House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (4)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1233
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1233”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1347
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1347”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1687
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1687”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1737
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “you, Mr. Chairman. Committee, I'll bring back to you House Bill 1737, which basically is the enabling legislation for Amendment…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Speaker 5
0:12
you, Mr. Chairman. Committee, I'll bring back to you House Bill 1737, which basically is the enabling legislation for Amendment 1 that was passed by the voters in November. And Representative Link had a question that I agreed to answer And by doing that, if this chair will permit, I'll ask Ms. Garrett, Marty Garrett, to come and join me at the end of the table.
Ms. Garrett, if you would, identify yourself for the record. You're recognized. 1737. Thank you,
Speaker 10
0:41
Mr. Chair. I'm Marty Garrett. I'm with the Bureau of Legislative Research. Just let me begin with our normal statement that we have, which is I've been asked by Representative Branscom to explain certain aspects of the bill to this committee. However, the Bureau is a nonpartisan impartial, and as an employee of the Bureau, I cannot advocate for or against this bill or issues presented by this bill. As I understand, the question had to do with emergency rules and provisions for agencies
to promulgate emergency rules if approval is required. On page 5, line 24, beginning at line 24, and on page 10, beginning at line 15, It's the same language, but it provides for emergency rule either by ALC or by signatures of the chair. This is similar to actions, the authority that the chairs of ALC currently have with regards to emergency rules of contracts
or rules, other issues that are brought before ALC subcommittees when there is not time to present it to the full ALC committee. and so there's a provision already that allows the chairs to sign off on an action by an emergency action and then it's reported to the full ALC at the next meeting. Representative Lane, does that address your
question? You're recognized for a question. All right, Ms. Garrett.
Speaker 14
2:13
So let's say that there's an emergency in the agriculture community and they need to use a certain pesticide immediately. They don't have time for the rules, understandable circumstance, so they do this, but what happens then? Is it eventually brought forward for the rule to be approved, for the past procedure to be approved, or what happens afterwards? And what's the time frame they have
Speaker 10
2:39
in there with regards to the currently emergency rules last for 120 days.
the chairs in the approval can determine the length of that emergency rule and then they would still need to go before the rules committee for the full implementation of the final rule our chair potentially could and
Speaker 14
3:00
this would obviously not hopefully never happen they could potentially approve a rule for five years an emergency rule they could potentially, but
voted on by the full council, from my understanding. Is that right?
Are there additional questions for members? Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Branscombe, and I think this has been addressed or there have been questions about this before or Marty, either one, to answer this about the
State Highway Commission, State Highway Department, and Arkansas Game and Fish Commission Game and Fish Department. Are they included in this? Yes, they are. Under this? Yes, they are. Okay. And you, can I ask one follow-up? But you had some discussions with those agencies. I mean, it is constitutional and all of that. Did you get those clear?
Speaker 5
4:14
Yes I have and I've talked to the highway department and I've tried to from the chair's
perspective of AOC it is my intention of working with these agencies that game of fish and highway I mean I don't believe that when people voted for this that they intended for this thing to get down to a nitpicking thing to mess with little stuff. But if there's something major that would come along and the highway department wanted to do something big or whatever, and before they could just go ahead and do it, which is fine in most places at times, and I'm sure that 99.9% of the time the council will go along with what they see best
because they are the experts in the field, but they will have to bring it before council and let the legislators hear it and then we'll vote on it, as it probably should be in a lot of our opinions. But in no shape, form, or fashion are we looking to micromanage these agencies because they are under constitutional authority, but it's my understanding with the passage of this bill that with this constitutional amendment that it does then give the legislature some authority to have some review
over a lot of these rules that would be implemented.
Okay, thank you. Additional questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone from the public here to speak for or against the
Speaker 5
5:46
bill? Representative Branscombe, would you like to close for your bill? Well, Ms. Garrett just brought up on concern in Representative Lynx that there is a timeline of 120 days for the emergency rule, so that's as long as it could go.
