Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

February 19, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (4)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1376 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1376”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1349 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1349”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1362 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1362”
Pre-2017 bill
SB227 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB227”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Representative Bell, I think I saw the name, there he is. We've got a special order on Representative Bell's bill, House Bill 1376. Representative Bell, are you ready? I am, Mr. Chair, thank you. You're
▶ Play
recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. With permission to chair, if I could ask the 18 West prosecutor, Andy Reiner, and his investigator, Elena Cannon, to join me at the table. I'd appreciate it. You got it. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Each of you should have in front of you a copy of an Arkansas Court of Appeals decision, Melissa Cann Arms v. State of Arkansas. Well, that case is actually the reason that I am running this bill, at the request of Mr. Reiner, who was the prosecutor in the original case. And I think to kind of lay the land for you, I want to, with the permission of the chair, ask Ms. Cannon to kind of give you the background on the case. You'll recognize, if you'll just remind everybody who
▶ Play
you are, you can proceed. No, you just need to turn your mic on there, Elena.
▶ Play
Just talk right there. You have to get it fairly close to you. My name is Alaina Cannon. I'm
▶ Play
the investigator for... Can you turn on your mic, please?
▶ Play
It's on. She just needs to get it closer.
▶ Play
Speaker 63 1:57
Okay. My name is Alaina Cannon. I'm the investigator for... Probably the other one there, Alaina. It's on now. Turn it on. Push the button. It's on now. Okay. My name is Elena
▶ Play
Speaker 18 2:08
Cannon. I'm an investigator for 18th West Judicial District. I became aware of the Melissa Arms case. The MENA Regional Health System and MENA Labor and Delivery Department actually contacted the MENA Police Department in reference to a pipe that they had found in the Labor and Delivery room of Melissa Arms. they responded to that notified me as well the hospital did drug testing on the baby both maybe and mother were positive for methamphetamine we in turn got a search warrant and got blood and urine samples from both the mother and the baby that were sent to the crime lab and it again showed positive testing for methamphetamine and criminal charges pursued from there mr. chair
▶ Play
with your permission I'd like to then defer to prosecutor Reiner to explain what happened subsequent to that sure you recognize
▶ Play
you'll just introduce yourself everybody thank you
▶ Play
mr. chairman my name is Andy Reiner I'm prosecuting attorney for 18 West Judicial District, which includes Mena and Mount Ida, Arkansas, and Polk and Montgomery counties, and I'm very pleased to be here with you today. We kind of backed into this issue, actually, is how we became aware of it. Some time ago, and I would encourage you to read the McCann Arms decision if you get a chance. This is a very important bill for that reason. Just to give you a bit of history of how we got involved with drug-addicted infants, we began to cooperate very closely with our county DHS workers. And our county DHS workers began to make us aware that this was a really big problem. And you guys, I'm sure, know that every county in Arkansas has a multiple disciplinary team. And on your multiple disciplinary team, you have medical professionals, you have DHS case workers you have juvenile service workers and we take an approach to all of it and and y'all know what it's like you're sitting around a table at your multiple disciplinary team and they look at the end of the table and they say what are you going to do about this we got a problem and so we began to look at how we would address that state law does not require us to be notified when a child is born under Garrett's law it's called into the Arkansas child abuse hotline but it's true but exempt it's given a priority one so prosecutors are never notified about this and so through the multiple disciplinary team we began to address this and since we started to address it I believe we've prosecuted one we've prosecuted two cases to completion we've got one pending we have eight that are awaiting my decision and there were three that I couldn't prosecute, and I'd be happy to talk with you about the specifics of that. But in any event, that just kind of tells
▶ Play
you how I became involved. Mr. Chair, with the indulgence of the chair, I'd like Prosecutor Reiner to explain the McCann case a little more and the appeals court decision and what led us to filing the bill. Sure.
▶ Play
So, like Elena said, we got that call, and with previous cases, we had been involved. We were getting calls after the fact, but in this event, once the child was born, we immediately went to the hospital, and we obtained blood and urine samples from the mother and a urine sample from the child to send them to the state crime lab, and that was an important step since we'd been notified by the DHS, and we kicked it around and investigated it. Elena interviewed Ms. Arms there at the hospital and also later and visited with her about what was going on in her life that led to this. Ms. Arms was on probation and that really aggravated me because if you're on probation and you have a drug problem, you need to be asking for help with your drug addiction. And we elected to file criminal charges and the charges were introducing a controlled substance into the body of another. If you read the decision in the case, you can see what this child suffered from. This was a peculiar case according to a lot of the medical professionals, especially the RNs at the hospital, the suffering that the child went through. And I'll just tell you this. One of the things that they described that broke my heart was as these babies lay in these beds, many of them are withdrawing from controlled substances. And they described many of the medical health professionals, most of them RNs, LPNs, A shriek that these children would let loose with. Blood-curdling shriek. And these children want to be swaddled and they want to be held because they're born shaking as they withdraw from these controlled substances. If you're a prosecutor and you have anything in your body that has compassion for a human being, it makes you sick. and i think back as i'm hearing all these stories to all the times that i've been really angry about sexual abuse that has occurred to children and i've been really angry about physical abuse that's occurred to children and i've had people come in my office and say what are you going to do about this child that's abused and i'm supposed to sit here and i'm supposed to hear these ladies tell me, these medical health professionals, about this child shrieking, wanting to be swaddled, being a poor feeder, not being able to suck properly of a bottle, and I'm supposed to do nothing. Folks, in my mind, leaders don't duck problems. Leaders address them, and that's what I've tried to do, and I appreciate you guys hearing
▶ Play
