Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Education Committee

February 24, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB265 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB265”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1273 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1273”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1419 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1419”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
You are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee members. I told some folks, one thing I came down here to do was to stop bills and not actually run bills. But this is a bill that would allow a school board member to attend the meeting remotely. In some instances, when it's hard to get there and they may not have a quorum, Personally, being on the school board, 29 years, I think I've missed four meetings, but there is times that that would help. The good part about this bill on the second page, the board may do this. It is at their discretion. Should not be any extra cost to them. We do mostly everything else electronically and remotely. and of course they cannot vote in an executive session or they can't attend it or they can't vote on something that was discussed in an executive session it would just be an avenue that they can attend the meeting if they need a quorum and again it's up to the local school board to do that I would appreciate a due pass and no questions but I
▶ Play
will take some questions Are there any
▶ Play
questions from the committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. There is a provision existing in the law that says a school board member who misses three consecutive meetings is disqualified from further participation on the school board. So if you have the situation that you posture or posit, there is a remedy already in the law to address that. If you have a perennially absent member or members, then the other members can reduce the size of the quorum. because if you have, say, two, and those two are put off, that leaves five who are active in the quorum becomes three out of five. I don't know. Can you tell me the purpose of this bill other than that
▶ Play
somebody wants it? Well, the school board association is the one that asked me to run the bill. And, again, personal experience, there's times, now I know it's probably not statewide, but I know in our area, A lot of your school board members are self-employed, and sometimes you're tied up. You could actually attend the meeting from even out as a farmer out in the field, or in my instance, a lot of times I was tied up at the shop, and I'd have to run to the meeting and then come back and finish my work. I don't think the intent is to circumvent the law. It's just an avenue that the school board has. And, again, it's a May bill. If the school districts don't feel like it's good for their district, they don't have to do it. But it just helps when it's hard to make it to a meeting. Personally, I don't know that it affects the law that we've got right now. I may have some folks here from the school board association that might want to help me answer
▶ Play
that if you need more clarification. Follow-up, after someone else has spoken, if someone chooses to speak. You're recognized for a follow-up. Thank you. It's my understanding that school board members are not paid people. Yes. And they have to rely upon whatever their primary occupation is for their sustenance. And I also understand that there is a bill to put them in the general election and have them run for office. what's the inducement to school board members in small situations like that to pay a lot of money to take on a public responsibility for which there is no compensation or credit or reward? Does that pertain to this bill or for running for school board? Well, it's the same thing because if you take a person off the board or allow a person to be taken off the board for failure to show up due to economic reasons of his or her own, that's causing discredit to the person. And, of course, it discourages other people from seeking school board office for essentially a voluntary position. So all of these things work together, and I'd just like to know your opinion about that before I
▶ Play
vote. Okay. With my opinion, the purpose of this wouldn't be to try to remove a school board member, but it would help the members that have a hard time that they run for the board to serve. Of course, you don't get any compensation, and you catch mostly grief most of the time, but they run because they want to be an asset, and this would just save some of the members. And I don't think, honestly, that it would be used that much. I can't promise that. But, you know, we do basically everything else online, electronically. It's just an avenue for the school districts if they want to use it. Personally, I don't see how it's a detriment to the school board members themselves.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, could we ask the head of the school board association to explain his position? If he would like to come forward and testify
▶ Play
to that, I will allow that. State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized. All of this stuff works together.
▶ Play
Speaker 26 6:07
My name is Tony Prothero, director of the Arkansas School Board Association.
▶ Play
Speaker 27 6:16
Let's restate your question to
▶ Play
you, Representative Walker. I'd like to know the school board association's rationale for
▶ Play
support of this bill. This bill is a local choice bill for districts to allow for remote access to a board meeting. We've had several board members across the state who have talked about things such as there may be an instance where an approval for a contract is needed. there may be some type of a fiscal act that's needed the hiring of a teacher right before school starts and in the time that we're in many of them may be out of state across the state and this would allow for those decisions to take place where the the board member in many cases may be physically be able to be seen by video and could place that vote and be counted for a quorum. So it would comply with the freedom
▶ Play
of information law? Yes, sir. And they could not
▶ Play
vote in executive session. They could be counted for presence at the board meeting. Their vote would be counted, but they may not go into executive session within
▶ Play
this law. Thank you, and I appreciate the explanation, Mr. Chair, and
▶ Play
the several questions that you allowed. Representative Douglas, you are recognized. Just a small question. I'm wondering about the expense of this to the school district, and then would these call-in absences, like Representative Walker mentioned, would not count as one of their absences from the meeting if they're calling in, so that they would not be under the rule of dismissal if they can't meet at the meeting? If they're counted for presence of a quorum and they are counted for that, then it would allow that presence by remote attendance to count as being there. And then have we got a cost on what this equipment would be like to make the call-in possible, or is that just kind of something easy to put together with your technology department? Well, it depends on the local board member, and once again, it's a local decision on it. They may be, if you have a laptop and you can Skype in, if you already have that, I mean, it would basically be no cost. Sometimes it may be through a phone-type situation, depending on, you know, once again, what the local policy would allow the school district to be able to do. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Bale, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. draw your attention to page 2 line 12 as I read it that simply strikes out all reference to the absences and leaves a board with no ability to remove a member who does not attend meetings yes sir there are several bills that we
▶ Play
put forward for the people to be able to put into draft form 613 613 which is another school all bill has the language which specifically states that and I can read that if they if they move their bona fide residence or if they fail to attend a meeting of the board of directors for over a period of 90 days his or her office as a school board member in any position may be declared vacant by majority of the board members so very similar language is in a different area and we have another bill that's coming through dealing with vacancies which consolidates all of that into one so this is redundant language which is in another part of the code
▶ Play
follow up mr chair you're recognized the language you just mentioned i'm not familiar with that code section but is permissive it says may this is the way you just read it and the language that's in this statute may be removed from office by a majority vote but only after opportunity for a hearing that would seem to indicate that the hearing has that that there's some there's some requirement for a mandatory hearing can you help me out with that
▶ Play
are you saying the code that was stricken would require hearing but the other code does not correct in the language that we have that would come before the committee and vacancies it had not only talks about the hearing but it will lay out very specific circumstances for the hearing about the appeal process going to the circuit court and many other items. But you're asking
▶ Play
us to strike this language prior to actually hearing the other bill. From what I
▶ Play
understand, I'm not an attorney, and we have an attorney on staff that might be better to answer your question here, but from what I understand, according to other codes, that the board could not just go in unilaterally, that because they are an elected official, they would have a right to appeal to circuit court regardless of whether it's spelled out specifically in the language. Mr. Chair, if
▶ Play
you'll put me back in queue, I've got additional questions. Representative Saban, you're recognized. I'll defer to Representative
▶ Play
Bell so he can ask his question and come back to me maybe. Representative Bell, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Another problem I see in the bill is there's no limit on how many times these virtual meetings can occur. I can understand maybe occasionally there being the need to do this, but this bill doesn't place any limitation on it. And I can literally see us getting into a situation where we
▶ Play
have virtual school board meetings. Once again, there would be no limitation on this. It would be, once again, up to the local school board. I would think, though, that in most communities that if you had someone who missed six, nine, and it was all by virtual, that there may be issues when it came time for re-election.