Yes, sir. I am closed for the bill. All right. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Walker moves do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Branscombe. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. All right. Next up, we have Representative De La Rosa to present HB 1233. Representative De La Rosa, you are recognized
Thank you, Mr. Chair I've actually spoken to, I think every single person on this committee in advance about this bill, so there shouldn't be any big surprises here for anyone. What this bill will do is require statewide and district candidates that follow the Secretary of State's office to file their campaign finance reports online. Currently, you can file either on paper or
online, and the problem that that's causing today is that when you file on paper, while the report itself goes into a database and is reviewable, the contents of the report are not included in the Secretary of State's database for donations, and it's therefore not searchable. So So there's about 3,500, 3,600, somewhere around there, filings during an election period. And if you want to search for, say, who all Joe Smith gave money to during the election cycle,
there's no way to do that right now because the database is incomplete. And if we all file online, then that database will be complete, and that type of information will be transparent. We're in the unique situation where the granular data is available to everyone, so if I want to know what Trevor Drown has done, I can pull his reports and look at it, but the 30,000-foot view is not available. It's just too cumbersome for people to have to search through manually all of those documents.
Just some details about it. This will require carryover reports and campaign contribution expenditure reports to be filed online. This does not include statement of financial interest. That's kind of a unique report for each individual, so there's really no reason I saw to roll that into it. It will become effective on October the 1st of this year, which is a quarter-ending date, So it makes it very clear, so it gives everyone time, if this passes, to get an ID and get used to the system before they have to start filing.
And it's a downtime for campaign reporting, so you're not going to have to do it in the middle of a campaign or anything. You can start when you have just a couple of donations, hopefully, to report. And that's the part that I spoke to everybody else about at the beginning of this. So that's everything I think that you guys already know about this report. or about this bill. So what I want to cover is the amendments that I added to it in the meantime, and that's actually why it's been delayed so long in coming to this committee, is I wanted to make sure that everybody was happy
with it. So I've added a couple of amendments to it because there were some concerns from some legislators about different portions. One amendment that was added to it is an exception for anybody that doesn't have the technology or internet reliability to be able to file online because when you're filing you have to be connected to the system for a lengthy period of time and there was concern from several house members and also over in the senate that there are some areas of arkansas where you cannot stay online for a
long enough period of time to be able to follow this report so there is an exception for that in there and it will be in the form of an affidavit that the candidate will file with each paper filing. They just get it notarized and they simply have to state they do not have the ability to file online that it presents a hardship. And it will go with each paper filing and that will be posted online. The reason for that is is because the purpose of this is to have a complete database and if you don't know what's not included in the database it's kind of useless. So these will be
posted online so the folks that are searching the database will know exactly which reports are not in there and then they can go search through those manually. And hopefully it'll be just a few but you need to have that distinction out there so people know what isn't isn't included. The other piece of it is an upgrade to the system. And this one's kind of tricky. It is contingent upon funding. It's very specific. If the funding is not provided and the funding will be provided through GIF, which we know is not always dependable
but if the funding isn't provided for this then it will not happen but what the upgrade is is the ability to upload multiple transactions at the same time which is not a capability we have today and for those of us in this room it's not terribly inconvenient for us not to be able to do that because you know we don't have thousands of records to upload but this applies to the governor as well and those types of races they do have a tremendous number of donations and expenditures
to report and it can become very cumbersome for them so this is kind of the I call it the governor's upgrade but I've built that into it and and I'll be going around with my 10 cup later asking for GIF donations I'll be passing the basket around so if anybody wants to donate to that but the secretary of state wanted to make sure that they didn't get stuck with something that they would have to implement with no funding. So that's why that's contingencies in there. And I think that covers all of it. So
if anybody has any questions, I'll be happy to answer
them. Representative Ballinger, you're in the queue for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. This is something I've asked you about, and I don't, I mean, I was looking in the amendments to see if it would address my concern. But I have an old accountant who's been working with me for a long time. great guy who is a really sharp guy, and I use him because I want to make sure everything's done right. However, what he does is fill out a paper form and fax it in. He's, you know, I can't hardly
