Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

March 12, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (16)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1203 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1203”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1240 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1240”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1236 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1236”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1322 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1322”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1456 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1456”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1532 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1532”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1543 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1543”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1672 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1672”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1855 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1855”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1001 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1001”
Pre-2017 bill
SB152 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB152”
Pre-2017 bill
SB528 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB528”
Pre-2017 bill
SB57 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB57”
Pre-2017 bill
SB58 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB58”
Pre-2017 bill
SB612 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB612”
Pre-2017 bill
SB698 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB698”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Representative Hammer, we previously adopted an amendment to House Bill 1203, but I believe Representative Hammer has a new amendment he would like adopted. In order to do that, to replace it, we actually need to expunge the vote by which we adopted the previous amendment. Motion. Okay, we have a motion to expunge the vote by which we previously adopted an amendment to House Bill 1203. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? Okay, the motion passes. Now we have an amendment to House Bill 1203. Should be on your tablets. It's not showing up. Actually, it's not on the tablet, so we're going to pass out a hard copy. I'm great. Sorry. Okay. Committee, we have a motion by Representative Vines to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. Representative Hammer, you're recognized to present House Bill 1203 as amended. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, and committee
▶ Play
members for your tolerance. When I was a kid, we had this big old hay barn, had a big silo by it, and by the time I got done painting that, not that it was a means of punishment as much as it was a means of teaching good, solid, worth ethics, when I got done, my dad said, now that you've done it the hard way, there's an easier way to do this, And he told me, and he taught me a valuable lesson. Unfortunately, when it came to this bill, I forgot about painting that barn. This is the simplest way to address the way in which it meets the intent of what I want to see achieved in this bill. And that is it removes the gray area as far as if you as a citizen are put in a position that you have to defend yourself. What is it that gives you the greatest amount of coverage without being too far overreaching? I'm going to be real short and sweet on this one because I worked with the Attorney General's Office. My understanding is prosecutors are comfortable with this as well. And with that, I'll be glad to answer any questions or if the chair would allow and if a member of the attorney general's office, prosecuting attorney's office, would like to come and speak either way. But I'll yield to the chair at this
▶ Play
time. Any questions? Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
I'm just trying to comprehend all this. So you actually deleted your entire bill and the amendment's a complete substitute? I don't know that it deleted the
▶ Play
entire bill, but it probably got the majority of it because this is the simplest way to achieve, and I wish this would have been a thought of in the first place, but it is what it is.
▶ Play
If I'm I to follow up. So the cartilage language that was changed is taken out?
▶ Play
It is taken out. It remains in the bottom of the bill. On your hard copy, it's on the bottom of page one, I believe, is where
▶ Play
you're referring to. And that's current law,
▶ Play
right? Yes, ma'am. Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question. So Representative Hammer, just can, for my sake, just reiterate, again,
▶ Play
what this bill does differently than the present law. Sure. Basically what it does is it removes the gray area. I'm going to give you an example. If you are anywhere at any point in time and you are in a position that you feel that you need to defend yourself, as long as you can show that you are unable to retreat with complete safety, you are going to be protected by the law. So that's the big thing that this does. It still allows and retains a degree of responsibility that you have to show that you couldn't retreat with complete safety. But I'll give you an example. If you are trying to get away and you run into an obstacle, an obstacle in that split second causes you not to be able to retreat safely, you as a law-abiding citizen who has had an act of aggression initiated against you would be able to defend yourself. It takes the gray out of the law is what it does.
▶ Play
Representative Talley, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. Do we have a – I don't see a definition. Am I missing a definition for complete safety? I think that – Mr. Chair, I'd like to
▶ Play
extend an offer if there's a member of the community out of the Attorney General's office or maybe some of the prosecutor if they want to come just so I don't weigh down too deep on this, being that there are several well-qualified lawyers on this committee. Mr. McMahon, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 36 5:40
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Bob McMahon, the prosecutor coordinator. In response to the question, Representative, there is no specific definition in current law that talks about complete safety. It specifically does say, though, the person knows or has been interpreted to be reasonably believes he cannot get away from the situation with complete safety. So that's all the law currently says. This doesn't change that at all. That has not been a prosecutor's problem in interpreting this with any cases that I'm aware of. So we are comfortable with this the way it's written, and it's not a change from current law. It should make it clear, but with regard to
▶ Play
Speaker 38 6:16
that, there's no definition and no big change here. Representative Scott,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hammer, let me just get clear on this, okay? I don't mean to confuse you or make the passing of this bill any more difficult for you. I just have a very simple question as a grandmother. Let's say, God forbid, I walk in on someone abusing one of my grandchildren, and I have a gun on myself, a gun that I have a permit to carry. and in my mind the first thing that I think I would do is probably shoot that person right then right there no questions asked does does this bill say that what I should have done is walked in on that situation and thought and maybe prayed about it for a minute and then shot the person or given the person time to walk out who was harming one of my grandchildren
▶ Play
can you help me I can help you but I want to put a disclaimer out there I'm not an attorney so I don't want to be convicted later for giving legal advice but what I am going to tell you is what this law would do in my understanding as it would apply to your scenario it would give you coverage in order for you to do what you felt you needed to do in that particular situation as that grandmother with that child it's going to clear up the gray area that's going to give you greater authority to act against somebody who actions were aggressively initiated toward you first
▶ Play
and give you greater protection. Follow up, please, Mr. Chair. If I shot that person more than once, would I still be okay? Are you asking me? Yes,
▶ Play
sir, I am. I'm going to tell you my personal thought. But if that was happening in my house and that was my granddaughter, I'd do what I'd have to do to defend my family member until the battle was over. Thank you. Representative House, your recommendation. Mr. Chair, before you do that, can Bob address something on that point, please? Sure. Representative, under
▶ Play
Speaker 36 8:31
current law, you may not even get to that specific section that we're amending today. Under current law, under 52607, the very first section under subsection A says a person is justified in using deadly physical force upon another person if the person reasonably believes that the other person is committing or about to commit a felony involving force or violence. So you would be walking into a situation where you would be using that portion of the law to defend that individual from the force or violence being used against him or her. So I think that section covers you under current law. Vice
▶ Play
Chairman Wright, you're recognized for a question. And
▶ Play
Bob, of course, in that situation, the prosecutors would have discretion in evaluating how they handle that case, correct? Yes, Representative.
▶ Play
As always, that's correct. Thanks. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This question, well, either one of y'all, but the prosecutors may want to answer it. From my standpoint, what I'm seeing here is that we've got a new element that's being added to this defense that essentially if a person is currently in their home and the person uses deadly force, essentially they have a defense. Now, if there's some reason why they should have realized that they could retreat with complete safety, they would not be able to use that defense. I mean, I don't think that this actually strengthens it. I think this kind of – this actually weakens the defense.
▶ Play
Speaker 36 10:16
Representative, I mean, this isn't the association's bill, but I think I follow your argument. I'm not sure that I agree that it actually weakens it. I think it just basically restates what current law is in another way, as Representative Hammer said, intended to clarify that. But from the prosecutor's standpoint, I don't believe that's a big, big change. And I think under current law that they would be able to do that. They would be able to defend themselves. So I'm not sure I'll follow
▶ Play
you then. Okay, so let me try to clarify. Currently under code, if you look at what the law says under, and it's a little hard with two different um bills here but you know under you know b1ab it where it talks about however a person is not required to retreat if the person is right and so now we're talking about saying that there's no requirement to retreat the original law said in a person's dwelling or on the curtilage surrounding a person's dwelling right the code originally said that now and that was one element the next element it says the law enforcement officer doesn't have a duty to retreat now it says there's one more element put in there that says you don't have a duty to retreat if you're unable to retreat with complete safety which is what the law is any other place besides outside of a dwelling but currently the law within a dwelling is you have no obligation to retreat so now we've added an element in there saying you have no obligation to retreat if you're in your home and you can't retreat, you know, and you can't retreat with complete safety. So this is actually just the opposite of what a person would call a stand your ground law or, you know, cast a doctrine or whatever. What this doctrine says is now if you're in your home and you're faced with a thing, if you can retreat with complete safety, you have an obligation to do so with no with no due disrespect because I
▶ Play
really want your vote on this bill but somebody said before that if you get two lawyers you get three opinions if they're all in the same room and I think that's where where we may be all I know is that as I worked with the attorney general's office on this the the opinion was to my conclusion as well that this actually provides greater safety and provides a greater clarity of the law so that in the event that person has that situation occur, whether it be in their home or whether it be outside their curdley, that they are going to have the full benefit without that split-second moment of doubt in the back of their mind, that as long as they can show that they did not have the opportunity to completely or safely retreat, which might be standing on their front porch or it might be in their bedroom, that this is going to give them that greater clarity to be able to defend themselves. Okay.
