House Aging, Children and Youth, Legislative and Military Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (8)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1523
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1523”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB12
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “We're going to run House Bill 12-16, 12-18, I'm sorry, amendment to adopt. Mr. Chairman, tha…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1218
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1218”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1719
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1719”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1723
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1723”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1033
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1033”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1040
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1040”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1042
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1042”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
You'll recognize Representative Vines. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. I'm going to lie to you. We've got to pull it up on here.
Here we go. Yes, thank you. I appreciate your deviating from your agenda to accommodate me. I do appreciate that. I simply have a House resolution that honors one of mine and I believe probably Representative Rushing's middle schools as a high-achieving overall school and recipient of an Arkansas School Recognition Program Award. And I simply request a favorable vote to present this resolution to the House floor.
Okay. And I'll answer any questions. Thank you. Are there any questions from the committee? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this resolution? If not, the Chair will entertain a motion. Representative Vaught, you're recognized. We have a motion due passed. All in favor, vote aye. Opposed? You've passed your resolution. Thank you, Representative Bynes.
Thank you. Thank you, committee, for accommodating me.
Thank you. This time we'll move to House Bill 1523. Representative Sullivan, are you ready to present your bill? Mr.
Chair, with your permission, I'd like to invite Dr. Mark Haney to join me for this presentation.
Dr. Haney, would you state your name and affiliation for the records, please? yes Mark
Speaker 19
2:50
Haney I'm the vice president of Tech Friends Incorporated located in Jonesboro Arkansas thank
you thank you Mr. Chair committee this bill allows for a paradigm
change in how business is conducted at the Arkansas Department of Corrections it doesn't
mandate it it just allows for that change And if adopted, it will implement a model that would reduce recidivism rates, reduce prison costs, save tax dollars, and simplify the process. The Arkansas Department of Correction inmates are permitted to purchase snacks and hygiene items over what's referred to as a commissary. These items are sold at the store window inside each facility. This model requires the individual staffing at each location, translating into approximately 25 positions.
In addition, each individual facility is responsible for ordering, reordering, and restocking the store. Vendors that provide the product mix are shipped relatively small qualities to individual facilities on a weekly basis. This new model would allow the Department of Corrections to centralize the commissary operation and eliminate the need for ADC personnel to provide point-of-sale service in the distribution of necessary commissary items.
Inmates would order the desired commissary products, and these items would be packaged and delivered to appropriate facilities and distributed to receiving inmates. It's proposed to utilize inmate labor via the Arkansas Correction Industries for that purpose. The program is in the spirit of Governor Hutchinson's initiative to reduce incarceration rates. There are established studies demonstrating that inmates involved in work programs are less likely to reoffend.
The recidivism rate is typically 30 percent lower for inmates involved in industry programs. There are several states currently utilizing this model, including Colorado, Kansas, North Carolina, and Washington, and there are several other states who are in the process of adopting this model. Currently, items assembled or packaged by Arkansas Correctional Industries are prohibited by Arkansas law from being sold to inmates.
The proposed change would make this model possible should the Board of Corrections decide to pursue it. Someone once told me that effective is doing the right thing, which is our goal, and that efficient is doing things right. If passed, this law would allow us to allow us, not mandate us, the opportunity to move to a more efficient and effective model. Mr. Haney, Dr. Haney is an Arkansas resident with an Arkansas company
who currently can't do business in the state of Arkansas. This law would allow his business and others' businesses like his an opportunity to make proposals to the Department of Corrections. Again, this law would not mandate that the Department of Corrections move to this model. It just would allow the Department of Corrections an opportunity to move in that direction. I'm going to let Mr. Haney make just a couple of brief statements, and then we'll take any questions, if that's all right, Mr. Chair.
Speaker 19
6:18
You recognize Ms. Haney. Thank you, Representative Sutherland. Yes, we've implemented this model in several states and seen it have some very successful outcomes. In researching Arkansas statute, we realized that there were a couple reasons why ADC really didn't want to pursue this. First of all, correctional industries can only sell to government agencies and nonprofits in the state of Arkansas. So we need to free them up to be able to market directly to these inmates.
The second reason is correctional industries must sell their products at wholesale. All right, well, right now at those store windows, ADC is marking up those prices, and those funds are used for inmate benefit, for inmate welfare fund. And so they really can't afford to lose that. So Correctional Industries needs to also be able to mark those products up above wholesale just to maintain the status quo. So, you know, one of the big things we see here is when you get inmates involved in these correctional industries, that recidivism rate goes down. So the three-year recidivism rate in Arkansas is currently 42%.
If we can get a 30% reduction in that, that's a dramatic savings to the state. So these folks become productive citizens, and they don't get back on the taxpayer rolls. So that's all. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd be
glad to take any questions. Questions? Representative
Johnson, you recognize the question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And how does the Department of Corrections feel
about this? Have you asked them? As a matter of fact, I've
I've had a number of emails with Kathy Fry, who is a public information officer and the legislative liaison for the Department of Corrections. I emailed her. I heard from her on March the 2nd. He replied to that email the next day, sent an email to her on March the 5th, and said that we are planning to run at our earliest convenience. I'd like to hear from her. I emailed her again later on March the 5th after I talked with our chair about running this bill, and I have not heard back from them. Their first comment was that they've looked at it and they'd like to tweak it a little bit.
And I would be happy if and when they contact me, if they have some tweaks that fit with the spirit of the bill, to offer an amendment on
this is not mandating, but an opportunity to choose this model by the Department of Corrections. That's correct. All right. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Tucker, you're recognized. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. Could you just explain the price adjustment to me one more time?
