Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs Committee

February 18, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HJR1005 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Members of the committee, I bring to you HJR 1005 and a couple of preliminary comments on my part. Number one…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1024 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Members, I believe that's HJR 1024, if you're looking at the number.”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Hey, we've got more than I thought here, actually. Well, first of all, who do we have here to present amendments? Representative Branscombe, Representative Shepard, Representative Ladyman, Representative House. Do you have one as well? No? Okay, yeah, we're going to hear HJRs. And the purpose for the meeting today for everybody here and watching is informational only. We won't be taking motions on any of these. It will be informational for members of the committee. And for any committee questions, committee would advise you that with regard to questions, keep in mind these folks are not making a formal bill presentation today. It's informational only, so keep your questions in that tone, please. With that, Representative Branscombe, I think you're first up. You are recognized to provide information on HJR 1006.
▶ Play
Speaker 7 0:53
Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee, audience. what I have is a amendment to the constitution concerning infamous crime and if you don't know what it is that's good because it means you haven't been in any trouble but the infamous crime which last session I had a bill which is a really good bill and it defined infamous crime I had my legal team work on it they did a great job the only problem was infamous crime is in the Constitution in two different places and because it's in the Constitution, we cannot codify this bill and therefore there is no definition of infamous crime. To keep this short and simple, this is really a pretty big deal. It needs to be done. Now whether we do it this time, whether this is one of the three or not, I don't know. But the Supreme Court needs some guidance in my opinion, and I've talked to some of the justices, they're all for it, for legislative intent on what an infamous crime is. And what I have is, and I'm going to have an amendment. I've talked to the Bureau, and I'm taking out line 2 on page 2, well, it'll be line 3 on page 2, where I'm taking out the misdemeanor of theft because that's the whole basis of this helping define infamous crime. I had a sheriff, what reason why I'm doing this, I had a sheriff in Searcy County in Marshall that was our sheriff, and he got removed the year before last because of a truck wreck in 1979. A Tyson's truck wrecked at the bottom of Still Springs Hill below Marshall was loaded with frozen Cornish hens, and him and a bunch of good old boys were down there taking the Cornish hens and distributing them. That's where they used to do commodities in those days. And he was a deputy sheriff at the time. Well, because the insurance didn't come in on him, and they give him a misdemeanor and a $50 fine, and that was it. Well, then he was elected sheriff two terms ago in Searcy County and was doing a great job. Everybody loved him, and then for whatever reason, the prosecutor says, no, you cannot serve in office because that's deemed an infamous crime. And I already didn't know what infamous crime was until this all came about. Now, to put that in simplistic terms concerning all of you guys, if a prosecutor so deemed that somebody had a speeding ticket and they didn't like you, then they could say, oh, that's an infamous crime and you could be removed from office or could stop you from ever serving from office the rest of your life. Now, has that happened? Not on a speeding ticket, but it has on misdemeanors, and that just, you know, it doesn't seem right, and because there is no set definition under the Constitution of an infamous crime, then here's your opportunity to do it. That's all I've got. Any members have
▶ Play
any questions for Representative Branscombe? Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Do
▶ Play
you know where else it's defined in the Constitution? It's not. I thought you said it was two
▶ Play
Speaker 7 4:24
places. It's in two places. And it says about murder, rape, whatever, and any other infamous crimes. And because it's any other infamous crimes and because there's no, I mean, you can go to the dictionary. And, I mean, I think of an infamous crime when I presented the bill was when Japan bombed Pearl Harbor, they would live in infamy. Now, that's an infamous crime. I wanted it to be big. And, you know, of course, if you've got a felony now, you can't do that. But the misdemeanors, because they deemed that could be an infamous crime, and it was used as that. And it's been used in several other instances. I think a former member had a hot check charge, and then he chose not to run again because he knew that he was going to be deemed ineligible over 25 years ago, and that knocked him out of it. And so it's something that in the environment we're in, we kind of need to clean it up, and it probably needs to be done. Am I going to fall on the sword for this one? No, but it
▶ Play
does need to be done. Additional questions for members? If not, thank you, Representative Branscombe. Do
▶ Play
Speaker 7 5:37
you have anything else you'd like to add?
