they're not even in this bill. We've got so many red herrings. What is the real issue? The real issue is protecting freedom of belief. The real issue is lowering litigation costs. If you want to see expensive litigation, you litigate where the standard of judicial review is not clear. I know there has to be a balancing of interest. Government has to regulate. Sometimes it has to step on religion's toes. Absolutely. I am all for that. I have worked for a public university for several years as a senior administrator. That's part of my past career experience. I've also represented a public school district in a First Amendment issue, so I know the needs of government. What I saw when I worked for a public university, we did something. We got legal counsel. If there was a tricky issue, if there was an issue that might pose a First Amendment problem, We got legal counsel because we tried so hard not to infringe upon our employees' freedom of speech rights, their freedom of religion rights, and we did the same thing for our students. If this bill makes our governmental entities think twice about whether or not they might be infringing upon someone's beliefs, that is a very good thing. I think we absolutely should join half of the other states, actually more than half, I think it's 31 is the latest counts that have some type of religious protection like this. It's about 19 other states that have RFRA type bills, but there's constitutional amendments and court rulings in 31 states. I don't see why this is controversial, to be honest. The data is just not there. but I do want to tell you what is there and that is the need I'm going to describe a scenario to you that I never expected to be involved in last year and there's a lot of misinformation out there about this scenario but last year in my First Amendment work I ended up representing 12 churches with a total membership of over 10,000 citizens because they were scared to death that their rights were going to be curtailed by the city of Fayetteville. And let me tell you why, because this is not widely reported in the media. The black letter of that law had no exemption for pastors and other service providers. Even if you provided services for free, you no longer got to choose which ceremonies you did or didn't service. I support freedom of belief for all people, including those who disagree with me. When I protect the rights of people to disagree with me, I am protecting the rights of myself and my children. We don't have to be threatened. There is room for all of us in Arkansas. Another thing I want to mention about the Fayetteville situation, to clarify that, it would have forced people to be subject to criminal prosecution if they chose not to participate in the same-sex ceremony. And if anyone has any questions about that, you can email me. I'll get you a copy of that ordinance in the subsections. It did pass. What was really scary to me about that process is I'm a very strange attorney. I don't like to go to court. I like to resolve things in advance. I like everybody to get along. I like to advise the school district or entity before there's really a problem. I like to come to an agreement in advance. So what we tried to do with the city of Fayetteville is we brought this information out early in advance when the ordinance was first proposed, like, hey, did you know there's a problem here? There's a problem with the way this text is worded. There was also a provision in the ordinance where churches could no longer have complete authority over their hiring practices. If you're a church or any type of nonprofit, even if you're the ACLU or Planned Parenthood, it's critical that you are able to hire those who buy into your mission and share your beliefs. That's absolutely critical to a free society. So for church practices, church hiring practices to be dictated by a city and for a church, for its leaders to be subject to getting a criminal record just because they violated the city's perception of who they should hire, that's a very big thing. And I think the good thing about a bill like this is I would hope what this would be is not a litigation magnet, but more of a let's think twice when we pass ordinances and regulations that could impact other people's sincerely held beliefs, even when those beliefs are not my own. I look at life as a big, giant quest for learning what is true, what is just, what is good. My beliefs have changed many times throughout my life, and I think that's the way it is for everyone. And I think the more we can do as a state to preserve freedom for that journey, the better. We need to remember this law still permits government to regulate. Government just has to have a good reason to do so. And I think government needs to be asking that question before we regulate. If our government entities are not willing to ask that question, that makes me a little bit suspicious, especially when I've worked with so many governmental entities who are working hard to get it right, who are willing to ask that question. I would recommend that you clarify the judicial review standard for Arkansas. I don't think it needs to be left as an open question anymore and we need to join the federal government and the majority of states who are doing the right thing I appreciate your time and I'm free to answer any questions you
▶ Play
may have Thank you for your testimony We've got one final individual signed up Kristen Garrett signed up to speak against the bill If you would, take a seat at the end of the table state your name
▶ Play
Speaker 180 1:42:34
and who you represent and then you may make your statement thank you Kristen Garner I apologize for my handwriting Arkansas School Boards Association I'll be very brief the Arkansas School Boards Association is a private nonprofit organization we serve the 237 public school districts 11 charter schools are also members k-12 public education is likely the largest employer in the state of Arkansas with approximately 89,000 employees and we're educating over 450,000 students. We share many of the concerns previously articulated by the Municipal League and the Association of Arkansas Counties and I will not repeat those. I will simply bring out a couple of additional points and sit down so you can consider this legislation on its merits. What we see is that this isn't simply the matter of restoring the former legal test that this is a substantial change and shift in terms of burdens of proof. It will now be the duty of the government, not the plaintiff, to demonstrate that the burden on a complainant's religion is essential to a compelling government interest. We believe that this will make legal defense for institutional defendants, such as governments and political subdivisions, such as school districts, much more expensive and costly the attorney general does not represent individual school districts in matters that are brought against it with respect to things such as policies or student matters. Even non-meritorious lawsuits are very costly to defend and are tremendously consumptive of school district resources and school district employees' time. And we firmly believe that money spent on litigation is money that is not spent on students and that is a poor use of taxpayer funds to have to defend ourselves against non-meritorious litigation. We believe that the current law presents ample and adequate safeguards for the people who do have sincere religious beliefs that are honestly being burdened by religion. We believe that this law will actually be perverted so that people who wish to have a more favorable burden of proof or who wish to take advantage of the ability to get attorney's fees, if they're even slightly successful, will be used particularly with respect to litigation brought against school districts by school district employees who have been terminated or non-renewed due to misconduct. A great deal of employee misconduct is, in some cases, misbehavior of adults towards students. The standard for anti-discrimination in a public school setting is more expansive than the strict scrutiny under the Arkansas Supreme Court. So there would be sort of a subject matter gap, and that's where we feel that we're vulnerable. I would stand for any questions at this time