▶ Play
And this is every one – oh, I'm sorry. It's going to fall off. So every once in a while, I have a moment of mental block. So what we have here is we don't have to meet each one of these elements. So this is a new element that provides safety and defense. So I take back everything I said. Representative Ballinger,
▶ Play
you don't know how much great pride me as a non-lawyer that did for me. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question was just to answer in the earlier
▶ Play
dialogue. Thank you. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Hammer, Representative Hammer, is there a situation that has come up in Arkansas that the current law doesn't address that this would address? Has anybody been charged that wouldn't have been charged?
▶ Play
representative bennett i couldn't sit here and tell you a case but and maybe this is a good thing or a bad thing the way my mind works why do we always have to wait until something happens to create the law that gives the law abiding citizens the greatest benefit of the doubt it's kind of like how many people have to go through a you know through an intersection before you put up a stop sign if you knew that a stop sign would help prevent anything Why wouldn't you do that? If I might have followed up.
▶ Play
Well, I guess, you know, when I look at this situation, I mean, if I'm threatened, I'm going to do whatever it takes to protect myself. I don't think I'm going to stop and think, now, wait, was that provision in the law that allows me to do this or not do this? And I guess what gives me some concern is, one, I'm not sure we're really changing the current law. But if we are changing current law, I mean, I don't think I can ever retreat with complete safety. I could trip over a rock. I could, you know, if you're adding that standard in there, now as a defense attorney, I'm going to have to prove, or a prosecutor, I'm going to have to prove whatever this means, complete safety. And it seems to me that we have about as broad a protection in our current law as we do. and I just am concerned that we're adding things that we don't know what they mean, we don't know what the impact is, and there's no problem, and I'm just generally against laws that don't solve a problem. Representative, I
▶ Play
Speaker 36 15:36
do not think that this is a problem in current law. I think this is another way to state something under Representative Hammer's intentions is to make it clear here, and hopefully that does that, but there are not any specific problems with that complete safety language as it's currently written that I am aware of. I do not think the change here will cause us any problems either. Again, it's intended to clear things up, but the language as currently written is not a big problem, and I, again, do not think that this
▶ Play
would cause a problem either. Representative Gray,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess maybe this is back to Representative Ballinger's question to some degree. I'm just trying to understand this perfectly well. So if I'm on Section B, 1A, B, and it says unable to retreat with complete safety, so I've got the number 1, 2, and 3 there. I have to meet number 1 and number 2 or number 1 and number 3 since there is no or after number 1.
▶ Play
it's not intended to do that as i understand it it's kind of like there's a and there there's a succession of events that need to occur in order for you in a situation where you're having to defend yourself to give you the greatest benefit of the law because remember you are not the aggressor so if you're not the aggressor what is it that gives you the greatest benefit and and partly by dropping that down there under number two it establishes a sequence which brings clarity, and in the event that you would have to show that you couldn't have completely retreated with great safety, that's part of what this law does, is it makes it, you know, it gives you greater defense. It gives you, as one who the violator came against, greater ability to prove that you could not retreat with great safety, regardless of wherever it is that you are. I think, just as
▶ Play
a point of clarification, and there's plenty of other people on this committee that could correct me if I'm wrong but generally with regard to the statute and we have a long-standing member of code revision on our committee here Representative Vines but when there's a sequence like one two and three there's only an and or an or after the next to last item in the sequence so that that would should mean one or two or three and in fact Representative Vines says actually there may be one too many ORs after 1B3, but that's beside the point. But as I understand it, the normal statutory construction would be any of the three.
▶ Play
Speaker 49 18:20
Mr. Chairman, I agree with that. I
▶ Play
Speaker 36 18:23
believe it is one OR, two OR, three. I believe that answers the question. I think the final or refers to Section 1 or Section 2. So I think as it's written, I mean, that's the way I would understand that. I think it's probably okay as it's written. But I understand your concern. But with regard to what Representative Gray said, I believe it's one or two or three. Only one has to be present.
▶ Play
Any other questions? All right, I see no further questions. We have a few people signed up to speak for or against. Sonia Rios signed up. Hey, if you'll
▶ Play
Speaker 80 19:13
take a seat at the end of the table.
▶ Play
If you'll take a seat, state your name and who you represent, and
▶ Play
Speaker 81 19:31
then you may make your statement. Good morning. I'm Sonia Rios. I'm here representing the Arkansas Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. And the one comment I really want to make is regarding the presumption and then also the standard of the person reasonably believing, the individual person reasonably believing that there is a threat. I believe that changing it to a reasonable person standard instead of that individual would make it a lot better for this bill to go forward and be more clear. The way it is written will create a situation where any person who might be threatened by something that is not reasonable could use deadly force. And I think that changing that language to a general reasonable person standard would would make a big difference in this bill and make it a lot more easy to it would make the standard more even keeled because one person may think something is very may perceive something as a threat whereas another one wouldn't. So this will make it much more even across the board. Any questions from
▶ Play
the committee? All right, thank you for your testimony. We have one other signed up. Paul Calvert signed up to speak for the bill. Mr. Calvert. All right, moving on. There's no one else signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Hammer, would you like to close for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I do not
▶ Play
think that in working with the people that I've worked with in order to make sure that this is a bill that improves, does not hinder or set us back as far as protecting the citizens who are just going about their business and have an aggressor come against them is going to do anything to hinder that. In fact, if anything, I think it takes us a step closer to doing what sometimes we have down here, what we call cleanup language. This is clarity language, especially in clearing up and getting rid of the gray area. So I would
▶ Play
appreciate a good vote. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Ballinger? We have a motion to do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. The bill passes as amended. The next special order is House Bill 1240. Representative Tosh, you recognize to present House Bill 1240. And I understand you have an amendment. Looks like it's not on the tablet yet, so we're going to hand out hard copies. The amendment that we have that's being handed out simply adds co-sponsors. Do I have a motion to adopt the amendment? Representative Howes makes a motion we adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor of adopting the amendment say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. Representative Tosh, you're recognized to present House Bill 1240 as amended.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, fellow colleagues. Originally, when I introduced this bill, 1240, I had the title on the bill was Stand Your Crown. However, as we kept reviewing this piece of legislation, we realized from a lot of input, some of you on this committee and from others throughout the House, also from the prosecuting attorney's office, from the attorney general's office, and also from the Sheriff's Association, it was brought to my attention, and I'm glad it was, is that the language of my intent of the bill was not matching up with the title of the bill. My approach to this and what I wanted to accomplish with this bill was to provide civil immunity or a layer of protection for those that had to use deadly force. But in no way do I in any way want to have any wording that would be in conflict with our current self-defense law that's already on the books. And I've reviewed that law. I'm very familiar with that law. And we probably have one of the best self-defense laws of any state that I know of. So the intent of this bill was to do one thing. And that was if an individual was in accordance with the law, the self-defense law, If you're in accordance with that law and you have to use deadly force, then if someone brings civil action against you, this bill will provide you with civil immunity in regards to that. But you have to be in a lawful place, and it has to be in accordance with the self-defense law. That's the intent of this bill. I've also, the prosecuting attorney's office has given its blessings along with the attorney general's office, along with the sheriff's association, and along with the Arkansas State Police. And I'll take any questions. Representative
▶ Play
Broadway, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Tosh, for bringing this before us. I have reviewed your bill, and I have some concerns about language set forth in Section 2B that basically just says all other expenses. And I believe that language is a little bit vague, And I was wondering specifically what's your intent, what other expenses that you were concerned about being awarded. You specifically enumerate some that I understand and I think could be good policy, but all other expenses is very broad. And so I was wondering what your thinking was with regard to
▶ Play
that. Well, since the court is going to be awarding these reasonable attorney fees and all other court costs, Those expenses that I'm talking about would be anything that's related to you defending yourself in a court of law. Any court-related expenses is what this would cover.
▶ Play
What kind of court-related expenses are there besides attorney's fees, court costs, and then you also address compensation for loss of income? I'm not trying to trick you. I'm trying to really understand what other expenses one could be reimbursed for Because we don't talk about medical expenses here or other things of that nature. But it could, in this language, encompass that. So I just think I'm trying to understand. I think the bill's very broad, and I want to make sure that you're addressing what you want to, but we're not opening this up to just ad infinitum somebody's lunch when they're litigating a case and
▶ Play
that sort of thing. That's a great question, Representative Broadway. And the intent of this is exactly what you said. It's for court-related expenses. Anything outside of that would not be covered under
▶ Play
this bill. Would you be perhaps amenable then, Representative, to amending that language out or putting something in there specifically that says court-related expenses only, something of that nature? because I understand your intent, and I think that it's well-intended. I just think that it's so broad that I think it really could cause some concern and actually create some abuse. If it's okay with you, I'd be glad to do
▶ Play
that. If we could do that on the Senate end, would that be okay? I certainly have every
▶ Play
reason to take you to your word, Representative.
▶ Play
Speaker 106 27:48
Yes. Okay. Any other questions? Representative Bennett. I, too, think this is a
▶ Play