▶ Play
No, if you've got any questions, you can ask me. I mean, that's pretty much what it is. All right, folks, if you have any questions for Representative Branscombe, you know how to find him. All right, next up on the list is HJR 1027 by Representative Ladyman. Representative Ladyman, you're recognized to present information on your resolution. Thank you. Can you
▶ Play
hear me? This resolution was actually presented by Senator King, and he asked me to help him with this, and I was glad to do it because I think it's a good amendment. um basically what 1027 does is is just one thing it uh changes the county offices from a two-year term to a four-year term and that would include uh county clerk county judge uh justice of the peace circuit clerk sheriff coroner and coroner and treasurer uh in this uh i don't know if you got a copy of this in front of you, but it does talk in here about the Justice of the Peace, Justice of the Peace, that they would vote at the local level to change it from a two to a four-year. It would be allowed, but they would have to vote locally on that particular office. Now, Senator King is working on amendment to change that and make that four years because he has got some questions about that particular office. I don't know where he's at exactly on that. I haven't talked to him today. But that's basically what it is, changing the county offices from a two-year term to a four-year term. So I'd be glad to try to answer any questions you have or take them
▶ Play
down and get the answers and get back to you. Representative Layman, I actually have one on this. This is something that I have some reservations about. the four year term change it sounds like you've got a pending amendment that addresses the justice of the peace in particular for at least me I have concern with any of the policy making positions becoming four year as opposed to the ministerial positions and you know county judge and justice of the peace at least at a minimum make policy or part of the policy making process so are y'all also would you entertain the idea of removing the county judges from that I don't think so I mean we
▶ Play
could have that discussion but speaking as an ex-mayor where the mayor has four-year term the city council has two-year terms in some cities but they have the option to for four-year the judge is really the executor of the county so I mean his duties it's very difficult to run an election every two years if you're an executive. So I would think the judge should be one of those persons that would get a four-year term. That's my opinion. Certainly.
▶ Play
Well, as somebody who runs every two years, I have some sympathy for that argument. Well, it is difficult. Let
▶ Play
me just add to that, and if you've been a judge or held in office like that it's difficult to run for an election every two years if you're the executive because you're doing things that are a little bit longer term sometimes and you need a little more time to get those things into effect so I think it's a good bill for that very reason the the group that I would pull out would be the justices because they are they're they're not full time they're you know A two-year term for them, I would think, would be more realistic in my mind.
▶ Play
Speaker 26 9:43
That's just my opinion. Any other questions?
