House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (6)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1687
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1687”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1440
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1440”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1405
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1405”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1688
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1688”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1788
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1788”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB743
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…orum. Representative Bentley, you are recognized to present Senate Bill 743. Thank you, Chairman”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
it's amended and ready to refer we're going to wait till Friday morning at 9 a.m. to have the final vote on our referrals on the amendments so no amendments will be heard this afternoon I'm sorry that we didn't get that out to you all earlier it we had a couple issues with timing and so with that we're going to take up regular bills for the rest of this afternoon's agenda
All right, Chair sees a quorum. Representative Bentley, you are recognized to present Senate Bill 743. Thank you, Chairman
and Committee. We have a very simple bill here. It's a little cleanup bill for notaries across our state. So we're going to make it a little bit simpler on here. before the bill it was you shall charge $5
now you may charge so the charging is just leaning a lot of people like to do it for charity purposes and not charge so that's going from shell to May on that and the other thing is we're allowing them to charge for mileage the federal mileage rate which in the past they have not been allowed to charge for mileage if you look before on paragraph B they have not been able to charge any of the fee demand or service along with the $5 Now they'll be allowed to charge the federal mileage rate on that. And the last thing that would change here on page 2, in the past,
they had 30 days before their notary expired, they had to start with the secretary to start the application fee. We've moved that to 60 days because it's a very long process. There's seven steps involved. It has to go through the mail. It can't be faxed. And so we've extended it from 30 days to 60 days that they have to start the application process. Is there any questions
from the committee? Questions from the committee for Representative Bentley Alright Seeing none
Representative Bentley would you like to close for your bill I'm closed Chairman I appreciate a good vote I'm sorry I did get out of order there Is there anybody here from the public speaking forward against this Alright Seeing none Ms. Fusco is going to sit there quietly What's the pleasure of the committee Alright Representative Ballinger moves do pass Discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Bentley. You've passed your bill.
Thank you guys very much. I appreciate it. Have a great day. All right, committee, one thing by way of notification, we're getting to the point in the session where timing becomes really critical to folks getting their bills passed, and we are going to start to be much more conscious of timing. So we're going to ask that if someone's presented a bill once, that they go to the bottom of the line and we'll take up the bills in the order so that everybody has the opportunity to be heard at least once. So with that, Representative Dotson, if you'd like to present House Bill 1440, you're next in the queue.
Representative Dotson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. If I may, I've asked Colonel Bryant to come join me at the end of the table to present this bill. This bill, very simply, if you look through the bill, the first page is a little bit of clean-up language in the code. The second page is where the meat of the bill is, and what this bill does, the initial application fee for a concealed handgun license is currently at $100 for anyone that is under the age of 65,
$50 if you're over the age of 65. What this does is changes it to where it would be $70 for an applicant who applies for a license year on a paper form, and then $50 for anyone who applies online. So it reduces the fees overall. I've been working with the state police and trying to identify alternative sources of revenue to help with their budget overall. And Representative Bell, myself, Senator Woods, we've come up with a an alternative
revenue source that will offset this. Senator Woods is carrying that on the other end and we'll be sending it our way while we work on this bill to send this their way. Both of them will will work together. If one bill doesn't pass the other one won't go forward so I would certainly appreciate I'll try to take any questions you might have but appreciate a good vote all right Colonel did you have anything to add to that at
this point or if so go ahead and introduce yourself for the record and tell us who you're with thank you mr.
chairman my name is Bill Bryan I'm the director of the Arkansas State Police and represent representative Dawson's testimony is correct we've been working working with Representative Dodson, the chairman, and Senator Woods to develop a new fee increase to offset the revenue we would lose in this. And I think we're working together and trying to get this accomplished. All right. With that, are there questions from the committee?
All right. I have Representative McGee first in the queue. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
we talking about that we're going to have to go try to find someplace else? Well, the overall impact just depends on the year. There's a lot of spike from year to year with regards to how many new applicants have applied. So it can be anywhere from $800,000 to over a million dollars in some years. Just to give you kind of a case in point, this particular revenue stream in 2012 brought in about $2 million worth of revenue overall.
In 2013, it was about $4.6 million. In 2014, it was $2.6 million. So it fluctuates depending on what sort of events might happen. So like Sandy Hook, if you recall, happened at the end of, I guess, 2012. So that was one of the reasons for the large spike in 2013. It's kind of an unstable revenue stream. And so it fluctuates depending on how many applicants come in from year to year.
