Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Education Committee

February 12, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (5)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1255 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1255”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1242 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1242”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1347 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1347”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1015 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1015”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1017 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1017”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
I'd like to call this to order. Chair sees a quorum. Today we have with us the Arkansas Community Colleges Leadership Program. If you'll raise your hand or stand up, be recognized. We're glad to have you today. At this time, we are going to recognize Representative Broadway to present her bill, HB 1255-1255. You are recognized, Representative Broadway. Thank you so much, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. i appreciate so much the opportunity today to present bill 1255 you will note that there are two bills that are companion pieces 1255 and 1256 currently we still have some bugs to work out in 1256 and even though they're companion bills they are quite independent so we'd like to move forward today with 1255 which is our uh bill to establish a building better futures program what building better futures is designed to do is two things first of all because of amendment 50 i'm sorry amendment 33 we do not mandate what higher education does but we hope that this legislation will enable, encourage, and incentivize them to create the Building Better Futures programs in various institutions. What these programs are is they are post-secondary educational and vocational programs for intellectually disabled students that complete high school, not necessarily graduate but complete. Right now there is a void in that area. We expend millions of dollars on our K-12 students and hundreds of thousands if not millions on our special needs students. Currently we do this to bring them to a level where they can function as highly as possible and when they complete high school they go home and they do not rise to the level in their capabilities that they could and we strongly believe that the creation of these programs will help them. Another goal of these programs are to basically make a section of our society, again, intellectually disabled young people who have right now been dependent on the system, become independent to contribute, to become at least partially self-supporting, and to have a feeling of quality and contribution in their lives. Many of you that are freshmen are not well acquainted with me, but this has been a two-year labor of love for me because the fact is that I have a 22-year-old son with autism. When he was in junior high, my husband and I started thinking about what would happen when he grew up, and we started looking. And at that time, when he was in seventh grade, there were essentially no choices for him besides for the program, the rehab program in hot springs when we looked at that we decided that was not quite the fit for our son and we simply did not know what we would do when he was a junior in high school we discovered that there was one program in Arkansas called project launch which is a collaboration between a local service provider lifestyles and the University of Arkansas and it was designed to give young people with intellectual disabilities a college-like experience and that was a wonderful thing for him. But I'll be frank with you, I'm from Paragould, Arkansas. Fayetteville, Arkansas is five and a half hours from where I live and besides for the death of my father, taking my child that I had carried around on a pillow for 18 years and plunking him five and a half hours from me, and leaving him on faith was the most traumatic experience of my life. For us, it turned out to be a tremendous success story. My son completed that program. He has a job. He lives in his own apartment, and he functions as a normal person would. We are enormously proud of that. We're also enormously proud of the fact that our son's social security income has diminished from $780 a month to $200. We have made a contributing citizen out of someone who would otherwise be drawing on the system. Something that we need to consider is that with the enormous rise in autism that no one can currently explain, as well as the fact that medical technology has enabled us to save many, many premature babies that have lifelong consequences, our intellectually disabled population is not shrinking. It is growing, and we have to figure out a way to include this segment of our society with us to give them quality, to allow them to contribute, because there are so many that have that capability, but they have no avenue to get there. We have found, through this legislation, through the 2008 Higher Education Act, a comprehensive transition in post-secondary program created by the federal government. But higher institutions often are not aware of these programs or have not created them, and this legislation encourages them to do so. Since my son started at Project Launch, there are three other programs now in the state, and I have with me today the Pulaski Tech 3D program, who are currently making application to become recognized as a comprehensive transition and post-secondary program. And I have invited them to speak to you about these programs. And so with that, I would like to introduce Bentley Wallace to come and speak to what Pulaski Tech is doing.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, Representative Broadway, on behalf of Dr. Margaret Ellaby, our president, on behalf of our faculty and staff, and most importantly... Would you please recognize who you are, please? I'm sorry, Mr. Chair. I'm Bentley Wallace. I'm the Vice President for Economic Development at Pulaski Technical College. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We appreciate the opportunity to be here, and Representative Broadway, thank you for your efforts to work on programs that offer opportunities for individuals with intellectual disabilities. The Pulaski Technical College 3D program is a workforce training opportunity that offers young adults with intellectual disabilities post-secondary education and preparation for employment. The program began as a pilot project in the fall of 2013 with five students. Nearing the end of its second year, the program now has 11 students. We are still in the pilot phase. Classroom instruction for the 3D students is provided in a pre-employment skills leading to certification in a variety of culinary and hospitality functions at the college's culinary Arts and Hospitality Management Institute. Instruction is also provided in critical thinking skills, independent functioning, and professionalism needed in the workplace. The classes involve instruction, hands-on lab practice, individual planning and coaching, and student mentoring. The ultimate goal for each student in the 3D program is to find and keep competitive employment. The program is focused on the students, their families, and their employers, and success is measured by the satisfaction level of program graduates and those employers. As a proven and successful model of workforce training for individuals with intellectual disabilities, the 3D program is currently pursuing accreditation as a comprehensive transition program through the United States Department of Education and will provide continued guidance and best practices for the development of the Building Better Futures program throughout the state. As Representative Broadway mentioned, we are in the process of pursuing accreditation as a CTP, and we expect that that will take another year or so to complete all of the documents necessary. At the point that we have that completed and submitted to the DOE, We anticipate becoming an accredited school and being that exemplar for the state as to how the Building Better Futures program can be successful in serving these students in workforce and economic development. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any questions from the committee from here?