good bill. Am I there? I, too, think this is a good bill. My concern, and if we're going to amend it, let's fix it. And there is standard language that's used in reimbursement, so we can come up with that. But my concern with it is that you're going to require a criminal trial before you get to the civil part of this. And I talked to Representative Tosh just a minute ago about this, and if we can fix this. What I think we need to say in the bill is that either you haven't been charged or you've been found not guilty. Because if we don't put that in there, if somebody sues you before you can get it dismissed here, you're going to have to have a criminal trial to determine whether they met the criminal standard. So, and I think I'm right about this, but if I'm not, correct me. I'm sorry, Bob McMahon, prosecutor coordinator.
▶ Play
Speaker 36 28:58
I'll have to do a little checking to make sure I follow the question there. I do think I understand what you're saying. I'll just have to do a little checking to make sure that's correct
▶ Play
before I can comment on that. I'm sorry. Representative Whitaker, are you recognized for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is probably directly related to Representative Bennett's concern because, you know, in the last section of Section A, it says, in accordance with 52607, is that determination made by a determination of not guilty because your defense was successful at criminal trial, or could the Civil Court make that determination? I mean, it's not clear there, so I would concur with Representative Bennett's concern that that be cleared up.
▶ Play
Representative, I can clear that up at the same time we clear up the other issue with Representative Bennett, if that's okay
▶ Play
with you. Thank you. Representative Ballinger, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question goes back to the fees and all other expenses. To me, that language seems to be very similar to language in a lot of other code sections because there are things like expert witness fees. There's a lot of other things that go into if you're having a trial that would be fees. So in that basically, I mean, you really couldn't have a list that would include all your fees and expenses associated with the trial because of the fact that, you know, you'll need to have it broad enough to cover everything that would be covered and be a cost of your defense in the trial, correct?
▶ Play
I think the wording should be court-related expenses. That's actually related to the proceedings of the court. Okay, thank you. Any other questions?
▶ Play
And just to be clear, since we've had a couple suggestions on things that need to be changed, Representative Broadway, what you're asking for is, are you asking that expenses be struck altogether or just that the reference be consistent with what's utilized elsewhere for traditional
▶ Play
court expenses? Mr. Chair, I would be fine with that, or as Representative Tosh said, as opposed to all other expenses, all other inserting court-related expenses would satisfy me.
▶ Play
I want to make sure that, and I know Representative Tosh has done a lot of work on this, I don't want it to get to the Senate end and then have questions come up about what he was willing to do or what he was
▶ Play
asked to do. But is that clear for you,
▶ Play
Representative Shepard? It doesn't. You know, I guess my only concern would be that it seems whatever is traditionally used in other sections, that's the language. I mean, I think court costs and expenses is something that's utilized quite a bit. I don't know. I haven't looked at what other statutory provisions say, but just my main concern was whether it was you were asking him to strike it all together or
▶ Play
just try and clarify and limit. I would be fine with clarification. I think all other expenses is just vague and overbroad at the end of this sequence. Okay. And he said his intent is court-related, so I'm good with just clarifying that
▶ Play
language. Alright, and then on the other, related to Representative Bennett's concerns, could you state those again if you don't mind again I know we're kind of getting into discussion but if this is something that everybody's going to be generally okay with after it gets worked out I
▶ Play
just want to make sure we're all clear my concern and I'm perfectly happy with Representative Tosh being able to fix this and I think it's an easy fix. If you're accused and you use the proper standard to defend yourself, I'm afraid that this provision will make the civil court have a criminal trial of whether you actually were guilty or not before you can use the protection of this system. So I just want to put in there that if you weren't charged with any crime or you were found not guilty of any crime, this kicks in so the court doesn't have to go through a trial first. Does that make more sense? And I think it's a relatively easy fix.
▶ Play
I think. I guess some of the concern I would have is what about the situation so you're saying if they're not if they've not been charged or if they or what was the second part found
▶ Play
not guilty or what we can put in null prost whatever i guess that's the that was what i
▶ Play
was thinking what it happens in the event of a null price a dismissal or any anything else um i just don't want
▶ Play
you to have to defend yourself criminally in a civil case that's my concern okay Representative Ballinger you recognized for a question
▶ Play
and this actually may be more
▶ Play
of a statement maybe it's a question whether or not the representative would be okay with it but if we just included the elements what we're talking about here is a defense in civil liability what if we include the elements that is a defense and criminal liability the same way so we just essentially said the elements of the defense, we want to reference the code section in case Representative Hammer's bill becomes an act and just reference the code section and say if you meet the elements of this code section then you're, I think that would
▶ Play
Speaker 117 35:25
probably cover that and I do understand their concern with that.
▶ Play
I think that's basically what his amendment refers to 52607 which is what, that's the section we just
▶ Play
dealt with. Well except Therefore, it says instead of saying that they meet the elements of it, it says unless you're immune from deadly force against a person who is initial aggressor, if used deadly force was in accordance with. So I guess maybe you can clarify that, but I can see they're concerned of saying that they'd have to actually have the defense in a criminal before they could use the defense in civil. The other thing is that I have some concerns about is if we use the word other court related expenses I think that that could actually mean the court costs or anything the expenses associated with the court and not other things like a expert witness or what other fees associated with that and so I would if we're going to do that say trial related expenses but I don't know that that's not already covered in the last part of that sentence that says expenses incurred by a person in defense of a civil action brought by another person Here's what I think.
▶ Play
Why don't we do this? We're going to be back this afternoon. Why don't we hold off on taking action on this and Representative Bennett and Broadway and Representative Tosh, if y'all are willing to get together maybe Representative Ballinger and between now and this afternoon try and work on what the amendment would look like. We can get the amendment sent over take up the amendment potentially adopt the amendment and then pass this out as amended it's given the two-day rule it i mean it's not gonna it's not gonna hold you up as far as the bill going to the senate in and i would feel better about everybody being on the same page and understanding exactly what's being voted on representative tosh is that acceptable to you yes mr chair it is okay well and i don't think we had no other questions and i'm just going to hold off on taking up public comment until we bring the amendment back this afternoon and which will be upon adjournment. Thank you, Representative Tosh. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1532, Representative Vines.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 38:31
Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm just waiting for – I've got a hard copy, but I wanted to pull up the – I've got a – is that the amendment? Yeah. Okay. I've got a hard copy. I'll just proceed if everybody else can pull it up. I do have an amendment. This will be, I believe, the second amendment. First amendment was adopted. We did members' own. When it was adopted, added Representative Bennett and changed her district. We fixed that in the first amendment. This is the second amendment, and I'd ask for
▶ Play
a due pass to add the amendment. Representative Vines moves adoption of the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. You're recognized to present the bill.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Friends, this is House Bill 1532. It's a bill that became, out of necessity, I believe in the 2011 session, which would have been the 88th General Assembly, we adopted a statewide district court bill. And since that time, as we all have these various judicial districts, things have changed, times changed, judges changed, structures changed, and this is an amendment to that bill. It affects several districts. We've tried to work with every district. I know my district in Garland County, we had requested to move back in line, if you will. I believe everyone that's a co-sponsor, I think, on this bill, as you'll look through the roster of co-sponsors, had some issue. And rather than run five to ten individual bills, we tried to all get together and fix them all in one attempt. As you thumb through, you'll see they're basically in the gross copy that you'll see so far without the Second Amendment, you'll see we addressed several, and what it is is it moves the implementation date to 2017 and or 2021. I've tried to talk with most everyone that had issues or had judges in the process presently, Presently, and I can bring Keith Kavnis from AOC up, but presently about a third to half the state has gone into this system. And what this bill does is deals with those districts that have not, and we're trying to accommodate them. We had some problem issues with various counties. We've addressed those. Representative Rushing had some issues in her grant in Hot Spring County. We fixed those, left those as it is. They come full bore in 2017. Pike and Clark County had some issues We addressed those I had some issues in Garland County Betty Overby had some Representative Betty Overby had some issues In the Clarksville area I think Representative Ratliff And Representative Neal Everyone like I said that's been associated or spoke with this bill We've tried to fix or accommodate in some form or fashion Hence the second amendment And hence why it's laid around so long I'll be glad to answer any questions I also have Keith Cavanaugh here from the AOC that can give you more of a detailed history if we want to get off into that portion of the debate, but otherwise I'll be happy to answer any questions.
▶ Play
Any questions from the committee? Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. I know it's in here, but I
▶ Play
can't find Lone Oak. You were in Amendment 1. I can't pull up the I've got an old copy before we amended yours It's in there Representative, but I can't pull it up on the screen right now But we did adopt your amendment one Thank you I hope you're taken care of Representative Beck, I think we took care of you in this amendment Any other questions? It doesn't appear
▶ Play
that anybody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Vines, do you want to close for your bill? I hope so. Do you move? Do pass as amended? Move a motion. Do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Representative House, did you have? Just wanted to thank you for all the hard
▶ Play
work, and the coordination that went in. That's a lot of work, and we appreciate it very much. Thank you. No problem, but you
▶ Play
better check with your judges first and make sure they're okay with it. Thank
▶ Play
you. You've passed your bill as amended. Okay. We're going to go back to the top of the regular agenda. Representative Bain, House Bill 1456. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. Thank you, committee. This is a bill that you saw about a week to 10 days ago. There were some concerns or questions about what would happen with a judge and what would be the ability for a judge to appeal. I sat down with Judicial Discipline and BLR, and we've crafted an amendment, which is the issue that we tried to directly address that on page 2. which would basically set forth the reasoning for an appeal of the automatic suspension. I'd be happy to take any questions. Any questions from the committee? Seeing no questions, no one has signed up