▶ Play
Are there questions for the members? If not, anything else you'd like to add, Representative Layman? No, that's it. All right, I think next on our list today is Representative Mayberry with HJR 1024. You're recognized to provide information on HJR 1024. it's not on
▶ Play
actually I've got three and I'd prefer if I can to kind of batch them together is that okay with you let's do them one at a time well they kind of all go do you mind if I just share an overall and then separate them walk a walk a narrow path there okay well I filed three purposely because I feel that this will allow us to have an opportunity to have open discussion on a topic that has really been a hot topic, and that's the position of the lieutenant governor and what the role of the lieutenant governor is in the state of Arkansas. As many of you know, we have been without someone in that position for nearly a year. Obviously, we now have someone in that position but we went almost a year without someone in that position we went more than six months without even any any staff in that position when we as legislators turn around and tell our state offices that in order to hire someone when you've had the position vacant for a year we need to have serious discussion as to whether or not we had that position I think we need to do the same internally and we need to look at this and figure out do we need to either keep this position and make it useful or get rid of the position and eliminate it and that's what these three bills do and I want to open discussion I am not dead set on any one of them I need input from you to say what's the best scenario but I think there are enough people out there that have expressed concern over the role of the lieutenant governor so the first bill would be to eliminate the lieutenant governor's position, and that is not unusual when you compare to other states. There are six states that do not have a lieutenant governor. Alaska, Hawaii, New Jersey and Utah share it with the Secretary of State. Tennessee and West Virginia, they use the President of the Senate to serve as lieutenant governor. Five states have no lieutenant governor whatsoever. That's Maine, Arizona, Wyoming, New Hampshire in Oregon. So the first bill is to actually eliminate the position. The other two bills that are out there, if we don't want to eliminate it, then at least let's make it useful. And there are 21 states that make the lieutenant governor and the governor run together. So we have a primary election in May where your governor and your lieutenant governor would run together, they would pick each other, and they would run on the ballot together, and that's what the Second Amendment refers to. And then whoever wins in the primaries, of course, then runs in the general election. There are some states, five, that have them run separately. They have them run in the primary as governor, run as lieutenant governor, and then they join up in the general election and run together. That's another possibility. there are 17 states that do it like we do okay so we're not unusual that they would run run separately I don't know what's the best solution but I do know that we need to have discussion over what that role is and the second bill if we want to keep the position this would allow us as legislators or as the governor to assign duties and responsibility to that lieutenant Governor. Representative Mayberry, if you don't mind,
▶ Play
let's do this like this. You've told us kind of your overall component. It's becoming a little difficult to understand exactly which one you're talking about. Let's take them one at a time. So you've told us kind of where you're going in general with all three. Let's talk about each one sequentially. I think, at least from my standpoint, that'll certainly help me stay organized about where you're going.
▶ Play
Okay. Well, the first one does away with the position okay we would not have a lieutenant governor this would not go into effect until the next election so what it would do is it would take away that that position and then the duties and the powers of that position get spread out if something were to happen to our to the governor of the state of Arkansas they got kicked out of office they died whatever it is, those powers would then go to the Secretary of State. And I know that there's been some discussion that maybe it should go to the Attorney General. I believe that some people have discussed that. I don't think that that's really the best way to do it. The Attorney General, you have to be a lawyer to be in that position, and I think that kind of limits who your potential governor could be. So the duties and powers would then go to the Secretary of State. So that's similar to what just happened in Oregon.
▶ Play
Sure. Oregon, their governor just resigned and the Secretary of State became governor. Yes. Okay. Okay. Now, I want to make sure I understand one thing correctly, and I think Representative Bennett, did you have a
▶ Play
question as well? Okay. I was just, when she was referring to first bill, second bill, I was trying to get numbers.
▶ Play
Okay, okay. I was having that trouble also. Sorry. Okay. With regard to the Attorney General being required to be a lawyer, there's nothing in the Constitution that actually makes that requirement. So just to be clear on that. Okay. It's something that the voters typically do require, but it's certainly
▶ Play
not required. I think it is, but I'll pass on that part. But anyway, I'll pass on that. The – where was I? Okay, so if something happened to the governor, it would go to the secretary of state. If the governor goes out of state, the governor does not have to give up power and authority. I mean, my goodness, if he goes over to Memphis, he or she in the future, goes over to Memphis, really do we need to give powers over to somebody else? I think that's kind of antiquated. We all know that we have our cell phones and can handle business. The governor can certainly handle business when he travels out of state. If the governor felt like he needed to or she needed to pass down those duties, going out of the country, going to be gone a long time, certainly you could still do that. And then the other duty of a lieutenant governor is to preside over the Senate. And I don't think we actually have to have someone presiding over the Senate. We have a Senate pro tem. So those are the ways that we would handle just eliminating the office. The office, there's a $400,000 budget. To me, this is being fiscally responsible. This puts money back into taxpayers' hands or into other services that are definitely a little bit more needed. So that's the first bill would be to eliminate it completely. Questions on that one?
