House Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (13)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1251
· 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1251”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1114
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1114”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1282
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1282”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1392
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1392”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1456
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1456”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1458
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1458”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1462
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1462”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1463
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1463”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1467
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1467”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1474
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1474”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1484
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1484”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB161
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB161”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB261
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB261”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
All right, we're going to go to House Bill 1251. Representative Vines, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If you'll oblige me for a minute, I can't be prepared with no hard copy, and I'm going to pull it up on the screen if it wouldn't harm the committee.
Yes, thank you. Yes, committee, Mr. Chair, this is House Bill 1251. And if the committee would indulge me, I do have John Muldoon here, and I'd like for him to come help me explain the bill. The bill itself is very short and to the point. It basically says the board can appoint a director and then gives the director, should be allowed to designate investigators and portable board as specialized law enforcement officers. And what I've done is I have a gentleman here today to testify for it
and explain the bill and the need and the requirements. So if we could do that, I would
much appreciate it. Mr. Muldoon, you're recognized. If you would, state your name, who you represent,
Speaker 11
2:15
and make your statement. My name is John Muldoon. I'm the president of the Arkansas Professional Bell Association. And what we have here before you today is House Bill 1251. This bill, it basically, it gives specialized law enforcement status to the investigator of the Arkansas Professional Bail Bond Board.
I apologize. What this bill does is it gives specialized law enforcement to the investigator for the Arkansas Professional Bail Bond Licensing Board. And that's basically what the authority allows for them. This bill is going to help give them access when they're doing investigations for the current. Anytime we have a complaint filed with the Bell Bond Board, the investigator goes out into the field and investigates that complaint for the citizens.
And they've had specialized law enforcement status in 2007. The board was created in 1993. The investigator at that time has been acting in such. It was brought to the attention of the board in 2014 that there wasn't statutory authorizing that. There wasn't any statutory authorization, and that's what we're here today
to try to fix. Could you specifically give us some examples of what this agency or what these officers would be investigating,
the types of complaints, and what those investigations would entail? Well,
Speaker 11
3:49
the investigations, mainly the board investigates any complaints that's filed by the citizens that are in the state of Arkansas in regards to the licensees of the bail bond board, which are bail bondsmen, and any violations that might have been accused of in the complaint. And in doing such, they have to meet with law enforcement officers. There are certain documents that they may not be privy to that specialized law enforcement
would give them the opportunity to see. Representative
Ballinger, did you have a question? Yes, Mr. Chair. Thank you. In general, and it goes along, and I think that you almost answered what my question was, but in particular, I guess, why do you need the police powers? What would be the activity that you would carry out? I mean, tell me how that would function differently with these powers.
Speaker 11
4:50
Well, the investigator for the licensing board works closely with law enforcement, and there's certain documents that they would need to be able to see. It would give them a better access to the facilities, the jails, things of that nature, different agencies that they go to. Representative Tosh, you're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Jarrett. How many people are we talking about that this is going to affect?
Speaker 11
5:24
How many investigators are there for the licensing board? Yes. Right now the board has one investigator on staff, and the executive director also handles certain investigations depending on the circumstances. He oversees all investigations as a matter of speaking. Follow-up. Sure. So if
I understand you correctly, you're telling me that this is only going to affect two people? Is that what you
Speaker 11
5:54
just said, two? It gives the regulatory entity more authority to pursue these complaints that are filed
on behalf of the citizens that come to the board looking for some relief. Yes, it's
two. Yes, it's two. Two people? Yes, sir. And one more. Tell me again, so I understand. Tell me again, these two people, tell
Speaker 11
6:21
me exactly what their scope of authority will be. Their scope of authority? Yes. To investigate complaints filed by the citizens of Arkansas against bail bondsmen if they've done some inappropriate actions.
Any rules, regulations, state statutes that have been violated, these investigators would have authority to oversee and to look into.
Representative Scott, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Vines, would you give me a real-life situation
where this bill would be beneficial? Well, if you had been arrested, Representative Scott, and your bail bondsman, bail person, I should say, acted unethically, deceitfully, fraudulently,
With any sort of, I guess, criminal intent, it would give these guys authority to investigate and police the situation. I think the concern is right now that there's no matter of recourse if that happens because that is such a delicate situation because usually the person that's filing the complaint or alleging the allegation is already criminally charged. So they're not, in a lot of ways, in the best standing to pursue, I don't know,
I guess civil remedy or any other remedy that might be available to them. I'm not saying they can't, but they're not exactly in the best position in the world to do that. So I think that's where you're looking at. I think Mr. Muldoon could add to that. And I also have, and we haven't talked about that, I think they're signed up to speak forward. We have a couple, three sheriffs and representatives from the Sheriff's Association here that can probably give you a better explanation than I have. Fortunately for me, I've never had to post bond, so I've been lucky.
A follow-up, Mr. Chair, please. So, Mr. Vines, this is actually a consumer protection bill? Sure, yes. Thank you. I
– we'll leave it at that. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Muldoon,
you mentioned that this status would give your investigators access to more documents that without it they would not have.
Would that include access to the ACIC database?
Yes, it would. Thank you. Representative Ballinger,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Does this bill, and I apologize, I should have read over this beforehand, but does this change the requirements as an investigator? So currently is there an application pool that would be broader that you could actually get investigators from, but after you give them police power, are you also requiring them to have some sort of additional training?
Yes, they would have to have additional training. and I'm sorry could you explain what that additional training what the process is, what
Speaker 11
9:38
those changes are is there a possibility I could yield my time to somebody that might be able to answer that more correctly possibly somebody from the Sheriff's Association that would be fine
I think if it would please the committee we have Sheriff Ronnie Baldwin from the Sheriff's Association here if he could come forward and join us he can probably shed light on a lot of these
technical questions, if you will. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. I think most of you know me as Ronnie Baldwin, director of the Arkansas Sheriff's Association, but I'm before you today as Ronnie Baldwin, a board member of the Arkansas Professional Bail Bond Licensing Board also. To give you a little history, I think Mr. Muldoon already stated that our investigators did have special officer status for several years. It was discovered last year
that it had no statutory authority to do so. So, mainly, that's what we're trying to do now. In many instances, the situations they're investigating, I remember one situation in Jonesboro where a bail bondsman was firing some shots. That's more frequent than you realize. The instances where these investigators investigate, they're investigating often times the same people
that we have had in jail. So we just feel that the special officer is needed for them to do a thorough investigation because the people that they're interviewing, they're going into these houses, going into the neighborhoods, and it's a dangerous situation sometimes. Representative Tosh, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. I just want to make sure, Sheriff, I understand that when they're conducting the investigation, are they conducting the investigation into just the policies and procedures of the bail bondsmen?
Are they conducting a criminal investigation? And if so, once they uncover information that leads to a criminal act, what would they do with it at that time? They're
investigating the rules and regulations and statutes that govern the bail bond industry. If they discover a criminal offense
that's outside the scope of their responsibility, that's turned over to the prosecutor for their discretion to be determined whether they want to file charges or not.
Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I apologize for my lack of understanding of this, and I know when you're familiar with a certain area, it all makes sense. But when I first read this, I assumed that they would be interviewing the bail bondsman, investigating their practices, talking to the person who was maybe not refunded their money by the bail bondsman or something akin to that.
But when you start talking about them going into people's houses, I'm a little confused as to
why that would occur. If someone makes a complaint, and often they're going to have to go inside the house of the complainant, and that complainant many times is the person who was in the jail and was bonded out. So that's where we're talking about there. There may be witnesses involved. So they're going to have to do investigations basically kind of just like any other law enforcement agency would,
regardless of where that investigation takes them. But it would be exclusively for the statutes and regulations that regulate the bail
bond industry. If I might follow up, that makes more sense to me. Would this also, and I think you've limited it, but they would not be providing law enforcement data to bail bondsmen? No, ma'am. No,
ma'am. That's, can't do that. Thank you very much.
Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question. Previously, the testimony said that you guys or someone has been doing this already, but there wasn't statutory leverage to do it. Had there been at some time and just it went away? Is that what happened? There had been.
Used to, the bail bond industry was under the regulations and authority of the insurance commission.
And I don't know exactly the year. I think in the 90s it was taken away from. In 93, it was removed from the Insurance Commission, and the Arkansas Professional Bail Bond Licensing Board was set up. Those investigators were transferred to them, but the statutory authority for special officers was not transferred. So it was an oversight whenever it was transferred from the Insurance Commission to an individual board. May I follow up?
This is kind of a two-part question. One is the access that the gentleman previously mentioned that you guys need that you don't have. You actually did have it, and you were utilizing it. You just didn't have the statutory capacity to actually do that, correct? Yes, and I think
I've got the president of the Arkansas Sheriff's Association here, too. He's wanting to testify, and he was going to touch on that
part of it. Then who will supervise these officers?
I mean, who will hold them accountable? Like our sheriffs and police, they're held accountable. Who will hold these people accountable? The members of
the Bail Bond Licensing Board, which is made up of one sheriff, one chief, two citizens, and three company owners. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for another question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have just a couple questions,
hopefully, if you've got liberty. The first is, within the bill, it says the board may appoint a director who shall serve at the pledge of the board.
Do they currently not have a director? Yes, we
do. Okay, so what was that language put in there for you? In case that director, whenever he does, would
decide to retire. Okay. And then, if I may, Mr. Chair, I just have a follow-up question. Representative Ballinger, let
me speak to that also. So I think the portion of that section one also is it just simply wasn't in code, and we need to get that on the books just because, you know, similar to. You want them to be doing it right.
Yeah, we don't want to be put loose and fancy free. So I think that first section is probably more cleanup
than anything. Okay. And so currently how many investigations are done each year? Oh, my goodness, I think
you would actually have to. We get a report every month, and there are always several ongoing investigations, but a yearly total, sir, I think you'd have to ask someone, either the investigator or the director himself. Okay, and I guess
that would be a question for them when they come back. And then probably the follow-up question for them,
where they can be getting this information, would be how many actually lead, and you may know this, I don't know,
but how many lead to criminal charges? Again, you would have to
get that information from the investigator. Okay, thank you.
Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question. One more question, Sheriff, and I'll leave you alone. But I just want to make sure I understand. In the bill, it says a specialized law enforcement officer. But then in the testimony, it says you're only going to be investigating basically policies and procedures under the statute.
But my question is, are these individuals going to have the authority of a police officer to stop and detain, or is this strictly going to be investigating policies and procedures within this agency? This is investigative policies and procedures within our agency, the way I understand it. They would have any other right as a private citizen if they would see a felony. But the scope of this is to investigate the rules and regulations and actually complaints in the bail bond industry.
Okay, I think it's misleading when it says a specialized law enforcement officer, and when we hear that terminology, obviously we relate that to someone that has the authority to stop and detain and make an arrest. I understand. Okay. All right,
seeing no further questions, we'll go to the list of individuals who have signed up to speak for against the bill. David Lucas, if you would take a seat, to state your name and who you represent, and then you may make your statement.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is David Lucas. I'm the sheriff of Jackson County. I'm also the president of the Arkansas Sheriff's Association. In reference to House Bill 1251, I can only reiterate what the other people have testified to. These investigators, they go out, they do interviews, They investigate allegations of misconduct in the bail bond board.
And as far as the Arkansas sheriffs are concerned, we stand behind them 100%. We work very closely with these investigators and the director, Mr. Peters. And there was some concern from what I was hearing a while ago. there was some discussion as far as how far this would go, the specialized law enforcement officer status would go. The thing about it is, is Act 452 of 1975,
it basically says that a specialized law enforcement officer is a full-time or part-time officer whose duties are restricted to the area of work, which would be the bail bond business. That job also would include the enforcement of agency rules and regulations. In order for these investigators to have access to some basically classified information as far as ACIC criminal histories, right now it would be illegal for me
to furnish that information to a bail bond board investigator. If he had a special law enforcement officer status, my officers can work closely with him. He would have access to the ACIC criminal history files. He's out when he's doing interviews with potential victims, complainants, and also the bail agents themselves. It pretty much gives them some teeth into their job.
And the thing about it is these investigators, they're overseen by the bail bond board, and they work at the pleasure of the citizens of Arkansas. And with the specialized law enforcement status, they would be able to more efficiently and effectively conduct their job as far as the investigation of any wrongdoing or complaints against a bail bond agent.
Okay, I see no further questions moving down the list.
Actually, I believe that's the last person he signed up for or against. Representative Vines, would you like to close for your
bill? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate all the testimony we've had, and hopefully we've answered the bulk of the questions and any concerns this bill has. With that, I would close and just appreciate a good vote. Representative Scott, you're recognized.
Okay, we have a motion do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Representative
We're going to move down to House Bill 1114.
Actually, House Bill 1260, you asked that we place that on deferred. Okay. Then House Bill 1114, Representative Lowry, you're recognized to present House Bill 1114. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank
you, Committee, for the input that you gave me the last time I was before you on this bill. Some suggestions were made. I took those to heart and made amendments.
This is a bill that creates the criminal offense of criminal impersonation in an election. One of the first questions that was asked the last time I presented it was by Representative Whitaker. He asked why school elections were omitted, and that was an oversight, so we've made that correction. The other issue was questions about why language had been changed about perjury, and we've gone ahead and corrected that as well. That was not intended.
I think the bill drafters were just trying to clean up some of the language. They weren't really trying to change anything in the statute about perjury. The other question that was asked was, why are we putting this in Title V when there are laws related to election fraud or violations of elections in Title VII? And the answer to that really is that I know this is not a technical legal term, but the attorneys have pointed out to me that Title VII is kind of a hodgepodge.
of it's almost as if every time something would come up it's like well let's just add it on and it really was not it's probably something that bears looking at but most of Title VII actually relates to acts by electioneering or candidates but in the middle of it there are references to things like no person shall vote in election more than one vote no person shall vote or attempt to vote other than his or her legal ballot.
That would seem to cover criminal impersonation, but it's very, from what I understand from the Bureau of Attorneys, that's very vague. And what the legislation that's before you does is it really gives much more specificity to the offense of voting a ballot that is not your ballot. Voting as if you are voting for someone else. It covers both absentee ballots. It also covers real-time voting on the day of the election.
To try and at least balance out the fact that we do have some references to that kind of voter fraud over in Title VII, and this would be in Title V, one of the things that we did here so that there's not, even though I love to talk about prosecutorial discretion and give them discretion, One of the issues that we had there is that in Title VII, it would have been a Class D felony if you were charged under that.
If you're charged under this particular statute, it would be Class C. So we've gone ahead and changed that to where criminal impersonation election would be Class D felony so that there's really no discretion there. You're charging the same penalty, and Class D is up to a six-year penalty. Frankly, I'll just tell you this is an answer to the voter ID statute that was voted in in 2013 being voted down.
It gives us some protection. It certainly gives us some deterrent protection that notices could be put out, letting people know that this is a serious offense. It's not just something that comes with a wrist slap, that you're not just stealing a vote, but you're stealing someone else's vote. And so hopefully I have fixed most of the issues of concern and would be open to any questions that you have.
I see no questions. We're going to move to the public comment sheet. Jeff Rosenzweig. If you
Speaker 108
26:56
you may make your statement. Jeff Rosenzweig, Arkansas Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. We're concerned about two things. One, we think that since this is an election law issue, it needs to be in Title VII.
But obviously that's, in other words, you keep all the election violations in one place. Secondly, we're concerned about, and this will be on line 28 and 29 of the first page, applies for an absentee ballot in a name other than his or her own name. We feel that written a little bit too broadly and might get people you're not intending to get. In other words, the person who, let's say someone's elderly mother is in a nursing home
and the child goes down and asks for the absentee ballot to be given to the mother or to take for the mother, it could, the way it's written, affect a person like that and a person who is not intending to commit any sort of fraud but merely attempting to get the ballot for another person could be swept up in it and we think that needs to be fixed.