▶ Play
Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Yes. Thank you very much. It sounds like an outstanding program. You've got 11 students now. I was wondering, it's a pilot, where do you get that funding, and what is the cost of the program for
▶ Play
those 11 students? Certainly. We're still in the pilot phase, which has been made possible through an affiliation with private donors, affiliation with Arkansas Rehabilitation Services, the Governor's Commission for Peoples with Disabilities, and student tuition that's paid by the student and their families. It is not an inexpensive program, but the goal of our CTP application is to allow us to receive or the students to receive federal financial aid to offset a large portion of the cost of the program. So because of the nature of the program, it requires a high faculty-to-student ratio, and the more people that you have involved requires extra dollars, and that CTP certification is critical for programs like this because it is costly and typically beyond the means of a typical student that would be in the
▶ Play
program. So did you mention the cost of
▶ Play
the program presently? Currently it's about $7,500 per year per student. We expect that with the, which is not significantly more than other typical college programs around the state, a little bit more than what a typical student at Pulaski Tech might experience, but not as much as a student at a four-year school. But we anticipate because of the features of the program that that cost will continue to go up a little bit. But, again, we're still in the pilot phase. We're still working that out, and it will continue to morph as we gain that accreditation through our CTP process.
▶ Play
But what you're saying with the introduction of this program, the cost would come down because you would have a different designation that would open you up to extra funding like Pell Grants. Well, I don't anticipate the cost to go down,
▶ Play
but I anticipate being able to offset where the money comes from so it doesn't have to come out of the student's pocket.
▶ Play
Yes, thank you very much. Are there any other questions, committee?
▶ Play
Speaker 25 12:16
Representative Walker, you recognize? Motion at the proper time. Okay. Mr.
▶ Play
Chair? Yes. I had two witnesses or folks to testify that would like to give brief testimony. We're going to public comment right now. Okay, thank you. Is
▶ Play
there anybody that would like to speak against the bill? Is there anyone that would like to speak for it? You're welcome to come to the end of the table and recognize yourself. If you
▶ Play
would, please state your name and who you're with, and you're recognized. Good morning, Mr. Chair, Representative Broadway. My name is Linda Ducro. I am the director of the 3D program. I'd just like to speak to the benefits of the program. I'm actually going to turn that over to Quentin Robinson, one of our students who will be graduating this spring and who is currently in internship and transitioning into employment. The only point that I would like to make, in addition to what Bentley has already said, is the importance of inclusion in our program, meaning that this program is conducted in a mainstream culinary institute where our students stand side-by-side in the labs with mainstream students. The benefit of this is twofold. First of all, our students, when standing side-by-side mainstream students, that is how they learn. They don't learn from other folks with intellectual differences. They learn from you and I. They see you sitting the way you sit and doing what you do, and they imitate that and learn. The other thing is that we feel that we are creating a culture in our culinary institute where people with all types of differences are accepted and valued. These students, mainstream students who are training our students, will be the chef managers of tomorrow who will then feel comfortable to hire them and welcome them into their restaurants and hotels. Thank you very much.
