House Insurance and Commerce Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (7)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1549
· 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…epresentative Letting in the room, so next what we'll do is HB 1549, Representative Lowry.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB487
· 4 mentions in transcript
Matched: “On our calendar is SB487, which is a special order of business, and I think Represen…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB181
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…bjection, I'd like to suspend the rules so that we can hear SB 181 from Senator Williams. This is a bill that we talked about…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1486
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…t he's not here now, we'll go to the next bill on the list, HB 1486, which is Representative Letting. I don't see Representativ…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1592
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…going down our list of bills, the next bill on the list is House Bill 1592. Representative Beck, you're recognized to present your bil…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1734
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1734”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB755
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB755”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
On our calendar is SB487, which is a special order of business, and I think Representative Douglas is going to present that bill if Representative Douglas is in the room. And the other thing about the calendar, to this point, we've generally had what I'm going to call non-complicated, non-controversial bills. As the session is moving forward, you know, we're now moving into the world of more complicated, more controversial bills.
So, you know, just everybody get ready for a little bit more discussion than what we've typically had. Is Representative Douglas in the room? All right. What I'm going to do is if somebody's not here when we have their bill, we're just going to pass over it. And then since that's a special order, if Representative Douglas comes in, then we'll come back to it. If we get to a place where we're through the special order and we pass over a bill, then what we'll do is we'll go back to the top of the list if we've got time to do it.
So one more call for Representative Douglas, and then we're going to move to the next bill. And then when Representative Douglas comes in, we'll complete the bill we're on and then go back to the special order. I'm doing that without objection because I think that's the most efficient way to move forward. Last call right now for Representative Douglas. Okay, given that he's not here now, we'll go to the next bill on the list, HB 1486, which is Representative Letting. I don't see Representative Letting in the room, so next what we'll do is HB 1549, Representative Lowry.
You're recognized to present HB 1549. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And
with your permission, I would like to have Mr. Horn join me to explain the bill. Yes,
we can. Dick, go ahead and introduce yourself and who you're
Speaker 7
2:03
with. I'm Dick Horn. I'm an attorney here in town. I'm a lawyer with a member of the firm of Goldberg Dixon Horn.
And I'm representing interest in this bill. who are interested in the Barrel Association provision being altered so that it will be more beneficial to the association members and Barrel Associations in Arkansas. So far as I know, Mr. Chairman, this is a non-controversial bill. It's been a – I'm sorry? Well, I – Continue, Mr. Horn, and continue your presentation.
I must be mistaken. Barrel associations have, barrel associations are governed by the Arkansas Barrel Association Board. There are about 134 barrel associations in the state of Arkansas. They are, they provide an insurance policy, but they're not regulated by the insurance department. But what they have provided for many years is a barrel certificate of up to $500, which
was a family certificate, and you could have as many or add as many members of your family as you wanted. Uh, there, in 1987, the law was changed so that the, uh, the barrel associations could been right as much as $2,500. The subject of this meeting is that there are
Barrel Association certificates that have been in, been in place for many, many years and they're the, in most, in most instances the Barrel Associations are not solvent entities. They're just simply, they're not regular, the barrel board does not have the authority to regulate them in certain ways. One of those ways for example is insurance company must maintain reserves and must maintain a certain amount of capital and surplus in order to do business. Barrel associations
are not required to do that and as a result the vast majority of barrel associations, I won't say the vast majority, but a number of them are simply solvent. Nevertheless, the present to present time, there are some very solvent barrel associations. One that comes to my mind is the Drew County Barrel Association down in Monticello. It has about 215 members. It has about a million and two hundred thousand
dollars in assets. When a person dies, insured by that barrel association, that person gets $500. If you made a study of the amount that each person was equitably and reasonably fairly entitled to, you would find that they would be entitled to several thousand dollars more than what they're going to get.
What happens is the buildup happens over a long period of time. As I said, barrel associations have been in existence since 19, have been regulated since 1954, but they were in existence even, I'm sorry. Let me go ahead and interrupt. Okay. I think we're belying the
fact that it's a non-controversial bill by giving you all this background. but it's very much more straightforward. Some of these burial associations are overfunded.
And at the particular time, the statute only allows payout upon death of exactly what the certificate says, $500 or up to $2,500. This legislation would allow burial associations who are overfunded to be able to pay out in excess of the certificate value. So those who have been paying in on this will actually be able to get an amount in excess if you pass this bill
of what they had been hoping through these years that they would be
able to get. Excellent, Representative Lowry. Are there any questions from members? Representative Lowry, you're recognized
for a question. Okay, Mr. Lowry, I haven't been able to look at the bill. So I guess my concern would be how do you decide how much will be paid out? I mean, I understand. I mean, I do sympathize with the fact that if you've paid over 500
and you can only get 500 out, then it's some sort of inequity. But how do you decide on how much is going to be paid out if it's not defined in this? Because as I look at your bill, it's not defined in
there. I mean, I'm just trying to figure that out so that. Well, the specific language that applies is that the Barrel Association Board, of course, would have final say-so over it. And the local association would bring requests, if they have excess financial resources,
as determined by their own board, to adopt a plan to pay death benefits in excess of the face value of a certificate of benefits issued by the Burial Association. So the fair and equitable distribution could be done as simply as if you've got $2 million in it and you have 250 certificate holders, you would divide 250 into that. That would be the simplest way. Other methods available to the board is that they may be able to distribute based on how many years you had been paying into that plan.