this from me today. The bill that we're debating today is filed subsequent to the appeals court decision where one of the justices specifically requested that the legislature further clarify what our intent is with regard to the battery statute and in this case. There are a lot of folks who have drawn a lot of conclusions about what this bill does that the bill doesn't do. So I'd like to just take you through the bill. It's very simple. As used in 510-101 and 510-105, which is existing law, and we add 513-201, person also includes an unborn child in utero at any stage of development. So we're not changing the definition of who the person is to include a child in utero. That's already been done. The only thing we're doing is applying one more criminal statute that charges can be subsequently and successfully prosecuted in these cases. I think as we look at this, both these folks have told you a little bit about one case. There are many other children in the state who are being born addicted, having to go through those withdrawals. It's been done by people who should be caring for that child, who should be the person who is most conscious of protecting and defending that child. this is something that as as a state we simply have to give these prosecutors within their discretion and they have broad discretion but within their discretion the tools they need when these in these particularly egregious cases to protect the rights of these children to not be born addicted I think with that Mr. Chair we I'm certain there'll be questions and I would like to defer to questions at this point. Looks like
▶ Play
Representative Scott has a question. Representative Scott, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First of all, Mr. Reiner, I appreciate so much your compassion. As long as you have that compassion and that heart and soul in your voice and in your heart, you'll be doing a good job as prosecutor. So I really appreciate that as a citizen of the state of Arkansas. Representative Bell, I have a question that I'm sure you can answer very easily, but I do need to have it clarified, please. My concern with this is that there's a young pregnant woman who, because she is using drugs and is doing this horrible thing to her unborn baby, that the fear of prosecution might scare her so much that she would not get any kind of prenatal care for that unborn child. That's my question. Can you please explain to me, will this deter that? And if it does, I think that's a detriment to our children, our unborn children. Well, I think one of
▶ Play
the two folks that's with me here, I don't know which one, referenced Garrett's Law. And Garrett's Law provides some protections in those cases. In this case, Investigator Cannon indicated something that I don't know that everybody heard, but the original report and the probable cause in this case came from a report of a pipe, I believe, that was found in the labor and delivery room, drug paraphernalia. So that's how this case began the trend of prosecution. So it doesn't address a Garrett's Law situation. This is a case where hospital personnel reported illegal drug paraphernalia in a room that subsequently led through the probable cause chain to this. This wouldn't touch a Garrett's Law type situation. It's not asking anybody to report anything that they're not already reporting. So, you know, again, there are a lot of people that are trying to infer a lot of things outside of what this bill does. It doesn't alter that process. But if a hospital finds drugs in a room, that does open the door for investigation and what they find subsequent to that is and should be subject to prosecution. Follow-up, please, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
That's all right, Representative Scott. Go ahead. So also a young mother-to-be who would go to her OBGYN for the first time for a checkup, and he realizes then that there are drugs present in her system, then would they at that time report and do follow-up testing? Representative Scott, I am not as much of an expert on that area
▶ Play
as I should be. I'm going to defer to one of these folks who's a pro at that and let them tell you what the process is on that
▶ Play
right now. Well, as a specific, I can tell you what I've seen in my career, and you can go back and ask other professionals. What we've seen with regard to prenatal care, is we've seen in the, how many cases did I say? Eight, 11, there's 16 that we've looked at, 14 or 16. In those, the most prenatal visits that we've seen is seven. Okay. And the average one of these women had had two prenatal visits. One of them delivered at home, but out of fear, she delivered at home out of fear prior to our involvement in this, out of fear of DHS getting involved in her life. So I think that prenatal idea may be a bit of a specter that may not be there, but I don't feel eminently qualified to address that, but that's what I've
▶ Play
seen. Thank you. Representative Whitaker, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bell, am I correct in concluding after reading the opinion that this, by seeking to add the term and 5-13-201 at seek, this bill merely seeks to address Judge Whitaker, no relation, concern that he expressed in the concurrence. That is most definitely the intent of the bill, is to simply address the concern of the Court of Appeals that we clarify the intent of the statute and that we make it so that these prosecutors don't have to spend their time at the Court of Appeals defending a case down the line on the basis that this case was appealed on. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Motion at the proper time.
▶ Play
I've got a couple before we go to the audience. Thank you all for what you're doing, and I agree 100 percent. This is terrible. My concern would be How you're going to prove the elements Who's your witness going to be How are you going to prove the elements of assault and battery I mean that reasonable fear How are you going
▶ Play
to prove they were in fear As to the assault I don't know that it's necessary to include the language With regard to assault With the battery What I'm concerned with, as Representative Bell and I discussed this bill, is as I understand it, under the current law, the way it exists, there's no protection for a child inside the womb. Let's say if there's a domestic battery or a battery, if that child is injured and birthed early and has an injury, I'm not 100% sure that that child is protected. and with regard did I answer your question well I think we're going the
▶ Play
same way and I agree with you they're not protected but my concern is when you're prosecuting the case how are you going to prove your elements of assault and battery how are you going to prove who's your witness going to be
▶ Play
Mr. Chair may I address that for a moment for you and and I'm not going to go on the courtroom side of it but I want to go back to the actual content of the bill the 513-201 addresses only the battery side of the statute. The title is a bit misleading on the bill because that's the overall section in law is the assault and battery section. But 513-201 specifically addresses only battery. Thank you. Thank you, Representative
▶ Play
Bell. Another question for whoever wants to answer it. Let's say there's a car wreck and somebody's pregnant that's driving. there could be a civil claim there as I'm sure you know in Arkansas there can be a civil claim for the battery is there now going to be two different claims if I'm the lawyer am I going to now say I have a claim for the driver
▶ Play
and the fetus and how does the insurance company feel about that yeah well the criminal side could already be prosecuted but there's a case and I believe It may be out of Texarkana, and it was a district court case called Crussell versus Electrolux Home Products where an infant and a mother was injured. She was injured on a forklift accident in Texarkana, and there was civil action for battery that lie against Electrolux home products for that injury. So we already have that, at least in the federal district court law. Thank you. Are there any other questions
▶ Play
from committee right now? Okay, we're going to go. Oh, I'm sorry. Representative Bennett, you're
▶ Play
recognized. You know, I guess one of, I have a couple of concerns about this, but one of them is if I'm reading this correctly, we're basically criminalizing addiction. So a mother who's addicted to drugs, which is a horrible thing, and horrible things happen to her children, And is that the intent of this bill, is to hold criminally liable a person that has an addiction?