▶ Play
to speak for or against the bill. Representative Bain, would you like to close for your bill?
▶ Play
I just want to say that we've tried to make sure this is as fair as humanly possible to any judge who may come underneath the auspices of the automatic suspension, and I would appreciate a good vote, and I would make a motion do pass. We have a motion do pass.
▶ Play
Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 698. Vice Chairman Wright, you're recognized. Present the bill. I understand we may have an amendment.
▶ Play
I do have an amendment, Mr. Chairman. The amendment is very simple, and I appreciate adopting the amendment, and then I'll just explain what it does in the bill. It just adds some stricter language, another hoop to jump through. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Vines, do you move for the adoption of the amendment? We have a motion to adopt the amendment. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. Representative right
▶ Play
and recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Committee, what this bill does is does exist. I know sometimes titles don't tell us what the bill does, but it really does exactly what the title says it does. It grants certain law enforcement investigators, grants them access to the prescription drug monitoring program. It doesn't mean that they can just go to the prescription drug monitoring program and say, I want to check it out. They have to be certified. They have to be commissioned. They have to be trained. There has to be an open and ongoing investigation. basically the whole bill are safeguards for what the investigators have to do before they can get access to the prescription drug monitoring program. I'll be more than happy to take any questions. I'll also have Chief Lane. I'll ask him to introduce himself real quick, and I'm sure he'll be able to help answer any questions as well.
▶ Play
Sure. My name is Chief Lane. Kirk Lane. I'm with the Benton Police Department. I also represent the Arkansas Chiefs of Police Association, and I'm also a member of the advisory board to prescription drug monitoring program any questions it doesn't appear that anybody signed up
▶ Play
speak for against the bill represent right are you closed for
▶ Play
the bill I'm closed for the bill have a motion
▶ Play
do pass as amended we have a motion do pass as amended any discussion all in favor say aye any opposed the bill passes as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Next on the agenda, Senate Bill 58. I understand Representative Fiedt is going to present Senate Bill 58.
▶ Play
You're recognized to present Senate Bill 58. Mr. Chair, we also have Senate Bill 57. Is it shown on your schedule? Yes, it is. Okay, all right. We'll start with 58. And I have with me Mr. Solomon Graves. Senate Bill 58 is an act concerning parole rules and the award of parole to make technical corrections. Sections 1, 4, and 6 establish rulemaking authority in various sections of the code that deal with parole, and this is a result of questions raised by the administrative rule sections at BLR due to what they believed was murky rulemaking authority pertaining to parole in general. Then Sections 2 and 3 clarify mentions of the Board of Corrections. As the releasing authority for the state, the parole board is responsible for setting parole rules and conditions along with establishing a course of action before release. The current language does not reflect the dual authority exercised by the Board of Corrections and has raised questions about the parole board's authority to regulate the granting of parole. Then finally, Section 5 makes technical corrections and in addition clarifies the ability of the board to conduct parole hearings for offenders in the custody of the Department of Community Corrections. I'll be glad to take any questions. Any questions from the committee? No one
▶ Play
has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Feiter, are you closed for the bill? I am. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Scott, you're recognized. We have a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill
▶ Play
57. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Senate Bill 57 is an act concerning the use of a victim impact statement during an inmate's parole determination. And with the chair's permission, I will ask Mr. Graves to explain this bill.
▶ Play
Mr. Graves, you recognize. Please state your name, who you represent, and then make your statement.
▶ Play
Solomon Graves, Administrative Manager with the State Parole Board. Senate Bill 57 is a victim protection bill being presented by the state parole board. Over the last two years, we've seen a steady decline in the numbers of victims who are taking advantage of their statutory right to provide impact or their input on the parole process. And we've been able to attribute that to two causes. One is the current travel burden placed on victims to participate in the victim impact process. And secondly, there is real discomfort on the part of the victim community with the fact that the board is compelled under existing law to provide these statements to the inmate, regardless of who writes the statement, whether it be a minor victim or an elderly victim in the early stages of dementia or whether the statement provides address information or some other identifying information. So what this bill does is three things. One, it makes various technical corrections throughout the code relating to victim impact statements. It also allows the board to conduct those hearings via video or on a satellite basis. Say we have a victim and a commissioner from the Waldron community, instead of having to drive across the state we can set it up to where we can send that commissioner home do the hearing after hours one day or even on a weekend to make it a little bit easier for the victim to participate and then the language as presented in the bill would also prevent the disclosure of a statement to a sex offender we want to ensure that minor victims elderly victims victims who might not have ever had opportunity to be confronted or deal with that offender are not re-victimized as a part of the parole process. So we are setting a shield of sorts in the statute while protecting the rights of the offender by allowing the board to disclose those either with an order of the board or an order of the court should it be determined that the needs of the offender outweigh those of the victim or to enhance the board's decision-making process, say there are allegations of untruths in the victim statement. I see no questions. No one has signed up to speak for
▶ Play
or against the bill. Representative Fyter, are you closed for the bill? I am, and I appreciate a good vote. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Ballinger Moves do pass Any discussion? All in favor say aye Any opposed? The bill passes Thank you Mr. Chair Thank you committee Without objection We're going to move to House Bill 1322. Representative Boyd, you're recognized. That's all right. Mr. Chair Mr. Chair
▶ Play
You recognize I present the bill Thank you There are several people in the audience that are out here I'm not going to ask them to come up here unless there are questions that I can't answer and at that point we will do that if that's okay But I know you have a long agenda, so I'm going to try to move this forward fast. So basically what this is is what happens, first of all, we're only talking about minors or juveniles. So what happens is a minor is arrested. They get fingerprinted and photographed. So they might be arrested, say, for a felony, but then it could be that charges are never brought or that's adjudicated down to a misdemeanor or whatever else. So, basically, we're having fingerprints go into a system, but we don't always have a great way to close the loop. And so, what this bill does is it will kind of move the football down the field by a three-pronged approach. One, we will focus on why A and B felonies are the ones that will be fingerprinted. Now, keep in mind, also, if someone is ever arrested as an adult, you go into the adult system. Two, there will be a way for if I were arrested but never charged, ACIC will be notified by the prosecutor that there were charges not filed so that you just don't have that hanging in the APHIS system where you're arrested for a felony and it's just indefinitely hanging out there. Then third, the Administrative Office of the Courts will be sure and send ACIC the adjudication of the final disposition of the charges. So that said, if there are any questions, I'll do the best I can to
▶ Play
answer them. Representative Ballinger, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Boyd, the thing that I have some concerns about is that, you know, well, or you may be able to help me, why is it a matter, what does it matter that we have a record of their fingerprints? To me, it seems like it may help investigations down the road if there are people who continue to commit a crime. If they don't, then what does it matter that their fingerprints are kept in
▶ Play
record? representative ballinger i appreciate that question that's why we're here today and i didn't really explain that so this all started with a constituent concern that wanted to go to the national guard and he had been arrested for a felony basically he had entered an abandoned building and then that was adjudicated down to a misdemeanor but there was never a closing of the loop so he was not able to move into the national guard after visiting with various agencies and people involved in juvenile issues apparently it's not infrequent that this happens where people have a background check something shows up and there's no final disposition and so that's why it's necessary because in my view I feel like my job is to facilitate people being taxpayers especially and so in a system that is supposed to be innocent and until proven guilty we're potentially tagging people with something that's that's not really happening so I think it's an important issue help that answer your question looks like you still have a question yeah just follow follow up
▶ Play
well and i and i understand that and so and i agree that what you're what you're seeking to do i think that we ought to do it i don't i mean i don't think if the kid is never charged i don't think that should keep him from being able to go into the military that seems kind of silly but the but at the same time if you have somebody who who if we have their fingerprint because they committed a crime, whether as a daughter or a child, and later on in the future they commit another crime and their fingerprints in the system, it will help solve that other crime possibly. And so that's my concern is, is there a better way to do this that doesn't take that little piece of information out of the system? And my guess is you may have worked on trying to do that. And so I guess that's the question is the tradeoff. Do we kick this out and lose that information in order to help this young man?
▶ Play
So people, if I'm found, it's not called guilty in the juvenile system. If I'm an adjudicated delinquent, you wind up fingerprinted and photographed. To me, the most significant concern is when I'm just arrested and charges are not filed or what have you, it's closing that loop. So they're still in the system. So, you know, this moves the football down the field. It's going to funnel the fewer people that are just arrested. But still, once those charges are, you know, adjudicated delinquent, then that information is going to be communicated back, which is part of the problem. So, yes, it is necessary. Yes, it moves it down the field. Does it solve all the problems? No. But we're also going to file an interim study. I've got a commitment from ACIC, state police, public defenders, the prosecutors, and the administrative offices of the court to continue to work through this over the next two years so that we can move the football even further down the field.
▶ Play
Representative Boyd, I want to make sure I understand the application of this bill, and you and I have talked a little bit about it, And I just want to make sure that I'm clear, and it doesn't go farther really than what I initially thought. But the situation that you spoke of with your constituent, was that individual adjudicated delinquent or not adjudicated delinquent? He was
▶ Play
arrested for a felony, but as I understand it, adjudicated delinquent for a misdemeanor. and there's not a closing of the loop so the administrative part of the the approach is to make sure the administrative offices of the courts sends that information back to acic so acic is going to develop a form which they apparently already have in adults but they don't have for juveniles to help make sure that all of this is is communicated so that the left hand knows what the right hand is doing and the let me uh ask for some backup here if that if you will grant me that liberty okay sure okay
