Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House State Agencies and Govt'l Affairs

March 20, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1425 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ommittee next We're going to take Representative Tucker For House Bill 1425 Without objection All right, hearing no objection Represent…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1119 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…r special order, and we have Representative Love to present House Bill 1119.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB995 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…t, so without objection, we'll go ahead and hear that bill. Senate Bill 995. Hearing no objections, Senator, you're recognized to prese…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Go ahead and take a bill by Senator Elliott up first on our queue. Bill did just come over from the Senate last night, so without objection, we'll go ahead and hear that bill. Senate Bill 995. Hearing no objections, Senator, you're recognized to present your bill.
▶ Play
All right, thank you, Mr. Chair, and good morning, committee members. Right now, we find ourselves in a position where we have a huge gap in critical skills, and that's what we are dealing with. We might have seen that coming had we taken the time to stop and take a look. But what we generally do is wait until we get into a position where there is a crisis and then we decide that we are going to act. And it's a really good thing that we are addressing that middle-level skills gap right now. What this bill proposes to do, and you might notice just by the sponsors alone, we really did strive to make this something that is bipartisan because this is not about anything except the future of our state. So to keep us from getting into the same predicament with what I refer to as skills of necessity with some emphasis on those that are required you to have a degree, the degreed professionals, and some of those really, really specially trained, highly skilled people, I ask the Department of Workforce Services to work with boards and professions and other agencies that are appropriate for us in the interim to take a look at and do a little study about what do we need for quality of life in our state. And the whole idea behind looking at all these professions and looking ahead is we are never going to have the communities that we want. We're forever going to have to be making compromises about what kind of folks we allow to do certain practices and how we're going to attract them to our communities. And so what we hope to do is not find ourselves in the same predicament for these professions of necessity as we do right now by doing some planning and thinking about quality of life ahead of us. So that's it, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I'll take any questions if anybody has
▶ Play
Speaker 6 2:15
any. Questions from the committee? Representative Douglas. Yes, Senator. Dr., kind of give me an example of what's wrong and how this is going to fix it. Right now, for example, teachers. We can start there.
▶ Play
Good. In many places, it's so difficult to find teachers, and in many instances, we don't have enough teachers in certain areas. And the same thing is true with it. You might live someplace where it's difficult, especially in underserved areas, to get doctors to locate there. They just don't. Or lawyers. or you might have to have somebody drive an hour just to get a plumber, for example. And so what we're trying to do is make sure that we are not just ignoring that because all the things we face in our schools and many of the other ills we have in some of our communities is because we are not attracting and we are not preparing for people in these professions of necessity to even want to come to our communities. And I think we shouldn't just wait for it. And we need to even look ahead to what are going to be the demands of the future. For example, right now we tend to say don't bother with getting a degree in psychology. I think that's a huge demand. I mean, especially for me and now here in the last three or four days, I could use one probably on a daily basis. But I think we say we don't need it primarily because we are not acknowledging all the mental health needs, for example. and by the time we get around to acknowledging it we're probably going to have discouraged so many people from being psychologists and psychiatrists there will be another big gap those are just some examples of the things I see when I look down the road thank you Representative Link you recognize for a question
▶ Play
Speaker 11 4:00
in one of our other committees we passed a bill and made it to the house four never made it any further it was Representative Womack If he's in here, I don't think so. And it talked about how many boards and commissions there are. And that was actually, the idea was try to eliminate and not eliminate, but at least lease up some of these boards and commissions. There are so many of them. And actually we weren't even able to identify how many there was. And so I'm wondering how long is it going to take? Can we actually accomplish this by the end of 2016 to find, identify all
▶ Play
these boards and commissions and have meetings with them? Actually, we are not, we will just be dealing with, for example, if we determine we don't have enough, say, doctors in a certain area, we would just deal with the Medical Board Society. We're not trying to do anything about getting rid of all these boards and commissions. What the bill requires is that we work with the ones that are appropriate for those areas where we either have now or might have a gap moving to the future. But it's not about trying to get
▶ Play
Speaker 11 5:01
rid of any boards. Well, no, no. I didn't think it was about that, Senator. I just didn't know how the Logistics-wise, if it's possible to meet with all these people, and especially to
▶ Play
have a report in basically a year and a half. Yeah, I did something parallel to this back in the last interim with the re-entry bill that we had. This was the same procedure that I used, and that's why I feel comfortable about it and without getting a lot of other people all wrapped up in it. And I didn't take your question that way, Representative. I just know
▶ Play
we'll get who we need to. Thank you,
▶ Play
Chair. Representative Tosh, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator, make sure I understand. It sounds like all you're trying to do here is just target those areas where the workforce help is needed in certain areas and be able to assist them in making sure the necessary services are provided in that area.