▶ Play
Representative Bennett, I think I've expressed what my intent is, which is to clarify, as directed by the Court of Appeals, to try to solve their problem in not having a clear sense of direction of what our intent is so my intent is the child in a case like the mccann case which is the one that i'm directly following the bill related to that that mother had disregard for the welfare of her child no question we we have neglect statutes that address that child in a number of different ways that some of them are felonies as well this this is a case where because of the charge that was filed and I think it was the most appropriate charge the element of proof became questionable with regard to the definition of a person and if you read the appeals court case I don't know if you had the opportunity to read it yet but if you read that case one of the things that they specifically talked about from the defendant's side was trying to use various obscure definitions of a person to obscure the facts of the case. They basically stipulated the facts of the case, but then they tried to use the definition of a person as a way to avoid consequences for the action. So I don't think there's any intent to further criminalize addiction to go to the meat of your question. I think it's more to deal with and address behavior that is already criminal, but someone's trying to use a definition to avoid successful prosecution. Thank you. Any other committee
▶ Play
members? Seeing none, we've got Dr. Charlotte Hobbs that's going to sign up to speak against the bill. Dr. Hobbs, are you out there? Oh, okay, you're recognized. Go down to the end of, I'm sorry, go down to the end there where they were sitting. Microphones, just introduce yourself, please.
▶ Play
Speaker 63 22:00
Hi, I'm Dr. Charlotte Hobbs, and I work, I'm here representing the American Academy of Pediatrics. I have been on faculty at UAMS in the Department of Pediatrics since 1996, and I do all of the clinical work that I do in the newborn nurseries at UAMS. So I attend the deliveries of babies and then care for babies during their newborn admission at UAMS. And one of the things that I'm most concerned about with, let me start first by telling you, when a newborn baby is born and the mother has addiction to either a prescribed medication like opiates or a non-prescribed drug, then that can affect the baby. And I agree with what has been said here this morning that we are, as physicians, having to do sometimes some babies that are born to mothers who are addicted will require extra care in the nursery. It's not every baby, and it's not just the illicit drugs. Sometimes the babies that have the most difficulty will be those that are prescribed, that are taking prescribed medications such as opiates. And when we have a baby that has been exposed to an illicit drug, the mother will have, frequently will have a urine drug test, And then what I will do as the attending physician is I will order a urine drug test on the baby and also a meconium drug test on the baby. If either of those are positive, then by Garrett's law passed in 2005 and the amended Garrett's law passed in 2007, I am then required and have the opportunity to contact DHS. I contact DHS and from there then I can order further evaluation of the mom and it's particularly important I think is to, I can also have a home evaluation done so that professional staff will be able to go to the home, do a home visit and come back and tell me before I ever discharge the baby how the baby, what the baby's home situation will be like and I also can take the recommendations of the professionals that work at DHS as to the disposition of this baby on discharge. So sometimes those babies are discharged home into the care of the mom, and sometimes particularly important is that the mom can receive care herself, and she can receive care herself for her addiction, and also the baby can receive the appropriate medical care. I am very concerned with this bill, if this bill criminalizes addiction, that we will lose a window into the treatment of both the mother for her addiction if a criminal file is made and if she, I don't know what the sentence would be, I don't know where the baby would be. I'm a physician, so I'm speaking out of my area of expertise at this point. But I know that for the baby, it's very important that the mom gets prenatal care and is not afraid to come to the hospital for prenatal care. And I fear, and not just I, but I have a document here with comments from multiple professional organizations, multiple professional national organizations who speak very strongly out about their concern about this. And if you will, Representative Shepard, I'd like to read just one very brief. Briefly. This is from the American Academy of Pediatrics. The American Academy of Pediatrics is concerned that arresting drug-addicted women who become pregnant may discourage mothers and their infants from receiving the very medical care and social support systems that are crucial to their treatment. End of
▶ Play
statement. Representative Petty, do you have a question? You're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I just wanted to know how this
▶ Play
Speaker 63 26:50
bill would alter Garrett's law. My understanding that it would alter Garrett's law by criminalizing what is now not a criminal, but a child maltreatment law, the Garrett's law, is not criminal law. And so, therefore, that's the major difference. Representative House. Seeing
▶ Play
no further questions. Representative Beck, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And just depending on your expertise, is it possible that this bill might delay medical attention to the child or something like that because of the criminal side of it? I mean, is it possible that by closing down this window that you might not have all the tools that you need to treat the infant soon? I mean, is it the case where we could get caught up in a legal battle here trying to find out
▶ Play
Speaker 63 27:57
what's the best attack? Yes, my concern would be that a mom who is having a baby and if she knows that when she goes in to the hospital setting that she will have a drug test and if that drug test is positive that she will then be charged with criminal charges that she can intend, that she could have that baby at home. And having the baby at home is, as we all know, is not, especially if not prepared and not ready if the home is not ready to have a home birth. We know that the best place for most babies to be born is within a hospital system where there are professionals that can care for their baby. And not only in our state, but in other states, it has been shown that when women are faced with the potential that they may be charged criminally for their addictions, they are less likely to seek medical care. Representative Gray you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question Thank you Mr.