▶ Play
Are there any questions from the committee? Thank you. Is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? If not, state your name
▶ Play
and who you're with, and you are recognized. Okay. Hello, my name is Quentin Robson, and I'm going to tell you about the duty program and how much it changed my life. It has helped me tremendously. I'm actually in the kitchen now cooking things and doing different things. And I just recently started an internship. I am cooking and doing different things in different labs with different chefs. So many chefs like to work with me, and I like doing the cooking in the different classes in the kitchen with all the chefs. This is not an easy thing to do. You must pass sanitation first before you can go in the kitchen and cook something. If you do not pass sanitation, they will not let you in there. I wasn't doing this before I was at a workshop, before I was doing this. And I didn't get a chance until I came here. And so far, I liked it. And this year, I'm actually about to graduate this year, 2015. Quentin is
▶ Play
speaking for the bill Quentin would you like to hear would you like some
▶ Play
questions Sure, I don't mind Representative Douglas you have a question
▶ Play
I was just wondering what you would prepare for us as a committee your favorite dish maybe that you have become proficient at. All right. I've actually prepared I actually know how
▶ Play
to do a bread pudding. I just recently did that. Okay. And it's not easy. And I also know how to do a French onion soup for you. You're getting major points. Yes. And I can also do you a grill pork chop on the grill and I can cook you some other stuff also. Thank you
▶ Play
very much. I'm signed up. Okay. Let me
▶ Play
ask this, though. Any other questions? There
▶ Play
Speaker 46 16:44
you go. Thank you. Are there any other questions? Anyone? Quentin has
▶ Play
spoken for the bill. Thank you, Quentin. You're welcome. Anytime. Is there anyone like to speak against the bill? Anybody else for the
▶ Play
bill? Would you like to close for your bill? I just simply cannot follow anything. I'm
▶ Play
close for my bill. Representative Walker, you have a motion? I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? You have passed your bill. Congratulations. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. At this time, we're going to hear a presentation from Forward Arkansas. If Ms. Smith and Dr. Scandelberry would come to the end of the table and tell us who you are and who you're with, and you are welcome to present your program this morning.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair and members. My name is Kathy Smith with the Walton Family Foundation, and I'm here today with
▶ Play
Dr. Turn your mic on. I'm not
▶ Play
sure if that's on. I'm sorry. Kathy Smith with the Walton Family Foundation. I'm here today with Dr. Sharice West-Scanalberry of the Winthrop Rockefeller Foundation and and Jared Henderson, who is the program manager for Forward. And we're going to present from the PowerPoint that you have at your desk just as an overview of the program. What is Forward Arkansas? Forward is a partnership between the Walton Family Foundation, the Winthrop Rockefeller Foundation, and the State Board of Education with the idea of writing a plan to improve P-16 education in Arkansas with a specific emphasis on academically distressed schools. If you look at the partnership, the vision, mission, and goal, we have the goal of the vision of every student in Arkansas graduating and prepared for success in college and the workplace, and our mission is to create one of the finest public education systems in the nation. If you look also then at the next slide that it talks about who our steering committee is. We have nearly 30 members of the steering committee that represent across several sectors for the state, from educators, parents, community members, business leaders, people that have had a deep and long involvement in education either directly as teachers or retired teachers, those who have served on local boards and those have been very involved with the K-12 public education system. At this time, I'm going to turn it over to Dr. Scandelberry to talk about our timeline and our activities so
▶ Play
Speaker 67 20:02
far. And Cherise West Scandelberry? Right, okay. You're recognized. Thank you. I appreciate the opportunity. So we are doing this in phases. The first phase was to develop what we're calling a state of education in Arkansas. and you have that report at you all's places. We wanted to just get a sense of what is taking place in education in Arkansas to help inform and guide the process. It's also a public document so that all will understand and know what we're working from in terms of just basic data. Next, we're now in the process of gathering data. We want to complement the agency data with data from people. and from throughout the state. So we are now in the process of doing discussion groups, an online survey, focus groups, and the like around the state with various stakeholders, everyone from students to administrators, custodians, you know, everyone, to just be able to talk with them about and get their ideas around solutions and how we can improve education in our state. With the agency data and the qualitative data, we plan to create a plan by May, and that plan, again, will be informed by both sets of data and then ongoing assessment and implementation of that plan afterwards. So what we want to do now is give you a sense of what the State of Education in Arkansas report actually says, and for that, I'll turn it over to Jared. And as they mentioned, my name
▶ Play