▶ Play
Is that correct? That's correct because we've done that with the middle skills right now, and that's why we're huffing and puffing over workforce services right now. That's what I thought. They don't want us to get into the same position all over again, which we are there to some extent. Thank you very much. Additional
▶ Play
questions from the committee? All right, seeing none, anyone here from the public to speak for or against this bill? Seeing none, Senator Elliott, are you closed for your bill? I am closed, Mr. Chair. It's a pleasure to committee. Representative Gray moves to do pass. All in favor, say aye. Opposed? All right, Senator Elliott, you've passed your bill Thank you all so much, I appreciate it All right, committee next We're going to take Representative Tucker For House Bill 1425 Without objection All right, hearing no objection Representative Tucker You have an amendment to add to the bill Before we start on that, Mr. Chairman
▶ Play
Speaker 24 6:55
I just want to wish Senator Elliott a happy birthday Before
▶ Play
she leaves the room Thank you if it looked like that bill
▶ Play
Speaker 24 7:10
was going to have some opposition I would have made the birthday known earlier yes I do have a very short and simple amendment it's some language that I copied and pasted from an Alabama statute they have on the books it's very similar to the bill I'm proposing today generally just to give the background for the amendment The bill deals with campaign finance issues and communications related to campaigns, specifically electioneering communications. And this amends the definition of electioneering communications to kind of specify and help narrow the definition. But essentially, the gist of the bill, which I'll get to in just a minute, is if you make a communication that identifies a candidate with a certain number of days before the election, then you have to take certain action to report who's paying for the ad and whatnot. And one issue that was brought to my attention is you could say that if, for example, gubernatorial candidate Asa Hutchinson was at an Arkansas football game before the election and they identified that on the air, that that could qualify as an electioneering communication. And so basically this will add to the definition of electioneering communication. The only reasonable conclusion to be drawn from the presentation and content of the communication is that it is intended to influence the outcome of the election. And so I think if there's an inadvertent mention of a candidate on TV or radio, which is the types of communication the bill seeks to regulate, then those would be excluded from the reporting requirements that this bill seeks to impose. And so I think it helps narrow and focus the bill in an appropriate way. So I'd appreciate a good vote on the
▶ Play
amendment. All right, committee, are there questions on the amendment? Seeing none, it's a pleasure to the committee. All right, we have a motion to adopt the amendment. Discussion on that motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Tucker. Your amendment's adopted. You are recognized to present House Bill 1425 as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, members
▶ Play
Speaker 24 9:12
of the committee. Basically, there's a lot of language in the bill. essentially what it's about is the integrity of our political system in my view and it seeks to close two major loopholes in our contribution reporting requirements both of which came up in the 2014 election cycle the first is if a candidate coordinates with an outside group and that candidate purchases so let me just back up for one second and again the types of communication that this bill seeks to regulate are only radio and TV commercials so anything related to The mail pieces, Internet advertising, flyers, handouts are not touched by the bill. Only television and radio advertising is essentially regulated by the bill. And so in that context, if a candidate coordinates with an outside group, like just take, for example, in the 2016 election cycle, if Representative Bell wanted to spend $100,000 on my campaign, he could do so under the current law. and I'm hoping that he does want to do that but he could do so under the current law but instead of directly contributing that money to my campaign all we would have to do is he and I could get together we could put a TV ad together we could completely coordinate about it I could be in the ad and we could talk about the fact that I'm a candidate for office then he could pay the $100,000 for the TV ad and it would be completely legal under Arkansas's current laws we're virtually the only state in the entire country that allows that type of coordination to not... And so what this bill would do is say you can still do that. It would just constitute an in-kind contribution to the campaign. It would be subject to whatever the contribution campaign limits are, which is $2,000 right now. Virtually every state in the country has done this. The