▶ Play
just um it is my understanding that under current law we do not report these fingerprints once the juvenile has been reported as not being committed of a felony the problem is that the courts are not always prompt in providing that information so it's really as i understand it not changing what current law is it's making well it's changing current law to make it match what practice should have taken care of
▶ Play
that's my understanding let me i have several people in the audience uh so someone from the state police is here someone ACIC. Why don't we get
▶ Play
Brad up here? I think he probably could help me understand this better. He was instrumental in the drafting.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Brad Cazort with the Arkansas
▶ Play
Crime Information Center. so can you help explain what we're trying to do with
▶ Play
this bill yeah i think i can certainly give it a shot mr chairman the the situation in in this is on but it's okay is that better okay the situation in juveniles is completely different than than than people who are adults and juveniles who are arrested, again, are not convicted. They're determined to be delinquent if they're found, quote, guilty of the crime or acquitted. Juvenile records are the only records that actually physically get destroyed out of our system. Adult records stay with us forever, but juvenile records at a certain point actually get deleted. If a juvenile gets arrested and fingerprinted, fingerprints are what opens the file in our system. And if they ultimately don't get charged, you know, they may get arrested and the prosecutor determines that they're not going to file charges, we don't generally get that information back in order to take that information out of the system. So we may be having juveniles sitting there with an arrest on their record that will show up on a background check, essentially when they're going to the military, something that we could have taken out if we had known that there was no charges filed. So this bill really helps us to be able to make sure that we're trying to keep juvenile records as clean as possible, you know, for the period
▶ Play
of time that we have to keep them. So this bill is really just to ensure that what was supposed to happen is actually happening.
▶ Play
And part of the way it does that, Mr. Chairman, is it changes a little bit. Instead of printing every juvenile on the front end, we're going to print, they're going to print the juveniles who are alleged to have committed the most serious crimes. and then on the front end, but on the back end, print all of those who were actually determined to be found delinquent of any felony or Class A misdemeanor. So it lessens the pool of juveniles who are printed on the front end. It keeps the same pool of juveniles who are going to be ultimately printed on the back end if they're found delinquent,
▶ Play
which will help make sure that we're keeping the proper records. And, of course, you're familiar with the bill Senator Sanders has related to some of the Adam Walsh reporting related to juveniles. Does this take away from anything that Senator Sanders is trying to do or that we already have in place with regard to juvenile
▶ Play
offenders? No, because on the Adam Walsh, you're talking about convictions at that point. And in this case, any juvenile who was found guilty would be printed. So this bill wouldn't affect that at
▶ Play
all. Okay, and then my final question is the other day we had a bill related to taking DNA upon arrest, and I don't recall specifically how that treated juvenile offenders. Do you or Representative Boyd know what the interconnection would be between this? This doesn't speak as to DNA, but I guess I have a question about if we're treating photographs or fingerprints one way, have we done something else with regard to DNA, and I'm curious if we know how that interrelates. I can tell you, Mr. Chairman, I've read
▶ Play
that bill, and I don't think it has any effect on this bill or this bill has any effect necessarily on that bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 22 1:06:27
Representative Bennett. I can explain that
▶ Play
a little bit because I had the same concern. DNA evidence is never attached to a name or a charge. It's held in a separate system and would not show up on an employment check, which is what the concern here is. And to be clear,
▶ Play
a juvenile offender who's charged as an adult, this bill would not have any application as to. That's correct. Representative Vines, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. Thank you. Just a quick
▶ Play
question going back to the fingerprints. Well, let me make a comment first. I'm not sure the way your bill is drafted representative that it would help your situation in Fort Smith because I think the second paragraph there, it talks about even if they're taken into custody for commission of offense, that if committed by a adult would constitute as class YA or B felony. I think your guy, was he not picked up for commission of a felony before it was pled down?
▶ Play
but then it closes the loop so that when we actually decide not to charge file or file charges ACIC is notified or if we go through the court process then we make sure that the final adjudication is also sent to ACIC so that all the information surrounding the fingerprints on that person match.
▶ Play
Is that not already done? Generally speaking, Representative, yes, but we don't get information now of charges not filed, so we're maintaining records that we don't need to be maintaining because we're not getting that information. We do get the information from the AOC about juveniles who are adjudicated delinquent, but we don't necessarily get all the other information. particularly the charges not filed information.
▶ Play
Let me ask one more, and I promise you I'm not trying to cloud you, Bill, but do you not need the fingerprint of a 12-year-old because he may look a little bit different at 14, 15, or 16? The prints don't
▶ Play
Speaker 206 1:08:50
change. That's my point. Don't you need those prints because they won't change, but
▶ Play
his appearance might? Well, again, juvenile records are not maintained permanently. I mean, by law, even if they're adjudicated delinquent, but there is a point in time that all juvenile records get deleted out of our system. So the only thing that stays in our system forever are adult records. Okay. Thank you. Representative House, you're recognized for a question. I detect an undercurrent of something all my years as being with the Guard and the attorney for the Guard and dealing with security clearances. This I know. So the military, when you do a security clearance or an enlistment, they don't ask you if you've been convicted. They ask you if you've been arrested, and they want to know for anything other than a traffic offense. Now, I'll tell you why, and this is preparatory to my question. We all know that our armed services have things like nuclear weapons and very dangerous and very expensive and very technologically advanced hardware. So when they do the enlistment search or the security clearance search, you may have been charged with capital felony murder or arrested for a capital felony murder and the key witness died and there's no trial that can be brought against you because they don't have the proof. or you may have set a fire and burned down a school as a 14-year-old. That might be something you'd want to know if you were going to hand that person the keys to such a device I've described. If you've got a theft of property or a consistent history of theft of property, you might not want to entrust an individual, whether they were convicted or not or a juvenile or not, with those highly technological devices that can be sold on a terroristic market. Brother Drown's nodding his head. That's life. And, again, the FBI, when they do the background check for an enlistment or a security clearance, they don't ask you were you convicted or what. They do, they will come back and ask you the circumstances. You know, if you got a shoplift in charge, yeah, when I was 14, They'll let you go into that, and that probably won't keep you out. But that fingerprint is key to, and you could perhaps answer this, it seems like there are like 18 different points of identification they use, and that's one of the key ones. So do you just want the military not to know that you've got a juvenile out here that does do stuff like that and keep that information from the military? because that's what it's going to do. Representative, I'd like an answer to that for you is that under current law, if a juvenile is determined not to be found delinquent, is acquitted of the charge, the judge can order it sealed, and that record is then removed from our system, and you would not know about it anyway. What this bill does in addition to that
▶ Play
Speaker 206 1:12:08
is allow us now to be able to take care of those charges where those arrests where charges actually
▶ Play
were not filed. May I follow up, Mr. Chair? The Federal Bureau of Investigation, the United States Army, don't care what an Arkansas judge does. Their focus is on something entirely different than justice. Their focus is on protecting the country. So they really don't care what we do in our courts, and they don't care what we have in our ACIC. They just used the arrest record to make some very hard choices about what's going on for the defense of the nation, defense of the world. So that's the point I'm trying to make. And, Representative, let me say the NCIC record is based on ours. So when a record is created in ACIC, it's created in NCIC. When we take a record out of ACIC, it comes out of NCIC as well. So if a juvenile record has been deleted in our system, it's been deleted in the NCIC system as well. Representative Beck, did you have
▶ Play
a question? My question has already been answered. Representative
▶ Play
Copeland, you're recognized for a question. Representative Boyd, it sounds like that everybody that's going to be affected by this, state police, crime statistics, everybody is on board and thinks this is a good thing. Am I stating that correctly? My interpretation is
▶ Play
the people who are involved in this, ACIC, state police, administrative office of the courts, public defender's office, and the prosecutors believe that this will not put the public at undue harm. It will move the football down the field so that we have fewer people that wind up tagged for something that is later not adjudicated. again so i'm arrested but they never file charges there needs to be some closing of the loop to let people know that charges were never filed we might have arrested the wrong person these are our kids these are youth that are trying to move into another world and not all people that arrested were arrested correctly and they're not all bad people so yes you should be asking a lot of questions i appreciate that but this is an important step to protect our young people i mean i talked to a judge in sebastian county she says she deals with this eight to ten times a week so it's not like this is one isolated attempt that i just came up with and said hey i've got a constituent with an issue i started researching it and it was it bothers me in an innocent until proven guilty society that we're ready to tag people guilty just because they were arrested I realize law enforcement does a great job, and most of the time they get it right, but what if it were you? What if it were your kid? What if they had to do that? So, again, this moves the football down the field in a way that people believe or this group, you know, felt comfortable moving it. So I hope that answers your question. Yes, sir. Thank you. I see no further questions. is it appropriate for me to ask a question i mean of this committee i mean i my goal is not to uh i tried to work all the controversy out before i came here but i understand that all the people on this committee weren't in all the meetings where i was but rather than having a big production what i had hoped was to try to get everything worked out so you know if we need to so I'm sorry so do you want to I mean
▶ Play
you want to run your bill or you want to pull it down
▶ Play
and we'll do whatever you want I want this committee to be comfortable because I believe in this so if I need to send it to interim study if I need to do something different that's fine I mean I it's your call
▶ Play
I mean we've already heard everything but it may be best to pull it down at least and get with some of these members and talk. I'm