▶ Play
Chair So currently are you telling me that When a mother delivers in a hospital Can the mother not be charged for drug use Without the baby Can you charge the mother currently
▶ Play
Speaker 63 29:10
right now When the mother When the baby is born To a mother who is drug addicted The mother The baby is We report that case to DHS To respond to your exact question about whether or not that mother could be charged by the legal system, that's beyond my scope of expertise right now. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Copeland, you're recognized for a question. Okay. Seeing no further questions, thank you for your statement. You're welcome. Going back to the public comment list, speaking for the bill, Paul Calvert. Okay. And then we only have one other signed up. Speaking against the bill, Jason Files. You would take a seat at the end of the table, identify yourself, who you represent, and then you may make your statement. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Jason Files. I'm here this morning on behalf of the Arkansas Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. There are a couple of issues with the bill. My understanding is that it has been run in order to address the McCann case, but it is overly broad to accomplish that purpose. McCann was really concerned with one very small part of the battery statute. And by simply just saying, well, we're just going to change this definition, you change the entire statute and not just the part that McCann was concerned with. The Battery Statute actually already addresses injury to unborn children. There are two separate paragraphs that talk about purposefully causing injury to an unborn child or knowingly causing physical injury to a pregnant woman, which then causes injury to the child. So that's already addressed in the bill. And by doing it specifically, the legislature has already addressed the culpable mental state. If you just blanketly change the definition of person, you're going to affect a lot of things unless you go back and address each paragraph of the existing statute. So I think there's some formatting issues. You're not going to have a culpable mental state available for all the other ways that you can commit battery. so it in some ways it's not necessary to add this language in other ways it's necessary to add more language so that you know you don't always know that someone is pregnant you don't always know that you're potentially harming an unborn child McCann really only addresses the specific case where the injury is caused by introducing a controlled substance to another person. And that's where the issue lies. And that's what the court was asking the General Assembly to address. The second issue, of course, is what I think y'all have been keen on, is the policy issue. One of the things that we heard from the supporters was they had someone delivering it home out of fear, that's probably what you would see more of. You criminalize this activity. What could be done, certainly, is the bill could be amended to include some sort of affirmative defense if you seek help, seek treatment, because I think our goal is to protect the child, punishment is fine and in answer to an earlier question, pregnant women are not immune from prosecution for the crimes they commit, so the actual drug possession, the having of a pipe in the delivery room, she could be prosecuted for that. But this could be addressed in a way that if you do what you need to do Pregnant women become addicted, and what we want is for them to get treatment so that before harm occurs to the child, they quit using drugs instead of if they go in and say, I need help, and the result is that they're going to get arrested, they are much less likely to seek that out. So to help the children, the best thing we can do is help the mothers. We're not going to let them get away with crimes, but help them protect their children. one other thing that Dr. Hobbs brought up that's not really addressed here is the way the statute is written, it's illegal to introduce a controlled substance to another person if a mother is prescribed a drug she can't give that to another person, she can't just say oh I've got a prescription for Vicodin here, have one modifying the statute this way would make it criminal for her to take that prescribed medication because she would then be introducing it into her child, who is another person who doesn't have a prescription for that. So there's no exception for that in the statute either. So there are some draftsmanship issues.
▶ Play
That's the best way to put it.
▶ Play
Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like your opinion on how this statute might affect prosecutorial discretion. Do you feel that it would perhaps almost mandate prosecutors to go in and prosecute women that deliver babies that are addicted under this statute? Or do you feel like that, I mean, you talked about drafting issues, but would there still be some lenience if there was a mother in a situation, you know, that, you know, was very, I've lost my vocabulary, was very penitent about what she had done, evidenced a desire to enter recovery. Could they elect not to prosecute, or what's your opinion about that? I don't think it eliminates
▶ Play
prosecutorial discretion, but it would certainly make it difficult for a prosecutor who is prosecuting these cases to say, but I like you, I'm not going to prosecute you, because there is no gray area, really, you did or you didn't. So it's going to be hard to exercise that discretion in a way that's not going to look preferential. So they will still have that discretion. They always have the discretion, but it always raises scrutiny when you choose not to prosecute certain people. Sure. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Petty, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. I'm sorry, but I'm not a doctor, but I've had three babies. And generally, a physician will not prescribe an opiate or a narcotic to a pregnant woman. And so that's why I'm having some confusion about your argument a little bit. Right. And it
▶ Play
wouldn't have to be an opiate, though. There are, and I'm not a doctor, there are cases where it could be a possibility. But the bill isn't talking about just opiates or just, and certainly, you know, doctors prescribing things. But there are a host of controlled substances that aren't necessarily harmful. but they're still controlled substances. All prescription drugs are controlled substances. So it needs some refinement, I would say. Representative Copeland, you're recognized for another
▶ Play
question. Go ahead. I didn't want you
▶ Play
to count that against me, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Speaker 95 37:21
I call your name. No, just
▶ Play
kidding. Go ahead. Thank you so much. Counselor, I'm a little confused. First, you mentioned that harming a fetus or the mother of a fetus is already criminalized, right? Correct? Correct. So this is not necessary? Well, whether it's necessary or not, I think it is a decision for you guys. But I didn't want you to be left with the impression that we didn't already have a law on the books that makes it criminal to harm a child or to harm the mother. But this is an issue that the legislature has already looked at, already has a law in the books that's been very carefully tailored and drafted. So before you just wholesale change it, I think you should probably take a look at the way that's been addressed already because it is criminal. but it was done in a way that you could make sure that the right people were getting punished. Right. Well, my point was I think you said that it was redundant that there was already criminalization of harm in a fetus or the mother of a fetus. So we've heard from the good doctor now from you this rash of home deliveries that's getting ready to happen. If it's already criminalized, wouldn't we already have this rash of home deliveries all over the state? I guess there's a difference here. The specific statute that, as it sits out now, is more aimed at harm from a third person. So I think that part is not so much, if I'm understanding your question, you're saying, well, if we already have this, and it's not causing people to go deliver at home, that sort of thing. I think the statute as written is, it's more addressed at a third party causing harm, you know, assaulting a pregnant woman and doing harm to the child, that sort of thing. I think my point is what the bill is aimed at is addressing the McCann situation, which is the harm is coming from the mother. but if you want to address that situation you need to make sure that's the situation you're addressing instead of just saying we're changing a definition that applies to the whole bill because this is a battery the battery bill itself covers a broad range this 513-201 is not specifically limited to the fetus or anything like that That's our general battery statute, so if you just wholesale change it, it's the law of unintended consequences. You need to go through it paragraph by paragraph and say, do we need it to apply to this paragraph and this one? And what the legislature has previously done is said, well, for unborn children, we need paragraphs five and paragraphs six to address that situation. And now you're really the problem that is looking to be addressed is introduction of a controlled substance to a child. Do we need to address that narrow issue again because of the McCann holding and the possibility for confusion there? And we can address that specifically instead of just changing the entire statute is the issue. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Part of my
▶ Play
question I think you just answered. You would agree that this is an issue that needs to be addressed. You would agree with the appellate court in the concurrence that it's an issue that needs to be
▶ Play
addressed, correct? Probably so, because there is some room for argument there. I mean, that's great if you're a defense lawyer. and you want to argue about it, but the court did say, you know, this needs to be looked at. But it was talking about that specific situation, so I think that's the key.