is Jared Henderson, and thank you for letting me speak here today. What I'm going to do quickly, you have several documents in front of you that have been alluded to. There's a full report that is publicly available and accessible on our website, fordarkansas.org. But I'm going to give you all the two-minute overview of what the story, the emerging story is from that document. And it really breaks down into four pieces. You know, the first is about access, and it's a bit of good news. Due to a lot of purposeful effort over many years by this body, by educators at all levels, Arkansas has been successful in improving access to education and increasing, sometimes dramatically, participation in higher-level educational activities. A few examples of this in terms of pre-kindergarten. We have a top 20 going rate nationally. Our high school graduation rate is well above the national average. In the last five or six years, the number and percentage of our students that are taking both AP exams and the ACT has gone up. And in the case of both, the scores have either remained flat or in the case of AP exams, performance has actually increased while access has increased at the same time. And then last but not least, we're actually one of the top 20 states in the country in terms of the percentage of our students that are actually being admitted to and matriculating to college. We've also got a lot to celebrate with respect to policies and standards. And, you know, a lot of that's due to the work of this body and many of your predecessors. But we have adapted and we have pursued policies and standards as a state that should support improved student outcomes. And our report details a number of these things. But for a few examples, you know, we're now several years into implementation of Common Core. We have been one of the most aggressive states in trying to set a high bar for both school leader and teacher licensure and training. And in terms of per-pupil expenditure, we've maintained expenditures that are near the national average, even coming out of the Great Recession. And these are important things that we can build upon. In terms of student outcomes, however, though, I think as we all know, we're still below the aspirations that we would have across the state. And there's a real important opportunity to improve. A few examples of that, you know, with respect to pre-K, we know that a lot of our children relative to other states are attending, but we know that still too few are leaving fully developed. In terms of fourth and eighth grade math and literacy, our performance is in the bottom 20 in the country, and it's actually fallen slightly over the last 10 years. And finally, while I mention we're sending a high percentage of our children to college, were actually one of the very lowest states, second from the bottom, I believe, in terms of the percentage of our students that are actually completing college within six years. Finally, just to add a bit more detail to the story of student outcomes, although we have some recent gains to celebrate, we know that the achievement gap in Arkansas is still very significant and is reflected in economic, racial, and regional disparities. We see this played out in different areas of the state. And while we see examples of excellence in all corners of the state, we also, each region has a real opportunity and need to improve. And I will note, as we've dug into this data, we have found some really interesting findings with respect to performance. And, you know, one I would share, for instance, that in terms of absolute performance levels, for instance, the southeast region of the state has been the lowest performing in recent years, but they're actually the region of the state that has grown the fastest over the six years, which is something to celebrate, to better understand, and to build upon. And that's one example of something that we'll be digging into in the next phase of this work as we learn more about why these facts are the case and what
▶ Play
Speaker 73 25:33
we do to accelerate our progress. Representative Murdoch,
▶ Play
you have a question? Yes. Thank you, Chairman, and thank you for coming today. My question is, as you're interacting with these districts and looking at the state and trying to help us in our lower-performing districts, how have you engaged specifically with the leadership, the superintendent, school boards in those areas? How is that engagement going on? I'm happy to speak
▶ Play
to that. I think there are three broad strategies that we've been using to date on this. One is simply just expert interviews. We've been talking with a representative set of expert educators, expert higher ed professionals, directly interviewing them to get their knowledge and to wrap it into this. Two, we have online and still active right now both educator and community surveys that have been active for several weeks and will continue to be active to the end of the month. We've already received over 5,500 responses around the state to these surveys. It's actually quite an extensive survey. It takes about half an hour to complete, and so it's yielding an incredible amount of information. Last but not least, we've already conducted 14 focus groups in different areas of the state. These groups are comprised of parents, of educators, of children, and community members. We have 28 more that have already been scheduled all over the state, and I suspect we'll add at least another 12 to 14 to that total before it's all said
▶ Play
Speaker 80 27:08
and done. Quick follow-up, okay, Mr. Chairman. Okay,
▶ Play
thank you. Thank you, and I'm encouraged by some of this, But I want to make sure that we hit the targets that we are aiming at. And so that engagement is very, I'm very aware of the surveys. I'm aware to some degree in my area of the focus group. And what I would like to encourage you as you do this is that we engage directly. There has not been engagement. I represent some of the lower performing districts. And so I'm very well aware that they have not been specifically engaged school board members, superintendents and I think that will help really get you where you're trying to go get us where we need to get to as we certainly need those improvements those assessments to truly happen but they need to be real and tangible so that they can be useful in improvement so and even the surveys the focus groups that I'm aware of it's somewhat a little bit distant from where we need to get to touch so you can truly get what I think you're trying to get to touch what's really going on So my encouragement, please, would be to engage directly with leadership in those areas. When you come to the areas, engage with representatives in those areas so we can help make this happen as we really try to fix problems that are real and really need this attention. So I thank you so much for your efforts, but please listen and engage with us a little bit more on this. I appreciate it. Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, have a question? Yes, sir. You're recognized. Yes.