But that's up to the local association board, and then the final determiner of it would be the burial association board at the state level. But in any case, every one of the certificate holders is going to be receiving in excess of the face value
Speaker 7
8:33
of the certificate they hold. It will be figured very closely, Representative Love, because they are going to want to do all of them fairly. Each Barrel Association that has excess funds will submit their proposal to the Barrel Association Board,
the Arkansas Barrel Association Board, and it will approve it. Okay.
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Are there any other questions for members? Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill for the bill? Seeing none,
Representative Lowry, are you closed for your bill? Yes, I
am closed. I'd appreciate a due pass recommendation. I move due pass on House Bill 1549. All in favor? Any opposed?
Congratulations, Representative Lauer. You've passed your bill. Without objection, I'd like to suspend the rules so that we can hear SB 181 from Senator Williams. This is a bill that we talked about before, and Senator Williams is here, and I'd like to recognize him now to present SB 181 without objection. Thank you very much, committee, and Senator Williams, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate it. I know
it's a little dangerous coming down here late in the session because I could get payback, right?
But it is an honor to be here. Not here, sir. Thank you very much. We'll do our best on the Senate and through the Congress, especially in my committee. I appreciate that, sir. You can't remember the time I didn't, did you? Can you? No, sir, I cannot. Thank you. We made some adjustments to the bill. We made two amendments to accommodate this committee, and I know it's been discussed in detail, and I'll be glad to answer any questions. It is a consumer bill, and with that, I would appreciate a good vote.
Are there any questions from the committee for Senator Williams? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Are you close for your bill, Senator? I am. Thank you. Representative Jett, you're recognized for a motion. Motion do pass, Mr. Chairman. We have a motion on the table. Is there any discussion of the motion? Seeing none, all in favor? None. Any opposed? Congratulations, Senator Williams. You've passed your bill. Thank you, sir.
All right, committee. As I said, I'm going to go back to the top of the list to see if Representative Douglas is here for SB 487. I see Representative Douglas is here to
present SB 487. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We were waiting on an amendment to show up here. Has it arrived yet? No.
I have one amendment, Representative Douglas, with my name on it.
We had one other amendment. If it would not be an imposition, sir, if you could go on to another bill until we get that amendment, I would appreciate it.
Yes, Representative Douglas, we will do that. All right, going down our list of bills, the next bill on the list is House Bill 1592. Representative Beck, you're recognized to present your bill, and I understand you also have an amendment as well.
Representative Beck, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Yes, I guess I'll first speak to the amendment. It's pretty straightforward. Representative Gosch is asked to be put on the bill as a co-sponsor. That's the first part of the amendment. You should have this on your tablet, by the way. The second part of the amendment is really just to add a couple words to line 10 of page 2. This was done at the request of some of the RTOs.
And the adjustment was made so that the term there was more aligned with the terms that they used within their operation. So with that, I'd ask for a motion. Okay. You asked for
Speaker 49
12:50
a motion to adopt the amendment? Is that what you're talking about? Yeah, a motion to adopt the amendment. Okay. So moved. All in favor?
Aye. Those opposed? Okay, your amendment has been adopted. You are recognized to present your bill as amended. Thank
you. I first got involved with this bill as a result of some imminent domain. I won't say conflicts, but some imminent domain issues within my district. We have many gas pipelines and oil lines as well as transmission lines, so a lot of my constituents are concerned about imminent domain. What we did then was we started drafting this bill,
and we got a very good group together, the Public Service Commission, the RTOs, and everyone was represented in the group. And that's really this bill is a result of that effort. The bill really is designed to give the PSC a little bit of directive or guidelines as far as issuing these projects that would have internet domain across the different areas. And with that, I'll take any questions.
Okay, are there any questions from the committee? Yes, sir. Representative Jett, you're recognized. What's the Public Service Commission, what are they saying about this? Are they on board with this? Yes. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Are there any other questions
Speaker 49
14:26
from the committee? Okay, from the audience, is there anyone here to speak against the motion? I mean, excuse me, against the bill? For the bill?
Seeing none, I have a question. No question? Okay, are you closed for your bill, sir? Yes, sir. Okay, Representative Love, you're recognized for a motion. Motion do pass as amended. We have a motion do pass. All in favor? Aye. Those opposed? Congratulations, Representative. You passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you, committee. All right.
We're now going to go back to the special order of business,
and Representative Douglas is going to present Senate Bill 487. There are two amendments for Senate Bill 487. So Representative Douglas is going to present the First Amendment and he'll be now at the end of the table in just a moment.
Representative Douglas, you're recognized to present your bill, and I realize first you're going to have an amendment before I introduce an amendment, and I see you have Mr. Riley with you, so sir, when you speak, if you would introduce yourself
and who you're with. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. I apologize for the delay here.