I'm not sure I'm fine. Like, how much is it marked up and the prices for the prisoners and just kind
Speaker 19
9:06
of explain that. Sure. The current model has – they basically buy this product in bulk from several vendors in pretty much small quantities. You're shipping small amounts to each of the 25 facilities. It's mandated marked up by – the Board of Corrections sets that number, and I want to say it's like a 45% markup right now. So that would just be maintained. So the price to the inmate should stay the same. It's just that – you know, it's basically just a little adjustment to the law to preserve what's already going on.
So correctional industries would mark up that product by that same amount, selling it to inmates instead of ADC directly marking it
up. I'll just finish up with that question, Representative Clark. Mark explained it to me is that right now we're on a brick-and-mortar model and we're moving to the Amazon model, which is much cheaper in production and processing.
Representative Brown, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So if you're going to the Amazon model, does that mean that even with the markup, a specific product could actually conceivably cost less to the inmate? You know, I think you would need to, I don't know
if Ms. Fry is here or if they have a representative here, but I think we're not speaking to what we do and what this bill does.
The prison industries is the one that sets that, and any decisions made in that regard would be up to them. So if they were here and would like to testify to that, I'm sure we'd like to hear the, it's a good question,
but we don't, that's their decision. Thank you. Are there any more questions from the committee? If not, is there anyone else, anyone in the audience that would like to speak for this bill?
Against the bill, Representative Sullivan, would you like to close for your bill? Yes,
just real briefly. Again, we don't set, this bill does not set the pricing. It has nothing to do with pricing. This bill just offers a different model to help save the state money. and I'd appreciate a good
vote. Thank you. Okay. Representative Brown, you're recognized for a motion. There's been a motion to do pass. All in favor, vote aye. Opposed?
You've passed your bill.
Thank you, Representative Sullivan. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. Is
Representative Lowry here? Is Representative Lowry present? Okay. Representative Charlotte Douglas. Representative Bain is here. Representative Bain, you're
We're going to run House Bill 12-16, 12-18, I'm sorry, amendment to adopt. Mr. Chairman, that is correct.
I did bring an amendment before the committee. I'd appreciate its consideration for adoption. The amendment actually adds one additional segment to the original bill. I had a conversation with the Arkansas Hospital Association.
They have already got substantial protocols in place at their nonprofit hospitals that deal with all patients, and I was satisfied after talking to them that they likely will exceed the threshold that we were trying to set in this bill. And that amendment basically would amend them out of this process. Okay. Thank
Speaker 60
13:24
the amendment? Yes. Thank you, Representative Bain. I think the amendment, just to make sure, is MGF 238.
Is that correct? It says delete lines 24 and 26 and
Speaker 60
13:38
Mr. Meeks. Can you explain how that would affect, like, a church? Because a church would be considered a nonprofit organization. Is that
correct? Yes, Mr. Meeks. a non-profit would include a religious institution or could include a religious institution. So how would
other than a non-profit hospital? It would be all non-profit organizations other than a non-profit hospital. It would include, I think what you're thinking typically a church or other religious institution, it would cover those
Speaker 60
14:16
employees of that church. So with this amendment, I understand why you're excluding a hospital, but are we going to get into the argument of, well, why not churches? Why not other nonprofit organizations? Well,
first of all, I would point out there's already 39 other mandated reporters in this,
and you've already got almost all the medical – actually, I've got an expert witness that can go into the other 39, but we've already got substantially coverage on the hospital side is already in the first 39. But if you would, Mr. Chairman, with your permission, I'd like to bring Sherry Williamson with the Arkansas Commission on Child Abuse, Rape, and Domestic Violence up. She can actually kind of elaborate on what's already covered in a hospital now. I'll go ahead. Let's go
Speaker 60
15:00
ahead and just do the amendment, and then I guess we'll go ahead and do the bill, Mr. Chair, if that's okay with you.
That's fine. I'll make the motion to go ahead and do pass on the amendment, and
then we'll discuss the bill as a whole. Okay. There's been a motion to adopt the amendment. All in favor, vote aye. Opposed? The amendment has been adopted. Now we'll proceed with the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, committee. Would you state your name and affiliation for the record? Sherry
Speaker 74
15:33
Williamson. I'm the Child Abuse Project Coordinator for the Arkansas Commission on Child Abuse, Rape, and Domestic Violence. Thank you for being here.
You may proceed. Okay. Just to let you know, as far as the existing mandated reporter list, as it already exists in the Child Maltreatment Act, many of the employees and professions in any hospital are already on the list. We have nurses, physicians, surgeons are actually on there separately from physicians, even though they obviously have to be physicians, osteopaths,
many medical professions. Then we also have a catch-all category, just in case there's some other profession that's not listed, and it actually says medical professionals engaged in the admission, care, or treatment of persons in the hospital. So I'm not sure what the percentage would be, but many, many folks who work even at non-profit hospitals are already going to be on that list. Are there any other
questions from the committee? Representative Meech, you're recognized.
Speaker 60
16:43
Now that we're discussing the bill as a whole, again, my concern is mainly, and I'm sure that there may be others that may not be on the list that I'm not aware of, but my concern is churches. When you have youth pastors that are hired by the church and other ones, yes, I would like them to report child maltreatment, but is that going to are we going to run into an issue with
under the mandated reporter act so we already have an obligation under members
members of the faith and the clergy um and and let me also first in addition also say there was a lot of people that wanted me to cover all volunteers related with non-profits and so forth we didn't do that we actually backed that lineup and only said paid employees we're only people that are actually get their employment, their gainful employment from working for a nonprofit. We didn't want to bring in the youth counselors or the, you know, if you're talking about, you know, maybe parents that chaperone, that kind of, that is not, that is not, would not be brought in in that regard.