▶ Play
Members, I believe that's HJR 1024, if you're looking at the number. Are there questions for members on HJR 1024? All right, Representative Mayberry moved down to HJR 1026, I believe, is the next one you
▶ Play
have. Is that correct? Yes. Okay, so the next one would be to look at the office and decide that the two offices, the lieutenant governor and the governor, should work together. Let's make it useful. If we don't want to eliminate it, let's give some jobs, some responsibility, there and you would put the lieutenant governor and the governor on the same ballot in the primary and they would you're not guaranteed when you have two different parties that they're going to work together we certainly have seen that and in the offices where they don't work together you're also not necessarily guaranteed when the two offices are of the same party that they're going to work together but if they choose before the primary and they say hey we want to work together, we have similar ideas. I think that you're going to have quite a lot of, I'm sorry, you're going to have them working together, and I think we're going to have more cohesiveness in the office. And so they would run together in the primary, and then in the fall, they would continue to run if they won. And the legislature and the governor could also assign certain duties and responsibilities. We don't want to put those in the Constitution because I think that that might be hard if we ever needed to change it. So I wanted to write it a little bit more open that we could change that by the legislative body or by the governor. And then the third one is a shell bill. And it's a bill of, hey, if you don't like these two ideas, tell me what you think would work. And that's what I'm trying to accomplish here. Just have conversation. Are there questions
▶ Play
from members? All right. Representative Mayberry, I do have two questions. You know, whenever you go into this area, obviously I think everyone knows your husband ran for lieutenant governor and lost to the current lieutenant governor. How do you answer the obvious question that comes up regarding sour grapes? Oh, I would be doing this
▶ Play
Speaker 49 19:46
if Andy won. This has nothing to do with the
▶ Play
current lieutenant governor there. If Andy were in that position and won, I'd be sitting right here doing the exact same thing. Certainly. I know he promised he would. He would. I'd be happy to fire my husband. There you go. All right. So that has nothing to do with sour grapes. It has nothing to do with the current person. And I've actually addressed this with Tim Griffin. I've had conversation with him about it. and I've said look you know here's your opportunity to make this position what you really think this position should be if we're gonna hire you let's give some duties and responsibilities that are there is he supportive of either one of these he he was willing to listen to some ideas he has I don't want to speak on his behalf I think that's something that you all would want to talk to him about I'd love to include him in this he's in that position I am open to ideas as I've mentioned let's either use it
▶ Play
or lose it. The second second question I had is you mentioned the concept of having the governor and lieutenant governor run as a team. The founders of the country of the United States wanted to have ideally the vice president be the first runner-up essentially for a president with the idea of keeping tension in government that's the way we have it set up in Arkansas where it can be where the two are people who maybe don't necessarily agree as a means of potentially maintaining some balance what are your thoughts on that I just like to hear well I think if something happens to our governor I think we would
▶ Play
want someone who can step in right away and pick up where things have been left off I think it works better when the two are working together. I just, I just do. Any other questions for members? Representative
▶ Play
Ladyman. Yeah, what are the issues with things the way they are? I understand the cost and are the savings by eliminating the office. Are there other issues other than cost with leaving it the way it is? Quite, quite frankly, I don't
▶ Play
think that the position is used very well. I mean, there's three things that a lieutenant governor has the responsibilities of doing. The one responsibility is to fill in if the governor walks out of state, drives out of state, flies out of state, and I think that's archaic. I think we definitely need to look at that. Number two is to preside over the Senate. Well, you have a Senate pro tem to do that. And then the other one is to just sit there and wait on something to happen to the governor, whether that's leaving office or not and if we can fix that another way this is just this is being fiscally responsible if we go to our state agencies and we tell our state agencies that they need to look and figure out what positions they really need not positions they want but that they really need we need to look internally at our positions
▶ Play
as well okay well and and your other bills may address this but there are jobs that when a person gets into the job they can make the job and I know that our current lieutenant governor ran on this because I heard him speak many times about things that he wanted to do where he could promote policy and actually be productive and help the state along so there are jobs where you can make the job the person can make the job and I think maybe that's what you're trying to address in your other two bills
▶ Play