Speaker 21
6:41
Want to follow up? You're recognized for follow up. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Well, if it fluctuates this much and we're going to change this and they could lose anywhere from $800,000 to $1 million, dollars. Can you comment on what's happening on the Senate that might make that, that those issues might balance out? I mean, we're talking about passing a bill that's going to decrease their income in hopes that something down there is going to happen to balance that out. So I have little problems with that.
Colonel Bryant can speak probably to the specifics overall of the other bill, but the portion of it that would be offsetting for here. It's estimated that it would be about $1.2 million worth of additional revenue coming in from the fees that are down there for the concealed carry portion, the revenue offsetting portion of the bill that's coming from the other end. Yes, sir. In regards to that, I think what they
were saying is just a shale bill at this time, but it was
regarding the direct lien filing fee or the lien filing for title lien fees, and they have not adjust that the amount of revenue that's going to try to be generated for that. We're still trying to work through this process. Only a shale bill has been filed at this time. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And just
by way of comment from the Chair, since I've been a part of some of these negotiations as well, one of the things that is an advantage for the state police in this agreement is the other source of revenue is much more stable and fluctuates a lot less
over the long term. All right. Next in the queue, I have Representative Bennett. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for
question. Why are we doing this? Well, the basic overall premise, in my mind anyway, is that currently we charge people for concealed carry licenses, which is basic, the right to keep and bear arms is a basic Second Amendment right.
And so that basic Second Amendment right, I don't believe should be charged. There should be enough fees to cover the cost of the program, but not an incredibly large amount of revenue source coming from that particular right and fee. So currently, right now, like I said, I mentioned before some of the overall revenue income that comes from this. The expenses to the program, just to administer the program, have never exceeded, in the most recent year, FY14, about $375,000.
And I believe that was, according to the numbers I have, the most expensive year to administer the program that they had on record over the last roughly 20 years of the program. So as you can see, there's a lot of additional revenue that comes in above the cost to administer the program. This would bring it more in line with the fee that's charged to cover the cost of administering it for people to exercise their basic constitutional right.
If I might, Mr. Chair. Greg, as for follow-up. $20 a year just does not seem like a tremendous charge to me. to risk, I mean, you know, there's also there may be cost exactly with the fingerprinting and processing of this, but there's additional cost to the state police for monitoring these things and dealing with the issues that arise from it, and I agree with you, no problem with people bearing arms, but $20
a year, or what is that, $15 a month, I mean, $1.50 a month just doesn't seem like a lot of money.
The cost for fingerprinting, background checks, and that sort of thing is on top of this. So this is not the initial application fee is $100. However, background checks and various things like that are on top of that. So another $47.50 to get your initial application for your background checks, FBI, and I forget what all else goes into it off the top of my head, and then that's after you've
completed the required training and course, which can range anywhere from $70 to $75. So you're talking about quite a bit for someone to shell out just to be able to qualify to apply for this, and that's a non-refundable fee even if they're turned down. To have the option to exercise their basic constitutional right. I think it needs to be more in line with the cost of administering
it and not have an additional revenue stream on top of that. And so we're just trying to get this more in line with the cost of the program, offsetting revenue for that, and trying to make sure that the state police is able to continue with their operations by having additional revenue stream coming from a different area. All right. Next up, I
have Representative Drown. Representative Drown, you recognize for a question. Thanks, Mr. Chair.
This is for the director. What exactly, if my problem is right now, and I don't disagree with the intent, but I'm a little concerned because we have the tax cuts and the revenue streams coming into our state coffers, and this to me, if it can be fixed, I'm all for it. If not, what would be the effects on the state police if you lost $800,000 to
was it $1.5 million? If indeed the streams didn't exist. I mean, if you just lost that outright. Sure,
yes, sir. I'll be glad to answer that. Basically, the Arkansas State Police is composed of five divisions. We have the Highway Patrol Division, the CID Division, Crimes Against Children, administrative, which includes training, and also the regulatory. Those cuts we would have would impact those five divisions of the services that we provide. You know, this fee has been around since, whether it's 1995, we would have to make adjustments.