▶ Play
So, and while you kind of hit the nail on the head as a defense attorney, it being a bit ambiguous leaves you a little bit of room, but in general, as an attorney, you would say that you're for consistency and clarity in the law, correct? That would be a wonderful thing. Right. And as I'm turning your practices in Arkansas, I can see your humor and what you said. Under murder, are these, the fetuses, are they already generally treated as a person? Now, that's my understanding is if
▶ Play
Speaker 107 42:18
you, I've got a copy of this.
▶ Play
I mean, you can look at the definitions and where it applies. So under the code section, 101 through 105, it already is applied and defined that way, correct? Correct. Okay. And then for self-defense is another area. Fetus is basically defined as a person in self-defense. I know that because I ran the bill, but that's correct. From my standpoint, I think that all this does is create some consistency. Would you not see that, that this just basically applies it equally for all these different
▶ Play
criminal statutes? Well, it might be consistent in the sense of definition of person, that sort of thing, and I don't think that's my issue. Okay. You can be consistent in one way and inconsistent in others, And I think probably the main issue we're going to see is you've got two paragraphs right now that were designed for unborn children, battery as to unborn children. They're specifically designed to give you a culpable mental state when you harm an unborn child, meaning you've got to know what you're doing. We want to punish people for doing something intentionally, so that's the way it's drafted. The other paragraphs, since they weren't intended to address unborn children, you could then find yourself in a situation where you're getting prosecuted for causing an injury you had no idea that you were going to cause, never intended to cause. So if this change gets made, I think we need to, it may not need to apply to the entire statute or it may need to be specifically exempted from certain paragraphs. That's the consistency I'm looking
▶ Play
for. Okay. And I understand, as a defense attorney, that less statute or code sections apply to, the better for you. But in general, you would say that this does create some consistency in the law, because now we're recognizing that if you commit this act against a person, that at least for these criminal statutes, this is recognized as a person consistent with these other code sections.
▶ Play
Right. All right. So no further questions. Thank you for your statement. We have no one else signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Bell, would you like to close for your bill? Close, Mr. Chair. One
▶ Play
of the things that you get into when you file a bill like this is you always have people who read things into the bill that the bill doesn't do. So I think I'm going to go back and I'm going to try to specifically address some of the things I've heard today that were claims that the bill does something that the bill doesn't do i heard a bunch of people talking about garrett's law situations and how these would lead to prosecutions in cases where someone sought medical treatment this bill does not touch garrett's law in the case that we're talking about here there was probable cause that existed outside of the medical protections there was a crack pipe or a methamphetamine pipe found in the delivery room this is a very narrow situation there has to be probable cause it does not arise from the medical community for this to even begin to be because Garrett's law provides protections for those. We're not going there with this bill. The two statutes mentioned by the gentleman's defense attorney talking about both require purposefully and willfully in the conduct that goes to state of mind does not address at all recreational use of drugs because there clearly was not purpose or intent to harm when they decide to go get high. When you look at criminal cases, you have the elements of proof that are required to be proven. You can't prove a case without evidence. This is not going to lead to increased prosecutions for moms seeking medical treatment because this guy can't prove a case if The medical professionals under Garrett's law can't provide him with information. It only exists when there's probable cause that arises from outside that community. We heard a comment about that this would lead to prosecutions for mothers who took a prescribed drug. I want to lead you to 513-210, which is a part of this statute. It's referenced in the appeals court decision that you have in front of you on page 3. unless it specifically exempts controlled substances provided by a licensed practitioner. You've heard a bunch of straw men reasons not to support this bill today. You've heard from the people who prosecuted a case. You've heard from the Court of Appeals and the decision you have in front of you as to why we need to clarify this statute. This does that in both the opinion of the people who investigated it, people in the judicial system around it. I'd appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Ballinger? We have a motion do pass. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed?
▶ Play
Speaker 58 47:44
Bill passes. Thank you Mr. Chair, members
▶ Play
of the committee. Without a without objection, we're going to move down to House Bill 1349, Representative Harris. You're recognized to present your bill. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. I really hope to just take seconds of your time and not minutes. House Bill 1349 is the famous drone bill. It has changed from House Bill 1079 to now just the change in statute to the video voyeurism to add into The language, the drone bill, unmanned vehicle or aircraft, and what it does is just basically take the drone and if someone's spying in your window or in your backyard, basically the word peeping Tom looking in on you, they can be prosecuted. And so that's what this bill does. the previous bill kind of I really was endeared to my previous bill but after bringing everybody to the table there was going to be too many exemptions and it was a little far reaching than what I had intended so we just scrapped the bill and did this one I'm seeing
▶ Play
no questions are you closed for your bill? Yes I'd appreciate a good vote Vice Chairman Wright recognize for a motion? Got a motion do pass. A motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed?
▶ Play
Passed your bill. Wow. Thank you very much.