and we need to put some outline into that because right now really there is no authority for that lieutenant governor to truly accomplish those things other than just having a pulpit okay so so we don't want to eliminate it and we're paying someone to do a job and we have a staff there then let's make it useful and that's what this position that's what the other proposal is is to say let's look at it and let's figure out how we can actually make this position. In some states, they'll put them over, I know one of them, don't ask me which one, but like over the Department of Transportation. You know, give an actual, this is your responsibility, this is your area. And the way that the proposal is written is that there would be flexibility in that because it would allow us as the legislative body or the governor to assign what those positions are.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you. Additional questions from members? If not,
▶ Play
Representative Mayberry, anything else you'd like to add? I'd be happy to answer any questions from any of you at any point. My issue in doing this, this is why I've got three different proposals out there, is I want your feedback. I think there are enough people out there who have expressed concern over this and want to fix it, and I think it's up to us to just not turn our head and when we are talking to our state agencies about positions and funding certain positions and if it's not being useful, let's get rid of it. I think that we need to have discussion on it and that's
▶ Play
what my goal here is. All right. Seeing no further questions. I think next we have Representative Shepard with HJR 1005. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Members of the committee, I bring to you HJR 1005 and a couple of preliminary comments on my part. Number one, any time it comes to any law, but particularly with regard to amending the Constitution, It's something that I take very seriously and that I think it is important that those resolutions be well vetted. And so I don't take it lightly presenting this resolution. Of course, the Arkansas Constitution has been amended and is amended much more often than our federal Constitution. But by the same token, I think it's something that we have to take very seriously. and so I appreciate the task that this committee has in vetting those proposals. Secondly, let me say that with regard to my proposal and the selecting of justices of the Supreme Court, there is no perfect system by which to elect or select a judge or justice. And so I want to say that at the outset. But quite simply, what HJR 1005 would provide for is the merit selection of Supreme Court justices. Currently, the justices of the Arkansas Supreme Court are elected. They serve for eight-year terms, and we've seen, of course, there have been articles written recently on this. We've seen over the past several years, we've seen these races become more and more expensive. We've seen the influx of outside money and outside groups on these races, And I would point out that I actually filed this resolution two years ago. I didn't run it, but I filed it as much as anything just to start the discussion. And I think what we've seen since that time has probably only confirmed the concerns that I had two years ago. You know, when it comes to electing judges, or in this case justices, they can't speak to the issues that may come before them. and, quite frankly, I don't think we would want them to. I know some people say, well, I'd like to know what their views are, but as someone who practices in front of judges very regularly, I don't want to hear from a judge as to how they would decide an issue. I want judges and justices to come into it with an open mind and apply the law to the set of facts that are presented to them. So they can't talk about the issues, as you probably all have voted in races for the Supreme Court and you can use your own judgment as to how much information you had at the time you voted for particular individuals. I'd also point out that this is not an effort to attack the current Supreme Court or clear the current Supreme Court. The provisions of this resolution would allow the current justices to continue to serve and stand for retention. The mechanics of this resolution, it's largely based on what is commonly known as the Missouri plan because Missouri, I believe, was one of the first states to adopt it. And actually, I believe Missouri uses it for all of its judges, from very low trial courts all the way to its highest court, the Missouri Supreme Court. But this resolution would provide that with regard to the Arkansas Supreme Court, there would be a selection committee put together. The governor, as drafted, the governor would have six appointments to that committee. They would all be non-lawyers. The Arkansas Bar Association, which, of course, is an organization made up of attorneys, would have six appointments. They could provide for the election of six individuals who would obviously be attorneys to that committee. The Speaker of the House, the Senate Pro Tem, would have an appointment each. I believe also that provides that they're not attorneys. And then finally, of those 14 selections, then the committee itself would select a 15th member. When there's a vacancy in the Arkansas Supreme Court, the committee would make a recommendation, would submit three names to the governor. The governor would have a limited period of time to select one of the three names. If the governor chose not to make a selection, as currently drafted, the chief justice would have the opportunity to make a selection from those three names. so that's that's in a nutshell what it would provide for additionally the justices would would no longer stand for election in the sense of having