federal government has done this. And so anyway, that's the first part of the bill. Basically, the second part is... And this came up in the 2014 election cycle, as I mentioned. And so if you identify a candidate a certain number of days before the election, and the way it's written in my bill right now is 90 days before general election and 60 days before primary election. If you identify a candidate in a television or radio ad, then you have to disclose to the Secretary of State who paid for the ad. And that is another major loophole in our bill. and it came up, I'll just, you know, two examples that it came up in the 2014 election cycle were the Attorney General's primary where there were these ads that came out against our current Attorney General, Leslie Rutledge, but nobody knew who paid for them, nobody knew who was behind them, and then the other was in the Supreme Court race between Tim Cullen and new Supreme Court Justice Robin Wynn, and again, there were ads that came out, nobody knew who paid for them, Those ads essentially painted Tim Cullen as a person who defends child pornographers. And I don't know if it made a difference in the outcome of the election, but it may not have. But in any event, I think everyone agrees that anonymous large money ads coming in to influence the outcome of the election that are completely anonymous, that affects the integrity of our political system. And so this bill would not seek to affect in any way whatsoever the content of someone's communication because that's their First Amendment right. All the bill would seek to do is, if you identify a candidate in an ad, TV or radio ad, 90 days before a general election, 60 days before a primary, you have to report to the Secretary of State's office who's funding your ad. So those are the primary two purposes of the bill. It's primarily drawn on a federal statute. The definition of electioneering communication essentially mirrors what's in the federal statute. The federal statute was challenged, and it was not all parts of it were challenged, but a big part of it was challenged and upheld by the Supreme Court of the United States in a case called McConnell v. FEC. In Citizens United, the Supreme Court overturned some parts of the Federal Campaign Finance Act, but none that is in this particular bill. I just wanted to highlight for you the places where I sort of tweaked the federal law for the purposes of this particular bill. The first is, in the federal law, it only applies to electioneering communication 60 days before general and 30 days before primary, and I've extended that to 90 and 60 days. That part has been challenged and upheld by a federal court, and when a federal court uphold that law, they don't say, we uphold it because it's 60 days and 30 days. They say, we uphold it because it's a clear number of days before the election, and this certainly has that clarity. On top of that, other states have extended that federal window in their own state law. For example, in Alabama, they have a 120-day window before a general election. And in Connecticut, they actually cover the entire pre-election period. And so it's basically the gist is the entire election year. And I think it should be obvious, because we're talking about money and politics, that it affects both parties, but just to try to drive that home a little bit, that this is a bipartisan issue, the plaintiff in the Connecticut case that sought to invalidate the Connecticut law was the Democratic Governors Association. And so this is an issue that both parties at points may have a problem with, but in my opinion, both parties should get behind because, as I said, in my opinion, it affects the integrity of the political system. And then as far as the financial aspects of the bill go, I sort of lowered those across the board because it just takes less money to affect campaigns in Arkansas than it does federal elections. And so, for example, if you have a disbursement leading to a radio or TV ad, the federal law is that it has to be a $200 disbursement that's reported. I did $100 because that's what our expenditure requirements are for candidates. The contribution to a political advertisement, the minimum in the federal law is $1,000. I lowered that to $100,000, which is still twice as big as the contribution reporting requirements for candidate contributions. And then the aggregate distribution. So in the federal law, before an election nearing communication has to be reported to the Secretary of State, they have to spend an aggregate of $10,000 in Arkansas. I lowered that to $5,000, again, just because it takes less money to affect an election in Arkansas. And just as another example, Alabama actually has that as $1,000. So they have the threshold even much lower than Arkansas does. And then just two more quick ones. One is in the federal law, once you make your electioneering communication, the disclosure, you have to report your contributors within 24 hours. And I actually extended that to