▶ Play
Thank you all for coming. I will have several follow-up questions, Mr. Chair, so I'll just take one at a time with your consent. I do have some others on the list, so I'll give you one and a follow-up. Let's see. This is not a public agency. How can the public have access to everything you do since you're
▶ Play
Speaker 67 29:19
not covered by the Freedom of Information Act? So we are making, this is, it's a process, and throughout the process, all of the data will be made available publicly on our website, And we will engage folks with our findings in actual meetings, whether it is the Rotary, whether it is conversations. We have a plan, or let me just say, we intend to make available at different points throughout this process the
▶ Play
data that we have. Mr. Chair, I don't think that's a real answer to my question. Then I might have misunderstood. UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT, MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC, ESPECIALLY SINCE THIS IS PUBLIC BUSINESS, ARE ENTITLED TO SEEK SPECIFIC INFORMATION RATHER THAN INFORMATION SIMPLY THAT YOU WISH TO HAVE DISCLOSED. AND I WANTED TO KNOW IF THERE IS AN INTENT TO ALLOW THE PUBLIC TO BE FULLY KNOWLEDGEABLE ABOUT NOT ONLY what information you all gain, but about your undertakings and interactions and intentions. And let me tell you the reason I ask the question. As I look at the steering committee, in all due respect, it is not inclusive. It is very dominated by the economic interests of the state. And those economic interests generally have not been demonstrated to hire poor people and minority people on a fair basis. And they have no demonstrated record of having ideas that move the state forward. I'm reminded of 50 for the Future in Little Rock where you have 50 people who are gauging the future for Little Rock. And in the 50 or more years of 50 for the Future, the future of black people in Little Rock has been dismal as the city has been allowed to resegregate with one side of the town being basically poor and bleak and the other side of the town being prosperous. it's sort of like the Lion King you recall how the people who lived in the thickets were the ones who were disfavored and things and things never got better for them and of course the Lion King was a wonderful movie and we all applauded it and we of course applaud what you're doing but I wonder how the people who are in most need are going to profit by by this Now, I won't go any further right now because I'm told that I can have another question. But if you could address that, I'd appreciate it. Primarily, the lack of inclusivity among a group which has no record, other than you, Ms. West, of, when I say other than you, I mean in terms of the leadership of the group, in terms of trying to improve the lot of the poor. What would you have differently? Well, first of all, I would have, if I may respond, Mr. Chair, I would
▶ Play
have a more inclusive group. Mr. Walker, if you could make those questions a little shorter, I believe they could understand them
▶ Play
a little better. That's a pretty long question. Well, I don't think that she did not understand. She didn't indicate. She wanted to know whether or not the directions would be different. And, of course, the directions would be different. They would not include, the steering committee would include people who have a genuine commitment to change, identifying the problems and relating to them. We all know that the main problem in Arkansas is race, which is heavily influenced by poverty. And we know where the areas are of underachievement, and we know that the width of the achievement gap between the haves and the have-nots remains.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you're not asking a question. You're making statements to her. Could you please just ask her a question? Well. Thank you, sir. and
▶ Play
I do need to move on if you're pretty quick. Well, no, I'll defer to you because there are others. I'll get another chance to say. Representative Armstrong, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is very similar. You know, I look at your steering committee, and I don't see anybody from grassroots level, and the only way you're going to improve education, you've got to go in and pick people at the grassroots level. You've got to go in communities where there's low achievement, high poverty, Nobody on this committee is from that section. So what's the reason that you didn't go in? Because it takes total communities to turn around anything, especially education. What is the reason that they are not included? You know, I hear you talking about leadership. Well, that's great, but you've got to involve people that's there in order to make things improve,
▶ Play
Speaker 67 34:31
and especially parents. So I don't want to go into individual names and organizations just simply because I want to be respectful and respectful of time. But some of these folks on this list would differ, would feel as though they do represent that grassroots and do have the community connection. Just a couple on here, Rural Community Alliance. Anyway, I didn't want to go through all of the individual lists and organizations, but we actually do have several on here. It's not majority folks who aren't connected or who aren't doing grassroots. It's actually a mixture of both. Can I follow
▶ Play
up on that, Mr. Chair? I figure I represent 30,000 people, but if I was on that committee, I do not represent everybody that should be there, the parents of grassroots, that's got children in there that can see and help make changes. Wouldn't you say that's what I'm looking for?
▶ Play
Speaker 67 35:44
I understand, sir. And again, many of these folks who do represent that grassroots would beg to differ from you, because they themselves, in the work that they do daily, with their memberships and with the folks that they represent, They believe that they are bringing that voice to the steering committee. You said they believe. You know, I would like to have some of
▶ Play
them say who they are making contact with out in the schools and stuff like that. I used to be on Little Rock School Board. I know about the six schools that's out there that's failing, and none of those people are included in here. You might have a representative that represents that area, but they don't have time to get out there and really
▶ Play
go to the schools and see what's happening in there. Representative Walker you are recognized. Thank you. I don't want to be totally hostile. I think that they the initiative is purposeful, but Inclusivity is a question that you all can address But I'm and my question went to the manner of addressing it Which is usual and that manner has usually failed 50 for the future has failed the city of Little Rock Little Rock's black and poor people It's been 50 for the 50, and some of those 50 are on your steering committee, and so I do not wish to have the schools become the pawns of the 50, or of the persons who happen to be in the dominant economic establishment. Public schools are for everybody, and the purpose is to maintain public schools. I should not like to have you all come and, for good purpose, be trying to undermine public schools. My direct question to you, is this an effort to strengthen public schools, or is it an effort to privatize public education? This is an effort to strengthen public schools. Without equivocation? Yes. All right. Now, Mr. Follow-up?
