Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

March 5, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (9)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1573 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1573”
Pre-2017 bill
SB260 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB260”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1049 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1049”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1432 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1432”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1448 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1448”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1614 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1614”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1628 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1628”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1629 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1629”
Pre-2017 bill
SB177 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB177”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
before. We're going to cancel that without objection, and we will reset that at a later date. I believe Senator Hutchinson wants to run Senate Bill 260. Without objection, the senator is recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I don't have
▶ Play
the bill in front of me. I'm trying to pull it up here, but it's a pretty easy bill. It simply, I know that's code in this committee for Let's kill it. It's an invitation to beat it to death, but it simply comports our estate tax laws in such a way that we can take full advantage of the federal estate tax exemptions. Currently, our citizens are not getting the full advantage of the federal estate tax, And this bill would put us in line with that so that it wouldn't be a terribly common use, but it would allow some of our citizens to maximize the estate tax exemptions under federal law. And it obviously doesn't cost the state anything.
▶ Play
See no questions by the committee. Okay. Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Senator Hutchinson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator, have you any idea how many people this would impact on a yearly basis?
▶ Play
I don't have a specific number. It would be high net worth individuals. but it would be probably a few hundred, a few thousand I've got my brother here his law firm actually is the one who brought this to my attention I don't know much more than
▶ Play
Speaker 14 2:01
Jeremy but with chair's permission if you'll have
▶ Play
a seat and introduce yourself and then you can respond to the question I'm Tim Hutchinson with Reese Moore Pendergraft
▶ Play
Speaker 18 2:12
it would only apply to those individuals who can there's a 5.2 million That's an approximate amount, federal exemption for the estate tax. So this would be a situation where a husband and wife want to put assets into a joint trust, so it would be looking at about $10.4 million worth of assets. So only for those people who have 10.4 or
▶ Play
excess would this apply. And it would affect their federal
▶ Play
Speaker 18 2:40
tax liability? Estate tax. Right. Yeah, correct. and only the federal estate tax basically so they can capture that full $10.4 million that is exempted from the federal estate tax. And, of course, that number changes. And so Congress could change that number to $1 million per individual next year, and then it would affect anyone who has $2 million worth of assets. But currently, with the exemption under federal law, it's about 5.2, and so we're looking at individuals, couples with 10.4. Okay. All right. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And this is my fault. I should have probably read this bill before now. But my question would be just, if you don't mind explaining how this actually functions. What is, I mean, I do some of the state planning, so it's kind of, I guess, important to me
▶ Play
Speaker 28 3:33
to feel like I know what I'm doing when we
▶ Play
Speaker 18 3:37
vote on it. I'll take my best shot. When a couple will form a joint trust, they'll each put in $5.2 million. They have a system where if one dies, the other is appointed trustee. Right. So the idea is that they're each able to put $5.2 million into this trust, and that is tax-free from the federal estate tax purposes. Well, there's been some case law throughout the country that when one of those individuals pass away and that $5.2 million reverts back to their spouse, then that says that now this remaining spouse, surviving spouse, has $10.4 million, and thus they're not going to be able to take full advantage because they're saying, no, you have $10.4 million estate versus the $5.2 million. Does that make sense? It does. So it basically allows two settlers to put money into the trust and allow that to avoid the federal estate tax. And when one of those settlers pass away, it doesn't revert back to the other settler.
▶ Play
Okay. So currently when I do my trust, I set up as an A trust, B trust. One is irrevocable so that we can maximize the exemption, the state tax exemption. So in this case, you wouldn't necessarily have to do it. It could remain in one trust and still get the full marital exemption and the full
▶ Play
state tax exemption. Exactly. Okay, thank you. Representative, no further questions. Does not appear anybody signed up for or against. Senator Hutchinson, are you closed? I am. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative House, we have a motion due pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Senator, you've passed your bill. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1573. Rep. Bennett, you're recognized to present the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, committee, and I appreciate your indulgence this morning. Today, Jan Siepich, who's come in from New Mexico to testify about this bill, I'd ask that she be allowed to join me at the table. If you'd have a seat and introduce
▶ Play
yourself. Thank you. My name is Jayanne Sepich.
▶ Play
Ms. Sepich has brought a PowerPoint to kind of explain some of the details of this bill. I think it may help a lot of the questions if we allow her to do that first. Basically, what this bill does is allow for DNA testing. We currently have that in law now for certain identified offenses. However, as the science is advanced and law enforcement is advanced, it's occurred to a lot of people in the criminal justice field that it would be helpful to have DNA testing for any felonies that arise. Now, the bill that you have before you, they are hopefully in a second bringing over an amendment to this bill. It's a very simple amendment, but let me warn you about that before everybody gets worried about juveniles. The amendment will basically, if you look at the first page of the bill where it says DNA can be taken for any felony offense, it is going to say of a person over 18 years of age. But then we are still going to allow DNA testing of people under 18 for the offenses that we had previously listed in law. So for people under 18, it will make no change to current law. For people over 18, it will expand to offenses. And it does have a very simple way to expunge the record if a criminal charge is never initiated. initiated, if you null process the charge, if you put, you know, it's a very broad, expansive way to remove your DNA from the system. I'd also want to let you know, I know we've had a lot of discussion about expunging fingerprint records. These records are different than fingerprint records, where fingerprint records always follow a charge. DNA is taken and kept in a separate database, So it's a little bit of a different animal. So with your permission, Mr. Chair, I'd like to allow Ms. Seepage to go ahead with her presentation, and I'm going to slide out of the way.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 8:55
Something just happened. Representative Scott, for what
▶ Play
purpose? A question. I know this is early. I just need the definition of a word in the bill. Could I
▶ Play
please get that or a term? Sure. Is
▶ Play
that proper, Mr. Chair? Representative Bennett. Okay. Representative Scott has a question. I am so sorry. And those of you who are attorneys know this. Let me see. It's N-O-L-L-E, prosk, like null prosk.
▶ Play
Basically what that is, and this is not uncommon in the criminal justice system, You basically, instead of finding someone guilty or not guilty, you may enter some sort of agreement that they do something, and basically the case just kind of gets expunged. Is that the attorney? Expunged is a bad word. It basically is processed without a finding of guilt or innocence.
▶ Play
It's more like it's just short of a dismissal. I mean, a dismissal is where the charge is dismissed. Null process, it just nothing happens with it, kind of, so. Okay. Right. It's like non-pros, they're not going to
▶ Play
Speaker 63 10:13
prosecute. Much better explanation. Thank you all. All right.
▶ Play
Speaker 67 10:27
Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, I want to thank you for allowing me to be here today to talk about this legislation and to share my story with you. My daughter Katie brings me here. My daughter Katie was a 22-year-old graduate student pursuing her Master's of Business Administration when she left a friend's house one night and was very brutally raped, sodomized, strangled, and set on fire. And her body was left in an old abandoned city dump. Katie was the light of our lives. She was our firstborn. You can tell that she was a beautiful, beautiful young woman. She was so much more than that. She was full of joy. She was the state champion of Odyssey of the Mind. She was a fierce protector of all those she loved. We used to say if Katie loved you, she loved you like a freight train. She brought light and joy into every room she came into, and we loved her so much. Katie was fierce, and she fought for everything she wanted, and she fought for her life. And in doing so, she got the skin and blood of the man that killed her underneath her fingernails. And about four weeks after she was murdered, the detective in charge of her case came to us and said that they had extracted a DNA profile from that skin and blood and had uploaded it into the national DNA database called CODIS. And he said about once a week they would cross-reference that against the offender database to look for a match. This gave our family such bright hope because the detective told us that was really the only evidence they had, the only clues that they had. But this gave us such bright hope because we knew we had the identity of the man that killed our daughter. And we knew that once that matched up to his DNA profile in the database, we would be able to see him brought to justice and, more importantly, know that he couldn't do this to any other young woman. And I made the offhand comment to Captain Jones that this man was such a monster that surely he would be arrested for something else and his cheek would be swabbed and they would put his profile into the database, into CODIS, and that we would get that match. And that's when Detective Jones said, no, Jan, it doesn't work that way. It's illegal in New Mexico and almost every other state to take a DNA sample when someone's arrested. Even for a felony, we have to wait until they're convicted and only of certain felonies. And I was stunned. I couldn't believe it. I couldn't believe that when someone's arrested for a felony, we take their fingerprints, We take their photographs, and we have this scientific tool that is so accurate, and we can't use that. So I started doing research, and I started looking into it. And for two years, I did research and talked to people. And two years later, I went to my home state legislature in New Mexico and asked that they consider passing a law. We're going too fast here. that would mandate that DNA be taken upon arrest for a felony. And in March of 2006, the New Mexico State Legislature passed a bill that they called Cady's Law. It went into effect January 1st, 2007, and it mandated that DNA be taken upon arrest for all violent offenses, sexual assaults, and burglary. And I can tell you that since that went into effect until today in New Mexico, we've had 845 cases matched to arrestee DNA in New Mexico, and that's to arrestee DNA. The very, very first man that was swabbed one hour and 14 minutes after the law went into effect saw his DNA matched to a double homicide, and he has since been convicted of both of those murders. Here in Arkansas in 2009, a law was passed called Julie's Law that mandated that DNA be taken upon felony arrest for five charges, certain murders and kidnappings. Julie's Law in Arkansas says that DNA can be taken at arrest for only certain murders and rapists. It's a very limited collection. There are 28 states in the United States that allow that DNA be taken upon certain felony arrests. 