House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (8)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1539
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…y. Representative De La Rosa, you are recognized to present House Bill 1539.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1408
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ou're recognized to present your bill. I'm going to present House Bill 1408. This is an act to modify the personnel”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1526
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “House Bill 1526. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. This is another bill from ADE m…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1527
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “call. House Bill 1527 is your next bill. Do I want to press it, Mr. Chair? I want…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1273
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1273”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1372
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1372”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1836
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1836”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB511
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB511”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Also another change, it removes the requirement of the commission to meet at least quarterly. Basically, they'll meet as needed. Some of the meetings currently, when they meet quarterly, they really don't have any business to conduct. But at other times, they need to meet much more often, so it just gives them some flexibility as to when they need to meet. The third change has to do with the federal fund. The current statute refers to federal facilities funds. There's not any, so they're going to strike that language.
And then finally, there's some indication in the current statute that implies that school districts do not have to have an architect and that it might imply that the facilities division would supply the architect, and that's not accurate either. So it just clears up that language. Those are the four changes in this bill. Are there any questions?
Seeing no questions from the committee, are there anyone who would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for that bill? I am closed. What is the will of the committee? Due pass. I have a due pass motion. All those in favor say aye. Anybody opposed? Motion carries and passes. Congratulations, you have passed that bill. Next bill is 1526,
House Bill 1526. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. This is another bill from ADE making some minor changes.
There's three basic changes in this. Currently, under Arkansas law, school districts do an ACCEP plan. They also put that same information in AppScan. There's been some issues periodically where the numbers don't completely match up in those two documents, which creates a little bit of an issue. Basically, at this point in the ACSIP plans, they'll just put a general description of where the funds are going to be spent, but we're going to keep the actual numbers, the budgetary numbers, in APS scan.
Also, the second thing that changes, it requires school districts and schools and school improvement to submit a revised school improvement plan with my plans. Are there any questions on the committee? Does anyone like to speak against the bill? Mr. Nagle, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
How are you so good? Is he speaking for you again? We'll see. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Rich Nagel with the Arkansas Education Association. We think this bill does a lot to eliminate much duplication of records, and I think the important part of this is that the information, especially the information on how NSLA funds are spent
And for what purposes will will still remain so that's good information for us to have so we support this Are there any questions committee Seeing none, thank you sir Is there anybody else would like to speak I'm sorry go ahead represent Walker you recognize
I will take that motion right now. All those in favor. Oh, I'm sorry. Yes, Mr. Nagel. Change is possible, Mr. Chairman. There is. There is hope for y'all. The reps of Walker, I wasn't talking about you. I was talking about Ridge. All right, I have a do pass motion. All those in favor say aye.
call. House Bill 1527 is your next bill. Do I want to press it, Mr. Chair? I want to stop right here. You're recognized.
Speaker 28
4:29
This bill is what I would term a flexibility bill. Currently under Arkansas law in grades
PE is required to be 60 minutes this bill allows flexibility where any of those courses, art, PE, music can be 40 to 60 minutes. The importance of that is that it provides the flexibilities that local school districts need at times as they develop schedules. These are typically what we'd term buddy courses that are offered at the same time. This may be the point in time in which teachers have their prep times, so on and so forth.
It does not require anybody to change the schedule they currently have in Arkansas. Again, it just provides flexibility. Are there any questions? Representative Saban, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gossage, just in terms of providing flexibility, my reading of the
of minutes that can be provided for instruction in these particular areas.
So I guess my question is, does it provide more flexibility or less in terms of the amount of time that these districts can spend in these particular subject areas? I think if you're asking, could they do it over an hour? I'm sure they still could do it over an hour, but I think
the practical matter is nobody does. Representative Deffenbaum, your record. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
is this 40, let's say an art, is it 40 minutes a week or 40 minutes a day? Week. Okay, so they're just required, they're required 40, 40, and 60 right now, is that it? Correct. That is correct. 40 for art, 40 for music, and 60 for PE are currently the minimum levels of performance. So can they go ahead
and actually have more minutes per week in any of these? Oh, yeah. Okay.
Thank you. Are there any other questions from the committee? Does anyone
like to speak against the bill? for the bill? Representative Walker, you recognize? I have a
motion of do pass, I take it? Are you closed for your bill? Yes, I am. Do you want to speak for it? I really, I mean, if you want to, you're welcome to. Yes, AA supports this bill.
Okay, all right. We have a motion of
do pass if you're closed. I am closed All right,
all those in favor say aye Any opposed? Congratulations, you have passed three bills in a row Thank you, committee And next time, I want you to give me some of the easy ones Representative Harris, you are recognized if you want to run your bill And then Representative
Mr. Chair, Madam Co-Chair.