Does anybody, the question I have is with regard to the application for an absentee ballot, is that a statement made under oath? Is that application made under oath? Does anybody know? Well, my
response generally to the comment that was made in your question is that in picking up the application, that's all you're doing, or picking up the absentee ballot.
You are just picking up the ballot. You're not applying for it. The application process would be in the signing of the absentee ballot, which really would be covered by perjury statutes, but we've gone ahead and clarified that that would be taken care of under criminal impersonation, but yes, they do sign a test that they are the person that this ballot is for. But the person picking it up in the example Mr. Rosen-Swag gave, going and picking it up for an elderly parent, you're not applying for an absentee ballot, you're just picking
one up. And I guess that really gets to my question, is currently if someone applied for a ballot in another person's name, knowing that they were applying in that person's name, is that already perjury? Title VII states, it shall
be unlawful for a person with the intent to defraud a voter or an election official to possess an absentee ballot issued to another.
I guess my other question is, does an application for an absentee ballot, is that an official proceeding? the subsection A refers to it person commits for perjury if in an official proceeding he or she knowingly and then one makes a false statement
under oath or two applies for an absentee ballot I don't, I mean an official proceeding I think that's always probably been taken to be a court proceeding or some type of administrative hearing under oath and I'm just wondering whether subsection 2 could ever be satisfied if you were prosecuting somebody under that section. I think that's... Would you turn your microphone on?
I think that's a good point. Representative Lowry, I'm just curious if that had been looked at and it's something I was just noticing here as I sit here looking
over the bill. Well, I think it's just maybe semantics in terms of what it is to apply. The application would be actually attesting that you are filling out this absentee ballot in your name or in someone else's name.
The actual process of going and picking up an absentee ballot to deliver to someone is not an application process. It is just being handed an absentee ballot. The application process comes when they actually finalize the absentee ballot itself. And there are, in Title VII, there are exceptions to that. If a person is employed by any of the departments of the state, excuse me, I'm reading the wrong section,
employed by the United States Postal Service performing the normal course of the employee's authorized duties, Obviously, they're not applying for absentee ballot. They're just delivering it. A common or contract carrier performing the normal course, the administrative head of a long-term care or residential care facility licensed by the state, or an election official acting in his or her official capacity. So there are exceptions already built into the law where there would not be a violation. Okay.
So, I mean, as I understand it, really, when somebody votes, that's going to, under this
bill, that's going to be criminal. If they were impersonating another person, that's going to be a violation of 555.602. That's going to be criminal impersonation in an election. But to be clear, even though this bill states that appears to make the application for an absentee ballot in another name, appears to attempt to make that perjury, to be clear, under the statute, it doesn't appear that that could actually ever be satisfied because of the official proceeding language.
Speaker 108
33:01
Excuse me. Applies for can cover, unless you define applies for, can cover a whole bunch of things, including things you may not intend it to apply to, such as going there and just asking for the documents for the ballot on behalf of your elderly parent or something like that. And of course, what the defenses are in a Title VII wouldn't necessarily be the defenses
in the Title V charge, because it's going to be, the defenses
to those that are in the relevant statute. Representative Bennett, you recognize for question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Rosenzweig, would it fix this concern if we added language in the absentee ballot
that It says unless
Speaker 108
34:02
acting in accordance with statutory law or proceedings. Well, I think it would be better to revise the 71104 to stick it in there.
That's the felonies involving voter fraud. And just put whatever you're going to do in there. and that solves the official proceeding problem that you have by the Title V and also you can define what applies for means and
what it doesn't mean. No further questions. To be
clear, I don't necessarily have a problem with the application
being perjury. I just don't think that My concern about the official proceeding language is that that would, if you attempted to prosecute somebody based on this statute, I think there would likely be a defense because the argument is it wasn't an official proceeding. Representative Howes, did you have a
question? Yes, ma'am. Representative Lowry or counselor, I noticed something here. In subsection 1A, we add the word knowingly, which means there must be knowledge.
And then down in B, lack of knowledge is not a defense. Are those inconsistent?
I believe lack of knowledge actually clarifies the knowingly. if you knowingly committed this. And along the sense you're looking at that section, one thing that I would point out the argument about being able to prove that this was an official proceeding, the key word there is or.
We're not saying that applying for an absentee ballot is an official proceeding. We're saying that perjury applies to official proceeding or false application. Well,
that's not the way the bill reads. Subsection A applies to both one or two, and that, again, I don't necessarily have a problem with the intent. I'm just concerned that it may create a pretty large loophole.
Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. A motion. So let's hold off for just a second on the motion. I'll come back to
you. Representative Ballinger, for what purpose? What's your question? I have a question for Mr. Lowry. Okay, you can ask your question. It's pretty clear what your intent is here, and I think in general I support and probably a lot of people do.
we want to make sure that we the people who are voting that they're the legitimate people who are out there voting and this is the way to do it and I think that you'd have almost no voter suppression by doing it however I don't know the official proceeding I'd have to look and see how that's defined but the way this bill is drafted this is only if you apply for an absentee ballot in an official proceeding so maybe somebody who's a little more informed and you may explain to me what an official proceeding is but if that wasn't your intent Would you be willing to pull this bill down and amend that and bring it back?
Well, I certainly want there to be clarity on something that I believe most of the members believe there's a necessity for, and it has good intent. And I would certainly welcome any input in clarifying this. And by the way, I'm sorry, my mistake about the or. I circled the wrong thing a while ago. It was talking about he or she. So, sorry. But I think what it is clarifying is that there is perjury in an official proceeding,
and then there also would be an incidence of perjury in terms of application. And I think that it's clear that you're not applying for an absentee ballot of all you're doing is picking it up, that the actual application process or the official proceeding would be when you sign your name on that ballot saying that this is your ballot. That's the only thing that really makes it an official proceeding is the fact that you're signing. If you're signing someone else's name, then you have violated this statute.
To be fair, while we've had some of these questions, I did look up what official proceeding is. Official under 553.101, official proceeding means a proceeding heard before any legislative, judicial, administrative, or other government agency or official authorized to hear evidence under oath, including any referee, hearing, examiner, parole revocation judge, commissioner, notary, or other person taking testimony or depositions
in any such proceeding. Official proceeding includes the signing or marking under oath of a voter registration application, an application for absentee ballot, or a precinct voter registration list. So I guess it may clear it up. I guess the question is whether those applications are under oath, and I don't know. I think Representative Whitaker pulled up one application that actually referred to federal law, but I wanted to at least state that I did find the definition of that. Thank you. And I believe that that's what
it's speaking to, is that you were attesting in front of a notary that this is who you are. That would be the official proceeding, and it would, if you falsely notated that, then it would be a violation of the statute. Okay, we have nobody else signed up to speak for or against. Representative Lauer, are you closed for your bill? Yes, I am. I would appreciate
a due pass. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a motion.
Motion to lay on the table to work through some of these issues.
I think the intent of the bill is a good bill, but I'd like to be sure that we're doing what
we hope we are doing. Okay, that's a proper motion. That's non-debatable. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed? No. The motion passes. So the bill is laid on the table. We're going to move on to, without objection, we're
Is that right? Mr. Chairman, would you object if I took 261 first? It's a little less controversial. I don't think either one of them are, but
that one I feel very confident about. That's what you told me last week before I ran your bill on the floor. I stand by that. It was not controversial. Okay. We're going to pass over Senate Bill 260, and we'll go without objection to Senate Bill 261.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Where is that at? Okay. It's on
page three of the agenda. You recognize Senator Hutchinson? This is a bill that some judges have brought to my attention, and I've actually had a client who had to deal with this. If police officers respond to an incident, they find a person who may be suicidal, got issues going on in their life at that moment, and for their safety they take typically a gun or anything that they could harm themselves with.
currently in order for that person who's committed no crime and has no reason to have their property confiscated you have to go to the court and petition the court to get your property returned to you again even though you're a law-abiding citizen of committed no crime just had a bad night and may have been suicidal at one point this bill sets into a mechanism by which they don't have to go back to court, and they just simply wait 72 hours, kind of a cooling off period, and
then they can go with proper identification and proof of ownership, retrieve their property. Judges hate having their dockets filled with, it's not like it happens a lot, but when it is, it's a pain for the judge, and it's particularly a pain for that citizen who, for no reason So they're on safety, but for no criminal violations if they've had their property seized.