▶ Play
Appreciate it. Without objection, I'd like to move down to House Bill 1362. Mr. Chairman, you're ready. to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Committee, House Bill 1362 creates the Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act. As you can see, it's been amended twice, but that was simply to add Representative Broadway and Representative Sabin as co-sponsors. They actually had other bills that were very similar and attempted to address the same issues that this bill attempts to address. This bill actually was brought to me. You'll recall that a week or two ago, we passed a bill with regard to the uniform partition of heir property. And during those discussions, actually, I believe Professor Foster from the law school here in Little Rock brought this to my attention as well. And with the chairman's permission, I'd like to bring Mr. Craig Lair, who's a practicing attorney, up to the table to make a few comments. He can explain the bill better than I can. And I would say I think all of us may have received an email yesterday from an out-of-state group promoting some other proposed bill. I would say that the response has been generally positive from attorney practitioners in the state who actually deal with these issues. This bill, what it does is it attempts to address the issue of digital information. As we all know, as we move into the 21st century, we all have various types of electronic accounts, digital information that 20 to 30 years ago were not contemplated under the law. And so what happens to that information in the event of incapacity, incompetency, or death? And this bill attempts to address that. And so with that, Mr. Chairman, I'd ask that Mr. Lehrer be allowed to make a statement. Sure.
▶ Play
Mr. Lehrer, just come to the end table and just introduce yourself, please, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 120 52:39
Thank you, all. I'm Craig Lehrer. I'm a practicing attorney at the Rose Firm here. I'm head of approximately 10 estate planning attorneys, former chair of the tax section of the bar, and here on behalf of ACTEC, the American College of Trust and Estate Councils. There's a reason why we think this bill is needed. You are on the edge of cutting-edge law because what's going on is, as each of you increase your digital presence and as Arkansans increase their digital presence, we have a disconnect between what happens in the event of death or disability for those assets. As you all are certainly aware, online bank accounts are increasing. PayPal, Ally, other bank accounts. Your photos are probably no longer stored in photo books on your dresser. Instead, they're on Snapfish, Facebook, and other accounts. You probably don't get near as much mail as you used to get. Instead, you get email. And all of your important records, your banks are pushing you more and more to push your records to email accounts. Your assets include not only bank accounts and investment accounts, which you may only be able to access by email, but also frequent flyer, hotel points, Starbucks rewards, etc. All of these digital assets are the subject of this bill. Purpose of this bill is to allow you, should you choose, to elect a fiduciary or a guardian who will be entitled to access and to be able to transfer or otherwise obtain information about those assets. What we have, and the reason I'm here is we have a disconnect we appoint fiduciaries we you may have elected your spouse or another person to muster your assets at your death or your incapacity and we require them to do that but it's a criminal offense in most cases for them to log in and impersonate you and in fact what you may not realize is the first time you set up many of these accounts you opted for the default provision which on most service providers says if you're deceased or not able to access your accounts gone so you can't access your snapfish to pass on photographs you can't log into Facebook there's been several documented cases you can't access email you may not be able to determine who owns your assets or even what all of your assets are so the purpose of this bill is to clarify the inconsistency between those two laws to allow your designated representative to both access and to transfer, if appropriate, any digital assets that you have and also to be able to report on those assets. Mr. Chairman, I
▶ Play
think Mr. Lehrer has done a good job summarizing the bill. Again, this is a uniform law, so it's something that has been vetted quite a bit gives me some degree of comfort in terms of that we're not, this is as he said, it's kind of a cutting edge area, but in adopting this we would be adopting a uniform law that has been looked at very closely, very thoroughly, and I believe it's the right thing for the people of Arkansas at this time. As I understood some of the concerns raised in the email last night, I think one of the things that was mentioned was that individuals wouldn't want other people to have access to their photos and information online. And particularly in the event of death, I mean, when someone becomes, well, number one, does it really matter at that point? But number two, when you have someone appointed as an executor and they have access to things in the house, I mean, there's information at home that nobody else knows about but maybe the decedent. So, I mean, that's already an issue where we are at this point. This is just simply allowing access to that digital information that as we move further and further into this type of age of technology is going to become more and more an issue, and it needs to be dealt with. this allows us to be proactive and and again from the practitioners I've heard from who are some of the the very finest practitioners in this area across the state who have vast experience the ones I've heard from are all in support of
▶ Play
this legislation no questions representative Broadway got a question Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Isn't it true, Representative Shepard, that under the current status of the law if a person passes away that their personal representative may, because of the absence of this language, have to go and petition the court for a court order to be able to gain access to the digital information. And because of that, that increases attorney's fees and basically cost of administration of the estate. And so this is also a fiscally responsible bill with regard to saving the decedent's estate and the guardian money.
▶ Play
Speaker 120 57:53
I would agree. I would agree, but I would say even worse, I would agree with your point, but even worse, there are instances where you're not allowed, even with a judicial order, to access certain of your accounts. But yes, it is responsible from that standpoint. Thank you. Representative Bain, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. I guess I'm really struggling with this bill because I don't necessarily understand how your Facebook account is an asset. I'm struggling to understand how your Twitter feed is an asset. I mean, if you're Beyonce or somebody like that and you've got a million viewers, maybe you could sell it to Coca-Cola. But I'm just wondering how for your average run-of-the-mill, average Arkansan, how we construe this is an asset of value, and that's where I'm struggling. I'll respond,
▶ Play
and then I'll let Mr. Lair respond. But I think when you're thinking of the term asset, I think it sounds like you're thinking of it in terms of something of monetary value. In this case, an asset of the estate is really just any piece of property or other item that belonged to the decedent. And so while nobody else may find a Twitter feed or Facebook information is valuable, that's really somewhat irrelevant to what really is the issue here, which is who should have access to that information. And additionally, those examples with regard to social media are one thing, but this also covers, as Mr. Lehrer has alluded to, it covers a lot of other types of digital information that have great significance and importance in terms of administering the estate or in terms of a guardian administering the estate of an incompetent. So that would be my response. I would clarify a little bit.