14 of those states mandate that DNA be taken upon arrest for all felonies. And Arkansas is only one of those, only three of those 28 that do not allow DNA to be taken upon arrest for burglary. And I'm here today to say that I'm hoping that Arkansas will join the other 14 states who take it for all felony arrests and I'm going to give you some reasons why. First of all, it's very, very important to include burglary because, and it's ironic that Arkansas's law does not because burglary was the charge, the conviction that led to the arrest of Julie's killer. He was convicted of burglary, and that's how they got the match. Now, why is burglary so important? Because nationwide, 53% of the matches to violent crimes are from burglary, arrests, or convictions, 53%. So that means right now, under Arkansas's law, over half of the rapists and murderers are not being identified. People ask me, well, what about lower-level felonies? What about white-collar crimes? What about drug possession? Well, we know that we get a lot of matches from those as well. California is one of the states that takes DNA upon arrest for all felonies, and they are getting 10 matches every day to their DNA database. In California, a man named Shelby Glenn Shamblin was arrested for drugs, for simple drug possession. And when they swabbed him, they found that he had murdered Elizabeth Crossman, and he was arrested and convicted of that crime. There was also a man arrested for receiving stolen property and had his cheek swabbed, and it matched the 1977 rape and murder of an 80-year-old woman. Now, in 2011, we went back to the New Mexico State Legislature and asked that they expand their law to all felony arrests, a bill very similar to what we're talking about today. It passed, and what's very interesting is in New Mexico, since we expanded the law to include all felony arrests, we have seen an increase of 88% in our matches, an increase of 88%. And New Mexico was already collecting from burglaries, and that's where we get the highest percentage of our matches. So if Arkansas were to go ahead and expand to all felonies, they should see an increase much higher than what we saw in New Mexico. Another real interesting fact is that in New Mexico, since we did the expansion, we've had 18 matches from our arrest eDNA database to murders, 18. 12 of those were from the expanded crimes. In other words, if we hadn't expanded our law in New Mexico, 12 murders would still be free. Colorado, there was a very, very, well, the most prolific rapist of all times in Colorado raped 14 women, and he was finally identified after he was convicted of a forgery. If they had taken his DNA upon his first forgery arrest, 13 of those women wouldn't have been raped because he would have been identified and put away for his first rape. Drug possession, receiving stolen property, forgery. These are crimes that have identified rapists and murderers. and under the current Arkansas law, these rapists and murderers would not have been identified. Michael Lawless was convicted of forgery, and when he was convicted of forgery, and this was in Colorado, that DNA match led to a conviction of nine rapes, three kidnappings, and three robberies. If his DNA had been taken at the time of his first felony arrest, six rapes, five kidnappings, and all three robberies could have been prevented. Theodore Castillo was convicted of theft by receiving, and his DNA match led to the conviction of seven rapes. If his DNA had been taken at the time of his first felony arrest, seven of those eight rapes could have been prevented. it. I've been talking about prevention of crimes, and to me this is the most important reason to take DNA at the time of felony arrest. And I'm going to tell you the story that I came across that really hit me, and it was the reason that I started working on this. There's a man named Chester Dwayne Turner in California. Chester Turner was arrested 21 times over a period of 15 years without ever having his DNA taken upon arrest because the law did not allow it at that time. When he was finally convicted of rape, they swabbed his cheek, and they found his DNA matched 12 raped and murdered women. His first victim had been murdered two months after his first arrest. Her name was Diane Johnson. Chester Turner went on to rape and murder Annette Ernest, Anita Fishman, Regina Washington, Deborah Williams, Mary Edwards, Andrea Triplett, Desiree Jones, Natalie Price, Mildred Beasley, Paula Vance, and Brenda Brees. And when I see this list of names, I don't see names. I see the faces of daughters, and I feel the pain of their mothers. And I know that these women could have been spared. Two of these women were very pregnant with unborn babies when they were raped and murdered. Thirteen lives could have been spared. And to make this tragedy even worse, there was a man named David Allen Jones who was wrongfully convicted of two of these murders and served nine years in prison, and after they finally convicted Chester Turner of that rape and took his cheek swab and matched that DNA, David Allen Jones was released from prison with the apologies of the state of California. One cheek swab taken at arrest could have saved 11 women and two unborn babies and prevented a man from spending nine years, an innocent man, nine years in prison. Remember I said there were 21 arrests over 15 years. Twelve of those arrests would not be covered under the current Arkansas law. I want to show you some other statistics. This is a pie chart that talks about drug arrests, and I'm talking drug possession, not selling drugs, drug possession. This is in Virginia. and there were 139 matches from the DNA database to crimes. And what's really interesting about this is the ones in blue and the ones in red were matched to violent crimes, rapes, and murders from simple drug possession arrests. This is forgery. These were, excuse me, that previous slide was from drug possession convictions, not arrests. This is also from Virginia's statistics. This is for forgery. Of all of the matches from forgery to crimes, the ones in blue and the little sliver in purple and the ones in red were the matches to violent crimes, to rapes, murders. DNA in the database solves crimes sooner, prevents crimes, saves lives, and we have seen it exonerate the innocent. There's a man in New Mexico who was falsely accused of killing, raping, and murdering a little 11-year-old girl in her own bed. and he was awaiting trial for two years when there was an arrestee DNA match to another man. And he was being held because he knew so much about the crime scene that the authorities were convinced that he was involved in that rape and murder even though the DNA didn't match. But they arrested another man and they got a DNA match and they started an investigation and they found that those two men could never have known each other. so Israel Diaz was arrested for the rape and murder of Victoria Sandoval and Robert Gonzalez was released from jail after being there for two years an arrestee DNA hit in New Mexico got an innocent man out of jail we've seen this again in Illinois where a man was actually convicted of raping and murdering his daughter and her best friend And there was an arrest made in Virginia with a DNA match, and the exact same thing happened. The man was released from prison and exonerated. I think it's very important to know that it is not our DNA that goes into CODIS. Our DNA does not go into the database. It is a DNA profile that goes into the database, and that's very different. When you look at that double helix that is our DNA, there are over 3 billion markers on that double helix. Genetic scientists have selected only 13 of those to go into CODIS, and those 13 markers have no potential to disclose any medical diagnostic information or physical characteristics. A very renowned genetic scientist, Dr. Eisenberg, explained it to me like this. he asked me if I knew what a 33 RPM record album looked like, and I said, absolutely, that's what I had in high school. And he said, if you look at that vinyl record album, you can see the bands where the music is played, and you can see the spaces in between the bands where there's no music. When you put the needle in the spaces, you hear no music. He said, those are the markers that we selected to put into CODIS because they have no genetic information and can reveal nothing about a person. The DNA profile in the database does not identify genetic traits, reveal medical information, or reveal any private information. This is exactly the profile that goes into CODIS. This is it. This is what it looks like. There's a lab identifier. There is a specimen ID number. There are the markers. There's 26 numbers that denote those 13 markers. And there's the analyst's initials. What's missing? there are no names. There are no social security numbers in CODIS. A name is only matched to that information after there is a hit or a match to crime scene information. So in the database, there are no names, no identifying information whatsoever. These are my markers. This is my DNA profile. And I am so absolutely certain that there's nothing private in that DNA profile that this is printed on the back of my business card. I hand this out to everybody I meet, everybody that gets my business card gets my DNA profile. I wouldn't give them my social security number, I wouldn't give them my home address, but I'll give them my DNA profile. Also, there was some talk about fingerprints, and I think it's very important to note that there are actually more protections around a DNA profile than there are to fingerprints. Fingerprints become part of the permanent arrest record. DNA profiles are never part of that arrest record. They only exist in that CODIS DNA database. They're not connected. DNA profiles, fingerprints cannot be expunged, but DNA profiles absolutely can be expunged and are expunged. Actually, federal law requires that there must be a provision for the expungement of DNA profiles if the arrestee is not ultimately found guilty for the charge for which he was arrested, and that's federal law. The lab here in Arkansas testified yesterday in the Senate Judiciary that they are ready, willing, and able to start processing arrestee DNA. Kermit Channel said that he has the equipment and the personnel to do so, and they are ready. And one of the things I want to talk about is we've had opponents say, well, this is going to add to the backlog. This is going to make the backlog worse. What's actually happened in states that have expanded their arrestee DNA database is that there's been a reduction in backlogs. As a matter of fact, Ohio, California, and Colorado have announced that they have totally eliminated their backlog since they passed arrestee DNA and expanded to all felony arrests. Some people say, well, this violates the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution. Well, the Supreme Court said in Marilyn v. King in June of 2003 that arrestee DNA does not violate the Fourth Amendment. They said DNA is like fingerprinting and photographing, a legitimate police booking procedure that is reasonable under the Fourth Amendment. And this is where we talked about exoneration, that DNA is helping exonerate people. I also know that if we used DNA at the beginning of the process, at the very beginning, that we would have the right individual, the right perpetrator, and the wrong person would never be harassed, would never even be questioned, arrested, tried, or convicted, or incarcerated. Now, what about money? DNA actually saves a great deal of money. The University of Virginia released a study in January of 2013, an independent academic study that said for every profile that goes into the DNA database, which nationwide has an average cost of about $30, every one of those profiles goes on to save the taxpayer $27,000. Congress passed the Katie Seppich Enhanced DNA Collection Act, was signed into law in 2013. This establishes grants to help states pay for their DNA processing. These grants are available through 2015, and what that means is if Arkansas were to pass this expansion law, and I've checked since you don't collect for burglary, you would be eligible for the Katie Seppich grants. The solicitation is already out for this year, and it would pay for the cost, the first-year cost. So it would pay for the kits, so there would be no cost to the local jurisdictions, and there never are. Those are borne by the state, but these grants would be available. And last year, the grants were awarded to Rhode Island and Mississippi, so a lot of times people say, oh, there are grants available, but are they really awarded? Yes, they absolutely were. I'd like to conclude by saying that arrestee DNA has been taken in this country since 2003. That's when the first arrestee DNA was taken. So that's 12 years that it's been taken. In those 12 years not one person has been harmed by having their arrestee, their DNA, been put into the database as a result of an arrest. Not one person has been wrongfully identified through the DNA database. No private information has been revealed. There have been zero instances of misuse or there's been zero breaches of information. There are grave penalties for misusing the system. If someone were to even try to misuse the system, they could go to jail for two years and have a $250,000 fine. There's never been a misuse of the system. So arrestee DNA has done no harm to anyone, but harm has been done when arrestee DNA has not been used. I testified before the Nevada State Legislature in 2007 and asked that they pass a law to have DNA taken for all felony arrests. That law was not put into effect. That was in 2007. In 2009, Brianna Denison was murdered. We can look back now and say that if that law had passed in 2007, James Bela, who raped two women previously to Brianna, would have been identified because the DNA evidence from those rapes was in CODIS, and he was arrested for assault with a deadly weapon. That match could have been made, he could have been identified, and Brianna would still be alive. Bridget's mother went back with me to the Nevada State Legislature and they did pass an arrestee DNA law, taking DNA from all felony arrests. That law is called Brianna's Law, but I can tell you Bridget would much rather have her daughter than a law in her memory. In Virginia, Morgan Harrington was murdered in 2009. Her murderer would have been identified previously if Virginia had a law that took DNA from all felony arrests. Because Jesse Matthew raped a woman in 2005, there was DNA evidence in CODIS, and he was arrested in 2009 for attempted grand larceny. But that charge was not covered by the Virginia law, so he was not identified. And in late 2009, he raped and murdered Morgan Harrington. And then in September of 2013, he went on to rape and murder Hannah Graham. Thank you. Remember these names. These are Chester Turner's victims. These are the women that could have been spared. and I can tell you that in the months and years to come in the states that do not utilize DNA upon felony arrest there will be a list like this and we'll know their names and we'll know their faces we'll know who they are and their mothers and their fathers and all those who love them we'll know who they are and they will also know that their lives could have been spared I'm not asking for your sympathy I'm not asking you to tell me you're sorry for my loss I'm asking you to take action I'm asking you to do what you can do to protect the lives of beautiful daughters everywhere so that their families will not have to live with only memories so I'm asking you that you please vote to pass this bill because it matters