▶ Play
Speaker 107 37:51
Yes, sir. Short follow-up, please. I will. As I look through this, you all deal
▶ Play
with outcomes. You know, the state of Arkansas until three weeks ago never had an outcome direction or directive when it came to achievement in public education. The objective was to open the door, open access, and then whatever the results were were the fault of the people who went into the system. Now all of a sudden you're talking about having outcomes. How do you shift from an access standard to an outcome standard without first having the outcome standard well understood and having people who are stakeholders in the process such as teachers, administrators, and community leadership and parents understand that access is not the objective but that is the outcome and that these students have to not only learn but they have to learn how to get along with each other and that they have to be in classes where there are people such as with the last person who spoke where you learn from each other and you don't do that by segregating people by putting all of the high class so called class high achieving students in one group and then the low achieving in another especially in view of the fact that it is very demonstrated that children learn from each other, are motivated by each other, and notwithstanding high achievement, high achievement people have a tendency to learn also from those who are not so well achieving. So my question for you is how do you incorporate that into possible legislation so that the outcome expectation can be driven home, and do you have any recommended legislation contemplated? MS. So access versus
▶ Play
Speaker 67 39:52
outcomes is still a discussion within our steering committee. We haven't gotten there yet. Again, we're still working and developing and in process.
▶ Play
Let me interrupt. The reason I raised that question is because all of a sudden, we've had access. We told federal courts and the like, the main thing is open the door. Access is one thing. And then, in a fell swoop of the pen, you say to Little Rock, access is not the issue. It is outcome, but you don't have any time to get the outcome, and because of that, we're going to take you over. Why doesn't this state just take over all the schools since you don't have an outcome expectation? Rep.
▶ Play
Speaker 111 40:33
Walker, what I would recommend is you need to sit
▶ Play
down with these people and talk with them one day.
▶ Play
I mean, there's a deliberate effort. That's part of what Mr. Armstrong was saying. But it was not said well, Mr. Armstrong, in all due respect. You were being tactful. There's a deliberate effort to exclude those persons who have a devoted interest to the needy of our state to be involved in the process of trying to determine resolutions and solutions to the basic problem that we refuse to face, which is race and poverty, all entwined.
▶ Play
Speaker 110 41:13
Thank you. If I can just, I'm sorry, he did
▶ Play
Speaker 67 41:20
ask about legislation and others. If you want to answer a question, you're welcome to. Yeah, so we are not yet at the place where we can recommend legislation or recommend policies, Again, because we are developing in our process. The other statement I do want to make for the record is that there has not, under any circumstance, been any deliberate attempt to exclude anyone under any circumstance. And I just want to state that for the record.
▶ Play
I have two people for questions, and I'm in the questions. We have got to
▶ Play
move on. Representative Douglas, you are recognized. Yes. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. my question is a chicken or the egg question and in looking at rural school districts we see that declining populations then kind of start this snowball effect of well then they get in maybe a little fiscal trouble or then they may get into some academic problems And I'm wondering if there is some place in your research to look at remedies for declining, you know, not just how do we boost the academics or how do we keep them in good standing, but what are those factors that led to the schools getting in that, you know, in that trouble? And could it be, you know, the declining, you know, populations due to economics or, you know, a lot of different factors there, but just an interesting piece that I think merits some, you know, visitation. And I wondered about your opinion on that.
▶ Play
Well, when you look at, and again, so far we've done the state of education report, and we are gathering information literally from thousands of surveys and other meetings across the state. What we hope to do then in our recommendations, and as Jared referenced earlier, you know, what are the success factors that we can replicate, right? So focusing on success factors. We know that there are large schools, there are small schools that are doing very well. And so how do we want to dig into that information? What makes them do well? How do they year after year perform well? And how can we sort of spread the word
▶ Play
Speaker 44 43:43
about that and create more opportunities for success? Just a follow-up, if
▶ Play
I could. And then will you have a delivery system or some kind of a carrot to put out there for school districts to take your suggestions? because that, you know, sometimes there's a disconnect between what will work and then what they're, you know, willing to
▶ Play
try. Yes. One of the things that we talked with the state board about when we formed this partnership, you know, beginning back with a concept in July of 2014, was that what we hoped would come out of this as well is then how do you take best practices and create incentives for schools to do well? And sometimes that's already funds that exist publicly or public-private partnerships that can be thought about in a little bit different way. And so we thought that there might be some things that come out of that that would be positive in how do we direct efforts for successful practices.