We're not, again, we're not trying to target all people in nonprofits. We're targeting specifically people that actually work on payroll. I will say that a lot of nonprofits I've talked to, even for their volunteers already do this and do criminal background checks on their on all their volunteers they make them go through mandated reporter if you go out there and google it you'll find like arkansas 4-h and a lot of other organizations that have any any relationship with children anybody that works with children even on a volunteer basis they want them to go through
the mandated reporter trained to have an understanding and awareness of what to look for when they do work with children and and so i you know i'm trying to i think i'm trying to keep on the curve and not get us behind the curve and trying to make sure that we do I'll even go as far as say I'm not one of those 39 mandated you know and people say well how do you become mandated reporter how do you do it what's involved well actually the state of Arkansas has a website which cost me absolutely nothing I actually went I've even got my certificate if I ever fall into one of the the categories I've actually got a certificate saying I've gone through mandated
reporter training took me less than an hour on the internet didn't cost me a penny to do Very easy, very simple. I mean, it's basically written, geared toward maybe someone with a high school education background. And it's very clear-cut, very easy for people to know what those bright-line standards should be about. Because I'll tell you this, up until I became a member of the General Assembly, I didn't even know we had a 1-800 hotline to call for child maltreatment. And this talks about what hotline to call, why you should call.
A lot of really good, clear, bright-line tests for me nowadays. And it also, you know, so often we always get in this situation where it's situational ethics. Well, you know, I'm sure somebody else will call in or somebody else will do something. Well, sometimes we need to basically make sure everybody that's involved with a nonprofit that's there, that in the normal ordinary course of business and they're dealing with children, that that needs to be the responsibility of that nonprofit to step up and make sure that people are aware of the law and follow the law. and that basically would be call the 1-800 number
and report the incident follow up Mr. Chair yes one follow up
Speaker 60
20:01
so Representative Bain and I'm sorry again if I missed it because again so clergy would they be exempt from child maltreatment or not exempt but also too as kind of a secondary question because you have other people that are hired by the church that are not that are not clergy it could be you know a secretary It could be, you know, there might be other positions within the church that they might not necessarily be a clergy.
And I'm trying to find out how that will affect them as far as this
law is concerned. And I would say in every church I've ever been dealt with, if it was a sexton or a secretary, they're all going to deal with kids in the church at some point or time. And they're going to see activities at the church. And these are some very basic warning signs in the train they ask you to look for. I promise you don't have to be a rocket scientist. I don't have a clinical medical background, but it was some very bright-line tests you could kind of look for and identify. But as for the clergy exemption, I'll defer to the commission so they can explain how they interpret it and how they treat that.
Speaker 74
21:04
Thank you for your question, Representative Meeks. If it's acceptable with you, I would like to just read the brief statement of how it exists currently in the Child Maltreatment Act related to clergy. So this is the way it's written in our existing code. A clergy member, which includes a minister, priest, rabbi, accredited Christian science practitioner, or other similar functionary of a religious organization, or an individual reasonably believed to be so by the person consulting him or her,
except to the extent the clergy member has acquired knowledge of suspected child maltreatment through communications required to be kept confidential pursuant to the religious discipline of the relevant denomination or faith or receive the knowledge of the suspected child maltreatment from the alleged offender in the context of a statement of admission. And so that's the way it's written currently. And when that was added in, excuse me, during the Huckabee administration, It was in 2003 or 2005 when we worked with a large group of clergy and folks from around the state to get input before we even brought that to anyone to have that added.
And clergy are one of the few professions on the list of mandated reporters, as it currently exists, that have an exception, that are given that very specific respect to have that exception that has to do with their religion and their faith. One of the other groups that has any sort of exception is attorneys ad litem. It's only within the function of their job. Most of the other folks, if you're a mandated reporter, you're a mandated reporter 24 hours a day. So the way Representative Bain proposes to change this is to move from, as it exists now,
which is currently only clergy in a church are considered mandated reporters by law, and he wants to add any other paid employee of the church. We're not adding volunteers. A lot of the professions, if you look at the list of mandated reporters, we have a lot of volunteers on this list. A lot of places where they have employees and volunteers, both the employee and the volunteer is listed. So this is increasing the number of people to the list, but it's not increasing the number of people to the list as much as it could be.
Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Thank you, and you answered several of my questions there. Just to be clear, so if we have teachers that are paid and who are very likely to have very extended relationships with those people in their congregation and they go into those homes and they know them well, now
Speaker 74
23:56
they're a mandated reporter. Yes, that's my understanding. I'm not sure that there's ever been an attorney general's opinion on it,
but it's my understanding that unless it's outlined specifically in the law that you have an exception, you're a mandated reporter. So, for instance, I've adopted three children from the state. I'm technically a licensed adoptive parent. If I see someone abusing a child or have reasonable cause to suspect that a child has been abused, I would be required by law to make that report directly to
the hotline. A short follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes. so in some of these churches there's not a real clear line other than the pay of what the job is
so there are a lot of volunteers doing the very same job that someone's paid for and someone in one classroom is a mandated reporter and the other one is not and there's no base salary for that so if they were to get reimbursed ten dollars or paid twenty dollars for working today, then they're now an employee? I'm
Speaker 74
25:01
not an attorney, so I'm not really sure how that would be determined as to whether or not they were considered an employee of the church.