▶ Play
thank you thank you for your testimony are there any questions from the committee Representative Petty you recognize
▶ Play
Speaker 73 35:34
thank you Mr. Chairman do pass please
▶ Play
I'm going to I'm going to hold off on recognizing that motion. I believe Representative Bennett has an amendment that she wants us to consider. And then we've also got some individuals signed up to
▶ Play
speak on the bill. Thank you, Representative Petty. Thank you, Chairman. The amendment that I addressed with you earlier has been received, and is it up on the screen? If I can, I'll just read it to you. It essentially, on the bottom of the first page where it says takes a DNA sample of a person, it now adds who is 18 years' age or older, arrested for any felony offense. And then, however, if the person is a minor, like I said, it goes back to the same law before. What I failed to tell you before is that we did add residential burglary in the case of a minor, so that would be added. I said it went right back to the old law. I misspoke. We actually did add residential burglary, and I would appreciate that we could pass the amendment. Okay. Any questions on the amendment? Are
▶ Play
you making a motion to adopt the amendment? Please, yes. Please adopt the
▶ Play
amendment. Okay. We have a
▶ Play
motion to adopt. Is this amendment number one? We don't have an amendment, it's just amendment. Okay. We have a motion from Representative
▶ Play
Bennett to adopt the amendment. Question. Okay. What's your question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. If you don't mind kind of explaining what the purpose of the amendment is, we're kind of looking across the table, and we're not sure if we don't like the bill better without the amendment than with the amendment. So if you don't mind explaining what the purpose and intent was of the amendment, that would be great.
▶ Play
Quite frankly, I'm personally okay with it with or without the amendment. There has been some concern that juveniles' rights may be infringed, that the parents may not be there to give them permission, that we swab a juvenile and it's in there for the rest of their lives. You know, some of my response to that is that, you know, I like the fact that you can eliminate this record at any time if you're not convicted for something. I don't know if there's someone here that wants to speak for the amendment, possibly. I'm certainly not being a great
▶ Play
advocate for it. Well, I've already recognized the motion for the amendment, to adopt the amendment. Is there any discussion on the amendment?
▶ Play
Representative Tosh, for what purpose? A question concerning the amendment.
▶ Play
I'll give some leeway because we can have discussion on the adoption of the amendment, and so I'll give some leeway. If you have a question,
▶ Play
you may ask the question. I agree with Representative Ballinger. My concern is, and just make sure I understand, if they, what I understand, if they're a minor, and I know you're trying to protect minors, but if they committed a crime and they're going to be tried as an adult, shouldn't
▶ Play
they also have to submit to the DNA testing? Thank you for the question. And, you know, I think Arkansas has been acting under the current law where it included murder, kidnapping, rape, sexual assault. We're adding residential burglary to this. I think one of the concerns is that, you know, we're adding hot checks in here. I mean, if it's a felony hot check, you're going to get a DNA swab. that there may be some things that kids would engage in that we would not want them to have their DNA in the system. You know, the flip of that is that DNA doesn't really do anything. It's, you know, and when I talked about the fingerprints earlier, one of the things we were concerned about is that people create, they get a record out there and then they go to get a job, and when you pull a background check you get that they've been arrested, well, DNA does nothing to that. It only comes into play if there's ever a hit for a match. Representative House, did you have a question?
▶ Play
I think so. I'm trying to find the logic. If a 17-, 16-, 15-year-old is arrested for aggravated battery or battery in the first, which is a very violent crime, you shoot and hit somebody, but you don't kill them, I'm trying to justify why, and this is my question part, why would you not want a DNA test among those circumstances if they are arrested for a felony? That seems a reasonable demarcation at this point, so I would appreciate your thoughts.
▶ Play
Thank you. If you could indulge me one second. I guess one response to this would be that you could get a court order to DNA test anyone. I mean, for a hot check or running a traffic stop, if you had probable cause to DNA test them, this is creating an automatic everyone who goes in is getting tested.
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. One thing I guess we need to find out here is, did you tell somebody that you had amended here on the House end to include that? Because if that's the case, then we just ought to take your amendment and pass it if you've told someone else you're going to do it. But if not, and the will of the committee is to pass this without the amendment, I mean, my intent would be that we deny the motion, we vote against the motion to amend, and that we would then vote on the bill without it. But if you told somebody that you had amended at this end, And then I'd say that, you know, there's probably not much room
▶ Play
for us to discuss this motion. I've made no promises to anyone, like, to get their support. However, I have been telling the people that this was an amendment that had been suggested and we were going to incorporate it into the bill. But I haven't, like, without this amendment, I don't know that we have a better chance of passing the bill or not passing the bill. I do think that there is, you know, somewhat of a concern if a kid's picked up for truancy or picked up, of course, I guess truancy wouldn't
▶ Play
be a felony, but. Representative Whitaker. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is related to the whole amendment and including different handling of minors. But it also ripples over into the rest of the bill. I'm reading this, and it's my impression, though not confirmed by anything in the bill, that this would only apply in those cases where the juvenile was being processed as an adult in a criminal court rather than in a juvenile delinquency proceeding.
▶ Play
As usual, your brilliance saved me here. I think that is exactly the purpose of the amendment is that there is nothing in here that limits it to adult processes. So that juvenile court, which operates very differently, that I think that was one of the concerns is that we would be collecting anything for any juvenile charge that could be a
▶ Play
felony. If I may follow up quickly. Yeah, because I'm worried, too, because if it does reach into the juvenile court system and children that were not planning on running through the adult system, the method of getting rid of the sample, of removing the sample, doesn't include any language that suggests a juvenile proceeding and they had reached the age of 18 and the juvenile court had relinquished jurisdiction because they felt like the once delinquent child is now reformed. There's nothing in there. Because you're not going to have any of these documents that you're listed if you came out of the juvenile system. Thank you.
▶ Play
I think that's, thank you so much for that question. I think that is the purpose of this amendment, is to avoid having this carry over into the juvenile justice system, which operates very differently from the adult system, and this would greatly increase the complication. There's nothing to say two years from now when we have more evidence about how this works that we couldn't modify this law, but I think this is such a critical law that we need to enact now to provide as broad a protection as we can, And if there is a legal concern about getting into the juvenile justice system, I would really appreciate if you would
▶ Play
pass the amendment. Representative Drown, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First of all, I think this is a good bill. I have extensive experience in this very field. My question is, and I'm not a lawyer, but in juvenile court or when a juvenile is involved in a crime it seems to me that the courts go through great to the greatest extent possible to keep the name of the juvenile out of the public eye so based on your presentation there's never a name of a juvenile put into the national database it's always an ID number so therefore if the juvenile committed another crime at some point in his life it would all it would whether he is beyond the age of 18 or still considered a minor it will only ping the ID number and as to where to go and find the information on that person correct so that's that so what would be the issue on the whole juvenile side of it when their name is never involved in the process once their DNA is swabbed. Mr. Chair,
▶ Play
if you would indulge me, Jeff Rosenzweig and I had a discussion about this earlier, and I would ask if he could explain some of this. I think it may help the committee on the deliberation of the amendment.
▶ Play
I'll allow it, Mr. Rosenzweig, if you'll state your name
▶ Play
Speaker 116 47:51
and answer the question. Is this on Arkansas Association of Criminal Defense
▶ Play
Speaker 118 47:56
Lawyers. And I do appreciate Representative Bennett. She and I have had several productive talks about this bill, and we've made some suggestions, some of which haven't been taken. One of the suggestions, which was spearheaded by a lawyer other than me, was to deal with the juveniles in a different way. And as Representative Bennett said, this is something that can be fixed. Now, with regard to it, they put an ID number. Obviously, there has to be a name associated with the ID number, so if there's a hit, then that can be accessed to that ID number is John Smith, you know, whatever. At that point, what they're supposed to do then is take another confirmatory sample, and they won't rely solely on that, but that's a way of finding it. I had signed up to speak against a portion of this
▶ Play
Speaker 120 49:00
bill. Do you want me to go ahead and express our concern now? Let's hold up
▶ Play
on that. Let's just deal with the amendment
▶ Play
right now. I don't know if that answers everyone's questions, but I really think, given the complexity of the way it affects juveniles at this time, my recommendation would be that we pass the amendment and that if we need to come back two years from now, this is still going to catch such a broader net than we're catching now. There could always be a court order to take a sample from a juvenile at any time.
▶ Play
All right, any other discussion? the motion is to adopt the amendment all in favor say aye aye any opposed no rule that the no's have it the amendment is not adopted so now we're and I
▶ Play
would move do pass well I guess we need to have discussion on the bill
▶ Play
sorry we've you've already made your presentation on the bill we've got a couple people signed up Jeff Rosenzweig has signed up to speak against the bill. We have, and of
▶ Play
Speaker 118 50:13