Describe a situation where law enforcement would take a weapon without an arrest.
Suicide. It's if somebody's threatening suicide. Further on safety. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Make sure I understand, Senator, you're saying after 72 hours that the weapon would be released back to a minor that was attempting to commit suicide, is that correct? Well, it wouldn't be a minor. I mean, I believe there's a guardian.
There's already procedures in place where there has to be a guardian. It can't ever be released to a minor. but it would be released to their guardian or to an adult within 72 hours. 72 hours, if there is a bigger issue at play than just having a bad night, there may be a need for commitment that would give time for family to file a petition to have them committed or other precautions taken. But bottom line is they've committed no crime.
They should have their property returned to them without having to hire an attorney and this is an anti-lawyer bill. How about that? They should just be able
to go get it. Representative Scott, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Hutchinson, the weapons that are going to be returned to the individuals who, sadly enough, have chosen this path, are those weapons that are taken from them,
Are they licensed? Do the people who are going to commit such a heinous – I'm sorry. This is a little close to me, so I'm going to struggle through this. Do these people have a concealed carry permit or a license for the gun that they were going to use to harm themselves with? And if not, would this bill allow an officer to check to see if they did indeed have a permit or a license for this weapon?
Thank you. Well, I mean, it doesn't change. You don't need a license to own a gun. Now, you do if you're going to carry it in public. But this is simply returning seized property when there's no lawful reason to seize it except their own personal safety. So it doesn't change anything except it removes an enormous headache and obstacle for a lawfully abiding citizen to retrieve what's rightfully theirs.
But I don't think they'd inspect the licenses because you don't have to. They'd inspect ownership. and obviously identity, identification, but you don't have to have a license to carry guns. I don't think they'd ask about concealed carry
or anything. Follow-up, please, Mr. Chair. I think if this served as a deterrent in any way, I think this would be absolutely wonderful. Don't you
agree? Sure. I mean, yeah, I think giving a cooling down period is very helpful.
And just to clarify, I was looking here at the statute. Actually, the bill and I guess this is what you were saying and it may have been just not apparent to me the statutory language regarding law enforcement taking a weapon is already there. This is strictly geared at putting a time limit on the return of
the weapon. A mechanism to retreat it with out petitioning the court and and giving them some delay and so that they'll cool down some.
Okay. Thank you. Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I could be wrong with this, Senator, in what I currently think, but if a person ends up being admitted to a psychiatric hospital, are they not banned at that point from owning a
firearm? I don't know if that's a permanent ban, but, yeah. What the 72 hours does is allow a family member or that person, if they recognize they have a need,
it allows intervention to occur. And if they are committed, then yes, they certainly would not, a judge probably would not allow them to have firearms for, but that's up to each individual judge depending on the, they've committed no crime, so it's not like a felon where they're a lifetime ban, but a judge typically will intervene and keep all deadly weapons from them until they can establish that they're not a threat to themselves. A follow-up, Mr.
Chair? Thank you. And I guess my other question is, to kind of follow up on that,
it appears that the language is stricken that shows that it's returned to a parent, a guardian, or other person entrusted with care and supervision of the person so disarmed. So when I look on page 2, line 8, it says, after the 72-hour hold, it's returned to the lawful owner upon request. With that lawful owner, it's the person who was just – you see what I'm saying? If that person – it's taken out the minor part of it,
so technically by this statute it's showing that you could actually return that gun to the minor that you
took it from, even though that's not legal. Well, I think, but I'm willing to pull it down and get verification, but I believe that lawful owner refers to another definition in the code that the bar association is the one who asked me to do this, and that's no guarantee that they're right. I don't want to. So let me out-verify and make sure that that lawful owner
refers to a guardian or parent or somebody. Okay. So with that, I'll pull that one down, and with your permission, Mr. Chairman, run
Senate Bill 160. I'll tell you this, we're far more kinder to the House members who come to Senate Judiciary than y'all are us. Some exceptions.
All right. All right. Senate Bill 160, 161, thank you, Mr. Senate Bill 161 is also a bar association bill. This is the young lawyers section of the bar, and it's, I'll be honest with you, I've struggled with whether or not to file it, but I think it, On balance, it is a very good bill, but it's not an easy bill necessarily.
What it does, we've had a rash of really frat parties mostly in colleges where somebody over drinks and instead of seeking medical attention for your friend or acquaintance, whoever it is. Instead, the party breaks up and everybody flees because they're afraid if they call EMT or emergency personnel that they'll be arrested for minor in possession. So this bill
grants immunity only for minor in possession. It's the only thing they've got immunity from, and that's only if they've notified emergency medical personnel. They cooperate and they remain on the scene. They would then be granted immunity from minor possession. Chiefs of police initially had a concern that that would inhibit their ability to do a probable cause determination
or search for other potential crimes. So we amended the bill, the last paragraph, section G13 says that it shall not impugn their ability to probable cause determination in regard to other criminal offenses. Since that amendment was added, I've had no opposition from prosecutors, from law enforcement, chiefs of police, anybody. But I do recognize that in one sense we're encouraging irresponsibility, but in so doing
we're trying to encourage responsible response to their irresponsible initial acts. So it's kind of a dichotomy. But by and large, I think it will save lives. There's a father in Conway who I believe is his daughter at UCA. This exact scenario happened to her, and he's been on TV asking for this type of legislation. With that, I'll take any questions. Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question
Senator, are you aware of any other states that has this and what has been the results of that? There are other
states that have it. I don't know if there's been a study to determine results, but there are other states that have it
Okay, I see no further questions. Nobody has signed up in the audience. Senator Hutchinson, are you closed for your bill? I am. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Whitaker, you recognized?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Motion do pass. Move a motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor
say aye. Any opposed? You've passed your bill. It is
first try. I thought that would be more controversial. All right, going back to the regular agenda, House Bill 1282, Representative Wright, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. I'll tell you all what 1282 does, and I'll be as quick as possible. In Arkansas, every single crime on the books, from capital murder to rape, aggravated robbery, anything can be negotiated down or reduced by the prosecutors
for a million different reasons at least. The only crime that cannot be negotiated is driving while intoxicated. My whole intent of this bill is education. I am tired of seeing cases, bad cases, where they are forced to be tried and people get no education whatsoever. they walk out of the courthouse almost emboldened because absolutely nothing happened I have seen over and over the cases
again for a million different reasons officers moved blood tests are not available a witness can't be there because they're responding to an emergency and the prosecutor's hands are tied in that they have there's no negotiation when they are filed they must be tried and so somebody who may have said you know, I need to go to some classes, I need to get some education I need to do some community service instead of doing that
they walk out of the courthouse and absolutely nothing has happened that's all this bill does to be as open as I possibly can because I'm sure the question is going through y'all's mind I have contacted Mothers Against Drunk Driving three separate times I've yet to get a response I contacted them the first time told them what I was doing asked them to please give me any input that they may have and they haven't even called me back
I would be more than happy to visit with them or make additional amendments if I can get it out of here on the house but I've heard nothing from them
I'd be more than happy to answer any questions Representative Copeland you're recognized for a question Representative, do you know how many cases, is there any idea how many cases end up like you described? I mean, how big a problem is it that they're not tried? It's a big problem.