With me I have Mark Riley with the Pharmacists Association, and he will be testifying to this. First, we have an amendment here I would like to introduce. This has been vetted through the Insurance Commissioner's Office, this amendment. Basically what it does, the bill would put pharmacy benefit managers, make them register as a TPA or third-party administrator in the state.
This amendment takes out the third-party administrator responsibilities as a fiduciary to self-insured or ERISA plans. So that's all the amendment does. This has been clarified by the attorneys at the insurance commissioner's office. And with that, I would appreciate a good vote on the amendment. Representative Love, you're recognized. Motion. Are there any questions by the committee
before we get to a motion?
Seeing no questions, is there anyone that would like to speak against the amendment? For the amendment. Representative Douglas, are you closed for your amendment? Yes, Mr. Chair. Representative Love, you're recognized for a motion. Motion to adopt the amendment. There's a motion to adopt the amendment. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? The amendment is adopted, Representative Douglas. And now I'm going to turn the chair over to Reginald Murdoch, Representative Murdoch, Representative Murdoch so that I can introduce a second amendment.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. There has been a lot of work this session by the pharmacists and by the pharmacy benefit managers on a series of bills that the pharmacy folks have brought forward to really help in the business relationship from their perspective, and I applaud the hard work and effort of the pharmacy, the Pharmacy Association, Mr. Riley, the whole team in terms of the diligence
and, frankly, aggressiveness that they've moved forward with on this package of bills. This overall bill is about subjecting the pharmacy benefit managers to a regulatory body, which is a new thing for these folks in the state. And the regulatory body is going to be the insurance commissioner, so Commissioner Kerr and his team. This bill is going to do that, and the question is more exactly how does it do that?
One of the very difficult elements to manage if you're regulated with a fiduciary responsibility in a situation like this is that component of the bill. The first amendment that we just adopted would exempt the fiduciary responsibility for some of the PBM relationships, relationships with the state, relationships with self-funded plans, and some others. But it would not exempt the fiduciary responsibility for all of the PBM customers.
And that's what the amendment that I'm introducing would do. It would exempt the fiduciary responsibility across the board. the insurance commissioner is also comfortable with this amendment. So in my view, a fiduciary responsibility between one business, the pharmacy benefit manager, and another business, their customer, the company, doesn't exist in other places in business.
I've not seen it. I don't see it as a normal business practice, and I don't think it's appropriate here. I think the TPA bill, the third-party administrator bill, with this amendment is the right balance between the two groups in this situation because it gives the pharmacist something they can count on. They can go to the insurance commissioner and say, we believe that the PBM behavior is not appropriate and the insurance commissioner can act on that.
This fiduciary element, in my view, becomes very, very problematic. There are lots of federal rules regarding these things. It's just too big of a step, too risky, too problematic, in my view. That's why I'm introducing this amendment. And with this amendment, the PBMs would also be comfortable with this new regulation over them. So with that explanation, I'd like to take any questions that the committee has.
Speaker 49
22:42
Okay, thank you, Representative Collins, for presenting your amendment. Are there any questions from the committee? Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. I guess is it fair
think that's fair to say. And if the fiduciary responsibility just means you're acting in the
best interest of the clients, why would the PBMs oppose it? Well, let's say that I worked for a company that was selling toothpaste to a grocery chain.
My fiduciary responsibility is to my stockholders as a company, not the stockholders of the company I'm selling products to. So that would be an example of where we don't have a fiduciary responsibility. It's different if I'm managing your money. If you give me your money and the agreement we have is that I'm going to help you grow your assets, for example, or conserve your assets or whatever that agreement is, and I'm an expert and you're not, then the fiduciary responsibility is there to protect an innocent person from an expert taking advantage of him or her.
The fiduciary in this use has most often been designed to help a company to have from somebody absconding with their money. For example, I hold your money temporarily, I put it in my bank account, and I steal it. And that's really more the concept. If something like that were to happen, obviously we have fraud laws today, and certainly Commissioner Kern, his folks, if something like that happened, would be able to intervene and do something. So I don't believe we need this fiduciary responsibility in here.
I think it really complicates and messes up the business relationship, in my view, and I have confidence that the insurance department would be able to manage the disputes. And if they can't, we can come back in two years or four years and
Speaker 49
24:43
change it. Okay, Representative Love, any other questions from the committee? Representative Love, did you still have one? You okay? Anyone else? In the audience, is there anyone that want to speak against the amendment?
For the amendment. Oh, sorry. You're against the amendment? Oh, you're recognized. Please state your name.
Speaker 74
25:06
I'm Mark Ryer with the Arkansas Pharmacists Association. I would like to clarify a little bit, and I respectfully, one comment. I think Chairman Collins said that our amendment exempted the government and insured. It's the reverse. It exempts the self-insured plans, which are the ones that are governed under the federal laws he talks about,
and so it takes care of that. What our amendment would do is leave fiduciary responsibility, as Representative Ferguson said, interest of the client, best interest of the client, on government programs and fully insured programs. So theirs would take it off everything. Ours leaves it on the state of Arkansas. It leaves it so that they would have to do what's in the best interest of the state of Arkansas if they're dealing with them and with fully insured plans. But it takes it off of the self-insured plans like Tyson or whoever that can make their own decisions and have the right to do that.