▶ Play
Additional follow-up, Mr. Chair? another issue i see with the bill um this removes the quorum requirement to lack so that you don't have to have physical presence but then denies the physical prayer the virtual presence within the executive session so you could literally have an executive session taking place without
▶ Play
Speaker 62 12:43
a quorum present no sir quorum i think would be required for the executive session not as i read
▶ Play
the statute, sir, I would have to ask someone that's more knowledgeable in this than I would.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, if we could get somebody that could answer that, I think that's a very important question here. I'm not sure
▶ Play
who we need to call on for that. I'd ask that you call Lucas Harder, who is the staff attorney. That would be fine. Lucas, if you would come
▶ Play
forward. If you state your name and who you're with, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 68 13:31
Lucas Harder with the School Boards Association. My understanding is that this would be solely for the way we were attempting to draft this is that it would be solely for the purposes of establishing a quorum. since you can't conduct any business in executive session those members may be able to go into executive session but they couldn't do anything since they couldn't come out and vote on anything because they wouldn't have a quorum that would be capable of voting Representative Bill you're recognized
▶ Play
for one more question Thank you Mr. Chair I appreciate your indulgence Mr. Harder the plain read of the statute would indicate that an executive session could be held under this language although no action could be taken there could be discussion there could be other things take place within that executive session regarding personnel issues without the physical presence of a quorum and without the virtual presence of a quorum under this legislation as I read it are you are you saying that's not the case That is not what I said. What I said is that while they
▶ Play
Speaker 68 14:48
may be able to go into executive session for that particular issue, they wouldn't be able to take no action because there would be no quorum that would be capable of voting on that issue.
▶ Play
Rep. Sabin, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative McNair, I definitely understand this bill as a matter of necessity. My concern would be that it kind of could drag into a matter of convenience for members of the school board. And, you know, one experience we had in Little Rock with our airport commission is that one member got in the habit of participating simply by teleconference in all the meetings. And eventually, a lot of the other members felt that that person wasn't engaged and their participation obviously suffered as a result. And so I guess my question to you would be, would you consider putting in a maximum limitation on the number of times somebody could participate in this way so that it was reserved really for only when it was necessary? Because again, I understand why this might come into play. But I just worry it could be very easily abused or somebody just doesn't feel like making the drive and just says, I'll just call it in.
▶ Play
Speaker 68 16:11
May I answer that? You recognize. In the bill that we are hoping to put forward for vacancies, we are placing it so that a member must be physically present for at least six meetings in a year's time. or at least physically present once every three meetings so that hopefully in that manner that should address your concerns.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess I share Representative Bell's concern, though. I think that passing this bill before we pass the other bill, it just seems a little bit out of order, or at least we could see both of them at the same time because you're basically asking us to take it on faith and add this to the statute before we know what else is going on. I'm not trying to be difficult, but
▶ Play
I think it's important. Thank you. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I, too, share the concerns that have been expressed by Representative Bell and Representative Sabin. The problem I have is that the only matter that you can have discussed in personnel, I mean in executive session is personnel and I can't very well see how you if you don't have a quorum I don't see how you could allow three people out of seven to go into executive session hear personnel matters and then come out because you do have a quorum because of the call-in and have those three people who went into executive session make the decision. So I would like for you to rework to work on this bill some more or at least defer it until the other bill is presented. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Douglas, you're recognized. I think that
▶ Play
was my question as well. If they go into the executive session without a quorum and then they come out and vote on that issue, I think I would feel more comfortable if they had to have a quorum in order to discuss the issues in executive. Is that, or am I wrong to, is that already the case?
▶ Play
Did I misunderstand? If they don't have a quorum going into executive session, they wouldn't have a quorum to vote because the board member attending remotely can't vote on that. And, again, this is up to the local school district so much for a simple bill. But, anyway. But I'm just saying you would. They have the, I mean, my opinion, again, which that and a dollar, buy you a cup of coffee. But I don't, if that's not going to happen, I don't believe the superintendent would call up the executive session. But, you know, I understand. And as far as changing the bill to limit that, I don't know that that's a problem doing that.
▶ Play
So you're saying you might would change it to say that you can only have an executive session if you have a quorum on site. You can't use the call-in quorum. That's right. I think that would make us all
▶ Play
more comfortable. Representative Bell, you're recognized. Mr. Chair, I don't exactly have a question. I've got sort of a line of recommendation. Can I have the indulgence of the chair for a moment? You can. Representative McNair, personally, I could be comfortable with this bill with the limitations that Representative Douglas mentioned and placing some limit on the number of times within a calendar year that this could be done. So that there are cases where I think everybody recognizes that this could benefit the process. But I would encourage you to look at a complete bar on executive sessions when you don't have a quorum physically present and looking at a limit on the number of times it can be done. I think that would greatly improve your bill. Yes. Representative,
▶ Play
I will give you the option of if you want to pull your bill back and amend it and bring it back or we
▶ Play
Speaker 85 20:40
can continue. I'll pull it back and bring it back. You're
▶ Play
recognized to do that. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Bell, you are recognized to present Senate Bill 265.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. I think with the permission of the chair, I'd like to ask Dr. Bobbitt and Dr. Moore from the University of Arkansas to join me because a lot of the content here is going to get over my head pretty quickly.
▶ Play
If y'all would like to join him at the table, then just state who you are and who you're with, please. Senate Bill 265.