Do you have any idea of a number? No, Representative Copeland, I mean, it happens all over the state. I've seen it from my own personal experience. as somebody who I've gotten out of the criminal defense work, but as somebody who has seen it happen over and over and over and it's my opinion that if we could have somebody that would I'll just tell you I'll go out there. I had the situation
happen to a client one time and it was close to it was in the eastern Arkansas area and for that reason the blood test that was done was processed in Tennessee. Well, you're not getting the nurse or biologist that took that blood sample from Tennessee to come over to Arkansas District Court and
nothing happens to the individual. May I follow up, Chairman? I'm assuming that the prosecutors and law
enforcement are in support of this? I've not heard
from any law enforcement, my understanding is the prosecutors are split roughly down the middle. But, you know, our prosecutors, I would just go out there on a limb, say uniformly caused the state are excellent. And why we tie their hands like this, I don't think it's ever made sense. And you're
really just saying it would give discretion, correct? It would just solely give discretion. It
doesn't do anything else. They still have to charge, just have to immediately
be filed. Nothing of that changed. It just simply says that like every other single criminal offense in the state of Arkansas, the prosecutors themselves, who are the ones dealing
Representative House, you're recognized for question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Wright, Counselor. Yes, sir. I came up in a time when you could negotiate DUIs, DWIs, as we call them, and And also remember the push, particularly Mothers Against Drunk Driving, were wonderful advocates to require no discretion.
And it was passed by this legislature. I'm asking you if my impression is correct. I get the impression that since the prosecutors cannot negotiate a charge by law, that there are emergencies, that blood tests do get sent across state lines, that breathalyzers don't seem to work, that they are, in essence, sidestepping the law rather than doing things in a more transparent and open and honest manner.
Am I correct or am I way
off base? I believe you're correct. That's the whole point
in this. Representative Beck, you're recognized for a question. Is there any way this change
could be used to, like, lessen a DWI offense? Yes, to many of other lesser offenses. That's the point in that it's an all-or-nothing deal right now, Representative Beck. You are required to, once the charge is filed, you are required to try the case, okay?
And so it's an all or nothing. There's no middle ground. If it's the worst case in the world, the case must still be tried. If you have, again, I've said it several times, on any other crime in the state of Arkansas, if there are bad facts, if there are witnesses missing, I mean literally I could come up with reasons all day long to tell you why a case may be negotiated maybe it's to save a trial maybe it's you know the person wants to take their punishment and get it over with
but this is the only crime you can't do that and again I just don't know why we've tied our hands and I have total faith in the court system to handle these cases properly I
guess the only concern I would have is that does this open a door to where there's a good case that could be negotiated down? I don't think it
does. I mean, if you're going to ask that question,
why not ask about every other single crime in
the state of Arkansas? Representative Tosh, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Counselor, is there not another law in the books, just to make sure I understand, there's not another law in the books that says that it's a violation of the law in itself for anyone to try to reduce a DWI once the ticket has been issued, including law enforcement, prosecutors, or anyone else? Is that not a separate statute, and if so, how would that be affected by this statute here?
I don't know any other statute other than this one that says it can't be done. This statute that I'm amending is one that says it
can't be reduced Did that answer your question? Well maybe so I think there is another statute to my understanding that prohibits and it's actually a separate charge and you are law enforcement or anyone else that tampers with the DWI or tries to reduce it for any reason before it goes before a judge is to be charged with a violation of the law
for trying to lessen the offense of DWI. I just want to make sure if, unless I'm mistaken and this may be included in that but it's my understanding there is a law in effect to that. I'll check on that. I'm not aware of
if it will or not, but if it were I think it would negate that and then there would be some clean up language about getting rid of that. Okay,
I see no further questions. No one has signed up. Representative Wright, are you closed for your bill? I'm closed. Appreciate a good vote. Motion
to do pass. Okay, we have a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Those opposed? No. The ayes have it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Can I run 1467, Mr. Chairman? Okay, so we're going to pass over House Bill 1371, House Bill 1374, and without objection, we're going to House
Bill 1467. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. Thank you. This is I hope a little more simple of a bill. All this bill does
is clean up some language that was brought to my attention by the prosecuting attorneys. Right now there's a gap that we've kind of discovered between when somebody is arrested and when the criminal information formally charging and accused in that what is happening is this gap that discovers that sometimes you're arrested and then you have, this is what this does, is make sure you're required to show up in court.
The gap that's there now is that when you're arrested and you don't show up to court for your first court date, but the formal criminal information has not been filed, you can't be charged with failure to appear. What this does is it clarifies pending charge. It says once you've been arrested for a crime, by gosh, you've got to show up to court. And that's all it does. I'd be more than happy to answer any questions.
Okay, I see no questions. Does not appear anybody has signed up to speak for against the bill. Representative Wright, are you closed for your bill?
I am, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Again, committee, I appreciate a good vote. We have a motion due pass. We
have a motion due pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? You've passed your bill. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Okay.
While we go back to the regular agenda, Representative Scott has sent me a note that we have the Republican Women of Arkansas in our committee today. So welcome to the House Judiciary Committee. Okay, we're going to pass it over House Bill 1371, passing over House Bill 1374. That brings us to House Bill 1392. Representative House, are you prepared to run House Bill 1392?
Yes, we do. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, colleagues. My wife is in the audience, so y'all act like you like me, please. This is brought to you by the American Institute of Architects. Very simple bill. Mayflower is in my district. You know about the tornado and the oil spill. There are certain people that were architects who are architects
and, as we discovered, engineers who were willing to help with the cleanup up, to make evaluations about remodeling, whether a structure could continue to be used and rebuilt, or whether it should be demolished. And they were doing this sort of thing, free gratis, at the request of the city and the county. And it occurred to them that some of them were reluctant to do so because of their liability. If they're acting as a good Samaritan at the request of civil authorities, then they would
be immune just like any other Good Samaritan if they're rendering professional services without pay. That's the bill in a nutshell. Glad to entertain any questions,
Mr. Chairman. I'll go ahead and ask my question that I've asked previously related to this, but not to you, Representative House. What about other professions? For example, attorneys. There are plenty of times attorneys provide pro bono assistance for individuals.
I'm just wondering if that's how we draw the line or the distinction between what an architect does or what an engineer does versus what an attorney or some other professional may do. An accountant, for that matter, if they're providing assistance to someone who has experienced some kind of emergency situation and an accountant prepares tax returns or other things to help that person out through that time. I'm just curious how we draw the line or the distinction between various
professions. You don't, Mr. Chairman. I'd support any such bill that would grant such immunity. Bulldozer operators, truck drivers, anything else if it's without compensation. But this one was asked, the American Institute of Architects asked this and I added engineers to their title after talking with some of our engineer friends here in the House and Senate. But, yes, sir, I think there is some appropriate movement in that direction. Thank you.
Representative Talia, do you have a question? Representative House, on these recommendations, is there any kind of level? I mean, will these recommendations be sealed with their seal and everything? I mean, is it going to be the same level professional as the Good Samaritan, or as they would be in charge? Well, I mean, like. These recommendations like me and you stand on the street and I'm looking at your house after a disaster and say, you know, I'm an architect and just look at this and I think this will work or here's how you make corrections. What I'm saying is I think there's a difference between me walking down the street and helping you after a disaster
and me and my professional business and giving you the same guarantee as an engineer or architect.
Is there any kind of difference in those two? Well, yes, sir. And the key to this, at the request of approval of a national, state, or local public official, law enforcement official, public safety official, building inspection official, believed by the registered architect or professional engineer to be acting in the course of their capacity. We're talking about the police or the city or someone like that.
Ask a professional architect, we need your help, or an engineer, we need your help to assess the damages, whether we ought to bulldoze down this building, whether we ought to save it and try to rebuild on it, something like that. Working on an individual basis doesn't necessarily rise to that level unless you've got some municipal involvement. Did I answer your question? And, you know, it might be a bad judgment. I think we need to go ahead and save this building and then it fall on somebody.
Well, that's the sort of thing that could conceivably happen, and that would really make an engineer or an architect be reluctant to get involved unless they had a contract and their insurance covered it and all that other sort of thing. Representative
Petty, you're recognized for a question. I see no further questions. Nobody has signed up to speak for or against the bill.