But I think that's why we're working together here in this committee to, I think they realize that and we're trying to work as a team to get this accomplished. But it would have significant impact if I did lose that $800,000. Just keep in mind that the governor's balanced budget this year, I'm going to lose 1%, which is another $800,000. Unfortunately, I'm new to this job, but what I have to battle is, or what I'm learning in this process, is we have a troop school. We never give any extra funding. We have to take it out operating expenses. State police, from what I can tell, is very good with their money, been a good steward of the state's money.
But, again, we're trying to work with this committee and the Senate side to achieve the same goal. And I think that if we can get this worked out, we'll be fine. But if not, if we lose that, it will be a significant impact upon
us. You recognize for follow-up, President Joe. So you feel that there is a solution to the shortfall? I mean, you believe that the state police can get behind this?
Yes, if what we talked about today and Representative Dodson, if we have an agreement, and if they cannot get that fee increased, I think then we're not going to proceed through the process anymore.
This bill will come to a halt and will not go into law if that other does not go through.
All right. Next up, I have Representative Hickerson. Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I do also agree with the intent of the bill, but the concern of the funding for the state police, that's a real concern for me. Is there a fiscal impact statement
on this? there's not an official fiscal impact statement
can we request one I'm sorry may I have a follow up you may representative Hickerson may I request a fiscal impact statement I think that
might give us a better grasp the challenge with the fiscal impact like I said is the fluctuating revenue I can certainly give you a look back as far as what it would have cost what the change in revenue would have been had this been in effect over the last couple of years. So by year, that would be in effect if that would make you more comfortable.
Representative Hickerson, I do want to say, and I think the Colonel will agree with this, we certainly, it's your right as a member of the committee to request fiscal impact. It's difficult to achieve a fiscal impact on this because, as the Colonel, I believe, is prepared to testify today, this simply will not go into law unless there is a we have passed offsetting revenue in the Senate. And so if that makes it clear, there should be a net zero impact or nothing happens with the bill.
Well, is there someone, Mr. Chairman, is there someone from DF&A that could answer that? I don't know
if we have DF&A here. Colonel, do you have your finance people here today? Yes, sir, I do. Maybe they could help respond to Representative Hickerson's question. Okay, this would be
Speaker 54
16:16
Police. I don't know if I'll answer your question correctly, but we have looked at this. If the online is lowered to 50 and the mail-in is lowered to 70,
the minimum impact to our agency will be a little over $806,000 a year. Ms. French,
if you might also tell what the impact would be of the offsetting fees, assuming that they go forward as agreed. Yes, it would
you have clarification on that? Go ahead and get your clarification, and we'll come back to the regular questions.
Speaker 60
16:59
So you're saying the fiscal impact that you were speaking about was in the $800,000 range, and the money that will be coming to you is $1.2 million? Yes, ma'am,
Speaker 60
17:15
Go ahead. Does the money in the offsetting, is it earmarked just for concealed carry, or does that go into your operating budget and you can use it for anything? It would
Alright, I'm going to get back on my questions in queue Representative Ritchie, you're
Speaker 38
17:45
Chair So this fee that we're moving from on the Senate side where does that money go to right now? Or is it just all new
money through an increase? This would be actually increasing that fee. So it would be new money, new revenue stream.
So that would be new money. Did you have a follow-up, Representative Ritchie? Okay. Next in queue, I have Representative
Gray. You're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess this question stems back to Representative Bennett's question. which I can barely remember
at this point in time, but she was talking about a yearly maintenance, the cost to maintain these licenses.
Can you tell me what the expenses have been over the past few
years versus the income? Like what's the net profit? The net profit on the overall concealed carry handgun license fee, is that what you're talking about? Okay. Okay, so in FY 2014, total revenues that came in was $2,872,000, but that also included a $250,000 one-time deal from the Attorney General's office.
So fees from the program actually was about $2.6 million in FY 2014. In FY13, and in FY14, the expenses, total expenses, $375,543. In FY13, you had $4.6 million, $4,594,000 in revenue incoming, and expenses in that year were $359,000.