get him to check his email. I have to call him still. You know, I don't expect him to be, he's an old dog. I don't expect him to learn new tricks, but incredible accountant. In this case, would I qualify as a hardship because of the fact that I work with an accountant who doesn't want to file online. Whether or not you consider it
a hardship is going to be up to you. There's going to be no review of that. It's not going to be up to the Secretary of State or the Ethics Commission or anyone else to determine
whether or not you truly have a hardship. However, these will be viewed by the public so it's kind of got its own police system in it in that you're going to have to be able to verify to others that are looking at this that you have a hardship so if you can explain that it is a hardship and you feel that people will agree with you then you're certainly available to do that and if you don't mind can
you can you point out the section where it deals with does it specifically list what the hardships are no it doesn't
specific what you have to do is you fill out an affidavit and it says you'll submit with each paper report a notarized
affidavit declaring that and there are two two declarations that are included in that one the the candidate does not have access to the technology necessary to submit reports in electronic form, and submitting reports in electronic form would constitute a substantial hardship for the candidate. Okay, so
in this case, I mean, if, you know, since I personally probably have the bandwidth in my office to do it, I wouldn't, that exception probably wouldn't qualify for me, and I would even say my accountant probably has the bandwidth, but yet, you know,
he's not not using I mean I would either at this point either have to you know beg him to learn how to use this new system which will probably cost me more money because it's going to take him some time or find a new accountant to take care of it that would be my
recommendation yes thank you all right uh representative ladyman you're recognized for question that was the same
question okay uh representative hickerson thank you mr chairman um the and you may have stated
this but i just pulled up the fiscal impact a hundred thousand dollars would be all that would be needed for upgrades yes and that
is contingent uh upon funding it'll be gif funding and i'd gone to the secretary of state and asked him to just give a ballpark as to what it would cost to to provide this upgrade, and it was in the $50,000 to $100,000 was the range. So it's $100,000. Motion
at the proper time, Mr. Chairman. All right. Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question.
Yes, thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Perhaps had we spoken in advance, you could have answered this question. I know in the court system, which has gone electronic in recent years, Many times there are glitches in the system that are not the fault of the sender, and many times persons may experience technical difficulties on the last day.
Do you have an exception for those kinds of situations here? And if a person, the second part of it is if a person has the technology and can do this and doesn't do that, what is the punishment for it?
It might be easier. Graham Sloan, director of the Ethics Commission, is here. If the chair would allow, I think he could answer that first question with more authority than I can. Mr. Sloan,
if he's here, is welcome to provide information for the committee.
Mr. Sloan, if you would, identify yourself for the
record and who you're with. Thank you, Graham Sloan, director of the Arkansas Ethics Commission. Those type of situations, the technology glitches or problems like that, those are already encountered with faxing. People try to fax stuff in on the deadline. And the way the law is written, the commission doesn't have to impose a sanction if good cause is shown.
And so if there was a glitch in the system and just, for example, it was adding numbers up for you and it came up with an incorrect total and there was a complaint that your total is incorrect, Well, if it was, you know, if the system had incorrectly added those numbers, then, you know, the commission would find that would be good cause shown for the violation and there wouldn't be a sanction imposed. And so I don't think that electronic filing would, I mean,
and those type problems are already being encountered with, you know, filing by fax. If I may, Mr.
Chair. Go ahead, Representative Walker. Thank you. And that, Mr. Sloan, in all due respect, doesn't answer my question. Let's assume that your office does not have the capacity to accept a filing on the last day. And a filing is attempted, and it's several days. Let's assume this is on a Friday afternoon, and you all can't do it on a Friday, and a person gets it in on a Monday or Tuesday.
Do you put the burden on the person for your office's glitch in that hypothetical I've just set
forth? Well, the filing system is actually maintained in the Secretary of State's office, so the filing would not be made with us. But I think if it was shown that the system was down and somebody had attempted to file during that period of time, then that would be good cause shown. And it could be an ice storm that had brought telephone lines down. We've had that situation before where people in an entire region had lost electricity
and therefore couldn't submit a filing in that inclement weather would be good cause shown. But
the burden is going to be upon the person who sought to make the filing rather than upon the agency for the, let me just use the word, ineptitude of its facilities to receive the documentation. I think it
would, I mean, if it was just, if the entire system was down and everybody's was filed three days late,
I think that there would be readily apparent something had gone wrong. But if it was just one person that had some sort of glitch, then it might be upon them to bring forward the reason that it was late. But it's all within your discretion or the agency's discretion. Representative Walker.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Your couple questions passed your limit, so.