▶ Play
Members of the committee, Mr. Chair, in 2013, the House and Senate both passed resolutions applauding the U of A system for exploring creative and innovative approaches to reach additional Arkansans and make college credit more available using its online learning efforts. Since that time, a lot of work's been done, and this February, the U of A Board of Trustees voted to establish Eversity, which is a fully online university within the U of A system that will offer workplace relevant degrees, certificates, and affordable tuition rates to meet the needs of adult learners around the state primarily. Those who have work and family responsibilities and need an option to finish their education in a way that's flexible enough to meet their needs. Eversity is the result of U of A's attempts to meet that opportunity. Six week courses, rigorous academically, low tuition costs, advisors who are paying attention to the point of almost being intrusive, all for the student from the comfort of home with an internet connection. U of A System is literally creating a university from scratch. It's a new business model that really doesn't exist anywhere in higher ed. It challenges the way higher ed has operated for more than 200 years, and it's disruptive to many people who don't understand it. Dr. Bobbitt recently said that he's tired of Arkansas always being ranked 49th in the country in the number of Arkansans with the degree, and he's insisted that higher ed look for a new way to move that needle. I share those concerns. That's why I'm at the end of the table. I represent a district in western Arkansas that's comprised of three counties, Polk County, where I reside, 12.3% of the adults have a bachelor's degree. Sevier County, the southern end of my district, 8.6% have a bachelor's degree. Montgomery County, 12.9%. But what I also know from the census data on that district is that many of those people, many of the people within that district who don't have a degree have some college. many have are well on their way towards a degree but simply life has gotten in the way of completing it for example in polk county we have nearly 34 percent that have some college montgomery county is right at 30 severe county's 25 so there is a large percentage of people who have some college already under their belt but are just simply for whatever reason be it a geographic barrier, a time barrier, are unable to complete. Here at the Capitol, we often look at ways to lessen the regulatory burdens on business and industry. This is a case where we're looking at lessening the regulatory burden on higher ed to help them develop a new model that meets the needs of our time. E-Versity will not seek any general revenue funding. As a critical component of this, this is a completely different way to do education. It will be tuition and grant-driven from outside of our state general revenue. This bill is needed to give eVersity the flexibility it needs to operate within the model that it's in. Many of you are familiar with online universities, the for-profits, such as University of Phoenix, Kaplan, and some of the others that are out there. We've got over 14,000 Arkansans enrolled currently in that type of education. This simply gives us an Arkansas-based higher ed option for those people and people like them in the future who want to attend Arkansas's flagship university with that level of academic rigor and do it with an Arkansas university. This is groundbreaking. The things that we learn as we develop eVersity, as it begins to go forward, will be shared with all the U of A system campuses to improve on the work that each of them is already doing to help students attain their goal of getting a higher education credential, whether it's a certificate or a degree. With that, Mr. Chair, these gentlemen are here. They're experts in higher ed. I'm certainly not. But I would be glad to entertain questions from the committee. Are there
▶ Play
any questions, committee? Representative Douglas, you recognize. I applaud
▶ Play
this idea. I think it's timely. I'm glad that we're going to be on the cutting edge. And I know Dr. Bobbitt has been thinking about this for at least two years, I've heard. So it's sad that we have so many regulations that it's taken two years to get it off the ground. But I think seeing this list of 24 exemptions gives me a little heartburn. The two questions I would have are the oversight that would be missing with all the exemptions to reporting data like graduation, success of the students, and wondering how we might feed that back into the process so that we could be able to see some reports on what I think is going to be very successful. And just, you know, that one thing I think might be missing. You might have it in there. You might address that. Representative Douglas, I'm
▶ Play
going to defer to Dr. Moore, But before I go there, I want to make one key point that I think everybody needs to keep in mind. We're not asking for general revenue. And as a result, a lot of our legislative oversight responsibility comes from the fact that we're keeping track of the state's money. Now, there's no question there are some U of A system resources that are involved in this. But they are minimal in the amount of money that's actually in line with this university. So you can make a solid case for reduced oversight because of that. There's no question that these folks are going to be going out and seeking private grants and other things to move this university forward, and they're going to have to be able to provide data to be able to do that. The issue with these specific line items that they're asking for exemptions from deals mostly with cost. This is a model that each of these has a cost associated with it of compliance, and being able to sidestep those costs and be able to compete in an environment where the for-profits are functioning is critical. So let's talk about the tuition side of this for just a second. Well, if
▶ Play
I could just have a follow-up before you get to that. If you're collecting the data for grant proposals and that kind of thing, is that data going to be available to the
▶ Play
public? I'm going to get there with Dr. Moore, but I want to make the point regarding tuition because it's critical to this overall model, okay? This e-versity is going to be positioned kind of in a unique place with regard to tuition. A three-hour course, I'm being told, is going to cost somewhere in the neighborhood of $500 total, okay? That puts it slightly higher than community colleges, so it shouldn't directly compete with community colleges. It puts it cheaper than most of the online universities and clearly cheaper than physically being present at a higher ed institution. So the location within the overall tuition model is critical to understanding where this fits, and it's very important that they may be able to maintain that level of tuition to hit the niche market that they're wanting to hit. Mr. Chair, with your indulgence, I'd like Dr. Moore to respond directly to Representative Douglas' question. Dr. Moore, if you would state
▶ Play
your name and who you're with, you recognize.
▶ Play
Michael Moore, Vice President for Academic Affairs, University of Arkansas System. Representative's question is a very good one, and we fully intend to share the data that we collect about the success of our students. The reason the exemption is necessary is because the way the state government and the federal government define graduation and retention is based upon the definition of a normal student enrolling in a full load of courses in a typical fall semester or spring semester, and that's defined as 12 hours of study at that time. And so they define your success as whether or not you've gone, for example, from your freshman year into your sophomore year based on the full-time student status and then also whether or not how quickly you graduated, whether in four years or six years. By definition, none of our students will meet those definitions because our students will enroll in a single class at a time. So none of them would ever be considered full-time. So if we were to adhere to the definitions that are currently required by the state and federal agencies, it would appear as if 0% of our students were successful. We fully intend to issue annual reports to show how much learning is occurring in our courses. We're going to measure that with pre-test and post-test. We'd be happy to make that data widely available, but the current reporting requirements don't serve our needs, and that's why the request for the exemption is there. Did I have another follow-up? Representative Walker, you're recognized. With the chair of indulgence, I'll defer for the moment to Representative Douglas for a follow-up.