Yeah, you know, I'm very in favor of what you're doing, so I'm not trying to throw a roadblock up. I'm just concerned about what happens in a church when people have a, by their belief, a desire to minister to folks and now we're changing that ministry role considerably. Well, I mean you've got
the exemption where the person presumes that they are in effect acting as a clergy then there still is that there's an exemption to
the mandated reporter on the clergy side and we really, you know I will say this, I had just as many people call me and say you ought to make it for volunteers and everybody else and I said well where do you find that you get on a real slippery slope when you start talking about volunteers versus somebody who draws a paycheck and and so we really tried to limit it just to people that are on staff who are already going to be in involved with and it's not and I first I want to make sure yes it does impact religious decisions but it's also secular institutions as well it's not
targeting you know we've tried to be very careful the way this this language is here that this is not to target a religious institution at all this is actually just throw out a broad blanket for all those employees of organizations and with the focus of children. Representative Feight, you recognize for question. Thank You Mr. Chair
and thank you Representative Bain for bringing this to us and I'm one of the ones who talked to you and said I thought every volunteer should be included. Everyone who comes
in contact with a child should be mandated to report suspected child abuse or neglect and so I thank you
for your bill. Thank you. Representative Mayberry, you're recognized. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Representative Bain. You know, we've had several discussions about this, and I have great concern that our nonprofits won't know about this, and you're now mandating something. So how are those nonprofits going to know that their employees need to, you know,
take the computer test that you mentioned and how are they going to know the definition of maltreatment and can you help me out with that? I would first say that first of
all to be a mandated reporter you don't have to have a law degree or you shouldn't be expected to have a law degree. We're trying to just determine standard black line tests and by the same token I think it'd be fair to say that we don't necessarily as a state send out letters to our other 39 mandated reporters saying oh by the way you you know they don't all get a certified letter saying you need
to be compelled to do this what we've got to do is just aggressively get the word out both through the media and through state channels through the commission and through associations out there there's several associations for non-profits and make sure that they get that word out when they get they do their various outreach on updates from the general assembly the goal here is not to play got you with any of them and you know we're not i'm not asking for any money to go around and have a mandated reporter check off police to make sure every single non-profit's doing this but we're
trying to raise the bar i think we've seen i think a lot of us have been frustrated with a lot of situational ethics going on and in our not only our country but our state where and this came from back in my district there was an instance where somebody basically should have done it should have should have addressed it and they didn't and it was what the their lack of action was inexcusable but they weren't technically covered under the 39 that we had but for all intents and purposes they were just as involved with non-profit with children as many of the other ones in the 39 that
are and so we wanted to make sure that that if we had anybody that was falling between the cracks in those 39 that were dealing with children non-profit they couldn't say well i wasn't specifically enumerated on here so I have an out. And that's what our
goal here is today. Representative Mayberry, you recognize
for one follow-up, please. If someone, you know, give you a scenario, they don't know that they have to report this and now something, you know, the child that was discovered that there was
some maltreatment or whatever, what's the penalty? What happens to that person who didn't report it and And they don't know that they were required to report. I mean, I would hope that we have people who want to report things, okay? But I'm also just trying to think outside the box and understand that sometimes people don't know. They don't understand that that's maltreatment. And they're not the nurses and the doctors and the teachers that go through all of the training and all that.
And I just fear someone who was trying to help in a situation and now they're in legal matters and didn't realize that they were going to get themselves into some legal trouble.
Can I answer your question with a little away from the chairman? Can I have Lisa McGee? She's an attorney with the Department of Human Services, and she knows this side of it far better than I ever would. Okay. And with Mr. Chairman's permission, I'd like to
have her answer that question. Ms. McGee, would you state your name and affiliation for the records, please?
Speaker 101
30:19
Yes, Lisa McGee. I'm an attorney with the Department of Human Services. With the exception of judges and prosecutors, if you're a mandated reporter, you have both civil and criminal liability if you are a mandated reporter and you fail to make a report. In the statute, failure to report in the first degree, if you have cause to do it and you knowingly fail to do it, it's a Class A misdemeanor. And then if you recklessly fail to do it, it's a Class C misdemeanor. so bottom so bottom
line if you if you know you have a responsibility and you fail to act
on knowingly willfully then you are going to be looking at civil and criminal penalties but but at the point though is you know there is going to be some that are going to say for whatever reason they didn't know they were a mandated reporter they didn't know to go through steps and the problem is that you've got is that they didn't have they didn't knowingly know that they were a mandated reporter and they didn't know they were acting recklessly under the code because they just and we always run into this problem where we have certain people that they just didn't realize they were covered under a section of the code and so it's going to look
at a little bit differently versus what they knew versus what they knew they were a mandated reporter and they just didn't care is totally different than I didn't know I was a mandatory reporter and I didn't even know to look for this and the
courts are going to look at that totally different Representative Brown, you're recognized Thank you, Mr. Chair I believe my question has been answered but I too am concerned about how we're going to get the word out to make sure that people are aware because I would think that that would be something that you would want to do
is to get that word out I think so and I'm sure the commission, that is one of their goals I mean, they're basically charged with trying to administer the mandated reporter system, and I'll let them speak a little bit
Speaker 74
32:20
about what they're doing to also communicate that to the program. Generally, what we do when we're successful in getting different professions added to the list of mandated reporters, it's interesting because that is a question that comes up every profession that gets added to this list, and it's a good question. What we generally do is try to find any statewide group or professional, if they have any sort of a board that they report to, that we can share this information with.
We also have 27 commissioners who are appointed by the governor, and we have several standing committees within the commission that all are from different parts of the state. We share information with them. We supervise the multidisciplinary teams around the state and work in conjunction with the children's advocacy centers. So we have those lines into local communities and we ask that they share the information. We currently have multidisciplinary teams in 63 of the 75 counties and they're made up of different professionals, mental health, medical, local law enforcement,
you know, those sorts of groups. So we share the information with them so that they can get that information out to other people. And I would say, I had a concern when we developed the mandated reporter training, how are we going to get this out there to people after we funded it with a federal grant? How are we going to get people to know that this program existed? And I can tell you that in the two years it's been online, through word of mouth and through the way we get information out to mandated reporters, we've had more than 21,000 people complete the training.