▶ Play
getting a little mixed feedback so may I come back to your committee say next week with a time? Let's pull it down and then
▶ Play
you can get with members and then figure out where you want to go from there. Okay, well
▶ Play
I want to go ahead and run it if you're okay with that. So you do want to run it?
▶ Play
I do, if you're okay with that. I would what I would rather do given the fact that you brought it up is I'd rather be pulled down for now we're going to be meeting we've got several other meetings including this afternoon pull it down and talk with committee members I want the chair of this
▶ Play
committee to be happy with whatever decision so i'm good with that i want people to this is i understand that this is a big issue and i want people to be comfortable with it so if uh we need to do that that i'm perfectly okay you did ask the question yes i did and i appreciate it mr chair and i appreciate your uh um letting flexibility in presenting this okay all right thank you thank you
▶ Play
Without objection, we're going to move to Senate Bill 152.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:18:19
Representative Servillo, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 152. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, Committee, for letting me bring to you SB 152. I ask the Chair's permission to have Elisa White assist me in this presentation. This is a simple bill. It's only 45 pages. I'm sure you all have read it and certainly want to open it up for discussion. Thank you. That's fine.
▶ Play
If you'll just introduce yourself, please, ma'am,
▶ Play
remind the committee who you are. Thank you. My name's Elisa White. I'm one of your Arkansas Uniform Law Commissioners. You'll remember me from the last time I came up here to confess that I'm one of the nerds who sits in rooms and debates bills. This is a uniform law that has already been enacted in Arkansas, and you'll see that a lot of the changes are fine-tuning of existing wording of the statute. I will give you the bottom line of this bill. It is basically to improve the enforcement of Arkansas child support orders across country lines in the international realm. The original Uniform Interstate Family Support Act, which is already the law in Arkansas and in all 49 other states, set some universal and uniform rules for enforcing family support orders in the United States. This bill amends that law to allow Arkansas child support orders to be enforced more easily abroad and to make sure children living in Arkansas are going to receive financial support from parents, even if they're outside the country. The bill also sets some guidelines and procedures for registration and enforcement of foreign support orders other than, you know, within our state. But I will note for the committee's benefit that it contains a provision that says no Arkansas court has to enforce an order from another country if that order violates our state's public policy. And so there is a mechanism there to object to any foreign order if there's a public policy basis for doing it or if the foreign court did not already have jurisdiction in that case. Any questions? Seeing no questions. No
▶ Play
one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Sevilla, are you closed for your bill
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:20:59
or would you like to close for your bill? I'm
▶ Play
closed for my bill and ask for a good vote. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Whitaker makes a motion
▶ Play
Speaker 161 1:21:17
to do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill
▶ Play
passes. Without objection, we're going to go back up to House Bill 1236, Representative Baltz. This bill was re-referred to the committee. It has an amendment on it that's been engrossed, so we're taking up the bill as engrossed. Representative Baltz,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. What we did on this bill with the amendment was just take out the crime part of it and just leave the civil part in. We had some issues with self-incrimination. With the prosecutors, they've looked at it, and that's what they've suggested, and that's what we did with the bill.
▶ Play
Take any questions? Any questions? and no one has signed up to speak for against the bill. Representative Baltz, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed for the bill and I'd appreciate a good vote. What's the pleasure of the committee? We have a motion from Representative Bennett. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. I'm going to go back up to the regular agenda. House Bill 1506, Representative Meeks and I'm reminding the committee we're going to make sure after three times passing over, we're going to move this stuff to the deferred agenda. It can always be brought back If the sponsor comes to talk to me, we have that option of bringing it back, but trying to clean up our agenda a little bit. House Bill 1543, Representative Neal. House Bill 1544, Representative Sullivan. House Bill 1570, Representative Armstrong. All right, I'm going to, without objection, we're going to recognize Representative Ballinger to present two Senate bills, Senate Bill 1001. that's on page four last item on our regular agenda thank you Mr. Chair
▶ Play
this is a relatively simple bill and what this does is this just enables the courts to be able to clean up title on tax sale property make it where there's a little more value maybe a little more money comes to the state And it just basically says that if there's an adjudication of the confirmation of the tax sale or a quiet title action, that that terminates the right to redeem on the property. So that would be the due process would be actually the court case. Notice everything is provided in that. Pretty simple bill, and I think it's just good cleanup stuff. So I'd be happy to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:24:55
take any questions. Representative Vines, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Make sure I follow, Representative. land that's purchased from the state that is cheated to the state for failure to pay property tax the property tax sale after three years and you buy it back typically you get that limited deed from the state that you have to go back and quiet title that quiet title would then quash any redemption periods
▶ Play
that's correct outstanding there yeah thank you Representative Ballinger The follow-up action, that's pretty much standard in terms of clearing the title from any property that's acquired at a tax sale, correct?
▶ Play
That is correct. I think that the issue is, and I've always thought that actually did clear it up, but I don't think there's any language anywhere that makes it clear that doing the quiet title action does clear up any right of
▶ Play
Speaker 4 1:25:51
redeems. What would be the time period for this?
▶ Play
90 days is standard, so you have a redemption period of 90 days. So if you buy it, you're going to get your quiet title action done. Well, we can get them done basically in 60 days. So essentially you've got 30 days, but that's not typical. Usually it takes a little longer than that before you ever even file it.
▶ Play
So the point of this bill is really to make certain the fact that once a property is bought at a tax sale, the purchaser could immediately turn around, file a quiet title action and confirm title and cut off any redemption period or other rights that the delinquent tax, the delinquent owner might have.
▶ Play
Correct. And the reason why I think that it would be justified because now you have all sorts of notice requirements that are being put out there and they've not shown up and petitioned or entered.
▶ Play
in the matter. This just occurred to me. I've seen occasions where mortgage holders, lien holders on property were not notified by the state. What would be the implication as to a lien holder or a mortgage holder? Quite honestly, I've had the state even tell me that a lot of times they don't even worry about notifying a bank or a mortgage holder that the property is delinquent. And so I guess my question would be, what would be the impact to a mortgage holder or a lien holder? None
▶ Play
at all, because a mortgage would be a super priority. So if they have that priority already and they're not notified, now if you notify them in the quiet title action and they don't answer it, then you could cut them off. But if they're not notified in the quiet title action, then whatever rights they had to the property is still there. And I guess
▶ Play
that's my question just to confirm that the intent would still be that if you were going to attempt a quiet title you would still need to do your own title search maybe or obtain a commitment to look at it. You would notify the delinquent owner as well as any prior mortgage holder or lien holder. That's correct. And if you don't, whatever rights
▶ Play
they had, they still have. Any other questions? No
▶ Play
one has signed up to speak for against the bill. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Beck? We have a motion. Do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill is passed. and if
▶ Play
the chair is okay I wouldn't mind running Senate Bill 612 as well
▶ Play
without objection we're going to move back up to Senate Bill 612 you recognized this
▶ Play
is a bill that actually worked with state police to work on and essentially what it does is it opens up that if you're a legal permanent resident then you can still apply for a concealed carry permit so if you're here legally and you have a permanent residency status and you can go ahead and apply for concealed carry permit just like a citizen in the state of Arkansas. And I'd be happy to take any questions. Any questions from the committee? No one has signed up to speak for
▶ Play
against the bill. Would you like to close for the bill? Yes, and I would move to pass. Can we have a motion to do pass? Any discussion? All in favor
▶ Play
Speaker 161 1:29:34
say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Bill passes.
▶ Play
Okay, I understand we're going to pass over House Bill 1571. Representative Armstrong, you have some amendments coming. House Bill 1598. Representative Douglas, House Bill 1599. Senate Bill 152. Senator Hutchinson, we passed it already. Okay. House Bill 1624, Representative Meeks House Bill 1631, Representative Douglas Pass over House Bill 1371 and 1374 House Bill 1400 Okay House Bill 1403 House Bill 1441 Representative Bain House Bill 1538 Representative Ballinger, you want to pass over that for now? That's the Dower and Courtesy Without objection, we're going to move House Bill 1538 to deferred House Bill 1648 Representative Letting, pass over. Okay, we're going to pass over House Bill 1660. We're going to pass over House Bill 1666 and House Bill 1667. Is there anybody on
▶ Play
Speaker 251 1:31:55
the committee that has a bill they want to
▶ Play
run? All right, Representative Broadway, you're recognized. House Bill 1672. Which one?
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. This is an extremely complex bill. It concerns who is eligible to be an executor of a will or an administrator in a state. Frankly, that was sarcastic. The only thing this bill does is diminish the age from 21 to 18. Basically, my thought in this bill is 18-year-olds are able to do contract. They're able to do essentially everything else under the law, and there's no reason why they should be prohibited from serving in this capacity if they meet the other
▶ Play
Speaker 153 1:32:58
requirements. That's my bill. Hold on just a second.
▶ Play
1672, the only language that's changed in existing law is page 2, lines 2 and 3. I got it. He changed the age. He changed the
▶ Play
age. Okay. All right. I see no questions. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Represent Broadway. I
▶ Play
close for my bill and would move for do
▶ Play
pass. We have a motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed?
▶ Play
The bill passes. Thank you so much. With regard to the next bill on the agenda, I believe that's going to be re-referred to Aging and Children. It's part of an AOC package and relates to some other bills that are currently assigned to that committee. So I would ask that that be well, I know you can't remove it until you officially get the word, but that's the deal. Okay, thank you. Which
▶ Play
one did you say were removed? 16? Okay, without objection, we're also moving Representative Vines House Bill 1667 to the deferred list. Who else on the committee has bills to run? Representative Rushing, what bill do you have? 528? Okay. You're recognized to present Senate Bill
▶ Play