an opponent that runs against them they would simply stand for a retention election and what happens in a retention election is the justice would would be on the ballot but instead of having an opponent that it would simply be a question of yes or no do we retain the justice and the public would have the opportunity to speak its mind on that issue by way of their vote. If the justice is not retained, the selection committee would submit three names to the governor. The governor would make that choice. So those are the mechanics of the resolution in a nutshell. Again, a lot of the concerns that brought me to bring this resolution primarily relate to the fact that these races are becoming more and more expensive. If you look at surrounding states, it's almost an arms race in terms of you have very, whether it's the trial bar, the business community, or other interested groups raising extremely large amounts of money. And my concern is that Arkansas is trending in that direction. And again, there's also the concern about outside groups as well having an impact on these races, and so I'd be glad to answer any questions, but I wanted to at least be here to answer any preliminary questions that you might have.
▶ Play
Speaker 74 31:28
Representative Douglas, you were first. Thank you for your description of this. So would it be your contention that or your observation with this new system that we would have a better quality judge that would be serving because it would not be led by who has the most money? I think in
▶ Play
terms of how things progress in the future, I think this system helps to ensure that we have quality justices going forward. And that's one of the issues that's been raised is individuals have said, well, in other states There have been instances where maybe a judge or justice makes a decision that was unpopular. I think Iowa was an example of that, and two or three judges were not retained. The public basically chose not to retain them essentially for a particular decision. And, you know, I think that that could happen. That could happen. The public could say we're not going to retain a judge or justice in this case because the public doesn't agree with the decision. That can happen right now. I mean, essentially you could have a justice who is involved in an opinion and somebody can run against them and you could have outside groups and others saying this justice needs to be defeated because they cited, they reached this decision. So that could happen now. But the advantage of this system is if that does occur and a justice is not retained, it's not simply that there's someone who becomes justice by default because they happen to be the person running at that particular time. You go back to this committee that hopefully is independent, that will look at the backgrounds of the individuals who are seeking to serve on the court, and then they can make those submissions to the governor. So I think it helps to ensure the quality of the justices that we have and also ensure that those who are selected are not, that they don't strictly attain their position based on a particular issue or a particular group that may or may not have supported them. Representative Douglas, you can have a
▶ Play
follow-up right quick, then we'll get to Representative Bennett. So
▶ Play
Speaker 74 33:50
how are we going to cushion those 12 men, women, that are going to pick these justices from those same influences that you say are coming in through elections or through outside money?
▶ Play
Well, that's a good question, and I think that, you know, that's something that, you know, we may be looking at further. I would think, and I don't know that we have that in the bill right now, and I maybe need to look at some other states, But, you know, certainly my inclination and what I would desire is that those individuals would be independent, that they wouldn't be – I mean, they're not elected to those positions. They – the bar, I think, would provide for election. But it was not in the sense of them going out and soliciting funds and campaigning. Now, you know, with regard to the governor's selections, you would think that a governor would select people that he believes have a similar ideological viewpoint in terms of what they're looking for in a candidate or in a selection for the Supreme Court but certainly my desire would be to to do whatever we can to insulate that committee from any of those outside pressures and so I'd certainly be open to looking at ways to strengthen that whether it's in this resolution or if it comes by way of enabling legislation that's I think that's a that's a great point and that's clearly what I would what I would desire is that this committee would be very much independent, that they would be looking at qualifications, they would be looking at educational background, their prior service, their judicial temperament, how they interact with individuals, their knowledge of the law. I mean, we want well-rounded justices, and again, this is not an effort, an attack on the Supreme Court. I have no issues with the current Supreme Court. My issues are about what I see happening around us and what we may be headed towards in the future if we're not proactive. Representative
▶ Play
Bennett, you're recognized for a question. And you may have addressed at least one of these issues. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I always love the saying it's terrible to run for a judicial position because all you can promise people is justice and nobody really wants that but this would in no way change the governor appointing someone to fill an unexpired term if there was an immediate need and a vacancy is that correct?