course, a lady from New Mexico has made a very powerful presentation, but there are a couple of concerns that we have. One is we think this may run the risks of a lot of bogus arrests. There are two ways people get arrested, with a warrant and without a warrant. Now, if a person is arrested without a warrant, then within a certain period of time, the arresting agency has to submit an affidavit to the presiding judge saying, here's our probable cause to arrest, and the judge looks at it and whatever. If we allow DNA to be taken before any magistrate has any look-see at any facts, what you will almost certainly run into, in our opinion, the defense lawyer's opinion, I mean, you'll see a lot of people just sort of jacked up by the side of the road for no reason at all to get their DNA, and then the charges are dropped or they fall away a year later. I think it's subject to a lot of abuse, and I think it can be fixed just by saying if it's a warrantless arrest, you take the DNA after the judge has made the probable cause finding, which is not a real adversary proceeding. He just looks at the affidavit and says, you know, sees whatever it says and approves it 99 percent of the time. The other issue here is, and this is something Representative Ben and I are talking about, this doesn't solve the exoneration of the innocent problem, and she and I are discussing a separate bill that hopefully will resolve some of that problem, and it deals with defendants' access to results. for alternative suspects, things like that. Representative Tosh, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
You know, I guess it behooves me that every time there's a law that somehow relates to law enforcement, that the integrity of law enforcement is always placed on the line. I'd just like for you to give me an example as a former law enforcement officer of how law enforcement in some way could manipulate this law to infringe upon someone's civil rights. Okay. Well,
▶ Play
Speaker 118 52:38
sir, I'm not accusing you of having done anything, of course, but there are a lot of people out there. You have a lot of auxiliary people, part-time people, all sorts of people who decide, I think so-and-so is good for this particular offense. I don't have any basis. I don't have any evidence. I just think he's good. He looks guilty or whatever. So it's possible just to say, you know, we do a warrantless arrest for theft of property, take his DNA, then send him on. And they've got his DNA there, you know, for a year. I think the exclusionary rule, for instance, is a break that's adopted by the U.S. Supreme Court that is a break on law enforcement. It says if you mess up and it's not in good faith, the search will be thrown out, et cetera. And that doesn't mean the Supreme Court doesn't think most law enforcement officers are good. But, I mean, there are protections in the Constitution that are there for a reason. And we suggest that at least having a judge fined either before the arrest with a warrant or after the arrest with what is called a Gerstein determination find that there was probable cause for the arrest.
▶ Play
That's all we're saying. All right. I see no further questions for Mr. Rosenzweig. Next, we have no one signed up to speak for the bill. House, let's see, we have Paul Calvert signed up to speak against the bill. Mr. Calvert, if you'd have a seat at the end of the table, state your name and who you represent. You may make your statement.
▶ Play
My name is Paul Calvert. I'm from Faulkner County. I'm here on my own behalf, specifically on this issue. My concerns are in regard to the Fourth Amendment and also Article II, Section 15 of the Arkansas Constitution. One of the things about your Fourth Amendment rights, or your right not to be searched, is that one of the requirements is that it be supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, or the persons or things to be seized. I think when it's just a general felony, there are some things where a DNA sample is entirely irrelevant to the case. And so if someone's being charged with a hot check that's a felony level, their DNA is not relevant. And so I don't think it should be legal to take it when there's no relevance to the case. If it's a rape case, obviously I think that's pretty relevant. But when it's something of nature, maybe theft, or maybe even a case of theft, because sometimes people cut themselves when they're stealing something, so that could be relevant there. But hot checks, it's just not relevant, I don't think. And so I think it needs to be specific and needs to be a specific justification for it. And that's my concern
▶ Play
here. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question, Paul, would be in the case of making arrests, we've already decided that this person, we're not going to allow them to move freely anymore, so we've now detained them. We've also decided that we're going to search their person to verify that there's not any weapons. We're also going to find a lot of different ways to identify them, including a fingerprint, looking at their driver's license to collect all sorts of different information on this person who we've already basically a lot of their natural and able rights, we've said in order to protect safety and protect other people's rights, we're going to curtail those. And in this case, all we're doing is just taking a sample of their DNA for identification purposes. And don't you see that that's basically analogous to all the other ways that we're identifying a person?
▶ Play
No. Okay. No, because it's not relevant to the case itself. I don't think you've already got him in custody. He's not going anywhere. If it's determined that he's not guilty, then it's no problem. But the thing is, though, it's still not relevant to the case. And so if he's a rapist, it would be. But the DNA, that extra level of identification, is not necessary, I don't believe. Is their fingerprint relevant if it's a hot check? It could be because you often collect fingerprints on the checks themselves when you take it and deposit it.
▶ Play
All right, no further questions. Representative Tosh, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would you agree or disagree with me that this bill, that it allows for our judicial system to make sure that the right person is brought to justice, would you agree or disagree with me that that should be the objective of our judicial system and this is only a step in the right direction?
▶ Play
No, I don't believe so. I think it steps away from that, at least in part, if it's being required for cases where it's not relevant, if that makes any sense. I think in some cases it could be, But I think most of those are already there anyway for rape cases or maybe murder cases where the DNA would be relevant and specifically indicated by the crime itself.
▶ Play
Representative Tosh, do you have a follow-up? Yes, sir, I do. Mr. Chair, thank you. Again, is it not our objective that your judicial system makes sure that the right person is brought to
▶ Play
justice? yes or no. Absolutely. Any other questions? Thank you, Mr. Calvert. Thank you. No one else has signed up. Representative Petty, are you closed for your bill? Bennett. Sorry, I've got somebody telling me Petty has a motion, Bennett's at the end of the table. My bad. Representative Bennett, are you closed for your
▶ Play
bill? Yes, Mr. Chair, I would just like to say that, you know, I think in this case you said that your daughter loves you like a freight train. I think you've loved her like a nuclear rocket. I mean, this is a good bill, and I would recommend to do
▶ Play
pass, please. Okay. Representative Bennett moves to do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? the bill passes. We're passing over House Bill 1371, passing over House Bill 1374. Representative Overby is not here. We're passing over House Bill 1400. We're going to pass over House Bill 1403, House Bill 1432, Representative Wardlaw.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. House Bill 1432 is a very simple bill. I think it's been a little misunderstood by a few people, but what it does is allow concealed carrying and a pole in place. And the misconception part of this bill is that people think it's going to allow it in schools and colleges and courthouses, and that's just not true. There's other bills out there that do that, but this one's not that one. What this one does is it allows it into like a country store where people go in, eat their dinner every day, and carry their gun. And on voting day, they're not allowed to do that. So with this bill, it will allow that. It also allows churches that allow concealed carry to allow concealed carry on voting day. And with that presentation, I'll answer any
▶ Play
questions. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Armstrong,
▶ Play
you're recognized for question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. With all due respect, Representative Ward-Long, has there been an outcry in polling places or churches for our good country brethren to carry their handguns if they so choose? Has this been brought to you by people that have said we have to have this? This bill actually came to me
▶ Play
from a pastor of a large church in my district who feels it's necessary for him to have his gun with him on voting day. That's exactly where this bill came from. Can I
▶ Play
have a follow-up, Mr. Chair? Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Wardlaw. Number two question. A number of instances criminal-related in polling places or churches over the last 10 years in polling places during election season that have deemed necessary that we now need to have the opportunity to carry handguns in while we're casting votes for great representatives like yourself
▶ Play
and me. I don't want to comment on something that I don't know the exact stats on so
▶ Play
Speaker 111 1:01:57
I'll be glad to let you look that up
▶ Play
well thanks for bringing the bill before us thanks Mr. Chairman Representative Wardlaw basically this bill just strikes the polling place as being a specifically excluded area the character of the location otherwise may exclude it for example if the church determine that they don't allow people to carry, or if a private business determined that they don't allow concealed carry, or if it's a courthouse or a school or one of the other excluded areas. Is that correct? I'm glad
▶ Play
you brought that up. The list of places that you cannot carry is still in the concealed handgun list, and courthouses is in that list. And that's what's been so confusing to me is why the counties are against this bill for that reason. We did not take that out of the list and churches that do not allow concealed carry to the current law have to have a sign that says you cannot carry here well obviously if they don't allow it you're not going to be able to carry it on a polling day so it does not do anything to any place that you cannot carry a gun every day anyway so if you can carry a gun there every day and you vote there on that one day you're just going to be allowed to carry that one day also representative bennett you're recognized for a question um would this allow uh people working at the polls to carry a concealed carry and if so you know that gives me a little bit of pause that they're walking around helping people vote and if people knew that they you know felt strongly about an issue or something i don't could you address that I think it would allow them to carry it if they're in a place that they could carry it. But if they're in a courthouse, absolutely not. And if they're in a college, absolutely not. Or if they're in a church that doesn't allow it, absolutely not. Once again, it only allows them to carry it in a place that they could carry it every day anyway. So, I mean, we're not taking poll workers out of this. I mean, if they have a kit seal gun permit and they want to carry it and they're in a country store that allows it, absolutely. Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I'm evidently just showing my ignorance. But if it doesn't affect regular places that exclude carrying a gun anyway, as you said, like in a courthouse, something of that nature, I'm just, I guess, trying to understand what it does apply to. You're saying there's a lot of polling places and country stores and things of that nature? In my district, and actually a town next to me, they vote in
▶ Play
a country store where a lot of folks gather for lunch. Those people have came to me and complained that they can't go there and eat that day because they can't carry their guns, so they don't go. And, I mean, a lot of folks in public say they want to take their gun off. Well, it's their right and their ability to keep their gun on. The pastor that brought this to me is very adamant about carrying his gun everywhere he goes, And the day of voting, he cannot carry his gun around in his church because they're voting in his church. So, yeah, that's where this bill came from, and that's the reason I'm
▶ Play
running it. Okay, thank you. That clarifies it
▶ Play
for me. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
So just clear this up for me, Representative Warlaw. Your constituents said they don't want to go and eat if they can't carry their gun, so no
▶ Play
Speaker 125 1:05:29
gun, no food. Got some that believe that way. Okay.
▶ Play
Okay. Would you be in any way interested in making this optional versus mandated? No. All right. Thanks very much,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
I guess my question is, isn't this optional? So if someone wanted to post and say no carrying, they can't. So it is optional. Any location that doesn't want someone to carry a gun, that just posts, right? That's
▶ Play
what makes sure there ain't no thunderclouds up there when you
▶ Play
and I agree, but I would say yes. Follow-up question. What's wrong with our relationship that you didn't ask me to co-sponsor this bill? Well, I
▶ Play
guess you wasn't around the day I walked around. If you want to do that, we can amend it
▶ Play
in the Senate with your name on it. All right. I see no further questions. Representative Scott.
▶ Play