And I believe in my study that the federal law, that's what it aligns with. And so I would appreciate. I just wanted to clarify that. I do disagree also that they don't hold money. They hold money on every prescription that's filled. It comes to them, then they distribute it. They hold money from rebates that they get from drug manufacturers. They hold literally millions and millions of dollars in their accounts and then redistribute that. And that's part of the problem, how they redistribute it.
Speaker 49
26:32
Are there any questions? Okay, we have a question from Representative Leading
for Mr. Riley. Two hours in the past, have there been any issues with third-party administrators
Speaker 74
26:46
regarding fiduciary issues? No. According to the insurance commissioner, there's not been any cases brought against third-party administrators for fiduciary responsibility breaches.
Speaker 49
26:59
Thank you. Okay. Are there any other questions for Mr. Riley?
So let me go again to the audience. Is there anyone to speak for the amendment? Anyone like to speak for the amendment? Okay, you're recognized to speak
Speaker 81
27:22
for the amendment. Okay, good morning. My name is Michael Harold. I represent Express Scripts, a pharmacy benefit manager, and we are in support of the amendment that Chairman Collins described. I think he probably did a better job than I could have. It's a complicated issue.
But the bottom line here is that we did not have this standard in any other state. It had been enacted in one state and repealed. It had been in Maine, they overturned that law. And then the District of Columbia, it was had and a court overruled there. So it isn't common to have a fiduciary standard in a TPA aspect like we would be looking at and facing here. And it really does limit the types of relationships, actually, and the flexibility that we can have in crafting a pharmacy benefit program for our clients.
The FTC has looked at this issue and unequivocally stated that it is harmful to the types of business relationships and arrangements that can be made in the best interest of the plans of their members, and that it is anti-competitive in that sense, and that it puts a chilling effect to some degree on the types of things that can be developed. So we would highly support that it come out, that as we've had discussions with Dr. Riley over the years, the frustration has always been that there is no enforcement authority.
And what this does is it licenses us as a TPA. As Chairman Collins said, it gives the insurance department authority to respond to concerns and problems that are brought to them, and we think that that is a good compromise of where the
Speaker 83
29:07
yourself. Hi, I'm Catherine Bell, and I represent CVS Health. We're the parent company for CVS Retail, and then our PBM is Caremark, which operates in the state. I'll just reiterate what my colleague from ESI said.
This is, we feel like a good compromise. It's new for us. As Representative Collins said, this will be a new regulatory scheme, and we're comfortable with that. But like my colleague from ESI said, we do not fit a fiduciary, so that's why we have agreed on this amendment. And I'm happy to take any questions if there are any.
Speaker 49
29:45
Thank you. Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing no questions from the committee, is there anyone else to speak against the amendment?
For the amendment. Thank you. Seeing none, Representative
Collins, would you like to close for your amendment? Yes, Mr. Chair, thank you very much. I would just suggest that this has been a very laborious process to get to this point. There have been multiple meetings in advance of this, and it feels like we've gotten to the point where we're almost to a package that both sides can feel comfortable with.
And I would just submit to this august body that with this amendment, this TPA bill is the right step forward for Arkansas in terms of balancing all these interests and being in the interests of the people of our state. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'd appreciate
Speaker 49
30:51
a good vote. Okay, we have a motion. Do pass. All those in favor? Oh, excuse me. okay for clarity's sake
we are adopting the amendment that's what this vote is for are those a favor signify by aye those opposed I'd like I'd like
a roll call Mr. Chair wait just a second okay I'm
Speaker 49
31:31
going to do that again please I'm going to do that again all those in favor of the amendment
of Representative Collins please signify by voting yes those opposed I'm going to say the motion fails We ask for a roll call. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Thank you.
Representative Douglas, you recognize to
present your bill. thank you sir i think most of us pretty much presented because uh after all that this is to make uh pbms registers third party administrators with the amendment in there to exempt
self-insured plans and the rest of plans there so that's basically the amendment But I'll be honest, the whole crux of this issue, and I think when it gets down to, as we used to say, the nut cutting, whenever we get down to it, we all want the pharmacies to make a reasonable profit. We want the PBMs to make a reasonable profit.
But we don't want anybody to be taken advantage of. We need a little oversight, a little clarity on that, put a little sunshine on it, and that's where we're at. So I would appreciate a good vote on this bill. Thank you. Are there any
questions for Representative Douglas? Seeing none, would anybody like to speak against the bill? Seeing none, anybody for the bill? What's the will of the committee?
Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a motion. We have a due pass as amended motion on the table. Any discussion? All those in favor? All those opposed? Nay. The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Douglas. You've passed your bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Next on our list is House Bill 1734.