528. Thank you, Mr. Chair. committee. This bill is just redefining and make a clarification on the meaning of malicious in use with recreational use status. As most of you may recall, the Albert Pike flooding that happened several years ago, there was some misconception on exactly what malice was. And so this will just clear up for when And landowners want to make their property available for recreational use. This will kind of help protect them, changing the actually clarifying malicious to mean an intentional act of misconduct that the actor is aware is likely to result in harm. And malicious does not mean neglect
▶ Play
or reckless conduct. All right. I see no questions from the committee. All right, we have one individual signed up to speak against the bill. George Wise. Mr. Wise, if you'd take a seat at the end of the
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:36:22
table. If you would, have a seat. State your name and who you represent, and you may make your statement. George Wise, Arkansas Trial Lawyers Association. I'm the current president. Punitive damages has been well-defined in the law, and there's a well-defined body of case law that defines punitive damages, and it's always been either intentional conduct or reckless conduct. And what this bill does is makes punitive damages in the context of the recreational use statute only intentional conduct, so that if you had someone that, for example, that you'd invited onto your land to hunt, you knew they were drunk and they shot someone, not intentionally but recklessly, that would no longer fit under the definition of punitive damages. It would take away rights from the person who is injured by that reckless conduct to claim punitive damages, so on that basis we oppose it, and I'd ask you to vote
▶ Play
no. Representative Broadway, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sir, I'm wondering, how does this interface with, like, DWI or BWI? We recently passed a BWI statute where if someone's boating, a victim flies out, intoxicated victim flies out of the boat, hits a pylon, sustains head injuries, dies. That's not intentional conduct. Does that remove their ability to seek punitive damages?
▶ Play
Speaker 260 1:38:04
It might if this were on a private lake that someone was letting others use.
▶ Play
Yeah, sure. Thank you. Any other questions from the committee? Thank you for your testimony. I believe no one else has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Bennett,
▶ Play
Speaker 264 1:38:30
would you like to close for your bill? Well, I
▶ Play
will. Representative Rushing would like to close. Representative Rushing, sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd appreciate a good vote on this. This is to protect our property owners and the private property rights and to be able to open up recreational use of the property, and so I would appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote. You move do pass. Yes. Okay. We have a motion do pass. Any discussion? All
▶ Play
Speaker 161 1:39:04
in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. The bill passes.
▶ Play
Representative Petty, you're recognized to present House Bill 1855. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair and Committee. I don't know if my folks are still here, but if it's okay with you, I would like to ask Cody Hyland to join me. And I'll go ahead and get started while he makes his way to the table. This is an act to be known as the Courthouse Dog Child Witness Support Program to recognize the special circumstances and needs of a child witness during a criminal court proceeding to protect the child witness from unnecessary emotional discomfort or anguish by providing for the assistance of a certified facility dog and for other purposes. I really like this bill because I'm a child advocate and I just think that to comfort a child at the time that after a child has been raped or sexually assaulted and is in court, and if you can have a big old dog come up that has been trained for several years to be next to that child with a handler, I think that it would comfort the child and I think it would just be a great thing for kids. And I would love for Mr. Hyland to say a few words about
▶ Play
Speaker 270 1:40:51
it. You wouldn't mind? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I know that everybody's hungry. I'll try to be brief. When people ask me what, you know, we've had a lot of high-profile cases in our district. People ask me what the most memorable one was. And I immediately go back to an 8-year-old little boy who was repeatedly raped by his father and had an idyllic childhood with the exception of that. And I don't know that people fully understand what these young kids have to go through. First of all, they have to disclose. And then once that happens, they have to meet with law enforcement. They have to meet with the CAC. They have to tell their story over and over again. Then they come to our office, and we meet with them four or five times before trial. They're not talking about things like we talk about things. When they talk about rape, they have to talk in terms of penetration, things that we wouldn't want to talk about just together and alone in a room, much less in front of 12 strangers, including the monster who raped them. And so what I would like to see happen with this legislation is to provide them with some level of comfort, some level of anxiety relief as it relates to testifying in a hearing or in a criminal trial setting. And so with that, we'd be happy to answer questions about the Courthouse Dogs Foundation, which is where we're going to try to get our dog through. We're in the process of doing that right now. Defer to the chairman and the committee
▶ Play
members for questions. Any questions? Representative
▶ Play
Scott, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I love this idea so, so much. I look at this picture of this dog, and I'm thinking, this is just perfect, absolutely perfect. Can you tell me how much this
▶ Play
Speaker 270 1:42:46
will cost? Yes, ma'am. The Courthouse Dogs Foundation, it's a foundation. They have money, and we've applied for a dog through that program. Not only do they pay for the substantial cost of the dog and the training, and the training, I will tell you, is a two-year process for the dog so that they're not going to bark, they're not going to interrupt the proceeding. And so it's a pretty high standard. So there's no cost there. They also provide a $1 million liability policy that they pay for. We don't have to pay for it. The only thing we have to pay for if we get the dog is the upkeep of the animal. It will be in our office every day. It will be handled by my victim witness coordinator, Susan Bradshaw, who I will give credit to for this idea because we're just not smart enough sometimes to get it, but they are because they spend more time with the victims than we do, and they care about these kids. And it's not about giving the prosecution a leg up. This is about being able to provide those children with some level of relief when they have to face the monster who attacked them. And so when you're facing a monster, it's nice to have a friend,
▶ Play
and that's what this legislation is about. A follow-up, please, Mr. Chair? Possibly some of us legislators could take on the job of maybe providing food for these animals. I know I'd certainly be happy to do that
▶ Play
Speaker 270 1:44:02
in Benton County. Well, I appreciate that. And I will add, too, that there are 27 other states in which courtroom dogs have been implemented. And it's a cutting-edge thing. Oklahoma recently passed legislation relative to this, similar to this. And so Arkansas is going to be on the cutting edge of an issue that I think is very important to our children.
▶ Play
Thank you. A few questions just to make sure I'm clear on this. This only applies in criminal trials. That's correct. And then there's nothing in here that mandates any prosecutor go out and have to acquire one. It's strictly just enabling the opportunity if that's what the prosecutor's office decides to
▶ Play
Speaker 270 1:44:39
do. That's correct, Mr. Chairman. I think the language states that if there is a certified facility dog within the jurisdiction within which the case is being
▶ Play
tried. And then there's also, I think, the last provision. there's basically a jury instruction that would be read to the jurors just to clarify that they're not supposed to give any greater weight based on that. It's not supposed to prejudice
▶ Play
Speaker 270 1:45:03
any party. That's correct. And also, Mr. Chairman, there's a voir dire opportunity. When prosecutors and defense counsel have the jurors there and they're questioning them about things before trial, there will be an opportunity to voir dire on this issue as well. Thank you.
▶ Play
I see no further questions. It looks like we have a couple people signed up. The other is Susan Bradshaw. Mr. Chairman, we'd sign Susan up just in case there were other questions. And then Diana Tyler. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:45:47
the committee. Actually, I just wanted to come talk about something that was nice. You all know me in my role at Community Correction and prior to that at the Department of Correction. During my stay at ADC, I had the privilege of helping start a program there called Pause in Prison. It's a little more than three years old. We take shelter dogs and train them. The inmates do. They live with the inmates so that they're more adoptable. Also during that process, we have trained specialty dogs, just the kind of dogs like Mr. Hyland is talking about. We have done reading dogs for schools. We have done dogs for therapists who worked for abused, neglected, and battered children and several other kinds, and I wanted to talk just briefly about the impact of the dog. There may be some hesitancy on someone's part about having a dog in a courtroom. Those dogs are highly trained. They will be the best-behaved person in that courtroom, even though they have four feet, I promise you. but the impact they have on children is profound. The reading dogs are able to take a child who struggles with reading and give them the confidence to keep trying. That is what these dogs will do, give them the confidence, the stability, and the security. And most of all, which is critical in these kinds of cases, dogs don't judge. So I want to support this idea, this concept, and actually commend Faulkner County for looking at it. That's it. Thank you. Seeing no further questions,
▶ Play
no one else has signed up to speak for or against the bill.
▶ Play
Representative Petty, you can close for your bill. Yes,
▶ Play
I'm close for my bill, and I ask for a due pass, please. Okay, we have a motion due pass by Representative Petty. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Looks like we have time for maybe one more bill before lunch. We're going to go back up to the top of the agenda. Representative Neal, you're recognized to present House Bill 1543.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. 1543 deals with state prisoners in county jails. I've been working on this for a little while. It's an agreed-to bill by the governor's office, AAC and DCC, and I have Director Sharp with me. Mr. Chairman, if you could recognize her, and I'll let her speak to the
▶ Play
Speaker 281 1:48:29
bill. You're recognized. Thank you. Sheila Sharp, Director, Arkansas Community Correction. And Representative Neal is correct. We have worked with the governor's office and the Sheriff's Association and Association of Arkansas Counties to try to give the sheriffs, I guess, a little relief from previous legislation that would require 30 days prior to the departments paying for any emergency medical care. And what this would do is allow us to pay those costs upon receipt of a valid commitment order and require the sheriffs to let us know when that emergency care happens.
▶ Play
any questions no one has signed up to speak for or against okay actually we do Wendy Kelly she's okay alright so no one else has signed up representative Neal would you like to close for your bill I'm closed for my bill okay representative Farrar motion do pass we have a motion do pass any discussion all in favor say aye any opposed the bill passes that'll conclude our business this morning a few notes we are going to come back upon adjournment this afternoon we've got several matters of legislation members i would ask that you if at all possible be here because we there's we've still got some big issues on the agenda. Members of the public, we're going to be doing business this afternoon, so if you've got a bill you're interested in, you may want to come back this afternoon. I would also remind the committee we have a planned event this evening, so I would certainly appreciate if you're able to attend. With that, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1203