So, you know, it fluctuates from year to year. I mean, I wish I could get that sort of a profit off of anything I ever sold, but it's a pretty large amount of additional revenue, which goes into general operating budgets of the state police, currently anything above the expenses. All
right. Next up I have Representative Walker. Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
From what I understand, you'll be increasing one fee in an area which has not been identified that you all are working on. We've identified it. I mean, I didn't hear the identification, if I may. Yes, sir. It was the direct
lien filing fee and also the lien filing for title fee. It would be an increase in that. that the state police has never gotten any revenue from that, to my understanding, but we're pursuing that fee increase to cover the loss of revenue if this bill passes.
But that's a tax, isn't it? It's a fee. If I may follow up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized for follow-up. Now, my concern is in the cutback in services. What you're saying is that you're going to, with this $800,000 plus the other $800,000 to a million or more dollars that you're going to be losing, you face, Colonel, a possible cutback in services. And the cutback in services, which means cutback in policing, will be offset by private persons being
able to protect themselves more.
No, sir. Make sure we're clear on this. We will not jeopardize any public service to the citizens of Arkansas. This agreement is contingent on the other bill being passed, the fee increase. If not, then I think Representative Dotson and the other members involved in this are willing to pull down their legislation and will continue on and will not lose that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Next, I have Representative Douglas again. you're back in
the queue recognized for a question yes thank you mr. chair I just
Speaker 60
22:08
wondered if the need for concealed collect carry classes is going to kind of diminish as we redefine the open carry law and the other question is I know when I took my concealed carry they asked me to or they said there's other their options that are cheaper in other states. So a lot of people out of my class asked for their license from another state
that was cheaper. And I'm wondering if we're not responsive to these two things. You're going to lose that revenue anyway to a certain degree. And I'm just seeing a need by your agency to be responsive to that diminishing revenue from the concealed carry if you're not you know able to adjust your prices and people will go to other states I'm
I'm sorry ma'am I think we've discussed this I have our concealed handgun supervisor here also today but that has come up in our discussions that we do see people apply on the internet to other states some surrounding states are comparable to ours other surrounding states are more expensive than what we charge but that is a concern that we have discussed and And that's on
our radar. I think the need, regardless of what happens with Act 746, I believe is what you were referring to,
and the public, whether or not they have the desire to openly carry or not, whether that's defined differently by the courts or the Attorney General's office or something else in the future, we will continue to have the need for reciprocity between states. so you will still continue to need to have a concealed carry program in place in order to be able to carry across state lines regardless of what you can or can't do within the state of Arkansas. So I'm full support of the program being in place.
I'm just in support of making sure that the revenues that come in for the program cover the expenses of the program and not a lot of extra for that to be a burden on people's constitutional rights. All
right, Representative Bennett, you were back in the queue for a question. All right. Additional questions for members? Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. I guess I shouldn't know this, but I just don't know who we're raising fees on on the Senate end.
It's direct lien filings? Yes, ma'am, that's correct. It's
the direct lien filing fee and lien filing for title lien. That's the proposed shale bill. You're recognized for follow-up, Representative Vickers. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And who pays
that? Is that Citizens of Arkansas will have their... I believe that's going to
be an example, and I could be wrong. I could ask for clarification for my staff, but it's, for example, if somebody buys a
car and they have to repo it, then that dealership has to get a new lien and a new title, and that's where the expense would incur.
Thank you. Additional questions from members? All right, is there anyone from the public here to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Dotson, would
you like to close for your bill? I think the bill you have before is fairly straightforward and simple. I think it will certainly help out
the citizens of Arkansas exercise their right to keep and bear arms their Second Amendment rights, and I would certainly appreciate a good vote and move due pass. All right, what's the pleasure
of the committee? Okay, sorry, Representative Dodson, I didn't hear you. All right, I have a due pass motion. Is there any discussion on the motion?
Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. No.
Speaker 92
26:39
Rule the eyes have it. Rule call. All right, call the roll. Representative Link. No. Representative Wardlaw. No. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Hickerson. No. Representative Walker. No.
Representative Douglas. Yes. Representative Ritchie. Representative Ritchie? No. Representative McGee? No. Representative Dodson? Yes. Representative Armstrong? Representative Armstrong? Representative Miller? No. Representative Holcomb? No. Representative Ballinger? Yes. Representative Ladyman? Yes. Representative Drown? No. Representative Gray? Yes. Representative Tosh? No. Representative Fite? Yes.
Representative Bennett? Representative Womack? Yes. Sorry, Representative Dotson, your bill fails. All right. Next on the agenda, I have Representative Ballinger with House Bill 1687. Representative Ballinger
you are recognized for House Bill 1687 Thank you Mr.