▶ Play
You're recognized, Representative Douglas. Just something you said, Dr. Moore, was so will we have a new definition of success under this program? Well, my definition of success
▶ Play
will be measured in two ways. One will be the persistence of the student to continue to stay enrolled in the program. So one course, the next course, and then also the second one would be did they earn the credential that they were seeking. So a lot of that will depend on when the student, where the student enters. Their definition of success might be simply a certificate of proficiency or a technical certificate and not the attainment of a degree. That's another shortcoming, frankly, of the current definition. We define students, unfortunately, that stop short of earning an associate degree or baccalaureate degree as a failure because they have not graduated with a degree, whereas somebody that, you know, earns that certificate of proficiency, technical certificate, ought to be seen as success. So we're happy to share all the data we have. We just don't think the current reporting requirements serve our needs. Thank you. That's very clear. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Let me say at the outset, I generally give Dr. Bobbitt credit for creativity and good faith. And my questions don't address either of those points. I'm concerned about things that we talk about here. One, for instance, Dr. Bobbitt, the cost per student to the state and the way the state has projected that cost. Another thing would be the standards of academic achievement. They seem not to be explicit and they seem to be less than the standards of academic achievement for those at the flagship university where presumably this would be primarily focused with private philanthropy being its funding source. The other is the staff and staffing of it and how their work is to be evaluated. I am concerned about things that sort of exclude people of my hue, which are GPA and ACT. And I'd like to know how you plan to address this as you seek to compete with the other schools that are online, like the University of Phoenix. Thank you, Representative Walker. The fact that we If you would please recognize yourself Excuse
▶ Play
me. My name is Donald Bobbitt. I'm president of the University of Arkansas System. We decided very early on in our business model that we wanted to look at students as being the sole focus of the institution. And one of the reasons that we declined to go into the pool for general revenue is that we need to be absolutely focused on these students because I think as you were alluding to, they come to us with a record that has not allowed them to complete at this time, whether it's financial or whether it's academic, and we want to help them succeed. So our cost, I would say that the cost to the state for them continuing in one of our programs is going to be less than the cost to the state of them not having the credential they need to be able to economically contribute to their family, their community, and the state. I would tell you that I believe the academic standards will be no different than at any of our institutions. Dr. Moore has done a very good job of enlisting the faculty from our institutions to serve as both the arbiters of the quality of our programs, development of the programs, and in fact, one of the key points of our business model is that there is capacity within the system. And we intend to take advantage of that capacity to use these individuals to teach our courses. And so their courses will be taught by University of Arkansas faculty. They just will not reside on a single campus, but on multiple campuses. And finally, for the staffing, I think I just alluded to the fact that because costs are going to be a tremendous driver for us, we have to look at ways to reach the students using technology and then secondary with staffing because, you know, without the cushion, if you will, of state funding, we don't have the luxury, in fact, of having students not succeed.
▶ Play
And I don't know if Dr. Moore wants to add to that. Just to add briefly to the admission requirements, we're actually going to be very much an open access institution. The basic requirement for getting into most of the undergraduate programs will simply be a high school degree. We have a large portion of our state that started college that never completed it. They earned some college credit. We have over about 350,000 students that began the path to college and did not finish that. And you're right, Representative, it is disproportionately allocated among the state. There are different achievement rates based on economic status and income status. And we believe, given our price point and the target population we're after, we'll actually reach out to more of those that historically have been disadvantaged through this process than through the more traditional means of education. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. Do you have a scholarship component? We are working towards that. So scholarship money tends to come from private dollars and you may have recently seen coverage of a sizable gift from the Tyson Foundation. Part of that money is going to be used for operating costs, but we have set aside a portion of that to be used for scholarship dollars. We will continue to try to develop scholarship dollars on the, as long as I can speak for a moment about the financial aid component, we're working aggressively to make sure that the students are eligible for federal financial aid so that they will have access to that. and we will continue to pursue private philanthropy to fund scholarships. Follow-up, please. You're recognized. How do you intend to be non-discriminatory and inclusive with respect to faculty, staff, evaluation, and outcomes? Our faculty and staff right now are being drawn. Well, let me take faculty specifically at first. Those are being drawn from the existing UA institutions. So we've sent out requests for faculty to develop our initial courses. Those are the ones in our core curriculum, and I can tell you that we have faculty members from most every UA institution participating in that, and there is diversity in that pool. On the staff side, we do have a staff of about nine members right now working for Eversity, and there is both gender and racial diversity in that staff as well. It's an important value to me. It's something I think is very, very important for our state. Our university needs to reflect the qualities and the attributes of the people that we're teaching. The evaluation of faculty, since they're being paid as overload, will occur back at their home campus. So if you're from Pine Bluff, you'd be evaluated by the Pine Bluff there because that's part of where your normal job is at. If you're at Monticello, that's where your evaluation would occur, so through the existing university. We will have for our staff members internal evaluation procedures that would occur on an
▶ Play
annual basis. Could I just add to that? Amongst the regulations that we have listed here, you do not see the reporting requirements where we have to provide information to the General Assembly about the demographics of our students, our staff. And, in fact, we are not exempt from them. We don't choose. We don't want to be exempt from them. And we will be reporting to you
▶ Play
on that data. Representative Gossage, you're recognized. You may have already said this, but I just want to be clear about the cost. Normally, of course, the university year, you'll take 10 courses, five each semester. We're talking about $2,500 each semester, $5,000 per year. No. Our courses will be six weeks in length. There will
▶ Play
be a buffer week in between. So over the course of a year, a student would take seven courses, one course at a time. and the price will be roughly $500. We haven't nailed that down just
▶ Play
yet. So you can only take one course at a time with this, and is that the reason why you're having to do some negotiating to get Pell Grant money for students because this is no? Yes? So let me answer this in maybe two
▶ Play
ways. The first reason is a little explanation as to why we're doing one course at a time. So the target population is not the 18 to 22-year-old that we find at the brick-and-mortar institution. It's the adult who's working a job, maybe two jobs, has family to take care of. Their ability, based on our experience, to take three or four courses at a time is very, very limited. They do much, much better in a learning environment where they take one course at a time, can focus on that in an intense period, then move on to the next course. If we get some experience and we find that we have some exceptional learners in the bunch and they want to petition us to take a second course at the time, we'll consider that. But we want to do that based upon having some success from the student to show that they're an outstanding student and can handle that level of learning on top of their already busy lives. The funding aspect of it from the federal Pell Grant, they do allow two types of funding. One is the normal, what's called term-based funding, which is what most institutions do, and that's based upon 12 hours of enrollment for full-time aid or six for part-time and an undergraduate. They also allow what's called non-term-based aid, and that's what the model that we will be using, it's provided for in the federal regulations, and you're funded on a course-by-course basis.
▶ Play
Reverend Douglas, you're recognized. was wondering how this fits into the umbrella of higher ed and whether there's any coordination or will this be spreading to other universities or I didn't know if we needed to bring Dr. Powell to the table and and and find out how what how this piece fits into higher ed or Thank you, Representative Douglas.
▶ Play
When we take a look at the higher ed landscape, it really appears that there's a bimodal distribution of students. There's the traditional students and we would encourage them to attend our traditional institutions. There's a social maturization that occurs in addition to the intellectual maturization. However, if you take a look across the state and use the Lumina data, there are over 350,000 students who started and life got in the way. And our focus is going to be at least initially solely on those individuals. One of the reasons why we chose to do it this way is it reminds us each and every day the most important thing that we have in front of us are the students that we serve because frankly if they are no longer enrolled at our institution, we no longer have an institution. So I don't know whether this would spread. Our plan is that we will identify best practices. You'll see in the regulations textbooks, for example. And we've looked at that as a cost driver that's an inhibitor for students' progress. And so we're looking at two different models. One, using what's called open access materials that are available. Faculty would determine them, not us, but faculty would determine them. Michael also has talked to publishers who have worked out agreements where, for example, for $35 or $40, as long as each student pays that money or we pay that money for the students, we can have the textbook for the course. It would normally cost well in excess of $100. So again, our business practices that we're looking at are focused on the student, focused on keeping costs down. And we hope that things that we identify that are successful will be adopted by others.