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Murdoch,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Chairman. And again, going back to what I hit on the first part, and hopefully what we're getting from this is you come to visit with us, let us know what you're doing. We're giving our input, so hopefully there's a give and take that's appreciated, because we certainly appreciate what you're trying to do, and hopefully you appreciate our level of input and passion as we do it. When I look at representation, inclusivity, as we look at across the state, and we look at superintendents, school board members, those people that should be very key, in my opinion, to what you're trying to do. And the Delta, and let's put it on the table, we have lower performing schools in Delta. A big focus has been the Delta, which it should be and is appreciated. But when I look at your committee, you know, I only see from the Delta truly one individual that represents a school, which is Mr. Scott Shiree. So I don't see any other representation. I don't have a problem with that. Obviously, that makes sense for him to be there, but just want to make sure if this interchange can help us improve even what this group looks like so that the proper people will be at the table giving you input at the grassroots level, at the decision-making level, not just from a survey, but I mean really at the table. So if you could go back and look at some of those, because I've texted a couple of my superintendents, board members, just while we've been here, and they have not even been contacted according to them directly. And I just think it's important that we do that, because you're going to be evaluating their performance, their leadership, what they've done, what they've not done, and those outcomes associated. So I think it's very important that we do that. So
▶ Play
Speaker 67 46:31
I didn't answer you before, only because I know for sake of time. Keep in mind, we just started two weeks ago. And so we plan to get to those folks. We just started the interviews and the discussion groups and the like a couple of weeks ago. And so we're getting to the superintendents and the board folks. We're getting to them. We just haven't yet, just because of time. And then the other 28 that Jared described, they're included in that 28. So we were shortchanging it for time, but we do plan to have that conversation with them. Also from the Delta, again, not putting out names, but there are four people from parts of the Delta on the list. You just may not recognize where they're from, but there are. We have Pine Bluff on there. We have Blyville. I mean, you know, so there are some other folks on there. Yes, ma'am. So I get you. I mean, maybe, you know, they may not be who you want to be on the list, but geographically we worked hard to ensure that we did have some representation. Okay, I think
▶ Play
you understand my point, so I won't belabor it. hopefully they'll be considered. Thank you so much. I would
▶ Play
at one point, just because this has come up, all of these individuals have agreed and currently have a biography that is on our website, which provides a lot more color into their background, both the professional experience they bring, but also the part of the state that they've had that experience in, just for reference for the group. I'd like
▶ Play
to have, Mr. Chair, if I may, I'd like to have some understanding. Representative Walker, you're not recognized. I'd like to have some understanding of. Representative Walker. I thought you
▶ Play
recognized. I did not recognize you. Oh, I'm sorry. I apologize. Let me make a statement first. I want to end the questions. We have a lot of bills we need to present. This was a 10-minute presentation. We've run into almost 30, and I need to get through with this pretty quick. What I would like for you to do, if you guys have questions, these people will probably be around after the meeting. They would be glad to talk with you, but I do need to move on. We took too long. Thank you for your presentation, and if you wouldn't mind staying around, I believe there will be some people that would like to talk to you. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Fielding, you are recognized to present your bill, House Bill 1347. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. I'm also looking for Mr. Broway if he's still, oh, all right, right there in the back of my office. Representative Fielding, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good morning, committee. I have House Bill 1347, and this bill is simply what it does. It gives the nonprofit institution of higher education the opportunity to participate in a statewide accreditation. Those schools that are accredited by a national entity can be able to transfer those hours to a regional entity. And Mr. Broadway, Mr. Chair, can explain this furthermore if you need to allow him to speak.
▶ Play
Ripson, I'm sorry. Mr. Broadway, you're right. No,
▶ Play
Speaker 129 50:03
it's all right. I actually prefer that title, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Speaker 130 50:06
Shane Broadway, former director of the Arkansas Department of Higher Education, Dr. Brett Powell, the current director of the Arkansas Department of Higher Education. Back in 2009, just a quick history, 2009, Yeah, 2009, the legislature created what is called the Rogers-Phillips Transfer Act. At the time, a lot of members were receiving complaints from constituents whose student was attending an institution of higher education, and they would transfer, and those courses wouldn't transfer. And so the legislature set up a process by which now the institutions, there are members of faculty who come together and review coursework, mainly general ed courses, but I think at the last count we were up to about 90 courses that have been reviewed by these faculty committees for their curriculum and everything and have been approved by them that if it's taken at a state institution, it can be transferred to another state institution, which has greatly decreased the amount of phone calls you receive and we receive at the department. At the time when it was created, there was a provision that allowed private institutions, such as what Representative Fielding is talking about here, to participate in that process. In our looking at it, somewhere along the way, this language was removed. And it may be, our best guess, is that it was part of a cleanup bill or that because at the time no institutions participated, when they came back in 2011 with the next step of the Roger Phillips Transfer Act. It was just taken out. Most of the private institutions in Arkansas will probably never participate, will never ask to go through the process. I know of one that is interested because they are located locally and a number of their students transfer to either Pulaski Tech or ULR or UCA. And we've spent a lot of time trying to work with those institutions in terms of the ability of a student's coursework to transfer to those institutions. So this would allow a review and a better avenue for that opportunity to exist. Are you ready
▶ Play
for questions? Yes, sir. Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing no questions Anyone in the audience Whoop I'm sorry Representative Deffenbaum would you like to ask a question You're recognized Thank
▶ Play
you Mr. Chair Representative Fielding I just want to make sure what we're doing here To allow private institutions Of higher education to participate In the statewide transfer agreement We're not saying they have to but they just can't?