▶ Play
I believe that if there was a vacancy created that this process would then kick in with regard to the Supreme Court only. I have to look back at that, but I believe that's my understanding, but I could be wrong about that. But certainly my intent is that any time there's a vacancy, that the committee would make its selections, recommendations to the governor, and the governor would make that selection. I think that's what makes the most sense.
▶ Play
If I might follow up. and then the other thing is this does not change any of the terms of office of the judges is
▶ Play
that correct that's correct I believe we stick with an eight-year term now it would change in the with regard to there's some provisions in here with regard to the initial retention election and it states that if there's a general election occurring outside of 12 months of appointment, then there would be an initial retention election. But generally the terms would still stay the same. They would be subject to an eight-year term. And again, I think that the eight-year term I think also helps to continue to insulate the court because they're not running every two years, every four years, or every six years. I mean, eight years is a fairly lengthy period of time. And, you know, additionally, I think that that's something that we should retain is the eight-year term in office. Representative Dotson, do you have a question? Yes, sir, Mr. Chair. Go ahead.
▶ Play
Speaker 81 38:14
You may have covered this, but how many other states actually have this process in place? I believe 19.
▶ Play
And how many of them are elected like what we currently have? I'm not sure. I mean,
▶ Play
Speaker 84 38:29
I could check on that. I just
▶ Play
don't recall off the top of my head. I believe Missouri, Oklahoma, and Tennessee are a few states
▶ Play
Speaker 85 38:40
around us that have some sort of merit selection system. Are there any, besides elected or merit, are
▶ Play
there any other types of systems that you're aware of? There may be some that are gubernatorial appointment, maybe some with some type of confirmation process I'm really not sure I think that the ones you hear the most about are either the direct election or some sort of merit selection system similar to what I've proposed here Thank you Are there additional questions
▶ Play
for members? If not, is there anything you'd like to add
▶ Play
Representative Shepard? No, I thank you for the opportunity I thank you for the questions. As I said, it's not something that I take lightly. I mean, we're talking about a fundamental change with regard to our courts. And let me say that really until probably four or five years ago, I've always been a proponent of judicial elections because I think it gives individuals the opportunity that if they desire to be a judge and feel called in that direction, they have that opportunity. But I think with what we've seen going on in states around us, I think it's important that we consider what does the future look like for us. And one of the reasons why I'm only proposing it with regard to the Supreme Court is continuing to allow our circuit judges to be elected, continuing to allow our Court of Appeals judges to be elected. Those are elected on a much smaller basis, a judicial circuit or an appellate division. and I think there's a greater familiarity when it comes to those more local races. But then I also think that those are great opportunities for individuals to obtain judicial experience and that hopefully those individuals will help to generate a very qualified candidate pool for this committee to review and possibly make recommendations to the governor. So I thank the committee for your time, and if anybody has any further questions, comments, suggestions, or otherwise, I'd certainly be glad to visit further, you know,
▶ Play
outside of the committee. Thank you very much, Representative Shepard, for your information. Next up, we have HJL 1007 by Representative Lowry. Representative Lowry, you're recognized to provide information for the committee.