▶ Play
So the question was that there's, is there a coordination or is there oversight by Department of Higher Ed yes shortly
▶ Play
Speaker 139 44:19
after our board adopted created the eversity we
▶ Play
did take a proposal to ADHE and it was recognized by ADHE so they'll get the reporting of
▶ Play
your numbers yes in addition we will seek
▶ Play
the accreditation that's necessary to secure the financial aid as well so that's another level of review and reporting that's required
▶ Play
as well motion of proper time I just want to continue along my line of questioning. If a student receives a full Pell Grant based on this six, seven courses per year, what percent of the cost is, it looks like $3,500 per year, what percent of the cost is that full Pell Grant
▶ Play
ride going to I'm going to get into deep waters here that I'm not probably skilled enough to navigate I have somebody on my staff that is a financial aid expert the amount of money that you receive is dependent upon you know the factors of your own personal financial situation so how much money you receive as a student your full amount may or may not cover the whole amount because it would depend on how much money you're receiving So representatives at Saban sitting next to you may receive a different amount than you serve based on your financial circumstances. We believe that most of the students that we're going after the Pell Grant will cover most of this. We are, for example, also, just to add one other thing on the Pell Grant area, doing what we can to eliminate as much fraud as we possibly can in this sense, that a lot of students today, some students today, will take the full Pell Grant, And, you know, that covers cost of living expenses, that it covers cost of books. And then there's no requirement that they actually go to the bookstore and buy the books. They could use it to pay for other expenses, living expenses, for example. We won't have those costs factored into our cost of attendance because we won't have any cost. There won't be any room at board. These are fully online students. So it will actually be less expensive for the federal government in this sense to fund these students. Follow-up question?
▶ Play
Yeah, I was a counselor for a long time in my past life, so the cost of attendance I understand, and I'm not sure what all is going to be. I know normally you do have room and board and those sort of things, but in this particular case, I don't know what all you can count beyond whether you can count the fact you've got to have Internet connection, whether you have to have a laptop, whether you have to have child care. Those things can be factored into this, But I guess the bottom line is I would love to see this program developed in such a way. And I approached Senator Broadway several months ago about letting someone who qualifies for a full Pell Grant to be able to attend free. Because, again, I think that gets to what Representative Walker is talking about, the access that would be available to that population of students to remove almost all the barriers before them, the opportunity would be there. So that's more of a comment than a question. That's our objective. Thank you. Representative Douglas, you're
▶ Play
recognized. If you would like to call, I think, someone up. Yes, I
▶ Play
just thought it would be good to hear from higher ed and see how these pieces are fitting together and how the coordination is going to occur. If
▶ Play
you'd state your name and who you're
▶ Play
Speaker 149 48:15
with, you can recognize. Good morning. Brett Powell, Department of Higher Education. I just want to say, first of all, that I applaud the work that Dr. Bobbitt and Dr. Moore have done with Eversity. I think they are tackling head-on two of the primary issues that keep us with that 49th statistic that Dr. Bobbitt keeps repeating. One of those is getting adults to a degree, and the other is the cost of higher education, and they're obviously working directly on both of those issues. As far as coordination with the Department of Higher Education, one of the things that I hope that we can do better in the future is to encourage innovation like this and to encourage innovative programs to permeate the rest of the institutions in the state. So we would love to see ideas like this broadened so that they can be repeated in other institutions. I do – we would like to ensure that we have appropriate reporting and data so that we can share that kind of information with the other institutions. You know, from what I know about the program at this point, I feel like it is going to be wildly successful, and we would love to be able to share the kind of efficiency and effectiveness data that I think are going to come out of this with the rest of the institutions so that we have a model that we can follow. And so as long as we've got that coordination piece in place so that we can share that kind of information, then I think it fits well with what we would want to do in the department.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My concern with what you all say is that we have a good, as a state, a good record for admitting people to college. Our failure is in graduating them. So we may be 20th in terms of college admissions, but 47th or 48th in college graduation. I don't see how this affects college graduation. It gets more people into college, but I haven't heard you address how this is going to ensure increase of the persons who actually finish college. And I'm concerned about that. I guess that has to evolve as time goes on on the basis of the good faith of Dr. Bobbitt and Dr. Moore. But I don't see how, if you could explain to me how getting more people into a failing system is going to cause the failures to be obliterated, I'd like to know how that's going to be. Thank you, Representative. It's a very important question to answer, and you're right, the removal of regulations in and of themselves will not lead to increased student success. So the answer to that question comes more from how we're going to approach dealing with students. From the very first time that we get in contact with students, we want to begin to immerse ourselves in what's motivating them to come back to school, understand what their educational goals are, and as Representative Bell said in his introduction, almost to the point of being intrusive about the level of support that we're going to do. Let me just perhaps give you a very quick illustration about how we will be different in how we approach these students. We know, for example, at most universities about some students, how they perform, say, for example, in high school math. Math is one of the biggest stumbling blocks of many, many college students. We'll know they had trouble in high school. We'll know their SAT and SAT scores in math. We'll even know whether or not they ended up placing into a remedial or developmental math course and how many times they had to take it. And yet, when that student signs up later on to take their college algebra course, We typically, in higher ed, do not tell the instructor of that class a single thing about that person's prior math experience. That faculty member is flying completely blind in that class. We don't know whether or not this student or that student is the one that needs the extra help. So if on day one we can focus on that student and tell the instructor, this student has had some trouble in math in the past, you might want to pay a little extra attention to them, and if on our side we can reach out to that student and say, we have free math tutoring available for you, Have the tutor contact that student on day one and help them. What we typically do now is we wait until that student fails three or four tests, and then about the midterm, we contact them and say, oh, by the way, you're not doing real well in math. We think you might want to pick up the pace a little bit. We need to have a different approach where we are on students monitoring their activity on almost a daily basis and helping those students that are in trouble before they get so deep into trouble they can't dig themselves out of the hole. Dr. Bobbitt, does not this sound like the program that UALR has undertaken with the Pulaski County Special School District to address students who are failing before they finish school by providing specialized subsidies and focused attention on the deficiencies so that the chances of them being more successful in a conventional academic environment will be increased? Absolutely. The only difference probably is one of 10
▶ Play
Speaker 151 53:35
to 15 years in the age of the students who are being
▶ Play
helped. Thank you very much. Are there any other questions, committee?