The answer wasn't responsive, but that's fine.
I'm satisfied with this answer. There was a second part to my question that Representative Della Rosa was going to answer herself. Well, let's see if anyone
else has a question. If not, I'll come right back to you. Does anybody, any other member of the committee have a question for Representative Orr or Mr. Sloan? All right, Representative Walker, go ahead. Well, the question
was already posed, and she brought Mr. Sloan up for one part of it. Could you answer the second part of it? I don't
even recall what the second part was at this point. Can you repeat it for me, please?
The question, quite frankly, I can't, so I'd have to. So since I can, I'll ask you privately, but I think that you had indicated earlier that you had spoken with everybody beforehand about our concerns, and you missed me. I did miss you. I had tried to call you, and I didn't end up leaving a voicemail, and I think you
were the only one that I wasn't able to speak to prior to this. That's why I said most. I knew there was one or two that I hadn't got to speak to.
I understand. All right. Are there additional questions from the committee? Representative Fite.
Representative, you said you were going to do this with general improvement funds? Yes, sir. Okay. When will they be available? It'll probably be if we actually
get any. And it is not just me. Senator Woods is on this as well, and he's committed that he'll put money towards this. So between the two of us, we're looking to fund this. And like I said, if anybody else wants to put any money in, I'll certainly take it.
But it will probably be close to August before you know for sure whether or not you're getting anything. And that's why there's no deadline set on when they have to do it, except for towards the end of the fiscal session. And the Secretary of State's office had asked to make sure that there was a sunset for this, that it doesn't hang out there for five years and somebody says, oh, you know, now you have this obligation to do it and there's no funding. So they had wanted to put a sunset in there. But you have through the entire biennium to fund it and implement it.
Thank you. All right. Additional questions from members? I have Representative Holcomb. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I
think she already answered. and I talked to you about this, my concern was those that were in real rural areas that don't have computer access. Did I understand you right to say that you had covered that in the bill, that they would?
Yes, sir. You weren't the only one that had that concern. Yes, you file a notarized affidavit. And if you're filing on paper, you already have to get the paper filing notarized.
So this is not anything. You already have to go to a notary already. that just verifies that you are claiming you don't have access. And the reason for that is because the Secretary of State's office didn't want to have to try to make that determination on a case-by-case basis. It's more of on the honor system. If you say you don't and you're willing to put your name to it, then it's on you. I'm not crazy
about it, but I'm saying I'm on the bill, so I'm guessing I'm coming from it.
Additional questions from the committee? All right, anyone from the public here to speak for or against the bill? Mr. Speaker, you're recognized to speak for the
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. I come here today to speak on behalf of this bill and really on behalf of the efforts that Representative De La Rosa has put into this bill. She approached me back around orientation week.
This had been something that the governor and lieutenant governor and other individuals had spoken about on the campaign trail, and we discussed it. And since that time, she has worked, I think, very diligently to try to address the concerns that not only our body but the Senate and the governor's office and other constitutional officers had on any kind of problems that existed maybe with some of the previous ideas that were existing in the bill. She's done a great job of trying to meet with everybody to address those concerns.
I applaud those efforts. She did it the right way and brings you a bill I think that is a very good bill. I think it does something that most of us are all doing anyway. And I know that there are a few instances, like Representative Ballinger's, you know, that he mentioned earlier with his accountant, and it may require the accountant to do a paper version and then hand it off to Representative Ballinger and then Representative Ballinger did the typing in. And there's some things that might change a little bit on this. But I think this is one of those changes that's good for us.
I think it's good to be able to be as transparent as we can. I know this body to be of the utmost, you know, with integrity and ethical standards. And I think that this will just be one of those methods that will prove that. So I'm very much in favor of this bill and would ask that you support it. I
guess I'll turn my mic on. It'd work better. Questions for the speaker?