Is Representative Dotson here? Representative Dotson, you're recognized to present House Bill 1734.
committee members this bill very simply promotes the free market competition of student course material by ensuring state supported
institutions of higher education cannot add the cost of course material into the tuition or fees a student pays this bill allows the student to continue to shop for the best deal on their course material without ever running the risk of being locked into a monopolistic no competition solution for their course material. The intent of the law is to promote free market principles and allow students to keep the choice of how, when, where, and in what format to buy their educational materials. If they want to buy on campus, that's okay. If they want to
buy from Amazon, that's okay. If they choose to shop with local private retailers, that's okay. If they want to buy e-books or if they like print, all those things are fine as well. What the law says specifically is a state-supported institution of higher learning shall not add the cost of materials to the billing account of the student, meaning if the institution of higher education elects to add the cost to the student's account or embed it in tuition or fees, it is this act that takes away the student's choice. This
law does not restrict any scholarship in the state of Arkansas from being used as it has been in the past. Students can still elect to charge against their already verified aid and shop on campus if they choose to do so. Again, it's the student's choice to elect to charge their already verified positive balance account, and the state-supported institution of higher learning cannot make that choice for them. Hence, it's free market. With that, I'm open for questions. Representative Love, you're right, can I ask for a question?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think I see the intent of your bill, but Representative Dotson, how does higher ed, what's the higher ed's take on this bill? I'm sure you can ask them
if you like. They probably are here. Okay, well. Representative Dotson, are
you ready for someone to come in at the table to help you answer questions?
Absolutely. If there's no other questions for me other than that, I can't speak for higher ed. Well, you know what we're going to do, Representative,
we're going to have an opportunity for people to speak for and against the bill when we get done with these questions, and then that gentleman will be able to get to the end of the table. Any other questions? Representative Hodges,
you recognize for a question? So is the intent of this bill to prevent universities from requiring, essentially requiring their students to buy
from the campus bookstore? The intent of the bill is to continue the process it is and put safeguards in place
so that we've had an instance in the last few years where universities have tried to include fees and create charge accounts where they include the cost of course materials and the tuition or the fees and locks out any competition. We stop that during the interim. This bill basically ensures that that can't be done in the future so that the state tax-supported institutions have to play on a level playing field
with all private businesses and industries. Follow-up?
Yes, Representative Hodger, you're recognized for a
follow-up. Thank you, Chairman. So is the net effect of that, if they're adding the costs into tuition and fees, that money can only be used at the campus
bookstore? Well, right. I mean, if the tuition and fees were increased to cover the cost of the materials, then it would be the institution selling the stuff, locking out any other competition or student choice
and being able to go around and shop for the best deal. So whether that deal is good or not can be debated all day long, but it locks them in and
they don't have a choice. Okay. Thank you. Representative Talley,
you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So are you telling me that right now you're saying that students do not have the freedom to
go out and buy their textbooks elsewhere? They do currently, yes. And so this just ensures that in the future no institution can add it into the tuition or the fee
and require basically 100% student participation in purchasing that course along with the cost of tuition. So the free
market currently exists, right? Currently exists. This ensures that it continues. Now then if that student needs to charge the cost of a book to their account while they're waiting for like a Pell check
to come in, does your bill here not prohibit that from happening? This would not change the current practice as far as how it works currently. It doesn't restrict any scholarship.
As I stated in my remarks, they can already elect a charge against a verified positive balance account. So if they have a Pell Grant or they have something coming, then they would be able to say that this is coming against this. but they have the choice in that instance on where they spend those dollars. It's not already included in the tuition and fees. One more question, Mr. Chairman. Yes, Representative Talley,
you're recognized. Could you please clarify in lines 30 and 31, it says higher education shall not add the cost of course materials to the billing account.
Isn't that language out there going to prohibit them from being able to put it on the student's account until that
Pell check gets there? I don't believe so, but having had this looked over when it was drafted, I did ask that question, and my understanding of it was it did not. Representative Love, you recognize for a question?
Mr. Chairman, I think Mr. Talley made my – I'm on the same mindset of Mr. Talley, because it says it shall not be added. And so if we put this, even though it might be your understanding, if we enact this language, then that means that will prevent kids from being able to do so. And I have a very big concern in regards to that. So I don't know if you want to possibly pull it and then address that issue,
but right here it's just saying they shall not do that. And so I have very, it's a very big concern. So thank you.
Representative Lauer, you recognize for a question? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Based on these several interpretations, Representative Dotson, it appears to me, and I'm just asking you to clarify, if the word including, and I know what you're trying to do, is clarify what your bill is trying to cover.
If you remove the word including, I believe it does clarify then that you are specifically talking about incorporating the cost of course materials into the tuition rather than using that as just as an example of something that couldn't be done. So I just offer that as
a... That, let me actually, if I may, Mr. Chair, I do have someone who understands the billing process a little bit more than I do here
that can speak to that probably a little bit better than I can, an expert in student purchasing. All right, have them come to the
end of the table and they can address that question. Please state your name and
Speaker 113
42:47
your organization, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. My name is Steve Wilson, and I own a company called Campus Bookstore, and we're located in Fayetteville, Arkansas. We support students
that attend the University of Arkansas, as well as Northwest Arkansas Community
College. Okay, and the question, as you've probably heard, has to do with is this overly restrictive in terms of how a student account can be charged, in other words, to the point where it actually becomes a burden on the student, is essentially the question. And if you'd address that, that
Speaker 113
43:18
would be great. Yes, sir. Thank you. When Representative Dodson came to me with this idea, and the plain reading of the bill
reads, a state-supported institution of higher education shall not. And that's the whole intent. The intent is free market activities. the actual intent of the university selecting students to purchase only from their store does away with the student choice, which is what this bill is trying to protect. And so it does not bar students electing to charge against positive financial aid accounts, for example, Pell Grants, VAs, lottery money, et cetera. Then those students that have those positive funds could elect to charge their account,
but it is their election that it is their choice that they are choosing to elect, not the university doing that for them.