We've had more than 23,000 begin the training, but I can see from my reports how many have completed it. So it took me more than a decade working at the commission to get 10,000 people trained in person, and we trained more than 21,000 in less than two years. So I think it's a great question, but I really feel that it's
one we're willing to do everything we can to assist with. One follow-up? Yes. And I agree that there are many religious organizations that have either statewide or regional central offices that could be communicated through.
But I know we have a lot of smaller independent churches throughout Arkansas, and I'm just kind of concerned about them. And I
Speaker 74
34:38
completely understand your concern. I can tell you that the concern with someone failing to report, when we think about protecting the person who has failed to report, certainly if they just didn't know any better, they didn't know they were a mandated reporter, in order for something to actually happen to them, one of two things has to happen. You either have to have a prosecuting attorney who wants to file charges
and prosecute them for failing to report and feels that they can get people in their community to get on board with the fact that they should have known they were a mandated reporter and chose not to report or you have to have you can file a civil case for somebody failing to report and I contacted the prosecutor coordinator's office yesterday to find out if they could tell me how many prosecutors have actually charged someone in this state and it's one and I can tell you that
we've had mandated reporters in our state since the first capital federal capital law was passed which was in 79, so we've had one person prosecuted for failure to report since 1979, and it was a doctor. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Vaught, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I
want to thank you for this bill. One, I had a child in my district that fell through the cracks,
and I believe that the church staff wanted to report this child for this child but was scared to because they didn't know that they could or what actions would be taken against them if they did proceed. This went on for years and years for this young lady. She's now graduated from high school but because of all of that happening she went through a lot of eating disorders. She's been put into facilities for eating disorders because of the tragedy that happened and no one was there
to have her back because everybody was scared to go forward for her so I appreciate this bill highly um being someone who has been uh sexually abused myself as a young child I would think that we would want to do everything within our powers to help a young child who doesn't really know where to go or who their support system really is. And with that being said, also, everybody keeps talking about just churches, but this is every nonprofit, am I correct?
And for a follow-up, Mr. Chair, if that's all right. And I want to know, has the family council weighed in on this and what are their thoughts about this?
I think it's fair to say I've talked to Mr. Cox and others, and I think they're neutral in the current language. I think
Speaker 60
37:32
it's an amazing bill. Thank you. Representative Meeks. Thank you, and I appreciate the remarks by Representative Vaughn. It helps me feel a little bit better, you know, because, again, I think, in my opinion, yeah, they should be reported.
I guess me being the small government guy, I have a problem with the mandated part of it. But my question would be is, you know, do you think that this will have a negative effect in the case that folks that may want to come and get help, you know, for other reasons or maybe even for this, that they will not want to do it because of the fact that they are afraid that, you know, it will be, that they're, I'm sorry, I'm trying to grasp for words here.
and it's probably not coming out very well, that it will keep somebody from getting help in other aspects because they're not going to want to bring the child or whatever forward for fear that they're going to get reported. Maybe they're homeless and they need food or whatever and they're like, I don't want to go get food because I'm afraid if I do, then somebody might report me and
so therefore... Well, there's definitions of, and if you go through the training, which I went through, it explains.
Maybe that's what I need to do. Yeah, there's basically a difference between child maltreatment and just being a mediocre parent, and there is a difference there. And I look at my eyes, I take the most conservative viewpoint. I think it's all maltreatment, and I want to interject, and I can be a nosy guy back home. I've done this a few times where I've just kind of cut in. But, no, there are things that parents can do, have poor judgment, that is not child maltreatment. And so we're not – this doesn't try to re-legislate what maltreatment is.
And, actually, I think when people go through the training, they'll get an understanding that, yes, not – parents can behave poorly. You know, you've got – honey boo boo, by definition, was not child maltreatment, but I thought it was. But, you know, legally it's not. so you know it just you know so i'm yeah i understand where you're you know you don't want but but the bottom line is a a mandated reporter is not there to try to evaluate the situation beyond recognizing that we potentially have a problem and i've i've got that duty to report and then that's where the next steps come in and i'd be happy to turn it over ms mcgee to kind of
Speaker 101
40:03
follow up on that thank you churches are wonderful about providing food to families and we want them to continue going and, in fact, the definition of neglect in the Maltreatment Act says that we cannot say that someone has neglected their child if it's primarily caused by financial inability of the person who's legally responsible and no services for relief have been offered. So if we get a phone call that there's a family that went to a church to get food, we have to go out there and offer food ourselves. We cannot even find that report true for neglect if it's because people
don't have finances. So lack of resources in this state is not going to get you a true report on our hotline. What it does is get us out there to say what is it you need to
do to take care of your kids. Thank you.
Representative Rushing, did you have a question? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. We keep talking about the volunteers and all and who has to report and doesn't have to report. If they don't report, what is the maximum, and they were charged by the prosecuting attorney, what is the maximum penalty
Speaker 101
41:10
law, and I don't know. I know one of the misdemeanors is one year, I think, in county jail. But again, there's been one prosecution that I know of, and it
was a doctor. Yeah, I just worry that we're opening up the basis to that when we add more people in. I mean, I think it's a great bill, but I just, I'm concerned, so I
Speaker 101
41:29
just was wondering if we knew what the You'd have to prove the person recklessly or knowingly failed to call the hotline. And so you can't attach to them unless they knew they were a mandated reporter
and then recklessly or knowingly failed to do it. Okay, thank you. Representative Vaughn.