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. I thought at first that was the beginning of a question there. All right. Is there anyone else here from the public speaking for or against the bill? Seeing none,
Representative Dolorosa, you're recognized to close for your bill. Just to add to it, this is about transparency for the people of Arkansas. It's a small step that we can take on our end. And, again, it's not that anybody in this body is trying to not be transparent. We individually already are extremely transparent, even with the paper filings.
Everybody knows that there's nothing that we report in here that somebody, if they want to come after us, can't already do. I mean, we are individually very transparent. What we're trying to achieve here is transparency for the overall system, which is inadvertently, I believe, been ignored in the past, and we need to move forward. It's 2015. It's electronic filing. We've had the capability for a while. I think it's time to move towards that so that we get transparency in our political system.
And I would certainly appreciate a good vote. All
right, Representative Hickerson, you had a motion? Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I move to pass. Is there discussion on the
motion? All right, seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Call the roll. Chair, call for the roll.
Yes, I'm not sure that there
Speaker 92
26:46
are 11 votes for the bill. Representative Link? Yes. Representative Wardlaw? Representative Wardlaw? Representative Hickerson? Yes. Representative Walker? Yes. Representative Douglas? Representative Ritchey? Representative Ritchey? Representative Magee? Yes. Representative Dotson? Representative Dotson? Representative Armstrong? Representative Armstrong?
Representative Miller? Representative Miller? Representative Holcomb Representative Ballinger Representative Ladyman Representative Drown Representative Gray Representative Gray Representative Tosh Representative Tosh Representative Height Representative Bennett Representative Womack Yes Mr. Del Rosso, your
bill received nine votes.
Let's hear your point of order. No, sir. The question was not a quorum. The question was, were there 11 votes for
the bill? The chair did not hear 11 votes for the bill. there were not two hands or a roll call that is correct and and when you called for a roll call it was to determine whether or not there was a quorum no
sir representative Walker the it is the discretion of the chair when the chair is unable to determine if there was a sufficient majority for the passage of a bill that the chair can direct staff to call the roll. That is always a discretion the chair always has been that's entirely in order. I disagree I don't
know that there's a rule that says that could you draw my attention to that rule Mr. Bell? If
you'd like we can get the parliamentarian to take that up Alright
now if we didn't have a quorum then we don't have enough people
here to conduct any further business and I suggest that we adjourn. We do We have a
quorum present, Representative Walker. Would you like to get the parliamentarian here to address? Well, no. You can do it
later. I'm not going to obstruct in that sense. All right. Representative Dillard, so your bill fails. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, committee. Let's see. Where's the list? All right. Is Representative Bentley here for House Bill 1405?
All right. Representative Ballinger, are you planning to run 1687? Yes, please. All right. You're recognized. Present 1687. Thank you.
thank you mr. chair and this is something that a friend of mine brought to me and brought to my attention it is actually came up as an issue in a in a referendum that was brought there was actual litigation on it and and judge Lindsay and in Washington County basically said this is an issue it's it's the way he ruled but he said this is an issue that needs to be addressed by legislature and so this is an attempt to address it just basically provide some
clarity so there are three ways that the public in a municipality gets an opportunity to vote on the city ordinance one is if the ordinance is actually referred out to the people from the City Council one is if the the citizens actually initiate the ordinance themselves so it's initiated ordinance or if there's a referendum on ordinance that are is already passed and what this does is it just clarifies what the language on the ballot will be if it's a referred out ordinance it's going to be for or against the ordinance if it is initiated ordinance by the
public then it's going to be for or against the initiated ordinance if it's a referendum it's going to be for or against repeal of that ordinance and so it just offers a little clarity on that issue so if you if you uh you know look through it it it isn't exactly under easy to to read through and understand unless you're thinking about that process of what the actual ballot titles are going to be, and I'd be happy to take any questions about this.
All right, Representative Ballinger, unfortunately, we do not have a quorum present, and we're not going to be able to transact further business. Okay, that's fine. Thank you very much. With that, folks, for lack of a quorum, we stand adjourned. No.
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Speaker 5
Speaker 10
Speaker 14
Speaker 9
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Graham Sloan
Unverified
Representative Lanny Fite
Unverified
Representative Mike Holcomb
Unverified
Representative Jeremy Gillam
Unverified
Speaker 92