three days just to make it a little easier for the people who have to report that. And then the other tweak is you have to do it no later than the close of the business day before the election. And then I changed the added threshold number of viewers. So in Arkansas, if you have an electioneering communication that hits 25,000 viewers in a statewide election, 2,500 viewers in an election for a legislative district, or 10% of the population in any other state or local, municipal, or county election, then it triggers the statute. And so just a few more points, and I'll take questions and wrap up because I'm sure there are some questions. Other states have actually gone further than what's in this bill. Other states have regulated print and Internet ads. I didn't include that in the bill just because I thought we need to take this step first. But other states have done that, and federal courts have upheld challenges to the regulation of print and Internet ads. Other states have said that if a contributor to an electioneering communication is a corporation, you can actually, this is a legal term of art, pierce that corporate veil and get to the original human donor. I'm not seeking to do that here. so you could still have a corporate contribution to an electioneering communication. And there's others, but in any event, I've also run this past Graham Sloan at the Ethics Commission. As you know, agencies don't normally take positions advocating for or against bills, but he's vetted it, and he doesn't see an issue with it. I also ran it past the Attorney General's office. I met personally with the Attorney General and also Corey Cox and Carl Vogelpohl. Asked them for a constitutional analysis of the bill. They made one suggestion to change the bill, which I incorporated, but they did not identify any constitutional issues.
▶ Play
Speaker 32 17:42
And so that's basically the gist of it,
▶ Play
but I'd be glad to take any questions. Representative Tucker, I have two questions that I'd like to hear from you on. You just mentioned a couple moments ago in your presentation that corporate contributions would fall under this. Did I understand
▶ Play
Speaker 24 18:05
that correctly? If a corporate contribution contributes to an electioneering communication and the entity that buys the electioneering communication has to report who contributed to pay for the electioneering communication, then yes.
▶ Play
My question goes to the fact that your bill requires that to then be reported as in-kind, which effectively is prohibited under Amendment 94, also known as Issue 3. so aren't you in effect prohibiting those uh advertisements let me clarify so again i'll just just for the purposes
▶ Play
Speaker 24 18:41
of big picture the bill i kind of separated into two different categories one is a coordinated communication and the other is an electioneering communication that does not have coordination only the coordinated communication counts as an in-kind contribution and what I'm talking about is an election airing communication where there's no coordination and so the entity that buys that TV or radio ad can spend as much money as they want and they can say whatever they want because that's their first amendment right and in the course of that does not count as an in-kind contribution to the candidates campaigns because they can spend as much as they want and in the course of raising money to buy that ad they can raise money from corporations or whatever And that's not prohibited by Issue 3 because it's not a contribution to the
▶ Play
campaign. So a nonprofit, let's go to nonprofit corporations, a nonprofit that wants to purchase an ad addressing an issue of concern to that nonprofit that falls within the period that you've outlined here, how would that ad be treated? If they spend $5,000 on the
▶ Play
Speaker 24 19:50
ad and it's within 90 days of a general and 60 days of a primary, They can still run whatever ad they want. All they have to do is file a statement with the Secretary of State's office identifying every person who contributed
▶ Play
$100 toward the purchase of that ad. Okay, one additional question. You mentioned in the Rutledge campaign back in the primary, I know you and I have talked a little bit about the coordination aspect of this. I know that came up in the general election, the issue of coordination. um i as you and i have discussed regarding um coordination i i generally agree with i think where you're going with the whole aspect of of banning coordination why are you going so much further with the second basically what's the second portion of your bill A couple things.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 20:51