Motion at a proper time. Okay, thank you. If there are no further questions from the committee, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for this bill? Against this bill, Representative, are you recognized to make a motion on House Bill
1218 as amended? Motion do pass. As
motion do pass as amended. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed? Representative Bain, would you like to close? I will simply close Thank
you Mr. Chairman and thank you committee It did carry Thank you
without objection, we do have an amendment you need to sign for us. Yeah.
Speaker 144
43:21
Oh, how funny. So where's mine, Clark? I'm just picking Oh Oh, I'm sorry I'm sorry Okay
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. Essentially, the amendment just adds some language saying that we will send this information to the Secretary of State. She took the amendment. I don't have it in front of me. But it just added some additional language saying that we would – I'm sorry, let me – yeah, let me see.
House Resolution 1042 is what we're looking at. Yeah,
the amendment just adds some language saying that we support the effort to preserve fundamental rights, free media, and democratic principles in Turkey and to recognize the Turkish-American citizens' endeavor to improve ties between Arkansas and Turkey. And it said to support efforts to preserve fundamental rights of the media. And then whereas these arrests that have been made in Turkey by the media,
it recognizes that they have been falsely arrested and detained. and then on the back page it says with the adoption of the resolution an appropriate copy will be provided for the Secretary of State and Senator Boseman and Senator Cotton and the House of Representatives but and that's in addition then I can explain the I can explain the resolution after we've adopted the amendment I would appreciate a good vote on the amendment thank you Are there any questions on the amendment?
Okay. We'll entertain a motion on the amendment. Representative Sturge, you're recognized. Motion to adopt, Mr. Chair. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. All in favor, vote aye. Opposed? The amendment has been adopted. Now we'll hear House Resolution 1042 as amended.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. i i've had the pleasure of going to turkey a couple of times and my older daughter actually
studied in istanbul and in the audience today i have a couple of my friends from turkey we actually have a small turkish community in little rock and a turquoise council that represents turkey and azure bijon and um representing mcgill and i had the pleasure of going to turkey together and I've been very I don't know if you followed the press but I've been very disturbed by President Erdogan and the suppression of the press and the arrest of journalists and
even last week a journalist was arrested for tweeting and their suppression of social media so Congress sent a similar letter that French Hill signed to the Secretary of State and Representative Bozeman, I mean Senator Bozeman and Senator Cotton are in the process of signing a letter and sending it to Secretary of State to oppose the human rights violations and the suppression of the press in Turkey as well. I'll just read you a little. It says, Turkey is our long-standing ally. As you know, Turkey has been democratic. We have bases there
and they have been one of our true friends in the Middle East with all of the conflict going on. And when Representative McGill and I were there, we had an opportunity to see where they were doing food distribution programs for the Syrian refugees. They've housed hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees and have been a real friend to the U.S. And so that's why all of these actions by Erdogan and the Turkish government are so concerning to us at this point. It says, Turkey's our longstanding ally, a key North Atlanta treaty organization member, and a strategic partner in the Middle East.
Whereas a strong democracy requires both tolerance and transparency in recent decisions by the Turkish government to intimidate other opposition voices and threats to democratic principles that Turkey has previously upheld. Under the leadership of President Erdogan, the Turkish government has become increasingly authoritarian as it detains journalists, suppresses political dissidents, and completely disregards the rule of law and fundamental democratic precepts in Turkey.
Turkey has become one of the top countries for detained journalists and restricted access to social media. The recent arrests by members of the Turkish media are alarming, and detained members of the Turkish media have ties to known critics of the Erdogan administration. Whereas this is a chilling effect on freedom, democracy, and economic principles in Turkey. The free media must be supported, protected, and fostered as an environment for open to constructive political discussion and to ensure
freedom of expression. And like I said, the amendment says that we will send this letter to the Secretary of State just as the Congress has done. I appreciate a good vote if you have questions. Thank you. Are there
any questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience that would like to speak for this resolution? Come forward and state your name and affiliation for the records. Thank you
very much. My name is Mehmet Ulupunar. I'm a volunteer for the Turkish
Council of Americans and Eurasians. I was one of the two guys in the group that went to Turkey in 2013. And back then there were street protests in Istanbul. And as people defending the current government, we said, these are just street governments. These are just people, young people. But it turned out that those people were right and I was wrong. Now our government in Turkey has made a dramatic U-turn from all the democratic
principles and today I appreciate representative Ferguson to bringing this up and as Turkish Americans in the state we work hard to promote relations between Arkansas and Turkey and we do our best thank you very much for your support. Thank you. Representative Ferguson, would you like to close
for your bill? I'm closed. I
appreciate a good vote. Okay. Chair will entertain a motion. Representative Petty, you recognized we have a motion to pet we have a motion to pass as amended as a minute all in favor vote aye opposed the motion the bill has passed thank you mr. chairman thank you committee
Representative Petty, are you prepared to present your bill? You are
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. This is House Bill 1719, and I really, really like this bill. I don't know if you guys all knew this about me, but way back in the day, I was a paramedic for about eight years,
and I was down in the ditch and down in the rain and starting IVs in the crud. What this bill does basically is if a paramedic or an EMT is killed in the line of duty, that much like the military or the firefighters that the Department of Health may present them the family of the deceased with a flag and I just think it's really the right thing to do Representative Link brought this to me and I kind of fell in love with it so if there's any questions
I would take them we get a lot of flags to give away and and so that's all I have for that so any questions okay any questions from committee no questions from committees
and anyone in the audience that would like to speak for this bill against if not the chair will entertain a motion representing Bart you recognized we have a motion to pass all in favor vote aye opposed you passed your bill thank you
Thanks. Representative Lowry, we saw you walk in. Would you be available to present House Resolution 1033?