Representative Howells, are you closed for your bill? I am, Mr. Chairman. Thank you very much for your patience. And we had Representative Petty, you have a motion? Do pass. Okay, we have a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, colleagues. Continuing down the regular agenda, House Bill 1400 Okay Alright, we're going to pass over House Bill 1400
House Bill 1403 Pass over House Bill 1403 House Bill 1414 It's without objection we'll move it to deferred Senate Bill 260 will pass over Senate Bill 260 House Bill 1432 Representative Ward Law Okay, we're going to try
and take that up on Thursday House Bill 1203 Hold on just a second Thank you.
Okay, members, we're going to take up House Bill 1203. Representative Hammer has an amendment, and after speaking with Representative Hammer, I think what we are looking to do is adopt the amendment, and then we'll take up the bill as amended at a later date.
Representative Hamer, you may present. Representative Hamer, can we hold off? Well, you're the chair. I'll do whatever you tell me. Let's hold off. I want to make sure we get this done correctly, so let's hold off. I apologize for that. No problem. Thank you. House Bill 1441, Representative Bain, pass over
House Bill 1448, pass over House Bill 1449, pass over House Bill 1450, Representative Copeland, pass over House Bill 1456 Representative Bain, you are recognized to present House Bill 1456.
Good morning, committee, and with your permission, Mr. Chairman, I'd like to bring a witness to the table as part of the presentation. Okay. Go ahead. Mr. David Sacher with the Judicial Discipline and Disability Commission could come forward. And Mr. Chairman, if you give me a little latitude, I don't believe Mr. Sacher was here for introductions at the beginning of session. If we could give him maybe one minute to briefly discuss what his commission's responsibilities are. You're
recognized. State your name, who you represent, and you may make your statement.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm David Sacher, S-A-C-H-A-R. I'm the executive director of the Judicial Discipline and Disability Commission. We're essentially internal affairs for the judiciary, the ethics arm created by a constitutional amendment. So we handle all the complaints against judges from ethical misconduct and, of course, coordinate if there are other agencies involved as well. You would know some of our bigger cases that have happened in the last several years that have made headlines, but we also handle about 300 or so complaints, mainly by citizens, each year.
Representative Bain, you recognize and present the bill. Committee, this bill came out of – the conversation about this bill has been around for a while, but I think the reason this bill I chose to bring at this session was we saw some recent events in the prior year with a circuit judge who was removed from the bench for cause. But the questions often came about what if a lot of the information was not already publicly available out there and what if certain entities that were not part of the investigation that led to the removal of this judge.
In other words, what if that information was not publicly available? What if the Arkansas Supreme Court had not had the option or the luxury of taking their course of action? we could have potentially been left with a situation where a member of the bench was indicted by a U.S. attorney in the morning and then they were holding docket that afternoon. Quite literally, it would have been a mad race in Little Rock to go through a suspension process. There's not anything in the law that says if they're indicted, if there's actually
the charge of information, there's actually an indictment out there that they are barred from hearing cases. And so this is a stopgap measure to allow the judiciary to put the brakes on any judicial office holder who has been indicted, who basically the charge of information has been brought against them, to put the brakes on that individual. Now, there is a process they can go through to appeal, virtually any other process of appeal. There's a way they can
go and petition. But we just want to This is more about protecting those who are going before a judge. You may have a criminal defendant about to go before a judge who is already indicted under the way Arkansas law is written. I don't think that's healthy or productive for our society. I think we need to make sure that any judge that's on the bench that's hearing any case, criminal or civil, does not have any charges, does not have anything hanging over their heads, and this would create an automatic suspension process for those judges.
And, again, this is a very limited situation. This conversation happened, you know, I thought about this bill two years ago, but a lot of us really just didn't see or want to see what had happened in the past year. But the reality of the situation is this does happen. It's happened just last year, and it will happen again at some future point, and we need to be ready for such an event. I'd be happy to take any questions from myself or my witness.
Representative Copeland, you're recognized for
a question. Representative Bain, does this not, it's kind of irony here because we're constantly fighting for due process for those charged and even indicted. And yet we're not affording that same, I mean, they wouldn't lose their job if they were indicted. I'm talking about a citizen.
They wouldn't lose their ability to go to work. And in our legal process, anybody that's indicted is not convicted. And I think our process allows that. And I'm not a lawyer, but I just seem like on the face of it, it's almost like we're leaning toward this person is guilty by removing them. Well, I will say that
there are protections in here. There are appeal protections. but I would say the overriding most important issue is the integrity of our courts.
Making sure that a criminal or civil defendant standing in front of a judge knows that they're going to get a fair shake. And I think there's a real question mark over any decision by any judge under any kind of pending indictment on their decisions. And it would cause me great pause if I was a defendant in a case or if I was involved in any way in a case to know if that decision could be reversed. because of the situation that that judge is in. May I follow up?
Are there other states that has this, and what have been the results of that? There are.
And could you give them to me, please? As far as exact examples, I'd have to come back to you and get you other examples. Certainly interim suspension is used in a lot of different states, a lot of different ways. We've used it here before, but previously the statute as it is now and the rule as it is now require us to petition. So that four or five days where a judge defiantly goes back on the bench after doing a perp walk would be incredibly damaging to the judiciary and the people of the state of Arkansas.
So that's what we're really trying to accomplish. But as far as I talked to the National Center for State Courts, they didn't think there would be any due process problems because the judge is suspended with pay. No benefits are taken away, much like a police officer after a shooting. Look, you may be the most justified shooting in the world, but we're going to let you stay home, and then if the judge wants to go back on the bench, within 10 days we would have to defend that in front of the Arkansas Supreme Court. So there are some due process considerations there that hopefully would satisfy your concerns.
I have a question. The appeal process, based on the suspension, the only thing that would be subject to the appeal is whether he was under indictment or not, or had been charged,
correct? I'd have to review it again. Can I pull it
I guess I read it as hold a hearing no later than 10 days at the request to determine whether the suspension with pay remains in effect. So I kind of read it as whether the Supreme Court would determine whether it should remain in
effect. Am I misreading that? And I guess to me it seems when A1 says a judge shall be suspended from office with pay by the Supreme Court if the following things occur.
And then later on, I mean, I think it's ambiguous as to what's the purpose of the hearing. Is the purpose of the hearing to say that I was not indicted or I was not charged? Or is the purpose of the hearing to say, even if I was indicted or charged, I have evidence to exonerate myself, and the charge is baseless and without merit, and therefore I should not be suspended during this time? And I don't think that's clear from the way the proposed language is drafted,
but that's why I asked the question is whether you all had some other understanding of how
it would be handled. Well, I agree with your understanding that it should be a meaningful due process. opportunity for the judge, including, yes, I've been charged, but for some reason I can explain to you why it's not damaging to the people of the state of Arkansas for me to continue to hear cases while I'm facing a felony charge, which, as we know, doesn't happen very often, but still. So I agree with you. They should have the opportunity to have that meaningful exchange in front of the Supreme Court. If it doesn't read that way, certainly I have no problem with it
being changed. Of course, that's up to the representative, not me. But as far as what you're asking, Chair. I agree. If the Chairman gives,
with your permission, we can pull that down and clean that language up and bring that back to the committee. I mean, that's
certainly fine. It's your call if you want to do that. I'd be happy to pull
this bill and go back and amend that language and make sure that we have complete clarity on that issue. Okay. I see no further
questions and without objection we'll allow Representative Bain to pull the
bill down. Then if we could pass over HB 1457 with your permission. We'll
House Bill 1458 Representative Bain you're recognized Thank you very much
Mr. Chairman this bill is in my mind it probably is the closest definition to a little old bill that don't do nothing this bill simply goes through and I'll actually I'm going to let my expert testify to this he's much more knowledgeable on this issue but we're simply going to go ahead and we've got a part of the Arkansas Supreme Court
has already declared unconstitutional. A specific section refers to judges, and I'd like to defer to my witness to give us a little bit
of the historical background. Thank you, Representative. The Arkansas Supreme Court struck down a portion of 1610-401 at SEC during Proctor v. Daniels when Judge Proctor tried to get back on the bench even though he'd been removed from office. So there's a section that was declared unconstitutional under separation of powers where the Supreme Court said they define what
removal is and the legislature could not. Again, conversations with the representative, I just pointed it out as something that I knew had been overturned and probably should be officially repealed by this body. And so that's pretty much all it does. I see no questions. I don't believe
we have anybody signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Bain, are you close for your bill. Mr. Chairman, I'm close for
my bill and I ask for a good vote with a due pass. We have a motion due
pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. We'll circle around
later today. Thank you very much. Thank you all. House Bill 1462, Representative
Bennett, you're recognized to present House Bill 1462. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If I
could ask Keith Kavanis to come up and help me with these.