First, on the coordination issue, I'm glad you raised that because I intended to mention it in my presentation, but the federal law does not actually define coordination, but the federal regulations do and the FEC guidelines, and at the chairman's suggestion, actually incorporated those FEC guidelines into our statute to provide clarity as to when a candidate and an outside group coordinate. So that's actually another change I made to the federal law, which I believe will help clarify what can constitute a coordination. Basically, to answer the main part of your question, Mr. Chairman, we've got two issues here, in my opinion. They could be run in separate bills, I guess, but they both deal with electioneering communications, which is why I put them in the same bill. We don't have a definition of electioneering communications in our campaign finance laws right now, so I just grouped them all together in the same bill. But to me, both issues are major loopholes in our campaign finance law, and so that's why I'm pushing for both of them. The coordination aspect, as I said, we're virtually the only state in the country that has not banned that. There was a complaint filed on the coordination issue that you mentioned by the Ethics Commission, and they dismissed it by a unanimous vote because it's not illegal in Arkansas right now. So there was no illegality in that whatsoever. But in my opinion, it should be prohibited moving forward to the extent that it's more than $2,000. On the other issue, again, I just think if you have a group that comes in and spends $400,000 or $500 or $1 million on a campaign and the people of Arkansas have no idea who's funding that, then that threatens the integrity of our political system. The basis of our entire contribution and expenditure reports that we all have to go through ourselves is because the public has a right to know who's funding our campaigns because they need to be able to examine our decisions that we make in the chamber. And just to take one more example, in a judicial race, you could have a judge that an organization contributed essentially a million dollars to that judge's campaign, but the public does not know who contributed and that judge is sitting on a case in which that entity is a party in the case and that threatens the integrity of the judicial system and the people of Arkansas have a right to know who is funding that particular judge's campaign and so anyway, they are somewhat separate issues but they're also somewhat related they're both important in my opinion that's why I included them both in the bill and they're
▶ Play
both in the federal statute Alright, committee, I do have a couple of questions We have a special order set for 9 a.m. We're at 9 a.m. With committee's indulgence, we can continue on this for a little bit, or we need to take care of our special order. I'm going to just solicit some feedback from the committee on how you all would like to proceed.
▶ Play
Representative Bennett. If I might suggest, I think this is such a critical issue to our state and to this body. It takes a lot to digest the things that are in this bill. I would love if we could have a little bit additional time to consider this at a later time. But I do want to be sure. In
▶ Play
response to that, Representative Bennett, I will say that it's the chair's intention to call a meeting Monday afternoon. Everyone, I believe, is aware that we have canceled the constitutional amendments meeting that was scheduled, and hopefully everyone had that time blocked out in their schedule already. And it is my intention to have a meeting Monday afternoon following adjournment, and we could take this back up. Again, I'm just looking for guidance from the committee at this point. If someone wants to tell me how you all would like to proceed, someone put them put that in the form of a motion we'll uh we'll we'll we'll address it if I might I move that we
▶ Play
make this a special order of business at the beginning of our meeting on Monday afternoon all right well we have a motion
▶ Play
is debatable motion discussion on the motion representative Tosh we don't need a second representative Tosh this is not the Senate thankfully all right all right representative Tucker are you generally you have anything to say on on that point of discussion I serve with the pleasure of the committee mr. chairman all right well we're we're trying to extend the courtesy to you if you would like to go ahead we certainly wouldn't want to stay in your way but I think we do have the motion from representative Bennett committee all in favor all right All right, Representative Tucker, anyone opposed? All right, Representative Tucker, we'll take you up as the first item of business, set as a special order at our meeting on Monday afternoon following adjournment.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 25:52
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I do recognize it's a complicated issue, and so maybe the extra time can help. If anybody has any
▶ Play
questions in the meantime, please don't hesitate to ask. All right, committee, we are now going to move to our special order, and we have Representative Love to present House Bill 1119. Representative Love, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Committee. I'm here to present House