Hold on, is that some pending? Can we run that? Yes, sir. It's still pending.
It's going back. Hold on. If that's $12.73, I can't run
it. Okay. You're getting a fiscal impact. We're still waiting on a fiscal impact on that. Okay. Can we, Mark, can you check on that then just at some point because that's five days old. I'll check on it. Okay.
We still have it listed. Okay, thank you. We still have it listed, so I'm sorry I can't do that. Okay. Representative De La Rosa, you are recognized to present House Bill 1539.
Speaker 67
8:51
you're recognized is it on is this on can you hear me it doesn't sound like it
Speaker 71
9:16
down here well first of all since i'm on public transportation and city county and local let me just say how nice it is to actually get to send a committee meeting in the state capitol instead of over in Big Mac all of the facilities over there are great what House Bill 1539 will do is allow parents
some flexibility in deciding when their kids start kindergarten and I know that this bill has been touted as a new start date for kindergarten which I know makes everybody want to groan but that's actually not its intent and that's not what it does what it's trying to accomplish is to eliminate the absurdity that exists today of saying that a child that is born at 1159 on July 30th cannot or can go to school and one that is is born at 1201 on August 1st may go to school. What it's
trying to do is widen that gray area which right now is a very fine black line drawn in the sand and widen that out so there's a little more discretion on the part of the parents as to whether or not their child is ready. What this bill does is it opens up a four-week window where the parents may petition the school. They just simply have to request it. They can petition the school and ask for their child to go ahead and be accepted. And the schools do not have to
complete any kind of evaluation or put any time into it. They simply accept the petition and put them on a list it's first come first serve and they have the parents have until June 1st to submit the request which aligns with the way school choice works so that this is the same deadline for the ease of the schools and the schools have until one week after school starts in order to determine whether or not they will accept the child which will be based solely upon class size if they have the availability and the reason to wait until a week after school starts
because some of the schools expressed concern that they have transfers and they don't know who's coming or going until three or four days after school starts. So we thought a week would be a good, safe number that wasn't detrimental to the child starting but still let the schools accommodate it because the purpose is not to overfill the classes. We want to make sure that they don't have to start a new class for a child that's starting early or hire a new teacher or anything like that. Let's see if I remember everything in here.
There is no appeal, so there's no process for that at all because since it's based completely on class size, there's no reason for an appeal. Either they do or they don't have the space. And when I spoke to, I believe it was when I spoke to the AAEA about this, they had expressed concern about the capacity, so we went back and we redefined what available space means as 90% of capacity. So if they're at 20 students, they don't have to take 21. If they're at 19, they don't have filled their class to 20, so it's at 90% of capacity.
So a child being accepted into this is not going to overfill or the intent is not to cause the school any problems. This was brought to me, or the request was brought to me by a constituent who's going to speak for the bill here in a little bit. She's got a daughter that was born on August 2nd who she believes is absolutely ready to go to school. she will have to complete another year of pre-K that she doesn't need in order to begin. So that's what we're trying to accommodate here is some flexibility for these parents.
In terms of how many students this could possibly affect for the schools, there's about 3,500, I can't remember the exact number, but approximately 3,500 kids a year in Arkansas are born in August, and there's about 1,100 schools, so that averages out to be about three kids per school on average. some are bigger, some are smaller, that this would pertain to. Now, not all of those parents are going to want to send their kids early, so it's going to be based on what the parents request. But just so you get an idea of the volume that could be involved here.
And I think that's everything on it. If anybody has any questions for me. Are there any questions for the committee? Representative Eubanks, you are recognized for a question. representative de la rosa can you make the same argument for the people that were born on september first or second i mean you
could but what you're doing is you're widening out the window the start
date still still stands at august 1st what you're doing is giving a window after the
Speaker 71
13:51
date so if they're september 1st they're not only not near the start date but they're even outside of the window of exception. Okay, you're talking about start date for school? Yes. Okay. Kindergarten start date. Yes. Okay, thank you. Any other questions, committee? Does anyone
bill. Please state your name and who you're with, and you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. My name is Mike Mertens. I work for AAEA.
Actually, I'm representing one of our constituent groups today, and that's the Association of Elementary Principals. Before I start, I would like to thank Representative Della Rosa.