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. Many of you are familiar with the fact that in 2013, the Arkansas Legislature passed a statute to require photo ID in voting. That law, some would probably say that I'm especially invested in wanting to protect that because I was summoned from my sickbed to be the 51st vote to override the governor's veto. We did that, we passed the bill, but then the Arkansas Supreme Court overturned that statute. Immediately upon that decision being made available, I contacted the Bureau of Legislative Research and asked them if they would specifically look at Justice Corbin's judgment and craft a constitutional amendment, a referred constitutional amendment, that answers all of the questions, all of the issues that he stated in his opinion. I believe that that's what you have before you. He specifically referred to, of course, it violating the Arkansas Constitution because it added a, the statute added another qualification for being an elector and that you could not do that statutorily. However, we can do that by constitutional amendment. The history of photo voter ID goes back to at least 2006. The state of Indiana passed what is considered to be the most restrictive voter ID law, and it was challenged and went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court where the United States Supreme Court ruled in favor of the Indiana law on a 63 vote. There's some interesting quotes that come from the justices on that, one of which being the Supreme Court ruled that the United States has a long history of voter fraud. So we're always asked, you know, is there a necessity for this? Well, the Supreme Court seems to believe so. And they stated that when it upheld Indiana's strictest in the nation voter ID. The landmark opinion said that, and this is a quote, there is no question about the legitimacy or importance of the state's interest in counting only the votes of eligible voters and that states, such as the state of Arkansas, have justification for carefully identifying all voters participating in the election process. I know that many of us who favor this and favor doing whatever we can to protect the integrity of the ballot recognize that it is a small burden to require photo ID there is a long list of things that we have to do in our daily life where we have to provide photo ID if you want to buy alcohol and you happen to maybe be around that age of 21 they'll ask for photo ID. If there's question about whether you're old enough to buy cigarettes, you'll have to show photo ID. If you want to board a plane, you have to show photo ID, and the list goes on and on. So it's not a huge barrier. This particular referred constitutional amendment that I bring before you also directs the Secretary of State's office to make available to any voter in the state for free a photo ID. So the issue of disenfranchisement is also dealt with in this particular constitutional amendment. And that's an overview of that, and I'm open
▶ Play
for any questions. Questions from the committee? Seeing none, Representative Lowry, is
▶ Play
there anything additionally you'd like to add? Well, one thing I would want to bring to your attention is that there is a similar proposal by Senator Brian King. He does address this in the drafting in a different way that is not specific to Justice Corbin's ruling. And I just think it's very important for us to look at that ruling that overturned it, where Justice Corbin says that you cannot add by statute a qualification to be an elector. The language in the proposed amendment that I've brought to you does that specifically. It says here is a new qualification that to vote you would have to present a photo ID. So when you are considering whether to merge those two, I know that's one of the issues that you'll have to deal with is which one of these two voter ID issues is the superior or
▶ Play
Speaker 91 46:07
one to move forward and that would be my
▶ Play
Speaker 29 46:13
closing. Thank you representative Lowry. Thank you committee
▶ Play
representative Letting was here to present HJR 1021 I haven't been able to make contact with him if someone wants to try to call him right quick and see if he's is he close by we're going to do more of these we'll we'll go ahead and we'll catch representative letting on the next if the committee will just indulge us for just a second you trying to call him representing Bennett let's see if she can reach him if he's close we'll go ahead and hear him if If not, we'll get everybody out of here. Is he going to wait? Okay. Committee, with there being no further information to be presented today, we'll stand adjourned. By way of advice...
▶ Play

Agenda

No agenda available.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Nate Bell Chair Unverified
29 segments
Speaker 7
11 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
6 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 26
1 segment
Representative Julie Mayberry Unverified
28 segments
Speaker 49
1 segment
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Unverified
32 segments
Speaker 74
2 segments
Speaker 81
1 segment
Speaker 84
1 segment
Speaker 85
1 segment
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 91
1 segment
Speaker 29
1 segment