Quick one. Okay. Sure. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We recognize your question. Before you leave out of here today, I'd like the name of that restaurant. If they're carrying guns and fighting over that food, I might need to eat there sometimes. My concern about this bill, Representative Wardlaw, is do you think this would deter churches who have had polling places for years from wanting to do this? Do you think this would cut down on our good polling places? I don't. I think
▶ Play
that you may see some signs go up where they don't want carrying in those churches if they're polling there now. But I don't see how it could deter it. I mean, really and truly, I mean, it shouldn't be a problem. These people carry their guns every day anyway without problems. I don't see where the problem is going to be for that one second or 20 minutes they walk in to vote. So absolutely not. And my grandfather used to own that restaurant, by the way. All
▶ Play
right. Moving to the public comment, Lindsay Bailey is recognized to speak against the bill. If you would, state your name and who you represent, and then you may speak against the bill. Thank you, Chair. Good morning, Committee. My name is Lindsay Bailey.
▶ Play
I'm with the Association of Arkansas Counties and specifically representing the County Clerks Association, who unfortunately none of them could make it here today to represent themselves. I'd like to make a couple of brief points. As you've seen on this bill, all it does is strike out three words, any polling places. The section of law, section 573.306, lists 19 different types of buildings in which a person is exempt from carrying their concealed weapon, a polling place being one of those. There are several other exemptions, some schools, specifically public schools on campus, capital courthouse, well, right now a courthouse, that you can't carry. And Representative Wardlaw is correct. You still would not legally be able to carry into a polling place that was a courthouse or a public school campus or things like that. However, we have polling places. I'm not sure if Representative Wardlaw did this research about polling places in counties statewide, but when I saw this bill running, I certainly did, and our county clerks certainly have. There are places such as fire departments, town halls, community centers, private businesses, and off-campus school administration buildings that it is not clear that you would not be able to carry weapons in here. Also, there is nothing in this law or anywhere else in the law that says all you would have to do is put a sign out front to trump what Arkansas code says you can carry. At the minimum, this would cause confusion. It would cause anger in people who came to vote who carried, and then when they got there were told not to. As you all know, since you ran to be here in the positions you're in today, These races can be, for lack of a better word, volatile sometimes. People are passionate and heated, and especially with our county clerks, we have people show up all the time who get so frustrated about the smallest things, being asked to show an ID, people who probably don't necessarily need to be having a gun on their hip at that time. um another point i would like to make is both federal law and state law currently have voting rights acts one major part of that voting rights act is that no voter can be intimidated or threatened with intimidation when they come to vote this would allow anyone in a polling place including not only poll workers, but poll watchers who are actually working for a candidate to stand in a polling place armed, and even if they didn't threaten someone, if someone was perceived that they were threatened, that would be a deterrent to someone's voting rights and to them voting free of fear. speaking of those poll workers you may already know that it's fairly difficult to find people to work your polls most people who work these polls are retired folks or other volunteers who are there on their own goodwill in their own free time if this is a deterrent to any of those poll workers i think that one day of not eating lunch at the country store is not worth that again along the same lines pulling places are hard to get and I'm going to disagree with Representative Wardlaw here I think there are several places I think there are several school administration buildings, I think there are community centers, I think there are town halls I think there are several churches who if this law went into place would pull out and not allow their place to be used as a pulling place um that brings up one hurdle for the county clerks that i wish they could be here to speak about and that's the process that is required under arkansas code section dash 5 dash 101 of what they have to do when a polling place is changed the notification requirements um how many days you have to wait you have to run it in a paper it's a very extensive process when a polling place has changed, and I can tell you definitely that there will be places that will pull out if this bill passes. That's pretty much all the points I have to make. I would just like to say that there were numerous county clerks that wanted to be here to speak about this bill who know more about this than I do, and I apologize that none of them could make it. And I would urge you to respect their office and respect the jobs that they do and maybe hold off until they have the opportunity to be here and speak on their own behalf because this won't only affect their jobs on Election Day in the various polling places across the county that they're charged with, but also with this extensive notification process if they have to change polling places.
▶ Play
Thank you for your testimony. I have a question or two. I mean, what I understand Representative Wardlaw's bill does is it strictly eliminates that the polling place as being an area where concealed carry cannot occur. And so by deleting that, then the normal character of the property would control. So if it's the meeting place of the governing body of a governmental entity, it's excluded. If it's a courthouse, it's excluded. If it's a public school, it's excluded. If it's a business or establishment or under subsection 19, the entity exercising control has already excluded the carrying, it's excluded. So I'm not sure. I guess I just don't follow the examples that you gave. A fire department, it seems that that would fall under section 19. If the fire department is already precluding the carrying of concealed carry, then it would already be excluded. or alternatively if this bill were enacted they would have the opportunity it may in fact cause them to make a determination not to allow concealed carry. So I guess I just don't follow on the several examples that you gave as to where this really has any impact. I mean basically that location is going to be treated as it would be the other 364 days out of the
▶ Play
year. Thank you, Chair. In my opinion, not all of these places are as clear in the law as a courthouse, as a public school campus. Some of these places have never had to come up with concealed carry policies before. This is nothing they've considered. I would specifically like to point to the example of a church, though, because churches are probably the majority of polling places around the state. And back in 2013, the law concerning carrying in a church was changed, and it was changed. The law currently still exempts churches from concealed carry. You still can't concealed carry in a church, except, however, it says this does not preclude a church or other place of worship from determining who may carry a concealed handgun into the church or other place of worship. Most of these churches don't just have a, hey, everyone who comes in here with a concealed carry can carry. The pastor may carry, as in Representative Wardlaw's example, they may have two or three people in the congregation that they have said that can carry, but no one else can. This is at the very least confusing to people who come to vote. And when people come to vote expecting to be able to carry and then they can't, there will be altercations and our clerks will be put in a place where I don't believe they should be. They don't feel they should be. All they want is the right to make this optional for
▶ Play
them. And I appreciate your comments. And I guess that's kind of my point is that if a church has not passed a policy allowing specific individuals, or even if it has, many churches have determined that they're only going to allow certain people, then that means if a voter going to vote on that day, they're not allowed to carry. And so with regard to the issue of altercations, in order for someone to have a concealed carry license, there's training that goes along with it. And so they're educated on what they can and can't do. So I appreciate the comments. I just wanted to make sure that I was following along with where you were going with your testimony. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair, and I think you pretty much covered it, but I just would kind of like to have her opinion. In Section 19 that the Chair referenced, it says very clearly that any place that the sign is posted, So it just has to have a sign that says carrying a handgun is prohibited. So what, I mean, you've expressed all these concerns, but to me it sounds like, you know, taking an 8x10 sheet of paper and writing a handgun, carrying a handgun is prohibited, sticking it on the wall near the door, you're done. I mean, that's honestly the, it seems like it's a fairly simple process, and I don't understand really the confusion that would be with it.
▶ Play
if every place took the measures to do that you may think that there shouldn't be any confusion and I may think there shouldn't be any confusion but that doesn't mean that when someone shows up there to vote that day with their concealed carry they're not going to say I read the paper I saw this on the news and I can carry my handgun into a polling place again these are my concerns as an attorney and for the counties. The clerks have their own concerns that I cannot express to you in a way that they would be able to if we were able to have this discussion when some of them were here. I think if something affected the job that you all do every day, you would like to have the opportunity to be able to speak on your own
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:18:56
behalf. Representative Breshing, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think that you've pretty much covered it when you addressed these issues. I just wanted to make sure that we all know we're talking about a concealed carry and that there is a background check and there are obligations that go along with carrying a concealed carry. And so we're not talking about just, in this particular, we're not talking about open carry or anything like that. So I guess what I'm saying is I don't understand how it becomes a threat to have your concealed carry inside a polling place that you may be threatened because, you know, if I'm walking down the road and I have my gun on, I mean, how many people know that I have my gun on? I mean, am I a threat by doing that? I mean, I guess that's my question is, why would it be a problem if we've already gone through the concealed carry background?
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative. There are people in this state, and in fact, there is at least one attorney general opinion done in recent years that says the current law could be interpreted to say that Arkansas has open carry. There are probably people in this room that are of that
▶ Play
thought. Recognize for follow-up. Follow-up. But this says concealed carry. Does it not? It doesn't refer to any of the other act. This one particularly addresses concealed carry. Yes, Representative.
▶ Play
I if I may comment chair I I think one part of this that is being perhaps minimized is that polling places aren't going to pull out these some of these communities the only places they have that are large enough for these people to go to and vote that is close to them is uh are these churches and some of these churches will pull out. I promise you
▶ Play
that. Representative Drown, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Addressing
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:21:25
this, I'll just ask you a question because this morning I happened to be, of course, reading the news before I came here this morning and Arizona is running into the same kind of roadblocks that you're presenting here today their answer was and I know the answer to this from you but their answer was passing through their house bill 2320 that if you would not allow people to carry concealed handguns in these areas that you would be or the counties or the state would be required to set up metal detectors therefore to make sure that everybody is on a level playing field so the question today is would you rather allow people who have gone through background checks who have spent their own money getting a concealed carry permit, something that nobody knows they have on their person, or would the counties, rather, at some point in the future, possibly, if we chose to follow Arizona's lead to protect the people of this state, require that all polling places, regardless of where they are, have metal detectors at
▶ Play
the entrance to the doors? uh that is i appreciate your question representative and i wish i could answer it um unfortunately that's not in the bill before me today and i can't speak on behalf of what the clerks would respond to that i again that's a question that i would love for them to be here sitting next to me to be able to answer that um but i can't speak on