▶ Play
Bill 1119, which is the, as it's been pegged, the Robert E. Lee Martin Luther King separation bill. So, here's what I would like to say and do, committee. First of all, I'm not here to replow ground. That's not my intent. I know that you have debated this bill before in different forms. But what I am here to do is plant a seed of goodwill. I've listened to a lot of the debate both times that this bill has, or a version of this bill has been debated. And I think I've come to a kind of a solution for this issue. First of all, let me tell you exactly what the bill does not do. Number one, this bill does not strike the celebration of Robert E. Lee Day. Number two, this bill does not attempt to strike Robert E. Lee from history. Those, I mean, these are some of the emails that I have received, and so I wanted to respond to that because I think that is important. So that's not what this bill does. But let me tell you what this bill does. The bill will separate Martin Luther King and Robert E. Lee Day. That's what the bill is. It's the intent of the bill. This bill continues to celebrate Robert E. Lee by declaring the second Friday in January a Memorial Day for Robert E. Lee. noted. In this bill, the governor has the power to issue a proclamation for the state agencies and state to be closed. So therefore this bill, that's what this bill does. But number three, most importantly, and this is where I would really like to have this discussion. Most importantly, this bill moves Arkansas ahead and forward in the areas of race relations by separating these two days. It is just another step in healing the scar that we have of kind of this deep issue in regards to race. And so that's where this conversation is. This bill is not to disparage Robert E. Lee in any way. I mean, I've heard from both sides of this issue. It's not designed to strike Robert E. Lee from history. But what this bill does do is it moves Arkansas as a state forward in race relations. And so with this committee, I will pause to take any questions, address any concerns, and then I'm pretty sure that there are people signed up to speak for and against this bill. And that's what I would like to do at this time, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. And I yield. Alright. Representative Love has completed this presentation. Are the questions from the committee? Representative Love, I don't see any questions from the committee. We do have a number of people signed up to testify for and against the bill. I'll go ahead and start with that list. Mr. Tom Bird, you will be recognized to speak against the bill. The chair will caution everyone to speak on the bill and remind everyone that we have to be in session at 10 a.m. to please keep your presentations brief and try to avoid re-plowing old ground.
▶ Play
Speaker 49 30:04
My name's Tom Byrd. I'm just a citizen. I'm not here with the Klan, the skinheads, or anything else, and I am against this bill. It's, I don't understand after 70 years what the problem is with it now. You know, having Robert E. Lee Day, and since the 80s, having them both combined, I've not heard any kind of comments. But I do attend some of the coffee shops, some of the ones that you all go to when you get running for re-election and what have you. And that's the main question. They want to know why. Why are you doing this? There's been no problem. So that's basically all I've got to
▶ Play
say on it. Are there questions from the committee for Mr. Byrd? Seeing none, Mr. Byrd, you're excused. Thank you. Anyone here to speak for the bill? I have Ms. Karen DePippa. If you would, please identify yourself and who
▶ Play
Speaker 52 31:08
you're with, and you'll be recognized. Mr. Chair, representatives, I'm Karen DePippa, and I am representing Catholic Charities from the Catholic Diocese of Little Rock. that comprises the entire state, and we will be very brief, support this bill on its social justice merit that respects the life and dignity of each person, particularly the most vulnerable. We feel that Dr. King represents the culture of life, and we're not here. Representative Love took most of my talking points, so just to kind of reiterate, we're not here to judge Robert E. Lee. We're not here to judge him on his military service, his valor, his personality. What we're saying is we're here to support Dr. King, particularly his actions of non-violence further his quest for justice and equality. We find that the symbolism and the manner of Robert E. Lee is incongruent with the nonviolent quest of Dr. King. He embraced nonviolence, he promoted nonviolence, he embodied non-violence. I think he deserves his own day. We feel that the time is now. We haven't always been as vocal as we could have been in this issue, but this is the time. There's a lot of unfinished business in the racial divide, and this is a step to bridge that gap. So we do appreciate your consideration and hopeful
▶ Play
support of this bill. Questions from the committee for Ms. DePippa?