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, committee, for accommodating me. um this house resolution uh actually stemmed from an original bill that i had that would
direct the administrative courts the families the child support chart is revised or at least is looked at my understanding every four years supreme court appoints a committee and they look at it. And the original bill was to direct the committee to look at the income shares concept of child support, which looks at the income of both parents, the custodial parent and the
non-custodial parent. Currently, our system really only looks at the income of the non-custodial parent. And about 35 other states look at income shares. After I filed the bill, I was contacted by Judge Mackey Pierce, who's been appointed by Justice Hanna to head up the committee to look into the revision of the chart. And he indicated to me at that time that the committee is working towards the income shares concept. I think it's still important. In my conversation
with them. I told them I understood that there would not be possibly any need for legislation if that's the way they're working. But I still think that there is a necessity for the legislature to send an affirmation to the committee and to the Supreme Court that we think that this is the proper approach and this is a good direction for them to take. And so that's why I've actually have pulled down the bill. I think I've actually already withdrawn it and instead had it redrafted as a resolution. So that is an explanation of the resolution.
Okay. Thank you. Representative Johnson, you're recognized. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. I have a question. When you talk about shared, are we talking about the biological mother and father, or are we talking about the spouses of the biological mother and father that's also included in that
sharing process? My understanding is looking at the income of the biological parents, the custodial parents. And not their spouses. Correct. And even the non-custodial parent, even if they are dramatically out-earned by the custodial parent,
they still will have skin in the game. They will still be expected
to contribute. Any other questions from committee? Yes, Representative
Brown, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, I don't know if this is germane to your bill, But one of the things that has concerned me in talking with generally been women, but it could pertain to men also,
is that oftentimes the non-custodial parent will be working in a way that their income is not properly reported. and that I think that would present a great deal of I think that could be a problem for you know the custodial parent that's got a legitimate job files their income taxes has a regular paycheck and all that when you've got somebody else
that's working like an independent contractor and getting paid cash under the table they might be making considerably more money So, anyhow, I just want to express that concern. I don't know really if I'm opposed to your bill or not because I'm not, but that is a big concern for me. Well, it is an issue
that's tangential to this, and Judge Pierce has indicated to me that one of the other areas that they're going to be looking at is looking at gross income rather than net income because of that very issue that you've talked about.
Someone who's an independent contractor is able to, you know, work out that, well, I have expenses that totally offset my gross income, so I have a net net of zero. And my understanding from Judge Pierce is that that is one of the revisions that's going to take place is looking at gross
income. Follow-up. Yes. In my own situation with my former husband, who's the father of our son, he got paid
I mean he was a business owner a partial business owner and I had no way to prove it but he was still able to keep a roof over his head and eat and what have you and it was obvious to me that he was getting paid under the table in unreported income so that is an additional concern that I don't know how the judge would ever deal with that but those are legitimate concerns that custodial parents are facing.
Representative Johnson, you're recognized. Motion in the proper time, sir. Are there any more questions from committee? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for this resolution, against it? Representative Johnson, you're recognized. I make a motion to do pass. We have a motion do pass. All in favor say aye. Opposed? Your resolution has passed. Thank you, Representative Lowry. Thank you, committee, and thank you, Chairman.
Representative Scott, are
you ready to present your bill? you're recognized thank you mr. chair good morning committee now you all
do know this is my favorite
committee and I don't say that just to get you to pass this very good bill that I'm bringing to you Honestly, you are my favorite committee, okay? Having said that, I'd like to introduce, if I may, Mr. Chair, two very dear friends of mine from Rogers, Arkansas. Is that okay? If you intend
to testify, we'd like for you to state your name and affiliation for our records. Would you please? My
Speaker 176
1:00:28
name is Thomas Dunlap. I am the State Legislative Affairs Director for the Arkansas Society of Human Resource Management.
Speaker 179
1:00:34
Okay. Thank you for being here. Good morning, Mr. Chair. I'm Corporal Eric Madkin. I'm a Veterans
Advocate and Leadership Fellow with the RAC and Afghanistan Veterans of America.
Glad you're here, Captain Corporal, and thank you for your service. You may proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Veterans returning from active duty identify finding a job as their greatest challenge to transitioning to civilian life. Nearly 35% of working military spouses require a license or certification for their chosen profession,
but are more likely to have moved across state lines in the last year instead of staying here in Arkansas. We lose many fine servicemen and their spouses annually to other states. In addition to their spouses, we also lose their children, children who would attend Arkansas schools, children who would be assets to Arkansas schools, bright, smart, wonderful children. House Bill 1723 that I present to you today will keep our servicemen and their families home here in Arkansas.
Let's give our servicemen and women, along with their spouses and their children, the welcome home they all truly deserve. Giving consideration of military training and experience as a substitute for state-issued credentials is the right thing to do. Our veterans can return home, get to work, and build a future for themselves and their families. We owe this to them. Aaron Macon, Corporal Aaron Macon, who is here with me today, went to high school with my two boys and one of our daughters.