▶ Play
behalf of them for that Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question Thank you, Mr. Chair You know, voter ID laws that were passed in the last session were struck down as being unconstitutional They deterred, made it harder for our citizens to vote It seems that this measure would actually make it easier for citizens to vote In my opinion, that would actually be what the clerks would want more participation in voting is that not correct i
▶ Play
don't see how being allowed to carry your gun would encourage voter participation it
▶ Play
would encourage excuse follow-up mr chair it would encourage participation with those who carry a handgun because first of all if that handgun is not concealed that person is breaking the law therefore all of the other citizens at the polling place would not know that that person was carrying a handgun this would in fact increase voter turnout. Do you not
▶ Play
agree? I can't say that I have the information or any instances where this has caused increased or decreased voter turnout. I'm not, the counties and the county clerks are not against the idea of people being able to concealed carry into polling places. They would just like for it to be done in a controlled way, done with deference to them where they can be involved in the process of how it's done, how it's regulated, how we can put in some restrictions so poll watchers aren't sitting there armed and possibly intimidating people. That would be against the law. Thank you. Representative Armstrong, you
▶ Play
recognize for a question. Representative Wardlaw,
▶ Play
I would just like to ask if you've really taken pause to understand the Pandora's box that you may be opening, I heard Representative Michelle Grace mention that we struck down the voter ID law, and there's a remarkable movie out right now called Selma that relates to, and I don't usually draw the race line, and I love the South, but when African Americans were entitled to recite the Constitution and name their county judges, and now you're simply saying, Representative Gray, that this would encourage voting in small towns like Warren, Arkansas, or any small town in our great state representative ward law where neighbors know neighbors they attend church they run up and down the streets with each other you share tomatoes with them they know each other they're close to comfort more than anywhere else in our great state wouldn't you think that this law would open up pandora's box to once again intimidating now blacks that don't have to recite the constitution don't have to know their county judges but now if they knew maybe you as a neighbor and me and you had a difference and we're friends and our differences spilled over into an election and I do not carry guns because that's just my deal and you do, I'm now intimidated to maybe go in and cast my vote because a poll worker that's not making me recite the Constitution is now saying because the law has passed that they can carry, even with the options or the exclusions that our chair has raised, it still has an impact of creating some intimidation with poll workers or voters that go into these polling stations. And I guess my question is, with all due respect to you and the constituent that brought it to you, why in the world do we need this when there isn't a problem in our polling places currently, even with the signs that may be posted as Representative Ballinger has raised that says you are prohibited to carry your gun in here. You wouldn't know if they had it or not because it's a concealed weapon. but it still could create this intimidation factor in most of our small towns and communities, Representative Gray, and I just wanted to make certain that you would understand that and tell me exactly why, again, this is needed when we've got such heightened racial strife across our country, and especially in the South sometimes, and I hate going there, but it's the truth of the matter, and I just think we're going down a slippery slope with creating legislation like this. Could you please answer the question on why this is
▶ Play
actually needed? Hold on just a second. Ms. Bailey, I think we've concluded our time with you, so you're excused. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 46 1:27:14
you. Thank you. Representative Wardlaw, you can respond to the question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess I'll start this out with all due respect, because this is going to sound like a really smart-aleck answer. But do we have to wait until we have a murder in a polling place, or do we have to wait until we have this huge problem? I mean, that would be my answer to that question. Mr. Chair, can I follow up? You can
▶ Play
Speaker 199 1:27:42
follow up. Thank you. We don't have to wait. There have been countless murders, people hosed down and bitten by dogs, people killed on bridges and streets, people prohibited to go into polling stations across small towns across this country, and especially in the south. This weekend, I'll be traveling to Southern Alabama to celebrate the 50th anniversary of a time in which murders did happen that prevented people from going to the polling stations.
▶ Play
representative Wardlaw, and I'm just afraid, with all due respect, and you are my friend, that we're going down a slippery slope of opening this box on something that I truly don't think we need. That's already happened in our history books. It's proven. I respect
▶ Play
your opinion. Alright, going back to the list, we have one other signed up to speak on this bill, and that is Paul Calvert signed up to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Again, my name is Paul Calvert. I'm from Falker County. I'm here on behalf of Liberty and Justice. I would like to actually bring some clarification here. There was some, the attorney suggested that some of these other public buildings that people, that it would be subject to this permission to carry, but they're not. If it's publicly funded, it's off limits. According to 573-122 in the Arkansas Code, let me read it for you. It is unlawful for any person, and I'll skip some of the exceptions, to knowingly carry or possess a loaded firearm or other deadly weapon in any publicly owned building or facility. That excludes your fire department, your fire stations, your other buildings, your community centers that are publicly funded. those are off limits already. This bill does not affect them. Let's see if there's something else. One neat little point about this is that this law only applies to people who are concealed carry license holders. I don't have a concealed carry license. There is no law that prohibits me from carrying in one of these bold places already as far as I I know. So something to think about. I can carry right now, not here, because it's a prohibited place, but if it's a private business that has a polling place in it, I'm not aware of any law that prohibits me as a non-licensed holder to carry in one of those places. So right now, all we have is prohibited for concealed carry license holders, but not for those of us who do not have them.
▶ Play
And I'll take questions. I see no questions. you. Representative Wardlaw, are you closed for your bill? What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Gray? Motion do pass. We have a motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Bill passes. we're going to pass over house bill 1203 and it's my intention on house bill 1203 to set that for a special order at at some point house bill 1441 represent bain we're going to pass over that. House Bill 1448, represent Broadway. Do you want to run that bill? Okay. You're recognized to present House Bill 1448.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you for a committee. Hopefully these next two bills are going to be much less controversial than the last few that we've done. I have vetted them and I've not come across any resistance to them. Also, these are not bar association bills. These are very basic bills that affect the practice of law for the street lawyer, basically. The first one is basically concerning the limitations period for intentional torts and other purposes. The statute of limitations, for those of you all who may not be lawyers and not sure what that means, is just basically the finite period of time that somebody can file a lawsuit. In discussions, frankly, with my husband, who is also an attorney, we talked about the irony of the fact that someone can have an intentional act committed against them and they only have one year to bring a lawsuit against the person who committed that wrongdoing against them. Whereas if someone unintentionally causes you harm, one has three years. Sometimes I think that's been legitimated by the fact that there's things called the unknown tort feeser. You're not sure who actually, you know, in a hit and run or some circumstance, it may not be readily identifiable as to who committed that tort. But what this bill does is it's honestly pretty simple. It brings consistency to the statute of limitations and basically says that if someone has committed an intentional tort against you, that you have the same amount of time which is three years as someone who unintentionally wronged you that's what the bill is it does not affect any other statutes of limitation like medical or professional malpractice or anything else that's specifically enumerated in the statute contracts anything like that it applies to intentional torts and that's my bill
▶ Play
representative broadway a couple questions it basically takes the statute from one year to three years, is that correct? That's correct, yes, sir. And then it doesn't go into effect until January of 2016? There's no emergency clause. What would be the application for, say, let's say an intentional tort was committed a year ago today. The statute by law now expires today. So I'm precluded for the next until the end of the year to file that suit. Would I then have the ability to file later? I mean, what's your understanding of how that would
▶ Play
apply to those types of situations? My understanding would be is when the act was committed, the law that was in, what am I trying to say? The current law at the time that the tort was committed would be controlling. So this would basically be applied to all acts occurred after this act takes
▶ Play
effect. Okay. And there's nothing in this that shortens any time period. It only expands the time period. That's correct. Okay, thank you. All right, I see no questions. No one has signed up. Representative Broadway, are you closed for your bill? I am, and with
▶ Play
that, I would ask for a due pass, please. Okay,
▶ Play
we have a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? You've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are you going to present 1449? I think so, yes. Thank you. Okay.
▶ Play
If I can have one sec to pull it up. This is also pretty short and straightforward, I hope. Again, for individuals who are not engaged in the practice of the law on a daily basis, there are two ways, basically, to probate an estate. One of them is a lengthy process when there are considerable assets in an estate. When an estate is smaller and assets are less than $50,000, there is a shortened process called filing an affidavit for collection of small estate. This is what that law or what this statute affects. Right now, an attorney is required to, there are two things. When you file an affidavit for collection of a small estate, you file an affidavit with the clerk's office. But also, in both processes, one must print notice in the newspaper that an estate has been opened, and so it makes creditors aware that there may be assets to collect in the estate and allows them to file a claim. um in this situation or in in a large probated estate uh that involves significant assets you print that notice in the newspaper but you're not required to put in a legal description of any real estate that may be in the estate and there could be tons of it and so you don't have to do that however when you go through the small estate process you have to publish in the newspaper a legal description of all real property, real estate. And basically, what that does is it creates more expense for the client because it's expensive to publish those things in the newspaper. So frankly, this is a cost-saving mechanism. And we just didn't, again, see the consistency of requiring this in a small estate where there's not a lot of assets versus a large estate where there may be numerous assets to collect against, and that's what this bill is. All right,
▶ Play
I see no questions. Nope. Representative House, you recognize for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. Representative Broadway, I've got some judgments against people 20 years ago, and I'm just waiting for them to die so I can collect against their real property. I know. And so if you don't publish those properties, how do I know where to go to find out that that estate's got property?
▶ Play
You go look at the affidavit because you have to continue to put it in the affidavit. This does not remove that requirement from the actual document that's filed with the clerk's office. It just doesn't make you have to publish it in the newspaper. Okay. Thank you. Sure. I didn't hear that, Representative Vines.
▶ Play
All right, I see no further questions. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Broadway, are