▶ Play
Not seeing any. Is there anyone who would like to speak against the bill? For
▶ Play
the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? just briefly mr. chair this bill is important to me personally you know many of us get asked to carry bills i actually asked the university of arkansas if i could carry this bill i'm certainly not a higher ed expert but i represent a part of the state that there are significant geographic barriers to a four-year degree we're 85 miles from anywhere where you can get one except a few very, very limited online programs. This will give the folks in a lot of the outlying parts of the state the opportunity to pursue an education that currently just simply doesn't exist for them with a degree of this kind of academic quality. I'm very appreciative of the University of Arkansas for doing this and would very much appreciate a good vote. Representative McElroy, you're recognized for motion.
▶ Play
Motion do pass. I have a motion to do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say no. Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. Could I ask Mr. Bell one question? We're going to move on. I'll let you all do that personally. At this time, I'll recognize Representative Harris to present House Bill 1273-1273.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee members. I think I'll hurry because Representative Walker walked out of the room. So let's get this done. Now I'm teasing. I have great
▶ Play
Speaker 3 55:57
respect for him. I can get him
▶ Play
back in here if you want me to. No. House Bill 1273 was brought to me from a constituent, and it's an act to provide for the voluntary student expression of religious viewpoint. And what it is, it's a religious student freedom bill, and it just allows the student to have freedom of expression on their viewpoints when doing homework that pertains to the actual assignment and be able to wear a T-shirt that may have religious expression on there. And also, I mean, you've seen it on the news where, you know, maybe they've had to turn their shirt inside out or not wear a cross necklace, and this would just allow them to do that and it's also where you see across the board different schools having different policies and this just will make it all across the board and I'd just like to say also as you've hopefully read the bill that the Arkansas Parent Teacher Association they support this bill and I want to make it clear that this law tracks with the federal equal access laws as well as case law affirming students' First Amendment rights at school. And it also, we already have it in law that the public schools, they do not sponsor clubs. This is done after school, so this is not creating sponsorship of particular clubs or events such as See You at the Pole. This is still done, or Prayer at the Pole. This is done by students, so this is not creating anything different. Just allowing students to do artwork, paper assignments, who they may, like, if they want to, who's their biggest influencer, if it's Jesus or whoever else it may be, I mean, they can write about it. And the teacher can't keep them from writing about that in their assignment. Well,
▶ Play
I have a question. Yes, sir. Is that open to all religions? It's
▶ Play
all. I mean, they could write about Muhammad, whoever it may be. I don't want to
▶ Play
be. So also on their T-shirts, any open religion that is practiced could have something on that T-shirt that had their religion on it?
▶ Play
It's their deeply held religious belief. That's
▶ Play
all my questions. I'll recognize Representative Murdoch. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 161 58:35
Chairman. and thank you, Representative Harris, for at least trying to bring something. I think I understand the intent. My concern would be that that's a real wide, because there are some varied beliefs out there. Some of those beliefs that someone can assert could be very offensive, could be very demeaning, could be very in the name of their religion. So wouldn't we be careful that if we say whatever they believe because what is the litmus for what is an established belief and how do we limit that from really getting out of bounds? I think I know your intent for sure, but I'm concerned about the boundaries or the lack thereof because when we say their intent or what they really believe in, How can we define that, and how can we make sure, more importantly, that we keep that encased in the manner that I think you're trying to present this?
▶ Play
There's already statutes out there. I mean, there's uniformity laws, but it's also core religious beliefs. And so, I mean, there's still uniformity that the students would have to adhere to, but it's also there's the freedom of religion and your First Amendment rights of free speech. I mean, it's still in there, and there's case law. And so, I mean, I understand what you're saying, but there's still the freedom to do so. And so, I mean, I don't want to answer your question without answering the question.
▶ Play
Speaker 161 1:00:12
One quick follow-up, if I may. So, with statute currently being out there, there are defined boundaries and limits. I think that's what you're saying. then this legislation became necessary for you for what reason? With the freedom constitution being what it is and with statute being there to limit and bound to keep us safe and secure from some of the things that I mentioned as a concern, what's the impetus for this legislation then that's different from what's already on the books?
▶ Play
Well, I mean, there's different interpretations from school to school. And so if you read in the bill, it says this is what a student may at a public school may do and what the public school shall and what the public school shall not do. And so it pretty well spells it out. And so there's, you know, interpretation of there's no interpretation actually says what it can and cannot do as far as artwork. And then it gives what the student may do as far as what they can wear and freedom of expression.
▶ Play
Speaker 161 1:01:17
Thank you Chairman Thank you Representative Harris
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:27
Representative Gray you recognize Thank you Mr. Chairman Representative Harris thank you for taking these questions one of the things I've learned in my short time here is that a good idea sometimes has other consequences and as we touch on subjects like this where they blend over into constitutional issues has there been any discussion or input from the Attorney General's office as to the bill as a whole or specific parts of this bill? There has
▶ Play
been. I mean, one thing we talked about was the title to make it more of a religious, title it, Religious Student Freedom Bill, and we also talked about changing some of it to made deeply held views, and I did not change it after consulting, we made it after looking at that there's already federal equal access laws, and so I chose not to change the wording of the bill, and so because there's already federal access laws. I've been working with on another bill that you will see coming soon with Liberty Council on different issues, and so there was no changing that I made, did not make any changes to this bill. Follow it, Mr. You're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:45
you. So, without getting into specific changes, this is your bill, but so the Attorney General's Office didn't weigh in or weighed in on this bill as it is? It works or I'm looking for the right word there, but they were supportive of the language that you, as you have it? MS. As far as support, is the The language as you have the bill is something the Attorney General's Office felt comfortable with? MS. The AG
▶ Play
had their opinions, as the AG always has their opinion, yes.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:26
Okay. MS. Mr. Chairman, if possible, maybe someone is here from the Attorney General's Office to address these. That's what we're looking for. Is there
▶ Play
someone from the Attorney General's office here today? I don't see anybody here today. She's there? She is not here. Sorry. You mentioned the name, and she took a walk.