I think the question, if I just kind of rephrase the question, I think everybody gets the general context of expanding the free market, but I think the specific issue that several lawmakers have brought up is if I want to charge my books because I don't have any money in there yet, but my classes start tomorrow, and I want to read the book first. The way the language is written here, not conceptually, but literally,
the way the language is written here, there's been a lot of concern that the language would prevent the university from allowing a student to do that in the student bookstore. I'm not a lawyer, so I can't answer whether or not the language does. What I'm just suggesting to you is several lawmakers have brought that up. If we don't have an expert that can say, no, that's not a problem, then my hypothesis is we're going to need to get that figured out before the committee is likely to approve the bill is what I'm just reading from the members.
Speaker 113
45:04
Understood. The process currently with any state-supported institution of higher learning, if a student does not have a scholarship that is part of their account, then they cannot go charge to the campus bookstore anyway. They don't offer or they're not allowed to offer the credit of the state, if that answers any of the questions. Representative Murdoch, you're recognized for
Speaker 49
45:29
For a point of clarity and transparency, to make sure I understand this whole picture,
when I was there, there was a university bookstore and campus bookstore. Is the university bookstore still there? Yes, sir. So the university bookstore, does it allow for what the question is being asked? Does it allow for the question that's being asked? As my understanding, yes,
sir, it would. Thank you. Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Wilson, you know, you were down here two years ago, and I really do understand the sentiment of what the University of Arkansas did put in place
and how that affected your bookstore. I do understand I'm familiar with this case. However, the language in this bill prevents U of A or any other state institution from allowing that to happen. And so while I did support, actually, what we did two years ago, I'm thinking that this bill is going to really have an unintended consequence of actually allowing students to be able to purchase books with their accounts.
And so we can fix that language. Trust me, I support exactly the action that we took against Fayetteville two years ago in regards to making them pull their program. Trust me, I do, because, I mean, I understand where you're coming from. But this bill is going to have a further reaching effect that would be detrimental to students. And so if you all could pull this bill and actually work on it, work on some of the language, I think we could get to where you need to be.
And so with that, Mr. Chairman, but I am familiar with this situation and what U of A was doing. We actually fixed that two years ago. So I understand where you're coming from, but I'll be more than happy to work with them on this bill. But this bill is going to be a little more detrimental than what we're trying to fix in
your situation. Representative Hodges, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You mentioned in your statement that students charging for these books to their student accounts, if they don't have a scholarship or Pell Grant or anything already there,
was not allowed because you're extending credit of the state. Yes, sir. Has that ever been settled in law, either by court
Speaker 113
48:00
case or attorney general opinion? It has not, except that the issue has popped up twice within this committee, back in 2006 and then again in 2012, I believe, 13. And at that time, the Insurance and Commerce Committee said that it was a possible tax liability for the state of Arkansas to have possibly tens of millions of dollars charged against a student's account.
As long as the student remains a student, of course, they have to pay the bill before they return the next semester. However, if a student chooses to drop out and do whatever, then the university is left to try to collect those funds, and the books only adds to that bill. Follow-up?
You recognize for a follow-up? Was it your intent with this bill to prohibit that practice? My intent?
Yes. You or Representative Dotson, whoever worked on
the bill. The intent is to not extend the credit of the state or not to have a 100% pass-through requirement for students to have to purchase a certain set of course material along with their tuition or fees without being able to shop around, try to find the best deal for themselves, but have it all included in their tuition and fees and thereby charge for the sale.
of that merchandise, having the state basically make a profit or try to extend the credit and take a loss as a business without locking out, in the meantime, locking out any competition
in the process. Representative Dotson, is there a difference between me saying the tuition of the class is X thousand dollars, and me saying the tuition of the class is X thousand plus some hundreds for books, And then making you purchase and in effect bundling the book and tuition.
That I think, again, I'm just sensing and I certainly would agree is an unfair competitive practice because a bookstore cannot bundle the mandatory thing, your tuition, with the books. And in that type of a practice, the university would be unfairly competing with the bookstores. And if that's what you're trying to prevent, things of that nature, you know, I'm certainly in favor of it. But I think the question that's being raised is that this goes far beyond that in terms of really hamstringing the university's ability to bill students.
And, again, I'm not a lawyer. I don't know the answer, whether it does or it does not, for sure. But the reading of the bill by several folks is raising that question. So it's that question, not the concept of free markets that people are asking about.