She did reach out to us and was gracious enough to meet with us and listen to some of our concerns. um if this if this uh bill passes i think it'll be the fifth change in kindergarten start date although representative de la rosa this is a waiver but it'll be the fifth change regarding the start date of kindergarten in the past eight years um we haven't heard back from every elementary principal in the state but we've heard back from quite a few and uh to a person they've
all said we need to stick with the August 1st deadline. I'll speak a little bit from experience. I have a granddaughter whose birthday is August 3rd, and last year my daughter called me and said, Dad, can't you do something about that start date? And I said no. And a year later, I'll tell you that it benefited my granddaughter to be one of the older ones when she started school. I will relate another story from an elementary principal that I received an email from today.
She's an elementary principal. She taught kindergarten, and she has a child that's birthday is September 2nd and goes to Representative Eubanks' comment. If we have a waiver that opens it up to September 1st, then we'll be back here. If you look at past practice on what we've done with kindergarten start date, We'll be back here in a couple of years saying we need to widen the waiver period.
So it is our recommendation that the start date of kindergarten needs to remain a firm date of August 1st. And the last thing I would say is, speaking from experience, I was an elementary principal for eight years. and it's my experience in general every child is is different but it's my experience in general if you have a child that experiences difficulty in kindergarten it's a typically a little boy
with a summer birthday and you know a month or two months at that age is a lot different than a month or two months for us as adults so with that all in my testimony I'll be glad to answer any questions? Representative Walker, you're recognized for question. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is there not research
the child makes a difference at this point in that the children do not, are not maturing at the boys, for instance, don't mature at the same rates as girls, but you still want to give them equality. So you want to try to use the starting date on a uniform basis so as to sort of cause them all to be equal at the time, at the particular time when they start, so that you won't have Some have the double whammy of starting too early
and then having the maturation problems evolve later on. Yes, sir, I would agree with that. I can't quote any research. Again, just my experience as being an educator at basically
all grade levels. I was one of those that
had a summer birthday, too, and I started earlier. And then I was also in a district that we, well, I won't, it ended up I couldn't drive a car until I was 16. So the only point to that story at all is that if they start early,
then they're an early birthday all the way through, and it can affect them all the way through. Rep. Deffenbaugh, you're a recognized member. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just got thinking here about a particular situation, but I wanted to know if you'd seen any studies
on starting school early could contribute to
dyslexia. And the reason I'm asking that is because that's kind of what happened to my son.
That was a psychiatrist's opinion. So I'm wondering if early is good. I would agree. Thank you. I wondered the same thing. Any other questions committee? Thank you, sir. Thank you. I have Melissa Locton to speak for the
you're with please and you're recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you very much. My name is Melissa Locton and I represent myself. I am that mother
that representative de la Rosa spoke to you what I want to tell you is that we're talking about an exception not a change in the date and if I might add I think a change is sometimes a good thing I'm not saying what we need to do is backtrack from whence we came but we need to acknowledge that certain exceptions are important I actually had the fortune of speaking to all of the principals and elementary school principals in Rogers Arkansas and got
their feedback. And I think when they hear certain perspectives, it's a little bit of a neutral subject because it really is on an individual basis. We all have stories of children who either started too early or were held back and did fine. But I have a personal experience myself. My husband and I both started school early, August 15th, July 28th, and were successful, productive citizens. And what I want to tell you is when you have a child that has had all the preschool education she can,
in fact, I have her in Tuesday, Thursday bilingual preschool where she's learning to be the family interpreter in speaking Spanish, what I will say is that there is an opportunity for consideration. A birthday can be an arbitrary date. And if we can allow for a certain small window of exception without any, you know, hindrance to the process that's already in place, we give ourselves a benefit to show that we understand a birth date is an arbitrary date. What I will also add is what we talked about is equality.
What I'm not seeing is equality to the constituents. We currently offer an exception to students who come from out of state and an exception to students who come from out of the country. And we don't offer an exception to students or parents to petition for those students who are Arkansas citizens who have grown up in the preschool system and who want to educate their children at an early date. So I will say there are some considerations that need to be made, and a line cannot be drawn in the sand that is made of concrete. And what
I would ask is for the opportunity to have an exception. And other than that, I have nothing further, but I thank you for the time and opportunity to speak with you, and I most certainly appreciate the consideration that you've given to this bill. Are there any questions? Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. I appreciate your concerns, and what you're addressing is the exceptional child.
to read and was on television at two years of
age, 18 months, in fact, and she had no school to attend for years. And the public school rationale was that we have to treat all these children alike because we cannot start making exceptions. It then comes down to making exceptions on the basis of subjective factors such as parental choice or belief or really desire, maybe in some cases, to just be rid of a child.
and I know that's not your case but if we have these rules and they are reasonably promulgated in the first place it would seem that they should be uniformly implemented across the state and if there are going to be exceptions the exceptions should be set out in some predetermined legislative definition so that everybody who is going to get an exception or petition for an exception would be subject to the same rule Otherwise, my child may not be able to get the exception, and he or she may have the
same circumstances as your child, but you may be able to get it because you have persuaded the deciding person that it is appropriate because of the advancement of the child. And while I am empathetic and sympathetic, I would certainly opt for uniformity of rules across the board rather than making exceptions because of the special circumstances that have to do with advanced intellect and preparation of children in all due respect.