▶ Play
Representative Saban, did you have a question? Yeah, actually I did. I'm generally concerned about any limitation on freedom of speech or expression, whether it's among our young people or otherwise. So I was wondering, do you know the current restrictions that exist that would impede this kind of expression now in our public schools? MS. Well,
▶ Play
I mean, we've seen it in the news. I mean, it's been several years back as far as prayer at graduation ceremonies, as far as led by students, or we've heard of different situations of students having to turn their shirts inside out because it's been offensive if they've had a cross on their shirt or different emblems on their shirts. I mean, it's been widespread throughout the school systems. I mean, some parents have the option of taking their children out of the school system and providing something different, but not all parents have that option. And so that's, I mean, so this is just, I mean, that's why I run this, I'm running this bill, but I'm running this bill because it was brought to me during the fiscal session and we couldn't do
▶ Play
anything during the fiscal session. I follow up just real quick because, again, I agree with you. I mean, the instances that you mentioned should not have been restricted, clearly. I guess my question would be, again, I mean, if the schools violate the law or if they don't correctly enforce existing law or policy, that doesn't necessarily mean we need to change the law. It just means that obviously somebody needs to challenge them and tell them they're doing something wrong. So I guess my question just had to do with what is the state of law currently that makes this particular thing necessary? And, again, just to clarify why I'm asking the question, my concern would be, you know, after this, do we need to go through and clarify all of the other forms of expression also that are protected, that aren't just religious but that are just in general important to protect for our students and the citizens at large?
▶ Play
I mean, I think that's a great question, but I'll just tell you, in my particular school district, We've had issues with when a substitute made, I don't know how, she shouldn't have made a student stand up and do the pledge. And because of what she did, by forcing the student to stand up, it became a national issue about four or five years ago. And because of that, the school system has become hypersensitive to everything. And there has been no challenge to some of the issues that they've done. And so instead of someone bringing a lawsuit, there's been nothing done. And I don't think parents necessarily know, well, we're going to challenge it with a lawsuit. So we're just going to be hypersensitive to everything. So I think sometimes we as legislators have to change the laws to make them better to secure our liberties. And, you know, it's not that we need to pass laws every time. Sometimes it's necessary to protect the freedoms that we do have. And, you know, it is ridiculous that we have to pass laws for everything. Sometimes we have to protect the laws to protect religious freedoms, and it's sad that in this day and age that we're having to do
▶ Play
that, but that is what's happening. Representative
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:34
Murdoch, did you have another question? No.
▶ Play
Okay. Representative McElroy, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Representative Harris. I realize that, you know, that sometimes our freedoms are shortchanged, I think, and religious. But I have one question that concerns me. You know, sometimes people worship strangely, and maybe we don't always agree on it, but some people actually worship Satan. Do you think that this protects their freedom to their religious beliefs at school? I mean, that's a possibility.
▶ Play
I mean, I understand that that is a possibility. Representative Bell, you
▶ Play
have a question? You're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Harris, I think all of us are familiar with some of the cases that have come up. You mentioned a few, but one that I saw is where a child was chastised by a teacher. I don't remember if it was specifically an Arkansas case, I believe it was, for referencing their personal religious experiences in a paper where they were asked to write about a personal experience. And we've all seen some of those kind of cases. And I share your concerns about making sure that we have uniform application of those students' rights. And I think that's where you're trying to go here is to make sure that it's clear what those policies will be so that different school districts maybe aren't treating them differently. My question goes mainly to a lot of this is already dealt with in case law. um tell me a little bit about your background of why it's necessary to codify what has essentially been done in course is it is it mainly to make the individual school districts more conscious of what the students rights are is that is that your goal help me understand
▶ Play
where you're going there you know it it is the goal and i think sometimes we have to know So, you know, it gets aggravating as someone who's had to deal with the religious side of having to sometimes have to protect your religious freedom and have to pull your child out of public school because of being ridiculed for their religious beliefs and not having the public school system protect them. And then you can go to the Board of Education or the Department of Ed and ask for their help, and then they say, well, there's only so much we can do, and then you need to go to your local school and ask them for their help. yet they do nothing for you and then i hear you guys say well it's a local school issue or i hear you like local control yet they do nothing for you and then i think about my own situation with our preschool that we have religious freedom but actually sometimes you don't have religious freedom and i think sometimes we have to pass laws to make sometimes the Department of Education to understand you can't send mixed messages down to your local school system where you can do this or you can't do this, but this is what the law says. And that's what's happening with another bill I'm going to be bringing up. And so that's what this religious freedom bill for students is about. I think Representative Bell for that question because that brings up what this is all about is saying you can do these things in the school system. You can write about who influences you most. And Representative McElroy is right. Things can happen just like you see in Oklahoma City on the state capital law as far as the Ten Commandments being right in front and then a pagan symbol can be put in front but those are some things those are unintended consequences those are things can happen that can be battled out in court but we need uniformity what is freedom and what is not freedom and that's what this bill is about follow up Mr. Chair
▶ Play
Representative Harris I know I represent a pretty poor district and a lot of the folks in my district don't have access to or easy access to legal counsel, some of the organizations that like to step in and intervene in these cases. Is it your intent here to simply make it where families don't have to go and find those kind of resources when they encounter this sort of situation, but just to make it clear, is that what
▶ Play
you're trying to do here? That is correct, and I will tell you, my wife and I could not afford the legal counsel that we needed to go forth with the lawsuit that we needed, and so we had to stop short. So I guarantee that parents cannot afford a lawyer, that they need to fight these cases. And even the Alliance for Defending Freedom, they do these things pro bono, but it still costs money. So we need laws to protect these students to have freedom of religion, whether it's what I believe in, Christianity, whether it's Islam, whatever it may be, They need their freedoms protected
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:14:05
in the school system. Representative Gossage, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I, too, share your concerns about situations that have happened through the years in school. But having been one of the arbiters many times in these sorts of things, they're extremely difficult to weigh the balance as a school administrator or whoever is in charge at that time. You're trying to evaluate whether it's affecting the educational process in schools, which is the Supreme Court standard has been. does the activity that's taking place within the school substantially disrupt the educational process? And it's a very difficult call sometimes. Some of the situations you're placed in are not 95% one side and 5% the other. They're 51-49 or 50-50, but you've got to make a decision. How will your bill change the standard that school administrators currently have to follow, which is whether an activity is disruptive? And I could certainly imagine someone wearing a T-shirt of a religion that's not particularly popular in that neighborhood that's going to cause a disruption at school. So what if a student wears a T-shirt that disrupts 95% of the student body? It's offensive to them and situations begin to occur. What would happen under your bill? You know, I can't
▶ Play
answer what-if questions. But sometimes I wonder if it's the adults that have most of the problem than what the teachers do. And sometimes I wonder if it's really, if a cross is really as offensive as what people think it is. And I understand you're not talking about a cross, but you're talking about other things. But I wonder if it's the adults that really find things offensive