My notes today are written on college-ruled notebook paper for a reason, because while my boys and my daughter were in college, my dear friend Aaron was going through very different trials. And I bring him here today to literally put a face to this bill to show you the challenges that these young folks have when they come home. There's not a Thanksgiving or a Christmas that goes by when we say our blessings at our dinner table
that Aaron Mankin and his family are not mentioned. Let me get back on track now. I am so proud of this bill. I'm so very proud of this bill. And with your permission, Mr. Chair, could I ask Aaron to say a few words to this committee? Yes, Aaron. Thank you,
Speaker 179
1:03:24
Mr. Chair, and to the committee for giving me time to share briefly a bit of my story,
which really in my heart translates as more of our story. I haven't grown up and been educated here in the state of Arkansas, and now being a single father of two kids here doing the exact same, And I see how far I've come through my military service in the Marine Corps. And what I did in the Marine Corps as a combat correspondent, as a journalist, having a camera in one hand or a rifle in the story, it was my job to tell the Marine Corps story. And I loved it.
I tell people I had the best job in the Marine Corps because I got to see every angle. I got to see all corners and everything that the Marine Corps did, everything that we had our hands in to complete the mission. And I'm thankful for that. in conducting combat operations near the syrian border the vehicle that i was in struck an improvised explosive device wounding myself and and killing six marines some fathers all sons giving all that they could for our nation and everywhere that i go now that i'm home
and in the loving arms of my country i i find that everyone wants to say thank you And I'm amazed by how much of my life has taken up, affording other people the opportunity to do that very thing, to just say thank you. Some people want to shake my hand. Some people want to hug my neck. Some people want to buy me a beer. In some cases, want to give me facial reconstruction and fix my face as part of a program out at UCLA Medical Center called Operation Mend, where I had the opportunity to be the first patient
that really bridged the gap between public and private sector health services to afford active duty service members to fly out to UCLA and receive the best plastic surgery that our nation has to offer. And what I see is the removing of obstacles to allowed services for veterans as soon as they return home to make that transition as easy as possible. And what I found is that my transition, while having its own challenges,
was relatively easy compared to most who come home and struggle to find job placement. And what I see that this bill does and what these amendments do is alleviates that and gives people here in the state of Arkansas an opportunity to say thank you in the most meaningful way possible and to provide employment and security for those who return home to say thank you. And that's something that I feel like here in the state of Arkansas just comes naturally. Thank you for your time. Thank you.
Are there any questions from committee? Representative Brown, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. as an Air Force dependent who grew up in the Air Force. That's what I mean by that. Currently an Air Force dependent married to an Air Force retiree. But when my father, I just want to lend some support to what you're saying. When my father retired from the Air Force, we were living in Jacksonville, Arkansas,
Arkansas being his home state, so he wasn't going anywhere. He found it extremely difficult after having a stellar career to find a decent paying job to support his five kids. And I fully support this bill. But he did eventually use his GI Bill and attend ASU and get a degree in agronomy and went back to work for the health department. And when he retired from the health department,
He went into business for himself, so I just want to say that we owe our military veterans a big thank you, and we do need to give them credit for their military careers because my dad had an unblemished, I think, 23-year career in the Army Air Corps and then in the Air Force, so
I applaud this bill. Thank you, Representative Wallace, you recognize the question?
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Hoo-ah, Corporal. My company hires as many veterans as we can find. They make great employees. I can tell those guys that I need you at 0200 hours on a Sunday morning and they'll be there. sometimes some of the folks I hire can't show up at mid-noon on a Monday I can attest
that after the Vietnam era it was very difficult for veterans with a lot of good training to find anything and this bill will help the training that the military gets is unsurpassed they have leadership training they have skill training and I've been a COO in a corporate world, I own my own company I could not afford the training that are
given to our military folks, they're really good people and this is a real good bill and I guess I would end up
Speaker 142
1:09:08
by saying don't you agree yes, yes Representative Representative Fyte okay
thank you is there any more questions from committee Representative Tucker I just want to add my thanks to the
course of everyone else all the thanks
that you deserve and I'm sure everyone on the committee agrees with me so thank you very much doesn't everyone agree
thank you for your question I'm sorry is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for this bill against the bill represents Scott would you like to close for your bill yes mr. chair
thank you thank you so much Aaron and thank you so much Thomas you have given me the opportunity to be an integral part of what I now pray will be two very important life-changing bills for our veterans here in Arkansas. I ran a bill my first session that was a veterans employment preference bill that Walmart, Sam's, J.B. Hunt and Tyson tout and I'm hoping that this companion bill will
mean just as much to our veterans as that bill did. Many of us campaigned pledging to do our part to keep jobs in Arkansas. House Bill 1723 which I speak of today will do just that. The best part of this bill however will be to send a very important message to our service people. We want you to come home to Arkansas and we want you to stay in Arkansas. Thank you committee. Thank you
Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Meeks, did you have a
question I think that would go to reps in a fight we saw her hand first reps in a fight to recognize for motion please thank you mr. chair motion to pass we have a motion to pass all in favor vote aye opposed you passed your bill thank you very much represent Scott and thank both of you for being here with us today.
If there is no other business before the committee, we adjourn.
Agenda
HR1040
HB1523
HB1218
HR1042
HB1719
HR1033
HB1723
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative John T. Vines
Unverified
Representative George B. McGill Chair
Unverified
Representative DeAnn Vaught
Unverified
Representative Dan Sullivan
Unverified
Speaker 19
Representative Bob Johnson
Unverified
Speaker 32
Speaker 7
Representative Clarke Tucker
Unverified
Representative Karilyn Brown
Unverified
Representative John Baine
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 60
Speaker 74
Speaker 66
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Representative Julie Mayberry
Unverified
Speaker 101
Speaker 119
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Speaker 129
Speaker 132
Speaker 138
Speaker 140
Speaker 144
Representative Deborah Ferguson
Unverified
Mehmet Ulupunar
Unverified
Representative Rebecca Petty
Unverified
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Representative Sue Scott
Unverified
Speaker 176
Speaker 179
Representative Dave Wallace
Unverified
Speaker 142