So the question, I guess, if I may restate it so I have an understanding of it, is if, in fact, these scholarships, the Pell Grants, whatever it happens to be,
If that's a positive balance that the student has the ability to charge against and this prohibits that, then we need to fix it. However, if currently this bill in its current form would not prohibit the charging of that against a positive balance that was created by scholarship or Pell Grants or anything of that nature, then everything is fine with this bill. Well, in answer
to my question, the piece that I would add to that is if today the university can say tuition and fees are allowed to be billed,
credit or pick your word for whatever you want to call that, and then you have to pay at a certain date, and in tuition fees and books they're all allowed to be billed so that you get a bill for the semester and it includes everything you need to be a college student that semester. And what this is doing is preventing the college from doing that. I think that gets into part of the problem, because there may be some students who for convenience reasons would choose to say, I'd like to have my tuition fees and
books all billed this way, very different from the university saying, you must buy this package which includes all of these things. And so preventing them from forcing you to buy a package of tuition, books, and fees, are nodding their heads yes to but preventing a student from choosing to have it done that way I think is what people fear this bill does if
that's helpful. Absolutely I understand that and upon the advice of the committee the chair and everyone I will pull this bill down with the committee's permission to
try to make sure and clarify that within the
language of the bill. Without objection permission granted thank you very much representative Dotson the next bill on our list is HB 1562 is representative Meeks here to present that bill I see movement is representative Meeks here to present that bill if not We're going to pass over that, and the next bill on our list is SB231.
Is somebody here for Senator Elliott, representing Senator Elliott? Seeing none, we're going to go to HB1797. Is Representative Wright here? I don't see Representative Wright, so we're going to go to 1798. Again, Representative Wright. I don't see Representative Wright. HB 1814, Representative Love. Representative Love is not going to present that bill today.
HB 1824, Representative McGee. I don't see Representative McGee. HB 1870, I don't see Representative Sabin. HB 1809, Representative Charlotte Douglas. Is she here to present her bill? HB 1894, Representative Vines is going to pass over HB 1894 today.
HB 1906, Representative Hammer is Representative Hammer here. HB 1907, Representative Neal is going to pass over today. HB1931, Representative Letting will pass over that today. SB466, is Senator Irvin or a representative here to present SB466? SB755, Representative Neal, you recognize to present Senate Bill 755.
Representative Neal, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. I'm going to have Ms. Shannon Newton come up and help present today.
Ms. Newton, if you would introduce yourself and who you're with, you're recognized to present SB 755. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I'm grateful for
the opportunity to be before you today to talk about Senate Bill 755. Senate Bill 755 is for the purpose of regulating anti-indemnification clauses in motor carrier contracts. This This bill is in current law in 41 other states, and Arkansas is seeking to follow suit and make that practice prohibited in Arkansas as well. The existing problem is that we have shippers forcing their liability onto motor carriers who enter their property and haul freight for them.
And what happens is that they have what they refer to as a standard contract, and the language in that contract indemnifies the shipper from any wrongdoing or negligent acts that might happen while on the shipper's property or due to their negligence in loading the freight or anything that might happen while they're on the property, including an errant crane or forklift driver that might drive through the side of the trailer or injure the driver while on that property. The clause in the contract says, unfortunately, that's just the cost of doing business with
that shipper. So what we're asking is that those provisions not be allowed in those contracts and that they be void and unenforceable to protect the motor carrier from risk that
they are out of control of. Ms. Newton, is there anything in this bill that would extend the liability risk the other way? For example, when the truck is on the road and driving down the road, Is there anything in the bill that would create a liability for the shipper when they no longer have possession of the product and the truckers have the product?
What our bill says is that we're responsible for the things that we're in control of, and you're responsible for the things that you're in control of. And you can't contractually obligate
that liability in either direction. So let me give you an example. Let's say I had a truck and it was full of something that was very expensive and the truck was loaded by, I'm the truck driver because I want to be the good guy. So I'm the truck driver and the shipper loaded expensive vases in the back of the truck.
And I was driving down the road and I wanted to take a shortcut, so I went on one of those bumpy roads and I was bumping along and I smashed every vase in the truck. And then I got to my destination and I landed there. How would you figure out the liability in the absence of this bill and with the bill passed versus where we are today? Currently,
the situation you described would always be the trucking company's fault,
no matter if the vases were loaded negligently or incorrectly. You have to kind of understand it's a common industry practice that the trucking company and their employees are not allowed in the trailer or to participate in the loading procedure. In many cases, that stuff is loaded and locked, and the seal cannot be broken until it arrives at the destination. So currently, the trucking company would be at fault, and I believe in the case that you described, the trucking company would most likely still be at fault unless you could prove that it was loaded with negligence, in conflict of best practices or the way that the receiver had instructed it be loaded.