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:16:20
more than the students. Well, that certainly could be the case. I mean, it's certainly bad judgment. We're all guilty of that from time to time, and I probably was too. but nevertheless there's a reality of having to deal with these situations I would love to quote one of the t-shirts that come to mind in my school that was handed out to a local revival but I can't say it here and it was extraordinarily difficult decision to tell those students to take that shirt and turn it around and they were fired up about getting to wear that t-shirt but I mean I totally understand the point of your bill but I also can see the difficulty that it places people in and I think the same standard will have to apply whether your bill passes or it doesn't if it's disruptive to the school process somebody's going to have to intervene thank
▶ Play
you Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think, Representative Harris, we are all impressed by the sincerity of your efforts to get relief from some of these things that you have identified. I'd like to put it on another plane. the freedom of religion is analogous to freedom of speech under the First Amendment, as I understand it. And picking up where Representative Gossage mentioned, in a school context, it's somewhat analogous, isn't it, to being in a movie, a crowded movie where somebody says fire You think that person who says fire can disrupt that environment and create an adverse situation any more than a person can do likewise in a school situation with the excuse being freedom of religion? I can say what I want to because this is an expression of my religion. You know, you can answer that, but do you really want to try to push this bill at this time with all the questions we have. I just wondered whether or not you'd rather pull it down for the
▶ Play
moment and try to work on it. I can hear your question today better than I can hear yesterday, so I can hear you today. But, no, I mean, I understand what you're saying, but I don't think this is one of those situations where I'm crying fire in a theater because this is an actual across-the-board situation that is happening. And if it was a one-time incident, I would understand, but this is happening several incidents across in multiple schools. It may not be publicized or in the media a lot, but it is happening. And then I also take the opportunity, as it says, a student in a public school may wear clothes, accessories, or jewelry of an established and recognized religion and that complies with the school uniform policy, if applicable, under Statute 618-102. So it has to stay within the school uniform policy that is set forth, which should help Representative Gossett's question, too, that
▶ Play
Speaker 193 1:20:04
he brought forward. Representative Douglas,
▶ Play
you're recognized. My question would be, do we see a timidity on the part of some students and teachers in a school setting or really just in our community settings to express religious beliefs because they just do not know where they stand? And like you said here, in a school, can a student do, you know, express their religious beliefs in their artwork or in a paper they're writing? I think kids have gotten, and I think especially possibly Christian kids, have gotten very timid in how they can express their beliefs because of the administrators being afraid for them to express their beliefs for fear of lawsuits. So if this would clear that up and give people the confidence again that they do have that freedom to express that, then I see this as a good thing that we need to reassure the public that they do have this freedom of expression. Is that going to bring both sides? Well, we've already brought that. But I see a timidity, you know, that we need to reinforce for kids to know where they stand with expressions, you know, just even in classroom assignments on history. So my question would be, do you think this will maybe clear up some of that timidity on people's parts of where they stand in the law or where they stand in, you know, like school expression?
▶ Play
I think it will, and it just gives them the opportunity I mean, will it happen? Maybe not. I mean, will children, kids choose to wear a shirt that expresses their religious view? Maybe not. I mean, I don't think it's going to open the Pandora's box for a whole lot of it. No, but it will give them the opportunity to do so. Will they write about who most influenced them? Maybe not. It may have them talk about a historic figure that did follow Christian beliefs. that it may do and allow them to write about it, that it may do. But I think you're right. It will give them the opportunity to do so where they may not have
▶ Play
had that opportunity before. Representative Lowry, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Harris, is it your belief that by passing this legislation, the issue of addressing uniformity from school district to school district could be enhanced because you do reference things that school districts shall and shall not do that it would have to become part of school board handbook policy, student handbook policy that this may be the only way to be able to make sure that there is that uniformity in the policy that's handed down to the school districts I
▶ Play
do because I see time and time again just an example in my opinion was the bill you passed on the I mean I'm just going to use this to better just to hurry on the top of my or in my mind the Tim Tebow law as far as homeschooling on the plate there was such a discrepancy of schools whether they allow homeschoolers to play in football, so to speak. There was such an interpretation of that law. This will just make it uniform so everyone would be on
▶ Play
Speaker 196 1:24:13
the same page, and that's what this is about.
▶ Play
Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized. Your reference to the Tim Tebow law, of course, part of the problem there was interpretation at various schools, and I know I had to work with Director Kimbrell and making sure that the schools uniformly interpreted law. But that does underscore the need to have something in statute that, for instance, I know the School Boards Association, after this session, will probably provide to school districts new sections on school board policy based on legislation that is passed. So, again, your hope would be we can all hope that case law is going to win the day. But the bottom line is you have to know what that case law is to uniformly apply it. This is going to get us one step closer to being able to have that uniform application? That's correct. All right. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Are there any other questions, committee? is
▶ Play
there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill or the bill would you like a close for your bill I just would really appreciate a good vote what is the will of the committee I have a due pass motion all those in favor say aye aye opposed bill fails I have two hands. I have a roll call.
▶ Play
Speaker 199 1:26:01
Representative Letting. Representative Murdoch. Representative Murdoch. Representative Deffenbaugh. Representative Deffenbaugh. Representative Harris. Yes. Representative Eubanks, Representative Eubanks, Representative Ratliff, Representative Ratliff, Representative Gillum, Representative Gillum, Representative Walker, Representative Walker, Representative Bell, Aye. Representative Balz. Representative Balz. Representative Douglas. Yes. Representative Lowry. Yes. Representative McElroy. No. Representative Armstrong. Representative Armstrong. Representative Gossage. Representative Gossage Representative Saban Representative Saban Representative Hodges Representative Gray Representative Gray Representative Lampkin Representative Lampkin One, two, three, four You only got five affirmative
▶ Play
Speaker 200 1:27:43
votes, Mr. Chairman and fail. Bill fails.
▶ Play
Thank you. Is there any, well, I have a little bit of business. There will not be any luncheon today for committee or for anybody. I think Capitol Hill is going to be closed today also for the luncheon that was prepared over there. So you're on your own today. Anyway, is there any other business coming for the committee today? If not, without objection, you're dismissed.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1419

0:18 - 21:46 77 segments 11 speakers

SB265

21:46 - 55:53 95 segments 11 speakers

HB1273

55:53 - 1:28:11 93 segments 16 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Ron McNair Unverified
10 segments
Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
21 segments
Representative John W. Walker Chair Unverified
55 segments
Speaker 26
1 segment
Speaker 27
1 segment
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
35 segments
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
37 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 62
1 segment
Speaker 68
4 segments
Speaker 85
1 segment
Donald Bobbitt Unverified
10 segments
Chair Unverified
22 segments
Speaker 139
1 segment
Speaker 149
4 segments
Speaker 151
1 segment
Representative Justin T. Harris Unverified
37 segments
Speaker 3
1 segment
Speaker 161
4 segments
Representative Mark D. McElroy Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 193
1 segment
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 196
1 segment
Speaker 199
3 segments
Speaker 200
1 segment