▶ Play
Speaker 130 53:05
Yes. This is just an option. If OBU decided they wanted to participate they would submit their courses through this process, but they would not be required to. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Representative Douglas, you're recognized. I just wonder
▶ Play
if that basket weaving class that Deffenbaugh took at OBU would transfer anywhere. That would be an automatic approval. That
▶ Play
Speaker 138 53:32
would automatic? Okay. Basket weaving is basket weaving, no matter where you take it, Representative. I'm just making sure.
▶ Play
Speaker 130 53:37
Kind of like the water aerobics class I took.
▶ Play
Any other questions? Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? You were recognized closed for your bill? Well, closed. Thank you, committee. What is the will of the committee? I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. Representative Ratliff, you are recognized to present H.R. 1015. 1015. You're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 122 54:22
you, Mr. Chair. H.R. 1015 is a
▶ Play
Speaker 142 54:29
House resolution recognizing National FFA Week, which is February the 21st through the 28th. And it's a great organization, and we're going to honor them in the House, and I'd really appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Are there any questions from the committee? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? I have a motion of due pass from Representative McElroy. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, you passed that bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You're recognized to present H.R. 1017, 1017.
▶ Play
Speaker 142 55:18
Okay, I'm presenting this bill today for Representative Overby, and I thank Mr. Chairman and good members this morning. I bring HR 1017, which does exactly what it states. It's recognized February as Career and Technical Education Month. It's a great program, helped many people, and I would appreciate a good vote. Are there any questions on the
▶ Play
committee? Does anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill, for the bill? I have a motion of due pass from Representative Armstrong. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? congratulations you passed your resolution at this time representative Lauer you are recognized to present house bill 1242 1242 you are recognized when you are ready
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. I'm going to be especially respectful of the time of the committee since we have discussed this bill at length in the last committee meeting. However, I do want to address a couple of things that were raised and also specifically focus on something, that this is just, as I said the other day, enabling legislation. It does not create any changes in the petition process. It does not create any changes in the body that the presentation would go before. The option is that it could go before the local school board or before the Department of Education. This is just enabling legislation that takes into account that the statutory language we have now has to be changed, that numbers have to be changed to take into account that Jacksonville is already separated from Pulaski County. And so the numbers that are there would potentially allow the Sherwood and or Maumelle school areas to be able to separate from Pulaski County. These numbers allow that. There are so many other hurdles and proper documentation that would have to be produced before any of that could happen. As was referenced the other day, the very first thing that would have to happen is that the Pulaski County School District would have to be declared unitary. That is part of the DSEG settlement. If any of you need, I have a copy of that DSEG settlement where it specifically does say the state will oppose the creation of any other school districts from PCSSD's territory until PCSSD is declared fully unitary and is released from federal court supervision and that specifically addresses this bill that is before you today that as it applies to Pulaski County, any area wanting to separate would not be able to do so before unitary status is established. This has limited scope. I believe only about 13 school districts would actually fit within the size parameters that you could separate from so it's very limited in its scope. So I hope that that gives a good reminder and a good overview of the bill, and I'm ready to proceed as the chairman feels we should.
▶ Play
I have questions. Are you entertaining questions? I would, yes. I have Representative Balch, you recognize. Motion for immediate consideration. I have a motion for immediate consideration. That is non-debatable. It takes two-thirds of the quorum. All those in favor of that say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion carries. Immediate consideration. Question for the House? I need a vote on the bill. I have a motion. I have a motion of due pass. Representative Baltz made that motion. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Motion carries. You passed. You have passed your bill, Representative Lowry. Thank you. Is there any other bills before the committee today? If not, without objection, we are adjourned. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1255

1:05 - 18:17 51 segments 9 speakers

PRESENTATION: FORWARD ARKANSAS

18:17 - 49:01 95 segments 15 speakers

HB1347

49:01 - 54:29 21 segments 8 speakers

HR1015

54:29 - 55:25 3 segments 2 speakers

HR1017

55:25 - 56:18 2 segments 1 speaker

HB1242

56:18 - 1:00:49 8 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
32 segments
Representative John W. Walker Chair Unverified
46 segments
Bentley Wallace Unverified
11 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 25
1 segment
Linda Ducro Unverified
3 segments
Quentin Robson Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 46
1 segment
Kathy Smith Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 67
14 segments
Jared Henderson Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 73
1 segment
Representative Reginald Murdock Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 80
1 segment
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 107
1 segment
Speaker 111
1 segment
Speaker 110
1 segment
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 44
1 segment
Representative David Fielding Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 129
1 segment
Speaker 130
8 segments
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 138
1 segment
Speaker 122
1 segment
Speaker 142
2 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
5 segments