▶ Play
seeing no questions thank you for your testimony thank you very much that's the end of our public comment list representative Ballinger you're recognized to close
▶ Play
for your bill Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate it. It is disappointing, and I understand a person preparing to come in testimony and not have the amendments that we made, but the amendments that we made makes this bill substantially similar, in fact, almost exactly consistent with the federal RFRA. So this is law, it's interpretation that's been around for a long time, at least since 1963. This heightened scrutiny standard has been around. As we discussed, 38 different states already have this. There's no evidence of any increased litigation costs associated with it. All we're trying to do is create a little bit, strike a little bit of a balance, create an incentive for a state actor to consider whether or not their actions actually infringe on someone's deeply held religious beliefs. And having said all that, I would appreciate a good vote, and I do make a motion do
▶ Play
pass. As amended? As amended, yes, sir. Okay. We have a motion for do pass as amended. Is there any discussion? All in favor, indicate by saying aye. Aye. Those opposed? No. The ayes have it. Bill has passed out of committee. do pass as amended. We're going to try and take up one more bill, House Bill 1236. Representative Balz, you're recognized to present House Bill 1236.
▶ Play
Speaker 184 1:47:47
Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. House Bill 1236 was brought to me by a constituent there was a an incident that happened in the district up there where there was a property dispute this gentleman pulled up with his young two year old son in the back seat of his car into a gate. The person that owned the property walked up and killed the gentleman driving the car. He left the two-year-old son in the car for over three hours and never told anybody what he had done. That's in a nutshell what this bill deals with. If you know of some incident that has happened and you don't notify to protect that child, that's what this bill deals with in a nutshell. I'll take any questions at
▶ Play
this time. Okay, Representative House, we're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Representative Balch. Have you discussed with anybody whether this bill maybe violates the Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination? if I have indeed committed a felony and they've nabbed me and the kid in the car example, if I disclose that, do I have a choice between committing this felony or violating my fifth? Have you all talked about that or have you thought about that? No, sir, I sure haven't. Okay. I'm still going to vote
▶ Play
for it. Okay, I see no further questions. Going to the list, we do have one. And the individual who signed up, Jeff Rosenzweig, signed up to speak with a suggestion, I believe. Yes. Well, actually, it's different
▶ Play
Speaker 187 1:49:44
when I have a suggestion. Okay, state your name. Jeff Rosenzweig, Arkansas Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. And Representative House picked up one of the three problems with the bill, that there would be a lot of Fifth Amendment litigation. Secondly, the evil that he is trying to prevent in this bill is already against the law. It's called endangering welfare of a minor in the first degree, and it's already a felony and does not have the Fifth Amendment problems. This bill would felonize the failure then to call, whereas the failure, in addition to leaving the child, whereas the child abandoning someone in a dangerous situation is already a felony. The other problem is in the other section of the bill dealing with the restitution. Of course, as I read it, they are including in restitution essentially using the child support chart to figure out what the deceased would have earned. And the problem with that, I say the problem with that, I think an unintended consequence of that is going to be that it would entitle the defendant in a case, in a criminal case, to a whole lot more information because he's entitled to defend against it. And so he would be entitled to know exactly what the deceased earned, whether there were any health issues, in other words, things like that, any children's health issues, which he would absolutely be entitled to or due process in order to defend against such an allegation. I don't think that's what's intended, and I think that type of stuff should be left to any wrongful death lawsuits that might be filed. Seeing no questions, thank you for
▶ Play
your testimony. Representative Balz, are you
▶ Play
Speaker 17 1:51:45
closed for your bill? I'm closed for my bill, and I appreciate a due pass.
▶ Play
What's the pleasure of the committee? I have a motion from Representative Armstrong. Do pass. Any discussion? All those in favor, indicate by saying aye. Aye. Those opposed? It's passed out of committee. Do pass with a due pass recommendation. Thank you, Representative Valtz. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. With that committee, without objection, we are adjourned. 3 3 4 5
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:52:22
5 5 3 6 7 20 10 21 21 21 22 22 22 22 22 23 22 22 22 22 22 23 23
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1012

1:12 - 5:59 12 segments 3 speakers

HB1228

5:59 - 1:47:56 311 segments 22 speakers

HB1236

1:47:56 - 1:52:47 15 segments 5 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
61 segments
Representative Rebecca Petty Unverified
2 segments
Representative Jeremy Gillam Unverified
6 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
57 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 52
32 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
11 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 87
1 segment
Jay Fred Unverified
17 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
2 segments
Chair Unverified
55 segments
Speaker 101
1 segment
Representative Douglas House Unverified
8 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 137
1 segment
Representative John T. Vines Chair Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 163
4 segments
Paul Calvert Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 82
1 segment
Reverend Marie Unverified
11 segments
Stephanie Nichols Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 180
6 segments
Speaker 184
3 segments
Speaker 187
4 segments
Speaker 17
1 segment