▶ Play
you closed for your bill? Yes, sir, I'm closed for my bill, and with that,
▶ Play
I would motion do pass, please. Okay, we have a motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye.
▶ Play
Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If
▶ Play
I may be excused. House Bill 1450, we're going to pass over. House Bill 1456, we're going to pass over. House Bill 1457, we're going to pass over. House Bill 1488, we're going to pass over. Representative Ballinger, we're going to pass over. House Bill 1490. Without objection, we're going to go down to House Bill 1614. Representative Collins, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you very much, Mr. Chair and committee members. This is a bill that came to me from a constituent, and the constituent is a labor lawyer. Her name is Eva Madison. She is the daughter of former Senator Sue Madison. So when she first called me, I was frankly a little skeptical, to be honest with you, that it would be an issue that I'd be excited to carry forward. But then after she walked me through it, I said, wow, this really is something that we need to work on here in Arkansas. And basically what this bill does is it helps clarify two things to be consistent with the original intent of the Civil Rights Act of 1993. And the two things that it does is in Section 102 of that code, it defines employer as actually the employer as opposed to people that or individuals that work in that company so that for the purposes of this code, you would take your action against the employer. The second thing that it does is it clarifies that the intentions which are in Code Section 107 for employment actions, things like discrimination, harassment, retaliation, and the penalties associated with those types of actions in an employment situation are confined to Section 107 and the penalties that are there, and the sections from 106 that have to do with hate offenses, which apply outside of the employment situation, apply outside of the employment situation. This act, the changes do absolutely nothing to change any of the classes for hate offenses or any of the penalties associated with those things. It just clarifies that it's the penalties in Section 107, which is right after 106 under Section 2, are the penalties that apply in the case of employment. So that was the legislative intent. Those are angles that have been used. This labor lawyer tells me that have created much different outcomes than were intended in employment situations, and it's creating a lot of burden on Arkansas businesses. And with that, I'd be happy to take questions, Mr. Chair. Any questions?
▶ Play
I see no questions no one has signed up Representative Collins are you closed for your bill yes Mr. Chairman all right what's the pleasure of the committee Representative Beck do pass we have a motion do pass is there any discussion all
▶ Play
in favor say aye any opposed you've passed your bill thank you very much Mr. Chair and committee
▶ Play
greatly appreciate it Senate Bill 58 we're going to pass over Senate Bill 262 Senator Woods Passover House Bill 1505 Is 261 Is that the one You
▶ Play
Speaker 214 1:43:26
don't It's regarding the placement of
▶ Play
a Community Correction Center we'll pass over House Bill 1505 we're going to pass over House Bill 1506 we're going to pass over House Bill 1529 we're passing over House Bill 1530 pass over House Bill 1532 pass over House Bill 1538 Representative Ballinger pass over House Bill 1543 we will pass over House Bill 1544 pass over Representative Armstrong pass over both of yours House Bill 1570 and 1571 we're going to pass over we've already taken up 1573 Senate Bill 57, Senator Woods pass over Senate Bill 261, Senate Bill 472 Senator Hutchinson pass over House Bill 1322 pass over House Bill 1598-1599 we'll come back to Senate Bill 152, Senator Hutchinson pass over House Bill 1624 Representative Meeks pass over House Bill 1625 Representative Tucker pass over House Bill 1626 Representative Lemons pass over House Bill 1628 I'm going to go ahead and run that bill Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Shepard you're recognized welcome
▶ Play
to House Judiciary Thank you with the chairman's permission I'd like for Mark Hayes with Municipal League to be available to testify as well Absolutely Alright Committee House Bill 1628 is a bill that was actually brought to me by Mr. Hayes concerns the Deputy District Court Clerk Employment and Compensation, and basically he can explain it further, but as I understand it, there is some distinction between the actual clerk and the deputy clerks in terms of who employs those individuals, and so there's a distinction between the two, and this law helps to provide that the district judge will ensure compliance by the deputy clerks in following the handbook and protocols that the city or county have in place. And with that, I would turn it over to Mr. Hayes for further comment.
▶ Play
Good morning. My name is Mark Hayes. I'm with the Municipal League. This issue has arisen around the state several places. Representative Lemons has talked to me. Representative Douglas, Charlotte Douglas, has talked to me in several other places. So what's occurring effectively is this, whether it's a city or a county set of employees, it doesn't matter. If you'll think in terms of this side of the table being water clerks and secretaries and that sort of thing, and this side of the table being deputy court clerks, there have been instances where the deputy court clerks who are subject to the handbooks, the policies, protocols of either the county or the city are being allowed to do things differently, leave time, all sorts of other kinds of related employment issues than the folks on this side of the table. So what we have set up on several occasions have been fairly substantial equal protection lawsuits, and the judicial branch, of course, isn't responsible for those. It will either be the city or the county who has to pay the judgment. So I've actually talked to the district judges about this, and they concur that it needs to be consistent, and the language that's in the bill is actually at their suggestion, which effectively says that the employer, either the city or the county, whomever that may be, can take a direct disciplinary action against the judge if the judge is not requiring the employees to follow the appropriate employer's policies and handbooks. Originally, we had suggested that the deputy district clerks be hired and managed exclusively by either county judges or mayors. The district judges weren't, shall we say, not inclined to go down that road, and they made a good point. They need to be the ones supervising it since they're responsible under Canon 2 for the management of the courts. So it's really designed to stop a problem that's occurring in several places around the state and some significant liability issues that taxpayers would have to fund. That's the essence of the bill. It literally is just a practical fix, and the judges are all on board with it. I talked to them last Friday, and that was their language, and so it seems like a good fix to the problem. All right, very
▶ Play
well. Representative Bennett, recognize for a question. Mr. Hayes.
▶ Play
Yes, ma'am. You're going to assure me that this in no way changes the payment for the district court operations, are
▶ Play
Speaker 226 1:49:38
you not? But let me assure you and the committee that this bill, nor any of
▶ Play
the other ones currently filed, will have any effect on any compensation or funding issues with regard to the district
▶ Play
court system. Thank you so much. Yes, ma'am. Any other questions from committee? There's no one signed up to speak for or against at this time. Representative Shepard, do you wish to close? I'm closed, and I would move to pass. All right. That is a proper motion. Hearing no further debate, all those in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, Representative Shepard. You've passed House Bill 1628. Are you willing to run House Bill 1629? I would like to.
▶ Play
Thank you. You are recognized. Committee, House Bill 1629 is another bill related to the operations of district court and basically it provides that unless mutually waived, that district courts shall be held in each court at least one time a month. Very well.
▶ Play
I'm sorry. Questions, Representative Armstrong? Yes, Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 233 1:50:56
Shepard. Could you further explain that? I mean, just from non-legal background. Yeah,
▶ Play
district courts hold court, and they have to have it one time a month. It's pretty – they're apparently – I'll let Mr. Hayes
▶ Play
take over. I can explain. I'm still Mark Hayes. Yes, the – here's the problem. In some smaller locations, we have – there are departments of district courts and outlying areas, And in a few instances, some new judges have come in and said, I don't want to drive that 15 or 20 miles, so I want to go every two months or every three months. The problem with that, if you're in a smaller community, is it jams up all sorts of record-keeping issues, reports that have to be filed with the administrative office of the courts. It's just sort of a pain in the neck is what it boils down to for those small departments. So this will say at least do it once a month, more if you like, or if everybody agrees, then that's fine. You can put it off for a month because every now and then dockets just aren't big enough to hold court. That's it. That's
▶ Play
all it's designed to do. And I'll just ask this question. Maybe this will clear it up. Doesn't this prevent someone from getting a traffic ticket,
▶ Play
Speaker 223 1:52:22
having to wait six months to go to court in some instances? Precisely.
▶ Play
Yeah. Representative Bennett. Great, Bill. Just one question. It says that the city or town will agree. Well, a lot of these courts are also handling county tickets. Should we consider adding that the county also has to agree to this change, or would that confuse
▶ Play
the bill? I don't think it's necessary because the courts we're talking about are actually housed by city governments, so that's the reason it's written that way. Yeah.
▶ Play
Any further questions from the committee? Seeing no one has signed up to speak for or against this action Representative Shepard would you like to close I'm closed and I would move do pass As a proper motion hearing no further debate All those in favor signify by saying aye Any opposed no Congratulations Representative Shepard you pass House Bill 1629 All right, we're going to go without objection.
▶ Play
We're going to move to Senate Bill 177. Representative
▶ Play
Saban, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members of the committee, this bill basically corrects an oversight, which I think was embarrassing to everybody involved, unbeknownst to, I think, I guess everybody involved in drafting issue three, which became Amendment 94. Prosecuting attorneys are actually constitutional officers, and so they were meant to be included under the auspices of the Independent Citizens Commission, but they were not. So this bill simply corrects that and acknowledges that they are constitutional officers and should be subject to the same jurisdiction, so to speak. So that's all this bill does. It passed, I think, pretty smoothly through the Senate. And with that, I'd be glad to take any questions.
▶ Play
Representative House, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Save, that means that the Independent Citizens Commission would be setting the salaries of the prosecuting attorneys of the various districts? That's correct. But not the deputy prosecutors? That's correct. Thank you very much,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. All right, I see no further questions. It looks like we've got one, two, three, four. We've got four people signed up. They're waving off. Okay. We did have four prosecutors signed up to speak for the bill. No one has signed up to speak against the bill. Representative Saban, are you closed for your bill? Yes, Mr. Chair, I'm closed. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative House makes a motion to do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Bill passes Thank you Mr. Chair and members of the committee Members if you'll hold on just a second Let me make sure we've completed all of our business For right now Okay
▶ Play
Speaker 111 1:56:04
Members Consistent with what the Speaker has requested for us during this
▶ Play
Session I think our time is about out right here so just continue to be aware that we may have meetings at some odd times so listen for announcements pay attention to your emails we're gonna when things have been passed over three times unless unless you've confirmed I would ask in the future to visit with me and I'll make a determination as to whether we leave it on the regular agenda but from this point forward after three times we're going to move it to the deferred agenda Additionally, those that we leave on the regular agenda, we may drop them to the end of the agenda. We need to run as many bills as possible because our agenda is getting stacked up. And we will, I think it's likely we'll have a couple special orders next week to tend to some bills where either we have witnesses who are traveling in or items that are of particular interest to the public.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:57:08
Without objection, we're adjourned. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB260