Thank you. Thank you. Might I? What I would say to that is, yes, I think we have considered a standard exception and It would be on the evaluation that's done and when
they register for kindergarten to see whether they're ready for kindergarten, right? So you go through that series of tests, and the school determines whether or not, if they have enough room, that they are qualified to be in kindergarten. But what I will also say to that is when you want a standard, perhaps we can look farther than our state line,
Because when you look at the other statutes in other states, the minimum start date for kindergarten on average is August 15th or September 31st. And in Northwest Arkansas specifically, there are quite a number of transferring students. And so the individuals coming from out of state are available to benefit from that as well as out of the country. But me, myself, who's an Arkansas resident, is not afforded the same exception. And then when you move out of state, you have essentially a child that is a year behind other children
because those children from the August 1st through August 15th or August 1st through September 1st are being educated at the age of five if they're ready. So just considerations for you, and thank you for the time. Are there any other questions, committee? Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? Yes, sir, I would.
I have a September 16th birthday, and back when I went to school, that made the cutoff. So I went to school when I
Speaker 71
25:56
was four years old, and I had no problems with it. I think the whole point in all of this is not whether or not August 1st is the appropriate date, but rather whether or not we should have some flexibility, because I think the comments around have just shown that it's subjective. Some kids are ready. Some kids are not ready. And, again, we have this arbitrary line drawn in the sand that says,
as of August 1st, this is the way it's going to be. All this does is open that up for a four-week period to say you can use some discretion during that four-week period to decide whether or not this child is going to go to school. and it's up to the parents to ask the school. It's not for the school to decide. It's for the parents to request, and they only get in if they have space so that we are not taking a child that is ready for school and displacing them or requiring the school to incur more expense for it.
This is voluntary. This is not mandatory. We are not changing the date. Again, we're just widening it up. And I just want to express that this is kind of coming down to a disagreement between or a difference between administrator convenience and what's right for the child. And I would certainly hope that what's right for the child would be what prevails in that scenario. And I would appreciate a good vote. What's the will of the committee?
I have a do pass motion. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed say no. The ayes
have it. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. I'm going to turn this over to my vice chair, and I'm going to run a couple of bills.
Representative Kozak, you're recognized to present your bill. I'm going to present House Bill 1408. This is an act to modify the personnel
policy requirements for school districts and for other purposes. And I'm going to recognize Tony and let him go ahead and recognize you.
Thank you, Madam Chairman of the Committee. I'm Tony Prothrow, Director of the Arkansas School Board Association. Thank you, Committee, for enduring this afternoon. We're going to try to get out of
Speaker 110
28:40
here as soon as possible. Appreciate everybody hanging around. What this bill does is changes up some legislation
and changes a few deals. And I'm going to really let Tony tell you this. We talked about it already. I think I've got it. But I think if we just go ahead and do it right the first time, he'll tell you all the right stuff on it.
So I'm going to turn it over to Tony. Okay. You recognize Mr. Protho. Basically what this does, I'd be happy to take questions, but what this does is it changed
Speaker 110
29:14
a policy. Once there is federal or state legislation which requires a policy, If it would be, say, a special session that might happen in the fall under current law, that may not take effect until the next calendar year, and you would have a conflict between current policy and the law.
This just allows, it extends the start date once the policy is formulated after the law is enacted within 90 days. Okay. All right, are there any questions by the committee? That is for certified only. Okay. That does not affect classified. Okay, certified employees. Okay, any questions from the committee? I believe I told you that,
page two, it also would affect classified in the same manner.
Speaker 110
30:08
it would affect either then. Okay, any questions from the committee? I missed that. Okay. Is there anyone? Mr. Walker.
Okay, Representative Walker, you're recognized. All right, thank you. We'll accept your motion at the proper time. Is there anyone in the audience who'd like to speak for the bill? Mr. Nagel, you're recognized.
Madam Chair, Rich Nagel with the Arkansas Education Association. ASBA came to us with this proposed amendment. We worked with them kind of back and forth a few times, and we now believe the bill's positioned to have a good amendment on it, and we support the measure. All right. Is there anyone in the audience who'd like to speak against the bill?
for the bill all right thank you are there any other questions by the committee okay representative
Cozart would you like to close for your bill we are closed all right appreciate a good vote representative Walker you are recognized for a motion okay we have a motion of do pass on bill 1408 all those in favor say aye Aye. Opposed, no?