Chair Okay this is a bill that I started running earlier and I won't belabor the point, but essentially it's something that is supported by the county clerks,
just provides some clarity that makes it consistent with a circuit court ruling in Washington County and just makes it where we know exactly what the language is when a municipal ordinance is being referred out or is being repealed or is being initiated by the public. And having said that, I'd be happy to answer any questions. Questions from the committee?
I don't see any Representative Ballinger. Anybody here from the public to speak for or against his bill? Seeing none, would you like to close for your
due pass. I'll recognize you for a motion due pass. Have a motion. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Ballinger. You have passed your bill. Do you want to go ahead and are we roll
calling? All right. Moving on, do you want to go ahead and present 1688 while you're at the end of the table? Yes,
and I absolutely deserve that, so I appreciate your gigging me. Okay, 1688 is also a real simple bill. Now, this is something I visited with the Municipal League about, and there may be an amendment. I'm going to run it as it is, but it's possible that it could end up being amended, but because of the nature of time, if I'm going to amend it, I'm going to do it on the run. But essentially, currently, if you do a referendum, you have 30 days to collect the requisite amount of signatures,
which is a difficult task, especially if you're talking about a very large number of people that has to be gathered. And this just provides to our citizens a little more access to have a little more effect in their government. And it provides, instead of 30 days, it provides 60 days. And I'd be happy
to answer any questions. Questions from the committee? Representative Ballinger, you're not generating a lot of questions today. It's pretty simple. Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question.
All right. And on that note, is there anyone here from the public speak for or against the bill? All right. Seeing none, Representative Ballinger, would you like to close? I am closed. I do move to do pass. No, you've got Representative Walker up here who was ahead of
you. Oh, he had a motion. Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't get to go. Representative Walker, you
are recognized for a historic motion. I want to make sure Representative Ballinger understands I voted one time for something he came up with. A motion
to do pass. All right. We have a do-pass motion.
Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Ballinger. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Committee. Representative Womack, if you'll take the chair, I'd like to go and present House Bill 1788. I guess it's all
members we have an amendment we're working on just a second please Okay, the amendment should be on your tablets.
Does everybody have it? Mr. Chair, I would move adoption of the amendment.
All right, is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. All opposed, no. All right, the amendment has been adopted.
Representative Bell, you are recognized to present your bill as amended. Members, this
is a fairly simple bill that actually has already had an effect just from its filing. This morning I received an email from the Arkansas Building Authority thanking me for filing this bill and that they were not aware that they could access this database and that it was going to be helpful to them. They were here this morning to speak for this bill. Unfortunately, due to the scheduling, they weren't able to come back this afternoon. But the bill is pretty simple. It just makes it so that when the Arkansas Building Authority is looking to cite a state agency department, et cetera,
it asks them to check the building and sites database with the Arkansas Economic Development Commission. Those are the buildings and sites that are available out in the various communities around the state to see if any of those would meet their needs and makes it so that they always consult that as an option. Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for a
question. Motion at the proper time, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 128
33:23
Okay, Representative Link, you're recognized for a question. How do we know if they check that or not?
It just says they shall. So we have normal legislative oversight to, I guess, ask them if they did, but I didn't want to put a lot of encumbrances on them other than just to encourage them to do that. And I appreciate that. Thank
you. All right. Are there any other questions for members? Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for or against the bill? representative bell would you like to close for your bill i'm closed mr chair and i would move adoption or move do pass do pass as amended do pass as amended all righty everybody in favor say
aye all opposed no congratulations representative bell you've passed your bill thank you mr chair members of committee All right.
let's see I don't think we have any senators here to present let me double check my agenda committee we may be about wrapped up alright any committee members have any bills to present alright representative Hodges did you want to go ahead or do you need to wait alright committee I think that wraps us up for today being no further business coming for this committee we stand adjourned
Agenda
HB1405
HB1440
HB1687
HB1688
HB1788
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Representative Mary Bentley
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Bill Bryan
Unverified
Speaker 21
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Representative R. Trevor Drown
Unverified
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Speaker 54
Speaker 60
Speaker 63
Speaker 38
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 55
Speaker 92
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Speaker 120
Representative Richard Womack Chair
Unverified
Speaker 128