0:26 - 5:56 21 segments 7 speakers

HB1573

5:56 - 59:59 135 segments 16 speakers

HB1432

59:59 - 1:31:23 103 segments 16 speakers

HB1448

1:31:23 - 1:35:47 13 segments 2 speakers

HB1049

1:35:47 - 1:39:45 14 segments 3 speakers

HB1614

1:39:45 - 1:45:42 16 segments 3 speakers

HB1628

1:45:42 - 1:50:33 15 segments 5 speakers

HB1629

1:50:33 - 1:53:56 15 segments 7 speakers

SB177

1:53:56 - 1:57:41 9 segments 4 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
73 segments
Senator Jeremy Hutchinson Unverified
4 segments
Representative Mary Broadaway Unverified
19 segments
Speaker 14
1 segment
Speaker 18
6 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 28
1 segment
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
48 segments
Speaker 54
1 segment
Representative Sue Scott Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 63
1 segment
Speaker 67
46 segments
Speaker 73
1 segment
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
6 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
4 segments
Representative David Whitaker Unverified
4 segments
Chair Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 116
1 segment
Speaker 118
10 segments
Speaker 120
1 segment
Paul Calvert Unverified
8 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 111
2 segments
Speaker 125
1 segment
Lindsay Bailey Unverified
25 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
4 segments
Representative R. Trevor Drown Unverified
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 46
1 segment
Speaker 199
1 segment
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 214
1 segment
Representative John T. Vines Chair Unverified
8 segments
Mark Hayes Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 226
1 segment
Speaker 233
1 segment
Speaker 223
1 segment
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
2 segments