▶ Play
Speaker 120 59:49
There are assets that you have that are valuable to you. Personal family pictures, for example, have value to a family that may not have, obviously I wouldn't pay for your family pictures, but that's an example of one where somebody would pay for for their own family's pictures are the rights. The other example are eBay accounts, for example, or PayPal. They're often stored electronically. There are accounts such as that. Frequent Flyer I've administered in a state that had over a million frequent flyer points, which had hundreds of dollars of value in that case. But the estimates range that you may not realize the value of your digital assets range from $30,000 to $50,000 per person just when you start assembling all of these components together. But beyond even that, the ability to determine what assets that you have is frequently now controlled by email. Every bank account, every investment account that forces you to online statements, the only way you can access that is through your email account. And if you can't get into an email account because the terms of service that you click precludes it, then you can't even determine what assets are out there for an estate in order to effectively administer it.
▶ Play
Follow up, Representative Bain. Thank you, Sherman. I agree, probably my
▶ Play
pictures are pretty much worthless. Now my parents liked them, but I probably didn't worry about them. But I guess my other question then becomes along this line, what about the terms of service that a lot of people, subscribers have already signed up for? What kind of burden is going to be put on subscription services that they've already got a TOS and this
▶ Play
Speaker 120 1:01:30
may not be covered? I would say that the decision point should be what would your default be and most people don't realize that their default is often to destroy those assets and for most Americans that's not what they want. I've practiced for 20 years I've never had anybody say at my death destroy my assets. I've never seen that case, and that's what is often the default rule for these. Now, I think what will happen, in fairness to your question, is as these laws get enacted, I think you will see more like Google and Facebook have done and provide an alternative system where you can designate a person. That would be ideal for this, but in terms of the default provision, the rule would say that the terms of service would have to be overcome by something subsequent to this bill, that for you, you'd have to affirmatively opt to destroy your assets at that point, if that's the decision. That's what I was
▶ Play
going to point out. I think it's back, I believe it's under 2869-909 with regard to compliance and
▶ Play
Speaker 132 1:02:39
Actually, it may not be under that
▶ Play
section, but I was just reading that the there has to be an acknowledgement if the terms are contrary to the law that's void as against public policy unless after the effective date of this act there is some type of affirmative agreement to those terms that would preclude the application of this. Representative Howes, you recognize for a question?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. In the back of my mind somewhere I understand And my recollection is that the doctor-patient privilege exists past death. You may correct me if my assumption or my memory is wrong. I don't want my kids to find out I'm not really their daddy or something. As I read the definition of asset, my doctor says I'm not releasing his medical records to you kids. how does this bill now affect that relationship that I have with my physician and that assumption that I have with
▶ Play
Speaker 120 1:03:56
him or her? This may need clarification from Professor Foster or someone else, but my understanding is that what we're talking about are digital accounts, and that doesn't change a couple of points. There are unrelated provisions out there that allow authorization to health care records, And you can designate a person, that's a separate statute, and you can designate a person or not designate a person. You can designate that these records won't be passed on. So I don't feel that this particular bill is intended to change or alter the course or the conversations between you and a physician. What it would instead allow is access to general, no different than opening the mailbox, except now we're talking about a digital mailbox. I appreciate the intent, but I have
▶ Play
to look at the words. Look at the definition of digital asset. Doesn't that include my doctor's medical database?
▶ Play
I think Professor Foster's here. I think maybe, and she's signed up to make a statement, so it may be best to let her answer that question specifically. Okay. just remind us who you are can
▶ Play
you hear me hello my name is Elisa White and I'm one of your Arkansas Uniform Law Commissioners I'm one of those kind of nerdy people who shut themselves in a room and debate these things ad nauseum so I know It scares me sometimes, too. I appreciate you hearing from me today. It just so happens I'm a health care attorney as well, so I might be able to address that issue. The definition, I would agree with you, the definition of digital asset might encompass those medical records. But if you look, again, at the access by the trustee to the information or the access by the fiduciary, it says subject to federal laws and other laws of the state. And the federal HIPAA law is going to be the one that's applicable there. So all of those HIPAA protections would kick in to protect that asset. Representative Petty
▶ Play
you recognize for a question Representative Whitaker you're next on the list Thank you
▶ Play
Mr. Chair if you could has the Arkansas Bar Association's Uniforms Law Committee reviewed this and or come out with any recommendation
▶ Play
It is not it's not part of the bar package I'm not sure, I know that there's a legislative committee of the bar that meets I believe every Friday to review the bills but I have not heard from them specifically and perhaps she may have some information to shed on
▶ Play
that. Elisa White again. I'm the chair of the Bar Association's Uniform Laws Committee and we have very good I'm taking off one hat and putting on another and we have circulated it to the committee We haven't done, normally that committee does lots of writing and research in advance of preparing the bar package. I have previous experience with that. Yes, yes, yes. And so, but in this case, we have circulated it because this is moving very quickly because there is such a need for it in so many states. It was just developed this past summer in final form. And so the bar committee didn't have its chance to kind of do that full one year worth of look at it. But informally, in circulating it, we all agreed that this was important enough that we didn't need to delay it to go through our usual process. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Ballinger, you have a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. One thing that I just, Representative House's question brought up a question. Typically, when I prepare a state plan, I actually have them sign a HIPAA form at that time. So really, we're talking about having them having access to medical records, that they're probably, the fiduciaries are already going to have some access to them anyway, more often than not. Would that be correct? In a
▶ Play
standard, under a standard HIPAA form, and I think you're right, a lot of times state planning attorneys will make that kind of part of their package, and if the HIPAA form's signed, then yes, then they would have access to it.