2:05 - 23:42 74 segments 16 speakers

HB1240

23:42 - 39:54 57 segments 10 speakers

HB1532

39:54 - 44:10 16 segments 5 speakers

HB1456

44:10 - 45:39 5 segments 2 speakers

SB698

45:39 - 49:21 10 segments 3 speakers

SB58

49:21 - 51:31 6 segments 2 speakers

SB57

51:31 - 55:05 9 segments 2 speakers

HB1322

55:05 - 1:18:07 74 segments 10 speakers

SB152

1:18:07 - 1:21:42 11 segments 5 speakers

HB1236

1:21:42 - 1:24:32 7 segments 3 speakers

SB1001

1:24:32 - 1:28:56 22 segments 5 speakers

SB612

1:28:56 - 1:32:18 9 segments 4 speakers

HB1672

1:32:18 - 1:34:57 11 segments 4 speakers

SB528

1:34:57 - 1:40:06 19 segments 7 speakers

HB1855

1:40:06 - 1:48:08 27 segments 6 speakers

HB1543

1:48:08 - 1:50:34 6 segments 3 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
114 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
20 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
16 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
3 segments
Representative Brent Talley Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 36
10 segments
Speaker 38
1 segment
Representative Sue Scott Unverified
10 segments
Representative Marshall Wright Unverified
7 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
28 segments
Representative Mary Broadaway Unverified
18 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 49
1 segment
Speaker 80
1 segment
Speaker 81
3 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 106
1 segment
Representative David Whitaker Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 117
1 segment
Representative John T. Vines Unverified
15 segments
Chair Unverified
4 segments
Representative Douglas House Chair Unverified
21 segments
Representative John Baine Unverified
3 segments
Chief Lane Unverified
1 segment
Solomon Graves Unverified
5 segments
Representative Justin Boyd Unverified
24 segments
Speaker 22
1 segment
Speaker 206
2 segments
Elisa White Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 161
3 segments
Representative Scott Baltz Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 4
1 segment
Speaker 251
1 segment
Speaker 153
1 segment
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 260
4 segments
Speaker 264
1 segment
Representative Rebecca Petty Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 270
9 segments
Speaker 274
4 segments
Representative Micah S. Neal Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 281
2 segments