Some of the shippers have said to me they wish they were faster on their feet. Okay, they wish they were faster on their feet, and so they're very sad that they weren't as fast on their feet as they ought to be, right? And people get paid for being fast on your feet. There's an old expression, if you snooze, you lose. Yes, sir. I'm not a believer in that. So my question is, is it possible to work with them to take a look at this
and see if there can be some alignment so that the very, what I would agree with you, is unfair treatment of a trucker at a shipper and a crane dropped ten times on the truck until everybody in it is passed away would be the fault of the trucker. That's not fair, and we need to fix that. But conversely, some legitimate questions about complication, lots of extra lawsuits, et cetera, et cetera, could be worked out in a way potentially that there can be more alignment to this and still achieve the goal that you have.
and I would commit to you that we would do a special order if needed or I would suspend the rules without objection to get this bill heard and so this is not some Collins trying to delay but rather get to an outcome that everybody could feel good about. Is that something that you folks would be willing to consider? I respect
your request and your position. However, I think what we've done is arrived at as simple as it can be and that we're responsible for what we're responsible for
and they're responsible for what they're responsible for. And currently, any potential litigation of that is prohibited. And while litigation is not good and has certainly a negative connotation, I think the ability to litigate in those instances is a necessity and it's part of the rules that you and I operate under and that shippers and motor carriers ought to be able
to operate under those same rules. Are there any
other questions? Representative Seville, are you recognized for a question? Yes. Is there any way of arbitration besides litigation if there is a question of whose fault it would be?
Sure. Let's keep in mind that the two parties, that there is a customer relationship there. And so, you know, there's not a problem until there is a problem. And so in many cases, small incidences are going to be looked over. We're not talking about suing over, you know, a dented dryer or something of that nature. We're talking about millions of dollars of pharmaceuticals being spilled all over the interstate or a driver being killed by a crane or steel dropped on their equipment while they're in the facility. So I think those are the types of instances that we're really trying to focus on.
And in little instances, I think you would just go to whatever the rules of the court would be. If it rose to the level that it would be worth litigating, then it would. And there's no commission or board or something that's set up to handle this. And like I said before, we're the only state west of Mississippi that doesn't have this legislation, and so I think they've figured out how to make it work everywhere else, and I don't think there's going to be a
lot of unintended or surprise consequences. Representative Bain, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So I want to make sure I heard you correctly or if I misunderstood what you said earlier.
So if there was a shipment that was damaged, Would there still be the ability for the shipper, excuse me, the one who prepared the shipment, would they still have an option to sue the shipper or would they be barred from bringing a suit for the damages? Could there still be litigation? Would anything in this bill, the way it's written, prevent a company to come back and sue a transporting company?
Speaker 101
1:03:04
No. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Seville, you're recognized for a question. Motion at the proper
time. Are there any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anybody that would like to speak against the bill? Anybody that would like to speak for the bill? Representative Neal, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. I'm closed for my bill. Representative Seville, you're recognized for a motion.
I move to do pass. We have a do pass recommendation on the bill. Any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor? Any opposed? Nay. The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Neal. You've passed the bill. Without objection, I'm going to recognize Senator Elliott to present SB 231.
Senator Elliott, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, I don't think this is going to take a lot of brain matter to get through this bill. Back in 2009, we started, I started working with the cemetery board to try to bring some possibility of preserving perpetual cemeteries with historic significance. And so we have the appropriation, and the cemetery board has tightened up its rules so that we make sure a limited amount of money can be used in a very thoughtful way to get the maximum bang for the buck.
And so this legislation was necessary to make sure that what we have in the appropriation and what they have in their rules is also codified to the extent that it needs to be. And this really was precipitated by what's happened with the Haven of Rest Cemetery that you may or may not be familiar with over on 12th Street. But it's historic in the sense of this is where Daisy Bates is buried, Scipio Jones, and people of that nature are buried there.
And this is what this bill is designed to do to make sure that we are all working together and we've got the rules synced up. Representative Love, you're recognized for
a question? Motion. Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Seeing none, Senator Elliott, are you closed for your bill? I am, yes. Representative Love, you're recognized for a motion. Motion do pass. We have a do pass motion on the table.
Is there any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes.
Congratulations, Senator Elliott. Thank you. It was a pleasure
being here my first time. I remember that when I come back. All right. Going back down our list of bills, we're now at SB 796, Senator Woods or a representative. I don't see one.
The next bill is SB 667, Senator Sanders or his representative. saying none I'm now at the end of the list and as I said at the beginning of the meeting I'm gonna go back to the top of the list and I'm just gonna read through them quickly so if anybody is did not get a chance to present their bill and is now here we'll see if we can try and get them in so I'm going back to the top of the list and I see HB 1797 representative Wright HB 1798
Representative Wright. HB 1814, Representative Love, told me he was going to pass over. HB 1824, Representative McGee. HB 1870, Representative Sabin. HB 1809, Representative Douglas. HB 1894, Representative Vines. HB1906, Representative Hammer, HB1907, Representative Neal, HB1931, Representative Leading, SB466, Representative Irvin, SB796, Representative Woods, SB667, Representative Sanders.
Seeing as we have no more bills to be presented today, without objection, we are adjourned. Thank you.
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlie Collins Chair
Unverified
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Speaker 7
Representative Fredrick J. Love
Unverified
Senator Eddie Joe Williams
Unverified
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Representative Rick Beck
Unverified
Speaker 49
Representative Joe Jett
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson
Unverified
Speaker 74
Representative Micah S. Neal
Unverified
Speaker 81
Speaker 67
Speaker 83
Speaker 91
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Representative Brent Talley
Unverified
Speaker 113
Shannon Newton
Unverified
Representative John Baine
Unverified
Speaker 101
Senator Joyce Elliott
Unverified