▶ Play
Thank you. All right, seeing no further questions from the committee, Professor Foster, you had been signed up. Do you wish to speak? I guess we don't get to question a law professor. We always enjoy getting that chance. Thanks a lot there, Professor Foster. Representative Shepard, do you want to close your bill? I believe I'm closed for my bill. All right. Representative Scott, you have a motion. What's your motion? Got a motion to do pass. All in favor say aye. All opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations, Mr. Chair. Passed your bill. Okay. All right,
▶ Play
without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 227, which Representative Vines is going to run.
▶ Play
Representative Vines, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is a bill I've been working on for about five minutes. Our good friends down in the Senate had to go into session, and our friend, Senator Irvin, asked me to run this bill for her. Pretty straightforward in talking with her. It just adds some language, as you'll see down in line 35, deals with criminal impersonation. I think they had a problem maybe up in her area, her district, of some candidates. for, I think, Sheriff, leaving some insignias, some logos, possibly misleading the public. And she's crafted this bill to deal with marking your car with emblems, logos, markings, decals, insignia, or design that would lead someone to think you were a member of law enforcement in some capacity. And also down on the second page, it allows your circuit or district court to order the immediate removal of those post. I believe, post-election cycle. A very simple, straightforward bill. It may affect you in some of your districts or counties. So with that, I'll take questions if you have any, or I'll refer them to Senator Irwin. Representative Bain, you
▶ Play
recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. With your five minutes
▶ Play
of knowledge of this bill, let me ask you this question. And I do
▶ Play
think your picture is all assets, Representative Bain.
▶ Play
When I'm in the capital city, sometimes I'll actually have a vehicle pull up alongside me that looks like a cop car, a police car, but it's actually a security vehicle for a security firm. How are we going to be able to, under this bill, make sure that those people can still do
▶ Play
their jobs and not run afoul of this? Well, I think the separation is the different distinguishing different factors. If you look down there on 36, line 36 on that first page, it talks about resembling a motor vehicle or motorcycle belonging to a federal state, local law enforcement agency, or law enforcement officer. So I think that's going to be the distinguishing factor there. And my experience has been with security firms. While they may have some sort of insignia, most of the time they do distinguish that with some sort of security or other option. And I think, without putting him on the spot, I think Captain Tosh could probably vouch for
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:12:47
that also. All right. I see no
▶ Play
further questions, and no one is signed up to speak for or against it.
▶ Play
Representative Vines, are you closed? I am, and I will take the risk and ask for a motion for due pass. Or make the motion for due pass,
▶ Play
sorry. I was going to say, is that your motion? That is. All right. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Senator Irvin, thank you. Let's see. Without objection, Representative House, are you wanting to run House Bill 1392? It's the Good Samaritan
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:13:34
Law for Architects. Mr. Chairman, I beg
▶ Play
your pardon. Mr. Chairman, filing an amendment probably today, and it's real simple. It just changes the title in a couple of words. Is it possible to run it without seeing the amendment? We would have to come back here. It would have to come back here anyway, so let's just hold off. I can be ready next meeting. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. All right. Let me go through the list here. House Bill 1203, Representative Hammer, we're passing over. House Bill 1240, Representative Tosh, we're going to pass over that. House Bill 1251, Representative Vines. Okay, we're going to pass over that. House Bill 1252, without objection, Representative Broadway, this is the one that we need a special order for next Thursday. Okay, without objection, House Bill 1252, we're going to set for special order next Thursday at 10 a.m. for the purpose of having a witness who's coming in from out of town. House Bill 1260, Representative Vines. Okay. House Bill 1268, Representative Broadway. Okay, why don't we, I guess let's just set both those for special order on Thursday. Representative Lowry, House Bill 1114, do not see him. Representative Wright, House Bill 1282, we're going to pass over that. Senate Bill 55, Senate Bill 56, Representative Woods, Senator Woods, Representative Bennett was going to run those, but she's not here, so we'll pass over those. We're going to pass over House Bill 1345, House Bill 1371. We're going to pass over House Bill 1374. We're going to pass over Senate Bill 81, Senator Hickey. Representative Hickerson is going to run that bill, and without objection, we're going to set that for special order Tuesday at 10 a.m. Senate Bill 204, we're going to pass over House Bill 1392, Representative House, we've already heard on that we're going to pass over that for today House Bill 1400, Representative Overby do not see her, we'll pass over that House Bill 1403, Representative Vines, pass over that Senate Bill 156, do not see Senator Hester we're going to pass over that and then Senate Bill 311, Senator Hester's not here we'll pass over that So that concludes our regular agenda. As we've indicated, we've set a special order for Tuesday at 10 a.m. and then two special orders for Thursday at 10 a.m. And the reason for the special order is on all those bills, there are witnesses traveling in, and so we want to make sure that we get those heard when the witnesses are here. I would mention, of course, the governor made an announcement yesterday with regard to some criminal justice reforms. I anticipate that a bill will be filed later today, and if there are any questions from the committee as you review that, please feel free to contact me or Senator Hutchinson. All right. Without objection, we're adjourned. Amen.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1376

0:22 - 48:11 139 segments 19 speakers

HB1349

48:11 - 50:05 6 segments 2 speakers

HB1362

50:05 - 1:10:02 56 segments 11 speakers

SB227

1:10:02 - 1:16:56 23 segments 6 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Marshall Wright Chair Unverified
18 segments
Representative David Whitaker Chair Unverified
29 segments
Alaina Cannon Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 63
16 segments
Speaker 18
3 segments
Tobias Peoples Unverified
19 segments
Representative Sue Scott Unverified
5 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
1 segment
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
39 segments
Representative Rebecca Petty Unverified
3 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
2 segments
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
27 segments
Representative Mary Broadaway Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 95
1 segment
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 107
1 segment
Speaker 58
1 segment
Representative Justin T. Harris Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 120
15 segments
Representative John Baine Unverified
5 segments
Representative John T. Vines Chair Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 132
1 segment
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
5 segments
Elisa White Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 157
1 segment
Speaker 160
1 segment