These should be really simple little bills. Actually, they really are. 1462, we have, with your indulgence, there's three bills that the administrative office of the courts has asked for to clean up some of the language. The first one removes installment restitution, and I'm going to ask him to explain that, please.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Keith Cavanaugh, Administrative Office of the Courts. Those of you who were members in 2013 may recall the passage of a bill which amended various code sections concerning the assessment and collection of court costs in our courts in an attempt to shore up the state administration of justice fund. That bill, I don't remember the bill, and it became Act 282 of 2013. One of those amendments said that when a court authorizes a defendant to make installment payments of court costs and fines,
the payment of those installments first represents payment of court costs and then restitution. This bill would repeal some language that should have been taken care of in that bill. This language says that a district court judge has discretion to say, well, restitution can be paid first and not court costs. It's just to bring current law in conformity, more uniform law.
Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question. I'm sorry to keep asking everybody a question, but the one thing I have a concern, and I just want to make sure this does not eliminate someone being able to make payments, correct? It just simply gives the court the option to apply that payment in whatever form to court costs or to
restitution, correct? Currently, the law provides, we have two laws. One says court costs are paid first, then restitution, then fines.
This language gives a judge discretion to say rest in, yes, sir. Okay, great. Thank you. I see
no questions. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Bennett, are you
closed for the bill? I am, and I would appreciate a
good vote. Do pass, please. Okay, we have a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes.
Mr. Chairman, with your indulgence, would it be possible to take up 1463? Without objection,
Thank you, Mr. Chair. 1463 is another cleanup language for district courts and just specifies that under record retention, it previously was a little ambiguous as to which court records had to be retained
and allowed for expungement of small claims processes that may not yet have been satisfied. It also did not require the courts to retain quashed or unexecuted warrants. So this just cleans that language up. Any questions? I see no questions. No one has signed
up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Bennett, are you closed for your bill? I am, and
Do pass. Okay, we have a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes.
And Mr. Chair, if I might push your indulgence and ask if we could take up House Bill 1484. Okay,
without objection, we'll go back up to House Bill 1484.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. 1484, again, is a cleanup bill and makes it clear that when a district court issues a writ of garnishment, that they can also charge a $10 fee for that.
and that, as with a lot of bills we're seeing in this session, clarifies that that money goes into the general fund of the district court, I mean of the city, city or county or whoever
issued the writ. Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question. Is there not
a fee currently? There is a $10 fee that's assessed, but it's not clear that it's assessed on writs of garnishment.
And so this just makes it clear. So some courts are, some courts aren't. So this just, you don't have to charge it. It just allows a court to charge it. But they couldn't allow,
this wouldn't allow an additional $10? No, it will not. Okay, thank you. Right.
no further questions. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Bennett, are you closed for
the bill? I am. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I recommend a good vote.
Do pass, please. We have a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? You passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you.
We're now to House Bill 1474. Representative Smith, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr.
Chair and committee. Today I'm introducing House Bill 1474, and I want to call your attention to some of the reasons why this bill is important to me. It deals with American laws for American courts. I'm involved in presenting this bill to you today because, having lived overseas for more than 20 years in various countries and under various rules of law or lack of rules of law, this is a personal bill for me.
Lived and worked under military government rule, monarchies, Islamic states, including China, Burma, Laos, Thailand, and Iraq. So I've seen the broad range of what governments are, what they should not be. And after coming home and winding up here at the Capitol, along with many of you, I see a golden opportunity to set the bar maybe a little higher or to bring clarity to the court for those men and women who sit on the bench.
I'm sponsoring this bill because of current trends in the United States where foreign laws conflict with our own. The founders of our nation believed that the United States of America and its individual states should never be subservient to any foreign power, country, or legal system that has no foreign power. Country or legal system should be allowed to encroach upon our rights under the Constitution. The purpose of American laws for American courts is to preserve the sovereignty of U.S.
Arkansas and their respective constitutions by preventing this encroachment of foreign laws and legal systems that run counter to our individual fundamental constitutional liberties and freedoms. By passing American Laws for American Courts, the Arkansas Legislature will be preserving fundamental individual liberties and freedoms which become eroded by encroachment of foreign laws and foreign legal doctrines.
It is imperative that we safeguard our Constitution's fundamentals, particularly individual guarantees of the Bill of Rights, the sovereignty of our nation and its people, and the principles of the rule of law, American laws, not foreign laws. And so with that, that gives you a basic idea of what this bill does, what it will do. It brings clarity to our system and to our Constitution in relation to foreign laws.
I'll be happy to answer questions. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Smith, in any way does this
law unfairly target any protected group? Absolutely not. As a matter of fact, it doesn't target any specific group. The language is written broadly, and it actually protects everyone.
Arkansans, it protects us, but it also, as our immigrant population grows, it protects those incoming immigrants that want to live under our Constitution. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. Representative
Smith, would it be a fair statement? I'd like you to elaborate if possible. Does this, in your opinion, does this law add another layer of protection for our
Constitution? It does, and let me tell you the reason why.
After having lived in these other cultures, my primary job description was humanitarian aid, relief, development, and field researcher. Living and working in these environments, and especially after two extended deployments in Iraq, where I served with the United States Army, my job was to go out and work in the communities and bring back intelligence reporting to my brigade and battalion commanders. What I discovered was even though there were tribal laws, there were laws that were set up that basically the sheikh or his small community of strong men or head men would set in judgment and render decisions,
a lot of people within these other cultures around the world, and in particular women, never felt like they had a voice. As a matter of fact, the research that I conducted, Representative Tosh, one of the questions that I asked in that environment was simply, how did they feel about expressing the freedom of expression? Because in our country, we know we have a First Amendment right. Even though immigrants come here and live among us,
many of them are grouped into small communities that hang on to their traditional and foreign law. They prefer it, but not everyone in that community. And, for example, 73% of the people that I talked with said they were afraid to speak their mind, even though they had the right to do so. 18% said that they did not fear speaking out, but that's a small minority. And so what I've noticed, even in our country, and even in the state of Arkansas,
as groups come here, they tend to cluster because they're comfortable. But particularly women that are in domestic disputes, even though the court is there for them, And there's not the clarity that we need that even provides them the protection of our Constitution and specifically the Constitution of the State of Arkansas. So it adds a layer of protection. Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question.
Representative, is this, and I'm just, it sounds like what you're trying to do is
really good. You've talked quite a bit about being in another country, but obviously we're here. Is this kind of a reaction to a trend towards Sharia law in some areas? And I know I'm just kind of throwing that out here.
And with that, is there another state that's done this, and what is the real threat that we would need to do this? And I think you know me and you and I are friends, so that's
an honest question. That's not a trick question. Well, I appreciate the question. And honestly, if you look through this bill, the word Sharia, Sharia law is not mentioned in this bill because we wanted this bill to be more broad because we're talking about much more than just simply zeroing in on
and targeting a specific group or religious sect or religion. We wanted it to be broad and have some depth to it that would protect everyone. And so we're not singling out, but that would be one of the benefits, that it would prevent Sharia courts from being established in Arkansas where people would say, I've got an option. I can go to my county courthouse or I can go to my federal courthouse.