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question. I have a motion. This is an issue that we've heard, we've debated, we've spent hours on. I was a co-sponsor on the original bill. What I would make a motion is that we would table... Representative Ballinger, you weren't recognized
▶ Play
for a motion. Thank you. You're recognized for a question. Does anyone else have a question for Mr. DePippa? Seeing none, you're excused. Next, we have Vicki Bailey to speak against
▶ Play
the bill. My name is Vicki Bailey. I'm from White County, Arkansas, and I'm against this bill. I don't think that we should be able to separate Robert E. Lee from MLK. I think all birthdays should be celebrated. I just don't think that we're doing the right thing.
▶ Play
Thank you. All right. Next up, we have Mr. Larry Page to speak for the bill. If you would, please, sir, state your name and who you're with. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 64 34:24
Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Larry Page with the Arkansas Faith and Ethics Council, but I'm also here as a citizen and a parent. And I will honor your time. I know you've heard a lot about this. I'll try not to be repetitive, hopefully bring a little different perspective. It's a difficult bill, but it's an important issue. And it's important not because of logistics, which day we celebrate these two men. That's not the important thing. What's important about this is the symbolism. And it's symbolism that is offensive to a lot of people. We're among three states, Alabama, Mississippi, and ourselves, who still do this. Even Virginia, General Lee's home state, separated these holidays 15 years ago. Why? Because they saw that it was the right thing to do. This is not about denigrating General Lee. His startling qualities are well noted and was a man of character. So then why is this symbolism offensive? Well, it's offensive because of all the other characteristics of his life and attributes. General Lee led an army of the Confederacy, and had they prevailed, that pernicious and evil institution of slavery would have been perpetuated for we don't know how long. That alone is the only reason you need to celebrate these days of celebration. It's not about rewriting history. It's about acknowledging history and doing the right thing because of that. General Lee's legacy is set. That's not going to change. Arkansas's legacy is still a work in progress. And for many people, our legacy is Central High School 1957. Now, we've done a lot to move from that. We've moved a long way from that. But we have a chance here to move a little further away from that. And it's not under compulsion from the federal government, loss of funding. It's not litigation. it's opportunity to do this because it's the right thing to do and i'll try to wrap this up very quickly but i'm going to share one other thing with you now among our five children my wife and i have two black teenage sons we adopted them as infants and raised them i'm trying to raise them to honor and respect america not to dismiss our past bad deeds that we've had but to acknowledge that it's a it's a great country and i want them to aspire to the principle of E Pluribus Unum, one for many. And I can't give them one halfway compelling reason why these days have to continue to be, or these men have to, their celebrations have to continue to be joined together. I've heard it said, this is the right thing to do, but now is not the right time to do it. When is it never the right time to do the right thing? And I'll leave you with a quote from General Lee. General Lee said, I think it is better to do right, even if we suffer in so doing, rather than incur the reproach of our consciences. It is the time to do this, and I would encourage you to give this bill a due pass recommendation. If there are questions, I'll be glad to take those.
▶ Play
Are there questions from the committee for Mr. Page? All right, seeing none, we'll move to the next person against, and that would be Mr. Robert Edwards.
▶ Play
Speaker 65 37:42
Good morning. I'm Robert Edwards, and I'm here to speak against this bill. I do not share Mr. Page's views, and I do find this bill to be discriminatory. I gave testimony in the past that said that the bill was a racist bill I'm having a real hard time trying to understand how two representatives from two different districts, two different parties Hold on just a minute Mr. Edwards, Representative Gray I'll
▶ Play
call for a quorum Representative Gray, there are eight members present there. We don't have a quorum. Thank you. Folks, due to a quorum call, we are required to cease our business. Committee is adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB995

0:34 - 7:13 23 segments 6 speakers

HB1425

7:13 - 26:25 49 segments 4 speakers

HB1119

26:25 - 38:56 34 segments 8 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Nate Bell Chair Unverified
29 segments
Senator Joyce Elliott Chair Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 6
1 segment
Speaker 11
3 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 24
34 segments
Speaker 32
1 segment
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
2 segments
Representative Fredrick J. Love Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 49
2 segments
Speaker 52
4 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Chair Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 64
7 segments
Speaker 65
2 segments