No. Congratulations, Representative Cozart. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you, committee. Thank you, Representative Walker. Madam Chair, I would like to
present House Bill 1836. I would like to ask former Representative Ann Clemmer if she would join me at the table. Okay. You're recognized to present your bill. I may have to use her if I have a question, so.
Okay, she would know. If you want to go ahead and recognize yourself. Ann Clemmer, Department of
Higher Ed, Senior Associate Director for Academic Affairs. All right, this is
an act to amend the Governor's Scholars Program and for other purposes, and what we've actually done is changed up some
language, and we're doing away. If I'm wrong, you correct me at any time. We're going to do away with the distinguished and just make it a governor's. No, we're doing away with governors. I'm sorry. We're doing away with governors, just make it a distinguished.
I'll hit it backwards. I'm sorry. Okay. I got you. All right. And then what this will do, it's still going to keep the same amount, right? You might want to talk about this, 370. Would you let me say something? Yes. Essentially, as you know, we don't have enough money for all the kids that have a
32 on the ACT. that's who receives the governor's distinguished scholarship and they have other factors but one of the chief eligibility hurdles is the 32 on the act and in years past we had enough money
to give that to everyone who had a 32 we have had lots of kids studying really hard and now we don't have enough money to give to everyone with a 32 the governor scholarship you didn't have to have a 32 on your act but there was one per county and so you had students with less than a 32 getting the governor's scholarship since we've run out of money for governors distinguished the law wasn't changed for the one per county governor's scholarship so you had kids
that had less than a 32 that were going to be guaranteed a spot a scholarship and you had kids with a 32 that might not get one. So sort of with the idea of fairness, we're going to give to the kids with a 32. Now, I'm anticipating my former colleague Representative Walker's question. If there are counties where no one has a 32, there will still be a recipient in that county. So there will be one in every county still. We knew that there would be folks wanting to look out
for those counties. So that's in the bill. Sorry, my mistake. I don't know that you made a mistake. I just didn't want to say you weren't in case you had. I have to read too many bills today. We'll be glad to take questions, yes. Are there any questions from the committee? I have one, so just to clarify
it in my mind, how does this change? We're still going to have one from every county,
and we're still going to have all of them with a 32. what we what we're trying to make sure doesn't happen because this year we've got a it looks like we're going to have
extra money put in but in previous years because we said one per county they would be eligible when perhaps there were kids with a higher act that would not have been eligible so we're essentially putting that 32 as the requirement to get a scholarship but if
there's no one from your county that has that, then they will still get the scholarship that they would have gotten under the governor's. Okay, I've got it. Thank you. Are there any other questions from the committee? Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. That prompted a
question, though. Are you guaranteeing to all these students, irrespective of the qualifications, that if they
make a 32, they get this scholarship? I did not mean to make that sound as though it was
the case there are other criteria still gpa leadership and ranking
class is still in there but the i was just
saying the big hurdle is the 32 okay are there any other questions by the committee is there anyone in the audience who'd like to speak for or against the bill for the bill against the bill all right no more
questions representative cozard would you like to close for your bill we are closed ma'am all righty what are the wishes of the committee representative armstrong you recognized oh do pass okay we have a motion of do pass on bill
1836 all those in favor say aye opposed no congratulations you've passed your bill Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you, Committee. Yes, Representative Ratliff, you have a bill? It will be Senate Bill 511 of Senator Ingram and Representative Ratliff.
You are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is Senate Bill 511, folks. It's a small bill. It's less than one page. It's an
Speaker 142
37:31
act to concern the authority of a state-supported institution of higher ed to refinance outstanding obligations for other purposes. And if you read the bill, it says that they can refinance bonds and things kind of like everybody else is doing right now and saving some money. So that's all this little bill does for you. Are there any questions, committee?
Seeing no questions, anybody in the audience like to speak against the bill for
the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? I need a good vote. Thank you. Got a vote of due pass from Representative McElroy. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed, no. Motion passes. You have passed your bill. Congratulations. Is anybody like to run another bill today? Is there anything else? Seeing none, without objection, we are adjourned.
Thank you. Thank you.
Agenda
HB1372
HB1526
HB1527
HB1273
HB1539
HB1408
HB1836
SB511
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Chair
Unverified
Representative Bruce Cozart
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 28
Speaker 31
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh
Unverified
Representative Justin T. Harris Chair
Unverified
Speaker 67
Speaker 71
Representative Jon S. Eubanks
Unverified
Speaker 75
Speaker 46
Speaker 110
Speaker 142