I can do that. But maybe they're being guided by an imam or mullah to go to Sharia court. And we're saying when those two laws conflict, American law trumps all
foreign law. Representative Copeland, you're recognized. Because I've heard of places, Dearborn and places that, you know, and I've not been there, so I don't know. I'm just hearing second-hand accounts. And I'm very interested in this and very wary with everything going on internationally.
But at the same time, do you know of anywhere that that is, and I know sometimes we pass laws all the time for things that haven't happened yet, and I think that's not a bad thing. but do you know of situations where whether it be Sharia or any other alternate law has been an issue and how other states have addressed this, and is this
new to us or has somebody else done this? It's not new. It's gaining ground across the United States as we see various populations increase,
outside populations coming here. I'll give you an example. example, Minneapolis, Minnesota, huge population of Somalis. There are issues there, specifically in some communities, no-go zones. Michigan, the same, no-go zones. Down in Texas, believe it or not, even in Texas, and everybody hates to mention the name Texas, but, you know, it's true. There are actually no-go zones down there, or there is the attempt to establish those.
And what we're trying to do is get out in front of a problem before we have to deal with it. And let me give you a personal account. One of my, there are several people that I know that I've actually helped come to the United States out of specifically Iraq. They're here on special immigrant visas. And because of language issues, even though some of them speak pretty good English, this is a whole new world for them. They love our country, and they're so happy to be here out of Iraq.
These are Chaldean Christians, for example, and they're here, but they're living in communities of like kind. And so just three or four weeks ago, an individual called me, and he said, Brother, I'm finally here. And he said, but I'm concerned about the community where I live because it's not much better than what I came out of in Baghdad. And so I think what we need to do is present a strong effort to clarify American laws for American courts.
Whether you're native-born or an immigrant, our Constitution guarantees you specific rights and privileges that other nations will not be allowed to infringe. Representative Drown, you recognize for question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. My only question
you and I have both traveled many of the different parts of the world. I have been in the no-go zones in some of the European countries and the U.K.
And it is an issue, but the issue I see is specifically at this point in not only our nation's history, but in our world history, Sharia law, as we have just been discussing. Do you not feel like, and that's why I'm asking this question, is would this, if we specifically mention Sharia law, and of course that is of today, the problem of today that is spreading, not only is it foreign law, but it's also religious practice.
based on how you view Islam. So what I'm getting at is do you not think that this might be something that should be focused on and addressed directly within this legislation? Not specifically in
this legislation because what we have to do in order to get where we want to go is we have to have some law here now that allows us to at least safeguard what we have, what we hold dear,
and that is not only our U.S. Constitution but the Constitution of the State of Arkansas. And then there can be other legislation as needed. But we didn't want to use any specific language in this bill that would target a specific group or religious group because we're concerned it would be struck down as unconstitutional or unfair. But what we do know is that there are numerous cases in which Sharia doctrines have been invoked in the United States.
Notes here, the Center for Security Policy's recent study found that 50 legal cases across 23 states all published appellate cases where Sharia was either relevant or highly relevant to the arguments or outcome of the case. And so it's a matter of time. My day job, I'm a professor, an associate professor. I teach intelligence studies, threat analysis, analytics, numerous other courses.
The trend is toward this encroachment. We're seeing a higher degree of frequency with small events happening around the United States and then potentially in the state of Arkansas. And while we can't use predictive analysis with 100% certainty, it's a matter of time before we deal with this in our courts. And this can set the stage for handling these kinds of cases more seamlessly as we rely back and fall on a bill that deals with these things.
Representative, the question I have is with regard to companies that may be based in Arkansas. We have a number of companies that are international, companies that do business in all different places around the world. is this going to inhibit their ability to contract with individuals, vendors,
or other entities in these other countries because many times there are choice of law provisions and other things that when they're contracting that they're negotiating with regard to. And so I guess my question is specifically with regard to the business community who are obviously, I mean, those are sophisticated parties in terms of their negotiations. It's not necessarily the same as individuals being subjected to Sharia law or otherwise.
You have sophisticated parties that are trying to conduct business internationally, and I'm curious as to how, if this bill would protect their ability to continue to contract with entities around the world. Well,
as I understand it, and, of course, I'm not an attorney. I've been a field researcher most of my life. The fact is this bill does not conflict with those contracts and treaties. As a matter of fact, we're dealing primarily with domestic issues with this bill.
So we're safe in that regard. As a matter of fact, as far as what you're talking about, I believe on page 4, line 15, we're talking about if a resident of Arkansas subject to personal jurisdiction in Arkansas seeks to maintain litigation, arbitration agencies, or similar binding procedures in this state, and you can read on down there, it does not impact some of those legally binding contractual agreements.
I may be on the wrong page with that. Page two, foreign law, legal code, or systems does not mean, doesn't relate to Native Americans. And then we're talking about three, but a court, arbitration, tribunal, or administrative agency ruling decision violates the public policy. But we're dealing primarily with domestic disputes. For example, if an individual wanted a bill of divorce,
in some cultures it's not quite as cut and dried as it is in ours. A citizen within the state of Arkansas could go before our courts and deal with that as opposed to some other legal system brought in from a foreign country.
and and i understand that i mean i completely understand with in the domestic relations realm uh and can appreciate the intent um i guess i just have the the general concern about
whether this is so broad that it would create an impediment for business to conduct business or Or alternatively, should those businesses end up needing to avail themselves of the courts, I think normally business prefers to litigate near their home, and if it's an Arkansas business, they would prefer to litigate in the state courts here or federal courts here.
But I'm wondering whether if we pass this law, does that essentially force them to litigate outside the state in jurisdictions that may not be as friendly? And, again, that's just my general concern with regard to the specific language. But perhaps you can shed some light on that and alleviate my
concerns. Thank you. This bill does not impact comity, okay? and that friendly cooperation that we enjoy or that we have with other countries
or even other states that may be impacted. This bill deals strictly with, primarily with, domestic issues. Representative Ballinger,
you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. On page 4, line 23, which is paragraph E, does it specifically exclude, without prejudice to any legal right, this section does not apply to a corporation, partnership, limited liability company, business association
or other legal entity that contracts to subject itself to foreign law. So in this case, would a corporation like Walmart that chooses to do business in other countries, would they be specifically exempted from this?
be. Okay, thank you. And I'm not sure that that section, again, with regard to that, that essentially forces them to litigate outside the state of Arkansas, correct?
I wouldn't think so. But, I mean, they may, but I think that's up to the parties involved
in the dispute. I mean, Section E only deals with subjecting itself to foreign law in a jurisdiction other than Arkansas or the United States, and I don't know with regard to all the various contracts I've been entered into. I have a little experience in some of those areas, but I guess I just have the general concern that we may be creating an issue for some of those entities as they do business
and as disputes arise. I have no issue with regard to the domestic relations area or some of the other specific things that you've outlined. That's a general concern from reading the bill. I see no further questions. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Ballinger makes a motion. Do pass. Any discussion?
Speaker 257
1:52:48
All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and
committee. Seeing as we're approaching the lunch hour, we're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1251
HB1114
SB261
SB161
HB1282
HB1467
HB1392
HB1456
HB1458
HB1462
HB1463
HB1484
HB1474
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair
Unverified
Representative John T. Vines
Unverified
Speaker 11
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Representative Sue Scott
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Representative Donnie Copeland
Unverified
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
David Lucas
Unverified
Speaker 100
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Speaker 106
Speaker 108
Speaker 121
Representative Douglas House Chair
Unverified
Senator Jeremy Hutchinson
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Speaker 164
Speaker 172
Representative Marshall Wright
Unverified
Representative Rick Beck
Unverified
Speaker 181
Representative Brent Talley
Unverified
Representative John Baine
Unverified
Speaker 224
Speaker 229
Speaker 244
Representative Brandt Smith
Unverified
Representative R. Trevor Drown
Unverified
Speaker 50
Speaker 257